05/15/2012 Final Minutes MINUTES OF THE
MONROE COUNTY
VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Final Meeting
Marathon Government Center
Tuesday, May 15, 2012
The Final Meeting of the 2011 Monroe County Value Adjustment Board convened at
10:00 a.m., on the above date, at the Marathon Government Center located at 2798 Overseas
Highway, Marathon. Present and answering to roll call were School Board Member John Dick,
Citizen Member Nancy Mayhew, Commissioner Sylvia Murphy, and Citizen Member John
Repetto. Absent was Mayor David Rice. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk; Pamela
Hancock, Deputy Clerk; Karl Borglum, Property Appraiser; Robert Tischenkel, Attorney to the
Value Adjustment Board; and John Dent, Attorney to the Property Appraiser.
Motion was made by Citizen Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member
Dick granting approval of the Minutes from the October 17, 2011 Organizational Meeting.
Motion carried unanimously.
Robert Tischenkel, Board Attorney, addressed the Board concerning the procedures the
Board should follow regarding the Special Magistrate's recommendations. Motion was made by
Citizen Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member Dick to allow anyone to
address the Board. Motion carried unanimously.
Luciano Alvarez, Petition No. E024 -2011 addressed the Board. After discussion, motion
was made by School Board Member Dick and seconded by Citizen Member Mayhew to uphold
the Special Magistrate's Recommendation. Motion carried unanimously.
The Board read the letter dated May 10, 2012, from Keith & Donna Golan, Petition No.
E008 -2011. Mr. Tischenkel addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by Citizen
Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member Dick to uphold the Special
Magistrate's Recommendation. Motion carried unanimously
Motion was made by School Board Member Dick and seconded by Citizen Member
Repetto granting approval of the Special Magistrate's Recommendations of the 2011 Exemption
Petitions. Motion carried unanimously (attached hereto as Exhibit 1).
Dagmar Lesick, Petition No. R086 -2011 addressed the Board. Special Magistrate Kevin
Talbott and Karl Borglum, Property Appraiser addressed the Board. After discussion, motion
was made by Citizen Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member Dick to uphold
the Special Magistrate's Recommendation. Motion carried unanimously.
1
George Scott, Petition No. R056 -2011 addressed the Board. Special Magistrate Patricia
McGrath and Mr. Borglum addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by Citizen
Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member Dick to uphold the Special
Magistrate's Recommendation. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Citizen Member Repetto and seconded by School Board Member
Dick granting approval of the Special Magistrate's Recommendations of the 2011 Real Property
Petitions. Motion carried unanimously (attached hereto as Exhibit 2).
Motion was made by School Board Member Dick and seconded by Citizen Member
Repetto granting approval of the Special Magistrate's Recommendations of the 2011
Commercial Property Petitions. Motion carried unanimously (attached hereto as Exhibit 3).
Motion was made by School Board Member Dick and seconded by Citizen Member
Repetto granting approval of the paid invoices for Special Magistrates, Counsel to Value
Adjustment Board and Legal Notices, as well as any pending invoices and the forthcoming
invoices from today's meeting. Motion carried unanimously.
Mr. Tischenkel addressed the Board concerning approval of the revised Agreement for
Special Magistrate Services. After discussion, motion was made by School Board Member Dick
and seconded by Citizen Member Mayhew granting approval of the revised Agreement. Motion
carried unanimously.
Motion was made by School Board Member Dick and seconded by School Board
Member Mayhew to approve the Certifications of Tax Roll. Motion carried unanimously.
Mr. Borglum addressed the Board with statistical information pertaining to the Value
Adjustment Board.
There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
of Monroe County
by: Pamela G. Hancock, Deputy Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
Exhibit 1
Type Number Name Agent Hearing Date Outcome
E 5 Linda Jean Boals 20 -Jan Denied
E 6 John DeMelo 20 -Jan Denied
E 8 Donna & Keith Golan Thomas Sireci 23 -Apr Denied
E 10 Jorge F. Hernandez 20 -Jan Denied
E 24 Luciano F. Alvarez Elena Vigil - Farinas, Esq. 20 -Jan Denied
Exhibit 2
Type Number Name Agent Hearing Date Outcome
R 1 Jorge & Margarita Pella 3 -May Denied
R 4 Steven F. Sonstein 6 -Dec Denied
R 5 Deja View LLC John Harrison 6 -Dec Denied
R 11 John Marston 6 -Dec Denied
R 14 Jose & Charlene Pagan 12 -Jan Denied
R 18 Stephen Pearse 16 -Dec Denied
R 19 John Maestrelli 16 -Dec Denied
R 21 Pader Corporation Trudie L. Fort Sanders 16 -Dec Denied
R 56 George Scott 26 -Jan Denied
R 78 HH2 ORC LLC Michael B. Willner 26 -Jan Denied
R 79 Allan S. Danoff 27 -Jan Denied
R 80 Robert Albrecht 12 -Jan Denied
R 83 Suzanne Miller 26 -Jan Denied
R 84 Petr Blahout & Radmila Brozkova 12 -Jan Denied
R 85 Scott & Donna M. Januik 12 -Jan Denied
R 86 Thomas & Dogmar C. Lesick 12 -Jan Denied
R 95 MarK Hohmeister Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 98 Conch Investors II LLC Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 99 Doris Pardo Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 100 Doris Pardo Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 102 Doris Pardo Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 103 Doris Pardo Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 106 National Realty LTD Daniel Weiss 9 -Feb Denied
R 108 Weiger Family LTD Jack N. Schlossberg 26 -Jan Denied
R 118 166 -6 Bayview Drive LLC Jeffrey J. Smith 9 -Feb Denied
R 119 Terry C. Pellegrini 23 -Jan Denied
R 130 Paul W. Boutin 12 -Jan Denied
R 141 Bluegreen Resorts Mgmt. Wendy Beck 27 -Jan Denied
R 160 David Greenberg 12 -Jan Denied
R 198 Leonard C. & Sally T. Atkins 27 -Jan Denied
R 199 Leonard C. & Sally T. Atkins 27 -Jan Denied
Exhibit 3
Type Number Name Agent Hearing Date Outcome
C 16 121 Duval Street Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 17 Old Harbora House, Inc. Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 18 126 Duval Street Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 19 135 Duval Street Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 20 211 Duval Street Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 21 619 Duval Street Mark Gunderson 2 -Feb Denied
C 283 Knights Key Corporation Louis Breeding 3 -Feb Denied