Loading...
Item O05 0.5 t, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS County of Monroe Mayor Sylvia Murphy,District 5 The Florida Keys l'U � � Mayor Pro Tern Danny Kolhage,District 1 �pw° Michelle Coldiron,District 2 Heather Carruthers,District 3 David Rice,District 4 County Commission Meeting May 22, 2019 Agenda Item Number: 0.5 Agenda Item Summary #5513 BULK ITEM: No DEPARTMENT: Sustainability TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Rhonda Haag (305) 453-8774 10:45 a.m. AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Presentation update on the partnership agreement with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for investigating storm and sea level rise vulnerability for the Florida Keys to provide the recommended list of alternatives for moving forward. ITEM BACKGROUND: This item is to provide an update on the Study Agreement with the United States Army Corps of Engineers (USAGE), who are conducting a 3-year vulnerability study to assess the risk to the Florida Keys from sea level rise, storm risk, surge, evolving weather patterns and other changing conditions which pose a potential risk to Monroe County. The Study has been expanded to include all of the Florida Keys area, in addition to the U.S. 1 area previously included. The Study is a collaborative partnership with Monroe County and associated stakeholders with input from related agencies and the public. It is guided by the USACE and undertaken in partnership with Federal, state and local government representatives and other non-government organizations, academia, technical experts and interested parties. The presentation will include an update on the suggested list of alternatives for moving forward for structural measures, non-structural measures and nature-based measures. These measures are to help reduce our risk and vulnerability to storm surge. The goals of the Study are to: 1. Provide a common operating picture of coastal risk to provide decision-makers at federal, state and local levels with a comprehensive risk analysis for the Florida Keys. 2. Identify high-risk locations and characterize current and future hazards and develop depth damage functions. 3. Evaluate and recommend risk reduction measures to address identified problems. 4. Review and incorporate adaptation or storm resilience project recommendations and formulate projects as appropriate for future planning and funding. The end product will consist of a final Feasibility Report to include National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) documentation, which may authorize new Federal projects for construction focused on Packet Pg. 2258 0.5 protecting the Keys. PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: 09/19/18: Approval to enter into a Study Agreement with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to initiate a study partnership to investigate storm and sea level rise vulnerability for the U.S. 1 corridor in Monroe County, funded up to $3 Million by the USAGE; also, ratification of the Letter of Intent submitted by the County Administrator; request for Chief Financial Officer to sign the Self- Certification of Financial Capability; and authority for the County Attorney and the Mayor to sign related documents. CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATION: N/A DOCUMENTATION: FINANCIAL IMPACT: Effective Date of Agreement: September 19, 2018 Expiration Date: 3 years after the Effective Date Total Dollar Value of Contract: $3 Million—funded by the USACE Total Cost to County: $0, unless the study costs exceed $3 Million, then the County would fund the differential if the County elected to keep participating. The County has the option of terminating the Agreement if the Study Costs exceed $3 million. Current Year Portion: N/A Budgeted: N/A Source of Funds: USACE CPI: N/A Indirect Costs: N/A Estimated Ongoing Costs Not Included in above dollar amounts: None Revenue Producing: No—the USACE is funding their work. Funds will not pass through the County. If yes, amount: Grant: Yes County Match: Only if costs exceed $3 million. Insurance Required: No. Additional Details: REVIEWED BY: Rhonda Haag Completed 04/26/2019 4:31 PM Pedro Mercado Completed 04/30/2019 2:43 PM Budget and Finance Completed 05/05/2019 10:45 AM Maria Slavik Completed 05/06/2019 7:39 AM Kathy Peters Completed 05/06/2019 10:46 AM Board of County Commissioners Pending 05/22/2019 9:00 AM Packet Pg. 2259 FLORIDA KEYS COASTAL STORM RISK MANAGEMENT FEASIBILITY STUDY Alternatives Briefing for Board of County Commissioners May 22nd, 2019 Dan Hughes, PhD Rachel Haug Kristin Mazur Planning Resources Chief Planning Lead Project Manager MONROE COUNTY U.S.Army Corps of III I Engineers FLOW DA ��, Norfolk District PRESENTATION PURPOSE a '„ a f Discuss the Florida Keys Coastal Storm Risk .. iVlanagement Study potential solutions for reducingdamages and risksfrom storm impacts. The study will result in a recommendation to congress for authorization of a cost-shared (65% Fed eral/35% Locality) construction project. {+ KEYS COASTAL STORM RISK MANAGEMENT STUDY x`¢r3S'e>tr::n iaFr,4's�fNr' 4xrtro4e 3e;k?^&: ",,w�' i:r82 „fir FNi�.d`. x't •`".,:<..:. ., u� ,•. ' 4 , .. ".:.. .Fes? :'. ..".•' 4.•: �.r •,z A,�� 1. Work within the Corps authority to improve resiliency from coastal storms and ° understand remaining Residual Risk. 2. Develop a combination of implementable solutions that provide value to the community and the nation. Objectives Reduce economic damages from coastal storms to the natural and built environment in the Florida Keys. y Reduce the coastal storm risk to human life, health, and safety to the population in the Florida Keys. Improve the resilience of the Florida Keys to the impacts of coastal storms and flooding .:Iy •�. �`:: ., $..a�Yr'„ ar'+Kr 'a* L+a.'w�v.'S "'r+ y`sc ..... ..,.,.<., .��f '` ,r e bat�3- h'i' '�' `�^:r'xs.te° iis' @ 4' .r,A`•le ^: < w+w.,.,u+s+ Pq"�Ma•Ei4�Y4fd wN,w K'+x.h[R•itK•N,: 'i1FML.Y.»•+44Nr. y .... . e xr,r ..xr... LeW+.•W nY'f.':^'x'r""`x'. •.3•aHle•4•i •'+�S•T!•znIFNY Y"'^R';lkt'^i°'� .:„... .ri Jam• µtrv.,rurs.r.,.w. M IIn•Y:h.1t .... ..,. -, ,•. k ...K xs.b:.vt.oT°..s..a4�.s:rt r.Ez� . ;:-.u,.:a L...�.r;.:.�s.."°,{Y.,.Y.�<9EL7..x�.�$.iv,ee�a,,.,«.`�,.a,r•.^a,ia ar......0,d_,.:.eze Y .�..,.....,e.f.:.,..,,..II-,S.....z f�,.c..r�.h e4...s.sS,s,.,s..:.E,,zxc.,r..a<.L..-..,.,.�.,c.Y°c...>Y ue°.:3.........S.r.,are,„.r.Ly....°<�4:.>.z..-,,L.t,Pc....,<,.x.. c,a ct°.�r,...x......r:<i..`,S_zf.we<:�z:2.:.4:.•.�.e._...w..�..„,h,A..^�t a.a..` ��a v..6..f,T�.4_'�..;a:,.U.t;.,..,,..,s'•.i4W..-.«.E x_.•E�Y t,.,,.t,'.�.&.xtr+�.,..::�..b<.r.�}..:rr 3"6`E^e.i..,�,..M.,r$''�<.,�d. .r.<•,t'�'..<Y • Ps�� '4Ci° EAV lbE.<}P.ay:,.•.�ka,na:..,9. t kR''.tr 4"^� ",.t, r . x µy s rt' ! at� ' � ; ^`1,„ r.c�§42 s , b n 4.^ C � 4$ 4}�. r �r.� �«+ 3'� � t : r : a ,s W �0. +iT" P, 5 ., at E `a... s, SS a t... . ..z.. s r c �2.c x...E a a. 2n s.ro i.+ c.3 c7` r' `:'s+.s as v.a. � Ei� .ar.u,-„:�°as E < r{• :.<,t:>....`�r ,"�:.,::,.�E"'�',�e,-•4- , R } •...� L ,2 ..> x Y..a sT;i. EY.er.•6b•i E,a;aEfat Lf P< :.<. l°rar,.a-%.s L,dw.<„...... ,,,,, ....,...•, .-_.,�.d,•�. ,... .S., ., �.ro:^> ,,,_ ,r,.,,°i, a•sx.,,.�.a...._°_�.°, .u._. .. �..�.•,a;,._. ..•.,c.°.., , x �..:.� ..z„°...�„x.R ,Y..a s+.., ..<.s x ;;c�`� sa.�,`r°ati ty�t .m�,a�.s••s.a .k�q,....=ct.rx-m,a.tr„aa; e:�.r„�s� �t�.< =. 1`, ALTERNATIVES FOR RISK REDUCTION CI Measures developed with input from the Monroe County and key 1.41.14i stakeholders • '..i; .... .: „ r..!n. :14001Pl .'.5,*:", ' '':140.giirAL-r-` vi,:..,.. , , . . ,,..,,,,--.5.i.4....,W...-.:-.,.i,e-,-,',4,,,..,?,.,;;,,2!.-'.,-:.''-::,'t-:,..;:;-•-''.o'-,-ill-,- - .- 44'R)2I0,".iIFrl•4,„I J 1.4,•1:.';."'!'t"-,.gIit,.0.,..120,7A,,-:.-.g.gi i*.,,&,•,0o,:;'$4''':-7•,. tVi..r"''''::'.,!:..Aai."i"''m'.t- ,4I.,,',0,',0:/,k14,4,,,,-Onri,i1-F„,,-4'bP,o,:R.„,4-.-1 1.,t-..•ie6,,,,-,40-'V'..1.,''i;1:..&4ac,1,..r1.*..:P4"rrgig 4z0I4, k : Consiuerations ,y4Wgv 2204 1 „,I o•V.1f'*r,,...,??-ex.-f-3.1.1..,.$l pe1g4lr;,ie 0 g.4,,•Ag-,a4.I" - .-p"24„''4.-"•',.;,qvpg004r0.1 ,.,r 4jk`-:11 r,41.%1.„1:1t-0,o10it4)1.1i l.1'„a..t"4p-•.4.,5:„ia 00p„,,-g00o1.,.h.„.-r,,,.;i::.$4.,.'-.J-4 4,p44.-i*•,`4,ge'1:' ., .- , KO go*di , '„ .rsic FilK -4, ' -,,ar,.. .•<, •4•,••.•2 . ,',.4,-,,,2i.,11., pz '1. ',,,V,•...,-heg * g. qr. mt! iwz..,14 lei 42' 7.. , • Does the solution reduce coastal storm risk. 0......„,„:24„ grg A • • Is it technically feasible considering the FL Keys characteristics? li 1„lit• !pc-•:.!r.,r,,,- 1 -1.-N • :„.„ .,7 Af, .A., r.9-47,1i7.,-,7... 2;!..j...7,r.....,,:r„..;,,,,1,-. ,*Ix .,:,,, ,-- ,.„. .„ ,,,, -;-,.,,..i.,,,, ,,.: ,.,, -.,..„-,i.„,„;;. ,,,.',.. ars,g0.1 ,fire1WWOrr .:-...---,, • r.. '15wmt$0MP14.4: g,,,rn;I-,-,4,,,,,-,,,,A-.1,TA-4.,, „,-,h-, „,„: K, .„,..,.4.M.ii„, ,1;11.%..W1:,...k,,AP.:5,„ • Is the solution economically efficient? ::I,,,g:?qi',;;AkN4P'Ai,cr':;x7-4-txtxzdtv:rA4:;'%im:I- 4,-4 ,'-t,N,;,::'2,:e,:,,4::g.,': _i,- - -•r -'''''''-''''-'''-''''''-'..,,-,,, -r,mb- v,gor.4pat.„,e,, ,a14,s,,5s.„.io.h,,n,ib.,a,viz,,t,4;-.2,g,,,iT„,,,,,,,,,„;,,,,, t* ...,ligigulOINEIMU4SE4INKSMO.14HEMAqa.• Xklaii.:rabVigiTiar.320/reghlikTgalittk.V.A.V1/g"'StalRgAlli, -jw, "''"''''''"'. ''.-"N,,,WPAM,Wi,til,*.gr{4WM;4grgro;.W,4t,hv,;;‘,4,A.o.*4;,41,,Arr,-4',..t.„,,,,,s1:4,-,g3,h,..„, :ph .--- • I s the solution within Corps author'ty? AtairiMagMpitiarlAWMPPrri'mit75.-me*Vrelgmri'V'mW*14i,wiVngsViVvRa ','-'''' ''". ..,.„,, . . . , _ _. _.. _. ._ ... .., „. _, ... . _ ....... ..: .., ,, ..: ... .,: .,: ,.„Algvommoglamgmgmagralowill.011040100NOMPOPOS00800rOgkiggr ...:„„ ..._.. ..,,,,,.„.„.......:„... ,. ..:. ......,, . ......._ ,try.t,wwzte.,-,,,,i4 4 ,0103i,:,ik,,,i-x,,,R.,,,I.,-4 ^-;,2ee62if'i2;2;'t2222i22g',4222C2222r.222222,2'2e,224i0.A2i;',22i'A';'g•2222i":aP.4222:122,k'i2A2.2Ri2;2•r.23.i72P224'tf:22;d4222;'12'2iiii,2'24;2F42Pi'g,;.4iilii,iifc*;,..:6aio9.4izi,p4,'e§Agoq*izir,k;lkikzaii,,tltir,igoe,A,24iiics!i:koAFAkoi:igied*st%,,,A-qiVilA*-IFVLI;,..i!iii%:rikealgRiziki.,ge':'aAii,ikIV4,eiiP,L,w: ; 4..2ogi4N,?42ii464W '',WEIV:iliPtia.:IMPF.OPF":. .: 1:1 Measures are combined into alternative plans that will be evaluated with ':,',Igigwigiohimmin,Qi. : .A,TmatmoAggigmogsro .,...:,...„ • • • 1 Aiiiiiiiiiiiiiiikiiiiiko-.. ''."'=;- ,...:"'",,,s,i .'''.4.,.4.iaai'.iki.fiii. iR4'g;' !ikkk..4-igiif,;or. -giQgakE-. .,ii, itigilai.E-IFAEt'iNk;ltkaRV engineering and economic modeis4lipmv4,110 ,_. --.-nf,,,, ,,.;,,,,,,, 500-kipkimir,,,,a5vogiviyefati,:wpwvg-4440iggiow,p4m.,-.04,0 ,.,. •-ktiaie, ';-"''4,,,* '''' 'ilt-Mtpg"Pgeigr4t5rgIP';-4,IAFI,,,fg'friii4O31,:',,AP,i,.., t-Q'aq "' , .0,4441Pk2ki4i01*W..2,1§4",' ,,,, -.44,-,J.041ii.)-104e .Joirii4,10A- .dg,1=1.1.egwiir,44 VRAO*k,k4q,,ii,$47, 4ig,,, ,:ir&vi,,,le' ,:A•4,m*•w,,-..*:,.7„u4vEp;.,4e?, 20.0 ::.';,,i.:,,,.. ," q!mAbPV04k •3?,ez.,,,t, -„.!•.:, . ; I F . ., EXAMPLES OF POTENTIAL MEASURES Residential Nonstructural Solutions Non-Residential Nonstructural Solutions • Elevation " '""1 • Wet / Dry Floodproofing • Acquisition -4 ---�' • Acquisition in,t :' mla,i11l • Rl evation ---- -, ,. .41 _ _ �' '� . 4 ' 1 1 FT FLOOD DEPTHS J•14 FT FLOOD DEPTHS 14+FT FL000 DEPTHS a - —`— ir R 1� 11 [�Il 11 C I � IIII J4 J J b rsra:; qi,. "r+ sz r E:, n t "z; s r s Other Nonstructural Solutions , , , F $ Structural . ._. . • Roadway and shoreline stabilization Floodplain Management • Warning Systems -- ' Q ��"` • Ringwalls - • Breakwaters d 1a • 1 . A LTERNATIVE 1 : ROUTE 1 DAMAG 4iitiort) UCTIO hs KcY:. SR-9 Road Stabilization near ,, ,,1 Gulfview along the south side of ,� Lower Matecumbe Key,3,861 Ft, .,, *, " 1 ❑ Address segments of Route 1 ' , Mile Marker 75 - �� �� + identified as vulnerable to �` y .-,` �- ",,`u, coastal storm damage. P ya g r'' ❑ Shoreline stabilization, to ,N„,,,, . ry , ;, reduce erosion impacts on :lie , 4 the roadway itself. " ` °�' ❑ Shoreline stabilization and /1', r r ` ` NNBF solutions will be "'_$ . economically justified � ,, . ' •' primarily by reduction in damage to the roadway '�'. , infrastructure itself and — _..-: - that 'arc _ - other structures ,✓ C7. located behind. 4' 4lot { r y . 0 4" % P "9^ • r rt y 1 Road Stabilization t• ' .,M ,' " '` `�,,tv ku,. - z � ,a7 n Roads ' • Cities and Towns Horn, ALTERNATIVE 2 : CRITICAL INF ,• a CTU ' _ • ,:,,, tea, • ' ''- .« NNBF-3 't *. ❑ Includes fire stations, medical facilities, police �; NA AIIAIR I, :. stations, potable water STATION Boca "' NNFsF-2 NNBF-`4r. r.HrA FIRE ST ,is.1 ^ facilities, wastewater PH' ,fir. � "zz:z Acre s2TAcres - an rove Ira facilities, EOC facilities, `' NNBF-1 •• and airport facilities. The r:, Mangrove�� 0• ` e7oq Acres \ ; . ., , T� -«- ,* - - 4. I following measures have �, � ,, been identified as :. �.• ,,. ` '~- ' i effective in reducing k damage to Critical „ . i .; •-. g y, � ,KWIA FIRE/RESCUE#,t'1 �•� infrastructure: . �`• Floodproofing • Elevation ,. • Acquisition • Small scale Roads Police Station structural measures liat • Cities and Towns School on a per structure z ;.: -4 Airports Wastewater Facility basis (ex. ring EOC Facilities Potable Water Pumping Stations walls) leFire Station Mangrove • NNBF fa Health_Care_Facility w�:, SAV _ ALTERNATIVE 3: STRUCTURE D A * ' '''- ' "411!4 DU •ZY ' " •, , -Of 117Z Xey.5 .2 - . rale 1 @trrE5 t I -r, --- • -- e, . , p , I *r•to --- 4 D Address the areas of development V . . ' 4 I vulnerable to damage. •v lik; , , ,NNBF-41... / . • NNI3F-1 - . - V 'Mangrove CI Consider measures were carried ..„.. ,-,,, , . . Mangrove 1 , , 14'NNBF-3' 5-2 TA c re s . . , forward to reduce damage to .... 57.1 Acres I ' 1 ,, .' -- 45.3 Acres structures in the study area. Study . ,- , . 4k, 1.,,O. 1.14 ' 44 will examine over 55K structures _'w, a 4 . _4, p pm N jil . • ;, ,•. 40- ,41::44-, .. 0 •; "*... ., ......7.. ' ' .•.,, ,i. . for potential impacts to storms and - .. i"'' -,-1. . ,- ' 41 :'-vit . ''' - , determine which ones would be , - . - - _ ,. - - ...1 -74,44,:i , '. . 1 candidates for one or more' 'i.. ' c,I. measures including but not limited —"cle- / 4r.....!..t40 .1 tO: r*I• • Buyout/Acquisition • Elevation • Dry/Wet Floodproofing .,-...4.1 • Ring walls ,,,),q,., ie,' ....q.e.+4,04+;:44-,4-4,.., ...,' - $1.. 3-4-6,v4'. 4(0.1VO ,',,,Y,414."xi Roads Mangrove . No Nonstructural Measures Proposed -4.+,,,,, - - Y, , -- , Y.- Y-- --. Y ....• -, ..z.4.1 Y ._____• Cities and Towns SAV Nonstructural Measures Proposed . , , Hai,« ° FULL ARRAY OF ALTERNATIVES 4.311 i' � .., ,,,, livi.., e,,,,e, . , , . .. . , SR 4T Road �, ,, Stabilization along ' �. south side near. v m ,. .,, rMMrrr . ,� western bridge �•► abutment 584. Rh ". a,:.„„,,,,,,,,,,„z, 40k, , Cudtoe Mangrove .4.� .,,�, , �' cv.' ' w,,;: .. ' 'iLOWER$UGARlOAF" _ .. ," u ��VFO 10" ., Mange ve 78 3 Acres ' NNBF-6 , tilt - + ,t 'Maw �- Alt Description ve; `.' - '_ � 4>C��i .3 Route 1 Damage �s ta. 1 Reduction tylp . "�' 2 Critical Infrastructure ' ' f -�-- . . Structure Damage .. 1 -Al � 3 Reduction . . } 1 Combo Alts 1 + 2. .: 5 Combo Alts 1 + 3 Road Stabilization 0 Fire Station ' Potable Water Pumping Stations Roads © Health Care— Facility Mangrove 6 Combo Alts 2 + 3 — • Cities and Towns 0 Police Station =-`- SAV -'7 Combo Afts 1 +�2 + 3 ' + Airports School No Nonstructural Measures Proposed Nonstructural Measures Proposed 52 1\I� n.-r;,,., EOC Facilities • Wastewater Facility MEASURES SCREENED OUT 51,. . .. . "MV"44t,E HM. '" . '7, 441tNNVA4g,V=0•N '',MO''''lf 0.4'• 0' ` '''" *1 ''' ' 4 •,`01)1 l', -,4 ' "04 - &MPIAMIVOCENMPTIMM114400400100tithltON " ,'..""'L'P''11 r!L,;,---4---,,,,,:-.,,.,- -:--,--.--,,-,,-— - .. t,•- ' ' ' ' -..;:,,. . -,,,, ,,i,...,-..4 ,,,,,,g.,,,,,,,--..7-4.;=,,L.,--',-,,,,..,-.:-...,,,J;:!......t,..,;...; :,-,..,xm-A.„,-,...- ,:)7t,,,,..4-..:,:-,--1. --;;, ,,,w,a.... ,,,,,.!..v.:..2-0.. :..,:•-.....,,,,,,-;., ,4".^.: .?1,,,,,,,..,- , CISea Walls and floodwalls - Existing walls were considered for elevation and/or improvement, but there is no • • , „,. .„., .. ............................. .?................... . ............ $.....„.., high ground in the Key . ,r,IPAIMMONMXNHEINONNIMAGONNOINNUMINNOMMONERNMEMIWANNHOMMINNOMMIGMORMit..,..4. S '',UX.14NOONIMINCIMINPARNAMIraltOMMI-0251:0,14M-UNIMINIMMINTAMCA11".1i/OMMIMUMINNIN'AtHEINZIMMLook....,” '''NMINIMPT.gRINNMM9,99VPNFFT"'''MP'„Fil**UT.M,W,Y,5i4NFNEITMP'S'adWMM°41?Pl'4NgHNM4P3Mar4E, M -1AENTENEEMELTREIVIAINik.',.. '. '',,!mri.rmF.4i2m1,4immiimm,?iFenvivinsPER0404:: . : DLevees- Require a large footprint because they are-1..tiNTK,,,,7,,,,,,..,,, i.,.... constructed from earthen fill and require a trapezoidal ,„,. ,.., „, , ,„ ... .... ...„... ,A • -„,,,,',-,,,,,-...,.,,-.,,",,-„,:,,,,, P.,1N.1.5A'P,1i1M.A4,E'4M4,.315,,'I6AN..i•:?=UE.ABW,.,AO,.iRg',giAMgS.A.,P,lOi.kARrOr.,.gL,n design. . II. • 4-, into Li Storm Surge Barriers - Usually tied a seawall, tied into L'ITOPTnti.`' floodwall, or levee or higher ground. ir,mtvrom,-0-Tar=.9,w-F-- --- , MOON* . ..".. It . 4. w lot 440'04'40?Miiii. x..,i ' en•' -,PAR4r Aiittaggi -ligt*I,FirAii Iiiielli- -2':444,1;k0' leitarigligAvivz • 'railaW14-' IkEw4tx-u- • •§11. t • dilm, '14.4 il- • .. • • ' - • g • Wiwi IF '''''"ISiNvAiraqiii - 'rAfi ppkviav &ROM IMM.MIM'AMMORM46444V144444tRiSZK4M4h4031464144E01414d4MbalitliAMMMMAKMMMErrAdigi4MMIARMINOME4M4MakMEMMINF444K .*Miir '' KC M "mininingi oho' karmanadionionowit mido Azoi gommummomm.,4 all .4 a r•('AMMI4M4,1MOMMINMMOMMX404,741444a4M4C4MOMM*142044444.4444rANNVIMM.M44MMMMMUMIMICIMMVAIMM4B4MEMPAMMIMMNMIDOMMOMMADOMIMMAMMOMMMx4MM 14404.1404004R.. MICIAMP rOMMWAMMIM.. 10447AMEMINMAMMUMMAM4MK44441M4MOMM4440444=144411=141444 MOMM4400.404411414WMOVAMANX4a.014M44440,4=4440444MMMM404444,4MMOOMMANNAM4414M4141444M44M=MWMMM440.404MMM4,44404MMVAMMAti4MM=4.410, MMFAMMIX4M4MMWM44MMNMEM444,44HMMAIARMAI.mmlm4NAgm.144ENHAEmirgamompimmEmApoimmilmEmlmoisomr.spIng§Fvm 444044,144MMMTAMMUMMAIMMMMUMM.14100454MMOMMX444414504N444044144MENUMINLIMMT4MIX=4MMITMUPMCIMMIIMMUMINNONNNIIPONNMEVANNAISNIMILMINNIMMIFUMG. ..2,MoZ-A-q-N,a.,m...t.m-x,o4,&.,x,„k—m.44..tt.x-N-a-,m.gc.x..s...m..0-m..A..a,-§t,a,.m..a.AN MOAMICIMMONNOMICMPFMNOMMUMNMMOMpigHltiNNOMMOAttlMIOMMOCOMWtOMMN5PWOF.NeMa‘,4ERinny.F,REF,ISAFASWiEwma&pls4Anpag?pqp„ogagmox;iommmm4,4x4r.htseppeni;514wis.=smsnFamNigNEmmtax,popmrpiamiimp.),F4, 25,opg "" rrdnEMEININPVISMindubiliir4RIPArtaliittllidPifilliiL,'SiNEMREOPtoViiktAlliiktauhill'Ulghttit•IFSIPlaitiglikibi3/400gileilltirvir- lliftilypiliFirlii PlnENNIHRONOMINHIPENINNNIUUNahmallitiogigmiwku'Ismr,i.4t4wiii-Alneqw-hrg-tmnrim-guvwqonkt,uokmei&Nruhlk4Amwogr,whwiiixgAilighwiwpxnlmmix.=ag.arthriwrkuq•umiale .4n AU" A 44.04AMM A . 4. .., own Rm laNkmo,PNE0 4.1,000PiPoigilNitrmiPANVIT4NANH9541110t PAgN4,01,NW4:'0FloqiNFNNWimhdNkmihRiMigiNFOPM,414gEMAH 4.0igNneEmnonighoON4014NOmPliNtrghnpnIroigiimerrnshilmngYpn...n4 n P dIANAmm•H dm d 404 HR. FCIDS0,14.4 vtirc N.,011.4444.04,M7.44...7 ..001.,.%..M.2. .,%.,A 1,:IA wgi,Nr.ntloffl , aL.; ,..,4%,:e4..., . p,. .. ...&,,,!,, . ... ..0,4. A44,p. .gteo.. Yr.•MMtw.,,, Mr...7.g xv !.&,.NG. •jprh %G.w4 v.1,1?O x xxr:v. w r,*4rt.Mqv ..0. • , MEASURES SCREENED OUT LiBeachfill/Dune - The cost of sand is prohibitive based on the benefits a beach would provide. f H 4 %. ,,, • , „, ,,,x LJCana1 Improvements -Coastal engkfilddie ineers have wmpoopittioug tAhlfilMMEnaltaghtigiix established that there would not bea measurabl er Ti .� Yw1"Mzi"�i"e4:73?i,'Kw"A{f"anta?Sizi',eik' ,--,Aik"�2'a'hY..'S'.Ys"�*"hiw�aa•C':tie-}`.e`i^i'�G'h'.".,.'...'h"r'�f�t`"�iL'..iF'h•.�k":F'iY',iG'h'da'�'i.S'S'h .1".k-'.4',S.'ink-'i x-r''''.i'h' 5{rii`a4,44:X'7, +"ix'vx--,..,,, ,C,t,F:A':'h',1`i'f?,,,r'i3x•".kY$'1, NSF{+"i5k�r''�Ci-a'4—;+�',,,I,--• —`,--'i'h'i,'•'2L'u'".—.;,1�i".y 4'iC.•t'i`"."..`5fi,'••x,. e •�Fv.,Sk4.i,1t k•.e. 4 � C x.:� "� -�. A S .s.;. . � 'sE-. L '4 4 'N �- L Y.„4 R ::,k. 6 '� X 5 :5;. h.e}: '� ., X ,L., X.M,{. �.,.,,. ,.F..C,�. 4 zt"..€ #„7s: .. S C � �. AC .0 . � reduction in storm surge...... or wave `actionduring� a , , ,000,0R000-0,!opfi00,F „:„ „: significant coastal storm event. LJRoadwayElevation - While needed it is difficult to ali n t., g • with the Corps,„...„,.„:_„,,,„„„,••„,-, _:,..„ .,,,,,:,,„,,,,.„:„,,,,,_, , , . „ . „ mission and authority. ;,:„,„..„„,,,„,,,,.,,.:,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,t„,,,,,,,,,,„„„,„,:,,,,„„.:,:,„„,„i„,,:.,, : a a, a do ,kk X •1 IV-ti'•P,t Ny,: t t i }�1' 14 5 F, Y.tlC7G ZC :7, '''''KKihry,„ , 1 ." 1 "•t.: 4 T A t a. ' . .Ei fi t .,? .w.t ,.., � 7C, - ...„..,,„. , . r .. . ., :••---. . 1.t,..,4-. ;. "..z t..tll .,•i' ..", -.'�''-P1+... ,. '.,, .,t+i F,'� H ,}�'#.�V:�{,{,( .i m.�-i'� t, 4 j'*.(r} . 6," r,r "'SC : .'v"4,,NG„ ` "..i&ii .:.,,,. ....: ... ..�,. ,r,"o" 3 ,..,R •,..•� ? '+r.. N,.ai.;xs,.,,+, ,'!+.�,:_+.,sty:, .,.7; .P+A;_, ^;.7� �t .�r.,","��,:';y�j�-:Ii�?:` i''�`�+tF�t�;.•hx.�r,�tk ... � .;'"s1;�'�, ` � �C `��C�i � 7C:C9CR ;.�:" x s ri i; a k,... x fit. x i�xa� A .. �:; c ". ".>, •a .. ,, • ; +z "a tr;, :p.! :[x;fs:�"a:;,*- ,F;: .- :;f-'1Altc� ;::. :;. ... ._v5 . , � s04 a. ,�x:" : n a xa 141 :a .;xx.c�z..�• .,� '.�" � ... fit,� '� +—;,*,r. H ! '£ i. �.+r:e .. ,. ,..'" x � �" .c.c��n.c�sx.c.cxxx.c.c.z. csx •P ..�c i--413:1 ''4 k i?r�,: : z,' ., -.`9;V"+ ,a:'4w:.i.�`a !-r,,;:i i x-..a..zr•. �..rE x.•cxac.c4 F .IFII .;x.,x.ARglcx....c.x..A tx.., •azinccP oil ''sII gc.exx ," x ca ''' .. '.F44 ir' .31 4i*- .6•c• s zaxac.s.a. x• •.�xa m x.s 5'14 cx .Lx...c.cs;exxxa.x..xxx xx xxxxomom xx.,,. 1111 x"a "c� � ' c c c.4.cx c° . " . . ." x c c. M n•"Gi"w •xs.. ".x:.:c ..` .z.cx" d" cc.c" ca• xcc.....c.xc cc:x.xx..x. .;.c.cxc.x..xc.;.cc.c. . rx ?a • :t,'. • .• •� .•' ?3 ,,. d s .?;'fix •x„-�•".,: ' xx . •• .exx- .�C x• • • •• • ••• . ..xx c x • .• c..cs.xxc x scxxxx. xN . ..x.c xxxx x 3a 111 EE. 1.* •" �a I&� � C .c s11 , �S 1 ,.cue ` °` ".;' 3 k`+• " 3� ' e."C S C'3r`�1•`s11101c11 1'` " 00! t � li ' ` c3 " 10 • c9 "11 , c x•c .>ce04 . Nc, ,; c. . .�`a,...c ::x• .. ""<—— " t". ,",. .."<," "N' "" .". ' .� " •.. ,j !" .'"n" ".t•. "..t".,, .. .,,. , s'. ..,..,._ .'`a'..., ��.++ 5.. � • R..0�S"k� C 6 .C7E.A' 'x.,'Y. A X XX �C.0- • SMART Feasibility Study Schedule: Florida Keys CSRM , DE transmits final report _._,. Concurrent review package SCOPING & ALTERNATIVE FEASIBILITY- PLANNING FORMULATION LEVEL Chief's Report STRATEGY & ANALYSIS • ANALYSIS Tentatively Selected Plan (TSP)Milestone: 16 Jan 2020 ,,`_,; Agency Decision ) Milestone: 24 Sept 2021 40,1 '� 4 10 August 2020 " , r i ', 4 . It I�I " State and Agency Review: 13 May 2021 FCSA Alternatives Milestone: 9 Oct 2018 ti..-..) 15 Jan 2019 i y .vim �� .w .. 7 LL 2 yyk� DISCUSSION .. ,...r-- --''•',. '' t . L ' ' a'" , >_. , �7.xz r. eta, 5 L wk-. +r : aw :,.., 41,y off ,� `• c _ T ' � Y +v` w � .-+ ...wiw.dw yy,, ,a 1 1�•y �eN.e ♦ 1. *, �r �1 q.. sari r �k �\ t{� 4 r}tra ;' c sY i : Stabilization along _a , -`'' ,.. .,k " < . south E near ,,, .1 , western bridge =" ,w A j., abutment 584 Ft - d eJ rx. M 1. " .*. Cudjoe Key w n umm rlan d ," , ..,..,....,........ ___,,, ... 4,‘,,,i,....._ . 7.'''' *I?'' . -:."''',..."-:4 11,,,,,. ' '7 -4--.„ .-,,,',:---:: T ., 4, x r� ° c.. ,, Road Stabilization Gras'-' Roads • Cities and Towns 0 0.5 1 IMi Monroe County - Cudjoe Key Miles Map Monroe AHernatives us Army Corns Developed By.Tammy Knecht orangineerr Alternative 1 -Route 1 Corridor Date 5/172019 . ' Hom,teAdi •s', :# , Florida Keys, 1'' (113 0 1;2001 Stabilization .. . •-.,. :: 1 EM ga) ,,,. „........,.. ra:13e3GccCiStabiliTtion 317,) ga) ----.,._ ----, ._ „. .. - • . , . , ..„....., . t .• :,.-. :-, ,... ..,.. ..,.. ,.. ., ...., ,: ,......., ' . 114 14 .,- ;.ti.,:i.',-,At„.•" ....,fflegNt '..-....'''tV!,74,-;*, :;:',":1':,.':',1.4.Ii-',,,,S=1.,';..2-'•:.';',.?,,t7..:.!1.."':",k:r•'-:-7.4A. iittAr ' ' '-‘ -,-:"' - - ' . '','''' .•,"Y*,,,,,," , ' -.. . -„,. •, -,,- ,.,.- .. ':•,...• .•.„, Road Stabilization ;,.. ',:,,'..-..,.•.1,,,..,,;,.,.,„,,,,,,,;,,,,_, , L, ,„ ,,,,.,,,_ ,,,..„„,,,„,„,„„,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,,.. ,.., ..-:,.. ,,,, ,1,, ,?.;•„ ,,,,?i'ltiMA,,A, f..4$4„00,004:4-•,-.11:,:-.':,,,,,•:‘). .7;,j?:,*, Roads 04:lt:AfiP:7;.1Xiiil'::/ '','' t;ifPft2i.gAiOtfi4qjqiii;t.;i%l;r;'4Ribiil.t::':: • Cities and Towns ,',.,:',,:... ,-,..-,,,. . r:,.,.,-.,::.?.,..:,-:',:i",ii:14.40:#14.i0,' ' ',2.1t1,t4*,tiiine7.,,,:.!.'''''.',.:''''';',''',,'''','.,•.':!::',',:',14,,Olttfl,4fVtif.,:f,;t;,;11:g'..444190!00P;'j.fg:i'jFi:',:.:5,;y,- :,AW-4,d.rl,', 0 0 5 1 Miles Monroe County - Duck Key 1l Map MonroeAlternatives Eil) US Army Corp Developed By:Tammy Knecht s Alternative 1 - Route 1 Corridor Date 5/17/2019 !7Z Homeste5rl w :(.7,',:triti ' ,..,: Florida Keys 2.1... Fry 0 " • • • Stabilization .G G)narrow portions 10 " • • Stabilization CS]roadway along a:panCiT portions (11:0 south r of CQroadway along R33C0 C347 MI G7 I south drb of F ` V Stabilization >,. " a2 27 portions , .. CQroadway along ti Qb south of a , �1 Layton 4- kF r .v w ; 'rem" 'Sy'"" Sx5 r' :fs"r ` �e ,� . 11IM, ,'4: 3ah A` ( ' .'wide , r ti Road Stabilization ,max Roads *� • Cities and Towns " s y 0 0.5 1 MII'. Monroe County - Fiesta Key Map Mooroe Alternatives US Army corps Developed By:Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 1 - Route 1 Corridor Date.5/172019 i...air csu� Stabilization for the majority of the south r •� t: €Qlndian[1 • -6 Q +� ' Stabilization C3J( C� " ' for the majority of the r south side of Indian '-• Stabilization for the majority of the r south side of Indian l IDC347 41.,ECE1 l > Y k g gym'. -rm $fir ` " . " MY. r p Road Stabilization Roads T • Cities and Towns f Aitti. 0 05 Bisi Monroe County - Indian Fill Key 0 Map Monroe Atternahves US Army Corps Developed By;Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 1 -Route 1 Corridor Date:5/172019 riel Norfolk nwhYl , . _, • -- .,,„. „, ali'0011310Stabilizationi „,, , eida Keys E ' gitj south side,,,,,4•,,,:,,I... .;-,1;.2:,,,,,,• ,,, . , , Ililanticomtk.,; ,-• .'- '.i•%•, ?.• : . , .. ,,, „ • ., ,. `\ Qtalj Ft:/' .., - ,,,•,• ef '''-',',.: '-'• -•' \ ' 11',--',:;:''' •-,,f ' ' • •-s ,,,,,-,?-4 - -.. /•.,,,,,,,,- •.„„• -,,,•-.-,, -2:'1.-,.' '•'.•.,;*?*''' ' -,4,,••-,.!*•; -.4.0. . ..• :-, ;,,, •„•* :4:',,•':T., ',.'-,,F.,., :•• ••••'....1 ./ .:••••:'‘..- ' ‘,„,.. . ,,,• •;:.-;•,0•'''..:;7.-',''''' .. ,E.-. :70qoik 4 - . . ,..........-7-,r, .' -- ..;,.;-• • •'`,7 40, .../ ,.....t. .- . ,.... 4 ...... ,.,f ...,. r , , '0-••' .:. ' Road Stabilization .''..r....k:,•.2.,'.7,.,. , Roads i).''''N'l ' '-- c, •-, .. „:„.'...,::-'' ..,— . • Cities and Towns 1.--,...,.;' '''.,:--,-- , ' - . ',--.,':.,'.:'• ,-'.,..- - 0 05 ED Monroe County - Lower Manticombe Key Map Monroe_Alternatives 0 Developed By.Tammy Knecht USArmy Co/P Alternative 1 - Route 1 Corridor Date'5/17/2019 P7:1 .�. -.:; - .W" -"'__t, .. •.yF Homeste d - , 'Vei t - Florida Keys .c''' 14:, .." x° x ., . niE ,r. a :..a.. _ y�• _ r." . _ Big Pine Key ' • -Stabilization 4/ 1 k 1; ClA41 . . . S.;>., Stabilization �� ,,,. ram ' ,,W — Road Stabilization Roads • Cities and Towns .. 0.5 (Mil Miles Monroe County - Spanish Harbor Key Map Monroe_Atematives US Army Corps Developed By:Tammy Knecht US Alternative 1 - Route 1 Corridor NA. Date 5/172019 Nn�crt C+s r� . : om P5tpar: *40) W -"i. ..;*-" ...... . . Islamorada °Ker.„ ' - .... ._. .,.....„., ......... ,„...,.s, .. .. .. . . ... . .., . .. , . .... , . ......,:s.,,, ...,..„ ,..,.... ggpgg Road Stabilization ',,',. -,,, „._ ''' ''-'''. ••-,,'" ,-:,.,' ri along the'southarbC0 Wilson Key east bri. .e ^.4 -• abUtment al) t. . - • .1.- _::•-,' „. ,' ...b. ...- , , -,,,, •:,a, ..., , ;fttivfESt°4* ( .,..•1 'A" . , .. Nk. 4q - ,, .0. . 4 Road Stabilization I Roads . - - ,.;,,,. .- -',.---- .1-... •-.- , ,--- ,- -'1"4-•444-,--;',4',-...?-,•:--4P-',: • Cities and Towns 0 0 5 1 lin Monroe County - Wilson Key 421 MaP Monroe_Alternaltves Mlles US Army Corps Developed By Tammy Knecht of Engtneers Alternative 1 - Route 1 Corridor Date 5/17/2919 .11: Hom ,y :. . N *� r. "_* a 'Ida Keys sa. � yv T , 4 1. u- , w X t . w a A* yf - Big Pine Cudjoe C� `.Summerland y --xaa ' �. Y , - 4 • ......t.,." .. ,,,,...., ,,,,,,..,..,,o,,... ai4 , , , Roads ra • Cities and Towns »y `r , , -- Airports EOC Facilities • Fire Station (a Health_Care_Facility Police Station School Wastewater Facility Potable Water Pumping Stations 0 05 1 2 3 Miles Monroe County - Lower Keys- Big Pine Key Map Monroe Alternatives US Army Corps Developed By.Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure Nano, Date 5/1712019 rvonar.osun r.��# j r, H .n •t ' Florida Keys t° ..ilea ., °„a mm � • p �r '} .ate$ �w W � �. #*4- --,8 .Ats„..4144-- ''.02:547 .--L?:-4,1116. �,, Ewa. Cudjoe Key : Summ erland r . suaaaconF Acres :'w _ �Mlangrove `�; ram' q"".• , vFo,o. C Mangrove �' �'. i ` `- `78.3 Acres '` / : - J t' ''": ,.. ,-.‘\. Ca ‘..,, , ii.:.„. l'.,.� ,, 6 " NNBF-5 Mangrove ► v V Acres "� NNBF-6 '" 10. f 4 1 ._ SAV - r U ..,..__...„..,2.,„_:.„ ilfr:. ,,, il; ft,407:0„41. . , 0- , , , , 1/4-21-11f :,$) .;.,t. .;--•''41 r'''- BIG COPPIT FIRE ST 9. N \: , t - ' NNBF2 . , •.'s •y SAVE = - Mangrove ' + _ 22.2'Acres .f' 52 Acres .., , e-. P • h ,. NNBF-3 � ;,-' Roads Police Station � 45.3 Acres • Cities and Towns School Airports Wastewater Facility 1 ..,t114)1 t.�c"` >3 t EOC Facilities Potable Water Pumping Stations G Fire Station Mangrove I:I Health_Care_Facility SAV 05 E Monroe County - Lower Keys- Cudjoe Key Miles Map Monroe Alternatives ofo Army Corps Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure Date 15/172019ammy Knecht Engineers Norfolk Oisvin ,._ ..r s. , 0.' *T la %Pt-,,,, iiL ,,,,,, NNBF-3 I • 45: j 14" P at" " �, .<: O. STATION Bopik. ,. NNBF-2 ;NNBF=4, : •').., ,j a. # CHICA FIRESr.E "` �. SAY . 'Man rove i h° 2eAcres 52TAcres `'- �+�--y�� 04 v'r LOWER KEYS • ' *e Mangrove MEDICAL n 90' �ff�CENTER d. x� I , log Acres\��, , I i'' w S. ti, . :;..'NAVAL BRANCH y r ;, y HEALTH.CLINIC,` ..., -.r " I 9 ,., .. '. KEY WEST I r y S , ,� ...... 43i:1< „` �, M.. . ,A, " nitre i ." IN KWIA FIRE/RESCUE#411 t • a '•mow, w . „, 4 Roads W Police Station "' • Cities and Towns School + Airports 0 Wastewater Facility o EOC Facilities Potable Water Pumping Stations 4.4.,7'-: 0 Fire Station Mangrove lil Health_Care_Facility SAV 0 05 t 0 Monroe County - Lower Keys- Key West Miles Map Monroe_Alternatives US Army Corps 0 Developed By.Tammy Knecht Engineers Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure Date:5/172019 * Homeste4rl _ _lit i OCEAN REEF ., _„/-- . 'CLUB FIRE E - STATION 26 ` rlortda Keys s'., ~ y a ,''.“.:).601; ' 1'.., '4414', liktitt SW ..' . ''''''''...: ' .4111r: ** NORTH KEY y ".:- LARGO FIRE ,.. ^: ST 25\ � .e 1 a , 2 x 4 s Key Largo KEY LARGO FIRE} ,• r 1 RESCUE ,�1 iw Roads '' Cities and Towns :< 4- Airports o EOC Facilities y' lel TAVERNIER `' VFD ST 22, Fire Station s3 „ t RIN • [a Health Care Facility Tavernier • Al," —4 ISLAMORADA • R, MARINERS E 0 Police Station ..�-' FIRE ST 21 F. ..,, HOSPITAL 'POSchool Q �:� = Wastewater Facility ��'44 Potable Water Pumping Stations +e� - a Islamorada 0 0.5 1 2 3 4 5 6 Miles Monroe County - Upper Keys Map Monroe Alternatives oUS f army Coq>s Developed By.Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure Date-.5/172019 Nn'ipY.Lis,iiU • e. Horneste3d LAY TON VFD *Fa STle' - Florida Keys e,' Long Key _ -"` '' r Layton CONCH KEY ��. • e ' ,VFD ST 17 ., "`" r - w', IC a • il MARATHON '' ,fir FIRE ACADEMY r. er6 ,&° .,FAC LI TY -ter 7 !� y ,y FIRE ST 14 k, h . ie,I" KeytColony sa Marathon'p Beach• ' ' fir+' •• , ,:la - - - e t FISHERMEN'S Hosr Roads • Cities and Towns .•• 4- Airports i-' EOC Facilities �, G Fire Station [:I Health_Care_Facility 3 Police Station School Wastewater Facility Potable Water Pumping Stations n 05 1 2 3 0 Monroe County - Lower Keys Mlles Map Monroe_Alternatives US Army Corns Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure DateDeveloped 19ammy Knecht t Engineers Norror.Uisne� d F y k k , x R 6 i!' 1 1 -P� -" ;3 y c .--iiir,--,,,iN,,t,,,,t,-, y , ,,,,,o,.,, , II 0 ''' ) *' ' ' , 1 ". - f1Gi ,.i 1.v� by � .�f , r 4.1 __ ` ' lslamorada ` Iti I fi 1 .� • ' ,, '`r a•.. K�" z ISLAMORADA r .. ,; FIRE ST 19,•„ a m ,_-„w• LAYTON Roads vror... •• Cities and Towns ST 18 , -4- Airports Layton EOC Facilities % Long Key 1120 Fire Station CONCH y fa Health_Care_Facility KEY VFD •°�• sr n 1 Police Station . 1 School Wastewater Facility Potable Water Pumping Stations 0.5 1 _ 3 0 Map Monroe Alternatrves Monroe County - Middle Keys Miles uS Army Corps Developed By.Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 2- Critical Infrastructure Date:5/17/2019 rz t. H om este d 8\ ..t 1 ,,„ e ,,,;r .� �� �" , aG tr is 4. * • fit 69 ' * r, s' � fir,�.F:: ! ,# • • act. .vakW ,:was.- , :..,, d --- - • es-pro �. r ,x � � •. h Roads • Cities and Towns No Nonstructural Measures Proposed Nonstructural Measures Proposed 05 I Miles Monroe County - Lower Keys- Big Pine Key Map Monroe_Alternatives US Army Corps Developed By:Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 3 - Population/Development Date'5/17/2019 Norton DIso Kf .�1� - f „ Hom cste5d ,x r lr �:., t e. j[' $ , i,,..... . ,., „1 —.^ry r .._ yL • ne 9 `1'1k. ryr, , 1 , A • 9 Y 61, ✓' •, @ w rFlorida Keys F ',.., - • it•iti ,.• t ,y •••• Cudjoe � �"} . " r ° 4. . % �� Mangrove „--"It... whdAcres . , � (xl • r•b itt A. - �fr 1 .. ..`fir o Mangrove ' � ► ,,' 78T3'Acres ` 1 - ' -a. v,. ,•.._ ,. Mangrove 'TA 3 �:., co Acres - lApt 1000 1, + • �ti jb,.,. .‘t .11c0.07.7", . .,,,...,_,,,_3" . . '.44NNImi �,7 � ,., , ; s,: em ,. ei , •' _ ® grove ,,, .i.1 _..'r' Acres , e. <'°. 45.3'Acres "' Roads Mangrove • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed • Cities and Towns SAV Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 0.5 Miles Monroe County - Lower Keys- Cudjoe Key Map Monroe Alterr es �'S Atrni Corm Developed By:Tammy Knecht Alternative 3 - Population/Development Date 5/17/2019 Is rlda Keys .ra . g,4.'" • GgEPEt � k -_I -b � I•_ * / NN F-4• q. Y ti. NNBF-1 ManBrove .{,� 52TAcres Mangrove , I • 57d0 Acres .. •yiFY•. `w' ,. r 4 * •Pt?:* .. 1, • - - y `= w 1� r.� �•, n+ ,•v • ,�1�,,.r, • - •`•dam "� 'J 4. yam' 'rc J i .P� •• � t • • „ ," • q •,�_ -• •� • •j- 4 .+: *� „,n{�wa4 "" <:I t,P i ^ } kl , om,,:. ;+ '_04% Roads Mangrove • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed :, Cities and Towns 1- SAV Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 0.5 , 0 Map Monroe Monroe County - Lower Keys- Key West Miles US Army Corps 0 Developed By:Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 3 - Population/Development DateS„7R0,9 Horrqtead 1 0 _F Florida Keys Long(J • Layton ray 4.0000 a• p Marathon . °" • Key Colony,. Beach • Roads s No Nonstructural Measures Proposed • Cities and Towns Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 05 1 2 0 Monroe County - Lower Keys04 Miles Map Monroe Alternatives oof Army Corps Alternative 3 - Population/Development Date'�ed�,9ammy Knecht Erglneers uonow oti,Kv {. .=ad �, T rn ier Nomc � ave- t *4"‘" t, 4"Ak Orr 111k. der Florida Keys ,:- +T (Ce"dePy��f$� S� 1. r l /.. Vie. . ' • w . .0 le Islamorada . e,. 10 r. • a ir + - • , • yY ..,,,, Long Layton Roads • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed '`,• # • Cities and Towns Nonstructural Measures Proposed rf0' 0 0.5 1 2 3 rill Monroe County - Middle Keys Map Monroe AN M"B5 ernatrves ofU nmyr, Alternative 3 - Population/Development DDate'5°;;rz0;9ammyKne`h' E Amy Corpsrs T. --.a Homestead • F lir 410,. Florida Keys • ..„,„,,,,,xz:,.s ..t.,.`f. ,,....."4. .,...$44 Pn. t 4111 .0 lio'r ; - fi, • i., .: . ,itiliam_. ,,... .,. A.1.. IIPAINkt7 ‘ . • \'''"444%,.. ion Key Largo 51. 4^j4 k ti �. ' 44` -41r: 40 r � .N.- . tv .! 1 W w '• t aw+ �.� •d C� Tavernier ,�` ' - Roads 9 No Nonstructural Measures Proposed itire • Cities and Towns Nonstructural Measures Proposed Islamorada 0 0.5 1 2 3 4 5 6 0 Monroe County - Upper Keys ap.M onr oe Alt Miles Mrnaive US Army Corps Alternative 3 - Population/Development Date 5/17/201gaemmyt Knechts of Engineers r•.o=cF-r . ue' ..: • ...___ rda Keys �' t A .„, HomerteTr " a. * w fi M! Cam., T n x s, -, t ... q - .. . -7„ -,Stabilization along54. to*. • south - � ... �'` ��bridge 4 ' abutment 584 G�3, . _ SR-3 Road /- + *, R,;f .Stabilization cud .. a SR-2 Road Stabilization • 516 Ft. ,,, 6x^: a t�� Road Stabilization CI Health Care Facility 4' Roads 0 Police Station • Cities and Towns School Airports a Wastewater Facility EOC Facilities a Potable Water Pumping Stations 0 Fire Station • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed Nonstructural Measures Proposed 05 1 _ 3 Miles 0 Monroe County - Lower Keys- Big Pine Key Map Momoe_Alterna„yes eUS Army Corps Alternative 7- Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Development e Date Deve15ped/17/201By.9ammy Knecht f Engineers uonar.ow r. • •• .. • )r H orn Ps-teSf! • ' .• V*12, le 74';'.41: 6, , ...•',/4,4° v f A. .0.•• # ' It,"• :W"Al *V 4: ''P:i ' .: .'• " .f.'".7 '• -..----...r.---: ..-?•.. - , .• -,,/,,,:.- Stabiliz tion along • '--.„1 '''sk, ' "4,,\ -,,7' '' . .. . south side-.' , - .._ near -, ,,da K e y s , .".• 5. Senteei . '''' ..,. western bridge * — 4•L , ' . - .,..611. .. '0 a•-* itrir"-. V''":6 6 6 ' " . abutment 584 RI .A, twx-.1"«•1,..4 t - a11 , , Cudjoe G2V ? ...."1, ' '''‘, ' •,,, Mangrove ( l'or, . :.,,,,,A,„,: - =.% ,, - — 1 clapAcres' -1- i'X" . .. "1 ' •• . 640 ... I 1 -,;‘.. • . • ' .... „. . I&- ' \ •NNBF-8 -I , „ Mangrove .,0 .iAcres , OZ / 46 14L3f-5 N.,: •• '•-. i<n_ci juj ,ft,, ,. 4t, ,lit.vt, ..:Mangrove it • ,ik \ og Acres . 4-- ,-- - ,-- , , ......„ - -, ---,, -. ,.,•..:-..4-44 ,,,,,,.- ., :,,,i..0-1'.*4'" ' . .. ..14..4 , , -t'..-- -Mangrove ,-K-1;•7'. - '''.- lc CS Acres -.,,.... 22.2 Acres 'l.lers Road Stabilization 0, Fire Station Potable Water Pumping Stations 145.3,AcreS' Roads iv Health_Care_Facility Mangrove • Cities and Towns 9 Police Station SAV - , r. ,..- ..--4-;7,.- ;.. . • ',-',.: ,-- -,-. + Airports School - No Nonstructural Measures Proposed EOC Facilities - Wastewater Facility Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 0 5 1 2 in) Monroe County - Lower Keys- Cudjoe Key Map Monroe_Alternaltves US Army Corps 0 Developed By Tammy Knecht Alternative 7-Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Development Date 5/17/2019 F7:1 .c,; as .. Homestead r' Nw . l`p ilk l r Ida Keys ..c AiK' ,. arEglzalt- .z, ,„, 22.2 A r . r ".‹. c : NBF- , Mangrove '`' ` NNB.ac 'S2 Acres �,,w,v � � N. MsMangrove *� .H . * . _ ille SAV 57 }Acres ; u a * , -' ." . ' •VtAgit ''' :. 10. '" \ Atii ' • ":%';er-ii.,V• ''., ' 0„•,;hr ' t-": #- ',i'‘' " \ rdr • 6_.. ` $tF RE'9T2 c +$ . t r. `a *y;.,• • , '"` L X ��s C' • � �.r1�.r.T Wur+ � 4 � i .4- "4" , ;,,,.*st,44; "-. -. ,,,,,, : , 4001,,,..skv,b-, , - — .,, - 4„,„ wk sit x arm a. -. h` Road Stabilization 0 Fire Station Potable Water Pumping Stations�� Roads © Health Care Facility Mangrove zr��� — — SAV v '.ii, • Cities and Towns CO) Police Station 1,4x, + Airports School • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed o EOC Facilities Wastewater Facility Nonstructural Measures Proposed V, 0 0.5 1 Miles Ell Monroe County - Lower Keys- Key West Map.Monroe_Akernatives 05 Army Corps Developed By.Tammy Knecht of Engineers Alternative 7 Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Development Date 5/17/2019 n„oik on� i ) Homrstr d r of c %sId LAYTON t1 -._S.,—,.p*t-4 VFD t ST.18 ti^' u, Florida Keys r%"' x � Layton le � cfi'Kvcc�"° .. __ ,.. , .. 4144, .. ` abiization • • 552 G MARATHON ` F:,.. FIRE ACADE - SR 4 Road FACILITY �f°,, t t Stabilization ,, �`MARATHON x _ FIRE ST 14 • /�:•""'� :101KeyColon • Marathon_©Beach '`` FISHERMEN'S a ? HOSP y — Road Stabilization lID Health_Care_Facility it Roads 0 Police Station • Cities and Towns School Airports Wastewater Facility o EOC Facilities i Potable Water Pumping Stations 4) Fire Station • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 05 1 2 3 Monroe County - Lower Keys Map Monroe_Alternalives Miles . �SA`mY°°rp Alternative 7- Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Development Dotel5p;;,20;9ammYKne`M of Engineerrs "` TAVERNIER VFD ST 22' Cr 'ft Homestead -. . i► :.: T r Y e Hier � © AL v ;} ,r ;, • MARINERS ; HOSPITAL { Florida Keys IS AMORADA U' FIRE ST 21 �r -ar" &yW so ar w " ' , Stabilization for the _ " ` '� majority of the south SR_ 4i1 Road Stabilizatial'I I. _ Stabilization(gip " * cgIndian RD along the south side of �a /# � „ ( I I ��majority of the , Wilson Key east bridge Q;�O Road Stabilization . , south de of Indian ,.. � abutment 510 ,Ft. - ' ` p eag Ol heading G$I�Key 685 Ft. SR-6 Road'Stabilization —Gig along Q south side ` for narrow portions €flLower Manticombe 4. of roadway along � b • the south side of � } r " . Fiesta Key 654 ��Ft. tr +�� a • , t .41- ______ ��Road Stabiliz ion for the'majority of the, .. ' "A south side of Indian` �f . . Fill Key 1,382 Ft. :4'. ,r kl,re, . ' .+ ' - ,, ' #t , '. \ Road Stabilization 1 1 Health_Care_Facility yLayton .0 �`°' Roads ti Police Station � ::'' i a7 Rad Stabilization • Cities and Towns School • tomorrow portions -I, Airports o Wastewater Facility �'� Stabilization zation of roadway along MS the south side of EOC Facilities o Potable Water Pumping Stations Fiesta Key n532 Y Ft. 1)i Fire Station No Nonstructural Measures Proposed ,. Nonstructural Measures Proposed 0 05 1 2 3 Miles Ci Monroe County - Middle Keys Map Monroe Alternatives DeveUS Army Corps Alternative 7- Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Developmentrz e Date lor�pled1By 9ammy Knecht of Engineers • • , .... e OCEAN REEF'... CL FIRE STATION UB 26 0 ' .r 0 Florida Keys :. b 'Y.eY 1`rt.. p, ., ��� ill* ..e`f4,...... '. t lAtilor,, , ...t.. . e -,-a� ' NORTH KEY -' LARGO FIRE ST 25% , is Key Largo . ' KEY LARGO FIRE`� , , RESCUE#24 i i,. • .' �► '` Road Stabilization (a Health_Care_Facility , , . IAVERNIER (' '" 1~• Roads C Police Station i . VFDSrzz ate`= ; ` — • Cities and Towns School a.K,. I©tHTTavernier ( Airports 0 Wastewater Facility ISLAMORADA ,MARINERS 7 ..-"' FIRE ^, :'-HOSPITAL a EOC Facilities Potable Water Pumping Stations CO :it) G Fire Station • No Nonstructural Measures Proposed dieNonstructural Measures Proposed Islamorada 0 0.5 I _ 3 4 5 6 id Monroe County - Upper Keys0 M"ez Map Monroe_Akernatrves of EngiArmyneers Corps Alternative 7- Route 1 Corridor, Critical Infrastructure, & Population/Development DateI°P;7rzo;9an y l<necI1 /Engineers WOO,Disvic+