Resolution 209-1981
"
RESOLUTION NO. 209 -1981
'{HEREAS, the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY,
FLORIDA, has received an application from SCHARF LAND DEVELOPMENT, and
WHEREAS, in compliance with State Statute, it is necessary as part
of the permitting procedure to read the following Biological Assessment
into the Record, as follows:
The Applicant proposes the excavation of 1240 cubic yards of coral
rock from two existing residential canals. The northernmost canal will
be extended inland approximately 62.5 feet to a depth of 5.5' MLW, while
the southernmost canal will be extended, on the average, 30 feet, also to
a depth of 5.5' MLW. Also in the southern canal, the last 45 feet of the
canal, as it now exists, will be maintenance dredged to remove emergent
limestone blockage.
Both of these canals are 40 feet wide and will remain at this width
after extension. Approximately 1003 cubic yards will be removed water-
ward of MHW and 237 cubic yards removed landward of MFnv. Depth of the
proposed maintenance dredging in the southernmost canal was not given.
Silt screens will be used and all dredged material will be loaded
.directly into trucks via public access roads. The material will be
deposited in an upland area. Dragline will be used for excavation.
No blasting will be required.
The canals proposed for additional excavation are part of a network
of canals contained within the Tamarac Park Subdivison. The southernmost
canal connects directly to the Atlantic Ocean and is oriented on a north/
south axis. The canal leads into a deep water channel after connecting
to open water. This channel runs east/west parallel to 'the Atlantic
shoreline and connects with three other canals before extending south to
deeper water at the westerly end of the channel.
The northernmost canal, on the other hand, is presently sealed
from state waters by a berm on the northern end. This berm presently
acts to enclose four canals that are also part of this dubdivision.
For this reason, the waters contained within this canal should be con-
sidered exempt from permit requirements and any proposed impacts upon these
waters will not be addressed here.
Depth of the existing south canal proposed for excavation and
maintenance dredging is approximately 11 feet }~W. This canal is con-
nected to shallow (1-2 ft.) flats of the Atlantic. These flats support
productive seagrass and algae communities characteristic of the shallow
open waters on the Atlantic side of the Florida Keys.
Canal lots have been approximately 75 percent developed. Seawalls
extend the entire length of this canal.
The depth of the south canal referred to in section B shallows
considerably to approximately 5 feet MLW over the terminal 45 feet of
the canal. A limestone ridge protrudes from this shelf near the deep water
end of the shelf, emerging above the water surface in some areas. Because
of this emergent limestone ridge separating the deeper water of the canal
proper from the terminal shelf, organic debris has collected at the end
of the canal and water circulation is poor.
Page 1 of 2
.,
SCHARF LAND DEVELOP~'IENT
RESOLUTION NO.209 -1981
Bottom sediments, primarily organic, were~ two feet in depth along
this shelf, at which point solid oolite was encountered. Sediments over
the deeper portions of the canal were primarily inorganic and were consid-
erably shallower.
At a ~epth of approximately 8 feet in the canal a brown layer of
floc was observed while diving. A thermocline was encountered in conjuction
with this floc layer, indicative of anoxic bottom conditions and poor
water circulation within the canal.
Canal walls supported populations of Batophora sp, Caulerpa sp,
Cladophosa sp, and Colpomenia sp, in addition to several species of
ascidians and poriteras. Gray and schoolmaster snapper (Lutjanus sp)
and grunts (Haemulon sp) were also observed here, habitating the
incongruities formed by seawall construction. Over the shallower shelf
area not covered by sedimentation, Caulerpa sp was found.
The upland portion to be excavated is limerock with limited ground
cover. The shoreline has been partially eroded with scattered sea
purslane (Sesuvium portulacastrum)and white mangrove (Laguncularia racemosa).
The impacts expected from this project are primarily long term, the
-most serious of which is water quality degradation. The removal of the
-existing limestone ridge by maintenance dredging should enhance water
circulation if the depth is kept at a 5.5' MLW maximum. Further extension
of this canal will, however, increase undesirable nutrient assimilation
by increasing upland residential runoff in the form of stormwater, septic
system, effluent, fertilizers and drainage associated with State Road 941.
Because of the present condition of the canal, it is anticipated that
the following water quality parameters would be affected adversely:
dissolved oxygen, transparency, nutrients, bio-chemical oxygen demand and
biological integrity. Depending upon soil percolation rates, bacterio-
logical quality may also be affected by the proposed project.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY,
FLORIDA, that the above Biological Assessment has been read into the record
and duly considered pursuant to Florida Statute 253.124 by the Board of
County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, this 14th day of
July
, 19
81
at a regularly scheduled meeting.
BOAR~NTY COMMISSIONERS OF
MONROE UNTY, FLORI~ ~
By ~ c.. C. _ .0 J1.: cf/
'Mayor. , d_<_:
(Seal) n .~L~U ~U ~.f<.c:,r.Tf. r~ ;;rn'K.
Attes t : .m Yo ~~. tw .ll~ ~ d..f ~tl..~n~
t., '( ~m) ()\.?~
cr Cle
Page 2 of 2
APPRO 'D AS TO FORM
~<L~
rt ,.. a C-L t-~
A..~.CM'IN ' - ~.r-~
MEMORANDUM
TO Honorable County Cornmissioners
FRO~ 1;!1~ector
Building, Planning & Zoning
DATE
July 6, 1981
SUBJECT Scharf Land Development
Canala - Geiger Key
_ Your favorable action is requested on the subject per~it
request.
A brief recapitulation on subject permit request is in order,
as follows; and as shown in copy of minutes attached.
1. The request for the perrni t was first heard at the
October 6, 1980 meeting at Key West.
..
2. A.ction on permit request was delayed at the request of
the Tamarac Park Property Owners Association on the
possibilities of a bridge rather than a dead-end canal.
3. Public Works Director was requested to investigate the
matter.
4. Public ~orks Director has reported to the Property
Owners Association, and the writer,that the bridge
proposal was not feasible.
5. Tamarac Property Owners Association has withdrawn
objectIDnto co~pleting the canals without bridge -
copy of letter attached.
6. Reco~mendation of County Biologist's for approval,
and the writer concurring with said recommendation.
ffi)~~~ll~7W.. TIn
~J9 ~ -'\)1)
JUL 6 1981
COUNTY ATTY.
FORM IX
I
~l;~
.----' i--r ~ .~~-=-_
~ ....'L~ " .
~. ~~~". ;!-1t1~.
t ~ ~:~ '~. !:~~ 'D"
tl~~"; -. ,;!..Jf(~\~,i~..~
-I~'J.,I, , ~':'l ,,\lJ "i;~
-:V.;.;:r~7:"":i""'-~~"'~~.J?. . . \
1.~C'~i..v .", I$\is;::5".L;..
OKYV~:;~R~~'~04qE
(305) 294.4641
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Wilhelmina Harvey. District 1
Curt Blair. District 2
Mayor Protem Jerry Hernandez. Jr.. District 3
MAYOR George E. Dolezal. District 4
Ken Sorensen, District 5
Monroe County Legal Department
Key West, Florida 33040
OFFICE OF:
Planning & Zoning Dept.
Public Service Center
Key West, Fl 33040
~
I, the undersigned. do hereby attest that all data and information
is complete in the package of the applicant as follows:
1. Certificate of Complete Enclosures V'
2. Permit - v
3. Application for Permit ./
4. Site Plan ./
5. Location Map v
6. County Biologist Report v
7. DER Assessment V-
8. Resolution V
BY -f6c~a. ~
Administrative Secretary
DATE 1/:3 oj.?'!
( I
'~,/(. .~
~E. ~M. , rJT.'
"p..F ~.: ".,.. ... ~ .. ......
MONROE
COUNTY
PL~NNING, BUILDING & ZONING DEPAR~mNT
. PER}IIT FOR EXCAVATION. TRE DEPOSIT OF
FILL, OR STRUCTURAL ACTIVITIES IN THE
WATERS OR HETL<\NDS OF HONROE COUNTY
PERl-HT
NO.
-
1) Property owners name & mailing address 2) Date FOR DEPARTHENT USE ONLY
.'
Scharf Land Development Company Resolution No.
P.O. Box 1031 3) Phone number
Miami, Fl 33156 Date:
(305) 253-6166
4) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address & phone number
Same
5) Legal description of property: Tamarac Park, Geiger Key i
Section 27 Key Geiger Key Subdt'isionMobile Romes I
I
Township 67 Lot Block
,
Range 26E Street, road or mile marker Between Mars Lane & Venus Lane j
- I
-
Volume of material: dredzed/excavated filled/deposited
1001 c.y. 717 c.y. . c.y. c.y.
waterward land~vard waterward wa tenvard
. of M.R.H. of H.R.W. of M.R.H. of t-1.R.H. I
ZONING; RUt'S
Proposed Use;
Cost of Permit
Extend c~nals to providewa,ter access ;for upland lots.
Estimated cost of Construction
Approved by
Chairman
BOARD OF COUNTY CmmISSIONERS
OF HONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
Biologist Comments - Restrictions or Special Conditions, if any:
"Approval"
CODY in File Date
Building Official
tJLJ\f-L-: I :;~.. ~ 1 LU I ;JG /J /_C;~ ~ ~~G J~P!~RT:';[
~O.fP'tJ" fJEE:.ili MPPL C;;TIG:I F ? UC;,'ihT[Gil, Itlc.
~"'- ~ - DE )('5 IT f'F ., L OR Tnr '(~-':-l-.-"-;:--L- ( ~ ['/ I...... T""'r-
~ t,......" t) I J - 1 L" I I t-<\j "j J~_h ;\~ I ; l. t J
.;.,~ w, [~I -II'E '.lr.TC;)-~-()rl "!E~l f-.n""'--l;f'--'.~tJ"()OE (O'J~lT'(
-. j 11 ~ j \ I '. - " .J , \ ,~ '. ; "t _ , ,.J ...) J '" 1 , \ ~ l I
:.,.-.1) Property O\'l.ners name &maTl i ng ~-d-(fress----:~ if-O-J-te-- H___ - -- TO!=_UY2~-;~t~~:n ~_~~e O_n_ljJ----. -
Scharf Land Development Company B/ll/BO
P. O. Box l03l
~ami~ Florida 33156
MONROE
COUNTY
L 3 r Phone number
(305) -25,3-6l66
4} Contractor or agent's name, mail ing address 6. phone nUillber
-5) Legal description of property:
Section,
27
Key, Geiqer Ke!1
Subdivision,Tamarac Park, Geiger
Mobi le Homes
Lot,
Block,
Street, road or mile marker, Between Mars Lane & Venus Lane
dredqed/Excavated filled/deposited
volume of material: \. .
- lOO,3 c.y. 237 c.y. . c.y. c.y.
"laten-lard landv/ard \-/aten-/ard landward
! of M.H.W. of M.H.W. of M.H.W. of M.H.W.
i _J+--Name, address & zip code of adjoining property mmers I'lhose jJropert'l affronts 'dater way.
i Charles Schueleri 211 Venue Lane~ Tamarac Par~ Ke3-1 Westi Fl. 33040 "
iMichael Radlow~ : 59 Mars Lane, Tamarac Park~ Key west~ F. 33040
iJanice Klindt~ l86 Venus Lane~ Tamarac Park~ Key West~ Fl. 33040
iJohn Rossi~ 80 N. Prospect Drive~ Coral Gables~ Fl. 33133
: Charles Wiseman~ 7235 S. W. l26th Street~ Miami~ Fl. 33156
jWilliam Martin~ llBl5 S. W. l02nd Court~ Miami~ Fl. 33176 .
; David Slachter~ Biscayne Bldg.~ Suite 8l6~ 19 W. Flagler Street~ 'Miami~ Fl. 33130
This completed application form will be accompanied by the following, or it will
NOT be processed.
'-d;.1Jl.T1YO (2) sets of drawings, on 8~ X 11 paper, shoh.ing location, plot plan, tor VIel,
,<--O<-;'frrd cross section of proposal, dra\Vn to scale.
b) Application processing fee as follows:
$25.00 for dredge, fill, docks OR any structures affronting natural \Vater bodies.
$10.00 for vertiCClI seawalls on mCln-made bodies of '.vater.
$25.00 for any combination of the above activities per 3ite.
Application is hereby made for a permit to authorize the activities described herein.
I certify that I am familiar with the information contained in this application, and
to the best of my knowledge & belief such information is true, complete & accurate.
I further certify that I possess the authority to undertake the proposed activities.
All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied
with, whether specified herein or not. The granting of a permit does not presume to
give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any county, state or federal law
regulating construction or performance of construction of this type of facility.
L....X'-.
Sf
c?-/J-cYu
. Da te /
For Department Use Onl
Person accepting application
~ J::;O 0 -50 c6 S- IS
Fee & receipt :!
/JU~~~~___
~'bY I~ssistant Dil'ector
Cos t of penni t
Estimated cost or constr~ction
DREDGING PLAN - GEIGER KEY, MONROE ~~Yl FL.
LOIllGiTVl>E: 'aIO-3l:f'-30" LATITU~~: 2.10-31('-50" SE.C.'l.7 iW~OVTIl RGE.2'EAST
}
\ m - AREA 10 & DREPGED
h-! I fIillJ - cANAL MAINTENRNce DREoc,JNG ARfA
A
o&iLf;;.
cJ-i&j~~s
UJ
Z
q
-J
V)
oc
<t:
~
uJ
z 12.
.5
g] II
<C
~
:J
ct:
:2
q:
(J
~
z
.-
J-
en
UJ
Z
q C(
.J
8 ~
:2
lu
:>
/0
-r1it.1IlRI/e
P,f/I2K
'0
'ij
PURPOSE; DflEDGIf#G vpf~tJ1) 1;.?En
OA TUM 1 eM.. = So FaT
AOJACENT PROPERTY C;HERS:
. iCHI/RI.C:S $C.H lie let{ ~ MIC flAU. RAl>LOW
2. WIIII~'" MI11{riN , JOhN RosSi
DI1..,'O SLAch1e~ J"1:WICE. KLI~DT
CfiRRLEs WISEMAN
MI/W
MNW'~
~ -
MSL...:J:..
......
,.."IiWr-i
. i"lSL-=k.
.....
r: 1\1L.>V
i's'
tf--lWrr.___i
.. - DI~"SIO"'S NOT TO SCALE.
I N U;>~ND ,o.Re/1
AT TIlPlIlf'JH~ ~..ql< (G~jOEQl\ey)
COUNTY 01' MONROE. SUTE FIO;liM
APf'IL I CAT I ~ BY
l' ('ATE
;1. f'xfv4j ~~
e.
TOPS 'y., FORM
3397
LITHO IN U. S. A.
DE?ARTMENTALCORRESPONDENCE
DATE f8 Seotember 1980
SUBJECT SCHARF LAND DEVELOPMENT CO., EXTEND CANALS
H. WE tNKAM
FROM
R. DENNIS
j) /~!
DEP'T
ZONING
To
DEP'T
ZONING
LEGAL
TPSP 678, RGE 26e, SECT 27, Geiger
~tobile Homes, Gei~er Key, Zoning is
RU-5.
Ao"tic~nt wiehe., to pxtend two de.-d end c-nf>l., one "north")f St~te Ro-"'d 94'
::.t'!d one J'eouth" of Stpte Ro"'d 941 t" "rovide wJ'ter pcce"'" to home lot"'. V" 1 ume
,f m~tertPl to be dredged ~itt be '240 cubic y~rd" ('OO~ cubic y~rd.. ~~te~~~rd of
me~n high w'ter ~nd ?~7 cubic yprd'" l"'ndw~rd ~f me"'n high ~~ter)
Both 're~'" "'re re"identf~l. The nryrth cpn~t WP" found to h~ve clepr w~ter, p
number of loc~l. fi.,h ""ecip" J'nd the .,rev"qing Td.nd'" f~cilit:>te remov,-l..,f debri".
The "outh c n~t 'o"e~red to h~ve d~rk w"'ter the "revRiling wind" tended to entr-.,
~rgpnic debr!" (Thpt"""i~ ~nd Svr;n2od~u~). The Ipnd "re~ t~ be dredged i~ oreviou.,
1 ~nd fi 11 .
There p"oep~~ to be no rep"'on to .,u."ect ~ny ch"nge in the .,re~ent condition., for
either c"'n<>l PC: ,.. re"ul.t of the .,ro"""ed ~ctivity
REASON FOR PROJr.CT:
1. ~emova1 of coral rock debris.
2. Extend canals to provide wnter access for upland lots.
Recommendption----Aoorov"l
*DER AND COE PERMITS MAY. BE REQUIRED.
..~ .'>......~ ,.."~..,.~)j"!,'.J1.~;a:..~"'...~.
~FPl~~:a!So^.......~KUl.........KJ....-x~~...~r.Jl'll'T~~-\.".......... T
PEmlI l' ArPLICAT::-C)~1 APPRAISAL
File No.: 44-34036-5E
County:
Monroe
Date: 9/3/an
A 1 t '" Scharf Li1i1\! Developmf~nt
pp i:an ...2~e:
Address: PO Box 1031, Hiami, Florida 33156
Agent (if applicable): Gary Sams, Esq., Hopping, Boyd, Green ~ Sams, p.~.
Address: Suite 400, Lewis StaLL Bank Bldg., PO Box 6526, Tallahassee. F
j~JC\
Locati~n of project: Section(s)
27
Township
66S
Range
26E
Section{s)
Township
Range
Local Reference: Tamarac Park/Geiger Key
Watel Body: Man-made canal/Hawk Channel/Straits of Florida
- -- -.--..--.- . -..
Water Classification of Project Area:
III Adjacent Waters:
III
Aqu~tic Preserve:
- Outstanding Florida Wat2-s:
On site inspection by:
John A. Heyer
Date of Inspection:
9/15/80
Original Application: Yes~No__
Revised Application: Yes No X Date~
Date of 2nd In~p.
Biological and Water Quality Assessment
A. D~scription of proposed project and construction techniques."
Quantify area of project which extends into waters of the state
(including the submerged lands o~ those waters and the transi-
tional zone of the submerged land) as defined in Section 17-4.02
and Section 17-4.28, Flor~~~ ~d~lnistrative Code.
B. Biophys ical features of general area. Inclu.de conunents conCerni!1'1
extent of development of adjoini~g properties as well 3S releva~~
historical facts about the area.
c. Biophysical features of specific project site and spoil site if
applicable. Include identification of bottc:n types and any
relevant historical facts about the area of the project.
D. Potential impact of project on biological resources and water
quality. Address long-term imoact as well as immediate impact
for all aspects of the project.
E. Suggestions, where appropriate, for modifications that may reduc~
or minimize the potential impact of project.
-\
;:PERM 16-10 (Rev. 6/79)
"...-." ,
'~~flIl'1Il'>!""r'
~"'~-"'-........-.-..............'_. "" ..~. .........
.-.---.- .-"'.-' ..
SCHARF "LAND DEVELOFMENT
:if44-34036 -SE
Monroe County - Tamarac Park
Page THo
(Gei~(~r Key)
. .
A. The applicant proposes the excavation of 1240 cubic yards of
coral rock from two existing n~sidential canals. The northern-
most canal will be extended inland approximately 62.5 feet to
a depth of 5.5' MLW, \vhi1e the southernmost canal will be
extended, on the average, 30 feet, also to a depth of 5.5' MLW.
Also in the southern canal, the last 45 feet of the canal, as
-it now"exists, will be maintenance dredged to remove
- emergent limestone blockage.
Both of these canals are 40 feet wide and will remain at this
width after extension. Approximately 1003 cubic yards will be
removed waterward of MHW and 237 cubic yards removed landwayd
of MJnoJ. Depth of the proposed maintenance dredging in the
southernmost canal was not given.
Silt screens will be used and all dredged material \vi11, be
loaded directly into trucks via public access roads. The
material will be deposited in an upland area. Dragline will be
used for excavatioll. No b1ast~ng will be required.
B. The canals propo~ed for additional excavation are part or a n2~-
work of canals containeJ within the Tamarac Pa.rk Subdivis:.on.
The southernmast canal connec t:, direc tly to the Atlantic Ocean
an~ is oriented on a north/south axis. The canal leads into d
deep water channel ~fter connecting to open water. This ch~~~ '
runs east/west parallel to the Atlantic shoreline and connects
Wit!l three other canals before extending south to deeper water
at the \vesterly end of .. lV' ~h'1nnel.
The northernmost canal, on the other hand, is presently sealed
from s cate water~ l"'v a berm on the northern end. This berm
presently acts to e~close four canals that are also part of this
subdivision. For this reason, the waters contained within this
canal should be considered exempt from permit requirements and
any proposed impacts upon these waters will not be addressed here.
Depth of the existing south canal proposed for excavation and
maintenance dred.~ing is approxirlla tely 11 feet HLW. This C;.ina 1 L;
connected to shallow (1-2 ft.) flats of the Atlantic. These
flats support productive seagrass and algae communities chara...:-
teristic of the shallow, open waters on the Atlantic side of the
FloriJa Keys.
,
Canal lots have. been;1pproxilllcr.ely 75 percent developed. Sea.-
T,valls extend the l!ncirc length :)c this can:ll.
. ,"
.-....."l,'.~~V~,.I,y............., '-"- ~~ _........~... -~~~.......U"...._......""
--~-"'.....,...-- ..1OIlt.....___,.,-........~.,. _,...'_. .,.......""'..~.,.-..-11.._..~.,,__.__ __._...~...._____.__.
SCHARF LAND DEVELOPMENT
114 +-3L~036-5E
Monroe County - Tamarac Park (Geiger Key)
Page Thr~e
C. The depth of the south canal referred to in section B shallows
considerably to approximately 5 feet HLW over the terminal
45 feet of the canal. A limestone ridge protrudes from this
shelf near the deep water end of the shelf, emerging above the
water surface in some areas. Because of this emergent limestone
ridge sep.aL"'ating the deeper ~vater of the canal proper from the
~e~inal shelf, organic debris has collected at the end or the
"canal and water circulation is poor. Bottom sediments, pr~marily
organic, were two feet in depth along this shelf, at which point
solid oolite was encountered. Sediments over the deeper po~tions
of the canal were primarily inorganic and were considerably
shallower.
At a depth of approximately 8 feet in the canal a brow~ la'ler of
floc was observed while diving. A thermoe1ine was encountered
in conjunction with this floc layer, indicative of anoxic bottom
conditions and poor water circulation within the canal.
Canal walls supported populations of Batophora sp, Caulerpa sp,
C1adophosa sp, and Colpomenia sp, in addition to several species
ot asc1dians and porIreras. Gray and schoolmaster snapper
(Lutj anus sp) and grunts (Haemulon sp) <;vere also observed here,
habitating the incongruities formed by seawall construction.
Over the shallower shelf area not covered by sedimentation,
Cau1erpa sp ~as foun~.
The upland portion to be excavated is limerock with limited
ground cover. The shoreline h<1s been partially eroded \vith
scattered sea purslane (Sesuvium portu1acastrum) a~d <;vhite
mangrove (Laguncul:lria racemosa).
D. The impac ts "expec t(~d f,-h' s proj ec tare priP.l<,xi 1y long term,
the most serious of Vlhich is W2.ter quality degradation. 1ne
removal of the existing limestone ridge by maincenance dredgiI~:>
should enhance water circulation if the depth is kept at a
5.5' HUv maximuITI. Fur ther extcns ion of this cana 1 Hill, hOT..,rC"'c'r:.
increase undesirable nutrient assimilation by increasing ~pla~d
residential runott in the form of stormwater, septic system
effluent, fertilizers and drainage associated with State Road 941.
Because of the present condition of the canal. it is anticipat:e~!
that the following water quality parameters would be affect~d
adversely: dis~;olved oxygen, transparency, I~utrients, bio-
chemical oxygen demand, and biological intcgr ity. Depending llt:U:'
soil percolation rates, bacteriological quali~y may also be
affected by the proposed project.
:........ ~ .....~....,~ ~7"__"I'"""",, ....... ..'!'lP!JIIl"
~_."_...._-~ ~~"".Cf r'~ ____
"'If. !lI1CI1.IWteiS...,~? ~
"---~~"'JJ l 'I~""
~ .........~. . v
SCHARF LAND DEVELOPMENi
1/44-34036-5E
Monroe County - Tamarac Park (Geiger Key)
Page Four
. .
E. In accordance with Chapters 253 and 403 of the Florida Statutes
and Chapters 17-3.121 (7), (14), (20). (28), 17-3.061, 17-4.07,
17-4.28 and 17-4.29 of the Florida Administrative Code.
recommend denial of this application as proposed.
Suggest tp?t the application be modified to exclude the exten-
~ion of the south canal connecting to state waters. Maintenance
"dredging of this canal should be limited to a 5.5' ML~v depth
with dredge material placed over deeper canal bottom to decrease
existing canal depths.
,--... " ,r-- ( I
"--':'_.. (', { ~I ,\" ,~
....... " \ .. -- . '---1 \. '\ ,....-. ......:....--""---
JOHN A. HEYEf{, . SPEC.,. II
Date:
Read:
JAM/dvo
,~ ~'""!'-: .........,-.,........-
"....'+O:...,.~~_,~~,.,,,___, _
.......--.. _. ---~--...._-
'..--. ~.--~-..._-_.._-
. .-.'" _,\>"...
',,:w~,.\
.~. ',.;~t'~.2.i~r
. ~.,..~,t "A"
'. "~..~~~;
PHOTO 1/2
Borth canal and adjacent
proposed for excavation.
canal is not connected to
\Vaters.
uplands
This
state
. 'h.po .._. .._._
PEOIO i; 1
South canal and uplands to ~e
maintenance dredged and excava-
ted for canal extension, res:",","
tively. Note the rock obs tF!~'"
in the ~Qntc~ ~E the Dicture
the end of the canal.'
PHOTO :lf3
Entire area from w~~ch c2npl
be eXca"at~d as v-"'~\12C. ':"1.'"01.1
to north. State Road 941 is
in the center.
(:)......,....
:-) C I ~
TOPS ~ F~RM .3397
LITHO IN U. $. A.
DEPARTMENTALCORRESPONDENC~
SUBJECT
DATE February 20, 1981
SCHARF LAND DEVELOPMFNT EXCAVATION - Tamarac Park
To
~-ptt.;;;c;;Y' Dire ctQr
. . Weill am, .irector
DEP'T Public Works, Roads
FROM
DEP'T BI dg .. PI alllling & Zoning
In regards to the subject matter, there seems to be some question
as to where the project stands. Let me draw your attention to
the minutes of the January 13, 1981 meeting of the County Commission.
I have enclosed for your perusal a copy of the page of the
minutes of said meeting and have underlined, in red, the portion
of said page regarding the subject matter.
I will await ypurs' and the Commission's response.
Thank you.
cc: Mr. Kermit H. Lewin
County Administrator
ment of Labor and Employment Security and Florida State
Employment Service at the Key 1;vest Office until January 27,
!I
:,
I'
II
il
It
II
Ii
I
1981. The County Administrator was instructed to obtain
I
I
was instructed to research the contract to see if Elected I
Officials can serve on that Board. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Harvey and secondedll
a copy of the Consortium Contract and the County Attorney
by Commissioner Dolezal to adopt the following resolution
I concerning application of Jerry Richmond for construction
Ii
I' of deep commercial boat slip and incorporating the biological
1 assessment into the records per staff recommendation.
Motion carried unanimously.
I' RESOLUTION NO. 6-1981
II See Res. Book No. 21 which is incorporated herein by referenc~.
Ii Motion was made by Commissioner Harvey and seconded!
l
Ii by Chairman Dolezal to adopt. the following resolution con-
cerning application of Outdoor Resorts at Long Key, Inc.,
for repair of existing breakwater island at Outdoor Resorts
Inc., Marina and incorporating the biological assessment
into the records per staff recommendation. During discussionl
a motion was made by Commissioner Hernandez and seconded by
Chairman Dolezal to postpone action on this item until the
January 27, 1981 meeting. Motion to postpone carried
unanimously.
The Board discussed a resolution which would
I'
I
I
I
I
I
Secretary of Tamarac Park Property Owners Association ad-' II
dressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Hernandez,l
and seconded by Commissioner Blair to postpone action on thiSI!
item until the January 27, 1981 meeting and the Public <<orks II
II
II
'i
I
incorporate a biological assessment into the records for
Scharf Land Development for escavation of coral rock from
two (2) existing residential canals.
Mr. Bill Sywetz,
Director was instructed to review and report back to the
Board on this item at the next meeting.
Motion carried
unanimously.
Motio~ was made by Commissioner Blair and seconded
by Commissioner Hernandez to disapprove a resolution con-
cerning application of Safe Harbor Railway, Inc., for
l.
r,
~
~
- ..
1
-- j