Resolution 101-1983
.
.~
,
.-"
/
"/
RE.$fDCU~!fDN NfD.
101
-1983
IDHEREA.$, the BfDARD fDF tfDUN~Y tfDmmI.$.$IfDNER.$ fDF ffifDNRfDE tfDUN~Y, FCfDR!DA, has
receivea an application from Charles Rosenberg & Ira Sochet
ana
IDHEREA.$, in compliance wibh .$tate .$tatute, it is necessary as part of the
permitting proceaure to reaa the following Biological Assessment inbo the Recora as
follows:
Applicant proposes to create a 0.95 acre upland boat basin and create an
access canal/channel of 80' x 50' x -5' through upland and wetlands into an existing
canal/channel. Applicant further proposes to enhance circulation in the boat basin
by installing a 3' x 20' x -2' MHW calvert at the northwest corner of basin into
adjacent mangrove fringe.
As the substratum appears to be (from the exposed sides of nearby existing canal)
solid rock, the sides and bottom of basin may be relatively smooth, consequently
applicant proposes to place rip-rap around the 15 boat capacity basin at base of walls.
Applicant wants basin to furnish boat mooring for residents of proposed upland
development.
Most of the previous development to the northeast along the mangrove fringe/shore of
Upper Matecombe Key has been S.F.R's. Southwest of this site a 50' x 150' boat basin
exists. The shoreline southeast, beyond the basin, is serrated with private breakwaters,
docks and boat slips.
Waterward of the proposed access channel
mangrove fringe exists, up to 600' wide.
this fringe is approximately 300' wide.
and boat basin, an established black and red
In the area of the proposed circulation channel,
The upland, to the east of the east of the proposed basin is vegetated with Keys hammock
species, including, but not limited to, gumbo limbo, poisonwood, cacti, stoppers, brazil-
ian pepper and mahogany. Sesuvium sp., Salicornia sp., Borrichia sp. and to the south
extensive lawn grass are present adjacent to the access channel site. The owner of the
adjacent property has evidently extended its lawn onto the applicant's lands and has
used this area also as a repository for lobster carcasses and trapping debris, as well as
installing and using a boat ramp where the access channel is proposed.
The access channel is proposed to be cut mostly through the underlying upland rock
prevalent in this area. A triangular area approximately 80' long and 50' on the wide
side will be dredged through wetlands. Five mature red and black mangroves and a dozen
smaller Avicennia germinans and Rhizophora mangle are in this area, as is an abandoned
boat skelton and other debris. Sediment is a few inches thick over the rock layer.
Thalassia testudinum and epiphytic algae cover this sediment layer.
The area of the proposed upland basin is totally vegetated with mature hammock species.
The area of the proposed circulation culvert is transitional zone and terminates in a
mature black/red mangrove fringe approximately 300' wide.
The impact of this proposed project will be the destruction of approximately 0.2 acres
of wetlands and transition zone with the accompanying loss of associated vegetation.
The basin will, in the proposed configuration, collect debris and organic detritus in
the interior corners, causing degradation of water quality.
As most boats will be motorized, petroleum residue will collect in this enclosed area.
The circulation culvert will encourage the introduction of nutrient-ladened waters from
the mangrove fringe into the enclosed basin.
BE !~ RE~~C~ED BY ~HE B~ARD ~f t~UN~Y t~rnm!~~!~NER~ ~f m~NR~E t~UN~Y, fC~R!DA,
that the above Biological Assessment has been rean into the recorn ann nU1M consineren
pursuant to f10rina ~tatute 253.124 bM the Boarn of tountM tommissioners of monroe
tountM, f1orina, this 15 t h naM of Ap r i 1 , 19 83 at a regu1ar1M
schenu1en meeting.
BM
B~ARD ~f t~UN~Y t~mm!~~!~NER~ ~f
m~NR~E t~UN~Y, fC~R!DA
.9V~..
(m or) ~/;I
(~ea1)
RALPH tA, p,mJ"TE CLrRK
Attest:.. n. ~iU J . t
L \[ L\A~ fY\. ~ D.~ .
6 D (t1erk) .
APPROVED AS TO FORM
~S~LE~~ /
BY ,0-<..t..~--t....._ ~ ""...c -;:..1.. L
AttGrMy'. Office / . ._
PERMIT
MONROE
COUNTY
PLANNING. BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT
PERMIT FOR EXCAVATION. THE DEPOSIT OF
FILL. OR STRUCTURAL ACTIVITIES IN THE
WATERS OR WETLANDS OF MONROE COUNTY
PERMIT
NO.
1) Property owners name & mailing address
Charles Rosenberg & Ira Sachet
P.O. 430756
S. Miami, Fla. 33143
2) Date
3-28-83
FOR DEPARTMENT USE ONLY
3) Phone number
Resolution No.
Date:
4) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address & phone number
H.E. Rhodus
P.O. 256
Islamorada, Fla. 33036
5) Legal description of property:
Section
28
KUpper Matecumbe
ey
Subdivision Bay Hammock
Township 6 3 S
Lot
Block
Range
37E
Street, road or mile marker
Volume of material:
dredged/excava ted
filled/deposited
266 c.y.
waterward
ofM.H.W.
12, 7i~.
landward
ofM.H.W.
c.y.
waterward
ofM.H.W.
c.y.
landward
ofM.H.W.
ZONING:
PURPOSE:
Cost of Permit
Estimated cost of Construction
Biologist Comments - Restrictions or Special Conditions if any:
•
DEPARTMENTAL CORREPf1N` CE
DATE: March 31, 1983
SUBJECT: Charles Rosenberg and Ira Sochet:Proposed Boat Basin and Channel
TO: William Russell, Acting Director DEPT: Building, Planning and Zoning
FROM: Mark L. Robertson, Environ.Biol. DEPT: Planning and Zoning
7/77a4--"a A",
LEGAL: Bay Hammock Subdivision, Section 28, Township 63S, Range 37E
Upper Matecumbe Key
ZONING:RU-1 (approved Major Development and approved subdivision plat)
INTRODUCTION:
This application, which proposes an excavation of greater than 100 cubic yards
extending navigable waters, should be reviewed by the Board of County Commis-
• sioners pursuant to Section 19-111(b) (4) of the County Code.
DISCUSSION:
The applicants propose to develop a boat basin of 0.60± acres landward of the
mean high water (MHW) line requiring clearing and excavating of 12,743 c.y.
of uplands. The proposal requires the excavation of 266 c.y. below MHW through
mangrove wetlands and submerged lands to connect to an existing manmade channel
into, Florida Bay.
The proposed basin is part of the Bay Hammock Subdivision, which received Final
Major Development approval from the Zoning Board on June 2, 1982. The sub-
division plat was approved by the Board of County Commissioners on March 4, 1983.
The Florida Department of Environmental Regulation and the U,S, Army Corps of
Engineers have issued permits for this proposal (copies attached) .
This basin proposal was previously reviewed by the Board of County Commissioners
on November 29, 1982, but no .decision'was made and the proposal-:was returned
to County staff for clarification of unresolved questions. My previous report,
dated October 22, 1982, is attached. The basin plan has subsequently been
revised so that it is not within the Shoreline Protection Zone established by
Section 4-18 of the County Code. The shoreline mangroves on this site are a
highly_ productive wetlands area. Although questions may still be raised con-
cerning the effect of the basin on water quality, the Florida DER has issued a
permit certifying that State water quality standards will be maintained.
The new plans show a boat ramp, which was not part of the plan that received
Major Development approval from the Zoning Board.
The attached DER biological report discusses this project in greater detail.
The higher acreages and volumes of fill in the DER report do not reflect the
current proposal, which is a modification of the original plan.
•
Charles Rosenberg and Ira Sochet:Proposed Boat Basin and Channel
Page 2
EVALUATION:
The modification of the proposal, removing it from the Shoreline Protection
Zone, will maintain a natural buffer landward of the shoreline mangroves, thereby
promoting the long-term productivity of these wetlands.
In order to provide baseline water quality data for future boat basin proposals,
it is recommended that dissolved oxygen and flushing times be periodically
monitored in this basin and transmitted to the County Planning Department.
The boat ramp', which was not part of the approved Final Major Development Plans,
may require review by the Zoning Board pursuant to Section 6-238(c) of the
County Code.
RECOMMENDATION:
Approval with the following conditions:
1) mangroves to be preserved outside channel areas;
2) reference markers for "Limits of Work" be placed before
clearing and excavating;
3) periodic monitoring of dissolved oxygen and flushing
times is recommended.
Attachments:
County Application Form
Plans (2 sheets)
Previous report dated October 22, 1982 (3 sheets)
FDER report (5 sheets)
FDER permit (2 sheets)
ACOE permit (2 sheets)
"""~'","" E ---/~.H'--~~~-'~:\ ~~~:~.~- "'1) .,. \., I \,' '! I' \1''" ': ',~ !'i pHI 'I'I'J I .1'!; (VI 1.'('1'
':Ui,,';y' ~.f'..'..dl.t~\ ':'.{..\".". 1(\':..:lp. :"!r(1sr! (Y [:fl..: ,..!.!'~!'\r'(-[1'!\\1 .... T lr..l' I'. -TF
~......__.__ ._... I~~"_ .::'::-.-:--'~\L'I'l \.';I:S 1'1: "(~"JI(lr-TT"'~.2....._-------
(ii'" .~.. (;\\neL 1,.:;"(' r, ,<Ii j ir:'~ a(l(lrc,:;s .' i 1':lt(' c;) P),on(' mrrnr-er
Charles Rosenberg and Ira Sochet
P.O. 430756
S. Hiami, Fl. 33143
3-28-83
('nt1':lC: or or
:!<':l'rlt's n:une, mallini: :,tldrcss,
I
I,
plwflC r; Cl'rt i I. i c!t i (in flt ITnl'cr .
H.E. Rhodus
P.O. 256
Islamorada, Fl. 33036
- ~,. ----_.
'(':.;:11 d('~cripti on of prOpt'rty:
;cction, 28
,uh11srip, 63S
F.,rngc, 17E
(if acreage)
Vey, Upper Matecumbe ~lIhljvision,
Bay Hannnock
Jot, Plock,
onlng,
Street, ,'r):Jd or mil" 1I':Ir):cr,
11c:~crihe the propose(l actjvity, methods of constructjon r~ ,unollnt of rnnteriCl1 (in cuhic YClrcs),
to he exeav3ted or disc}'arged. Descrihe purpcse f, intcnded use of project.
Boat Basin (As per attached plans)
dredged /exclvatf'd
fj~lerl/~er9sjted
, I ume of
I ('r i :IJ
. 266 c.y.
waten~'(lrd
of ~'.!f.I'.r.
12 743 c . y.
1 :~l(1W;mr
of p.!!.!".
c.y.
\Vat envarcl
or ~'. f'. \".
c.v.
1 an(~wm=rr '
o f' ~ f . " .1': .
N:lIlle, ::lddrcss r = iI' cede ('f c1c1j oininl' pr0p('rty (lhl!Crs \.;hnsv prq1cny :Irr,.onts \vater \\'(JV.
1. Floyd C. Russell, Etux; Post Office Box 963, Islamorada, Fl. 33036
2. R.G. Warren Russell, Etux; Post Office Box 44, Islamorada, Fl. 33036
3. Monroe County; Monroe County Building Department, Public Services Building, Wing II,
Stock Island, Key West, Fl; 33040
:!) J ist other permits issued and/or Jpplie(l for, ine 111de ;!f1n 1 icant 's naJ'w, ~(1r ths site:
See enclosed ACOE,FDER and USCG permits
b) If applicotioo }1c.5 neen sul:mittcd for this pro.ieet (or ope similar) in t1--e 1'(15t,
explain re<lson for ne\v application ;md give ;1j~p1 icmt ':; n:U!1C i r \1i rfcrent from current
applicant.
N/A
I ist all fe
. tate agencles t at ave recel\'ec; app lCDt 1 ellS
proJ ect .
Florida Department of Environmental Regulation
111is complete applIcati on 01111 wi 11 le 3ccanpmlle(
following, or it ,\'ill r-:rr he processed.
, Two (2) sets of drawings, on 81:2 x 11 pClper, sno\ving loc]tion, plot p13n, tor view anel
cross section of proposal, drawn to sC;:11e.
''PplicJtion precessing fee as folloh's:
$75.00 for dredge, fil1, dcd:s Cl' any structures 3ffronting natura] water bodies.
$30.00 for vertical sea\.;alls onman-mane rmjes or h':lter.
$75.00 for any canbination of the ahove activities )ler site.
':1)11ication is hereh\' m:Jde for ;J pcnnit to ;Iutl'ori::c th' :ICt ivi! iv:; dc:;crihcd J'erein. T
"rLfy t!~:1t I : Dr' fami1jar with the infonnation cc))ltainc(1 il' t)lis :l!'J'lieation, nnd to tl1e h'st
,: ITl;: kJ1O\vlcd~:e I; ]'c1ief sllcn infonnation is trllc, cnrllr']ctc :; :1CCllr:Jte. 1 !'urth:-r certify t1:(1t
possess the ;Ililhurit;. to 1IIldC'l'Ll~C t)'e I'r<iposc,! :,,-: i\;1 ;~'.. .I'll prl)\'::. ;(~rL. ni' l:n.:s ;1Jl(1
rrdin3I1ecs govcrning ths t)11C' of h'Ork h'i11 he conJ11ic,! hitl, \,,)'ct1('r spec-ii-icel rercjn or not.
'r:mtjng of a pen:1it does not preSlu11t' to give ulIt1:orit;: to \.jo]:11c r cmcel th.' I~rovisjons Of
iil" COllllty, st:1te or federal 1:11\. 1'C,\.:,'111:1t in:~ canst - ct i en or i'cr. n:;l"ce of c(lnstnlcti on cf ths
\pe of Lie i 1 j t:: . , .
~-2!:-.Ytd_ ~_~_ _____~_
. ]'.'l1:ltllr:' ;t~~r'!'] 1''':Ult/;I:.~ent
j-e e. jJ Ovt Cd u./ / f-/t
O:frt' i I <IY1C~ / . Ct///"C4;% h_
I- e (I receipt ::
~ ~ cY.3 /-;:nc...~
"n'e
'I' 1Il,t>:lrtl11l'l1t 11se enl\)
---.----'-------.----------- ---_-4.-
I';lte
--------
\-rson accept ing :lpI'l ie;1t ion f!
Dat ('
:'l'prt)\'cd hy J's~~ 't. T)irector
c():~ tor penn i 1
r,~t il'l:!t('C1 cost or COI's1TlICt j on
'~'YF l:M~~Lbj~'~~)"/:.~'/.l~'/:~' ./~ ",
T II IIII '1:-
!I II' I,~il~
I Jilt. 1.\ .11
II (1;1 '111'\ I, i~!~
I '11I.1lli1/./1 ~f.:~
: 1:11111.~ Jt!
\ ;1 ~ : I I
~~ I'~;: I' I
olIO oil '
.~ I I r: II I
f:~ \ 'i : I
" I I II I'
~~ ! ; I I'
.,,,, 1'111
~~ \, II
<z. I I I' I'
I' , 1 .
r 'I
\ II
,; I I'
I'll I
III I I
1 -....--
1.,1 t!''''' ~~'.
j __ iJ!p'
1)
r
l>
Z
o
'1
:u
o
o
o
o
^
to
II
,
o
E_ ac. JU II
-.., 00 ~
.IJ ~(/) ., t Z
!o ' . a
" .. 0 I
If CI'I , ~.. .
~ . "
~- -t .!. L.. a t
0_ z, 0 t
a. 0 U 0
0111 ..t 0
.. zC ~ 0( ~
-4 oX 0
ilia iO
III" 0
-.. .. t
~-4 ..c.
a;V t
C
II G z
milt -i
~ III
, . 0(
!! I' ' !
I III J 0
II - I .
!! :: .
0
'.
/
/
'.
~.
.~
..
....
........
0.
ClIPL.
~1~~i!l>~~
1IC\-r:-.r4-l
~Z~"'('\II",
~z:~:S:r-()P"
J> ~-T.
r.'lI' Jir..-,lC!
Ii'ClnQI1IOr_Jl\
)J 0' t:/1Il>
~rt"tiiifJ z
..:10:1;)10)01 '"
.., r. 1. 'II - ~ 1:
,.~rll'~7.Il-
Jlf_pJllWtli'
, T-l>1I'2C,!l.I:
. "~P ,,!Co
~~'-~ ~~ ' \
~-_._._-_.
.........T ...., -
~,
.1'''
X oj." · OJ
0" .. " i
r'l , to \I 0
,,~.. .
0;: .. \I "
. '" ... l>
~ . ~
g 1\ f.
, . . , ~
' t
J,f1~=
'I." ~,
oC ~. '2 ,.
"0 . , - OJ ,
p ~ ~:
II \I l>
".!'.. I,
r:~=" (f)
~1lI ..
, ." II
= . ., ~ , - ,
~ .. f\ ~ Z
"....."
r i 0 r
p ~ -l ~ ,
j Oil r.
OflZ: l> tr r.Il""
~ " . , ~ ~,,~ ~
( i. -< "~"h)> ,
IO~'~ ""1\1" \
/l:"~~ 0 "l~'" .. ~
- !: I" /'
l' ~ ~ p -.
IP ~ ; ~ . C :;;~, "." r.
~ ~ ~ .. t II" "
. . . . ~ ".. \~ljI""
1.... 0 ~ \ ..;;:r..al~",.... '~l
.. .. 0 ~ . (111I1~
, 1 ~ I e.-- '-"~-4:
~ ~" I is
" 'In
. '" Ill. ;--::. L~! ~!!~;-..
. " - ,. 7 ~,..
I & ~ ~ ~Vi~~
.. II It ~
II '<l -iL.~
" ,. I\) 'J r~J .
~ ~ \ \''''~I -t'-'- .
@ 0
!I , l~ r ---i - ...i... , ---.1
II
~ S ~ .....G.. AT ,.....
~ '-.~ ~ L +
,
I
I
o
"
"
..
...
..,
i
"
t1
,.
(
/)
,.
/
.-......
:1
I /
_Ii '~
~ g .'11
I .:10
~ - ~':
I /r
. ,('
't.~.v/
/1
I
"'-.. I
"k...........
'~ ...--...,....
i .
S
-~
- ,
01
~~
=:1
-421
~
......... ~....
.....
......... -,
.............. ---.
"..'.
@,\
~ r1 \'
~x
~o
~l>
,<
~l>
~-I
G-
,,0
~z
.
4
o
l
1""'0
~r
'"
~l>
ez
I"
,.
'"
r
..
"-
" -
- -
l
.. II
~~
rQ
'\~~
~ ~
~mS!!
!:~
~ ~g
~;:o-
-'O~
~m"
~ >-
~8:g
C:;:o
--20
' ""-I <
:-~" \ ~ -< >-
'~\\ ~g ~
, \'~
'~, ---., '-(\ ~
' "'" ~
''\.
~
1
..
\
\
\
\
,
\
\
'\
..
~
.
... e'
~ ---.....
~. --.,-.',
. 'a-a,. "'" ......
• n 0 Nl,Fl 0E Ai 1 P1._LNNINC, l<<1I1.!`1YC ;;�,;)�;(' nnFPAP11 'I:\:l' I'7:P'1 :t.PPIICA'1'f(': FOP
.,1 )i.1i�;91r Y r`"_AV-VI'ION,. .TFIF PFPOS_IT OF P-I1.1,, PP STP1'C11'r'L� IT[PS IN Tl'F •
__ • li,,', i�\'r r iP (Iv: ' -,,,,TT) • rN' 1•
roperty owners name e! nailing address ' .- __ 2) -Pate 3) Phone number
Charles Rosenberg and Ira Sochet' ' '`
P.O. 430756 3-.28-83
S. Miami, Fl. 33143
Contractor or agent's name, mailing address , phone certification number.
H.E. Rhodus - -
P.O. 256
Islamorada, Fl. 33036 .
legal description of property: -
Section, 28 . . • Key, Upper Matecumbe Subdivision, Bay Hammock
Township, 63S •� .Range, 37E -Lot, Block,
(if acreage) - � -
Street, road or mile marker, •
Zoning, . •
-) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction F, amount of material (in cubic yards) ,
to be excavated or discharged. Describe purpose i; intended use of project.
Boat Basin (As per attached plans)
dredged/excavated filled/deposited
afore of 266 :,c.y. 1:2,743. `c.y. c.y. c.y. '
Ia t erial. waterward landward waterward ]andwar�c.
of M.H.W. of r".1!.l''. of P.P.W. of M.H.W.
•.) Name, address F, zip code of adjoining property owners whose property affronts water way.
1. Floyd C. Russell, Etux; Post Office Box 963, Islamorada, Fl. 33036
2.. R.G: Warren Russell, :Etux; Post Office.Box .44, Islamorada, Fl. 33036
3. 'Monroe County; Monroe County Building.Department, Public Services Building, Wing II,
Stock Island, -Key West, Fl. 33040
a) List other permits issued and/or applied. for, include applicant's name, for this site:
See enclosed ACOE,FDER and USCG permits'
b) If application has been submitted for this Project (or one similar) in'the'past,
explain reason for new- application and. give-applicant's name if different from current
applicant. .
N/A
7 Iist all Fe eral and State agencies that have received applications .:or t i.s projec
Florida Department of Environmental Regulation
- Department of the Army• Corps of Fngineers
• This completed application form will be accompanied by. the
following, or it will NCT be processed. .
a) Two (2) sets of drawings, on 81 x 11 paper, showing location, plot plan, top view and
cross section of proposal, drawn to scale.
)) Application processing fee as follows : .
$75.00 for dredge, fill, decks CP. any structures affronting natural water bodies.
$30.00 for vertical seawalls on man-made bodies of water.
• $75.00 for any combination of the above activities per site. •
application is hereby made for a permit to authorize the activities described herein. I
.:ertify that I am familiar with the information contained in this application, and to the best
. ,af my' knowledge F, belief such information is true, complete FT accurate. - I further certify that
possess the authority to undertake the proposed activities. All provisions •of laws and
trdinances governing this type of work will be complied with whether specified herein or not. T1,
' ;ranting of a permit does not presume to give authority to violate r cancel the provisions of
' :any county, state or federal law regulating const ction or per - manc.e of construction cf this
:vpe of facility. •
`oAlnat.ure F appl icant agent Pate
or. Department Use C{tltir/ fe< /0G�- ( e�/`/-/z
. �c f, /k` 5,
.- .
. • .F ! . el receipt II Approved by Ass 't. Director
Person accepting application F, .
Date
Cost of permit Estimated cost of construction
' .
I :. • •
. • '''•
• •
•
• •
:
..,
. •
.. • A
L-IMIT5 .
/. - 2
•
i -4 ,•
• -.-- •
.)1•,---8. /
.-- / ----_25-;
i MZ
i r-
, -02-BIOLOGIST: APPROVAL 11/4/f3 •,....;z2F 0.,........„..„...•- .-3----1C :,/ „,. .. ,./_______io.
, .
/.. / r- ''' ''.Yr 4- ' ..:-/s . ,...• • .
AS, PER MONROE COUNTY C DE .
.. ,
. •
.• ---. \./4.::..---___-_ --;•.••-• ------,..! 4,...,6,, .- ,,..a R. --. . •-•-• b ,
reviewo by LL.c. .-:
• /0 e....
/ . / :j, ------!-- vc. ' 0._ -------......_•
// . .
..i:
1.."-.1
/ 0 ..„.... ....:?..wramvEsii ,...:; • j ----j•‘Alk.
-/coNc.77-24.- T tr.'.,.."` I i.7 . .1-..""rir..„:"Z.1., /............,...5„,...774M ' • :
• 1 /t,'
.- -• /... ' i • . -7.• • -‘,.... •\. /
• • !
..., ..„/ OA.' / '14. • '.." '
„,..is, Yr
a - I • , .to.1149..
. :
1.• /. ..... 0. .I.
.4= +1. r •
!
. c AT-Ail: -4 •
, .
- / • r A /N, 'v.,. ,
'B. ii -.1 /,' ;\;.C....+4?-‘7-. --",', . '.•1
\----1
/r•
. / a
/ - '•..4:I. '/6?
. NI, -... •' .-
• 'rt.' j•4, - ..
j° •40 (C-JT LINE ' I•
///0•.' , ,., IDN. „.., i' - • • l / J./ / Y ...`',, ' . •
,- •I;
*V-
-. / 0.07E: MEAN L• /II&N " ...,A/ A.V /. '•-•.. ;....° - -1- • ..
N.... ., . i ... • ea
N . ' -•
. / ..VATET2. LILE 5I4oV44 ' 0// v .., '.I;.;s
• .......,,eFt'Ael.;k: • i 43-
_at„.15.r
•
/ . p..,C.ota-roC12. _IKE+1.0:1/ -
- TI415 LIQE IS APPa0X• - a ..,• 0 /
A" , . V
A =. .‘,..2.t.4SF(.....07.4c) ri: -•••'-1--- -6 5.6 1 •
1?-1
' 0 / u i a
f 1..kkatigv ivtaki&izove /i -PI
// a 47 :.-..e....ie-i-Ea... 147 FT.2L1.::LA..A-
Ve.r.TH
ji
LW.OF SLAPS. t."-P._ -fl PER.LVT) 41- -.. --1.-=, 3-7—:7271..1.1
4
"*..."•.N...... i i .E--.L40M.1 SO' Lat.:pweep ' 1.......OF VOC.E,i. !T '
L:O.OF PILES. ...-...7 .... 1.p
1 1.......... '
.1..4 4 OF IA Ai....&.-z.c1.-E FRikar./ /
• / . • . .
•
.4 Fa=b..1.4 sr,
[ /•
,.....„.- -...,..J 1 / : i
r. . / •-•"Ilk - "--. ri•
/ -.• .
. : . . .
. .
:
. +4.
it. l'' •
+.N. •
. I !j _.42144R 8.
..., 1 /-'" ---- — ,
'.
• 4/ N.'••.... ... '
./-- / •.. i
S--S- I
, ill 0 C-.1
- .9?
._ . s---...„..... ...,i......N"....N.N.......„.N.
/
/"."
„
.. ..,
-
. _-- . t /
- 7- Nz
/1-\
,‘" 2 - . .
...,.., - . - •
. . ..
•
. .
. • '-
-.a.- -
• • 1 -1- ,, - I
• mac:qua:4r/
--1- cp,...E.40 • : r,...., L-.../.7
z!Il. - /
• _ ____ a.-- .
--- --- ---'• ••:.....-:" id• ... 1 ,--
! .,-_-v:,...,ii. Lit-IS _ • 1 . I '1 ----:-!-ric".7-49 45'.. zz" . 1
! . I I ! i ' I - ,, R a SER.y ES
/ • -.•..-.&-. •- : .• - O • •- - 4.--
-
I '
\I . .......f .
— .....m.e_s-„. VS.•.....-"-- ..."- - 2 .
0 2 .
! .
1.1,7m _-rt- I r :11.---/). Lamp,. 1
.._‘.7:
. - • - ,... . :/-4...2.--cUr-L ,- . '" ; i t
' -." ; 1 ; • il . 0 i 11 I '••••.-
. • i ! Z / _if. Oil . _
..., ' .-..........„. ..k.z,1. 110 •• ••.0' /
• •
."---- .
•
. V---- .... ......, .....• ammomm,
C
/ 1 I
.,' • '..."
..•••••: ''.... ------ - - - 6 S-Tlo-"..1 11.-+c a 44..•+••‘. 'YR 0. O.0 c.AL
-I275-r 1_,I.A.117.5.6-6( STILIP•---." - -. r:ra.E,Tca Fa.mvcarT 7Lair.r0P.P. ..„......-12., 1...oaq p [-Are t....-rmil."--..-
*.) • .
- 1' 2' 5' . 4' .1.- e.-. ‘•
. .
.. .L........,_ 7' • .- • a'
• !•I
.
.
'S.. -...,
••.,,,m-....,
-.....,
a "•••
A4.-------.
Ai.
et:
rd .
u
. '. .
.
_ .. • .. :
. - .. •
BOAT
BASIN LAYOUT
_: I.• I%ID.C.46.,XS aeou"LEV P E.M.A4.4.1u_1+4-r oF r F_amuc„s_ IN_A.o. owl ?A'.
(111111 1)1111111h 1.1 =2 0'
0.5-1-Er.s_ ao17.• . -
. .
`....,.
2'5 C O.. DO....I.44 I+4+Rs,T. FOR- MAC...Oa.-non IN:/OP.i...k••TraN-
'
_,. ' .
. ale-ft r OCR_ To P.IL.rt...OOP C.O.IL- FE12.•4 •- IR 4"FS .2- s rm G.r.e./...-rt08.19 •.SO'-
- .
.
•
,, ' .1"E ToMS On•MoTTO A4 . Q a ST=MA 1.101.8. A-La. won. 5 t..M..:!-E CT To
.../ ' - '• . .
- ' . .
• .• _. MOO Goa GoaraTT IZ.sit.....5 LuD 4...GGI.....710.15 FOR- 15.4.5.44 f. a VISO 100 C.Y. 1.
. . .
-
• ?.......4 41.7v2 WALK . . . - - . - .
' .
'
•-A 114-e... - Lo.L....* May . • . . .. - . . . ' ..
. . •- .
. . ,,r-, ___.• ItLe......11."-ltorrway
. :
- - -
--
-
. '1::' —— ----...,---r--------------------,-----_ __._ ______ .. ...,,_-- BAY HAMMOCK COMMUNITY
.
,.... _ _a-•-\— ! • . . • • - MONROE COUNTY FLORIDA
• z..4. —— ,_: _ . _____ __ • 1 -3 .,.
_ _, s, _in. • . uoTS.D ......... ....,...;yo
.---,.--.
.
. • - --..-. . . I 000 •F-1..D-R• ..........,
N.r----7--.......--rac .osr•z....:.z. --.... . _ . -
.• ' JOSE M. MUXO JR.
. ,.
.
• ____________.___...._ „4-,---:-___ --- 4._4...
CONSULTING ENGINEER 2313-3135, . ... 4 ' ••••••••••••....- =:- (. FEEC•AET 2r2Ca SE4.7-.0N - 9720 S. W. 195 STREET
...:
82-81-BBI , •Ic•••b- 1-0.:(•,seT ler ;_ave,.... • MIAMI. FLORIDA 33157- .
' .
•.... . ____--...._ .PLAN OF A C. DOCK I/2" = It-0 • , ...
..
. .., .
• -
-•
_ --
/
...
Pi -/ /
/ --------1 --- -1') y ..:._s_x•s-r,..:G C. 1,70 s..11Z...-",
1
I . :
I - ../ • .....--
/ / /I
. . 1 A_., / ,
1 in4 K_BIQLOGIST: APPROVAL cf94-9 - .,.. ,?.......,....,..: , , j i m
i • .0,..,..:-..,• -•••••:::.- • , .......fArf„. r I:.
i AS PER MONROE COUNTY C DE /- / / I r
• ,
• , ...--- so' .• -••
I
/1
• izz.
/ e rie.view-eer kv Ac.a
• .' - is:1'.V11,,,,i... .
, / • .
. f i ,. -- • . ..„......, ,,,, .4 ,/ .4..,,,,,... .... 7-E5
1 ,
1.
I ..... / • ./\ .1 .
4 4 4..••
/..
• I
. ,
1/ .- AI. . • .
...,i ...
.. . .
....t..„, 't -!,/ ••• -. .
/ • - :Ze ;/ • / -
•.' .
• 4,• // „....---<:< .. ,' •11, / // 10P_II:" ..
C .• / : /
II , , . ,C?. ,'/ Ve ...• r . /
. I ,C, -C• ./.., /
. A
a
/// ,—. ..1„... /
• ,
.• - ,- 4 35'41 z ,
4 /
.I iij t.4 on /
• •
- - i 4. I 7'
i , ,., .,
. .4, // i-
/ . . 9.E.FS• r....;ce vrs-f.
e .
/
• • o - 6 !/ , t ' ' ;fp / ...., -.11/
_ /
•• 5.•
./ . • -‘,1";;S.„'Afo. , 4'i2',' / ' i • / • _::1-‘• It •.
;0-1, .• ' ; . .51'
',..11.• ter..G' 4.7. 5.., Ice," ay g7/ - • . '
_._. ., • . -..._.,•
1 1.2
— .11222.2_vA--18E7- P.R.M.
..6 .........„.......,...............„..................s.
. a eter tse v-w -4 -,
. .NN......\......,........................./2i
. I OFFSET'
f . /
//
P., „./. ;
1 El 8 S• 57'W ,/ ,'''' !
I.
/ S
/ IFT)
I
f • ill
-
ry --,,./ ......" ..
15.
-1L---1--Tve
. -
---:4--------J':---
,.----riimur We
."' :.---: • .
.....O.S1
.........-C Pe.e..1
i --- .,‘ J . • / . ....- •
-
- • Zw,iitratt-ii 1110.11011111i1 ILIII.4.,}1.ryf ...... ...4.1l1.111111,1111•1 -, / •
t:
•
111 7.°1.1,_ .• ••.....•
.t --,..- /‘ -
/ /
/-....--------/.-
—...•••.••..---‘.... - ..--:i:.,
-• .
_
.,
/ • , •/ . 1. I ' / ...•-• • :,.. .• ,2.s•x •--_-t I i , ....."....... y•
••••111012 1 aysiNtigaivpitillii,,,iL li lll 1:riii rptj 1 .111.11111..111,..Ili a 1111......!...511.111 lerilli1)1(
-- , 1cil.111
. ,
75 I 1 ...-•'1' . . ,.; •
11 .-
( 'N 8 B.Ise s"r•E •
952
1 i
- 1. s lk....
SET Ft RM. " - •
• -"‘..„..0
• OFFSET EXCAVATION .
PLAN I" = 201' -
._. -
. tk.
.c4,v
ES 71201PG, 6-C, e-Le.vA.-7 I c7s4. 1-11,41e.S. P...12 -1.1C1-.P12.1211 IA Z.-Te-11-7 -
--
. .. • . • .
• • • . •
. • ..
. .
. . .
. .
. . . . ' .
. . ., -
.
. - .. . •
. ,
. . .
- .
' -....--
. 4---- .
BAY HAMMOCK COMMUNITY 28 SEC - ,—
- --.' Av--_ --- ---,.--- _...
• ;GOV.LOT I, . .TWP. 830.ROE.37E
-
. — .
FLORIDA • --- - _ •--
I MO N R OE COUNTY, 1
•••••••••• Li L11C0 -
M17 ..P.0-:—-----.--7--- -- -. - -. - ._ _-• . .... .- .-.---.--------—---_—
1..M., .........
. I mem 2,-2 JD-I.• . - awns . .
__—--- ..--..—---- ._ . -- _____ --...
.
. •
Jose M. MUXO J R. - . • _____ . .
..., CONSULTING ENGINEER 238-3135 • .
...............
9720 S.W. 185 STREET • ' - SEOTION .
- 82-8FEIB2
_
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33157
• HORIZONTAL SCALE 1"=20'
• .
- VERTICAL SCALE 1"= 10'
. . -
. - .
.-.. .
. .
. . . .
, • -
• . -
DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE
DATE: October 22, 1982
SUBJECT: Tra 4nrhPt and rh leG RoSPnhPr a
c3T g Prnnn� Rcat Basin_ and Road Constructio
TO: Alar1 T,Pssler, Djrect2ix _DEPT: Building, Planning and Zoning
FROM: 101\1-4".
Ma'CX L. Robertson, Environ. Biol. DEPT: Planning and Zoning
LEGAL: Section 28, Township 63S, Range 37E, Upper Matecumbe Key
Zoning: RU-1 (Major Development)
INTRODUCTION:
This permit application, proposing an extension of navigable waters, is to be
reviewed by the Board of County Commissioners pursuant to Section 19-111(b) (4)
of the County Code. •
DISCUSSION:
The applicants propose to excavate a boat basin of 0.60 acres landward
of the mean high water (MHW) line, requiring the excavation of 5,200
cubic yards of uplands. The proposal will require the excavation
of 133 c.y. through mangrove wetlands and submerged bay bottom to connect
the boat basin to Florida Bay. -The excavated material (5,333 c.y.)
would be used for roadways 'on the adjacent uplands.
The basin and roads are part of the Bay Hammock Major Development, an
RU-1 subdivision that received Final Major Development Approval from the
Zoning Board on June 2, 1982.
The proposed Bay Hammock subdivision plat has not yet been approved by
the Board of County Commissioners, as required by Chapter 17 of the County
Code.
The Florida Department of Environmental Regulation and the Army Corps of
Engineers have issued permits for this proposal (copies attached) .
Two aspects of this proposal deserve special consideration:
i
1. Violation of the Shoreline Protection Zone Established by
Monroe County Code. The basin reviewed by the Zoning
Board (see attached copy of development plan) is within
the Shoreline Protection Zone established by the Monroe
County Code (Sec. 4-18) .
The Shoreline Protection Zone extends fifty (50) feet
upland from the landward edge of the shoreline mangroves.
The proposed basin, along its northwest edge, extends 41±
feet into this Zone. Boat basins are not a use that is
permitted within the Shoreline Protection Zone (Sec. 4-19,
Monroe County Code) .
•
Ira Sochet and Charles Rosenberg:Proposed Boat Basin and Road Construction
Page 2
2. Water Quality. The proposed basin may alter water
circulation along this shoreline by creating a dead-
end pocket where the accumulation of debris and
pollutants can lead to poor water quality. The
Monroe County Comprehensive Plan states:
"Any project which may produce changes
in circulation patterns will be approved
only after sufficient hydrographic in-
formation is available to allow an ac-
curate evaluation of the possible impacts
of the project." (Coastal Zone Protection
and Conservation Element, page 36)
The applicants have not performed any hydrographic studies
examining circulation patterns or flushing in the proposed
basin. Florida Bay has a very small tidal prism; therefore,
tidal flushing of the proposed basin may not be adequate
to maintain water quality.
Concerns about water quality have prompted me to measure
dissolved oxygen in two boat basins similar to the
proposed basin, and in the canal to which it will con-
nect (water quality data attached to this report) . Water
with low dissolved oxygen can kill fishes and other marine
animals.
The data indicate that water quality may be a problem
in the proposed basin. On several occasions dissolved
oxygen in the canal to which the proposed basin would
connect was slightly below State standards. Both boat
basins were permitted by DER, the canal predates DER reg-
ulations.
The attached DER biological report addresses other aspects
of this proposal. The higher acreages and volumes of fill
in the DER report do not reflect the current proposal, which
is a modification of the original plan.
EVALUATION:
1. Shoreline Protection Zone. The location of the proposed boat basin
within the Shoreline Protection Zone established by Sec. 4-18 is
not a permitable use within this zone (Sec. 4-19) . The construction
of the proposed basin within 10± feet of the shoreline mangroves
would eliminate the natural buffer upland from these trees. This
violation of the Shoreline Protection Zone could adversely affect
the productivity and health of these mangroves.
Ira Sochi Charles Rosenberg:Proposed Boat Basin and Roaa"'Construction
Page 3
2. Water Quality. The data collected by me in similar DER-
permitted basins indicate that water quality in the proposed
boat basin may not meet State standards. This emphasizes
the need for a hydrographic study of water circulation patterns
as required by the County's Comprehensive Plan.
3. Road Construction. Until the plat is reviewed and approved
by the Board of County Commissioners, no clearing or filling
of roads in the subdivision should be permitted.
RECOMMENDATION:
Disapproval. A more favorable review may be possible if the proposed
basin is removed from the Shoreline Protection Zone and a hydrographic
study by the applicant shows water quality will be maintained.
Read: E %w /D oy e_�
Robert Dennis /
Attachments: County Application Form
Plans (4 sheets)
DER Report (5 sheets)
DER Permit ( 2 sheets)
COE Permit (2 sheets)
Water Quality Data (3 sheets)
ARTLALNT: CIF FNVIRorat,ENT Are ..T >> Lr,Tio?`T
P. -F:1II'I'' h[.y'I?LICA'i'i01J t PPP I�.�i
File No :44 i0:306-5E County 1,on'ro .. Date . 8/1.5/80. .
Applicant Name : Sachet and :oser?berg '
�:3r'.ress l'0 Iiov 403756 , _Sci ith :�I] ern] FL =;1 'i
Aag:nt ..(;lf :aUulicahle) TyfP 11 3:ci�ha: L , l.c� ,7C:c,Io;>y Inc .''
dress Whitehead St Key .Uesr. , - _
� t3S T ., 37E OGd�'10�'2 O` P'rC�]E C;��.: .St?C+�i'-,•� ( ? `�� _ Town sfli Zc7'nCiL
i Secti.on ( - ) 7'ol i:shit, i?ange
Local Reference : Island- Christian Sc1 ool Church , Russel Lane N ,
tr,r Body •: Florida Bay .. - .- _ ..
,vatcr. Classification Of Project, Area :; III •' Adjacent Waters ., III
�.iat = Pr'eserve •
No, but 'opposite' Lvc' rglcide National Park Waters'.
Jutstarr'ing. ';'1orida Waters : :rho
•C! .;:'smote" ins.pcct_o:, b� . •Richard F. r)urn�-is
Date o{ . Insp, et��z 8�14/. Or .gi-1 �. ^rl�ca� i oi1 . "es r.;c '
Revi red Application : Yes No. X )ate :: of
2nd .Insp.
. BiOlOgiCa1 r'ci Water Q 1C , 1 tv -sse .sr. . :t.
\ .Dc_,sc]"iptiori of Proposed project and Construction l r'. al�. ,c .
Qu_ntlfy Iea of project. 'wn ch e`:t+endS into W.tf:'"S C' the state
:ii iu!3 J G the submerge lanes 'of' thosi aLers
-_
ona1 ;c'r .land)-- a cc= - ncc i:n Se - ;o 17 -.i r; > .
ti • Sec_ion. 17-4 . 28 Florida . t'di i ri stic.ta.ve
ical features cf ao'-1 ral ai"t.,=: -, �1 ..me .S concerning
.tt. .t. 01 (le oo 1t_nf_ .off rI'1'?17�iit!T �T L' i `i ' s 'lS: tit
• L t '" L"mil_ 7a: t
ni st;:rical `acts about t: t: ui't_.
C Pio:)hyslcal features of s7Dcc..fic Title and
ication ;sr:t '.i)irl `'' _er and ael'r'
- �1avant 1]l�'•:OJ :LC:�1] i c't.: about 7-1:1
1). .'otential 13n•']?r-+' o :pro- i=C'- on .i nl- -•r' - ., _. Solj,r.`c: an water
i1 � nt:c . lc Ct. -
_ i s i:icG: G_at iMpact
rod" 11 aspect• q-±-. •.. ne L1"LJ&ct' . I _
�. SuL-1,,.jesticas , . - .. . _ i 1 ` , for ~Cd1r] Cat] OlS that _,,8` -( ^LC=.
:n].ninll.:i:
(, 791 -
•
•
• SO ,HET & ROSEN BERG
144-30306-5E
Monroe County Islamcn ada
Page Two
•
A. Applicant proposes to create a 0 . 95 acre upland boat basin and
create an access canal/channel of 80 ' x 50' x -5 ' through upland
- . and wetlands' into an existing canal/channel . Applicant further
proposes to enhance circulation in the boat basin by installing
a 3 ' x 20 ' x -2 ' MEW Calvert at the northwest corner of basin into
adjacent mangrove fringe .
• As the suhstr. atum appears to be (from 'the exposed sides of nearby
existing canal) solid rock , the sides and bottom of basin may be
_ . relatively smooth , consequently applicant proposes to place rip-
rap around the 15 .boat capacity basin at bas ., of walls .
•
•
Applicant wants basin to furnish boat mooring for r:Isidr nts of
•
proposed upland devel opmen•. _.
Ii • - Most of the previous development to the northeast along the man-
grove fringe/shore of Upper Matccombe Key has been S . F . R ' s .
. 'Southwest of this site a 50 ' x 150 ' boar basin exists . The
shoreline southeast , , beyond the basin , is _ serrated with private
break aters , docks and hit slips .
Yaterward of the proposed access channel and boat basin , an
eStabl.i sh d black and red mangrove fringe exists , up to 600' wide .
In the area of the -,-•rc-posed circulation channel , this fri-r,s;e is
• approxir:.a.tely 300 ' wide .
•
The upland , to the east of 'the proposed basin is ve, etatcd with
' Keys hammock Species , including , b-et not limited 1 o , gumbo limbo ,
poison.wood , cacti , stoppers , brazil i an pepper and mahogany.
- SeSuVium so , Salicornia :gip , Bor:-ichia sp and to the south exter-
Ive -Tawn grass are spresent j acen.. to the access channel site .
- T,;e owner of the adjacent property has evidently extended .ts
1 awn onto the applicant 's lands and has used this area also as
repository for lobster carcasses and trapping debris , as well as
installing and using a boat ramp where, the access channel -Is
• proposed .
The access channel is proposed t:o be cut mostly through the under-
- - e lying upland rock prevalent in this area . A triangii1.^.r area
approximately 80 ' lonc:, and 50' on the wide Side will be dredged
through: wet] anus . Five mature red and black. mangroves and a dozen
smaller Avicennia germ ;_naes and Rhi.z.ophora manti;.ie are in this area ,
as 1_s an abandoned boat 4 elc Dr) mu or:ier d(_Dris . Sediment 7 s a
few inehe ck over the roar: ] .� er }:al.,, S; ` -.r r_ r �i ., ,
�.- and
epiphyt-ic algae cover this sediment 1. :• _: .
The ,erect of the propce:,.,I upland basin i., t.o': :: . 1 _ eec •_aced with
11 , i;iT"c: Iia::'.11';o;:k ::hPr: i (.•:.
• SOCNET & RQSENBFRr_,
P44-3030E-5E
Monroe County - Islamorada
Page Three
The area of the proposed circulation cul7ert is transitional
zone and terminates in a mature black/re:; mangrove. fringe
ap,:roximately 300' wide .
D. The impact of this proposed project will be the destruction of
approximately 0 . 2 acres- of wetlands and transition zone with the
accompanying loss of associated vegetation .
The basin will , in the proposed configuration, collect debris and _
organic detritus in the interior corners , causing degradation
- of water quality.
As most boats will be motorized, petroleum residue will collect
in this enclosed area.
The circulation culvert will encourage the introduction of nutrient-
ladened waters from the mangrove fringe into the enclosed basin .
•
•
SOCHET & ROSENBERG
q 44-30306-5E
Monroe County - Islamorada
Page Four
E. Under the provisions of Chapter 403 F. S . and Chapters 17-3 and
17-4 F.A.C. , recommend this application be denied.
If the circulation and flushing within this boat basin can be
improved , the project would have less adverse impact and more
favorably appraised .
R1 IA1ll P. D HAS , ENV. SPEC . II
Date : Au i t 22 , 19SO
Read : ;72 5-2( ("0
� N DOE
RFD/dvo
For F-ovtin;-1•o Dlortict Oti:xt
L�aie of Ftorict• And/Or Yo , T o rddr .—
•
DEPARTMENT OF ENMENTAL REGULATION To: Loom .
•
To: Lain.:
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM To: Loctn.:_
From: Data:
TO : Philip A. Barbaccia FRO:": Richard F. Dumas0(2
DATE : September 3 , 1980
SUBJECT: Monroe County, File No. 44-30306-5E
Sachet & Rosenberg
KeyCology submitted plans for a redesigned basin (8/29/80) on which
the basin corners are replaced with curves , reducing the areas of
debris accumulation and enhancing circulation within basin.
Although the revised plans still include the circulation culvert , I
wish to defer judgement on this to a person qualified to determine
whether the proposed increase in circulation will outweigh the
introduction of nutrients from the adjacent mangrove fringe.
Therefore , based on the redesign of the basin solely, I withdraw my
original objections .
RFD/dvo
cc : Lynn Kephart
•
•
i(5 F+iv 7r76
•
ipi ENvlaoncy�tir�\
BOB GRAHAM
3201 GOLF COURSE BOULEVARD '— � :11 GOVERNOR
PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950 l � JACOB D.VARN
x
JA�l ��! SECRETARY
,if OF FLOC-. -
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
SOUTH FLORIDA BRANCH OFFICE
•
APPLICANT: Sochett & Rosenberg PERMIT/CERTIFICATION
c/o Lynn Kephart Na 44-30306-5E ' -
. 414 Simonton St.
Key West, Florida 33040
COUNTY: Monroe
•
PROJECT: Private .Boat •
Basin
This •
•
permit is issued under the provisions of Chapter 253 & 403. , Florida Statutes, and Chapter 17-3
& 1 /-4 , Florida Administrative Code. The above named applicant, hereinafter called Permittee, is hereby authorized to
perform the work or operate the facility shown on the approved drawing(s), plans, dccuments, and specifications attached hereto and
made a part hereof and specifically described as follows: to excavate approximately 5200 cubic yards
- landward of MHW for a . 60 acre boat basin accomadating 30 pleasure craft;
to dredge approximately 133 cubic yards waterward of MHW for a proposed
80 ' X 30 ' X -5 ' MSL access channel connecting the basin to Florida Bay
(Class III Waters) , in Section 28 , Township 63 South, Range 37 East, Monroe
County.
•
PAGE 1 OF 3
DEA FORM 17.1.122163) 1/4 (1/801
-• -••. .,;.,•,:,.:1,.7 ..-.•••. •-...,":•--'
• , .... -•. • , ..--m-i'"'"'"`"" "Fr- - . , ..._
, .
,, . . 1 v• -••••,-,p ..,,,,t, •C i •
.-
Zr --• •44 -4.7,-'4.,;V 4.'.fin•i,..'i::••-b;"-ri-•••••••k....„.4.-.„714 4.,
.... .. .1111 _...___....ww............-'.
- ••:. ‘•'::1;-••.•L. -;.•;-:7.--,•.••••••,',1.-,;.,-,• _ :-!.. .
, ,..
---- --• .--...----...-. ---..___. ....—
T.a......„,..........".".......'.
4 •' ' '
. •• '-.- ,.-' 4' •- --• -•- : '•-•-•,1;;;-•.•-•-..,'• ‘.'`..,;.•••,'?I'•'-'. 1.:-''';fkn'!•-••7• '--;t:q.rr•-.. '_...,..;.
• •• '''' --.• •4 1,..,4-,..,`.-,-.'-:"...."..S::-...,-..:,.';':.-c:=::::;,1,-•:.-7- 7-,,i-••:..‘sN't : '''•.f----'
. - .
. •. ,
: .. -I, ' ... •r'. --!'-` .-:••,•,---.4---t4 iief4tor
• '''' - --- . • ''•- ; •• ••'''•-•".-';';'‘''''-;:fs .7..1.-•'•:--::',-:''''';X-j:,;.`.:- '7,".",:•;:i.,,_1•,.'r'c;:.4,:r:' . '"-rr *.'• --14-4'.
' : :.•. •• •-. -..' ' 7 0:..„------ ___,----.;.`:",.., " .:-, .„-:::'. ...:7•1:.!.-:.:.."-::-.'4.r:,-";;;:::-:?.-:.!---_-‘k;`..:_-;"•;•1_•:-;'-'r_le.144--4 :: •:---p
,../
.1-.---; •:- ..,-,.,
• -
' - . : 7:--' ,-,,--.,--•\c.). , .-.• : •... „II:-,-,. ,-,..-..,,,,,.,.. .,-.-...-.-,:‘,.'&,,,,,ri..tj,,,r,,..r,reli '• ,4:4
. . . r-..=-_,--- --:::=7" \',;•.:% .. .. ', , . ...;,_',.:.:•,.... ..-ry -• •':,-",•:.‘:•;-, .:,:::,v if Al!, .t. i::-*.
',' . " : y. -.,'-,'•'....".'••'....'-'''.•,‘.'. 7.•',,;,;_;•,;P‘S'.. Ari .. ;•••.1.711:
i i I . j•-k
-• • • -- -.•.7-.••'_. .:',.,..! -114,:-.1:10.• .1. , i'".-1
• . .
• . . . - - •- • ..--:•-:::-: .:-.;.;i:,,•':'-',A.-:41-- ,-'4••: .2.2
'i- • '• . •
i • i
--, .,_ v.-• _ ....;..y i -.0-.1:-.„.'!,,,„);_._I : - •• • :-' .: ' .,•- -,A..-tts... '",r4.4; - -'2--'
.. •• , . •
.• •if y: 1.:•••t%•:::•, . ,...;
i.,'... ',') ••1 I.- -<. ''-.....''. ,', • " '
•
•• . '-;.•:•i').•:s? ''..',------- , / . ,• :.,-,•;:-4 -.2.,
. . •
•
• ' . . .... .
• • • '-''. - \ s, '•;•. . I•'','I .., i ,
•
• •, .,.-..'. •. \ ,2"-,-.. .'....' , • -.,..." ....y . . . • - -• •''•r.N..r-•;:c:-:•••• - ...-,... ,
• , `- --,i....v•-.;?i,•-.; 7.•-•;-.'
. - •
. , -.. ,.- ;''''••,-4.7.•-•:7- ' ---:-.
..•• - -.:-,...2••'...7,:*•-•;IF,Tt• • .''..i'r
. -_ ..
-..... -'= • :f.'.7.,!'-iii,f'n't: ', ;-:''....
•
. .-, . ...
_, .. .
'-• • - ,- •--.-;:.!!,'''',i'.i.;;7'..::7-•::•-'',,--7'1:":-.',-. ...••-.--'''- • - "'..--::;:''-'.-T 7--- ••.- '. 1, ..' •.•' .:--'-•::. •..:..,,:'-; --:''..,7:4 -.:47,-... ..--'. '.%-..,..
. .. . • ..:-'''-'. ., :;.;:::-Z., ':-i:;',S.:1')."..':‘''''.'- " .:!=''•-
STATE: 0 r._ -[..„,--i. . :—.., 1:..:, i; I.ft ?,,'.:r.!,:-.1...4.:.:r.,4,.:;,-.., ci-
-
' i -..-- 1..-. : ....t-... .' i % 1 +.0 r'L'i..-,';'•;;.•„-.'..?..ijr•-.J,.t.'-`114'.'''''PkIltil. '1'•-ri-r-t --- .1;,,.t.%".!
. . .
.• .
- -; '-.• • -.•._-.,-....;:,:: -..:-.,• '''..-: •-•-...':-:-',"-'-,-..re •. --.-..4-,z ',./....,.. ... .11;,;.'17.-:.A.s,'-.••;...lvil'41kiA:41,
. .. •
. 4 1,... ,-,.,t 1 ._,-,,... -cy,.....1 .. t. r,.. --;,.7..,•,.,-';'!:,•.--,"...ff ,?`...',-:-. ..-017tof_... - •• 4 -27,"114.;-1
* * -,.. • •-.2s. , , - • ''. il 4'.... • .. L I . .i r ...,.,-....:.
, . ,.. ... ,,,. .:..•,•„ .. ., . . ••• .• .......-::.-.-.,'•:7''::..•••-•'.• %"?'.,' '';''' -;;--_,,-7.5.- ...i..;:. . .,,t.- —1.-q;.,-
---11\iViRON T..4.dri i i\!-T-il_ r t.-...i..-..c.!,::u L.:-i, 1:•0
... , ,
jr.. ."- r,
. _
N.
.... .-... ..,.. -.- _
..!
•• •..• -,.... ..„.„...,,...-....„.„.„... .„ ;
. -. • ,: .....,--.:-,J.::-.-::::::;..- '..•-,..,,':.---;,•-•:-.-',..--„•;,.."-•,:;•:".-,".:-... .:-•--.••''...,....: •. - .-.•- •. , •.• ':-:-,f,-,.*.•::::.''..:-:,-......-'-'," -- • . . _..;_:-.......-.7.,..4.4- •.114,. .; -4-...,,,-,
i: . -• •2 -".:,.." •;•.,....;.•,.:....'..-...:i,.......t\,:; ,.,.''',...- ;;S oche tt ' &•,Rosenlierg . ,.....-..,:. . '."-; ..,.,' .....:...;•:•,, "'.--):41,F 3-7 it.''''..-i' ...- '"(:„._:;.•"4:-.•
•_: .: ....'s77.',-.1/4"- --;-.-f--4.....-2-i";";•`•:`•!,-.--•,;3:-;:•,7...,••••-';'•.: :'-- ::-:••; .'-'-:-."--"•"•:.-4-•.-.'••••• ...-"-'''77.43:-:..2•4:•':- -':-.:''?"..!• ..' ".. ',. ,--.•:..":::•:; '.'•_"--51:•71:" .,.•::',
.- ,..-:'. ,••••••''',:!•".,7•-=';--•-%rz.--,•.:':,,,•112.q.,::-:....-'.r•"-„-....:;.,.--,--?f.::-..i"..' I,,,:r.'`,:Z.';. "•- 'A. •'• .- .-".-"::. • . '...•-...' :.- s , - -:•:;1t-.....4
' ..:..,:..•;.-.7......'.*•••••-•?..'•••*-rr_.;4.,:.4/L-_,...4.:•..4‘.'....: i.,;.,.....'„•:::_:•:,;;;;„: ;•,::••;::_.:.,-,i.,, ,.....1,0-,,,.4.k, ,. :. P.-f„,:;•,.....4„,...,,.,....•, ",,,,..r.,.,-,, ,Asti, ,;;;.,, ... . ,,,,,Tc...
- _. .„••-. • ..••,,A,„...,17,. :,„!„..4,-.,,,,,..-:........--,,-,..-...:,:--i.:i...,.:_,:‘,..::-..„-,:•-•,--,-. :-.-i9-:._•.,..,:w.„1 ,,,......„?.......mg-,;•,,, .-..,..•-....;„,„..: ....,,,...-,,,-,:vrap.:...,_,.; „,„,„•110-1; ,.., -J--... •:
. -.,--,:•-:,:::•:%;::::•••• ::•-:-.i.Tz.v.1:•:`..-7,t.:":"::;',..s:-...,---:-:.--:,!-'i--i... .--.,',-.1;,-,Tie.:4:';':iL,.......,,,- -.A..•„Ams,?-:....,>,„rt•-__.4.....:4,:•.:-....!..,,,,..,,,,.,:rs. .,lf.,r;7,.R,:v._,.i.„,„,, ; _,7,4,-,.
• -• -...i.;;;I:•:--4,(,,,:',a:-:".-.';',ZA.-,-,,''•--..iyel,142i'',1•E•?:•„?;,...:iiie - •:•,-*--T-T="1:
. • ..".."-;
C . R. .,!. S,. ,
_.. .'. r.,,•....,':•.:..:,..-*•:._:.•,•,:,.,',..•.•.-'-•,.•--.:".-.:,`.,.'.,.....'.•..1.“!.-'•(,•-A•.:.,;;-:4?*:'-r'1':.4.:','..,:-...-';.'.•;e."p-!,••.••,-r...',,--::.-•-'-C'...',''1',..--'-•,•u-•••,.','••.•..ef' •,' 17o... 4
.* 1 ::t,4•‘:.'1,4,w.';,7.:.:t1..0,•5.• •,..''.,'.,'.,-'L.,)•'..'..-,:......:...‘•:,,;:'1..:.i.a•..,,'.4t..4",;L,•-..-1-,,%.•4,:‘A'','•.•••..•.t=-'1.31..1,.,,N:-4";,.;,..::-)i;-:'i:r,':-...i f,\.1.;.?r..,......-..1..i.:..:05.k.z......•,.-....0,.r.,..S... 4:.•g .'1.,;?...„M.:4..,.v_5..,,..4 1....,...i..:..!,..._•.,,• ...,-,4.,.F.:_•.,„-,;.7.,L'.,•,'A4.
..-.ER T • 41
•.,•..'.';''''..,•-•••,'..".;-•7;'7".;':-..i!y:::::1:,:-'', ;,••.iit''':
- - •.--.- :: !,''.':. •:-"-c•-•;; :•:',..v-.-,:?x.--4,..'•.t,'.'..,.,•.•,".:,.".• -:.: •-..!• -- •:: --:: .-r•..-,.,. - _ :-.:!:• •:- :..,:-.,.: ,..- :•......- .:-- ....., •,,,, , r:-.-.:.::
. . - • _.
....e.-,-
.
. • . , . .
.:: -.:::•'.-..-,-- :•:'.-.?,...-.-, "•••:-•''':!.;•- • *.; '- . : • • ..
•-, ..
• .. '
• • •• .-.:-- '.,',•%'.•'•
.
. ., • - •
44-3030G-5E
.,.
. .
. ..:. ,..,._ .. ....,.. -;••,..-...?-:.
. ,.. • --...,......, • ____ ______ ______ .
•
. .... . • .,., :•••••••=.„-..-.•-•.:,•-••• ri2:1-!...--4.
•
- •
• . - -,..--.•r:,--r.7:'I.), ; •ti0.-,C2::'
•, • . . . . .
• •- •'.' • - ,
- ' •
'• -: .'••.'•'•‘..•:•;•"A'-':,4el‘;`. :'::: ' 72-•':•..."
. • • • . . .
. • . ....
. . . . . •• • -• " . . _.'.. •,-.P',•`fi.•*441.Mri•r= • '•:'•`;',.>"‘:
.• • .." .. . . .
• "-•••" .l''''''•;;••••.•'•44.;'. t..,,,..,'-'-g .••:',241.....e.
.-
• _, •
• . .••-.';;,;',..,:e,..W7.11',-1,-.11;.i... -44"4; 2 -.:‘,.;i'sc,"
. .
. .
• -
- .
.. . ' 7-- r-:.:-t. ::: •-•:,
. .
. ..
•
' • --- •• •''
• ' .
. .-• ':::;, -.•; •-. - ' •--: : • ' -.' •:--'•:',-,;:::;.!-i; - .-;!'-':1- 7.
DA-'-!:-.:%::...)F ISSU f.• IFs•-!(--.'u.:--. .: .:r:i--- -:• ' . : .
- . •-• .1=,:-.:tt,-.--4", '. ,v:."-..--
. ..... •
- .•
' • . ,.. '.ir:::,:-:-....,. :. • ..":-.-..-.;.:.'
- . ..., .. . . ...• • _.•,....,--_.7-, . ..--_,,---r:t
. .
. " •"'",•••‘,...i-: . :—,..-.'7•.•
,- . , • .
npr_.1:::.-NP1'. 8 , 1980 . , .. ' .7;71).)UC • '''•-• •-':' '--7-' . -7: --...•
. .• • c_ lir): ••-•';'•••••%•••:•..147.•:•-•.,, ..
..... . . _ .
... --**P*.•-...y-..,
13h i 1.i.p :"-:. E d‘,;a-2 a S , " ..:...:!,-...,.„- •-'7,=•,?'',
ED A -i. :7... OF EXP11-:::. , 1 ,... .,. Dis-'-r:Lct Ivian;.--.).ger • -,
•-,--,: .
-. .-.-1„-,-.• •
.-f-.--"-____:----------.
(-7_, .-;•-- :,. -)• ...i.•:%,,,,, -11:F2"!"-"'•
_____,....ve":1":2, ......---,, --r,---...-a„....„- • ...e._,,, -44•••‘ ;*
•
•:./
,
- 3 anua-..!:-v 1r 1983
— - -,--7
.-.•:,....7-
...• .
. .. . •. . .• . .. . . . •
- •- '-
.. •
. . ,..
..--;...--....:-....1
-----
• ... .
. . .. . • -- . .
DER FORM PERM 1.1--! .2 • - - • . , . . • , - ,•- •
•
• , ..
•
- •
. .
-•
- .
. . .
. .
•
•
- .
•
. .
•
. _ __ .........._.
. F
823-0228 _ •
•
ul Applicant SOCHET AND ROSENBERG
•
APR 2 0 19S-21
• Effective Date
• .; Expiration Date (If applicable) APR 20 1985
•
•
•
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY •
PERMIT
•
20 March 1980
Referring to written request dated for a permit to:
(x) Perform work in or affecting navigable waters of the United States,upon the recommendation of the Chief of Engineers,pursuant
to Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 (33 U.S.C.403);
•
.( ) Discharge dredged or fill material into waters of the United States upon the issuance of a permit from the Secretary of the Army
•acting through the Chief of Engineers pursuant to Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (86 Stat.816,P.L.92-500);
( ) Transport dredged material for the purpose of dumping it into ocean waters upon the issuance of a permit from the Secretary of the
Army acting through the Chief of Engineers pursuant to Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972
(86 Stat. 1052;P.L.92-532);
•
Messrs, Sochet and Rosenberg
P.O. Box 430756 -
South Miami , Florida 33134 •
•
is hereby authorized by the Secretary of the Army:
to excavate a .6 acre basin and connect to Florida Bay with a 80-foot by
30-foot by -5-foot (m.s.1 .) access channel (133 cubic yards excavation below
mean high water).
•
•
.in '
Florida Bay
•
at Section 28, Township 63 South, Range 37 East, Monroe County, Islamorada,
Florida . '
•
•
in accordance with the plans and drawings attached'hereto which are inr, rporated in and made a part of this permit (on drawings:give
.file number or other definite identification marks.)
three sheets labelled "82J-0228," dated February 1982
•
•
•
su'gect to the following conditions: -
I. General Conditions: •
-
a. That all activities identified and authorized herein shall be consistent with the terms and conditions of this permit;and that any
activities not specifically identified and authorized herein shall constitute a violation of the terms and conditions of this permit which
may result in the modification, suspension or revocation of this permit, in whole or in part, as set forth more specifically in General
Conditions I or k hereto, and in the institution of such legal proceedings as the United States Government may consider appropriate,
whether or not this permit has been previously modified,suspended or revoked in whole or in part.
I'(
ENG FORM 1721 EDITION OF 1 APR 74 IS OBSOLETE. (ER 1145-2-303)
JUL 77
11!
i.� 1
yr(1(v. l c:l 'rl 1',t)SSC I I ) Nei t: )7 11—
t\. J 1�
( ).;i:t_;l (' ) il
� U�, " f�l �rCz7[.)� j_�- - [�'�) • ..1_�
.
7 "V
t• N 0 5.
o 1.. A. , • . •
T
• . .
.• .9
,. 5 ...< •, , . .
. .
. . • .
•,. .
..-
,--
- ---'
0 0
s
,•
, 1- • '3 . "', 'P ° • ,i4 .
....". • .:0 y" • . ., ' ,,...../
y,. .6 -• c› 0 , ,--
,
,
,.$ 0 •.
• 0 0 ..IA
. . ..'
V t' a IA '
.••..',., 0 0 •7 • ,.•
, A
• - ...,-
.
o 0 • ,,,•
.
. •\ 4 ,..s, ...N 0
. vet .0 et, ,•-•
.
.••••'-'
., e 0
„
I • .
. 0 .•
0 . _.
,
4, 0. ' • •
4A .e1'.
. .
• c? CA
1 C. f‘l.!..4 ,
0 . .s:"..,,e "....,•:' ' -T:-- ', .', ',,:,• i.',, ;'.'.. ..../..----: :...,.:. ,
e, J" ,..33,0 . ,•-46•4'..:••• ••.iu-',i.,l''',.,i.i'.••';?:'-c, ..-•-••••• '- '• ' . ..,.•''.'"'",. -C-..;;.4..""".•'-'' ..• - ;
. 1, \s
0 7 , .•41 4,,,,.,,,,,.„4„,,,,.,..„ 4.,.,,,• ., ,.4. •i-,w:T.,,.,..,•:,•,..,•?,,'., -7,`.: ..'' ..
- Lit far .'I 4.:7 St.1,°;',..,..'•••• .i. ,i'' .. ••''''''''0.,.'; •°':' ''1::•'''''`
IA 1.1.3 r •r•'=-14117-1- • 1•14.4""'-'1':'.E.21-'''''''':':-"'"qi''.'"-•'_ 'I —••-.'•"..-,...:1;•ir.-•"i';'-......7',
..S) v'•N 0 0 4, •.••. ,.• -,-;-"4-.*A.4111`,'I;:1,-.'''' ...1'• "•,-.•.,,.,. • .- .'-'.•,'„.', , ' ',,.. ••-' , . .;
..k 0 • •:''',,-.c.;.4.4:`,",PkTe. '',;'..i,:.' -,•' .1,.,.••• '.. -' • i,",."., , t•'....i 1....... :c•-.."' • •
.4 ' '.•', ' • ...)1,41‘.."
. • \
•,
\ ''tPr; A • ,. -f)tPARTMENTO OFtrilE. 1.!:.!. k.....
. , ,.....,..:‘,:-. :.' ,. : ....; 01....-N.-..,-,--rWeft1P,ir-r• ,..,..,,,.t:i.T.,,,...,,,,3-. .,,:l...,,q1.,,,-;.,:,..i.,•,;,.,.e,ri:..t,-,:;;;.,
.. . i. :, :. • .,-,15i-..-:,1.0i. ,;.-.?‘ ..?',,q,.)re;,Giv,I.'.b..;'..-----.--....-.',....1,;..."7.“-'''''''''•7',c'•..;,.'''''iTi,.•.?"'"i&iit''.., ;:z3'..;?i`....,V1',:,-N-'7,..
' -'''''' '-t.'''-', - ."• Aii•-::r.+1,7x,ia'''''‘i",' "'-4i;IrrA'A'i• 1,;;,,ttA ^,.. .';.. .,,:,,;:, ,, \
. • .,,,:..-•,,,..,, ,r-f .1'..,..,•:i60,••••,,/41;ne.,,,,••., 41..• 1 A , . • „.-.,„,A.L..,44.2./".', -• •hi...-•:,';:r •.--•:1.. •;,".•.,..1..••='•1'.,-...;-• '' ''''
(-N.'` - ,,,.•.,;e,..,-;‘,...:,',-,..:,''iti'l''.•'., );,';.r. (170-.:',,,,;-'4:f.7-'1',47,!4''41;614,01r- 4,04.eal , 1-„Li4,,i,,,v....1.3t,,,,,it....., .;...:.;,14,,,,.•.ri•'... 9i,ji.A'As.Y.V.A.:
•--__......ir'--. .,..'.i:''•.'',5''''":'1• ".1,'"'''...i.?ii-4*,',•.1'47.,,q;. .t',31-'•.t.**".**.t41.1.4 i• ....,.,..*-4..,! ,..., ...r.r›, ?.! tri, o.,. „. •.,...,••.„ ,r r = ...,. ,..1 .
i i r.,.„..1„,,...„,,,,I., ....t.i.,-.,7.....,!•••,,..r.-,,,,....,••;,-; ';'.1:4.'itkille 0--vii.:t..'• .-.• 4
• `-•--fer--- •;7.'•,"-":;:t;f0:6-:.P.1,:ii, r,:41;(4',-.;:,,;•5.3;..i:•,,',;';;.,•i•I,9,!:_-.14:r.':',f-416;10t,,A,t1fis Ilya izAili,.,,,..*07,,cov„4,..,,,• .;,;.,,,,,4,31„,„..7,4.,,,4,,,,-itv.,,,,,I,,,,,!,....,. •!..)4
,_.4
.., ., "....._,. ,, -,,,..,....„-„,,,:„.„,,,,, •'-'7-;•` ''.', ,- ,,`.: • .. ;-Ii-.....af.:4N 7:, • ' -..044?.pr,i, ,.,i',1;..t,.,„:1 .,;;r•P'`..--..- . •:;,:c..:::1,;1:-.,:;;AEL.?::1'1;,;.'s: :, t ,
. •:": • ..,.......-w..,„,4c..s„.„-Ity,..,,,..,,-,:.,,,?•f.-.44.,4'f if f'',F.IN'f'.1.k.: ".••.f4sti'•'.' i'a.. .„ "XtietkOW..!".i..`:0,',,iiii,•S'V. .-1 n i
. : !..7-t..!T-.:4;„114,:sz•4;...i..:-e?';,.;;.,.,,,g,!,1,....$,,,.,,,fi.vi..c.---t3.4-1:14,),..Ars;..•4 ---dt= :. k - e4lia'4,1.r.g.-•:'" ..:.I.:1 u -i.:',..,.--,, •:•;i,-... ',:,.'k,•••.•e!s.--.• -• . •
.. .. , ,..5.4,,,_,•,..1„.r.,,;:t,,„,,.,,,,,..y_,•.•.,-•,,,tlf,:i?...,5,,,,,,.;:,;;,,-r.-,'•,,,,. -.,;••_i",1,y_&,,,._ .. .-N.. :•''f,i-0-• ,V.;r-A,ZA', . '. •.:- , •1-::,•34=1--',14,:-.-P;:'..7.! .-.••,..;.: i:--.....'t
. ••: •'-',-.A74.4- 1-4.tert."..z.,.7...;);.,i'1,....-',',',::,`el,.,-,',",',?!,•••.:;4"yo.T.47 .7-kti, 4.114 1N, -Tvi,.. ,L., ...:,,f.,-.. . .. ;4...:...,-_ .:.., .‘,..-).!..tp,r,,,-..-:•!..! •,.....-...s.......,.- r-:,
*
:7, , .- . s-,,,,,*;-7,!..t.leccz,(it.:,.2,1_2..•:,,,..,...::,-,;1.,,-!.1 4!„.,,•:-„,t;„;,*•,,44e- ,, .,. ;-4-:,,,ir.,,,v,:::7.:,.or.i t--,44.-ii,..ni,.14:;:=.,k:kfzi.- +•„. :';,,,,‘ 2,-..., ,,F.T=2.........,.,p, !....:ie••041.ti:-,,' ::,.:;,. a :..,•;,,,- ' ' ..-j-'-7 ii,54„:3A4;:••:Zs•: . ',••-'4-'-', '',-.111i,lk--!',1i1,,'•e,ih:Ar• • *s`.,'•-•-'-'1'1,c4-4•:':•07.4:1,11,!t,i'r;',fs':=•i ,'':'41-4/': 'r ' , '•'''• ' - "L i, .. :••••,?
'...i...-; 1,E. ,7rIti.—Fcii::.c..?,. ).kh,t1-!,-:::;'('',.1/-\:\l,A1'.:"E,..Ar', ]167.0/,c-iT"1:Ft.; fi'i,13A;Sie.ii;:-.AT'1\If 7r):,,,, ..i.C;Ow...Ni4.4,1(...,E;CTA" TcOE'si':r;.L:.,ac ;i j••••••,,r1!:ut.:•11.,,X(..•'.,:;1...,:.ji.1........,".,:t.;'f ',.f._,...!)...i..c/.;:\i-...:/_...'-:.11
. ••• •.•ttrli‘,F,,i-..,,,,,,0.F00 r- r.fi _.u-; L! 4.....?.- f.- ,.. f. ; -; .., .-•.4....:f,:,i,`.•*..-.;Vris:-: •'.•±..J. t..• ,: .''':,•?..':,:,'"ff..7',:.:;.' , ''''''''''
:• .,",I 1 1 A-T'r rs NA r rtf-4..5 ...0.71!•15,_.11:,24;‘:.:if-.,.1W:..... .,..:1,.„.. ,5„,.,•.,: ',...:4,wi.::.0.-,..2.:•;;••• '' : •••
'•',. .F.:7.41TY'l;;-i ti;410 E 1 r.1.1 !'i F.kit,1:11,1 ic.r!.,yiti I Cr%i -,; v_...- 'I.''w.'4,....s -1.,-4 '.,,•• • -.--'''•f.,-*.4-•,.!,.i•••,:•.:•'-55 r - ' i,; :':•••••'-.. ..1
:,' • - '•,, •--%'•-•,.,r1..•;":-;1 •-•-,-1•',.... - -*: '7,, --..: ',••L d..:•;11.':;;:.1-0 .-• .NOAY 1 ....1 ,-,:ir .i.-.1'.:••-;-7•:°.-,j'',, :, :f-.'!i;ST'.:.---...!..J);.. ,ix., -;-,;!:,N 4.'.4.,;;;;c.: . i
. ,: - -...-,,--. ,...,.... ..,,,.,.:....i,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,,..:,%;•.;.:..,.• -:!..,..1.-,-...• .--.. .:.,;,,..0.; " --",,,,,. ••-,,,,, .,-,1,714.. ..,,-4...:,.;:„:,,,,,..„.,• . :.. . . ,.:-.:,.- c‘... : ;.,:ni,,,f.,r)A.,... •... .1.
., ..4-..,17.-,-Ir,e?...;. ..-p,-.i:::,,,,e;r1•••.-.7:".• ' '''• .7,'": .4. •, .r.'.'"••• -'...-., '". *•••••••..." .•`i.',•••'-• .'"'s.
' S.7:-:.•-.-" ROE COVA;i-ii..?,, -1-/ . .-;:.; ..... ;',.
t• A's! .. ,-.....-L. ' ' S...r..
. *.,
,.CEC..T...'ib1112.4..84.-;"';.TCY:iii$111:1):::6,3,:::§pUr. .}-I,;'•'4,1,1/A..1,;,..,NGE37..t.ri,„,•EA4...,,...;,..,,,,,,..f._•,-. - • ...•.g.. ,..., !1,,,,,i,•;,..?.,1,„t,,,,,,,..,., , , 4
•.,,4., ..• ., -. ...•,,:,....,.,. :'',-.`.• • '...-,p,..t4,041.1tr,",r2ri---1-2,11; ''‘'''' '''.'. '14 A V.'•-• '' 'A2 •,,t ' '' 'P."'" • ' **.1' • : '"'*'F' ()RI Ll, '---...'7•!1,-..., ';.• : .„ .:,..,. ,; .-.., ..,: ..,• .••. ••, - - :=•.:,-, a.-...' ft.,mi -1.ri 1S,0 • 'VI f.',Y.!.L. .•
; • ....u •. .4! .! •.r •
,, , •••,• •
' 1 '. • r r"-•!' "N I-- . 1 0'..• '' •'' l'''''," - -IL' =.-- •,..44.4.-A..--....,.•-,c,,.•'.,,:;,',;•:,:• -,-;,i • , ,•-•:,:.. --4,:,'00143,4-Z-V-Ii-,--:. -•-•. .-!
' ; , .-.'; ..,,-.....:• .i,J•'..1.. .1
• .
L-- - . ''''-'. '' —•c^C 11 ET.:;Ai,....;iN p: 0,45E1\1B..,v...7 G,;,..::- ...
I
r r.a.- ••••••0..
' Ohl:.... i 1..••,••• . ...•
' ‘..) • •C:(") P Ey.- .k:i\,71:,.. IlLi :
_...
. ..:,
Ps61_1T°H. BriOIAXM4I3;?7F51-60R.'-'1..t.AL::.f.''.;.z__"'1.,,V;; ./...( ;:i'. ;;..:11';' 1: '''' :
. • .:-;. ..),„;;;•,-r : --,17.,:.‘•111,1,,,.., -0 b,-, ,0 i:. I: ''.. - , ... 5''; '•:.:' ':: .•' ., ,•...4 '
_.
. •',. ,' •
1.'?3'.71 'P 2 1-°28 ..-. .':.'..i...f... t)..,5.'.''',.,....•.. , ‘,," ., '..". . ..' . ..1 7.7.r...1-1:-I:rt::.:-1,1::jirr,e:: ::•(::(:;:.,;::,.LL.::•.:,
. . • . •,..
:• , -. - ., ,. ,.';'• • 1, • ! - ' •••' -....•: ''''''" ;`C''''.1'•'';•:k ' . ••-:--: ' -.',,!: ',",.-..'"„ ':•'.`.J4jc,',,rt'!!eli.,:-',...1-,';•"':-.-•4
. . ., . ..i ...!.:-. .:•,,:,:,:-,..:,._ ,. ..• ... .., •.:. .,,,,:. ........-..i:3-;',i . ,.5:,;:;;:,-,.,..,.......,,,,,.. ...-;:.!....!..:i::•.,::,:.:•:',"4„::-,.;.;;;'. ,,-;:.:‘,-;.00,.-:;•:....;,?..i i-.,.:;..":,'..r,:...i..t.'l .
1 " •.;. . • !!:.,.:!.'',:: -' .. • •• - •:.•.,'.'.-..4-,1.••. ..,.'..:, .443:61 t :.4i;..;..;' i,,,2,.-i4 i.!...,/ 7:•.=.:1:,-?,-,,,.,,...Aff,:,,t, .:ul tA';.y .
:, , , . . • . ,-,::,..:. -i.......:-_,,...,.........t,.i... .,..., ,,,•;;..., ,.:„.: • : . . ..„; •f„,• .„,..:12 -..! — • ••• • •'Al '9'''.Wii... fir V-"N”? .!'', •4 'i'•
i ; .• . •. ."....'. . . i; . ,:,.q:':,.C..•?",:i?.' ,. •,. .• •.?,..,. ,....,;•;.,[0.-;..', .:AO.1r••,,,,M-E,,.t,...::'• :••4... ,'e :•.'",,:•,-.±•1-1,`, :••12;t1.:i.ft!.?".•'•'-'.•'::r..•,',,t'.., •,.•"•,I.':1 r..:i.,,y:::11-A
;' • tt, .
4336 -.:*.i.,-s,if.'.',:,:.--
-., .•....-,i
•
, 0'. ,,Al't...•• `'.."-"fi ',14.4,4.,...-,r_'•0;610-10"...i14‘.7,14.;:tli t:''•ilt CIP0:-.i9/7 292..984..';',. i..:,/,„: 'T.,-•,.,.,
k ... Jul 70 ,....„-v,:yi;r:•::.;...,,,'..q,i',...• V,.'F.,..:::.„. , ;. .;.:...;•;,:.,,,,i:3-1-.1f4.2.•:11Vg.',.....-.7.1-;z•s-,.el. , ;', !•'•• .'-i,.-.1,;,,-,•••-'''...--:, :••• ' • '• " •— • '''•''' "•.'"- •
li I... I 111. ,, .• . ',;1".. iiiii •.....•••,-,5".:r.7-1.?,
'4Y TPIS NOTICE MUSIBECONSPICUOUSLY.,,,DPIA:LED, ‘,,.....,,, . „... .,. ,.,....,...,,,,.,.,.,,
, ,,,.. • •,,.. , • • .: ...,:,,,!•,..„,-••-?,....:::,7'''..•''''."...I.':*- '.."..•.:1'''•., ,'-'•4 •*."- ''-' ''' '' ' ',.., .• " ..:..,.... .. v.-.,.....'•"0:4...rmg "..drovne.04147MVI.,:4,i.+2•071,7,-:it'
a,, .. ......''v.,.e.ei,,,.00- '...44......0..1: ..- :..,rr V•'.1 . ., •
. ,- t
t.,
,r.,.,e•, .t 7' 1-,t.4...."..0.„,..... :40',.: •°4' ,
•
. . '
•
a ..
. .
•
.0. .