03/09/2007 Final Meeting f
MINUTES OF THE 2006/6
MONROE COUNTY
VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Final Meeting
Harvey Government Center
Friday, March 9, 2007
The Final Meeting of the 2006 Monroe County Value Adjustment Board convened at
10:00 a.m., on the above date, at the Harvey Government Center located at 1200 Truman
Avenue, Key West. Present and answering to roll call were Commissioner Charles "Sonny"
McCoy, Commissioner George Neugent, Commissioner Dixie Spehar, and School Board
Member John Dick. Absent was School Board Member Duncan Mathewson. Also present were
Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk, Pamela Hancock, Deputy Clerk; Karl Borglum, Assistant Property
Appraiser; Suzanne A. Hutton, County Attorney; and Attorney John Dent, representing the
Property Appraiser.
Motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Commissioner Spehar
granting approval of the Minutes from the November 13, 2006 Organizational Meeting. Motion
carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick
granting approval of the Special Magistrate's Rulings with regard to the 2006 Denied Late Filed
Petitions. Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached hereto.
Debra Malone, Petition No. E100-2006, addressed the Board concerning the denial of the
Save Our Homes value. Special Magistrate William Webster and Suzanne Hutton, County
Attorney addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and
seconded by Commissioner Neugent to uphold the Special Magistrate's Findings. Motion
carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick
granting approval of the Special Magistrate's recommendations of the 2006 Exemption Petitions.
Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached hereto.
Salvatore Gutierrez, Petition No. 622-2006, addressed the Board. Special Magistrate
Patricia Peacock-McGrath and Karl Borglum, Assistant Property Appraiser addressed the Board.
After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Commissioner
Spehar to uphold the Special Magistrate's Findings. Motion carried unanimously.
Louis Prigioniero, Attorney for Tamara J. Leach— Petition No. R009-2006, addressed the
Board. John Dent, Attorney for the Property Appraiser addressed the Board. After discussion,
motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Commissioner Spehar that the
Save Our Homes does not apply to the whole and to approve the result of the County Attorney's
03/09/2007 2006/7
opinion as the parties agreed that would impact the Special Magistrate's determination. Motion
carried unanimously.
Pamela Hancock, Deputy Clerk advised the Board that the approval of recommendations
of Special Magistrate's 2006 Real Property Petitions had an amendment as Mr. Ray Wood,
Petition No. 462-2006, withdrew his petition earlier in the week. Motion was made by
Commissioner Neugent and seconded by School Board Member Dick granting approval of the
recommendations of the Special Magistrate's 2006 Valuation Petitions, as amended. Motion
carried unanimously. Said list is attached hereto.
Motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Commissioner Spehar
granting approval of Expenditures for Special Magistrate paid invoices and the forthcoming
invoices from today's meeting. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick
granting approval of Expenditures for paid Legal Notice invoices and the forthcoming invoices
from today's meeting. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick
to adopt the following Resolution adopting the Good Cause Form for Late Files. Motion carried
unanimously.
RESOLUTION NO. 003-2006
Said Resolution is incorporated herein by reference.
Motion was made by Commissioner Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick
to approve the Certification of Tax Roll. Motion carried unanimously.
Mary Andrejek, Petition No. E066-2006, addressed the Board. Special. Magistrate
William Webster addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner
Spehar and seconded by School Board Member Dick to uphold the Special Magistrate's
Findings. Motion carried unanimously.
There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully submitted,
Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
of Monroe County
by: Pamela G. Hancock, Deputy Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
2006 DENIED LATE FILED PETITIONS
by Special Magistrates
Name/Address Brief Reason
William Allen Medical records—no good cause shown
301 8th Street SM Webster
Key Colony Beach FL 33051
John R. Ballantyne Petitioner not present & did not present any
903 N Pine Hills Road reason
Orlando FL 32808 SM McGrath
Mary M. Bennett Petitioner not present—advised she was out of
1133 Calle Ensenada town
Marathon FL 33050 SM McGrath
Bi-State Realty, LTD Illness of petitioners brother-in-law
444 N Main Street SM Corcoran
Hubbard OH 44425
Henry L. Bikofsky Petitioner not present & did not present any
1123 Calle Ensenada reason
Marathon FL 33050 SM McGrath
Thomas Booth Found TRIM Notice confusing & overlooked
8914 Briarwood Lane deadline
Orlando Park IL 60462 SM Corcoran
Christa Bruett Traveling to relocate mother to nursing home—
1124 Seminary Street dates outside of period in question
Key West FL 33040 SM Corcoran
Circle K, Inc. Petitioner not present & did not present any
Attn: Michele Milner reason
PO Box 4900 SM McGrath
Scottsdale AZ 85261-4900
Charles M. Cisneros Did not receive TRIM Notice until after
334 S Airport Drive receiving tax bill
Summerland Key FL 33042 SM Corcoran
John W. Conlin Petitioner not present—state they were out of
3515 Jonathan Harbour Drive town &mail was not forwarded
Jupiter FL 33477 SM McGrath
Lisette & Edward Cutie Petitioner not present—letter sent with petition
212 Pimlico Lane objected to by PAO as hearsay
Key Largo FL 33037 SM Webster
D & E Land Trust Petitioner not present—no good cause shown
Don W. Jessup SM Corcoran
PO Box 108
Hanna IN 46340
Adrian Davies Petitioner not present—out of country
1403 Truman Avenue SM Corcoran
Key West FL 33040
Joyce Ann Dunwell Petitioner filed for late homestead 10/12/2006
31024 Avenue F did know she could late file
Big Pine Key FL 33043 SM Corcoran
2006 DENIED LATE FILED PETITIONS
by Special Magistrates
Name/Address Brief Reason
Andrea E. Edwards Petitioner did not know an appeal was possible
14310 SW 14th Street SM Corcoran
Davie FL 33325
John& Kathleen Fredal Petitioner not present—good cause not shown
96000 Overseas Highway L6 SM Webster
Key Largo FL 33037
A. Henry Fretz TRIM received late due to failure to notify
PO Box 876 Property Appraiser of new address
Stevensville MD 21666 SM Corcoran
Richard T. & Geraldine C. Gilles Recently being taxed—admits negligence
5641 Hillcrest Avenue SM McGrath
Mentor OH 44060
Rodolfo Gomez No appeal until thought other were appealing
7730 SW 89th Court SM Webster
Miami FL 33173
Denise Harmon Petitioner not present—out of town for family
812 Simonton Street—Front illness 5 %2 weeks—don't know time frame
Key West FL 33040 SM Corcoran
Fiona Houghton Petitioner thought property would be fixed
2825 Harris Avenue from hurricane—not done so filed 11/8/2006
Key West FL 33040 SM Corcoran
Diane Jameson Petitioner not present—documents considered
17041 Marlin Drive hearsay by PAO—no good cause shown
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 SM Webster
Steven A. Kidd Petitioner not present—never received TRIM
PO Box 5606 but address given say as Property Card w/PAO
Pompano Beach FL 33074 SM Corcoran
Frank Martilik Petitioner not present—no reason for late file
31033 Hollerich Drive given
Big Pine Key FL 33043 SM Corcoran
Judith McGill Did not receive mail—mail forwarded back&
7750 NW 25th Street#219 forth
Miami FL 33122 SM Corcoran
Thomas &Deborah Newman Wife failed to file petition during the time
829 Westshore Drive permitted
Summerland Key FL 33042 SM Corcoran
Scott Robins Petitioner not present—no reason given
230 5th Street SM Webster
Miami Beach FL 33139
Rory Rohan Petitioner not present—no reason given
900 Colony Point Circle Suite 310 SM Webster
Pembroke Pines FL
John T. Sangston Petitioner not present - documents considered
401 E Emma Street hearsay by PAO—no good cause shown
Key West FL 33040 SM Webster
2006 DENIED LATE FILED PETITIONS
by Special Magistrates
Name/Address Brief Reason
Gerhardt Schmitz Petitioner not present - documents considered
PO Box 622 hearsay by PAO—no good cause shown
Cape Canaveral FL 32920 SM McGrath
Carolyn &Daniel Seckinger Petitioner not present—no reason given
17 Bounty Lane SM Webster
Key Largo FL 33037
Richard Servais Has many other properties & did not realize the
329 Calzada deBougainvillea procedures to file
Marathon FL 33050 SM McGrath
Danette Baso Silvers Petitioner not present - documents considered
301 Avenue B hearsay by PAO—no good cause shown
Key West FL 33040 SM Webster
Mark & Marie Thompson Letter apologizing for missing date for filing
3776 Birchwood Drive SM McGrath
Rogers City MI 49779
Michael Tinnell Petitioner lost two family members—had
31232 Avenue D sufficient time to file
Big Pine Key FL 33043 SM Corcoran
Maria Fabre & Frank Valdes Petitioner not present—no reason given
87 Bernice Drive SM McGrath
Freehold NJ 07728
Gertrude Vural Petitioner not present—no reason given
20 Shalimar Boulevard#1003 SM Corcoran
Toronto Ontario Canada MSN
John &Daria Wagner Petitioner not present - did not see TRIM
15755 Lindbergh Lane Notice
Wellington FL 33414 SM McGrath
Timothy G. Wegman Petitioner not present - documents considered
702 Pearl Street hearsay by PAO—no good cause shown
Key West FL 33040 SM Webster
George H. Wilson, Jr. Medical reasons—good busy
28115 S Side Isle Creek Road SM McGrath
Trappe MD 21673
Thomas D. Wright Clients not present—no way to cross examine
PO Box 500309 SM McGrath
Marathon FL 33050 (representing 3 clients)
Alan& Lucille Zelinsky No reason given
256 Lagoon Drive SM Webster
Northfield IL 60093
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
Petition No. Name/Address Hearing Date Outcome
E003-2006 Peter A. Estenoz January 12th DENIED
3738 Eagle Avenue 1:00 p.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-0088
E006-2006 Allen P. Rossi December 12th NO SHOW
152 Palo deOro Drive 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-9883
E034-2006 James J. Goodroe December 18th NO SHOW
1601 Venetian Drive 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-9915
E038-2006 Harvey F. &Patricia L. Brion December 12th DENIED
500 Burton Drive#4306 9:00 a.m./KL
Tavernier FL 33070
E046-2006 Jeffrey A. Gambrazzio December 18th NO SHOW
27370 W Indies Drive 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Ramrod Key FL 33042
E048-2006 Shelley Bregman& December 18th DENIED
Emil Ourednik 1:00 p.m./KW
163 Barry Avenue
Little Torch Key FL 33042
(305) 872-0555
E051-2006 Claire C. Gorsuch January 11th GRANTED
413 Barry Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW
Little Torch Key FL 33042
(561) 351-0096
E060-2006 Harry Iwanyckyj January 11th GRANTED
3905 Mary Road 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-0572
E061-2006 Susan Doyle January 22nd GRANTED
%Siemon & Larsen PA 9:00 a.m./M
J. Michael Marshall
433 Plaza Real, Suite 339
Boca Raton FL 33432
(561) 368-3808
E062-2006 Warrick William LED Retained January 11th GRANTED
Income Trust No.1 9:00 a.m./KW
%John H. Pelzer, Esquire
Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster
&Russell PA
PO Box 1900
Ft.Laurderdale FL 33302
(954) 527-2469
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E065-2006 Malcom A. Leonard December 12th GRANTED
%Robert C. Stober, Esquire 9:00 a.m./KL
Hershoff Lupino & Yagel LLP
90130 Old Highway
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-8440
E066-2006 Mary Andrejek December 12th DENIED
PO Box 378555 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
E068-2006 John Gebhardt January 11th DENIED
1731 Seminary Road 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(561) 248-4321
E072-2006 Stefan Hunter as Trustee of January 11th DENIED
The Stefan Hunter Living Trust 9:00 a.m./KW
2 Go Lane
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-1323
E077-2006 Alfred S. &Yesmin B. Naranjo January l lth NO SHOW
13250 SW 104th Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Miami FL 33176
(786) 295-2870
E083-2006 Nancy Havens January 1 lth NO SHOW
%Frank P. Iannuzzi, CPA 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
1175 W Long Lake Road, Suite 201
Troy MI 48098
(248) 641-0005
E086-2006 Kevin G. Kliza January 11 th DENIED
3930 S Roosevelt Blvd. 109W 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-1299
E089-2006 Andrew Lippi January 11th GRANTED
32 Driftwood Drive 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 923-6480
E092-2006 Darlene Nelson December 12th GRANTED &
%James Lupino, Esquire 9:00 a.m./KL SOH
90130 Old Highway REINSTATED
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-8440
E095-2006 Robert W. Werthamer December 12th DENIED
169 Sebring Drive 9:00 a.m./KL
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-4141
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E096-2006 Caryn I. Schlesinger January 11 th GRANTED
1800 Atlantic Boulevard C319 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-8158
E097-2006 Laura Amendola January 22nd DENIED
5000 NW 100th Terrace 9:00 a.m./M
Coral Springs FL 33076
(954) 340-7874
E099-2006 Bernadette Restino Noe December 12th GRANTED
139 Stinger Road 9:00 a.m./KL
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-5936
E100-2006 Michael & Debra Malone December 12th GRANTED
109 San Juan Drive 9:00 a.m./KL
Plantation Key FL 33036
(305) 664-5436
E101-2006 Valli B. Leone December 12th GRANTED
364 King Avenue 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 453-9639 or(305) 772-3073
E102-2006 Brian J. Holden January 11th DENIED
1309 Newton Street 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-1010
E103-2006 Wayne A. VanDenHandel January 1 1th DENIED
846 Gulf Drive 9:00 a.m./KW
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 849-1794
E104-2006 Bruce E. Moore January 11 th DENIED
1429 Johnson Street 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 295-0847
E105-2006 Robert Mongelli January 11th DENIED
908 Trinity Drive #3 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-3207
E106-2006 Laurel D. Marsh January 22nd GRANTED
716 26th Street Ocean 9:00 a.m./M 100%Disability
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-6375
E107-2006 Craig Rodney Brogli January 11th DENIED
1611 United Street 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 295-9890
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E108-2006 Kenneth E. Brogli, Jr. January 12th DENIED
5442 5th Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-6990
E111-2006 Bruce Telhiard December 12th DENIED
1524 Aqueduct Lane 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(786) 547-6010
E112-2006 Jose L. & Elida C. Gonzalez December 12th DENIED
175 Tampa Drive 9:00 a.m./KL
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-4192
E113-2006 William &Kathleen Harrigan December 13th GRANTED
148 Bahama Avenue 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-6086
El 14-2006 Randy E. Flynn December 13th GRANTED
14 Mangrove Lane 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 215-0893
E117-2006 Edward T. Olszewski December 13th GRANTED
807 S Jade 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 853-7063
E119-2006 Kerri & Joseph Walbroehl January 12th GRANTED
29035 Bigonia Drive 9:00 a.m./KW 100%Disability
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 304-6513
E120-2006 Angel V. Fernandez December 13th DENIED
816 S Jade Drive 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-4412
E121-2006 Michael G. McCall December 13th DENIED
426 4th Road 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-9415
E122-2006 Peter I. Brown January 12th DENIED
PO Box 430104 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-4747
E123-2006 Cheryl D. Sargent January 12th NO SHOW
235 W Cahill Court 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-1579
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E124-2006 The Evelyn Miscella Family December 13th GRANTED
Rev.Trust 9:00 a.m./KL W/SOH CAP
81 Lakeshore Drive
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 766-3254
E126-2006 Kevin Dalton January 12th NO SHOW
1209 Johnson Street 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(754) 224-1704
El 27-2006 Gary Land January 12th DENIED
16781 Cypress Road 9:00 a.m./KW
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8418
E128-2006 Scott Wile December 13th DENIED
569 Bonita Avenue 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(612) 209-0769
E129-2006 Barry L. Barroso, Jr. January 12th NO SHOW
5605 College Road #103 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(305) 304-1367
E130-2006 Harold S. Belew January 12th DENIED
27437 Tobago Lane 9:00 a.m./KW
Ramrod Key FL 33042
(305) 395-1085
E131-2006 Joyanne M. Scott January 12th DENIED
34 Palmetto Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(215) 806-9850
E132-2006 Kelly Castellanos January 12th GRANTED
2819 Staples Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-0444
E133-2006 Kenneth B. Nichols January 12th NO SHOW
PO Box 420323 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 745-1414
E134-2006 Ruth Ashe January 12th DENIED
308 Julia Street 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-5521
E135-2006 Donald Wayne Knigge January 12th DENIED
2 Ibis Lane 9:00 a.m./KW
Geiger Key FL 33040
(305) 797-5949
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E136-2006 Timothy Weaver January 12th DENIED
%Wayne Kruer 9:00 a.m./KW
600 Whitehead Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-4184
El37-2006 Robert &Albert Kluck January 22nd DENIED
151 Avenue G 9:00 a.m./M
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-5481
E138-2006 Peter& Suzanne Adorno January 12th NO SHOW
30356 Killdeer Lane 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-7090
E140-2006 Michael Sean Sullivan January 12th GRANTED
1800 Atlantic Blvd. A102 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 394-6167
E141-2006 Robert R. & Diane R. Hills January 12th DENIED
15410 Old State Road 4A 9:00 a.m./KW
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 744-0859
E142-2006 Gwen M. Burns January 22nd DENIED
412 122nd Street Gulf 9:00 a.m./M
Marathon FL 33050
(810) 334-3696
E144-2006 Patricia Sage Popovich December 13th DENIED
128 E Ridge Road Box 202 9:00 a.m./KL
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 853-5773
E150-2006 Jeff Neidlinger January 12th DENIED
30854 Ortega Lane 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 481-0240
E151-2006 Wayne Buchanan January 22nd NO SHOW
81 SW 5th Street 9:00 a.m./M DENIED
Pompano Beach FL 33060
(954) 943-6370
E152-2006 Vicki L. Pietig December 13th DENIED
96000 Overseas Highway Unit I2 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(612) 242-1702
E153-2006 Robert & Geraldine Fiorile January 12th DENIED
3915 Diane Road 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-7665
2006 EXEMPTION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E155-2006 Edward W. Lowe DENIED
53 Indies Road
Ramrod Key FL 33042
(305) 923-4251
El 56-2006 Edwin B. Koressel DENIED
4102 Coverbrooke Court
Louisville KY 40220
(859) 433-6435
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
Petition No. Name/Address Hearing Date Outcome
R007-2006 Britt J. & William Lemon January 29th DENIED
123 W Cahill Court 9:00 a.m./KW
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-7911
R009-2006 Tamara Leach February 13th Referred to
35 Snapper Avenue 9:00 a.m./KL CAY
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-0792
R015-2006 Mike Hasty February 6th DENIED
112 Key Drive 9:00 a.m./M
Brunswick GA 31520
(912) 264-2765
R033-2006 John V. Battillo January 29th DENIED
55 Boca Chica Road Lot 420 9:00 a.m./KW
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-5923
R042-2006& Stephanie Coffer January 29th R042 WD
R043-2006 22937 Port Royal Lane 9:00 a.m./KW R043 DENIED
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-9952
R048-2006 William &Rochelle Marceau February 13th NO SHOW
132 Harbor Lane 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-2555
R049-2006 Brice Brown February 6th DENIED
403 Harbour Drive 9:00 a.m./M
Duck Key FL 33050
(954) 728-9900 X206
R053-2006 Ronald Crockett January 29th DENIED
PO Box 420131 9:00 a.m./KW
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 304-5518
R058-2006 Anna Aboltins January 29th DENIED
%Drusilla Fox 1:00 p.m./KW
29171 Iris Drive
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-3011
R071-2006 Susan Taylor January 29th DENIED
22837 Calico Jack Circle 1:00 p.m./KW
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 744-0926
R072-2006 Thomas R. &June M. Kozitza January 29th DENIED
530 Seminole Drive 1:00 p.m./KW
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(763) 786-3625
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R077-2006 John J. Murphy January 29th NO SHOW
3967 Venna Road 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(954) 492-3457
R079-2006 Joseph F. Becker January 29th NO SHOW
11 Rigby Court 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Wayne NJ 07470
(973) 628-0654
R081-2006 Dennis & Helen Owens February 13th NO SHOW
6638 Newport Lake Cirlc 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Boca Raton FL 33496
(561) 271-4497
R092-2006 Vaca Key Properties, Inc. February 6th DENIED
Karen Dennis, President 9:00 a.m./M
3520 Overseas Highway
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-6519
R093-2006 Richard L. Phillips February 6th NO SHOW
R094-2006 PO Box 198 1:00 p.m./M DENIED
Oxford MI 48371 Reschedule to
(248) 505-4058 2/13
R107-2006 William S. Magenau February 6th NO SHOW
PO Box 9 1:00 p.m./M DENIED
Churchton MD 20733
(410) 320-3121
R114-2006 Walter F. &April Bennett Stone January 30th DENIED
2521 Broadway#205 9:00 a.m./KW
Boulder CO 80304
(303) 449-0175
R120-2006 Olga&Raoul E. Hernandez February 13th NO SHOW
35 Prospect Drive 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Coral Gables FL 33133
(305) 298-1586
R123-2006 Elisabeth P. Fennell January 30th DENIED
37 Summer Hill 9:00 a.m./KW
Newport KY 41071
(859) 912-2562
R127-2006 Robert& Lenora Singer Schur February 15th DENIED
108 Coral Way 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-5152
R130-2006 Alan& Angie Gross January 30th NO SHOW
20716 Fifth Avenue W 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(605) 973-2356
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R136-2006 Raymond G. Strable, Sr. February 6th NO SHOW
420 9th Street 1:00 p.m./M DENIED
Key Colony Beach FL 33051-0723
(305) 289-1616
R138-2006& Orestes Gutierrez January 30th NO SHOW
R139-2006 PO Box 421156 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-6684
R140-2006& Rodolfo Martinez January 30th NO SHOW
R141-2006 16817 NW 91st Court 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Hialeah FL 33018
(305) 512-0497
R143-2006 William Dudziak & January 30th NO SHOW
Emily McClintock 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
4130 NE 31st Avenue
Lighthouse Point FL 33064-8439
(954) 943-0274
R164-2006 to David F. Kozak February 7th NO SHOW
R168-2006 1580 Hogan Avenue 9:00 a.m./M DENIED
Chesterton IN 46304
(219) 405-9064
R196-2006 Charles F. Roberts January 30th NO SHOW
5585 2"d Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(305) 304-0481
R203-2006 Mary Lin Johnson January 30th DENIED
21601 Old State 4A 1:00 p.m./KW
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-3100
R209-2006 Francis J. Cuneo, Jr. February 7th NO SHOW
232 North Washington 9:00 a.m./M DENIED
St.Naperville IL 60540
(630) 961-3101
R214-2006 Alida Rodriguez January 30th DENIED
2386 Palm Road 1:00 p.m./KW
W Palm Beach FL 33406
(561) 512-3124
R245-2006 David &Joan Bittner January 30th DENIED
5050 SW 168th Avenue 1:00 p.m./KW
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33331
(954) 261-6324
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R247-2006 Robert &Astrid Dublis February 7th DENIED
2480 Coco Plum Drive 1:00 p.m./M
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-0002
R282-2006 Priscilla Davis January 31st NO SHOW
R283-2006 1605 Jamaica Drive 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
R284-2006 Key West FL 33040
(305) 849-1689
R292-2006 Alfred L. Frith January 31st DENIED
Rissman, Barrett, Hurt PA 9:00 a.m./KW
201 E Pine Street 5th Floor
Orlando FL 32801
(407) 839-0120
R296-2006 Henry M. Prior January 31st DENIED
1865 NW 108th Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW
Plantation FL 33322
(954) 538-4406
R324-2006 John Michael Ramsey January 31St NO SHOW
104 Morganscliff Court 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Chapel Hill NC 27517-8382
(919) 619-4324
R402-2006 Ralph DePalma January 31St NO SHOW
11 Aquamarine Drive 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-5858
R406-2006 Robert E. Highsmith January 31St NO SHOW
3820 Eagle Avenue 1:00 p.m./KW DENIED
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-8851 Ext.12
R459-2006& Ileana Cabrera-Rodriguez February 13th NO SHOW
R460-2006 7420 SW 66th Street 1:00 p.m./KL DENIED
Miami FL 33143
(305) 529-9966
R462-2006 Ray F. Wood January 31st Rescheduled
3912 Mary V Road 1:00 p.m./KW Withdrawn 3/7/2007
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-0082
R483-2006 Peter& Suzanne Adorno February 1st NO SHOW
30356 Killdeer Lane 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-7090
R486-2006 Kenneth R. Smith February 15th NO SHOW
100 Palm Lane 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 393-2883
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R487-2006 Norma Ledesma February 15th DENIED
811 Narragansett Lane 9:00 a.m./KL
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 801-3157
R493-2006 Rebecca Ritter February 15th NO SHOW
77420 Overseas Highway 9:00 a.m./KL DENIED
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 681-1278
R522-2006 Reynaldo L. &Vivianne M. Alvarez February 8th NO SHOW
132 Pinecrest Drive 1:00 p.m./M DENIED
Miami Springs FL 33166
(305) 216-7461
R524-2006& Jorge P. Rovirosa February 15th NO SHOW
R525-2006 PO Box 011254 1:00 p.m./KL DENIED
Miami FL 33101
(305) 775-3223
R527-2006 Luis &Flora Landin February 15th DENIED
11275 SW 43rd Terrace 1:00 p.m./KL
Miami FL 33165
(305) 951-0016
R536-2006 Barbara A. Wilber February 1st NO SHOW
29682 Forrestal Avenue 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-0371
R543-2006& WC Ventures LLC February 15th NO SHOW
R544-2006 4417 Tamarack Drive 1:00 p.m./KL DENIED
Sharpsville PA 16150
(724) 962-9790
R546-2006 Kathleen Edgerton & February 1st DENIED
Wayne Jessup 9:00 a.m./KW
1933 Coral Gardens Drive
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33306
(954) 563-6945
R551-2006 Sandra R. Johnson February 15th DENIED
2411 NE 31st Court 1:00 p.m./KL
Lighthouse Point FL 33064
(954) 941-0250
R559-2006 Kathryn J. Malone February 1st NO SHOW
PO Box 348 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Howell MI 48844
(810) 750-2618
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R568-2006 Salvatore V. & Deborah M. Lentine February 1st NO SHOW
27 Lindbergh Road 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Ringoes NJ 08551
(609) 466-3693
R572-2006 Bradley K. & Loretta Baker February 1st NO SHOW
20712 2nd Avenue W 9:00 a.m./KW DENIED
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8897
R595-2006 Gary Lee Mandolfo February 1st DENIED
1915 Park Avenue 1:00 p.m./KW
Omaha NE 68105
(402) 871-3339
R606-2006 Lawrence J. Bernazani Requested not to be NO SHOW
32 Johnson Street scheduled DENIED
Malden MA 02148-2971 February 1st
_ (781) 322-0383 1:00 p.m./KW
R611-2006 Richard R. & Sharon M. Renk February 1 st DENIED
6694 Wilburn Road 1:00 p.m./KW
Sun Prairie WI 53590
(608) 837-6828
R615-2006 Rafael Mendoza February 1st DENIED
6785 SW 40th Street 1:00 p.m./KW
Miami FL 33155
(305) 740-4444
R619-2006& Joseph &Elizabeth Yanello NO SHOW
R620-2006 46 Ocean Drive DENIED
The Harborage
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-9719
R621-2006 Frank Schmidt DENIED
2513 NE 27th Street
Lighthouse Point FL 33064
(954) 782-8293
R622-2006 Salvatore Gutierrez, Jr. DENIED
PO Box 368
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 896-5930
R625-2006 Thomas Robert NO SHOW
31231 Hibiscus Drive DENIED
Big Pine Key FL 33043
*Overseas Military*
•
2006 VALUATION PETITIONS
Special Magistrate Findings
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R626-2006& Jean-Sebastian Gros NO SHOW
R627-2006 5000 Godfrey Road DENIED
Coral Springs FL 33067
(954) 684-0855
R628-2006 George Wayne Williams DENIED
8205 Inverstone Lane
Raleigh NC 27606
(919) 859-3116
R630-2006 Rudy&Roseann Krause DENIED
26351 State Road 4A
Ramrod Key FL 33043
(305) 395-1876
R634-2006 Christopher& Crystina Bass DENIED
PO Box 432145
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-2033