Item J2
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Division: Growth Management
Department Planning
Meeting Date: May 19 , 2004
Bulk Item: Yes No X
AGENDA ITEM WORDING:
Consideration of an appeal by Mr. Charles Bryan pursuant to Section 9.5-123(a), Monroe County
Code of the assignment of environmental points under the residential Rate of Growth Ordinance
(RaGa) for Building Permit # 03-3-3651 on property described as Block 12, Lots 5,6, 27, and
28, Angler's Park, Key Largo.
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The appellant engaged an approved Biological Consultant to perform a Habitat Evaluation Index
(REI) for his property in March of 2003. The REI that resulted scored 19 points and was in the
range (16 through 26) of moderate quality. This REI was revised by the upper Keys Biologist to
reflect that the property was not mapped as "threatened or endangered" species habitat. The
revision resulted in the scoring being decreased to sixteen (16) points but the quality of hammock
remained as moderate with the assignment of minus five (-5) points. This appeal is based on Mr.
Bryan's contention that the Biologist's determination of his property as being Group 3
(Hammock of moderate quality) and the accompanying assignment of Minus 5 (-5) points is not
accurate. Additionally, as March 16, 2004 a total of 344 REI have been reviewed by the upper
Keys Biologist and 272 of those were moderate quality hammock areas.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOARD ACTION: N/ A
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Denial
TOTAL COST: NA
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY: NA
SOURCE OF FUNDS: NA
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes No X AMOUNT PER MONTH
YEAR
APPROVED BY: County Attorney _ OMB
CP
DIVISION DIRECTOR APPROVAL:
DOCUMENTATION: Included X To follow
Not required
AGENDA ITEM # ~ 2-
DISPOSITION:
BOCC STAFF REPORT
MEMORANDUM
TO: Board of County Commissioners
THROUGH: K. Marlene Conaway
FROM: J. G. Buckley, Senior Planner
Ralph Gouldy, County Biologist
DATE: April 21, 2004
RE: ROGO (Permit # 03-3-3651); Appeal (9.5-123) by Mr. Charles
Bryan
MEETING DATE: May 19,2004
REQUEST:
A. Description of Project
The appellant is currently in the ROGO process awaiting an allocation award
having entered the system on December 16, 2003 with a total of twenty (20)
points.
B. Location of Property:
The property is located on Barracuda Blvd. in the Angler's Park subdivision of
Key Largo further described as Block 12, Lots 5, 6, 27, 28 and west 1'24 and west
1'2 29 with the Real Estate Number 00552930.000000.
C. Appellant:
Mr. Charles Bryan
3788 Cocolake Dr.
Coconut Creek, FL 33073
D. Precise Decision Being Appealed:
Assignment of five negative points (-5) for property being a Group 3
classification per Section 9.5-122.3(7)(Habitat protection).
E. Date of Decision:
12/16/03
F. Appellant's Desired Solution:
The appellant is requesting that his property be assigned only two negative (-2)
points under Section 9.5-122.3(7).
G. Appellant's Basis of Appeal:
The appellant contends that his property is the only property in the Upper Keys
that has been assessed minus five (-5) points for high hammock, moderate quality.
H. Staff Response:
Staff review of this situation indicates that the appellant had a Habitat Evaluation
Index (HEI) survey preformed by an approved Biological Consultant (Marcella
Nemec) in March 2003. This HEI was conducted under the HEI format adopted
by the county in January 1999. The score of the HEI performed by the appellant's
consultant was 19 points which indicates moderate quality. The point range of 16
through 26 indicates moderate quality hammock. The upper Keys Biologist
reviewed the HEI and conducted a site visit in September 2003 as indicated in a
memo from Niko Reisinger to Ralph Gouldy, County Biologist. In that memo,
Ms. Reisinger points out that the three points assessed by Ms. Nemec for
"Threatened and Endangered Species" was not warranted as the property is not
mapped on the officially adopted Protected Animal Species maps as animal
habitat and no protected species were observed by either Ms. Reisinger or Ms.
Nemec on their site visits. The reduction of three points yielded a total score of
16 which is deemed to be moderate quality.
Mr. Bryan's assertion that no other property was assessed with the minus 5 (-5)
points is not accurate. As of March 16, 2004 a total of 344 Habitat Evaluation
Indices have been reviewed by the Upper Keys biologist; two hundred seventy-
two (272) of those HEI were moderate quality. The dearth of applicants currently
on the ROGO list reflects the fact that many do not pursue an allocation if
assessed the minus five (-5) points.
The position of the Planning and Environmental Resources Department is that the
points assigned for habitat value are accurate and valid.
March 29, 2004
TO: The Director of Planning
CHARLES E. BRYAN
3788 COCOL.AKE DR.
COCONUT CREEK FLA 33073
RE: Permit 03-03-3651
Pursuant to Section 9.5123, I am making this notice of my appeal.
RecentlYI permits have been issued on both sides of the Marvin Adams Water Way. I have
owned my five lots since 1980 and observed that the canopy in that whole area was the same as
mine.
I have only made a cursory investigation of the biologist points reduction for the top 215 Upper
Keys applicants. However, none of the 215 applicants lost more than 2 points. I could have lost
2 points and been one of the top four who received an allocation award at the March 10/2004
meeting.
I have to make an in-depth investigation and wish to have access to all necessary records to
properly represent my interest in the hearing to be scheduled before the Monroe County Board of
Commissioners.
Sincerely,
€~e63AAP
Charles E. Bryan 1
\
. ''1ISt'
'~
Revised H.E.I. score shee1:~ high elevation hammock, Key Largo
SCORE~ I
1. Tree size:
r
J -"e ;A(,S-r(~
st Canopy Species I Mean DBH All 3 are> 811 = 1.5
--, I
I i"'", ":"/;. 1"'i" RIND i .221 ~ Only 2 are > 8" = 1.0
'... !,....<. _' t, I r->.. , !
r M [60 - L I M 8..0 t J 7'7 Only 1 is > 8" =0.5
L L 0 \^/ !3:. us. rl c, l <0 None are> 8" =0
<I::""
'"
L. c;C,
-.
...."":. \,..../ /
.... ~. '1 D h
__. ')0, 'eptt:
SCORE:' Z
A'h'eruge Soil .Depth
L1. inches or D10re
:2 in c11 es UD to 4 inches
1
--.------
Less than 2 inches
Score
2.0
1.0
o
3. "f,:\7oody Phlnt Species Diversity:
'",-
SCORE: '+
rVoodv Species Present
37 or more
jl)'COre
6
5
...,,..., ~6
-').: - .)
,.., _. - 1
~_~ , "I
?'I
/
4
~:~, ~ :.16'
-- .:..~
.-----
l7-21
. ,..., . 6
L.L - j
'1
,j
Lc~s ::han 12
/2
LB
..:. T/E, Exp!oited or R.1. Plants Present:
SCORE~ I
I Li:,.tc~l Plants Present I Score I
~ ~2 01: more I 3.0
I 2.0
/ - 1 ! I
I
1 - 6 ry 1.0
,j \.
:-Jone I ()
\ r
~ i- ~'\'>;/~
.., .
.
- -';:d~<'t-~.
5. Invasive Exotic Plant Infestation:
SCORE~ 4
% Infestation
Invasive exotics at 5% or less
Invasive exotics> 5% with Cat. I at 5?iO or less
Category 1 invasives at 6% - 100/0
Category 1 invasives at 11 % - 200/0
Category 1 invasives at 21 % - 30%
Category I invasives more than 30%
6. T & E Animal Species:
if-Iab-itat
JZnown or Probable
Potential
Not Documented
I Score
.0
2.0
o
7. Forest Size:
Acres Score
10 or more 5
7 - 10 4
--~---
4-7 3
: -4 .......,..,.,/ 2 I
.J.
-- .,;i"""",,-
.375 - I 1 I
i
< .375 0
'---
8. Perimeter Disturbance
Edge to Area Ratio Score
.005 or less 3.0
---
>.005 but <.01 2.0
--.
.01 or more but < .02 1.0
.02 or more X 0
./
Score
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.0
1.0
o
SCO~ J .
SCORE~ 'h
"
SCORE'\-; 0
~~;;O;
" ---.."
9. Wildlife Habitat
.~.-
SCORE: L
I Fruit Producing Species Score
15 or more Category 1 .3.0
12 or more Cat. 1 or 22 or more Cat. I & 2 2.5
10 or more Cat. 1 or 18 or more Cat. 1 & 2 [>( 2.0
20 or more of any fruit producer 1.5
15-19 any fruit producer, at least lofCat. lor 2 1.0
< 15 fruit producers, or all are Cat. 3 or less 0
,.
10. Comrnunity Connectivity
SCORE~ .0
Acres a/Canopy Coverage Score
12.5 - 30 of Closed Canopy 0.5
> 30 acres of Closed Canopy 1.0
10 - 50 acres of combined undisturbed habitat 0.5
> 50 acres 0 f combined undisturbed habitats 1.0
HABITA T EVALUATION,
TOTAL SCORE:
~ (h
CUl11ulati'..'e Score Hammock Quality
-, ,..., High Quality
L / or greater
16 to 26 l>< Moderate Quality
Less than 16 Low Quality
'---- -
HErs REVIEWED BY NIKO
DATE NAME LEGAL DESCRIPTION HAMMOCK TYPE CLEARING r'5
12/27/00 Academy (cV, ORC Tract C Harbor Course Low(M) 57845 SF
12/7/92 Anon L13,B4 Harris Oc. Pk. Low (M) 3207 SF
6-19-91 A.V.G. Corp L16,B5 Indian Hbr High (M) 4132 SF
5/13/92 Applegate L3 B 11 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
7-31-02 Ashby L8.9.10 &11 B1 Lazy Lagoon High (L) 6,000 SF
12-27-89 A ylor L 17 B3 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
3-27-91 Baker L9 B5 Plantation Bch Low (M) 4800 SF
9-8-94 Barnes L21 & 1/2 20 PlantBch High(M) 8401 SF
. 5-13-98 Barnes, Joel L20B5 Harbor Cs SharborDR Low (M) 7515 SF
3-27-91 Barrett L25 Tract A Tropical High (M) 25080 SF
j 8-6-02 Coral Reef Ests
Barrett L16, 17 B12 Anglers Prk & King St High (L) 11349 SF -~
"""" DisturbedlLC Violation must replant total 7566 Square feet
7-19-90 Barry L4 B8 Key Heights Low (M) 4943 SF
11-9-95 Bascilius L26&27B7 AnglersPark High (M) 4160 SF
8-6-02 Barrett L16,l 7 B12 & King St Anglers Park High (L) 11349 SF
,,,, ,,,, Disturbed 5200 SF
2-22-01 Basset L29&30B3 HCS4 Low (M) 11840 SF
,,,, ,,,, Disturbed
1129/94 Bay Hammock L25 Bay Hammock High (M) 4800 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L4 Bay Hammock Low (M) 4943 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L3 Bay Hammock Low (M) 3456 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L33, Bay Hammock High (M) 4868 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L24 Bay Hammock High (M) 9680 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L26 Bay Hammock High (M) 5920 SF
3/29/94 Bay Hammock L2, Bay Hammock Low (M) 3584 SF
5/12/94 Beardsley L38 B 5 Harbor Course S High (M) 9,060 SF
3-8-91 Belcher L23 B3 Ocean Park Vill High (M) 2400 SF
9-24-96 Betancourt L14B4 Bahia Mar Est High(M) 2520 SF
12-23-96 Betancourt L 12B4 Bahia Mar Est High(M) 2226 SF
12-26-96 Betancourt LqB4 Bahia Mar Est High(M) 2310 SF
8-12-98 Bie, Eddie L24-27B14 Lake Surprise High (M) 8400 SF
4-3-91 Bieri L4, B6 Riviera Vill. High (M) 2200 SF
9-21-2000 Biondoletti L 18 & 19 B 2 Sunrise Point Hi gh (L) 8580 SF
1-27-03 Biodoletti L 18-20 B2 Sunrise Point with Julie High (L) 12886 SF
7-24-90 Bird Pt of L3 McDonalds High (M) 31500 SF
Disturbed 25200 SF
7-24-2000 Bland, Nelson L2&3 B 1 Silver Lake Park High (M) 4319 SF
3/5/92 Boals L19 B3 Bay Harbor High (L) 3030 SF
~ 5-30-97 HD Booth L13&14B7 Anglers Park High (M) 4160 SF
S,,;loJ~ /5 /G: B7 lire. 0 -;
#E/' ~?l
8-14-90 Bovce. J. L1 & 2 B9 Twin Lakes Low (M) 4280 SF
2-6-91 Bovce. M. L21 B2 Bahia Mar Ests High (M) 2916 SF
5-10-01 Brandon M&B MM 94 Bavside Low(H) 35300 SF
( on1v low elevation hammock reviewed at this time)
Brennan L19 & 11. B3 Oceana
7-25-03 Burke Sunshine 2000 L9B7 Hcourse S OR 18 Low (M) 4794 SF
and wetlands and scarified
6-11-90 C & M Ventures L23 B6 Harbor Course S. Low (M) 7847 SF
3-13-02 Cannon L5.6.7 B14 Bowens Riviera Village High (L) 12.600 SF
9-11-90 Care Management L9 Randall Adams High (M) 4720 SF
8-31-90 Carlton L24 B6 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
10-16-03 Carson L5-7.13&14 B8 Pirates Cove High (M) 50000 SF
8-18-90 Carv L 18 B6 Harbor Course S. Low (M) 6934 SF
6-25-97 Carv (JH&SL assist) L16 B3 Harbor Cs S Bridge Low (M) 8118 SF
8-27-93 Chittum Wl/2 L3 Plantation Kev Low(M) ATF Clear
5-17-95 Century 21 L8-13B5 KL Park High (M) 10.400 SF
5-12-94 Cleveland L 17 B 1 Harbor Course S High (M) 4725 SF
4-11-03 Clemmons 3.4.33&34 B9 KL Park High (L) 6000 SF
6/26/92 Colon/Hernandez L4 B9 Ocean Park Village High (M) 2400 SF
7-6-89 Conklin L11B6 Plantation Beach Low (M) 4200 SF
3-30-98 Contreras. 1 L1/2 22-24Bl4AnglersPark High (M) 2594 SF
4-1-98 Contreras. 2 Ll/2 22-20Bl4AnglersPark High (M) 2500 SF
10-19-90 Combest L8 B 1 0 Twin Lakes High (M) 3790 SF
7-6-2000 Coradeghini L1B2 Harris Ocean Park Estates Hi gh (L) 3614 SF
8-14-90 Cossuth L5 Randall Adams High (M) 4880 SF
7-3-91 Crawford L6.B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
7-3-91 Crawford L5.B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
10-07 -92 Cushman Trust L6.Coconut Row Tavernier Low (M) 31.027 SF
7-1-96 Dabek. Alec L4B2 Buttonwood Shores High(M) 2640 SF
9-5-95 Damian Pt38ModelLandCo MMl 00 High(M) 26.318 SF
two Districts. IS and SC
8-18-90 D & P Ventures L 1 B6 Harbor Course S Low (M) 7560 SF
8-9-91 Davidson L 7 B2 Sunrise Cav Low (M) 11 000 SF
1-10-92 Davis S. Plantation Beach High (M) 22128 SF
1/14/92 Davis Parcel A Plantation Kev High (M) 22128 SF
7-30-02 DelFante Ll.2.3 B3 Oceana High (L) 9.450 SF
3-27-90 DeMaggio L19 B7 Plantation Bch Low (M) 4200 SF
2-25-00 DeRosa M&B Lime Grove Est(Glidewell) High (M) 30.685 SF
7-15-97 Dinsdale L18Bl HarborCs (presrve) High (M) 7080 SF
2-14-90 Dixon L12 B2 Buttonwood Sh High (M) 2820 SF
10-2-2000 Donofrio L22 B2 Winston Park Low (M) 2100 SF
10-24-2001 Dominguez L27 B3 Ocean Park Village High (L) 3600 SF
1-16-97 Dovle L4 B 1 Kev Largo Beach High (M) 2640 SF
7-10-89 Dressler L33 B 1 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 4920 SF
3-5-91 Dressler L30 B 1 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 5280 SF
3-6-95 Dressler L21 B7 Harbor Course S 3 High(M) 7920 SF
3-6-95 Dressler L4 B7 Harbor Course S 3 Low (M) 6968 SF
2-15-96 Dressler W1I2L9B7 HarbCs S 3 Low (M) 1950 SF
8-9-89 Dressler L 12 B6 Harbor Course S Low (M) 5760 SF
Disturbed & 2 Wetlands
7-15-97 Dressler L21B3 Harbor Cs Baker Low (M) 5429 SF
3-23-94 Driscoll Prop L19 Harbor Course Sec 3 Low (M) 7920 SF
6-11-90 Driscoll Prop L23 B6 Harbor Course S Low (M) 7847 SF
2-26-91 Driscoll Prop L8 B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 4608 SF
2-21-91 Driscoll Prop L25 B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 7970 SF
8-29-94 Driscoll Prop L24 B7 Harbor Course S Low(M) 8630 SF
2-14-91 Driscoll Prop L23 B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 8970 SF
4-25-91 Driscoll Prop L4 & 5 , B6 Harbor Course Low (M) 15490 SF
6-26-91 Driscoll Prop L7, B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 4608 SF
Disturbed 6635 SF
6-26-91 Driscoll Prop L27,B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 8034 SF
6-26-91 Driscoll Pro L6 B7 Harbor rse S Low M 5632 SF
.~ Disturbed 2607 SF
6-26-91 Driscoll Prop L26,B7 Harbor Course S Low (M) 8398 SF
5/29/92 Driscoll1Dressler L3,TrtC B7 HarborCourse S Low (M) 9407 SF
6-12-90 Droney Gvt L4, Plantation Key High & Low (M) 25800 SF
10-23-2000 Dudley L7.8.& 9 B3 OceanalAnglers Park High (L) 9360 SF
2-1-2001 Dudley L13-16 B7 An~ders Park Hi gh (L) 12000 SF -,2
3-10-97 Dunkelburger L27 B5 Harbor Cs So. Low (M) 6838 SF
1-9-90 Ellis L6 B2 Harbor Course S Low (M) 8982 SF
6-14-00 E & T (Popp) M & B Lime Grove Estaes High (M) 44610 SF
1-20-95 ElwelLRoss L9&35B8 Key Largo Park High(M) 3300 SF
7-12-91 FabeL Roy Ll L12J4J5,B2 Largo C. High (L) 5400 SF
11-28-90 FKEC L16 Amos Lowe Homestd High (M) 11520 SF
9-19-02 FereiralRubio LI04&15-18 B8 Pirates Cove High (M) 8,000 SF
12/13/91 Ferraro L15 B9 Indian Harbor High (M) 2200 SF
7-2-98 Frack L9 B6 Harbr Cs #2 Low (M) 9803 SF
10-4-02 Frey LI0 B3 HCS #4 wetlands & Low (M) 8093 SF
5-3-00 Fried,Hal L 9 & 10 Singleton's Addn Tav CoveHigh (L) 6000 SF
12-15-03 Fried, Hal L20B9 Bahia Mar Estaes Low (M) 2100 SF
08/5/92 Fritz L33, Tavernier Cove High (M) 2000 SF
2/28/92 Fuchs, John L14 B4 Ocean Park Vill. Low (L) 5070 SF
7-3-90 Gardner L8 B7 Key Heights Low (M) 3880 SF
9-1-89 Gautier L23 B4 Indian Hbr High (M) 2640 SF
10-26-90 Gentes LI0 Bll Kev Heights High (M) 2880 SF
10-10-97 Gentile PtTrct Southcliff ESt Low -------.... 10448 SF
11-13-97 Geor e LI0 B6 Harbor Course S2 9235 SF
7/27/93 Gernon L18 B5 Ba HammoCK 3960 SF
2-6-91 Gibbs L5 B4 Tavernier Hts 3930 SF
4-11-97 Gilbert. John L3 B6 Key Heights 3024 SF
4-23-97 HD Gilbert. John L4B6 Key Heights 2964 SF
11-18-03 Giordano L14 &Pt 13 B1 Bay Harbor 6443 SF
4-14-98 Given L3&4B 11 Riviera Village 5155 SF
...2-
6-4-96 Gregg L9B9 Indian Harbor Low(M) 2200 SF
6-5-96 Gregg L8B9 Indian Harbor Low (M) 2200 SF
7/15/92 Godwin PT L3 Key Largo High (M) 13220SF
4-27-95 Gonzalez.Angel L29B3 OceanParkVillage High (M) 2400 SF
7-11-89 Gonzalez L9 B7 Harris Ocean Pk High (M) 2200 SF
4-27-95 Gonzalez.Dinorah L28B3 OceanParkVillage High (M) 2400 SF
10-23-92 Graves CommercialL 11-14.B 1 Holiday Home High (M) 122795 SF
6-1-93 Greene.Monte L12B10 Plantation Bch High (M) 10660 SF
5-13-91 Green. Sandra L17. B2 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
11-16-95VCGregis.Ronnie L 14/15 B 7lndianHarbor High (M) 5280 SF
1-23-96 Groover/Roi as L6B4 Tavernier Harbor High (M) 10088 SF
11/20/91 Grzybowski L6. B2 Ocean Park ViII. High (M) 2400 SF
3-6-97 Guardado L8B6 Twin Lakes Low (M) 2880 SF
01110/92 Guerrero L19&20 B5 Largo City High (M) 3000 SF
9-5-91 Guttierez L11.B8 Indian Hbr High (M) 2640 SF
6/23/92 HabitatlHumanity L 19 .20 1 1218B 1 Thompson Low (M) 4800 SF
6/23/92 HabitatlHumaity L16.17 1/218B1 Thompson Low (M) 4800 SF
11-18-02 Hager L37B5 HCS #1 Low (M) 7709 SF
11-4-91 Halpner L12 Bay Hammock High (M) 4232 SF
7-19-02 Hann L7&8 B7 Anglers Park High (L) 6240 SF
1-9-97 Harris L16B6 HarborCsS2 Low (M) 6968 SF
11-8-02 Haas L6&7 B 11 Riviera Village High (M) 5160 SF
5/13/92 Hearlth L2.3.16.17 B 1 0 Pirate Co High (M) 4000 SF
2-4-98 Heft L 17 B6 Harbor CsSo #2 Low (M) 5563 SF
6-19-98 Hendricks L22 B6 Harbor Cs 2 Low (M) 10140 SF
10-31-2000 Hess L11 B1/Tr A Harbor Cs Caloosa Low ( M) 6043 SF
Disturbed 4885 SF
3-12-98 Hilmer L24B5 HarborCsS 1 High (M) 6925 SF
7 -10-89 Holzman L32 B1 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 4400 SF
10-17-2001 HovtlCont. Dist. L20B6 Harbor CsS #2 Low (M) 9313 SF
5-26-95 VC Hopman L13B8 Indian Harbor Low (M) 2640 SF
5-26-95 VC Hopman L14B8 Indian Harbpr High (M) 2640 SF
8-24-95 Huard L11B9 Key Height #2 Low (L) 3960 SF
1-7-98 Hutchings L9B3 Harbor Cs Low (M) 7864 SF
3-16-90 Hrtsig L6 B 13 Palma Sola High (M) 2000 SF
9-19-02 Island Escapes L 32 & 33 Tavernier Cove High (L) 6000 SF
12-1-93 Janco L3B3 High Point High(M) 2937 SF
8-2-02 Jema InvlMonteagudo L5B10 Twin Lakes High (L) 4720 SF
12-01-92 Jennings L34.B5 Harris Ocean Pk. High (M) 2010 SF
11-15-89 Jernigan L5 B25 Indian Hbr Mixed (M) 2640 SF
4-10-97 Johnson. David L24B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
12-29-89 Jones. D. L30 B8lndian W/W High (M) 2640 SF
2-13-97 Jordon L3-9 B 1 3Anglers Park High (M) 11287 SF
6-25-97 Kent SL&JH L 10 B2 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 9369 SF
4&5 94 KMART. S Industrial Acres High (M) .'
Low(M) and Distrubed clearing in Acres
3-9-90 Kaczka L31 Singleton's Add High (M) 2600 SF
to Tavernier Cove
4-5-91 Kaczka L 11 B8 Bahia Mar Low (M) 2100 SF
4-2-92 Kaczka L3 B 1 0 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
2-21-95 Kearsley L 11 B2SilverLakePark High(M) 2091 SF
10-19-90 Keller L8 B5 Indian Hbr Low (M) 2640 SF
10-19-90 Keller L 7 B5 Indian Hbr Low (M) 2640 SF
6-25-97 Kent LI0B2 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 9369 SF
7-21-97 Kent L9B2 Sunrise Cay Low (L) 12818 SF
11-13-2000 Kentco Lll B 3 HCS Low (M) 8208 SF
Isolated wetlands
8-30-91 K.L. Church Christ L2 &3 Sec 28 Burlington High (M) 1606 SF
5-13-91 KI0.L. Palm. Inc. L3. B2. Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
1-9-91 K.L. Vol Fire L7-10 B13 Sunset Cove High (M) 7290 SF
5/14/92 Kellner L6.7.8 B55 Crains Subd. Low (M) 9725 SF
8-29-90 Kloski L18 & 19 B25 K.L. Park High (M) 2600 SF
9-11-95 Ki yaski Tract 1 Upper Matecumbe High (M) 68.232 SF
Hammock 0.9 acres) Disturbed area (0.84 acres)
7-12-91 LaCross L7. B6. Riviera Vill High (L) 3300 SF
7-18-91 LaCross L8. B6. Riviera Vill High (L) 3300 SF
7/23/92 Larocco L2, B2. Seaside High (M) 2981 SF
8-18-90 Langille L17 B6 Harbor Course S. Low (M) 6969 SF
5-4-93 Lageux L23 B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
1-27 -03 Lasseter L 10 Block 1 Holiday Homesites High (L) 2794 SF
10-25-89 Leggett, Murphy L21 B5 Harbor Course S. Low (M) 9431 SF
9-9-03 Lighthouse Church Sunset Cove High (M) 5500 SF
8-9-90 Link, B. L17 B2 Ocean Pk Vill. High (L) 3600 SF
9-20-95 LevyIMontessori Tav. OceanShores/TavOcBeach Low(L ) 2700 SF
11-22-89 Link. B. L16 B2 Ocean Pk Vill. Hi gh (L) 3600 SF
1-29-96 Luis. Agustin L 7 .8&9Bavwood High (M) 36900 SF
11-12-92 Lvrnneous/Zannis L8 Tarpon Acres Low (M) 7667 SF
(1 Tract.2 Hammock types)
2-28-95 MacKinnon L5&6B5 Bahia Mar Est. High(M) 5040 SF
1-16-98 Mangle(Frey) LI0B3 Harbor Cs 4 Low (M) 7355 SF
Isolated wetlands
10-9-97 Manfre L 17 & 18B 9 Pirates Cove High (M) 2000 SF
1-25-95 Mangi1/KMART Tract E Tradewinds High (M)
(1 Tract.2 Hammock Types) Low (H)
1-15-98 Mangle L 1 OB3 Harbor Course Low (M) 7355 SF
approx 1845 SF Wetlands
5/17/94 Mahoney L6 B2 Key Heights High (M) 4800 SF
9-30-91 Martin UBI Seaside Addit. High (L) 3300 SF
9-30-91 Martin L5 B 1 Seaside Addit. High (M) 2200 SF
8-9-95 McLeod PtTrA TropCoralReefEst High (H) 17.444 SF
3-31-95 McNulty L9 Tarpon Acres High (M) 21.080 SF
Hammock & Disturbed Dist. UP to+- 17 .000 SF
3-10-95 Mendez. Al L3 B 1 Harbor Shores Low (M) 3000 SF
5-2-01 Miga1ia L10 B2 Oceana High (L) 3150 SF
11-2-95 MillerIDavis L11B7 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
6-2-98 Miller L14B3 Harbor CsS Low (M) 8034 SF
4-19-01 Mir L10 B7 HOPE Low (L) 3150 SF
3-3-97 MJB Corp L17B7&B6 Anglers Park High (M) 8027 SF
6-28-96 Montesino L 17B2Harris Ocean Park High(M) 2010 SF
12/26/91 Mora L6 B 11 Palma Sola Low (M) 2130 SF
12/26/91 Mora L7 B11 Palma Sola Low (M) 2130 SF
7-21-03 Morris. Joshua L 9& 10 B7 Twin Lakes High (L) 9216 SF
9-2-97 Muir L13B2Sunrise Cay Low (M) 11100 SF
11-1-94 Murphy L20 B2 Tavernier Hrbr High (L) 5940 SF
1-13-95 M.V.P.Properties L22 B7 HarborCsS Sec3 High (M) 8562 SF
7-7-97 SL M.V.P. L52 B8 HarborCSS Sec4 Low (M) 10056 SF
7-21-97SL M.V.P.2 L54 B8 HarborCsS Sec4 Low (M) 9911 SF
10-16-97 M.V.P.1 L56 B8 HarborCsS Sec2 Low (M) 10679 SF
5/15/01 MVP L49 B8 Harbor CsS Sec 4 Low (M) 11754 SF
8-5-98 M.V.P.207 L20 B7 HarborCsS High (M) 7920 SF
10-25-01 Naples Cattle Co. L8.9.24.25B12 Anglers Park High (L) 5700 SF -2
,,,,,,,,,,,, Disturbed 8000 SF
10-30-01 Naples Cattle Co. L10.11.22&23B12 Anglers Park High (L) 10500 SF -~
Disturbed 1600 SF
11-1-01 Naples Cattle CO. L12.13.20.21 B12 Anglers Park High (L) 9900 SF
Disturbed 2400 SF
2-10-02 Naples Cattle Co L7 & 26 B 12 Anglers Park High (L) 3030 SF
"" Dist Hammock &Disturbed 960 & 2600 SF
9-11-90 Nelson L20 B5 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
10-5-95 Niebauer L9B4HarrisOcParkEst High(M) 2010 SF
9-11-90 Newcombe L4 B 1 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 5120 SF
10-31-97 Newman L3 B4 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
4-5-95 Nicholas M&B by Cocoplum Rd.MM98 High (M) 20.079 SF
and SM/BW. mangrovesSM/BW 960 SF
3-5-01 Nolt L9B4 Pamela Villa High (L) 3210 SF
2-28-90 Oliveros L6 B5 Indian Hbr Low (M) 2640 SF
5-14-90 Oliveros L14 B4 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
10-30-2000 Oliveros L1 B2 Seaside High (L) 5280 SF
7-25-2000 Olson. Mike L55 &56 B1A Bav Harbor High (L) 6000 SF
2-5-2001 OR Acquisition UO 151 Addn Gravvik High (M) 11.963 SF
6-28-96 Osborn L22&23B7 Anglers Park High(M) 4180 SF
2-25-97 Otto. George 1-3.22-24 B2 Knowlson High (M) 18126 SF
12/4/91 Page L22 B4 Indian Harbor High (M 2640 SF
7-12-02 Parkinson L 1&2 BI0 Bowens Riviera Village High (L) 8374 SF
7-12-02 Parkinson L3.10 &11 BI0 Bowens Riviera V High (L) 9528 SF
5/19/92 Pauza L35.B2 Harris Ocean Pk. High (L) 3015 SF
7-2-98 Pinnacle Inv L18 B3 HarbrCs #3 High (M) 8560 SF
1-13-95 Pozo. Miguel L9 B2 Harris Ocean Pk High (M) 2010 SF
12-29-94 Prebel L19&20Bl Harbor Cs 2 Low (M) 10490 SF
11-1-96 Prebe1.1 L29B7HarborCs S3 High(M) 7800 SF
3-31-98 Prebe1.2 L25&26B5 HarborCSS#1 High (M) 13902 SF
8-5-98 Prebe1.81 L8 B 1 HarborCsS#2 High (M) 12727 SF
10-4-02 Prebel L27 B2 Harbor Cs S# 1 High (L) 1951 SF
5-31-90 Redress Corp L8 B6 Harbor Course S. Low (M) 10435 SF
9-13-93 Regal L7 BI0 Key Heights High (M) 2654 SF
2 & 4 93 Register PtTrB MatOceanBay High (M)
& Disturbed 2.24 Acres
2-11-91 Reike L 7 B 1 0 Key Heights High (M) 2640 SF
10-20-94 Richardson Tr 20-23. Govt 3 KeyLargoMIXED HABITATS incl DISTURBED
Low (M) 21431 SF
7-17-03 Rodriguez. Miguel L4B4 Pamela Villa High (L) 3210 SF
2-22-96 ROE#2 Millionaires Row High (H) 20626 SF
2-5-96 ROE#3 Millionaires Row High (H) 21.000 SF
2-8-96 ROE#4 Millionaires Row High (H) 20857 SF
2-27-96 ROE#5 Millionaires Row High (H) 20811 SF
5-10-89 Rodriguez L12 B6 Pamela Villa High (.M) 2140 SF c1
7-17-03 Rodriguez. M L4B4 Pamela Villa High (L) 3210 SF (Y
5-13-91 Rogen. Inc. L8. BIA. Bay Harbor High (M) 2000 SF
2/21/92 Rohan. Rorv L16 BI0.Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
2/24/92 Rohan. Rorv LIS.BI0 Pamela Villa High (M) 2140 SF
8-2-02 Root. John Lll&12B 7 Twin Lakes Hogh (L) 9216 SF
5-21-91 Rosenberg L21. Bay Hammock High(M) 4400 SF
5-21-91 Rosenberg L32. Bay Hammock High (M) 5577 SF
3-12-98 Roth/Lesko Lot 23 Bay Hammock High (M) 6072 SF
10-21-96 Rothrock L 1 OB2 Buttonwood Shores High (M) 2880 SF
10-4-02 Rowland L 7 &8B8 Bahia Mar Estates High (L) 7560 SF
5/28/92 Roy L 16 1/217B3 Bay Harbor High (M) 3030 SF
10-30-2000 Rusk Inst. L5-0 B14 Sunset Cove Low (M) 12.000 SF
10-19-90 Russell L4 Coral View High (M) 2472 SF
1-23-97 Sabin L4&5B2 Sunset Point High (M) 5720 SF
6-1-94 Schweiss L3&4.B7 Anglers Park High (M) 4.160SF
2/8/94 Scott L5 &6 Bahia Mar High (M) 5040 SF
3-19-97 Schultzes L 15B3 Harbor Cs S Low (M) 8034 SF
3-4-98 Schultze. 1 L18B2 Harbor Cs 1 Low (M) 10054 SF
6-2-98 Schultze.2 L ISB3 Harbor Cs S Low (M) 8164 SF
9-23-91 Saunders/Cri ttenden Ocean Hammock High (M) 8276 SF
1/26/92 Stahlberg L22.Bl Key Heights High (M) 25961 SF
5-6-91 Shelley L25.B 11 Riviera Village High (M) 2800 SF
5-6-91 Shelley L26.B 11 Riviera Village High (M) 2800 SF
1-9-91 Shields Ll5 B2 Sunrise Cay Low/Mangroves 8080 SF
10-31-02 Sigle L16 B3 Pamela Villa High (L) 3210 SF
7-1-96 Silver. Donna LIIB2 Buttonwood Shores High(M) 2880 SF
5-13-91 Slettvet L1.B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2610 SF
5-13-91 Slettvet L2.B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
4-6-89 Smith. Robt L16 Bl Bay Haven 4 Low (M) 2000 SF
2- 7 -92 Smith L13.B6 Plantation Bch. Low (M) 3995 SF
6-26-91 Snowman L12.B9 Indian Harbor High (M) 2200 SF
11-17-93 Snowman L4 B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
11-17-93 Snowman L3 B3 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
12-14-94 Snowman L21 B7 Indian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
5-1-95 Snowman.Nancy L2 B3 High Point Amend High (M) 2995 SF
3-3-95 Snowman LI0 B7 Indian Harbor High (M) 2400 SF
9-18-95 Snowman L23B31ndian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
9-18-95 Snowman L22B31ndian Harbor High (M) 2640 SF
12-18-95 Snowman L5BI0Key Heights High(M) 2640 SF
9- 7 -95 Sorenson. John L21 &22B2ButtonwoodShores High (M) 4909 SF
11-6-2000 St. Nicolas Church Tract A Caribbean Heights High (M) 17243 SF
10-25-94 Summer Hill LIB2 Sunrise Cay Low (M) 8274 SF
4-12-94 Sport LIS .B6 Harbor Course Low (M) 6598 SF
1 26 92 Stahlberg L22.B 1 Key Heights High (M) 25961 SF
4-6-94 Stewart Duplex L4 & 3.BB Adobe Casa High (M) 3765 SF
4 6 94 Stewart Duplex L2&3BB Adobe Casa High (M) 3765 SF
7-27-2000 Strode. Inge& JP L 7B7 Harbor Cs S Harbor Dr Low (M) 5800 SF
,,,,,,,, Disturbed 5500 SF
3-5-91 Sunnv Hilands L9 B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 3120 SF
3-6-91 Sunny Hilands L4 B6 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 3086 SF
2-28-91 Sunny Hilands LI0 B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
2-28-91 Sunny Hilands L 11 B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
2-28-91 Sunny Hilands L12 B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
2-28-91 Sunny Hilands L13 B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
3-5-91 Sunny Hilands LI B3 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 5220 SF
3-5-91 Sunny Hilands L3 B6 Largo Hi-Lands Low (M) 2111 SF
3-5-91 Sunny Hilands L18 B3 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 3775 SF
4-11-91 Sunny Hilands L7 & 1/2 6. B6 Largo Hi- High (M) 3000 SF
4-11-91 Sunny Hilands L5 & 1/2 6. B6 Largo Hi- High (M) 3000 SF
4-24-91 Sunny Hilands L4.B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
4-24-91 Sunny Hilands L6.B4 Largo Hi-Lands High (M) 2000 SF
5-23-91 Sunny Hilands L8.B6 Largo Hi-Lands Low (M) 2000 SF
8/7 /92 Sunny Hilands L7.B5 Largo Hi-Lands Low (M) 1830 SF
8/7/92 Sunnv Hilands L6.B5 Largo Hi-Lands Low (M) 2000 SF
10-10-89 Swenson L29 B5 Harbor Course S High (M) 7480 SF
11-15-95 TafoyalMCFFraming L3BI0 Twin Lakes
6-20-01 Teach. Miles L29 B2 Harris Ocean Park Est
6-20-01 Teach. Miles L30 B2 Harris Ocean Park Est
9-3-03 Thiery. Andrw L 15 & 16 B4 Bahia Mar Estates
6-6-96 Thomas. Hal L 16 Bay Hammock
6-11-96 WM Thomas. Hal L 17 Bay Hammock
8-17-93 Tindall L18 B6 Plantation Bch
6-27-90 Todt L9 & 10 B3 High Point
7-27-2000 Topercer L28 B3 Harbor Cs Baker Rd
12-18-95 Wall. Randy L19B8 Plantation Bch
1-17-91 Walsh L6 B4 Indian Harbor
11-25-97 Weinstock L31 B3 HarborCS Sec4
5-14-90 White L5 B3 Harbor Course #4
10-23-89 Whitley Tract Matecumbe Ocean Bay
6-16-97 Wollard L5&6B3 High Point
10-10-90 Y oh L 7.B 1 Sunrise Cay II
10-24-04 Young/Lucas L14&15 B9 Pamela Villa
Total 344 update 3-16-2004
rJ 00 ~ 7<..
High (M)
High (L)
High (L)
High (L)
High (M)
High 'M)
High (M)
High (M)
Low (M)
High (M)
High (M)
Low (M)
Low (M)
Low. Cactus (M)
High (M)
High (M)
High (L)
3360 SF
3015 SF
3015 SF
7560 SF
4232 SF
7480 SF
4200 SF
5120 SF
4602 SF
4200 SF
2640 SF
6933 SF
7020 SF
11848 SF
5079 SF
6238 SF
6339 SF
~
o
I
00
I
~
en
IV
C)
c:
:i2
c:
IV
~
IV
~ en
.2~
C)~
c: ~
+: Q)
Q) a.
Cia.
E:J
o
u
+:
en
en
...
c:
IV
.~
Ci
a.
<C
~N~~NNNN~NNN_N~~~~MMNNNMMMMMMNNNNM
~
i~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i~~~~~~~i~~~
~ ,QQQQQqq9qqqqq;qqqq , , .~Q999Q9 ,QQ9
wo~~ooc~ooooo~o~~~~w~oo~~~---oooo-
~~NNg~~m~;~m~M~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~;jlj;jlj~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
088888ggg88808g888g888g8g880888g8
~_~~~~~~~~~~~~~MM.~M~~~_M~~~~NN--M
~
~
't5 a)N~C:O.~N.~"lI:.O
-l...........,...."'>.....3:M.....,....
a:i
"!.
_fn"ll"
CON....; M ..... ..... N
,..:~:ll.t-:<O..,~~<O<DIlC>.:~~..,
Ntllii:
<0 N
oqoCD~;:!-n:Vad~
~ -
NN ~~=~~~~ ~
~~ N;~~~~I.~ 'C$
~~~ ,~d~OOOOOOOO~~> ~~I~-lll
~m~ B~~~~~g~~~~eee_C-C-Cee ~W
Cm~!~~~~~S~~~coo~gg~~~~~S_S_S-!!~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~55~~~~~~~~~~~OOOO!~~
~m~~~~~~~~~~~~e=~~~~OoStif.$f.f.f.~~OOOO~
~S~~.~.~.~~~~~t~~~~~~~~~!C!!!~~88~
i~c~frfrf~~~~~~~t-:t-:~~~~~~~~~~B~o~~~
l'5~ ~~~~ ~m~~~~~~~~~~~~g ~cc~
>> ~~~~~~~~~Bt~~~mm~~mm ~OO~
., m~~~~m cc~ mm!i~~
~~ m~~~~ ~~~ m~e
<< __~~OO~ <.)
mmmmmm.g
..J
~~~
W60~~~~~~~N~~~N~~~~~N~~~~~~~~~~~N~~~
>t-:<.)
o U)
~_ W~W.....W.....W.....,....,....~wwwwwwmww..........wwwwm~.....wwmv
~~
~t-:
m
0;
.~~
:2t-:
~
~
~~~
.Q
e!!:!~
~~'
!21!:!0
~~"7
i~
:I:::E
---~--~-~-~-~------~-~-
....._'II""'_-~~.....
g'N
Z'
. I I I' I I I I I I
~o
'lli~
~,
o
o
~o
U~
.~o
0._
0:'
, , , , , , , , , , . . , , , , .
. , , ,
, , , . , , , , , , ,
,
, , , , . ,
. . , , ,
. , . , , , . , ,
Q)
'Eo
~-
t-:'
~ ~~~ ~~
O~ ~ ~ ~~I~ ~~~~~~ I ~
~ ~~ ~ ~ ~
~
.g E!-N
:I:Cl'
~~
~
"!
~
~.
.g E!-~
:I:Cl'
~
~
.g E!-o
::t(.!)~
.~s
~~
0:
~ .~
'2~~
m 0.0
~~
0'0
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.~MMq~qMq~M~M~~~~~N~MNOM~90NmM~.~
~i9~~1~i~li~~ili~~~ii~~~~i~~8~~~~~~
N, ~~O~~N~~O~~~llC>q~O~IlC>~qA~~~~N~~~..,
~~ ~~~~N~OO~~~~ ~O~~OO~N ~~~O~O-
iii
~ 0; € -;
~ Q)~~ E ~ -C~C%g~Q)
t t-:=~~_ ~~ - ~~~'E ~~m~me~~gt ~
o a~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m ~fi~~~~~OS~~ O~
""~'e~~!5ffi~mllio~~c.. - C.g>~ -m -'5'5 .~.Q.g.~""m
gO<.) m<.)t-:~.\.! 5::E _m~ ~ ~ ~ ~ {!'8 _c:~ CClCl 5 o~<'3 c:"1:
m :",0. gi<.)-~o_",~ E .0 e ~e~~q: g ~~ ~.101.\.! ~<.). ..:"'~ ~~
~1~~~~~JIg>ll~~'t~tj~~~I~III~~tll~l
~Cl~::E:I:~~~OO~zocwo~~oc~<.)~:I:U~:I:~<<~U)~o<.)U)~
_~~~~~~~N_~~~~~~N80~.~M.~M~~~~mNmN
~~g~~~g~~~~~g~~~~~~~~~~~~:ll:ll8~~~~~re
.EI~.~~~~~~~I9~~~~~9~~~~I~~~I~~~~I~
~ '~'?"(~ .~~.. ''?'?''(~~.'? .'1"(,.. ."(, ,''(.",
~ao~Soaoo8o~SSSooaoSSSS8ammgomSaam
@@@@@@
@@@
@ @ @
@ @
""
c
&_NMv~w~~m~~~~:~~~~~~N~~~~~~~~~M~~
~
o
I
~
~
III
ca
C)
c
:i:
c
ca
...
ca
... III
o >.
.... Q)
C)~
c ...
:0: Q)
Q) Co
-0.
E~
o
u
:0:
III
III
-
C
ca
.~
Q.
Co
~
.~~MMNNNNNMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
I-
~~I~lii~~~II~I~~I~~~~i~ii~~~ii~i~~I~!~iiii~~~~~
~o~o~ogoo2~ooooooo28gooooo82ooo~oooogooooooooooo
~~~~~;~~mMV~m~~~~MM~Q~~~~~~~~~~N~~~OO~~~~~~~~~~O
OO~~~~~~~~NNM~MMmmQ~~mO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~O~
~~~~~~~~lil~~lil2222mmm~~~2~mm~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~
8888880888888888888888gg8ggg888888g8888gg8gg888
~~~~NNNN~~~~~~~~~~~~v~~~~w~wvwmm~~~~m~NN~m~~~~M~
m
~~~~~~~~:~~~~~N~m~~~~~~~~
N:!_~""N""VM
<<)C)L()~ .c6-.."":, .N,.....-,....V~N~~~CO
~MV~V,....('f)NM
. , 'ISSj'~
"C"C"O -aoel t::
1ii1ii1ii1ilSl ,;~ei!i!ee;'i;'i;'i -gl' 2! .. .annn'l
J~ wwww~~~~~~~~~,g,g,g,goeee~< < ~~~~~~~ ~~
c~~e~~~~wm~~m~M~;'i~~~~~,g,g,g~00ee~~~<<<~~~~~~~~~~~~
~W~,g~~~~~~~~oo~oom'fi~m~~c~~~~~~,g,g~~~~~~~~~ .~~~~~~~~
~tl~~~~~~~~~~~~oom8888m~c~~~~I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~&~~
~~~QmRRR~~~~~~~ooo 8 888cc~~~~~~~&~~~~00 ~~
~u~~8ooo ~~~~~~2'00&0~0 ooo~~ 8~~~~~~00&02'2'&0~&00
OO~E~0000 ~~~~~~~~~~~m~oooo8~ o~~~~~~~~~~~~m~mm~~
oro ~'E'EE0~~~~~~~~~~~~j~~~~OOoo~~~~~~j~~~ ~~~~mro
OI mromro'E ~~~~>~~~~~~OO~~ ~~~~~~~ ~~
~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~
~~~~;.;.~~
~~~~
~
~;lll!
~bo~~~~~~~NN~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~N~~~~~~~N~~NNNN~~~~~~~~
>I-u
o ~
~_ ~N~~~~~~~~~~W~W~~ww~~~~w~~~ww~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ww~~
:2~
'5 I-
al
1;;
~~
,2 I-
m
~~N
3:1-'
.gWlO
lti=:'
~~~
i~
:r:E
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..-..-~~
~ '
I I I I" I I I I I I I I I . . I 'I I
5l'')l
z
I I' 'I t . I' I
~O
1li~
00'
, , ,
, I' . I' I I I I
o
,
, , ,
I I I I I I I I I' I I I
~
,
I I , I I .. I , ..
~c . .
j";'
, ,
I I I I , , I I
. I I I I I' .. I I
,
, I , , . '
.~O
Q.~
a:: I
, ,
f I I I .. ., I I I I I
m ,
~o
.=or;
, ,
I . I I . I I I I . .. . I 'I" I I I I I . I
, ,
,
. . I I' I' . .
'I I , I
I . I I . I I I I I I I .. I I I , I I
~ g~ ~ ~ ~ c ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-~ -- ~-~ -
.~~- ---~~--~~--~~~ - - ~ ~~-- - ..-
1il e-N
:rCl'
'')l
~'i'I
~ ~'9 .
,
I I I I
I .. I . I I . I .
1il e-o
J:(!)~
I I . I I I . I
0>
c-
'1: ~
~I-
0::
.~ 6
1-'"
~,g~
IV a. 0
" a.
1iic
015
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~O
Q~NO__~~_09M~NNMNQNNN~_N~_~N~N9MNa~~MNMNNMMN9M9M9MN9M
~~99999999 99999y999Q99999999 9~9999999999 9
:ta~3a~~~3a~~~~~3aaffi~~3~a~~a~g~3m3~305~~33~~~~a~
''f~7<f 977'f~79 7'<f<f:E9u..70'f97<f:EC ,7,?7:E7q7~(/)77z,. ,'f~
N~ I COll) ll)M~NO"lt~ ~a6(1')ll)cb~cJ,~ I O(J)CON' ,AOll)('l')N I o~~cbcbv.q-cO~"--Nll)
~ob-O_~~M_NN"-_O-__OO_N~"-OO~~O"--NON"-OOOO~"-_----
ui ~ I!! ~ tl
cQ ffi e. i ~ VI >~ m
~!0 e~0 _ -8 ~w ~8~0 ~~~ -00> uuu d
~~3 ~~~m 0 F>o~ _ ~~u..IVC0m~ >om~o 00 ~EEE E
~CI~ ~~U0 mCi~~~- ~c~~ '-~~Q ~Q.,~~~~~~~~~o>~o
B~~~~~~s~~j~:2l~ ~~~~~~~~.~~gl!!~~~li!li~~~~eeg~~i~i
li .0~""-'-m"fNNo~' 00 cC~.c C~0.0 ~ 'E~w' ~-6o~~~~ooooo-
~E .5l':E.~~~~.9!.9!0:':.. .c~oU .:ilo: ..il~u...E'~<6,.:i~mw:~~c<i:~:r:r:r~~
~.~IIIII~~~~fi~ll~f~.~I~~~~~~l'i~~t'Ef~ffii~~~~~~
~c~<81-1-1-~~~~~~o~~~I-ll!~~I-~~~>8~~8u!:Eg~~~~~~~~~~~~~
MN~N~~~NM~O~~~~N~~~$~mN~O~~~~~~~~~~~mM~mN~Nomg~
i~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Q) C? <? "? t? '? '? '? t? '? <? c? M '? ~ '? '? '? '1 '? '? ~.( ~l '1 cJ) '? t? '1 <? CO? C") '? '? '? ('l') M '? '? '? "'( '? ('l') '? '? M ~ '1 c?
~8~S8oooS8gagSoSS8SoSSoss0aoassssaasssssa~sagasa
;2
@;2
@@@@@@@@@
:E
'"
c
~~~~~~m~;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~t~~~
"lit
o
I
CO
I
"lit
II)
CI:l
0)
C
:;:
C
~
CI:l
.. II)
o >-
- Q)
O)~
c ..
;: Q)
Q) Q,
-Q,
~:)
o
u
;:
II)
II)
-
c
CI:l
.~
c..
Q,
<
~MM~MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMNMMMMMMM
i=
m!liil!liiiiiil;li~!i;lilll!li!illliiililillll!~
~00~~~~~~~8808-888~m8~~~~~~~~~~~-~~N~-wg~-NN~~m~
~~~~~mmmm~~~~g~~~mm~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~XX~~~~~~~~~X~X~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~
88oggoo8oo88ooggo8ogggg88gggogggggagggggggggggg
i~~~~m~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~MMMM~~~~~~~~~~_M_~~~-__NNMM
a ~ ~~o ~~~ N 0
~~~~N~-NM~~~_. N~~~M~-~~-~
_NN
Q)
Cl
'"
I!!~
:i.
~~~
~Ol~
~O)~"ltCO~~co,....::CDcn~M~~
~~~ --
~~~Q)Q)Q)Q)Q)Q)Q)~Q)Q)Q)Q) ~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ggggggg~gggg~Q)~~WW ~~~~;;~
"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''___------------'''~mm~0~ ~~~~mm~
C~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ============~~~~Q)Q)~ ~~~~~~~
1~~~~~~~~I!I~~!I!IIII>~>~~>~~~~>~!w~~ggl ~w~w~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~lglgglgggglg~~~~~~~s~~~~~~~
~WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!!~OOOOOOOOOOOOWeeeQ)Q)~z~~~~~~~
~ OOOOqOOOOOOOQOOOO~~~~~oowoooowwoowoooo~~~~~e>o ffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~00~ 8888888
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j~~~3j~~~~~~~ 00 0
jjj ~~
...J
~ci!~
WbO~~~N~~~~~~~~~NNNN~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~N~~~~~~~~~~~e~~
>1-0
o W
~ ,....,....,....coco,....,....,....,....,....,....,....,....,....,....,....,....www~~~~wwwwwwww~wwwww~ww~w~~~w
~~
:JI-
a:>
~
~~
,2 I-
a:>
~I!:!N
;:1-'
~I!:!~
~I-'
2 I!:! 0
~~"7
.0-'
"':;
J::::!i
.g e-_
J:0
.g e-N
J:0'
.g e-~
J:0'
i ,~~ I I
J:'-',
Cl
.~ ~
ffil-
a:
.~ g
~ ~ Q)
C=~
'" 0.0
~~
0'0
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~----~~~~----~~~~-~-~--~
:i!'N
z'
, ,
, ,
:Eo
"'-
a:>
~
~
~~
0'
,
, , ,
,~o
0._
[:'
Q)
1:0
:J-
1-'
,
, I' ,
-~-----~--~~--~~----~--~--~~~---~~---------~-~-
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~
NNMOMMMMMNMMMNMMM---q9q9N902~MMMOM9-9N~N9MN-NNN
~1~1illll~lil~i~illl~~~~l~~~~i11~i~1~lll~1~~~~~
~~~~~oooo~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~O~~~ON~~~~~~~~
~~N-_----N--- NNN~~~ N N- -~-N- 0---0 _O_N N
~ ()
~ gggg ggg... ~~~~e ~
8 eeee---- ---ggg ~ ~ ~N~~~~ ~~~ - ~
I~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~t ~~~~~~ ~o ~",~ffiQ)_~c.~
~ .S ~'CS 0 0'CS ~~~g>o.g>g>g>g>~~~~ ~E ~ ~oo - -_:!! :!!'S;'C,C a:> = Q)'5l!l <=
._ '0 E~et:~et:._._._.-lX._._._._._.- -.- -OO<{Q)Q)",Co.e..:'CC:i:.i'! )('0
~ o~~ ~ ~ ~ ~:g~~~~~~~~=8~ ~ '"" ~ IUS t-0t"g"g "a:::C~'ii ca'-'W C ~.!:! C15W
J:0J:~ _cccCJ:J:J:J: _J:J:J:J:J:J:<ll000i!:<lli!:0 ClClg - -NOO:>s":lil.9!~lil~":
c:~:E R!.~~m~c:c:c:c:IUc:c:c:c::c:c: R ~ ~ -- ~-.... mm.t:lg~Q) .~mc:~c:ca -c::~,g
~~~;:~E~~~Q)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~=~~ee~~~~~'Eeg8~~~~~0
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~88~~888~~~~0~~~~~~~
~~~~~~g~~~~m~~~N~~~~g~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Na~~~g~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~a~aaaaa~sss~~S~oo~SSSS~S~g~S~~g~gg~~ooa~~o~o~
CUll@@
:Ii
:Ii
""
~~~~~~~~~~8;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~E~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~
<i'
~
~
II)
ftl
C'l
c
:i2
c
ftl
...
ftl
... II)
o >-
.... Q)
C'l~
C ...
:;:: Q)
Q) Q.
-Q.
~::)
o
u
:;::
II)
II)
-
C
ftl
U
C.
c.
<
~MMMMNNNNNNNMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMNMM_NNNNMMMMMMMNNNNNMM
j::
~~~~~~~~~~!~~~li~~I~~!iiii~~~~~~~~~~~~i~l~ii~~~1
~g~~gg~gal~alRO~8~gggRoo... ~~~~00~OmOO~0002~~r.eOC02000COO
~8~NMO~"''''~'''~~''''~ "'~co~~........'-'-'-'-~~~'m ~~~~~~.~. M~....~"'li3....~
OOO~~~.........~...~...~...~~"''''''''''~~~~~....~~ ~"""""'~"'''''''~O'''''''''~~'''M
~~~~~.~W~~~_~___~~~~~~~~~~_~~~ ~~~--~~~~mNNNMO~~
888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888
~~~W~M~~VV~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~
MC\lNMlO~m-__CO~C\INNM
"'...
:9...co~~t:::;
." M
~ lO 0 ~ NMlOCOlO-M- lO co "It lO M
~_"'m-~"''''_~~~~~~~~~~~~;lO~~lO~NlON-_~~'''co-C\IMm~CO~
.c
, ~ c:
cc cc~ _~ ~ i ww
0000~~~ ~~~~~ ~~ ,p~~ ~~~~-~ ~~~~0000~ee
~~~i~oO 8>8>8>8>8> ~~~E~~ o~~~~'" ~~~~~~~~d~~
c:!~! =~~mmmm ~~~~~ ,S0~~===~_~~>~.cmmm~zoooo
00~0 5555555~~~~~~2~~o~~~c~~~e~~555 ~~~~~~~~~~~c:c:
~wwww~~~5>>>~~~~~m~~~~~~"'~~~I~~~~~~~~Q.~~~~~~~~~mm
:~~~~~mmm~~~~Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.~j~j~~~~"'''':!l,xoo~e~~~~~ll!~~~~~~~~u88
1~~~~~~~EEEEll!~ll!ll!ll!iiiii~~m~~~~~~UUUUE~~Q.Q.Q.~~~~~J~~
00~~~~mmm~Q.mQ.mQ.m~~~~~Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.mm~mm.>-m_z~~~~pc:Q.~ll!ll!ll!Q~000E~~
~~~ eeeee ~~~~~ oooo~SSSS~EOO~~~~C:C:C:C:~EE
66d ~~~~& ~i~~im ~~~~~~ ~~gi~~~~~~~
Q.Q. Q.Q.~ oo~ OOOOOOg ~~~
a:: ~ en
~
~a!~
woo~~~~~co~~~~~~~N~~N~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~NN~~~~~~~~N
>~U
o 00
Q WT~TWWWWWW~WWWWMWIDWWW~W~W~W~W~~W~~~wwwww wwwwww_
~~
~~
al
l~
Jl~
al
~ '
'Ow
~j::~
eb!!."
Q.~'
gb!!o
~~"7
.c:!.
m ~
x::;:
'lil e- ~
xC>
.c e- '"
:!2c>'
-..-..-.....~
-~-C}l..--.....-
C}I.....-
C}I~-~--
I~
:20
m~
al
. , .
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~
o
~
~O '
;5'7
. , .
, , , , , , , , . , , , , . . , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , . , , , , , . , , , .
, ,
. . , . . . , , , , ,
, , , . , , , , , , , . , . , . . . , . . . .
. , ,
, , , , , , , . , , , . . . , , . . . , , . . . , . . , . , , . .
. ,
, . . . , . , , , , , . , . . , , . . , . . , , . ,
,
, , , . , , , , .
.~O
...~
a:: ,
~ ,
'Eo
~~
- ,.. ,..,.. ..-
0--..-----..----- -- - ---..- -
, , I , C}I I
~
~
,~~
~ ' ,
~ $'9' .
. ,
i ,r;;~ I I I I I I I' I " I I I t
x......
~- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'2 ~
ffi~
~
,~ .~
~j~
m "'0
~~
00
..-m9MMNM~-M~-NNNNM-NNN22q~M~NqNNg~qNMMMM..-~MNMNMaO
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A~&l~~~~~~~~~9~~~t9~
m9c~m~9 ~m::;:7m97m<~~~~~~9~~m~9~m~~0~~~mmo~~ ~cm~
~"'~~~~co~o~...~~10o~o~om"'om~~~~o~~1~~~~o~~~~~~ ~~~...
0- __0 -_-..-..- _M__OO_N N-ON O-NN-.....--NN_NN..-N_O 0
m e> 0
c: c> c: U
~c~- c ~oee ~ ~~ __ ~ 0
~ ~~i~~~~.~ ! ~~ ~.~~~ ~~~~ ~~!! ~ ~ i ~~~~~~ i
~~~!~~~~~&~~~ ~~1~~~~~~~~8 &~~~ ~ ~ g ~~~~rr~!~~
~e..,<i:lij..:~N~ .~Slwc:c~t.l<i:oEE~~5iC>~ eu.~o.Ec~jj'j~O_~~'N' -~rl--:
:!~~~~~~~f~~g~[~~!~~~~8~j.~~~~!i~~~ci~~!~~~IJI~~~1
~ ~ ..!!._.5;J &.g>~ m~~ 2 aiE OC0.2 5i 5i 00 ~ll! ~e.>1 E"'-.c ~.5 E,5 ..5..,-..,-.;1O.c: ~ ~ ~n~ eN
m ~~~~~I~I~ij~~~~~~8c:1~~i~m~I~J~~~~12i!J~~J~loo~~~)
zooCU~O>al~Z~~~~~~Q.> OOalalOO~X~~~>~U.~xQ.UCQ.OOU.U.~al~C>C>Q.~~W
~~.......'"
: ~~~~~
.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Q. 8mooo
O~"""'~"""'''''''~'''''''MOO~~~M''''O'''~'''''''''O'''~''''''~~OO'''COCO'''~~OO
... ~~"'...~."~.....,,...o....~~ ....."~"'o."~"'.,,.,, CONCO~~N~"''''''''~'''''''''
o N....."."...~.,,~~...."'.,,~~ "'~MM""~;"'~g O~M~~~N"'o""O~""""
~ ;!; c? ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ <? ~ ~ ~ ~ <? <? ~~ '7 <? ~ ~ ~ <? <? ~ .., ~ ! ~ ~ ~ <? ~ ~ <? ~ ~ ~ ~ <? :J: M~
N~M..-Mm"-_"-N"-N_NNNm ~NMMNMN-~M~N8M~~_~NN~NN~
ooooomoooooooooom oooooooomooo oooomoooooo
@
@
@ l!J
@
@
@
:IE:IE
~
~~~~~M~a~~~~!!~~~~!~~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~e~~~~g~e~~~
~
<<;>>
19
~
II)
ca
C)
c
:i:
c
E
ca
~ II)
o >-
.... Q)
C)~
c ~
;: Q)
Q) c..
-0..
E~
o
u
;:
II)
II)
-
c
ca
~
c..
c..
<t
~MMMMMMMMMMMMMMM~~M!~_ MMMMMMMMMMMMMM
g~8iil8
~~O!~~08'~
0:: ~..... ~ N..... OJ
~~~~~~:5
U';U';U';U';;:Ij",,,,
ggggggg
~~~~lli~ii~~~I~I~~~III~lil!
.....~:5g~88g~:50~~~0~000~~~0~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~~
gggggggg8gggggggggggg~~~~~~
<{
~~ca~~
~ZCZzMN~N~m~~~~~~~~~~~~~
g
iiiN...,.........~~~~~
NO
~NN;;~M~~m~~~re~~.~~~~N~O.....~mW...........^_~~V
::0) v . .('1')('1)('1') .............................
. N ~ ~
ccgcc NN ~~ii
tillEllt ..~.~~~~~~~~~a~~~
j ~~~~~~~~~~IIIII~lrr~rltlllllll!!!J
0~~~~~~~~~""'~~~~0_~SS~SC~~CCCCCC~~~0
~~~~~~~~~~.~~NN~OC~~~~BBB~B~BBB~~~i
~ cccCcccCC~0000~~s>>>>cammwmwmmm Ceara
~~~~~~~~~~j~~~~~~~C8CC:S::S::S::S::S::S::S::S::S:~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~C~~mmmy.~~0~~6ggggs5gs~~s~
~,5~~~~~ .5~.5.5~~IIIIII'ggl~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :s::s: :s: :s: ,- ,- .- .- .- .- ,- ,- ,- - - C
~~~~~ :S::S::S::S::S::S::S::S::S:~~5B
~~~~
~
~~W
ffi~d3 ~~~:::~:!!
i3~CI)
lil<<>lil.....<<><<>N<<>O<<>O<<>.....O~ID~<<><<><<>~~~<<>..........<<><<>
..... .........................N-N__NN_~___________
~
~_ ~~~~,....~~~~mww-wm.....m~wQw~WWmWWWWQ~WWW
:E.g
'5 I-
al
'liS
t~
.2 ~
m
~I!:!N
:s:~.
J:> '
d:~U;>
gl!:!o
~~";'
.c=i
lU ~
:I::::!!
'aI E?-..... ,......-
:I:<.!l
J:> e- N
~<.!l'
~au;>
.g ,~~
:I: v ,
~C}I~
-------C}l------~----------~
o
~N
z'
:20
lU~
m
o
,
'I I" , , I ,
o
, , I , , , I ,
~O
B";'
I' I' I' I I
. , ,
I t I I I I I I' 1 I I 1 I I I' I
. ,
1 1 , 1 I I t 1 'I
.~O
o.~
5:1
, ,
I I I , I , 'I I' I I
., .
1:!0
~~
~.
, .
1 I I I I 'I I 1
..... ~ ~ .....
I~~~~ ~...............~o ..... ..........~............................................. ..........
'C":'~C":'
<:'
N
c;i
, I 1 I I 1
a ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.~ ~
lij~
0:
E
i=
'0
C
lU
B
~'6
C
,2
ri .,
=iii
2;0
<(
OMMVMNNN.....MNN~N22~.....MNMM.....NNN...............NNaMM
~9~~9~~~~~~~~~~~6~~~~~~~~~~~~9~~~9~~~~
Y lUlUlUlUo-y~~lU~.,~ 0 lUlUlUo.-lU~ ~., ~ lUlU
"'~ ~~~1M~~NN~~~M~~~N1~~~$~~0~~"'~~~~
o ..... .....M.....N ..........N....................O ..........N..... .....0..........0.......... ..........
C w
15 OJ ~6
U) &2:' t: m of! 1) 1::()o-
t:.,lij<>!l~ E ~ e> ~!3,'~~~~:2efl J~.~~o .
U) ~~P~~~_. EC~t:~~~~~c~m~-~mg~c 3
.,!II .c:'liS~OEc&w...,.,.,.~.... :2>;;:"""l.9:::!!Jc~c~mO::2.~
Q)EcU)Q) ~.. J: .-C::;C)tDct: 0 .._IIC_........ cu>>1.: Q)::::I"
~lU.g~>..5WO~...31!! .glU:::!!:I:1iiOCO.g ~~~l<.:;j ...B
....-.-. ..5J5 iIl....:.O> ."~Co.O....;::;;J:>i::~-g1!'iE<Ii"": <li1iie~~
i~!~~l~I~!~j~~3j~l~~j~~!j~~!~;~~~~~
N..........~~<<>:ll'"
::e~~M~;:l;",m
E~~~~~~~~
&8~~~~~C;~
"'~~~S~~~~~~~NC;~~~~~:e~~N~~~
lll"'o~~""'~~~~O~~.<<>"'<<>~N~"'~~~N<<>
~~~~M~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~M~~
OM~NNNOO~~~~~N~N~N~~O~~~NN
00000000000000000000000000
@@
@
@
::E@
...
.~ ~ S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~