Item K5County of Monroe
<r
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
�1 t t 0.
Mayor David Rice, District 4
IleOI1da Keys
��x
Mayor Pro Tem Sylvia J. Murphy, District 5
Danny L. Kolhage, District I
P f,<
George Neugent, District 2
a
Heather Carruthers, District 3
County Commission Meeting
March 21, 2018
Agenda Item Number: K.5
Agenda Item Summary #3967
BULK ITEM: Yes DEPARTMENT: Planning/Environmental Resources
TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Barbara Valdes -Perez (305) 289-
2523
N/A
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Approval of a resolution prioritizing local applications for the 2018
Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) to provide projects to be funded in the 2024 FDOT
Work Plan. Rowell's Waterfront Park (multi -use path /trail with parking lot and rest rooms to
connect to the Florida Keys Overseas Heritage Trail) for $1,150,000 and was ranked 41.
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) announced on January 12, 2018, the 2018
Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) application cycle. The TAP is federal funding available
for non - motorized transportation that is administered through FDOT. The current application cycle
was open until February 23, 2018.
As part of the application review process, FDOT requires local priority rankings be approved by the
Monroe County Board of County Commissioners (BOCC). This year only one application was
received for projects within Monroe County. A selection committee, consisting of representatives
from Monroe County, evaluated the application based on the criteria found within the FDOT
application.
Criteria for scoring the projects included:
1. Project safety improvements for bicycles riders and /or pedestrian.
2. Intermodal transportation linkages improvements, including those that provide access to
transit stations and /or facilities.
3. Mobility enhancement or community development for disadvantaged groups (i.e. children,
the elderly, the poor, those with limited transportation options, and the disabled).
4. Contribution to local funding or the completion of previous phases of project development.
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air,
noise, water quality, and /or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips.
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions,
letters of support from local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations,
political leaders and other groups.
The recommended prioritization of the 2018 applications is as follows:
- Rowell's Waterfront Park (multi -use path /trail with parking lot and rest rooms to connect to
the Florida Keys Overseas Heritage Trail) $1,150,000
Upon approval by the BOCC, the decision will be transmitted to the FDOT for funding consideration
and inclusion in the FDOT 5- Year Work Program.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION:
May 17, 2017- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2017 TAP application cycle.
June 15, 2016- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2016 TAP application cycle.
May 20, 2015- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2015 TAP application cycle.
June 11, 2014- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2014 TAP application cycle.
August 21, 2013- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2013 TAP application cycle.
July 20, 2011- Approval of staff recommendations for the 2011 TAP application cycle.
CONTRACT /AGREEMENT CHANGES:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval
DOCUMENTATION:
TAP Priorities Resolution
TAP Prioritization Staff Report
Final Overall Score
Individual Score
Notice of Transportation Alternative Program Application Cycle
TAP Selection Criteria 2018
2018 -TAP Application- Rowell's Waterfront Park
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
Effective Date: N/A
Expiration Date: N/A
Total Dollar Value of Contract: N/A
Total Cost to County: N/A
Current Year Portion: N/A
Budgeted: N/A
Source of Funds: N/A
CPI: N/A
Indirect Costs: N/A
Estimated Ongoing Costs Not Included in above dollar amounts: N/A
Revenue Producing: No
Grant: YES
County Match: No
Insurance Required:
Additional Details:
If yes, amount: N/A
REVIEWED BY:
Christine Hurley
Completed
03/05/2018 4:33 PM
Steve Williams
Completed
03/06/2018 9:58 AM
Jaclyn Carnago
Completed
03/06/2018 10:25 AM
Budget and Finance
Completed
03/06/2018 10:31 AM
Maria Slavik
Completed
03/06/2018 11:47 AM
Kathy Peters
Completed
03/06/2018 12:22 PM
Board of County Commissioners
Pending
03/21/2018 9:00 AM
t
RESOLUTION NO. -2018
A RESOLUTION OF THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY,
FLORIDA PRIORITIZING THE 2018 TRANSPORTATION
ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM APPLICATIONS.
WHEREAS, The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) opened the 2018
Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) announce the application cycle on January 12, 2018.
The Transportation Alternatives Program provides federal funding available for non - motorized
transportation, which FDOT administers; and
WHEREAS, FDOT requires local priority rankings be approved by the Monroe County
Board of County Commissioners as part of the application process; and
WHEREAS, only one application was submitted for consideration for funding by
FDOT: Rowell's Waterfront Park, requesting $1,150,000; in the unincorporated areas of
Monroe County; and
WHEREAS, a committee consisting of representatives from Monroe County evaluated
the application based on FDOT's required criteria; and
WHEREAS, the score of the 2018 application is based on a 100 point scale: where
Rowell's Waterfront Park received an overall average score of 79; and
WHEREAS, at a public hearing, the Board considered comments from citizens wishing
to speak on the matter; and
WHEREAS, the Board fully supports the funding of the application;
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA:
1. Monroe County prioritization of the 2018 Transportation Alternatives Program
applications is as follows:
1. Rowell's Waterfront Park - $1,150,000
2. Requests the Florida Department of Transportation provide Transportation Alternative
Program funds in the upcoming FDOT District Six in the fifth year of the
Page I of 2
Department's Tentative Work Program (2024) for Monroe County as requested by the
applicant.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida,
at a regular meeting of the Board held on the 21" day of March 2018.
Mayor David Rice
Mayor Pro Tem Sylvia J. Murphy
Commissioner Heather Carruthers
Commissioner Danny L. Kolhage
Commissioner George Neugent
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
(SEAL)
BY
Mayor David Rice
ATTEST: KEVIN MADOK, CLERK
Deputy Clerk
490 ROE COUNTY ATTORNEY
A YE TO ;7 AS
ASSLr
orate
Page 2 of 2
5
� n
MEMORANDUM
Monroe County Planning & Environmental Resources Department
We strive to be caring, professional, and fair
To: Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
Through: Christine Hurley, AICP, Assistant County Administrator
From: Barbara Valdes - Perez, P.E., Transportation Planner
Date: March 3, 2018
Subject: Prioritizing of application received as part of the 2018 Transportation Alternatives
Program.
BOCC Meeting: March 21, 2018
Background
Historically, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) District 6 opens an application cycle
for the Transportation Alternative Program (TAP) funding when federal funds are available to local
governments to fund improvements that create transportation alternatives for the non - motorized user.
TAP is federal funding for programs and projects defined as transportation alternatives, which
includes planning, design or construction of on and off -road pedestrian and bicycle facilities,
infrastructure projects for improving non - driver access to public transportation and enhanced mobility,
and similar projects. The process for obtaining TAP funding for transportation projects is competitive
in nature. Proposed projects are evaluated and ranked based on a specific set of criteria developed by
FDOT. Part of the criteria includes local prioritization. Monroe County is an area outside of a
Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO); therefore, the County is responsible for establishing
priorities for projects within the Florida Keys. Therefore, all applications submitted by jurisdictions
within Monroe County must be evaluated and ranked by the Monroe County Board of County
Commissioners. A committee consisting of representatives from Monroe County reviewed the
applications submitted for consideration and ranked the applications based on criteria found within the
FDOT application guidelines.
This year, FDOT invited the local jurisdictions to submit applications for projects that can be
developed for Fiscal Year 2023/2024. Only one application was submitted for local prioritization. A
summary of the project follows.
2018 TAP Applications
Rowell's Waterfront Park, Key Largo
2018 TAP Request: $1,150,000
Previous Awards: $149,000
Jurisdiction Match: $0
Total Project Cost $1,371,000
1
Monroe County requests $1,150,000 for Phase 1 construction of a 2.25 acre Overseas Hwy /Heritage
Trail rest stop and vista. FDOT previously awarded $149,000 in TAP funds for the project design.
Phase I construction includes a multi -use path/trail to connect to the Overseas Heritage Trail; an off -
highway parking lot with designated RV /Trailer spaces; restrooms; drinking fountains; an
informational kiosk with lighting; and new landscaping.
Review
The project was submitted to FDOT for funding and on March 30, 2018, FDOT will determine the
feasibility of the projects. The project was reviewed by a committee of representatives from Monroe
County. The application was assessed by each member of the committee based on the six criteria
provided below:
1. Project safety improvements for bicycles riders and /or pedestrian.
2. Intermodal transportation linkages improvements, including those that provide access to transit
stations and /or facilities.
3. Mobility enhancement or community development for disadvantaged groups (i.e. children, the
elderly, the poor, those with limited transportation options, and the disabled).
4. Contribution to local funding or the completion of previous phases of project development.
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air, noise,
water quality, and /or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips.
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions,
letters of support from local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations, political
leaders and other groups.
7. Prioritization:
b) Monroe County Projects — Top priorities identified by the Senior Director of Monroe
County's Department of Planning and Environmental Resources Department and BOCC
Resolution.
The overall score is based on a 100 point scale. Each committee member scored each project based on
the six criteria listed above, assigning points as allowed for each measure. This accounted for 85
points. In accordance with criteria number seven, the Monroe County Planning and Environmental
Resources Director assigned the remaining 15 points. The same six criteria used individually were
assigned a value, which totaled 10 -15 points. The final score for number seven scored by the Planning
Director was then added to the individual scores from each committee member. The total scores from
each member were averaged.
Recommendation
The Monroe County Rowell's Waterfront Park received an overall average score of 79. Based on the
average score and discussion by the committee. The recommended prioritization of the 2018 TAP
application cycle is as follows:
PA
1. Rowell's Waterfront Park - $1,150,000
Upon approval of the resolution by the BOCC, the decision will be transmitted to MOT to be included
as part of the agency application review process. If selected for TAP funding the project will be
included in the fifth year of MOT District Six Department's Tentative Work Program (2024).
IN
1. Project safety improvements for bicycle riders and/or pedestrians (15 points) 5-11
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air, noise, water
quality, and/or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips (15 points)
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions, letters of
support from local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations, political leaders and other
groups (15 points)
7. Prioritization (15 points):Top priorities identified by the Senior Director of Monroe County's Department of
Planning and Environmental Resources Department and BOCC Resolution
otalScore
Printed Name:
—ri La cm�
e- I
, 0
Data 11 /0 1
ilV
111
Ile / - k 6
-
Signature:
cy� - /t A- - "f� e
1
x I ) 1q ' ) V// r/
11
Printed Name:
-A b ml
Data
Signature:
Printed Name: -
Data 2-A
Signature:
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Rowell's
Waterfront Park
1. Project safety improvements for bicycle riders and /or pedestrians (15 points)
3
13
2. Intermodal transportation linkages improvement's, including those that will provide access to transit
stations and /or facilities. (15 points)
0
��
3. Mobility enhancement or development for disadvantaged groups (i.e. children, the elderly, the
those limited
poor, with transportation options, and the disabled) (15 points)
4.Constribution to local funding or the completion of previous phases of project development. (10 points)
7
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air, noise, water
! 3
1
quality, and /or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips (15 points)
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions, letters of
support from local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations, political leaders and other
1 3
13
groups (15 points)
7. Prioritization (15 points):Top priorities identified by the Senior Director of Monroe County's Department of
Planning and Environmental Resources Department and BOCC Resolution.
Tota I Score
Printed Name: —E J x
Signature:
Date
EVALUATION! CRITERIA Waterfront Park
1. Project safety 'improvements for bicycle riders and/or pedestrians /I5points)
4.Constribution to lIoca I funding or the completion of previous phases of project development. (10 points)
Printed Name: Date
Signature: 4
YJ
EVALUATION CRITERIA
wells
Wateerfront Park
1. Project safety improvements for bicycle riders and /or pedestrians (15 points)
3
2. Intermodal transportation linkages improvements, including those that will provide access to transit
l
stations and /or facilities. (15 points)
3. Mobility enhancement or community development for disadvantaged groups (i.e. children, the elderly, the
r
poor, those with limited transportation options, and the disabled) (15 points)
4.Constribution to local funding or the completion of previous phases of project development. (10 points)
�O
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air, noise, water
quality, and /or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips (15 points)
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions, letters of
support from local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations, political leaders and other
15
groups (15 points)
7. Prioritization (15 points):Top priorities identified by the Senior Director of Monroe County's Department of
Planning and Environmental Resources Department and BOCC Resolution.
Total Score
Printed Name: Borbara
O n 6GJ
Signature:' 01, Oj� A011I C lYW12
0
Date
January 12, 2018
Ms. Aileen Boucle, Executive Director
Miami -Dade Transportation Planning Organization
111 NW 1 Street, Suite 920
Miami, FL 33128
Mr. Roman Gastesi, Jr., County Administrator
Monroe County
1100 Simonton Street, Suite 205
Key West, FL 33040
Subject: Transportation Alternatives Application Cycle - 2018
Dear Ms. Boucle and Mr. Gastesi:
The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) is pleased to announce the Transportation
Alternatives application cycle for 2018. The FAST Act (§ 1109; 23 U.S.C. 133(h)), which was
enacted on December 2015, eliminated the MAP -21 Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) and
replaced it with the Transportation Alternatives Set -Aside (TA) under the Surface Transportation
Block Grant (STBG) program. The TA grant program provides funding for all projects and activities
that were previously eligible under TAP. It allows for a variety of smaller -scale transportation
projects, including: pedestrian and bicycle facilities, recreational trails, safe routes to school projects,
community improvements such as historic preservation and vegetation management, and
environmental mitigation related to stormwater and habitat connectivity.
Agencies are invited to submit applications for projects that can be developed for Fiscal Year
2023/2024. Miami Dade County Transportation Planning Organization (TPO) and Monroe County
Planning and Environmental Department are responsible for forwarding this announcement to
municipalities within their respective jurisdictions. New projects are typically programmed in the fifth
year of the Department's Tentative Work Program (2024). However, funding is subject to the
availability of TA funds and annual spending authority approved by the Florida Legislature.
The TA is administered through the FDOT District Six Program Management Office. Miami Dade
applications must be submitted to the Transportation Planning Organization (TPO) and FDOT by
February 23, 2098. Monroe County Applications must be submitted to FDOT and Monroe County
Planning & Environmental Resources Department by February 23, 2018.
www.fdot.gov
Ms. Aileen Boucle
Mr. Roman Gastesi, Jr.
January 12, 2018
Transportation Alternatives Application Cycle 2018
Page 2 of 2
Thank you for your continued partnership with the Department. Please contact Harold Desdunes at
(305) 470 -5464 or Xiomara Nunez at (305) 470 -5404 if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
mes Wolfe, .E.
strict Six Secretary
Attachments: Transportation Alternative Evaluation Guidelines- Selection Criteria
Transportation Alternatives Application
cc: David Henderson, Miami -Dade Transportation Planning Organization
Christine Hurley, Monroe County
Kevin Wilson, Monroe County
Mayte Santamaria, Monroe County
Judith Clarke, Monroe County
Harold Desdunes, P.E, Florida Department of Transportation
Mario Cabrera, P.E., Florida Department of Transportation
Dat Huynh, P.E. Florida Department of Transportation
Curlene Thomas, Florida Department of Transportation
Ken Jeffries, Florida Department of Transportation
Antonette Adams, Florida Department of Transportation
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
APPLICATION SUBMITTAL PROCESS SCHEDULE:
• TAP Workshop:
■ Miami Dade TPO & Monroe County Agencies: January 19, 2018 in the CITT Conference Room,
10 Floor, 111 NW First Street, Miami 33128. (10 am to 12 pm) or call in to 1- 888 - 408 -9943;
enter Pin: 6196936
• Application deadline:
ACTIVITY
DATE AND TIME
.O AGENCY APPLICATION RKSHOP .O
COUNTY AGENCIES CALL IN
APPLICATIONS DEADLINE .r
APPLICATION SUBMITTAL INSTRUCTIONS:
Miami -Dade County send one (1) original Application and ten (10) hard copies to David Henderson at the TPO address
below AND one (1) electronic copy of each application to: xiomara.nunez@dot.state.fl.us
aIfredo.reyna @dot.state.f1.us and alina.philipp @dot.state.fl.us
Monroe County: send one (1) electronic or disc copy and five (5) hard copies to Mayte Santamaria at the Monroe
County address below.
MIAMI DADE TPO
MONROE COUNTY
David Henderson, TAP Coordinator
Mayte Santamaria
Miami -Dade TPO
Sr. Director of Planning and Environmental Resources
111 NW First Street, Suite 920
Planning & Environmental Resources Department
Miami, FL 33128 -1999
2798 Overseas Highway, Suite 400
Office: (305) 375 -1647
Marathon, Florida 33050
Email: david.henderson@mdtpo.org
Office: (305) 289 -2500
Email: Santamaria- Mayte @MonroeCounty -FL.Gov
FDOT
Xiomara Nunez, LAP Coordinator
Florida Department of Transportation
District VI -Adam Leigh Cann Building
1000 NW 111th Avenue, Room 6112B
Miami, Florida 33172
Office: (305) 470 -5404
Email: xiomara.nunez@dot.state.fl.us
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
General Criteria for Selection
1. No more than $1 million of TAP funds will be awarded to any single project in any single application cycle, and no
more than $3 million dollars of TAP funds will be awarded to any single project. Applicants whose project costs
will exceed $1 million must demonstrate that they have the additional funds to complete the project.
2. No more than 3 applications per department can be submitted. If your agency is submitting more than one
application, please rank the applications based on your agency's priorities as needed.
3. The Application package should consist of the following:
a) Completed application (may not exceed 15 pages)
b) Attachments, exhibits, typical sections, plans, and letters of support (may not exceed 20 pages)
c) Report of all previous funding awards and the status of each project.
4. The following must be identified in the application:
a) Right -of -Way needs and status, including easements
b) Environmental and cultural resource analysis
c) Permitting requirements
Note: Please be advised that all questions on the application should have a response. Failure to respond to all questions
will result in a disqualification of the application. Should you feel that a question is not applicable to your project, please
respond "not applicable."
ELIGIBLE CATEGORIES FOR TAP PROJECTS'
1. Construction of on -road and off -road trail facilities for pedestrians, bicyclists, and other non - motorized forms of
transportation, including sidewalks, bicycle infrastructure, pedestrian and bicycle signals, traffic calming techniques,
lighting and other safety - related infrastructure, and transportation projects to achieve compliance with the
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990
2. Construction, planning, and design of infrastructure - related projects and systems that will provide safe routes for
non - drivers, including children, older adults, and individuals with disabilities to access daily needs.
3. Conversion and use of abandoned railroad corridors for trails for pedestrians, bicyclists, or other non - motorized
transportation users
4. Construction of turnouts, overlooks, and viewing areas
5. Community improvement activities, which include but are not limited to:
a. Inventory, control, or removal of outdoor advertising
b. Historic preservation and rehabilitation of historic transportation facilities
c. Vegetation management practices in transportation rights -of -way to improve roadway safety, prevent
against invasive species, and provide erosion control
d. Archaeological activities relating to impacts from implementation of a transportation project eligible under
title 23 of the US Code
1 Please use FHWA Guidance for more information on eligibility
http: / /www. fhwa. dot. gov /environment/ transportation_ alternatives /guidance /gui dance _ 2016. cfm #EligiblePro ects
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
6. Any environmental mitigation activity, including pollution prevention and pollution abatement activities and
mitigation to:
a. address storm water management, control, and water pollution prevention or abatement related to
highway construction or due to highway runoff, including activities described in 23 U.S.C. 133(b)(11), 328(a),
and 329; or
b. reduce vehicle- caused wildlife mortality or to restore and maintain connectivity among terrestrial or aquatic
habitats
7. The Safe Routes to School (SRTS) program eligible projects and activities listed at section 1404(f) of the SAFETEA -LU
include:
a. Infrastructure - related projects
b. Non - infrastructure - related activities
c. SRTS coordinator. SAFETEA -LU section 1404(f)(2)(A) lists "managers of safe routes to school programs" as
eligible under the non - infrastructure projects
8. Planning, designing or constructing boulevards and other roadways largely in the right -of -way of former Interstate
System routes or other divided highways
9. The recreational trails program under 23 U.S.C. 206 of title 23
ELIGIBLE PROJECT SPONSORS
A. Local government: Local government entities include any unit of local government below a State government
agency, except for a TPO. Examples include city, town, township, village, borough, parish, or county agencies
B. Regional transportation authority: Regional transportation authorities are considered the same as the Regional
Transportation Planning Organizations defined in the statewide planning section (23 U.S.C. 135(m))
C. A transit agency: Transit agencies include any agency responsible for public transportation that is eligible for funds
as determined by the Federal Transit Administration
D. A natural resource or public land agency: Natural resource or public land agencies include any Federal, Tribal, State,
or local agency responsible for natural resources or public land administration. Examples include: State or local park
or forest agencies; State or local fish and game or wildlife agencies; Department of the Interior Land Management
Agencies; U.S. Forest Service
E. A school district, local education agency, or school: School districts, local education agencies, or schools may include
any public or nonprofit private school. Projects should benefit the general public and not only a private entity
F. A tribal government
G. A nonprofit entity responsible for the administration of local transportation safety programs: Examples include a
nonprofit entity responsible for: a local program implementing construction, planning, and design of infrastructure
2 https: / /www.fhwa.dot.gov /environment/ transportation_ alternatives/ guidance / guidance _2016.cfm #RecreationalTrails
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
related projects and systems that will provide safe routes for non - drivers, including children, older adults, and
individuals with disabilities to access daily needs; and safe routes to school program
H. Any other local or regional governmental entity with responsibility for, or oversight of, transportation or recreational
trails (other than an TPO or a State agency) that the State determines to be eligible, consistent with the goals of this
subsection.
REVIEW PROCESS:
Miami -Dade County:
• FDOT Technical Review of applications for
project feasibility
• Results sent to TPO for Project Committee
review and ranking
• Presentation of priority projects to the FDOT
Scoping Committee
• Approval of TPO program priorities by TPO
Governing Board
Monroe County:
• FDOT Technical Review of applications for project
feasibility
• Results sent to Monroe County to review and rank
projects.
• Presentation of ranked priority projects to FDOT
Scoping Committee for final selection and
recommendation to the Monroe Board of County
Commissioners (BOCC).
• BOCC's approval of priority projects to program in
FDOT's Work Program.
FDOT TECHNICAL REVIEW Evaluation Criteria (100 points):
1. Overall application completeness and accuracy (5 points)
2. Ability to implement the project (50 points):
a. Scope implementation feasibility (20 points)
b. Project schedule accuracy and detail (15 points)
c. Permitting identification and status (5 points)
d. Environmental considerations (10 points)
** . Please note: Environment impacts may affect your total project cost and budget. Should you need
assistance assessing the budget considerations that should be given to environmental impacts, please
reach out to our team prior to submitting your application **
3. Project Cost Estimate (15 points):
a. Information provided to validate cost estimate (5 points)
b. Accuracy of the estimate ranging from order of magnitude estimates to an opinion of probable costs using
unit prices, including estimates for required professional services including environmental compliance
with NEPA (10 points)
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
4. Previous Funding/ Administrative Performance (30 points)
a. Agency responsiveness (5 points)
b. Accuracy of estimates as compared to actual costs (5 points)
c. Meeting schedule commitments (5 points)
d. Level of compliance with state and federal regulations (5 points)
e. Maintenance of Local Agency Program Information Tool (LAPIT) (5 points)
f. Invoicing timeliness and accuracy (5 points)
Once FDOT reviews the applications, the Technical Evaluation results are forwarded to the TPO Review Committee or
to Monroe County.
COUNTY AGENCY PROJECT EVALUATION (100 points):
1. Project safety improvements for bicycle riders and /or pedestrians (15 points)
2. Intermodal transportation linkages improvements, including those that provides access to transit stations and /or
facilities. For applications in Miami -Dade this includes the Strategic Miami Area Rapid Transit (SMART) Plan. (15
points)
3. Mobility enhancement or community development for disadvantaged groups (i.e. children, the elderly, the poor,
those with limited transportation options, and the disabled) (15 points)
4. Contribution to local funding or the completion of previous phases of project development (10 points)
5. Neighborhood or community quality of life improvements, improving environmental air, noise, water quality,
and /or reducing the need for single occupancy vehicle trips (15 points)
6. Community support, including minutes of public meetings, newspaper clippings, petitions, letters of support from
local business owners, property owners, nonprofit organizations, political leaders and other groups (15 points)
7. Prioritization (15 points):
a) Miami -Dade County Projects —Top priorities identified by
a. TPO's Citizen's Transportation Advisory Committee (CTAC) (5 points)
b. Bicycle /Pedestrian Advisory Committee (BPAC) (5 points)
c. Transportation Aesthetics Review Committee (TARC) (5 points)
b) Monroe County Projects —Top priorities identified by the Senior Director of Monroe County's Department of
Planning and Environmental Resources Department and BOCC Resolution (15 points)
FDOT PROJECT PRESENTATIONS (100 points):
Project presentations are scheduled for the TPO and Monroe County ranked projects. The District Six Scoping
Committee scores each project up to 100 points.
Prioritization (25 points)
Up to 25 points awarded for TPO and Monroe County agency prioritization: The top ranked project from each county
agency receives 25 points, the second ranked receives 24 points, the third ranked receives 23 points, etc. The final
is
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT VI
TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES PROGRAM (TAP)
SELECTION AND PRIORITIZATION CRITERIA
2018 CYCLE
ranking is submitted to the TPO TAP Coordinator and to Monroe County for Board Approval. All applicants will be
notified of the results.
PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION
Projects prioritized in this funding cycle are programmed into the FDOT 5 -Year Work Program. Project sponsors work
with FDOT to execute project funding agreements in a timely manner.
Project sponsors must enter into a Local Agency Program (LAP) agreement with FDOT prior to the start of any work
for which reimbursement is requested. The LAP will administer the project funding process. Project sponsors must
have or obtain LAP Certification in order to qualify for project funding'. Funds expended by the sponsor before
execution of a LAP Agreement cannot be reimbursed by FDOT. LAP projects must meet federal requirements,
standards and rules and procedures governing federally funded transportation projects, including right -of -way
certification, environmental review and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliance. Local Agency Program
information can be found at: http:// www. fdot. gov/ programmanagement /LP /Default.shtm
3 State and federal agencies are generally exempt from the certification requirements of this section. This is due to the fact that state and federal
agencies undergo extensive annual auditing protocols by both state and federal entities which are available for department review as needed.
However, a District may request a state or federal agency obtain certification or recertification as needed.