Item B
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Meeting Date: May 16.2001
Division:
Mayor George Neugent
Bulk Item: Yes
No-L
Department: Mayor George Neugent
AGENDA ITEM WORDING:
Approval to submit a grant application for approximately $300,000 for the purpose undertaking two
projects; (1) preparation of a Master Plan that will identify appropriate sites for mooring fields, develop
the necessary management plans for utilizing State submerged land, provide for pump-out facilities,
and coordinate land-based marina facilities and (2) provision of limited funds for the purchase of native
plants for restoration of native habitat on public lands. Agreement to hold a public hearing on the item
ITEM BACKGROUND:
Through the Coastal Impact Assistance Program (ClAP) administered by NOAA, $296,387 in grant
funds are available for (FDEP words - "entitled to") Monroe County. The Florida Department of
Environmental Protection administers the program for the State of Florida. As the designated lead
agency for coordinating the ClAP, FDEP will prepare a proposal for the Governor's consideration and
submission to NOAA. It is anticipated that Florida's ClAP plan will be certified by July 2001 and that
Counties submitting projects will receive their ClAP disbursement by November 2001. Monroe
County will work with the Department of Community Affairs and others to develop a Mooring Field
plan and to obtain funds for native habitat replacement. See attached project descriptions.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION:
None
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES:
None
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS:
Approval.
TOTAL COST:
$296.387
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY: None
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes -K... No
AMOUNT PER MONTH unk
Year _unk_
APPROVED BY: County Atty NA
OMBlPurchasing NA
Risk Management NA .
DIVISION DIRECTOR APPROVAL:
Mayor George Neugent
To Follow_
Not Required_
DOCUMENTATION:
Included X
DISPOSITION:
AGENDA ITEM #
Overview
The NOAA Office of Coastal Resources Management has made a significant amount of grant
funding available to the State of Florida. Each County in the State has been allocated a portion
of the grant funds. Monroe County's portion is up to $296,387. Submitting a proposal (for
single or multiple projects) is virtually assured, as we understand it.
The NOAA program, which provides the available grant funds, is called the Coastal Impact
Assistance Program. There are fifteen authorized areas for which grant funds may be provided.
In general, these include:
~ wetland conservation, protection and restoration;
~ mitigation for damage to fish and wildlife, including activities related to oil spill mitigation
and contingency planning;
~ shoreline erosion control;
~ control of invasive exotic plant species;
~ monitor or control coastal pollutant runoff;
~ map coastal resources;
~ manage seasonal fluctuations in tourist populations; or
~ other related issue areas.
We would like to submit two projects for consideration. The first (project 1) is the development
and implementation of a mooring field plan for the unincorporated area of Monroe County and
the municipalities which individually desire assistance. This project would require the majority
of funds, approximately $250,000. The second project (Project 2) is the provision of funds for
the restoration of upland areas where invasive exotic vegetation has recently been removed.
Principally, this would be in the Big Pine area where a number of large parcels along U.S.
Highway 1 have recently been cleared of exotics.
The Mayor was just recently made aware of the grant program and the need to expedite an
application to the Department of Environmental Protection. Proposed grant project summaries
must be to the State by the end of the month. Approval to submit a grant proposal for these two
items will then necessitate a public hearing, which has been set for 5:30 PM, 16 May 2001, the
evening of the first day of the May BOCC meeting.
Project 1 Summary
In an effort to address increasing boating impacts, specifically in regards to heavily used
anchorages and liveaboard areas, Monroe County is proposing to implement a regional system of
managed mooring fields in strategic locations throughout the Florida Keys. Recent studies have
indicated numerous problems related to the increasing number of liveaboard vessels in South
Florida and the Keys, including: overcrowded anchorages, illegal dumping of raw sewage,
anchor damage to seagrass beds, vessels dragging into docks and power lines during storm
events, improper use of public and private property for land access, depositing of marine debris,
proliferation of unpermitted and unsafe moorings, and the ever present derelict vessel problem.
A regional system of mooring fields is being recommended as a management strategy to
eliminate these boating impacts by providing legal and appropriate land access, much needed
shoreside amenities and services, as well as a safe and secure system for vessel mooring in high
density areas.
Background
The Florida Keys have experienced significant development over the last several decades, due to
the attraction as a tourist destination as well as to the increasing local population. This increase
in growth has not only taxed the land-based infrastructure, but has carned over into the marine
environment as well. These impacts are well documented and are easily observed throughout the
nearshore environment with the proliferation of boaters from every user group. One of the
greatest boating impacts we are currently experiencing is the large number of vessels at anchor,
which is dominated by liveaboard boaters. Liveaboard boaters include cruisers (transients), but
in the popular Keys anchorages are predominately localliveaboards.
The proliferation of localliveaboards is due to a combination of the desire to live an alternative
lifestyle and the increasing cost of living, which has caused many locals to choose living on the
water. This is an unfortunate circumstance as these boaters often live on vessels that are neither
safe or in compliance with state and federal boating standards. In addition, the Florida
Department of Environmental Protection has indicated that the State does not consider living
over State owned submerged lands an acceptable form of affordable housing, and it is in
violation of departmental policy (the State has identified a six month limit for anchoring in any
one location). Furthermore, as local liveaboards become more dense in anchorage areas, the
availability of anchoring room for transient vessels has diminished. This problem has become so
severe that some cruising guides now recommend that cruisers not stay over at these previously
popular anchorages so as to avoid the crowded, haphazard anchoring scenarios, as well as the
rundown conditions and lack of shoreside facilities. This problem is further exacerbated by the
ongoing disputes between localliveaboards and adjacent shoreside residents. The bottom line is
that the number of boaters desiring to use anchorages has increased while the available
anchorage area and shoreside services have not. The popular anchorages can no longer sustain
the current level of usage, and associated physical and environmental impacts, without the
implementation of a comprehensive plan of management.
Project Objectives
GeneralObiectives:
1) Provide appropriate and equal access to user groups for utilization of popular anchorage
areas
2) Minimize conflicts between anchor-outs and shoreside residents
3) Ensure compliance with the Clean Vessel Act
4) Provide approved pump-out services at all popular anchorage areas
5) Assist with the implementation of 'no discharge zone' status for the Florida Keys
6) Provide necessary shoreside services and amenities to transient and localliveaboard boaters
7) Remove accumulated marine debris, including illegal moorings, in anchorage areas
8) Eliminate abandoned and derelict vessels
9) Provide safe and secure vessel mooring in anchorage areas
10) Protect and promote the health of benthic resources in and adjacent to anchorage areas
Specific Objectives outlined in the Monroe County 2010 Comprehensive Plan:
Develop and implement siting and discharge regulations, fee requirements, and enforcement
provisions designed to reduce pollutant discharges into surface waters from moored/anchored
vessels in nearshore waters to the extent allowed by law.
Project 2 Summary
The principal objective of project 2 is to provide funds to replace exotic vegetation recently
removed from a number of sites in the Big Pine Key area and other locations. The properties
involved are all in public ownership. The project is intended to accomplish two things. On the
one hand, replacement of exotic species with native plant species will restore dwindling native
habitat to the Keys. On the other hand, planting of native plants will keep exotics plant species
form recolonizing.
It is a goal of the Monroe County Comprehensive Plan, the Florida Keys National Marine
Sanctuary, and the South Florida Ecosystem Restoration process to eliminate where possible all
invasive exotic plant species.
Background
The federal government, the State of Florida, and Monroe County have all engaged in significant
and costly land acquisition programs. The purpose for land acquisition in the Keys, among
others, is to protect vital habitat for Keys animal species, to protect remaining examples of
tropical hardwood and wetland communities, and to purchase property made unbuildable through
recent growth management efforts.
Increasingly, management of these lands is becoming an issue. In many cases debris has been
placed indiscriminately on some of these properties and in some cases invasive exotic plant
species have taken over, particularly at the margins or in areas where previous disturbance has
occurred.
In order to project Florida and Florida Keys habitats it has been an outstanding policy at all
levels of government to engage in the removal of exotic plant species. However, as often as
management efforts such as this have been overlooked in the past, more often the replacement of
exotic plants with native plants has not occurred.
This effort will provide funds to replace exotic plants removed in recent and future clearing
efforts with native plant species.
Project 2 Objectives
General
1. Identify parcels of land in public ownership that have been or will be cleared of exotic plants
species.
2. After considering potential future uses for these properties, if any, implement a program of
native habitat restoration
Comprehensive Plan
1. Specific Comprehensive Plan policies reflect the need to remove exotic plant species where
possible and to replace those plants with native plants. To the greatest extent possible these
areas should be restored to native habitat, while considering any potential passive or active
uses of these public properties.