Item M4
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Item Summary
Meeting Date:
July 26, 2000
No /
Division: B.O.C.C.
Bulk Item: Yes
Department: George R. Neugent
Agenda Item Wording:
Presentation by Florida Department of Transportation Environmental
Management Office and approval by the Board of Commissioners to restore
seagrass habitat along the western edge ofthe Horseshoe Pit located east of the
Bahia Honda Bridge, oceanside. The project would result in restoration of
approximately 1.5 acres of seagrass habitat.
Item Background:
Attached
Previous Relevant BOCC Action:
Commissioner Recommendation:
Total Cost:
x N/A
--
Budgeted: Yes No
Cost to County
Revenue Producing: Yes_ No_
Amt per month
Year
Approved By: County Atty _ OMB/Purchasing _ Risk Mgmt
c2::1s~rt::Jt~
Documentation: Included Q To Follow Not Required _
Disposition: , _ tv\. I
Agenda Item # ---I::L.tL'"t
.JEB BUSH
GOVERNOR
July 11) 2000
~
Florida Dehartment of Transhortation
Dis1rl!i Six Environm~ntQll1anQgement ~fJlce
1000 NW III Avenue, Room 6101 Miami, Florida 33172
THOMAS Y. BARRY, JR.
SECRETARY
Mayor Pro Tom George Neugent
Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
25 Ships Way
Big Pine Key, Florida 33043
Re: Request for Consideration of Item for July 26 Meeting of the
Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
Horseshoe Pit at West Summerland Key
Monroe County, Florida
Township 66S, Range 30e. Section 33
Dear Commissioner Neugent:
As per my conversation this morning with Ms. Terri Marble of your staff) the FOOT is seeking the Monroe
Colmty Board of County Commissioners approval of the utilization of the Horseshoe Pit fill areas for seagrass
~ation purposes. The Horseshoe Pit is an excavated pit sWTounded on all four sides by fill remaining from
the original borrow activities within the 3. 6-acrc site which occurred in 1960. It is located on the Gulf side of
u.s. 1 near the: Key West end of the Bahia Honda Bridge on West Summerland Key. This property is owned by
the Florida Department of EnviromnentaI Protection (FDEP) but is under a twenty-five year lease to Monroe
County. The lease began in May, 1977 and will expire in May, 2002. In the attached copy of the Horseshoe Pit
lease agreement between Monroe County and the Board of Trustees of the Internal hnprovement Trust Fund., Item
1 provides for the following:
TO HA VE AND TO HOLD the abow described land for a period of twenty-five (25) years from the
dote hereof,for the purpose of preserving, developing, improving. operating, maintaining, protecting,
and otherwise managing said land jOr outdoor recreational, park. ~nservation (emphasis added) and
related purposes.
The FDOT is requesting that Monroe County approve the FDOT's use of a portion of the Horseshoe Pit for
conservation purposes. The FOOT is proposing to restore seagrass habitat along the western edge of the
Horseshoe Pit by removing the fill along the pit from the chlDDCl opening at the north side to the edge of the
acc.ess road at the south side. This activity will remove approximately half of the upland fill area which surrounds
the Horseshoe Pit while leaving unimpeded access to the eastern and southern sides for continued recreational
use. The access road will also remain. The proposed mitigation project would result in the restoration of
approximately 1.5 acres of scagrass habitat. Rubble riprap to be placed as energy breaks along the perimeter of
the seagrass restoration area will provide additional substrate for hard bottom communities.
The FOOT is seeking this restoration project as mitigation for an emergency repair project recently completed
at the Harris Gap Channel Bridge (MP 17.5) in Monroe County. The limerock stabilization at both abutmmts
of the bridge was in critical need of repair from damage which occurred during Hurricane Irene. BecaU9c the
bridge is a aiticallink within the US lISR 5 hurricane evacuation route, this project was done as a high priority
item However, unavoidable irnpacu to 0.016 acres (695 square feet) of seagrass were incurred as part of the
emergency repair. The FOOT is requited by pcnnits from the South Florida Water Management District
www.dOl:..statefl.us
~ RI;CYCl&;O PAPFR
W 39t;1d
.:!.:!O 19~1 Odlf\H3 lOG.:!
SOZ:S-OLP-SOE
bE:Pl OOOZ:/ll/LO
Commissioner Neugent
July 11,2000
Page Two
(SFWMD) and the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) to mitigate for the unavoidable impacts and to
provide that mitigation as quickly as possible. Both agencies have stated that they will readily accept this
project as mitigation if it can be accomplished within a reasonable timeframe. Because of the short time frame
required by the pennits for performing the mitigation. we are requesting to be added to the Board of County
Commissioner's agenda fOT the next meeting date of July 26. 2000.
This request was previously made to Mr. Dave Koppel, Monroe County Public Works, with the understanding
that it would be preseot.ed for ccmideration by the County Commission. Mr. Koppel instead presented the projc:ct
to the Monroe County Board of Parks and Recreation. It is my understanding from a phone conversation with
Mr. Koppel that the reaction of the Board of Parks and R.tcrcation was negative because of perceived negative
impacts to recreational usage of the area. However, recreational activities will not be precluded as a result of this
project as significant area will still remain for the current uses, particularly diving. The FOOT would like the
opportunity to fully present the benefits of this project to the County Commissioners for their approval.
Thank you for your consideration of this matter. Should you require my assistance or need additional
information, please contact me at the letterhead address or at (305) 470-5223.
Sincerely.
~
Melanie A. Calvo
District Permits Coordinator
cc: Mayor Shirley FreemlUl, District Three
Commissioner Wilhelmina Harvey, District One
Commissioner Mary Kay Reich, District Five
Conunissioner Nora Williams, District Four
Dave Koppel, Monroe COWlty Public Works CoWlty Engineer
Mike Ciscar, FOOT District Environmental Management Engineer
Barbara Culhane, FOOT Environmental Administrator
File
EO 39'Vd
~~O .L9W OclIAN3 .Loa~
SOlS-OL"-SOE
5E:"1 OOOl/lllLO
~.../ ~,
~tta(hment A: CODceptual Mitigation Plan
ERP APPLICATION 000209-4
Harris Gap Channd Bridge Shoreline Stabilization Project
Seagra!! Miti~8.tion
The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) proposes to offset the unavoidable seagrass
impacts associated with the emergency hurricane repairs to the Harris Gap Channel Bridge by
restoring seagrasses within the Horseshoe Pit on Surmnerland Key at the southwestern end of the
Bahia Honda Bridge. Tbe Horseshoe Pit was created as a borrow pit. A remnant fill pad surrounds
the entire pit except for an opening along the northern side which is adjacent to the existing navigable
channel.
The Horshoe Pit is located within State sovereign submerged lands that are currently leased to
Monroe County. The FDOT has requested that Monroe County pemut the western portion of the
site to be restored as seagrass habitat. Under the 2S-year lease which expires in March 2002, Monroe
County has been utilizing the Horseshoe Pit for recreation purposes. The Department's Conceptual
Plan would restore approximately one-half of the remnant fill pad s~rrounding the Horseshoe Pit to
seagrass habitat. The rc;:storation acreage achieved by this activity will probably exceed the required
compensatory mitigation requirement. If so. the FDOr will request thai the additional acreage
produced be cCbank~" and available for future use by th'e mOT. / .
The FOOT proposes to excavate the existing fill down to an elevation which corresponds to the
elevation of the exi~ing seagrass bed along the western $ide of the Horseshoe Pit. The removal of
the existing fill will pro\ide suitable habitat for seagrass growth and development. In order to protect
the restored seagra.n area from wave impacts asso~iated with fetch across the borrow pit a berm of
rip-rap boulders will be constructed along the edge of the scrap-down area adjacent to the side-slope
of the borrow pit. .
Monitod1"\i 4nd Maintenance
The Department proposes to monitor the seagrass restoration site for a period of one year on a semi-
annual basis for natural recruitment. If the site does not show significant signs of natural recruitment.
for example, at least 30 percent vegetative cover by seagrass and macroalgae. the Department will
then conduct a seagrass planting program. Seagrass plugs measuring 8 inches in diameter, will be
harvested from the adjacent seagrass flat on an interval of no less than 10-foot centers. The harvested
plugs will then be immediately replanted in the restoration area on 3 -foot centers. The Department
will maintain at least 80 percent survivorship of the planted seagrass plugs until the seagrass begins
to coalesce and the vegetative cover reaches 60 percent within the restoration site. The Department
will maintain the restoration site free of trash and debris during the monitoring program.
PI) 39lJd
~~O 19~ OdIAN3 loa~
SOlS-OLP-S0E
6E:Pl OOOl/ll/LO
Attaehment A: Conceptual Mitigation Plan
ERP APPLICATION 000209-4
Harris Gap Channel Bridge Shoreline Stabilization Project
Page Two
Hardbottom Community Miti~ation
During the construction of emergency repairs to the Harris Gap Bridge. the mOT relocated
approximately 90 percent of the shallow hardbottom community to the southwestern side of the
Harris Gap Bridge. The relocated hardbottom habitat was reconstructed into a small "patch reef'
which measured 12 by 20 feet. In addition to relocating the majority of the shallow hardbottom
community within the consuuction footprint of the repairs to the Harris Gap Bridge, the FDOT also
aeated new hardbottom habitat along the northwestern side of the bridge. The Department placed
approximately 5 cubic yards of clean concrete rubble into the scour hole located on the northwest side
of the bridge. A small "patch reef' measuring 12 by 18 feet was created by piling the concrete rubble
in a mound along the bottom of the scour hole. Additional hardbottom community habitat will also
be created with the construction of the rip-rap berm within the seagrass restoration site at the
Horseshoe Pit.
Monitonn" and Maintenance
The Department has conducted a baseline monitoring survey of the relocated hardbottom q:>mmunity
habitat located along the southwestern side of the Harris Gap Bridge. During the next semi-annual
monitoring event. the condition of the concrete rubble "patch reef' located within the scour hole will
also be documented. In addition. when the rip-rap benn is constructed along the edge of the borrow
pit at the Horseshoe Pit site, the hardbottom community which develops within the benn will be
documented.
SO 39'Vd
..:L:lO J.9W Oi:lIAN3 J.OG..:l
SOlS-OL r-sOE:
6(:rT OOOl/TT/LO
Uii11i.2UUU
1~: 3':J
':rl" -~,-
_ _ _, I U 5.20:,
F [(.I r l t
cl\,o'l F'I-I r'I1'_,1
rlFf-
F'AI"E
Ut.
~
.X", .'
..:~,"
\".:,~iJ..0,~. ...r:. ...... '3;' '. .... ..::<'.
.' . ...."..... .,,,,-.,;.. ....... .. -.' . ..... ..""-
.:::,,:,:..~h.';ii':""':~'" <",'::' . ;:.. :.Y. .. .,' .' ,. '. '. ,;: .... .' . ... ':;;.-."
NAI.E .::..:' ""'."cYi' :;"':'" .,,'. .~. !.."",:,,=.. ,,1. .'~!. ~ "~ ~..-=-= · ~..,.....-. !.-,.,.-,,~..,.... :.
KEY.. ..~~~!~~:\"f~~K
.... ~ ............ .:,. .:::s;", .' ....... ..... .' ..,..' .... ..;:., ..... .... .......... .:..' ..' . "':.,. ..,......., .., "",.,.: ......."",.'
:::" . . i:::: ::fi :':~ i.'I:::j,''; !.:,::; :.'::'.'.: i( i:i:" iiii ;i: (i: i ii~::f i. ~:~.:.... {:::; ::!::6' i, i'iii:::!: ifii; ~; iii(Dr.: if.::. ,,'1ii.;;~': :if,
\ . ::., 19 :. ....:..". ....::. .....:.. _;: ~~:....: :.:., . :::..: ..::. ..:...... .:::...: ;:. '.-::." -; :..' ,."';:.' =:::. .....':...... ......:rffl.:: :"~~ ..:.;r..:' .:::.:.
\\., .' ." .... ..' - .... ..... ..' ..' ..... ..... ., .., .... ..' . ..' .' ....... .... ~.." ....
.::,'.:,. . : .,;;..:::,;::i;:::;:;i: .. ."...;::.,,:.:,;' ,:::! ,;::i' ,,:;!::: ::iN:::iii..::::.......:;.:..,......' :,::::::.:iJJi" liTi.:E::::::~:" ~~:.:::
'..,. .i.-..K: ',:.'....i:;' ..:i.:..:o,..:,.'i!::.:i,,' :;:i::::i:i::;;:::;:::: ....i.::::'.::::.:','::;' :;;::: ::::'i:;;:';~"""""Y ::::: .-:..';::::: ;.::
..... ....... .' ..,...... . ............ .., .... ...:. .., .... ..,:..... .... ...... :.... .:..' ..:......",:".. ...:............ kEy....'.........
':REfUG€ '. ,..,., , ,,:::':':'::' ..." ;::' ':::: ::, :::' :.,,;.:, ....::..,.:,;.. .,,::., .~~........ .:;:..,..::. ..:...:.- ,:. ...,,::...,.....
;':::.: KEY":;':::: :.:::; :.:;: :::;: :::.i:: ;~'=o ':",' ..,;::j.......i::~::...!i: ".';;!;!'!i:...~n'" i::':"::";:;:'::::::;:':;;;::;:::::::'"'' ., .,..:.:r...ii
." .... . ." ..... .' .' .... .., .., ......... j(i .... .... ..' ..' ....... ~""iZH' .
:':': ,.. .".... :.... :.... ",,:"'''''' ~ ..:.:,..:::::. ,,,'....::.: .:::.. ,,,.. ,:,....."......S..5oo... R' -.:::. .., .... .' .:.:
.::.... :...., ..,.... .' ..". ..,::. .:::....:. ~ ......::... ....:. ..' ."..,,,.., . .,...:::., .",....,: - ...... .- . ,... .:
";:.:.:.:.; :.:.: :::~i;:~:: :.:: :::: :.::::::': ..:::;::~:?!.~c::~: .=: ::.:;:::::: :..::':::.:Z' :::: ~: ..::,-,~::..::::.:~~::: ...::::; ,"~y'1 .' ..; L ITYLt" r.....e.~KEY ~r:::
..' . .... .... .... .... .., _ ........ .' .' .....' .' ." _ .,'" . .... "EY al..Y ft..-. - ..-
:'{l;' . BIG :::..,...,.:,.......,:.: .....,:...,::. ~:.." :.,., :,...,.:,,:. .......... .... .,.., v.,.... . ..', "". ",,::.::.. ...,:,.'" ':.
." .., ..... .., ..... .' ".' ........ . .... .' ..... ~ ...". '.' . .' ..... ...... ..... ....... .
,. w MANGROYE" ';:.' .::..... ,.... ........ ,... ..,. ....:... ":. ,~,:.... ~. . ..,. ...~::....:., .-.:.... .:',.... '.,. .... .,.
i;. .u . ,. ..,. ::i.. i' :........ ,;,::;..:...... :~,,:: i. la.':':' :;.::: :\1i{e":" ~ ..!.':;. .,. . :"i;" i::i~:r': I,::.:,:::: :.:i:i "::;:: i:;;
;~{r;}JJ:~{/J}X{/~;.EY.::.iiii~~i:~~~)/~{~~.~~t{{({!}}jf..r!!l(~JJ!{f ...:' )i::::l!1}fM:~t!!!:1~jtf!:~!{W!JJ?U!}1[~
. . i::': .' : ":..:,, , ....,.:,:::..:!:.. _ ;:;:. 'i(:;:'" 'J>Y " . ..:.. .....;:",:: i:: :::: ::'ii:' , "i.."ri:: ::,:::: :::iii:::
. Span(5h. .... ........-.. ...... . .... .... ." ...... ..~.. .. ., ." · ........ ....... ......... . ..' . ., ...,. ..... ....
i.l:( b . :.i;if::! i;:ir:.:.... :.:ri!i;:.: ,":.~' .'" ,,;::::. . .... . . "i! ~j;:!f,..:.., ~!j}rfi;!i fiiii:;:: !jj:~l~'!f Ii ~l;'jf'::,:i;ii! i iii,
;:.::.e-;~:::9~;'::: ::'i:::'i;~:: -':.' .! D....:.. ,,~ 8" ::: .:::8AHiA .H....O:.N..:O::..A::;:S::.T.::::::.:..::1::::..:ii':::1:::::.::~~:::.:.:.:€~::;::.;[:":::1
.n .... . ..' ." .' p '"""', ........ R ATE..... .... .... ..... ..........
~:.:::... ...:::..;.-::. :. ..;...::: ....::.. .. .::::... ECR~ p" ...:.:.:::::...::::...::::...:::...:::.
"'.... .. .... ..' ." ...... . ..... ~ ....... ..' ...... ....... .., .
..' .::..' . ..' . spaul ..:.JIj...~. ..........:....::.... ..' ..ATION AftE&....~;...... :...:......;1......:. ....:~.
.' . _ .. .:.... ."...,...... ," .... .,..... .... .,. .,. ..' "" "...... ......,... '., ....: .....".... .::....
. ....,... _ .... lWlllO(t :.:...::., ,.,:::: "....:...::,.::' .."i:::" "i':':: .......' .:':'::: :!:,::.. ::::::"::"::':" '" :.,','..:: :.:"':::: ,;::....
~ ."'.:.. .:...".'. ..' :', KEYS: ' ,:,:::. ::,: :. ..~:' ....::,:::..::: ;.:';':: ::,,::::: :::":::: ::i,::: i'i..:.:r..::: .:l"::: :.:,:: ::,,,:' .,~.: \.,,~. ::. '!r.:.
'~. ... .WE.ST s' u'" ...... .... .., .... ....... . . ..--.' ..- . .,' ....... ..' . . ..' ..... ...... ..... . .~. p' ......
.' ,.. ':,'" ... _Rl... :::: :::':~::" ,..:.:,:.. . ',,'. .... .........:... ..::,::: :::.:::,::! ::"i: i:::::'" .~ ..:..:.... .:,'
. \,::: ::;:i:'::~E"I'''::'i:::I1'....i.:::;,....i!!...'':i: :.:ii::',: THIS PROJECT ::;:: ::::::::::;:-i::: :.:::...~~::::.:.:;: :::.
.... ..:. '. ::; if i..:. ,',,:: ;..:': .......' ;.<':':: 'i; l: !i:i::,: If::i::" ............. .. : :::ii:" ::i!if~ii-*:: :!,,::: ii,:::;:; I;:
f;A;[f\M)JXfM!!~(MjN;jjMJ!:iMt7Z{@JX{(Dlt(Mj}jY~};iFf!!FWf!Ai\~l.'j~'!!f!;jJ.Z(M))WMW~)'fII:;'
[Mif(!M0Imrf~WJr({fMi~~t~ftMff.f/;ff[1;~tflMJJ0({~j),*~j!ff'JIxllJfMJB{Mlj;Fiii;;::''''
.... ..' ....... ....... . .., ........J.. ..... .., ...... .... .., . "~" ..... . .... ...... .., ....
/jj));'i!!)j~fj};\~.'!PWjjP{;1J},::[J!i))i'f!DWNi{ij*tf(~iJ}'::fi)gjf!(':::,::.
::., ....:... ..::. .."..... ."..' .::.. .,:., "SJji,":~'.~"""'::" .;:..... ,.... ."."
7<<~)W!jjij?!jjjl!J/!/f;~ffff!!~;.;;~;;~j)rif;)r!!!!AiUN{~;;J,~>/~;..:::,.
:.... .~~~~;. _"::'.' ::::. ..t::.. .~;:., ..:::. .:::.,. .;:.... .:..' .-'
~..~;. ':~::'C ..:.:..... n" ;:::.:; ..:: :..~:.:., .:~;:..: ::::.'
:;=::::: :'.::';; :::" I.a,nl ~~.:. ::.:!:: :.:;::::: .::'.::':;::'"
. ..' ..' .' ,~ ..' ...,.... ... .'
~MijfJ~iP;~([;}j{l!Y:::i::;:"'" .'
\
\
HORSESHOE PIT
U7/11/2000 1~:39
305-~7(j-52(j5
FDOT Et~IJIRO MGT OFF
~
- , U)
",...;
;Z
w
CI
c
CIt
10
of
o
Z
o
:I:
d:
:r
d:
10
I-
eL.
l.LJ
o
:c
en
w
en
a::
o
~
I/)
1/)....
-o:[d:
G:.J
~ll-
W
I/)
~
w
~
0
Z
d:
.J
0::
W
:l
&I. ~
0 ~
I/)
II.
..J
::l
C1
11.1
C)
o
a:
CD
d:
o
Z
o
X
-0:[
X
-0:[
CD
o
.J
o
Z
d:
w
u
o
o
I-
Z
-0:(
.J
...
d:
PAGE 137
oc(
w
a:
c
z
0
...
~
0 Z
l-
I/).
IloI 0
cr
rn -~
rn
oc(
a:
CJ
oc( a:
11.1
en 0
.~ bi
w
a:
~
~
w
en
1::
0-
W
0
J:
en
W
~
0
J:
07/11/2000 1~:39
305-~70-5205
FOOT EtNIRO ~K;T [IFF
PAGE 08
-
FILL PAD BORROW
SEAGRASS
FLAT PIT
"'5 +5
0 0
..........
....
-5 50' ...""" -5
-,
SECTION A-A
MANGROVES
STAKED TURBIDITY
BARRIER
FILt. PAD
BORROW
PIT
+5
o
-!>>
-5
50'
S.~CTION B-B
h\\\~ EXCAVATE
_- --- El(I 5 TlNG
PROPOSED
HORSESHOE PIT - CAOS~ SECTIONS
Ui/1li20110
..l-
1..): 3'3
305-,,)70-5205
FLIIj! Et.I\IIPO l,jC,T 1...1f'1'
: . .'t:'""':.: , ...
...... t! I
..~, ~~
:~"l! .~~""~
l .' ;
,. i'}~4"3~
..', >~
. . .. .
.'
'-
.'
BOARD OF ~ OF THE DlTBJilnt. IJIPRl"1VEMDr.l' 1iasT FUN!)
(1)~~3a
LU.5li: ~
.1'0_ 2932
W8P;m:AS, the Bo&1C'c!l Of TrwI~e~!: of: the Int:ez'Du ~vem8Qt
"rrQ$e Fund o~ the Sta"te of 1"'.1.or.l.da by virtue o~ Section 253.03.
J:"lor.i..&I. Sutut.., hoids Ut1e ~ c:crl:cU.n 1.an4s and p~opa.rty far u....
use an.;} be%1ef:i.t of. f;.he lh:Ilu of .~oxida;- 0Ul4
WJmRBUf the lSlIi4 2.rus-f:tate$ by ~XJA' act:1cm.em Ma.xck 1..
l.'77, atltbod,.e4 aD4 ~ve.;l an ..gr~ 'lri.tb ~e Cc7UDq,
1'1o:r1a.... t:.o pe.z::ad.t: c~ Ul:ea o~ and a~v.i.uAS 011 t.h. 1.and.
, I
.' \,
.
. .
. :..:
. ":..
. fl..' ..i
~d. p~~es lIBnUla:tt;e:r dperibed ~or the pW;polli. o~ prese.rri.ag,
. .. '.
deve1op1Ag-. OP,Cr&t1Ag alld maia1:&ining said ~ ~ p:-ope.rt;y faz:
out:4oo:r: X'8CI:eatioaaJ., ~, ClODSe:v1lti.oD IUld uIated ~da.
.
. ......
".!
.. .. }
~ '_.:i
....J.
_ ;;f~~
. ...;
. . "
.!j~'
BOfI, ~_, t:h.iJs egx-C:cma.nt::. JD;ade bet:veen ~ lroa%d
, .
,. .:~
. :..~
. !:~:
~l:~: 'that ~ part;.i.~s lLere1:o, for _d'in .c:ousid- .' . ,.:i
erlitioG o~ t:be 1IIU1:lI.a1. OOY*Danu and iI.!JX' J uDllm'bJ ~~te:r: OOQt:a1.ne4': :. : :t
.so hereb.lr ~t: tI1id o;up:IIIe ~. ~no_. :., :::: . - ~:.'~ ~
".. -f.
1. rha lessor 4be5 lIA2:'eby leaM b? 'tile les:n~. t:he. tD1-' .i';..-_::)l
I . . ',.,J., .' '.~
sl:taat:.e 10 IIom:oe ~t:y. P.1.orida.. ,:';" :'::.;
'\.~~-:'. ~ ..:~~
.....:"..--fr".:O;
. ......r;
~~;;. ::;:_~~
o~ l'~ees of t:Jle Iilt:e:'1la1 brpzoveme.n1: ~i: ~ of t:be Sta~
of Pl.or1d~ ~UJ .~, and HoD.roe (lQunty, Florida. a.s, LBSSA..
1~ ~os<:J:'u.4 ~Ol~ of iaDd.
nz:
(Se@ ~it. A - Attach.cl)
:I:O _VB AND 1'0 mn.o t:he above described !aDd for a ~
of W_t::y-~ive (25) y~=- €lI:OIII t:be d4t:e llceof, ~Cl:' t:be puqao.. of . :. '.
~-~-~ - ,~.
~_rv~.. GeveI..op~. ~~.. operat:in9, JIIa.iA~9', Pro:-
...>~
.. ',.
:~
..
~g ua.4 o~.e JIIaDa9'~ 5a..ia ].and .f~ pub1J.o outdoor~. ,
t:.J,oa.a.~. pam, QQ~t.iQll IIDod re1.11ted paa:pose$~
~ ,,!
I..~
2. ~ l.elS:JeEI 1IIha11 have 1:hG r.i.ght 1:.0 enta' uprm said .. ..::}
l.A.Dc:1 r07: aU PW:r.o- lIGr:elSs.:l%7 t:6 uia ~~ _~oymen~. h:t sa1.4 11U1I1e,,:' - ~h. -, ::~~
. .
oE -t:.h~ ri,ghu ~ c:o~ed to Jot:.
3. 'J'he l.eGsee .ball ~ag~ i~. ageA'tlS and eIllpl.oyees .
cooperate to .pre'9'8llt: the ~~:r:.i.~ 11.1;;11 l!)f ~u4 land or 0Ul1" U~,
tilltreof Ilat: ~ eoa.fOJ:mity ri~ t:h1.s 1ease.
..- ~;
. '-.
"",:
~
:. ~,'
. :j.: :...~:.~~
........ '.' "!G.
_p_.J...-...., --- .........._.'_-:.....I...._........_.~. ~...... ......~.k.c--.........,..-......:.'-O;""~~~:~
F'AIJE
U'3
'.:4
,;
of
Uilll/2000 14:39
305-470-520''::;
~-[liJT [tj\/ IF'U }~GT UFF
...
~ . ~
.
..
4. !!he 1ecsor or .its Qul.y OlLllthorillled agent 5hAt~ ha"l1e the
:rIght;. ~t any t.ime t:o. ~e t:.b.c '"..U'l ~<Gd and the. If'Oxoks ~ opera-
tions tbe~ of t:Ja. l~~ee i.a. <my IlIat~ ~~~ t:o t:hi. ~_
.eat;.
s. ft.e .I._uree agree$ 1:0 obtain. f~ ~%QVa1 b:OIll the
19Qtlt o~ Plorlda Dep~t 0:: JII~'t:uX'&J. KOa:01:lrQOs, D1.vid.on o~
Resom:ce HiulageJllQDt, ~Oll: allY aDd a~1 .f~ci1..ity ~OD&t:rnntio.n on .:a.id
1i1Wd. and t:o Dd.nia.iaa 1:he 0Ipp2;OV.d. .facil.it:i.es ~or tile ~ieia~ use
o( the pelle. ~ .l.essQr 119l:ee$ ~ GnblDLt. . COIlIprohezud.'V"e d"eve1.-
opl8:nt aa4 lDiUlalil'elllent plan wit1U.A aQe (1) r-.u fl:Oll dau I...e was
8ft>....vvcl ~ CCIIpI~te all. COA8truat:.ioD wi~ bro (2).:rears ~._
~bSr.
I
I
6. ~ 1ees_ .h~ CO-..mlaA1;p .-ad agxee:r t:O 1.Dves.U_qat:.e
aU alabls of -er.r ~~e at it:: OWD ~=ef. <<m4 to ind..m.fJ',
p%'Ot:ect:, ductc1, ho~. a.od 50lye hanll.esa; ~e .Board of ~Re~ .of
tJalt Int::ecal lDprOV~1: :L"rwJt: FImd of the State ot l!'l.or.ida aJJd,loX'
" .
the Snte of Florida fro:. aDy ~ a.ll. c:1.abn5, &:ti.ons, 10lLwsui,t:.s; eel
d....;n.A'" of: .my k~ c:ar Zlatau:w. aria1Zlg out of 'thia ~emeka~.
7.' m.,1l~ U the D{)i.n1.on of the Board o~ 2'rusf:... or ~
Xnt:erna..t. ~~~t: ~t Pv.A4. "ai.d lands are Dot - 1&ti..u...a 1!.or
t:he puxpose outllned ~ t:h.ia lease.. tlUs agr__nt: .r;.haJ.J. tondnll.t:a
.2D<l ~ l.~ds. :iJI!p.re.seecl wj;t:h :R1Ch a9~e_en~ ~ .revert ~ tAe
said 'rJ:USte_. Any c:ast:& .en- ~es ~1a1.nq oat. o~ ~ UIpl~
uU.QA or this oJ.a\Ul. U&l1 ~ ~~ COlRJil.~l:r, Wholly aDc1 C!J1tire1x
by t:h. 1......
8. ~ illequiU,us that mar SUb$eq\leZlt:ly ~ in thiG
.l.eese ~ be subject: to" ~~lon DpQI1 1a"i..t;tea .r;~ of! e.i~
pany, and t:he pilJ:t.ies agree to .negotiate .in 9C?O<l fai..t:b as ~o any
5ucb :1nequJ.Ues.
9. rh1.s .agreeDlen~ i.s ~CIl1:cd h Clup~a1:O, .~cb. copy of
..jhlcl1 sba11 ~~ all ~Q:Jes be cons~ered GIl ortg.1ua.l._
:m ~ ~', by aut:hodt:y granted 1"~J:'Qar.r 15-,
~977, the 1.892J.1y de.s19Z'8ted ;tC,jJent o~ tlIe ~ g~ Trus~ o~
the l:D-t:91MaJ. ~t ~1: !'aIl4 bas h8r~unt:o 6ul),sl:J:"~ Ids
=mre and ball caused the of~ic.i.a1 seal. of -the JJOa%d of! TJ?D8tees o~
potge :2 of
,Lc.-~ A9X~Qt; JrD. ::.,.:1t2
......... -
",
-'.,. ..
'-:
.~::.{('~':"~:.....~
'." ~
'.5'
f"'t<GE 1 0
Uiill/2UUU 14: 3"::l._ ___3Q5-4-nJ-'S2D5
f UIJ! f:jj\j 1f.:'1J r~G T lJf-'f
, ....
. -'.. ~
..
.
:-.=.. .,.~ . .:.:..
,. 6-:;'
. -.
~ .IDte%.D.lll. ~t ~ FQ.Qd to ba bexeunto aUi.%ed. hi
the d.~ o~ ~.::!l1"l..h'""'s@e. 1'1o.r:ia., on ~ ~ /4Z' ~ 0% 0. ~_
L~1'~. ~
(SI:&l;J . - ,
JIosrd. of ~ste.K
_ tJae xnterna:1., _
- :IJllpron!lllen~ ~st:
Ft1DCl
of
:
,
>>o.1I.R.Q OR rxu~s 01' ~ ~
%MPBOVJiHEH'l' T1UJ~ rtJI5rO
JJr;Jt.~.~~
. DBl'AIICI:JIErtt Qi' RM'OJW;, a~ .
.Ao~ .tis1. 24th
da,y o.t"
.Ar1'E~;
u/ ;:, ./U'/..,g..;.:..
lta1pb w. White
c:l.ea:'~ 1:0 ~e BoaJ:d.-
P""9G 3 of
r.eas. A9reement lllo_ 2Sl~:l
Kay . 19~.
Doit. Sc:h1oessex- .
aai.aMlaa - IIr::ID2eoe COant:y Boou:d of
Co\mt:y CoaIId.ssiQlIBrS '.
~-- .
. H;aae :I. ~,
By
.
- '.
-'
, .
u ~:
~~.,.
: . ..::.:~
.,_:,.~ -.....:a;.....
F'Al.Jl 11
F [JI-I r Ell\/ I RO MI.;' T OF F
~17/l1/2000 14: 3"3 .._3~_5-~70-.s~~5 - "~::I .....
::: ,'~:: :: ~ .~ ?7",~:t~1l?:' _, ::~ '.':', ~ <, :"?;~::-: ,:,,'
.._~-..-
.. .
~ - . ~.
E%!'l~l_';I\ ..... ~ tw_, Z~3Z
l!CAl DESCRIPTIon
~.'
Certain lltld.s ~ .Spanlsh .Harbor- ley, Mo.,r'Oe CounQ-;. legaTl.>' described
as follQWs: . .
.4~"J.1
The su_rged lands. sand bar-s. isl.nds' and other la~s .' ,.... /"
$n Flor-jda:~ 1,yi"9 .ItOl"tllerly of Spat\1sh Jlarbat' ~ in . ~ ....
SeC1:f~ J2 and 33. Tcwnshfv. 66 'So~tlt. .'~ngl! '0 East. IGonroe .
Cou,,~. F.lorid.. s.fd parts Irore pllrticularly .'
cfescrfl;eJ(t.s f'Ql1ows: . ... .
.. . !-, ;'1
(A' :Jredgfng IiIrea t.e1'1: S~nion 70 ~ 00.00 :... ' ,
. . '..,' .".'
~nc:fl1g 'f; t:h~ pofnt of intersection of th~. (asterl,). eoo . : "
of ~ 8ig Pffte Key - Spe"1Sh'H&t'bor ~~.8I"fdge wr~ the, .
bse.Une..of Suney Qf State..~oa'd No. S. rim North 84'39':. ':
(cst a In$~QCe of"- 3%31.85 feet,;., thence North "l'SZ'4.D" Fast: :
adiswnc:e at' c183.38 feet to Base-.;Line Statfon :/0 + 000.00.' .
th~ l(orth 28.07'20~.Ile$t.. dts.bnce of 550 feet to the './~ '"
Point Of I~lnnjng. .thence contil'tUr .Mort.. 28'01~~" ~t ~L ":
. di5taD~ of 600 .t'eet. ;thence'Hor-Ut 67'52'40' ('$t . d1stanee .
01 fico f'eet;.t".ce South 28'01.ao~ Eut.. distanc.e.ol':fj(J() . . .
f".rt. ~ $Q"tb6't.SZ.40.."~~ a .dbblnt:e Of"6OO feet to
~.h.. ~int ,of BeSJ:.n(1!~ of IWdglA$I .~ra; AIID ' .~.. ..
. . ".:. . . .
(8). S?,raga Al'e~ -. Left .StatiOlJ 10 + 00.00 .
CoaRencfnfj at the ..ve _ntfonc4' 6as~ line Statton' '..
. 70,+ 00.00 run NoH:h.,2S-07'ZO" WKt;' ~ 4istance of 550 .,~
to tM Po,pt;. of 8egfnntng. th~1t "fQrth 61.5Z'~" 'East: a
distance of ~ f~. thenceSolltli ZS.01'20" 'East '. d'i$Qnee-:,
of 250. 'feet. thi!nct: SoutJI 61'!5:l.40.. West . distanc~ of .GOO ;.~'
f'eet.. thehc:e North 2S.f17'z.O. lIest 01 dfsta'!ce of ZSD feet. tg ;
'the ~iftt ~~ 8.eghUll"9 of S~r.~e {l~.ai: ~. .. .. :. .
(t) Kaul Route - Left StattOft 1S 4 85',33 . ,"
~~ing. ."t the ..f'o~ti";'~ 8as.e.iine' .$tatfon ..
70 + 00.00- om ICorth 61'~'40" cast & dhtlnc.. of 585.33
fett. thence IiIorth 28-07.2'0" U~.t .. dfsiance 0' .f70 'Ht to .
. th!! 8O'$t ~r.th>fes.terlJ' r:ight of waY,11ne of Stne ltc4d Ifo'_ '.5.
.$ shown on the riSJDt 0" w.Y.~ of.'Sec:tian !)()OJlJ...2S10, '."
State Road'No. 5 .1Il4 ~ rvin~ of Be9tlUl'ng..tbeA~ conti"~ : '
North 28-01-20. lien. df..stallCe of', J3U .fe~ to. trr~ Soutli~ :.
..~,..ly ane O"f the a"Ol"elDentfo"td'Star~ge Ara. tMnc.-, '.. .,
Soutla .'*52'40" Vast a cf:1sUlnce of 50 feet. tJI~e- South ..:
,ZS-01"!O". ~t. .. di'stanc:~ of 130, f'~t to the irf,orcwid IIIOSt. '.
~r-:t"-sterl'y right of ~.Y ltae 0' sitfd St;rte Roa4 NIl. S. '.
thence North 1;1.52'40" l.st: along ~1lI'41IOrt"~ly rtght of
~ nile ~ dist~nceo~ -50 f'eet .to tb~ PoInt 01' &e,ini1ing of ;.
Haul Rou~_ . .
.. '. .
'. .:..1.
Rote~ ~ve d'escrfption "'SecI On Propos'ed ~fn\J an~ Fi 1) Storage: _....
Area aJlpltQtion prep~retlbJ' Florida ~artme~t of' n-.f1"pg..tUiOli
date~ lfoveaaber; 1969. job 90030-2510; &nrI the approval by the' ." ....
Florida ta~fRet. fa th.fr caP~ci~ .st~e aoerd 0' Truste.s ~f .
the {ntel"'Nl llop",~ent Trvst Fu'\d. of' Urat oCet'taitt blenty-f1ve '
Y.~r leas. ~que$1:ed bJ' Honr"D9 Comty. norf~.it the'T.I.I.T_F..
_eting of ~rc:h I. 1917. . '. .... '. "
"fII:,..:;
"." .
-. '
" :.~-:' . ~~ .... 'l~" , .:..
I ..." ".
".-J. .
. ~ ','..
..
.)
"
....
. ,
PA(;,[
r. u~
12
305-470-5205
~DDl Elj\/lRIJ '-'li.,1 .9FF....v
'IU~
.a.....J.O
BRElnlRD '-N~ INDtNT RIVER COt7NTIES - Central and Southern !'lo~;i.da
!'~tJOC! Cont:.z:ol 1?;i:tta".i.~ maclo app~1cat1<n for an easement tOot the
purpose of cleaniD9 OU~ chaQne~s i~ ~. Sebastian Rive~ in Section
24. ToWn~h1p 30 South, RangQ 39 Ell:t. Brev~d and Ind,i,an R.f.yer
COWlties, O"e~ appro:dJl\tl~.l;r 8.7 aeres lying -within ~. U..i.bl of
the State Jtoar1 Departllulnt. right of '-tay of ~basdll.Jl 111:W'er Br1-4,..
~ uni~ed States CC~ps oe !:ng1neor. and the Stat@ ROad DePitrt:ment
"W81v~ objections to the project.
}(OUQ.. -Ii _dot by Mr. c:oll~r. seconded by Mr. l>ickinsol\, ~
adopted unanil::ousl)[ . that the 'Z'r1.l.t4ll6S 9:t'.m~ ~pet.1:1l1 e~&Illent
to tho Pisuict f!or lI1;).intenance ot. ~he chann.el as req'lest.d.
~
~
""
~'"'
INDtAN' JUVZJt COlJN'rY - Th. >>ON'd <>.t cOIlnty COlllllU.8s1onera of Indian
River coun~y.by ~e~olut1on G~~.4 ~.bru~y 23. 1966. re~..ted
dedication of 4'1.04 aeres ot land 0WDe~ hy the T~toe' in Section
4, !l'owru::hip 32 South. Range 39 hst. one-half mile wcst of 11. s.
H~ghway NO'. 1 ouod fi\1e 11111... Dt'rt:h of Vero B4ach. Florida. fln"
.PU!>llc pArk &1:\<1 ~e~"ati.onCll purpose.!.
~he county lSubm1..t~.s a p::,opo_d te~-year development plAn cieet\f1lM
by t2\. Board O'f paru and Hi.t.~a.r; lhuIp~1&l. with a detailed
schedul.e of! a!lUCl1pil~ed elCpCDditurea and develO'paleDt tbIe. 'l'!\e
park WQUld be deve~oped by c~nty torces. private contractllJ. and
with 1!!Jsanc:i.a.l. aid of the Kiwanis C.1C1b _4 ~ther civtc: ~%qan12:.t~Qn~.
~ota1 expenditure OY.~ a ten-year periOd ~o ~ $222,000.00. 'l'he
cow:at:y .1ntended to ded.i.cll.u t:hll pule eo. _ wUdlIfe %efuge aDd
sanctuary. leav1n'3 all much niLtu:r:ill qrOIln;Q as was compatible vi.th
u~e of the are. for recreation. The O\lt4oor aac:reat1O'nal plaJUl1n'51
comni~tee reviewed the pl~ aDd ~ecommended d.dlcatto~ c:ond1~ioaed
upon th. ClNllty'5 adhering- to the p%~J:lOsfld ~en-year developc.ent
,plu as elosely as po.s1b~..
J
'-
j
~
%he Staff recQI:lMended dedJ.c:ai;io~ of t.h. trac::~ 0:1:: land 1:0' In4.t.lU'i
Jt,iver count:y ~gl: olltdoor pule .-n4 recreational purposes s~)ect
to 1:be ~oll~i III 1:he event, thQ c:oun~y shall (1) fail t.o
develop the entt~e ~a~t for public park and ree~ea~iona2 us.
L.n ~e miumer as dhewn ~I'l Ute devllllopment plan withiQ t..A )"ltU5,
or (2) Ude t:h~ land or any pert ~'h.r.oll ftJr purPO.~. Oi:her thZUl
cOWlty park aQd re<;lIreatiollal P'Qrposes, the dCCUciltion shall at the
opeion of tbe 'l'r'Ust:4!:.,. :b(, subjeet to ~~ation Upon vr.i.ttllln .
notic:. as to any 4l:ea reJllaiJling undtsVelope4 for ~ccrea.tional
purposes upon exp.Ll':leion of the ten yea.t'. and as to any area used
for ot:he. than park and recreational )>\I.l:',po.O:ll.
~
~
\'0
The D.1.rector said tbe land "',.. ~C1rt1\erly )mder a Illint!ll:.'al leall:e
(a:~ar1:) ~c:h expJ.red. ThQre would l:le reverter provisiO!1 .in the
d..d. he ~s.~v4 Hr. WL1~1ams.
HQtton was IIlade by Kr'. J)iQ)(inaon, .sec:ondecJ 1>y Mr. Wi.1U,UIS. ano!
adoptee W1.a:>aouCl;y. that the Trustee. grant Ue reques~ of J:ncUan
~.i.ver CoWlty for de4ieat.1Qn gf the 491.04 a=-e:c o~ 1M4 tor park.
and r.cr..~.i.ona.l purposes aubject to the two provision& .e~ forth
;above, 1lIhteh 1o/0uld be 1.n.lIlr"C1 1.n t:hll in.uIJIBent: ot decU<:At:lon.
~
~ONROE COUNTY - The S~ato ~o~q p.partmcnc ma~o applicat.ion for
~~~~.:.:lto- .e~i.:jl~~-,,t..c:"i9rt~: ~~ 4redi1ni J .SS i1Q."fI$
In Section 32. ""Township '6 South, -'Rlin'i.~-:(O East. III .Monroe COWlty.
to~ an .ighty-foot na~i9deion channel in connection w~~h ~Q.~c-
tion o~ a sta.te rOil~ on 6pani~h Barbo~ K.y.
3-1-67
- 174 -
PAGE l~
I.. UV
l'
"
""'
U7/11/2000 14: 33
305-4 7Q-?20'j__,
FUCJT
~
~CO, tbe State Road Depa~~ent ~.quas~ed dedie~tien of .ubmorged
land in sectiQns 32 and 33, 'l'O\msh1p 66 5outh, R.ange 30 EAst, con-
t.aining O_~l acre, llIore or 1es_, on whiCh opo11 I\I4terial frOll\ ..14
c:hannel would be placed ahll~~lng Spanish Hubor Key upl<and proS't';,ty
O1oued by MonrOl!t COunty. By tole']t'am receivod March 2 the county
approged ~e ~p~11cation.
Stkf~ ~ec~end.4 ~pproval of ~. ~emporary 4r.d~in, .a~~nt L~d
the decUcation of subcer9'cd bnd to the State R.oaa Depa:tlllent,
sqbject to r.~~ipt of official county resolution confirming the
tel.gr. of approval.
Hotion was In.de by Mr. Dic!<ineQn, .seconded by !>1r. ra1rcloth, ;;and
~dopted unanimously, that ~he Trustccs a.ccC!pt the recolllllendation of
. ~h. Staff .. \1\" action of th.. Jloard.
PAUl )JEJl.CR cOwrY _ Attorney J"ranc;LlJ E. z,ove made requ.s;t for tha
issuanc:~ of a dllpli~&to deed in lieu 0: Trustees' Deed NO. 24013 .
(1~28-50) 4.t.a JUDe 23. 1965, to Cecil c. rults and Hazel E. pults,
his ",Sof.. - Od.g!DA1. deCld was 1:cport.a to be loet withOtlt h."'1n9
been recor".4.
,-
--
t~
.
, .'
."
Motion va.. .ade by 11r. tll~cm, seeorsae,cs 1>)'" 11r. Fa1.rcloth, an4
adop\ed withou1: dbjeetioa, t:hat the '1'rus~es authoru. issullIlce of
~e dupU.o~n;. d..d to~ the w;ual f10.00 t;:harge. .:
SUBJECTS ~R ~ER 1829~ .
on motion lUd. 1:>1" w _ Dlckincon. seeonde'" br HI:. connor _"",do adopt:.d I
unan~lSl.y, t:he 'J,'rulitees approved Bidding lteport lIfo. ~04 li6tinc;f
one &"C9II1u bi.d ~or &ale of land in l'X'ankU.n county under prov' !
"i.ons of dUlpte:: 18296, AcU O. lliJ37 - ~e MIlrphy A':~. . i
I
I
i
On motion 4uly <adopted, the meetin9
ATTEST;
o~~_ ~~
DIP.EC'l'Olt - SECIU:l'~
..
..
.
...
.
"
....
.
.
.- .
;J-7-f>7
- 17~ ~
F-.AI.JI:: lJ