Item R09
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Meeting Date: 4/20/05
Division:
County Attorney
Bulk Item: Yes -22L- No
Staff Contact Person: Bob Shillinger
AGENDA ITEM WORDING:
Authorization to issue release of Code Enforcement lien against Joseph C. and Ruth Sutton.
ITEM BACKGROUND:
In February 2003, the Special Master imposed a lien against property titled in the name of Joseph and
Ruth Sutton. Joseph Sutton died in 1999; Ruth Sutton died in 2001. Upon learning of the lien, the
surviving son quickly removed the abandoned vehicle and vessel. Unfortunately, due to his own battle
with lung cancer, the son is disabled and unable to pay any fine. In addition to 2.5 hours of staff time,
the County has incurred costs of $1 00.00 in collection efforts.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT DOCC ACTION:
BOCC approved collection efforts on June 18, 2003.
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: n/a
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Approval.
TOTAL COST:
0.00
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY:
0.00
SOURCE OF FUNDS:
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes
No xx
AMOUNTPERMONTH_ Year
APPROVED BY: County Atty _ OMBlPurchasing _ Risk Management_
DIVISION DIRECTOR APPROVAL:
John R. Collins, County Attorney
DOCUMENTATION:
Included xxx
Not Required_
DISPOsmON:
AGENDA ITEM ##
Revised 2/0S
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Meeting Date: 4/20/05
Division:
County Attorney
Bulk Item: Yes...JQl......... No
Staff Contact Person: Bob Shillinger
AGENDA ITEM WORDING:
Authorization to issue release of code enforcement lien against Joseph C. and Ruth Sutton.
ITEM BACKGROUND:
In February 2003, the Special Master imposed a lien against property titled in the name of Joseph and
Ruth Sutton. Joseph Sutton died in 1999; Ruth Sutton died in 200 1. Upon learning of the lien, the
surviving son quickly removed the abandoned vehicle and vessel. Unfortunately, due to his own battle
with lung cancer, the son is disabled and unable to pay any fine. In addition to 2.5 hours of staff time,
the County has incurred costs of $100.00 in collection efforts. A waiver of all fines and charges and the
issuance of a Release of Lien is requested.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT HOCC ACTION:
BOCC approved collection etTorts on JUDe 18, 1003.
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: nla
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Approval.
TOTAL COST:
0.00
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY:
0.00
SOURCE OF FUNDS:
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes
No xx
AMOUNTPERMONTH_ Year
APPROVED BY: County Atty~ OMB/Purchasing _ Risk Management _
DMSION DIRECTOR APPROVAL:
7-l{ . ('
John R Collins, County Attorney
DOCUMENTATION:
Included xxx
Not Required_
DISPOsmON:
AGENDA ITEM #
Revised 2/05
Gary johns
8860 NW 16th St
Pembroke Pines, FL 33024
RECEIVED
! '
_____ : ~ ~ ~~J#Lk~EA/-#-~---------L-J2L~
JUN 0 9 2004
.-.\WNROE-BGUNTY ATTORN
Ii ._f /(/p7t/L.,.2> .k.f/<'L_f~ /9/l12LOGZ.z5 h~ A1~_ .-------------
i :...z/V.ccdj/~Nr5A.1~ C!/Jd.f'fl.$f' my ?A'~.Nr.f' ~~ ----------
; l ANI) -/81//1'/ 7?/fir Y./E./<E .l"A~~ .#T~E-_____._
I!
li.l/~V~~ J'.n-~1.tL!--Z9'L.?fi 45'~~GEj~t$e . .
,i r .//55a/ZE'jI'/Yd -r#fi1r..A:? L7/l~>>rs AL/U/7".s'
,I ,
; i ~ES' p..G--C!7#0~ ~7 /9M2>. #Lb .L~_-----Zii#TJnZPI@/lf-- ----
Ii 7h'P', PVEAE.. 6f? KE,P./-LR'/ .Pfi'.P.#E/<7)1-4:L_m--
!I~k/'\' 6?Efi'k .r'6P~.tE'.$'.J'._ 7'/77 L-/Z€~.A'~T nn___
_____ i \ /JJ}o/f.cu; rh/.Ef~ ~,r77ZE./?.?A'~~ L:.,.J.~~/f',67Gt7"' -----
i! &g /l;>&lY7r/?~.s_22/4d~~#~AkAWfi// n
: ;..M#--ZAI~A/C'~_L?Z?d_ZA/gL/??~~Z2l-?:2't/-024V~PA't?/S9'-
II #.AilJ J'r..z:Lr.L r.Z;LJF...L- zo 7/Y f J' ~7 ~_~~LCA'J' L7~~._______
jjT//f PL/lt:!E: p'd A!__U/E5/<Ljl- 8/9J"J~-~~C!g.J'-~-..-._- ....-
I 1,4 ~ bE &A?f .J'/..__~E#t/~_..J;-_~L~. 4,/l/~ /1'?L'..kd.L~L. L-/lkkN-
I'
. __ l: ~.ALl)_S/2~..LAkk--LffE' J"~.ggt?~.%dCi---G~ 5'.b rC?L<
____ ____! :~~.j2.s~_~A/C5 _/l?y .J2/J2J_$f?/f J'.f'.z-No/j f #$/E ./f;J4f/.GJ:)
__~~_. i: AU bENkfg~L2///.L/.8HAL&~&).__?'A~F~f2?/Z //f$.:
,. #'
----- --. i: ""rE~!/L;?~,J~j/Er. /22Cb27Lw - u_______ -
.-+---~~~-.t?~f g~t5~_.ZA!~_.CA/<. :7#/lT a/AJ' uaE u
~~~~ ~~-
___ ___~H.sE~.J:P~-~-----Z---L!7Li.6&!m~d5Rd .
_u___._ __liLu~rALG-L~4.7""'..:?=".t?~f~# 41.4EAg__~/"C ~E -.
. , ~
. u_uu__.+-.,_.BP#Z- kJ!?~NC ,6?~A!kIZF 7;?I/i'rT#E ..Z?~M.c;; #A(2;_~
..8Ep/'J' /#E.6i'Cl/9;rfF frN~~A/s.--...z-.A/usG: #..I'J'a:?Al
b /l-:5f wA$ .4tU//?~ c7r.4 /2~?;SLE/V0 f~;7/U..40 r#.E
. ...?#gJ/..6lE-CI4~ 7z-. ~fr. kEfi//~.-4/t@ #E hr-rj,--7--j?/J7?7f .6~A7:
I j
Ii
! ;
, i
j!
I;
I;
I:
_ I: ___ -? 01"''7
11 ----------- -~--~--. --.------.~- --- - n_ __~__~.--2-~- _.__n______
__---++~rt?gr-<<A.Igzz---?-~ -;1 - Llk'E - LC Lh"~ fAfJ'-'d'Li&/V/~n- -
l! /
-~-4/l ~0'<<f~A/7X~-e?2g--L~L?~L1/~~~~--...1ZL7A!~-m---....--~-.
__.____n_-* 1 _" J:. :;eAr~Q~~~ ..?~~'~d'r~~~m----~- _n..
I j 11//1/ 27/# ~--L?~~~~-..-_z;;F~L?hd~~~Nic- _
.._~_ ___ I /?~4~~-----T#/lL;7h/~-?:!~$-~L~~EP--b4/~ fl~_._______ T
L!.uk!A'E~ rF fr pV'EA~A/j- AErpo/ ...6).R;TV.E!//
11 PN77/EA~_~_.___________._m__ ____._____~___n__
--~l ..
______+7H~~~.&cKPdt?~- _:AJA<2.8~&- ~EA./f ~/?:.s ~-- _H_
_ ___~k.il t!JL LffF" .5'1"/k.&r.B?d,.%",g//JoLAL.# k7~ ~A/L__.
____ i ;d/lI/~~$;$.fJ~~#12LdL/~ZZ;_:.J'ELE~~~----.-
____ __~_#L c?4~ oA r~.BcAL-__ ..----------.-----~---- -------~
I:
Ii rp/~~iy-I fd 4/1/ 5r~-oL<L_L22~.?/? /J'1e W~# /?17~
_____-4e~d.;;-d.f~~/Ut) _PLL!fEN~- Z/AJot/~ZJe'/W&~__ - -
___ m_____._._~.%~T...iJ.&;.c~~~B----&aU.EPE-~~L!2?Y~ .~~~
i I
i,
... .___ __lJL/~t?.&'72<-1!..&-rEk-tL/ ./#G:C8'/f_?/JAS A..2JfE-E.Gf~~ /1'J>9f~/(.
I: /.
_________Hg~~-~~-k~,?:7Z~ ._YdA.U'k.. d/'tD ..dt2r//~dr;/7;/FMZ!~,f
_ _ _______~~FA?l.U€~--E..P'&,-LLf'~-M~;}- ~L.~_q-u;z::7Ed-/?/?,E:p~C'If/'!1E/V':
___.j~~~~::::-d-~~~/lif~~~~ ~-:A~~_ .
r; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ./9 -l-7'A'!.. f"S/l!. 7_.
. ,_~--- I ~-f &t7C?~~_~~&22L-#/l..J' ,g1fi"ELf.L2__&Et::~1dCi--CS.z-Al<€. ...
n__~__._m .1 z:: b</.--Ll:d~/lr;gO~__~.k~tY- ~A,/t./~fdL2~~L..//E~
j:
~---1. ?7/~SLlA' GELj/ _ZLz_AE /!l~f~ /1T-/-.u--&~r.. ;Z;L!c7/f'/7/f/?c:-r?;j)
.Hi+AN~ .#E'.k'n ,?;!{/4c?"..e;,A/ ,/141 _c#E S/:7;&'/I / c:d/l.;' ..7A/~~EIf#~
i1 M/I/...-j ~//E.A./ ..z AE4~c;r-y.5~ /?/l?Jf/?~A/ z;k'EA17.A?'EA/7J' A~
11 ~#~ft1PT#.r.r"-?..-9..-o~, ..?/l.7CA.f.:A/>>',p JU7?~/!/a<<An ~dz7#,L6fA:&./f/!,
____.__+_ .__.__ ___._._____ __ __ __ .. .__._______ ._. ._._._____.______...._ _...._.______._...__. .;f1. !?L1__ _ .
m___~__u_h_-_ .jj~"":l1!@-dp./ Ct?m/'kA/A/rd9'/1La--aA/7T-~rd..r;
_____~~_Z72.j!f~;FN 7-~Z2</171aLL. d/?~ .._~~_R~C!.8/E.M_._____
--+--~_~~~ ,t7.A!..rO/< r~~/l4j! .-Z;.L,.LA/..€~.,s ES'/~&!Ll v /".4 HA-t/E
n._____-+~A/E /0 ~ ~.6!LLt7_~AA/2J /?ESc.bi.L.~ fT /Cfd#LLL _
_______~~ ~LLlm~/C//?Z2a:-T7~.#.&/df'AL:c.d4f.:~...d.d4:zp----..
. __ ! i /J7#A:Z:.1"/: 2Jt':?WN 7#?.;(?E /b~ /?;7/1~ ?EA~ s. $r at/1t
_~_.____L.-LlZ(7d~~7J/P-.;?~.G~$I/€.zS Z2/~~o/?? /J1p JrrS,tJ~_
.____ ! i LW'g;f. 5/J?# /27oAJT#~~_~~_______.___n____________ - ----.-.-
: -
_ --t.------- L ---.8m-.VE~ J2~S'E~ a.,/J'T;7' ~J'/ /IS you
__ ______ __l-/Z'2%#~f.L?/~.%df ~~.6'..t4:.. d~?L ~E; ~________.__n_
-. ..-- ., --- ,-+----
. .
--- - -----. ~ ------.- ....- ----
~----=----=--=-~=_..~=-~;;f;;~-=~~--=
. . ----~.-r:_.---.
.'.-- -----t-+- ..-- ----.--------..~,~_.------.----.---.- -----~..-.-..._.-_._. -------.. --.-..
_ _ __~ fN.C!/--cJ5AO---L?-~_ ~t?",/?,.f5".> tP//l?? /A~d~H_____ --
~~__ 4F""-<7~f e4T~S- AL1L);)- d /VoTE ~t24<- LVjI_ Ahez214 L2/~
~. ycu /fE tflU&'::7;r-e,]:).
--------..-- _m_--.---r-t" ".--
, ,
-- --..-.." --..-.....;....-
,
_.__....-+-_ __._ . '_n_.____..___ __ ._"._ _____ _________ __ _ ~
.----t
- .._~---*-_..
,
_u~_
1 ~
; I
-.- ~..
I
I
t 200
11
l~
!
1I~
! .
1 DoII'E llf'.l>.EAfH- 0.,. -I
Octohr '23. 1999 379-18:"3195 .
l DATE OF "'TH~. 0.,. _I .. BlRTHPlACE,or,_ _ '" ~ ~l
August 28. 1922 Toronto, Canada
... PLACE OF ~HjClIodI""""o: _ __....__,
HOSPItAl2,~~ . E__ OOA OTHER
Ie, fAClt.ln NAYI(Ii_~. ........,.,..,Md~t
Aventura Hospita.l and edicsl Center
tOo PEQEDENT' uSUALoec:uPAtIOl<
"'--'-..
eo
--
10 QrVIIGNCI QIF
""""""""
..........,.IT
r...~
""' ..,...0
11.
1k RE:&I:DINCE
", ::,.
Florida
13e. ItlSlDE CITY '
LIMItS? l'1IIu:orlfli'
Yes
33162
11. FATHEilrS HAt.lEII~. iIIIdcIIl w"J
. . John . Sutton
,...~n_l~
Ruth Sutton
An.~ _OIM1"~~
iG_ ClT'( fOI;.iN. OF\ t.OCArK:)fri OF DC:ATti >
Aventura
U. MARITAl STATUS -M.&rriecl.
,...,.., Ir.Wr". Wdarw.d.
~rst>odrJ
!!arried
.. .....DECEPENT EVER" U.S
_~~ST""''''''''J
II>. _ CITY I.AIITSt,.... "'''''J..
Yes
to COUNTY OF DU.l'H
Miami-Dade
Rogers
l2 SUFIVMtlIG SPOUU (It...... .p..1Nia1M IIMNJ
Ruth
44's'NE L65th
MiaJd. Plorlda
33162
2lC. NAME AND ADttRESS OF FAOurv
Lithgow-Bennett-Philbrick Funeral Home
15011 WestD1xle Hlgbwgy
North Mismi. Florida, Plorida 33181
II: 2)aco.,l:tII'~oI~IOftAddlot'II'MltfI~."'tnJ~"~M
eJ.. ..........!lMO...._"!d-....._--..-
I;;; 1S-...._TlIlof ·
~ 23). DA.l'E ~G""'ED (w-. o.r. 'ftt
~~ '
!j3 2'3d_-MEDICALe)(~I;N:ER"S CASE!'
,llW
"
I no ~OF DEATH
M
24. NAMe ~ ADDRESS Of CERT.FiEA (PHYSU~4N. WEtwC\L Eu......NEAI. fP gr Pnnt.
JerOllle 909 N. MisllIi Besch Blvd North HisllIi Beach Flodda 33162
7~~~1)~k IkDmrs199g:
doI-a1h l:)o""" ar1lOr the mode Dt cfVing: .uth u Card..- Ot '-.,....... Ifflt.lt. ..hQ(;k, Ot' ........ ApptoII.... .,...,..... '\
I _0....0_
I llooIh
: 'l-w,aNt(J
: f rrvo iJf1...
^~~ M
~tvNk.f
a CASE REPORfEO
TOMEOI<:AL
eXAMINER?
l"Hffo""J
.....11
PART 11_ 01* :uQn1hc:anl condIIlIOt'Il CON:nbuI'ng 10 dealh bul
Uftderll'lno C.I-liM OM'" It'!- ~n I
".
2'9 r.F FEMAlE. WAS THERE A
PREGNANCY IN THE PAST
3MONTH$' _VES _ NO
31, PA08A&l..E MANNER OF
DEATH _,
~~~
32f
01,1 Jt2~ ""
tt.plac:.. Has
<0<.. $131
~.._.....~._u"" .
32__ OArE OF IHJuA't
r_ 0.. _J
32b. 11....e Of S2l:: INJUAv AT 'NOAK'
_NJUR"t ['Mt 01 Nol
3DO DATE OF SURGf:.... (Wo. 0.,., -J
..
a.z., pLAC( Of INJURY /It~. "',m.
,,_. ,_. OIC. (Sp<<Jr1
THIS IS A CERTIFIED TRUE AND CORRECT COpy OF THE OFFICIAL RECORD ON FILE IN THIS OFF}CE
BY
~~~~
OCT 28 1999
Slate Registrar
~ / '
W~ ARN I NG THIS OQCUME;NT IS PRINTEQ9f\ PHOTOCOPIEP ON SE;CURlTY PAPER WITH A WATE;BMARK OF TI1I',GRI'AT
~~ S~ 9F TI-lES!AT.E OF F~ORICA. 00 ~OT, A~tPT WITHOUT VERIFYING THE PRESENCE OF THE WATER';Y'RI(. ~_
'~n.'''o ~i n.~.'A. 8'~. "~ THECP. CUMI''''.T FAC. E C'oNT.4l.N~ A~ut..1'1.ciORl'.. 0 BA. '..CK.G. R~UNO. ~O. GCJt.[} E~~OSSED'S~ TH~BAd<
. ~~~v.:~'It .~. ,. ~T~INSSP~C~fINEf'YI~TEXTr3~t:SI,NT~RM~CHROMlcrNJ( '~r ,.
/0,,; .}.. ?.".. '-.."''''.'' ..,.' f i I '-:.~, ~"~""."-';~ .:'~ ': ',' .......:' ~::, '- ,"\,,,-.~~.,, _,:.{
6. W~S DECEDENT EVER IN U.S.
ARMEO FORCES? 1* ",No)
1\U"Hot
- Allapattah
Plrt It
IMI.tEOl~lE CAUSE (FlnaI.
;~UI or r;:onlfton
......""..doIo..l ~
Soq""""."Y Oat ......'1011.. { .
MI *"Y. IN.dirtg 10 immedlaw. b.
c:.a.... EntIN UNOERlYING
CAUSE (OlHBN 01' Injury
'Ihalln6tllllld .....-ntt
,...Itlng"<loo"jl.l.ST
d.
PART ll. Olhllr .IDI"Iifld.l'tt condtIIoru- COIUribut!ng to de&!h b4JI naI muIIInQ ... 1M
~c&yp~lnPaI'lL
.. c.oc.vte. ..-'^-()~ V'\~
OUE TO lOA ~S ~ CONSEQUE!'lCE 01'1:
Due. TO (OR .'.S ,., CONS€QUENCE OF)"
OUE TO {OR ..s A CONSEQuENCE OFI:
321.
:19. If FEw.Lf. W>.S !Iif.RE A
f'IIEGIWIC't'lNlI<EPOST
:3 WC)NTHS1 ~ No
31. PAOBABlE MANNE'WF 328. O~TE Of' iNJURY
OeATH (~ 1_'" ""~ \N~
N_. -......-.
fIomIddI.OI' undtlIIn\'lln8d.
27,.. wAS AN AlJTOf"SY
PERFOAt.ieO?
(*",NOI
32b. n~E OF ::J,2e. IMJlJRY AT WORK?
INJUflV 1*"'Il1o)
...
321. LOC...TIQN C~ and Numb<< or Runll R:oruM ~(, City or Town. SUhil)
321.
32.-. iPlACE OF INJURV AI t.otM. larm,
_< ..-y. 010. {SpI<oII')ol
\-
DH 512, 9IM
_HAS
Form &121
TI'IIS IS A CERTIFIED TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE OFFICIAL RECORD ON FILE IN THIS OFFICE
..J
L..,
"BY
9I/~f)~fl1j
Jll N 07200t
State Registrar" ~
, ::
'1/
/ i.':A'RNhl N'''''';. iHIS DOCUMENT IS PRJNTEO~ PHOTOCOF>lED ON SECURITY ;APER WITHeA WATE.a~~ Ol"M GREAT
,'V~, " :, ~ EAL,9F}~ES{A'l't01'''9RlOA;:OO.NO\ACCEF>TW1TI-\OUT\fER1FYINGTHE'PREiSEN(:&Op~W,\Te~AA'S.
.~.' ~ ~41~6'9 THE qocuM~T F~CE- c~iiINe-A ~~ TI-ecl.ORED BA-cKISR~UNo ~ GOtQ. E~~SS~~ ~'tHi ~ H llI!P 01'
i~,?"U D.O~, 1''fT~INSSF>$~LINE~''1IlTrTEXT~SEAlSINT>fERMpCHROMICjNK' ~-~< <; ;;:: EALT
. .~;, '- ' '>_>..:.<) :; ,( c \ . \D9~fiojM ~11~Il!~r -\.
PULMONARY GROUP OF SOUTH FLORIDA
Internal Medicine, Pulmonary Disease, Critical Care and Sleep Disorders
R. Lata-nae Parker MD FACP, MarkJ. Hauser MD FACP, Jeremy I. Tabak MD FCCP,
Louis T. Gidel MD PhD FCCP, Javier Perez-Fernandez MD, FCCP and George D. Yatzkan MD
7000 S.W. 62nd Avenue. Suite 201, South Miami. FL 33143
Office: 305-661-9404 Fax: 305-661-1510 Internet: www.lungdoctors.com
March 1, 2004
RE: Johns, [ra
Dear Sir/Madam:
This patient is being followed in our office for cancer of the lung and chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease. As a result of these conditions he is limited in his ability to travel. Also he is on multiple
medications including pain medications which limit his ability to drive a motor vehicle.
Sincerely yours.
.:12 .h j;:.",. /'-~"~-/'/
R. Latanae Parker M.D., F .A.C.P.
Electronically signed
Record locator:
C\M EDICAL RECORDS\Johns. Ira 07-16-1945\CORRES PONDENCE\03-O 1.2004 140B.doc
Click 'n Cluck Dictate .to. Copyrighl @ 2003 by Click 'n Cluck Medical Dictation toe
Johns. Ira
March 1. 2004 Page 1 of I