Item M10
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
**ADD -ON**
Meeting Date: Wed., December 20, 2006
Division: BOCC
Bulk Item: Yes
No XX
Department: Comm. Mario Di Gennaro, District 4
Staff Contact Person: Tamara Lundstrom
(305 289-6000)
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Discussion and direction to staff to consider non-resident
commercial fishing use of property in the Big Pine Commercial Fishing Special District #12 as a
legal "non-conforming use" until such time as proper revisions to the Land Use Development
Regulations mn be made to remove the residential provision for this zoning district.
ITEM BACKGROUND: CFSD#12 is the only commercial fishing district in unincorporated
Monroe County with a residential requirement provision. The Marine Port and Advisory
Committee is looking at this specific issue as a part of their recommendations to the BOCC for
Working Waterfront and Public Access preservation.
PREVIOUS lRELEV ANT BOCC ACTION:
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES:
STAFF REOOMMENDATIONS:
TOTAL COST:
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY:
SOURCE OF FUNDS:
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes
No
AMOUNT PER MONTH_ Year
APPROVED BY: County Atty _ OMBlPurchasing _ Risk Management_
DOCUMENTATION:
Included XX
Not Required_
DISPOSITION:
AGENDA ITEM #
Revised 2/05
MJO
~-
-
,/;4...'-"''-'
d~~C<{f,"'-""""'J..'~
:..,..t~ ,,-'"'-"
,/
;,' -Z) .c~~) ;?"
/ d~1 pi v; iLl (
Co ~~v'r, ,~(J \,1<L._-
/ D r -l::t- ,( /
L . r/ r-
1~~,
.-/~t>:I"'..
J-7J-~J-
~, I//,(/ /.1 /i 5 ,.1-
L____;-1",l"I....-. If
_.~--
t<lEMORAl1lDUM
- -
irE,
~ovembeT 8, 1988
Ron Stack
Code EniOrceme. nt: ~ritof.
Randy Ludacer 'y~ l..-.A~~
County Attorney
Monroe county Cod. Sec. 9.5-247(L) CFSD 12(1)a
nATE,
TO:
FROM:
------~.
I ha,re reexamined the. above-cited provision which reads as
follol~iH
"'Commercial fishing, excluding processing Illnd packaging
.ss well as trap storage and constnu.~tion by persorul other
dll!lll residents of the district I"
Despit:e the tortured construction of the sentence I hel.ieve the
intent of the draftal:' is as follows:
1. To permit commercial fishing.
2. 'To prohibit processing and packaging.
:3. To prohibit trap storage and construction by persons not
residents in tbe district.
4. To pend.t trap storage and -construction by persons resident
in the district.
The legality of these provisions I think is subject to further
.-.
..A_'_~;:;:'I\OII1li!"'l.""
- 2 -
exa,mination since t-.ho reat1d.c1::Lous dODal: apply to re.si.dents of
tbE' property. hut resi.dents wix'hi.n th'edi.striet. 1 believe this
is not a lawful. els8l!lificat.i.otl. for these p,u:poaes and 'I do not:
asc;e"t'tain any pa'!:t:icular publi.c purpose bei.ng served by t.his
provision. If the lIlXclusious of trap storage and cQnstTUc.tion
apv1y to all persons otbfU: than the residents of a particular
propet:ty I could understand that tb1.tl was meaDt: to 'keep it a
minor use; however, where traps can be constructed by persons who
arle residents of tbe dist-rict: and merely residents of the subject
p-roperty 1 think this objective is no longer served and the
restriction bas questionab1e legality.
R"" I.j eh
ec, 'Don Craig
-----.....--
'LIJID t)&VUO~u:ouu.'l"iONS
3-~~
b. De~ d_linaa;
e. A>- ] ~ ,....
(2) Su~ to the lk"yiai'J'\ ec a ~ C -M ..,..1____ ibIt
~ .. the cJjIIl:rict ~ a ...6"-....1 ~ sa .. ..
""i""'" eoudi~-'
.... A~ ~ ~ \b.at. - wt.al t]oor ldtlil
of ....,;......ual ~ b> . c:O"".-rciod ~ ....... t\il>-
trict. c- 1JDl; ~ ~...-w.fi'" ~ ...-t or tbD
laBd'- ia tba~ t\lihb>g...... ~
b. ~ .~. w-:. - ---~ ..-.
~ that the goooW and ~ -~ \0 or
su.ppo.~. -. \he _~a16Shi""~;
e. 1.J&bt ~ --. iucludi:A& usari1.'l8 repair ~
_ .~ that _$ QIlIIli8 ute UtIA' ....... \0 ser"f'll the
needs.,cthe~i fisbi.>C~'
(i) cFSD 9 (~,...... u.- M:~
i~
o,.~ ""....m~
-~-_._-"-
... ~. 1D"'~....="........nd " ."IP' gj~
(}1 CJl'SDlO~O..~r)f~ .....
(l) As cl ripi'.;
... .~,~' ~.1Ift"'~'P-"poiO..nd ~
. ...or~
b. ~.~~llinp.
(1r;) eFSD 11 (l,(r......l 0" OJ1P"T JI..t~'
(1) .Ascf~
a. ~al veese1 dodUnCo
b. l4anufty:tUl'fl.... ...bly.~. mam~ and ...
. .... of u-aps and ether t\IIhing eq\l~t.
....--'-'-....;):1) CFSD 12 ~ on Bill ~
,/ ------
(1) SubjeCt-to the limit,ati.on tbBt llC ..... sha1'l....voi.... · '1l!lIlEI8i
tha\.draWll ___ thsn 5i... (6) feet. lll!l of rigbt:.
1/.. Co~fi8bing.~ma~nl;tllDli~'
\,..l1li-" _tppa&arAP and ~ton by ~--
~ar tban resideats or the disUo}cl.;
floq:lP.No.U
800.129