Resolution 277-1984
"'.
RE$(DCllQ;I(DN N(D.
277 -1984
IDHEREA$, the B(DARD (Df ((DllNQ;g ((DmmI$$I(DNER$ (Df ffi(DNR(DE t(DllNQ;g,
fC(DRIDA, has receiven an application from (CgDE ffi. K(DBE
ann,
IDHEREA$, in compliance with $tate $tatute, it is necessary as
part of the permitting procenure to rean the fallowing Biological
Assessment into the Recorn as fallows:
Applicant proposes to construct 48 l.f. of retaining wall and 840 sq. ft.
of private dock at a future residential site on the Atlantic Ocean. The
dock surface will be an open lattice decking design. The proposed activities
will require a total of 37 cu. yds. of limerock placed landward of MHW, and
5 cu. yds. placed waterward of MHW. Total area to be filled is .016 acres.
The project includes 7.2 cu. yds. of riprap at the seawall toe (in a 5 ft.
wide zone).
Also proposed, is a 12 foot wide x 14 foot long concrete boat ramp for
launching the resident's boat. Construction techniques are not specified.
The project site is located in Summerland Key Cove Addition No.6, a water-
front community on the Atlantic Ocean within the Key Deer National Wildlife
Refuge (Class III Outstanding Florida Waters). This region is characterized
by a network of manmade canals and channels providing access to Kemp Channel
to the west and Niles Channel to the east. Substantial alterations have
been made along the shoreline, including bulkheads, docks, and ramps. A
deep navigational channel is found immediately offshore with sheer side
slopes.
Adjacent to the project site, a riprap wall and concrete block dock were
recently completed to the east (Permit #440750925). The adjoining lot to the
west has been recently filled (landward of MHW).
The project site consists of an undeveloped parcel of property with 60 l.f.
of water frontage on Summerland Cove (Atlantic Ocean). The rubble shore-
line currently exhibits sparse vegetation, including buttonwood (Conocarpus
erecta), seagrape (Coccoloba uvifera), and beach elder (Iva sp.).
The historically filled upland lot is bordered by a 10 ft. wide (~) littoral/
sublittoral zone to the north of the excavated channel. Dominant submergent
vegetation includes scattered algal growth, Batophora sp. and Penicillus sp.
specifically noted. Water depths along the rock ledge range from 0 to -1'
(MHW).
Aquatic fauna noted on-site included periwinkles, horn shells, nerites,
needlefish, barracuda, pinfish, and juvenile snapper.
Expected short term impacts include elevated turbidity levels as a result
of the proposed construction activities in and adjacent to state waters.
An insignificant amount of submerged algae will be directly eliminated by
the ramp construction.
No long term adverse impacts on water quality or the biological integrity
of state waters are anticipated. The dock design should allow for partial
sunlight penetration, which should sustain existing submerged floral growth.
The riprap is expected to provide a source of habitat.
I recommend approval of the project as proposed, in accordance with Chapter
253 and 403, F.S. and F.A.C. Rules 17-3 and 17-4. Turbidity should be
controlled at all times.
Resolution
Clyde M. Kobe
Page Two
BE It RE$~~ED BM tHE B~ARD ~F t~UNtM t~mmI$$I~NER$ ~F m~NR~E
t~UNt~ FC~RIDA, that the ahove Biological Assessment has heen rean into
the recorn ann nuly consineren pursuant to Florina $tatute 253.124 hy the
Boarn of tounty tommissioners of monroe tounty, Florina, this 21st nay
of
September
,19 84 at a regularly schenulen meeting.
B~ARD ~F t~uNtM t~mmI$$I~NER$ ~F
m~~~tg, fC0RIDA
XJ2-n- d
By ._ ___ ~~( ...
. maynr--' - . '--~
($EAC)
AHest :DANNY L. KOLHAGE, Clerk
,,/)
~--S
/ '__ I
Cucien t. Frohy
tounty Attorney
~Y.~D' ~~~,~~E
(305) 294.4641
Lucien C. Proby,
County Attorney
310 Fleming Street
Key West, Florida 33040
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Wilhelmina Harvey, District 1
Ed Swift, District 2
MA YOR Jerry Hernandez, District 3
Alison Fahrer, District 4
Mayor Pro tem Ken Sorensen, District 5
I, the undersigned, do hereby attest that all data
and information is complete in the package of the applicant
as follows:
1.
County BiOlogist Report
2.
Resolution
(CLYDE KOBE)
3.
Permit
4.
Application for Permit(Retaining Wall,
Dock & Boat Ramp)
5.
Site Plan
6.
Location Map
7.
DER Asses~ment
~
v
~
~
~
~
Date
tj- ~-tftf
~
~,C2~
By
tR\.D.1?,(fITh':n?~]., "'.
'j!rfl. LJ \::')( . i .' ;~, ; I!
. f:V
SEP 6 1984 "
COuNTY ;1 TTY.
OK~Y~!: ~A~~,~~E
REC~-"''' J'r""D'
',. ~-=>~~;l:"~
. :.... iL..,.,... II J ~~_ ..:..
rr-.....-
(305) 2944641
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Wilhelmina Harvey, District 1
Ed Swift, District 2
Jerry Hernandez, District 3
Mayor Pro tern Alison Filhrer, District 4
Mayor Ken Sorensen, District 5
MEMORANDUM
AUG 2 7 Et.:'.4
DATE:
MONRO;:: CGU,':T'{
FLl\NN!NG G'::PT.
,03
August 15, 1984
BY
TO:
Dr. Jeffrey M. Doyle, Director
Planning and Zoning
FROM:
p,~<;:JL"Q2
George Schmahl, Biologist
SUBJECT:
Applicant Name: Clyde M. Kobe
Legal: Lot 26, Block 1, Summerland Key Cove Add. #6,
Summer land Key
Zoning: RU-l
Introduction
This application for a retaining wall, fill below mean high water, dock
and boat ramp should be reviewed by the Board of County Commissioners"
pursuant to Section 19-111 (a)(5) of the Monroe County Code.
Project and Site Description
Applicant proposes to construct an eight inch concrete xetaining wall
two feet landward of mean high water and backfill with approximately 30
cubic yards to the existing lot elevation. Rip rap boulders are to be
placed seaward of the retaining wall, of which approximately five cubic
yards will lie seaward of mean high water. A 14 foot wide dock running
the length of the property is proposed, supported by concrete columns
and beams. This dock is for the purpose of providing access to a dredged
channel waterward of the shoreline. A 12 foot wide boat ramp will pene-
trate the dock.
The site is a previously cleared and filled lot in a developed subdivision
in Summerland Key Cove. The site does not lie within the shoreline pro-
tection zone as per section 4-18 of the County Code, but is capable of
supporting wetland vegetation. Present shoreline vegetation includes
buttonwood (Conocarpus erecta), one small seagrape (Coccoloba unifera),
Ox eye daisy (Borrichia spp.) and Sea purslane (Sesuvium sp.). A rocky,
....
Dr. Jeffrey M. Doyle
August 15, 1984
Page 2
submerged shelf is present seaward of MEW about 11~ feet to the dredged
channel line. The only biota noted on the shelf was the algae Batophora.
This property fronts open water and it is evident that some erosion has
already taken place, indicating that shoreline stabilization may be neces-
sary. A vertical bulkhead seawall is present on the adjoining property
to the east. The shoreline to the west is undeveloped. Docks and sea-
walls are common in this subdivision shoreline.
A joint application with the D.E.R. and A.C.O.E. (file #440883695) is
currently being processed. A copy of the D.E.R. biological report is
attached and recommends approval for the project.
This dock proposal may be under the jurisdiction of the Department of
Natural Resources Marina and Dock siting criteria, which limits the size
of docks that service single family residences.
Evaluation
The proposed development should have minimal environmental impact. The
rip rap below mean high water could actually provide additional submerged
habitat. The decking to be used for the dock will be open lattice con-
crete, which will allow some penetration of. light to the area beneath the
dock to allow for plant growth.
The construction of the boat ramp will require placement of fill and
concrete below mean high water. As the present shelf does not support
an extensive benthic biota, this activity will have only a minor impact
on the environment.
Turbidity curtains should be employed for the augering of holes for the
support columns and during the placement of fill and cpncrete for the
boat ramp. A small berm should be incorporated at the landward side of
the boat ramp at the point where the ramp grades into the existing lot
elevation. This will prevent storm runoff from being funneled directly
into the coastal water.
Recommendation
The biologist recommends conditional approval of this project.
Conditions: 1. Turbidity curtains are to be used during augering and
placement of support columns and during construction of
boat ramp waterward of existing erosion line.
2. A retention device should be incorporated into the land-
ward side of the boat ramp to prevent storm runoff from
flowing directly into open water.
Other Observations
There is no principal structure on this site. A septic tank has already
been installed on this property.
PERMIT
MONROE
COUNTY
@'~'
. ,. '..';"~.-~.' ,
-F(' ~-
PLANNING, BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT
PERMIT FOR EXCAVATION. THE DEPOSIT OF
FILL. OR STRUCTURAL ACTIVITIES IN THE
WATERS OR WETLANDS OF MONROE COUNTY
PERMIT
NO.
1) Property owners name & mailing address
Mr. Clyde M. Kobe
1014 Bay Breeze Terrace
Largo, Florida 33540
2) Date
6-12-84
FOR DEPARTMENT USE ONLY
3) Phone number
(813) 585-2246 Date:
(813) 585-2246
Resolution No.
4) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address & phone number
OWNER CONTRACTOR
5) Legal description of property:
Section
35
66S
Key Summerland
Subdivision Summerland Key Cove
Addition #6
Township
Lot 26
Block
Range
28E
Street, road or mile marker U. S. # 1 MM 24.5 So. over Bridge
Rast on C~~;hhp~n n~
Volume of material:
dredged/excavated
filled/ deposi ted
c.y.
wa terward
of M.H. W.
c.y.
landward
ofM.H.W.
5 c.y.
waterward
of M.H.W.
35 c.y.
landward
ofM.H.W.
ZONING: RU-1
PURPOSE:
Cost of Permit Estimated cost of Construction
Biologist Comments. Restrictions or Special Conditions if any: COND I T ION AL APPROVAL
1. Turbidity curtains are to be used during augering and placement of
support columns and during construction of boat ramp waterward of existing
erosion line.
2. A retention device should be incorporated into the landward side of
the boat ramp to prevent storm runoff from flowing directly into open water.
There is no principal structure on this site. A septic tank has already been
installed on this property.
Dr. Jeffrey M. Doyle, Director
Planning & Zoning Department
/~.
/. MONROE
, COUNTY
t;.<.....~ .
~21
PLANr lNG, BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT PERMIT APPLICATION FOR
EXCAVATION. THE DEPOSIT OF FILL. OR STRUCTURAL ACTIVITIES IN THE
WATERS OR WETLANDS OF MONROE COUNTY.
1) Property owners name & mailing address
2) Date
3) Phone number
6-12..-B'4
&73 - S8S-.;Ld... <q.ta
~ S- /'d-~'Ib
OWN~F!- (ONTRACTIJ f:.
5) Legal description of property:
Section.
:35
r{.6 S
c? f-F
'" ~
(if acreage)
RUL
tt..
Key, SVAU\.EIU.A",j)Subdivision, S~Jt{l(e.le..L'V0P KE: 'I CIJ VE ~.D i.) Co
Lot, do fo Block, ,
U r -u.., MM.;;}n.S- SeuTI-J
Street, road or mile marker..;:::) -. ./
OVER.. 'BRIl)bt - E"A'ST DO CAR.7BBe\A> J>"fJ1Jc
L. 01 LV I."'" St"EE"L OI...J IT
6) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction & amount of material (in cubic yards) to be excavated or
discharged. Describe purpose & intended use of project.
Township.
Range,
Zoning,
SEE'- A T1J<\ C!.J-/-€i) s It EEl
volume of
material
dredged/excavated
c.y. c.y.
waterward landward
of M.H.W. of M.H.W.
filled/deoosited
5"' c.y. .3 5"
waterward landward
of M.H. W. of M.H. W.
c.y.
7) Name, address & zip code of adjoining property owners whose prooerty affronts water w, T.
5~~T S 1'i)'E ~ t) ~J.) 1\. 'W t+tTE' \)(l;~T -5'1:>8: ~ ~o S' B ~ 80 W ~ KI..
P. o. 'eo)(. ~5;}'" F=L Ki ~ 4.1 Dx:. ~ eo
s~~~.u~ KeV:J. 5v~~6:.-t;}.LJ+L-iJ I<€)I PI..., -8,~ (J <1~
8 a) List other permits issued and/or applied for, include applicant's name, for this site:
\) .s E;"ll>11 <!... ,AuK. 1:l K ( (.)~ - 84
'2) BOI~t)IIJ~ PEl!.ll\Al"', f=.oR... flOuSe: l ~ l ~ p~
b) If application has been submitted for this project (or one similar) in the past, explain reason for new application
and give applicant's name if different from current applicant.
tV/A
9) List all Federal and State agencies that have received applications for this project.
-FI...". "bElT 01= E~". RE"<q ~ ~VIUTi\- 60R.OIlr rL.) "Ji:"o,/fPPLI(!.Il-TIDN
A R~ '\.l <!.e e..p 0 1= E' kJ <:r C!.. p" I..),~ <Oo~~ R.. ---:) s ffo~T ~ ~
This completed application form will be accompanied by the
following, or it will NOT be processed.
a) Two (2) sets of drawings, on 8'/2 x 11 paper, showing location, plot plan, top view and cross section of proposal,
drawn to scale.
b) Application processing fee as follows:
$75.00 for dredge, fill, docks OR any structures affronting natural water bodies.
$30.00 for vertical seawalls on man-made bodies of water.
$75.00 for any combination of the above activities per site.
Application is hereby made for a permit to authorize the activities described herein. I certify that I am familiar
with the information contained in this application, and to the best of my knowledge & belief such information is
" true. complete & accurate. I further certify that I possess the authority to undertake the proposed activities. All
provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied with whether specified herein or not.
The granting of a permit does not presume to give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any county. state
0' fedenlllaw ...gulating construction 0' pe,(o,mance of con~~ ~ UlhOc I,,!, l'1lf1
Signature of applicant/agent Date
For Deoartment Use Onlv/
;fr?<)":. S/6/SS/
Fee & receipt
Approved by Ass't Director
-r, ,
Person accepting application &
Cost of permit
Estimated cost of construction
,
"",0
~
'{I
i
\~.
dj v ~ B a."
SITE
~
~
[DCA T/{)N
....
GCAL-E -NOA/C-
C... KO.L3c-
I;-jj-BS"
.~
'\l'
~.~
;~,
';;~
: ~
, ..
~, I~ O{~'..!
-tr " .
"" /', !
0"'4 tJ" -. '
(\ ,
~ :
.f. !',
(> , ,r
/..../// '''\~
' ,
/~. ;.
I "
~' , -
r/'
\ h' "., (\
NL\ ~r;
\;l~
'\ 0.. '''0~7 '.
) \Ul ~,:
lY ~.<./
'~I\ ~,> ,,)
~-".;/I
. ".- ~
'.' ...~)
) 0} r'
J:' N
>':~
-', i.J ,- \
~ ~.,.\
(';:.'.'0" '
.;
"
~
"
"
"
..:;:
"
~ }7
,~ U.: How..1J
. - Kll'Y
t,.:
.. :j
'..
"
c.
I"
I
J,
~~
~ .,' t:j
.~~.~
~~~
-'~ \
"",,~;,,\~
(\~""i""C l .''''!~:''-' \
'rl(:J"'O't~~
,;.i~'Q~~
"J' - ,I.' .'.' .."z.... .':':::
( ",. '--. , .
'; R.<~!'Tli'l(;i.~ey ,f'.:
// ..... -, .... "1,,,.._
#~.:~. 'F:,::
(I', ' /( _...1
"'.:;-""" ~r:'~'
U '1 r.... ._._-, r;..:.(
,,-....2.'.. _ -.""'G ~ 7"I-_
......... ,.;;.~.,,::.
. ." ?".:"
1\'
.1
,~,
'~;
,~ It
.,' ~ ",.1:. 0,
/~~:"
JOHN A. PETSCHE, JR.
P~OFe:SS:ONAL. ENCINEE~ &; SU~VEYOR
DATE DE!: 1(; 1",53
p..,.ONE r')"5;'M
AREA CODE J,:6
112'5FI~H AvE GUlj:'
M.A;:u.Tl-401ll. FLORI::)" ~
PUT OF SURVEY
lOT Zr, , EI.OCK~, SUE::>IVISION _=L,,"""E~L';ND KEf COVE ,qCD NO ~
KEY 5[//".~,'1EnI1NO . ::SCTION _"5, .;.;- 28 . r.LAT bOOK-L-, PAGE
MONROE COli:-;TY FLORIDA PU:a:"IC RECORDS.
F...... ~c 5.:2"J"'&E .;::H2
OHIO REG. S - 622. Po E...:e.J9
41
CLIENT: LLYLJE KOBE, /L'lo{ J;RY EREEZE TH:;::RU L,ck:t;O, neelDIl 3_~5o{O
::03S:
_~~ -~~~ high water line where shown
is U.S. Corp of Engineers Estimate
relative to ~ean sea level U.S.C. & G.
Dc. turn .
~- Ind ica tes 3/4" steel pipe founa
or se t.
-~- Indicates 40d spike or ?K. Survey
, control :'ou.'"1d or set.
~ L~dicates Bench ~ark. Spike or P.K.
nail set in utility pole or tree
gOO' Ft. above mean sea level.
:c-CRLE e:.:::-lY'eo"vE
F1r.'H Z/iNE ,/./2 EP.:E FLCOfJ a IZ'11.5.L.
,
------,1------
3/! t JJ;
'-"'1"-'"'
,
~~~_r?':-:/( :.'
@i@
1. fl'O
I~
(-;::.,z', :.' ?"\
'...!-J I~
7"1",'1 ,r"a--' .
\'
(
'--:::
".,
"
---.--- :;:, ..
,,,,. ~ir"I'/,lff11.'~ "'!~{P:;;M. . f~."- 3'::'0' p..![:,:: _~;.." _"":-!.'3:
,
I'
)_J j
----" -- t.~ --;".1---
;;'
:::: .-,/.,. .f.~_ PIN '," CC~.: ~.'r.."'.
50'
~:
\
\
El1fi/E!3EFfl fj;f/fE E/iJT
~:
J;e}~ .785. ,40.....
,"- .
('--r""f---
~ '!- )?
~. - >
yC.
, - ,....."'1
q;------'-'~
, \
. /
(
i
,-ee' <'~~
oJi.J"./JC C~j.
~:
~.,
___~!y'.'
0'
r"
i
,
i~
;~~
:
I
I
,,,e IT
. ':'O.u:'"
'"
.~~
?p' --. ....q.
'PE~['C:",3T1DN
'Ti:r hlllL
A:'~
,'.'
I
---
.0
~
,~'
~
~
':&,
~.
. ~'c.~.rENCE
:....
~.J,- :7
...
~.....
... ~ ::--
=::.... ~
~..... ;:
:: ~ ~
E: ~ ::
... :;:
~~
~ ~ ~
. ~
~~
~~
~,
W
. .
,.,
.~ ~
~.- :.,;
': I.... -
~ i~ ~
: :~ ~
~~~
~$~
-- ~-
~-..I
LIff 26
,...., ......~ ~
.~
~
\~
~. ~
TOP or l1EeH _ _
~\ ,~C'"
\\,). 'W"lTNE51 l..'ltE ..' +--.......~ ~ 0'
N57'.JIU~W ./J:JII', if\.
"--..--- - .-...-.----- .,- - ---.
,Ef 1
Vl'/lRlJ prOPECTY UNE ..-~J
.;,-...'4I1C.-&liJ C;,J:N'III.. cu;-:;J--.
t:i7RIi/IEL
F.:-:'.::,.",'-! - :.-"":-::,;:."
I HEREBY CERTIFY tha t
of a survey conducted
Bea.:-ings are rela ti ve
of delineating angles
established by U.S.C.
thereof. all of which
the attached plat is a true and correct representacion
by me or under my supervision on ZkYE/'78U''; l~e3
to an assu~ed meridian and are given for the purpose
only. Elevations are relative to cean sea level as
& G. Survey. Distances are in feet and decimal parts
I certify to ccrrect. p
YJ'. U-~.
. .:.TSCHE. JR. C.E.. P.E.. P. .S.
Professional Engineer No. 2374
Reg. :and Surv~yor No; 2914
CAR./BBEAN DRJYE EAST
,
~t:>
@
LOT-M 2.7
LOT I:J 2. tD
C. KIJ/3E
I
- ----m u
LOTII.2.S"
~-- ::;.
. - ,
DaN WHITl:
'.:
-- '..{':.
-"Jb"E" 'Br1315u--sa
lOt>'
--
--
........ -'"
--.-"'"
.
~_ _ $~"N I./NE
-
11'4 5 ~UOllI!.ES.
""- - - 771IS UT
--- ~. A"~-7
tJ~ /'
NO STRGlCrt/,€,ES
r"H/.!5 LOr
/
.,-
--.
- ----~~~~....._~" ~_-:-.......
/'....- DECK ~
EBB
77,/J/F
+
FI..OOD 1
T].lJc
G)ttl sr/NG" t::HANNEL NAl.L
....4S. AtL. yv,' L/"'~
SITE f3LAN i.()Tal~ SUM!nEeLAAJb ~E'I
COYE A/J[)/77()N~~ SUN/IfJEeLAAJ/)KEt FL.
&CALE /"~ at)'
~ I~ '!f ~
C.K_He
~ - 11-/Ui
SlIeET /oF4
Q -
V PURPOSE. Prevent erosion
channel.
DA TUM: Petsche survey &
G
'.u
~
"
~
o
-J
~
DRAWING SHEET
~lQ'~ '
'~ oJ'
f l4i~
" ~
. ,~
~~......
v~
.......
~"U
(}S~
..
o
~ N
.....
~
"
.......
II
...
... tV..
"*0
-
'.u
.J
ct
\)
If)
o
---------~ -.J - ~r
4l~~
~.
~ ,
~ ,
~ I
t-.
~
...
...
o
... ,
~
"I
~~~ "
Iii " I
'\J I
(Q~
ll~
~1Il
~~
.
~
V)
....
~
~ ~
~Vl \tJ
~~ -
~V')~ ~
~~ ltJ~~ <
~VJ ~JCll
., ~ I.. ~ ~ ~
'ok "IJ~\.3....J
.p ) liJ ~ ~ I ~ ~. Q
I, ")._ ;) " "~
I ',t V ~\)~ ~~
i ; : I I J: \!) ~ -J ~ ~ ~~
i! I I ~~ ~ I..' <l ~o
h I \ ~ I .J...... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~vi
111;/' :1: .~~ -$.~~ ~~~
II I i / \ ill I I ~ w -i ~ \J l.ij
::W,:~,\~Q ~..~~ ~~~
. II "'-I/o ~k
& provide access to Atlantic ocean
.J
~
~
\b
~ ' - ~ III
~ ! ~ I'"~
~. llJ:
..J ~.
Ui
--- --
""
onsite survey by C. Kobe
IN
. Adjacent Property Owner..
1. Dan B. White
AT
2.
:.T;;;, E B c. (1 D UJ S \:::"'T:
COUNTY Dr Monroe STATE Fl.
APPLICATION BY. C. Kobe
SHEET 2. or4 DATE
DEft ror. 17-1.20) 1 Errective Nove.ber lO, 1982
"'~
~ 141
- ~ ~
~ ~ -r ..~
\1 ... ()
~ C)
\!1 J ... ,..
\J ~ l., )( 'a
~ .....
lu ~J ~ ~ ~
- ~ ~ V'1-J ~q \Q
- ..... ~~ Q",
() ..J \J ~ a ?'llQ
I ~ ~ \JC\ ~"
.... )a~
Yl V' :t ~ Ii.
~n - ~"
~ en
~ ~ J ~M ::J ~ ~ ~~
~ ~~~~~ .... ~ .....~
N
~!.l.~!~ - Cf).
~ ~\)
~ ~~ ~iJ
~
..... , ..
~ ~ ~
\0 ~
~ ~ ~
G
~
~
~ V) U ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ()
~ ~ -J ~~ ... <<
......
<= ~..J~~ ~ II
~ 'll~~ ::~
~ ri ~ \() ~
~ ~~ ~~ IaJ
~'t . ...J
~. ~ ~
~~ ~ - ({)
::r ~
sr ~ SI-IEET3 OF 4
~.7-." C.K6.!JF
~
~ r'\
~ ~
~'"
~ () ~ ~
~~ ~
VJ · .... ~
)(~ q:
~ <J l.l
CQ ,
'f1 ()
~ cf.I \0
~ CQ It.
S I~
'~ c::1
--J ....
~ 0 3:
\u \J l1J ~
\J --. ~
~ > )...
~ ..... ...
..... u ..
()
~ ..(
......
~ "
&I) -
...
~ ,. ~
~ ...J CW) \u
~ I ~ ...
~ (II ~
..... \.I
~ J ,!.') - ~
'to:
tu . 4
~ ~~
:::t:...; s~~ET4 OF"' 4
~~
~- 7-e4 C.KoSE
., ..' ..,"r~':" .
::~ Ji~. ~~,;~1ft . .'.' , I , .
. ~.~ - or.... ,. II,' " I
it~- . . . r I
::~~if~~:':'" ", ' . ",,""" ~ ___ ~ .<!>~../ I I I .-
~.' ~.~'~~..:".'.'..:~'.~~.'. ~:'::'::.1~.'~.. :'":~ '";~'~;:;"J-~j;,.' ;:::~(~~-T.'fi~~~"'~.
~~,l-\f""'"~ ., . ....~ ~ ~.._~''''''':~~'~ -C-"
~~:r'i:.;~::':'~':Z~~ . - , , . '",,' ~ .... r _ .' -vv--.I':....:-,-..~ .'
.;.~~~Z~*~... ....~;;:;<~~ '~''''.' '-co
, . , ,"'~~~';"',~~: ;,:;';.;~..:.'~',. .. ~~. "~~~~~\'
OPEN .LA T/ CE DEc.,:<iNG
C by LyLE S,ARJ<:.. G~--W. CQ;"~7'21"2.)
.8,. .Go h I!/ E KcY-.J ~LA .
t
-
....
---
I
l~
"
'"
I~ ~
--
I'
~ i '
,,,:
-I' l: \', s :1 ..~:: '
~ :~ =~ ~~ ~~ ~:
.. \'.. r \ 11 :.-
,I
/1
:::1
::: i ~;::r
:: I t:~i
~~:i
~~
:~,
:."
Q
.=;
i~l
.;1
f
,
....
-
---=::310.
.~~ ,f-
,:..:""'-
LOT:t:: 2.~ Bl1JCK #: 1
SU ~hY1 EJ? LAN.J J::: E":f C. 0 V E
A..DP :z (0
SUM/WE-elAN/) J::E::i FL_
("LOT WITH 5/EtL f>EAni";
\.. ON IT J
2 q.<=> ~ 9'..3 0" N.LAT.
8/'"' 2~r 42" vv. LON6.
v J
~~
~ <\
<t lJJ
~ \J
~C)
j
SeAL-I: - No"UE
SITE LOCATJON
--
..
..
j
....1
.
C. I:::'OBE
b-/J-8~
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
3201 GOLF COURSE BOULEVARD
PUNTA GORDA. FLORIDA 33950-9359
BOB GRAHAM
GOVERNOR
SOUTH FLORIDA
BRANCH OFFICE
VICTORIA J. TSCHINKEL
SECRETARY
August 15, 1984
Mr. George P. Schmahl
Monroe County Building Dept.
5825 Junior College Rd. W.
Key West, FL 33040
Re: Monroe County, File No. 440883695
Retaining Wall, Dock & Boat Ramp
Clyde M. Kobe
Dear Mr. Schmahl:
Attached is a copy of the Department's biological appraisal for the
referenced project as per your request.
A hydrographic survey was not required.
Si ncerely,
ljWtkf4.JJt1
Richard W. Cantrell
Environmental Supervisor
RWC/jh
Enc 1 .
cc: Clyde M. Kobe
Protecting Florida and Your Quality of Life
....
.u_~_....~ __,... _
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
PERMIT APPLICATION APPRAISAL
.,.... -,....;- -"'~"\ .....,..,,0
r ',. --. ".J::W'l:
u ~ ~'.,\~-~::~:.ii 'J _
f< J .:.
File No.: 440883695
County:
Monroe
ffU~-t>O FBi' AJI~ISm:Cr
Da 1;~H..-Wt.lI 'lItf;~~_
Applicant Name: Clyde M. Kobe
Address: lOl4 Bay Breeze Terrace, Largo, FL 33540
Agent (if applicable): NA
Address:
Location of project: Section(s)
35
Township
66S Range 28E
Section(s)
Township
Range
Local Reference: Lot #26, Summerland Key Cove
Water Body: Atlantic Ocean (Sumrnerland Cove)
Water Classification of Project Area:
III Adjacent Waters:
III
Aquatic Preserve:
NA
Outstanding Florida Waters:
National Key Deer Wildlife Refuge
On site inspection by:
T.A. Kranzer
Date of Inspection:
7-l7-84
Original Application: Yes X No
Revised Application: Yes No
Date:
Date of 2nd Insp.
Biological and Water Quality Assessment
A. Description of proposed project and construction techniques.
Quantify area of project which extends into waters of the state
(including the submerged lands of those waters and the transi-
tional zone of the submerged land) as defined in Section 17-4.02
and Section 17-4.28, Florida Administrative Code.
B. Biophysical features of general area. Include comments concerning
extent of development of adjoining properties as well as relevant
historical facts about the area.
C. Biophysical features of specific project site and spoil site if
applicable. Include identification of bottom types and any
relevant historical facts about the area of the project.
D. Potential impact of project on biological resources and water
quality. Address long-term impact as well as immediate impact
for all aspects of the project.
E. Suggestions, where appropriate, for modifications that may reduce
or minimize the potential impact of project.
PERM l6-l0 (Rev': 6/79)
~
KOBE, CLYDE M.
#440883695
Monroe County - Summer land Key
Poge Two
A. Applicant proposes to construct 48 l.f. of retaining wall
and 840 sq. ft. of private dock at a future residential
site on the Atlantic Ocean. The dock surface will be an
open lattice decking design. The proposed activities
will require a total of 37 cu. yds. of limerock placed
landward of MHW, and 5 cu. yds. placed waterward of MHW.
Total area to be filled is .Ol6 acres. The project in-
cludes 7.2 cu. yds. of riprap at the seawall toe (in a
5 ft. wide zone).
Also proposed, is a l2 foot wide x l4 foot long concrete
boat ramp for launching the resident's boat. Construction
techniques are not specified.
B. The project site is located in Summerland Key Cove Aadition
No.6, a waterfront community on the Atlantic Ocean within
the Key Deer National Wildlife Refuge (Class III Outstanding
Florida Waters). This region is characterized by a network
of manmade canals and channels providing access to Kemp
Channel to the west and Niles Channel to the east. Substan-
tial alterations have been made along the shoreline,
including bulkheads, docks, and ramps. A deep navigational
channel is found immediately offshore with sheer side slopes.
.
Adjacent to the project site, a riprap wall and concrete
block dock were recently completed to the east (Permit
#440750925). The adjoining lot to the west has been recently
filled (landward of MHW) .
C. The project site consists of an undeveloped parcel of property
with 60 l.f. of water frontage on Summerland-Cove (Atlantic
Ocean). The rubble shoreline currently exhibits sparse
vegetation, including buttonwood (Conocarpus erecta),
seagrape (Coccoloba uvifera), and beach elder (Iva sp.).
The historically filled upland lot is bordered by a lO ft.
wide(+) littoral/sublittoral zone to the north of the
excavated channel. Dominant submergent vegetation includes
scattered algal growth, Batophora sp. and penicillus sp.
specifically noted. Water depths along the rock ledge
range from 0 to -l' (MHW).
Aquatic fauna noted on-site included periwinkles, horn
shells, nerites, needlefish, barracuda, pinfish, and juvenile
snapper.
~
~
KOBE, CLYDE M.
#440883695
Monroe County - Summer land Key
Page Three
U. Expected short term impacts include elevated turbidity levels
as a result of the proposed construction activities in and
adjacent to state waters. An insignificant amount of
submerged algae will be directly eliminated by the ramp
construction.
No long term adverse impacts on water quality or the
biological integrity of state waters are anticipated. The
dock design should allow for partial sunlight penetration,
which should sustain existing submerged floral growth. The
riprap is expected to provide a source of habitat.
.
KOBE, CLYDE N.
#440883695
Monroe County - Surmnerland Key
Page Four
E. I recormnend approval of the project as proposed, in
accordance with Chapter 253 and 403, F.S. and F.A.C. Rules
l7-3 and l7-4. Turbidity should be controlled at all times.
~~-',: ' l' j,/"
, A . /0 ['0_
(, " L'--,_, , ". If ""
-T.A. KRANZER; ENV. ~PEC.
DATE:
READ:
TAK/dvo
Clyde Koue
#440883695
PHOTO #1
view of project site, looking
east. photo was taken from
westerly adjoining property
(non-bulkheaded). Note recent-
ly installed riprap wall and
dock in background (on easter-
ly adjoining property) .