Item V5BOARD OF COUNTY CONMESSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Meeting Date: November 20, 2013
Bulk Item: Yes X No
Department: County Attorney
Staff Contact Person: Natileene Cassel
Phone #: 305 - 292 -3470
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Approval for Seventh Amendment to the Standard Legal Services Agreement
with Ira Libanoff, Esq. in order to clarify the terms of the agreement, facilitate agreement as to certain
outstanding invoices, and close out two of the three remaining cases under the agreement.
ITEM BACKGROUND: When the Standard Legal Service Agreement was originally approved in 2006 it
was anticipated that it would make the hiring of litigation attorneys less cumbersome. Over the
subsequent years interpretation of the agreement has become cumbersome; exacting numerous hours
of unnecessary work by of the county, the clerk and the attorneys hired under the agreement to sort out
what should or should not be paid. This issue is particularly acute when complex construction litigation
is involved. The changes requested will clarify the agreement and allow payment or non - payment on
outstanding invoices.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: Approval of original agreement on March 15, 2006, First
Amendment on March 21, 2007, Second Amendment on December 15, 2010, Third Amendment on
September 2011, Fourth Amendment on March 15, 2006, Fifth Amendment on August 15, 2012, and
Sixth Amendment on October 17 2012.
CONTRACT /AGREEMENT CHANGES: Section 8.2 deletes language calling for payment to an attorney at
the lowest time - keepers rate when more than one person from the firm is in attendance at meetings.
This language requires an experienced attorney who knows the most on a case to be paid at the rate of
an associate who was allowed to attend in order to assist in complicated matters. Approval from the
County to have more than one time - keeper at a meeting is already required.
Section 5.3.1.4 is clarified to apply to transcripts and to Court Reporters.
Section 5.3.2.2 applies the experts and consultants.
In addition, the amendment makes clear that representation in the case of Mailloux and Sons, Inc. does
apply under this Agreement. The changes are retroactive to the original date of the initial Agreement.
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Approval
TOTAL COST: $63,000 potentially INDIRECT COST: -0- BUDGETED: Yes X No _
DIFFERENTIAL OF LOCAL PREFERENCE: N/A
COST TO COUNTY: unknown SOURCE OF FUNDS:
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes _ No X AMOUNT PER MONTH Year
APPROVED BY: County Atty . OMB /Purchasing _Risk Management
DOCUMENTATION: Included X Not Required
DISPOSITION: AGENDA ITEM #
Revised 7/09
Seventh Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira llbanoff, Esq.
On this day of . 2013, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, as
the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance with the powers
enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County ") and Ira Libanoff, Esq. ( "Attorney"), hereby
entered into this Seventh Amendment to their agreement dated March 15, 2006, which bears a
reference number of 2005- 06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein, the parties
amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, to read as follows:
1. Section 8.2 shall be amended to read:
"8.2. Duplication of effort. Unless County approval is obtained, Attorney will not have more than one
time- keeper bill for court appearances, attendance at depositions, and meetings, including meetings
with County representatives, and internal conferences. Attorney is not permitted to use this matter to
provide on the job training for a time - keeper, and bill for that time - keeper's services, without County's
advance approval.
2. Section 5.3.1.4 shall be amended to read as follows:
"Section 5.3.1.4 Transcripts and Court Reporters. Transcripts should not be ordered without prior
approval from County. Transcripts should not be ordered on an expedited basis unless necessary and
approved by County. Attorney should obtain digital electronic /computerized copies of transcripts when
available at reasonable cost to avoid charging for time spent digesting or indexing transcripts, and to
allow County to maintain a digital electronic /computerized database of transcripts
Court Reporters shall be chosen by the Attorney, based on knowledge of the reporter's competency and
reliability. Court Reporter's invoices shall be reviewed by Attorney for accuracy prior to being attached
to the Attorney's invoice for reimbursement by County. If a Court Reporter has an unusual expense such
as extra time or billing for time outside normal business hours, or an increased rate, Attorney shall verify
with County Attorney the necessity and accuracy of the expense. County Attorney shall determine the
reasonableness of the time and relate that decision to the Clerk.
3. Section 5.3.2.2 shall be amended to read as follows:
"Section 5.3.2.2. Experts and consultants. Attorney is not authorized to retain experts,
additional counsel, consultants, or to outsource or delegate work outside Attorney's law firm, without
written approval by County. This section does not apply to selection of Court Reporters. Experts and
Consultants will be retained directly by written agreements between the County and the Expect or
Consultant. Attorney will be responsible for selecting and managing services of others so that their
services and expenses will be rendered in accordance with the terms of their agreement with the
County and to obtain cost effective services for County. Legal representation may not be delegated
outside the firm.
4. This Seventh Amendment shall be retroactive to original contract date, March 15, 2006 and all
Invoices shall be paid retroactive to that date.
1IPage
S. In addition, this amendment is intended to clarify that Ira Libanoff and his firm were hired to
consult on the general matters in the case of Mailloux and Sons, Inc. V. Monroe County and to assist on
Issues with the bonding company and settlement negotiations in that case. The authority for such
representation was established in the Second Amendment to this Agreement dated 11/30/10.
6. All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, which are not amended herein, shall remaln in full
force and effect. This Fifth Amendment shall become effective when executed by both the Attorney and
the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be executed this day
of , 2013.
(SEAL) BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
ATTEST: AMY HEAVILIN, CPA OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CLERK OF COURT
By
Deputy Clerk
By
Mayor
By
Ira Libanoff, E q
Date: I� S" 1.3
MONROE COUNTY ATTORNEY
A PROVED AS TO F
,,ATT, -EENE" CASSEL'
t ASSfSTAN1 k V ATTORNEY
Date -
21 Page
Sh owing Strikethroughs and underlines
Seventh Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
On this day of , 2013, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, as
the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance with the powers
enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County ") and Ira Libanoff, Esq. ( "Attorney "), hereby
entered into this Third Amendment to their agreement dated March 15, 2006, which bears a reference
number of 2005- 06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein, the parties
amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, to read as follows:
Section 8.2 shall be amended to read:
"8.2. Duplication of effort. Unless advance County approval is obtained, Attorney will not have
more than one time- keeper bill for court appearances, attendance at depositions, and meetings
including meetings with County representatives, and internal conferences. '^ «h^ ^••^^« morp t h a
Attorney is not
permitted to use this matter to provide on the job training for a time - keeper, and bill for that time-
keeper's services, without County's advance approval.
2. Section 5.3.1.4 shall be amended to read as follows:
"Section 5.3.1.4 Transcripts and Court Reporters Transcripts should not be ordered without
prior approval from County. Transcripts should not be ordered on an expedited basis unless necessary
and approved '^,re by County. Attorney should obtain digital electronic /computerized copies of
transcripts when available at reasonable cost to avoid charging for time spent digesting or indexing
transcripts, and to allow County to maintain a digital electronic /computerized database of transcripts
Court Reporters shall be chosen by the Attorney, based on knowledge of the reporter's competency and
reliability. Court Reporter's invoices shall be reviewed by Attorney for accuracy prior to being attached
to the Attorney's invoice for reimbursement by County. If a Court Reporter has an unusual expense such
as extra time or billing for time outside normal business hours, or an increased rate. Attorney shall
verify with County Attorney the necessity and accuracy of the expense. County Attorney shall determine
the reasonableness of the time and relate that decision to the Clerk. Legal representation may not be
delegated outside the firm.
3. Section 5.3.2.2 shall be amended to read as follows:
"Section 5.3.2.2. Experts and consultants
__. ises, Attorney is not authorized to retain experts, additional counsel, consultants, sappeFt
^•�^ ^F the like or to outsource or delegate work outside Attorney's law firm, without p4ef-written
approval by County. This section does not apply to selection of Court Reporters. Experts and Consultants
will be retained directly by written agreements between the County and the Expect or Consultant.
Attorney will be responsible for selecting and managing services of others so that their services and
expenses will be rendered in accordance with the terms of their agreement with the Countv Agfe^^° ^ ^ «,
11P ;)!7f3
and to obtain cost
effective services for County. URIess etheFwise agFeed iA WFitiRg,
4. This Seventh Amendment shall be retroactive to original contract date, March 15, 2006 and all
invoices shall be paid retroactive to that date.
5. In addition, this amendment is intended to clarify that Ira Libanoff and his firm were hired to
consult on the general matters in the case of Mailloux and Sons, Inc. V. Monroe County and to assist on
issues with the bonding company and settlement negotiations in that case. The authority for such
representation was established in the Second Amendment to this Agreement dated 11/30/10.
6. All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, which are not amended herein, shall remain in full
force and effect. This Fifth Amendment shall become effective when executed by both the Attorney and
the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be executed this day
of 1 2013.
(SEAL) BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
ATTEST: AMY HEAVILIN, CPA OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CLERK OF COURT
By
Deputy Clerk
By
Mayor
By
Ira Libanoff, Esq.
Date:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
STANDARD LEGAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
(LITIGATION)
AGREEMENT NUMBER:
CAY LIT 2005 06 02
THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, as the
legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance with the powers
enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes (the "County ") and
IRA L. LIBANOFF, ESQ. (the "Attorney") hereby
enter into this Agreement regarding the retention of Attorney by County to provide legal advice and
services:
1. Client: The Client is the County, and to the extent ethically permissible, its elected and
appointed officers and its' employees, unless County advises Attorney otherwise. In the event that
Attorney cannot ethically represent individuals in addition to County, Attorney shall advise County
in writing of that fact immediately.
2. Attorney: The Attorney is the individual named above and whose signature appears at the
bottom of this Agreement. Attorney is licensed to practice law in all jurisdictions relevant to this
matter. If Attorney practices with others who may also provide services to County, he or she
understands that County expects that Attorney will be responsible for managing the representation,
assuring compliance of others with the terms of this Agreement and ethical requirements, preparing
and substantiating all bills, and communicating with County. Attorney may not delegate or
outsource this work without full written disclosure to, and prior written approval from, the County.
3. Matter: Attorney has been retained by County in connection with the matter described in
Exhibit A. Attorney represents that he or she is competent and available to handle that matter. In
the event that additional matters are assigned by County to Attorney, this agreement shall apply to
those matters as well, unless a separate Agreement is required by the County.
3.1. Review of ethical obligations before initiating representation: Attorney has
conducted a thorough investigation and determined that neither Attorney nor his or her firm has any
ethical impediment, real or potential, to representing County. To the extent that any ethical
impediment, real or potential, is discovered or ever arises, Attorney shall immediately inform
County in writing of the impediment (regardless of whether Attorney believes he or she has taken
all steps necessary to avoid the impediment and regardless of whether Attorney believes that the
impediment is insubstantial or questionable), make full disclosure of the situation to County, obtain
County's express, written consent to continue the representation ofthe other client, and take all steps
requested by County to avoid or mitigate the impediment. Attorney understands that, if a direct or
indirect conflict of interest arises which, in the opinion of the County, cannot be avoided or
mitigated under the Rules of Professional Conduct of The Florida Bar, County may, in its discretion,
(a) obtain reimbursement from Attorney for all fees and expenses paid to Attorney in this matter;
(b) obtain cancellation of all amounts allegedly owed by County to Attorney; and (c) obtain
reimbursement for consequential expenses incurred by County, including the cost of replacement
counsel.
I of 15
1 3.2. Limitations to scope of representation: Except where prohibited by the Rules of
2 Professional Conduct of The Florida Bar, the Monroe County Attorney's Office will serve as co-
3 counsel in all matters covered by this Agreement. As co- counsel, the Office attorney's will assist
4 Attorney by performing tasks assigned by Attorney, including but not limited to serving as local
5 counsel; securing the cooperation of County employee's, officers, and others in discovery and other
6 matters; obtaining evidentiary materials from County files; assisting with discovery; attending
7 hearings and depositions; filing pleadings; arranging for closed attorney -client sessions with the
8 Board of County Commissioners; and performing other tasks as necessary and convenient for
9 Attorney. Decisions as to tactical approaches to be utilized shall be the ultimate responsibility of
10 the Attorney, and issues which rise to the level of a client decision shall be resolved by the Board
11 of County Commissioners. Any further limitations or special conditions shall be as set forth in
12 Exhibit A.
13
14 3.3. Term of Agreement and Representation: This Agreement and representation by
15 Attorney is effective upon acceptance and approval by County in accordance with County's policies,
16 ordinances, or governing statutes. The representation shall continue until terminated by either the
17 County, or by the Attorney in accordance with ethical requirements.
18
19 3.4. County expectations and goals: The County expects the Attorney to seek the best
20 resolution for the County at the lowest reasonable cost to the taxpayers. At the earliest reasonable
21 point during the representation, the Attorney shall report to the County, via the County Attorney,
22 any reasonable potential for settlement, including related settlement costs and expenses, the
23 estimated chances of the County prevailing on the merits, and the potential financial exposure
24 should the County not prevail on the merits. Any other expectations and goals shall be as set forth
25 in Exhibit A.
26
27 4. Attorney Fee (Hourly): Attorney will be paid for his or her services based on the number
28 of hours expended on behalf of County (rounded to the nearest tenth hour for each time entry), not
29 to include time billable to or compensated by other clients, multiplied by the Attorney's hourly rate
30 as set forth in Exhibit A. The following minimum billing documentation and time- keeper
31 requirements are a condition precedent to payment by the County.
32
33 4.1. Non - billable time: Attorney will bill County only for time reasonably and
34 necessarily incurred to render professional services on County's behalf in accordance with this
35 Agreement. Time attributable to billing questions is not billable. Time expended by time - keepers
36 who have not been approved by County as indicated on Exhibit A is also not billable.
37
38 4.2. Changes to hourly rates: Attorney will charge no more than the hourly rate quoted
39 in Exhibit A throughout the duration of the matter, unless otherwise agreed in writing signed by
40 County.
41
42 4.3. Discounts to other Clients: The rates Attorney will charge County represent the
43 lowest rates charged by the same time- keepers to other clients. In the event that lower rates or
44 discounts are provided to other clients, Attorney and approved time - keepers will also provide them
45 on the same basis to County.
2 of 15
■
1
2 4.4. Additional time - keepers: Additional time - keepers may not be added to the matter
3 without advance written approval from County. In the event that additional time - keepers providing
4 services which are to be billed to the County are to be added to the staff, then their hourly rates shall
5 be provided to County in a dvance, and upon writte by th e Count, their rates and billing
6 practices shall com with the requirements of t hi s Agreemen Additional time - keepers approved
7 By tie County are listed in E� i it�A to thus Agreement, and this Exhibit A may be amended from
8 time to time, upon mutual agreement of the County and the Attorney, to evidence the then - current
9 circumstances.
10
11 4.5. Existing work product: To the extent the Attorney makes use of existing work
12 product, e.g., in the form of research previously performed for another County, then Attorney may
13 bill only that time expended in using that work product for County. In other words, no premium,
14 markup, or other adjustment may be made to bill County for time spent on work already performed.
15
16 4.6. Travel: Travel restrictions, including restrictions on billing time during travel, are
17 set forth below.
18
19 5. Billing of Fees and Expenses: Attorney shall comply with the following requirements as
20 to billing fees and expenses as a condition precedent to County's obligation to pay each bill:
21
22 5.1. Monthly bills: Unless otherwise agreed in a writing signed by the County, bills shall
23 be issued monthly by Attorney within 15 days after the close of each month. Attorney understands
24 that County requires prompt bills in part to facilitate effective management of the representation and
25 fees.
26
27 5.2. Bill format: Attorney shall provide detailed, itemized bills which shall, at a
28 minimum:
29
30 5.2.1 Description. Provide a general description of the matter, to include the name
31 of the County department or constitutional officer, if not indicated in the title of the matter, for
32 which legal services are being performed (e.g. Richard Roe v. Monroe County —EEO Claim).
33
34
35 5.2.2 Personnel. Clearly identify each person performing services (i.e., time -
36 keepers) in conjunction with each entry.
37
38 5.2.3 Other Personnel. Clearly identify all persons who are not full -time lawyers
39 employed by the Attorney's firm (including subcontractors, independent contractors, temporary
40 employees, and outsourcing providers).
41
42 5.2.4 Time Records. Record the time expended by each time - keeper separately.
43 In those situations where the minimum billing increment exceeds the actual time spent on a task and
44 several of these "minor" tasks are performed, it is expected that the services will be aggregated until
45 the total actual time spent meets the minimum billing increment.
3 of 15
1 5.2.5 Totals and By Task. State the amount of time expended by each time- keeper
2 daily (and, within each day, broken down by task where more than one project or task was worked
3 upon within the same day).
4
5 5.2.6 Task Description. Describe within each itemized daily task entry, in sufficient
6 detail to readily allow the County to determine the necessity for and reasonableness of the time
7 expended, the services performed, the project or task each service relates to, the subject and purpose
8 of each service, and the names of others who were present or communicated wit in the course of
9 performing the service. Included should be a reasonably specific delineation of services sufficiently
10 itemized to allocate time within a matter to such categories of effort as Legal Research, Fact
11 Gathering, Internal Conferences, Communications with Client, Particular Document Drafting, Court
12 Appearance, Deposition Attendance, and so forth.
13
14 5.2.7 Summary of Rates. In a summary at the beginning or end of the bill, provide
15 the current hourly rate for each time- keeper, the total time billed by each time - keeper in that bill,
16 the product of the total time and hourly rate for each time - keeper, the total fees charged, and a
17 reconciliation between the amount charged and any applicable estimated or budgeted amount, by
18 task. In addition, each monthly statement should show the aggregate billing for that matter from the
19 commencement of the matter through the currently - billed month.
20
21 5.2.8 Digital/Electronic Copy. County is currently using Time Matters and Time
22 Billing software in the County Attorney's office, and prefers that an electronic reporting software
23 which can be incorporated into the County's software data base for tracking and reporting purposes
24 be used by Attorney. Attorney should discuss the capabilities of Attorney's billing system with
25 County before rendering the first bill. County should receive a digital electronic /computerized
26 version of each bill, together with a paper copy, to facilitate bill review.
27
28 5.3. Expenses: County will pay the actual, reasonable cost of the following expense
29 items if incurred in accordance with the guidelines below and promptly itemized in Attorney's
30 monthly bill:
31
32 5.3.1 Reimbursable expenses: Actual cost for necessary long distance telephone
33 calls, telecopying at $.25 per outgoing page, overnight or expedited delivery, couriers, photocopying
34 at $.15 per page, postage, court fees, and other expenses approved in advance by County or as listed
35 below:
36
37 5.3.1.1. Expedited or emergency services: Attorney is expected to
38 avoid using expedited or emergency services, such as express delivery services, couriers,
39 telecopying, overtime, and so on, unless necessary because of unexpected developments or
40 extremely short deadlines. County may refuse to pay for any such expenses when incurred routinely
41 or because of Attorney's failure to manage the matter efficiently.
42
43 5.3.1.2. Computerized research: Attorney is expected to use
44 computerized research services cost - effectively to reduce time spent on research, for example, while
45 closely - monitoring computerized research to insure that the charges are reasonable and
4 of 15
I
I necessary. Attorney is expected to pass through to County any discounts or other arrangements that
2 reduce the cost of computerized services.
3
4 5.3.1.3. Photocopying: Attorney is encouraged to use outside
5 copying services to reduce the cost of large - volume copying, provided that these expenses are
6 efficient, cost - effective, and incurred and billed in accordance with this Agreement. Attorney is
7 responsible for insuring that all copying complies with copyright obligations.
8
9 { 5.3.1.4. Transcripts: Transcripts should not be ordered withoutprior
10 approval fror: ounty. Transcripts should not be ordered on an expedited basis unless necessary
11 and approved in advance by County. Attorney should obtain digital electronic /computerized copies
12 of transcripts when available at a reasonable cost to avoid charging for time spent digesting or
13 indexing transcripts, and to allow County to maintain a digital electronic /computerized database of
14 all transcripts.
15
16 5.3.1.5 Travel Expenses: Travel expenses within the Attorney's
17 local or metropolitan area will not be reimbursed if the time spent in transit is billed. Travel
18 expenses outside the metropolitan area may only be reimbursed if the travel was approved in
19 advance by County. Reimbursable travel expenses, if approved in advance, are the cost of
20 transportation by the least expensive practicable means (e.g., coach class air travel), the cost of
21 reasonable hotel accommodations, and the cost of transportation while out of town (e.g., by cab or
22 rental car, whichever seems reasonable, at the lowest available rate). Travel expenses will be
23 reimbursed in accordance with the applicable provisions for "approved travelers" of the Monroe
24 County Code, will be summarized on the Monroe County Travel Form with all applicable receipts
25 attached thereto.
26
27 5.3.1.6 Travel Time. Time spent in transit, locally or otherwise, may
28 be billed only if (a) Attorney or time - keeper is unable to avoid traveling by using other forms of
29 communication and (b) Attorney or time - keeper is unable to bill time in transit to other clients.
30 Travel by more than one time - keeper at the same time to the same destination is not allowed without
31 prior approval from County. Approved travel time during time- keeper's normal business hours will
32 be billed at the hourly rate listed for the time- keeper on Exhibit A. Approved travel time outside
33 of time- keeper's normal business hour's will be billed at one -half the hourly rate listed for the time -
34 keeper on Exhibit A.
35
36 5.3.2. Non - reimbursable expenses: The following expenses will in no event be
37 reimbursable, unless specifically agreed to in advance in a writing signed by County:
38
39 5.3.2.1. Personal and Office Costs. Meals for time - keepers,
40 overtime, word processing or computer charges, personal expenses, expenses that benefitted other
41 clients, expenses for books, costs of temporary employees, periodicals or other library materials,
42 internal filing or other document handling charges, clerical expenses, stationery and other supply
43 expenses, utilities, and any other expense that is either unreasonable or unnecessary. (The fact that
44 the firm charges other clients or that other firms charge their clients for an expense does not make
45 it reasonable or necessary.)
„ W ,'
5 of 15
1 pf°
2 erts, consu nts, support- services, outs rced
3 services, etc. Attorney is not a orized to retain expert ,additional counsel, consultants, L
4 servi a like, or to out source or delegate work outside Attorney's law firm, without ri r
5 �ritCtej, by County. Attorney will be responsible for selecting and managing the services
6 ers ssotltlieu services and expenses will be rendered in accordance with the terms of this
7 Agreement, including terms applicable to Attorney. Attorney will manage others to obtain cost -
8 effective services for County. Unless otherwise agreed in writing, Attorney shall obtain a written
9 retainer agreement, in a form which may be specified by County, from each service provider, with
10 bills from each provider being sent to both Attorney (for management purposes) and County (for
11 review and payment).
12
13 5.3.2.3. Expenses not passed through at actual cost. County will
14 not pay any markup for expenses. County will only reimburse the Attorney for their actual approved
15 out -of- pocket costs and expenses, whether incurred personally by an approved time- keeper or
16 incurred by other approved personnel (such as experts, consultants, support services personnel, or
17 outsourced services personnel).
18
19 5.3.2.4. Overhead not charged to County. County will not pay for
20 any "expense" items that are in fact part of Attorney's overhead which should be included within
21 Attorney's fee.
22
23 5.3.3. Advance approval of expenses. In addition to the items noted above,
24 Attorney shall obtain advance approval from County before incurring any expense in excess of $
25 1,000.00 if Attorney expects to be reimbursed for that expense. County may refuse to pay any
26 expense for which advance approval was not obtained by Attorney.
27
28 5.3.4. Copies of receipts for expenses. Attorney shall include copies ofreceipts for
29 all expenses with the itemized monthly bill. County may refuse to pay any expense item for which
30 documentation is not provided by Attorney.
31
32 5.3.5. Expenses (and fees) after termination. Upon termination of the
33 representation, Attorney shall promptly bill County for any remaining reimbursable expenses and
34 fees. County may refuse to pay any fees or expenses not billed within 45 days of termination of the
35 representation. Attorney is also expected to cooperate promptly with all aspects of termination and,
36 if applicable, transition to other counsel. Payment for fees and expenses is contingent upon prompt,
37 full cooperation.
38
39 5.4. Bill and expense documentation. Attorney understands that Attorney must have
40 documentation to support all aspects of each bill, including fees and expenses, and must maintain
41 that documentation until at least one year after the termination of the representation. This
42 documentation shall be made available by Attorney to County (or County's designated
43 representative, including an accountant, the County Clerk or County Clerk's representative, or legal
44 bill auditor) upon County's written request. Attorney agrees to cooperate with any examination of
45 this documentation and Attorney's fees and expenses, e.g., by responding promptly and completely
6 of 15
I
to any questions County or its designated representative may have. Attorney shall notify County
2
in writing at least 60 days in advance of destroying any such records and, in the event that County
3
requests that they be preserved, shall preserve them at least one additional year or, at the option of
4
the County, delivered to the County for storage by the County, with County responsible for paying
5
the actual cost of storage. This documentation shall include, for example, original time records,
6
expense receipts, and documentation supporting the amount charged by Attorney for expense items
7
generated by the Attorney or his or her firm. County reserves the right not to pay any fee or expense
8
item for which sufficient documentation is not available to determine whether the item was
9
necessary and reasonable. Upon prior written Agreement by the County, Attorney may provide the
10
documentation in digital electronic form in Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) or in Alchemy
11
format in lieu of the manual preservation requirements detailed above.
12
13
6. Payment terms: Attorney's request for payments and reimbursements may be made in either
14
the Attorney's name or the name of the Attorney's law firm, as appropriate. Attorney bills
15
complying with this Agreement are due and payable upon receipt. If the bill materially fails to
16
comply with the requirements of this Agreement, then it is not due and payable until its deficiencies
17
are remedied by Attorney. County is entitled to a 1% prompt payment discount if a bill is paid
18
within 15 days of receipt by County or correction of deficiencies by Attorney, whichever is later,
19
(or if the bill is satisfied by funds held by Attorney, e.g., in a trust account). County shall not be
20
liable for interest or other late charges unless specifically agreed to in advance in a writing signed
21
by County.
22
23
7. Budgets. Attorney will, within thirty (30) days after the effective date of this Agreement,
24
re are an estimate or budget of likely costs b task of matter, including fees and P P g Y � Y g expenses
P
25
and a plan for handling the matter. Attorney will update the budget and plan at least once every
26
three months. In the event that Attorney obtains information indicating that the budget (or any line
27
item) may be exceeded by more than five percent, he or she will notify County of that immediately.
28
In a written statement accompanying each bill, preferably in tabular form. Attorney will reconcile
29
the budget with each month's bill, e.g., by explaining whether the billed amounts, by task, are more
30
or less than the amounts budgeted therefore. County shall have the right not to pay any amounts that
31
are over budget or not included within the budget.
32
33
8. Staffing and matter management. Attorney has been retained specifically because
34
Attorney, personally, is understood by County to be able to handle this matter. Employment of
35
additional individuals, whether attorneys, paralegals, or others, who will bill time to County is not
36
permitted without the advance written approval of County.
37
38
8.1. Time - keeper changes. Changes in time- keepers, e.g., replacement of an attorney
39
as well as increases or decreases in the number of the time - keepers working on the subject - matter
40
of this Agreement, must have the advance written approval of County. County expects to receive
41
discounts or other concessions so that any increases or changes in time - keepers will not result in
42
unnecessary or unreasonable charges to County, e.g., for training, internal conferences, and
43
management.
44
7 of 15
8 of 15
1
8.2. Duplication of effort. Unless advance County approval is ob__tain Attorney will
2
not have more than one time- keeper bill for court appearances, attendance at depositions an
3
meeting, including meetings with County representatives, and internal conferences. In the event that
4
more than one person attends, only the time of the person with the lowest rate will be billable.
5
Attorney is not permitted to use this matter to provide on the job training for a time- keeper, and bill
6
for that time- keeper's services, without County's advance approval.
7
8
8.3. Matter management. Attorney is responsible for managing the matter cost -
9
effectively and competently, e.g., by insuring that additional time - keepers are competent, properly
10
supervised, efficient, and in compliance with the terms of this Agreement as well as with ethical
11
obligations.
12
13
8.4. Communications. County will expect that all communications between Attorney
14
and County will be reviewed by Attorney and that Attorney will serve as the point of contact for this
15
matter, including billing questions. The point of contact for this matter at County is the County
16
Attorney or the individual specifically identified in Exhibit A.
17
18
8.5. Case monitoring. County will be advised promptly by Attorney of all significant
19
facts and developments in the matter so that County may mange the matter effectively and made
20
informed decisions about strategy, tactics, settlement, scheduling, costs, and other related matters.
21
County will promptly receive from Attorney copies of all orders, opinions, pleadings, briefs,
22
memoranda (internal and external), correspondence, and any other document material to the subject
23
matter of this Agreement, such that the County will have a current, up -to -date, "mirror" copy of the
24
County's file maintained by Attorney. For discovery materials or exhibits that are lengthy,
25
Attorney should discuss them with County before providing a copy. Documents available in digital
26
electronic /computerized form should be provided in that form in lieu of paper copies. Additionally,
27
Attorney may be required to submit, on a monthly basis, a case status and progress report to be
28
submitted to the Board of County Commissioners. The format of the report shall be in the form
29
required by the County Attorney.
30
31
8.6. Case control. Attorney shall discuss all significant issues of strategy and tactics,
32
including motions, discovery, pleadings, briefs, trial preparation, experts, and settlement, with
33
County before implementation. Attorney is expected to exercise independent professional judgment,
34
but to implement the decisions of County as expressed to the County by the County Attorney.
35
36
8.7. Attorney cooperation. Attorney will cooperate with County or County's
37
representatives to promptly provide all information County requests or needs about the subject
38
matter of this Agreement and Attorney's bills.
39
40
8.8. County cooperation. Attorney should consult with County about all opportunities
41
for County to save money or make use of County's expertise to assist in, e.g., responding to
42
discovery, preparing for trial, locating experts, and the like. County may also have personnel and
43
facilities available to reduce the expenses related to the subject matter of this Agreement.
44
8 of 15
1 8.9. Temporary staff, delegation, outsourcing. Attorney will not bill County for the
2 time and expenses of temporary employees, including so -called "Temps" or contract attorneys or
3 other staff from outside companies, nor ` outsource" or delegate work, nor charge for summer
4 associates, law clerks, or student clerks, (collectively "temporary staff' even if not temporarily
5 employed) without full advance disclosure of the employee's temporary or short -term status to
6 County, including disclosure of the actual amount paid or to be paid to the individual. Unless
7 County expressly agrees in writing to paying additional amounts after full disclosure by Attorney,
8 Attorney may not charge County more than the actual cost paid by attorney.
9
10 9. Confidentiality and public relations: Attorney is not authorized to waive or release any
11 privilege or other protection of information confidential, secret, or otherwise — obtained from or
12 on behalf of County. Attorney is to keep all confidential, privileged, or secret information
13 confidential. This requirement is perpetual, i.e., it will continue even after the termination of the
14 relationship and this Agreement. This requirement is also intended to prohibit Attorney from using
15 information obtained from or on behalf of County, including work product prepared at County's
16 expense, for other client's ofAttomey or his or her firm, without County's advance written approval.
17 Attorney is not authorized to identify County as a County, e.g., for purposes of marketing or
18 advertising, without County's prior approval. Upon termination of the representation, Attorney
19 agrees to return promptly all information obtained from or on behalf ofCounty to County. Attorney
20 is not authorized to communicate with the public, including the press, about County or this matter
21 without the advance approval ofCounty.
22
23 10. Ownership of Attorney files and work product: Attorney understands that all files and
24 work product prepared by Attorney or his or her firm at the expense ofCounty (or for which County
25 is otherwise billed) is the property of County. Without County's prior written approval, this work
26 product may not be used by Attorney or his or her firm nor disclosed by Attorney or his or her firm
27 to others, except in the normal course of Attorney's representation of County in this matter.
28 Attorney agrees that County owns all rights, including copyrights, to materials prepared by County
29 or by Attorney on behalf of County. Attorney shall notify County in writing at least 60 days in
30 advance ofdestroying any such records and, in the event that County requests that they be preserved,
31 shall preserve them at least one additional year (with County responsible for paying the actual cost
32 of storage). Attorney shall provide County with prompt access to (including the ability to make
33 copies of) all attorney files and work product, regardless of whether the representation or matter is
34 ongoing and whether attorney fees and expenses have been paid in full.
35
36 11. Dispute resolution: Attorney and County agree that all disputes regarding Attorney's fees
37 or expenses are to be resolved pursuant to the procedures and practices for mediation by the
38 Attorney Consumer Assistance Program of the Florida Bar.
39
40 12. Governing law, modification of this Agreement, entire agreement: This Agreement is
41 to be interpreted in accordance with the laws of Florida and with the ethical requirements of that
42 jurisdiction. The Agreement may not be modified in any way without the express, written agreement
43 of both parties. This represents the entire agreement of the parties.
44
45 13. Monroe County Code Ethics Provisions: This provision is found in Section 18.8 below.
9 of 15
1 14. Time Keeper Defined: As used in this Agreement, the term "time keeper" shall include
2 Attorney and other attorneys and individuals identified in Exhibit A who will be providing services
3 under this Agreement and who will bill the County for their services in accordance with this
4 Agreement.
5
6 15. Methods of Approval and Consent By County: Any consents or approvals required by this
7 Agreement to be made by the County shall, unless the context expressly states otherwise, be made
8 by the County Attorney or an authorized Assistant County Attorney in written form, to include but
9 not limited to hand - written, typed, or printed notes, electronic mail, letters, or facsimile
10 transmissions.
11
12 16. Florida Government -in- the - Sunshine Law: Attorney agrees that, unless specifically
13 exempted or excepted by Florida law, the provisions of Chapter 120, Florida Statutes, generally
14 require full and public discussion of matters to be voted upon by the Board of County
15 Commissioners. Attorney agrees to consult with the County Attorney's office concerning the
16 application of the Sunshine law from time to time concerning specific circumstances that may arise
17 during the term of this Agreement.
18
19 17. Florida Public Records Law: Attorney agrees that, unless specifically exempted or
20 excepted by Florida law or Rules and Regulations of The Florida Bar, the provisions of Chapter 119,
21 Florida Statutes, generally require public access to all records and documents which may be made
22 or received under this Agreement. Attorney agrees to consult with the County Attorney's office
23 concerning the application of the Public Records Law from time to time concerning specific
24 circumstances that may arise during the term of this Agreement.
25
26 18. County's Standard Contract Terms:
27
28 18.1 No Assignments. Without the prior written consent from the County, Attorney shall
29 not assign or transfer this Agreement.
30
31 18.2 Entire Agreement. The entire agreement between the County and Attorney with
32 respect to the subject matter hereof is contained in this Agreement. This Agreement supersedes all
33 prior oral and written proposals and communications between the County and Attorney related to
34 this Agreement. No provision of this Agreement shall be deemed waived, amended or modified by
35 either party unless such waiver, amendment or modification is in writing and signed by the party
36 against whom the waiver, amendment or modification is claimed. This Agreement shall be binding
37 upon and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto, their permitted successors and assigns.
38
39 18.3 Severability. If a term, covenant, condition or provision of this Agreement shall be
40 declared invalid or unenforceable to any extent by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining
41 terms, covenants, conditions and provisions of this Agreement shall not be affected thereby; and
42 each remaining term, covenant, condition and provision of this Agreement shall be valid and shall
43 be enforceable to the fullest extent permitted by law unless the enforcement of the remaining terms,
44 covenants, conditions and provision of this Agreement would prevent the accomplishment of the
45 original intent of this Agreement. The County and Attorney agree to reform the Agreement to
10 of 15
I replace any stricken provision with a valid provision that comes as close as possible to the intent of
2 the stricken provision.
3 18.4 Captions. The captions set forth herein are for convenience ofreference only and shall
4 not define, modify, or limit any of the terms hereof.
5
6 18.5 Governing Law and Venue. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in
7 accordance with the laws of the State of Florida applicable to contracts made and to be performed
8 entirely in the State. Venue for any legal action which may arise out of or under this agreement shall
9 be in Monroe County, Florida.
10
11 18.5.1 Conflicts in interpretation. The County and Attorney agree that, in the
12 event of conflicting interpretations ofthe terms or a term of this Agreement by or between them, the
13 final interpretation by the County shall apply.
14
15 18.5.2 Adjudication of Disputes and Disagreements. The County and Attorney
16 agree that all disputes and disagreements between them shall be attempted to be resolved by a meet
17 and confer session between representatives of the County and Attorney. If the issue or issues are
18 still not resolved to the satisfaction of both within 30 days after the meet and confer session, then
19 either shall have the right to seek such relief as may be provided by this Agreement or by Florida
20 law.
21
22 18.5.3 Cooperation. In the event any administrative or legal proceeding is instituted
23 against either the County or Attorney relating to the formation, execution, performance, or breach
24 of this Agreement, the County and Attorney each agree to participate, to the extent required by the
25 other, in all proceedings, hearings, processes, meetings, and other activities related to the substance
26 of this Agreement. The County and Attorney each agree that neither shall be required to enter into
27 any arbitration proceedings related to this Agreement or any Attachment or Addendum to this
28 Agreement.
29
30 18.5.4 Legal Obligations and Responsibilities; Non - delegation of Constitutional
31 or Statutory Duties. This Agreement is not intended to relieve, nor shall it be construed as
32 relieving, either the County or Attorney from any obligation or responsibility imposed upon each
33 by law except to the extent of actual and timely performance thereof by the other, in which case the
34 performance may be offered in satisfaction of the obligation or responsibility. Further this
35 Agreement is not intended to authorize, nor shall it be construed as authorizing, the delegation of
36 the constitutional or statutory duties of the County, except to the extent permitted by the Florida
37 Constitution, state statutes, case law, and, specifically, the provisions of Chapter 125, Florida
38 Statutes.
39
40 18.6 Attorney's Fees and Costs. In the event any administrative proceeding or cause of
41 action is initiated or defended by the County or Attorney relative to the enforcement or interpretation
42 of this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorney's fees,
43 court costs, investigative, and out -of- pocket expenses, as an award against the non - prevailing party,
44 and shall include reasonable attorney's fees, court costs, investigative, and out -of- pocket expenses
45 in appellate proceedings. Mediation proceedings initiated and conducted pursuant to this Agreement
11 of 15
■
I or as may be required by a court of competent jurisdiction shall be conducted in accordance with
2 the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure and usual and customary procedures required by the circuit
3 court of Monroe County.
4
5 18.7 Records. Attorney shall maintain all books, records, and documents directly pertinent
6 to performance under this Agreement, including the documents referred to in Sections 5.4 and 10
7 of this Agreement, in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, consistently
8 applied. Upon ten (10) business days written notice to the other, representatives of either the County
9 or Attorney shall have access, at all reasonable times, to all the other party's books, records,
10 correspondence, instructions, receipts, vouchers and memoranda (excluding computer software)
11 pertaining to work under this Agreement for the purpose of conducting a complete independent
12 fiscal audit. Attorney shall retain all records required to be kept under this Agreement for a
13 minimum of five years, and for at least four years after the termination of this agreement. Attorney
14 shall keep such records as are necessary to document the performance of the agreement and
15 expenses as incurred, and give access to these records at the request of the County, the State of
16 Florida or authorized agents and representatives of said government bodies. It is the responsibility
17 of Attorney to maintain appropriate records to insure a proper accounting of all collections and
18 remittances. Attorney shall be responsible for repayment of any and all audit exceptions which are
19 identified by the Auditor General for the State of Florida, the Clerk of Court for Monroe County,
20 the Board of County Commissioners for Monroe County, or their agents and representatives.
21
22 18.7.1 Public Access. The County and Attorney shall allow and permit reasonable
23 access to and inspection o1; all documents, papers, letters, or other materials subject to the Florida
24 Public Records Law, as provided in Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, and made or received by the
25 them, unless specifically exempted by State Statute, Rules and Regulations of The Florida Bar, or
26 case law. County shall have the right to cancel this agreement upon violation of this provision by
27 Attorney.
28
29 18.8 Monroe County Code Ethics Provision. Attorney warrants that he has not
30 employed, retained or otherwise had act on his behalf any former County officer or employee in
31 violation of Section 2 of Ordinance No. 10 -1990 or any County officer or employee in violation of
32 Section 3 of Ordinance No. 10 -1990. For breach or violation of this provision the County may, at
33 its discretion, terminate this Agreement without liability and may also, at its discretion, deduct from
34 the sums owed under the Agreement, or otherwise recover, the full amount of any fee, commission,
35 percentage, gift, or consideration paid to the former or present County officer or employee. County
36 employees and officers are required to comply with the standards of conduct delineated in Section
37 112.313, Florida Statutes, regarding, but not limited to, solicitation or acceptance of gifts, doing
38 business with one's agency, unauthorized compensation, misuse of public position, conflicting
39 employment or contractual relationship, and disclosure of certain information.
40
41 18.9 Authority. Attorney warrants that he and the authorized time keepers are authorized
42 by law and the Rules and Regulations of The Florida Bar to engage in the performance of the
43 activities encompassed by this Agreement. If Attorney is a member of a law firm, either as partner,
44 shareholder, associate, or other relationship, Attorney warrants that he is authorized to enter into this
45 Agreement by Attorney's law firm.
12 of 15
2 18.10 Public Entity Crime Statement. Florida law provides that person or affiliate who
3 has been placed on the convicted vendor list following a conviction for public entity crime may not
4 submit a bid on an agreement to provide any goods or services to a public entity, may not submit
5 a bid on a agreement with a public entity for the construction or repair of a public building or public
6 work, may not submit bids on leases of real property to public entity, may not be awarded or
7 perform work as a contractor, supplier, sub - contractor, or consultant under a agreement with any
8 public entity, and may not transact business with any public entity in excess of the threshold amount
9 provided in Section 287.017, for CATEGORY TWO for a period of 36 months from the date of
10 being placed on the convicted vendor list. Attorney warrants the neither Attorney nor any
11 authorized time keeper has been named to the convicted vendor list.
12
13 18.11 Anti- kickback. Attorney warrants that no person has been employed or retained to
14 solicit or secure this Agreement upon any contract or understanding for a commission, percentage,
15 brokerage or contingent fee, and that no employee or officer of the County has any interest,
16 financially or otherwise, in this Agreement, except as expressly stated herein. For breach or
17 violation of this warranty, the County shall have the right to annul this agreement without liability
18 or, in its discretion, to deduct any sums to be paid by County under this Agreement, or otherwise
19 recover, the full amount of such commission, percentage, brokerage or contingent fee.
20
21 18.12 Modifications and Amendments. Any and all modifications of the terms of this
22 agreement shall only be amended in writing and executed by the Board of County Commissioners
23 for Monroe County and by Attorney.
24
25 18.13 Independent Contractor. At all times and for all purposes hereunder, Attorney is
26 an independent contractor and not an employee of the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe
27 County. No statement contained in this Agreement shall be construed so as to find Attorney or any
28 of the authorized time keepers, to be the employees of the Board of County Commissioners of
29 Monroe County, and they shall be entitled to none of the rights, privileges or benefits of employees
30 of Monroe County.
31
32 18.14 Compliance with Law. In carrying out Attorney's obligations under this agreement,
33 Attorney shall abide by all statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations pertaining to or regulating the
34 provisions of this Agreement, including those now in effect and hereafter adopted. Any violation
35 of said statutes, ordinances, rules or regulations shall constitute a material breach of this Agreement
36 and shall entitle the County to terminate this Agreement immediately upon delivery of written notice
37 of termination to Attorney.
38
39 18.15 Licensing and Permits. Attorney warrants that Attorney shall have, prior to
40 commencement of work under this agreement and at all times during said work, all required licenses
41 and permits whether federal, state, County or City.
42
43 18.16 Non- Discrimination. Attorney shall not discriminate, in its employment practices
44 and in providing services hereunder, on the basis of race, color, sex, religion, disability, national
45 origin, ancestry, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, familial status, or age, and shall
13 of 15
A
I abide by all federal and state laws regarding non - discrimination. Upon a determination by a court
2 of competent jurisdiction that such discrimination has occurred, this Agreement automatically
3 terminates without any further action by the County, effective the date of the court order. Attorney
4 is aware of the provisions of Section 13 -101 through 13 -106, Monroe County Code, relating to non-
5 discrimination, and agrees to abide by the Code's non - discrimination requirements.
6
7 18.17 Claims for State or Federal Aid. The County and Attorney agree that each shall be,
8 and is, empowered to apply for, seek, and obtain federal and state funds to further the purpose of this
9 Agreement, provided that all applications, requests, grant proposals, and funding solicitations by
10 Attorney shall be approved by the County prior to submission.
11
12 18.18 Non - Reliance by Non - Parties. No person or entity shall be entitled to rely upon the
13 terms, or any of them, of this Agreement to enforce or attempt to enforce any third -party claim or
14 entitlement to or benefit of any service or program contemplated hereunder, and the County and
15 Attorney agree that neither the County nor Attorney or any officer, agent, or employee of each shall
16 have the authority to inform, counsel, or otherwise indicate that any particular individual or group
17 of individuals, entity or entities, have entitlements or benefits under this Agreement separate and
18 apart, inferior to, or superior to the community in general or for the purposes contemplated under
19 this Agreement.
20
21 18.19 Attestations. Attorney agrees to execute such documents as the County may
22 reasonable require, including a Drug -Free Workplace Statement, and a Public Entity Crime
23 Statement.
24
25 18.20 Signatures of Parties Required. This Agreement shall not be effective until
26 executed by both County and Attorney and received in final executed form by an authorized
27 representative of County.
28
29 18.21 County Authority. This Agreement has been at a duly noticed and legally held
30 public meeting conducted in Monroe County, Florida.
31
32 18.22 No Personal Liability. No covenant or obligation contained in this Agreement shall
33 be deemed to be a covenant or obligation of any member, officer, agent or employee of the Board
34 Of County Commissioners of Monroe County in his or her individual capacity and no member,
35 officer, agent or employee of the Board Of County Commissioners of Monroe County shall be liable
36 personally on this Agreement or be subject to any personal liability or accountability by reason of
37 the execution of this Agreement.
38
39 18.23 Execution in Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of
40 counterparts, each of which shall be regarded as an original, all of which taken together shall
41 constitute one and the same instrument and the County and Attorney may execute this Agreement
42 by signing any such counterpart.
43
14 of 15
{
1
2
4
5
7
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
c
O
C-)
w
d
C
Lam}
r
w
THIS AGREEMENT has been signed and executed by the Board of County Commissioners
r_ unty, Florida, and has been signed and executed by Attorney, on the dates indicated
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
A =� OF MONROE CO Y, FLORIDA
r-3..
BY:
. OL GE, CLERK MAYOR CHARLWS SOPNY" MCCOY
B " " Date: March 15, 2006
eput- Clerk
Date: March 15, 2006
Witnesses For Attorney: ATTO 7
Signature Signature
IRA L. LIBANOFF, ESQ.
Printed Name Printed Name /�
/SO ,5. /� /i, �venj .Pc
Mailing Addres 5C., /
Signature i re- 4co
Printed Name PC,. "., FL
City/State /ZIP
0
0
N
a
r—
GC
4
Z
0
N
W _Q
J U O
}' J LU
v o
Z Z
a o
o 1:
15 of 15
ATT y
To
NNE A. H ON
NIY TT RNEY
MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA AGREEMENT NUMBER:
STANDARD LEGAL SERVICES AGREEMENT CAY LIT 2005 -06 -02
(LITIGATION)
EXHIBIT A
Litigation Identification: Tropex Construction Services, Inc. v. Monroe County, 2006- CA -44 -P
Re: Tavernier Fire Station Renovation Project
References:
3.2: Limitations to Scope of Representation: County Attorney's office shall serve as co- counsel.
3.4: County expectations and goals: Prompt, efficient, competent representation by Ira Libanoff as
lead counsel.
4.: Attorney's Hourly Fee Rate: Ira L i bano f f $250.00 per hour.
Janet Ritenbaugh $225.00 per hour.
Lori Shapiro $200.00 per hour.
4.4: Approved Additional Time Keepers: Paralegal $85.00 per hour.
Name:
5.4: County Point of Contact:
r
2-MM-0 4 -
��
Date: tv
Hourly Rate:
Robert B. Shillinger
Assistant County Attorney
P.O. Box 1026
Key West, FL 33041 -1026
(305) 292 -3470
(305) 292 -3516 (fax)
Shillinger- Bob@monroecounty-fl.gov
County Representative
Date: - i 4<
f4 FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT DATED MARCH 15, 2006
BETWEEN MONROE COUNTY AND IRA LIBANOFF, ESQ.
On this c?/ - day of , 2007, the Board of County Commissioners of
Monroe County, Florida, as the legislative and governing body of Monroe County,
Florida, and in accordance with the powers enumerated in Section 125.0 1, Florida
Statutes ( "County'l and Ira Libanoff, Esq., ("Attorney'), hereby entered into this First
Amendment to their agreement dated March 15, 2006, which bears a reference number of
2005- 06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained
herein, the parties amend the Agreement of March 15, 2006, as follows:
Part A . This fast amendment is entered into to clarify the existing relationship between
the County and the Party. The attorney has represented the County through various
engagement letters since 1999 in construction matters. This March 15, 2006 Agreement
related to representation for the County's dispute with Tropex Construction Services,
Inc. over the contract to construct the Tavernier Fire Station.
By this amendment, the parties intend to continue the agreement as it pertains to Tropex
Construction Services and to formalize the attorney's representation of the County on the
following additional matters, which were previously billed under letters of engagement or
other less formal agreements:
Consultation on General Matters as necessary at discretion of County Attorney
Monroe County v. Bender & Associates, CA K 03 -915
Monroe County v. Jose Gonzalez, no case number yet
Monroe County v. Lodge Construction, et al, CA K 00 -617
D.L. Porter Constructors, Inc. v. Monroe County, CA K 07 -155.
Part B . In order to effectuate the amendments set forth above in Part A, the original
agreement is amended as follows to reflect new hourly rates and additional time keepers.
Hourly rates for ATTORNEY and additional Timekeepers will be set at:
Approved Time Keepers
Janet Ritenbaugh
Lori Shapiro
Sandra D. Kennedy
Jason L. Molder
Laura Papay
Hourly Rate
$225.00
$225.00
$200.00
$195.00
$165.00
'.
Board of County Commissioners
Of Monroe County, Florida
Mario Di Gennaro, Mayor
MAR 2 12007
Laura Gerwens, paralegal $85.00
Karen Gjertsen $85.00
ATTORNEY will charge no more than the hourly rate quoted above throughout the
duration of the representation on all cases covered by this Agreement, unless otherwise
agreed to in writing and approved by the COUNTY in the same manner as in this First
Amendment to original agreement.
THIS FIRST AMENDMENT to the agreement dated March 15, 2006 shall
become effective when executed by both the ATTORNEY and executed 6y the Board of
County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
Witness:
M 61al fr1
Print Name
Date:
Ira Libano , sq.
Date z a a
rn
C
.r- -<
I
-n
n?
CS
rn
MONROE COUNTY- AT�RI�
0
;i
PPROVED AS RMw
g
N TILEENE W. CASSEL
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
Date
0
Second Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
On this /S day ofgLc-, 2010 the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County,
Florida, as the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance
with the powers enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County") and Ira Libanoff,
Esq. ( "Attorney"), hereby entered into this Second Amendment to their agreement dated
March 15, 2006, which bears a reference number of 2005- 06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein,
the parties amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, as follows:
Part A. This second amendment is entered into to clarify the existing relationship between the
County and the Attorney. The Attorney has represented the County on several cases which are
now completed and this amendment is intended to update the contract to clarify the cases in
which the Attorney continues to represent the County and to add another case to the
responsibilities of the Attorney.
The Attorney shall represent the County in the following matters:
- Consultation on General Matters as necessary at the discretion of County Attorney
- Monroe County v. Gonzalez Architects and Jose' Gonzalez, Case Number CAK071428
- Consultation on settlement and any subsequent litigation as related to the Key West
Airport and Marathon Airport.
Part B . in order to effectuate the amendment set forth in Part A, the original agreement and
first amendment are amended as follows to reflect new hourly rates and additional time
keepers.
Hourly rates for Attorney and additional Timekeepers will be set at:
Approved Time Keepers
Hourly Rate
Ira Libanoff
$250.00
Janet Ritenbaugh
$250.00
Warren Diener
$195.00
Andrea Garcia
$90.00
Elizabeth Garcia
$90.00
Attorney will charge no more than the stated hourly rate quoted above throughout the
duration of the representation on all cases covered by this Agreement, unless otherwise agree
to in writing and approved by the County in the same manner as in this Second Amendment.
Page 1 of 2
All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, which are not amended herein, shall remain in full
force and effect. This Second Amendment shall become effective when executed by both the
Attorney and the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this lease to be executed this
DEC i 5 2010.
!
3
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
NNY L. KOLHAGE, CLERK OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
4
B _ T By -
Deputy Clerk Mayor Ifeathertarruthers
Witnes or Ira Libano Esq. By
(1 ��' �-- Date:
Ira j , q.
n tp. IfI3.1 o
G ';itTY ATTO" :cv
;t.TIL =`'N W. NA SSEL
AS +w• -. ' i
COUNT `! ATTCRNEY
Page 2 of 2
Third Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
On this c day o 2011, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County,
Florida, as the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance
with the powers enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County ") and Ira Libanoff,
Esq. ( "Attorney "), hereby entered into this Third Amendment to their agreement dated March
1S, 2006, which bears a reference number of 2005- 06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein,
the parties amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, and the First Amendment dated ,
and the Second Amendment dated as follows:
1. Part B of the Second Amendment to the Agreement shall be amended to read as
follows:
"Part B . In order to effectuate the amendment set forth in Part A, the original
agreement and first amendment are amended as follows to reflect new hourly rates and
additional time keepers.
Hourly rates for Attorney and additional Timekeepers will be set at:
Approved Time Keepers
Hourly Rate
Ira Libanoff
$250.00
Janet Ritenbaugh
$250.00
Warren Diener
$195.00
Andrea Garcia
$90.00
Elizabeth Garcia
$90.00
Attorney will charge no more than the stated hourly rate quoted above
throughout the duration of the representation on all cases covered by this Agreement,
unless otherwise agree to in writing and approved by the County.
This Third Amendment, the Approved Time Keepers and stated Hourly rates shall
be effective as of October 1, 2010 and all invoices shall be paid retroactive to October
1,2010.
2. All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, which are not amended herein, shall remain
Page 1 of 2
a
in full force and effect. This Second Amendment shall become effective when executed by both
the Attorney and the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
C1
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this lease to be executed this 2 ��
_. 2011.
Y L. KOLHAGE, CLERK
M.
Deputy Clerk
Witness for Ira Libanoff, Esq.
Date:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
B la
Mayor Heath Car ers
By
Ira 4 ib V Date: 6 1 19
MONROE COUNTY ATTORNEY
PROVED AS TO
NAT LEENE �.'v. CASSEL
ASSISTANT COUNTY TTORNEY
Date
Page 2 of 2
F
k
t
i
o
:
,
r rI
CD
- , v
CD
Na
O
_
N
M
to
M
Q
O
Page 2 of 2
F
k
t
i
■
Fourth Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
On this 15th day of February, 2012, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe
County, Florida, as the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in
accordance with the powers enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County ")
and Ira Libanoff, Esq., ( "Attorney "), hereby entered into this Fourth Amendment to their
original agreement dated March 15, 2006 ( "Agreement') which bears a reference number
of 2005- 06 -02.
WHEREAS, the Agreement between the parties specifies the names of authorized
timekeepers; and
WHEREAS, it is necessary to amend the Agreement from time to time in order to
revise the list of approved timekeepers; and
WHEREAS, the parties wish to amend the Agreement in order to add the name of
Alex Williams to the terms of engagement;
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained
herein, the parties amend the July 19, 2006 agreement as follows:
1. Part B of the second amendment to the Agreement shall be amended to read as
follows:
Part B . In order to effectuate the amendment set forth in Part A the
original agreement and first amendment are amended as follows:
Approved Time Keepers Hourly Rate
Ira Libanoff, Esq.
$250.00
Janet Rittenbaugh, Esq.
$250.00
Alex Williams, Esq.
$250.00
Warren Diener, Esq.
$115.00
Andrea Garcia, paralegal
$ 90.00
Elizabeth Garcia, paralegal
$ 90.00
Attorney will charge no more that the stated hourly rate quoted above
throughout the duration of the representation on all case covered by this agreement,
unless otherwise agreed to in writing and approved by the County.
2. All other provisions of the March 15, 2006 original agreement and the Dec. 15,
2010 second amendment, which are not amended herein, shall remain in full force and
effect.
'r WITNESS WEIEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands and seals the
da i *ar first above written.
'��• , KO GE
Deputy Clerk
Witness:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
May D vi ice
Ferencik, Libanoff, randt, Bustamente
And Williams
Ira Libanoff, E
Print Name
T "
t7:7
1
7 hJ
1
�
N
µ'
N
c7
O
im ON
Cl
P
FIFTH Amendment to Agreement Dated March 15, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
On this L day of; 2012, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, as
the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance with the powers
enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County") and Ira Libanoff, Esq. ( "Attorney "), hereby
entered into this Third Amendment to their agreement dated March 15, 2006, which bears a reference
number of 2005 -06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein, the parties
amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, to correct a scrivener's error in the Fourth Amendment to
the agreement as follows:
1. Part B of the Second Amendment to the Agreement shall be amended to read as follows:
"Part B . In order to effectuate this Amendment and to correct a scrivener's error the only
change will be the hourly rate of Warren Diener, Esq., whose hourly rate shall be One Hundred
and Ninety Five Dollars (195.00).
2. This Fifth Amendment, correction of scrivener's error shall be retroactive to September 21, 2011
and all invoices shall be paid retroactive to that date.
3.
All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, which are not amended herein, shall remain in full
force and effect. This Fifth Amendment shall become effective when executed by both the
Attorney and the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida.
IN VYITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this lease to be executed this !sue day
of
2012.
(SEAL)
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
ATTEST: DANNY L KOLHAGE, CLERK OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
B
BY
Deputy Clerk Mayor LL
c
o
Witness for Ira Libanoff, Esq. By
:
Ira Libanoff, Esq • : "- :
rn
(1)
Date: '1 • Z!• t L _ r,
ry
o
r
fV
fV
0
Date:
MONROE COUNTY ATTORN Y�
A ROV D AS TO FOi
SS AIL ENE W. CASSEL
ISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
Dete .j_
Sixth Amendment to Agreement Dated March 1S, 2006
Between Monroe County and Ira Libanoff, Esq.
/ 9 LL
On this /� day of C.T. 2012, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, as
the legislative and governing body of Monroe County, Florida, and in accordance with the powers
enumerated in Section 125.01, Florida Statutes ( "County") and Ira Libanoff, Esq. ( "Attorney"), hereby
entered into this Second Amendment to their agreement dated March 15, 2006, which bears a
reference number of 2005 -06 -02.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants and provisions contained herein, the parties
amend their agreement of March 15, 2006, as follows:
1. This sixth amendment is entered into to add another case to the responsibilities of the Attorney.
The Attorney shall represent the County on the following matter:
- Consultation on contract matters and /or litigation which may arise between the County and
American Bridge Company.
All other provisions of the March 15, 2006, and amendments thereto shall remain in full force and
effect. This Sixth Amendment shall become effective when executed by both the Attorney and the Board
of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida; and shall be retroactive to September 9, 2012, the
date when the County Attorney assigned the case to Attorney.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this amendment to be executed this / 7, t;k
day of 6 2012.
(SEAL)
ATTEST: DANNY L. KOLHAGE, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
Deputy Clerk
By
Ira Libanoff, Esq.
Date: '74 / t z --
By
Mayor Davld Rice
MONROE COUNTY ATTOR EY
ROVED AS T F
NA ILEENE W. CASSEL
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
Date
n
-
N
p
"O
%7
O
70