01/12/2006 Final Meeting MINUTES OF THE 2005/5
MONROE COUNTY
VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Value Adjustment Board
Marathon Government Annex
Thursday, January 12, 2006
The Final Meeting of the Monroe County Value Adjustment Board convened at 10:00
a.m., on the above date, at the Marathon Government Center, 2798 Overseas Highway,
Marathon. Present and answering to roll call were School Board Member Andy Griffiths, Mayor
Charles "Sonny" McCoy, Commissioner David Rice, School Board Member Walker, and
Chairman George Neugent. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk of the Court; Pamela
Hancock, Deputy Clerk; Richard Collins, County Attorney; John C. Dent, Attorney for the
Property Appraiser.
All stood for the Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by School Board Member
Griffiths to approve the Minutes of the September 27, 2005 Organizational Meeting of the Value
Adjustment Board. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by School Board Member
Griffiths to hear Petition No. E147-2005 Kenneth Sherer. Roll call vote was unanimous. John
Dent, Attorney for the Property Appraiser and Richard Collins, County Attorney addressed the
Board. Mr. Sherer addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner
Rice and seconded by School Board Member Walker to accept the Special Magistrate's
Recommendations. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by School Board Member Walker and seconded by Commissioner
Rice to hear Petition No. E094-2005 Mark Kresser, represented by Samuel Kaufmann, Esquire.
Roll call vote was unanimous. Mr. Kaufmann and Betty Kresser addressed the Board. After
discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy to remand
the Recommended Final Order of the Special Magistrate back to the Special Magistrate to be
rewritten in accordance with the provisions of Rule 12D-10.003 Florida Administrative Code,
and to have this done within 10 days of receipt by the Special Magistrate. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Duncan Mathewson read a brief statement into the record.
Motion was made by School Board Member Walker and seconded by School Board
Member Griffiths to hear Petition No. E127-2005 Vincent Tubiana, accompanied by David
Hutchinson, Esquire. Roll call vote was unanimous. Mr. Hutchinson addressed the Board.
After discussion, motion was made by Mayor McCoy and seconded by School Board Member
Griffiths to remand back to the Special Magistrate for a re-hearing to allow for additional
information to be placed into the record. Roll call vote was unanimous.
2005/6
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy granting
approval of the Special Magistrate recommendations for the 2005 Homestead Petitions, except
for those remanded back to the Special Magistrate (Petition Nos. E094-2005 and E127-2005).
Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached and made part of the record (attachment 1).
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy to hear
Petition No. R050-2005 Robert Grant. Motion carried unanimously. Mr. Grant addressed the
Board. After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor
McCoy to accept the Special Magistrate's Recommendations. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by School Board Member Walker and seconded by Commissioner
Rice to hear Petition No. R063-2005 Roger Akers. Motion carried unanimously. Mr. Akers and
Sandra Henning addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by School Board
Member Walker and seconded by Mayor McCoy to remand this back and request that a physical
examination of the property be made to determine which one of these drawings/maps may be
questioned. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Robert Dublis and Kathy Katherine, Petition Nos. R199-2005 & R200-2005, addressed
the Board. Mr. Dent and Mr. Collins addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made
by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy to uphold the Special Magistrate's
Finding in regards to the substantial completion. Roll call vote was unanimous. Motion was
then made by School Board Member Walker and seconded by Mayor McCoy to remand the
issue of land value back to the Special Magistrate. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy to hear
Petition No. R154-2005 Fredrik Endemann. Motion carried unanimously. Mr. Endemann
addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by School Board Member Walker and
seconded by Mayor McCoy to accept the Special Magistrate's Recommendations. Roll call vote
was unanimous.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor McCoy granting
approval of the Special Magistrate recommendations for the 2005 Real Property Petitions, except
for those remanded back to the Special Magistrate (Petition Nos. R063-2005 and R154-2005).
Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached and made part of the record (attachment 2).
Motion was made by School Board Member Griffiths and seconded by School Board
Member Walker granting approval of the Expenditures of the Value Adjustment Board. Motion
carried unanimously.
The approval of Certification of Tax Roll, County Attorney's Item, and discussion and
direction on the Auditor General's County Value Adjustment Boards Performance Audit, dated
July 2005 will be continued to the next scheduled Final Meeting.
•
•
2005/7
There being no further business to come before the Board the meeting was adjourned.
Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
of Monroe County
by: C
Pamela/A-.-v“-e6/41•-u-(4-e-k.
. Hancock
Deputy Clerk
AGENDA ITEM . C
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E001-2005 Keith Orman (PO Box 310) PAO
409 S Coconut Palm Boulevard Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-3683
E002-2005 Diane Wood PAO
1202 VonPhister Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-8058
E003-2005 Susan Lynn Williams Howanitz PAO
809 Ashe Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-2931
E004-2005 Paul A. Stabile PAO
4 Verde Drive (Big Coppitt Key) Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 766-9119
E005-2005 Tami Lynn Condella PAO
1201 17th Terrace Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-7048 _
E006-2005 John R. Dillon PAO
1507 19th Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-7254
E007-2005 David Hofmann PAO
322 Burton Drive Granted
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 853-3032
E008-2005 Daniel J. Donovan PAO
265 Lee Avenue Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-5196
E009-2005 Samantha Marie Curry PAO
79901 Overseas Highway Apt. 102 Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 664-8271 or (239) 565-3814
E010-2005 Melanie Gantt PAO
81 John Silver Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 394-0426
E011-2005 Craig K. Stephens PAO
122 Columbus Drive Granted
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 481-0045
Revised January 6, 2006
Attachment 1
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E012-2005 Grace Jones Community Center, Inc. PAO
230 41st Street Gulf Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 743-6064
E013-2005 James R. & Unnur Dora Potash PAO
79901 Overseas Highway, Unit 309 Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 664-2205
E014-2005 Charles Baker, Jr. Disability denied PAO
31108 Avenue J 12/13 Key West Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn
(305) 872-1377
E015-2005 Georgette Calogeras PAO
29136 Allamanda Lane Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn
(305) 872-0719
E016-2005 Tania Keller PAO
19524 Navajo Street Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 745-2809
E017-2005 Enrique Piwko PAO
245 Atlantic Boulevard Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 281-6700
E018-2005 Nancy P. Wozniak PAO
1351 20th Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-8765
E019-2005 Wyland PAO
134 Plantation Boulevard Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 852-4212
E020-2005 Raymond E. Missell PAO
1032 Gibraltar Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 394-0298
E021-2005 George Hanna PAO
2916 Riviera Drive Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-7738
E022-2005 Marjorie L. Grossman PAO
133 Navajo Street Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-3188
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E023-2005 Roger G. Gomez PAO
1219 Mockingbird Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-1815
E024-2005 Selwyn L. Joseph PAO
3203 Pearl Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-5961
E025-2005 Denice & Frank Bellido deLuna PAO
2824 Staples Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-5471
E026-2005 Deborah A. Turner PAO
6099 Overseas Highway#4W Granted
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-2228
E027-2005 Clarice Yentsch 12/13 Key West Show -
506 Bahama Street Denied
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-7174
E028-2005 Elaine L. Carey PAO
%Ed Salazar Granted
905 Truman Avenue Withdrawn
Key West FL 33040
(305) 304-0762
E029-2005 Terese Brown PAO
4290 Filer Cove Road Granted
Big Torch Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 872-7608
E030-2005 Evelyn Hansen Gigante PAO
%Dixie Doll Shop Granted
3499 N Dixie Highway Withdrawn
Oakland Park FL 33334
(954) 537-9325
E031-2005 Michael T. Gorton PAO
17274 LaBrisa Lane Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 744-0335 (has other contact #s)
E032-2005 James D. Wright PAO
PO Box 430315 Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 395-1546
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E033-2005 Thomas A. & Velia G. Vellanti PAO
209 Harbor Drive Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 852-9225
E034-2005 Leslie E. Dudley& PAO
Suzanne Bryant Dudley Granted
108 Golf Club Drive
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-1329
E035-2005 Kathryn Rodriguez, guardian for PAO
Alexander C. Marelia Granted
160 E Ridge Road Withdrawn
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 852-4165
E036-2005 Linda F. Saladino PAO
32 Flamingo Hammock Road Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 517-9633
E037-2005 Ronald G. Anderson PAO
76 Colson Drive Granted
Summerland Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-1965
E038-2005 Clement DiFillippo PAO
557 Ocean Cay Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 672-6312
E039-2005 Habitat for Humanity of Key West & 12/13 Key West Withdrawn
Lower Florida Keys, Inc. @ Meeting
PO Box 421003
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 872-4456
E040-2005 Ronny Howell PAO
311 Janet Place Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 896-1507
E041-2005 Constance Gilbert PAO
226 Julia Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 295-9466
E042-2005 Lowell Morgan PAO
274 Jasmine Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 872-0653
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E043-2005 Virginia Roach Miller Trustee Liv.Trust PAO
2009 Harris Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-5839
E044-2005 Philip A. & Lynn E. West 12/13 Key West Show -
1 Tiburon Circle Denied
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-4433
E045-2005 William S. Benson PAO
17216 Bonita Lane E Granted
Sugarloaf Shores FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 923-6114
E046-2005 Elizabeth& Timothy Estes PAO
72 W Plaza Granada Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 664-0595
E047-2005 Joseph E. Chernay 12/13 Key West No Show -
919 Bay Drive Denied
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-9166
E048-2005 Arthur& Seda Terzian PAO
105 Creek House Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
E049-2005 Steve Vetter 11/01 Key Largo Withdrawn
Key Largo Baptist @ Meeting
835 Largo Road
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-1642
E050-2005 Frederick W. Flancher 11/01 Key Largo No Show
108 Atlantic Lane Denied
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-4078
E051-2005 Linda Lee Sawart PAO
778 Canal Street Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 731-9066
E052-2005 Christopher C. Blatt PAO
3314 Northside Drive#101 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 293-0834
E053-2005 Gerardo Pin PAO
120 Key Heights Drive Granted
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-3552
Revised January 6, 2006
•
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E054-2005 Carlos & Elizabeth Rodriguez PAO
3 Aster Terrace Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 304-6128
E055-2005 Alice J. Cunius PAO
3930 S Roosevelt Boulevard N401 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-9098
E056-2005 Pedro J. & Jennifer A. Rubiales PAO
310 Belmont Lane Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(786) 229-3159
E057-2005 James A. Harrold PAO
320 Admirals Lane Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-0254
E058-2005 Ed Murphy PAO
159 Peach Avenue Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 853-1739
E059-2005 Albert F. Wirth PAO
29875 Ocean Lane Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-3465
E060-2005 Gerald O. Ryan PAO
55 Boca Chica Road #421 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-5786
E061-2005 Kelly Friend PAO
710 Galveston Lane Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-4817
E062-2005 Cynthia Sutton PAO
808 South Street #4 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-0322
E063-2005 Stephen J. Compas 11/01 Key Largo PAO
766 Largo Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 453-5429
E064-2005 Gregory Sousa PAO
1117 Grinnell Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 923-9183
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E065-2005 Richard J. Willingmyre PAO
29114 Guava Lane Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn
(610) 587-1869
E066-2005 Soni M. Stoye PAO
31566 Avenue B Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn
(305) 872-9610
E067-2005 Ann Olsen 12/13 Key West Show -
23971 Henry Street Denied
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-1952
E068-2005 Christopher Sclichter 12/14 Key West By phone -
PSC 277 Box 226 Denied
APO AP 96549-0200
011-612-62864305 (Overseas)
E069-2005 Timothy J. & Deborah R. Crowe 12/14 Key West Withdrawn
1707 Patricia Street by phone
Key West FL 33040
(305) 804-6022
E070-2005 Bruce Woodward PAO
833 Eisenhower Drive#103 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-1685
E071-2005 North Key Largo Utility Corporation Withdrawn
to E075-2005 David C. Ritz, President
24 Dockside Lane#512
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 367-3067
E076-2005 Sarah Brawer PAO
8980 Ocean Terrace Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 289-0516
E077-2005 Gail Wren PAO
27448 Haiti Lane Granted
Summerland Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 872-0203
E078-2005 Arnaldo A. Boza, Jr. PAO
6800 Maloney Avenue#20 Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-9153
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E079-2005 Stephanie Gilderman Withdrawn
138 N Rolling Hill Road
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-6490
E080-2005 Rahkmaan S. Harris PAO
1017 17th Terrace Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-9439
E081-2005 Karl Kasl 11/01 Key Largo No Show -
37 N Bounty Lane rescheduled to 12/6 Denied
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-3448
E082-2005 Dorothy Stunder Withdrawn
%Kenneth Hock
1213 14th Street Lot 122
Key West FL 33040
(305) 797-5168
E083-2005 Gerald D. Scott 12/14 Key West Withdrawn
31 Maple Lane by phone
Selbyville DE 19975 12/07
(302) 436-8119 - May to October
817 Bay Drive
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-1477 -November to April
E084-2005 Rusk Corporation Inc. 11/01 Key Largo Show
Mark Eugina, President Denied
9767 Overseas Highway
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 453-4219
E085-2005 700 North Emerald Drive Withdrawn
%Silver Shores, Inc.
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-5940
E086-2005 Cathy L. & Darell R. Matlock, Jr. 12/14 Key West Show -
3708 Palmetto Street w/cavaet to remove Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Tulsa HX
(305) 872-0656
E087-2005 Maryann J. Warren 11/01 Key Largo Show
829 Bonito Lane Denied
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 294-1427
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E088-2005 Timothy M. Leonard Withdrawn
31035 Avenue C
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 304-0745
E089-2005 Oval Office Investments, LLC Withdrawn
%William K. Crispin
93351 Overseas Highway#3
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-2775
E090-2005 Adrian S. Morera 11/17 Key Largo Show -
108 5th Lane rescheduled to 12/5 Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Key Largo
(305) 510-9252
E091-2005 Susan S. Doyle 11/7 Marathon Show -
102 Indies Drive N Granted
Duck Key FL 33050
E092-2005 M/A Com, Inc. 11/10 Marathon No Show
Attention: Dave Boyer Denied
Tax Department 38/58
PO Box 3608
Harrisburg PA 17105-3608
(717) 986-5604
E093-2005 Arthur R. Kara PAO
918 Cornish Lane #2 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-2653
E094-2005 Mark Kresser 12/14 Key West Show -
%Samuel Kaufman Denied
501 Whitehead Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-3926
E095-2005 Mark E. Schaeding 11/7 Marathon No Show
6099 Overseas Highway Lot 88E Denied
Marathon FL 33050
(989) 529-3568
E096-2005 Gaston Cairo 11/17 Key Largo Withdrawn
%Kurt Von Gonten, Esquire rescheduled to 12/5
Hershoff& Lupino LLP
90130 Old Highway
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-8440
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E097-2005 Robert S. Hill 12/14 Key West Withdrawn
22820 Blackbeard Lane
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-9095
E098-2005 Clinton Jay Barras Withdrawn
210-6 Southard Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 295-9008
E099-2005 Mario C. Quintana 11/17 Key Largo PAO
477 Big Pine Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33137 Withdrawn
(305) 971-3710
E100-2005 Jack Farran Withdrawn
30917 Malaga Lane
Big Pine Key FL 33043
E101-2005 Damian Waldner PAO
2409 Fogarty Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 923-4460
E102-2005 Peter C. Kouris 11/7 Marathon Withdrawn
6099 Overseas Highway Lot 47E @ Meeting
Marathon FL 33050
E103-2005 Thomas J. & Janice G. Hilliard PAO
213 Bristol Court Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-8979
E104-2005 Arlene Mathewson 11/17 Key Largo Show -
21 Jewfish Avenue rescheduled to 12/5 Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Key Largo
(305) 664-6343
E105-2005 Ocean Reef Cultural Center, Inc. PAO
200 Anchor Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
E106-2005 Dan Duimstra 11/7 Marathon No Show -
54 Seaview Avenue rescheduled to 12/6 Denied
Marathon FL 33050 Key Largo
(863) 444-1688
E107-2005 Sara Whitman 11/7 Marathon Show
%Franklin D. Greenman, Esquire Granted
5800 Overseas Highway Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E108-2005 Richard W. Hatch PAO
Suanne Kitchar Granted
1701 White Street Withdrawn
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-6697
E109-2005 Carol M. & Robert C. Schweitzer 11/17 Key Largo No Show -
87200 Overseas Highway rescheduled to 12/6 Denied
Executive Bay Club K1
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 852-9224
El 10-2005 R. Duncan Mathewson III 12/15 Key West Show -
28509 Jolly Roger Drive Granted
Little Torch FL 33042
(305) 872-3090
E111-2005 James B. Holloway& 12/15 Key West PAO
Jacob Gonzalez Granted
1011 Truman Avenue
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-9343
E 112-2005 Wetherbee& Mary Stedman PAO
6099 Overseas Highway Lot 25W Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 743-8367
E113-2005 Emilio Saida PAO
1901 S Roosevelt Boulevard 405W Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
E114-2005A Pierre & Marguerite Digeon 11/7 Marathon Withdrawn
E114-2005B 899 Copa Doro
E114-2005C Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-0631
E115-2005 Jeanette deMoll 12/5 Key Largo Withdrawn
46 Lakeside Lane Unit A @ Meeting
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 367-2370
E 116-2005 Steven Liberatore PAO
47 Coral Way Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 587-4169
E117-2005 Steven Torrence 12/15 Key West PAO
43 First Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-2875
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
El 18-2005 Rebecca J. Tomlinson PAO
1045 Loggerhead Lane Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 587-8961
E119-2005 Richard Farina 12/15 Key West No Show -
1612 Washington Street Denied
Key West FL 33040
(738) 512-2476
E120-2005 David S. Andrews PAO
21 S Bounty Lane Granted
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 304-3938
E121-2005 Frank Trano 12/5 Key Largo No Show -
3178 Sea Grape Drive Denied
Hernando Beach FL 34607-3429
E122-2005 Michael C. Castillo 12/15 Key West Show -
E5 11th Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-8944
E123-2005 John J. Curlett, Jr. & 12/5 Key Largo Withdrawn
Christian A. Curlett
5 Caloosa Road
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 367-8818
E124-2005 Rita A. Linder& PAO
W. Perry Arnold Granted
%Jerry Coleman Withdrawn
201 Front Street Suite 203
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-3517
E125-2005 Robert G. Thixton PAO
%Jack M. Spottswood Granted
500 Fleming Street Withdrawn
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-1982
E126-2005 Ryan Elwell PAO
857 Copa D'Oro Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 289-7586
E127-2005 Vincent Tubiana 12/5 Key Largo Show-
900 Lobster Lane Denied
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-4987
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E128-2005 Billie G. Dionne PAO
213 Atlantic Boulevard Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-1464
E129-2005 Michael Ancheta 12/5 Key Largo Withdrawn
116 Camelot Drive
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-7384
E130-2005 Donald E. Blews 12/5 Key Largo Withdrawn
221 Normandy Drive
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-3925
E131-2005 Harry I. Iwanyckyj 12/15 Key West Show-
3905 Mary Road Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(586) 944-9686
E132-2005 Marjorie Paul & Douglas Shook PAO
2328 Harris Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-0601
E133-2005 Key West Film Society, Inc. 12/16 Key West Show -
PO Box 1283 Denied
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-5884
E134-2005 Jack Jelsema 12/6 Key Largo Withdrawn
19 Jolly Roger Drive
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 942-5627
E135-2005 Karen K. Cabanas Withdrawn
1407 Sun Terrace
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-5808
E136-2005 John& Lori Stensloff 11/10 Marathon Withdrawn
171 Sandy Avenue rescheduled to
Marathon FL 33050 12/16 Key West
(305) 743-9180
E137-2005 Alberto Guernica 12/6 Key Largo Show -
%Andrew M. Tobin Denied
PO Box 620
Tavernier FL 33070
E138-2005 Robert D. & Sydney D. Ming PAO
68 Tamarind Drive Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 797-4790
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E139-2005 Gloria J. Sellers PAO
805 First Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-2056
E140-2005 Leslie McComsey-Busche PAO
1607 Venetian Drive Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 304-7176
E141-2005 David F. Demarest PAO
50 Marion Avenue Granted
Sausalito CA 94965 Withdrawn
(415) 332-8517
E142-2005 Richard M. & Kelly J. Klitenick 12/16 Key West Withdrawn
2916 Harris Avenue
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-4101
E143-2005 Wayne Lame Smith & 12/16 Key West Withdrawn
Seth D. Corneal
333 Fleming Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-0029
E144-2005 Blas Mesa PAO
3635 Eagle Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-4666
E145-2005 Richard C. Pouch PAO
24 Dilly Tree Park Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 367-4659
E146-2005 Freda G. Vaughn 12/6 Key Largo Show -
124 Gumbo Limbo Drive Denied
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-1933
E147-2005 Kenneth M. Scherer 12/6 Key Largo Show -
200 Wrenn Street #409 Denied
Tavernier FL 33070
(843) 343-7111
E148-2005 D'Ascanie Investment Corporation 11/10 Marathon Withdrawn
11500 Overseas Highway reschedule to 12/6
Marathon FL 33050 Key Largo
E149-2005 Kim C. Moore 12/16 Key West Withdrawn
PO Box 157
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 304-8389
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Exemption Petitions
PETITION NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
E150-2005 Judith A. Jack 12/16 Key West Withdrawn
PO Box 421061
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 304-1413
E151-2005 Jeffrey P. Wilson 12/6 Key Largo Withdrawn
5 S Bounty Lane @ Meeting
Key Largo FL 33037
(800) 522-5133
E152-2005 Bruce Sonnenfeld 12/16 Key West Show -
14600 Old State Road 4A Denied
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 304-3023
E153-2005 Joe E. Rodriquez 12/16 Key West Withdrawn
1307 Elizabeth Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 292-3791
E154-2005 Trina Trenkenschuh 12/16 Key West PAO
391 46th Street Gulf Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 879-1900
E155-2005 Ronald Salisbury 12/16 Key West Continued to
%The Smith Law Firm 1/5/06
333 Fleming Street Show-
Key West FL 33040 Denied
(305) 296-0029
Revised January 6, 2006
• AGENDA ITEM . E
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R001-2005 Pierre & Marguerite Digeon Marathon 11/8 a.m. Withdrawn
Numbered as 899 Copa Doro
E114-2005 Marathon FL 33050
A,B&C (305) 743-0631
R002-2005 Jack O. Olofson KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
813 S Emerald Drive
Key Largo FL 33037
R003-2005 Joseph Saladino, Jr. Marathon 11/8 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 500102
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-5268
R004-2005 Timothy D. Holder KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
234 Mohawk Street
Tavernier FL 33070
R005-2005 John V. & Chiana F. Battik KWest 11/3 a.m. Withdrawn
55 Boca Chica Road Lot 420
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-5923
R006-2005 Elsie S. & Gerald Metcalf KWest 11/3 a.m. Withdrawn
22862 Lookdown Lane @ meeting
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8355
R007-2005 Frank Weisener KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
9117 SW 72nd Avenue
Miami FL 33156
(305) 665-5276
R008-2005 D & E Land Trust KWest 11/3 a.m. Show -
PO Box 108 Reschedule to Denied
Hanna IN 46340 Marathon 12/2 a.m.
(219) 797-4875
R009-2005 Steven C. Dunlap KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
152 Tequesta Street
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-0698
R010-2005 Dan Jones KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
R011-2005 Rash& Associates
R012-2005 PO Box 260888
Plano TX 75026-0888
(770) 393-8081
Revised January 6, 2006
Attachment 2
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R013-2005 Emily Graves KWest 11/3 a.m. Show-
3746 Driftwood Street rescheduled to Denied
Big Pine Key FL 33043 12/12 a.m. KW
(305) 872-4668
R014-2005 Richard J. Willingmyre KWest 11/3 a.m. Show
29114 Guava Lane Denied
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(610) 587-1869
R015-2005 David E. Addison Marathon 11/8 a.m. Show
1501 63rd Street W Ocean Denied
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-6463
R016-2005 Julie M. Schwartz KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
100 SE 2nd Street Suite 2900
Miami FL 33131
(305) 375-6582
R017-2005 Mark & Donna Proskine KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
128 Villabella
Islamorada FL 33036
(847) 446-4924
R018-2005 Southern Tax Services, Inc. KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
R019-2005 C.K. Cattanach, Agent
R020-2005 2210 Hollywood Boulevard
Hollywood FL 33020
(800) 358-2155
R021-2005 Daniel A. Weiss, Esquire KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
150 W Flagler Street-Penthouse 2850 rescheduled to
Miami FL 33130 12/12 a.m.
(305) 374-7850
R022-2005 David R. & Susan M. Murphy KWest 11/3 a.m. Withdrawn
1188 Basque Lane
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 744-9725
R023-2005 Susan M. Barnett KWest 11/3 a.m. Withdrawn
29115 Rose Drive by phone per
Big Pine Key FL 33043 petitioners
(305) 872-7500 request
R024-2005 to The Bernstein Law Office, P.A. KWest 12/12 a.m. All w/d
R032-2005 Roger M. Bernstein except R032
300 Sevilla Avenue, Suite 310 Show -
Coral Gables FL 33134 Denied
(305) 445-8500
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R033-2005 David Holwadel Withdrawn
PO Box 430281
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(954) 647-6728
R034-2005 Robert G. Williams Withdrawn
280 St.Thomas Avenue W Unit
Key Largo FL 33037
R035-2005 & Carrie Ryan KWest 11/3 a.m. No Show
R036-2005 PO Box 555 Denied
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-3769
R037-2005 & Robert L. Garcia, Controller KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
R037-2005 Parcel L Island Development Corp. &
A.B.C.D.E Marpalm of Florida Inc.
1000 Market Street, Bldg.1, Ste.300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R038-2005 Robert L. Garcia, Controller KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
DelMar Largo Inc. & Marina Key LLC
1000 Market Street, Bldg. 1, Ste.300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R039-2005 & Robert L. Garcia, Controller KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
R040-2005 RamKey LLC
1000 Market Street, Bldg. 1, Ste. 300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R041-2005 Robert L. Garcia, Controller KWest 12/12 a.m. No Show -
Ocean Properties LLC Denied
1000 Market Street, Bldg. 1, Ste. 300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R042-2005 Coher& Coher Investment Co., LTD. KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
8745 SW 109th Street
Miami FL 33136
(305) 279-3300
R043-2005 Assessment Technologies KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
through Stacey Deloney
R045-2005 800 Wilcrest Suite 103
Houston TX 77042
(713) 977-4197
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R046-2005 Harry Iwanyckyj KWest 11/3 a.m. Withdrawn
3905 Mary Road
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(586) 944-9686
R047-2005 Steven Capriolo KWest 11/3 p.m. Withdrawn
22766 Jolly Roger Drive
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(732) 929-3289
R048-2005 Donna Lorenzo KWest 11/3 p.m. Show
29023 Pine Avenue Denied
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-2189
R049-2005 Richard J. Lutz Withdrawn
468 Sawyer Drive
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8664
R050-2005 Robert L. Grant KWest 11/3 p.m. Show-
5704 Bradley Road Rescheduled to Denied
N Olmsted OH 44070 12/12 a.m.
(440) 777-3184
R051-2005 Steve M. Fraysher KLargo 11/29 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 877
Islamorada FL 33036
(970) 846-5903
R052-2005 Marr Resort Property Inc. Withdrawn
%Easley McCaleby& Associates
100 W Cypress Creek Rd., Ste.955
Fort Lauderdale FL 33309
(954) 938-8801
R053-2005 Robert J. Dickman KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
4500 LeJeune Road
Coral Gables FL 33146
(305) 667-8488
R054-2005 Garth Realty Corporation KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
through Bay Point Office Tower
R059-2005 4770 Biscayne Blvd., Ste. 670
Miami FL 33137
(305) 576-0033
R060-2005 Darrin L. Mitchell KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
Florida Property Tax Professionals
3700 34th Street Suite 200
Orlando FL 32805
(407) 835-7533
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R061-2005 Robert E. Scalfarotto KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
200 Wrenn Street Apt.203 rescheduled to by phone
Sea Gulls Condo. 12/12 a.m. PAO
Plantation Key FL 33070 adjusted
R062-2005 Wayne Hillen KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
9 Foxwood Court
Huntington Station NY 11746
(631) 271-6495
R063-2005 Roger Akers KWest 11/3 p.m. Show
HC 62 Box 42 Denied
Raton NM 87740
R064-2005 Nathaniel Ostroff KWest 11/3 p.m. No Show
1525 Shipsway Road Denied
Annapolis MD 21401
R065-2005 Philip Conrad Withdrawn
28230 County Road
Little Torch Key FL 33042
(305) 481-1409
R066-2005 John M. Albin Marathon 11/8 a.m. Withdrawn
71 Homewood Circle
Yarmouth Me 04096
(207) 846-9784 until 10/15
R067-2005 & Tim Hart Real Estate Services Withdrawn
R068-2005 2000 W Commercial Blvd., Ste.218
Fort Lauderdale FL 33309
(954) 202-9696
R069-2005 Deloitte Tax LLP KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
Barbara Fitzgerald
200 E Las Olas Boulevard, Ste. 1400
Fort Lauderdale FL 33301
(954) 728-3800
R070-2005 to Pier House Joint Venture KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
R072-2005 One Duval Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-4600
R073-2005 Thomas Newman KWest 11/3 p.m. Withdrawn
829 W Shore Drive
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 304-3820
R074-2005 David J. Pfent Withdrawn
through 512 Noah Lane
R077-2005 Key West FL 33040
(305) 923-4219
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R078-2005 & Spottswood Partners II Withdrawn
R079-2005 506 Fleming Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-8262
R080-2005 Flynn Smith KWest 11/3 p.m. Show
21136 Sunny Lane Denied
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-1176
R081-2005 Diane C. Chaplin Marathon 11/8 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 500832 Rescheduled to
Marathon FL 33050 Marathon 12/2 a.m.
(305) 743-6084
R082-2005 Charles Jamison Withdrawn
373 Barry Avenue
Little Torch Key FL 33042
(305) 872-2875
R083-2005 Maria Barth Withdrawn
1100 37th Street Gulf
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 731-7872
R084-2005 Curt Bruno Marathon 11/8 p.m. Withdrawn
58262 Howe Street
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-4469
R085-2005 Rafael Halim KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 970606
Miami FL 33197
(305) 218-7572
R086-2005 Michael S. Hagen, Agent Marathon 11/8 p.m. Withdrawn
TaxCuts Inc.
PO Box 07463
Fort Myers FL 33919
(239) 275-0808
R087-2005 & Areea Assessment Consultants, Inc. KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
R088-2005 2000 W Commercial Blvd., Ste. 218
Fort Lauderdale FL 33309
(954) 202-9696
R089-2005 Property Tax Professionals KWest 11/3 p.m. Withdrawn
4214 Northlake Boulevard Ste. B
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
(561) 627-6551
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R090-2005 & Nora Jones KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
R091-2005 2041 Sugarloaf Boulevard
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 744-0400
R092-2005 Benjamin P. Acker KWest 11/4 a.m. Show
27 Azalea Drive Denied
Key West FL 33040
(305) 849-0086 _ _
R093-2005 Mary Vaughn KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
through PO Box 52085 DC17
R100-2005 Phoenix AZ 85072
(612) 728-3422
R101-2005 Wayne F. & Margaret Guidotti Withdrawn
91 Fox Valley Lane
Glen Mills PA 19342
(484) 356-9444
R102-2005 Susan& Anthony Dimaria KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
4002 Hudson Terrace
Tampa FL 33618-5349
(813) 960-9698
R103-2005 Carolyn A. Bullock KWest 11/4 a.m. No Show
30378 Watson Boulevard Denied
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-0976
R104-2005 Mary L. Barley KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
%Steven R. Bechtel, Agent
PO Box 2854
Orlando FL 32802
(407) 425-9044
R105-2005 Mark Kielar Marathon 11/8 p.m. Show
1655 SW 2nd Avenue reschedule 12/2 Denied
Boca Raton FL 33432 Marathon a.m.
(561) 338-7477 ext. 406
R106-2005 Garth Realty Corporation KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
Bay Point Tower
4770 Biscayne Boulevard, Ste. 670
Miami FL 33137
(305) 576-0033
R107-2005 Riviera Enterprises, Inc. KWest 12/12 a.m. Show -
%The Bernstein Law Office Denied
300 Sevilla Avenue, Suite 310
Coral Gables FL 33134
(305) 445-8500
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R108-2005 & Robert E. Pernai KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
R109-2005 %Flanagan/Bilton
200 E Randolph Drive, Ste.6900
Chicago IL 60601
(312) 782-5000
R110-2005 Commercial Property Services, Inc. KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
through Sheila M. Anderson rescheduled to
R117-2005 PO Box 590899 12/12 a.m.
Virginia Gardens FL 33159-0899
(305) 871-0071
R118-2005 & Burr Wolff, LP KWest 12/12 a.m. Withdrawn
R119-2005 1355 Windward Concourse, Ste.200
Alpharetta GA 30005-8899
(678) 808-1605
R120-2005 Ann& Richard Olsen KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
23971 Henry Street
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-1952
R121-2005 William Murchie Marathon 11/8 p.m. No Show
6403 Tarawa Drive Denied
Sarasota FL 34241
(941) 371-6392
R122-2005 Douglas G. Mancosh Withdrawn
Pumpkin Cay Condo #9 33B
Key Largo FL 33037
(401) 490-4841
R123-2005 Monika Eichmann KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
%Property Tax Service Inc.
2221 Peachtree Road, Ste. D642
Atlanta GA 30309
(404) 875-2256
R124-2005 Marvin F. Poer& Co. KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
through Tony Garcia rescheduled to
R127-2005 351 S Cypress Road, Ste.404 11/29 a.m.
Pompano Beach FL 33060
(954) 788-8833
R128-2005 & R. Larry Rentz KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
R129-2005 121 Alhambra Plaza PH1 Ste. 1600
Coral Gables FL 33134
(305) 443-1000 ext.522
R130-2005 Holland Knowles Hight KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
1025 Dove Road
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-0400
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R131-2005 Mark Smith Marathon 11/8 p.m. No Show
1323 Avenue H PAO made
Marathon FL 33050 adjustment
R132-2005 Barbara Solares Withdrawn
492 SW 81st Avenue
Miami FL 33144
(786) 275-9045
R133-2005 Jiulio Margalli Withdrawn
1306 Virginia Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 295-9382
R134-2005 Christina J. Larsen Withdrawn
through 7990 Highway 29
R136-2005 Kelseyville CA 95451
(707) 279-1380
R137-2005 Stephen L. Spellman KWest 11/4 a.m. Show
7201 Pinehurst Parkway Denied
Chevy Chase MD 20815
(301) 565-4646
R138-2005 Christie B. Russell Withdrawn
1114 Olivia Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-0878
R139-2005 to Interselect, Inc. Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
R141-2005 PO Box 227436
Dallas TX 75222-7436
(214) 946-2185 #266
R142-2005 West Marine Products KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 969
Red Oak TX 75154
(972) 723-0666
R143-2005 Eileen Wetzler KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
1701 Rose Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-6340
R144-2005 Yvette Talbott KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
9 Evergreen Avenue
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-7403
R145-2005 Joanne E. Alexander, Controller KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
Sunset Ventures of Key West, Inc.
5555 College Road
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-7101
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R146-2005 Kitty Carson Rescheduled as Exemption
240 Atlantic Boulevard Exemption based Petition
Key Largo FL 33037 on her conversation
(305) 453-5191 w/Toby PAO
R147-2005 Henry Danzig KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
223 Mohawk Street
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-6199
R148-2005 Frank Harding Marathon 11/9 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 46
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 849-0513
R149-2005 Ernest F. Wuest Marathon 11/9 a.m. Withdrawn
1240 Coury Drive rescheduled to
Key Colony Beach FL 33051 12/12 a.m.
(305) 289-9530
R150-2005 D'Abros, Inc. Marathon 12/2 a.m. No Show
11500 Overseas Highway Denied
Marathon FL 33050
R151-2005 to D'Asign Developments, LLC Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
R153-2005 11500 Overseas Highway
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-7130 ext.179
R154-2005 Fredrik J. Endemann Marathon 12/2 a.m. Show -
PO Box 501231 rescheduled to Denied
Marathon FL 33050 12/12 a.m.
(847) 644-7791
R155-2005 Gregory& Gail Vestal KWest 11/4 a.m. Withdrawn
45 Munson Avenue
Ramrod Key FL 33042
(305) 872-0948
R156-2005 David L. Rasmussen Marathon 11/9 a.m. Show
7544 Gulfstream Boulevard Denied
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2514
R157-2005 to JoJo's of the Florida Keys LLC Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
R162-2005 %Franklin D. Greenman, Esquire
5800 Overseas Highway
Gulfside Village Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2351
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R163-2005 John J. & Julie K. Burns Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
%Franklin D. Greenman, Esquire
5800 Overseas Highway
Gulfside Village Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2351
R164-2005 to Jig's Investment LTD Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
R171-2005 %Franklin D. Greenman, Esquire
5800 Overseas Highway
Gulfside Village Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2351 _
R172-2005 & Franklin D. & Judy B. Greenman Withdrawn
R173-2005 5800 Overseas Highway
Gulfside Village Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2351
R174-2005 to Hill-Nardone Realty Trust Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
R177-2005 %Franklin D. Greenman, Esquire
5800 Overseas Highway
Gulfside Village Suite 40
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2351
R178-2005 Marjorie Mearns Marathon 11/9 a.m. Show
400 70th Street Denied
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-3420
R179-2005 Arthur J. Apkarian Marathon 11/9 a.m. Withdrawn
216 W Seaview Circle
Marathon FL 33050
(616) 299-0337
R180-2005 Osvaldo R. Orozco KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
1230 SW 20th Street
Miami FL 33145
R181-2005 Daisy R. Dawson Marathon 11/9 a.m. Show
1701 Marion Williamsport Road E rescheduled to 12/2 Denied
Marion OH 43302 a.m.
(740) 382-2747
R182-2005 Garth Realty Corporation KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
Bay Point Office Tower
4770 Biscayne Boulevard, Ste. 670
Miami FL 33137
(305) 576-0033
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R183-2005 William K. Rockwood KWest 11/4 a.m. No Show
7 Sara Lane Denied
Barrington IL 60010
(847) 382-4569
R184-2005 Robert & Mary Jane Paans Withdrawn
73 Prim Rose Road
Blairstown NJ 04825
(908) 362-5343
R185-2005 Ann Blythe Harrigan Marathon 11/9 p.m. No Show
11538 Upper Sunny Circle PAO made
Eagle River AK 99577 adjustment
(907) 694-1133
R186-2005 Elisabeth P. Fennell KWest 12/12 a.m. Show -
37 Summer Hill Denied
Newport KY 41071
(859) 912-2562
R187-2005 Joan D. Gladwell KWest 11/4 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 513
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-2243
R188-2005 James & Judy Roberts Withdrawn
2545 Loring Street
San Diego CA 92109
(858) 270-1217
R189-2005 Linda W. Curtis KWest 11/4 p.m. Withdrawn
7694 E Washington Street
Chagrin Falls OH 44023
(440) 543-1917
R190-2005 Lance Pontin KWest 11/4 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 836
Summerland Key FL 33042
(609) 408-8899
R191-2005 William J. Falcheck, Jr. KWest 11/4 p.m. Show
817 Padma Center Road Denied
Hilton NY 14468
(585) 392-3328
R192-2005 Bi-State Realty, LTD KWest 12/12 a.m. No Show
444 N Main Street Denied
Hubbard OH 44425
(330) 534-4440
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R193-2005 Charlotte Alspach& KWest 11/4 p.m. Withdrawn
Peter Delaney
531 W Point Drive
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(410) 476-3984
R194-2005 Pamela C. Dobson Marathon 11/9 p.m. Withdrawn
387 Vista Baya Rescheduled to
Newport Beach CA 92660 12/2 Marathon
(949) 650-0542
R195-2005 Daniel A. Weiss, Esquire KLargo 11/30 p.m. Withdrawn
150 W Flagler Street PH 2850
Miami FL 33130
(305) 374-7850
R196-2005 Jeffrey P. Wilson KLargo 11/30 a.m. Withdrawn
(also E151) 5 S Bounty Lane
Key Largo FL 33037
(800) 522-5133
R197-2005 Eugenio & Michele DeSanctis Marathon 12/2 a.m. Withdrawn
12982 Kedleston Circle
Fort Myers FL 33912
(239) 561-8690
R198-2005 Patrick Sharkey Marathon 11/8 p.m. No Show
287 Stahl Drive Denied
Huntington Valley PA 19006
(215) 947-0395
R199-2005 & Robert & Astrid Dublis Marathon 12/2 a.m. Show
R200-2005 2875 NE 36th Street Granted
Fort Lauderdale FL 33308
(305) 743-0002
R201-2005 Robert A. Mittie Marathon 11/9 p.m. Withdrawn
Cindy Fox-Mittie
176 30th Street
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-6468
R202-2005 Walter Stuber KLargo 11/30 p.m. Show
4527 Sheridan Avenue rescheduled to Denied
Miami Beach FL 33140 11/29 p.m.
(305) 530-2407
R203-2005 Richard Kemble & KWest 11/4 p.m. No Show
George Korn Denied
1315 Eliza Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-1871
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R204-2005 Paul Slabaugh KWest 11/4 p.m. No Show
8642 Carradale Drive rescheduled 12/12 Denied
Caledonia IL 61011 KWest 12/12Show
(815) 885-3096 Denied
R205-2005 Alan K. Jackson KWest 11/4 p.m. No Show
PO Box 970097 Denied
Boca Raton FL 33497
(561) 487-8336
R206-2005 Jorge & Connie Coto LATE FILED Withdrawn
104 Mangrove Lane KLargo 11/29 p.m.
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 274-1037
R207-2005 Walter S. Grocki, Trustee LATE FILED Withdrawn
Snapper Creek Realty Trust Marathon 11/9 p.m. @ Meeting
135 Snapper Creek Road reschedule to 12/2
Layton FL 33001 a.m.
(305) 517-9417
R208-2005 to Daniel A. Weiss, Esquire LATE FILED Withdrawn
R210-2005 150 W Flagler Street PH 2850 KLargo 11/30 p.m.
Miami FL 33130 rescheduled to
(305) 374-7850 12/12 a.m. KW
R211-2005 Tradewinds Hammock LTD KLargo 11/29 p.m. Withdrawn
%Shane P. Sarver
5505 N Atlantic Avenue Ste.115
Cocoa Beach FL 32931
(321) 799-4090
R212-2005 German Perez LATE FILED Withdrawn
129 Fairwich Street KLargo 11/29 p.m.
Tavernier FL 33070
R213-2005 Stella A. Stamita Rylander LATE FILED Withdrawn
PO Box 126 OWES $15.00
Summerland Key FL 33042 KWest 11/4 p.m.
(305) 296-7192
R214-2005 Martha Jane Neher LATE FILED Withdrawn
& David Garry Culver Marathon 11/9 a.m.
79901 Overseas Highway Unit 320
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-2614
R215-2005 William R. Rice LATE FILED Withdrawn
3716 Coconut Terrace Marathon 11/9 p.m.
Bradenton FL 34210
(941) 920-5396
Revised January 6, 2006
2005 Valuation Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R216-2005 Renee & Nelson Grier LATE FILE Withdrawn
25359 Second Street KWest 12/12 a.m.
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-9030
R217-2005 & Consuelo V. Leopold LATE FILE Withdrawn
R218-2005 606 Virginia Street KWest 12/12 a.m.
Key West FL 33040
(305) 293-7351
Revised January 6, 2006