Item P4 P.4
Coty f � ,�� ,' BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
�� Mayor David Rice,District 4
The Florida Keys � Mayor Pro Tem Craig Cates,District I
y Michelle Coldiron,District 2
James K.Scholl,District 3
Ij Holly Merrill Raschein,District 5
County Commission Meeting
September 21, 2022
Agenda Item Number: P.4
Agenda Item Summary #11016
BULK ITEM: Yes DEPARTMENT: County Attorney's Office
TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Peter Morris (305) 289-2584
No
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Authorization to Initiate Litigation Against Mark Tucker,
Affiliated Natural or Legal Persons, and Other Responsible Parties, Regarding an Unauthorized
Floating Structure Located on Boca Chica Basin, and Any Other Property Owned by Such Person(s),
If Necessary, to Seek Compliance with the Monroe County Code(s).
ITEM BACKGROUND: Professional staff of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission ("FWC") have notified Monroe County Marine Resources Office professional staff
("Monroe County") of, and Monroe County has observed, an unauthorized floating structure situated
on sovereign submerged lands (approximate water depth 3-feet)underlying Boca Chica Basin.
The Monroe County Code ("MCC")prohibits floating structures such as this in county waters.
Under MCC Section 26-219, the County may LU initiate an administrative enforcement proceeding
with the Code Compliance Special Magistrate and/or(2.) file a civil enforcement action seeking
injunctive relief(e.g., dismantlement and removal of the offending structure) and damages in Circuit
Court to ensure compliance with MCC Article VIII. MCC Section 26-219 further authorizes the
State Attorney's Office to commence a parallel criminal action against the property owner(s)to
enforce against such County ordinance violations.
County professional staff recommends initiating civil litigation (Option 2.) against the above-
referenced property owner(s) for injunctive relief and damages (including but not limited to cost(s)
of prosecution).
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION:
July 18, 2018 —Approval of Ordinance No. 015-2018 prohibiting unauthorized floating structures.
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval, Option 2.
Packet Pg. 3306
P.4
DOCUMENTATION:
Ordinance 015-2018
Boca Chica Floating Structure
FWC Marine Debris Report Form -- Blue Cottage - Tucker
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
Effective Date:
Expiration Date:
Total Dollar Value of Contract: Approximately $421.50 in filing fees,plus cost(s) of
prosecution in an amount determinable at the conclusion of litigation.
Total Cost to County:
Current Year Portion:
Budgeted: Yes
Source of Funds:
CPI:
Indirect Costs:
Estimated Ongoing Costs Not Included in above dollar amounts:
Revenue Producing: If yes, amount:
Grant:
County Match:
Insurance Required:
Additional Details:
REVIEWED BY:
Bob Shillinger Completed 08/23/2022 2:18 PM
Peter Morris Completed 08/23/2022 2:30 PM
Purchasing Completed 08/23/2022 2:37 PM
Budget and Finance Completed 08/23/2022 4:01 PM
Brian Bradley Completed 08/24/2022 9:59 AM
Lindsey Ballard Completed 08/31/2022 11:29 AM
Board of County Commissioners Pending 09/21/2022 9:00 AM
Packet Pg. 3307
P.4.a
1 ORDINANCE NO. 015 -2018
2
3 AN ORDINANCE OF THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY
4 COMMISSIONERS AMENDING CHAPTER 26 ("WATERWAYS") OF THE
5 MONROE COUNTY CODE OF ORDINANCES TO CREATE ARTICLE VIII.
6 ("FLOATING STRUCTURES"); PROVIDING FOR PROHIBITION OF
7 FLOATING STRUCTURES; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING
8 FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS INCONSISTENT
9 HEREWITH; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORATION INTO THE CODE OF
10 ORDINANCES; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE SECRETARY OF
11 STATE; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
12
13 WHEREAS,the Board of County Commissioners is the legislative body of Monroe
14 County,Florida; and
15
16 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(46), Florida Statutes, defines"Vessel"as"synonymous
17 with boat as referenced in Section L(b),Article VII of the State Constitution and includes every
18 description of watercraft,barge, and airboat, other than a seaplane on the water, used or capable
19 of being used as a means of transportation on water."; and
20
21 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(22)(a)-(c),Florida Statutes, defines"Live-aboard vessel"as
22 "A vessel used solely as a residence and not for navigation,"a"vessel for which a declaration of
23 domicile has been filed pursuant to Section 222.17,Florida Statutes,"or"a vessel used as a
24 residence that does not have an effective means of propulsion for safe propulsion."; and
25
26 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(17),Florida Statutes,defines"Houseboat"as"a vessel that
27 is used primarily as a residence for at least 21 days during any 30-day period in a county of this
28 state if such residential use of the vessel is to the preclusion of its use as a means of
29 transportation."; and ®a
30
31 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(14), Florida Statutes, defines"Floating structure"as"a
32 floating entity,with or without accommodations built thereon,which is not primarily used as a
33 means of transportation on water but which serves purposes or provides services typically o
0
34 associated with a structure or other improvement to real property. The term includes, but is not >
35 limited to, an entity used as a residence,place of business or office with public access; a hotel or
36 motel; a restaurant or lounge; a clubhouse; a meeting facility; a storage or parking facility; or a
37 mining platform, dredge, dragline, or similar facility or entity represented as such."; and 00
38
39 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(14),Florida Statutes,provides that"Floating structures are N
LO
40 expressly excluded from the definition of the term"vessel""defined at Section 327.02(46),
41 Florida Statutes; and
42
43 WHEREAS, Section 327.02(14),Florida Statutes, furthermore provides that"Incidental _
44 movement upon water or resting partially or entirely on the bottom does not, in and of itself,
45 preclude an entity from classification as a floating structure."; and ..
46
47 WHEREAS,under the federal Rules of Construction Act, 1 U.S.C. Section 3, "[t]he
48 word"vessel"includes every description of watercraft or other artificial contrivance used, or
49 capable of being used,as a means of transportation on water.";and
1 of 11
Packet Pg. 3308
P.4.a
50 WHEREAS,the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners(hereinafter the
51 `Board")finds and recognizes that the Supreme Court of the United States(hereinafter the
52 "Court"),pursuant Lozman v. City of Riviera Beach, 568 U.S. 115 (U.S.2013),holds that an
53 article(hereinafter"entity") situated upon the water does not constitute a"vessel"within the
54 meaning of said Act if"a[n objective] reasonable observer, looking to"its"physical
55 characteristics and activities,would not consider it to be designed to any practical degree for
56 carrying people or things on water."; and
57
58 WHEREAS,the Court,by adopting the foregoing objective purposive test in that certain
59 Lozman decision, eliminated consideration of the owner's subjective intent in vessel status
60 determinations; and
61
62 WHEREAS,the Board finds and recognizes that while the Court, in that certain Lozman
63 decision,held that"lack of self-propulsion is not dispositive"of whether an entity constitutes a
64 "vessel"within the meaning of said Act,the Court nonetheless held that"lack of self-propulsion"
65 may be a relevant physical characteristic to consider in deciding whether an entity constitutes a
66 "vessel"; and
67
68 WHEREAS,the Board finds and recognizes that the Court, in that certain Lozman
69 decision,held that the Petitioner's floating home did not constitute a"vessel"within the meaning
70 of said Act in view of that(11)it was incapable of self-propulsion,(Q it had no rudder or other
71 steering mechanism,(D it had an unraked hull,(4)it had a rectangular bottom,(it had a draft
72 of only 10 inches below water,f its infrequency of past movement(based upon the fact that,
73 prior to its in rem arrest, it had traveled by tow over water only on four occasions over a 7-year
74 period),Q it could not be moved without dangerously swinging side-to-side(based upon the fact
75 that when it had been towed, it had required a second boat to follow it from behind to prevent it
76 from swinging dangerously side-to-side),U it had no special capacity to generate or store
77 electricity, (9)its similarity to land-based residences(based upon the fact that its rooms looked
78 like ordinary non-maritime living quarters), 10 it had ordinary windows and unsealed French
79 doors rather than watertight portholes, and 11 it had no other feature that might suggest a design
80 to transport over water anything other than its own furnishings and related personal effects; and
81
82 WHEREAS,the Board has identified that it has become an increasingly common
83 practice to moor, anchor, or otherwise affix floating structures over or otherwise upon waters o
0
84 included within the territorial jurisdiction of the State of Florida and County waters, including
85 anchoring,mooring, or otherwise affixing floating structures to unpermitted, unauthorized, or
86 otherwise unlawful objects lying at or near the bottom of said waters including but not limited to
87 upon sovereign submerged lands,Q anchoring,mooring,tying off, or otherwise affixing floating
00
88 structures to State of Florida and/or County-owned uplands and over or otherwise upon such
89 waters and/or sovereign submerged lands, and Q anchoring,mooring,tying off,or otherwise N
LO
90 affixing floating structures to plant species protected by federal, state, and/or local law(s),rule(s),
91 or regulations)pursuant to an endangered,threatened, or species of special concern designation
92 or listing and/or plant species(including, but not limited to,mangroves)whose defoliation or
93 destruction is subject to special protections under the Monroe County Comprehensive Plan and
94 Code(s)and special permitting requirements pursuant to the Florida Mangrove Trimming and
95 Preservation Act; and ..
96
97 WHEREAS,the waters surrounding the Florida Keys of Monroe County, Florida,are
98 situated within the boundaries of the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary and have, since
99 July 26,2001,been designated a federal No Discharge Zone(NDZ)by the United States
2of11
Packet Pg. 3309
P.4.a
100 Environmental Protection Agency pursuant to Title 40, Chapter I, Subchapter D, Part 140,
101 Section 140.4(b)(1)(ii),as may be amended from time to time; and
102
103 WHEREAS,the Board finds that floating structures in the county commonly(1)contain
104 greywater and/or blackwater discharge facilities such as washrooms, showers,toilets, latrines, LO
105 and/or outhouses,(2)do not contain a bilge pump(s),(D do not contain a marine sanitation
106 device(s),(4)hold unsecured or poorly contained stored fuel(s)and other potentially dangerous
107 and/or hazardous products and materials such as propane tanks and furniture,(5)contain living
108 quarters and/or recreational areas,(6)are utilized for the purpose of storage and/or habitation,(7)
109 do not have navigational lights,(8)do not feature identifying information which a local, state, or
110 federal government or enforcement agency may utilize to ascertain their owner(s)in a reasonably o
111 timely manner,(9)are rafted up to larger"primary"vessels or to larger"primary"floating
112 structures,(1O)do not securely hold on anchor,(11)are not built to any manufacturing
113 standard(s) and/or building code(s),(12�are unauthorizedly or unlawfully anchored or moored
114 upon sovereign submerged lands, 13 are commonly abandoned,(U4 lack means of propulsion
115 necessary to quickly relocate in advance of or during extreme weather events or other emergency
116 events, and(15)cost Monroe County significantly more than vessels to remove and dispose of,
117 and
118
119 WHEREAS, neither the United States nor the State of Florida have pre-empted the
120 several states or local governments from legislating in the field of floating structure regulation;
121 and
122
123 WHEREAS, Section 327.60(3), Florida Statutes,provides, in pertinent part,that Chapter
124 327, Florida Statutes, "does not prohibit local governmental authorities from the enactment or
125 enforcement of regulations that prohibit or restrict the mooring or anchoring of floating
126 structures[.]'; and
127
128 WHEREAS,Article VIII, Section L(f), of the Florida Constitution,vests the Board with
129 the authority to legislate countywide, except within a municipality that has adopted an ordinance
130 which conflicts with a County ordinance; and
131 _
132 WHEREAS,Monroe County Ordinance 14-2010 - Section 12-141, codified at Section
133 12-141 of Chapter 12 of the Monroe County Code of Ordinances(entitled"Environmental and
134 Natural Resource Protection"), defines"County waters"as"[A]ny Monroe County waters, >
135 whether contained within boundaries naturally artificially, or diffused, including,but not limited o
CL
136 to the Gulf, bays, canals, estuaries, and wetlands. County waters include those waters which are CL
137 part of the State as being specified within Monroe County pursuant to Section 7.44,Florida <
00
138 Statutes, and Article Il, Section 1, Constitution of the State of Florida(Rev. 1968),waters out to
139 three marine leagues, or waters in the immediate vicinity of county reefs.";see also Section 7.44, N
LO
140 Florida Statutes("So much of the State of Florida as is situated south of the County of Collier and
141 west or south of the County of Miami-Dade, constitutes the County of Monroe.");see also
142 Bateman v. State,238 So. 621, 626-27(Fla. 1970)(Ervin, C.J., dissenting)("Monroe County's
143 boundary is described in Section 7.44,Florida Statutes, as follows: "So much of the State of
144 Florida as is situated south of the county of Collier and west or south of the county of Dade,
145 constitutes the county of Monroe."It follows, of course, from this description that all submerged ..
146 lands or navigable waters in the southernmost portion of the state of Florida that do not lie in
147 Collier and Dade counties are a part of Monroe County."),rev'd on other grounds;see also
148 Lipscomb v. Gialourakis, 133 So. 104, 107(Fla. 1931)("[I]t must be construed that counties
149 bordering on the Gulf of Mexico include that area within the Gulf adjacent to the upland and
150 adjacent to the state boundary line."); and
3 of 11
Packet Pg. 3310
P.4.a
151 WHEREAS,Article II, Section L(a)of the Florida Constitution provides that the state's
152 (and therefore Monroe County's)territorial boundaries on the east side extend"to the edge of the
153 Gulf Stream or a distance of three geographic miles[,] whichever is the greater distance[.]"To
154 that end, on any given day,the Gulf Stream is in a different location.See Benson v. Norwegian
155 Cruise Line, Ltd., 859 So.2d 1213, 1215-16 (Fla. 3rd DCA 2003); and
156
157 WHEREAS, public and navigable waterways are public highways.See State ex rel.
158 Wilcox v. T.O.L., Inc.,206 So. 2d 69, 71 (Fla. 4th DCA 1968); and
159
160 WHEREAS,a county has the right to close public roads and highways where necessity
161 dictates on a temporary or a permanent basis, and the general authority of the boards of county
162 commissioners over the location of public roads in their respective counties has been held to be
163 plenary.Id., cf at 72; and
164
165 WHEREAS,the power of local governments to regulate and restrict certain activities
166 reasonably calculated to protect the public health, safety, and welfare, is subject to the State of
167 Florida's paramount power to regulate and control the use of its sovereign submerged lands; and
168
169 WHEREAS,where private ownership of submerged bottoms outward from the shore has
170 originated upon a valid conveyance out of the State of Florida, state law establishes that
171 submerged land included in such grants are subject to taxes lawfully imposed.See Section
172 253.141(4),Florida Statutes; and
173
174 WHEREAS, Section 192.001(17), Florida Statutes,provides, in pertinent part,that"A
175 floating structure is expressly included as a type of tangible personal property."; and
176
177 WHEREAS, "littoral or riparian rights are appurtenances to ownership of littoral or
178 riparian uplands. They are not founded on ownership of submerged lands."See Hayes v.
179 Bowman,91 So.2d 795, 802 (Fla. 1957); and
180
181 WHEREAS, littoral and riparian rights are those incident to uplands bordering upon
182 navigable waters, such rights are appurtenant to and inseparable from the littoral or riparian
183 upland, and inure to the owner of the littoral or riparian land,but are neither owned by the upland
184 landowner nor are of a proprietary nature.See Section 253.141(1), Florida Statutes; and o
0
185 >
186 WHEREAS, littoral and riparian landowners"have no rights in navigable waters and
CL
187 state sovereign submerged lands that are superior to other members of the public with regard to CL
188 rights of bathing, fishing, and navigation."See Walton County v. Stop the Beach Renourishment,
00
189 Inc., 998 So. 2d 1102, 1111 (Fla.2008),affd, 560 U.S. 702 (U.S. 2010); and
190 N
LO
191 WHEREAS, "[a]private action cannot be maintained by one who has no interest in [a]
192 waterway beyond that enjoyed by the public in common to use it as a highway."See Bertram v.
193 State Road Dept., 118 So.2d 674, 675 (Fla. 3rd DCA 1960);and
194
195 WHEREAS,while littoral and"riparian rights exist in Florida as a matter of
196 constitutional right and property law, it is the clearly established law of Florida that even ..
197 constitutional rights may be regulated."See Central Florida Investments, Inc. v. Orange County
198 Code Enforcement Board, 790 So. 2d 593, 597(Fla. 5th DCA 2001); and
199
200 WHEREAS, under Florida law,there is no recognized common law,constitutional, or
201 statutory littoral or riparian right to anchor,moor, or otherwise indefinitely or permanently affix
4of11
Packet Pg. 3311
P.4.a
202 or situate a floating structure upon or over waters included within the territorial jurisdiction of the
203 State of Florida, or upon or over County waters, including but not limited to upon sovereign
204 submerged lands; and
205
206 WHEREAS,the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners finds that this LO
207 Ordinance is necessary to advance the County's valid public, navigational, and environmental
208 health, safety, and welfare police power interests;
209
210 NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF
211 COUNTY COMMISSIONERS:
212
213 SECTION 1.-Recitals and Legislative Intent.The foregoing recitals and statements of
214 legislative intent are true and correct and are hereby incorporated as if fully stated herein.
215
216 SECTION 2.-Title.This Ordinance shall be titled the"Monroe County Floating Structure
217 Prohibition Ordinance."
218
219 SECTION 3.-Creation.That Chapter 26 of the Monroe County Code of Ordinances, entitled
220 "Waterways,"is hereby amended to create Article VI1I.,entitled"Floating Structures,"as
221 follows:
222 i
223 ARTICLE VIII.-FLOATING STRUCTURES
224
225 Section 26-214.Jurisdiction; Administration.
226
227 (a) Monroe County.This Article shall apply to waters included within County waters and
228 submerged lands underlying County waters.Monroe County and any authorized
229 federal or state enforcement agency may enforce violations of this Article.
230
231 (b) Municipalities Within Monroe County.This Article does not apply to waters within
232 the territorial jurisdiction of any municipality within the county unless and until such
233 municipality adopts this ordinance.Upon such adoption,this Article applies to waters _
234 included within the territorial jurisdiction of the adopting municipality and
235 submerged lands underlying such waters; upon such adoption, any authorized federal o
0
236 or state enforcement agency may enforce violations of this Article within the >
237 territorial jurisdiction of the adopting municipality.
CL
238 CL
239 Section 26-215.Definitions.The phrases,terms, and words used in this Article shall be,
00
240 except as specifically defined otherwise herein,the same as they have been defined in the Monroe
241 County Code of Ordinances and in the Monroe County Land Development Code. The following N
LO
242 terms shall have the following specific definitions as used herein:
243
244 Anchor. Shall mean use of traditional ground tackle,typically including an anchor,
245 anchor chain, and line, appurtenant to a floating structure,and used to hold a floating structure in
246 place.
247
248 Barge. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Section 327.02,Florida Statutes.
249
250 Floating Structure. Shall mean a floating entity,with or without accommodations built
251 thereon,which is not primarily used as a means of transportation on water but which serves
252 purposes or provides services typically associated with a structure or other improvement to real
5of11
Packet Pg. 3312
P.4.a
253 property. The term includes,but is not limited to, an entity used as a residence,place of business
254 or office with public access; a hotel or motel; a restaurant or lounge; a clubhouse; a meeting
255 facility; a storage or parking facility; or a mining platform,dredge, dragline, or similar facility or
256 entity represented as such. Floating structures are expressly excluded from the definition of the
257 term"vessel"provided in this section. Incidental movement upon water or resting partially or
258 entirely on the bottom does not, in and of itself, preclude an entity from classification as a
259 floating structure. In the event it is disputed whether an entity constitutes a floating structure
260 versus a vessel, such dispute shall be exclusively determined, under a preponderance of the o
261 evidence standard,by analyzing(1)whether it is capable of self-propulsion, (2)whether it has a
262 rudder or other steering mechanism,(D whether it has a raked hull,U whether it has a
263 rectangular or a square bottom,(5j by comparing its draft to the drafts of vessels of a similar 0
264 physical size,(6) its infrequency of documented past geographical movement,Q whether it can
265 be moved over meaningful distances without dangerously or hazardously swinging from side-to-
266 side,(B)if it has a(lawful)capacity to generate or store electricity, (9)whether it has a bilge
267 pump(s),(UO whether it has an approved marine sanitation device(s),(LIJ whether its above-
268 water surface area(s)bear similarity to the interior or exterior of a land-based residential or
269 commercial structure,(U2 whether it has ordinary windows, open doorways, or unsealed doors,
270 0 3)whether it has any other physical features that might suggest to an objective reasonable
271 observer a design to transport over water anything other than its own furnishings and related
272 personal effects, and CL4)whether it is titled and registered as a vessel.Payment of a tangible
273 personal property tax regarding the entity in question or issuance or receipt of a tax exemption
274 thereto,pursuant to Section 192.001(17),Florida Statutes, shall constitute prima facie evidence
275 that the entity in question constitutes a floating structure under this Article.
276
277 Houseboat. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Section 327.02, Florida Statutes.
278
279 Live Aboard Vessel. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Section 327.02, Florida
280 Statutes.
281
282 Marina. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Chapter 101,Monroe County Land
283 Development Code.
284 _
285 Marine facility. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Chapter 101, Monroe County
286 Land Development Code. o
0
287 >
288 Moor. Shall mean use of a device,placed on or affixed to the bottom, intended for
289 permanent use,to hold a floating structure in place. As used in this Article, except as to the terms
290 "lawfully moored in a public mooring field"and"lawfully moored on a permitted private
00
291 mooring,"to moor or a mooring shall include other meanings of mooring such as tying off a
292 floating structure to upland vegetation or to offshore beams, pilings,posts, or stakes. For purposes N
LO
293 of clarification, "offshore beams, pilings,posts, or stakes"means beams, pilings, posts,or stakes
294 neAer attached to nor meaningfully connected to a lawfully established dock which itself is
295 affixed and appurtenant to and extends out from an upland parcel.
296 _
297 Vessel. Shall mean that term as it is defined at Section 327.02,Florida Statutes.
298
299 Water Column and water(s). The vertical extent of water, including the surface thereof,
300 above an area of submerged land,regardless of such land's public or private ownership.
301
6of11
Packet Pg. 3313
P.4.a
302 Limitation Clause.Application of the foregoing specifically defined terms is limited to
303 this Article,and these terms shall not re-define,modify, override, or supersede any such term
304 defined elsewhere in the Monroe County Code(s).
305
306 Section 26-216. Construction and Interpretation.This Article, being necessary for the (n
307 health, safety, and welfare of the residents of the county, shall be liberally construed to effect the
308 public purposes hereof, and interpretation of this Article shall be deferred in favor of Monroe
309 County,the applicable federal or state enforcement agency, or municipality, and such _
310 construction and interpretation shall be entitled to great weight in adversarial administrative
311 proceedings, on trial,and on appeal.
312
313 Section 26-217.Prohibitions.
314
315 (a) All legal and natural persons are prohibited from mooring, anchoring, or otherwise
316 indefinitely or permanently affixing, a floating structure upon, or to,waters or
317 submerged lands included within County waters.
318
319 (b) All legal and natural persons are prohibited from anchoring,mooring,tying off, or
320 otherwise indefinitely or permanently axing a floating structure to State of Florida
321 or County-owned uplands and over or otherwise upon waters or sovereign submerged
322 lands included within County waters.
323
324 (c) All legal and natural persons are prohibited,within waters or submerged lands
325 included within County waters,from anchoring,mooring,tying off, or otherwise
326 affixing a floating structure to one or more plant species protected by federal, state,
327 or local law(s),rule(s), or regulation(s)pursuant to an endangered,threatened,or
328 species of special concern designation or listing; all legal and natural persons are
329 prohibited,within waters or submerged lands included within County waters, from .2
330 anchoring, mooring,tying off, or otherwise affixing a floating structure to one or
331 more plant species(including,but not limited to, mangroves)whose defoliation or
332 destruction is subject to special protections under the Monroe County Comprehensive
333 Plan and Code(s)and special permitting requirements under the Florida Mangrove
334 Trimming and Preservation Act,codified at Sections 403.9321-403.9333,Florida
335 Statutes,as may be amended or supplemented. o
0
336 >
337 (d) All legal and natural persons are prohibited from constructing,placing, or
CL
338 maintaining a floating structure violative of this Article; all legal and natural persons CL
339 are prohibited from proximately causing or proximately contributing to the
00
340 construction,placement, or maintenance of a floating structure violative of this
341 Article. N
342LO
343 (e) All natural and legal persons are prohibited from storing items upon, occupying, or
344 residing upon a floating structure violative of this Article.
345
346 (f) Any municipality that later adopts this ordinance may independently enact its own
347 separate-and-distinct subsection of enumerated prohibitions.
348
349 Section 26-218.Exceptions.
350
351 (a) This Article shall not apply to floating structures lawfully moored in a permitted
352 public mooring field.For purposes of clarification, "lawfully moored in a permitted
7of11
Packet Pg. 3314
P.4.a
353 public mooring field"means moored to a mooring ball or mooring buoy that is
354 authorized under federal, state,and local law(s),which has received all required
355 federal, state,and local permits and approvals, and which is situated within a
356 mooring field managed by a local government.
357 LO
358 (b) This Article shall not apply to floating structures lawfully moored on a permitted
359 private mooring. For purposes of clarification, "lawfully moored on a permitted
360 private mooring"means a private party's mooring to a mooring ball or mooring buoy _
361 when such mooring is both authorized under federal, state,and local law(s), and
362 when that private party has received all required federal, state, and local permits and
363 approvals to so moor.
364
365 (c) This Article shall not apply to vessels, including(but not limited to)barges
366 (including(but not limited to)mobile platforms such as jackup rigs),houseboats, and
367 live-aboard vessels.
368
369 (d) This Article shall not apply to a floating structure that federal, state,and local
370 proprietary laws and regulations expressly permit,when such structure has received
371 all such required federal, state,and local permits and approvals(such as, for example,
372 a floating boat lift or floating vessel platform permitted by the Florida Department of
373 Environmental Protection pursuant to Chapter 403,Florida Statutes,and Chapter 62,
374 Florida Administrative Code, by Monroe County pursuant to the Monroe County
375 Codes and b all applicable federal permitting agencies), and is in compliance with
( )� Y PP P g P
376 all conditions of said permits and approvals. For purposes of clarification, "expressly
377 permit"exclusively means express authorization,of both all material components
378 comprising the structure itself,and of the placement or situation of that structure in
379 its specific configuration, length, size, and location,by all federal, state,and local
380 government agencies pursuant to issuance of a written order granting, or granting
381 with conditions, a written application to so construct and place or situate that
382 structure.
383
384 (e) This Article shall not apply to government waterway markers(such as, for example,
385 regulatory markers and aids to navigation(the latter including, but not limited to,
386 channel markers, danger markers, information markers, and aids of no lateral o
0
387 significance)).
388
CL
389 (f) This Article shall not apply to a waterway marker when that marker is both CL
390 authorized under federal, state, and local law(s), and when its owner(s)and 00
391 permittee(s)have received,all required federal, state, and local permits and approvals
392 to so place or maintain that waterway marker. C1,4
LO
393
394 ,g) This Article shall not apply to a floating structure moored at a lawfully established
395 marina or moored at a lawfully established marine facility. It is hereby understood
396 that it shall be the responsibility of the owner(s)or proprietor(s)of lawfully
397 established marinas and marine facilities to ensure that floating structures moored
398 thereto comply with all applicable local, state,and federal proprietary, safety, ;
399 environmental,and pollution control laws, rules, and regulations.
400
401 (h) Any municipality that later adopts this ordinance may independently enact its own
402 separate-and-distinct subsection of enumerated exceptions.
403
8of11
I
Packet Pg. 3315
P.4.a
404 Section 26-219.Penalties;Enforcement Procedure.
405
406 (a) Criminal Offense. Prosecution of violations of this Article may be prosecuted in the
407 name of the State of Florida by the prosecuting attorney thereof as more fully set
408 forth in Section 125.69(1),Florida Statutes. Any person or entity found guilty of
409 violating this Article may be sentenced to up to sixty(60) days in jail,or fined in an
410 amount of up to $500.00, or be subject to both imprisonment and fines.
411
412 (b) Civil Offense.Violations of this Article may be prosecuted by Monroe County and by
413 any municipality located within the county, by original county or circuit court action,
414 or under Chapter 162,Florida Statutes, and Chapter 8, Monroe County Code, or
415 pursuant to the pertinent municipality's code compliance ordinances,
416 administratively, at law, and in equity, as may be necessary to enforce compliance
417 with this Article, and to collect damages in the form of fines authorized by law.
418
419 1) Authority to Dismantle or Remove Offending Floating Structures. For any
420 violation of this Article,Monroe County may initiate an original county or
421 circuit court action, or code compliance proceedings pursuant to Chapter
422 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 8,Monroe County Code.The County may
423 dismantle or remove a floating structure held in violation of this Article,and
424 at its sole discretionary election may make arrangements to store or return it
425 to the rightful owner, upon the owner's payment of all reasonable costs
426 associated with said dismantlement,removal, or storage.
427
428 2) Municipal Authority to Dismantle or Remove Offending Floating Structures.
429 For any violation of this Article, each municipality within the county may
430 initiate an original county or circuit court action,or code compliance
431 proceedings pursuant to its own code enforcement ordinances and Chapter
432 162, Florida Statutes. Each municipality may dismantle or remove a floating
433 structure held in violation of this Article, and at its sole discretionary election -J
434 may make arrangements to store or return it to the rightful owner, upon the
435 owner's payment of all reasonable costs associated with said dismantlement,
436 removal, or storage.
437
438 (c) Federal, State Authority to Dismantle or Remove Offending Floating Structures. Any
439 federal or state enforcement agency may by original action,or pursuant to its own
CL
440 codified or administrative enforcement scheme, criminally, civilly, or CL
441 administratively enforce against any violation of this Article. Any federal or state 00
442 enforcement agency may dismantle or remove a floating structure held in violation of
443 this Article, and at its sole discretionary election may make arrangements to
LO
444 impound, store, or return it to the rightful owner, upon the owner's payment of all
445 reasonable costs associated with said dismantlement,removal, impoundment, or
446 storage.
447
448 (d) Injunctive Relief. The county attorney,the attorneys for each municipality within the
449 county, and all federal or state enforcement agency attorneys are authorized to
450 immediately seek affirmative or negative injunctive relief authorizing or
451 commanding the dismantlement, removal, covering, or cessation of activities,
452 construction,maintenance,practices,renovations, repairs, or uses in violation of this
453 Article by motion for emergency, preliminary, or permanent injunction, including by
454 ex parte motion, or other forms of equitable relief,from a court of competent
9of11
Packet Pg. 3316
P.4.a
455 jurisdiction, upon presentation of prima facie evidence of a violation of this Article to
456 such court.
457
c�
458 (e) Units of Prosecution. It being that floating structures in violation of this Article
459 present a serious threat to the public,navigational, and environmental health, safety,
460 and welfare, a rebuttable presumption shall arise that violation of this Article
461 constitutes a violation that is irreparable or irreversible in nature. Each day that a
462 prohibited floating structure remains in violation of this Article constitutes a separate _
463 irreparable or irreversible offense.
464
465 (f) Joint-and-Several Liability.All owners,part owners,joint owners,tenants-in-
466 common,tenants in partnership,joint tenants,tenants by the entirety, lessees, sub-
467 lessees, assignees, sub-assignees, and holders of legal or beneficial title to or interest
468 in a floating structure held in violation of this Article, shall be jointly-and-severally
469 liable with respect to any legal or equitable judgment or relief obtained by a federal
470 or state agency,the State of Florida, Monroe County, or a municipality within the
471 county.
472
473 (g) Costs. Any court of competent jurisdiction, administrative hearing officer,the
474 Monroe County Code Compliance Special Magistrate,and the code enforcement
475 boards and special magistrates of each municipality within the county, are authorized
476 to impose against violators of this Article any costs associated with the
477 dismantlement,removal, impoundment, or storage of any floating structure held in
478 violation of this Article.
479
480 (h) No Waiver or Estoppel. It being that Monroe County, the State of Florida, federal or
481 state enforcement agencies,and municipalities within the county possess discretion to
482 enforce this Article, such local governments' or state or federal enforcement
483 agencies' delay or failure to enforce any provision contained in this Article, however
484 long continued, shall not be deemed a waiver or estoppel of the right for the local
485 government or state or federal enforcement agency to enforce this Article at any time
486 thereafter.
487
488 (i) The Monroe County Marine Resources Office is authorized to contract on an on-call o
0
489 basis with at least one marine salvage company to assist with the expeditious >
490 covering, dismantlement or removal of floating structures held in violation of this o
CL
491 Article. The Marine Resources Office is authorized to cover, dismantle, or remove CL
492 such offending floating structures pursuant to said contract(s).
49300
494 Section 26-220.Provisions to Be Cumulative.This Article is cumulative to any other N
LO
495 substantive laws, ordinances, regulations, and rules, and is cumulative to any
496 enforcement procedure that those laws, ordinances, regulations, and rules may provide.
497 This Article does not supersede or repeal or otherwise modify those laws, ordinances,
498 regulations, rules,or enforcement procedures thereunder in any way.
499
500 Section 26-221.Private Right-of-Action.Any natural person may seek injunctive relief
501 in a court of competent jurisdiction to enforce violations of this Article against a violator.
502
503 SECTION 4.-Inconsistency,Partial Invalidity, Severability,and Survival of Provisions. If
504 any provision of this Article, or any portion thereof, is held to be invalid or unenforceable in or by
505 any administrative hearing officer or court of competent jurisdiction,the invalidity or
10of11
Packet Pg. 3317
P.4.a
506 unenforceability of such provision, or any portion thereof, shall neither limit nor impair the
507 operation, enforceability, or validity of any other provision of this Article, or any remaining
508 portion(s)thereof.All other provisions of this Article, and remaining portion(s)thereof, shall
509 continue unimpaired in full force and effect.
510 LO
511 SECTION 5.-Repeal of Inconsistent Provisions.All ordinances or parts of ordinance in
512 conflict with this ordinance are hereby repealed to the extent of said conflict. The repeal of an
513 ordinance herein shall not repeal the repealing clause of such ordinance or revive any ordinance -
514 which has been repealed thereby.
515
516 SECTION 6.- Captions and Paragraph Headings.Captions and paragraph headings, where
517 used herein, are inserted for convenience only and are not intended to descriptively limit the
518 scope and intent of the particular paragraph or text to which they refer.
519
520 SECTION 7.-Inclusion in the Monroe County Code of Ordinances.The provisions of this
521 ordinance shall be included and incorporated into the Code of Ordinances of Monroe County,
522 Florida and shall be numbered to conform with the uniform numbering system of the Code. 76
523
524 SECTION 8.-Effective Date.This ordinance shall be filed in the Office of the Secretary of the
525 State of Florida and shall become effective as provided by law.
526
527 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida
528 at a regular meeting held on the 18'day of July,2018.
529
530
531 Mayor David P. Rice Yes
532
533 Mayor pro tem Sylvia J. Murphy Yes
534
535 Commissioner Danny L. Kolhage Yes
536
537 Commissioner Heather Carruthers Yes
538
53 Commissioner George Neugent Yes 0
LINTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
1 F' MADOK, CLERK
00
._ 54000e
N
54 By LO
54Z Deputy Clerk Mayor David Rice
tU ., .�
a- f MONROE COUNTY ATTORNEY
0-1 APPROVED AS TO FORM
Ll- i �=
=L
ua
•a
.m o PETER MORRIS
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
Date:
11 of 11
Packet Pg. 3318
P.4.a
KEYV VEST
The Florida Keys Only Daily Newspaper,Est. 1876
PO Box 1800,Key West FL 33041
P:(305)292-7777 ext.219 F.(305)295-8025
legals@keysnews.com
MONROE- COUNTY PLANNING DEPT °
2798 OVERSEAS HWY STE 410
MARATHON FL 33050-4277
Account: 138694 Ticket: 241096
0
PUBLISHER'S�AFFIDAVIT
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MONROE [legal.teXt]
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared
,who on oath says that he or she is
0 y�' l Cm'Q��,Q �� of the Key West Citizen, a daily
newspaper publish Ad in Keonest, in Monroe County, Florida;that the attached
copy of advertisment,being a legal notice in the matter of was published in said
newspaper in the issues of:
Sunday,July/2018 �Ulr.� t ZQ r t S C t�f�Lt
J
Affiant further says that the Key West Citizen is a newspaper published in Key
West, in said Monroe County, Florida and that the said newspapers has hereto-
fore been continuously published in said Monroe County, Florida every day,and
has been entered as periodicals matter at the post office in Key West, in said
Monroe County, Florida,for a period of 1 year next preceding the first publication
of the attached copy of advertisement;and affiant further says that he or she has
neither paid nor promised any person,firm or corporation any discount, rebate,
commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publica-
tion in a rid newspaper.
0
(Sign ure f Affian CL
JCL
A irmeti,an 'subs before me this!--day of July 2018
t — - 00
—
( tar) P blic ' nature) Suelynn Stamp;.
LO
COMMISSION#GG23280'e
(Notary P is Printed Name) (Nota �� EXPIRES:June 27, 2022
�-7 My commission expires
442� �° Bonded Thru Aaron Notan
�
Personal! Known X Produced Identification
y Sueknn Stamper
Type of Identification Produced COMMISSION#GG232802
=,, • EXPIRES:June 27,2022
Bonded ThM Aaron Notary
Packet Pg. 3319
MONROE COUNTY B P.4.a
OF COUNTY COMMISSIONEPO .
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETINI
AND NOTICE OF
0
PUBLIC HEARING, .
NOTICE OF-CHANGE TO
MONROE COUNTY CODE
OF ORDINANCES'
July 18,2018.
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Wednes
July 18;'2018, the Monroe County Board of Co a�
Commissioners will hold the following Public He,
at the Marathon Government Center, 2798 Over!
Highway, Marathon,Monroe County, Florida to re
and receive public comment for the following items:
3:00 PM (or as soon thereafter as may be heard);
AN ORDINANCE BY THE MONROE COUNTY BO,
OF COUNTY'COMMISSIONERS: AMENDING CHAF °
26 ("WATERWAYS") OF THE,MONROE COUNTY C
OF ORDINANCES TO CREATE ARTICLE Vill. ("FLOA
STRUCTURES"); PROVIDING FOR PROHIBITION
FLOATING STURCTURES;PROVIDING FOR SEVERABI
PROVIDING FOR REPEAL OF CONFLICTING-PROVISI
INCONSISTENT- HEREWITH; PROVIDING
INCORPORATION INTO THE CODE OF ORDINANi
PROVIDING FOR-TRANSMITTAL TO THE SECRETAR` .
STATE;AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
(File 2018-107) •
Information to the above item is available at the Mo C
County Marine Resources Department office in Mara CL
during normal business -hours and online at: v
monroecounty-fl.gov 00
Pursuant to Section 286.0105 Florida Statutes,if a pe cN
decides to appeal-any decision of the Board of Cc ul
Commissioners, with respect to any matter,consid
at the meeting or hearing, he or she will need a reco .
the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he or
may need to insure a verbatim record of the proceec
is made,which record includes the testimony&evid
upon which the appeal is to be based.
ADA ASSISTANCE: If you are a person wii a>
disability 'who needs special accommodat
in order to participate in this proceeding, ph
contact. the .County Administrator's Office,
phoning (305) 292-4441, between the-hours of
a.m. --5:00 p.m., no later than five (5) calendar i
prior to the.scheduled meeting;if you are hearing or
voice impaired, call "711".
Packet Pg. 3320
June 30,2018 Key West Citizen
P.4.a
GJt CCUR"°
o: Kevin Madok, CPA
.. .... Clerk of the Circuit Court& Comptroller— Monroe Count Florida
•ROE COUNT. Y1 pp
W
August 1, 2018
Department of State
Administrative Code & Register
500 S Bronough Street
Tallahassee FL 32399-0250
To Whom It May Concern,
ai
Attached is an electronic copy of Ordinance No. 015-2018 amending Chapter 26
("Waterways") of the Monroe County Code or Ordinances to create Article VIII("Floating
Structures");providing for prohibition of floating structures;providing for severability;providing
for repeal of conflicting provisions inconsistent herewith;providing for transmittal to the Secretary
of State; and providing for an effective date.
This Ordinance was adopted by the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners at a
regular meeting, held in formal session, on July 18, 2018. Should you have any questions, please
feel free to contact me at (305) 292-3550.
Respectfully Submitted,
Kevin Madok, CPA, Clerk of
the Circuit Court & Comptroller &
ex-officio to the Monroe County
Board of County Commissioners
E
0
by: Pamela G. Hancock, D.C.
0
cc: MuniCode
County Administrator 00
County Attorney
Marine Resources V-
BOCC
File
c�
KEY WEST MARATHON PLANTATION KEY PK/ROTH BUILDING
500 Whitehead Street 3117 Overseas Highway 88820 Overseas Highway 50 High Point Road
Key West,Florida 33040 Marathon,Florida 33050 Plantation Key,Florida 33070 Plan
305-294-4641 305-289-6027 305-852-7145 305- Packet Pg. 3321
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT 0 STATE
RICK SCOTT KEN DETZNER
Governor Secretary of State
August 1, 2018
E
Honorable Kevin Madok
Clerk of the Circuit Court u
Monroe County
500 Whitehead Street, Suite 101
Key West, Florida 33040
Attention: Ms. Pam Hancock
Dear Mr. Madok
d
Pursuant to the provisions of Section 125.66, Florida Statutes, this will acknowledge receipt of your
electronic copy of Monroe County Ordinance No. 015-2018, which was filed in this office on August 1,
2018.
a�
Sincerely,
E
0
0
Ernest L. Reddick
Program Administrator ®0
N
ELR/lb LO
c�
c�
R. A. Gray Building • 500 South Bronough Street • Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0250
Telephone: (850) 245-6270
www.dos.state.fl.us Packet Pg. 3322
P.4.a
From: ords2municode.com
To: Pete rs-Katherine2monroecounty-fl.aov; Pam Hancock
Subject: Monroe County,FL Code of Ordinances-2008(14298)Supplement 17 Update 4
Date: Thursday,August 23,2018 1:08:27 PM
Attachments: ATT00001.bin
ATT00002.bin
�9
0
****THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED EMAIL*
0
Below, you will find the material that we have received/recorded to your account. This
material is being considered for inclusion in your next/current update, Supplement 17 Update
4 ai
Ordinance No. 015-2018 7/18/2018 8/6/2018 PDF
Ordinance No. 016-2018 8/15/2018 8/23/2018 PDF
Update the internet version of your Code
more often than a printed supplement. We can post newly enacted ordinances
We can update the Internet quarterly, monthly, in the online Code after each meeting.
even weekly.
.E
0
0
00
-
N
LO
V-
c�
4i
c�
Packet Pg. 3323
PAb
i
a
/
/ 1
r
i
i
/
0
pp
I
r Y III
1 I Q
1
I � l
�!7
I uo� � � I I' � '� �. � IIIII luuliunllllll IIIII I �
b ���, dllhuuul uuluuuuuu luu
yl ,
:2�
� """ EI I� ��" �I ' � I Illllllllilllllllll Illlllll �
I �
u
�N�i�il I�Ih���� I Illlll,l�lloll�l � I,': ^
I
I I I I
m
lull �
r
ij ill��i4d°, I
r,
9
e,
� ux�rnm.
Packet Pg.3324
peziaD ineun:egg ul"Ie le`aerlonj MaeW IsuleCV ualle6l3!`U elell!ul al lenaadd�) eanb�nabS 6ugeald e�i4�e�a�:Aueuay�e}}� ( ,a r
"Pops,
f ;.l
r
rj
r
l� 1
Ali
I
flN��MflNflll�l�ll�ll��lll1���111119rat rrmORRUX
6u!�aalj pazlaatginaun :aN ul"la la`aaMan. MjeVy Isula6V UOIIBBII!-1 DIBII!ul a}lanaaddV) ainjanalg Bul3aalj aaltlo aaag :juauatgaajjV m
a
m
a
�1
>I
}
Ir
U
1
I
I
i
ri IP
u
1,1
l
r.
J
i
P
i
V,1 iil
1
I
l
1f
j
f ji IIII,
pozpoNlneun:oN ul"Ie to`joMony M�pjeW lsu!!! Ch
e6�uo�3��I31�al�lllul al l�noadd�) aanbonabS�ull�ol���IN��oo�:Auaualloell�'
i iuuiuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuul VV II i �"i
I
r
uuuuuuu� ��l'�i l IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
uuuuuu'dQil�i����l1�4'�Illk
� I
I
� r/ III, �"�Iil l�� I�� ✓�uoao
IIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIII„II, �
/
P.4.c
Marine Debris Report to Monroe County Marine Resources
Case Number. FWC21ON0004917/FWCS21IN0000883
Leith: About 29' '
a�
Description: Blue in color cottage like structure upon two cylindrical shaped floats
Identification Numbers (if any): None; Unregistered, unnumbered
U)
Material: Cottage is primarily of wood. Unknown material of cylindrical floats
Color: Light blue
Lat/Long Position: N24 34.102/W081 43.748
Geographical Location: Boca Chica Basin
Approximate Water Depth: About 3 feet c
0
0
Priority Level:
Routine Removal X
Environmental Threat
c�
Hazard to Navigation
Imminent Threat to Public Safety
Additional Descriptors/Details: Property claimant is 0
Mark Tucker U
1020 Duval Street
Key West, FL 33040
Mr. Tucker confirmed in person on 12/17/2021 that the above address is a good mailing address
for him. I verified his identity through Florida Driver's License. His telephone number is U-
(305)417-3752. I informed Mr. Tucker that he would be receiving correspondence from Monroe
County.
Additional direction to contractor:
a�
Investigating _Officer:
,c
U
Photographs:
c�
Packet Pg. 3328
P.4.c
a�
c�
r i
CL
CL
c�
0
u
0
0
CL
A
u
E
u
Packet Pg. 3329