12/20/2004 Final Meeting MINUTES OF THE 2004/6
MONROE COUNTY
VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Value Adjustment Board
Marathon Government Annex
Monday, December 20, 2004
The Final Meeting of the Monroe County Value Adjustment Board convened at 10:00
a.m., on the above date, at the Marathon Government Center, 2798 Overseas Highway,
Marathon. Present and answering to roll call were Commissioner David P. Rice, Mayor Dixie M.
Spehar, School Board Member Duncan Mathewson, and Chairman George Neugent. Absent was
School Board Member Andy Griffiths. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk of the Court;
Pamela Hancock, Deputy Clerk; Suzanne Hutton, Assistant County Attorney; Karl Borglum,
Chief Deputy and John C. Dent, Attorney for the Property Appraiser.
All stood for the Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance.
Motion was made by Mayor Spehar and seconded by Commissioner Rice to approve the
Minutes of the September 27, 2004 Organizational Meeting of the Value Adjustment Board.
Motion carried unanimously.
Pamela Hancock, Deputy Clerk advised the Board that Ms. Margaret Finney, had
indicated that she would be attending the final meeting to discuss the denial of her homestead
exemption, but that she had not yet arrived. Chairman Neugent requested that we postpone this
item until later in the meeting to give Ms. Finney an opportunity to address the Board. There
being no objections the item was continued to later in the meeting.
Joe Harris addressed the Board concerning his Petition No. 006-2004. Special Magistrate
James Elam and Karl Borglum, Chief Deputy for the Property Appraiser addressed the Board.
After discussion, motion was made by Mayor Spehar and seconded by Commissioner Rice to
uphold the Special Magistrate's decision. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by School Board Member
Mathewson granting approval of the Special Master recommendations for the 2004 Real Property
Petitions. Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached and made part of the record
(attachment 1).
Margaret Finney addressed the Board concerning her Petition No. H072-2004. Special
Magistrate Lee Rohe and Mr. Borglum addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made
by Commissioner Rice and seconded by Mayor Spehar to uphold the Special Magistrate's
decision. Motion carried unanimously.
f
2004/7
Motion was made by Mayor Spehar and seconded by Commissioner Rice granting
approval of the Special Master recommendations for the 2004 Homestead Petitions. Motion
carried unanimously. Said list is attached and made part of the record (attachment 2).
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by School Board Member
Mathewson granting approval of the Special Master Fees. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Mayor Spehar and seconded by Commissioner Rice granting
approval of the Legal Notices. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Rice and seconded by School Board Member
Mathewson granting approval of the Certification of the Tax Roll. Motion carried unanimously.
Assistant County Attorney Suzanne Hutton addressed the Board concerning adoption of a
Resolution adopting Administrative Rules, and read the Resolution into the record. Motion was
made by Mayor Spehar and seconded by Commissioner Rice to adopt the Resolution. Motion
carried unanimously.
RESOLUTION NO. 002-2004
Said Resolution is incorporated herein by reference.
There being no further business to come before the Board the meeting was adjourned.
Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk
to the Value Adjustment Board
of Monroe County
by:
Pamela6.-7‘"."G. Hancock
Deputy Clerk
•
//,
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R001-2004 John J. Whitman 11/08/2004 a.m. Canceled by
17 Misty Lane Marathon phone 10/4
W Milford NJ 07480
(973) 697-5528
R002-2004 Herbert G. Gantreaux 11/08/2004 a.m. Show-denied
5305 Ocean Terrace Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2031
R003-2004 Eduardo Kenneth Boza 11/29/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
2 Coral Drive Key West
Key West FL 33040
(305) 745-7602 new 797-0647
R004-2004 Alexei Saenko 11/29/2004 a.m. Show-denied
1019 Packer Street Key West
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-4458
R005-2004 Bruce D. & Janet C. Maxwell 11/29/2004 a.m. W/drawn by
4412 Pine Grove Key West phone 10/20
Fort Gratiot MI 48059
(810) 385-5422
R006-2004 Joe& Veronica Harris - Resort 11/04/2004 a.m. Show-denied
Property Management of the Keys, Inc. Key Largo
97802 Overseas Highway
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 852-7200
R007-2004 KW Beach Suites Ltd. Withdrawn
R008-2004 Home Depot USA
Deloitte Tax LLP
Jason Butterworth
200 E Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1400
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33301-2248
(954) 728-3800
R009-2004 John Thomas Keane, Jr. Withdrawn
16960 Driftwood Lane
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8678
R010-2004 John & Ruth Discher 11/29/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
22916 Bluegill Lane Key West by phone 10/14
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
RO11-2004 CVS Pharmacy 11/04/2004 p.m. Show-denied
%Commercial Property Services, Inc. Key Largo
PO Box 590899
Miami FL 33159-0899
(305) 871-0017
Revised December 3, 2004 Agenda Item E
•
•
•
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R012-2004 Thomas Blount 11/04/2004 p.m. Show-denied
%Commercial Property Services, Inc. Key Largo
PO Box 590899
Miami FL 33159-0899
(305) 871-0017
R013-2004 Julie Schwartz, Esq. 11/04/2004 a.m. No show
100 SE 2nd Street, Suite 2900 Key Largo Denied
Miami FL 33131
(305) 375-6582
R014-2004 Alicia P. Serrano Trustee 11/04/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R015-2004 E. Van Vlahakis Key Largo
R016-2004 Firestone
%Property Tax Consultants, Ltd.
Jack Schlossberg
656 E Hallandale Beach Boulevard
Hallandale FL 33009
(954) 454-3600
R017-2004 Marr Resort Property, Inc. Withdrawn
%Easley, McCaleb & Associates
Daneen L. Maly
100 W Cypress Creek Road, Suite 955
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33309
(954) 938-8801
R018-2004 Wingo, Turner A. Trustee 11/30/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R019-2004 Walgreen Company Key West
R020-2004 Walgreen Company
Assessment Technologies, Ltd.
Jim Driscoll
800 Wilcrest, Suite 103
Houston TX 77042
(713) 977-4197
R021-2004 to Gus Boulis 11/30/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R024-2004 %Southern Tax Services, Inc. Key West
C.K. Cattanach, Agent
2210 Hollywood Boulevard
Hollywood FL 33020
(800) 358-2155
Revised December 3, 2004
•
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R025-2004 Royal Palm RV Park, Inc. 11/30/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
Stephen Witmer, Treasurer Key West
PO Box 88
Hallieford VA 23068
(804) 725-7480
after 11/01/2004
163 Cunningham Lane
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-9856
R026-2004 Windley Key Ltd. Withdrawn
%Deloitte Tax LLP
Jason Butterworth
200 E Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1400
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33301-2248
(954) 728-3800
R027-2004 Gardner Odenbach 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
ORCC, LLC Key Largo
1150 Penfield Road
Rochester NY 14625
(585) 381-7010 ext. 225
R028-2004 Amari& Locallo 11/30/2004 p.m. No show
%Franco A. Coladipietro Key West Denied
One Tiffany Pointe, Suite G12
Bloomingdale IL 60108
(630) 307-3700
R029-2004 EDCO LTD Withdrawn
R030-2004 KMart Corporation
R031-2004 KIR Key Largo
%Garth Realty Corporation
Gary Appel
19495 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 301
Aventura FL 33180
(305) 935-4424
R032-2004 William R. Rice 11/08/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
3716 Coconut Terrace Marathon
Bradenton FL 34210
(941) 920-5396
R033-2004 Rodger D. & Jan J. Wolfe 11/08/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
868 Copa D Oro Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(402) 657-9438
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R034-2004 Barnett Bank of Jacksonville 11/30/2004 p.m. R037 &
R035-2004 Biosphere Properties, Inc. Key West R038 W/D
R036-2004 Barnett Bank of Jacksonville Withdrawn
R037-2004 Barnett Bank of Jacksonville
R038-2004 Citizens & Southern Bank
%Burr Wolff LP
Joyce Traynham
1355 Windward Concourse, Suite 200
Alpharetta GA 30005-8899
(678) 808-1605
R039-2004 Robert Pernai 11/04/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
%Flanagan/Bilton Key Largo
200 E Randolph Drive, Suite 6900
Chicago IL 60601
(312) 782-5000
R040-2004 NHC-FL13 LP 11/30/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R041-2004 NHC-FL16 LP Key West
%Innovative Tax Solutions
Michael Blase
4393 Sunbelt Drive, Suite 200
Addison TX 75001
(972) 248-8200
R042-2004 Paul D. & Lynn F. Alandt 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
3 Parklane Boulevard, Suite 1201 Key Largo
Dearborn MI 48126
(313) 336-2000
R043-2004 William& Gertrude Garofalo Withdrawn
%Lee Rohe
PO Box 420259
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 745-2254
R044-2004 Tracker Marine 11/04/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
%Assessment Advisors Key Largo
26519 Interstate 45 N
The Woodlands TX 77380
(832) 326-8558
R045-2004 Sandra M. & Alfred J. Latey 11/08/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
15041 SW 20th Street Marathon
Davie FL 33326-2027
(954) 625-6056
R046-2004 William E. & Holly K. Hall 11/08/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
76 Tingler Lane Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-0051
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R047-2004 Virginia Tabor, Trustee 11/29/2004 a.m. No show
PO Box 191 Key West Denied
Hinckley UT 84635
(435) 864-2079
R048-2004 Richard Hall & John F. Atkinson 11/08/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
%Michael S. Hagen Marathon
PO Box 6808
Fort Myers FL 33911
(239) 275-0808
R049-2004 Angela E. Novoa 11/04/2004 p.m. R051 W/D
R050-2004 Eric A. & Moria L. Peterson Key Largo No show
R051-2004 Nicolas & Ma Fernandez Denied
%Abatement Incorporated
Roberta Montero
PO Box 310625
Miami FL 33231-0625
(305) 374-3346
R052-2004 Manuel Fernandez 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
%David G. Hutchison, Esq. Key Largo
PO Box 1262
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-0013
R053-2004 Vincenzo Santi 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
1013 Dove Road Key Largo @ meeting
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 230-3008
R054-2004 Margaret A. Laron 11/03/2004 a.m. Show-denied
76 Sir Francis Drake Drive Key Largo
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 853-5753
R055-2004 Deborah L. Acker 11/08/2004 p.m. Show-denied
803 124th Street Gulf Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-3871
R056-2004 Lori Sue Lamb 11/29/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
460 9th Street Key West
Key Colony Beach FL 33051
(305) 289-0064
R057-2004 & Crawl Key Development, Inc. Withdrawn
R058-2004 %Property Tax Consultants, Ltd.
Jack Schlossberg
656 E Hallandale Beach Boulevard
Hallendale FL 33009
(954) 454-3600
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R059-2004 Paul E. Roberts 11/03/2004 a.m. Show-denied
324 Leonards Road Key Largo
Boulder CO 80302
(305) 449-6263
R060-2004 Conch Harbor Marina Associates, Ltd. 12/01/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R061-2004 Conch Hrbr Marina Condo Assoc., Inc. Key West
%Carter N. McDowell, Esq.
200 S Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2500
Miami FL 33131
(305) 350-2355
R062-2004 H. Carleton Godsey 11/29/2004 a.m. No show
516 Altagate Road Key West Denied
Louisville KY 40206
(502) 894-9086
R063-2004 William J. Shaw 11/08/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 523107 Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2458
R064-2004 & Daniel &Michele Miller 11/08/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R065-2004 PO Box 587 Marathon
Lake Orion MI 48361
(800) 531-4683
R066-2004 Jorge F. Pella 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
7795 SW 117th Street Key Largo
Miami FL 33156
R067-2004 Michael B. Nall 11/29/2004 a.m. Show-denied
1800 Atlantic Boulevard A-202 Key West
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-8750
R068-2004 William N. &Bettina V. Behringer 11/03/2004 a.m. Show-denied
88181 Old Highway Apt. B3 Key Largo
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 852-3890
R069-2004 Carlos A. & Maria C. Enriquez 11/03/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
1234 Andora Avenue Key Largo
Coral Gables FL 33146
(305) 798-5833
R070-2004 Theater of the Sea, Inc. Withdrawn
%Kenneth M. Bloom
1110 Brickell Avenue 7th Floor
Miami FL 33131
(305) 371-6800 ext.231
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R071-2004 Rupert A. Staudner 11/09/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
780 122nd Street Ocean Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-5442
R072-2004 & Jim Houser 11/09/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R073-2004 58324 Morton Street Marathon @ meeting
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-7442
R074-2004 Richard F. & Arlene G. Conklin 11/09/2004 a.m. Show-denied
565 Copa d'Oro Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-0765
R075-2004 John J. Lozano 11/03/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
318 Buttonwood Circle Key Largo @ meeting
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 451-4899
R076-2004 Mark Stevens 11/04/2004 p.m. Show-denied
%Commercial Property Services, Inc. Key Largo
PO Box 590899
Miami FL 33159-0899
(305) 871-0017
R077-2004 to Robert J. Dickman Withdrawn
R080-2004 4500 Le Jeune Road
Coral Gables FL 33146
(305) 667-8488
R081-2004 Stanley S. Budzinski 11/09/2004 a.m. No show
115 Windy Point Circle Marathon Denied
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 289-9381
R082-2004 & George Halloran Withdrawn
R083-2004 16B Hilton Haven Drive
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-6108
R084-2004 & Banana Bay of Marathon, Inc. Withdrawn
R085-2004 Banana Bay of Key West, Inc.
Thomas K. Manson
2319 N Roosevelt Boulevard
Key West FL 33040
(305) 923-1108
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R086-2004 to Circle K Stores, Inc. 12/01/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R091-2004 Mary Vaughn Key West
Property Tax Dept. D917
PO Box 52085
Phoenix AZ 85072
(602) 728-3422
R092-2004 Edward Sanchez 11/29/2004 a.m. Show-denied
18 Evergreen Lane Key West
Key West FL 33040
(305) 747-4820
R093-2004 Robert William Stevenson 11/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
20820 7th Avenue W Key West
Cudjoe Key FL 33042
(305) 745-8963
R094-2004 Matthew C. Shulte 11/09/2004 a.m. R094
R095-2004 Garabet Khatchikian Marathon W/drawn @
% Richard A. Malafy meeting
Campbell & Malafy R095 -No
10959 Overseas Highway show denied
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-2492
R096-2004 Scott Robins Withdrawn
88693 Old Highway
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 674-0600
R097-2004 Martha Delgado & Withdrawn
Mildred Hasmi
999 NW 161st Avenue
Pembroke Pines FL 33028-1179
(305) 610-3549
R098-2004 to James & Elaine Moore 11/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R100-2004 30752 Palm Drive Key West
Big Pine Key FL 33043
(305) 872-2302 or 797-4789
R101-2004 to William E. Rueff 11/09/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
R105-2004 PO Box 522693 Marathon
Marathon Shores FL 33052
(305) 743-6531
(850) 973-8318
R106-2004 Ocean Reef Investments, LLC 11/03/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 982 Key Largo
N Kingstown RI 02852
(401) 295-3200
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R107-2004 Gretchen Farmer Withdrawn
4921 Hawkes Bluff Avenue
Davie FL 33131
(954) 434-8337
R108-2004 to Parcel L Island Development (summary) 12/01/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R113-2004 %Robert L. Garcia Key West
1000 Market Street Bldg One Suite 300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R114-2004 Caroline Street Development Corp. 12/01/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
%Robert L. Garcia Key West
1000 Market Street Bldg One Suite 300
Portsmouth NH 03801
(603) 559-2105
R115-2004 to Parcel K Island Development 12/01/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R119-2004 %Robert L. Garcia Key West
1000 Market Street Bldg One Suite 300
Portsmouth NH 03 801
(603) 559-2105
R120-2004 to Sunset Acquisitions Corporation 12/01/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
R125-2004 %Robert L. Garcia Key West
1000 Market Street Bldg One Suite 300
Portsmouth NH 03 801
(603) 559-2105
R126-2004 Meridian West LTD 12/01/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
%Rash& Associates Key West
Mike Beauchamp
PO Box 1600
Rowlett TX 75030-1600
(972) 475-5555
R127-2004 The Key Ambassador Company 12/01/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
Armida Averette, General Manager Key West
3755 S Roosevelt Boulevard
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-3500
R128-2004 Vaclav Persl 11/09/2004 p.m. Show-denied
25 Brookside Avenue Marathon
Demarest NJ 07627
R129-2004 Jack R. Piatt 11/09/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
5061 SW 94th Court Marathon @ meeting
Miami FL 33165
(305) 595-5831
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R130-2004 Jan C. O'Malley 11/09/2004 p.m. No show-
PO Box 776 Marathon denied
Mantoloking NJ 08738
(732) 477-4200
R131-2004 Linda L. Popp 11/03/2004 p.m. Show-denied
95500 Overseas Highway Key Largo-resched.
Key Largo FL 33037 11/20/2004 p.m.
(305) 852-5201
R132-2004 David L. Wallace Withdrawn
412 Shore Drive E
Oldsmar FL 34677
(813) 855-6561
R133-2004 Mario C. Quintana 11/03/2004 p.m. Show-denied
477 Big Pine Road Key Largo
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 213-3676
R134-2004 Roberto M. Daniel 11/03/2004 p.m. Show-denied
1440 SW 12th Avenue Key Largo
Miami FL 33129
(305) 854-5590
R135-2004 Richard & Lisa Bennett 11/29/2004 p.m. Show-denied
1534 Palermo Avenue Key West
Coral Gables FL 33134
(305) 444-5925
R136-2004 Mark A. Brooks 11/03/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
43 W Plaza Del Sol Key Largo
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-3521
R137-2004 John R. Willis 11/03/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
81185 Old Highway Key Largo
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-4696
R138-2004 Gary Tiffany Withdrawn
PO Box 510253
Key Colony Beach FL 33051
(305) 289-1604
R139-2004 Walter Stuber 11/29/2004 p.m. No show
1009 Grinnell Street Key West Denied
Key West FL 33040
R140-2004 F. Louis Caraballo 11/03/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
36 Pigeon Drive Key Largo
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 978-7007
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Real Estate Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
R141-2004 Jeffrey Nelson Withdrawn
2000 W Commercial Boulevard,Ste.218
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33409
(954) 202-9696
R142-2004 O. Dean Madison 11/29/2004 p.m. Show-denied
4465 S Street Key West Valuation&
Titusville FL 32780 Exemptioin
(321) 264-2332 or (321) 749-6750
R143-2004 Sophie Painchaud 11/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 4750 Key West
Key West FL 33041
R144-2004 Thomas & Michele Brossard 11/09/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
42 Treasure Road Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-0764
R145-2004 Chris Sutton 11/09/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
57681 Morton Street Marathon
Grassy Key FL 33050
(305) 289-0237
R146-2004 Lawrence McDade 11/08/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
PO Box 510384 Marathon by phone
Key Colony Beach FL 33051
(305) 743-0287
R147-2004 to Kit Larsen 11/3 0/2004 a.m. No show
R149-2004 7990 Highway 29 Key West SM declined
Kelseyville CA 95451 to hear
(707) 279-1380
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H001-2004 Donald K. Raper PAO
1038 Gibralter Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-4247
H002-2004 Mark Lawson Rollins 10/29/2004 a.m. No Show
49 Bay Drive Marathon Denied
Key West FL 33040
(305) 745-7617
H003-2004 Vickie Pazo PAO
2812 Harris Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-2542
H004-2004 Kevin Cates PAO
820 1st Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 304-5138
H005-2004 Eduardo Boza PAO
B47 9th Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 747-4641
H006-2004 Howard M. Livingston PAO
526 Caribbean East Granted
Summerland Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-2455
H007-2004 Peggy Ward-Grant PAO
410 County Road Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-9736
H008-2004 Robert H. Cardenas, Jr. PAO
917 Eaton Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 293-4550
H009-2004 Sandra A. Brown PAO
17163 Green Turtle Lane W Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-3662
HO10-2004 Samuel Krinsky PAO
612 Elizabeth Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-4579
HO 11-2004 Michelle L. Irwin PAO
709 Windsor Lane Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 293-9177
Revised December 3, 2004 Agenda Item C
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H012-2004 Jeffrey C. & Cynthia J. Gneiser PAO
15 Buttonwood Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-9615
H013-2004 Dawn Marie Dykes PAO
1016 James Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 942-1247
H014-2004 Sally L. Hoover PAO
126 Ocean Shores Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 451-4720
H015-2004 Carl & Inger Olsen PAO
2105 Seidenberg Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-0932
H016-2004 Antonio S. Novo Withdrawn
122 Parker Drive
Islamorada FL 33036
H017-2004 Wintermyer, Lynn Gangi PAO
PO Box 747 Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn
(305) 872-4188
H018-2004 Jacek Kita PAO
3314 Northside Drive#151 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 295-5264
H019-2004 Albert T. Lojko MD 10/29/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
313 Olivia Street Marathon
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-3341
H020-2004 Kimberly Blanchette PAO
1312 Reynolds Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 295-0315
H021-2004 Kenneth L. Sheaffer PAO
877 Grenada Lane Granted
Little Torch Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 872-1642
H022-2004 James Warwick PAO
213 Bougainvillea Street Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 852-0746
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H023-2004 Galen C. & Brooke L. Spaulding PAO
308 Atlantic Boulevard Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-3344
H024-2004 Edwin& Faith Nielsen PAO
807 S Emerald Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 852-0847
H025-2004 Dennis Boyd PAO
55 Boca Chica Road Lot 28 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-6197
H026-2004 Paul W. & Cynthia D. Carter PAO
19552 Aztec Street Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-7467
H027-2004 George Murray Campbell Jr. PAO
60 Cortez Lane Granted
Islamorada FL 33036 Withdrawn
(305) 664-3136
H028-2004 Hannia Rivera& Steve Kibbe PAO
2412 Fogarty Avenue Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-9858
H029-2004 Jennifer C. & Bernardo Barrios PAO
280 Avenue F Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 797-5095
H030-2004 Lisa Bramson PAO
528 Hammock Drive Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-0388
H031-2004 Kevin Carlson PAO
211 Oleander Drive Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-3287
H032-2004 James Lytton PAO
701 Spanish Main Drive Lot 149 Granted
Cudjoe Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-8463
H033-2004 William Salyer PAO
125 Plantation Shores Drive Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-8057
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION# NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H034-2004 Janet Reichstein PAO
5409 Overseas Highway PMB 216 Granted
Marathon FL 33050
(305) 743-4356
H035-2004 William Paul Lorraine, Jr. PAO
98442 Windward Avenue Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 853-0875
H036-2004 Jessica Beedle PAO
280 Lower Matecumbe Road Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-4302
H037-2004 Wayne Spencer 10/29/2004 a.m. PAO
C7 9th Avenue Marathon Granted
Key West FL 33040
H038-2004 Joanne Neville Clark PAO
26 Gordon Circle Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-3064
H039-2004 Matthew G. McCool 10/29/2004 a.m. PAO granted
301 St.Thomas Avenue Marathon back to 2003
Key Largo FL 33037 w/Cut out
(305) 528-7600
H040-2004 Joseph Biondoletti PAO
150 Dickie Way Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-5768
H041-2004 Audrey Samz-Liggins PAO
1507 George Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-3781
H042-2004 Bahama Conch Community Land Trust 10/29/2004 p.m. PAO
of Key West, Inc. Marathon Granted
325 Julia Street Withdrawn
Key West FL 33040
(305) 294-0884
H043-2004 Drew& Virginia Haggard PAO
PO Box 421105 Granted
Summerland Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 515-0073
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H044-2004 Habitat for Humanity of Key West & 10/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
Lower Florida Keys, Inc. Marathon PAO
PO Box 421003 Granted
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 872-4456
H045-2004 Daniel C. Martin PAO
26958 Mariposa Road Granted
Ramrod Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 515-0226
H046-2004 Theater of the Sea 10/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
%Kenneth M. Bloom Marathon
1110 Brickell Avenue 7th Floor
Miami FL 33131
(305) 371-6800 ext. 231
H047-2004 Mark Fleer 10/29/2004 a.m. Show
12565 Overseas Highway Marathon Denied
Marathon Shores FL 33050
(305) 289-0565
H048-2004 Nancy Martinez 10/29/2004 a.m. Show
113 Madeira Court Marathon Granted
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 664-2655
H049-2004 Albert Creighton Ash PAO
215 S Coconut Palm Boulevard Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-4937
H050-2004 Christopher C. Beckman 10/29/2004 a.m. Withdrawn
1000 80th Street Marathon
Marathon FL 33050
(269) 838-2879
H051-2004 Patricia Marie Brennan PAO
918 Southard Street #111 Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
H052-2004 Ocean Reef Medical Center Foundation, PAO
Inc. - 30 Ocean Reef Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 367-2600
H053-2004 Steven P. & Victoria C. Steiro PAO
PO Box 430262 Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043-0262 Withdrawn
H054-2004 Roger K. Carpenter 10/29/2004 a.m. Show
369 LaFitte Road Marathon Denied
Summerland Key FL 33042
(305) 923-4679
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H055-2004 Kelly L. Rankin PAO
1416 Pine Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-2002
H056-2004 Wayne & Lorin Siniscalco PAO
97652 Overseas Highway#HH31 Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 852-0844
H057-2004 Leonard Moffo PAO
1975 Long Beach Road Granted
Big Pine Key FL 33043 Withdrawn by
(305) 872-4683 phone 10/5
H058-2004 Bryan Margulies PAO
655 Cabrera Street Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 451-1921
H059-2004 Coleen Moe PAO
11685 2nd Avenue Ocean#3 Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 289-1250
H060-2004 Kim Bernhardt PAO
50 Golf Club Drive Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 296-7244
H061-2004 Frank P. Ortiz PAO
190 Harbor Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-7330
H062-2004 Vickilynn Gajewski PAO
90341 Old Highway Unit 8 Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 664-5133
H063-2004 Dennis M. St.John PAO
721 Chapman Lane Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-3995
H064-2004 Alan S. & Barbara A. Pareira PAO
102 N Coconut Palm Boulevard Granted
Tavernier FL 33070 Withdrawn
(305) 852-8609
H065-2004 Robert Hollenbeck 10/29/2004 a.m. No show
137 Westminster Drive Marathon Denied
Tavernier FL 33070
(305) 852-7899
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H066-2004 Jay T. Weed PAO
551 Avenue C Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-5395
H067-2004 Joseph Ward PAO
126 Caribbean Drive Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 986-5004
H068-2004 John Thomas Keane, Jr. PAO
16960 Driftwood Lane Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 745-8678
H069-2004 Mark J. Wolff 10/29/2004 a.m. No show
126 Gulfview Drive Marathon Denied
Islamorada FL 33036
(305) 623-2370
H070-2004 James G. & Olga M. Maness 10/29/2004 p.m. PAO
180 Ana Court Marathon Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 289-0160
H071-2004 Vera Fielding 10/29/2004 p.m. Show
5000 SW 26th Avenue Marathon Denied
Ft.Lauderdale FL 33312
(954) 987-5296
H072-2004 Margaret Susan Finney 10/29/2004 p.m. Show
109 Second Lane Marathon Denied
Key Largo FL 33037
(305) 394-3736
H073-2004 Joseph P. Nascone PAO
58652 Overseas Highway Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Withdrawn
(305) 395-7537
H074-2004 Tamara L. Crouch PAO
720 Georgia Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 509-2554
H075-2004 Scott D. Stanley PAO
280 Sugarloaf Boulevard Granted
Sugarloaf Key FL 33042 Withdrawn
(305) 797-3023
H076-2004 Raymond Pack PAO
1414 18th Street Granted
Key West FL 33040
(305) 849-1913
Revised December 3, 2004
2004 Exemption Petitions
PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME
H077-2004 Robert Wallace PAO
1005B United Street Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 294-9878
H078-2004 David Averette PAO
1 Bamboo Terrace Granted
Key West FL 33040 Withdrawn
(305) 292-2803
H079-2004 Gay& Lesbian Center of Key West,Inc. 10/29/2004 p.m. Withdrawn
%The Smith Law Firm Marathon
333 Fleming Street
Key West FL 33040
(305) 296-0029
H080-2004 Shirley Wood PAO
88 Marina Avenue Granted
Key Largo FL 33037 Withdrawn
(305) 453-1622
H081-2004 Donald G. Hiller LATE FILE PAO
414 122nd Street Ocean 10/29/2004 p.m. Granted
Marathon FL 33050 Marathon Withdrawn
(305) 743-2256
Revised December 3, 2004