Loading...
12/11/2003 Final Meeting MINUTES OF THE 2003/5 MONROE COUNTY VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Value Adjustment Board Marathon Government Annex Thursday, December 11, 2003 The Final Meeting of the Monroe County Value Adjustment Board convened at 10:00 a.m., on the above date, at the Marathon Government Center, 2798 Overseas Highway, Marathon. Present and answering to roll call were School Board Member Anne Cohan, Mayor Murray Nelson, Commissioner George Neugent, School Board Member Eileen Quinn, and Chairman Dixie Spehar. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk of the Court; Pamela Hancock, Deputy Clerk; Richard Collins, County Attorney; Suzanne Hutton, Assistant County Attorney; Ervin A. Higgs, Property Appraiser; and John C. Dent, Attorney for the Property Appraiser. All stood for the Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance. Motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by School Board Member Cohan to approve the Minutes of the September 24, 2003 Organizational Meeting, and October 24, 2003 Special Meeting of the Value Adjustment Board. Motion carried unanimously. Attorney James Nolan addressed the Board concerning his client Charles Eidschun's Petition No. H031-2003. John Dent, Attorney for the Property Appraiser's Office and Suzanne Hutton, Assistant County Attorney addressed the Board. After discussion, motion was made by School Board Member Cohan and seconded by Mayor Nelson to deny hearing the Petition and to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was made by School Board Member Quinn and seconded by Mayor Nelson granting approval of the Special Master recommendations for the 2003 Homestead Petitions. Motion carried unanimously. Said list is attached and made part of the record (attachment 1). Thomas Blount addressed the Board concerning his Petition No. 015-2003. Karl Borglum, representing the Property Appraiser's Office and Mr. Dent addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by School Board Member Quinn to remand the Petition back to the Property Appraiser's Office. Ms. Hutton and Richard Collins County Attorney addressed the Board. After discussion, roll call vote was taken with the following results: School Board Member Cohan No Mayor Nelson No Commissioner Neugent Yes School Board Member Quinn Yes Commissioner Spehar No J 2003/6 Motion failed. After further discussion, motion was made by Mayor Nelson and seconded by School Board Member Cohan to deny hearing the Petition and to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Ervin Higgs, Property Appraiser, Mr. Dent and Karl Borglum addressed the Board concerning Petition Nos. 012-2003, 026-2003, 033-2003, 179-2003, and 190-2003. After discussion, the Board heard from Special Master James Elam on each Petition and made the following recommendations: Petition No. 012-2003 motion was made by School Board Member Cohan and seconded by School Board Member Quinn to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Petition No. 026-2003 motion was made by School Board Member Cohan and seconded by School Board Member Quinn to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Petition No. 033-2003 motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Mayor Nelson to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Petition No. 179-2003 motion was made by School Board Member Quinn and seconded by Commissioner Neugent to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Petition No. 190-2003 motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by School Board Member Quinn to uphold the Special Master recommendation. Roll call vote was unanimous. Motion was made by Commissioner Neugent and seconded by Mayor Nelson granting approval of the Special Master recommendations for the 2003 Real Property Petitions. Roll call vote was unanimous. Said list is attached and made part of the record (attachment 2). Motion was made by School Board Member Cohan and seconded by Mayor Nelson granting approval of the Special Master Fees, Legal Notices, and Special Master Pamela Andrea's expenses. Roll call vote was unanimous. Motion was made by Mayor Nelson and seconded by Commissioner Neugent granting approval of the Certification of the Tax Roll. Roll call vote was unanimous. There being no further business to come before the Board the meeting was adjourned. 2003/7 Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk to the Value Adjustment Board of Monroe County by: 670-6-&-‘41 Pamela G. ancock Deputy Clerk 2003 HOMESTEAD PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME H014-2003 David Alan Metcalfe 10/30/2003 a.m. Show-denied 903 Indies Drive SM Rohe Ramrod Key FL 33042 (305) 872-1427 H015-2003 Bruce W. Carlough 10/30/2003 a.m. Show - 202 Cromwell Court SM Rohe granted Tavernier FL 33070 (561) 329-2142 H016-2003 John R. Asbell 10/30/2003 a.m. No show- 1040 Westshore Drive SM Rohe denied Big Pine Key FL 33043 (239) 821-8999 H022-2003 Robert & Penny Burns 10/30/2003 a.m. Has HX 513 Lafitte Road SM Rohe wanted SOH Little Torch Key FL 33042 (305) 872-9456 H023-2003 Gerald F. & Marian J. Shinn 10/30/2003 a.m. Show - 368 Stirrup Key Boulevard SM Rohe granted Marathon FL 33050 (305) 743-6207 H031-2003 Charles Eidschun 10/30/2003 a.m. No show - 5181 113th Avenue N SM Rohe denied Clearwater FL 33760 (727) 515-3227 Attachment 1 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 002-2003 Diane E. Mullinax 11/05/2003 a.m. Show-denied 651 W Indies Drive SM Elam Ramrod Key FL 33042 (305) 872-2164 003-2003 Scott J. Nyman 10/28/2003 a.m. No show - 119 N Airport Road SM Elam denied Tavernier FL 33070 (305) 522-3584 008-2003 Kathleen Linehan 10/28/2003 a.m. No show- 171 Holmesdale SM Elam denied Albany NY 12208 (518) 458-9094 (305) 872-8739 (after 11/03) 009-2003 Wesley L. Kriedemann 11/05/2003 a.m. Show-denied 413 Frances Street SM Elam Key West FL 33040 (607) 257-4646 010-2003 Easley, McCaleb & Associates 10/29/2003 a.m. No show- & 011-2003 100 W Cypress Creek Road, Suite 955 SM Elam denied Fort Lauderdale FL 33309 011-2003 W/drawn (954) 938-8801 012-2003 Ronald J. &Lorraine P. Maniscalco 10/28/2003 a.m. Show- relief 907 Narragansett Lane SM Elam granted Key Largo FL 33037 (305)453-5394 015-2003 Thomas E. Blount, Jr. 11/05/2003 a.m. Show-denied 154 Key Haven Road SM Elam Key West FL 33040 (305) 296-0362 018-2003 Michael O. Williams 10/28/2003 a.m. Show-denied 34 Avenue A SM Elam Key Largo FL 33037 (305) 451-3216 019-2003 Linda I. Greenberg 11/05/2003 a.m. Show-denied 17027 Flying Fish Lane SM Elam Sugarloaf Shores FL 33042 (305) 745-2575 021-2003 Mark C. Wasser 10/28/2003 a.m. No show - 870 Narragansett Lane SM Elam denied Key Largo FL 33037 (305) 453-1324 Attachment 2 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 022-2003 Delia Ochoa 10/27/2003 a.m. Show-denied 1172 Coates Lane SM Corcoran Summerland Key FL 33042 (305) 745-2261 025-2003 E. Van Vlahakis 10/28/2003 a.m. No show - %Property Tax Consultants, LTD SM Elam denied Jack N. Schlossberg 656 E Hallandale Beach Boulevard Hallandale FL 33009 (305) 945-0038 026-2003 Hyatt Equities 11/06/2003 a.m. Show - relief %Granville Scott Inc. SM Elam granted 633 N Franklin Street, Suite 510 Tampa FL 33602 (813) 229-3991 031-2003 Rose Langer 11/05/2003 a.m. No show- 22942 Captain Kidd Lane SM Elam denied Cudjoe Key FL 33042 (617) 522-4889 033-2003 %Kenneth M. Bloom, Esquire 10/28/2003 a.m. Show-033 to 036-2003 1110 Brickell Avenue 7th Floor SM Elam Relief-034 Miami FL 33131 035 Withdrawn Denied-036 (305) 371-6800 Denied 041-2003 E. Paul &Anne D. Weis 10/28/2003 a.m. Show-denied 213 Aberdeen Court SM Elam Tavernier FL 33070 (305) 852-4925 044-2003 First American Tax Valuation 11/06/2003 a.m. Show-denied David J. Zachem SM Elam 300 31st Street N Suite 201E Saint Petersburg FL 33713 (727) 328-0798 047-2003 F. Ronald Mastriana 11/07/2003 a.m. Show-denied 1500 N Federal Hwy#200 SM Elam Fort Lauderdale FL 33304 (954) 566-1234 048-2003 Ricardo Rodriguez 10/28/2003 a.m. Show-denied 124 Marina Avenue SM Elam Key Largo FL 33037 (305) 271-2878 049-2003 Carl M. Bendik 10/28/2003 a.m. Show-denied & 050-2003 PO Box 602 SM Elam W Elizabeth PA 15088 (724) 329-2129 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 051-2003 Hampden Mepham 10/28/2003 a.m. No show - 3607 Fairway Forest Drive SM Elam denied Palm Harbor FL 34685 (727) 786-5968 057-2003 PTP, Inc. 10/28/2003 p.m. No show- John McDonald SM Elam denied 10241 Hunt Club Lane Palm Beach Gardens FL 33418 (561) 627-6551 058-2003 Cindi C. Thomas 11/05/2003 a.m. No show - 218 Harbor View SM Elam relief granted Largo FL 33770 (727) 584-7181 059-2003 Stuart Feiner 10/28/2003 p.m. Show-denied & 060-2003 American National Realty Corp. SM Elam 7860 Peters Road Suite F 101 Plantation FL 33324 (954) 382-4141 061-2003 John C. Noble 10/28/2003 p.m. Show-denied 3 Cannon Point SM Elam Key Largo FL 33037 (305) 367-4011 062-2003 David& Theresa Etzel 10/27/2003 a.m. No show- 20318 Beechwood Lane SM Corcoran denied Strongsville OH 44149 (440) 669-5051 064-2003 James P. Crawford 11/05/2003 a.m. No show- 1401 NE 9th Street SM Elam denied Fort Lauderdale FL 33304 068-2003 LH Chariot Jr. Trust 11/05/2003 p.m. No show- %Harding& Carbone, Inc. SM Elam denied 3903 Bellaire Boulevard Houston TX 77025 (713) 664-1215 069-2003 Burr Wolff LP 11/05/2003 p.m. No show- & 070-2003 Steven Graham SM Elam denied 1420 W Mockingbird Lane#575 Dallas TX 75247 (214) 631-3409 071-2003 Burr Wolff LP 11/06/2003 a.m. No show - to 074-2003 William P. Miller SM Elam denied 1355 Windward Concourse Suite 200 Alpharetta GA 30005-8899 (678) 297-9880 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 092-2003 Julie Schwartz, Esquire 10/28/2003 p.m. No show - 100 SE 2nd Street Suite 2900 SM Elam denied Miami FL 33131 (305) 375-6583 093-2003 Abatement Incorporated 10/29/2003 p.m. 093-2003 to 099-2003 Roberta Montero SM Elam Withdrawn 520 Brickell Key Drive#200 No show- Miami FL 33131 denied (305) 374-3346 100-2003 D & E Land Trust 11/05/2003 p.m. No show- Don W. Jessup SM Elam denied PO Box 108 Hanna IN 46340 (219) 794-4875 101-2003 Esther I. Arango, President 10/28/2003 p.m. Show - relief Signature Investments Corp. SM Elam granted 8960 SW 118th Street Miami FL 33176 (306)235-1637 103-2003 David C. & Janice A. Faustin 10/27/2003 p.m. No show - 10175 Camino Del Dios SM Corcoran denied Delray Beach FL 33446 (561)496-7776 121-2003 Walter Stuber 10/29/2003 p.m. Show-denied 4527 Sheridan Avenue SM Elam Miami Beach FL 33140 (305) 604-3882 122-2003 Marvin E. & Florence R. Hovel 10/28/2003 p.m. Show-relief 1000 Kings Highway#335 SM Elam granted Port Charlotte FL 33980 127-2003 Wayne Buchanan 10/27/2003 p.m. Show-denied 81 SW 5th Street SM Corcoran Pompano Beach FL 33060 (954) 943-6370 133-2003 Higinio Diaz 10/28/2003 p.m. No show - &134-2003 160 Lovelane Place SM Elam denied Key Largo FL 33037 (305) 632-7720 135-2003 Jesus& Carmen Lemus 10/28/2003 p.m. Show-denied 9261 SW 70th Street SM Elam Miami FL 33173 (305) 279-5758 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS -- ------ ------- PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 140-2003 Richard O. or Marion Reeves 10/28/2003 p.m. Show-denied 16415 SW 75th Avenue SM Elam Miami FL 33157-3805 (305) 852-8408 175-2003 Daniel A. Weiss 10/29/2003 a.m. Show-denied to 179-2003 Tannebaum, Planas & Weiss LLP SM Elam 550 Brickell Avenue Penthouse 2 Relief on Miami FL 33131 179 (305) 374-7850 180-2003 Bates-Appel, Inc. 11/07/2003 a.m. Show-denied & 181-2003 Richard Joyner SM Elam 19495 Biscayne Boulevard Suite 301 Aventura FL 33180 (305) 935-4424 182-2003 Brian J. Lake 10/28/2003 p.m. No show- 2323 Topsfield Road SM Elam denied S Bend IN 46614 (574) 237-1155 187-2003 Bobbe W. Dooley 10/29/2003 a.m. Show-denied 12401 S Dixie Highway SM Elam Miami FL 33156 (305) 235-6321 190-2003 Jerold E. &Eugenia H. Timpson 11/07/2003 a.m. Show-relief 30349 Prince Road SM Elam granted Big Pine Key FL 33043 (305) 872-7495 196-2003 Charles A. Maggio 10/27/2003 p.m. No show- 12 N Hollow Road SM Corcoran denied Rochester NY 14626 197-2003 Karen L. Terry 11/05/2003 p.m. Show-denied 20869 7th Avenue W SM Elam Cudjoe Key FL 33042 (440) 236-3873 198-2003 John E. Timinsky& 10/30/2003 p.m. Late file- Lisa E. Mann SM Corcoran denied 1285 NE 104th Street Miami FL 33183 (305) 751-2385 200-2003 Christopher S. & Amy G. Youngblood 11/05/2003 a.m. Show-denied 21021 Keeney Mill Road SM Corcoran Freeland MD 21053 11/12/2003 a.m. 2003 REAL/TANGIBLE PETITION SPECIAL MASTER FINDINGS PETITION # NAME/ADDRESS HEARING DATE OUTCOME 201-2003 Bates-Appel, Inc. 11/07/2003 a.m. Show-denied Attention: Christopher Bates SM Elam 19495 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 301 Aventura FL 33180 (305) 935-4424 (305) 935-7282 202-2003 Chris N. Kritikos 10/29/2003 a.m. Show-denied %Daniel A. Weiss SM Elam 150 W Flagler Street PH Miami FL 33130 (305) 374-7850