The URL can be used to link to this page

Item B11 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 in well developed subdivisions that were served by complete (or nearly so in the case of wastewater) infrastructure. The Tier recommendations made by the TDRC, staff and the Planning Commission are summarized below: Total Parcel Count by Tier TDRC Staff Planning Commission Parcels Acres Parcels Acres Parcels Acres Hammock Hammock Hammock Tier 1 525 170.28 373 58.33 367 58.26 Tier III -A 142 45.41 211 146.59 160 141.18 Tier III 2727 87.44 2810 98.21 2867 1 103.69 3394 303.13 3394 303.13 3394 303.13 It should be noted that most (60%) of the parcels reviewed are developed in some way, with a PC Code that indicates a structure or use exists on the parcel. There are 1,359 vacant parcels that were reviewed, containing approximately 90 acres of hammock. While the Planning Commission's recommendations listed above differ significantly from that of the TDRC, there are only 42 acres of hammock in vacant Tier III parcels under their recommended Tier designations. The impact on vacant lands is shown below: Vacant Parcels(excluding Public Lands TDRC Staff Plnpjjj& Commission Parcels Acres parcels Acres Parcels Acres Hammock Hammock Hammock Tier I 270 37.82 173 31.16 166 30.68 Tier 1111-A 108 22.97 140 23.82 90 18.59 Tier III 981 30.84 1046 36.65 1103 42.36 1359 91.63 1359 91.63 1359 91.63 The Table below illustrates the changes to previous Tier designations as a result of the various recommendations: Tier Designation Parcel Analysis All Parcels TDRC Staff PC Parcels Changed Tier 3 to Tier 1 Acres Hammock in Chan ed Parcels 154 88 8 10.77 6.81 6.95 Parcels Changed Tier 3 to SPA Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 119 109 60 24.1 1 21.95 16.84 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT1Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 5 of 25 Parcels Changed SPA to Tier 1 -jjQWNJijX.JLCelS Parcels Changed Tier 1 to SPA Acres Hammock in Chan ed Parcels Parcels Changed SPA to Tier 3 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 132 62 62 120.33 14.07 14.07 6 18 16 4.27 5 1 2.33 8 2.03 8 0.89 1.88 1.88 Parcels With No Change Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 2889 3016 3063 136.41 246.06 250.82 Parcels Previous Tier "0" to Tier I Acres Hammock in 0 Tier Parcels 13 13 13 5.5 5.5 5.5 3 4 II. Differences between TDRC, Staff and Planning Commission 5 Recommendations 6 The TDRC evaluated the challenged parcels with regard to the revised Tier 7 Designation criteria. The removal of acreage criteria from the Code resulted in 8 the TDRC making some recommendations for parcels that contained tropical 9 hardwood hammock vegetation to be Tier I and SPA, while staff felt in some 10 circumstances that these parcels, occurring within existing, substantially 11 developed subdivisions with improved infrastructure, were more appropriately 12 defined as Tier III in accordance with Comp Plan Policy 105.2.1 (3) and made 13 their recommendations accordingly. 14 15 Policy 105.2.1 16 Monroe County shall designate all lands outside of mainland Monroe County, 17 except for the Ocean Reef planned development, into three general categories for 18 purposes of its Land Acquisition Program and smart growth initiatives in 19 accordance with the criteria in Policy 205.1.1. These three categories are: 20 Natural Area (Tier 1); Transition and Sprawl Reduction Area (Tier II) on Big 21 Pine Key and No Name Key only; and Infill Area (Tier III). The purposes, general 22 characteristics, and growth management approaches associated with each tier 23 are as follows: 24 3. Infill Area (Tier III): Any defined geographic area, where a significant 25 portion of land area is not characterized as environmentally sensitive 26 as defined by this Plan, except for dispersed and isolated fragments of 27 environmentally sensitive lands of less than four acres in area, where 28 existing platted subdivisions are substantially developed, served by 29 complete infrastructure facilities, and within close proximity to 30 established commercial areas, or where a concentration of non- 31 residential uses exists, is to be designated as an Infill Area. New 32 development and redevelopment are to be highly encouraged, except 33 within tropical hardwood hammock or pineland patches of an acre or 34 more in area, where development is to be discouraged. Within an Infill 35 Area are typically found: platted subdivisions with 50 percent or more 36 developed lots situated in areas with few sensitive environmental WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 6 of 25 *vow I TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT DESIGNATIONS FOR APPROXIMATELY 2 NINETY-TWO (92) PARCELS COMPETING FOR BUILDING PERMITS 3 IN THE RATE OF GROWTH ORDINANCE (ROGO) ALLOCATION 4 SYSTEM IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FINAL ORDER IN DOAH 5 CASE NO. 06-2449GM; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING 6 FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR 7 TRANSMITTAL TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS 8 AND THE SECRETARY OF STATE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE 9 DATE 13 14 Ninety-two (92) parcels out of approximately 273 applications competing in 15 ROGO are tierless. Twenty-seven (27) of these 92 have an allocation being held 16 in abeyance by the Planning Commission. Abeyance means the parcel would 17 have been awarded an allocation, however because the parcels were rendered 18 Tierless the County is holding the place for an allocation. The Tier 19 recommendations for these parcels are summarized in the tables below. 20 21 Total Parcel Count by Tier TDRC Staff Planning Commission Parcels Acres Hammock Parcels Acres Hammock Parcels Acres Hammock Tier 1 10 1.01 8 0.74 8 0.74 Tier III -A 14 1.91 8 1.09 2 0.31 Tier III 68 2.33 76 3.42 82 4.2 92 5.25 92 5.25 92 5.25 Tier Designation Parcel Analysis All Parcels TDRC Parcels Changed Tier 3 to SPA 10 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 1.27 arch s _ - tinge A to Tier 4 , _ .. _ A `""" ' in Changed Parcels 0.29 Parcels Changed Tier 1 to SPA 0 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 0 Staff PC 7 0 1 0.9 , .2 ,, 0.12 2 0.29 0.29 0 0 0 0 _..:,. �.,_ .....�. _ arcel4s Change ier 1 to Mier 3 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels -W- ,v.. 0 0 0 0 0` Parcels Changed SPA to Tier 3 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 1 1 1 0.14 0.14 0.14 Parcels With No Change Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 59 62 68 2.27 2.64 3.42 WAGROWTH MANAGEMEN nTier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 9 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 One (1) of the 27 parcels being held in abeyance is proposed to be designated to a more restrictive tier (Real Estate Number 00445980-000000), 10 other parcels of the 65 parcels are recommended for change to a more restrictive tier. Below is a list of the 9 parcels. 8 of these 9 parcels have been scored based on the Tier designation previously assigned. 1 of the 9 parcels have been scored in ROGO as if it were Tier I and is recommended to go to Tier III -A (Real Estate Number 00445660-000000). It should be noted that the proposed Tier designation for 8 of these 9 parcels, if adopted by the Board of County Commissioners, would result in their current score in ROGO being reduced due to the change in Tier designation. The recommendation for 1 parcel would result in their current score in ROGO increasing. These parcels are shown below: RE Number Owner Name Previous Tier Staff Recommendation Scored in ROGO as Hammock Acres 00210500-000000 PARKINSON DEAN III -A I 111-A 0.13 00210811-005600 HANEY NORMAN & MARIA III -A I III -A 0.16 00445610-000000 DAVIS SARAH III 111-A III 0.14 00445660-000000 NATIVE RENTAL PROPERTIES LLC Ill III -A 1 0.14 00445820-000000 TAYLOR MARK AND ANDREA IlI 111-A III 0.14 00445970-000000 PARKINSON DEAN III III -A 111 0.14 00445980-000000 PARKINSON DEAN III III -A III 0.12 00446940-000000 HARPER LINDA W III III -A III 0.10 00510280-000000 WHITE RICHARD H III 111-A III 0.12 As shown in the summary tables below, TDRC, Staff and the Planning Commission had different recommendations for the Tier designations of 14 of the 92 parcels. The parcels in question and the rationale for the varying recommendation is provided below. RE Previous TDRC Staff PC Map Reason for Number Owner Name Tier Series Difference 00210440- 000000 PARKINSON III I III 11I 57 Scarified IS lot 00210450- 000000 PARKINSON III I III 111 57 Scarified IS lot 00445610- 000000 DAVIS III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00445660- NATIVE 000000 RENTAL III 11I-A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00445820- 000000 TAYLOR III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) WIGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 10 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 00445970- 000000 PARKINSON III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00445980- 000000 PARKINSON III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446940- 000000 HARPER III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00484450- PAZOS 000000 SERAFIN III III -A III III 30 < 1 acre hammock 00484460- 000000 NAVARRO III III -A III III 30 < 1 acre hammock 00484470- NATIVE 000000 RENTAL III III -A III III 30 < 1 acre hammock 00484480- NATIVE 000000 RENTAL III III -A III III 30 < 1 acre hammock 00510450- 000000 QUIROS III III -A III III 5 < 1 acre hammock 00510460- 000000 QUIROS III III -A III III 5 < 1 acre hammock 2. AN ORDINANCE BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNING TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT MAP DESIGNATIONS TO APPROXIMATELY ONE HUNDRED TEN (110) PARCELS DETERMINED TO HAVE NO TIER ON THE TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT MAP FOR MONROE COUNTY IN DOAH CASE NO. 06- 2449GM WHICH PARCELS HAVE BEEN THE SUBJECT OF AWARD OF ALLOCATION IN THE RATE OF GROWTH (ROGO) COMPETITION OR HAVE BEEN ISSUED BUILDING PERMITS,• PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND THE SECRETARY OF STATE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE 17 The Planning Commission has issued allocations for 110 of the Tierless parcels. 18 These allocations were issued prior to the County's knowledge that the ROGO 19 scores were incorrect due to the Tier designations. Many of these have had 20 building permits issued, have homes constructed, or are on the FEMA injunction 21 list. Total Parcel Count by Tier Planning TDRC Staff Commission Parcels Acres parcels Acres Parcels Acres Hammock Hammock Hammock Tier I I 4 I 0.38 ( 2 I 0.16 I 2 I 0.16 Tier III -A 12 1.27 13 1.39 5 0.6 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENnTier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 11 of 25 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 21 26 2j 2 3 31 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 41 4 43 4 4 4 4 4 4 5 51 52 53 54 55 cA Tier III 94 3.7 95 3.8 103 4.59 110 5.35 110 5.35 110 5.35 Tier Designation Parcel Analysis All Parcels TDRC Staff PC re Parcels Changed Tier 3 to SPA 12 13 5 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 1.27 1.39 0.6 Parcels Changed SY'A to Tier 1 Acres H4M in Parcels Changed Tier 1 to SPA 0 0 0 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 0 0 0 Parcels Changed Tier 1 to Tier 3 1 !Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 0 0 0 Parcels Changed SPA to Tier 3 1 1 1 A &MaLo Parcels 0.17 0.17 0 Parcels With No Change 93 94 102 Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 3.53 3.63 4.42 Variation between TDRC, Staff and Planning Commission Recommendations: 3 RE Current Previous TDRC Staff PC Map Reason for Number Owner Name Tier Tier Series Difference 00468420- 000000 WRIGHT UNDES III I III -A III -A 8 00468430- WRIGHT 000000 TRUST UNDES III I IIl-A III -A 8 00447450- < 1 acre 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III IIl 35 hammock 00445810- 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A 111 35 Policy 105.2.1 3 00445920- 000000 ZBRANAK UNDES III 111-A III -A II1 35 Policy 105.2.1 3 00446820- 000000 CALDWELL UNDES III III -A III -A II1 35 Policy 105.2.1 3) 00446960- 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447080- PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A IIl 35 tPolicy 105.2.1 (3 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 12 of 25 Variation between TDRC, Staff and Planning Commission Recommendations: 3 RE Current Previous TDRC Staff PC Map Reason for Number Owner Name Tier Tier Series Difference 00468420- 000000 WRIGHT UNDES III I III -A III -A 8 00468430- WRIGHT 000000 TRUST UNDES III I IIl-A III -A 8 00447450- < 1 acre 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III IIl 35 hammock 00445810- 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A 111 35 Policy 105.2.1 3 00445920- 000000 ZBRANAK UNDES III 111-A III -A II1 35 Policy 105.2.1 3 00446820- 000000 CALDWELL UNDES III III -A III -A II1 35 Policy 105.2.1 3) 00446960- 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447080- PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A IIl 35 tPolicy 105.2.1 (3 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 12 of 25 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 12 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 R 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 000000 00447090- 000000 PARKINSON UNDES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 3 00526620- NATIVE 000000 RENTAL UNDES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 3 00526630- JEMA 000000 INVEST UNDES III III -A III -A I III 17 1 Policy 105.2.1 3) 3. AN ORDINANCE BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ASSIGNING TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT MAP DESIGNATIONS TO APPROXIMATELY TWO THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED NINETY ONE (2891) PARCELS DETERMINED TO HAVE NO TIER ON THE TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT MAP FOR MONROE COUNTY IN DOAH CASE NO. 06-2449GM ; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND THE SECRETARY OF STATE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE The majority of parcels to be reviewed fall under this Ordinance. These parcels represent the focus of the original challenge. The challenge areas included entire subdivisions and as a result many of the parcels being reviewed are already developed lots. In addition, a number of the parcels reviewed are in Public ownership. As stated previously in this report, the impact to privately owned vacant property is considerably less than reflected in the following tables. Total Parcel Count by Tier TDRC Staff Planning Commission Parcels Acres Hammock Parcels Acres Hammock Parcels Acres Hammock Tier I 290 135.71 158 25.98 156 26.12 Tier III - A 110 37.96 172 141.78 137 138.24 Tier III 2491 80.59 2561 86.5 2598 89.9 2891 254.26 2891 254.26 2891 254.26 Tier Designation Parcel Anal sis All Parcels TDRC Staff PC ANEW' ed Tier 3 to Tiel ' 149 87 8 ` ocg 6.79 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 13 of 25 Parcels Changed Tier 3 to SPA Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels arce s _" .ge o ter t Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 94 89 54 21.11 0 19.66 16.12 60 120.0 Parcels Changed Tier 1 to SPA Acres Hammock in Chan ed Parcels Parcels Changed Tier 1- to`Tier 3 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcel Parcels Changed SPA to Tier 3 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 0 0 0 0 3 0 6 0 6 0.58 1.57 1.57 Parcels With No Change Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 2504 2638 2675 96.86 1 207.05 1 210.45 Parcels Tier "0" Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 11 11 T 11 5.5 5.5 1 5.5 Curr RE ent Prev TDRC Staff PC Map Reason for Number Owner Name Tier Tier Series Difference 00510400- KARROW UND 000000 ROBERT ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00510420- MONROE UND 000000 COUNTY ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00510430- FLAT ROCK AIR UND 000000 LLC ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00510440- FLAT ROCK AIR UND 000000 LLC ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00510800- PETERSON UND 000000 JAMES L ES III III -A III -A III 5 105.2.1 (3) -Policy 00510810- VARKIS MARIA UND 000000 ISABEL ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00510820- VARKIS MARIA UND 000000 ISABEL ES III III -A III -A III 5 Policy 105.2.1 (3) KUBIT DONALD 00466540- E & MARY UND 000000 ALICE ES III I III -A III -A 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) LOVERIDGE 00466550- FREDERICK C & UND 000000 MARY ES III I III -A III -A 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) LOVERIDGE 00466560- FREDERICK C & UND 000000 MARY ES III I III -A III -A 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) W:\GROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 14 of 25 00468310- DAVIS RONALD UND 000000 A ES III I III -A III -A 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00468320- DAVIS RONALD UND 000000 A ES III I III -A III -A 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00468390- MARTINETTI UND 000000 VICTORIO E ES III I III 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00468400- MARTINETTI UND 000000 VICTORIO E ES III I III 8 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00466830- UND 000000 VIGO JOSE C ES III III -A III III 8 < 1 acre hammock 00466990- U N D 000000 BOYCE JOHN J ES III III -A III III 8 < 1 acre hammock 00458560- RAYMOND UND 000000 MARIA J ES III III -A III III 12 >40% exotic 00458710- RAYMOND UND 000000 MARIA J ES III III -A III III 12 >40% exotic 00525110- CLEMMONS UND 000000 ROBERT ES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00525370- CLEMMONS UND 000000 ROBERT M ES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00526640- POWER UND 000000 ROBERT J ES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00526740- POWER UND 000000 ROBERT J ES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) JEMA 00526750- INVESTMENTS UND 000000 INC ES III III -A III -A III 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00526760- U N D 000000 ORTIZ BETTY ES III III -A 111 17 Policy 105.2.1 (3) commercial DAVID if property, not part 00487120- ENTERPRISES UND of a larger 000000 LLC ES III I III 29 ecosystem developed parcels 00088590- POPP LINDA UND with canopy, no 000000 LOU ES III III -A III III 29 hammock SOUTH FLORIDA 00486850- EQUITY GROUP UND 000100 1 LLC ES IIIA I III -A III -A 1 29 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00490090- BAY HARBOR UND 000000 29 LLC ES III I I III 30 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00490100- BAY HARBOR UND 000000 29 LLC ES III I I III 30 Policy 105.2.1 (3) W:\GROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 15 of 25 00490110- BAY HARBOR UND 000000 30 LLC ES III I I III 30 Policy 105.2.1 (3) MAHONEY 00088570- HARRY E AND UND 000000 ELVIRA F ES III I III -A 111-A 30 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00483370- GLENN UND 000000 DOUGLAS S ES III III -A III III 30 Exotic > 40% 00447420- JACOBS UND 000000 ROBERT C ES III III -A III III 35 Exotic > 40% 00447460- U N D 000000 MESKE ES III III -A III III 35 Exotic > 40% 00445580- POPKO UND 000000 EDWARD S II ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00445590- POPKO UND 000000 EDWARD S II ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) CORTIZO 00445830- MIGUEL AND UND 000000 TITA ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00445960- U N D 000000 GARCIA ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446070- GONZALEZ UND 000000 ANGEL J ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446090- GONZALEZ UND 000000 HOMERO ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446930- ANGELONI UND 000000 DOTTIE E ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446950- REGISTER UND 000000 CASEY ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446970- U N D 000000 MORALES ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00446980- U N D 000000 PEREZ ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447010- U N D 000000 ALFONSO ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447290- U N D 000000 BARR ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447300- U N D 000000 BARR ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447310- U N D 000000 MONTESIN ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447470- U N D 000000 MESKE ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447480- U N D 000000 POUZA ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 16 of 25 00447500- U N D 000000 FLISOCK ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447 510- U N D 000000 FLISOCK ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447610- U N D 000000 RHYNE ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447620- U N D 000000 VERA ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447770- U N D 000000 KOESY ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447780- U N D 000000 KOESY ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00447920- MCKAY UND 000000 PROPERTIES ES III III -A III -A III 35 Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00566010- U N D 000000 PURSLEY ES III III -A III III 40 < 1 acre hammock 00566300- UND 000000 ARROYO ES III III -A III III 40 developed -parcel 00215130- UND mangrove 000000 MATTILA ES III I III III 54 wetlands 00209150- U N D 000000 JOHANSON ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00209160- COUNTY OF UND 000000 MONROE ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00209170- COUNTY OF UND 000000 MONROE ES III I III 111 57 Exotic > 40% BRANCH 00210480- BANKING AND UND 000000 TRUST ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% BRANCH 00210490- BANKING AND UND 000000 TRUST ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00210650- U N D 000000 SHARPE ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00210811- U N D 011400 DONATHAN ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00210811- U N D 011500 DONATHAN ES III I III III 57 Exotic > 40% 00211200- U N D 000000 1 REITER ES III I III III 58 developed land 00211200- U N D 000100 MOORCROFT ES III I III III 58 developed land 00211230- U N D 000000 REITER ES III I III III 58 wetland lots WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 17 of 25 00211240- SCHNEIDER UND 000000 PROPERTY ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211250- SCHNEIDER UND 000000 PROPERTY ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211260- UND 000000 HOOD ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211270- U N D 000000 SHANEBROOK ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211280- UND 000000 RUSH ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211290- MONROE UND 000000 COUNTY ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211300- MONROE UND 000000 COUNTY ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00211310- CRUZ RENE & UND 000000 SHEILA K ES III I III III 58 developed land 00211320- CRUZ RENE A & UND 000000 SHEILA K ES III I III III 58 wetland lots 00185860- RICK JOHN & UND 000000 CAROLYN ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185870- U N D 000000 TATHAM ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185880- U N D 000000 KING JEWEL ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185890- U N D 000000 KING JEWEL ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185900- TATHAM UND 000000 BERNICE ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185910- U N D 000000 EWALD ERIC ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185920- HERBERTJOHN UND 000000 R ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185930- JENDRUSIAK UND 000000 GEORGE ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00185940- JENDRUSIAK UND 000000 GEORGE A ES III I III 111 69 wetland lots 00185950- UND 000000 DITZLER ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186040- SAGER UND 000000 MANAGEMENT ES III I III 111 69 wetland lots 00186050- LOUIS PAULA UND 000000 CREDIT ES III I III 111 69 wetland lots W:\GROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 18 of 25 00186060- CURTISS UND 000000 TRUSTEES ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186070- CURTISS UND 000000 TRUSTEES ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186080- U N D 000000 RICE SYLVIA ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186090- U N D 000000 RICE SYLVIA ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186100- U N D 000000 RICE SYLVIA L ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186110- ZUCKERMAN UND 000000 JACK ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186120- SAGER UND 000000 MANAGEMENT ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186130- SAGER UND 000000 MANAGEMENT ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186140- PHILLIPS AND UND 000000 TRICE INC ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186150- PHILLIPS AND UND 000000 TRICE INC ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186160- BEAUPERTHUY UND 000000 LUIS B ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186170- SAGER UND 000000 MANAGEMENT ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186180- U N D 000000 EWALD ERIC ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186190- U N D 000000 EWALD ERIC ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186200- U N D 000000 TAT CO ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186210- TATHAM UND 000000 BERNICE ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186220- MONROE UND 000000 COUNTY ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00186230- CHMIELEWSKI UND 000000 PATRICIA ES III I III III 69 wetland lots 00118420- U N D 000000 GOOD LLOYD A ES III I III III 78 Sugarloaf Lodge 00522590- 000000 LEVER-DUFFY UND ES III I III 1 20 < 1 acre surrounded by development W:\GROWTH MANAGEMEN nTier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 19 of 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 I; 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 4. AN ORDINANCE BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AMENDING OR RATIFYING THE TIER OVERLAY DISTRICT DESIGNATIONS FOR APPROXIMATELY THREE HUNDRED ONE (301) PARCELS PROPOSED FOR REVIEW BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, STAFF OR OWNERS WHICH PARCELS CURRENTLY HAVE TIER DESIGNATIONS• PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND THE SECRETARY OF STATE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE There are 301 parcels that have a Tier Designation where the property owners or staff applied for reconsideration of the Tier Designation, or were included in a BOCC resolution for Staff to review the Tier designation. Most of these applications were evaluated by a Special Magistrate using the now invalid criteria and need to be re-evaluated using the revised criteria. Total Parcel Count by Tier Planning TDRC Staff Commission Parcels Acres parcels Acres Parcels Acres Hammock Hammock Hammock Tier 1 221 33.18 206 31.45 201 31.24 Tier III - 6 18 A 4.27 2.33 16 2.03 Tier III 74 0.82 77 4.49 84 5 301 38.27 301 38.27 301 38.27 WAGROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 20 of 25 Acres Hammock in Changed Parcels 0 0 0 Parcels With No Change Acres Hammock in Unchanged Parcels 222 207 202 33.19 31.46 31.25 3 ** 3.17 acres mapped as hammock that is cleared land with no hammock. See Map Series 59; 4 RE #'s 00114090 & 00114120 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 �,.. 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 RE Owner Current Number Name Tier TDRC Staff PC Reason for Difference 00448140- MANNIX 000000 JOHN S I I I III Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00448150- MANNIX 000000 JOHN S I I I III Policy 105.2.1 (3) RASPALL 00448380- CARLOS 000000 & I I I III Policy 105.2.1 (3) CRUZ 00448470- MANUE 000000 L I I I III Policy 105.2.1 (3) 00453990- FRIED 000000 HAROLD I I III III no hammock hammock lots adjacent 00544590- to Tier I but within 000000 TIFF I I III -A III -A developed subdivision 00544600- 000000 TIFF I I III -A III -A COUNTY OF 00544620- MONRO 000000 E I I III -A III -A 00545100- 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A hammock lots adjacent 00545110- 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A to Tier I but within developed subdivision 00545200- 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A 00545230- 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A 00545240- 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A 00545250- 000000 YUHASZ I I III -A III -A 00545260- hammock lots adjacent 000000 TIITF I I III -A III -A to Tier I but within W:\GROWTH MANAGEMENT\Tier Committee Meeting and information\Staff Report\ Draft BOCC Staff Report Page 21 of 25 �1 �i ^^88^ "s�e;r„assmm�7„aland68s�' mmdv�dds m R 7�m��^ 3,„ �Sa7Sgti 8883a:s888a a8a^SmW8a8 8 0 5 .9 .9 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 2111 II I H M90 IN IN III Illml 11 IN Illml III IIII In 1111 NIPPON I ....... .... € Wpm E w � ' � 3 M 5 F c ° $ a s c° $ m° :o g y g q d ' °-' .% fl gg 9-°, fl ; m fl E m g $ m E F �° i • 8 gg 3•® _ 4 sfr�s2.ss8=3ss�s�ses� = 2 a• • i 6 ' - = 0 fl 9 6 _ 0 = y 9 " a _ .0 @ ° a _ fl - 0 C@• - - ' - W W w _= g g g g• g fl B p �� g= L m e g� Q 9 a_ g• o° $ oE`c 5� __ c E a -_; •n c = a_� • `3 m_ g°= c F c c c_ P i a�'3 c E g 3 3� c c_ f i 3 v c F S � 3« c c P g 5 'E '�, N A A«« r S �_ ?_ S !1 '°' 3 m ,°•, `« `« N a � W f d 2 2 g fl fl 2 2 ,. 2 d c<< n C 2 Z 2 v 2 2 g W m 2 c r fl A fl c e W v 3 2 c e o n d d o 0. fl A fl 2 W a fl fl c c Z • • v c 2 a° A d� 2 • v v 2 .gym v 3 fl A n - -- _ ............ S �' sg'g'E3G •• u �u .Fi 5555555555555 a a � � 555 @ a� e a� S• u u � � �_ u u � u z`... u u u z z.. U L Y u a... u u u u i.. u u a U. ��s�9�9993�s93-9393�551333333373933993359533.59333993333933939393.5359 a� 9 aaaa 299 G a e �f�drzd�gsdd�s��g€�drFigzgd€g€dg�€Frz cg `° a`o y o _ `g `e o `o y « p` `o ` _ ,`° c• co _ _ co o a fgz�gf€gggfg 2z 3 3 5 3 u 3 31 3 3 8 u 3 3 u 3 6€ 5 3 3 3 5 3 8 8 9 5 3 8 u 3 8 u 3 3 3 8 M;NN� A��N� end.^° mBry :°B.'° °�flN «N'.,9^..9�Ngmm�,mwom�.mmav°ivaeaea'd °1N cymm e• w W U W m m w w v w w a e a a a a a d v a e d v 0 0 0 0 O o 0 0 0 0 m) 0 0" d c •eE __ a = • = a __ _ _ _ _ - xe_____- - - - =- -o --__--___ ffit - - - m = a = _ _ _ _ = c E -------------------------- _ P +Hd — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -- � W____ F uZw p p_ > > wwwu"i'9www""^'^""W' p p p p p z > p p z z o > z 0 z z > > p o z z o O 0 z z z o > www"'L1w p z z z > > z z z > > z z o 0 ---- '^'^'u1 w z 0 w z z > > - p z z > > z z > > w z z o > w w z z > > w w z z > > wp z z z z z z z z z z G z z wp w z z o w w w w z z z p wp z z z E�8�8S88�8m8m8m888S88;��0�8$$$$$$$0080808 E ff-m x O d d 6 o d d o ap o!oo I ------------ occo 6 O!N a � •�N �n �$t �n o x •ui — sd '�' A `w v t�y� `w L¢. L c$t=• 't! m 4 i'e Te yC �mnn :ve��elee.�eee. di rya A u qe w geeepe m C m N S S S o 0 L Jz "s''L" m L f`1 L o o L o �o R i7 19 a H u u a 8i u FFt'• cLi�,. sss' ssssss�s dim ��W ism sum oo20000000 p,p a p p o O o p p e0," "� aaa�533a533 z 0000 o m O o z ? o p z = > > m > > > > > > > O¢ z z z Z z z z z z z 2 ��g�iigii�� 88555855558ff5588 ezrcrccxzmc�mmm SS mm S � a g g 8 a m 8uuuuuu8uuu o 8 0 0 8 8 0 8 0g. z .. g ... g g -0-.-0 � z Z- zz I� r�� zz �� z z �� aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0$$ o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o oojo i i J o'o >> 0000 J J J> SRO. u SRO. .J 7 J Ou 7 oc8800'o u z a 7 u u z u u mm Qa u wt m H vi a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a 0!!� a a a a a a a '��!��z2zo°��0000000000000o O O wGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG w ` p 0 0 0 p O p p o p p 0 W O fa 9 p p w m m m m O O O u O O O 0 O 9 g O O f � O O � oo O O f g O O zo f O O a oz O O ,0 ,0 u LL F — t C__ — — t — — _ — 2 Z z z z z Z Z z z z z 2 z z= Z z > > z z? > > j Z z > > z z z z > > 2 z~ O goB%84g%$%dg$d%BSoa%$$g%a $sp $$ g sp $sspssgo... .sas os g%oog� �000g cgs %$Ssppp 'U mp§MR— am n "—g @��a��„ m U8$8��66$%8 �d aic o� as as ` 88o8888ohSooSoo888oSS8888888Im"771-77- 58888888888888888888888888588888888888 _ w , p , cE OO T �ITI'l i 'e ae asaaeEa�._e____oaee____e a� Lz r t r r 8 8 6 6 S u -- V V aa.pge s V a 6 6 6 6 8 6 0 E^ - u u m�^ S 5 5 8 E-- aaeaa U t 6 f fi c___ q a q u M --- o E- E is e dx n v....... o e vzx$ .e:e.ev :eerdd� fr^ .. ..erd"ssaC�S;" 5 Zav 5 5 5 5 5 w 5 5 5 5 5 5 S 5 5 5 5 5 x 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 S 5 5 5 .z Id gg yy y y y y yy p v o v< c v v c c v c«««««« 9 9 dzu 9 9 9 9 d 9 9 o z3 9 9 c c 9 9 o 0 v� 9 9 0 0 gig 9 9 0 0 9 9 0 o g 9 9 a` ct z�gv 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 g€gzrdzz 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 fEE�ooVOW 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 3 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 u 9, t _ 099 3 335� 333 33 8ag8a 8� 388335888� �3338353 0�00000da aSc ale my<SmSSS$SSeoo��SSSSSSo oo�&SSSS�Q��SSvSSSS< a$aa w w w a v W aN O1aaav°1aN��a Si Sp °1 O1ae�N\\N�� NNNn� o e e e e< e v m v� e� Bm�e m v$< v e c e N B v a e �'u LlZ? SL' 50kl �8li 8�� uuuu 7 I uu88 0 0 0 0 ia _ _ -- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ E c _________________ _________-------_______---________---==a =_ o c = - +H+ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ d d W W w W w w w w w w w w w w o w o w o w w w w w w o 0 0 "Wo W w w w w w p w o w W w w m w w ul to m m-- m W w w w w m to to F z z? z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z? z z z z z z z z z i z z z z 0 0 0 0 0 z i z i z z z 0 z z m z z z - - -- z z > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >-> j > > > > > > > > > ? > > > > > > Ey E o '888888888SS888885$oo888S0008� o 6 888Ems8.- 88880$084$$400000000$8 a x old o �� v IN I m.a. .a+000rn, Y j q "°- E -L° E@ E@ N@ N °@ C C@ C E ..@ C C N E E E@ n u E y� w villa w-i a a-i - w min C v 'wn w 'w LL'LL3 ��, u°O�q��j7 C'Co ag n _oS LL c asm mom E z �ua� su g� g �� g � Stu gSg ag cg g gag gg �suag g S ggu u usu g SSS S� u�� g a�gs g S Sig � g �''"''� aaa a a 0o a a o o a a 000 a a 0000 a a a a o!oo�000 a a a a a a 000;!o�o a a s a a a 000!o�!o�Yo10 a a a a a a o a a 0 o!o�o a a a a o;!o�!!o�o a a a a o 000 a a a a o!o� a a o!o�!o� a a oo00 a a a a o aa 000000 a a a a of 0 u u 0 u a a a a a a a a o o o oa>» F 0 o a w o a 0 0 0 a a a o o a a a 0 o a a c o a a a a 0 0 s a 0 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 0 a a 0 o a a c o a a 0 0 a a a a a a a a a a a a o m o 0 0 z a t_ z 0 0 0 o w w o 0 0 0 t r L� 0 0 t 0 0 t t 0 0 t t 0 0 t t 0 0 r r 0 0 r 0 z 0 z 0 0 z .u„ o rc 0 0 0 m m z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z a z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z u o g C L F F C t= F F 0 0 0 �8o�8$$��888oggog$8�88888S8�ogg88a800008��00= 0000 o �o m$ Ooo88o0�880080 gg 25 Y S E E .mi o0 0 o m o 005888 g g gg a ti a N a o a o v a a e v v a e e o v a v v a a v a v v o a a o a a e a a s v v a a v a e 8 N N 8888��8888S888S.8888��888588'88888EEE88E880000o8888EEEEEEE8IT 8E888 .LA a O O