01/12/1990 Hearing t
Property Appraisal Adjustment Board
Friday , January 12 , 1990
Key West
A meeting of the Property Appraisal Adjustment
Board convened at 9: 00 a.m. on the above date in the Grand
Jury Room of the Courthouse Annex in Key West. Present and
answering to roll call were Commissioner Lee Ganim,
Commissioner Douglas Jones , Commissioner Robert Padron , and
Chairperson Wilhelmina Harvey. Also present were Danny L.
Kolhage , Clerk; Nancy Cohen , Deputy Clerk; Calvin Allen ,
Assistant County Attorney; Ervin Higgs , Property Appraiser;
John Dent , Attorney for the Property Appraiser; and Staff
from the Property Appraiser ' s Office .
The Board recognized Special Masters Jim Flenner ,
Flo Chabin and Raymond Bishop in the audience .
MAYOR STORMONT ARRIVED AND TOOK HIS SEAT.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Ganim to approve the recommendations of the
Special Master on those Petitions listed on Agenda Items A-1
and A-2 (attached hereto and made a part hereof ) , with-
holding any decision on Petition No. H-29 Robert and
Lorraine Potter until staff from the Property Appraiser ' s
office could obtain their file . Roll call vote was unani-
mous .
The Board entered into a discussion of Agenda Item
B-5 Petition No. 173-Marathon Air Services , Inc . d/b/a The
Flight Department (attached hereto and made a part hereof ) .
Al Frigola , attorney for the Petitioner , addressed the
Board . After a brief discussion as to the tax exempt status
of the Petitioner , motion was made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Jones to deny the tax exemption as
Marathon Air Services did not demonstrate a government func-
tion . Roll call vote was unanimous .
After a brief discussion of Agenda Item B-1
(attached hereto and made a part hereof ) , motion was made by
Mayor Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Jones to grant
a continuance to Petition numbers 117 and 119 , Ben Woodson ,
as the Special Master had sent them back to the Property
Appraiser ' s office to see if some agreement could be
reached . Motion carried unanimously . Also , under Agenda
Item B-1 , were Petition Numbers 126 , 128 , 139 and 145 ,
Truman Annex. Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Padron to grant a continuance of
Petition Numbers 126 , 128 , 139 and 145 under Agenda Item B-1
until the Petitioner could meet with the Property
Appraiser ' s office to see if some agreement could be
reached. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Padron and seconded
by Commissioner Jones to approve Agenda Item B-2 (attached
hereto and made a part hereof ) which listed those
Petitioners who had withdrawn their Petitions to the
Property Appraisal Adjustment Board. Motion carried unani-
mously.
The PAAB resumed discussion of Homestead Petition
• Number 29 , Robert and Lorraine Potter . John Dent , attorney
for the Property Appraiser ' s office discussed the denial of
this Homestead . Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and
1.
seconded by Commissioner Ganim to continue this Petition
until residency could be proved . Motion carried unani-
mously.
Jim Hendrick , attorney for Petitioner 22-Key West
Bight Marina , addressed the Board in reference to the deci-
sion of the Special Master. Motion was made by Mayor
Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Jones to uphold the
Special Master ' s decision to deny any further reduction .
Motion carried unanimously.
The next Petitioner to appear before the Board was
Petitioner 005 , George Halloran. Motion was made by Mayor
Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Padron to uphold the
decision of the Special Master to reduce the assessed value
to $236 ,092 . 00 . Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey Yes
Commissioner Jones Abstained due to a
conflict of interest.
Motion carried.
Michael Burton , Petitioner 21 , addressed the Board
in reference to his Petition and the decision of the
Special Master to reduce his assessment by $ 18 ,850 . 00 .
During discussion , motion was made by Commissioner Jones and
seconded by Commissioner Padron to continue this Petition
until further discussion with the Property Appraiser .
Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to uphold the decision of the Special
Master to reduce the assessment of Roger Akers , Petition
26 , on his 533 William Street Property to $144 , 215 . 00 . The
attorney for the Property Appraiser objected to the approval
of any reductions by the PAAB and questioned the authority
of the Board to make adjustments on property assessments .
Attorneys David Horan and Michael Halpern spoke in support
of the Board' s authority . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Ganim to uphold the decision of the Special
Master to reduce Petitions 35 , 36 and 37 , Southernmost Beach
Hotels , to $ 14 ,797 ,897 .00 . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to uphold the decision of the Special
Master to reduce the assessment on Petition 50 , Al and Edith
Amsterdam, to $ 1 , 409 ,850 . 00 . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Attorney Jack Pelser addressed the Board on behalf
of Petition Number 97 (Pier House Joint Venture) . Motion
was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Padron to uphold the decision of the Special Master to
reduce the assessment on Petition 97 to $ 21 , 408 ,683 . 00 .
Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes •
Mayor Stormont No
Chairperson Harvey Yes
2.
Motion carried .
The Board entered into a discussion of Agenda Item
B-3 , (Petitions 100 , 101 , 105 , 112 , 113 , 121 , 133 , 147 , 151 ,
152 , 153 , 156 , 158 , 175 , 191 and 196 , reduced by the Special
Master ) . Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to approve in bulk those petitions listed
above. Roll call vote was unanimous . During discussion ,
John Dent , attorney for the Property Appraiser , advised the
Board that Petitions 133 and 147 were for the Truman Annex
and all of their Petitions were in the process of being
reconsidered by the Property Appraiser ' s office. In con-
sideration of the statement made by the Property Appraiser ' s
attorney , motion was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to withdraw Petitions 133 and 147 from
the bulk approval . Motion carried unanimously.
Paul J. Sher addressed the Board concerning
Petitions 30 and 31 and the decision of the Special Master
who had ruled against any reduction in his case. After
discussion , motion was made by Commissioner Jones and
seconded by Mayor Stormont to uphold the decision of the
Special Master. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results :
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey No
Motion carried.
Petitioner 176 , Charles Valois , addressed the Board
in reference to the decision of the Special Master . Motion
was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner
Padron to uphold the decision of the Special Master to deny
any reduction in his assessment. During discussion , motion
was withdrawn. Motion was then made by Commissioner Jones
and seconded by Commissioner Ganim to postpone the
discussion of Mr. Valois ' property until further information
could be obtained. Motion carried unamiously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Padron to uphold the decision of the Special
Master on Agenda Item B-4 , Exhibit 1 (attached hereto and
made a part hereof ) . Motion carried unanimously.
Petitioner 24 , James Boyle , addressed the Board on
his petition . After lengthy discussion , motion was made by
Chairperson Harvey and seconded by Mayor Stormont to reduce
Mr. Boyle ' s assessment by an amount to be determined after a
review of the assessment of Marker 88 and Mr. Boyle ' s neigh-
boring land values and bring the findings back to the Board
at their final hearing . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Frank Greenman, attorney for Petitioner 34 (Kingsail
Resort Hotel ) , addressed the Board . After discussion ,
motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded by
Commissioner Ganim to approve the assessment at
$1 ,600 ,000 . 00 due to the improper use of comparables . During
discussion , the motion was withdrawn . Motion was made by
Mayor Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Ganim to approve
• the assessment of $ 1,600 ,000 . 00 based on income and
adjusted comparable sales , with a room rate of $ 30 . 00 to
$ 59 . 00 per night , rather than the high rate used by the
3.
Property Appraiser. Roll call vote was unanimous .
The Board addressed Homestead Petition H-26 , William
White . Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to approve Mr. White ' s Homestead con-
tingent upon providing the prerequisite documents . Motion
carried unanimously.
Attorney Frank Greenman again addressed the Board
for Petitioners 43 (John Brier/Paradise Trailer Park) and 111
106 (Ruth Scadlock/Lazy Lakes Trailer Park) . After a
lengthy presentation as to the comparable sales and ameni-
ties in trailer parks in Monroe County, motion was made by
Commissioner Jones and seconded by Chairperson Harvey to
assess Petition 106 at $700 ,000 . 00 due to the failure of the
Property Appraiser to provide information and locations of
comparables and quality of amenities . Roll call vote was
taken with the following results :
Commissioner Ganim No
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron No
Mayor Stormont No
Chairperson Harvey Yes
Motion failed. Motion was then made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Padron on Petition 106 to uphold
the assessed value as given on the basis that comparable
site ' s evaluation would produce a figure which has been
reduced by 14% to this figure considering the lack of amen-
ties . Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Ganim No
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron Yes
Moyor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey No
Motion failed. Motion was then made by Commissioner Jones
to send Petition 106 back to the Property Appraiser . Ervin
Higgs Property Appraiser advised the Board that they should
try to resolve this matter one way or another. During
discussion , motion was withdrawn . The Board then entered
into a discussion of Petition 43 . Motion was made by Mayor
Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Padron to assess the
property at $ 476 ,051 . 00 or 4% less than offered and equal
to comparables at $11 ,611 . 00 per site at 41 sites . Roll
call vote was unanimous . Motion was then made by
Commissioner Jones and seconded by Commissioner Ganim to
assess Petition 106 at $ 860 ,000 . 00 due to information pro-
vided on comparables , location and amenties . Roll call vote
was taken with the following results :
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont No
Chairperson -Harvey - - Yes
Motion carried.
111
Petitioner 47 , Carl D. Schneider addressed the
Board . After a brief discussion , motion was made by Mayor
Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Jones to accept the •
$ 57 , 457 . 00 adjusted assessment made by the Property
Appraiser ' s office . Motion carried unanimously.
4.
Vern Pokorski , Petitioner 107 , addressed the
Board and requested a reduction of $ 25 ,000 . 00 in his
assessment. After some discussion as to the problems
caused from having a trap business next to his house , motion
was made by Mayor Stormont and seconded by Commissioner
Padron to give Mr. Pokorski a 5% reduction due to obtrusive
noise . Roll call vote was taken with the following results :
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey No
Motion carried .
Arhtur Lujan and his attorney , Dave Horan , addressed
the Board in reference to Petitions 169 , 170 , 171 and 172 .
John Dent , attorney for the Property Appraiser , objected to
the request made by Mr. Lujan for a second hearing as he
failed to appear for his original hearing in the Marathon
area. After a brief discussion, motion was made by Mayor
Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Jones to allow the
Petitioner a second hearing with the Special Master , and to
continue this matter to the next meeting. Roll call vote was
taken with the following results :
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey No
111 Motion carried .
The next item on the Agenda was a discussion of
correspondence received by the Clerk' s office from Petitioner
193 , Hal Bromm. Motion was made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Chairperson Harvey to reduce the property
assessment to $ 198 ,000 . 00 based on a comparable at 606
White Street. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron No
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey Yes
Motion carried.
Alan Schmitt, Petitioner 211 (Winn Dixie Shopping
Center-Marathon) , addressed the Board . Mr. Schmitt ' s esti-
mated valuation of his property was $ 2 ,025 ,000 . 00 . After a
brief discussion by the Board with the Special Master
appointed in the case , motion was made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Padron to accept the decision of
the Special Master to deny any reduction in assessment , with
no continuance . Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Ganim No
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
•
Chairperson Harvey No
5.
Motion failed. Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and
seconded by Mayor Stormont to postpone this matter to the
next meeting , as no information was presented as to com-
parables in the Marathon area . Roll call vote was unani-
mous .
Petitioner 212 and 214 , Judy Shephard , addressed
the Board . After a brief discussion , motion was made by
Mayor Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Ganim to uphold
the decision of the Special Master to deny any reduction in
assessment , lacking any additional information on Petition
212 . Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey No
Motion carried . Motion was then made by Chairperson Harvey
and seconded by Mayor Stormont to uphold the decision of the
Special Master to deny any reduction in Petition 214 . Roll
call vote was unanimous .
The Board then resumed the discussion of correspon-
dence received from Petitioners disagreeing with the deci-
sion of the Special Master appointed to hear their case.
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Mayor Stormont to uphold the decision of the Special
Master to deny any reduction in the assessment of Petitioner
008 (Ruth I. Brundza ) . Roll call vote was unanimous .
Motion was made by Commissioner Jones and seconded
by Commissioner Padron to uphold the decision of the Special
Master to deny any reduction in the assessment of Petitioner
011 (Geraldine Greene) . Roll call vote was taken with the
following results :
Commissioner Ganim No
Commissioner Jones Yes
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont No
Chairperson Harvey No
Motion failed. Motion was then made by Mayor Stormont and
seconded by Chairperson Harvey to refer this matter back to
the Property Appraiser ' s office for review prior to the next
meeting . Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Ganim Yes
Commissioner Jones No
Commissioner Padron Yes
Mayor Stormont Yes
Chairperson Harvey Yes
Motion carried.
A letter was presented by the Clerk for Petitioner
014 , Mr. Ronald Gamble . Motion was made by Commissioner
Jones and seconded by Commissioner Padron to uphold the
decision of the Special Master to deny any reduction in his
assessment. Roll call vote was unanimous .
Final Agenda Item C-Approval of Bills submitted by •
the Special Masters-was presented to the Board by the Clerk.
6.
Motion was made by Commissioner Ganim and seconded by
Commissioner Jones to approve the following:
James A. Flenner:
49 hours $ 6 ,125 . 00
Flora R. Chabin:
21 hours $ 2, 375 . 00
Ray R. Bishop:
53 hours $ 6 ,625 .00
Palocrave Hearings $ 1, 375 . 00
Full Board hearing $ 1, 375 . 00
Total $ 17 ,875 . 00
Motion carried unanimously .
There being no further business , the meeting was
adjourned.
•
7.
1
1989 Homestead Petitions
H31-1989 Lottie Mae Adams Denied No Show
H52-1989 Gerald H. Aspinwall Denied No Show
H42-1989 C & J Bateham Denied No Show
H27-1878 Kathleen A. Baughman Denied No Title
H25-1989 Sarah Kaufman Beidler Denied No Hardship
H24-1989 Belden Mary E. Denied No Show
H-5-1989 Raymond Casamayor Denied No Show
H18-1989 Leonard L. Chin Denied No Show
H38-1989 Robert A. Clark Denied No Show
H08-1989 Roy E. Ek , Jr . Denied No Show
H09-1989 Helen E. Faulkner Denied No Show
H37-1989 James P/Edward Flenner Denied No Show
H51-1989 Mathilde Marie Giroud Denied No Show
H10-1989 Patricia J. Hill Denied No Show
H40-1989 Bill & Muriel Kurth Denied No Show
H35-1989 Patricia Lucas Denied No Show
H43-1989 Anthony Marchoine Denied No Show
H45-1989 James R. Mayer Denied No Show
H48-1989 Royal B. Newman Denied No Show
H28-1989 Jette Philbert Denied No Show
H29-1989 Robert/Lorraine Potter Denied No Show
H44-1989 Hubert/Martha Raabe Denied No Show
H03-1989 Richard O ' Findley Denied No Show
H02-1989 Denied No Show
H36-1989 Sergio/Daisey Rodriguez Denied In Dade
H15-1989 John Sahagian Denied No Show
H23-1989 Maria Sawyer Denied No Show
H2O-1989 Theadore Smith Denied No Show
H32-1989 Paul R. Sorenson Denied No Show
H46-1989 Lorenzo & Maria Toledo Denied No Show
H26-1989 William White Denied No Show
H47-1989 Wayne F. Ramsey Denied No Show
H39-1989 Kris Capes Denied No Show
H04-1989 Nathan Beinenstock No Show
H07-1989 Charlie Mae Clayton No Show
H12-1989 Nils & Florence E. Idman No Show
H13-1989 Carol M. Purvis No Show
H14-1989 Raymond Miller No Show
H16-1989 Aldis Rudd No Show
H17-1989 Arthur Tompsett No Show
H21-1989 Dennis A. Arnold No Show
H50-1989 Louis Cortina No Show
H-6-1989 Mary Elizabeth Case No Show
H-1-1989 Patricia Stosik No Show
1110 AGENDA ITEM A-1
Homestead Exemptions Granted - 1989
Name Number Status Reason
Carl H. & Ruth B. Meiss H22-1989 Granted Proof
Charles & Catherine Nolan H30-1989 Granted Proof
Michael D. & Juanita H. May H11-1989 Granted Proof
Cheryl A. & Carl E. Lindback 177-1989 Granted Proof
The following Petitioners had their homesteads granted if
required medical proof was obtained and submitted prior to
the meeting of the full Board .
Raymond E. & Diane C. Darrah H41-1989 Withdrawn 1/11/90
Charles & Mary Jane Pierce H33-1989 Granted Proof
111 AGENDA ITEM A-2
The following Petitioners had their petitions sent back to
the Property Appraiser to see if some agreement could be
reached .
117-1989 Ben Woodson
119-1989 Ben Woodson
126-1989 Truman Annex
128-1989 Truman Annex
139-1989 Truman Annex
145-1989 Truman Annex
AGENDA ITEM B-1
ill •
•"-
The following Petitioners withdrew their Petitions to the
Property Appraisal Adjustment Board .
003-1989 George Halloran
004-1989 George Halloran
010-1989 Eugene F. Poole
013-1989 James Ferguson
018-1989 Roland V. Feinberg
020-1989 Diane C. Chaplin
023-1989 Richard J. Powers
025-1989 Duck Key Club , Inc .
028-1989 Key West Womens Club
029-1989 Robert T. Feldman
032-1989 Anchorage Development Assoc . /Hyatt Key West
038-1989 Robert Remus
039-1989 Robert Remus
040-1989 L. B. Pete
041-1989 Donald O'Brien
046-1989 James Edwin Felton
049-1989 Marjean , Inc .
052-1989 Randolph Lirette
053-1989 Steve Condella
056-1989 thru 071-1989 Mckay S.J . Trustee &
Richards , William L. Trustee
072-1989 James Hendricks/Holiday Inn
094-1989 Pier House Joint Venture
096-1989 Pier House Joint Venture
103-1989 Tom Pennekamp
104-1989 Tom Pennekamp
108-1989 Ramlo Construction
109-1989 Ramlo Construction
110-1989 Ramlo Construction
111-1989 Hilario Ramos
114-1989 Michael Halpern
116-1989 Lucille & Jose Sanchez
120-1989 Luke Mcgovern
122-1989 Truman Annex
123-1989 Truman Annex
124-1989 Truman Annex
125-1989 Truman Annex
127-1989 Truman Annex
129-1989 Truman Annex
130-1989 Truman Annex
131-1989 Truman Annex
132-1989 Truman Annex
134-1989 Truman Annex
135-1989 Truman Annex
136-1989 Truman Annex
137-1989 Truman Annex
138-1989 Truman Annex
140-1989 Truman Annex
141-1989 Truman Annex
142-1989 Truman Annex
143-1989 Truman Annex
144-1989 Truman Annex
146-1989 Truman Annex
148-1989 Joan T. Knight
149-1989 Edward B. Knight
150-1989 Knibilt Corp.
154-1989 Spottswood Family Trust
159-1989 Deborah Ann Marshall-Snelgrove
160-1989 Carter Vinyard
163-1989 Sal Rapisardi
165-1989 John R. Rinehart
• 166-1989 John R. Rinehart
AGENDA ITEM B-2
167-1989 John R. Rinehart
174-1989 Karl A Ernst/Fla . Property Evaluation Service
178-1989 Juan Figueras
180-1989 Juan Figueras
181-1989 Juan Figueras
182-1989 Juan Figueras
184-1989 Juan Figueras
185-1989 Juan Figueras
186-1989 Juan Figueras
187-1989 Juan Figueras
188-1989 Juan Figueras
190-1989 Juan Figueras
192-1989 Juan Figueras
194-1989 Monika Bushe
195-1989 Henry Block Partner , Tavernier Joint Venture
198-1989 Stephen & Kathleen Streinmuller
199-1989 Bowlake Trading Company
200-1989 Bowlake Trading Company
209-1989 Lucos , Inc .
210-1989 Michael Cingue
213-1989 Pinewood Materials
• AGENDA ITEM B-2
The following Petitioners had their petitions reduced by the
Special Master.
George Halloran 005 Reduce to $236 ,092 .00
Michael Burton 021 Reduce to $272 , 930 .00
Akers/Henning 1426 Newton 026 Reduce to $144 , 215 . 00
Southernmost Beach Hotels 035 Reduce to $14 ,797 ,897 . 00
" 036 See 035
II " " 037 See 035
Al & Edith Amsterdam 050 Reduce to $ 1 , 409 , 850 . 00
Pier House Joint Venture 097 Reduce to $21 , 408 .683 . 00
Pontin Duke 100 Reduce to $4 ,500 . 00
Pontin Duke 101 Reduce to $4 ,500 . 00
Kemp , Wm 0. 105 Reduce to $3 , 438 , 577 . 00
Foley Square 112 Reduce to $759 , 824 . 00
Sloppy Joes 113 Reduce to $928 ,153 . 00
Key Largo Resorts 121 Reduce to $3 , 330 ,000 . 00
Truman Annex 133 Reduce to $375 ,000 . 00
Truman Annex 147 Reduce to $248 ,730 . 00
Mr. & Mrs . Robert Young 151 Reduce to $91 ,136 . 00
" " " 152 Reduce to $44 , 907 . 00
" " " 153 Reduce to $88 ,665 . 00
Spottswood Family Trust 156 Reduce to $270 ,189 . 00
Liannan Yvonne C. 158 Reduce to $79 ,541 . 00
Weiler , Robert 0. 175 Reduce to $66 ,500 . 00
Juan Figueras 191 Reduce to $1 , 238 ,682 . 00
Beckmeyer , Karl 196 Reduce to $169 ,640 . 00
• AGENDA ITEMS B-3
i e
The following Petitioners had their petitions ruled on by a
Special Master , these decisions are listed below. Several
did not appear for their hearings .
Samaha Fouad 001 No Change
Saddlebunch RV PK/L.A. Goode 002 No Change
Commercial Mgmnt/Days Inn 006 No Show
Commercial Mgmnt/Days Inn 007 No Change No Show
Ramirez , Frederick 009 No Change No Show
Kopplow, Roger E. 012 No Change
Ogden , Patrick J. 015 No Change No Show
Cooper , Marvin 016 No Change No Show
Huron Props . (Cheeca Lodge ) 017 No Change
Robinson , Joseph & Jackie 019 No Change
Cook/533 William Street 026 No Change
Cook/504 Grinnell Street 027 No Change
Cook/506 White Street 027 No Change
Sudduth , Richard H. 033 No Change
Mohn , Jean D. 042 No Change
Mattick , M & M Robert 045 No Change
James J. James 044 No Change
Holiday Inn Beachside 048 No Change
Rowe , Olivia 051 No Change No Show
Casa Marina 054 No Change
Campbell , Philip L. 055 No Change
Anthony Villamil 073 No Show
Eugene J. Weiss 074 No Show
Frank Guilford 075 No Show
Roger Ferese 076 No Show
Richard J. Patrick 077 No Change
Jilmart Hotels 078 No Change
Jilmart Hotels 079 No Change
Stock Island Apts . 080 No Change
Stock Island Apts . 081 No Change
Hampton Inn 082 No Change
Sheraton Key Largo 083 No Change
Carnival Fruit 084 No Change
Carnival Fruit 085 No Change
Suite of Key Largo 086 No Change
Ireland Properties 087 No Change
Buccaneer Lodge 088 No Change
Buccaneer Lodge 089 No Change
Buccaneer Lodge 090 No Change
• AGENDA ITEM B-4
(Exhibit 1)
The Petitioners listed below were either in the audience and
addressed the Board or mailed correspondence to the Clerk .
Orner , Ruth Brundza 008 No Change
Greene, Geraldine 011 No Change
Gamble , Ronald 014 No Change No Show
Key West Bight Marina 022 No Change No Standing
White, Virginia 024 No Change
Cook/533 William Street 026 No Change
Sher , Paul J. 030 No Change
Sher , Paul J. 031 No Change
Devine , John 034 No Change
Brier/Paradise Tr . Pk. 043 No Change
Schneider , Carl D. 047 No Change
Pier House Joint Venture 095 No Change
Scadlock , Ruth 106 No Change
Pokorski , Lavern B. 107 No Change
Arthur Lujan 169 No Show
Arthur Lujan 170 No Show
Arthur Lujan 171 No Show
Arthur Lujan 172 No Show
Valois , Charles 176 No Change
Bromm, Hal 193 No Change
Schmitt , Alan G. 211 No Change
Shephard , Judy 212 No Change
Shephard , Judy 214 No Change
• Agenda Item B-4 (Exhibit 2)
1989 Property Appraisal Adjustment Board
Marathon Air Services 173
This Petition was heard in the Marathon area , a decision as
to the tax exempt status has to be made . The Petition was
sent to the County Attorney ' s office , with a note stating
that this decision should be made by the Property Appraiser .
• AGENDA ITEM B-5
Buccaneer Lodge 091 No Change
Buccaneer Lodge 092 No Change
Buccaneer Lodge 093 No Change
Pier House Joint Venture 095 No Change
Farmer , Richard & Joyce 098 No Change
Roeding , Richard 099 No Change No Show
Saunders , Donald L. 102 No Change No Show
Smith , Randy 115 No Change No Show
Ben Woodson 118 No Show
Spottswood Family Trust 155 No Change
Fohrman , Darryl 157 No Change No Show
Cooper , Barry et al 161 No Change No Show
Sewaca Corp 162 No Change No Show
Rossi , Mark & Hurley , Harry 164 No Change No Show
Rinehart , John R. 168 No Change Not owner
Valois , Charles 176 No Change
Figueras , Juan 179 No Change
Figueras , Juan 183 No Change
Joseph H. Roth , Jr. 189 No Change
Ellan B. Channing 197 No Change No Show
Anthony J. & Linda Estevez 201 No Change
Eugene B. Weiss 202 No Change No Show
Roth , Jos . H. Jr. 203 No Change No Show
Roth , Jos . H. Jr. 204 No Change No Show
Roth , Jos . H. Jr. 205 No Change No Show
Roth, Jos . J. Jr. 206 No Change No Show
Gerald E. Marty 207 No Show
011ie Smithwick 208 No Show
Syer , Dick 215 No Change No Show
Culver , Donald M. et al 216 No Change No Show
• AGENDA ITEM B-4
1
°111111111S
f
z r^,`
--ramp - BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Mayor Pro tern Wilhelmina Harvey, District 1
OUNTY o MONROE :Al,. , _ Gene Lytton, District 2
likunisogoof
KEY WEST, FLORIDA 33040 v n1arty" Douglas Jones, District 3
(305) 294-4641 ; Mike Puto, District 4
Douglas M. Jones ;. .a MAYOR John Stormont, District 5
Commissioner Dist. 3 :,_.
310 Fleming Street
Key West, Florida 33040 ' Al
\
E-, !,
MEMORANDUM
DATE: February 1 , 1990
TO: Danny Kohlage
Clerk of the Court
FROM: Douglas M. Jones
Commissioner Dist. 3
SUBJECT: Voting conflicts-F.S. 112 .3143
As a Board member on the Property Appraiser Adjustment Board
and pursuant to F.S. 112 .3143, and as opinioned by the Asst.
County Attorney as a conflict of interest I therefore abstained
from voting on applicant Mr. George Halloren's application.
I received in my private business a contract of $2400.00 to
fumigate Mr. Halloren's premises and felt it would be improper
to vote on an adjustment of his taxes.
Since ,
Do as X. Jones -
Board 1 County issioners
Distr ' ct 3
Monro ounty, Florida
DMJ/mlj