Loading...
01/19/2000 Agreement "Ii. BRANCH OFFICE 3117 OVERSEAS IDGHWAY MARATIiON, FLORIDA 33050 TEL. (305) 289-6027 FAX (305) 289-1745 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT MONROE COUNTY 500 WHITEHEAD STREET KEY WEST, FLORIDA 33040 TEL. (305) 292-3550 FAX (305) 295-3660 BRANCH OFFICE 88820 OVERSEAS IDGHWAY PLANTATION KEY, FLORIDA 33070 TEL. (305) 852-7145 FAX (305) 852-7146 MEMORANDUM DATE: March 22, 2000 TO: Timothy McGarry, Director Growth Management Division FROM: Colleen Gardner, Executive Assistant Growth Management Division Pamela G. Hancoc~ Deputy Clerk U ATTN: At the January 19, 2000, Board of County Commissioner's Meeting the Board granted approval authorized execution of a Development Agreement between Paradise Island Park, Inc., Key West Oceanside Marina, Inc., Monroe County and the Florida Department of Community Affairs under Chapter 380.032 Florida Statutes. At the March 16, 2000, Board of County Commissioner's Meeting the Board granted approval of Exhibits for the approved Development Agreement between Paradise Park, Inc., Key West Oceanside Marina, Inc., Monroe County and the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) under Chapter 380.032 Florida Statutes. Enclosed please find three of the above Agreements executed on behalf of Monroe County for your handling. Please make sure that the "Clerk's Original" is returned to our office as soon as possible. Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact this office. Cc: County Administrator w/o document County Attorney File ./ MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS FILE ~1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGlt444 CLERK'S ORIGINAL .. DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT RCD Apr 07 2000 03:31PM DANNY L KOLHAGE, CLERK THIS DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT ("AGREEMENT") is binding on the "effective date" as set forth herein between the Monroe County (County), a political subdivision of the State of Florida; Paradise Island Park, Inc., (the "Park") a Florida Corporation; Key West Oceanside Marina, Inc., (Oceanside) a Florida Corporation; and the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA). WITNESSETH WHEREAS, Oceanside is the owner of real property on Stock Island, Monroe County, Florida, located at the terminus of Maloney A venue at its intersection with Peninsular Avenue, being further described as attached hereto in Exhibit A - Survey of the Oceanside Property; and WHEREAS, the Park is the owner of real property located at Sands Subdivision, Block 27, Lots 1 through 18, Big Pine Key, Monroe County, Florida, being further described as attached hereto in Exhibit B - Survey of the Park Property; and WHEREAS, both Oceanside and the Park are located in the Florida Keys Area of Critical Concern as defined by Chapter 380.0552 Florida Statutes; and WHEREAS, Sections 380.032 and 163.3220 Florida Statutes authorizes the Department of Community Affairs (DCA) to enter into agreements with landowners and or governmental agencies to effectuate the provisions and purposes of the Florida Environmental Land and Water Management Act, which created the Florida Keys Area .~ l:f 'AIN003 30~NOW of Critical State Concern; and ':0 .~I:J ')410 30\fH10}.l '1 A NNVO ~Q ;OJ NY S~ 5nW 00 OH003H HO..:l (]311~ FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PG#445 WHEREAS, the Monroe County Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan contains objectives and policies that seek to preserve and protect Key Deer Habitat on Big Pine Key by directing development away from Big Pine Key (Objective 103.1, Policies 103.1.1, 103.1.7, 103.1.9, 103.1.13, and 207.7.1.); and WHEREAS, the Park is situated on Big Pine Key in the Sands Subdivision adjacent to Key Deer Habitat; and WHEREAS, at present, on Big Pine Key, there is a moratorium on the construction of residential, commercial, and transient development, including recreational vehicle spaces, due to the lack of sufficient US Highway I capacity for new trips generated by such uses; and WHEREAS, the following is a statement of the history and circumstances and status of existing uses, land-use applications, and development approvals that apply to the Park property: 1. The subject property is a recreational vehicle/trailer park with seasonal, residential, transient, and permanent tenants existing in recreational vehicles and mobile homes. 2. The Park has existed in this capacity for over thirty (30) years with local and state licenses for such use. 3. There is a total of forty-one (41) units of ROGO (Monroe County Dwelling Unit Allocation Ordinance) -exempt housing, or credits for same, on the site, and the County has acknowledged that the Park has the right to establish a maximum density of forty-one (41) units on the property exempt from ROGO. Page 2 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 7 3 768 BKlt1 627 PGlt44 6 4. To be considered consistent with the 1986 Comprehensive Plan and its successor, the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan, the owners of the Park have been seeking an appropriate land-use district (zoning) designation since 1986. 5. The Park sought to resolve issues arising from the applications to obtain appropriate zoning through litigation against the County, which the Park, the County, and DCA acknowledge has not completely resolved all issues regarding development. 6. Monroe County Circuit Judge Sandra Taylor has issued an Order, Writ of Certiorari, in Circuit Court Case No. 94-1528-CA-18 granting the Park its request to rezone the property from Improved Subdivision to Urban Residential Mobile Home; and WHEREAS, the Park, the County, and DCA agree that the Urban Residential Mobile Home (URM) zoning designation and Residential High future land use designation would bring the Park into conformity as to use with the Land Development Regulations and to the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan as to appropriate land use designation; and WHEREAS, the Park is currently non-conforming to the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan. The future land use category, Residential Medium (RM), must be amended to Residential High (RH); and WHEREAS, the Park wishes to maintain the right to use or dispose of forty-one (41) units of vested density on the site as exempt from ROGO and also obtain the URM/RH land use designations in order to be able to replace existing units with replacement units that meet County Floodplain Management, Building Code, and Health Code standards; and Page 3 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BRit 1 6 2 7 PG# 4 4 7 WHEREAS, the County and DCA wish to reduce the density of the Park to that which would be consistent with the Land Development Regulations; and WHEREAS, with regard to the Oceanside property, the following is a statement of the history, circumstances, and status of existing uses, land use applications, and approvals that apply to the Oceanside property: 1. Oceanside is a marina of four hundred thirty-three (433) wet and dry slips with accessory uses consisting of a restaurant, tackle shop, marine retail sales, and marine maintenance and repair. 2. Oceanside has obtained a major conditional use approval for modification of its land use approval in order to add twenty-two (22) units of single-family housing to the existing mix of uses, the whole of which is consistent with the Land Development Regulations and the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan. See Exhibit C - Monroe County Planning Commission Resolution No. P52-1997 - Modification of Major Conditional Use - Oceanside Marina. 3. Oceanside Marina cannot complete the major conditional use by adding the residential units solely because of the fact that there are not sufficient dwelling unit allocations available according to the requirements of the Monroe County Residential Dwelling Unit Allocation Ordinance (ROGO), Sections 9.5-120 through 9.5-124.0, inclusive; and WHEREAS, both the Park and Oceanside were in existence at the time of the County's analysis and census of existing dwelling units, July 1990, whose results formed a major basis of the ROGO ordinance cited above; and Page 4 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BKi1627 PGlt448 WHEREAS, the County and DCA acknowledge that the transfer of ROGO exemptions from the Park is not currently allowed per the Land Development Regulations, Sections 9.5-120 through 9.5-124.0, inclusive; and WHEREAS, the County and DCA acknowledge that the transfer of excess residential density in the form of Transferable Development Rights (TDR's) is not currently allowed per the Land Development Regulations, Sections 9.5-120 through 9.5-124.0; and WHEREAS, according to the 1999 Monroe Public Facilities Capacity Analysis, there is excess traffic capacity for US Highway 1 serving Stock Island; and WHEREAS, the County and DCA acknowledge that the transfer of ROGO exemptions from the Park, which is in excess of that allowed by the Land Development Regulations for a property of that size, would meet several Objectives and Policies of the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan with regard to Big Pine Key; and WHEREAS, the County and DCA find that entering into this Agreement furthers the Purposes, Goals, Objectives, and Policies of the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan and the Principles for Guiding Development of the Florida Keys Area of Critical State Concern designation. NOW THEREFORE, the parties do hereby agree as follows: I. PURPOSE OF AGREEMENT The purpose of this Agreement is threefold: A. To resolve all existing litigation between the County and the Park with respect to the appropriate zoning and future land use designation for the Park property, the Page 5 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 737 6 8 BK#16 2 7 PGi449 ability to replace existing units with permanent single-family home structures, and the ability to use or maintain the existing density on the property, and to transfer existing or credits for previously existing ROGO exempt units to other properties within the County. B. To allow Oceanside to become a receiver site for the excess ROGO exemptions available from the Park as enumerated above and to limit Oceanside's role in this Agreement to that purpose. C. To reduce the density of the Park property to a level consistent with its size and the Land Development Regulations zoning designation and Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan future land use category. II. STATUTORY AND CODE REQUIREMENTS The parties recognize the binding effect of 163.3220 and 380.032 Florida Statutes as to the form and content of this Agreement and in accordance therewith set forth and agree to the following: A. Legal Description and Ownership The properties that are subject to this Agreement are described in Exhibit A, a survey of the Oceanside property, and Exhibit B, a survey of the Park property. B. Duration of Agreement This Agreement shall remain in effect for ten (10) years from its effective date as defined herein. It is the intention of the County and DCA to promote rational and timely development of the properties to maximize best land use management practices consistent with the landowner's rights and commitments described herein. Page 6 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGi450 C. Permitted Uses I. The development uses permitted on the properties, including the population densities and building intensities and heights are: As to the Oceanside property, the development approved is set forth in Exhibit C, Oceanside Development Order No. P52-1997, inclusive of twenty-two (22) single- family residential units enabled by the transfer of ROGO exemptions from the Park. As to the Park property, the allowed uses shall be the following: a. Residential use - nineteen (19) units of housing subject to the conditions set forth in Sections II D.4; II E.2; IV B.l, 4, 5, and 6; IV D.2; and IV E. of this Agreement and other appropriate uses. b. Accessory uses, including but not limited to sewage treatment plant, landscaping, and accessory storage for each unit. For the duration of this Agreement, the parties agree that any and all of the approved development shall adhere to, conform to, and be controlled by this Agreement, Exhibit C, the Land Development Regulations, and the Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan governing the development of the land effective when the County, Oceanside, the Park, and DCA execute this Agreement as authorized by Section 163.3220 and 380.032, Florida Statutes; however, in no way shall this section require Oceanside to undertake the responsibilities of the Park, nor shall this section require the Park to undertake Oceanside's responsibilities. 2. In the event that all or a portion of the existing or authorized development subject to this Agreement should be destroyed by a storm, fire, or other Page 7 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGt451 common disaster, Oceanside and the Park, their grantees, successors, or assigns shall have the right to rebuild or repair so long as such work is in compliance with this Agreement. D. Public Facilities 1. The Florida Keys Aqueduct Authority provides domestic potable water to both properties. 2. Electric service is provided by City Electric System to both properties. 3. Solid waste service is provided to both properties by a solid waste collection system franchised by Monroe County. 4. The Park shall provide wastewater and sewage collection and disposal via an onsite package sewage treatment plant approved by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) or the Health Department at the time of building permit application. 5. Oceanside collects and disposes of its sanitary sewage wastewater via an onsite plant approved by DEP. E. Local Development Permits The following is a list of all development permits approved or needed to be approved for the development of the property as specified and requested in this Agreement: 1. Approved Development Permits a. This Agreement b. The approved, final site plan, landscape plan, drainage plan, and building elevations and floor plans as encompassed by and referred to in Monroe Page 8 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 737 68 BKlt1627 PG#452 County Planning Commission Resolution No. P52-1997 attached hereto as Exhibit C for the redevelopment of the Oceanside Marina. 2. Further Development Permits Required a. Amendment of the future land use category of the Park from Residential Medium (RM) to Residential High (RH). b. Approved minor conditional use development order for redevelopment of the Park. c. Approved minor conditional use development order for the transfer of one (1) TDR and ROGO-exempt dwelling unit from the Park to a receiver site. The Park shall file the minor conditional use development application at the time it identifies a site for the transfer. The County will charge Five Hundred ($500.00) Dollars for the application. d. Building and related construction permits for all main and accessory structures, land clearing, and landscaping as appropriate on Oceanside and the Park properties. e. Federal, State, South Florida Regional Planning Council, and Monroe County permits for storm-water runoff and dredge and fill if required. F. Finding of Consistency By entering into this Agreement, the County and DCA find that the development permitted or proposed herein is consistent with and furthers the Monroe County Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan and all applicable land development regulations. Page 9 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK#1627 PG#453 G. Breach, Amendment, Enforcement, and Termination Exclusive of any others except those imposed by law, the following additional conditions, terms, restrictions, or other requirements are also determined by the parties to be necessary for the execution and enforcement of this agreement: 1. Breach of Agreement and Cure Provisions a. Upon the Park's or Oceanside's material breach of the terms and conditions of this Agreement, Monroe County or DCA shall serve written notice on and shall provide the Park or Oceanside the opportunity, within ninety (90) days, propose a method of fulfilling the Agreement's terms and conditions or curing the breach. The County or DCA shall allow the Park or Oceanside an opportunity to cure the breach or to negotiate an amendment to this Agreement within a reasonable time, not to exceed one hundred eighty (180) days after the Park or Oceanside's response or proposal absent exigent circumstances. b. The following events, unless caused by fire, storms, floods, or other acts of God or events beyond the control of the Park or Oceanside are to be considered a material breach of this Agreement: (1) the failure to maintain the open space provisions of this Agreement shown in Exhibit C; (2) the failure to maintain conditions placed on permits or approvals contained in or issued as a direct result of this Agreement; (3) the failure to comply with applicable permitting requirements of Monroe County after notice and opportunity within ninety (90) days to commence to comply with such permitting requirements or, if applicable, to commence compliance with Page 10 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 7 3 7 6 8 BK# 1 6 2 7 PG# 4 5 4 such requirements and have completed within a reasonable time frame, not to exceed one hundred eighty (180) days, as mutually agreed by the parties if compliance requires more than sixty (60) days. c. If Monroe County, through its Director of Planning finds that the Park or Oceanside or a successor is in material breach of this Agreement, and after notice is given as provided herein to respond to or cure said breach, the Park or Oceanside fails within a reasonable time to respond, cure, or secure and amendment resolving the breach, the County may utilize appropriate code enforcement remedies to cure any breach. 2. Amendment, Termination, or Revocation The parties hereto shall at all times adhere to the terms and conditions of this Agreement. Amendment, termination, extension, or revocation of this Agreement shall be made in accordance with the notification and procedural requirements set forth herein. Amendments to this Agreement shall subject the Park and Oceanside to the laws and policies in effect at the time of the amendment only if the conditions of 163.3233 (2) Florida Statutes are met. It is further agreed that no modifications, extensions, amendments, or alterations of the terms or conditions contained herein shall be effective unless contained in a written document approved and executed by the parties to this Agreement. 3. Hearing Requirements a. Before amending, terminating, or revoking this Agreement, Monroe County shall conduct at least two (2) public hearings. Page 11 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGlt455 b. Notice of intent to amend, terminate, or revoke this Agreement shall be advertised at least seven (7) days before the public hearing in a newspaper of general circulation and readership in Monroe County. The day, time, and place of any further public hearing shall be announced at the first public hearing and the date thereof shall be advertised at least seven (7) days before such public hearing. The notices shall specify the location of the property subject to this Agreement, the development uses proposed on the property, the proposed population densities, and the proposed building intensities and height, and shall specify a place where a copy of the proposed amendment, termination or revocation, and supporting information can be obtained. 4. State and Federal Law If State or Federal laws enacted after the effective date of this Agreement preclude any party's compliance with the terms of this Agreement, this Agreement shall be modified as is necessary to comply with the relevant state or federal laws; however, this Agreement shall not be construed to waive or supersede any contention under law that the Park or Oceanside has acquired vested rights under prior law. 5. Enforcement a. Monroe County, the Park, or Oceanside, their successors or assigns, any aggrieved or any adversely affected person as defined in 163.3215(2) Page 12 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4,2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK#1627 PG#456 Florida Statutes may file an action for injunctive relief in the Circuit Court of Monroe County to enforce the terms of this Agreement or to challenge compliance with the provisions of 163.3243 and 380.032 Florida Statutes. b. Nothing contained herein shall limit any other powers, rights, or remedies that any party has, or may have in the future, to enforce the terms of this Agreement. III. Compliance with Other Laws The failure of this Agreement to address a particular permit, condition, term, or restriction shall not relieve the Park or Oceanside of the necessity of complying with the laws governing said permitting requirements, conditions, terms or restrictions. IV, Additional Provisions A, Zoning Designation Monroe County shall initiate upon the signing of this Agreement action to record and reflect in all appropriate County records the rezoning of the Park property from its previous Improved Subdivision (IS) to URM-RH (Residential High), based on Judge Taylor's Writ of Certiorari in Circuit Court Case No. 94- 1528-CA-18. However, according to Florida Statutes, Chapter 163.3194(1), all land use decisions must be consistent with all elements of the Comprehensive Plan. Therefore, in addition to being consistent with the Objectives and Policies of the Comprehensive Plan, a change can only be granted if the requested Page 13 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PG#457 zoning is consistent with the future land use designation for the property. Pursuant to this statute, Monroe County shall initiate a change to the future land use map from Residential Medium (RM) to Residential High (RH) upon the signing of this Agreement. This change shall be adopted by the County and approved by the DCA prior to the approval of the rezoning of the Park to Urban Residential Mobile Home (URM). By signing this Agreement, the County and DCA acknowledge the appropriateness of the URM zoning for the Park property. The County shall allow the Park to submit an application for minor conditional use approval of the redevelopment of the Park contemporaneously with the County's initiation of the change of future land use map for the Park, B. Transfer of ROGO Exemptions and TDR's 1. The County and DCA acknowledge that the Park has excess density in the form of ROGO exempt units and TDR's that, by the covenants and stipulations of this Agreement, may be transferred to other properties. 2. The County and DCA shall allow the transfer of twenty-two (22) ROGO exemptions and TDR's from the Park to Oceanside to allow the construction of the residential component of Monroe County Planning Commission Resolution No. P52-1997, Exhibit C. 3. Should circumstances beyond the control of Oceanside prevent the use of some or all of the twenty-two (22) ROGO exemptions, Oceanside shall have the ability to transfer those ROGO exemptions obtained from the Park to other properties within the Lower Keys ROGO subarea, exclusive of Big Pine and No Name Keys; and excluding any properties receiving negative Page 14 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 7 3 7 6 8 BKlt1627 PGlt458 points associated with Habitat Protection; Threatened, Endangered or Species of Special Concern Animal Species; or Critical Habitat Areas pursuant to Policy 101.5.4 of the Monroe County Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan, subject to County approval via a minor conditional use approval. 4. The Park shall have the right to transfer an additional one (1) ROGO exemption to another property within the Lower Keys ROGO subarea, exclusive of Big Pine and No Name Keys; and excluding any properties receiving negative points associated with Habitat Protection; Threatened, Endangered or Species of Special Concern Animal Species; or Critical Habitat Areas pursuant to Policy 101.5.4 of the Monroe County Year 2010 Comprehensive Plan, subject to County approval via a minor conditional use approval. 5. None of the ROGO exemptions or TDR's transferred from the Park may be transferred to a site that is more environmentally sensitive than the Park property, pursuant to Section 9.5-343 of the Monroe County Land Development Regulations, nor shall the ROGO exemptions be transferred to the Offshore Island, Mainland Native, Native, Sparsely Settled, or Parks and Refuge land use districts. 6. Prior to the approval of any building permit which is issued pursuant to the minor conditional use order transferring any ROGO exemptions and TDR's to Oceanside, the Park shall demonstrate to the County, through twenty-two (22) demolition permits or other evidence acceptable to the County which documents the required removal of units, and provides evidence that a deed Page 15 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 173 768 BKlt1627 PGlt45 9 restriction has been placed on the Park property permitting its development up to a maximum of eighteen (18) single-family dwelling units. Demonstration by the Park and confirmation by the County shall occur within 30 days of the recording of this Agreement. For the purposes of this Agreement, this shall mean that the Park can demonstrate th<;tt mobile homes have previously been removed from the site or that the mobile homes will be removed within 30 days. Nothing in this provision shall abridge the rights of a tenant at the Park to exercise his/her rights under F.S. 723. Insofar as the time limits for the removal and transfer of any unit at the park are delayed by the exercise of those rights, the time periods of this provision, as to that unit only, are tolled. 7. Any cesspit credits created by the removal of cesspools or noncompliant septic systems on the Park property up to a maximum of twenty-two (22) credits shall become the property of Monroe County. Any cesspit credits in excess of twenty-two (22) shall remain the property of the Park. c. Oceanside Affordable Housing Donation Oceanside will donate $26,400.00 to the Monroe County Homeowners Wastewater System Assistance Program. D. Impact Fees 1. Impact fees assessed Oceanside for the development enabled by the transfer of the twenty-two (22) ROGO exemptions shall be for single-family homes. Page 16 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE ~1 1 7 3 768 BK# 1 6 2 7 PG# 4 6 0 2. The impact fee for the remaining one (1) unit shall be assessed as a single- family home prior to the issuance of a building permit less the credit for the impact fee for the existing one (1) mobile home. E. Method of Approval for Transfer of Density This Agreement shall be the instrument that allows the transfer of twenty-two (22) units of transferable density rights from the Park to Oceanside. The Park shall file and record with the Monroe County Clerk of Court (upon sale of the transferable development rights to Oceanside) a deed restriction on its property limiting the density to eighteen (18) units of single family housing or mobile home units plus one (1) transferable ROGO exemption. F. Termination of Legal Proceedings Against County Upon the signing of this Agreement by all parties and its subsequent recordation with the Monroe County Clerk of Court, the Park shall terminate, withdraw, and cease all claims and actions in law against Monroe County and the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) filed in local or circuit court or court of appeals related to zoning, site development, or code enforcement on the Park property. G. Development Site Plan Approvals for the Park The Park shall have the sole responsibility of preparing a redevelopment plan for the Park property, which shall specify landscaping, buffers, setbacks, open space, access, home sites, and location of wastewater treatment plant. The Park shall submit the plan as part of a minor conditional use application within 60 days of the recording of this Agreement. The County shall process the plan via a minor Page 17 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 6 8 BK#16 2 7 PG#461 conditional use approval within 120 days of the recording of this Agreement. The approval of the Park's redevelopment plan shall not be a condition precedent to the transfer of ROGO exemptions to Oceanside, nor shall approval of the redevelopment plan be required prior to the construction of units at Oceanside. This Agreement supersedes the time requirements of Section 9.5-72(a)(1). H. Park Compliance with 723.083 Florida Statutes The Park shall demonstrate to the County and DCA its compliance with 723.083 Florida Statutes, if applicable. For the purposes of this paragraph and compliance with 723.083 Florida Statutes, the Park shall provide documentation to the County in the form of a list of other suitable facilities for those mobile home owners whose units would be removed. The specified list shall be provided to the County prior to a demolition permit being issued. I. Recording Monroe County shall record this Agreement with the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Monroe County within fourteen (14) days following signature by all parties. Recording fees shall be paid by the Park or Oceanside. J. Entire Agreement This Agreement incorporates and includes all prior negotiations, correspondence, conversations, agreements, or understandings applicable to the matters contained herein and the parties agree that there are no commitments, agreements, or understandings concerning the subject matter of this Agreement that are not contained in or incorporated into this document. Accordingly, it is agreed that Page 18 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK#1627 PG#462 no deviation from the terms hereof shall be predicated upon any prior representations or agreements, whether oral or written. K. Severability If any part of this Agreement is contrary to, prohibited by, or deemed invalid under any applicable law or regulation, such provisions shall be inapplicable and deemed omitted to the extent so contrary, prohibited, or invalid; however, the remainder here shall not be invalidated thereby and shall be given full force and effect. L. Limitation on Individual Liabilities and Responsibilities Notwithstanding the individual liabilities and responsibilities of Oceanside and the individual liabilities and responsibilities of the Park, as described by this Agreement, nothing herein shall require the acts or responsibilities of Oceanside to be a condition precedent to the Park being able to carry out the development authorized by this Agreement (with the exception of the transfer of ROGO exemptions to Oceanside), nor shall the acts or responsibilities of the Park be a condition precedent to Oceanside being able to carry out the development authorized by this Agreement or Development Order No.P52-1997 (Exhibit C), with the exception of the twenty-two (22) units of ROGO exemptions transferred from the Park. Should the Park fail to transfer the twenty-two (22) units of ROGO exemptions to Oceanside, nothing in this Agreement shall prevent Oceanside from obtaining the twenty-two (22) units of ROGO exemptions from another source. Page 19 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 M. Jurisdiction and Governing Law The parties hereto agree that any and all suits or actions at law shall be brought FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK # 1 6 2 7 PG.4 6 3 in Monroe County, Florida, and no other jurisdiction. This Agreement shall be construed and interpreted under the laws of the State of Florida. N. Conflicting Resolutions All resolutions or parts thereof in conflict with the provisions of this Agreement and its resolution are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. o. Successors and Assigns This Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto, their successors in interest, heirs, assigns, and personal representatives. P. Notices All notices, demands, requests, or replies provided for or permitted by this Agreement shall be in writing and may be delivered by anyone of the following methods: (a) by personal delivery; (b) by deposit with the United States Postal Service as Certified or Registered mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid, to the addresses stated below; or (c) by deposit with an overnight express delivery service. Notice shall be deemed effective upon receipt. For purposes of notice, demand, request, or replies: The address of Monroe County shall be: Mr. James Roberts County Administrator 5100 College Rd. Key West, FL 33040 Page 20 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 The address of the Park shall be: Mr. John J. Brier and Ms. J. Leslie Brier Paradise Island Park, Inc. 59001 Overseas Highway Marathon, FL 33050 FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK#1627 PG#464 The address of Oceanside shall be: Mr. Roger Greene and Key West Oceanside Marina 5960 Peninsular Avenue Key West, FL 33040 Marci Rose 818 White St. Key West, FL 33040 The address of the Department of Community Affairs shall be: Mr. Steven Siebert Secretary Florida Department of Community Affairs 2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee, FL 32399 Q. Effective Date The effective date of this Agreement shall be upon last of the signing by all parties and delivery of proof of recordation to the County. (Signature pages follow) Page 21 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGi465 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands and seals on the day and year below written. Signed, sealed, and delivered in the presence of: Witness: Paradise Island Park, Inc. The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this 2000, by ~V\ r ~ri~r and J. Lp\ Ii! ~~~allY ~n to me or produced IdentifIcatIon and dId not take an oath. (FLORIDA) ~fA) ~ BJ1~Jf{ By: Print Name ~ "(Y\ ~ Signature A-n VIe ~(/YY'IIZrO Dated: :r Lesl,'~ Br;ev- Printed Name ~~?~/ Signature 5~(C'1 r: e~ State of Florida County of Monroe By: ~t;~~. . ie Brier Dated: ()2/jo /r)O , / IOlk day of Ff?~ Bn'u They as Page 22 of 25 ~_ (2-d Notary Public Printed name My commission expires: My commission number: Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BKi1627 PGi466 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands and seals on the day and year below written. Signed, sealed, and delivered in the presence of: Witness: Key West Oceanside Marina, Inc. (FLORIDA) ~~I~L..~) ~ :,/ Signature tl/U-bt:fh 1M htmJ1.f-tn Printed Name By: '. ()w Dated: .:1-/1/00 . ( ~ S / t re State of Florida County of Monroe The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this ~ day of jfb, >-1-Ul ,2000, by {:b.L~{P';. b. L-ualht-t' , . He is personally known to me or produced as identification and did not take an oath. '~~ r-i N P bl' ....",y~., 0 e 0 rs otary u Ie /!'b:~~ MY COMMISSION # CC906777 EXPIRES ~.,&.iff January 31, 2004 "'1,~"; t\,~"" BONDED THRU TROY FAIN INSURANCE, INC. .. :IRu,'" My commISSIon expIres: My commission number: Page 23 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE 11 1 7 3 7 68 BKI1627 PGi467 APPRO V AL OF THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS J , 1hOrY\G s Beck Print Name By: ~~ llre~/Co~~ ~ State of Florida County of \....eo('\, The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this ~ day of Apr'l ) 2000, by J.!he N'\l1.S -p) u,k . He/~ is personally known to me ~ pt=eQ\H':8G - a5 it:kntification and did not take an oath. N~ {1. UMd ....;tr.~~ Beth A Frost ~:f'~'1/~ MY COMMISSION # CC884492 EXPIRES ~'~~.l1! March 1, 2003 "'~kY..r..~., BONDED TH~U TROY FAIN INSlH!ANC~ INC. My commission expires: My commission number: Page 24 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK#1627 PGi468 APPROVAL OF MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS On the l'ltlr day of ~ ' 2000, Monroe County Board of County Commissioners approve this Development Agreement by Resolution No. N/A ROE COUNTY, FLORIDA .D.C- . By: ~~J~'~~ MAYORSHI YFREEMA Page 25 of 25 Walker Development Agreement February 4, 2000 I I ~ I.~ I IX) (,) ;:jCC l1.:~ ~lJ!JaJO~S '}fwd ..,L-__-~~- - .99/~ 0\ .~ '" -41: o U () () G:C) S 001' lD~ I'~ (Tlo.. I' HI' HN _lD caH o-J *' H:><:: c... l:Q -.J. ~ ~~'1 ,/.-1[.::: ~. /', , / "j ~~ f(~:'~ // t:1 . j"'! " ....... ,<I ~.; r" ~--.:t ................ ",1 I" -: ~1 I :J : ~t! t ..~ . ~I , J i ~I I. ,1 , I I : "1 .1 r I " :~II' ;:'j ~", ;3 [1'" , I ~ " ' ,,=; I ; ~ ;$1 ~ ' U l~. : I , ' :~l ~i I~I I! :~ I '~~ ~ ~:. ~ t Vll i.oJ L1 r'l, :'.: j . . ~ r;~ ,J .... t'j I,' . .' '\.., t., I';' .....", . '. '0) " '1:>.~.. :., '1"4 "-...:c~ ......t'lIIo.... ,.: to 1.;- ..- ".....~..~-J..l .~ ....,~ ,J:J . f' . '-.. iW~ .-.c..............J..,.. V .#.... Q-.;-...._ .... ,: ',' 0' . ..... . TI--. . C" "~':":':T.~'.:~'.:.', ... :~.~: ~. ti g :'! .. .? .:' . . ',' I):: 1 , ' '. .~ ~ ",),r- ~..:...~~-~lO-' , e 'l>>" E /ry' ~.J \ f " l::t ::t .f/ .,' I ~~ _ f '"'- ~ /V..~-l \ 8 I r:Y::~;":- ---' -/ I';' i - t~_~ ....r- .~~~...~~;.~~-. .~. :,:! ~. .... ~F",;:' , .,."- " . ,. ., ,. " '. ' . .~l;II:.~_.___'---.:.' · ,'. .' :-.__~>t:;Op !2...1~~~.___~J;)UO:1 . .LJ1'" '-~.' - o - ~ ~ Q ~~ IIi'S .~,...j en '- ... {j~~ , 1 e.'~ ~,:. t{ tr. I" ~ ' I . 41: _.-- I cr- ~. ~j {i r, :1; ~ 1 ~ r j ~ P. ~ f Cl ~ - f ~. ~ g i r~JO~ ~pj~ ~I'~ . .-42, 3f1~ d. t:r\ ~ Q ....... tr) Q -~--- ....... o o CO -() - - .......0 Q.)O) ~~ ~, ~li tr)~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ....0\. . ... 'S .... E~~1i .t~~~ ';) <:) 11\ ~ 'l) ~ J ci I ~~ ('\ t> ~ ~~ :,i':: vi t-: ~ '2. < 1..l (.,) o '< ~ < .~ 0 ..0 .~ ..d 0:. >< 0'\ 0 ~ rolD ....i "'- lD~ I'~ "'- (Tlo.. 0 I' () HI' >- HN ~ _U) m Iz:IH o-J *' H:><:: I%. l:Q dl YOg~ .!IVAI J() M'1f <b@ (.,) \- Q. ~ ~ ........, CI) ~ \) <: c: ~~ C) ~22 ~ "'-~ G o <J ~ 0 Q 2U) c: .~ " t! C) U <::Q O~ j::C: -----J Q..~ 5?~ (.).Q ~~ Of -.J~ Q. ~~ 1iIQ.. -.J~ ~ 'Z. < -.1 \- < -.1 '" '2. '2. ~ X U Q) -J ltJ (J Q:: ~ Q ~ ~ < -.r. . .~ . ~ r>..~_~~~~: .g ; "I I ' ';) I . ~ '.:.,1 "1 ;":11 ., ..-- ,- --..'. . 1~~" .~ " . I ~ . ~, " ~ ..! ".: : ~ _ . Li .r ~_..=.~..r:-.~"~, :~~;; .~. '., . '1:1,)(1' alaj"UOJ~'-"'~(-:' 9:' ,.i.~ ..' :';': "oJ61l1L~':~;:';~~'~ .~'..::.: !' . .~'1 c~~ ," "., I:J ~ ~,,: , ..' r: :-r~.:1 to- - . "\ 1 :.~ -J . I ,1: ~ r '~1: ~. ~\j a- '1 ~~:~j'd : f-'j ....1 . . . . . . . . .- .:.~ L~ ..,..:tt, ~'1 :~ i'; " i L-',':::::i f"d "I . . . . .00 DZf; ,Q9'lLL ;'~.~~~ .' r:1 F51 '.. '''1 '~l h~ -.- .~, rr. .1 :.~ r' \..1 ~ i ~~ ~ L~~=--;'.~~ ~. j ;~~:~I i' , :'1 I:: . ~ ".-.0:.; ~-:'1 t:,-----~ '. I '1 }.j "~ . . . . -- .~ '- : [ . "" .. 'r:: a ~ . . F.. - ...... - - .. ,.,... :"L": ~ . .- .1 ~ , .. I,:, . ; . It..:~ ., ," '" . ~~ 1 I <l:~ .. -.--, . .r- -..... - J '.-t : 'l t., . . . . . . . . . l' , <, , " . . ^; . . . . . . r"f;:':' : I.t '. ~. ',~~ ,..'I:.:. ' 'l\~: '. : o. . ~'. Cl' : ,. \ . i.~,+--. L_--:""..--! j. ,-'1 ,i , - ---1 c '" '- ~ lJ '"'- ~ . 'ii- ~ .c ( '. iU U ,'. __ ..... ~(~ 1:: ~ .- .... f) -Y. :.:l .c ll.' ~ :l, c u < '~ - <,(1) CiUr.ci - ~ \J f)'~ C If) ~ r-.i C'.... ~ C\i ~-.-1) .....-. tl..e~O~-...... J: -E--Q..;oO 1::lQ!? (.lC\) c C ( Q ,c: c: (J' '- ~ J - C\) c:~ ':rl.!2 " 'J) ~ .c: ~i c 'I) 1) ~ -- ..... ; '-~ ~-;;~ '-'~' ~ t.l Q c: " '" ~ .- Q;::: "'..... ~ 1I)__(j,Q~c: ~V)...........~:J C II) ~ /~ "')". 0....: <(1)- -(1)0 0 "?~1::l ~ . ~~ ... ~'-.....'- '="', ..Q co::::_.. ,-n'-C\)q)Q.~ 1tI "-4 ti <~ \.'~ o~ E !Il' ~ (/)1 ~C\)'\) ........ ~ tl'I 't) ..: Q .... II) C (..... 01 o ::llo" C f) '1) tl'ICt:: 1: ~ Q ~ ~1 C ~" .~ '- . -.... 'J -.I' 1tI..c: :J C 1) \J " ..... \J -- -c C\)_..J -.. ~. - flJ 10.0 (\,. 7.:'1 C 1::' fIJ; ~~ tl . 0 I~ lI) Q")__'~'44 :J r-- '- .~ ~ ~ c ~-g ~ 1tI o-J'i)Cl-- I.;. .9- C'.... '- a. ct-e ~ '- \.. ~ c: fJ) '.J ..0..: ~ctl'I'-'.l"".9, c ~.S U 0.... a tl~q)~ l} -..J -Qc,- ,: .... .~'...) ~ If)'~ 0(0 C'l1\11l1 """J c..... 0 ~ ~ 0~1~l)'1, \J C 0 ~ - ",S- '-.~ 'l'J..c: ~ .,;... Q: 'tJ 't 1: ~ Q.~ C\)_ fJ___ . <t' V) ~ <: ',,) ") lit. .~-J~r:;~ 'itL_..--_~ --t1t':' )(...~.__'~..:.-J ~. '" ~, :.l'l '., \1, ft':;ll~ .: :~I'I .. .' ,. -1;1 .. <'. .,1 I~ : .~..j di4'. ':r- .....~.4 ;' '.ttp--:':'..... :' ~l';. ':j[j fJ' .:. . .,,4j i~ :....:~~ I '. ';, '. +Ii ~." ..:: " t'l ~.. . . ,..t:..--, :-.- ., . Q': -..:' ) I - - '-' , .. . ,,'" ,'. . " _t. .' f!f~+i ~ ;~~:,;,~~,'~ . ~ '.1' ,..:....! j .., t~1.' :...~f :; .~.,1~'.. ,; ~'p'-' ') " · ~t~~:: ~~_u .. ri.l., :'.' l!ci · :' f:'.~ :l~~ r.~~ '.' II i I.. . l~.~ .. '; ~ ,':l'k::TT..-c:n .1. ,) _ ""I ., 'f:~ C" ...' ~::I".,,:j'..r.~ ,. 1, . ~ I ~ f . -;.tJ 4 ;.~ ':- N t. .' {'1 _J-" J.: ....---..".-...- -:: p.-~'" '~'-...~. . ~. _ C. .~',;. -,__ t: . ' I ' \,;/(: ,\ : . I ~ ~ . 'oj' ~. . ::. .' ~ l' : .-,:..~:.....>~. .- _ '-.,' ',~.: .,ij,! -, .. . -, ~ . f" .' -, . . ,~~ CLd - ' '1 . . .' , ....G.I : ~~:..,- ..:., ..::::t:.:-;~.--.. :,.:'l.?L-" ;'j -. '~I.-:-ir:jZl:---" , I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I 1-' II) I \'5 I I I ,.u ~ I ri \! I fl" if '-l. -- - 'lnos ~ u o ~ . . / ii.':.~:.:j' , f . .,: .:. ~'_.Il ./ ~.' ...,. ". :"'~1 L _.' " . ~J~;1;~ r ,.. ...~ -.t:.,l'~":~~~ ~-.f.- ~...~ : Li', ~ ~.t Ii) , .. ~. .. ~ . f ~ u' .\ C) .. I ..... t " -' . I ..~ ..... / (.j.. '" J1::: '" t..:'~' ...~., ...-j "~':~~~': ;f:':.'t.'~: 10'....... '1 I ~),~....~i '. I ~~.;/ ::: ;:~'r · : .~.~: ~'J Q.. . .~. '. ~ e : '.':.:"! I 'f':': " '. "1 ,e. ;....,."t.-;:'.~.... -1 h~:"A Q::: ~ --- , .. I~-f.'. ,...~ 1 ~ ~.l..'......~ ~ .~::;} ""5 '. ,1. .~. .,~~ ~ r;;..'~ :.:lj :--.J I ,f~";' "1 I . --; ". .,.,:.11 '-lJ ..,'- " ' "~:~ t':. ~ G - . . I(":"~ 0::: ' L~}:~?~ ~ Gr:,~,"~JLQ , 'I' . "1 ' 1"'1:'.:~: I . -l .' '<'I jj.' I .... ----'L /to I ,.. qos~ '."'",: :,..i.. .... '. . ~ ~ l, C '.I ,. . . . . . . . . . . . . c) . . . . . . . . I . -J Lu (j ~ rot' lD~ t'~ lTIo.. t' Mt' MN _lD t:aM ...:1* ~;::.:: lZ..1J:l Cl::: ~J:2 I "-I' ',." ~,.:::; I , ~ oj - <\t ~ Q 1__ V1 ~ I.) ."9'1_:;: .".... 'to.... C C U U ClJ ~ U ClJ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ \.: lJ \~ (J Ij 'J (J ::: ~lJ I.; U V '.J 0 '.J .J ClJ (J \J ~ U C C C C C C ~ C C C C C C C U C C ~U~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~2~~~~8~~~~~~~~~~~ClJ~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~g~ClJ~~~ ~~c -c -c -c -c ~ -c ~ _ -c ~ -C ~ ~ ~ ClJ~o ~ ~~ u~......~-~......~-~...... ......~......~-~......~-~......~......~......~-~-C c~......~ ......~~ . '. '. '. ,.0 '. '. '. '. '. '. ......~~ . .. :-~ .~ ........... ................... _. ~ ....... ... 0.. ........ ....... ....... ....... .~.. ...........~.. ..:~ ...~u~Q.);::Q.)~cu~Q.):q; :Q.)tJQ.)~q;;::cu;::Q.)~Q.)~Q.)~Q.)~~ ."""~~~ .... 'lJ ~ ~ R ~ 'l ~<< ~ It ~ t ~}U ClJ ~ ~ t ~ I Il) t ~ I ~ R ~ t ~ R ~ R ~ ~ ~t ~ t ~ ~ t II a " ll) ~ ~ C) -..::. _ 10 - 'I..;., !,Q ~ C) Q) "'t- - ~ I Q.) - ~ 4 '1'l ..... :- "') :t' Q) ~ "" :t co :t' ~ :- '" ~ ~ ~" ~ :- 'l) ~ ~ ~ C) 9 - ~ '" :t ll) ~ !,Q It) ~ ~ 9 '" SI Co) - Ii) 0') C) ~ to') 1.0 <0 0) C) Q) - _ C'.. Q) "" - 0") r-... ll) Q) C') Q ~ "') f', ,...... "') r-... "') ~ ..... <::l "') 0") ~QO')~ti~~~~~~~~~ti~~r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~!,Q~~~ - '" ;- r-) C) "') 'Y ~ loG - " ~ ll) ~ ;. - to ~ " "') - llj ... "') C) "'1 "'1 - - ~ ~ ~ Q) llj. - ~ co C1::l .~gllj~~~,~,~.....~,-,Q),Q),~~~.....~,~,~.....~.....~,~~~,~ ~I CI , ~ 0 ~ 0 (;) 0 (;) C (;) Q'.I) CI <Ii C l.n 0 (;) 0 In Cl <.. C <:.. Cl (I) 0 (,,1 C'J') CI . "') (;) C ~ ~, ~ ClJ ClJ .) ClJ ClJ It) It) Il) ClJ Q.) ClJ ClJ ClJ <lJ It) ClJ ClJ It) ClJ It) ClJ Q.) ClJ 1) 1) 'U It) ClJ 'U 13 'U It) Q.) 'Q.) 13 ClJ U U It) U <.J 0 U 0 U 0 0 0 \J 0 U U 0 U 0 U U <.J U 0 U U U U <.J 0 U U U Q.) CI 0 (J U -= C I) ~ C C C C C c: C c: c c: C c: c c: c c: C c C c: c C C c: C c: c c: C C'J C C C 1) ~ c ~ ClJ 0 Il) ~ Q.) 0 It) Q ClJ Q ~ ~ It) 0 U Q 'U ~ Q.) ~ 13 0 Q.) 0 <lJ ~ 'U 0 ClJ 0 C ~ <lJ ~ Q.) ""ClJ'~"""~-~~~-~~ """-c"""~ ~--C~~"""~""~"""~-Q.)V~""- ,~~ ':l ...... II) .......~ .......~ .......~ .......~ ~.(;) 'E ,fI1 .....~ ..... Yi....,~ ....~ .....~ .....~ .......~ ....~ -c c: ......,~ ~ ". 'tJ ..... iJ; ..'0 , "tj '. ~ '. ~ '. "tj . -0 , -0 . 'lJ . ~ -0 '. ~ '. "t) '. "tj -. "tj '. ~ '. "tj ........E '. "tj '. ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ 1)o~ <lJoQ.)o~~ClJ~ClJoQ.)~~oq)~U~ClJ~~~ClJOClJO~oQ.)o~~ClJ~CU~ 1) . ~ ~ ~ . ~ _ -.:;; . ~ . ~ . .~ ~ . ~ . ~ .~ ....-: . ~ . ~ . ~ . ~ . ~ ,~. ~ ,S ~ ~ ~ .1.0 ~ ~ ~ <::l ~ - ~ ~ ~ 0") tJ 'J") ~ Q ~ '" l..j "') ~ ... ~ IJ) ~ ~ ~ ~:t C) ~ -.;;. ~ - ~ "') E ) t tJ') ~ C".J : "') t "'1 << "') t "') R ~ t 1',) ,..) . "') ~ ~l" ~ Z ~ t "" t '1'l R ,~ I C1::l . ~ t - ~ '~~t ~~r-)~~~~~~~~g~~~~ti~~~~~~~~~~;~~~:t~~~~ . - CQ,.,,.,. ,..... -. "'). -. ,",,' ........ ll). !,Q. ,.,. -' ~. l'J. "'). '" · ~. <0 J~ ~ ~-'ll) . 1.0 ~'~O")-Q'a ~ '" ~ -' ~ ~ ~ _ '" ~ ~~; .....a.....~....."'1,.~ll)~C),a~a~Q~Q'''')~''').....llj,'''),Q~a~C)'Q c~~~CltocbClbc~ClbQ~c~CbO~ObC~Q~C~Cl~O~O~C1~o...... 1.: -t: lJ:- <lJ ~ Q.) "t: ClJ ~ Q.) ~ It) ~ ~ ~ 'I) ~ It) ~ ~",: 'tl r: lU "t: It) ~ It) ~ Q.) ~ 'll:t' ClJ ~ It).S u ~ 'oJ CJ \j <: (j <: \j V) (j (;) (J (;) ~ (;') ~ ~ u v) 'j IJ) U ~ U <: (J ~ (J (I) U (I) U ~ \) 'J 0 (;') 0....0 c: C.C C C C C C C ~ C C c: c C C C CQ)C c::.... ocuoV)oQ.)oQ.)2~......~Il)......~cuolt)~It)~~oq)oq)~Q.)2ClJ~Q.)~cu~Il)~~~<lJ~ U~ ~O~U U 0 U......U......o....o......o......o-u O~U......O......o......<..~o'7ll) ~ ;::~ ClJ~ c'~ c~ c~ c~ c'~ c'~ c.~ c'~ c'~ c~ c~ c'~ c.~ c'~ c.~ .~ c~~ ~~~~It)~Q.)~u~q)~Il)~U~It)"tjIt)'lJIl)~1)~Q.)~It)~<lJ~Il)'lJClJ~ClJ~lt)v...... ~ ' ~ ~ ~ -c ~ -c ~ ~ -c -c -c -c ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ......~~o......o......o....~......o.....~.....o......o......o.....~......~...~.....~.....~......~......~~o...~~ .. .;..: ...... .. ~.. ....;.: ": .;.; ...;..,.. ....;...... .. ~ ....;.,..... ... .:...,.. ...,;,.,... .. ~ :- ~ .. ..6..: ...;..: .. ~ ...:...,.. ....c ...;.,... ......... .Q.)~~~Q.)~Q.)~ClJ~q);::q)~Q.)W<lJWIt)~Q.)~'U~q);::Q.);::q)~Q.)~Il)~......;::'tl~~ ~R It)t ~. ~I ~R ~t ~: ~. ~: ~: ~: ~. ~t ~. ~: ~I ~t '.: ~: .~ C) . q,) ''1;) '::> t'-~ ... r.o ~ ,,~ ;:', C') Ii) ~ :? ~ r.o .... "') q; "') .: J .... J - ~4 ....:I Ii) ~ r.o ~ Q) S>... ~ ~ '!'> ~:t' ~. ") '.0 '0 "'t ~ II'J 9 'J ~~''l):t' a::- r.o!f) It':. :."l.b 'fJ ~~ :'/~. '-t: .() ':J'l '='l ": I~ ~ C) ~ ..... C'~ 0'1 ~ - -t: IJ) Ie: ')J ~ r-. C I i'... '::: '!> -: ::? '': '" ~ "'t ~ CJ ~ ~.. .... .'~ ...~ ',:; '-1-. ""} '!1 'l) 'I ~ : 4 ~ ~ Q) ~ <::l ~ ~ ~ ~ '!J r.. .l) () - c-~ :- r) :'1 "1 . ' ':0 ~ ..... :- ::)) ~J I." j ; ~ C1::l .... "1' .l) ("'I -. 'J") ~ 1 C. - ~ ~ "') .,. ..... I.t) - ~ Q ,,~ 14) ('\~ ..... - .., '0 - "'1 'J) ~ ~ ll") C' ~ ':0 ... C'~ - C\.j 1."''1 '.0 Cl ~" I.') 0'1 '.r) ~r ~ Q ~ Q) ~ ..... ~ ~ ~ ~ 'I .,. 'l) r.o r.o I.t).~ ~ . ~ . ' ...... . ~ . '.... ., ...... ...... . ~ -.... ..... ...... ,~ . ~ . ~ ...... ,'_ . "'1 ..... . '"- ") ') In - V) ':) <: ':) <: ':I V) Q (;) Q IJ') i)'J') ~ <: '" '-I) '"\ l,) () <: :) <: i) tl) fJ V) ,) U) i)'f) "1- (.I) (:) <: <) ~ u = -- 1'.1 ~.,) . c- 'U 'U -. ...c .... -c n -f"Ji ~ ""- "-- Ij___--=- ....... "- ~ I...:Q)CI) '-~" .Q.J<.J\J'U.....~ Q) 't:1'- $ "t) Q) c: c:: t:: t') C C :::..S Q a'" ~ is rJ" ,.8 1: 0 0 c:-, 0 C Cl 0 a ,(') -.J " - ...... _ ') ~ ~ '1:) \..) \..) U Q == 1..... 11.1 '') :,.,})i: " .~ ~ Q Il.l C :::: \J '3 ~ ,-' I ~ Q.) (.) o'~ '_ ~ .~Ct: Q '.Ii It) C' -- ..... . 0 ~ 1: --.. c';::' ~ C < Cl f 't) ., .5? I) ;; Q.) ~ I....:.c ~ ;,; C"-? C' ...... "I I.... ( '.-.. l: l'JI ~ 0 U +. C C) '"ll.) ~ ~ ,,~ 1..' ~ I.... ~. C '" C.~ . ~ ..': - (", -.:..,!l...... 1l )", ' t> -~ Q.) (', - t'j.1:: '... 11 -~ -:..... I ~ r .-: (,) I'J to Cl .~ 5; ~ ~ .() ~ " "'--- CI) ........ ....... ~ ct ........ l- V) V1 ~ II II II II II I.... "l-,-i . 'T'j , ' L..... Ii ,) , ,'" l.l _ I r If) .... .J ".1::' 'I II 'I 'I ?o;: .."",,' t, ,OJ l- '. '-' ...... - c t. . ... \.. \.; 1,1 (1. ....... .J C t1 ..... ...., ,- "', .u. t."'.. - Q) .,. c::.~ n A) 't'] I.... (.::: ~ 0 v ~~ ~~ lI).c _"_ Q.) fI1 ;:; '- _ o C:'~ .'~ III '" C) 0'1.. ~::..: - <lJ' 4.~ ":;- ~ r', c' ~~:J) C ct.' CJ'I "') . eel f'1 ~ ..;+;: C 'l:: !04.1 Q.) "J'l vl t-:: tl.S'~~'; ()t)I....Q.)Q)G ~ ..Q ':) ~l? c: r'!) CI) 0 - ,0 ~ ~'Q Q,I ~.~ ..:: I'\.r l) ..... I.... ~ .... I.... .., 0 t-'l t1 ...... ~a ~<.J'=C~ c: 'oJ c'" () CU ...._ Jl ~ '''-... E .... ~ t r' ":1 ~ ~. ,:, "t .f> ~ ~ ~1 '< r ~JI'J r: ~ , -. II " II it II II II II II If lJ ' l~ 1) ~ " ..... I r l fn ci, -_. - ~ "J ~. - 'h' ( '. . (' t~ I) ,; ~I I...: ~ It "- I. 'I II '1 II II II Ii i' ~ . . . . r.Ji ~.....:. ",.r- '.1 ~ .lJ ~ : Q) -< l ) ... .<L~~ .. ,,( ~ _.,"V)~.,.t. ;('}ll! n '. -~ ...... - j' ~ I (,~ -\ Cl'l .to I '1 , - , ci ;!~ q, I.... :.:- ,~() . Ili 1, ''tlIJ') .~ ~-i I'" C"..... . ~. ~ 0 Q .... .... c -- -- __.. o '- ~ ~ ~ .~ ~'" "- ... '.' ... "', {'oj -"'-''X ~~' 't:l ~1.' C' c.. 10..1 :) '::!......., q, 0 Q.'tl If) ~ L..:."J) H II II if ~... :; 'C~ CI .J .~ t~ l5 .:- (j') 1TI II) E (:J -<oJ rot' ~ - 0 0 C u'o t: w 0":: L. (j') t.D~ -J+A~"O ";( t'~ ~(J)a.C IX It)U 0 0 1: lTIo.. ~~..;: C t: \;.-u Q.)C 0 ~ t' E -:;:; Mt' :':: ~ 0 0 ~ .- ~..... 0 u w MN (;)0"">'0 (/) .cCl)en (f) .....~en 0 _t.D . ~ ~~-~ en t:aM ~'- -.l.l :.E 'l) - W ...:1_ :2 <<i '0 r= C ~;::.:: (;).ag 0 (f) lZ..1J:l ..J"" 'U (f) "'0 C L. W file...... 1) -.J 00(, 2: Z e-Cl)'O C C :) ":1 Ol L.. 0 ~ a Q.. '0 o.::! 0 :J Cl)Ol....c o"jCIl ~ en ~ -OOc(/) C '0 <( (f) ..- .- 1) 0 L. u- Z 0..::':: ..... ::J N rot' I.D~ t'~ (Tll1o t' Mt' N :lO I:lQM ....:l~ 1-1::0:; l%. !Xl M rot' lO~ t'~ (TJp.. t' Mt' MN _\0 I:lQM ....:1_ H::O:; l%.!Xl (;} l; ...- .... , ~ , ...., - ~ ..'"".I '-<J l' ,- 'r t'", '- -<J' I.... ..::: '.. 1> Q. - h c.. ~-: '< " - ',) ~ a 'l-- ) - C) r ':'l .J <l --.j l" I I << I I I ' , ;.. / . I "';. r ,,; T , t ~ __ ."" -'0' ";0'-' -.; ,- ;, i-'- - - -.~ - - -.k- :r-'<"'" .;;~f..c:8 t-PfP~. "~- I 1 \ \ ~'" ~ i ~,-\ .ti ~ ~. i -:f~ ~ ~) ~ " /'V'\ c_ ~ . J ~~ ~. J~ t .:t ': Ii\.'\ .:..- lJ ~, I ~, Q::! , I , i jCl -.II t:l: ,CIl! , , <:: i i :'"- ' o I .~ i I l&J ~, ! I I I ! I I I I~ I " 'I " I, "l: ~~ '1 1, t. \--- tf'!"'-.-.--------- ~ ' ,'s I I, .. ':~ ~ II ,.: , ' . f ii.. \ Ill" o I~' ! ;~; I'" I!: ~ I: I ~ Ii 't I, ~-- a -J i - - - - - - - ~ - - "- (.0 0\j ~ c:~ ~c: at) ~~ ~ ) , / ~':~/- ~~tL-1 t-.-----" I 'I ' I :1 ~. : I ~, : f" _d -- - --- , Ii :;d -..It-"'..- I ,; ~ i t i f : /;\~ ~ I'll ~ -j , Ii \>. 1 I ! 1 :i',". 1 i I: Lj ~ (J CiS Q: .- ~- -- - - - - - - - - Q ~ a -J ~ /--.. C) -J . ; & '1 : .. I ~ Cy _I.!:: t"Ji I I I ! ~:I --~-- --J GJ (j Q: (~ 2[ I' ,: ,,- la 'a Ie) :a ~ 0" . i " --k I , " 'll c- II -, . .. .... I "- VI '<.! ~ J '" ' c. .;': .... . .....t: Q- "T < 'b ~ t '1 t ( ;" -.', I .. . ~... .J. , ~ L r l , , . .::'C';~! ... 1) , , ~.,: ;" L.J:' :_ ,~-~ :-.;" ~j '~r)c :; l ~ r '4."""" .J I 'J'. f- .; trl -~:J ,......: . ~I 'I~, IJ J""t- ::),_"'..r.._-~~~ f_ I.. " : r~ . T-- ",- J '. J \, I '"' J" '.f ~ C-- ..... , '; ~ ~ ~~ :: ~ :.:: ~ '.l ~ '--4. i ~ ~::: :: :;: ..t....t..::::::::: ~ "Ccj --~..i lr;' G r-, "',.~ C"---;. 'J ;.: r """f; ~J ~~'. ~ '(; -, I "'t ; -.J -: ~ "J: :-:~, ~ :- ~ 'I: J . ~ ~i:L ::"'4,"I);C =: - 1" ':-. ?: ,[~ :-~ ~ : :1.1 -"'('J~,'i-).t'---J't-- \.. ~'J ,J\. 'tl.),~ J ~~ : _ (r,,:, ~, :- ;:.,] . :, ~l ~J:;j ~ :"--j ~ _ ' 1';'~ -;- (J "-.,; ,,: ~fj (.' .'.~ _. ~ r~ \X' c,.~ '.1-; 'J) '.) ,.; ~f; <: ~ ~~ ~ ~ <-: (/0, d. <l o~ -J c.' ~. <: . -", ,. W'-. ...""'~"j~,~'~'...:::"'..r.(jC-I_ ......,......" ~ ..J -1-.1 ,.1-1 ,J -" "J --.J.J -J -., I all uF,""'). /., : .(:- '_- , , c...l (J <.~ ;'} ~~ ~J C r";l.. ,ZL '6PP - - - .-~---- "' L 1 ',' 'it (J 1'\ L~ Cl .c (llQ l: ~ '- .\) 10... C (1) q; ...... oq- o . sc: 0' /' ~c' --- ~c 1.: 0" .c:' c: CI1 C o ~'1! CI1 'I <. Cl I -+ , --J ltJ C) ~ 2[ .; y- o 0...., ~ ,; t 7 ...; , 2~ Cl. r: 1. . .::~ I I j , 15', " I L l..J ~~--' r, I , ! I ':.11 I I , I "'~"L J '" Ell') OQ C) . oQ::1Q E-,..j 0"'1.&: ~~~ ---J I,LJ (j ct: ~~ l"L ". .' r----------, I I . ~ . . . . r'" .. ... .. .. .. .. .. .. ... .. .. ... .. ... .. .. .. .. ... ... .. .. ... .. '; J \' 1...-) {~'. \-l' r, j'......' ..-' J ..~ f. J '!" "... r-, j t._ ~ J t.- (', 1 J .. ...t'~~r i,.-J"""'~t',Q-J'J)~i._'L.~...........t J r.- :~i("':""""""'J....J'"'":" ,'... tr,- '.,)}.J . ,'" J'e ,rj "'t- C', "''':- "1' ~- f', fC' C"J l.-J ,.....J f ""-J ,-' ~ ,jJ -I .J I,., r. .. ,) ~ '.: ..t- I J i J ,. ( j ~ ~ ~ (.:: l.-~ "~ -: _ - J rv-~ [ ....) t'"" J (, . ( ~ " .. . ~ t L.:~:. ~ r__ i . (J . ~ ~t. (" i '. . ~~ .~ ' j . l,rJ..J'" ,... J '1'- ~ J ~ -I r_ ,-~ :-J ~1- .. J ..,.. ':j' _ I., ',~ ~ . t., ~ J '.-;...- J" ,~...t -t r.-'.).. ,.... J'.r " " - " "1'.t ,t' '. -t I, : ~ ;i?-i ::- ~ lJ..i I~ t.lj ~!j LJ L..; ~ I ~ :~ ~ ~ '..li ?s:: ~ ::: ::~ ~ ~:i.?i~' ~. ~ ~ ~~ ~i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ?i ~ :::: ~;:.' .~. ':.: ..t"'....::.. ."c t::..... "'t"'t"'....... ............ ....t............................. I -""j :'r) rr_ O'f '-r:. "j- ':., c: ',~ _ '{; "~'.J i.f; C _ \:, 'J \:; 1 --t ~X) i':,: --:, Cj OJ--t -1::' C' 'T) --t .~ ~ '-. ~ I'; \. -- 'C\ -,- I., i;, -;- J l' "'t.........; "'t r-J l!j -_ C":') ~ '"'J"j ~ ("J ,. c~,. :~-J ~--J"'~ '., (-~ '7 ~ C J C) 'J~ ~ '.-,'1-J ...... ~t ,.. '..iJ'; L-j .: l ':-J c_ ~-) to; --~ :'! ~ :..:;~_:;,;;;,: ~~)~:"'(::c,-r_(-:r :"'~,r r :,:>::r ~l)'-'(:":"~;:l~r ;J~(i ~~l~')~";"'~.j:,;~~ J .. - "t- ......) -- '. --., Jor-} ("J r ~ 1...["; \J <.:" L;-J .......} (... o_'~ J <. ~ .. -. J \.. .~.J :,.! --) .........J "") ..--; '.....J ....-,; I.. ) --- -- o. .I ~':--.i ( ; ..... ~ :- I :,J ..-t-.... ;:' l \,'; '~. , '.-.. _ F,~, ~ t') <- z'., ~ ~:J;..c t--, ~ ~ ~~:~.... ~ ~ :--- ~ (d c-. (.J lr) iJ'~; ~~.. 0,.:.:- bj (-J =") ~ ~--J Ct ;". ~tJ i{~ ~J r-,,;u 0- .-.. (~ 1 ( 'l. "1- CJ r ) ~. h ''J '0 V:-J '() 'D f(j ~::. (') C) c) <) ,~( IV)"J h ,. r-..~ ,. or, r oj, (1) (, r , ex.', Cl", (..:. ", Ci) cc') Lr:.: cc If; (I'. (f ; './) '/-i (~~ (~~J)'~ -; '.r; C~ 'fj () <: <..; '_.--; (_-~ (,) 'J-; (.1 (... 1 (J).:::;:;i ;= ~ ~ ~ tJ~ '.I~;' : I,......; r,) './) (,-) 'r; :~: 'I) ~,~ -;; 'F; L) t : :.~ >: 1.0 rot' IJ)qt t'; (T'l~ t' Mt' MN #1.0 tlI!lM ..;l ,.., H::':; c.:. lXl , ) '(; ~,r);:.'J'l~' ~ (" 1 1"i ~~) '.(, (', ')'" ') c.-~ .~, ~ J ") ~~; 'c,', ~ -,., C) ~- .'j ,~; 't l(~ '() r" :)":: -J) ( ~- ;'1 "', ~ ':; 'c t., J. ~. ~_ 0-_ "e J'; ~ "'.JC 1 -'I "'IC~(.I' , "-j", "-'; .~; '.) "; '<,"'; "-;'~; '.,. 't -t '1' '1 ,. -.,. ~ ~ 't 'J ,I.J ':) '{,'[; l;") L.", .j 'J; I J ,J-~~_J_j_J -J .J_,..) l_J_,._I-.j_j_J_,j_;'~J_,_J -J-, ) I_.,-J-J-:-.;,I~-J J-j,! J ..1,.1'1-' J ~/- '-\ ... J, I I ;~: i H.LnOS , \.:' ' ~'! ~-~----1i __ a ~b ~ <: Q! . I fiZ I :1' c'; -~ J .' l -..... 1 '4 ,. t i~ 7 Zi~7 t , .' I ... ~ I l\ .t> ~"-r; -' '"'- ,"\ () '.J :-i~ ~ t' r. . f..' '"l lLJ ~ '0 ~""', OJ .r' .-- ~ "0 o - ... ~\l:"I .<1; \l:"I. -/-. !I ffi::J 9(/) - :Lei :i! II t' , ;. 't ;:- . .or; '~ ';' 11 " ,) "2 'j .... '.- 'l ~ . ~ 0 ~;;j '''J~ ~~ " > ~":~ ........~J, 'a: :J ., r' ,~ r) .1 "-t: !/ ,<.... r r 'J 4- ,. , ... .Y ... n ,,,j Q c I "t } '" c 0 c::: ~ ~ /j 'J :> ,:- "") c: ..:i c: Zf.c Q ,.. ,., ..... '- .tjr-, ~ U) ..... ,0. c. c ~ <:;; ~, C u, ,., U Q' fIl -U' ~ f) ,a.... (\) (\) 2- 6 ~ a .... ~o (\) ~ 0\ ~ 5 (\) "' V)-J t:J l.. CI) c:~ (\)"tl - :) CI) c: CI) Q t) ~',S e--J ~~~~ ,~&' ~ l:c (\) ~ It) '0 (\) 0) (\) ~ '" Q.:J 'oJ ~) V) \/) .' - ~._.,-----_._---- '':' l() "i I ,.. ,}:' ''\I I"-. a 0, "- It) ".:.' II - a " l'\j , "~------- ".. --~ ,1t-., --.., ..' - ~-~o,....-------, - -1f"oo.3:~ "<: -6'/ :s " !! 'J J 101 '" ~ ('-: "'( C) ......... Q:: -....J a ~ -.....J ~ ~ ~ ~ .:t (J" ~ ~ c ~ , ,. 0" r , ......" - I -, i I I 1 0'. .' ,I , 1..-.. ;'j ,..) I I .: - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - -)I tl - . " ~'. " o. ,~ <. .0'- ......... <"'....{ I I . > .. ~~ , , rl. , I I I , , I I 'L.-' IL-ll ! I I , , I I " ,. l . j 0 L J j9:JJDcJ .. . --~... I , I ' l~.ll , , I " I .... " c;' 0 ..... e'" J Q,~ ~ "t- -J - l: ~ a 0 ~. U) c:i ~; -T 0 -l ('I ~li '.0 el..; I qo ~ ~ I I .. ~~ l .J LO rot' IJ)~ t'; (T)~ t' Mt' MN ,..,UJ l!I!lM ..;l ,.., H::':; l%. lXl .g ~ ...,. 1 4' 1 I.' -, I I. ~ .r.'.o':'" I It:r I I':! 01 L J (....:-::. . a <0 I .J " ~., l"'lliit' , I , ,-c: 'f.q I 3 2 , , I .. 1 , ,l I , ., , I ' I,.]' I '" l J 1>- ~ ~.~ ~~ ~o i ~... ~,. '" .--Tr----... .. . C':J f ........ " .! 9 ( U l' ~ .~ 1'. I J '- "- ("" ~ '"'- ., .;. t~~::. ('- ~:, " 1 ,...., , .: '.::: I ......_-J..-..-;.... \ j .~. o' J. -' ... \ .._________,______..1 '- L_--.a.rr- :', \ · I I J \ -:... I ,4 ~ . ,_ _.'. -,_,', ~,'-r.~ ....--~- _,;.~'1__~_ ~~-=-.-'t..,._-7""~ ~';,~.; '0"_ . -. ..:..~ .~.J.J~~:!:~"!..",,, .(\..' '...'.. ..~.Ma. ji.~J.....:t...,~ '~,..::".&.'>.:::.. ~ .a.....4t._I~.__ ..' ~i..\" 'if - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - ~,.. - - - '.' ~ ~ :~ '1' 't'. I,.t tiQJ ;.>:-,'l ,'.I" '., c' ~ .t"". 'I ; ri ~ . . ' ';. e e ~ " ..' 'j . ';. e eQQj ,..' , ,'. ' ,.. / c: . , ,~ ..,:' '-, i~....., "'.7,] e I r\r~f.~~ ~',~~. :.r · I.:': -;:' ..~~~t{;~~:il 'i . ,. I r'~'~:;:,:~j : or ' '.' I: eel kt'-,~~:f.1 . ..... J · · ~:~:..I~":~rl , -';\ Q' G ~ 1 . 6-..!! .. ~ (' I , 'n ~ _..J ""J lJ) -.I '~ , -,"f ,t,.,... '%. <\, '0 \ \i ';'~~ J ~: ~/-/\ -"'-.., ,) ... / '-" -~" 0;:,., ~ t\ tl ~ '. ~ ...J' ..." ~ '-., 1) ., " , , j II ~ _' ~ : \ ' .' . '" ~ :- -..tl ('J ,- _ ~ .. II 1:: .~ -i:: ,~ ~ t:J (\) \, .... .J..... .., ,!:, ..... ~I ~ III Ill..... ~ ~ o ~ <t) D ., ~C1 .'::. ,~,f;) IJ ~ '1::' "t: (-:) ::;:: (l ~!. ~ L... .j Q '.:::: 'I II Ii II II " 11 II II il II .c ~ [- .., ~ Q)' . .tl.: _..... " .\1r!J Q: "( .'" ~ cI:l l;1:: I J.. () '-'\. ~ J 0'1 G'C, _ '.J ~ ~ ..- r-:l\'-~ ~r:Yl C _ Q,l ~ ~) en .'c .... ~_..... L ()')C,,(' b ..... ...... .....- Cc.c:-.. '0 '() ''3 _tl Q. Q. Q, '-1., 1; ; . ~ t: .u ... lL.. c >l.J " )... ..:!o( :.:: 1):" c.-- .... .r '_ tJ ':- 'I ll) -I .' J 'J ") C c: -=: .r 6'- , a ll)..... Q.... -J "~ <.) Ol(.lll)/.; 0 o ~ ~ c:: c:.c.':;. Q.tuh Lu~'-.'J~ II II II 1\ 'I II Ii 1.,) .s:: ,'~ (.j , ~ -" '1.1 " n, - III c: r ' - J '. r,' " ~ '..I ',( j " II Ii II Ii r )' 'no . ~ ' '. ,'n '1) l "'. 'J C I..l \ I..l ..;: .:: ...., (J ... ..:: 0 V) ~ () J} ~ t,) Z <) ..:: ::) 't u: C) " -') ""7 ~ ./') ? .~5 J) .~ rr '-<J '} . ) _:, .j i , ,~ 6' ,..' , . \ , 1:,) u t c 't: <t) 0. -~ (l ~ :.0 (\) L: ~"Q b;J: J::l .!""'1 . ~~ ~i ~ CJ:l ---,.: ~s .~ i c:u c:u I .~i ~~ c:u ~I ~ co ~ ,- ..0 .- ...c: ><: p.J ! .s ~ 00 00" lDlifI ,,~ (TJo.. " .," MN _lD I!I!lM ...:l_ H:><:; lk.1Xl NO ~: ~cn t.c:Cf.l ~..ce:l Cf.l~ca: .~B ~ca:= ~~U E .M ~EE ~8 cn~~ 5:~ :i2 o 5. SI: r-- 0 N E ~=~ S~.n P=l \Q C,!) '""~~ OP=lC,!) .c: ~~~ > Cf.l . S~~ Cf.l to.::: ~~~ M~E-< ~~:s 8~~ . :,....',.,:....::..~~.:. . . , ....:-..;. : \t~:~.: ~.. ~ tr:J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Io.j ~ ~ ~ ti ~ ~ t1 I' 00" lD~ ,,; (TJo.. 1'" MN :lD lZlM ....:l_ H:><:; lk. a:l :'. ;.:' -"/", u.:~ ',~.:~ ;',...-:: t:::'-. ..~ ~ :;.:~ .~:'; '. L:"..... 't:: . v.:>."!..~. ~ Jit.~ If ~ ~ .. ':. ~ '..!J ::;::.; :., '=,,-, er-~"- f.:~ \ L..-.J11 :"~I ~ [:,:~ t ~ I.',,",, ~ r. '.f.; . .' ~.-,(.~ ::'; '; ~ (~~ : ~':;~ :'. ~ j..:....... ..0': \ ~ ~;:~ ,:.~,~; ~ :-..I :'..~1 :'~',i :::.; ::.; :..''"' .., . ~ ~ ~~~~ . ~:{ "'-I i~:"1 . ::1'.,: :::...~ '" .." . ','.. ata ~ i.I:. "0'::: ~ \.'~_:;,',::,:: )g\ ~ ~ :.t. <'~:.::'f ~ \,::, ~ t' ';~':;:;! f;>:' :V:\ !{: .:~ ,:f~ .11 ~',::.:. ~',:;:j " . ,.:" [:}:. .;;j (:>: :)j :':' . .., \:::'~;' ,':,:/,:?'!: j...:. " . '0' 2- . ~'.':) ::.!,.:'...;,..:::,;::,,~.', . ~ : "::~; ",:< "'/:': :.: :.~~: o \}i . "-': ,) ;..... :!..... :.,,' ::.' . ., .' .' . :.,': j: ;: ..... . '.. lt~,~. Cr., ......! b L!'; ,{)(.:r '4;- r ~. . ~ , ~ '. 'I~.. ....., ~ c:) ~; . t: .(1'?1 .: " 0, ~ '. Lr-; (" Ii:; ....~ .(}or !..r.: .-:.:: :~'; ....._\ .(/ell" c, L,.:, r'._. ..,..., -, ...., , t:..l; r (': I "' ~~ ( r, . -, ......: r- '. '" .- - " " .. " - "'. .0(':; . , .:- ,. " .... . ,; l . ," .: "~ .' .,. ',~ I.. " .. ~ h . . ". ~.(.; ".r: ;-:) ~ -. ~. ": : ~.~ ", -'" ,,0 .cor " .- . ~'. {',\ :.J-; o;:~.. ~ .COJ ('" l~'~ ;.,.... . . , r;"l' .'./,_:, (~. ..... i.;; (.oJ i~~; " ,.... .'.... SlNI7 J.U7-") ,OOT (" L~ ...."1 . (~() J. s moo 1..O.qt f"-; (TIlJ.o f"- rif"- riN #'-0 ~ri ,...:1# H::.G ~ c:o C;) It,; ::.) t:) ('" '.1 I". 4..: :" . r.~~: Oi. '. I t(:'; ;:' '.~' .~'. . U\:. ::,;',:'. i.... ::':~ :.. '" :::....... ~ ,'-' I " ~I .t'I.,j ~:.:~~ :. .:~.i ......1 ~:) " . t.', :'..~ ;. a.:; ~,'~ .. . F.:~ ;:,'..... . "':'t.:!l t:,l\I h. . ~.:< )'.::'.., .... . I'.. . :" -0'; ....... ," ..... . .\, - ~ ~;~ " " ....; :..:i ,', ~ " '. I",' ',0.: " ~ .:: I :.;. . " I. .' ,. CJ CI) .f"'4 s.. CI) .. ~ Glftl..-l,Q GlE..~E!. Cl)0r::0 >'OCJOOftl a>,:l. 'f"'4 SlCl "C >s..GlCl) .f"'4 w=.c.f"'4~w ='1:l.~>ftlO CI) 'f"'4~~ Gl 0\ "C ~ ~ Gl>C::,Q CI) .....f"'4 =' c:: .. OCl)~~",,>, 1:l.::JC:: ~ s.. ..... a> CI) "C r:: ::J CJ e - a>::J Cl,X::J'O"CO a>c::r::wu CJ OftlO .f"'4 a> e ~ CJ a> -.c a>o 'f"'4 ~ "C ~ s.. s.. u c:: 0 r:: a>wftl ~O Cl, 0 .. ftl :IE: CI)~t:7>r-~ r:: N Cl,_ IV "C 'f"'4 0 elI~~>. . CI)~IVU,QinCl) 'f"'4 U U 0 ~ '0 ='O~r:: w CI)"C~~~a>o 'f"'4 r:: 0 0\ U .cO-_.r::ftla> Eo-- U 0 0 Cl)c.. 0:: ~ :''':; .. ~ Eo-- 0 !Z ri 0000 1..0 lift "C f"-.... 1:1 t!J ::J (TIlJ.o 0 '1-1 f"- a> rif"- ,:l. .~ riN ,:l. ~ #1..0 a> CIl ~ri oioJ CI) 0-:1.... H::.:; & r:.:.c:o ~ ...... I"') CI) CIl ~ . ftl~ CJCIl ,~ In "C 1:1 s.. H 0 .. ~ ~ '~ :z: ::.1 "'! " , .. ".I : I .,'.t'. ., ~ ". " . . oioJ *"CIl . CI) c.. s.. s.. 0 o '0 CIl 1:1 ~::J .f"'4 0 ,:l.'I-I ~ r-I "Co Ow oo:l' ~ r:: CI) 0 CIl U oioJ ftl>. CJ ell 'f"'4 > '0 w r:: ::J H In I -,e-- I CI) s.. Gl CIl w CIl ftl Gl r:: Gl .r::....CD :. 0\ r:: 1:1 Gl~ftl. c:: Gl S .f"'4 .... S ::J r-IO ~ Oftl wCD~~ ell Cl, ~wCll. ftl'O>C1 :. U'f"'4 4J ... .r:: .ftl t:7> ~ ~ . 'f"'4 . ell U .r:::Jw, ~ r:: In CIl . ftl 'f"'4~:J ell ftl Er::e~ :. .f"'4 CIl CIl O~> .r:: .c CD CIl Eo-- In~~ o o . . tol::ClO . c..CIl CIl ww O~ e>s.. ~o .f"'4 ,:l.CIl ~ r-I o .. Cl, . ~ ~ w >. ell ftl~> :IE:.f"'4 CIl ~~ ,Cl 'f"'4 CJ ~ ftl ,1:1 ::J ell CIl In SlClr:: .f"'4 = CI) IV CIl~CIl ~CIlE ftl CI) U CIl .f"'4 ~ > '0 'f"'4 0 I:Iftl.t:l Hr::1V ~ ,~ o . .-H::~ M I>ClO OICC)I :Z:...-4 Gl I r::- N 00...-4 NO . . "CO'\> o Gl OC::D:: ~O ~.f"'4 .. 4JU ~ftl~ ftl>M 4JGlin CI) ~ ...-4 ftl~ o 0'\ U"CN 0...-4 wOin ftl~N elI~...-4 >- a>:IE: OCDD:: Oftl.... ...-4~~ // ;/ I I L O'l 001"- I.D~ I"-~ (T)lJ.. I"- MI"- riN #I.D flIllM ....:J_ Ht:G llc.m . t~ fia -=::l .1lC :~ M a=E-o II.l ~ . ... -.o, 1:':: ': . ',~ 'ii _ ,.o .. \,':t.: is.. . . t l<" ..... It~;" . , ..,.:'.:~\. ,4-'':.: : ' '. ':.' .t:\ :.::::~~t1}':' :;,. ~ .. ....;:~~~y~.~.........-,....,...... _.......... 111.1.1.1 Jl ,..t'~... : '. :~' ; ,~~,..t::.;. .:':': ':',:,:,=,::: ',??;::,~::<"::~~r:;:,.~~:~,~?:~f;::':~~:::,~;:~:::' i- :.h.... ,,'" :,: ,,:.. ...- ." '.. ,~ - :rl~ f T ,'~'~ : ;,~;~;.:-1,!;~~;;i~.;~:~i:;;;:.r:~':.:.::3..;;,~;;'l,~:,~~~:;,\';:.:~::,;;~,i':':l>,:,~/': . .. ' ... . . ' :.;:;t5 ~..., .1N~HIAlld rnONIJlnl/f1 :::;.'1... :.~':r ..... :! )(~{ :::.~~ ,. . ::=( '.:::~1 .:<~; . ,....., :"'.i ,0,:. '::::~~ ....... . :.,;: :",'1 '.',,:, '.~:~\} " ,.. ". : :;;: ~.,:i '-=':::: ,~\~1 ... ,..' ...:!i "!.;:~: ~'i:;': N"::: ~:;:j '~';\\ !!)..'.: ~~ft~, .....:. .~ ~':::'~ ...... ',...: : ....) '" ",.~" f.,. "" ~ ;,J.::;.,:- ~.: . iii:! t .-.....::~ ,.,. ~ ... .., ". ''';: ;',' .....: ~ ~ ,. ........ c:i i::: I::i .... ",'. :. , ~ :::, Jl: ,,:\:..., ~.;' . ~. .. . , "':,'. : r.. I t' \ ;: >: . :-'.0 " :001'" : i.:':' l !:,"'; : i :.': ~ ,.',. Pc: I',.:.. !:t: ". 't': :..: '" _t.. ;: :. ~ .... ~ r,:;, :t: i.::'.' ~ i",:'.: I .. ~':: ... ~ F':' h.: ~., " ..... .... . .. , :~ ~,.: . ;.-:--. . t: ~'.~ i.... r. .:. ;.:: :: l\:~:. I>:' :.... a ~ "" "" ~ ,'.' , .' !:", . :":." . :'. '.: ' h:: t'>'. t':':: I ,,:,.;,: . :.,. " ...:.'. /' ./ / j'j/ ~ //" ~ ~. ..s-. ~ ,DO;' ...., l;; r.:'1 ....:; .OOT Cl Ii'. ....f .....'t ..,"- .v'.'l {', ../ 't.: r. , ~.:'.~ i7t11 r:. i.' . $'.'" ~ '.' ,~, ' /.. , r:'..- /-,.. .., 'liS' 1S2J1.:l ~~ ::.."\C-. , '....... '" ..'.....;,' '.' ......' ;":'.'...:.....':r.:',.':',~:"',':.':;.:.,,:; ":." :..-:;,.,:'~,.;~':;:.;,;.:=?~....l., :.:'.: ': .::o~~ E! '~..~:,: :X>~::::,' '.>:' ':.< ':::,':':', .:"'::' r" ~: :::":\'. ~:: ,': f.:,:. >:'..,. .:.:;.' " .It:. . 7.10"ft -j}J. .OO"fl .s:-Ii '.' :.' ,..... ":':" ~'-:.: :'::;~: ;,,': :: ": '. " -..'.: ~ :.:'~..\~j..:;.:;.:;.::...:.l.;/,;:~~~;~.;:-:\;:::,;~.;~.,',~;~::::,;,:.,;.i';':~':';,,:,;;J,~"::~::,::,::::;.::.::.::;:,.::,;:~,~;~/:~ '.' :' " ',' .: :)~;;..:;;.;...."-'- 4IP-.=. ~': '.' . ' '. ,/' ,roo, ~N11 M/X ~ ~'\~.:,~.:~.:,'~:- :>~:,;,1 .('?;:":1 .. li:'~;";'::~' :{~ , ':'1 . '. : ..... "/ ...... . ..:. ',: ~ ::. :", .',,' ~" . ~:.:':~ '. . . ; ~: : :. . ',~ : .' ".. ': r::... .:~i . !:::: . '.: . :'o:.:~ 'i I i I i I I ! .- / /' r -1. .or-., 37H:7S" 1I1t1JDAI C'. ..:t~ , ,..~.. '''.. ,.., '..J i.-. 'j I"'!..... . ..:t:. ~i'; (.... .t.: . t:::! It'; ." :.. SlNI7 .107..'., .001" ". ....., Lr; r..". : i::a, '" : t:::i ... ''-.:_,~ . .,..N . :"'~ L ...,. t::::: :-;" ~""" ~ i~,;:-, ~.....,. :s:: F ' ~,.., ,,- :....' '" ::.:-": c.-, , .. r':'1 ..... I r". , {: fif'I ::.~\ , ':\ . . .:~ . . .:'c . . '" : . \.~:'f:.. .' . : '. ":~'~'.'~' ~ ~<, ~:'., I ~ ... r~ :. . :'~ .". :! . ..... o. . .... , " '. :i ::',:-:j .' "0... :~..;~ ~~ .: .::~ ;:'.' . :...~ r: Ii\ ~. ~ . .,' :: ".:~ .....; ;' .:: ~ " . .. " 0,' '.~ ....: .. 0, : : .~~ .<.~~ :.:J . . ,": ~ ~ . " ';. ~: , ":: ....: N rom 1D~ t'~ (TJo.. t' r-lt' r-lN .1.0 ~r-l ....:I. Ht>C: tz.lXl / -"- ...,~e>>~~ uo"'~... e>> . ..... t:g~ct: o~~e>>e>> uc.uu ~~=.... ~......., ~e>>~C-'=l . ~~ ~ U l::l ~ c:::a .... , e... -'=I cu e>>~. e Ii ..., ~ ~I"" c, . '8 g .... l::l . c e ~... o ..., e>> . . .... 0 ~ ..., .., t7I ,Qcu~c ~ .~..., e>>~~...,... -'=Ie>>...,. u"".e>> .u....~ "'=cu~.... ...,~........ .~ cu. o ~~ cuuf U -'=I . ... ...,.., 0 cu e ., ...,tZ'e>>= .l::l~c -'=Ie... ..., . "' tEl t: ... A -=a ....ti : ~ .:; · OClO...,_..., .... 0\ . U ...,.... e>> . ... c ... ~..., ..O~... ~.....oo e>> N .... U ~:J....~-:;:e>> ;: ... .... e>> ,. ,Q A....e>> CU A........ 0 .......llCt7Ie>>..., x 0-'-' ~ La.. La.. Exhibit C RESOLUTION NO. P52-97 FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BKi 1 6 2 7 PG# 4 8 3 A RESOLUTION BY THE MONROE COUNTY PLANNING COM- MISSION APPROVING WITH CONDITIONS THE REQUEST OF DOUGLAS WALKER, FOR AN AMENDMENT TO A MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE TO CONSTRUCT TWENTY-TWO (22) ATTACHED DWELLING UNITS (2-LEVEL, 2BR CONDOMINI- UM UNITS AT 1,480 S.F, EACH); ONE (1) SWIMMING POOL; A 372 S,F. POOL HOUSE & OFFICE; A 120 S.F. OBSERVATION GAZEBO WITH AN ASSOCIATED WALKWAY; A 22,000 S.F. BOAT STORAGE BUILDING; A 2,485 S.F. ADDITION TO THE EXISTING SAILFISH RESTAURANT; AND RENOVATIONS TO THE BAIT SHOP, THE DOCK MAS- TER'S OFFICE AND THE FUEL TANKS ON PROPERTY DESCRIBED AS. LOTS 1 , 2 , AND 3 , BLOCK 60 , AND PART OF LOTS 1 AND 2, BLOCK 61, MALONEY SUBDIVI- SION, STOCK ISLAND, MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, MILE MARKER 5, THE LAND USE DESIGNATION IS MIXED USE (MU) AND THE REAL ESTATE NUMBER IS 00127420. WHEREAs, during a regular meeting held on July 10, 1997, the Monroe County Planning Commission conduct~d a public hearing on the request filed by Douglas' Walker for an amendment to a major conditional use to Oceanside Marina; and WHEREAs, the proposed development is located on property legally described as lots I, 2, and 3, Block 60, and part of lots 1 and 2, Block 61, Maloney Subdivision, Stock Island, Monroe County, Florida; and WHEREAS, the above-described property is located in the Mixed Use (MU) land use district; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission was presented with the following evidence, which by reference is hereby incorporated as a part of the record of said hearing: 1. The Major Conditional Use Permit Application received by Monroe County Planning Department on February 3, 1997 including a site plan dated January 24, 1997, a survey dated January 30, 1997, elevation drawings dated January 24, 1997, a revised level 3 traffic study dated June 6, 1997, a revised site plan dated July 3, 1997; and 2. The staff report prepared by Edward Koconis, Development Review Planner and Ralph Gouldy, Environmental Planner dated June 12, 1997; and page 1 of 4 AMWALKER, 16/TXTDR, #97021 Initials~ 3. The amendment to the staff report prepared by Edward Koconis, Development Review Planner and Ralph Gouldy, Environmental Planner dated June 26, 1997; and 4, The SWorn testimony of the Growth Management Staff; and 5. The p:r,-esentation by Jose Gonzalez of Gonzalez Archi- tects, agent for the applicant; and WHEREAs, the Planning Commission has made the following Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law based on the evidence presented: 1. Based on the site plan, we find that the applicant is propos- ing an increase in the commercial floor area developed on the site, Therefore, we conclude that the proposed commercial development is subject to Objective 10.1.3 of the Year 20.10 Comprehensive Plan and must receive allocations in the non- residential permit allocation system or receive a determina- tion of vested rights; and 2. Based on the application, we find that 22 residential units are being proposed. Therefore, we conclude that the residen- tial units are subject to the provisions of sections 9.5-120. through 124, the Rate of Growth Ordinance (ROGO) which re- quires that the dwelling units be granted allocations prior to building permits being issued; and 3. Based on the site plan, the applicant is proposing 22 dwell- ing units which is the maximum net density permitted on the site pursuant to Section 9.5-262 of the Monroe County Code. Therefore, we conclude that 18,31 Transferable Development Rights {TDRs) are needed in order to construct the proposed development; and 4. Based on the application, the applicant is requesting a waiv- er of the shoreline setback to add a second floor and veran-. das to the existing tackle shop and dock master office which are located within the shoreline setback. We conclude that there is not sufficient. justification to waive the setback to add the second floors. However, a waiver of the shoreline setback is justified for renovations only due to the exis- tence of these structures within the shoreline setback, the fact that renovations to the buildings will not increase the impermeable area within the setback and the fact that mea- sures will be taken to channel runoff away from the waterbody; and 5. Based on the revised site plan, the residential structures and restaurant conform to the height limit of 35', While acceptable structure heights have been submitted in the form of a letter, heights of all structures must be included on revised plans. Therefore, we conclude that the proj ect is not in compliance with Section 9,5-283; and page 2 of 4 AMWALKER.16/TXTDR, #97021 Initials-'XL 73768 FILE # 1 1 PGi 4 8 4 BK#1627 6. Based on a meeting with the applicant, the applicant has stated that no more than 205 boats will be in dry slips, however, the number of dry slips in these buildings has not been indicated on the plans. Therefore, we conclude that the project is in compliance with Section 9.5-351 as long as the entire site has no more than 205 boats stored in dry slips; and 7. Based on the application, we find that the required stormwater management plan, including the calculations, has not been submitted. Therefore, we conclude that until the County Engineer approves the plan, the project is not in compliance with Section 9.5-293; and 8., Based on the community impact report, we find that the appli- cant has proposed to abandon the existing sewage treatment plant and replace it with a package sewage system. The appli- cant has initiated coordination with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) but has not received a DEP permit. Therefore, we conclude that compliance cannot be determined with Section 9.5-294 until an approved application from DEP is submitted; and 9. Based on the boundary survey, elevation plans, and the re- vised site plan, we find that the lowest,supporting beam of two (2) structures (condominium buildings) located in a VB (high-hazard area) zone is not elevated to the proper height. Therefore, we conclude that the project is not in compliance with Section 9.5-317; NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the preceding Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, support their decision to APPROVE the Major Conditional Use request of Douglas Walker for Oceanside Marina with the fol- lowing conditions: 1. If vesting is not granted the project shall be subject to the existing commercial moratorium. 2. 18.31 TDRs shall be approved as a minor conditional use prior to the submission of a building permit for the construction of the four (4) condominium buildings. 3. Plans indicating the heights of all structures with points of reference shall be submitted to the Planning Department prior to approval of the Planning Commission Resolution. 4, Boat storage shall be limited to 205 dry slips. 5. The stormwater management plan and calculations shall be sub- mitted and approved by the County Engineer prior to the issu- ance of a Building Permit. page 3 of 4 AMWALKER.16/TXTDR, #97021 Initials~ FILE #1 1 7 3 768 BK#1627 PG#485 6, Plans indicating finished floor elevations of all structures shall be submitted to the Planning Department and all struc- tures shall conform to the Flood Management Criteria of Sec- tion 9,5-317 prior 'to approval of the Planning Commission Resolution. 7, A waiver is granted for renovations to the tackle shop, dock master's office and fuel tank structure provided that the roofs have gutters installed to channel runoff away from the water in accordance with the stormwater management plan, No waiver is granted for second floor additions to any building within the shoreline setback, 8. A permit from Department of Environmental Protection for the proposed package sewage system shall be submitted to the Planning Department prior to the issuance of a Building Per- mit. 9. All residential units are subject to the Residential Rate of Growth Ordinance. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Planning Commission of Monroe County, Florida, at a regular meeting held on the 10th day of July, 1997. Chair Hansley Vice-Chair Nugent Commissioner Chaplin Commissioner Mannillo Commissioner Gorsuch -X- -X- -X- -X- -X- BY PLANNING COMMISSION OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA BY ~~l,f<jl ~ ~h Chair ~ y rsuc, Signed 17 18"" II day of h-u (;..u,f"1 , 1999. FILE #1 1 7 3 7 68 BK# 1 6 2 7 PG' 4 8 6 page 4 of 4 AMWALKER,16/TXTDR, #97021 Initials~ MONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS