01/15/1991 Final Meeting January 15, 1991
Property Appraisal Adjustment Board
Courtroom B, Monroe County
Courthouse Annex
Key West
A Meeting of the Property Appraisal Adjustment
Board took place on January 15, 1991 at 1: 00 p.m. in
Courtroom B, Monroe County Courthouse Annex, 500 Whitehead
Street, Key West, Florida. Present and answering to roll
were Commissioner Douglas Jones, Commissioner Jack London
and Mayor Wilhelmina Harvey, and representatives of the
Monroe County School Board , Dr . Geraldine Caron and Mrs.
Ruth Alice Campbell. Also present was Danny Kolhage, Clerk;
Nancy Cohen, Deputy Clerk ; Ervin Higgs, Property Appraiser ;
Mary Greenwood, Assistant County Attorney; and Staff of the
Property Appraiser 's Office .
Mary Greenwood, Assistant County Attorney, read an
opening statement to the Board concerning the obligations of
the Property Appraisal Adjustment Board. Ms. Greenwood read
from section 12D10. 003 (5) (a) of the Administrative Code and
F. S. 194. 032.
The-Board proceeded to discuss the pending lawsuit
brought by Property Appraiser Ervin Higgs.
Chairperson Harvey addressed those petitioners in
the audience and requested any petitioner who wished to
address the Board to sign up with the Clerk. After a brief
discussion of the agenda items, it was decided that any
action taken would exclude those petitions listed below:
003-Nathan Eden
010-Bruce Bryant/Lazy Lakes
055 & 056- Gilbert ' s Resort
114-Safe Harbor Marina
151- Key West Resort Golf Course
164 & 165-Larry & Max Puyanic
H003-Shrimp Culture Inc.
H043-Bartholomew Hovanic
H049-Perry Killin
H103-Gerald Fuchs
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item A-1 (attached
hereto) . Roll call vote carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item A-2 (attached
hereto) . RQ11 call vote carried unanimously.
After brief discussion of agenda item B-3
(attached hereto) , it was decided that the Board need not
take any official action inasmuch as the Property Appraiser
had already acted on those petitions.
Ervin Higgs, Property Appraiser, brought to the
Board 's attention petition H-002 which was a part of agenda
item B-2, and noted that it was not a homestead but a
request for agicultural exemption. Motion was made by
Commissioner Harvey and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
reconsider petition H-002-1990 as it was a request for agri-
•
*
cultural exemption. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Campbell to approve agenda item A-2 consisting of H-056,
H066, H082 H083 and H102. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by
Commissioner London to deny the requested agricultural sta-
tus of petition H-002, Melvin and Delores Brewer for Lime
Grove Business, as the petitioner had failed to overcome the
presumption of correctness of the Property Appraiser ' s
Office. Roll call vote on the motion was taken with the
following results:
Commissioner Caron Yes
Commissioner Campbell Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner London Yes
Mayor Harvey No
Motion carried.
Motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item B-1,
(attached hereto) . Motion carried unanimously.
The Board briefly discussed petition 134-1990,
Jeffrey L. Mandler for Barnett Bank, listed on agenda item
B-2 (attached hereto) , with Property Appraiser Ervin Higgs
and Special Master Jim Flenner . Charlton Courtney and Phil
White of the' Property Appraiser ' s Office discussed the
methodology used in assessing petition 134-1990. Motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Caron to deny the Special Master 's assessment of petition
134-1990 and reinstate the Property Appraiser ' s assessment,
as the petitioner had failed to overcome the presumption of
correctness . Roll call vote was unanimous. Motion was made
by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner Caron to
approve those remaining agenda items on B-2 petitions 107,
135, 137, 138, 147 and 186. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by Mayor Harvey and seconded by
Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item B-3 (attached
hereto) . Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to approve those bills sub-
mitted by the Special Masters as presented, under agenda
item C (attached hereto) . Roll call vote was unanimous.
Special Master Raymond Bishop addressed the Board and
requested that the Board approve those bills submitted by
the Special Masters for today' s hearing. Motion was made by
Commissioner Caron and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
approve those bills submitted for today ' s hearing. Motion
carried unanimously.
Attorney Hugh Morgan addressed the Board concerning
petition H-003-1990, Shrimp Culture, Inc. The Board entered
into a discussion with Special Master Jim Flenner , Assistant
County Attorney Mary Greenwood, and Property Appraiser Ervin
Higgs concerning Ms. Greenwood's memo on the Pisciculture
Industry and F. S. 193. 461 (5) . Mr . Morgan read for the
record Doyle Conner 's decision on the agricultural industry,
and an opinion by the Attorney General regarding catfish
farming as agricultural industry. Motion was made by
Commissioner London and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
approve the request for agricultural exemption on petition
411
cultural exemption. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Campbell to approve agenda item A-2 consisting of H-056,
H066, H082 H083 and H102. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by
Commissioner London to deny the requested agricultural sta-
tus of petition H-002, Melvin and Delores Brewer for Lime
Grove Business , as the petitioner had failed to overcome the
presumption of correctness of the Property Appraiser ' s
Office . Roll call vote on the motion was taken with the
following results :
Commissioner Caron Yes
Commissioner Campbell Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner London Yes
Mayor Harvey No
Motion carried.
Motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item B-1,
(attached hereto) . Motion carried unanimously.
The Board briefly discussed petition 134-1990,
• Jeffrey L. Mandler for Barnett Bank, listed on agenda item
B-2 (attached hereto) , with Property Appraiser Ervin Higgs
and Special Master Jim Flenner . Charlton Courtney and Phil
White of the—Property Appraiser ' s Office discussed the
methodology used in assessing petition 134-1990. Motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Caron to deny the Special Master 's assessment of petition
134-1990 and reinstate the Property Appraiser ' s assessment,
as the petitioner had failed to overcome the presumption of
correctness. Roll call vote was unanimous. Motion was made
by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner Caron to
approve those remaining agenda items on B-2 petitions 107,
135, 137, 138, 147 and 186. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by Mayor Harvey and seconded by
Commissioner Caron to approve agenda item B-3 (attached
hereto) . Roll call vote was unanimous.
Motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to approve those bills sub-
mitted by the Special Masters as presented, under agenda
item C (attached hereto) . Roll call vote was unanimous.
Special Master Raymond Bishop addressed the Board and
requested that the Board approve those bills submitted by
the Special Masters for today' s hearing. Motion was made by
Commissioner Caron and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
approve those bills submitted for today' s hearing. Motion
carried unanimously.
Attorney Hugh Morgan addressed the Board concerning
petition H-003-1990, Shrimp Culture, Inc. The Board entered
into a discussion with Special Master Jim Flenner, Assistant
County Attorney Mary Greenwood, and Property Appraiser Ervin
Higgs concerning Ms. Greenwood's memo on the Pisciculture
Industry and F. S. 193. 461 (5) . Mr . Morgan read for the
record Doyle Conner 's decision on the agricultural industry,
and an opinion by the Attorney General regarding catfish
farming as agricultural industry. Motion was made by
Commissioner London and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
approve the request for agricultural exemption on petition
H003-1990 as indicated. Roll call vote was taken with the
following results :
Commissioner Caron No
Commissioner Campbell No
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner London Yes
Mayor Harvey Yes
Motion failed .
Petitioner H043-1990, Bartholomew Hovanic,
addressed the Board concerning his request for homestead
exemption. Jim Flenner and Phil White addressed the Board
concerning the Special Master ' s decision to deny. Motion
was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Campbell to deny the request as the petitioner had not over-
come the presumption of correctness . Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Petitioner H049-1990, Perry Killin, addressed the
Board concerning the Special Master ' s decision to deny the
homestead exemption on his property. After brief
discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to approve the petitioner ' s
request, subject to the receipt of a letter from the
Appraiser ' s Office in Indiana stating that Mr . Killin did
not have a homestead in that State . Motion carried unani-
mously.
Petitioner H103-1990, Gerald Fuchs addressed the
Board concerning the Special Master ' s decision to deny the
homestead exemption on his property. After brief
discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Jones and
seconded by Commissioner Caron to grant the petitioner 's
homestead exemption, pending the receipt of a letter within
thirty days from the Appraiser 's office in Indiana stating
that Mr . Fuchs did not have a homestead in that State.
Motion carried unanimously.
Petitioner 003-1990, Nathan Eden addressed the
Board . Special Master Jim Flenner and the staff of the
Property Appraiser ' s office briefly discussed the assessment
on Mr . Eden 's property. Mayor Harvey questioned the
Property Appraiser 's staff on the method used to assess the
subject property. The Property Appraiser 's staff agreed to
discuss the assessment with Mr . Eden and try to resolve the
petition before the end of today' s meeting .
THE FOREGOING PETITION 003-1990 WAS
CONSIDERED LATER IN THE MEETING.
Property Appraiser Ervin Higgs addressed the Board
and requested that petitions 114-1990, Safe Harbor Marina,
and 151-1990, Key West Resort Golf Course, be postponed as
Attorney John Dent was not present to represent the Property
Appraiser 's Office. Attorney Jim Hendricks, Mary Greenwood
and Jim Flenner addressed the Board concerning petition
151-1990. Motion was made by Commissioner Jones that the
petition for non-taxable exemption be granted on the basis
• that the property does serve the public of Key West and the
Lower Keys. Motion died for lack of a second. Motion was
made by Mayor Harvey and seconded by Commissioner Jones to
postpone as the attorney for the Property Appraiser was not
present. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results :
Commissioner Caron Yes
Commissioner Campbell Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner London No
Mayor Harvey Yes
Motion carried.
Property Appraiser Ervin Higgs addressed the Board
regarding the settlement that had been reached between
his office and petitioner 003-1990, Nathan Eden. Motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Campbell to find the value of the property to be
$322, 589. 00, as agreed upon by the petitioner and the
Property Appraiser 's Office. Roll call vote was unanimous .
Petitioner 114-1990, Safe Harbor Marina/Roger
Bernstein, addressed the Board concerning his petition.
Special Master Ray Bishop addressed the Board concerning his
decision of denial on the petition. After discussion, the
Board directed the Clerk to the Board to furnish copies of
any information provided by the petitioner to the Board for
their review prior to the next meeting. Motion was made by
Commissioner Jones and seconded by Mayor Harvey to postpone
the hearing on petition 114-1990 (Alex ' s Junkyard) . Roll
call vote was unanimous.
Petitioner 010-1990, Bruce Bryant/Lazy Lakes,
addressed the Board concerning the Special Master ' s decision
of denial. Phil White of the Property Appriaser ' s office
addressed the Board . Motion was made by Commissioner Jones
and seconded by Commissioner London to assess the property
at $700, 000. 00 based on the sale price and the fact that the
actual income generated on the property does not come
anywhere near the income that was used by the Property
Appraiser , and that the Petitioner presented evidence that
overcame the Property Appraiser ' s presumption of correct-
ness . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Petitioner 055 and 056-1990, Dan O'Gorman/Gilberts
Resort and Marina, addressed the Board . Agent for the
petitioner , Juan Figueras, also addressed the Board. Carl
Hamp of the Property Appraiser 's office addressed the Board
concerning the methods used in assessing the property.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by
Commissioner Caron to appraise the petitioner ' s property at
$1,909, 507. 00 using the actual income figures that the
petitioner produced and based on the income approach that
the petitioner had overcome the presumption of correctness
of the Property Apraiser 's office. Motion to amend was made
by Commissioner Campbell to include the wording "and a large
percentage of other marinas were assessed using the income
approach" . Motion to amend was accepted by the maker and the
seconder . Roll call vote was unanimous.
Larry Puyanic addressed the Board concerning his
petition 164 and 165-1990, Tavernier Town Shopping Center .
After discussion between the petitioner , the Board, and the
Special Master concerning the subject property, motion was
made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Caron to deny the appeal on Petitions 164 and 165 and uphold
S
the Property Appraiser ' s appraisal. Roll call vote was una-
nimous.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner London to reconsider petition 174-1990 as
the applicant was not present to sign a request sheet to
address the Board at the beginning of the hearing. Motion
carried unanimously. Petitioner 174-1990, John Brier ,
addressed the Board concerning the Special Master ' s denial
of his petition. Special Master Jim Flenner and Phil White
from the Property Appraiser 's Office addressed the Board.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Mayor
Harvey to uphold the Property Appraiser 's assessment based
on the income analysis available . Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Attorney Hugh Morgan addressed the Board and
requested that Petition H003-1990 be reconsidered by the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Campbell to reconsider petition H003-1990
due to additional information made available. Roll call
vote was unanimous . Attorney Morgan addressed the Board
concerning the issue of whether or not shrimp farming should
be treated as an agricultural purpose under F. S. 193. 461.
After discussion, motion was made by Commissioner London and
seconded by Commissioner Jones to reverse the Special
Master 's decision based on the interpretation of the Florida
Statute and the Attorney General' s opinion. Roll call vote
was taken with the following results :
Commissioner Caron No
Commissioner Campbell No
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner London Yes
Mayor Harvey Yes
Motion carried.
Motion was made by Commissioner Campbell and
seconded by Mayor Harvey to authorize the Tax Collector to
release the bills on those petitions that the Board had
decided on today, with the exception of those two items that
were postponed. Motion carried unanimously.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned .
_i , ;
II, 4 .
The Special Master recommended that those Homesteads listed below
be denied .
H001-1990 The Guidance Clinic of the Middle Keyss
H003-1990 Shrimp Culture Inc.
H004-1990 Nicholas J. De Grazio
H006-1990 Charles F. Andrews
H007-1990 Paul R. Auchter
H008-1990 Jack E. & Joan W. Belden
H009-1990 Erling W. & Mary L. Blast
H010-1990 Charles M. & Joyce M. Bowers
HO11-1990 Paul W. Brown
H012-1990 William F. & Charlene G. Burris
H013-1990 Francisco Carpentier & Mark Donahue
H014-1990 Claire H. Chapin
H015-1990 John William Chrow
H016-1990 Gary & Cindy Civil
H017-1990 Julian A. Clark & Luis Ruiz
H018-1990 Robert A. Clark
H020-1990 Donald M. Culver & William D. Bickford
H021-1990 Thomas Curtin
H023-1990 Laverne Decker
H025-1990 Eugene Farfan
H026-1-1990 Kimberly Feinberg
H026-2-1990 Loren F. Gardner
H027-1990 M.L. Garland
H028-1990 Sharon Lee Gerpheide & Robert G. Vitiello,
H029-1990 Enrique & Sylvia Gonzalez
H030-1990 Quirina Gonzalez
H031-1990 Patricia Goodner F/K/A Patricia Perron
H032-1990 Floyd Gorham
H033-1990 Mary Lee Graham
H034-1990 Patricia W. Grande
H035-1990 Warren H. Greer
H036-1990 Robert & Robyn C. Gustafson •
H037-1990 Edward B. & Elizabeth Sue Hall
H038-1990 Marie P. Haskins
H041-1990 James H. Holt
H042-1990 Constance J. Hosler
H043-1990 Bartholomew Hovanic & Bonita Hall
H044-1990 Edward J. Hulse
H045-1990 Stephen D. Justice
H047-1990 Robert P. & Arlene S. Kaufman
H048-1990 Katheryn E. Kennedy
H049-1990 Perry L. & Loeta Killin
H050-1990 John A. Knight III
H051-1990 Earl R. Korpal
H052-1990 Joseph Laforney
H053-1990 Lawrence Harrell
H055-1990 Rene Lerouzes
H058-1990 Eugene Lowe
H059-1990 Catherine MacPherson
H060-1990 Ronae Martell
H061-1990 Henry T. McCollum
H062-1990 Ira L. Mendell
H063-1990 Juan Rafael & Martha E. Menendez
H064-1990 Jack M. Miller
H065-1990 William T. & Beverly A. Mixson
H067-1990 Caroline Minot
H068-1990 Michael T. & Anne E. Moody
H069-1990 Lawrence & Delores Nadler
H071-1990 John & Sarah Neawcomer
H073-1990 Pauline B. Papy
H074-1990 Parker E. Lee
H075-1990 Jose F. & Maria G. Perez
H076-1990 William S. & Sandra Pesch
H077-1990 Charles H. Pfeiffer
H078-1990 Rita L. & Thomas G. Pierce
H079-1990 Ralph H. Poole Jr .
H080-1990 Marion W. Pritchard
H081-1990 Jeanne Lettis Reggio
H084-1990 Mario F. Sanchez-Rodriquez
H085-1990 David A. & Bertram J. Schmitz
•
WI
IlL .
H086-1990 Leander 0. & Eva F. Scott
H087-1990 Edward W. & Carmen L. Shreaves
H091-1990 • Derwood & Sherry Stewart
H092-1990 Leo F. & Grace E. Sullivan
H094-1990 Evelio & Maria Elena Toledo
H095-1990 Allen M. & Lucille Tyska
H096-1990 Mario M. & Brenda Vidal
H097-1990 Harold A. & Penelope S. Wilson
H098-1990 Philip A. Winsor Jr .
H100-1990 John S. & Mary D. Wyatt
H101-1990 John W. & Mary Louise Yates
H103-1990 Gerald G. & Alice S. Fuchs
H104-1990 Hurricane Island Outward Bound School
H105-1990 Homer F. & Mary G. Stewart
H106-1990 James F. & Joanne V. Brooks
k
I • !
•
,,.,, . ,i41,,,,i . .,
. . .. .,
.. ,. .
The Special Master recommended that those Homesteads listed below
be granted.
H002-1990 Melvin and Delores Brewer
H056-1990 John and Marie Long
H066-1990 William Fuller
H082-1990 John Rolli
H083-1990 Charles Rosato
11102-1990 Liberty Zongker
k
I
A .A
t! :c {
{a:• - {r
K f { k
t ny. •A T4.
{
'
i f f { i r=
J p y.4
�l
i
• i
Those Homesteads listed below were granted by the Property
Appraisers office .
H005-1990 Howard Francis & Pauline H. Abbey
H019-1990 Georgia E. Cronacher
H022-1990 Barbara J. Dantzscher
H024-1990 Harold M. Diamond
H039-1990 Arlyn J. & Aurora Z. Higley
H040-1990 Ramon H. & Patricia Hillis
H046-1990 Ervin R. & Robin Kamrow
H054-1990 James Robert Lawson Sr .
H057-1990 Generosa Lopez
H070-1990 Joanne F. Ness
H072-1990 Henry Edward III & Ana Maria Ondriezek
H088-1990 ' Joseph Socha
H089-1990 Edward P. & Gloria Solaski
H090-1990 Arlene L. Sommer
H093-1990 I Alice Terry & Vaugh Gibson
H099-1990 I Marion & Barbara M. Wodka
•
PC/5
Those Petitions listed below were withdrawn by the Petitioner .
006-1990 William Depkin
007-1990 Barry Cuoquette
008-1990 Cylde & Angie Ford
013-1990 Pier House Joint Venture
017-1990 Pier House Joint Venture
038-1990 Gail Ann Miller
050-1990 P. Reed Wills II & Joanne T. Wills
051-1990 Angela Court , Inc.
052-1990 Angela Court , Inc.
054-1990 Juan Figueras
057-1990
058-1990
059-1990
060-1990 " •
061-1990
062-1990
063-1990
064-1990
065-1990
066-1990
067-1990 "
068-1990
072-1990 "
073-1990
077-1990
078-1990
079-1990 "
080-1990
081-1990
082-1990 "
088-1990
089-1990 "
090-1990 James A. Williams
091-1990 Truman Annex
093-1990 Truman Annex
094-1990 Truman Annex
095-1990 Truman Annex
096-1990 Truman Annex
099-1990 Joseph B. Allen III
100-1990 Kenneth Bloom, Agent Theatre of the Sea
101-1990 Holiday Interval Ownership, Inc.
111-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler , Esq.
112-1990 Roger M. Bernstein
113-1990 Roger M. Bernstein
115-1990
116-1990
117-1990 Tax Adjustment Experts of Fl.
120-1990 Anchorage Development Assoc.
122-1990 Jilmart Hotels
124-1990 Jilmart Hotels
125-1990 Jilmart Hotels
132-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
136-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
139-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
140-1990 Jeffrey Mandler, Esq.
141-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
142-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
144-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
146-1990 Jeffrey Mandler , Esq.
152-1990 Sam Cooper
153-1990 Billy & Carla Cabanas
154-1990 Key Carib Properties
157-1990 James R. & W. Diane Welton
163-1990 Judy Thompson Spero
170-1990 Hawks Cay Resort and Marina
173-1990 Ralph H. Smith
178-1990 RDB Development
179-1990 Appraisal & Real Estate Economics
180-1990
181-1990
• 183-1990 Sheila Malloy
187-1990 Larry Marks
188-1990 Claude Reed
93
a)
4
w •
ri
UI
0
4)
4
a
a+ rr rr zr CP
v N UI N VI U) . • •
UI WWWWW
O
ro
�:: ;
o v v v v v
Z r, r-I r-I r-I r-I
nu 'oR3vvT3
v Z Z Z Z Z •
'v
v u v
aaaaaU
z v «s
cI C >, >. >I >1 w
vvvvv
14 $.4W ,,, � �
O owwwu.rw +;
U W W W W W W UI
v t0v la) vvv •r+
LI
aI •
U▪1 (1)
( O
Z
'0
r I •
al
U v 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a) -0 rnrnrnrnrnrnrn
o, ahrnrnrnrnrnrn
UI 3 r♦ ri r4 r-I H rH r-I
O 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
vrA r- op r-
.0 aI OMMMM V' OD
C� •L] ri r4 r-1 r-i r•I r-1 r-,
The Special Master recommended that those petitions listed
below be ruled either no change oL the Property Appraiser 's
assessment be upheld . In some cases the Property
Appraiser 's office had already made reductions in the
petitioner ' s assessment.
001-1990 Shrimp Culture , Inc. (combined with H003-1990)
002-1990 Commercial Management Inc.
003-1990 Nathan Eden
004-1990 Joseph A. & Gloria Bruno
005-1990 Joan Rossheim
009-1990 Edmund Grant
010-1990 Bruce Bryant (Lazy Lakes Resort)
011-1990 Samual Rose
012-1990 Rochford C. Ern & Florence Ern-combined with
176-1990
014-1990 Pier House Joint Venture
015-1990 Pier House Joint Venture
016-1990 Pier House Joint Venture
018-1990 Sager Management Corp
019-1990 Sager Management Corp
020-1990 Sager Management Corp
021-1990 Sager Management Corp
022-1990 Sager Management Corp
023-1990 Sager Management Corp
024-1990 Sager Management Corp
025-1990 Sager Management Corp
026-1990 Sager Management Corp
027-1990 Sager Management Corp
028-1990 Sager Management Corp
029-1990 Sager Management Corp
030-1990 Sager Management Corp
031-1990 Sager Management Corp
032-1990 Sager-Management Corp
033-1990 Sager Management Corp
034-1990 Sager Management Corp
035-1990 Sager Management Corp
036-1990 Sager Management Corp
037-1990 Sager Management Corp
039-1990 William R. William
040-1990 Bruno J. Brazauski
041-1990 Bruno J. Brazauski
042-1990 Joseph H. Roth, Jr .
043-1990 Joseph H. Roth, Jr .
044-1990 Joseph H. Roth, Jr .
045-1990 Joseph H. Roth, Jr .
046-1990 Joseph H. Roth, Jr .
047-1990 Theodore & Patricia Tiemeyer
048-1990 Donald Davis
049-1990 Donald Davis
053-1990 Juan Figueras
055-1990 Juan Figueras
056-1990 Juan Figueras
069-1990 Juan Figueras
070-1990 Juan Figueras
071-1990 Juan Figueras
074-1990 Juan Figueras
075-1990 Juan Figueras
076-1990 Juan Figueras
083-1990 Juan Figueras
084-1990 Juan Figueras
085-1990 Juan Figueras
086-1990 Juan Figueras
087-1990 Juan Figueras
092-1990 Truman Annex
097-1990 Bruno J. Degiorgi
098-1990 K. Michael Keil
102-1990 Warren L. Chestnut
103-1990 Carl & Marlene Lindback
104-1990 Milton Rosenblatt & Bernard Rosenblatt
105-1990
106-1990 "
108-1990 John E. O'Brien
109-1990 John E. O'Brien
110-1990 Armer E. White
411 114-1990 Safe Harbor Enterprises . ,�
118-1990 Conagra,' Inc . D/B/A Singleton Seafood
119-1990 National City Bank Trustee
121-1990 Joseph B. Klock & Susuan M. Girsch
123-1990 Huron Partners , Inc. c/o Marvin M. Poer
126-1990 Buccaneer Lodge c/o Marvin M. Poer
127-1990
128-1990 "
129-1990 "
130-1990 "
131-1990 "
133-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
143-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
145-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
148-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
149-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
150-1990 Jeffrey L. Mandler
151-1990 K.W. Resort Golf Course Corp.
155-1990 James W. & Frances E. Hendricks
156-1990 Clarence J. Keevan
158-1990 Jon E. & Elaine Krupnick
159-1990
160-1990
161-1990
162-1990
164-1990 Max D. Puyanic
165-1990 Max D. Puyanic
166-1990 Roy & Jean D. Murphy
167-1990 Derlan Investments , Inc.
168-1990 Thomas R. Post , P.A.
169-1990 "
171-1990 Alexander J. Forsyth, Jr .
172-1990 Patrick W. Bell, Coury Investments
174-1990 John Brier
175-1990 William N. Devane
176-1990 Florence E. & Rochforn Ern (combined with 012-1990)
177-1990 William N. Devane , Jr .
182-1990 Walter E. Simendinger
184-1990 Donald Capuano
185-1990 Donald Capuano
189-1990 Thomas J. Burke
•
AM S IA. FLENNER : : • , ;;:.,.:::lit ilk
I al
REGISTERED rifist �,. f
Real Ztato 1 -- , ,.. ,..:.,,
, . - _• '.,
BROKER —J " �" • ( I
�.�. . E
416 FLEM►NG STREET
KEY WEST.FLORIDA 33040
T LFP�{pN y� Th.416 BudJlmg
Property Appraisal Board of Adjustment
Monroe County Court House
Key West, Fl 33040 '
Dear Bord Members
I
This will serve as my fee for serving as Special master for your
board on' October 29,30,31 and November 5, and 6th.
34 hours at $125 per hour $4,250
Very truly yours,
I
e---------14-.<-0—,Z4-- Z
• Y,;• i '>:
` • r • 0 .:
1 4
'.
• • • • A
r, ,_
` D4 • •
3Y
✓ f
' r. •; ° • ,
t
•
' 1 y -• • 5 1•
tN .4t.rti
w • e
1 i r p;
' l.' .4'i - f,. y.
tom.. .1• ;:1(ifs ,.i�..; A
1 M12
l't1
•
•
• �, . rw� a.: •fT
its ' IAA !
1
I
K,
• f ?i-:f,
~ Y ". 1
} y •
j.
INVOICE DATE : 14 DECEMBER 1990
************************************* PLEASE REMIT TO:
* * RAYMOND P . BISHOP, IFAS, NFA
* CLERK ' S OFFICE * RADIANT GROUP, INC.
* MONROE COUNTY * P . 0 . BOX 1031
* P .O. BOX 1980 * KEY LARGO, FL 33037
* KEY WEST, FLORIDA 33041 ( 305 ) 451-1031
* ** 59-2339044
*
*************************************
DATE
TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION AMOUNT
1990
Services as Special Master to
Property Appraisal Adjustment Board
Hearing at Key Colony Beach 11 . 25 Hrs
Hearing at Plantation Key 25 . 50 Hrs
Study & ,Report Writing 64 . 00 Hrs
Field Visits 3 . 00 Hrs
Total 103 . 75 Hrs
@ 125 . 00/Hrly $12, 968 . 75
TOTAL DUE UPON PRESENTATION: $12,968 . 75
*********************************
* *
* YOUR CONFIDENCE IN OUR *
* SERVICE IS APPRECIATED *
* *
*********************************
•
,1:--... :i 4:71.. ir: c,.
.. '..,.f- ' i
• I
9 4
p�7t Y , } `yY
i .
•M