The URL can be used to link to this page

Item P4BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY Meeting Date: May 20, 2015 Bulk Item: Yes No X TIME CERTAIN 2 PM Division: County Attorney Department: Code Compliance Staff Contact /Phone #: Steve Williams/292-3470 AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Discussion and direction at the request from Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen, the property owners, to address the BOCC, asking it to remove outstanding code fines imposed in code case CE07040059. ITEM BACKGROUND: As a result of Code Case CE07040059, Order Imposing Penalty and Authorizing Recording Lien was recorded as a lien on behalf of the County on December 21, 2009. On October 24, 2013, an online auction sale was held and the property was purchased by Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen, with outstanding violations. After receiving a partial payment of $2,910.37 and a New Buyer Affidavit from Mr. and Mrs. Andersen, the County issued a Partial Lien release and Mr. and Mrs. Andersen took responsibility for curing the remaining violations: Permit(s), approval(s) and inspection(s) are required for interior renovations (installation of new tile, painting electric, plumbing and drywall) and installation of (approximately 13) ground level exterior flood lights fixtures. In the New Buyer Affidavit Mr. and Mrs. Andersen agreed to a compliance date of April 29, 2014. Compliance was not achieved by that date and the daily fine of $100.00 began accruing. On May 22, 2014 the Final Order dated December 3, 2013 approving the New Buyer Affidavit was recorded as a lien on behalf of the County. Compliance was achieved on August 13, 2014, therefore a daily fine(s) of $150.00 per day accrued for 105 days, (April 30, 2014 - August 13, 2014) for a total fine amount of $15,750.00 Additionally Per F.S. §162.07(2), if the local governing body prevails in prosecuting a case before the enforcement board, it shall be entitled to recover all costs incurred in prosecuting the case before the board and such costs may be included in the lien authorized under F.S.§162.09(3). To date these costs were $704.60 and continue to accrue until the case is closed. Therefore the total amount of the lien to date was $16,454.60 and a letter was mailed on November 25, 2014. This letter included the maximum reduction amount allowed by staff, $4,642.10 ($3,937.50 fines and $704.60 costs) and explained that staffs authority to reduce fines was limited per resolution and any reduction in the fine amount lower than that would have to be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. This offer expired December 25, 2014. On December 4, 2015, staff, (Roman Gastesi, Steve Williams, Christine Hurley, Ronda Norman and Kathleen Windsor) met with Mr. Andersen. At this meeting the County agreed to stay the costs accrual until Mr. Andersen could address the BOCC. On December 4, 2015 staff received a request from Mr. Andersen to appear at the February 18, 2015 BOCC, and on March 28, 2015 the request was changed to the May 20, 2015 BOCC meeting. 1 PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: On May 21, 2008 the BOCC passed and adopted resolution 148-2008 adopting a maximum amount for the reduction of fines by staff after the property has been made compliant. CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: A daily fine of $150.00 per day accrued for 105 days (April 30, 2014 - August 13, 2014) for a total fine amount of $15,750.00. As of December 4, 2014 the costs were $704.60. Therefore the total amount of the lien as of December 4, 2014 was $16,454.60. Remove the fines that accrued during the permit application review period, (63 days) thereby reducing the fine amount by $9,450.00, and accept $7,004.60, ($6,300.00 fines and $704.60 costs), for 30 days and provide a Full Satisfaction and Release of Lien upon payment. After 30 days amount will revert to the full amount of $16,454.60. TOTAL COST: INDIRECT COST: DIFFERENTIAL OF LOCAL PREFERENCE: BUDGETED: Yes COST TO COUNTY: SOURCE OF FUNDS: REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes No APPROVED BY: County A" - DOCUMENTATION: Included DISPOSITION: AMOUNT PER MONTH Year OMB/Purchasing Not Required. Risk Management AGENDA ITEM # Code Compliance Department 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon, Florida 33050 Voice: (305) 289-2810 FAX: (305) 289-2536 County of Monroe Growth Management Division We strive to be caring, professional, and fair. MEMORANDUM Board of County Commissioners Mayor Danny L. Kolhage, Dist.I Mayor Pro Tern Heather Carruthers, Dist. 3 George Neugent, Dist. 2 David Rice, Dist. 4 Sylvia J. Murphy, Dist. 5 TO: Steve Williams, Assistant County Attorney FROM: Kathleen Windsor, Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst DATE: April 27, 2015 SUBJECT: Request for additional reduction in fines CE07040059, 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO SUMMARY: The County has received a request from Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen, the property owners, to address the BOCC, asking it to remove fines. CASE CE07040059 BACKGROUND: On April 5, 2007 a Stop Work Order was placed on the property for work commencing prior to a required permit. A case was created CE07040059 and on September 26, 2008, Philip Bowers, the property owner at the time, was sent a Notice of MotiomWotice of Hearing certified mail for a hearing to be held on December 4, 2008. Hearings were held on December 4, 2008 and February 26, 2009. Compliance was not achieved and the Order Imposing Penalty and Authorizing Recording Lien was recorded as a lien on behalf of the County on December 21, 2009. The daily fine accrued for 1567 days until a Certificate of Title to Bank of America was recorded in the Official Records on May 9, 2013. Subsequently, the property was purchased by Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen on October 24, 2013. In June of 2013, (and prior to the online auction sale in October), the County began receiving numerous inquiries from approximately 6 interested parties and on July 8, 2013 staff reviewed the circumstances of this case and the foreclosure action. As a result, the County would accept a payment of $2,910.37 for CE07040059, ($2,500.00 fines and $410.37 costs); and will provide a Partial Release of Lien to be filed with the clerks of courts. Staff was contacted by Mrs. Andersen, one of the interested parties. Prior to purchase, Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen were informed: • On July 26, 2013 an email was sent disclosing the remaining violations along with a New Buyer Affidavit. To -Wit: 110-140(1) - BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED. Permit(s), approval(s) and inspection(s) are required for interior renovations (installation of new tile, painting electric, plumbing and drywall) and installation of (approximately 13) ground level exterior flood lights fixtures. Corrective Action Required: Contact the Monroe County Building and Planning Department and obtain an after the fact permit or remove as directed. • On July 31, 2013 staff received an email from Mr. Andersen asking to waive the lien. • On August 2, 2013 staff received an email from Mr. Andersen asking the County to inspect the property. • On August 2, 2013 staff responded via an email that the offer was firm and staff encouraged the Andersens to obtain counsel. The County received payment and the signed New Buyer Affidavit on November 5, 2013. On November 25, 2013 staff received the Quit Claim deed from the closing company transferring ownership of this property to Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen on October 24, 2013. Staff executed the New Buyer Affidavit on behalf of the County giving Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen until April 29, 2014 to achieve compliance or the daily fine of $150.00 would begin accruing. The Partial Release was mailed to the property owners. A post -purchase time -line looks as follows: • On November 25, 2013 an email was sent to the property owners, attaching the inspector's photos for their use at the building department, and the executed new buyer affidavit. • On December 3, 2013 the Special Magistrate issued a Final Order approving the New Buyer affidavit. • On December 6, 2013 the Final Order was sent to the property owners. • On January 12, 2014 staff received an email for property owners disputing the need for a permit. • On January 13, 2014 an email was sent to the property owners, attaching the inspector's photos for their use at the building department • On March 3, 2014 an email was sent to the property owner in response to continued dispute of needing a permit to achieve compliance. • On April 24, 2014 an email was sent to the property owner stating that the fines cannot be stayed. • On April 28, 2014 Code Compliance staff agreed to make a site visit at the persistence of the property owners. • On April 29, 2015 staff received an email from Mr. Andersen with a lengthy punch list of inspections that he wanted conducted by the County. No permit application has been submitted at this time. • On April 30, 2015 the daily fine began accrue per executed New Buyer Affidavit. • On May 1, 2014, Code Compliance staff confirmed a May 6, 2014 site visit. • On May 6, 2014 Inspector Windsor made a site visit and took photos of interior renovations (installation of new tile, painting electric, plumbing and drywall), and photos documenting the removal of installation of (approximately 13) ground level exterior flood lights fixtures. Explained to Mr. Andersen, the inspections he is requesting can only be conducted by a Building Inspector after the issuance of a permit. • On May 6, 2014 the property owner applied for permit 14302143 and it was passed to Inspector Windsor. • On May 15, 2014 the application was reviewed with the Building Official, Jerry Smith and the he amended the application to the correct language. The permit was then passed on to the other required disciplines for plans review and approvals. Although the comments on page 5 of the application, SCOPE OF WORK, were inappropriate, the County accepted the application. • On May 15, 2014 an email was sent to the property owners offering an Extension to the compliance date of August 6, 2014. This offer was good until May 21, 2014. • On May 20, 2014 staff received an email form Mr. Andersen stating that Mrs. Andersen was out of the Country. Staff responded to accept the Extension with just Mr. Andersen's signature. • On May 20, 2014 staff received an email from Mrs. Andersen disputing the need for an extension. • On May 20, 2014 staff responded that they are not being forced to sign the extension. Daily fines began accruing on April 30, 2014 as per the New Buyer affidavit. • On May 21, 2014 the Final Order was sent to the Clerk's Office for recording and was recorded as a Lien on May 22, 2014. • On May 22, 2014 staff received an email from the property owners asking to stay the fines. • On June 4, 2014 staff received an email from the property owners asking to meet with County Administrator. • On July 17, 2014 Building Department staff emailed the property owner that review of the permit application by the Building Official, John Travers, resulted in the determination that the work done does require a permit. • On July 23 2014 Christine Hurley emailed the property owner that subcontractors would be required on the permit. • On July 25, 2014 the permit 14302143 for AFTER -THE -FACT REMODEUREPAIR INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR was issued. 0) • On July 28, 2014, the Building Official, John Travers, personally conducted an inspection and prepared a "punch list" of details that need to be corrected before inspections can be passed, and the permit can be closed. • On August 13, 2014, the building inspections passed and permit was closed, thereby achieving compliance of CE07040059. Compliance was achieved on August 13, 2014, therefore a daily fine(s) of $150.00 per day accrued for 105 days, (April 30, 2014 - August 13, 2014) for a total fine amount of $15,750.00 Additionally Per F.S. §162.07(2), if the local governing body prevails in prosecuting a case before the enforcement board, it shall be entitled to recover all costs incurred in prosecuting the case before the board and such costs may be included in the lien authorized under F.S.§162.09(3). To date these costs are $704.60 and continue to accrue until the case is closed. Therefore the total amount of the lien to date was $16,454.60 and a letter was mailed on November 25, 2014. This letter included the maximum reduction amount allowed by staff, $4,642.10 ($3,937.50 fines and $704.60 costs) and explained that staff s authority to reduce fines was limited per resolution and any reduction in the fine amount lower than that would have to be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. This offer expired December 25, 2014. On November 27, 2014 staff received an email from Mrs. Andersen requesting to have the funds paid for the Partial Release refunded to them. On December 4, 2015, staff, (Roman Gastesi, Steve Williams, Christine Hurley, Ronda Norman and Kathleen Windsor) met with Mr. Andersen. At this meeting the County agreed to stay the costs accrual until Mr. Andersen could address the BOCC. On December 4, 2015 staff received a request from Mr. Andersen to appear at the February 18, 2015 BOCC, and on March 28, 2015 the request was changed to the May 20, 2015 BOCC meeting. NOTE: As a follow-up to the inspection made by John Travers, Building Official, an email was sent to the property owners on August 5, 2014 regarding two expired permits. These permits remain expired. STAFF RECONEIIENDATIONS: A daily fine of $150.00 per day accrued for 105 days (April 30, 2014 - August 13, 2014) for a total fine amount of $15,750.00. As of December 4, 2014 the costs were $704.60. Therefore the total amount of the lien as of December 4, 2014 was $16,454.60. Remove the fines that accrued during the permit application review period, (63 days) thereby reducing the fine amount by $9,450.00, and accept $7,004.60, ($6,300.00 fines and $704.60 costs), for 30 days and provide a Full Satisfaction and Release of Lien upon payment. After 30 days amount will revert to the full amount of $16,454.60. LII J Attachments: Case Detail - 12 pages Stop Work Order Photos- 3 pages 2008 Property Record Card Notice of Violation/Notice of Hearing Final Order Order imposing penalty and Authorizing Recording Lien Certificate of Title to Bank of America October 24, 2013 - Quit Claim Deed to Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen July 25, 2013 - Email to Andersens with blank New Buyer Affidavit July 31, 2013 - Email to Andersens August 1, 2013 - Email to Andersens August 2, 2013 - Email to Andersens Payment receipt November 25, 2013 Executed New Buyer Affidavit November 25, 2013 - Email to Andersens Partial Release December 2, 2013 - Recorded Quit Claim Deed to Frances E. and Jon S. Andersen Final Order January 12, 2014 - Email from Mr. Andersen January 13, 2014 - Email to Andersens March 3, 2014 - Email to Andersens - 6 pages April 24, 2014 - Email to Andersens April 28, 2014 - Email to Andersens April 29, 2015 - Email from Mr. Andersen May 1, 2014 - Email to Andersens Photos - May 6, 2014 - 6 pages Permit Application - 5 pages May 15, 2014 - Email to Andersens Stipulation for an extension of time to comply May 20, 2014 - Email from Mr. Andersen and reply. May 20, 2014 - Email from Mrs. Andersen. May 20, 2014 - Email to Andersens Final Order and New Buyer Affidavit recorded as a Lien on May 22, 2014 - 6 pages May 22, 2014- Email from Mrs. Andersen June 4, 2014 - Email from Mr. Andersen. July 17, 2014 - Email to Andersens - 3 pages July 23 2014 - Email to Andersens Permit Detail 14302143 Building Official, John Travers, "punch list' - 3 pages Fine Screen November 25, 2014 - Fine Reduction Offer November 27, 2014 - Email from Mrs. Andersen Request to be heard at BOCC August 5, 2014 - Email to Andersens Plan review details 14302143 Day calculation for permit reviews Current Property Record Card FAI a" CODE ENFORCEMENT Case Number CE07040059 Case Date 04-05-2007 Origination 4 - CDF Operator reedere PROPERTY ON CASE RE Property Address City/State/Zip 00497930000000 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE KEY LARGO FL 33037 DETAIL Tenant Add Info Status Officer NO PERMIT: INTERIOR RENOVATIONS ( INSTALLATION OF NEW TILE, PAINTING ELECTRIC, PLUMBING AND DRYWALL) AND __... _. m..._._, _- - INSTALLATION OF (APPROXIMATELY 13) GROUND LEVEL EXTERIOR FLOOD LIGHTS FIXTURES. ORIGINAL INSPECTOR - TOM KERR THIS CASE WAS COMPLIANT ON AUGUST 1 2014. VIOLATION CODE(S 1: 110-140.(1) -- BUILDING PERMIT REQ/CH 6 2: 9.5-111(1) -- BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED NOTES Owner Owner Address City/State/Zip Phone COPIES OF ALL CORRESPONDENCE TO BE MAILED TO PO'S MIAMI COMPANION CASE IS CE08010003 7006 2760 0004 2254 4887 L -LIEN CREATED KW ANDERSEN FRANCES E Ft JON S ANDERSEN 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE KEY LARGO FL 33037 INSPECTIONS/EVENTS DETAIL DA"rE r1ME INSPECTION / EVENT TYPE INSTRUCTIONS / COMMENTS 35-20-2015 14:15:06 CASE HEARD BEFORE BOCC SCHEDULING http://egov.monroecounty-fl.Qov/eGovPlusicode/code dtl.asox?case no=CE07040059 A11RIMi1; Code Enforcement Detail Page 2 of 12 03-28-2015 14:13:15 COMMENT CODE PO REVISED REQUEST FOR BOCC TO THE MAY 20, 2014 MEETING. 02-18 2015 14 07 58 CASE HEARD BEFORE BOCC _ _ -- _ SCHEDULING PER PO REQUEST _. �... _ _— 01-12-2015 14:09:48 COMMENT CODE EMAIL FROM PO, NOT SURE HE CAN ATTEND _.. �......._... �_ ., m _ .. BOCC ON 2-18-2015 u . ._ .... _. �_....—_ -- ROMAN, CHRISTINE, KAT, STEVE AND RONDA MET W/ MR ANDERSEN AT GATO BLDG. HE NEEDS TO ADDRESS THE BOCC FOR REDUCTION, WE CANNOT DO IT, THE LIEN HAS 12-04-2014 14:05:29 COMMENT CODE BEEN FILED AND HE PURCHASED THE PROPERTY WITH VIOLATIONS. NEEDS TO REQUEST IN WRTING BY JANUARY 18, 2014. COUNTY WILL HOLD AMOUNT OF COSTS FOR _...�_ BOCC. ,._�..m. 11-25-2014 14:03:41 COMMENT CODE _. ... .. .._. .__. _............... _w— ORIGINAL FILE IN MTH OF LIEN - MAY 2014 „v....... _.............. _ �....... _ THIS CASE WAS COMPLIANT ON AUGUST 13, 2014 AND FINES AND COSTS ARE DUE. FINE(S) OF $150.00 PER DAY ACCRUED FOR 105 DAYS, (APRIL 30, 2014 - AUGUST 13, 2014) FOR A TOTAL FINE AMOUNT OF $15,750.00, ($150.00 PER DAY FOR 105 DAYS). TO DATE, COSTS ARE $704.60 AND COSTS WILL CONTINUE TO ACCRUE UNTIL THE CASE IS CLOSED. 11-25-2014 13:52:52 MITIGATION OF FINES OFFER THEREFORE THE CURRENT AMOUNT OF THE MONROE COUNTY LIEN IS $16,454.60 ($15,750.00 FINES AND $704.60 COSTS). THE COUNTY WILL ACCEPT THE MINIMUM AMOUNT ALLOWED, $4,642.10 ($3,937.50 FINES AND $704.60 COSTS), AND PROVIDE A FULL SATISFACTION AND RELEASE OF LIEN. FAILURE TO REMIT PAYMENT WITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE AMOUNT REVERTING TO THE FULL AMOUNT AND A REFERRAL TO THE MONROE COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE FOR .._. .. _..... — _ _ .. _._ _--. __. _ ` FURTHER ACTION. . _a_ ....._.— __ .. ...—_.w ...._ ®.. MAILED AND EMAILED TO PO 30 DAY LETTER. EXCERPT: PER THE AGREEMENT SIGNED BY YOU ON OCTOBER 29, 2013, THE AGREED UPON COMPLIANCE DATE WAS APRIL 29, 2014 WITH DAILY FINES TO ACCRUE IN THE AMOUNT OF $150.00 PER DAY IF COMPLIANCE WAS NOT TIMELY ACHIEVED. ON MAY 15, 2014 YOU SUBMITTED A PERMIT APPLICATION TO THE 11-25-2014 12:35:41 LETTER NON-PAYMENT/COMPLIANCE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO CORRECT THE VIOLATIONS. AS A RESULT, THE COUNTY OFFERED YOU AN AGREEMENT TO EXTEND THE COMPLIANCE DATE. THE DEADLINE TO SUBMIT THAT EXTENSION TO THE COUNTY WAS MAY 21, 2014. THE COUNTY DID NOT RECEIVE THAT SIGNED AGREEMENT BY THAT DATE AND A LIEN AGAINST YOUR PROPERTY WAS RECORDED IN THE OFFICIAL RECORDS OF MONROE COUNTY ON MAY 22, 2014. . 11-20-2014 15:14:13 COMMENT CODE ...... ... ...... _. KAT RTE VM TO PO, WILL HAVE FINAL AMOUNTS BY MIDDLE OF NEXT WEEK. 08-14-2014 14:57:36 COMMENT CODE IN COMPLIANCE 110-140.(1) COMPLIANCE DATE WAS: 08/13/14 08-14-2014 09:59:23 REINSPECTION ATF PERMIT 14302143 PASSED INSPECTIONS. 110-140(1) IN COMPLIANCE 8-13-2014. 08-05-2014 16:31:17 REFERRAL TO BUILDING OFFICIAL EMAIL FROM JOHN TRAVERS TO MR. ANDERSEN: AS FOLLOW-UP TO OUR MEETING LAST WEEK, HERE ARE THE RESULTS OF OUR HISTORY SEARCH ON THE FENCE AND DOCK PERMITS: http:l/egov.monroecounty-fl.gov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asvx?case no=CE07040059 412R/?O15 Code Enforcement Detail Page 3 of 12 DOCK - PERMIT 93311084 IS EXPIRED. IT NEVER HAD ANY INSPECTIONS PERFORMED. FENCE - PERMIT 98301431 IS EXPIRED. IT NEVER HAD ANY INSPECTIONS PERFORMED. PLEASE CONTACT ME TO MEET SO WE CAN RESOLVE THESE EXPIRED PERS. _ ....... MITz. _....... 08-05-2014 09:58:41 REINSPECTION PERMIT WAS ISSUED 7-25-2014. NO INSPECTIONS YET. JOHN TRAVERS AND CLINT MADE SITE VISIT FOR INSPECTION OF PERMIT 14302143 AND CREATED PUNCH LIST OF ITEMS THAT NEED TO BE 07-28-2014 16:26:24 REFERRAL TO BUILDING OFFICIAL CORRECTED AND INSPECTED TO COMPLY WITH THIS CASE. HE ADDITIONALLY INCLUDED DIRECTION ON OTHER REPAIRS MR. ANDERSEN WANTS TO PERFORM. _ .... m...-... -- .-.._..w.._ EMAIL FROM BLDG DEPT TO PO: MR. ANDERSEN, ON JULY 8, 2014, AN EMAIL WAS SENT TO YOU INFORMING YOU THAT PERMIT NUMBER 14302143 WAS APPROVED AND READY FOR ISSUANCE, AND PROVIDED INSTRUCTION FOR OBTAINING YOUR PERMIT. THE EMAIL SPECIFIED THE CURRENT FEES DUE IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,222.40 AND THAT YOU WOULD NEED TO PROVIDE SUBCONTRACTOR AUTHORIZATION LETTERS FOR THE SUBCONTRACTORS FOR THE PLUMBING AND 07-23-2014 12:13:57 COMMENT CODE ELECTRICAL PORTION OF THE WORK. A COPY OF THIS EMAIL HAS BEEN ATTACHED TO THIS CORRESPONDENCE FOR YOUR REFERENCE. A BLANK SUBCONTRACTOR AUTHORIZATION FORM HAS ALSO BEEN ATTACHED FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE. THE BALANCE OF FEES DUE MUST BE PAID, AND ALL REQUIRED SUBCONTRACTOR AUTHORIZATION FORMS MUST BE PROVIDED AT THE TIME OF ISSUANCE IN ORDER TO ISSUE YOUR PERMIT. PLEASE, DIRECT ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS REGARDING THE ABOVE -REFERENCED PERMIT TO COUNTY ATTORNEY STEVE WILLIAMS. 07-08-2014 12:20:49 COMMENT CODE EMAIL SENT FROM BLDG DEPT THAT PERMIT IS - .w_..._ ....._. READY .. .. _......__-. 06-10-2014 12:13:19 COMMENT CODE .... ... ... ........... _ �..._. _.—. CHRISTINE EMAILED MR ANDERSEN IN AN ATTEMPT TO EXPLAIN THE PERMIT PROCESS. EMAIL FROM MR ANDERSEN TO KAT AND 06-04-2014 12:08:43 COMMENT CODE ROMAN. KAT RECEIVED NO DIRECTION TO RESPOND FROM STAFF. RECIEVED SCANNED EXTENSION TODAY FROM 06-02-2014 16:51:03 COMMENT CODE PO. w PER CA, OFFER HAS EXPIRED. w- .. _..._ _ ----- . ..... __ ...... FINAL ORDER AND NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT WAS 05-22-2014 17:42:02 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO RECORDED AS A LIEN DOC 1982218 BK 2685 PG 1767 EXTENSION OFFER EXPIRED END OF BUSINESS MAY 21, 2014. COUNTY HAS NOT RECEIVED SIGNED DOCUMENT. RECEIVED 2 EMAILS REFUSING TO SIGN 05-22-2014 10:21:01 REINSPECTION EXTENSION. PER COUNTY ATTORNEY: "UNLESS DIRECTED BY AN ATTORNEY, NO MORE RESPONSES TO THE ANDERSONS" FINAL ORDER AND NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT 05-21-2014 13:26:26 ORDER SENT TO MCCO FOR REC SENT TO MCCO FOR RECORDING. 05-20-2014 13:30:50 COMMENT CODE KAT RECEIVED EMAIL FROM PO THAT HE WAS OUT OF TOWN AND WIFE OUT OF COUNTRY. EMAILED PO: COUNTY WILL ACCEPT DOCUMENT http://egov.monroecounty-fl.gov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asDX?case no�CE07040059 Al? R1?n15 Code Enforcement Detail Page 4 of 12 WITH ONE OWNERS SIGNATURE FOR THE EXTENSION. EMAIL FROM P0. KAT RESPONDED: MR. AND MRS. ANDERSEN I AM SOMEWHAT SURPRISED TO HEAR THIS RESPONSE GIVEN THAT THE COUNTY HAS 05-20-2014 11:24:52 COMMENT CODE AGREED TO EXTEND THE COMPLIANCE DATE. THIS EXTENSION WOULD HAVE STAYED THE FINES FOR 3 MONTHS TO GIVE YOU TIME TO ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE. YOU ARE NOT BEING FORCED TO SIGN THE EXTENSION. DAILY FINES BEGAN ACCRUING ON APRIL 30, 2014. .�. _._ ......... __. w .. _ _ _ __. .. ...—.___— .-_--- ........ 05-15-2014 11:46:54 SENT TO LIAISON FILE BACK TO NICOLE ............... _. __ _ ....... _ ,... ..me...w_..... _ — ................__..-_ .... ................. ... ..__._ ......... �_rn....._� EMAILED EXTENSION TO PO. OFFER FOR EXTENSION EXPIRES MAY 21, 2014: HELLO MR. ANDERSEN, (PLEASE CONFIRM RECEIPT OF THIS EMAIL.) TODAY I HAVE REVIEWED THE PERMIT APPLICATION AND, AS PROMISED, INSERTED THE PHOTOS I TOOK LAST WEEK. YOU ARE CORRECT THAT THE COMPLIANCE DATE HAS PASSED AND THE DAILY FINE IS NOW ACCRUING. HOWEVER, NOW THAT THE COUNTY HAS RECEIVED A PERMIT APPLICATION, THEREBY ACHIEVING "PROGRESS", I AM ABLE TO OFFER AN EXTENSION OF THE COMPLIANCE DATE. SINCE COMPLIANCE WILL NOT BE 05-15-2014 11:45:44 COMMENT CODE ACHIEVED UNTIL THE PERMIT HAS RECEIVED ITS REQUIRED INSPECTIONS AND IS CLOSED, I HAVE INSERTED THE DATE OF AUGUST 6, 2014 TO ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE. PLEASE SIGN THE ATTACHED EXTENSION IN THE PRESENCE OF A NOTARY AND RETURN THE ENTIRE DOCUMENT TO ME AND I WILL SIGN ON BEHALF OF THE COUNTY EXTENDING THE COMPLIANCE DATE TO AUGUST 6, 2014. THIS DOCUMENT EXPIRES MAY 21, 2014. PLEASE NOTE THAT CASE CE08010003 HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM THE EXTENSION AS THAT VIOLATION IS IN COMPLIANCE. THANK YOU APPLICATION 14302143 05-15-2014 10:15:02 PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW ENTERED PLAN REVIEW NOTES, PICS (BEFORE AND AFTER) FINAL ORDER, NEW BUYER STIPULATION, SWO. PASSED TO FLOOD. SITE VISIT, MET W/ P0. TOOK PHOTOS. CONFIRMED THAT NO LANDSCAPE LIGHTS EXIST 05-06-2014 21:19:09 REINSPECTION AND NEIGHBOR SAID THE "WHOEVER" WAS LIVING THERE TOOK THEM WHEN THEY LEFT. UNABLE TO CONFIRM HOW LANDSCAPE LIGHTS _ ....... A.._.... _ ...,v WERE POWERED. KAT ..._ _ _ ._ _ .. .. ....... MR ANDERSEN EMAILED KAT, CHRISTINE AND ROMAN AT 4.25 THAT KAT HAD NOT RESPONDED 05-01-2014 11:06:37 COMMENT CODE TO INSP REQUEST. RESPONDED THAT I HAD SENT EMAIL AT 2.38 TODAY. KAT AGREED TO MAKE SITE VISIT, EMAIL TO MR ANDERSEN: I HAVE MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO DRIVE TO KEY LARGO ON TUESDAY MAY 6, 2014. 1 WILL BE 05-01-2014 10:54:30 COMMENT CODE COMING FROM MARATHON, SO I ANTICIPATE THAT I WILL ARRIVE AT YOUR HOME BETWEEN 10 AND 11 AM, BASED ON FAVORABLE TRAFFIC. WILL YOU BE AVAILABLE? http://egov.monroccounty-fl.gov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.aspx?case no. CE07040059 4/28/2015 Code Enforcement Detail Page 5 of 12 04-30-2014 11:01:28 COMMENT CODE FINE OF 150.00 PER DAY BEGINS ACCRUING. NO PERMIT APPLICATION HAS BEEN 04-29-2014 15:00:32 REINSPECTION FOR HEARING SUBMITTED. PO ASKING FOR SITE INSPECTION. .,.___..__ -. .._...._.... . __._._._N..... .. _ ...__ _...__ ....... KAT RECEIVED HUGE EMAIL FROM MR ANDERSEN WITH INSPECTIONS HE WANTED ME TO 04-29-2014 10:55:21 COMMENT CODE PERFORM. AFTER DISCUSSING WITH STAFF, I WILL GO AND GET PHOTOS FOR REVIEW AND DOCUMENT BETWEEN SWO AND PRESENT. MR ANDERSENS RESPONSE: OMG I HAVE BEEN ASKING FOR AN INSPECTION FOR THE LAST TWO MONTHS. I WOULD HIGHLY ENCOURAGE YOU TO COME SEE THE PROPERTY ASAP. PLEASE COME SEE THE ACTUAL WORK THAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT. YOU SEE THE BASIC PROBLEM IS YOU SAY GO AND GET AN AFTER THE FACT PERMIT, BUT 04-28-2014 10:53:20 COMMENT CODE FOR WHAT? PAINTING DOES NOT NEED A PERMIT, THE TILE FLOOR FMV IS LESS THAN THE MINIMUM ESTABLISHED BY THE BUILDING CODE, ALL THE OTHER ITEMS ARE NEGLIGIBLE BOTH IN SCOPE OF WORK AND FMV. MY DETERMINATION IS NOTHING IN THIS CASE NEEDED A PERMIT PER THE BUILDING CODE. COME HELP ME OUT WITH THIS. ..................... _ ... ... ®._ ._._.._...�.. w WHEN CAN YOU COME OVER? --._. __m_A_ � ._.. _ �_. w ...... KAT RESPONDED:MR. ANDERSEN, WHAT YOU ARE SEEING ON THE WEBPAGE "EGOV SNAPSHOT" IS THE SCHEDULED INSPECTION EVENT GENERATED FROM OUR DATA ENTRY PROGRAM. THIS WAS ENTERED BECAUSE THE PROPERTY WILL BE CHECKED FOR COMPLIANCE ON 4-29-2014 AS PER THE AGREED UPON COMPLIANCE DATE IN THE NEW BUYER 04-28-2014 10:51:57 COMMENT CODE AFFIDAVIT YOU SIGNED. SINCE THIS ISSUE IS A PERMITTING ISSUE, AN ONSITE INSPECTION IS NOT NECESSARY AS IT APPEARS YOU DID NOT OBTAIN YOUR AFTER -THE -FACT PERMIT. I DO NOT RECALL YOU ASKING ME TO MAKE A PERSONAL INSPECTION, BUT IF YOU WANT ME ..... _...._.,.m..... _... TO, WE CAN MAKE THOSE ARRANGEMENTS. ._ _._._...�....m_ _. _ ........w..._ -._-_ KAT RECEIVED EMAIL FROM MR. ANDERSEN: MY WIFE FRAN DISCOVERED THIS ON THE COUNTY WEB PAGE. THE COUNTY HAS US LISTED FOR PHYSICAL AN INSPECTION ON THE 29TH. NO ONE FROM THE COUNTY HAS 04-28-2014 10:39:19 COMMENT CODE CALLED TO ACTUALLY MAKE AN APPOINTMENT WITH ME. MY PHONE IS 949 878-1452. 1 HAVE BEEN ASKING FOR AN INSPECTION FOR MONTHS AND BEEN TOLD THAT IT WILL NOT HAPPEN. CAN ANYONE CLARIFY THIS? 04-24-2014 10:37:16 COMMENT CODE EMAIL FROM CHRISTINE TO PO REGARDING STAYING FINES: MR. ANDERSEN. THE FINES CANNOT BE STAYED. THE PACKET OF INFORMATION I EMAILED YOU JUST PRIOR TO THE DATE WE HAD SCHEDULED A MEETING WITH MR. GASTESI INCLUDES THE CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE WITH PICTURES OF HOW THE PROPERTY WAS WHEN THE VIOLATIONS OCCURRED. YOU NEED TO OBTAIN AFTER THE FACT PERMITS AND BRING THE SITE INTO COMPLIANCE. ALL OF THE STAFF HAVE EXPLAINED THIS TO YOU. WHEN YOU GET A PERMIT WE WILL DO REQUIRED INSPECTIONS TO SEE HOW YOU'VE PROGRESSED SINCE THE htti):r'1ep,ov.monroecounty-fl.sovi'eGovPluslcodelcode dtl.asnx?case no=CE07040059 4/28/2015 Code Enforcement Detail VIOLATIONS WERE DISCOVERED. EMAILING US IS NOT ACCOMPLISHING COMPLIANCE. Page 6 of 12 04-24-2014 10:36:33 COMMENT CODE 04-17-2014 10:10:02 COMMENT CODE 04-10-2014 10:31:08 COMMENT CODE 03-03-2014 10:07:56 COMMENT CODE 02-27-2014 10:05:29 COMMENT CODE EMAILS FROM PO TO COUNTY OFFICIALS ASKING TO STAY FINES. MEETING SCHEDULED W/ MR. ANDERSEN TO MEET WITH ROMAN AND CHRISTINE - MR ANDERSEN DID NOT ATTEND AND IS ASKING FOR PHONE CONFERENCE. KAT PROVIDED FILE HISTORY AND COPIES TO CHRISTINE FOR MEETING W/ MR. ANDERSEN. JERRY EMAIL REPONSE TO EMAIL SENT TO BOCC, SENATOR BULLARD, ETC: SIR; YOU SIGNED AN AGREEMENT TO MAKE CERTAIN CORRECTIONS TO YOUR PROPERTY IN ORDER TO STAY FINES -THAT IS WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO. THIS IS WHY THE COUNTY ATTORNEY IS COPIED ON ANY EMAILS INVOLVING YOU. YOU REFER TO "NEAR -BY BUILDING OFFICIALS" ADVISING THAT A PERMIT IS NOT NEEDED FOR THE EXTENSIVE REMODEL LIST YOU HAVE CITED. I DON'T KNOW ANY "NEAR -BY" WHERE THEY ARE ENFORCING THE CODE THAT A PERMIT WOULD NOT BE REQUIRED AS ANY EXTERIOR DOOR REPLACEMENT WOULD REQUIRE A PERMIT AND AN N.O.A./PRODUCT APPROVAL. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO ANSWER EVERY "WHAT IF" SCENARIO THAT YOU HAVE POSED. THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, EXISTING BUILDING STATES, "THE PROVISIONS OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, EXISTING BUILDING SHALL APPLY TO THE REPAIR, ALTERATION, CHANGE OF OCCUPANCY, ADDITION AND RELOCATION OF EXISTING BUILDINGS." WITHOUT A SPECIFIC PROPOSAL, SCOPING THE EXACT WORK AND TOTAL VALUE, IT IS DIFFICULT TO DETERMINE PERMIT REQUIREMENTS. IF YOUR "NEAR -BY BUILDING OFFICIALS" CAN PROVIDE SPECIFIC CODE CITATIONS ALLOWING YOUR EXACT PROPOSAL DOESN'T MEET THE THRESHOLDS CONTAINED WITHIN THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE, EXISTING BUILDINGS, AND MONROE COUNTY CODES, I WOULD BE HAPPY TO ACCEPT AS I'M UNAWARE OF THAT TO WHICH THEY REFER. AGAIN, I CANNOT ANSWER HYPOTHETICAL QUESTIONS WITHOUT THE TOTAL PROJECT. REPLACING A VANITY FAUCET AS THE ONLY WORK IS SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENT THAN DOING A $20,000.00 REMODEL COMPRISED OF ELEMENTS WHICH MAY NOT HAVE REQUIRED A PERMIT SINGULARLY. I'M NOT AVOIDING ANSWERING YOUR QUESTIONS, BUT THE QUESTIONS CONSTANTLY CHANGE ALONG WITH THE SCENARIOS AND I CANNOT SIMPLY STATE YOU DON'T NEED A PERMIT. EMAIL FROM JERRY TO PO RESPONDING TO DISPUTING NEEDING A PERMIT TO CURE CODE CASE: WE HAVE DISCUSSED THIS, BRIAN COROCORAN AND MYSELF MET WITH YOU FOR OVER AN HOUR ON THESE TOPICS, AND WE HAVE PROVIDED YOU WITH THE REQUESTED INFORMATION. AS FAR AS THE PREVIOUS VIOLATIONS, AS I HAVE SAID REPEATEDLY THAT YOU HAVE AGREED TO THIS STIPULATION, SO WHATEVER httD:/teeov.monroecounty-fl.eov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asnx?case no=CE07040059 4/2R/2015 Code Enforcement Detail Page 7 of 12 WAS AGREED TO MUST BE FOLLOWED. FUTURE PROJECTS CAN BE APPLIED FOR ON THE BASIS OF THE CURRENT CODES .�...... _. ......_. m .... _.. ........ _- _,. w - -......................._ ... _ KAT RESPONDED TO ANOTHER EMAIL FROM MRS. ANDERSEN: YES FRAN, 01-21-2014 10:04:22 COMMENT CODE YOU NEED TO FILE THE PARTIAL RELEASES TO REMOVE THE CLOUD ON THE PROPERTY FROM THE PRIOR OWNERS SO YOU HAVE A CLEAR TITLE. KAT RESPONSED TO EMAIL W/ EMAIL: THESE COSTS BEGAN ACCRUING THE DAY YOU TOOK POSSESSION AND INCLUDE THE TIME SPENT BY CODE STAFF, SUCH AS SITE INSPECTIONS, PHONE CALLS, EMAILS, DOCUMENTATION AND ANY RECORDING COSTS, ETC. 01-21-2014 10:03:06 COMMENT CODE I SAID THAT IF COMPLIANCE IS NOT ACHIEVED BY THE AGREED UPON COMPLIANCE DATE, AND PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE, THE COUNTY WILL CONSIDER AN EXTENSION TO THE COMPLIANCE DATE. UNLESS THERE ARE EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES, MOST TIMES THE COUNTY AGREES TO EXTEND THE DATE. EMAIL FROM PO PARAGRAPH 9 REFERS TO POTENTIAL COST OF PROSECUTION FROM THE FUTURE "AFTER THE DATE OF POSSESSION" AS THIS WAS WRITTEN PRIOR TO US OWNING THE PROPERTY, SEEING INSIDE THE PROPERTY OR INSPECTING THE PROPERTY, AND PRIOR TO US EVEN RECEIVING THE COUNTIES CASE PHOTO'S AND OTHER DETAILS. WE HAD AGREED TO A SETTLEMENT AMOUNT AND THAT WAS THE TOTAL AMOUNT DUE TO THE COUNTY FOR ALL PAST DUE MONIES. BECAUSE SETTLEMENT AMOUNT WAS PAID IN FULL WE DO NOT OWE THE COUNTY ANY MORE MONEY ON THAT ISSUE AT THIS TIME. THEREFORE "THE COST OF PROSECUTION" 01-21-2014 09:59:53 COMMENT CODE REFERRED TO IN KATS EMAIL IS A POTENTIAL FUTURE COST THAT HAS NOT OCCURRED AND WOULD NOT OCCUR UNLESS WE ARE OUT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE ORDER AT THE FUTURE DUE DATE. ALTHOUGH I DON'T FORESEE ANYTHING CAUSING US TO MISS THE DEAD LINE, I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO CONFIRM THAT KAT HAS TOLD US: AS LONG AS WE ARE WORKING ON THIS AND TAKING STEPS TOWARD REMEDYING THESE TWO CASES THAT WE WOULD NOT HAVE THE FINES START UP AND THE COUNTY WILL NOT IMMEDIATELY PROSECUTE US FURTHER SHOULD WE GO PAST THE DUE DATE. THE COUNTY HAS OFFERED SOME FLEXIBILITY ON - _ T THE DUE DATE. 01-17-2014 16:54:02 COMMENT CODE _ _ _.._ _ ._.... -- FILE W/ KAT, MIDDLE DRAWER _......_.r.w _ - __...... _..... _........ ._ KAT RESPONDED TO EMAIL FROM PO DISPUTING VIOLATIONS: MR. ANDERSEN. THERE IS NOTHING MORE TO FIND OUT. 01-16-2014 09:58:57 COMMENT CODE YOU HAVE ADMITTED TO THE VIOLATIONS, THE APPEALS PERIOD HAS PASSED, THE TIME TO DEBATE THE REQUIREMENTS HAS PASSED. THERE IS A LOOMING COMPLIANCE DATE IN APRIL. EITHER YOU ARE COMPLIANT IN APRIL. OR NOT. 01-16-2014 09:57:43 COMMENT CODE KAT RESPONDED TO EMAIL ABOUT LIENS: HELLO FRAN, THE ORIGINAL LIEN RELEASES FOR BOTH CASES WERE MAILED TO YOU ON NOVEMBER 25, 2013. IT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO http://e..ov.monroecounty-fl.p-ov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asnx?case no=CE07040059 4/28/2015 Code Enforcement Detail Page 8 of 12 01-13-2014 09:52:14 COMMENT CODE 01-12-2014 09:51:08 COMMENT CODE RECORD THEM IN THE OFFICIAL RECORDS WITH THE MONROE COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS. THE COUNTY WILL NOT BE FILING ANOTHER LIEN UNLESS COMPLIANCE IS NOT ACHIEVED BY THE COMPLIANCE DATE AGREED TO IN THE NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT AND 50 ORDERED BY THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. THAT DATE IS APRIL 29, 2014. KAT EMAILED RESPONSE: HELLO JON, OUR EVIDENCE INDICATES THAT THE CUMULATIVE WORK DONE TO THE INTERIOR OF THIS STRUCTURE REQUIRED A PERMIT, APPROVAL AND INSPECTIONS. A HEARING WAS HELD AND THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOUND THE PROPERTY IN VIOLATION ON DECEMBER 22, 2008. THERE WAS NO APPEAL OF THAT FINDING DURING THE 30 DAY APPEAL PERIOD. THE VIOLATION STILL EXISTS AND PERMITS, APPROVALS AND INSPECTIONS ARE REQUIRED TO CURE THE VIOLATION. ADDITIONALLY YOU ENTERED INTO A BINDING AGREEMENT WITH THE COUNTY ON OCTOBER 29, 2013 ADMITTING THAT THE VIOLATIONS WERE ACCURATE, WAIVING THE RIGHT TO CONTEST THE VIOLATIONS, AND AGREEING TO THE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS. ALTHOUGH YOU MAY NOT AGREE THAT THE WORK REQUIRES A PERMIT, A PERMIT 15 REQUIRED TO RESOLVE THIS CASE. THIS PERMIT MAY BE AN AFTER -THE -FACT PERMIT FOR THE WORK THAT WAS DONE, OR YOU MAY CHOOSE TO GET A DEMOLITION PERMIT AND REMOVE THE UNPERMITTED WORK. AS FAR AS YOUR DIFFICULTY WITH THE PERMITTING PROCESS, I REALLY DON'T HAVE ANY AUTHORITY IN THAT DEPARTMENT. I HAVE ATTACHED THE INSPECTOR'S PHOTOS AND RECOMMEND THAT YOU TAKE THESE PHOTOS; AND PHOTOS OF THE CURRENT CONDITION TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT. THIS MAY HELP THE BUILDING STAFF UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU NEED. I HAVE ALSO INCLUDED BRIAN IN THIS EMAIL. NOT ONLY WILL HE BE PROVIDING ME PHOTOS OF THE VENTS AND THE REMOVAL OF THE OUTDOOR LIGHTING AND ASSOCIATED ELECTRIC, HE WAS ONE OF THE CODE INSPECTORS ON THIS CASE. _ .... KAT RECEIVED EMAIL FROM PO I SENT AN EMAIL TO BRIAN TELLING HIM WE ARE READY FOR A FLOOD INSPECTION. IS THIS THE NEW OWNER TRANSFER INSPECTION TOO? CAN THEY BE COMBINED IF NOT? IN REGARDS TO THE INTERIOR RENOVATIONS: NO PERMIT PULLED. I HAVE CALLED AND VISITED THE BUILDING DEPT 6 TIMES TO DETERMINE WHAT THEY NEED. I HAVE GOTTEN CONTRADICTORY INFORMATION SO I HAVE SPENT TIME ON THE WEB TRYING TO DETERMINE WHAT THE LAW I5. UPON FURTHER REVIEW OF THE WORK I DON'T SEE HOW IT NEEDED A PERMIT TO BEGIN WITH. • 1. THE WORK PERFORMED MOST LIKELY DOES NOT NEED A LICENSED CONTRACTOR ACCORDING TO THE FLORIDA BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS CODE. • 2. THE WORK IS MINOR ACCORDING httD://eeov.monroecounty-fl.eov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl_asnx?cace no=CF.07040059 a/17R/I)n15 Code Enforcement Detail Page 9 of 12 12-02-2013 11:28:17 STIPULATION AGRMT. SIGNED 11-26-2013 15:00:01 SENT TO LIAISON 11-25-2013 14:54:39 COMMENT CODE 11-25-2013 14:53:16 COMMENT CODE 11-25-2013 14:16:22 COMMENT CODE 11-05-2013 14:51:45 STIPULATION AGRMT. SIGNED TO THE DEFINITION OF THE FLORIDA BUILDING CODE AND MAY NOT NEED A PERMIT. • 3. THE VALUE OF THE WORK FALLS BELOW THE VALUE THRESHOLD ESTABLISHED BY THE FLORIDA BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND THE IMPROVEMENTS DO NO TRIGGER THE NECESSITY OF A PERMIT. • ( I SAY MOST LIKELY, MY RESEARCH INDICATES A PERMIT IS NOT NEEDED, BUT I HAVE NOT DISCUSSED WITH KNOWLEDGEABLE PEOPLE AT THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT) THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT (AT THE DESK) SAID "SUBMIT A LIST OF ALL THE WORK AND THE VALUE OF THE WORK, PAY US A PERMIT FEE THEN WE WILL LET YOU KNOW IF YOU NEED A PERMIT OR NOT". I THINK PAYING $75 EVERY TIME I WISH TO DO MAINTENANCE ON MY HOME IS EXCESSIVE. IS THERE A WAY WE CAN DISCUSS MY FINDINGS WITHOUT MY PAYING MORE MONEY? SIGNED AN AGREEMENT AND AFFIDAVIT OF NEW PURCHASER TO STAY FINES AND ENLARGE THE COMPLIANCE DATE SIGNED ON 10/29/13. COSTS IMPOSED UNTIL COMPLIANT AND CASE IS CLOSED AND FINES IN THE AMOUNT OF $150.00 FOR THE CHARGES OF 110-140. (1) AND 122-4.(B)(1)D PER COUNT PER DAY IF NOT COMPLIANT BY 04/29/14. NO REVIEW HEARING SET AT THIS TIME. THE SM APPROVED THE AGREEMENT AND ADDED IT TO THE FINAL ORDER. PASSED FILE TO NICOLE FOR NEW COMPLIANCE DATE AND ORDER ADDED FINE ON 110-140.(1) START DATE: 04/30/14 FINE AMT: 150.00 EMAIL FROM PO. TENANT HAS BEEN EVICTED. EMAILED TO DO LIST AS REQUESTED. PREPARED PARTIAL LIEN RELEASE AND PASSED TO CA FOR SIGNATURE AND MAILING. RECEIVED PAYMENT IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,910.00 FOR CE07040059, ($2,500.00 FINES AND $410.00 COSTS); RECEIPT 2000015481 _........._�.... _ .._.. __r.__.�...__w....u.. . EXECUTED NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT. NEW COMPLIANCE DATE IS APRIL 29, 2014. 110-1400) - 150.00 PER DAY EMAILED NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT TO ANOTHER POTENTIAL BUYER AND COUNTY HAS AGREED RE -EXTEND THE $5,620.62 OFFER FOR ANOTHER 30 DAYS, GOOD UNTIL NOVEMBER 15, 10-29-2013 10:20:30 COMMENT CODE 2013. A PAYMENT OF $2,910.37 FOR CE07040059, ($2,500.00 FINES AND $410.37 COSTS); AND A PAYMENT OF $2,710.25 FOR CE08010003, ($2,500.00 FINES AND $210.25 COSTS). QUIT CLAIM DEED TO NEW OWNERS AS A 10-24-2013 14:17:30 CHANGE OF OWNERSHIP RESULT OF SALE BY BANK OF AMERICA. UPDATED NEW OWNERS INFO IN SYSTEM. 07-26-2013 12:31:50 COMMENT CODE EMAIL TO ANDERSENS REGARDING BUYING PROPERTY AS IS, 1.NEED AFFIDAVIT ACKNOWLEDGING THE VIOLATIONS, ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THEY WILL BE CITED FOR THE VIOLATIONS AND ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THEY WILL BE GIVEN A REASONABLE PERIOD OF TIME TO ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE BEFORE THE FINES RESUME RUNNING. 2.NEED OWNERSHIP TRANSFER INSPECTION 3. COUNTY WILL ACCEPT A PAYMENT OF $2,910.37 FOR CE07040059, ($2,500.00 FINES AND $410.37 COSTS); AND A PAYMENT OF $2,710.25 FOR CE08010003, ($2,500.00 httD://egov.monroecountv-fl.gov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asox?case no—CE07040059 4/2R/2015 Code Enforcement Detail Page 10 of 12 FINES AND $210.25 COSTS). THEREFORE THE COUNTY WILL ACCEPT $5,620.62 AS FULL PAYMENT OF FINES AND COSTS FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY AND WILL PROVIDE A PARTIAL RELEASE OF LIEN (FOR EACH CASE) TO BE FILED WITH THE CLERKS OF COURTS. THIS OFFER IS GOOD FOR 30 DAYS. 4. PROVIDED COUNTY FORM FOR AFFIDAVIT 06-03-2013 14:44:14 COMMENT CODE EMAILED NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT TO REALTOR VM FROM REALTOR. RESEARCH REVEALS CERTIFICATE OF TITLE FILED MCCO 5-9-2013 TO BANK OF AMERICA. 06-03-2013 10:20:17 COMMENT CODE SUSPENDED FINES FROM 5/9/2013 TO 8/9/2013 (90 DAYS) TO GIVE BANK TIME TO COMPLY OR SELL PROPERTY. 25.00 PER DAY RAN FOR 1567 DAYS = _ ..._........... _ . .. 39,175.00 FINES. _..r _._.._.n ._m .., ®..® .._._....... ._. CERTIFICATE OF TITLE FILED MCCO 5-9 2013 05-09-2013 12:55:22 COMMENT CODE TO BANK OF AMERICA. STILL UNVERIFIED ON CLERKS WEB SITE, CALENDAR 14 DAYS 04-14-2011 10:50:30 SENT FILE TO COUNTY ATTY BOTH ORIGINAL FILES IN DEMAND DRAWER. .ur .__ ...- _ ...._. .._w FINES RUNNING ...... w _..a._--_ _ _ �._ �.... ....... _.._._. US MAIL FOR SM ORDER AUTH FORCLOSURE WAS 01-31-2011 14:47:22 COMMENT CODE "RETURNED TO SENDER NO MAIL RECEPTACLE UNABLE TO FORWARD" FOR 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE ADDRESS OF RECORD. SM ORDER AUTHORIZING FORCLOSURE SIGNED ON 01/27/11. 01-28-2011 10:47:32 SM OR CEB ORDER COPY OF ORDER MAILED TO RESPONDENTS 2 ADDRESSES OF RECORD AS INDICATED ON .,__...............m,.F ....,�.. _ .._...._ _................_._ _---._.__ _.... ...._. .._... ORDER BY LIAISON TODAY. w,.... ............... _._.,..-..�..._..�..._.......�A.... _.. ............. �_..._.._....�....�... HEARING NOTICE FOR MOTION TO AUTH COLLECTIONS WAS "RETURN TO SENDER NO 01-11-2011 10:45:20 COMMENT CODE MAIL RECEPTACLE UNABLE TO FORWARD" FOR THE 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE ADDRESS OF RECORD. NOTICE OF MOTION TO AUTH COLLECTION PROCEEDINGS Et NOTICE OF HEARING FOR 01-07-2011 15:00:23 COMMENT CODE 01 /27/11 MAILED TO PO VIA 1ST CLASS MAIL TODAY BY LIAISON TO BOTH ADDRESSES. SETTING FOR JANUARY AGENDA FOR COLLECTIONS. 12-21-2010 15:40:21 COMMENT CODE FINES TO DATE 17425.00 COSTS TO DATE 772.67 (INCLUDES 500.00 CITATION FOR AID/ABET WHICH WAS NEVER PAID - SAME CASE NUMBER) RESEARCH REVEALS THAT THE FORECLOSURE ACTION AND THE CERTIFICATE OF TITLE HAS BEEN VACTED - ORDER FILED MCCO 12-21-2010 15:34:36 COMMENT CODE 11-16-2010. THEREFORE FINES HAVE CONTINUED TO RUN THE ENTIRE TIME. STOPPED FINES AS OF 10/07/10 DUE TO FORECLOSURE, BANK OWNED NOW. 10-22-2010 13:46:17 COMMENT CODE PRC STILL IN BOWERS NAME. FINES = 15,550.00 COSTS = 244.47 ...,. s _,..m...-., v PC CALL FROM REALTOR NOW BANK OWNED. 10-22-2010 13:40:05 COMMENT CODE CERTIFICATE OF TITLE FILED MCCO 10-07-2010. _..._r.p .. _.....M_- _ ...._.._............ STOPPED FINES. LIAISON REC'D LIEN SEARCH REQUEST ON 10-13-2010 10:44:40 COMMENT CODE THIS PROPERTY FROM SKYLINE LIEN SEARCH, INC. 02-12-2010 _ 15:47:06 _. _. LETTER NON-PAYMENT/COMPLIANCE .� .. _ _._ m.� MAILED DEMAND LTR _._®............M_.�_.w. .a_... 02-03-2010 09:48:31 COMMENT CODE v �. PREPARED DEMAND LTR FOR THIS CASE AND CE08010003, PASSED TO LISA 02-03-2010 09:43 33 COMMENT CODE FINE CHANGED 9.5-111(1) START DATE: 01 /23/09 FINE AMT: 25.00 02-03-2010 09:42:18 COMMENT CODE - _ .... htti)://e2ov.monroecountv-fl.eov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asnx?case no=CF07O40059 4/?R/?()l 5 Code Enforcement Detail Page 11 of 12 02-03-2010 09:38:31 COMMENT CODE 01-07-2010 13:37:57 COMMENT CODE 12-21-2009 13:32:31 ORDER SENT TO MCCO FOR REC 12-16-2009 09:37:59 COMMENT CODE 12-14-2009 10:31:15 SENT TO LIAISON 12-11-2009 10:28:44 COMMENT CODE 02-26-2009 14:40:22 LIEN ORDER RECORDED MCCO 12-04-2008 15:43:39 SET FOR HEARING LIEN RECORDED 12/21/09 BOOK 2445 PAGE 1361-1363 RESEARCH REVEALS PO OWNS PROPERTY IN MIAMI AND BILLING ADDRESS IS SAME AS FROM BRIAN BRADLEY. UPDATED ADDRESS IN PENTAMATION. ORIGINAL FILE RETURNED TO ATTY S ASSISTANT- KW BY LIAISON. _.__.,. .. .._.. ... ....^. � ... _ �.. ORDER IMPOSING PENALTY AND AUTHORIZING RECORDING OF LIEN FROM 02/26/09 RECORDED WITH THE CLERK'S OFFICE DOC# 1771360 BOOK 2445 PAGES 1361 -13 63 RECEIVED GOOD ADDRESS FROM ATTORNEYS OFFICE - BRIAN PASSED CASE(S) TO HEATHER TO FILE LIEN ON THIS CASE. RESEARCH OF CASE: NO LIEN HAS BEEN FILED. COMPANION CASE FOR FLOOD VENTS CE08010003. UNABLE TO FIND "GOOD ADDRESS". LIS PENDENS FILED 6-13-2008. CALLED ATTNY FOR BANK. LIS PENDENS IS ON HOLD AND HAS HAD NO PROGRESS SINCE JULY 2008. FAXED BOTH LIEN ORDERS TO SABRINA MORAVECKY. EMAILED BRIAN BRADLEY FOR GOOD ADDRESS. SPOKE TO ALLAN, NO ONE EVER THERE AT PROPERTY. SM ORDER IMPOSING PENALTY AND AUTHORIZING RECORDING OF LIEN. SM FINAL ORDER FOUND IN VIOLATION AS CITED. COSTS IMPOSED UNTIL COMPLIANT 12-04-2008 11:36:06 XXXFINDING OF FACT AND FINES IN THE AMOUNT OF $25.00 PER DAY IF NOT COMPLIANT BY 01 /22/09. ._._ .. — -- m. HEARING SET FOR 02/26/09. m ..._ ___ �. 10-29-2008 12:57:24 COMMENT CODE . . SENDING ORIGINAL TO NICOLE FOR SM HRNG 12/04/08 10-29-2008 12:56:10 SENT TO DIRECTOR . ._ �,... uw�_.__. 10-03-2008 11:34:25 XXXNOV CERTIFIED RETURNED ....... .................... _..._..,,,,,,. _ CERTIFIED RECPT RET'D - NO MAIL RECEPT. _ .... ...._.__._... __. m.__.-..� _ 7006 2760 0004 2254 4887 09-26-2008 12:03:25 NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING �...'.._._... --.. .. RE -SEND NEW NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING TO PROPERTY OWNER SM HRNG 12-04-08 08-29-2008 _ .....�. 10:46:29 _ COMMENT CODE _ ORIG FILE GIVEN TO VILMA BY LIAISON. ®.. _ ........ ........ FINE CHANGED 9.5-111(1) 08-29-2008 10:43:16 COMMENT CODE START DATE: 08/22/08 FINE AMT: 0.00 THIS FINE WAS VACATED BY THE SM ON _.... ...... __ ._._..... _ _ . _ 8/28/08. ...... d _.... .... _ ............ .......... ------- PROPER NOTICE NEVER REC'D ON THIS CASE. 08-28-2008 13:54:27 SET FOR HEARING PULLED FROM AGENDA. NEED TO RE -RECITE AND/OR RENOTICE. 08-28-2008 10:39:41 VACATED ORDER BY SM SM VACATED FF ORDER FROM 7/31 /08. 08-21-2008 13:54:06 REINSPECTION FOR HEARING 08-05-2008 21:18:57 COMMENT CODE ADDED FINE ON 9.5-111(1) __.... _ ..._.___..._ _.__,._._... ........ START DATE: 08/22/08 FINE AMT: 50.00 — FF: $50.00/DAY AND COSTS CONT. TO ACCRUE 07-31-2008 13:52:06 XXXFINDING OF FACT UNTIL COMPLIANT. COMPLIANCE DATE: 8/21 /08 HEARING DATE: 8/28/08. 07-31-2008 10:17:52 SET FOR HEARING PERMIT HAVE NOT BEEN FINALED BY THE 07-30-2008 09:42:51 REINSPECTION BLDG DEPT AS OF THIS DATE. AFFIDAVIT __.... - _.._ FOR NON-COMPLIANCE FILLED OUT. - 07-15-2008 09:10:07 REASSIGN INSPECTOR ---- ... _... -...... ,. ,.... _ REASSIGNED FM B CORCORAN WHO MOVED TO ARCADIA TO A WHITE 06-02-2008 09:44:47 NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING NEW NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING SENT TO PROPERTY OWNER 04-17-2008 10:01:56 SENT TO DIRECTOR FOR REVIEW_ SENT TO DIRECTOR FOR HEARING REVIEW 04-17-2008 -- ..... 10:01:29 _ COMMENT CODE w.. _�.�u... .... PREPARE FOR SM/SENT TO ADMIN 04-16-2008 10:00:22 COMMENT CODE CASE TO BE MOVED FORWARD FOR SM PER R NORMAN/DIR httr):/leeov.monroecounty-fl.eov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asnx?case no=CE07040059 4/28/2015 Code Enforcement Detail 04-15-2008 10:48:53 REASSIGN INSPECTOR 04 15-2608 09:59:00 CHANGE OF OWNERSHIP 05-21-2007 14:11:09 XXXNOV CERTIFIED RETURNED 05-03-2007 10:08:24 COMMENT CODE 04-23-2007 16:36:58 NOTICE OF VIOLATION/HEARING 04-10-2007 09:07:51 CITATION ISSUED �_ 04-05-2007 _ ,,.., __ 11:49 16 - W.._ _._ �m= ... ,,._... _ . MAKE VIOLATION_ - 04-05-2007 11:42:57 INITIAL INSPECTION TYPE 04-05-2007 11:42:45 CREATE A CASE REASSIGNED FM T KERR WHO RETIRED TO B CORCORAN PER R NORMAN/DIR CERTIFIED RECPT RETD - UNCLAIMED 7005 3110 0000 0188 0768 PHILLIP PAUL BOWERS CERTIFIED CITATION RECPT RETD UNCLAIMED 7005 3110 0000 0188 6215 PHILIP PAUL BOWERS NOTICE OF VIOLATION SENT TO PROPERTY OWNER m_....... __..,..__....... ... ---- _ CITATION SENT VIA MAIL 7005 3110 0000 0188 6215 MAKEVIO RECORDED REEDERE PHOTOS TAKEN COMPLAINT RECORDED BY REEDERE Your privacy is important to us, for more information see our privacy policy. Copyright ® 2007 - THE PLUS SERIES ® - All Rights Reserved Page 12 of 12 http:l egov.monroccounty-fl.Qov/eGovPlus/code/code dtl.asnx?case no=CF07040059 a ilRI'nis STOP WORK ORDER N23679 INSPECTOR 3.DATE BY: CODE ENFORCEMENT BUILDING DEPARTMENT CONTRACTOR'S NAME_Je _r PERM[I T PROPERTY OWNER'S NAME—L L STREET ADDRESS-- I LOT BLOCK 3SUBDIVISION_Ze��,t,,,, SPECIFIC DESCRIPTION OF WORK BEING DONE: HAS THIS WORK BEEN COMPLETED? Yes No Partial Please bring this form to the Monroe County Building Department, along with a copy of your Property Record Card (which may be obtained from the Property Appraiser's office) and any other documentation pertaining to this project, Depending on the scope of the work, the building department staff will be able to determine whether your project can proceed with a permit AND/OR whether a demolition pennit will be required, Your prompt response to this notice is appreciated. U22er Keys- — Middle K!ys----- Lower Kg Plantation Key Govt. Center Marathon Govt. Center Building Department 88800 Overseas Flighway 2798 Overseas FEghway Room 2030 Tavernier, FL Marathon, FL 5503 College Road 852-7100 289-2501 Key West, FL 33040 292-4490 For office use only: Flag placed Date Initials Flag removed Date Initials P LmA m1IN 7 7FFS T EXHIBIT Fi CE07040059 149 Ocean Shores Dr. 04-05-07 Tom Kerr CE07040059 149 Ocean Shores Dr. 04-05-07 Tom Kerr CE07040059 149 Ocean Shores Dr. 04-05-07 Tom Kerr Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser rage i or 3 Ervin A. Higgs, CFA `_`'' i'r1; r} office (305) 292-3420 Property Appraiser fax (305) 292-3501 Monroe County, Florida Property Record View Alternate Key: 11 Parcel s00497930-000000 Ownership Details Mailing Address: BOWERS PHILLIP PAUL 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO, FL 33037 Property tag PC Code: 01 - SINGLE FAMILY Millage Group: 500K Affordable No Housing: Section.-Township- 33.61 39 Range: Property Location-. 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO Subdivision: AMENDED & EXTENDED PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES Legal Description: BK 3 LT 2 AMD & EXT PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHRS PB4-18 OR340-558 OR421-529-530 C J DOCKET 10-1 J OR554-838 OR830-1544/1546 LAND TRUST OR1100-425DC OR1145.279D/C OR1242-177C1/C OR1307-2382 OR1368-2027 OR1658-2185 OR1658-2197AFF OR2220 1823/240/C OR2281- 2098 XMIUMM Land Use Code Frontage Depth Land Area 010C - RESIDENTIAL CANAL 70 125 8,750 00 SF Building Summary Number of Buildings: 1 Number of Commercial Buildings: 0 Total Living Area: 150D Year Built: 1994 Building eta i Building Type Ri Condition G. Quality Grade 550 Effective Age 9 Perimeter 160 Depreciation % 9 Year Built 1994 Special Arch 0 Gmd Floor Area 1,500 hq://www.mcpafl.org/PropSearch.aspx 9/26/2008 rropeny bearcn -- Monroe i-ounq rropenY tipprmst r rago v>! Functional Ohs 0 Economic GO Inclusions: R1 includes 1 3-fixture bath and 1 kitchen. Roof Type GABLE/HIP Roof Cover ASPHALT SHINGL Foundation CONC PILINGS Heat 1 NOW Heat 2 NONE Bedrooms 3 Heat Src 1 NONE Heat Src 2 NOW Extra Features: 2 Fix Bath 0 Vacuum 0 3 Fix Bath 1 Garbage Disposal 0 4 Fix Bath 0 Compactor 0 5 Fix Bath 0 Security 0 6 Fix Bath 0 Intercom 0 7 Fix Bath 0 Fireplaces 0 Extra Fix 2 Dishwasher 0 i] 25 FT. _. i i 26 FT. FT. 25 FT. 125 FT. Sections: Nbr Type Ext Wall # Stories Year Built Attic A/C Basement % Finished Basement % Area 1 CPF 5,C.B.S. 1 1994 N Y 0,00 0.00 750 2 FLA 5:C.B.S. 1 1994 Y Y 0.00 0.00 1,500 3 OPX 5:C.B.S. 1 1994 N Y a00 000 408 4 SPX 5'C.B,S. 1 1994 N Y 0,00 0,00 288 5 II.F 5:G.B.S. 1 1994 Y 750 Misc Improvement Details Nbr Type # Units Length Width Year Built Roll Year Grade Life 1 CL2.CH LINK FENCE 1,500 SF 300 5 1997 1998 1 30 2 DAV.CONC DAVITS 1 UT 0 0 1997 2008 1 60 3 DK3:CONCRETE DOCK 840 SF 70 12 1997 2008 5 60 4 TK2'TIKI 48 SF 6 8 1997 2008 2 40 5 PT3 PATIO 1,800 SF 600 3 1997 2006 1 50 Building Permits BM9 Number Date Issued Date Completed Amount Description Notes 1 9801431 05/12/1998 1,500 Residential FENCE 8 PRIVACY WALL 04302450 05/2412004 1 R/R 2 5 TON AM Parcel Value 1-listory Certified Roll Value Vise Taxes for this Parcel. hq://www.mepafl.org/PropSeuch.aspx 9/26/2008 Property search - monroe county rroperEy iippraiser r aj3'Q -V UL -P Roll Year Total Bldg Value Total Misc Im 2008 337,868 38,487 Total Land Value Total Just IMarket ) Value Total Assessedl '11) 420,000 796,355 796,355 School Exempt Value School Taxable Value 0-- 796,355 2007 306,877 1,638 525,000 833.515 833,515 0 833.515 2006 312,554 1.708 525,000 839,2.62 839,262 0 839,262 2005 263388 1,802 481.250 746,440 746,440 0 746,440 2004 265,495 1,872 260,313 527.680 527.680 0 527.680 2003 196.663 1,942 172,813 371,418 371,418 0 371,418 2002 304,309 2,036 107,188 413,533 413,533 0 413,533 2001 204,364 2.106 83,125 289,595 289.595 0 289,595 2000 119,781 1,563 59,063 180,407 180,407 25,000 155.407 1999 119,781 1,631 56,875 178,286 176,387 25,000 151,387 1998 116,735 0 56.875 173,610 173,610 25,000 148,610 1997 116,135 0 56,875 173,610 173,610 25.000 148,610 1996 116,735 0 56,875 173.610 173,610 25.000 148,610 1995 138,015 0 56,875 194,890 194.890 0 194,890 1994 0 0 56.875 56,875 56,875 0 56875 1993 0 0 48,125 48,125 48,125 0 48,125 1992 0 0 48,125 48,125 48.125 0 48,125 1991 0 0 48,125 48,125 48,125 0 48,125 1990 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43.750 1989 0 0 43,760 43,750 43,7530 0 43.750 1988 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43750 1987 0 0 43,750 43.750 43,750 0 43,750 1986 0 0 39,375 39,375 39,375 0 39,375 1985 0 0 30,625 30,625 30,625 0 30,625 1984 0 0 30,625 30,625 30,625 0 30,625 1 1983 0 0 31,148 31,148 31,148 0 31,148 1 1982 0 0 31,148 31,148 31,148 0 31,148 Parcel Sales History NOTE: Sales do not generally show up in our computer system until about two to three months after the date of sale. If a recent sale uues i wk show up in this list, please allow more time for the sale record to be processed Thank you for your patience and understanding Sale Date Official Records BookWage Price Instrument Qualification 31912007 2281/2098 1,150,000 WD Q 101412000 1658/2185 390,000 WD 81111995 136812027 200,000 WD v 61111994 1307/2382 62,500 WD V This site is currently in BETA testing, any comments or feedback about this site are appreciated. Click the Contact Us link to submit comments or feedback to the website administrator. We appreciate your patience through this transition. This page has been visited 40,063 times. Monroe County Property Appraiser Ervin A. Higgs, CFA P.O. Box 1176 Key West, FL 33041-1176 hq://www.mcpafl.org/PropSearch.aspx 9/26/2008 ,` " NROE COUNTY CODE ENFOA =,;�T 1T" ICE OF VIOLATION/NOTICE Or HEARING TO: BOWERS PHILIP PAUL 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO, FL 33037 RE NUMBER: 00497930000000 LOCATION 149 KEY DEAR PROPERTY OWNER / TENANT, CASE NUMBER: CE07040059 OCEAN SHORES DR KL SHORES LARGO, FL 33037 You are hereby notified that an inspection of the above referenced property on Lk_045-0'* found violations of the following Monroe County Section(s) : 9.5-111 (1) No permit for interior renovations and installation of ground level exterior flood lights. Corrective Action Required: Contact the Monroe County Building and Planning Department and obtain an after the fact permit or remove as directed. NOTE: All permit fees and permit requirements are based on the specific scope of work. Additional permits, permit fees, mitigation fees, or restoration of the property to original condition may be required. The minimum fee for an After The Fact permit is $500.00 (five hundred dollars) as per Monroe County Code Section 6-29(a)(1). All permits will require final inspection(s). TO AVOID FINES AND/OR COSTS OF prosecution as per Chapter 162 F.S. all violations noted above must be corrected by 10/10/2008 IT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO CALL YOUR INSPECTOR AND REQUEST A RE -INSPECTION. If you fail to correct the above described violation(s) by the above date, or if you wish to contest the alleged violation(s), you must appear before the Special Magistrate as stated below. ** NOTICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING ** PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that a Public Hearing will be conducted by the Special Magistrate in the above case on 12/04/2008 at 10:00 AM at the Monroe County Government Regional Center, 2798 Overseas Hwy., Marathon, Florida. The purpose of this hearing is to determine if in fact, a viola- tion currently exists, the appropriate action to be taken, and any fines or penalties to be imposed. YOUR FAILURE TO APPEAR MAY RESULT IN A FINE OR PENALTY BEING IMPOSED AGAINST YOU AND A LIEN BEING IMPOSED ON YOUR PROPERTY You may appear in person and/or be represented by an attorney. If you are represented by an attorney, your attorney is required to file a written notice of appearance with this office prior to the hearing. *IF YOU DECIDE TO APPEAL any decision by the Special Magistrate, you will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which shall include the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Should you seek a continuance of your administrative hearing, the presiding officer may grant a co-� �d nce of a hearing for dfr �kT ause shown. Except in cases of emergency, rejests for continuance must be made at least FIVE DAYS prior to the date noticed for the hearing. A request for continuance DOES NOT GUARANTEE a postponement of your hearing. Contact the office of the Liaison for the Special Magistrate to submit your request. Pursuant to F.S. Chapter 162.09(2)(d), youTr failure to correct the violation(s) may result in the impositon of a fine, not to exceed $1,000 per day per violation for a first violation, $5,000 per day per violation for a repeat violation, and up to $15,000 per violation if the Special Magistrate finds the violation to be irreparable or irreversible in nature. In addition to such fines, the Special Magistrate may impose additional fines to cover all costs incurred by the local government in enforcing its codes and all costs of repairs pursuant to subsection (1). Date: 09/26/08 WHITE, Code Enforcement Inspector I hereby certify that a copy hereof has been furnished to the above named addressee(s) by Certified mail, Ret n receipt Request No. 7006 2760 0004 2254 4887 Iff OL, Code Enforcement Department Please contact your inspector at the appropriate Lower Keys: 1100 Simonton St., (Rm. 1-171), Key West, FL 33040 - (305)292-4495 Middle Keys: 2798 Overseas Hwy. Marathon, FL 33050 - (305)289-2810 Upper Keys: 88820 Overseas Hwy.Tavernier, FL 33070 (305)852-7135 If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate, you are entitled, at no extra cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact this office at (305)289-2509 within 2 days of your receipt of this notice. If you are hearing impared, please call 711. Monroe County Code Enforcement Office of the Liaison 2798 Overseas Hwy. Marathon, FL 33050 Phone: (305)289-2509 (305) 289-2858 IF SERVICE IS NOT OBTAINED BY CERTIFIED RETURN ACCURATE COPY OF THIS NOTICE WILL BE POSTED AT THE MONROE COUNTY COURTHOUSE RECEIPT MAIL, A TRUE AND THE SUBJECT PROPERTY AND BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE LARRY J. SARTIN MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA MONROE COUNTY FLORIDA, ) Petitioner, ) VS. ) Case No. CE07040059 PHILLIP PAUL BOWERS, ) Respondent. ) FINAL ORDER This case was heard at public hearing before the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate on December 4, 2008, at the Monroe County Government Regional Center, located at 2798 Overseas Highway, Marathon, Florida. Having fully considered the evidence presented at hearing, including testimony of witnesses under oath, the following findings of fact and conclusions of law are made: FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 1. The Respondent is the owner of record of property located at: BK 3 LT 2 AMD & EXT PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHRS KEY LARGO, RE# 00497930-000000. 2. The Respondent was duly noticed of the hearing; and 3. The above -described property is in violation of the Monroe County Code as described in Exhibit "A," which is attached hereto and incorporated herein. Therefore it is ORDERED AND ADJUGED: 13L 1. Respondent is found to be in violation of the Monroe County Code as described in Exhibit "A", and is ordered to correct all violations on or before January 22, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as the "Compliance Date") and attend a compliance/review hearing to be held on February 26, 2009. 2. Upon complying, Respondent shall notify the Code Inspector in this case, who shall re -inspect the property and, if the property is determined by the Code Inspector to be in compliance, notify the Code Enforcement Department. 3. Noncompliance by the Compliance Date will result in the imposition of a fine for each Code violation in the amount of $25.00 (TWENTY FIVE DOLLARS), for each day after the Compliance Date that Respondents are in violation. 4. Pursuant to Section 162.07, Florida Statutes, costs in an amount to be determined at the conclusion of this case are hereby levied for the administrative recovery of the costs of prosecuting and investigating this matter. Costs will continue to accrue until compliance is achieved. 5. In the event of nonpayment of fines and costs imposed on Respondent, a certified copy of an order imposing fine may be recorded in the public records and shall thereafter constitute a lien against the land on which the violation or violations exist and upon any other real or personal property owned by the violator. DONE AND ORDERED at the Division of Administrative Hearing, Tallahassee, Florida, this �2 �/day of December, 2008. Larry J. S Code EnforceiAent Special Magistrate STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF LEON I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in the County aforesaid, to take acknowledgements, personally appeared Larry J. Sartin, personally known to me, who executed the foregoing and acknowledged before me that he executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this day of December, 2008. amz-- W � 'Notary Pub1i�G" Elma Williams Commission # DD481642 Expires December 2, 2009 2 Troy Fam insurance Inc M365-7019 yy �i NOTICE OF RIGHT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW This Final Order may be appealed pursuant to Section 162.11, Florida Statutes, by an aggrieved party, including Monroe County. Any such appeal will be limited to appellate review of the record created before the Special Magistrate. Any appeal must be filed with the Circuit Court within 30 days of the date of the execution of this Final Order. 3 EXHIBIT "A" VIOLATION: COUNT 1. Section 9.5-111(1). No permit for interior renovations and installation of ground level exterior flood lights. CORRECTION: COUNT 1. Contact the Monroe County Building and Planning Department and obtain an after the fact permit or remove as directed. NOTE: All permit fees and permit requirements are based on the specific scope of work. Additional permits, permit fees, mitigation fees, or restoration of the property to original condition may be required. The minimum fee for an After The Fact permit is $500.00 (five hundred dollars) as per Monroe County Code Section 6-29(a)(1). All permits will require final inspection(s). CONTACT YOUR CODE INSPECTOR UPON COMPLIANCE Upper Keys (305) 852-7135 Middle Keys (305) 289-2810 Lower Keys (305) 292-4495 I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above has been furnished to the U7)pd:y nt via first class mail at 149 OCEAN SHORES DR, KEY LARGO FL 33037 this of December, 2008. Nicole Petrick Code Enforcement Liaison Please make check or money order payable to Monroe County Code Enforcement and mail to 2798 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050. i Doea 1771360 12/21/2009 9:20AM Filed & Recorded in official Records of MONROE COUNTY DANNY L. KOLHAGE Doc Bko 2445 NO 1361 BEFORE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE LARRY J. SARTIN MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA MONROE COUNTY FLORIDA, Petitioner, ) VS. ) Case No. CE07040059 PHILLIP PAUL BOWERS, ) Respondent. ) ORDER IMPOSING PENALTY AND AUTHORIZING RECORDING LIEN This case was heard at public hearing before the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate on February 26, 2009, at the Monroe County Government Regional Center, located at 2798 Overseas Highway, Marathon, Florida The Special Magistrate fully considered the evidence presented at hearing, including testimony of witnesses under oath. 1. The Respondent is the owner of record of property located at: BK 3 LT 2 AMD & EXT PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHRS. (RE: 00497930-000000). 2. On December 4, 2008, an Order finding Respondent in violation of Section 9.5-111(1) of the Monroe County Code, was entered. 3. The Respondent was ordered to correct the Code violations by January 22, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as the "Compliance Date"), and was informed that failure to do so could result in the imposition of a fine for each Code violation and for each day after the Compliance Date that Respondent was in violation. 4. Respondent was also ordered to pay the costs of the prosecution and investigation of this matter. 5. As of the February 26, 2009, Respondent had not corrected the Code violations. Therefore it is ORDERED: Docu 1771360 9kq 2443 Pga U62 1. Respondent shall pay to Monroe County, Florida, a fine in the amount of $25.00 (TWENTY FIVE DOLLARS) for each Code violation, for each day a violation remains uncorrected beginning January 23, 2009 and the costs of the prosecution and investigation of this matter; and 2. MONROE COUNTY MAY RECORD A CERTIFIED COPY OF THIS ORDER IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS, WHICH SHALL THEREAFTER CONSTITUTE A LIEN AGAINST THE LAND ON WHICH THE VIOLATIONS EXIST AND UPON ANY OTHER REAL OR PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNED BY RESPONDENT. DONE AND ORDERED at the Division of Administrative Hearing, Tallahassee, Florida, this 11A day of March, 2009. Larry J. Sartin Code Enforcement Special Magistrate STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF LEON I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in the County aforesaid, to take acknowledgements, personally appeared Larry J. Sartin, personally known to me, who executed the foregoing and acknowledged before me that he executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this /l 7e day of March, 2009. s;, Eima Williams Commission # DD481642 ::. ..... ? Expires December 2, 2009 '41ff, r5i Bonded Tm, Fan Insurance Inc 800.10E-7019 0,G1 W L'U't-11�1 Notary Public I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above has been fiunished to the Respondent via first class mail at 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, FL 33037 this day of March, 2009. Nicole Petrick Code Enforcement Liaison 2 f �+ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SIXTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AN FOR MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA DocH 1 /09/2013 1.17PM Filed CecordeYd in OYfficiLINal cords of MONROE CASE NO. 44-2008-CA-000469-P U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, AS TRUSTEE OF MASTR ADJUSTABLE RATE MORTGAGES TRUST 2007-3 Plaintiffrn w (- vs. m,"- o -mac o PHILIP PAUL BOWERS, et, al. Defendant C CERTIFICATE OF TITLECD The undersigned Clerk of the Court certifies that he or she executed and filed a Certificate of Sale in this action April 29, 2013 for the property described herein and that no objections to the sale have been filed within the time allowed for filing objections. The following property in Monroe County, Florida: SEE ATTACHED LEGAL DESCRIPTION was sold to: BANK OF AMERICA, N. . FOR THE BENEFIT OF U.S. BANK, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION. AS TR USTEE FOR THE HOLDERS OF MASTR ADJUSTABLE RATE MORTGAGES TRUST 2007-3 CIO RONALD R. WOLFE & ASSOCIATES. P.L. P.O. BOX 25018 TAMPA. FLORIDA 33622-5018 WITNESS MY HAND AND SEAL of this Court on May 9, 2013 05/09/2013 1:17PM DEED DOC STAMP CL: MT $0.70 AMY HEAVILIN, Clerk of the Court Doaq 1932362 Bkp 2628 PqN 602 By: Deputy Clerk Bid Amount $100.00 f c LOT 2, IN BLOCK 3, AMENDED AND EXTENDED PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 4, AT PAGE 18, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA AND COMMONLY KNOWN AS 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE, KEY LARGO, FLORIDA 33037, FOLIO NO 497390. A/K/A 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE, KEY LARGO, FL 33037 Bkqa26282gP99 603 i NOTICE OF RIGHT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW Any aggrieved party, including Monroe County, may have appellate rights with regard to this Order pursuant to Section 162.11, Florida Statutes. Any such appeal will be limited to appellate review of the record created before the Special Magistrate. Any appeal must be filed with the Circuit Court within 30 days of the date of the execution of this Order. OacN 1771360 BkN 2443 PgN 1363 MONROE COUNTY 3 OFFICIAL RECORDS Prepared by and return to: Mike Gordon Esq. DocH 1959673 12/02/2013 3: 29PN 2221 U.S.27South Filed & Recorded in Official Records of Sebring, Florida 33970 MONROE COUNTY AMY HEAVILIN File Number. BSN-20847 Parcel [D No: 00497930-000000 12/02/2013 3:29PM DEED DOC STAMP CL: Krys $3,480.40 Return to: Bay National Title Company 13577 Feather Sound Drive Ste. 250 Clearwater, FL 33762 File Number: BSN-20847 DoeN 1959673 Parcel ID No:00497930-000000 Bkp 2660 P9# 2401 Quit Claim Deed Made this / 6 — 2� y , 2013A.D by Bank of America, N.A., who acquired title as, Bank of America, N.A. for the Benefit of U.S. Bank, National Association, as Trustee for the Holders of Mastr Adjustable Rate Mortgages Trust 2007-3. whose post office address is 350 Highland Drive350 Highland Drive, Lewisville, TX 75067hereinafter called the grantor, to Frances F. Andersen and Jon S. Andersen, wife and husband, vrhose post office address is 163 Corerine Placee Key Largo, FL 33037 hereinafter called the grantee. (Whenever used herein the term "grantor" and 'grantee" include all the peones to this instrument and the hein, legal re- presentatives and assigns of individuals, and the successor and assigns of corporations) Witnesseth, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of $ FOUR HUNDRED NINETY SEVEN THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY FIVE AND NO/100 DOLLARS ($497,175.00) and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, does hereby remise, release, and quit claim unto the grantee forever, all the right, title, interest, claim and demand which the said grantor has in and to, all that certain land situate in the city of Key Largo, Monroe County, Florida, viz Lot 2, Block 3, amended and extended plat of KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 4. Page 18, of the Public Records of Monroe County, Florida and commonly known as 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, Florida 33037, Folio No 497390. A/K/A 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, FL 33037 More commonly known as: 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, FL 33037 Together with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same together with all and singular the appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said grantor, either in law or equity, to the only proper use, benefit and behoof of the said grantee forever In Witness Whereof, the said grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence. "This deed is being executed by virtue of the power of attorney recorded on 09/19/13 with Instr ent #2013000216008 of the Pub ice Rin Lee Co r FI &'4_ Pun //��/ Pri d Name: i Address. 350 Highland Drive, Lewisville. TX 75067 _ Printed Nam SIF psal The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this / 0 — 2013 by' i d/eea ! he �r&F, A Wfor Bank of America, N.A., by Nationstar Mortgage. LLC, as Attorney -in -Fact who is personally known to ri or o has produced driver's license as identification. State of County of �Eiti %�/y Bank of A eto-e-L401 ., by Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, as Attorn iBy: Print:S Its: Assistant Secretary 1 1�rr• ANOILIA WALLACE My Commission Explr®a January 18, 2017 Notary Publie Print Name'ANGILIA WALLACE My Commission Expires. Quit Claim Deed MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Friday, July 26, 2013 11:22 AM To: 'frannabananna@gmaii.com' Cc: Williams -Steve Subject: Bowers CE07040059 CE08010003 149 Ocean shores ki Attachments: NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS.PDF (Please acknowledge receipt of this email). When a property is sold "as is" the County has three basic requirements: 1. An affidavit from the prospective buyer acknowledging the violations, acknowledging that they will be cited for the violations and acknowledging that they will be given a reasonable period of time to achieve compliance before the fines resume running, 2. Fines and costs in exchange for a lien release to remove subject property from the lien, and 3. (if applicable) as per Monroe County Code 122-6(a) as follows: Prior to the transfer of ownership of any property occupied by an elevated residential structure with a below base flood enclosed area defined as "new construction" (i.e., construction commenced on or after January 1, 1975) under this chapter, a county approved inspection of the below base flood enclosure shall be conducted. The required inspection shall be conducted no earlier than 180 days prior to the transfer of the property by the seller or the potential purchaser, with the sellers permission. The intent of this inspection, which is strictly limited to the below base flood enclosure, is to identify for county records and purchasers any nonconformities or illegal structures or uses. I will address each. I The County does have a form for this which I have prepared and attached for your review, I have also attached the copy of the letter referenced in the agreement, This is a form the County uses to satisfy Florida Statutes 162 for the required acknowledgement from the new buyers and also allows the new buyers to stipulate to the violations and agree to a compliance date. By using this form the new buyers will not have to attend a hearing. This agreement will not becorne binding until the Warranty Deed is filed in the Official Records. 2. 1 have reviewed the status of these cases. A daily fine of $25.00 per day ran for 1567 days for a total of $39,175.00 on each case. So the total amount of the fines due is $78,350.00 and two liens were filed in the Monroe County Clerk's Office in favor of the County. A Certificate of Title was filed in the Official Records on May 9, 2013. Since the bank was noticed with these violations on December 11, 2009, the County has suspended the daily fines for 90 days to give US Bank a reasonable amount of time to correct the violations or sell the property. The fines will resume rurming on August 9, 2013. When the County has a lien on a property which is involved in a foreclosure action, we cannot commence any claim in the property but the lien in favor of the county attaches to all real and personal property owned by the property owners and serves as a Notice to prospective buyers. To not impede a sale of the property the County will issue a Partial Release in exchange for a partial payment of fines and payment of costs, thereby releasing the lien in favor of the County from this property so clear title can pass to the buyer. The County's lien remains intact against all other properties owned by the prior property owners. I have also reviewed the circumstances of this case and the foreclosure action with our Assistant County Attorney for Code, Steve Williams. As a result, the County will accept a payment of $2.910.37 for CE07040059, ($2,500.00 fines and $410.37 costs),, and a payment of $2,710.25 for CE08010003, ($2,500.00 fines and $210.25 costs). Therefore the County will accept $5,620.62 as full payment of fines and costs for the subject property and will provide a Partial Release of Lien (for each case) to be filed with the clerks of courts. This offer is good for 30 days. . 3. (Applicable to this property) The seller (or buyer) must apply for a transfer of sale inspection under the County's floodplain codes. I hope this helps. The New Buyer Affidavit describes the outstanding violations for these two cases. These are all the violations that are known to us at time. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any other questions. I= Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. MONROE COUNTY CODE COMPLIANCE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE Monroe County Code Compliance Petitioner VS. Respondent(s) Name and Address In the matter of: Re#: 00497930-000000 Case: and CE08010003 AGREEMENT AND AFFIDAVIT OF NEW PURCHASER TO STAY FINES AND ENLARGE COMPLIANCE DATE "Respondent(s)") named above and Monroe County Code Compliance ("Petitioner"), hereby declare under oath the following: 1) The Respondent(s) are the purchasers of the property commonly known as 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE, KEY LARGO, MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA. 2) The Respondent(s) acknowledge that the violation(s) of the Monroe County Code(s) outlined below and in the prior Notice of Violation/Notice of Hearing(s) charged in this matter are accurate and supported by substantial evidence. 3) The Respondent(s) understand and agree to waive the right to contest the following violations: To -Wit: 11 -1 (1) . BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED Permit(s), approval(s) and inspection(s) are required for interior renovations ( installation of new tile, painting electric, plumbing and drywall) and installation of (approximately 13) ground level exterior flood lights fixtures. P:MTMEMENT and NEW BUYER AGREEMENTSWEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059 AND CE03010003.dom Corrective Action Required: Contact the Monroe County Building and Planning Department and obtain an after the fact permit or remove as directed. NOTE: All permit fees and permit requirements are based on the specific scope of work. Additional permits, permit fees, mitigation fees, or restoration of the property to original condition may be required. The minimum fee for an After The Fact permit is $500.00 (five hundred dollars) as per Monroe County Code Section 6-29(a)(1). All permits will require PASSING final inspection(s). 122-4.(b)(1)d - PERMIT CONDITIONS/FLOOD HAZARD As per the letter provided to you from the Floodplain manager dated August 7, 2006 your downstairs enclosure is in violation of the following items: 1. The enclosure has insufficient flood vents Corrective Action Required: Contact the Floodplain Management Office for information to bring the enclosure into compliance. If you have already been notified by the Floodplain Management Office of the corrective action required please follow the requirements as stated in the letter. Items being stored under the elevated structure not defined as limited storage must be removed. building permits, approvals, inspections and/or final inspections may also be required. Floodplain Management Office (305)289-2866. 1`1is cr�nf C-6-0$01AU O03 4) The Respondent(s) understand and acknowledge that the fines will be stayed from the date the Respondents) are entitled to possession of the property until the new compliance date specified in paragraph 5. 5) The property will be checked for compliance on . (New compliance date). 6) The parties understand that a fine of $300.00 per day shall accrue daily if the property is not brought into compliance within the time specified in paragraph 5. 7) The Respondent(s) understands that if the Respondents(s) fails to comply within the time given, the fine(s) shall accrue each day the violations) remain as follows: 110-140(1) 150.00 per day 122-4(b)(1)d 150.00 per day PASEMEMENT and NEW BUYER AGREEMENTS\NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059 AND CE08D10001dom 2 8) The Respondent(s) waive the right to appeal any finding of violation or order that he or she would otherwise have under Section 162.11, Florida Statutes. 9) The Respondent(s) agree to pay to the Petitioner all costs incurred (after date of possession) in prosecuting their case within 30 days of compliance and that such costs may be imposed as a lien under Section 162.09(2)(d), Florida Statutes, and Monroe County Code section 8-29(b). 10) The Respondent(s) specifically agrees that this Agreement maybe recorded in the public records of the County and if recorded shall constitute notice to subsequent purchasers, successors in interests, or assigns that the violation(s) of Monroe County Code as stated in paragraph 3 exist. This Agreement shall be recorded as a lien against the property and upon any other real or personal property owned by the Respondent(s) if the property is not brought into compliance by the date specified in paragraph 5. 11) Respondent(s) agrees and represents that Respondent(s) entered into this Agreement of the Respondent(s)'s own free will. Respondent(s) further understands and agrees that he/she has the right to consult with counsel prior to signing this Stipulation, and has done so or has elected to waive this right. PME MEMENT and NEW BUYER AGREEMENTSNEW BUYER AFFIDAV rr BOWERS CED7040059 AND CE080100DIdocx By signing this Agreement, both parties represent that they have the authority to enter into this agreement and further, that they have READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND CONSENT to its terms and conditions. I I Signature of Respondent(s) I Date Signature of Respondent(s) I Date Print Name STATE OF _ COUNTY OF PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20 NOTARY PUBLIC My commission expires 20—: I Signature of Petitioner (County) / Date Print Name STATE OF _ COUNTY OF PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20 Print Name STATE OF COUNTY O_F PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20 NOTARY PUBLIC My commission expires 20_: NOTARY PUBLIC My commission expires 20_ PMEITLEMENT and NEW BUYER AGREEMENTS\NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07O4W59 AND CE08010001doa 4 Windsor -Kathleen From: Fran <frannabananna@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 1:12 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Williams -Steve Cc: jon andersen Subject: Affidavit re condition of 149 Ocean Shores Dr, Key Largo Hello Kathleen I received your email. I did not, however, like all those fines you will be charging us. Why do we, the new owners, have to pay for someone else's past problems? If we bring the property up to acceptable code standards we think we should be rewarded - not penalized. Therefore, we are asking that all fines be waived when the house is brought up to code, as you request. We are trying to get the bank to comply with the new buyers inspection requirement, but the hold over seller has dogs and a gun and won't let anyone into the property. We are powerless in this situation. We may lose our $ 53,000 deposit due to this problem. It is becoming a very ugly situation. Is it possible to get the Sherrill to escort us in to do the inspection by your order? Please give us any advice you may have. Fran Andersen 949-278-9294 Windsor -Kathleen From: jon andersen <154pearl@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, August 01, 2013 2:33 PM To: Corcoran -Brian; Windsor -Kathleen; Fran Andersen andersen Subject: 149 Ocean Shores inspection Hello Brian I am Jon Andersen I spoke with you on the phone about the inspections yesterday. We are winners of the Auction.com bid for 149 Ocean shores, Key Largo. I am not yet the owner yet but the process has started. Thanks for the info yesterday on the phone clarifying the new owner inspection. I have notified the Bank (owner) and the auction company that by law we are required to have the inspections done before we take title. Also Kathleen's affidavit has some time requirements that we are concerned about so getting the inspections done now will comply with those needs. I think it would be a good idea to schedule the inspection now. I would like to come along with you (or the assigned inspector). The tenant is the old owner and could be hostile to the inspection. When you give me a date I will inform the owner by mail (we don't have a contact phone) that the inspection will take place. Also there are some code enforcement issues that need to be inspected. Can we accomplish those inspections at the same time? I have been wondering if we should request the sheriff to be available to keep the peace, at least for the initial arrival. Rather than have all show up and be turned away it would be wise to have the law with us to save us all some time. If we think things are safe then the officer can leave. What do you think? Do you have any buddies in the sheriffs office next door that can help us out? Please let me know ASAP Is this email enough to request the inspection or do I need to do something else. Thanks for your help on this matter. Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Friday, August 02, 2013 4:32 PM To: 'Fran'; Williams -Steve Cc: jon andersen; Corcoran -Brian Subject: RE: Affidavit re condition of 149 Ocean Shores Dr, Key Largo CE07040059 CE08010003 Attachments: 149 Ocean Shores inspection Hello Fran and Jon, I am in receipt of this email, and the email dated 8-1-2013 which is attached herein. There is a lien attached to this property because it is the subject of violations. The total of the liens are $78,350.00. The violations run with the land, therefore with the promise of achieving compliance (by new owners) the County as agreed to accept $5,620.62 as full payment of fines and costs for the subject property and will provide a Partial Release of Lien (for each case) to be filed with the clerks of courts. As far as your questions about getting the tenant to vacant the property, getting entry to the property or any other legal questions you have about liens, etc. you should consult with your own counsel. Myself, or any of the Monroe County Attorneys are prohibited from giving any legal advice public. I am sorry I cannot be of more help. Kathleen Windsor, CFM Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon FL 33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 Fax: 305-289-2536 windsor-kathleen@monroecounty-fl.gov Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. -----Original Message ----- From: Fran [mailto:frannabananna@email.com] Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 1:12 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Williams -Steve Cc: jon andersen Subject: Affidavit re condition of 149 Ocean Shores Dr, Key Largo Hello Kathleen I received your email. I did not, however, like all those fines you will be charging us. Why do we, the new owners, have to pay for someone else's past problems? If we bring the property up to acceptable code standards we think we should be rewarded - not penalized. Therefore, we are asking that all fines be waived when the house is brought up to code, as you request. We are trying to get the bank to comply with the new buyers inspection requirement, but the hold over seller has dogs and a gun and won't let anyone into the property. We are powerless in this situation. — - — - - .... - ----- N T K p T� TL' FAT' 1,; -2 5 /2) PRI:.T T`:i0 ' 16 7 56 E FC 210 rE �72' rO 53141 Fai"qo tie pa Wells Fargo Bank, N,A 53141 5 621 C 0 0 PAY fll' VS T,"('Usariz� S a E.,s ........... Dc� a-s TO THE P.4orroe Cocmy C �de ORDER 2","S8 :1-1" vi'..i,' sea s H,,i a Nlarar'�o;- Ft, EMI cuSiNI ""' ",""4 C . . . ....... . .. . MOMOO CWq Code Canoe SOW Jon Andersen a) Nmm WWAddnM 1"l ' c A 7, 4>tl1 1 {l DOCV 1982218 Bkp 2685 P8p 1769 �5)� r�rrt0debmand MOruoe County Code n, hereby declam under as& the ng: The Respondents) are the fyf the ommrordy as 149 OCEAN 2) the R - s)OdMVWadge that the (s) of ft Monroe COW* Cods(s) oudned below and In do Prior Nodca ol'WissmWollog- of ems) dmqW In Mb "ether am aasrrsAe 3) The Resporulent(s)und9slOnd and WOO to walve the rVd to conied the bilowing !,: To-4Nt 110-140(1) -BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED Pe"s), appnow 99) and s) are MqUired for Interfor Gov (Installation of , plumbtng and drywal) and n Of � 1 )ground level PtSEMMMff mdNRWMrMAORHewevrAe rrWWOsca»owMAM 1 IN2218 2685 Psm 177s Convelim Action . Contact the Umww County Building end Planning DepubmM wW obtain an Owthe fed pwm* or ne nm as NOTE: AN pem*fees and perrrrit requirements ere b sect on the specific map of wo& Additional permits, perm*few. miti88bon fees, or restoration of the properly to _ migirial condition may be retluired. The minknum tree for an Attm The Fad perm* is $6M.00 ffin humW dd a* as Per monme County Cade Section 0-Max1). M permitswig require PAWING Snel s). 122-4.(bXl)d - PMIT CONMIXOMUM KVARD As per the letter provided to you from the FloodpW manager dated August 7,2008 your dommidelm endue Is to violation of the blowing iferns. 1. The enclosure has irnar(rdent ftod vents Co Action Required: Contact the Floodplain Maragarrerrt Me for mfommtion to bring the lure into If you a�dy en benol ied by the - - Office of the relents as stated to the letter. Herne being storodunder the eleveled shuctumpA Jilin 1111 081 IN MIR 0901flUstberernowd. bukft pmmft approa, kgwc &m and/or final may also be (M . 4) The Reaponderrt(s) cmdea WW and sclumaledge that the fines w8 be stryed from the date the ems) are er OR to possession of the property urd the new mnpOmm date spscftd in paragnph 5. 5) The pmWy vM be checMd fcw compliance on fia ELIM (New cmiplience date). 6) ThO Parties undeMEd that a fine OFMA per day 00 accrue daily K the pmp" Is not brought into compliance wdhin the time specOW in pwaWaph 6. 7) The Respondent(s) u _ nds that * the s) fafls to comply within the tkne given, ft fs*s) shag accn each day Ow s) remain as faft". limaxil 150A per day 1 i(1 IMOO Per day PissmimM Hew WM AGREENEENTMMW Buren APPM%'rr l0WM CM,o M AND 8) TheCA vmln the right to appeal any findiviolation or order that he or she would, allhel vise have under SectIon 162.11, BxWg Statutes. 9) The R ent(s) agree to Pay to the inner ON costs Inca (after dab of possession) in prosecufing their case within 30 days of cornpliarroe and that such costs may be imposed as a Dan under Secdon 162.09(2Xd), Florida SMM4 and Monme County Code section 8-29(b). 10) The Responderd(s) ihla Agmwnwd may be recorded in the public records of the County and rT recorded shall constitute notice to subsequent purchasers, w N successors in Interests, or assigns that the violation(s) of Monsce County Code as stated �m aN in paragraph 3 exist. This Agreement shell be recorded as a Dan against the property ua and upon OY om any other real or personal property wmxd by On PAspondent(s) d the property is not brought into compliance by the date specMed in paragraph S. 11) Respondent(s) agrees and represents that Resporrde d(s) enhwed kft this Agreement of the sys om fires will. Respvndsnt(s) fiulher under and agrees that helshe has the right to consult with counsel prior to signing this Sdpuatlon, _and has done so or has elecied to this right -THS S9:ttvj)m"yT Ajxr)A7y- OF-* 5te-v5 L� r�Ll rv�S G y / l�T 147 cac YU y -5F. 66i-bo Qve 24 ) 2o )3 I IL)cTr, y� pi a POEifz- '1'%TnaffiWwW NEW mrmAGummwYsww mr m AFFmvrr wwmcwmmwAmcmww doe 3 • .ap 1982218 Bkp 2685 PoN 1772 10 r o W an. n ile W fbft My Conan EXOM JW 2e, fell Comm-ssnr a FF 40M PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE W fhe (fl8 M Of abim an ! L 2O -� My Comm. Ewma Jal 20. fell OonaMssfon o ff ®Ol0e e-.'- NICOLE M. PETRICK Notary Public -Stale of FloridaMy Comm. Expires Dec 12, 2013�Commission DD 917995'Bonded Through NaOond Notary Alan. MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS 7,1 Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Monday, November 25, 2013 2:08 PM To: 'Fran' Cc: Jon andersen; Williams -Steve; Wingate -Mary Subject: RE: Bowers CE07040059 CE08010003 149 Ocean Shores Dr, ,Key Largo, A Attachments: CE07040059 photos.PDF; NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT CE07040059 CE08010003.PDF it For case CE08010003: you need to obtain the Ownership Transfer Inspection which will let you know if there are any additional violations that need to be corrected in the enclosure since the Flood Insurance Inspection that was conducted on 7-28-2006. Once you make all the corrections as required, that will take care of the violations in the lower enclosure. For case CE07040059: you need to get permit(s) for the unpermitted renovations to the elevated portion of the house. For more information on the permittingprocess you should contact the building department directly 05-43- 80. 1 have attached the photos from the file. I would suggest you share them with the Building Department regarding the scope of work for the permit(s) you will need. Once the permits have been issued, inspected and closed, please contact me so I can update your cases. The Partial Releases will be mailed out to you in the next day or so. I have also included a copy of the executed New Buyer Affidavit for your records. I hope this helps. Kathleen Windsor, CFM Sr. Code ComplianceResearch Analyst 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 Fax: 305-289-2536 i rm l r c -® v Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding county business are public record, available to the public and media upon requests Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: Fran[mailto:frannabananna@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, November 25, 2013 9:00 AM To: Windsor -Kathleen Cc: jon andersen Subject: Re: Bowers CE07040059 CE08010003 149 Ocean Shores Dr, ,Key Largo, FI Kathleen, Good news! We finally evicted the hostile hold -over tenant and are in the process of cleaning the place up and moving in. We want to comply with your requirements to remove any and all code violations. we have paid all the fines... What is the next step please? Fran Andersen 949-278-9294 This Instrument Prepared by: Steven T. Williams Esq. Assistant County Attorney 1111 12ih Street, Suite 408 Key West FL 33040 Partial Release of Lien MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, ) Petitioner, ) VS. ) CASE NO. CE07040059 PH LLIP PAUL BOWERS ) Respondent(s). ) TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: This is to certify that MONROE COUNTY, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, the owner and holder of the Lien for non-payment of fines/liens referenced in the FINAL ORDER/LIEN previously recorded in the Official Records of Monroe County on December 21, 2009 at Document 1771360, Book 2445, Page(s) 1361-1363, securing said lien upon the property situated in said State and County described as follows, to -wit: Lot 2, Block 3, amended and extended plat of KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 4, at Page 18, of the Public Records of Monroe County, Florida. More commonly referred to as: 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, Monroe County, Florida; Parcel ID Number 00497930-000000, hereby directs the Clerk of Said Circuit Court to record this partial release of lien in the official records of Monroe County, Florida. This release is a limited release of the afore -described property only and does not operate to release the Code Enforcement lien from any property other than described herein. (The County's Partial Release is effective only as to the Released Property described above. The FINAL ORDER/LIEN, previously recorded in the Official Records of Monroe County on December 21, 2009 at Document 1771360, Book 2445, Page(s) 1361-1363„ against any other of the real and personal properties owned by PB11 LLIP PAUL BOWERS remains in full force and effect, is in no way affected by this PARTIAL RELEASE and serves as no liability against any future fines/costs which may accrue in Monroe County Code Enforcement Cases.) Witness my hand and seal this day of , 2013, at Key West, Monroe County, Florida. by: State of Florida County of Monroe Monroe County Attorney's Office Attorneys for Petitioner 1111 12`s Street, Suite 408 Key West FL 33040 Steven T. Williams Assistant County Attorney I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an agent duly authorized to take acknowledgments and administer oaths, in the State and County aforesaid, personally appeared Lisa Granger, Assistant County Attorney for Monroe County, Florida, who is personally known to me. WITNESS my hand and official seal at the County and State aforesaid, this day of , 2013. Notary Public — State of Florida r 14 �. County of Monroe ',�`�,4 "; Growth Management Division Code Compliance Department 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon, Florida 33050 Voice: (305) 289-2810 FAX: (305) 289-2536 Frances E. Andersen and Jon S. Andersen 149 Ocean Shores Drive Key Largo, Florida 33037 November 25, 2013 Subject: Code Enforcement Case: CE07040059 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Andersen, Board of County Commissioners Mayor George Neugent, Dist 2 Mayor Pro Tem Heather Carruthers, Dist. 3 Danny L. Kolhage, Dist. 1 David Rice, Dist. 4 Sylvia J. Murphy, Dist. 5 Enclosed please find the original partial release for the above -mentioned code case. It is the recipient's responsibility to record the document in the Official Records of Monroe County. Respectfully yours, Kathleen Windsor Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst 305-289-2586 Prepared by and return to: Mike Gordon Esq. ,Aocg 1959673 12/02/2013 3: 2221 U.S.27 South Fl ed & Recorded in Official Recr MONROE COUNTY AMY HEAVILIN Sebring, Florida 33870 .. -_- File Number: BSN-20847 Parcel [D No_ 00497930-000000 12/02/2013 . , DEED DOC STAMP CL : Return to: Bay National Title Company 13577 Feather Sound Drive Ste. 250 Clearwater, FL 33762 File Number, BSN-20847 Doc# 1959673 Parcel ID No:00497930-000000 Bkp 2660 P911 2401 Quit Claim Deed Made this _1 (A� Z 1013 AD by Bank of America, N.A., who acquired title as, Bank of America, N.A. for the BeneOt of U.S. Bank, National Association, as Trustee for the Holders of Mastr Adjustable Rate Mortgages Trust 2007.3, whose post office address is 350 Highland Drive350 Highland Drive, Lewisville, TX 75067hereinafter called the grantor, to Frances E. Andersen and Jon S. Andersen, wife and husband, whose post office address is 163 Corenne Placee Key Largo, FL 33037 hereinafter called the grantee: (whenever used herein the term "grantor' and 'grantee' include all the panics to this instrument and the heirs, legal m- presentatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns of corporations) Witnesseth, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of S FOUR HUNDRED NINETY SEVEN THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY FIVE AND NO/100 DOLLARS ($497,175.00) and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, does hereby remise, release, and quit claim unto the grantee forever, all the right, title, interest, claim and demand which the said grantor has in and to, all that certain land situate in the city of Key Largo, Monroe County, Florida, viz: Lot 2, Block 3, amended and extended plat of KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES, according to the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 18, of the Public Records of Monroe County, Florida and commonly known as 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, Florida 33037, Folio No 497390. A/K/A 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, FL 33037 More commonly known as: 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, FL 33037 Together with all the tenements, heraditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same together with all and singular the appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said grantor, either in law or equity, to the only proper use, benefit and behoof of the said grantee forever In Witness Whereof, the said grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: **This deed is being executed by virtue of the power of attorney recorded on 09/19/13 with Instr ent #2013000216008 of the Pub ice Re��jjords in Lee Co , F71 Witness jj�� Pri dd Name: = �� Address. 350 Highland Drive, Lewisville, TX 75tM7 -' r Printed Nam S ry--� The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this J 0 — 2 2013 by rl dAea l He-e.4sas AS Wfor Bank of America. N.A., by Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, as Attorney -in -Fact who is personally known to me or o has produced driver's license as identification. State of TG-�X.4s Coun of I�EiII Toy✓ Bank of A ' , N.A., by Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, as Attorn i cL By: Print: 14 !1 'cer/J T�1 �1 /H *S Its: Assistant Secretary 1 rnm i ANGILIA WALLACE My Commission Expires January 18, 2011 Not—PublicNamblie ANGILIA WALLACE Print Name My Commiuion Expires: Quit Claim teed MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS BEF , , E COUNTY CODE COMPLIANCE SPECIAL M61TRATE MONROE COUNTY FLORIDA, Petitioner, vs. MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA Case No. CE_- Subject Property Real Esfato Number: FINAL ORDER DocN 1982218 8i/22/2014 12:14PM Filed & Recorded in Official Records of MONROE COUNTY A" WAVILIN Having fully co sidmed the evidence presented at hearing. Including testimony of the Code Compliance Inspector(s) and/or witnesses under oath, the following Findings of Fact and Conclusions of low are ORDERED, The Ressand/or Auttmdzed Eangamwa SIGNED AN AGREEMENT & AFFIDAVIT OF NEW PURCHASER TO STAY FiNES AND i N GE COMPLIANCE ware present and did not contest the viola6an(s) set forth to use Notice of VlolatbnlNotice of Hearing which Is incorporated herein as O idly set firth. ( The Respondents) Ware the owners) of property located within Monroe County and wL%kvm duly notk:ad of the hearing. ( The Respondenl(s) Ware in violation of the Monroe County Code(s) es fully set forth In the Notice of Violation/Notice of Hearing served upon the Respondent(s). ( ) The vohdon(s) Is found to be Irreparable or hreversible and a one4lme fine of $ 1 Is ORDERED, payable within days of this Order. ( Pursuant to Section 162.07(2) of Florida Statutes all coals Incurred by the County In prosecuting the casie Is ordered to be paid within thirty (30) days of compliance. Costs will continue to accrue untl compliance is addeved and the case Is dosed. (A The Raepondetd(s) shall carMly with the Code(s) referred to in the Notice of ViolationMotice of Hearing on or before °THE COMIPUANCE DATE'). ( In the event the vlalation(s) were or are not corrected on THE COMPLIANCE DATE PREVIOUSLY ORDERED or on THE COMPLIANCE DATE SET FORTH HEREON, tines) in the dollar amount of $ y .^ �+_ ,�y . .. w _ - t for each day beginning an THE DAY AFTER THE COMPLIANCE DATE that the Responderd(s) Ware In violation Wre hereby ORDERED. (16 is further ordered, that the County Is hereby authorized to make all reasonable repairs including demolition which are required to bring the property inm compliance and charge the Respondents) with the cost of repairs roared by the County, the costs of prosecution framed by the County and any fines Ordered in this matter. ( i The Respondent(s) were In violation of the MONROE COUNTY Code(s) as fully set forth in the Notice of VotetionlNotice of Hearing tiled in this coo and did not come into compliance on or before THE COMPLIANCE DATE but are now In compliance. The Respohdengs) shall pay the total amount of cost andbr tines ($ - to Monroe County Code Compliance within thirty (30) days of this Order. (4)AGREEMENT IS ATTACHED HERETO AND INCORPORATED HEREIN. rot DATED this day at _ — 1 20 Docq 1982228 Van Laningham, Spada] Magistrate BkN 2685 PgN 1767 Page 1 of 2 ry'44- DocN 1982218 FINAL ORDER PAGE 2 8kp 2685 PgN 1768 CASE NUMBER: CE07040059 Respondent(s) mailing address of record with the Monroe County Property Appraiser's Office: ANDERSEN FRANCES E & JON S ANDERSEN 163 CORERINE PLACE KEY LARGO, FL 33037 Location of Subject Property: 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE KEY LARGO, FL 33037 RE NUMBER: 00497930000000 CERTIFICATE OF ORDER I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of the above Order. Nicole M. Petrick, Liaison CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of this Order has been furnished to the Respondent(s) via hand delivery / fijX class U.S. mail to Respondent(s) address of record with the Monroe County Property Appraiser's Office as referenced above and/or Authorized Representative on this day of Aa ,20 Nicole M. Petrick, Liaison PAGE 2 of 2 Windsor -Kathleen From: Jon andersen <154pearl@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, January 12, 201412:15 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Fran Andersen Subject: Re: new owner inspection 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 I sent an email to Brian telling him we are ready for a flood inspection. Is this the new owner transfer inspection too? can they be combined if not? In regards to the interior renovations: No permit pulled. I have called and visited the building dept 6 times to determine what they need. I have gotten contradictory information so I have spent time on the web trying to determine what the law is. Upon further review of the work I don't see how it needed a permit to begin with. • 1. The work performed most likely does not need a licensed contractor according to the Florida Business and professions code. • 2. The work is minor according to the definition of the Florida Building Code and may not need a permit. 3. The value of the work falls below the value threshold established by the Florida building department and the improvements do no trigger the necessity of a permit. • ( i say most likely, my research indicates a permit is not needed, but I have not discussed with knowledgeable people at the building department) The building department (at the desk) said "submit a list of all the work and the value of the work, pay us a permit fee then we will let you know if you need a permit or not". I think paying $75 every time I wish to do maintenance on my home is excessive. Is there a way we can discuss my findings without my paying more money? On Sat, Jan 11, 2014 at 11:13 AM, Windsor -Kathleen < in so - at een , o oeco t - . ov> wrote: 110-140(1) - BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED Permit(s), approval(s) and inspection(s) are required for interior renovations ( installation of new tile, painting electric, plumbing Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Monday, January 13, 201411:04 AM To: Jon andersen'; frannabananna@gmail.com Cc: Corcoran -Brian; Williams -Steve Subject: 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 Attachments: CE07040059.PDF Our evidence indicates that the cumulative work done to the interior of this structure required a permit, approval and inspections. A hearing was held and the Special Magistrate found the property in violation on December 2, 2003. There was no appeal of that finding during the 30 day appeal period. The violation still exists and permits, approvals and inspections are required to cure the violation. Additionally you entered into a binding gr e ent with the County on October 29, 2013 admitting that the violations were accurate, waiving the right to contest the violations, and agreeing to the corrective actions. Although you may not agree that the work requires a permit, a permit is required to resolve this case. This permit may be n After -The -Fact permit for the work that was done, or you may choose to get a Demolition permit and remove the unperrinitted work. As far as your difficulty with the permitting process, I really don't have any authority in that department. I have attached the inspector's photos and recommend that you take these photos; and photos of the current condition to the building department. This may help the building staff understand what you need. I have also included Brian in this email. Not only will he be providing me photos of the vents and the removal of the outdoor lighting and associated electric, he was one of the Code inspectors on this case. I hope this helps. Kathleen Windsor, CFM Sr. Code ComplianceResearch al Overseas2798 i Marathon Phone: 305-289-2686 Fax: 306-289-2536 windsor-lkathlonroecon mfil ov Tease note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications s to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: jon andersen [mailto:154pearl@gmail.com] Sent: Sunday, January 12, 2014 12:15 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Fran Andersen Subject: Re: new owner inspection 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 I sent an email to Brian telling him we are ready for a flood inspection. Is this the new owner transfer inspection too? can they be combined if not? Windsor -Kathleen From: Smith -Jerry Sent: Monday, March 03, 2014 2:30 PM To: Jon andersen'; Norman -Ronda; Hurley -Christine; Williams -Steve; Granger -Lisa; Windsor - Kathleen; Corcoran -Brian; Senator Dwight Bullard; Murphy -Sylvia; BOCCDIS5 Subject: RE: 149 ocean shorers am # lolfffl=% I'' 17 =3=7=76MI71717-10 - Ing Y= j7trrmt is not ReFTMI —=e extensive r st you ave cited. I don't know any "near -by" where they are enforcing the Code that a permit would not be required as any exterior door replacement would require a permit and an N.O.A./Product Approval. It is impossible to answer every "what if' scenario that you have posed. The Florida Building Code, Existing Building states, "The provisions of the Florida Building Code, Existing Building shall apply to the repair, alteration, change of occupancy, addition and relocation of existing buildings." Without a specific proposal, scoping the exact work and total value, it is difficult to determine permit requirements. orintmill"11W. PETERS I "Wilaho �' III INI, low I IN to accept as I'm unaware of that to which they refer. Again, I cannot answer hypothetical questions without the total project. Replacing a vanity faucet as the only work is significantly different than doing a $20,000.00 Remodel comprised of elements which may not have required a permit singularly. I'm not avoiding answering your questions, but the questions constantly change along with the scenarios and I cannot ci,imply state you don't need a permit. A Jerome A. Smith, Jr., C.B.O., C.F.M. Monroe County Building Official Growth Management, Monroe County Nelson Government & Cultural Center 102050 Overseas Highway Key Largo, FL 33037 Ph.: 305-453-8800 Fax: 305-453-8818 Email: Smith-Jen@monroecounty-fi.fzov Website: www.monroecounjy:�fl�.ov From: jon andersen [mailto:154peari@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 03, 2014 1:31 PM To: Smith -Jerry; Norman -Ronda; Hurley -Christine; Williams -Steve; Granger -Lisa; Windsor -Kathleen; Corcoran -Brian; Senator Dwight Bullard; Murphy -Sylvia; B0CCDIS5 Subject: Re: 149 ocean shorers I object, 150 contacts! Are you kidding me? It might seem like 150, but let me assure you it's not true, I keep record of every email and my phone records too.... Are you planning to charge me like code enforcement has promised?, if you are, I will need a detailed invoice and you need to let me know upfront. (Provide hourly rate too) Your statement reflects on how difficult it has been to get a simple question answered. Have 1 really asked you this 150 times? Jerry, you have told me, that you make the decisions here. That your staff are unable to answer generic questions. You have also told me you answered my Question in our meeting (not true, but who cares). If you did answer then, why not now? For some reason I can't get you to write it down. Making me suspicious... what is the agenda here? Why are you forwarding this to attorneys is it that difficult to answer this? What law, regulation, scenario or precedence dictates & governs when multiple residential improvement projects (that, under ordinary conditions do NOT require a permit) cause them to need a permit when done concurrently (which includes being done in the same 12 month period according to you in our meeting) Although this question has come to light as a result from the past problems with my new home, I am asking for future edification. I plan to be doing some work on the home and I need to know the rules. Here are some examples:. These items don't normally need a permit (if I am wrong please advise) • Painting interior • Texture repair interior • Drywall repair (less than one sheet —assume neither has plumbing or electrical involved) • Loosening a few outlets to paint (not disconnecting the wires) • Replace damaged exterior outlet cover. • Change 1 or 2 outlets • Replace a vanity faucet (no in wall plumbing) • Replace angle stop (shut off valve) (that does not shut off- no in wall plumbing) • Change a shower head • Replace a ceiling light or fan • Replace base board • Re -screen patio room • Exterior wood or stucco repair (non structural) • Tighten metal roof screws • Painting exterior • Repair exterior gate or fence • Replace exterior porch light • Exchange interior cabinets • Build garage shelf • Replace a broken hose bib • Paving stones walkway (less than 100 sgft) • Paint exterior steps or patio • Replace a door or door hardware • Tile floor (less than $5000 fair market value) Based on your answer I may decide not to do some of the repairs on my home........ I need to know when I need a permit for these types of items. Can you give me an idea of what a permit would cost (for each item above if done separately) and what it would cost if done in the same 12 month period? I have had discussions with other near -by building officials; they told me there is no code items in the building code requiring a permit for such things even when done concurrently, and no codes or remarks in the building code stating that when done concurrently a permit is needed. One inspector even told me "How can I charge for an inspection if there is nothing to inspect, what am I going to do? Stand there and watch them mix the mud?" (This was in reference to a tile floor) It has been easy to get answers from the other Florida State code enforcement professionals , , but they are not here..... Are they? You are.... I need an answer from you. P.S. They are surprised that this is even taking place. P.S.S I added a two more recipients On Sun, Mar 2, 2014 at 10:17 PM, Smith -Jerry <Smi _Jerre o Deco -.m ov> wrote: Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Norman -Ronda" < o - onda o oeco ty-tl.ov> To: "Hurley -Christine" < ey-C stine o oeco -F ov> Cc: "Williams -Steve" < i i s- eve , o oeCo ty- ov>, "Granger -Lisa" < r e- _isa(a% o oeCo ty- L.Gov>, "Smith -Jerry" <S it-Je o oeCo ty- -0La ov>, "Windsor -Kathleen" < indsor- a een o oecount - . ov>, "Corcoran -Brian" <Corcor - ri pia,_ o_ oeCo ty-L, ov> Subject: : 149 ocean shorers Hi Christine, Attached is the "New Buyer Affidavit" which shows the violations and corrective action to be taken for compliance. There have been well over 150 email exchanges, phone calls, etc., sent to and with Mr. Anderson by appropriate staff members and legal to assist in answering his questions. If you would like the email exchange(s), please let us know. Thanks, Ronda L. Norman, CPM Sr. Director, Code Compliance Monroe County Code Compliance 2798 Overseas Highway #330 Marathon, FL. 33050 f 3 Q 9-2 1 Office Q5 289-2515 Fax o-ronda,(aa o oecounty- .Gov "If we did all the things we were capable of, we would literally astound ourselves." From: Hurley -Christine Sent: Wednesday, February 26, 2014 7:20 PM To: Smith -Jerry Cc: Williams -Steve; Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda Subject: Re: 149 ocean shorers Is there a notice of violation or a special magistrate finding that references the codes that were violated? If so, can we scan it and email it to this person? Christine On Feb 24, 2014, at 7:59 AM, "Smith -Jerry" < -Je Deco t FL. ov< ailto: Smith- o oeCo ty-F L. Gov>> wrote: We have discussed this, Brian Corocoran and myself met with you for over an hour on these topics, and we have provided you with the requested information. As far as the previous violations, as I have said repeatedly that you have agreed to this stipulation, so whatever was agreed to must be followed. Future projects can be applied for on the basis of the current Codes. Jerome A. Smith, Jr., C.B.O., C.F.M. Jerome A. Smith, Jr., C.B.O., C.F.M. Monroe County Building Official Growth Management, Monroe County Nelson Government & Cultural Center 102050 Overseas Highway Key Largo, FL 33037 Ph.: 05-453- 00 Fax: 305-453- $1 Email: Smih-eir� o deco �t!< auto: i -ertr? o Deco ov> Website: www.monroegjo . ov< :rlw o Deco ty fI. ov From: jon andersen [mailto:154 e 1 ail.co ] Sent: Saturday, February 22, 2014 9:35 AM To: Smith -Jerry Subject: Fwd: 149 ocean shorers Jerry I am still waiting for a response from you on my email sent over a month ago. "I cannot cite the Codes as this is an existing case which has already been adjudicated." If it was adjudicated on actual code violations or other civil statutes it seems that it would be easy to cite the code violation references numbers. The code violations are public record all I am asking from you is confirmation as to the violations for both this case and future projects I might work on. I am confused about the code violations because they do not seem to necessitate a permit: If we are going to address the violations involved in this case accurately (and purchase permits to remedy the infractions) we need the code reference numbers so that I can read them and do my best to comply. " I cannot address the legal issues from your perspective as I am not your counsel, or licensed to practice law." Jerry I am not asking for legal advice or representation. I am only asking what building code violations exist within my home, I am asking for the specific building code reference numbers for both cases. To date every thing is conjecture with non specific verbiage, not one code reference number from the law has been provided. No specific statutes or case law violation cited. We need to get specific for specific repairs or demolitions. When we have specific code violation spelled out including precedents and statutes then I can organize a plan to effect repairs. I think it will be impossible to effect the repairs if the laws violated are not specified. How can you issue a permit to remedy this problem if you dont know what was violated? How do I know you have not made a mistake if that information is not shared with me? Ask your attorneys if it unreasonable for me to read or be informed with the "actual" law that I am being charged with violating? Windsor -Kathleen From: Hurley -Christine Sent: Thursday, April 24, 2014 8:29 AM To: Jon andersen Cc: Cyr -Connie; Gastesi-Roman; Smith -Jerry, Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda; Williams -Steve; Windsor -Kathleen Subject: Re: Emails Mr. Andersen. The fines cannot be stayed. The packet of information I emailed you just prior to the date we had scheduled a meeting with Mr. Gastesi includes the code enforcement case with pictures of how the property was when the violations occurred. You need to obtain after the fact permits and bring the site into compliance. All of the staff have explained this to you. When you get a permit we will do required inspections to see how you've progressed since the violations were discovered. Emailing us is not accomplishing compliance. Thank you, Christine Hurley, AICP Monroe County Growth Management Division Director On Apr 24, 2014, at 8:14 AM, "jon andersen" <154 e l( ail.co > wrote: Jon did not create the schedule the county did. Fines of $500 per day will ensue on the 29th if this matter is not resolved. Can the fines be stayed? I have been writing the county almost daily trying to get resolution. The county has reject many requests to come see the property, see the facts. It is clear that I am working on this problem so the fines should be stayed. Can I get a YES or a NO on the fines being stayed? Then we can set a date that is convenient for all. On Wed, Apr 23, 2014 at 1:25 PM, Cyr -Connie <C -Co ie o oecoun _ ov> wrote: Yes, but Mr. Gastesi &. Christine Hurley have back to back meetings scheduled with the Commissioners and Mr. Andersen had requested to meet with them in person. I'm still trying to see what I can do. Thanks Penny! From: Kipp -Penny Sent: Wednesday, April 23, 2014 1:20 PM To: Cyr -Connie; '1S9pearl ail c ' Subject: Emails Hi Connie, I received two voice messages today from John who emailed you yesterday about the Key Largo Building Department. He wanted to know if you received the emails and had a Windsor -Kathleen -___ From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 1:56 PM To: Jon andersen'; Gastesi-Roman; Hurley -Christine Subject: RE: [BULK] Fwd: Hearing inspection CE07040059 CE08010003 71hat you are seeing on the webpage "egov snapshot" is the scheduled inspection event generated from our data entry program. This was entered because the property will be checked for compliance on 4-29-2014 as per the agreed upon compliance date in the New Buyer Affidavit you signed. Since this issue is a permitting issue, an onsite inspection is not necessary as it appears you did not obtain your After-th Fact permit. I do not recall you asking me to make a personal inspection, but if you want me to, we can make those arrangements Kathleen Windsor, CFM Fema Certified Floodplain Manager Monroe County Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon FL 33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 windsor-kathlec mfl ov Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: jon andersen [[nAftt_o@ _,154pear1 mail.. om _gC_J Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 1:06 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Gastesi-Roman; Hurley -Christine Subject: [BULK] Fwd: Hearing inspection Importance: Low My wife Fran discovered this on the county web page. The county has us listed for physical an inspection on the 29th. No one from the county has called to actually make an appointment with me. My phone is 949 878- 1452. I have been asking for an inspection for months and been told that it will not happen. Can anyone clarify this? ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: jon andersen < Date: Mon, Apr 21, 2014 at 6:22 AM Subject: Fwd: Hearing inspection To: monroe county building Windsor -Kathleen <Windsor-Kathlqen(�7 onroeco t�- ov> My wife sent me the below stating that we are to be inspected in 4/29/14. what does this mean? reinspect for hearing what hearing, where is the hearing held? Windsor -Kathleen From: jon andersen <154pearl@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 201412:57 PM To: Fran Andersen; Windsor -Kathleen; Hurley -Christine; Gastesi-Roman; Senator Dwight Bullard; BOCCDIS5 Subject: Re: [BULK] Fwd: Hearing inspection CE07040059 CE08010003 Importance: Low Regarding 149 Ocean Shores, Key Largo: Jon Andersen Dear Kat: I am so happy you have decided to come see and review the work done to my home 7 years ago, I am not sure if you are aware of my many emails I have sent to Jerry, Christine, even Roman Gastasi, Sylvia Murphy and State Senator Dwight Bullard have been copied over the last two months. The subject matter being: I need an inspection and the nature of the work here does not necessitate a permit (based on my understanding of the law; Bldg code Ch 6 sect 100 when permits are not needed) , Please be familiar with that code section. If there are other pertinent code sections regarding this project I would appreciate your sending me that info in advance. Please do not remind me that I singed the stipulation. Our approval of that document was based on faulty and misleading statements and facts That will be a matter for the courts to decide. I hope we can keep our meeting on track with the physical work that was done and how it applies to the building code and the present condition. If I were doing actual construction instead of writing over the last few months I could have remodeled the entire home in the amount of time I have spent trying to get this inspection. Thank you for agreeing to come see the home. Also, I thank all the others involved. As you know the time frame for the fines is expiring today. So I also want to also Thank -you for having agreed months ago that as long as we are making progress and working on this matter the fines will not be charge. I have little doubt that you will see any problems. I am still in disbelief that it has taken this long to get this meeting, I honestly thought we would be done with this many weeks ago and our dead -line had given us plenty of time. I have the Fair Market Calculations ready for you. If you want to inspect the attic while here, addressing the claims regarding rewiring and re -plumbing the home I recommend a very early morning inspection meeting to keep us out of the stifling heat in the attic. I have a building permit ap. ready in my hands; so we can complete it based on the results of our meeting and submit it the same day. Please come over ASAP. Thank -you again! I ! ! ! Jon (949) 878-1452 (however I dont always get my phone messages, so email is best for me) Inspection Goals: • check yard for flood lights, as they are not here. • check circuit breaker wiring, carport post electrical switch (in county photos) and perimeter of the structure for conduit, wiring or other signs that indicate the yard lights were ever connected to the homes electrical. inspect kitchen walls for signs of fixture relocation. • inspect attic for signs of re -plumbing or rewiring. • inspect the amount of drywall repairs. (1 sheet in the kitchen) • review the re -flooring project (sgft and FMV calcs) • address the need to permit the interior painting If I have missed something on the county's complaint let me know. • I will remove the switch plate covers and and switches from the fixture boxes (for the 3 outlets in question, depicted in the county's evidence photos) so that wiring and installation can be verified as original. On Mon, Apr 28, 2014 at 2:51 PM, jon andersen <154oe l ailoconl> wrote: ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: on andersen <1 e lr i.con > Date: Mon, Apr 28, 2014 at 2:48 PM Subject: Re: [BULK] Fwd: Hearing inspection CE07040059 CE08010003 To: Windsor -Kathleen < indsoath r-leen('a� o oeco OMG I have been asking for an inspection for the last two months. I would highly encourage you to come see the property ASAP. Please Come see the actual work that you are talking about. You see the basic problem is you say go and get an after the fact permit, but for what? painting does not need a permit, the tile floor FMV is less than the minimum established by the building code, all the other items are negligible both in scope of work and FMV. My determination is nothing in this case needed a permit per the building code. Come help me out with this. When can you come over? On Mon, Apr 28, 2014 at 1:55 PM, Windsor -Kathleen < indsor_ athleen(ca7, o oeco ty-fl ov> wrote: at ou are seein on the web �� og Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Thursday, May 01, 2014 4:59 PM To: Jon andersen'; Hurley -Christine; Gastesi-Roman Subject: RE:149 Ocean Shores r. Andersen, I e ailed you at 2:36 Today. I rote: "Mr. Andersen, I have made arrangements to drive to Key Largo on Tuesday May 6, 2014, 1 will be coming from Marathon, so I anticipate that I will arrive at your home between 10 and 11 AM, based on favorable traffic. Will you be available?". Windsor,Kathleen CFM Fema Certified i I i a e Monroeo n a Compliance Research Overseas2798 i Marathon L 33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 _ i r- l ec ®1 v Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law, Most sari .en communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure,. From: ion andersen [mailto,154pearl gmail.cor I Sent: Thursday, May 01, 2014 4:25 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen; Hurley -Christine; Gastesi-Roman Subject: 149 Ocean Shores I was told by Kat that she would arrange to inspect the property. Since that email I have not heard back from her. I dont know what is going on. A simple reply would be courteous. something like • too busy now... get back to you later • I misspoke I will not inspect, • pick a date • out of town anything along these lines would be appropriate. Please let me know what is going on. CE07040059 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KL 5-6-2014 INSP WINDSOR AFTER SHOT OF EXHIBIT CE07040059 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KL 5-6-2014 INSP WINDSOR CE07040059 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KL 5-6-2014 INSP WINDSOR AFTEROF EXHIBIT 3 1 CE07040059 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KL 5-6-2014 INSP WINDSOR AFTER SHOT OF EXHIBIT J Y CC N LLJ 0 Ln Z o W Ln V o Z rn R N a, z Ln � � 0 0 o � w , V N J Y OC cN w w O N w Z w 0 V O Z rn �: � a N Cj Z Ln 414- O cV O �p w , V �n END a mossm BUILDING — FL LAIN — DEVELOP ENTAL PE APPLICATION saeU eer. aooe we so+a one MONROE COUNTY ROWFH MANAGEMENT DIVISION DATEII- L IIt 'd fY Ig um ONLY � .u.l novisim IL (CM) AdWMAdb i moodpiam i 3) .._ �_ 81 R@9wbvdfkwAKLr IN lillpeclas Foos Area Assessaniant ik g.4) Deemed O PARCEL(Plan ): ❑ NO StalafFed Approval Required ftulred LU District 1111.1.11111 District: Flood Zone $ FJevabon: Flood el Tier: J ® Job 149 Ocean Shores Or RE #: W497930-000000 Legal Lot 2 Oom Shores P134-18 LOCIN on �Y.1616M MM 100.0 Description SlocidUnit 3 Infortltation Subdivocean shores ALL OWNER suiLom nuirrAPPEAIR IN PERSON -f .1o3M Oumalt Name Jon Andersen Phone: ( 949 ) Address (mailing) 149 ocean Shorse Dr. s78-9 tate,Zl> ., ._...m._,�. 1452 51%�Wflc" mple eheldoes Phone: - other ( ) than owner), Address, City, . 33P none . AKf. oanaaGon npuufe. bye Ar ConaOuctlan Note: Jon Ande has been Buslrum Name tractorinContlicensed C n # sins eb 2009 elect. & HVAC Emallpea l Phone Contractor Name tiding ompan`y Name, Addren Cnv. state Nam, Addraw City, Type Of Private Provider Service no work in dW dne will be ch Planned: not 13 Plan Review only 13 Inapechlon only ionge In Oew ., — Yee daide Footprint —yen No No ton : Current Proposed — Seer. Current Proposed_ FulVAll of Structure faPardal 0 below) A/L - 4; ATf Use page 5 NEW WORK WORK ATF F BELOW e M L 1 j4 UI IGNO 6 -too D Q IN THE CODE CASE ARE THEP AND NOT ECTED TO THE HOME • A Notice of Commencement must be recorded & posted on the job site before the first inspection, and copy to the Building Dept • Failure to post the Notice of Commencement at the job site will result In the inability of our Inspectors to offer an approved Inspection. • Your failure to record a Notice of Commencement may result in your paying twice for improvements to your property • If you intend to obtain financing, consult with your lender or an attorney before commencing work or recordi ng your Notice a f Commencement ASBESTOS AGREEMENT: (Initial If Applicable: 1 As owner/contractor/agent of record for t he construction applied for in thi s application, I agree that I will comply with the provisions of the Florida Statute 469.003 and to notify the DEP of m y intent to demolish/remove a structure at t he above address and remove asbestos, when applicable, In accordance with state and federal law. SOLID WASTE ASSESSMENT: Upon completion of the project for which I have made application for a Building Permit, I must pay the pro -rated residential solid waste assessment, or show proof of commercial service with a franchised commercial collector prior to issued Certificate of Occupancy. OUTSIDE LOCAL. STATE and FEDERAL AGENCIES: In addition to the req uirements of this permit, there me y be additional restrictions applicable to this pro party that may be found in the public records of this county, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as water management districts, state agencies or federal agencies! OWNER'S AFFIDAVIT: • Application Is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as Indicated. • 1 certify that 4work or installation has commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating construction in this jurisdiction. • 1 understand that a separate permit (sub on a permit) must be secured for Electrical, Plumbing, Signs, A/C, etc. as appropriate. • I hereby certify that all of the foregoing information is accurate and that all work will be done in compliance with all applicable laws regulating construction,snd zoning. Owner (print 9D° V V,r Qualifier (print) Signature: ti--- _ _ Signature:. l _ Date: NO ARY _Signature (as t er) NOTARY Signature as to Qualifier ) Sworn t subs 'bed t re me this Swom to & subscribed to before me this day of 20 he/she is day of 20_, he/she is n kn o me or eis ro ced personally known to me or has produced as as identification and who did (did lion and who did (did not) take an oath. M Commission Expires on IiMOCKLSY Y P flhlbllC . StMs cat fission Expires on icommissim a A wwwwrwwwrwwwww•wwwr • w••ww w) ..Dwwwwwwwwwwwwwwrwwrw:wwwrwrwwwwwwwww•wwwa ATION FEES All fees listed are from the MC Growth Management Building Fee Resolution and upon application approval credited towards fees upon Staff: I RECEIPT #: Building: $ ATF: $ 100% Building Application Penalty Fee (Section M) — NOT Credited Environmental Resources: $ Other Total $ Amount:$ Date: New COM BLG ($1500) New Duplex/Multl ($1600) New Conventional SF ($760) New Modular SF ($500) All Over Counter or Signs ($50) New Replace MH ($160) RES Repair/Remodel <$10K ($50) RES Repair/Remodel >=$10K ($100) COM RepairlRemodel <$1 OK ($50) COM Repair/Remodel >r$10K ($200) Seawall/RlpraplDmdge/FIIUDock or combination of ($80) Clearing/Grubbing ($30) Invasive Exotic (NO FEE) If determined by BIO review It is not Invasive exotic related, the applicant must apply for appropriate permit type with applicable fees. Private Provider (Administration Fee Non- Refundable/NonCredltable $125) HAZARD (NO FEE) If determined by BIO review It Is not HAZARD related, the applicant must apply for appropriate permit type with applicable fees. Write In: WASAIdIngIBLDG DEPT FORM5IFINAL PDFIFINAL WORDIDRAFTSIBUILDING APPLICATION va.docx— Updated 7/172013 Page 2 4j I Co IS t' • t VE Same Flood Et on: UZZQ�� •°••�• °� oY '7 VA One Mod EkNathm: member of beftm Beer XE Not Improvements t0 and Pr+Wrl E on VE Flood En: ExMdn on of 20 Lowed AUPPOft A F Elevation: AE'8 of hafto-, floor X Met Certification 1 y 1 n in to on nbelow lowest u minimum !n ! I hereby certft the i pro 1 on proposing% of the market V (steff retalne to right to evaluate Ode Improvement). Ltlw�� 1 w. ooDear FOWAMFMft PWfKM WMMDMFr&MLUM &MMT=vje*=—VpdWmdSMCMIa Pap 3 ounowrown se" � es" BUILDING - FLOODPLAIN - DEVELOPMENTAL PUICATION away w.AMRW COUNW GRDVHH MAKAGEMEff DrAMON EAWA Cbmk II that applIft lic amount of [=,T dwdwnpwmkvpw WABOW08=1DEPT AW.JrATWIuUm-L"Wermrm a Pap 4 CU�WCWW WMM a a r `�r 3 BUILDING — FLOODPLAIN — DEVELOPMENTAL PERmrr APPLICATION MONROE COUNTY GROWN MANAGEMENT DNWN Bufding Department Fees are One Hundred Penaent (1 ) n C F u Resolution, M. In addition, the following II . Code Compliance _ Information n l Information (Required for All ATF Applications) (Required M FILL or CLEARING ApplicationOnly) rOrAL = Pr Mir 3 The following information is required at the time of submittal of an After -The -Fad (ATF) building permit application: ❑ Completed Application: Pages 1— 3, Page 3, and Page 4 if applicable ❑ Detailed scope of work below ❑ Sealed "As -Built' plans designed to the current building code and wind speed, as well as other required documents based on the project. ❑ Survey or site plan (if applicable) ❑ Copy of Notice of Violation with Code Compliance case number (if applicable) ❑ Acceptable proof of ownership, if current owner is not detailed on the Property Record Card. ❑ Elevation Certificate (if applicable) oar rn ua4 AMWATM w, - snW=3 Poe 5 Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Thursday, May 15, 201411:39 AM To: Jon andersen' Cc: frannabananna@gmail.com; Hurley -Christine; Williams -Steve; Norman -Ronda; Smith - Jerry, Petrick -Nicole; Granger -Lisa Subject: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Attachments: EXTENSION TO NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059.pdf ' Il o Andersen, Today I have reviewed the permit application and, as promised, inserted the photos I took last week. In the email below you wrote: As you know the time frame for the fines is expiring today. So I also want to also Thank -you for having agreed months ago that as long as we are making progress and working on this matter the fines will not be charge. achievedYou are correct that the compliance date has passed and the daily fine is now accruing. However, now that the County has received a permit application, thereby achieving "progress", I am able to offer an extension of the compliance date. Since compliance will not be permit hasreceived its required inspections and is closed, inserted the date ♦ August 6, 2014 to achieve compliance. 'lease note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most wriften communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: jon andersen [mailto:154pearl@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 12:57 PM To: Fran Andersen; Windsor -Kathleen; Hurley -Christine; Gastesi-Roman; Senator Dwight Bullard; BOCCDIS5 Subject: Re: [BULK] Fwd: Hearing inspection CE07040059 CE08010003 Importance: Low Regarding 149 Ocean Shores, Key Largo: Jon Andersen Dear Kat: I am so happy you have decided to come see and review the work done to my home 7 years ago, MONROE COUNTY CODE COMPLIANCE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE Monroe County Code Compliance Petitioner vs Jon S. Andersen and Frances E. Andersen Respondent(s) In the matter of: Re#:00497930000000 Case: CE07040059 STIPULATION FOR AN EXTENSION OF TIME TO COMPLY Jon S. Andersen. and Frances E. Andersen (hereinafter referred to jointly and severally as "Respondent(s)") and Monroe County Code Enforcement ("Petitioner"), by and through the undersigned individuals, hereby agree and stipulate to the following: 1. Respondent(s) agrees I/we received and signed the Agreement and Affidavit of New Purchaser to Stay Fines and Enlarge Compliance Date on October 29, 2013. Under the Agreement we agreed to a compliance date of April 29, 2014. I/We are not going to be in compliance by that date. 2.. Respondent(s) agrees that the violation(s) still exist in the above mentioned complaint as alleged in the Agreement and Affidavit of New Purchaser to Stay Fines and Enlarge Compliance.. (a) The parties are now agreeing to extend the compliance date. (b) The Respondent(s) waives the right to appeal any finding of violation or order that would otherwise be available under Section 162.11, Florida Statutes. 3. The property will be checked for compliance on August 6, 2014, (New compliance date). CVTFAiQVIU T(1 URW W TVFR AFFinAVIT ROWFRS CF07040059, doe 4. The parties understand that a fine of $150.00 per day shall accrue daily if the property is not brought into compliance within the time specified in paragraph 3. 5. The Respondent(s) understands that if the Respondents(s) fails to comply within the time given, the fine(s) shall accrue each day the violation(s) remain as follows: 110-140(1) 150.00 per day 6. The Respondent(s) agree to pay all costs incurred in prosecuting the case within 30 days of compliance and that such costs may be imposed as a lien under Section 162.O9(2)(d), Florida Statutes, and Monroe County Code section 8-29(b). 7. Respondent(s) specifically agree that this- Stipulation Agreement shall be recorded in the public records of the County and shag constitute notice to subsequent purchasers, successors in interests, or assigns that the violations of Monroe County Code 110- 140(1) exist. This Stipulation Agreement shall be recorded as a lien against the subject property and upon any other real or personal property owned by the Respondent(s) if the property is not brought into compliance by the date specified in paragraph 3. 8. Respondent(s) agrees and represents that Respondent(s) entered into this Stipulation Agreement of the Respondent(s)'s own free will. Respondent(s) further understands and agrees that he/she has the right to consult with counsel prior to signing this Stipulation Agreement, and has done so or has elected to waive this right. 9. The parties understand and agree that the Respondent(s) may revoke this Stipulation Agreement and that such revocation must be done in writing or done in person with Kathleen Windsor by the end of business May 21, 2014. 1) FXTFNc1(1N T!1 NFW RI IVFR AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059.doc By signing this Stipulation, both parties represent that they have READ, UNDERSTOOD, AND CONSENT to its terms and conditions. Signature of Respondent(s) / Date Print Name STATE OF _ COUNTY OF PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20 NOTARY PUBLIC Signature of Petitioner (County) / Date STATE OF COUNTY OF PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20_ NOTARY PUBLIC Signature of Respondent(s) / Date Print Dame STATE OF _ COUNTY OF PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, who, after first being sworn by me, affixed his/her signature (name of individual signing) in the space provided above on this day of 20_ NOTARY PUBLIC 3 EXTENSION TO NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059.doc Windsor -Kathleen .......___.___ From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2014 9:45 AM To: Jon andersen'; frannabananna@gmail.com Cc: Williams -Steve; Hurley -Christine; Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda; Smith -Jerry Subject: RE: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Attachments: EXTENSION TO NEW BUYER AFFIDAVIT BOWERS CE07040059.pdf Fran does not need to sign the document since she is out of the Country. The County will accept it with your notarized signature alone, however 1 need the document by the end of business tomorrow, May 21, 2014 to grant the extension. I have attached it again for your convenience. The permit is being reviewed by each of the disciplines as per our normal process and you will be notified by the building department when it is ready to be issued. Thank you. Windsor,Kathleen CFM Fema Certified o t i r Monroe County Sr. Code ComplianceResearch I Overseas2798 I a Marathon33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon regaaest. Year e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: ion andersen [mailto:154pearl@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 6:29 PM To: Windsor -Kathleen Subject: Re: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 I am away out of town. Fran is still in england. I dont have a printer or notary now. You could see that the work the county claimed was substantial was actually minimal and below the building code treasholds. It poses no safety or other hazard. I have been working on this for months my many emails are proof. My goal was to get a county inspection. You came to inspect but informed me you are not qualified to inspect and you knew the circumstances before leaving your office. The county has not issued a permit either an unusually long period for the miner work involved that normally is excluded from the permit process. So now what? I am waiting on the county again.. On May 15, 2014 11:39 AM, "Windsor -Kathleen" < in sor® at leen(e7 onroecounty- . gy> wrote: Windsor -Kathleen From: Fran <frannabananna@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 201410:35 AM To: Windsor -Kathleen Cc: jon andersen; Williams -Steve; Hurley -Christine; Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda; Smith - Jerry Subject: Re: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Kathleen, How can you force us to sign something which has not been explained? #2 in this document states that Of we agree the violations still exist". What are the violations exactly? We have NEVER been told what they are specifically. How can you force either of us to sign something that is so vague? Its unconstitutional. Almost like blackmail. Telling us "You must siign this vague agreement that legally binds you but the county refuses to explain anything that needs to be done or how' to remedy the situation" is unacceptable co-ersion by a government body on a citizen who is trying to co-operate. How is it legal for the county to do this? We have co-operated fully with the county and there are no grounds for you to fine us. The first agreement sated that we needed to pull and pay for a permit (which we have done but we don't know what it's for and neither does the permit desk) and to show good faith in taking care of the purported problems. We have done that. We have cleared one case 2010-12-21 14:47:41 COMPANION CASE IS CE07040059 entirely and are in process to close the other if you would just tell us what exactly we need to do to complete this task. From the notes below you acknowledge that we have co-operated fully and are in compliance so how can you threaten to fine us for non co-operation? You even state NO DAILY FINES. CODE ENFORCEMENT Case Number CE0801000 Case Date a 01-02®2005 Origination Operator PROPERTY ON CASE RE 100497930000000 Property Address 149 ( City/State/Zip KEG' CASE DESCRIPTION INSUFFICIENT FLOOD VENTS PER D BAIR 10/22/2010-REASSIGNED TO BC. IL Tenant Add Info Status Officer Owner Owner Address City/State/Zip Phone am f•�I.1iItTt71�! irT?1 VIOLATION CODE(S) l: 122-4. )(I)D — PE IT CONDITIONS/FLOOD HAZ _ .__ ?: 9.5-317(B)(1)(D) — FEMA STANDARDS Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2014 4:37 PM To: 'Fran'; jon andersen Cc: Williams -Steve; Hurley -Christine; Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda; Smith -Jerry Subject: RE: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Mr. and Mrs. Andersen I am somewhat surprised to hear this response given that the County has agreed to extend the compliance date, This ,-;Xtension would have stayed the fines for 3 months to give you time to achieve compliance. You are not being forced to sign the extension. Daily fines began accruing on April 30, 2014, Please rote: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication atio: may be subject to public disclosure. From: Fran [mailto:frannabananna@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2014 10:35 AM ta To: Windsor -Kathleen Cc: jon andersen; Williams -Steve; Hurley -Christine; Granger -Lisa; Norman -Ronda; Smith -Jerry Subject: Re: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Kathleen, How can you force us to sign something which has not been explained? #2 in this document states that It we agree the violations still exist". What are the violations exactly? We have NEVER been told what they are specifically. How can you force either of us to sign something that is so vague? Its unconstitutional. Almost like blackmail. Telling us "You must siign this vague agreement that legally binds you but the county refuses to explain anything that needs to be done or how' to remedy the situation" is unacceptable co-ersion by a government body on a citizen who is trying to co-operate. How is it legal for the county to do this? We have co-operated fully with the county and there are no grounds for you to fine us. The first agreement sated that we needed to pull and pay for a permit (which we have done but we don't know what it's for and neither does the permit desk) and to show good faith in taking care of the purported problems. We have done that. We have cleared one case 20➢0-12-21 14AT41 COMPANION CIS CE07040059 entirelw., and a...,,w_.a...a......� .a.. ----,an-.a..-.a..-�w..-.a..-.a..- .a...a.. ,ti...a,.,a� y are in process to close the other if you would just tell us what exactly we need to do to complete this task. MONROE COUNTY FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. Responderd(s� BEF E COUNTY CODE COMPLIANCE SPECIAL IRATE MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA Case No. CEO 470 Subject Property Real Estam Number. FINAL ORDER FLIed & Recorded 6inZ0 ficdal Records of MONROE COUNTY AMY HEAVILIN Having fully consWa s the evidence presented at haring, Including testimony of the Code Compliance Inspecto(s) and/or witnesses under with, the following Findings of Fact and Conclusions of law are ORDERED: The Res ndent(s and/or Autihorized raentative SIGNED AN AGREEMENT & AFFIDAVIT OF NEW PURCHASER TO STAY FINES AND NLAGE COMPL m n preserd and did not contest the violauon(s) ad irth in the Notice of Vkilstoe of Hearing which Is 000rpomle d herein as O fully at forth. ( The ReWmWenf(s) Mere the owner(s) of property located within Monroe County and washwere duly noticed of the haring. ( The Respondent(s) Were in vi kbn of the Monroe County Codes) as fully set forth In the Notice of VldadonlNollm of Hearing served upon the Respondent(s). ( ) The volaton(s) Is found to be Inoperable or irreversible and a orm4lme fine of S Is ORDERED, payable within days of this Order. (vf Pursuant In Section 162.07(2) of Florida Staines all costs h=rred by the County In prosecuting the case Is ordered to be paid within thirty (30) days of compliance. Costs will continue to accrue neM compliance is achieved and the case is dosed. ( The Respondent(s) shall comply with the Code(s) referred to In the Notice of VolatonMotice of Haring on or before _ E COMPLIANCE DATE-). ( In the event the vobltion(s) were or are not corecded on THE COMPLIANCE DATE PREVIOUSLY ORDERED or on THE COMPLIANCE DATE SET FORTH HEREON, fine(s) In the ddlararnrohmtot $ 1 _ for each day beginning on THE DAY AFTER THE COMPLIANCE DATE that the Respondent(s) Ware in violation Were hereby ORDERED (i t Is After ordered, that the Canty is hereby authorized to rake all reasonable repairs Including demolition which are required to bring the property Into complance and charge the Respondent(s) with the cost of repair incurred by the County, the cats of prosecution incurred by the County and any fines Ordered in this matter. ( ) The Respondant(s) were In violation of the MONROE COUNTY Codes) as fully set forth In the Notice of ViolaOonlNuffm of Haring tiled in this me and did not come into compliance on or before THE COMPLIANCE DATE but are now In compliance. The Respondent(s) shall pay the Intel amount of cost and/or Nina Ito Mooco County Code Compliance within thirty (30) days of this Order. (W")AGREEMENT IS ATTACHED HERETO AND INCORPORATED HEREIN. r DATED trio _ __day of Do 1982218 . Van Laningham, Spedal Magistrate Bkp 2685 P9p 1767 Page 1 of 2 DoeN 1982218 FINAL ORDER PAGE 2 Bkp 2685 Pgp 1768 CASE NUMBER: CE07040059 Respondent(s) mailing address of record with the Monroe County Property Appraiser's Office: ANDERSEN FRANCES E & JON S ANDERSEN 163 CORERINE PLACE KEY LARGO, FL 33037 Location of Subject Property: 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE KEY LARGO, FL 33037 RE NUMBER: 00497930000000 CERTIFICATE OF ORDER I hereby certify that this is a true and correct copy of the above Order. 1--Z� 14A,1� Nicole M. Petrick, Liaison CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of this Order has been fiunished to the Respondent(s) via hand delivery / ff1st class _U.S. mail to Respondent(s) address of record with the Monroe County Property Appraiser's Office as referenced above and/or Authorized Representative on this , day of - . - ,20 Nicole M. Petrick, Liaison PAGE 2 of 2 A Door 1982218 monrce County Code c=qAmvo BkN 2665 Pap 1769 Jon Andersen (6) NAM arid Address in -C1 amrad above and Mmv= Owity Code Compilenca l H mowel. hereby dachas u path On �'�'�7 1) the r8) are the Of the FWWV !I kW= = 149 OCEAN SHORES , KEY LARGO, L40NROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, 2) a) Bduxmbdgs that the d) of the Monroe Cou nty Code(a) ouftsd below and In to prior Nodes of Violetiongwaft d &) chwqqd in this MOW we accunds and supImfled by wAdgndmI 3) the ems) wxWsWW and agree to wW" the OW to contest the blowing violations• 110-140(1) - BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED par"s), s) and wpacon($) are required for bmdw M ( hiftletlon of new dia, Writing electric plumbing ander�r fdFV%�� kmbdMDn ll" Of ( 13) ground wet P'WW WM A0 BM0NM tEW BUM AfFiDAWr WWMS AMCEOI 10M ftm DOGN 1982218 8kN U85 PON 1770 Corrective Action Required: Contact the Building and Pknr ft Depwkwnt and obtain an Marta fact permit or rwwva as dR dm& NOTE: AH pomdt fees and perms nequinennanis are based on this specitio map of work. Additional permits, psrmk bees. mitigation fbm or restudon of th pmporly to original condition may be required. The mk*mxn flee for an After The Fact is .00 O hundred dopers) as par Monroe County Code regains PASSING flral8ectian �(aK1). m Pem�Will irrepection(s). 122-4.(bXi)d - PERMIT CONDITIONSFLOOD HAZARD As per the tee Pad to you Garr the 7, 2006 your des enclosure Is In violation of kdomft items: 1. The enclosure has insulrcient food wants Corrective Acton Requked: Contact the Floodplain Managenwd OM= for Irdb ation to � the enure Into If you have already by AAOrrice of the � d stated In fhe letter. Iterns being stm s under the e structure not as k ited must be nerrroved. WUm pennk ap mwk kmpnfto and/or tirml inspeciiorns may also be _ _ _ (305p 2M. 4) The rd(s) WKIWOWW and admwbdge that the tunas will be - the dabs the tea) are entitled to PONBBWOn of tine _PmpwV until the raw cornplance, date specilled in paragraph 5. 5) The wqx4y will be deecked for complano on ,g (New compNance date). 0) The parties understand flat a firm off per day shell accrue daily K the Is not brought into complienoe wWn the *M specilled In paregraph & 7) The RegwW rt(s) understands that 0 ft Reopmxiiants(s) taps to Comply mlhln the time given. the, tsre(s) WW _ - each day the ' s) mnmin as 1 04 1) IN= par day 122-4(b)(Ild 160.00 per day 8) The Respond"vmtA the 09Mto i any jtl! n vMnbm or order Ow he or she would oftwise ham under SmAion 162.11. Florida 9) The R ent(s)89rim 1D PRY to #1e all oasts incurred (aftr dab of possession) to prosecuting their cam wfthin 30 days of conqAkrm WW that saich web may be imposed as a Nan urmW Sedon 162.09(2)(d), Florida Sbkbs, and Monme County section 8.29(b). 10) The Respondents) specMmly agreas that this Agreement may be recorded in the pulft records of the County and p recorded shen oonsfnute notice to sut:sgquent pwuhmorg, N N osuccessors in interests, or assigns that the violation(s) of Mmuce County Code as stebed •ow N in paragraph 3 exist. This Agreement shall be recorded as a Den against the property h om and upon any other reel or personal pmporly awned by On Respondenga Igo properly Is not brought into complimoe by the date speciftd In pwqrq3h S. 11) Respondent(a) agrees and represents that Respondents)enteiad into this Agrearrmt of the sps own free wiff. Respandent(a) further under+ahmds end agrees VW he/she has the right to consult with counsel prior to Woning this Stipulation. and has done so or has elected to walm this right. �t d.— 9 uo i U,) -m ruts j C eWsW &f oyc " NEw RuMAOUmmommm Bum nFFmAvrr eowm - awn cmm does 3 �� -T—f Lci- Pn err LPL JVOV 1 � ! . .op 2882228 BkN 2683 P1 1772 MAMINUMB My Comm ExOrn Jed 20,1011 Comm+Ssew O FF 40705 zo 011M join [new P=Wed FUNMANDeW . Notary Public - 810 M FIM My Comm. Ewm Jot 20. my COM MSelen O ff 40YOS Notary Public -Stale of Florida . •_ My Comm. Expires Dec 12, 2013 Commission O DD 917995 Bonded Through 0 nal Notary Assn. MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS Windsor -Kathleen From: Fran <frannabananna@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, May 22, 2014 6:14 AM To: Windsor -Kathleen Cc: Rigby-Brenedy, Smith -Jerry, Norman -Ronda; Williams -Steve; Corcoran -Brian; jon andersen Subject: Re: 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 The problem is that we NEVER saw INSIDE the house before we bought it. This was a foesclosure sale. There was a hostile squatter inside that denied us access. You knew that at the time we were forced to sign your first agreement. We signed the first agreement under duress because we would lose our $50,000 deposit to the Auction Company if we didn't compkete the purchase - even though we had to acknowledge " violations" that we were ignorant of at the time of signing, there was no way for us to know what was done by the former owner/ tenant. We finally evicted the squatter a month later and finally gained entry to the proerty. There was no evidence of work being done at that time. How were we to know what they did / did not do ? If you don't know how can we be expected to sign again that we acknowledge the violations when we don't know what tney are? Can you re- word that statement to say We agree to work with the county on correcting the ( so far) unidentified code violations that are suspected to exist? And please agree to stay the fines as we are co-operating with you to correct whatever it is that is eventually determined to be wrong. Fran Andersen 949-278-9294 On 15 Jan 2014, at 08:51 PM, Windsor -Kathleen < indsor- atleen(€}, o oecount -. ov> wrote: T � # Windsor -Kathleen From: jon andersen <154pearl@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 04, 201412:25 PM To: Fran; Windsor -Kathleen; Gastesi-Roman Subject: Re: Andersen 140 Ocean Shores Drive KL CE07040059 CE08010003 Kat Windsor: What is going on, are you charging us fines even though the delays in achieving the inspection to prove the house is and has been in compliance have been due to the county inability to send a qualified inspector ? (I have been requesting an inspection for months now) What can I do while the county is taking their time analyzing my permit ap? It has been over 30 days on our ap (while my roofer friend says he can get a re -roof permit in 3 days) Does it make sense to take so long on a inspect only permit ap? Why would my ap take so long? You are familiar with this case can you help get this permit issued so we can finally have an inspection? Also the building department has excluded the flood lights from the permit on the county web site, since discovering this. I have sent emails and asked that the lights be included in the inspection but no one has responded. There is no sense in inspecting if the flood light are excluded from the permit as this is the apex problem. Will you attest that the lights are not here to them? You still have not sent me the photos you took. Are you going to send them? Kat my wife made me promise that I would come to your office and see you personally about this .... when can we meet? Mr. Gastesi when can we meet to discuss this matter? I would like you to come and personally see what is going on here, I promise you can get in and out in about 15 minutes. Next time you get some fish at the Key Largo Fisheries or if you come by the Pilot House you are only a couple of minutes from my place please come by and take a look personally. I am desperately trying to get the home inspected and for some reason can not get this simple task accomplished. On Wed, Jun 4, 2014 at 8:46 AM, jon andersen <14 e 1 cr rnail.co > wrote: not yet I will this week I need to find out when when she is her office. On Mon, Jun 2, 2014 at 2:53 PM, Fran <r a a ,g ail.co > wrote: Did you go in and talk to her face to face like you promised? I really think it would solve more problems than emailing. People just ignore what they don't want to address in emails. Pleeeeeeeeaaaaaase go in and talk it out.... Fran Andersen From: Goetzman'[hrisdna Sent: Thursday, July I7, 20146:27 PM To: '154pead@gnmaiicom' Cc: Gastes-Roman;Hudev-Christine;VWUiams-Steve Granger -Lisa; Travers -John; Norman- Ronda;VVindsor-Kath|een;K4a|donado-K8aha; MoGi|vra-Lisa; Williams-Alison;Parker- Eric; MCT_CSR2; MCT_CSR1 Subject: PERMIT #143O214](ANDERSEN-149OCEAN SHORES DR, KEY LARGO) Please, be advised that I have consulted with Building Official John Travers, who has informed me that the work ju 305-289-2526. Senior Coordinator Murray Nelson Building 102050 Overseas Highway Key Largo, FL 33037 From: McGilvra'Lhay Sent: Thursday, July 1J,3O141:C7 PM To: Jon andepsem' Cc:Goetzmnan-Chhstina Subject: RE: pemnit143O3143 I am sorry to hear that you are having problems with this permit. While I am a customer service representative, I do not have the authority to waive fees, permit requirements, sub -contractors authorizations, etc., therefore I have forwarded your email and concerns to my supervisor, Christina Goetzman. Ms. Goetzman has assured me that she is looking into the matter and you will be hearing from her shortly. Lisa R. McGilvra NelsonMurray 102050 From: jon andersen [ ailto:peari ii.co__j Sent: Thursday, July 17, 2014 12:46 PM To: McGilvra-Lisa; Fran Andersen Subject: permit 14302143 I am Jon Andersen and I live at 149 Ocean Shores Key Largo. I have been trying to resolve this building permit problem since buying the home. Recently I was referred to you and I have left several messages at your phone number 305 453-8802. 1 was told you are customer service and that you can help me on this matter. I have been sending emails for several months to others with the county. We purchased a home that had a code case against it from over 7 years ago. Some work was performed by an illegal squatter tenant while the house was in foreclosure. We purchased the house a few months ago and have been trapped in a bureaucratic mess since taking possession of the property. We finally are getting the facts from the county I have found that this entire claim that the county has made is in error and no one from the county has verified their claims for over 7 years, the entire case built on bad assumptions. According to the building code requirements the work the county is concerned about does not need a permit. Because; there was no one to explain this to the county (absentee owner abandoned the property and a squatter tenant taking advantage of the confusion) this has slipped through the cracks. We were misled by the county when we purchased and coerced to sign some documents base on the mistruths reported to us by county employees and now that I have been able to inspect the property I can see the errors. I have been trying to get through the red tape, but I keep hitting road blocks. I have requested inspections by code enforcement and they have failed; sending unqualified inspectors, they actually disqualified themselves after driving all the way from Marathon. They directed us to contact you. Now I am following their direction and have submitted a permit for the sole purpose of getting someone on site to see what work has actually been attempted. I just want someone to come and witness what has taken place. Now it appears we are being charged an additional $1300 for a permit and in you are asking for electrical and plumbing professionals to be involved. This is not fair to charge me for a permit based on conjecture, I am telling you what has been done but the county continues to charge me for fictitious work. There should be no charges yet, just come witness the fact that no electrical, plumbing or drywall work has been done to this home. The tile and painting issues are well below the minimums set by the building code requiring a permit. No other work has been done. I can prove it if someone would just come and look. Please help on this matter. I keep getting the run around and more charges and more demands from the building department I have no idea of how to deal with this new requirement about electrician and a plumber as no work has been done requiring these trades. 1 don't even understand what you are asking for now. Please help Jon 949 878-1452 Windsor -Kathleen From: Hurley -Christine Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2014 2:57 PM To: Jon andersen'; Gastesi-Roman Cc: Goetzman-Christina; Williams -Steve; Travers -John; Norman -Ronda; Windsor -Kathleen; Granger -Lisa Subject: RE: PERMIT 14302143 Attachments: CE07040059 evidence photos.pdfi CE07040059 photos 5-6-2014.pdf done. Therefore, Thank you, Monroe County From: jon andersen [mailt 154pearl mail.comj Sent: Wednesday, July 16, 2014 8:07 PM To: MCT CSR1; Smith -Jerry; Gastesi-Roman Subject: Re: PERMIT 14302143 There is no electrical or plumbing work being done and nothing has been done in the past, why are you asking for a sub letter. These assumptions that this work was done is an error made by the county. Come and see!! There is no work that needs a permit on this application. I have been asking that a county representative come and see what I am talking about. I am being forced to get this permit because the county has made a mistake. How do you justify the costs with this application if all the work on the application is legal without a permit, per the building code? Can you provide the accounting and justification for the price? If you have integrity you would help me with this matter. I have been asking for assistance for months and not one person in the county will address any of the issues I have raised regarding this abuse of power by Monroe County. On Tue, Jul 8, 2014 at 9:31 AM, MCT CSRI <MCT C 1 a o oeco ov> wrote: Key Largo: - / Marathon: - - / Stock Island: 305-295-3990 PERMIT # 14302143 PERMIT INFORMATION PLEASE NOTE: FEES LISTED ARE ESTIMATES ONLY. BEFORE WRITING ANY CHECKS, PLEASE CALL THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO CONFIRM. Permit Number 14302143 RE 00497930000000 Permit Type 77 Balance Due $0.00 Property Address 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE Status Closed Permit I Plan Reviews I Inspections I Fees I Contractors I All ALL PERMIT INFORMATION Application Date Issued Date Master Number C.O. Number C.O. Issued C-404 Type Applied Value Calculated Value 05-06-2014 Operator Operator Project Number Operator Usage Class Units Contractor ID MTCCSR2 07-25-2014 parkere RES 806 0 0 OWNER PROPERTY ON PERMIT RE 00497930000000 Unit Address 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE City/State/Zip KEY LARGO, FL 33037 OWNER ON PERMIT Name ANDERSEN FRANCES E Ft JON S ANDERSEN Address 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE City/State/Zip KEY LARGO, FL 33037 Type Private (APPLICANT No Applicant Information on file for this permit MISCELLANEOUS INFORMATION / NOTES 149 OCEAN SHORES DR -OCEAN SHORES AFTER -THE -FACT REMODEL/REPAIR INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR_ NOTICE OF COMMECEMENT REQUIRED #f NfNNNNNNN#NNNNNN#MNNNNN#NN httn•/Iegovmnnrnecoranty-fl,envle(;ovPluc/nermit/nermit all.asnx?nermit no=14302143 4/28/2015 Permit Information - Permit 14302143 Page 2 of 4 PERMIT APPROVAL FOR WORK COMMENCING PRIOR TO PERMIT ISSUANCE INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR REMODEUREPAIR AS PER APPROVED PLANS. WORK TO INCLUDE:SEE CODE COMPLIANCE APPROVAL. ELECTRICAL — .--.--- ._w ., PERMIT APPROVAL TO COMPLY WITH CODE CASE CE07040059. TO -WIT: PERMIT(S), APPROVAL(S) AND INSPECTION(S) _ - ...._. ARE REQUIRED FOR INTERIOR RENOVATIONS (INSTALLATION OF NEW TILE, PAINTING, ELECTRIC PLUMBING AND DRYWALL) AND INSTALLATION OF (APPROXIMATELY 13) GROUND LEVEL EXTERIOR FLOOD PERMIT. NO OTHER WORK THIS PERMIT DEEMED NON -DEVELOPMENT. DEO EXEMPT. http://pegov.monroecounty-fl.aov/eGovPluslnermit/t)ennit all.asnx?nermit nn-14307141 a/)R/ln1S Permit Information - Permit 14302143 Page 3 of 4 PLAN REVIEWS Details Revision Stop Number Status Status Date Reviewer Notes BIOLOGIST 1 N 05-22-2014 MTCENVII 3 CODE COMPLIANCE MARATHON 1 _ _ _ P 05-15-2014 _..... WINDSORK .._.._ 11 --.1 ....._....v.® _ ELECTRICAL 1 P 06-02-2014 KASPRZAA 0 BUILDING STRUCTURAL/ROOF 1 P 05-29-2014 MTCSTRUC 0 FINAL REVIEW m .._..... _..... �.. 2 �... . ..._...� A ...____a . 06-18-2014 MCGILVRL ,. , ..... 0 _.. .,....___,..... _ FINAL REVIEW 1 L 06-03-2014 WILLIAMA 0 FLOOD PLAIN MANAGEMENT 1 N 05-16-2014 WINGATEM 2 MARATHON BUILDING DEPT 1 L 05-08-2014 BENDERD 1 MECHANICAL 1 N 0 __ �_...._. BUILDING OFFICIAL �._.. ...__.._ 1 . _........................._..._.....__.. A 07-08-2014 _ ...._. MTCCSRI _ _ 1 PLANNING 1 A 05-19-2014 BAUMANB 7 PLUMBING 1 P TUGWELLP 0 PERMIT READY TO ISSUE 1 L 07-08-2014 MTCCSRI 6........... UPPER KEYS BUILDING DEPT 2 L 05-19-2014 MALDONAM 0 UPPER KEYS BUILDING DEPT 1 L 05-07-2014 MTCCSR2 2 FEES FEE ID UNITS QUANTITY FEE AMOUNT PAID TO DATE ATE -BAPP FLAT RATE 1.00 50.00 50.00 ATE- BLD FLAT RATE 1.00 150.00 .....- 150.00 ,.. ATF -ELEC _..,_ _..........._....m,_.___ .. FLAT RATE w . _.... _......._._.... ._..___.-......_®v..... 1.00 m..__... _ _.. 100.00 . �.,....®.w_ _..._ 100.00 - _.. .. ATE - PLMB ........._ ®..` FLAT RATE 1.00 65.00 65.00 ATF-CE FLAT RATE 1.00 500.00 500.00 B- B PLAN EACH REVIE. . ....... _.. _ _._ . B- 0 EDUC FLAT RATE ...... m...__._._ . 1.00 m �... _ 2.00 _ _._.._....._.._.._.. 2.00 _ _ _0.00 B-1C APPL __._ FLAT RATE ___ 1.00 50.00 5 B- 4C STRU FLAT RATE 1.00 50.00 50.00 B- 7 FLATW SQUARE FOOTAGE 135.00 50.00 _,.�. ,.a.�..._ .. _ _. 50.00 ..., .._ u._.._ _.. CONT-INVES _.__.._ __.. _._. FLAT RATE __ 1.00 11.00 11.00 DBPR UNITS 680.00 9.18 9.18 DBPR RE ED UNITS 680.00 _ 1.02 _ _ u 1.02 � v..,. ._.0 DCA UNITS _..�...._ .._.. _.._.. 680.00 9.18 9.18 DCA RE ED UNITS 680.00 1.02 1.02 E- 0 EDUC FLAT RATE 1.00 2.00 2.00 E- 1 MIN -_._ _. .... UNITS . _ _ _ 1.00 _ _ u. . _ ...0 . 50.00 _._ _..... _._..._ 50.00 r . ..._ _. _ . .... w. _. _ � _ __ E- E PLAN EACH REVIEW -� 1.00 50.00 50.00 e . LDR 1P SFR _ _._ _ ..... ,. .. FLAT RATE --._ �_ . 1.00 .._..... ... ..._...... - 75.00 _ 75.00 P- P PLAN EACH REVIEW 1.00 50.00 50.00 P- 0 EDUC FLAT RATE 1.00 2.00 2.00 P- 2 FIXTU UNITS 1.00 15.00 15.00 PLAN ED FLAT RATE 1.00 10.00 10.00 T-2 FLAT RATE __ �- 1.00 20.00 20.00 TOTAL FEES: $1,322.40 TOTAL PAID TO DATE: $1,322.40 PENDING PAYMENT: $0.00 BALANCE: 1 $0.00 CONTRACTORS GENERAL CONTRACTOR Owner / Contractor ANDERSEN FRANCES E It JON S ANDERSEN Address 149 OCEAN SHORES DRIVE City/State/Zip KEY LARGO, FL 33037 SUBCONTRACTORS / PROFESSIONALS CATEGORY ID COMPANY/DBA OWNER/QUALIFIER EC 12830 BROWN'S QUALITY ELECTRIC INC BROWN, JAMES KEVIN httD://eeov.monroecounty-fl.eov/eGovPlus/Dennit/Dermit all.ashx?hermit no-14302143 4/28/2015 Permit Information - Permit 14302143 1 PC 12002 Page 4 of 4 ACTION MAINTENANCE LLC VELTRI, FRANK INSPECTIONS TYPE NUM INSPECTOR SCHED DATE INSP DATE FINAL BUILDING 1 AK 08-13-2014 ___......___ 08-13-2014 _ FINAL ELECTRIC 1w- AK — 08-1..__.. 3 2014 08-13 2014 FINAL PLUMBING 1 AK 08-13-2014 08-13-2014 INSP TIME RES CONFIRM NOTES P 20144527 0 P 20144528 0 _ ..- ....__._.. ...........— P 20144529 0 Your privacy is important to us, for more information see our privacy policy. Copyright ® 2007 - THE PLUS SERIES ® - All Rights Reserved httn•llepnv monrneenunt.v-fl,eovleGovP]us/nermitJDermit a11.asDx?permit no 14302143 4/28/2015 County of Monroe Growth Management Division Building Department Murray Nelson Building 102050 Overseas Highway Key Largo, FL 33037 Phone: (305)453-8800 Fax: (305)453-8818 We strive to be caring, professional, and fair. Mr. Jon Andersen 149 Ocean Shores Drive Key Largo, Florida 33037 Re: Case CE07040059 Dear Mr. Andersen, Board of County Commissioners Mayor Sylvia Murphy, Dist. 5 Mayor Pro Tem Danny L. Kolhage,. Dist. 1 Heather Carruthers, Dist. 3 David Rice, Dist. 4 George Neugent, Dist. 2 July 28, 2014 On Monday, July 28, 2014, Clint Arsenault and I visited 149 Ocean Shores Drive, Key Largo, Florida, owned by Jon & Frances Andersen, for the purpose of performing a courtesy inspection. The inspection was prompted by my need to understand and verify the present condition of the site, and the steps necessary to remediate any existing Building Code issues. Here are the findings that Mr. Arsenault and I noted: 1. A check of the receptacles in the backsplash area of the kitchen revealed that the countertop receptacles on each side of the refrigerator did not have GFCI protection. NEC 210.8(A)(6) 2. The cord connection for the dishwasher needs to be accessible. My suggestion was to bring the cord from behind the dishwasher and plug it into the receptacle under the sink. NEC 422.33 (For cord and plug connected appliances, an accessible plug and receptacle shall be permitted to serve as the disconnecting means). 3. Install a locknut on the 1" PVC conduit that terminates in the bottom of the electrical panel. NEC 300.11 (Raceways and fittings shall be securely fastened in place). 4. The unused 1" opening in the panel needs to be sealed. NEC 110.12(A) 5. The electrical panel shall have a correctly labeled directory. NEC 408.4 6. Electrical devices such as switches and receptacles shall have a proper device plate attached. NEC 406.5 7. Unused junction boxes in the lower level shall have wire nuts installed on the conductors and blank covers installed on the boxes. NEC 314.25 8. Neither Clint nor I could locate any exterior landscape lighting on the site, so I consider that issue closed. 9. As I noted at the time of the inspection, we will research the property for permits for the fence and dock/davits. That will take a while, so I will report the results as follow-up to this initial report. 10. Please provide working GFCI protection to the receptacles mounted to the side of the boat davits. NEC 210.8(C) 11. I do not have any issues with the interior painting or flooring that was done. These are not life -safety issues. 12. Please close up the switches at the base of the steps. I am convinced that they control the lighting on the steps and under the structure where your truck is parked. They do not control any landscape lighting. 13. Provide epoxy stabilization or some other grout stabilization for the railing on the south side of the steps to the 2nd floor. They are loose and have never been secured properly. Leaving the holes in steps is only going to retain water and cause rapid corrosion to the base of the railings. 14. There are other minor repairs that you have expressed interest in performing, but I would ask that you complete the items above first. Have your plumbing and electrical contractors call for their finals before you call for your OB final. 15. You can obtain an OB permit for the repair of the fascia, repair of the rotted wood, and repair of the spalled concrete slab on the ground level, after you have satisfactorily completed the items above and other items mentioned in the Code Compliance notification. Mr. Andersen, you have expressed a desire to comply with these corrections and I look forward to seeing closure on them so that you can enjoy your residence. Please consult me if you have questions about requirements for permits. I will be happy to advise you. Sincerely, % 7"00" John T. Travers, B.O. Interim Building Official Monroe County, FL Sincerely, CHRISTINA GOETZMAN Senior Coordinator Monroe County Building Department Murray Nelson Building 102050 Overseas Highway Key Largo, FL 33037 Cc: File Q A, ,!C ,o e if id In men MFZMMII� - Ordinance Code 1110-140.(l) Date Ordered 11105r2013 Comply By Fine Start 104/30t2014 ]3 Daily Fine Number of Days 105 Suspended Days CurrentFine 15750 Complied Date SettleAmount Setde Date t ", 7 Contnuous I . - 1 4 - 0 11 . ... ............................. . ................................. . .............. . ...... . .. . .... . ............ . ....... County of Monroe Growth Management Division Code Compliance Department 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon, Florida 33050 Voice: (305) 289-2810 FAX: (305) 289-2536 FRANCES E AND JON S ANDERSEN 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO FL 33037-4224 November 25, 2014 Subject: Code Case: CE07040059 Subject Property: 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO Dear Property Owner, Board of County Commissioners Mayor Danny L. Kolhage, Dist.I Mayor Pro Tem Heather Carruthers, Dist. 3 George Neugent, Dist. 2 David Rice, Dist. 4 Sylvia J. Murphy, Dist. 5 The purpose of this letter is to inform you that our records indicate that this case was compliant on August 13, 2014 and fines and costs are due. Per the agreement signed by you on October 29, 2013, the agreed upon compliance date was April 29, 2014 with daily fines to accrue in the amount of $150.00 per day if compliance was not timely achieved. On May 15, 2014 you submitted a permit application to the Building Department to correct the violations. As a result, the County offered you an agreement to extend the compliance date. The deadline to submit that extension to the County was May 21, 2014. The County did not receive that signed agreement by that date and a lien against your property was recorded in the Official Records of Monroe County on May 22, 2014 at Document 1982218, Book 2685, Page 1767. Fine(s) of $150.00 per day accrued for 105 days, (April 30, 2014 - August 13, 2014) for a total fine amount of $15,750.00, ($150.00 per day for 105 days). Additionally per F.S. §162.07(2), if the local governing body prevails in prosecuting a case before the enforcement board, it shall be entitled to recover all costs incurred in prosecuting the case before the board and such costs may be included in the lien authorized under F.S. §162.09(3). To date, these costs are $704.60 and costs will continue to accrue until the case is closed. Therefore the current amount of the Monroe County Lien is $16,454.60 ($15,750.00 fines and $704.60 costs). This lien is a lien on the property that was the subject of the code enforcement action and upon any and all other real and/or personal property you own. The County staffs authority to reduce fines is very limited once a lien is filed. In an effort to amicably resolve the amount of the lien the County will accept the minimum amount allowed, $4,642.10 ($3,937.50 fines and $704.60 costs), and provide a Full Satisfaction and Release of Lien. (At this time County staff is limited to a 75% reduction of the fines by resolution. Any reduction in the fine amount lower than that would have to be approved by the Board of County Commissioners.) You can resolve this matter by remitting a check or money order for payment in full within thirty (30) days to: Monroe County Code Compliance Department, Attention Nicole Petrick, 2798 Overseas Highway, Suite 330, Marathon, Florida 33050. The County will then provide a Release and Satisfaction of Lien to you. Failure to remit payment within 30 days will result in the amount reverting to the full amount and a referral to the Monroe County Attorney's Office for further action. Respectfully yours, Kathleen Windsor Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst Windsor-kathleen(amonroecpgpLy:fl.gov 305-289-2586 FA Windsor -Kathleen From: Windsor -Kathleen Sent: Monday, December 01, 2014 9:19 AM To: Granger -Lisa; Williams -Steve; Norman -Ronda; Hurley -Christine Subject: FW: 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 This email below from Mrs. Andersen, which begins Dear Kathleen, was not sent to me. Kathleen Windsor, CFM Fema Certified Floodplain Manager Monroe County Sr. Code Compliance Research Analyst 2798 Overseas Highway Marathon FL 33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 windsor-kathleen@monroecounty-fl.gov Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public disclosure. From: Hurley -Christine Sent: Thursday, November 27, 2014 11:30 AM To: Windsor -Kathleen Subject: Fwd: 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 Were gonna need the pictures too of the violations for the rntg w roman Begin forwarded message: From: Fran <rannabananna/"-.,-_-, il.corn> Date: November 27, 2014 at 11: 11: 00 AM EST To: jon andersen <154pear1dgmail.corn> Cc: jon andersen <154pearl@ ail.com>, Granger -Lisa <Granger -Lisa Mon�roeQpIIn!y- gm EL,Gov>, Williams -Steve <Williams-Steve(&,MonroeColqply:EL.,Qov>, Norman -Ronda <Norman-gonda rn Hurley -Christine <Hurle -Christine MonroeCount3L- FL.Gov> Subject: Re: 149 Ocean Shores Case: CE07040059 and CE08010003 Dear Kathleen, Due to the fact that there were no violations found when the county inspected our property and signed off all the bogus "code violations" that the county thought existed when we purchased our home, I am surprised that you continue to try enforce what is now, obviously,a null and void contract. We were forced to buy a permit for "no work to be done" because there were no violations in the first place, just to comply with your department's demands. There were NO code violations. (please check with John.Travers the interim head of the building department) We cannot understand why persist in persecuting us . Your entire case was based on assumptions that violations existed on our property but you admitted yourself, that you had never gained entry to the property so how did you know that there were any violations in the first place? We could not find any out- door lights. The flood ygnt&_werp_m compliance. There was no work done upstairs. It seems that all these cases are trumped up."How do you justify your actions? We respectfully ask for a refund of our 5,625 tat were forced to pay you to close our purchase escrow one year ago as our house was si off 20 years ago by Munroe County building Department as suitable living space for fans. Fran On 25 Nov 2014, at 10:50 AM, Windsor -Kathleen <Windsor-Kathlee n�(a).,mgonpriog�e�co��v wrote: These letters will be mailed out today, however I have attached them for your convenience. I MINE! I F'IIIIII I FI 11111111 1111 1!1111 1111 1 i Marathon FIL 33050 Phone: 305-289-2586 Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from the County regarding County business are public record, available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communication may be subject to public diSCIOSUre. <ANDERSEN CE07040059.pdf> <ANDERSEN CE08010003.pdf> Jon Andersen 149 Ocean Shores Dr. Key Largo Fl. -- 949 878-1452 --154pearl@gmail.com Meeting Date: 12/4/14 Location: 11oo Simonton Rm 205 Attendees Roman Gastesi gastesi-roman@monroecounty fl.gov, Hurley -Christine hurley-chrisdne anmonroecounty--fl.aov Steve Williamson Williams-Steve@monroecounty-fl.gov Ronda Normn: Norman-Ronda@MonroeCounty-fl.gov Cathleen Windsor Windsor-Kathleen@monroecounty-fl.gov I feel really good about the meeting, and it was a pleasure meeting you all. As a result of our meeting in Key West, December 4, 2014, 1 am following your advice, and requesting a meeting with the commissioners. I am glad that you have agreed to back me on the reduction of these fines. I hope I can count on your continued support with removing these fines and liens. Attached is the letter to the commission 12/4/14 To the Commissioners: Please put me agenda. I am requesting further reduction in fines and related costs and removal of the associated liens against my home at 149 Ocean Shore, Key Largo. Please schedule me for the board county commissioner meeting this May 20 in Key Largo. Respectfully Jon Andersen Windsor -Kathleen From: Travers -John Sent: Tuesday, August 05, 201410:03 AM To: '154pearl@gmail.com' Cc: Williams -Steve; Windsor -Kathleen Subject: 149 Ocean Shores Dr. K L (Jon Andersen) Mr. Andersen, As follow-up to our meeting last week, here are the results of our history search on the fence and dock permits: Dock — Permit 93311084 is expired. It never had any inspections performed. Fence — Permit 98301431 is expired. It never had any inspections performed. Please contact me to meet so we can resolve these expired permits. Thank you, 7. ?meow John T. Travers, B.O. Interim Building Official Monroe County, FL PLAN REVIEW STOPS FOR PERMIT 14302143 Review Stop BIO BIOLOGIST Rev No 1. Status N Date 05-22Cont ID 2014 Sent By MTCEnvi1 Date 05-22 Time E48 Rev Time 0.25 2014Received By MTCEnvil Date 05-21- TimeSent To EXAM 2014 2014-05-22 09:50:28.00000 INTERIOR RENOVATIONS DO NOT CHANGE FOOTPRINT OF HOUSE. Notes NO BIO APPROVAL REQUIRED. 2014-05-2109:49:21.00000 1 5/21/14 MTCENVII Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By CODE ENF 2 CODE COMPLIANCE MARATHON 1 Status P Date Date Date 05-15- 2014 Cont ID Time ERev Time TimeSent To windsock 05-15- 2014 0.00 windsork 05-08- 2014 FLOOD 2014-05-15 10:08:59.00000 "`THIS PERMIT APPLICATION IS TO SATISFY CODE CASE CE07040059. TO -WIT: PERMIT(S), APPROVAL(S) AND INSPECTION(S) ARE REQUIRED FOR INTERIOR RENOVATIONS ( INSTALLATION OF NEW TILE, PAINTING ELECTRIC, PLUMBING AND DRYWALL) AND INSTALLATION OF (APPROXIMATELY 13) GROUND LEVEL EXTERIOR FLOOD LIGHTS FIXTURES. FINAL INSPECTION(S) REQUIRED. PROPERTY OWNER TO CALL CODE INSPECTOR UPON COMPLETION OF ALL BUILDING INSPECTIONS. KWINDSOR ELECT ELECTRICAL 1 Status P Date 06-02 Cont ID 2014 kasprzaa Date 06-02- Time E13:48Rev Time 0.25 2014 kasprzaa Date 06 022014 TimeSent To FINAL -NONE... FINAL FINAL REVIEW 2 Status A Date 06-18- Cont ID Date 2014 Time 07:58 Rev Time mcgilvrl 06-18 0.00 Date 2014 Time 07:58 Sent To mcgilvrl OFFICIAL n^wW—AVPln0nPrmit/nlan cletailc acnx?nermit no=14302143 4/28/2015 Plan Review Details - Permit 14302143 06-18- 2014 Page 2 of 4 Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By I Notes FLOOD FLOOD PLAIN MANAGEMENT 1 Status N Date 05-16- Cont ID Date 2014 Time 11:28 Rev Time wingatem 05-16- 0.00 Date 2014 Time 11:27 Sent To wingatem 05-16- 2014 UK-BLDG 2014-05-1611:28:07.00000 1 N/A ALL WORK IN ELEVATED PORTION OF SFR- ALL FLOODPLAIN VIOLATIONS ALREADY CORRECTED-MW MAR-BLDG MARATHON BUILDING DEPT 1 Status L Date 05-08- Cont ID Date 2014 Time 07:49 Rev Time benderd 05-08- 0.00 Date 2014 Time 07:49 Sent To benderd 05-08- CODE ENF 2 2014 2014-05-08 07:50:16.00000 PER COVER SHEET TO VAT W MECH MECHANICAL 1 Status N Date Date Cont ID Time Rev Time 06-17 0.33 Date 2014 Time Sent To 06-17 PLANNER 2014 -*NONE—* OFFICIAL BUILDING OFFICIAL 1 Status TA Date 07-08- 2014 MTCCSRI Date 07-08- 2014 MTCCSRI Date 07-08- 2014 2014-07-08 09:29:24.00001 Cont ID Time 09:29 Rev Time 0.00 Time 09:29 Sent To READY APPROVED PER JT. AB 07/08/14 PLAN PLANNING 1 1 Status A Date 05-19 2014 baumanb Date 05-19 2014baumanb Date 2014 2014 2014-05-19 14:51:17.00000 PLANNING Cont ID Time E4.4Rev Time Time Sent To APPROVAL FOR INTERIOR RENOVATIONS 0.50 BIO _ ONLY ACCORDING TO APPROVED SITE PLAN. NO OTHER WORK THIS PERMIT. ADDITIONAL WORK WILL REQUIRE PRIOR PLANNING APPROVAL. NOTE: APPLICATION CLEARLY STATES LOCATION OF WORK KITCHEN AND LIVINGROOM. Review Stop PLUMB PLUMBING Rev No 1 I Status P Date Cont ID Sent By Date Time Rev Time li f—ilannu mnnrnarnnntv_fl anWPC.nvPlblc/nermit/nlan details.asnx?hermit no 14302143 0.33 4/28/2015 Plan Review Details - Permit 14302143 Page 3 of 4 Received By tugwellp Date Notes "'NONE"' Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes 06-17- 2014 06-03- Time 07:46 Sent To 2014 FINAL READY PERMIT READY TO ISSUE 1 Status L Date Date Date 07-08- 2014 Cont ID Time 09:29 Rev Time Time 09:29 Sent To MTCCSRI 07-08 2014 0.00 MTCCSRI 07-08 2014 2014-07-08 09:32:11.00000 MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT KEY LARGO: 305-453-8800 / MARATHON: 305-289-2501 / STOCK ISLAND: 305-295-3990 PERMIT # 14302143 OWNER: ANDERSON CONTRACTOR:N/A FEES DUE: $1222.40 DEAR SIR OR MADAM: PLEASE, BE ADVISED THAT THE ABOVE -REFERENCED PERMIT HAS BEEN APPROVED AND IS READY FOR ISSUANCE. THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENTS/INFORMATION WILL BE REQUIRED AT THE TIME OF PERMIT ISSUANCE: NEED SUB LETTERS FOR: -ELECT -PLUMB THE PERMIT MAY BE RETRIEVED BY THE PROPERTY OWNER (OWNER -BUILDER PERMITS), CONTRACTOR (CONTRACTOR PERMITS) OR AUTHORIZED AGENT (CONTRACTOR PERMITS ONLY) AT THE FOLLOWING LOCATION: MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT KEY LARGO OFFICE MURRAY D. NELSON GOVERNMENT AND CULTURAL CENTER 102050 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY KEY LARGO, FL 33037 MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT MARATHON OFFICE 2798 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY SUITE 330 MARATHON, FL 33050 MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT MARATHON OFFICE 5503 COLLEGE ROAD SUITE 203 KEY WEST, FL 33040 BUILDING DEPARTMENT HOURS OF OPERATION ARE MONDAY - FRIDAY, 8:30 A.M. TO 3:00 P.M. ALL REQUIRED DOCUMENTS, INFORMATION AND FEES ARE DUE PRIOR TO PERMIT ISSUANCE. PLEASE, NOTE THAT FEES DUE MAY BE SUBJECT TO CHANGE AT THE TIME OF PERMIT ISSUANCE. FEES MAY BE PAID IN THE FORM OF CASH, CHECK h"-Ulan mnnrnPrnnnty-fl anvleC}nvPhic/nermit/nlan detail s.asnx?nermit no=14302143 4/28/2015 Plan Review Details - Permit 14302143 OR MONEY ORDER. CHECKS AND MONEY ORDERS SHOULD BE MADE PAYABLE TO MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT. Page 4 of 4 Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes Review Stop Rev No Sent By Received By Notes IF YOU SHOULD HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS PERTAINING TO THE ABOVE -NOTED INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT OR VISIT THE APPROPRIATE OFFICE DESIGNATED ABOVE. SINCERELY MONROE COUNTY BUILDING DEPARTMENT UK-BLDG UPPER KEYS BUILDING DEPT 1 Status L Date 05-07- Cont ID Date 2014 Time :19Rev Time MTCCSR2 05-07- 0.00 Date 2014 Time:19 Sent To 1100 MTCCSR2 05-07- MAR-BLDG 2014 2014-05-07 10:21:11.00000 KAT WINDSOR REQUESTED FILE. ROUTED TO MARATHON 05/0712014. AL Your privacy is important to us, for more information see our privacy policy. Copyright ® 2007 - THE PLUS SERIES ® - All Rights Reserved h♦tw/lilane mnnrnPrnimty-fl vnv/eC;nvPlus/nennit/nlan details.ashx?hermit no=14302143 4/28/2015 TO: Date in Date out # of days application 5/6/2014 05/07/14 1 to marathon 5/7/2014 05/08/14 1 TO CODE 5/8/2014 fieldo review app w7 Jerry, Jerry amended application to correct language 05/15/14 7 TO FLOOD 5/15/2014 05/19/14 4 TO BIO 5/19/2014 05/19/14 0 TO PLANNING 5/19/2014 05/22/14 3 TO EXAM 5/22/2014 05/29/14 7 TO ELECT 5/29/2014 06/02/14 4 TO FINAL 6/2/2014 06/03/14 1 TO MECH/PLUMBING 6/3/2014 06/17/14 14 TO FINAL 6/17/2014 06/18/14 1 TO BO 6/18/2014 07/08/14 20 READY 1 7/8/014 07/25/14 17 63 ISSUED 7/2/14' 08/13/14 1 PASSED INSPECTIONS 8/13/2014 PACalculate number of days 14302143.xisx Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser Page 1 of 5 Key West (305) 292-3420 Marathon (305) 289-2550 Plantation Key (305) 852-7130 Website tested on IE8, IE9, & Firefox. Requires Adobe Flash 10.3 or higher Maps are now launching the new map applicationversion. Mailing Address: ANDERSEN FRANCES E AND JON S 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO, FL 33037-4224 ,; 11 ,' \,�� PC Code: 01 - SINGLE FAMILY Millage Group: 500K Affordable No Housing: Section- Township- 33-61-39 Range: Property 149 OCEAN SHORES DR KEY LARGO Location: Subdivision: AMENDED & EXTENDED PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHORES Legal BK 3 LT 2 AMD AND EXT PLAT OF KEY LARGO OCEAN SHRS P134-18 OR340-558 OR421-529-530 C J DOCKET 10-12 OR554- Description: 838 OR830-1544/46 LAND TRUST OR1100-425DC OR1145-279D/C OR1242-177 OR1307-2382 OR1368-2027 OR1658-2185 OR1658-2197AFF OR2220-1823/24 OR2281-2098 OR2486-1560/61 OR2492-387/88ORD OR2628-602/05C/T OR2660-2401 ,_....-. ------- 4/28/2015 Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser Page 2 of 5 CORRINE PL Exemption Amount 39 - 25000 HOMESTEAD 25,000.00 44 - ADDL HOMESTEAD 25,000.00 Land Use Code Frontage Depth Land Area 010C - RESIDENTIAL CANAL 70 125 8,750.00 SF Number of Buildings: 1 Number of Commercial Buildings: 0 Total Living Area: 1500 Year Built: 1994 Building Type R1 Effective Age 15 Year Built 1994 Functional Obs 0 Condition A Perimeter 160 Special Arch 0 Economic Obs 0 Inclusions: R1 includes 1 3-fixture bath and 1 kitchen. Roof Type GABLE/HIP Roof Cover METAL Heat 7 NONE Heat 2 NONE Heat Src 1 NONE Heat Src 2 NONE Extra Features: Quality Grade 450 Depreciation % 16 Gmd Floor Area 1,500 Foundation CONC PILINGS Bedrooms 3 2 Fix Bath 0 Vacuum 0 3 Fix Bath 1 Garbage Disposal 0 4 Fix Bath 0 Compactor 0 5 Fix Bath 0 Security 0 U-.ii....... ...- A --- /D..,...c—,.u— 4/?R/2(114 Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser 6 Fix Bath 0 7 Fix Bath 0 Extra Fix 2 30 FT 25 FT 7 P1a10 25FT 30 FT. Cpf !1D 25 FT 25 FT, Sections: Intercom 0 Fireplaces 0 Dishwasher 0 e FT. SPti 0 FT, 26graq 3 FT 30 FT 3FT. FLA 1151) 60 FT. 50 FT, FT 53 FT. 3oFT. 36 F OPx 40&27a Nbr Type Ext Wall # Stories Year Built Attic A/C Basement % Finished Basement % Area 0 EPB &C.B.S. 1 1994 Y 750 1 CPF 1 1994 N 0.00 0.00 750 2 FLA 1:WD FRAME 1 1994 Y Y 0.00 0.00 1,500 3 OPX 1 1994 N 0.00 0.00 408 4 SPX 1 1994 N 0.00 0.00 288 Page 3 of 5 Nbr Type # Units Length Width Year Built Roll Year Grade Life 1 CL2:CH LINK FENCE 1,500 SF 300 5 1997 1998 1 30 2 DAV:CONC DAVITS 1 UT 0 0 1997 2008 1 60 3 DK3:CONCRETE DOCK 840 SF 70 12 1997 2008 5 60 4 TK2:TIKI 48 SF 6 8 1997 2008 2 40 5 PT3:PATIO 1,800 SF 600 3 1997 2008 1 50 Bldg Number Date Issued Date Completed Amount Description Notes 1 9801431 05/12/1998 12/31/1998 1,500 Residential FENCE & PRIVACY WALL 04302450 05/24/2004 12/31/2004 1 R/R 2.5 TON A/H L++-rr.... —, ,.,..,..,fl ..r,./o.... 42--l' .— 4/2R/2015 Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser Page 4 of 5 WWTM`+�� Roll Year Total Bldg Value Total Misc Improvement Value Total Land Value Total Just (Market) Value Total Assessed Value School Exempt Value School Taxable Value 2014 178,524 33,602 276,497 488,623 475,609 25,000 450,609 2013 206,357 34,480 235,835 476,672 476,672 0 476,672 2012 222,927 35,352 196,119 454,398 451,976 0 454,398 2011 213,828 35,972 161,088 410,888 410,888 0 410,888 2010 230,091 36,845 245,000 511,936 511,936 0 511,936 2009 267,612 37,822 288,750 594,184 594,184 0 594,184 2008 337,868 38,487 420,000 796,355 796,355 0 796,355 2007 306,877 1,638 525,000 833,515 833,515 0 833,515 2006 312,554 1,708 525,000 839,262 839,262 0 839,262 2005 263,388 1,802 481,250 746,440 746,440 0 746,440 2004 265,495 1,872 260,313 527,680 527,680 0 527,680 2003 196,663 1,942 172,813 371,418 371,418 0 371,418 2002 304,309 2,036 107,188 413,533 413,533 0 413,533 2001 204,364 2,106 83,125 289,595 289,595 0 289,595 2000 119,781 1,563 59,063 180,407 180,407 25,000 155,407 1999 119,781 1,631 56,875 178,286 176,387 25,000 151,387 1998 116,735 0 56,875 173,610 173,610 25,000 148,610 1997 116,735 0 56,875 173,610 173,610 25,000 148,610 1996 116,735 0 56,875 173,610 173,610 25,000 148,610 1995 138,015 0 56,875 194,890 194,890 0 194,890 1994 0 0 56,875 56,875 56,875 0 56,875 1993 0 0 48,125 48,125 48,125 0 48,125 1992 0 0 48,125 48,125 48,125 0 48,125 1991 0 0 48,125 48,125 48,125 0 48,125 1990 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43,750 1989 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43,750 1988 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43,750 1987 0 0 43,750 43,750 43,750 0 43,750 1986 0 0 39,375 39,375 39,375 0 39,375 1985 0 0 30,625 30,625 30,625 0 30,625 1984 0 0 30,625 30,625 30,625 0 30,625 1983 0 0 31,148 31,148 31,148 0 31,148 1982 0 0 31,148 31,148 31,148 0 31,148 NOTE: Sales ♦ not generally show• in our • • -r system until aboutto three months after the date of s recent sale does not show up in this list, please allow more time for- record to be processed. Thank• i for o patience • understanding. Sale Date Official Records Book/Page Price Instrument Qualification 10/24/2013 2660 / 2401 497,200 QC 11 �..... ,..........,..41 ... M..., 42.-b 4/28/2015 Property Search -- Monroe County Property Appraiser Page 5 of 5 5/9/2013 2628 / 602 100 CT 12 11/16/2010 2492 / 387 0 ORDER 11 10/7/2010 2486 / 1560 100 CT 12 3/9/2007 2281 /2098 1,150,000 WD Q 10/4/2000 1658 / 2185 390,000 WD Q 8/1/1995 1368 / 2027 200,000 WD V 5/1/1994 1307 / 2382 62,500 WD V This page has been visited 219,776 times. Monroe County Property Appraiser Scott P. Russell, CFA P.O. Box 1176 Key West, FL 33041-1176 httn•/Ixxnxnxi mrnnfl nro/PrnnCaarrh acnx 4/2ROO15