Loading...
Item N1 May 2006 Litigation Report To :~..1t1YQr McCoy.~. .0tHJnt~{C.Ofnt1~~$$~cnf}rs Suzanri(~HhrtoffCbtihty f\tU)rhey Tdrt't VV:i~k (>>vnty-Acitrlint$tralc~r F~~H;l; Bob ShIWnff{~r,.. Ctl~~4/\~$t~~stJot - County At:k:~ttlt;y .. -J. _//. -... ,'J<, -.-. ~/; ~-..; :;;;-.V':" I : -~~_/ D!jt~j: ~~tay 12., Summary I:!!dllltftl of r:;ases New (;~S~t~meri-sirl(~f: .h=J'St .ii'K.H'1J.h ..4 c;-a$~SCk~S~Mls~nce.hw~treptHt :5 CAY w:tive ";!lS,,S &1 CAY Post .J\Kigmenl. ,:"HH1S 4 Potmntl;~l(,$$~$hbt.>1\7tmed to Outskl-~ C.ou nsi~~ Ca-$~$ 2-8 AirpoHs COI1\,hiu\ionu! Officcn\ EnginBering Gttl\<<Jtfl. tJ18n~~{;A{rW~;tH. Mis1,'.eilanBOt;S HWl1HO R<:lSOUfCes Publ:\: Works Rf~k~~,t?DagiJn)~~nt TQt;':1t. CiEt$OS:p<>3'odlrtJ 72 iooe'>t No~v CasG:@ CB;se$C~(J$t)4 CAY Utigmlof\ Cfl$(;<~ Tria! 8; Appellat" Lo",,! Cl~ \(. p~}$t. "fudqti~~~nt. Cas~:s 1"<")'<"'."'1 i(" ~"";:, r:~ h~l ~..1'( ... KA~'9._.,,,. O-ulsld~ Ct)Un~;el.Ct~Se$ FHOrlf.::k. UbatlQff (ira UI)>9r:off; 14 r;a~<I"1.\) Johns>)r:. Anselmo, n3n,l'~<:l JnhnsQn <& M!ch;;m! 6lil'k(1) f'alt HaS1ings (B,)b Freilich Th~Sfnlth L$~~F~nn{VVh:~lne:.Srnjtb}{ 1 \lernls& EH'}yvhno{D,$fnUs, 2 o ., ~;5 >, ,,( 2 4 t~, 2. (,l 1(\ 17 10 20 CAses fiLeD SINCE LAST MONTH'S REPORT Aguiar, Alexander $. Elizabelh Ginan v, NLMr<'>'U?9JLljJ:i,<<w<<w,"",<<w,CA f' 06,1$9 Circuit Court 1SI<; Jud<;le; Garda Date filed; 515/06. ^ ""~,.,, "^fP /lhA'I^'('" r,' <'~"" C^'1"^"~'''''t e'r'~--"\' "1--<1;'''''1'''1'' 1"~~l'-''''''~~'~~ ~~ ",l, j ll..; v"",,0'~1:~~ "ny{;/~~;,' ~; ,~",~"v:-~~~,; .>,,-,.q;q.,:x<.'" ~,~._....:H.~: ...... Growth Mal'lagam(lntlCo<l& Enforcement PJM Current Status: RttiXHd tobeCOfnpRedby AppeHard. Next Aclivay; Apj)(jllan('\\ Ilrid dUI" 7 1141\Jft Tima: Cc.sts; G.GO 801'ld, ,jilm~l!; T, !tt_al v, Monn{.ti&,H!1!.L.,w., CA K 06-394 Circuil Court 1fl'" Judga;: ,jonQ$ Dat<a filed: 412110$ De,~~t~Y8t(Jry' Judgn~~~nt8c:Hnn $(Jskintt. ihjunttfon, aga:~n$t. enfOf\:einent Dr -t~bod rHein. i'e{~Uh)t(H)~~' -Ofl .QownsMHrs ef~~t:.k)SUf(). th~t ()Kt'jf}t1dett$c<>peof. p2=rrnit Growth Maf1il9~l'lumtla\.lildln9 DeptiCodll Enforellment RSS Currenl StaWs: M~ynr $~;~r~l~~d. 4/24.10e;. CA.Y' h1)Unf~d. 5iJ;Y6. Ne,xt Activity: COtlnt/~' response i,; due 6! 1 Sf 0(;, Time: Costs: (H)() GraV~$, Frank !II v, Monroe County Circuit Court 161" Judge: Garda C~.K1o Enh:::rG{M'f1t..H1t~1~:}~H~HJ Growth ManagementlClJde Enf"rcement ell P 06-154 Date File<l; 417106 PJM Currant Status: RtlGcrd to be cGmpiiixJ by Appdl"nt N(ll(l Activity: AppdlanfS brid du<\ 6fHim6 Time: 0,,5 CO$",: O.DO: ,oiL'{!l.r.Q.$o Jfn~eph v, Ana l\A, Velazquez & MOfIroe Cuunty CirCUit Court 16'h J\ld9~: Garcia (1ul~)1. tW~ BeVen h> prpp-#rty C(Hlveyed \!'k~tax Con$tltuliul'lal OffkedClerkfTax Collector CA P 06-13Q Oate Flied: 3f20106 RBS Current .St~tU$.; ~/Bi'r'.$~nt(KI515fOfJ. Next Activity: Ceunly',5i n,tlpen5iivB Tim(l: 05 Costs: 000 CASES CLOSED SINCE LAST MONTH'S REPORT Gap ProRertles of SIN Florida-Line. v. Monroe County 3005.2413 Thkd DCA Judges: TeA Oalr: FJfed: 1(1114/5 SHqnnd. tliJ( ce!tk)tt~d. t~PH~l.d. of' fh;3f:~@~. tW peUtk:;n()han1;;ngln~J.Go l.~fsl)<':splat ~~PP((yvf.lt. hJi~s. tt.)f d~')~~~;()rnk'lk.Hrls; .s41@.CA.K04., t ~)2'1.h{Jl()v>;, Growth Mllna!;wm~l'lttPlarmin9 RBS Current Status: Cefllorarl petitiofl denied: t%poe,ed wic mandahl. Next Activity: (:10",(;(1 V 8. B fees billed to date: see tria! lavel C,u, K D4-tJ2'L K~ll11ler, StUllrt v. MQnf{)e County I:\'. Tom Willi 3005.2755 Third DCA Judges: reA Oate filed; 11 !28/05 APi.le<'l1 ot flon-i'!nal order ,1eny,ng KeS$ler'$ pehtion for temporary f(jlrwj"tement. Human Resoun::eslRisk Management RBS Current Status: Ivhnda(f~ i"Sll.od 3!31!06. Next Activity: Closed, J & A Billing 10 date: CAY Time: 2.0 see triM level case ell. K nS-1fiQS Costs: (JJ;(J Monroe COUI1t~ v. BoyAl;.2~!.t!U2tArmVi!;a Circuit Court 16(1) JudQe: TElA CO(% fino co(l(>ctkm <)<<iion <)uthOl'l2~d on \)In).!,)';) Growth ManaWl'mel1ttCode E.nwrcernent CA K fltH39 Oate Filed: 2/1016 Phe iixed at $408,t}()CtOu, PJM Current Status: SeU.ied; d~sfnlss-e:d. Next Activity: CLOSED Time: l.t} hOUfS G6$t$~.$2le..oQ Mom'QQ County 'f, f'Qst 8uclil'l>V, $Ch\lh, and Jeml\9i!ll _ ",,,,,,,,<<<,~QIt$.,~.:1~62. Third DCA Judg(!cs: TSA DlIte filJild: 81'1105. App1.ta~ (~f judg l'f)(1nthi. thfxrd.'){):v:$. CaSt), Engineering ReS Current Status: DiSfni}1$td.by l\lel(t ActMty: CI(I'%l<:l- Smith Firm F'l>Ql> billed to date: Sl!e tria! lmtel caSlfl CA K 95402, O'Danlel 8, Hill v, Monroe Cenlntv Third PCA Jud{ll'!s: 'faA ;\ppe-a~l.AGjrcuit cOPGdedski'1ihCA.P 02....141. Growth Mana~;wmill1tiCodG' EnfofCQn1lflntlPlan111l1g <<< ~t)-O$.',~~,;} Data flied: 311 filM JD5 Current Status: t4~t1dt.ltnH~MH~d ..1.;;~t;/{/rr5, Next Activity: CioSf){l M&H Sililng tu datl'!: CAY Time. L5 CA Y UTIGA 'f101\l ". Trial &, App(!cllate lewel $Qa Outsid(!c Counsel Silctlon for Cilses being HandhHl Jointly Ambrose, Thora et al '4, Monrq!!. C9j~f1W ~t al CA po 97.$36 Circuit Court 16J" Jlld~: Garch'! Date Flled:12f11197 Dedara1.D [Y, JU~jgfG$f~t .~'{;tk)n_ .Ht~~~nifl9. Ve$tft~J. righ:l~.. {tVt~iQ. stlb(f~ys-~o~~:. plats. Subseq~Je:nt . $p-peal~~{ stJrnrnary fddfJfne-nt {~rder. rf.:ivf;[s-e:d. :and. rernand~n<L Growth Mal'lagemilntiPllll'mlng JDS Current Sttltus: R<'iview of COlllt W., indicate$ '08$<3 $WI N$~;(t Activity: St-h$<itW~ . hn,aflflf}on <~~i<:<t:kll\t(; Distn~ss, M&1i Billing to daw; CAY Time; 2}\ $3n<t~$Q.,9a 11'1 re; Birch Telecom, Inc. 05-12231 PJW V,S,Bnktcy.Oel<fware Judge: Walsh Date Flied: an2!QS 8anknJpteya<:;t}oflP,/pay. pf':Dne.VGDdor. ~vtH(;.hdtlil'n$.!teVJe8GountyS,4: -1 5.. Admlnistrathtl!1 Servk"M.ITeehllical Services RaS Current Status: ~)~rss(}d Co~nty\~ lrin;;tl;)$t$4, 15, Next Activity: Non'), Time: 1 Costs: 000 80ft, Andrew & DOrln" v. CjJ:y' <i?f.]!Ll!!.!l.i!19I.L<< CA \VI 05-167 Circuit CQ\lrt (16\b) Judge: Payne Date Filed: 9/30105 D,eC:!arakM:1. J~^~<HJf6eht. t~c~itv~ t,:h~1H~f1g,~n9 v8lkHty()f{!lfi)Hlabk~ h{.KJ$~rt@. dBiS<1 r6stri:ciitin . Chy 6f' Man1tt1ori .~hhefHed. trern.G~)uhty' attHrl$, tAinG~)rpotatk)n, Growth ManagementfPlannlng RBS Cumml St.1tUS: Dismisso<l wilh pm}udlO) by Court 4i25i06: CCUl"-ty's ~nt:9f\,<entlon rn6tk)ri'h~(;fA. Next At::tlvity: N()n~l unit,ss diSm,$iJE11 <1PI)(,<'!I,,(L Tim~<'!- 3.,4 Costs: In re: Megnan Cole Bankrtcy_ S.U.Fla. Judge: Mark Bt-lnk'\lptey ,~ctj0l1 by lena"t 01 C<:)Ufltji property 6ankrupil':Y Q543679 RAM Date Filed; 10/17/05 County o',\md $760,00 in fent RBS Current Status: stance. Count:/s intti-f8St (t)O minim<ll Next Aciivit~,: Fin3J. apPffA'td 6f. rAt-vi _ ~,ir di*(:ht-U"$Jf{' Time; 1,{) CO$ts~D:no CoWI'lS, C, $. Sum Air Services v. Monroe COl.lnt~ et aL____ ,GAM-~5-14!:! Circuit Court 1 S'" Judge: PllYl10 Data Fil~d: 6/1105 DeClamiGry ji.H1grnent action regarding leaSiJ '>'\Iilh F80 81 ivlsmthOt1 ,c"lrporL Alrp<:>rts PJM Current Status: C{)rnpan~Qr!: (~f~~~~~;t~W$d. Next Activity; Dismissal after s<&ttlenwnl fina!iz-xj, Tim..: 0.5 hOUfS Costs; Cutaia, Thomas y,J'4.$!.Uf.9Jl ~"unty, MCSO, ?retdal Sarvice1:l CAK-OS.617 Circuit Court 16m Judge: Jon~s Data fH(\d; 6fl1iO$ Cornplamt lor unspecified damages Mayor not "erved ye\. Constitutional Officer/MeSO R8S CUffent StaWs: Inac1ivH, Ned Activity: N6n$ude~~~~&.t#)~i~ .sehiid. Tlrru)~'OJg.b){H$ Cosb$: 0 GO Eads, Barbara v, Monroo Count\' CA1"'.(j,3.117 CIrcuit Court 16'" Judge: Garcia Date Fliad: 2127103 .A;:}f~J.H~t ofrydeJ: Hnding th11:. Lp-sNeHo ;.s,sstc. b~ . In. . wr;:$af~J' o~mdm()n. Growth MatlaglllttentlCode Enforcement RBS Current Status: Histodd $ttuctur€b~}ing. fenovated. Next Activity: Non" ;~j this jimQ, Time: 4,8 hours C05.tS: [tOO EEOC v, Monroa CO}}Jlty <___<________________________1&Q~~!lJ1.~:'.q,i\"!Z2 EEOC "' Miami Judge: NlA DMw fHllU: Sri/OS Charge ,)f disan/lit'! dit>crimirl:il1ion filed n)< "in \"mployae, Public Works/Human Re$ources PJM Cumant Status: ~n!e -(do $ed vv{fh,Art Next Activity: Await filing of suit by employee. Time: 16Jl h<lufS Costs: 0..00 f\tchs, Walburlla ~,-!l1QtltQlj' C<;!,~!I1t\l Circuit Court telh Judge: Payne Thisl;!;o code enforce:lled appeal of an 081'DS Cil${i. Growth Management/Code Enforcement CAK-O 1-1:251 Pate FlIad: 10f5fot RBS Cunent SUltu$: TheCountlsbr!eJ JHett BaSe- n~.a$,$j9ned to Ju~jg~I Payn€ Ne)(t Activity: I\Wa~t. Courf'sdr-.l(;I;shjt).. Time: 11.5 hOllrs Costs: OJ!O GQ()d, L!Qvd v> N!mwr:w Count>.' CA K 01.$17 Circuit Court 1&'1, Judgo: P'ayn~ DatQ Fi!~d: &l9{fJt {:'P\h<.iri~-t~c(jl-df)-mnatkdft.actton OBSfJtf on.NROGQ and.ded$fs1orYJudfjrrw;nt that own'3r b,~ ,1warder! perrnits for prop'Jrties. Growth Mltna%jQfflantfPlanl'ling RBS Cummt Status: R.e-~fMJl1$~$. to. Cn50 · t'/lt1naqern-ehi. ()frj~r nied. Next Activity: tl$sringofl.G60nt{s j;Aotk>h 1(:: -Disrnks~~, M&H Silling tu oalti: CAY Timfl: $t,K52~1.41'.}JS uf.10H-HlOo., Graves, Frank v. N!Qi'!(r:w County CirC\lit Court 1611' Judqe: Garcia Appeal ()l code enforcement (hdsion. Growth ManaqamenlJCQoo Enfon:oment CA P Q{l.1S4 Dille Flied: 4171'0$ Current Status: R,~:;(J.'n'd. b(-)hi{Jc<.HnJ~ii'fld- N$xt Activity: Bndin[j 15<.:J)"dui':l to ,~tetwrnine(L Timfl:OS Costs: Hardin, Mlchelllil v. Monroo Count\' Cirel.lil CQurt 16'h Ju<lg<El: MlIIer Aptteal ofcode~3nt(>n~bmi.H")t dHblf1iOt\. Growth Manaijoll1entlCooe Enf()rc~m~nt __,,,_,,,_,,,,);6Jt~~JP4$ Dat~ filed; 913/99 RSS Current Status: S1<!tU$ leWiiwon pendmg molions. NOl!:t Activity: Heldrj.r~{J oa l\.-1btf:)f116 Dlsrn~gs, tb-a. M&H BiUing to date:$10,24157thru HJ:-W05 CAY Time: n.s Johnson, Lloyd y, MliIrlene ConawllY _____~__ CA KQ,?~ i24.@ CIrcuit Court 16,r, Jud{lll: PllYll~ Date flied: 10l:rotn2 Wnt (li M,mdafYH,;$ crwikmging Pianning Oiredor's detew,ination that i.lOUn{)g,y detB.nnkn~tkH1 :bY .f.lll#9Qt1.urfdr. {~;JquiP;:$ 2on1ng (qOP a!"flfij:odn1Qht Growth ManagementlPlanning JO$ Current StlltuS: StatiJs. rep(lrl fft~i'flJud{l~~'S. chamber$p*.Jnd~(l9. N(lxl Activlly: If.tt~1:e.ded,.$C!1:edutehe;:)d0g cn r~io-tjdri 1~>Qi$trI1Ss. M&H Billing to date: CAY iim~: ~U $2>2lgJ32th(t)U{~h. 813-1iQ5, Kalan, Suzanne \I, MQnroe CQunty Circuit Court 16'~ Judge; Garda lnverst::OQr1t'h~mn.atk)fl.-$ctiqn. Growth Management/Code Enforcem&llt CA P 03.155 Dat$ Filed: 3111103 RBS CUml!nt Slattl$: Held ,n abeyance perltling aUD Maring, Next Activity: FinaliZe rnoUon fOf &ubl;lI1uHon of eouns,)I. M&ti BilIinq to dat(l: CAY Time: Hl $.2,f)S5,77.&S. of fV3.1 lOS, ,M);;j!!jYr!l, ,!;gYJ(\IJ,t<!y,J~iehllU1B,~I.ftt ~~9~"_, US Oist. SOFIa, Judqe; Hoeveler CiVil Rigrns ad.ion 1H('J(j in 1060,')\/6, old jail fadlitiBt, Constitutional OOIC<ilrtMCSO ~(}.lL2i.C!V.WM1i Date !'!lad: fiSiSO SNlled ';21'1991 Cuml'M Status; SnHui reportb-e:tngfk~r:W:l(?d. Next Activity: Slatus conference to be sCheduk"d, CAY Time; 13,0 Costs: S$H rvlaffh 200S i MQnroo C<>unll( v. Matthew Bonnett ______________G~K.OS.9j:!. Circuit Court 16'" Judge: TElA Date fUed: 91$l5 God~. ~fJnf(}r<;~rrw.H1t: Uofrn c~)~h;;CtifH1. ~~J(;hon i~t1thbrl7..(.Xj '1 (Jl1?/04~S 18 ..000. Growth Manaq(lI1'HmtfCode Enforcemllnt . PJM Currnnt Status: DF's f.lnB'I',Br ',werr.tue. Nilxl Activity: M(W,1 kr <ielaulL Time: i33 hours Costs: $295,00 M.9.tlfm! County II, James Jel!!nquenat Circuit Ct,l.lf't 16'" J~I<l~: Garcia C:o,leGlion "cbnn <'l:\Jlho(L:ed by 80CO on 4i2'1iQ4. Growth flI'lanagermmtlCode lSnfqr(;~ment CAP-OS ~11 Oate Flied; 711 $fi.)5 Fi"o exceods 13G, j{)()JYl RBS Curren! StatUll: Molbn lor Dismiss fikxL Next Acthtfty: t"A(~H9h. t/~<1dng. T8A.. Time: 3-7 Costs: $:175.00 M,QI1XSUilJ;;,Q!-ll'\!)';,1*,.!i<&iJ..mst<a Oce 1\f1 Jiesorts eM!:!, 1m;. Circuit Court in' Judge: Garcia AChQp tQ. ft)rf:tkJ"St~a .i;(Rj~~. t~nf{)rQ~~J1~~nt Hen. Growth Management/Code Enforcement CAP.~6.21'1() Daw filed: S12{lJ96 RBS Current Status: ~v'etbprnent agroofdent.t1pplici.1tiorl.be~ng .f:f:.b/ie~<!",{ed. Nexl Activity: Status .0;3.portdtH1. wtththfJCourt7!1~ /DB, Time: 41.5 hours Costs: $3,ni.(iO M.Ql1t(,m County v, Pedro t.lz CAK-05410 CIr(;l.lit Court 1611' Judge: Jones Date flied: 4122105 Collection actkm all1horl:e:ed by 60CC on 7i17!OJ; (!nes e;~ceed $,816,3<1GDG. Crowth Manag(lmentlC"'de Enforcement ReS Cummt StatUI!;; Gu~rdian f~ppo;nI0'J 1\,.!Ql!on br default cancelled. Next AcHvity; v\h~ftinG .on bond. cW'"(3Uttn::Ha.n.to. fSeg;v(<:} BnU\<ver.. Time: 9 (j hours Costs: $555,00 Monroe COUllt't v, Mal~ Ii!tl'l.tl !.J<-,yd CAM.Q::}.::}62 Circuit Court H,\~ Judge; Jones Date flled; 12119103 q09f~.?nforCtJn't;;)flt kJf1JclogurV;.:iCt)tJ,n. >~HJtr-ort~,crJ .ti:l toCd:. aocq .1/1:8/03. The tmal amount ofth,~ liH1 ()wed 10 lh€l Co,miy i$ $143.50GOG. Growth Mana~ment/CQde Enforcement RBS CUrrllllt StMus: Ct'fi,dtyind dO!Jb~e tHing .V{prirJf cowr~$et Next Activity: Draft &~'itti(\m(\nl <lgr"en,ent ''</lil1 Ot;l1en:Jant '1&8 Fees bllled to dat(l: None CAY Time: ?3 hour" Costs: (J (j() Monroe County v. Arthur Mli!hr Circuit Court 16'l'; .Judge; Garda COd~i fine Coll<JC1lon acHorl- Fine exceeds S':2.0rXlJ.liJ Growth ManllgememlCod~ Enforcement CAP.1)S.3411 Dllte filet!; SI5!OS Res Curr.mt Status: Dil,iXJ\I\:lry Next Activity: Qis(,O""ry Tlme:~3A hour.. Costs: $$60,00, Monroe County~. ..I11I'l1Ii!S Mess"lr;!, eL~L_.".____<<<<<<<<."."._<<<<__ CAK.1)3.1S0S Cln;;uit Court 16' JU<lgll: Paynll Dat~ Flied: 12:f18103 Code .~nk~rz;.ern~bt ,k:t~dosvrettt2tk~t:atih{;.lrit~1 byt.h$. gOCO 4/1BiO;~, Growth ManagementlCode Enforcement RaS Cumll1t Status; CHsco<;jbr{ N~xt Activity: D~schvery. V&. B Fees bllllld to datil: NOfl(~ CAY Time: :W Costs: 0.00 M<ll'1roe County v. Putlam:! Pro~rtill$ Circuit Court 16'0 Judge: Garcia Collection action authorized by Bote on 10i17ln4 Growth Management/Code Enforcement CAP.QS-4no Date FHed: 919/5 Firlt1.ovt~f $22'5,000.00. PJM Current StaWs: nfrffJhd<!H1t$eJ\~ed : Next Activity: DlscQvet)1. Thne:..1A, htx~t'S C<lsts: JOO3JO ~9nroe County v. Joe Posada, III ______.GAK~4~.11103 Circuit Court H11.. Judge; Payne Date Filed: 1211 Sm3 CQd.e ehf(~H';etnent. fOf6ClpSLtr0 i8tt~6h.aUthndzi:kfbY' th~. 8Q()J 4!18j{K1. Growth lI'tanagementfCod* Enfl)rcem~mt RSS Cummt Status: Settlement 1Jgl'€'(mwnt t(} SOCC 5i17iOo. N~xt Aetlvlty; ~'f nr)ts~tU$d, bfH':ich jr;m!~M516({~B::4.s B.rrt V 8. e Fees 8. Costs billed to date CAVflmll: 69 hOlJf'S NOflQ, Monroe County v. Virginia ~jlwy~r ~~I9J)..YJt';~lters CAK..o3.1&05 Clr<:uit CQurt 16'" Jud9~: Pay"* Oat~ Filed: 1211&03 G,:)deent)n~erne(';t. f<>fedos-t..~re. <:H.Jk)n. th(!t :~va~. <nr~hohz~~d by'. thw - BOC(~.?.: 16fO$. Gwv<tth MiilI'U1l;1(lmentlCodlil EnforcliIment RaS CUrf(!t'lt Statuw SHltir;rfH;ml n''lgoti,'1tions pending, Next Activity_ tfun.s~KX.;B;~sfti~, rrH:hn~ -f:G.f.SUfr~rt1,ar:jjutitJ~rg:)nt V 8. 8 1"0lil$ billed to <:Iatlil: Nonie) CAY Tim<l: :2 n C01:l!$: 0 00 Monroe County v. Virginia SawMor CAK..03.tS06 Circuit Court 16'1' Jud9~; Jon~s Date filod; 12118103 (Xjd{~(~:'1ff3rf::(~th:(~tit. f()ri~r;to,s~..lJt1. ~~k;th)n - nWH'. Wil$ . i.:utlH)ri~:hd .by _ H1e BOC.C ; 7It5/q3.. Growth Man<'!9(!mentlC~l!l Enf(m;;~II'l(!nt RaS Current St<'!lu$: Cr.lUrl spproved setllflmBtl1 agrwemeM. injUn<:llof1, lien !\l<lxt Activity: En10fcernent - jf not. (:t"i:rnpH<~ nb~~. V&B rl!ll!l$ a COSu> blll~d to date: $11,745.44 CAY Time: 6.7 hours Monf00 G<lunty v, louis Welters CAK':.!!.1:&39 Circuit Court 16'" JUdgll: Janos Oat0 Fllll'd: 6114104 GddB :t3ntorce~1-~.ent fq(S:1qk)~OfeaCtEJn lh8tV;taS8utnofized tw th61B()CC7/15/(tt Growth Managem~nuCodo Enforcement RaS Current Status: Se\tIBfn$N nB(Jotiab()l)s ()(\Il\!iflg_ Nellt Activity ~f W'$w-;t-es$f~~L r:<K;:vBfrir $U~t~rnffiri vas Fe*$ bill~d to date: Nt,me CAY Tirm;!; 25 Costs: C{)O O:Q.flJlii1,,,4s.lm & Th~rt!$a till! II, MonrQi!l Counw Circuit C01.Jrt 1elb Judg*; Garda APFt:8~. O'fbodB~m~ft.:H.t%rne})t. actlOH anti. ves!i'":Jo. rights. {Jm.im, Growth M<!IniilgeIl'lIH'ItJCod~ Enforcement/Planning CA P 02<<141 Date Filed: 3/13/02 ,IDS Current Status; tA~lNd~te HOrn. Third . r.::l(~A. r(~dz~~lVi.:;d.1 {18/fH3. Next Activity; Slalu~ :nq\iiry with I;harnbers pell<:hrg M8.H BilHng to datl!l: CAY Time: 2.5 $42,782.13 NiilulrIont, Elizabeth at Ill, It, Wklllf'o<J 'Qui'll", ~9-10!l54.CV U.s, Dlst. Ct" S,I),Fla, Judge: Paine Date Flied: 5121199 Class aotion chalf"'t1~jl0g ~l1a(;1mfJ0t of vacatf00 rel1ta: ordinance, G.owtl1 Manil{leml1ntfPlanning RSS Cummt Stalus: Brieftitofupfb~$,j. Next Activity: NoM~::),. fh~v8-it. ruHn,g.. M&H Billing to date: CAY Time: 0.5 S'"t20":56:"i.QA,, NeumQnt. Eliitaoetn et al. v, MQrlroiil Count\! till> Circuit Court of Appeals. Judges; TBA Apv~:al or 99,1 OD54,CV ,;jbove, Growth Managemem:fPlanning 04.13610.)( Date FlIact: 7/151114 RBS Current Status: /J"Waltit10rNJdsionoftht=;CtHJ(t. Ned Actillity: ccunsd Fin~Ule. rn0t~(;'n f1;jf $wb$t~tutk)r~(:l {X.iU0$et (:tl~ CA~( tot hjunef BHliJ'lg to claht: $123.565,.10 ,\('; ()f erJ1JQS (by furmerolAsd<J ;;olJns<~I). CAY Time: 0.5 .!~kltt~,a!lte< Maril~n v, Monroe County C8K-(j4-1227 Circuit Court 16" Judge: JQoes Date Filed: 11/18/04 Suit.cn8JleJ1'fiin9 . f).aystiore"s. ru~e;; (eqtdrir~g tarhHy fnernbsrs. kfstih$kHz@. r:&$ld-d(l1:~;" Community Servlcel!>1Social Services RaS Cummt Status: PL has passe0 W,.<hJ'j Set1ieHTIenl offer (>(.~n<Wl'.1 Next Activity; County's motio(l to dismiss \0 be heard (j!16/0e ;ill 1 t:16 a,m. Tlma: Sn. 7 rWtlm COllts: 0.00 Shma C!;Jb, ~~" DC.~.. Miami Gade & City Qt Homestead 03. ij),n7,~M OCAI'{ Judgo: Maloney Oaw tiled; 1111/03 Gry,lliW idftlv<Jf\(,d in fldminh,tmtiw; chaHongo to <ll1'!1i3Fdment (It MiamH)I~de':; c()rnp< p~r.~,n red$$~9nt~hng ,Ktorn~ Avt~nu$: to a ~najor r<>adwmy ~3 or rnore lanes) Growth MlIflagemMt'Planning JD5 Cllffe!!t Status; PrOW;)~M:.H.i Ph:~()orn~n{1nd~d {jrdfH' m~Mj 2/3/5. NeKt Activity: A"l'iaft (tJNnp by !\LJ. BjfUog to Qat.e~ N{lntJ, {;1"O i)-ClOO.- {by fonner <)t.~tskie c()un~f.d). CAY Time: B.O Teal. Kimbllrl)' a. Keith If, Mlchalll AI1;;!l"i, MQnrQa CQUntY, et~L~CAM:!'H~4fl.1 Circuit Court 161" Judge: Payne Date Filed: 12!16!1l4 Declilfatory judgment "chon over roatj ,0 GHy d Marathon. Public Works/Roads and Bridges P.IM CUrrQflt Status: PL'" !"notion Ie "merd cnmplaint & <lad v~1y tiled 5:9/!:) Noxt Activity: HOileinQ on motion (:) amend tba, Timll: 9.& hours Costs~ $133..00 TrOY1 O~nit)t Scr:~~M.~r~~~gMlltM,.."<"<"<"<,.."<<".,,..,,,,,<,,<,,.,,..<...<,,<<.....".,,<......<<..Q8ttQ~::~<~~ Circuit Court 16 Jud{l~: Jones Date FHe:d; 8/24/05 Mi:l'1oamus ilctl<>n i)'J{jking after tho fact buiiriil'1g permits, Growth Malla911mel'lliPlanlllllQ RBS Current Status:: On flPPflfli in 30 05,74%" Next Activity: NOT~.e \ljlhHe on appeai Time: 2.0 hours CO$ls; G,GO Troy, Qaoiql $l;Qtt v. Nil:mroo Count'! Third DCA Judges; TBA Appt'i<'li d ,,jf)nlt~l i,ll'#rit (.)f ll)i,mOefmJ$ in C!\ K 05'.85E-. Growth Mana!ilem~ntJPlaflning :m 05.2419 (lata flle:d: '1017105 RBS Current Status: Troy given lJ!1ti1 ~Y23/0() to fii<'l hiS brief, Next Activity; Tro{s briHf o'lfHdv\). Or!)ft f\)piy bri€.lf wh.mever it tvrlves. Time: .f CU>'it.~; O.O{) 14 Wa!areens $. Ga~inl~ky.':td'i!,j:ll1roo County GAK.f!>~~~a Circuli Court 10\' Judge: Taylor Date flied; 3!11fGS Cert, review ()f DOAH order Llph<::M.Hn(j ~!f; findings supporbfl(j dBniai cf m<!jor condWonal use application for Big Pine Walgrl)P,f1S Growth ManagementlPll,mnlng RBS Current Statu:ri>; Settlement discl.iSSiollS urlgmg> Next AcHI/II...: P!<'lS(lFlt settlement 8gr(1l,xnent to soce S> COWlt lor OK or go to finai heating. TIme: 40.2 hours Costs: $318 iF in fe: Wil1tl Dixie Stores, Inc. O$-03811-3F1 U.S. Bankruptcy Cl., fIILO.Fla> Judge; Jerry Funk Date Filed: 2i25IQ$ Voluntary 011 1 case where County mignl !KWe a daim against th<a estate. Bankruptcy RBS Cumlnt Statu$; Ccuict finct no basis for filing plOof ()f ci.\im> N$xt Activity: None needed, Tim~; 0,9 houts Costs: 0.00 15 CAY POST JUDGMENT CASES Evans, Brl~l1 \/. Moni'~~ Couhty, ell.ll ~~,"__~~___...Q.+-'~IV.1Q,\l33.JLK U,S,Oi'lit,RD,fla, (Miami) Judge: Kil1{l Oaw Piled: 516J04 Wk~rh;}Y judgment ot $4,.579.0010 tm'S/tv of C?.)unty &: MeSt) for ru~e 11 .san(ik).nt~. COI'l$tltutlol'lal Officer/MCSO RBS Cummt Status: $4,:;79.00 in f,,<% 1lwatC,,'tl to CQunty 8. MCSO. Next Activity: GoHec.non. CAY Time: 9.5 hours Costs: 0.00 ,~t;1llr.Ql!S;Q,illJt1 ~., .\filMl1!!l1...bQt':LiL,___~~____,_____,<<__~_____.J?.A~:9A::W"1 Cir(;uit Court 1G' Jud9~: Gl.lrcia Oata FHed: 4115J04 M()i'\\'lY iudgmllt11 of $Z7,eUIUlll br unpaid o;J',:hl enfO'<.A'lmfml. f;[Rll;l ilnd nn\l.s. Growth ManagernenUCQl$e El'IfQrceml1ot ReS CUi'rl1nt Status: F:ina~ llR.igrn-ent r3 $23..4-31 JJO t$CQrded wi' DepL of State. Next ActMty: CoHection. Tirn~: 0 2 hours Cos:ts: $56..00 MOI)!.~,520I.ml~ v. Q~1I1 Gle$$otl 5CP.0.)-165 COl.lt1ty Court (Sm. Claims} Jud!;le: Ptomey Oate Filed: Sf51Q3 Money ilx19mallt (')f $521l.01l fer utlVlld o:ds Mfotr:etlwnt fin'i'~ iintj f)'1Sl$. Growth Management/Code E!'lfor(;$m~nt RaS Curr~llt Status: Fin<J j:.,'jgment rs'-xx~\'i'd wi Dept. of State. Next Aetivity: Co!iec.tion. Tlme: 9 5 h(.ll.<l'S Costs: $65.92 MQrwoe County v, Lilv Marks _,"", , CAK.03. 1152 Circuil Court 16* Judge: Jones Date Filed: t0t2103 MOIW)f j\l!Jqm'i'nt of 5795.270.00 for uflpl'lid cod" enf{l((:emef!1 fines an..j costs Grtlwth Mal1agem~nt!Code Enf(Jrcem~nl RBS Current St4.ltU$~ F:naf ju'(J~vn~nt entered for $705,;2"1'0.00 on 5l9i05, Next ActiVity: Collection. Time: t.G hour'~ Costs: $1.'>6 00 'i ~:1 POTENTIAL CASES THAi HAVE NOT YET BEEN FILED AGAINST COUNTY A$SOC, fur Ois;apled Am~ri(;ans 8. W.L~nleW5kl v, $hi~$wav, Inc. 116CV1!lQ34 U'sJ),C,!:UJ.Fla. Jw;lge: King Date< FilQc!: 417jfJ ADA suit <lgainst OWfH:l1' anti somH tenants at SrlipsWay oITlce buiiding. County is a tenam but 11m; not been named Ii) dalB. Public Works!Facilitles RBS Current Status: Monitmif\g suit since CClJf1ly not a pariy. N1illd Activity: Pl'eiirnill:ilxy Injunction hearing $f24f(j6 at 4pm. Time: 2.4 Costs: () 00 Ballard, Kimdl v, Bergen Trust and Monroe County TaA TBA Judge: TBA Pate Flled: TSA Persona! inJury Gase allegedly ansing fn.ml County hurrl.:;ane debris ",Clivity on property owned by Ber~n TwsL Risk Management/Engineering Current Status: 80rgen Trust receivl~d !,mer notifying of daim. Reviewing claim. Coun(ys obligations and li"bHilles under detlris site contract. Next ActlYlty: None until/unless sufi is filed. Timo: 7:1 Costs: $0.00 Calus!! Campgrzunl;l Condo >t. Monroe ~()ul'lty, et <ill., _~_ T!jlA Circuit Court {'f6 oi} Judge: Date Filed: Threatened action by oondominium resulting fmm sll.llemenls n(lgarding plattinl,) requirements by Gmv"th ManBgem.1nt perSOllnel. Growth Managemel'1tJPiannln9 JOS Currol'lt St<ltus: lnvestigatfng claim aflfJ aSSisting Growth Manag1iiment DiviSion in preparmion of I'~,spor'lses 10 cJHJmanL Next Activity; Awaiting claimant's fJin9 {}fOp.,r subdivision pial for approvil' Time: 25 Costs: 0.00 'l'! G~d~ l"lovd v. ~nro!1 County ~...:mA Circuit Court (16 ) J\.ld9~: Ollie Flied: B.11t .I, Hanis lIet claim regwding two par<~*ls of prupenyownoo by Uoyd Cooo Growth Management/Planning RBS C~!n~nt Status: Sett!efDent d~scuS$inn$ unde'Njt~~~, Next Activity: Nono, St<:lY(!fj during Good's application for major conditional use, Time: 8,G hours C<lst$: S5,56 Ham~lt(ln, Cnarh~$ v. ~8YJ*)\'lonme Count\' CA K 04.1Ml Circuit Court {16!"l Judge: MUler Date Fliad: "116104 Polential perSt.Hlalinjury claim by SCOOt.M accident VIctim and/or ulility seeking d.,magM !rom the Co\mt;t Handled jointiy with Jol'lnson. lInsdrrKl. Public Works/Roads and 8rklgesfRlsk Management RBS CUffent St.atus: County depositions 'xm,:ludoo; County not a party yet N$'ld At;tlvity: None schetiuled. F~es Billed tl:l Pate: (j,DO CAY Time: 14., Costs: 0.00 Kresser, Mar!<: v, Irvin HiggS, D. ~9.lbog~ l!ll1dJor VAS. ra~ Circuit Court (16h) Ql' US Oist Court Pate filed: TeA Potential action for extraordinary writ challenging denial ()f horoo$lead €.XE!ll1ptinn or f\ 1983 claim for damages dul'l to alleged lack of heanng notice for final hearing of VAB. COl'lstttutionai OffIcer ReS Current Statl,l$: VAB hei() sUPI::4em,H1t,)i iK'aring 46>'6. Next Activity: Close Me if no action 1\100 by 6l5/0 CAY TIHle: 11.5 Costs: 0.00 18 lee. Veta Eiplte of _" ~~;::f' K O:i\..:j12 Circuit CQurt 16'h Judge: Taylor Oat~ flied: 5114fG2 CQUmy has claim In pt'obab case ior an elderly home loan &. ,lnpaid taxes Howiling Authority & Constitutional Officer Cl.lmmt Status: FHe adm,nk,trativeiy dos€{) by Ih$ Judge; discussions lNHh heirs on soWem,mt ongoing N~xt Activity: Re-open (!state, seli pmpelty to de-at allliQns, Time; 2 a Costs: Monroo C{lI.lI'l~":LFstaw 01 ihoma$ O'Brlliln._mA Small Claims Monro1il Judge: TEA Date FIl~d: Action againsl esl<Jt<J to colled unpaid ambulance bill of $86Ul1, Probat<l' C,l$e is CP K 05-1f14. Emergency Servic1ilsfEMS RBS Curr~nt Status: Settlement <lgr.illmenl appm'MQ by the probate court Next Activity: AW1litk1g paymenL Time: J.2 Costs: 0.00 State of Florida v. Monroe CO\.loty ",,__ww TBA. TElA Judge: TaA Date File<!: nla AG'$ Medicaid Ftaud unit al!<eges ovel' blllings {or amhllh:1rlce SI'lf't'Ces. Public SafetyJfire Rf<lscue RES Current Stl1lhlS; Wailing for AG's oftice tl.) set liP c~,)nf~)(e()t$, Next Ad/vlty; Settlement confereni;~~ with State. Time; 9.2 hOlJrs Costs: 0,00 Stewart, Seek}' v. Monroe County T6A TBA Judge; T8A Date Filed~ T6A Property damage claim i$3,287.13) arising irom accident involving Co,mty vehide in Ocaia, County's ciaim agatn~;t $wwart ig $2,487.70. Risk Manag&ment CUffent Status; Negohahons slallf.td I:kle \<,) offseWflg claims. N~H(t A(:t!\Ilty: Dek~nd suit ii file<i: file suit if appropriate. Time: 1.4 Costs: $OJJO 19 CASES BEING LITIGATED BY OUTSIDE COUNSEL Ferenclk, liba!'loff, Brandt, Bustamanw and Wmiams~ PJ\. Monroe County lI. BiL!'lder & Assodatlls, etil! CAK-O3.:fl15 Circuit Couri1ti'" Judge: Jones Date Filed: 814103 Brw:lch of contract and negligent miswpresenlatlon achl)n arLsing from the defedtvtl wind<Jwt\ in the Gato buHding. EngilweringlConstructh:m MaMgement RBS Current Status: DlscO\'i\ry ongoing. Next twtivity: Discovery ongoing. Fees blUed to datt'l: $99;1 HLOO Costs: $12]17.63 (lhru3rWlOO) Monroe COI.ll1ty v. JQsQ-J~~m?i~lez CA K TBA Circuit Court 1tl1h Judge: TBA Date Filed; TBA Pc.ssibie breach of contract (~cthn <~gain$t County's former an:hitect. Engineerif\g/Construction Management RBS Currallt Status: Discussions with Gonzalez Next Activity: Schedllle meating with staff S. Gonzalez. Fees billad to Data: CAY Time: 12.5 $10,24tl}.lO Costs: $87221 (thru s/l0/0el Monroe County v, LS?d~ Construction, ,,( al CAK.OO-611 Circuit Court 16'" Judge: Payne Date Filed: 5111100 SlJit flied agaihslgenera! contractor l.o<:lgo Construction &. Its surely for brfiach of contract to bllild Gt~to Building. Engiml'eringlConstruction Management RBS Current Status: M~lti()n to \\(\\ befNa Senior JudfYl penc!lng. Ned Activity: Ruli!'1g on Senior Ju<:lge moti{)f1 pending &. trial dale to bo sot. Fees billed to date: $298.415.26 Costs: $71,523.31 i1hru 3/10/00), 2G Trj;\gI1lKCQl'1stf!.J{!t!on Service, Inc, 'I. Monroe Count)' CA P 06-44 Cl<<:ult CQurt 16 ' Judge: Garda Date Flied: 1130106 Breach fA ()1.)t1lr::~{;: s1.ll1fl1ed by (;,;mllaelm who km,ind1ed conlr,,;;! to bliUd TaW,;rl1]er fire 5t1!tion bdore cQrnrnencern"nt of consJxuc!i<;(L EflginelllflnglCol1structkm Management RBS Current Shltus: PL l~me!1ded {XJmpiBinl Bft"J( disroiiii,s,"i by couK Next Activity: f'A""!'''" r"$C'O""l;) "::1'" r..:')41'f, ....A,.t''''''~<~y.._ ..'" ~ r;,;,,,, \..~ ,,< ,...,;e;.. ~ Billing Reeaived to data: n<.,t'1$, CAYl'lme: 11 Costs; a.(jo Johnson, Al'1selmo, Murdoch, Burke, Piper, ,& McDuff. PA, Bauknight, ~!s>4~as ,& Rookett v, MQflrtli1 CQUI1t\t CAfQ)4451 Circuit Court 16 " Judge; Garcia Oate Ftled; 9124104 inlierse ';ond(."mn::~tionltaldng$ ctise tiled by Jimmy 8. Nancy BauKnight TeaguB SKa~J9S, 8. Kathleen ROGKott for thrOB jOj~ 0n Big Pin€l K",y, M8Yor (%ll'Vcid 1(;14/4. Growth Management/?larll1lng RBS Current Status: Thnl Pi~rly O,llllplwn( ilgainst Stat") flI",,11/11/OB. Next Activi1y: Disowery Fees billed to date: $832.24 Costs: OJ)O Baukniaht. ~kagg1; lit RQckett v, Monroe Countv 04-CV.16105 U,S, D,C. S,Fla. Judge: Moore Date FillH!: 1111/04 lr1vef$ii' condemnatlonilak.lngs case by owners; of;; 81,'1 Phe Int~. Growth ManagementiPlannlnq RSS Current Status: NON!. Next Activity: N-t>n1l". Fees billet! tQ date: None Costs; (1.0D 21 !i!~~kniQht at at v. MQl1r!?~"f;;ountv _ow 05.11l~~8.F 111 Cir. Ct of Appeals Judg~: TeA Date Filed: 2/i1i05 Property owners' ,3Pp<?al of denial of ,,~!1.llm(lj(& fees against the County Grcwth Manaflem~l1tlPlal'1ning ReS Current Status: 4/2516 11 I" Clrcuii 1iff!nNlct decision denyin{J own"m' le"$. Co\mty awp-rrJed appellate costs. Next Activity: None: await 90 day period lor (txpirstion of thn," \Z1 pHitiUi) U,S. $UprC1l'tWl Court for certiorari r")v~w, fees billed to daw: None Costs: (J.OO Florida K~V Ot'Hn Y:,..M!cha~lerQwn 8. Gll!~ Norton 90.10037.CIV.I"''Lqo.J;S U.S, Diat. Ct., SO Fla, Judge: Moore Date Filed: 412190 ESA t;<1se thai rO$utted In pen1K4l%1I'11 iniundion barring FEMA flood insuranO<i. Growth Management/Planning RBS Curnmt Status: lnjutlctlon in pla<:l1_ Next Activity: On appeal, $00 05.16374--11 Billing t<l Date: none CAY TIme: 33.8 Costs: 0,00 Paulson. R.D. v. Florida K~y O~u~r, et al _____, G5.1a$14~t! 11,li Circuit Judges: TeA Date Filed: 11l10l05 Appeal of S-oulh$f!'1 Distnct's injunction in 0()..1 0037.C1V. C(}\lI1lyappeared 3& amicus cvrkw beC(ilJ$~1 dernM int'iirlien1icn. See Case No_: 05-11599CHL Growth ManagqmentlPlanning RBS Current Status: Briefs complele. Next Activity: Awaiting (h~i$lon by Court. Billing to date: CAY Tlmtl: mme 0,.5 Costs: 000 '''J;<~ ~....... Monroe Countv \(. I;!gfida KeY.pjW;r, fit at _~___ t.l5-i6900.!l 1 t11\ Circuit Judget>: T6A Date FHlld: 12l12/Q5 Appeal of denial of CO(Jnty's motion to mhmmne in 90-10037 -CII/. Growth Management/Planning ReS Current Status: 1((1Y 00,,)('$ Answer Bnel filed 5/9/6. Next Activity: County's reply brtf'f dw 5!21J!6. Billing to Date; None CAY Time: '1.0 Flod~ Kelt Deer. et al It. Gale NQt'totl {Secd~t!!1teriorl OS.1U063-CIV.KI/IlG U,$.D.C. S.D.Fla. Judge: King Date Flloo; 6115105 ESA challenge to F&WS Nview 01 constl1lctiQn of pi.lr~ on BiD Ph," Key. Engll'leeringtCof\structkll'l Managlilmel'll RBS Current Status: Dismissed Wilh prejudice by 3greemer'lt on 2/13/06 because r(wised biological opinion satisfactory to Plaintiffs. Ne xt Activity: ResoJv\'J <my ilrtomeys fees & costs motilm$. Fees bill~d to date: $612.50 CAY Time: 6.5 Costs: o.on HI/lam:!. Thomas G. Y. D. Koll1al:l9 8. R. Thurston. _ lM..10102.C1V U's.O.C.$O.Fla. Judge: Highsmith Date Flied: 10/21104 CIvil RIQhts sotion ag<'li(lst Deputy Clerk of Court bv inmate. Ccnstitutkmai OfficerlCI(lrk . RBS Current Status: Discovery. Next Activity: Answers V.llntflrro<;.m!Orifls due 6/18106. CAY Time; ita Fees a Costs billed to date: M.2Gl.12. 2:.l fKCG, 11 Last Stand v, FL Aslroll'l, CQmm.; Monroe C~)Unty . OOAtI 04-2756 OOAH Judge: Car(llyn Holifiel<l Oaw Filed; 08105104 Adminlstrativo Rul~ dl(~llen(Je to partnership 80reenwmt with State. Growth Management/Planning RBS Curre-ot Status: Final Order In C'Al\.ll'lty's favor issuod 612.9.105, Next Activity: None pending appeaL Fees billed to <late: $f>~J,464.92 CAY Time; 190,1 hours Costs; 0.00 FKCC &. L:rtltLliJ.~nd '4. ft Admin, CQmrn" l\t1onroo Coonty, et al 30j)5-1~{) Third DCA Judlles: TeA Date Flfed; 7128105 Appeal of AU's de,ch,ion dl,mying rule chBlIenge in DOAH 04-21'56. Growth Management!Plannin~ RaS Current Status: M8f81hon dismissed because a<loption awl <'Jpproval of ih1 comprehensive plan mOQied its involvement in the rul.) challenge. Ned Adivity: County 8.. DCA's orief <Iue 5}lf,IO(L F$$S blllGd to date: nont) CAY Time: 05 h(}urs Costs; ODO H..rdee, E~~lltP '4 ,M()nr~ County Circuit Court 16/IT Judge: Garcia Tort ~lCU()n arising from {Jlleg~d f<lll at PK COllrt hOllse. RiSK ManagemiintlPunlic Works CAP.05.255 Date Filed: 6/3/U5 RBS Current 5ta1l.l$; Settled for $25,000.00. Releases being exchanged, Nilld Activity; Onc(1 finafl7ed, close me, feel.' billed to date: $t\004.33 !tllru 1IS1f(lt'll. CAY Time; 10.3 hours . , 24 Kessler, Stuart i' M~:;mroe Count" & Tom Willi Circuit Court 16 ~ Judge: Jones Whislle.Bbv>lr & Civil Rights claim by f()rmer employee, Personnel/Risk Management CA 1505.1006 Date FHed; 10/1112005 RBS Current Statufe 4f1 He Court dismissed :I of 4 {;(lunls, reserved ruilng on 1 count afwl denied tl1oiion 10 dismiss whi"U$bl()\I,mr rA"J1.Jnt Next Actlltity: Kessler's deposition sch'-~'.Jd~!d f(ir 7!11/iJ(L Fnes & Costs bllied to date: CAY Time: 28 e $1'1,554.97 (tnru 1/3V6) N~umal1, Kenneth v. Monroe CQ\.mtv ____M....@....<<< CAK.04-&63 Circuit Court 16'h Judge: Jones Oate Flied: 6121/04 Action for damages and to compd County to issue bulldll1g permits Growth ManagemenliPhllnning ReS Current Statu!>: Discovery. Next Activity: Discovery, Foos bUled to date; $2.321:\.92 CAY Time: 5.8 hours Costs: 0.00 Riv~l'\(lew Consultants. In(;, v. Monroe COUl'ltif CAK.05.373 Circuit Court 1611' Judge: Jones Pat,s; Flied: 4/13/05 Cf!S(~ alleqing tortious 1i'1t~rft9r<}nce with contract by airport DBE $ubcontraclot'. Risk Marllilgllmel'ltlAirports/MCSO PJM Current Status: Discovery June Trial continued. Next Activity; Discovery ongoing. Felll> billed to datil: $74~-l.86 CAY Ttme; 4.5 tml1f~; Costs: 0.00 25 Paul, Hll$til'l{,l$ (Bob Freilich 8'. Derek Howard) CoUlns, Tht)rna~ et al v. MOOfQ!L~Q.JJl1tv Clrtuit Court 16 l Judge: Payne Takln;)s action brought by 11 ~Jrovps of pl<'lirMf& Growth Managem~nt!Plal'lnI1l9 CAM.04.379 Date Flied: 11/22/04 fUSS Current Status: Discovery Next Activity; Case managenxmt c(}nf~)rfmCe to be m.set Total Fees hilled to date: $&08,36259 (tl'lru Sla1f)e) CAY Time:! 58.8 hours Costs: $90,3D2.13 Emm~rtJ;t.9'lefl & Greg v. M9nroe Cnl.ll'lt\(. ,~~~ Circuit Court 1Slh Judge: Garcia Inverse condemnation anrJ V(1sted riOi'll:; ectlon. Growth lYl1magementlPlaflning CA P 02-520 Date Filed: 10/2102 RBSIJOS Current Status: 4/1 ~l6, Court dismissed Counts 1 & ;;: iCl ;3 still pending). Next Activity: Court reviewing motion for reconsideration of dismissal. P, H Billing to dale: M&H Bilij"~ to date: CAY Time: 15.5 None $94,/550.5$ as of 10/31/05 Galieli10 ~)( y. ~9.nroe Covolv v. $~t$ of Florida Circuit Court 16 Ju<lge; Payne Inverse condemnation and vested rights action, Grwmh Mllflagement/Plllrmtng , "__ CA K It,H,95 Date Fil.d: 5/21102 RBS Current Status: Tria! preparation. Next Activity; PTC Si22!06; T rjal 5r)l1G & M5i6. fA & H Billing to date; Ptllll, Htlstlngs Billing: CAY TIME; 5f:L5 $54<322.5 thf~1 V25JOB, ~"'>,":" "1 ,,, N' C -.., $~7 '? "^ "N""',,,, I).vv 1)$,,,. ,}, "_.om 26 State of flofid.t~<<Mqnroo County v. GIi1I~A!l Bav Corp. 3006-927 Third DCA Judges: TeA Date FUed: 4i20t6 Petitio!') !looking Writ of Prdlihit!(Hl enjoining Clrcui~ Courtln CA l~ 02-595 tmm exncisitl~l !luUmrity in (1)({;(';SS of Its jurisdiction, Growth Management/Planniog RBS Current Status: Court has made p1ellmlnary wview and invited respon$e prlor 10 delerminlng wh\Jllwr il will issue an .)rder to sh.:lw C:iluse. Next Activity: Galk~(m Bay's R'1SPOf)$li! dll<'1 5115fOfL Billing to {jaw: none. CAY Time: Cd) The Smith l.aw Firm Monroe countll;k f'O$t Bucklev, $.QhUi.l.<<i!OO4!!J-nlgan CAK-95-402 Ckcuit Court 16 ' Judge: Payne Date Filed: 3130J95 Malpractice claim against t'W County's IOrmer en91f\f~erlnl:) firm lor mlllcalcula!lon of pondS ne<:1?issary to (inanc\J il11Pn;\;$mef)t$ to G(mf Sound Road. Engll'l&erlng RBS Current Status: Settled remaining issCl(: Next Activity: Ck)s\~ file once dismissed by Court F~e$ .& Costs billoo to date: $646,991.54 (doesn't include FBSJ lees paid of $28V'45 01) Vernis. & Bowling of the Florida Keys, fI.A. {,t~e.P.rg.n!trtl!i!!>~f.$.W f!,2!'iq1!:1.lnc. v. Monroo County CAK.04.1321 Circuit Court 16 ' Judge: Jones Date Fll&d; 12J10104 Cort roview of ac!bn Invoivlf19 bilurB to oOtwn plat ;.wproval of dod<. subdivision and an improper change oj use 'A'ithout a major or minor conditional use permit $rQWtI1 ManagementfPI!l!1nlng RBS Current StanIs: N<.m(! pending appiNll. 5'1,1 bdnw, Next Activity: Present settlement proposal to soce on 3;1516, FlWS billed to date: $26,87500 Costs: $306.43 27 Key Te~ S. 0, COfl~(l A$~{)(,:. \}, Momo& CQl,lJ:\tx.ffi..1.Jvl$GarfY_ CAi<..!:'4.224 Circuit CO\,lrt 1a'h Judge: JQflea Oat~ FlhHi: 31211)4 ActlOf? %0 pre'14$f'lt County -from denyi,ng peHr:~n:$ beC8US€ of t)Y';t:e.t:shjp c.6rrverS.10t) to ccndominiurns and com;ull County j,) ac'~~pt pam,i! appiiwHcns Growth l'.hlf1~gemef1tfPiafll'l!ng ReS CtIlTant Status: Motion 10 dismiss pending; settlement dlscw3Sions ongomg. Next Aetil/ity: A:.vmt 1\llifl(J of lhe court Fees bWed to date: $32.2':'10.50 Costs: $2,MO 84 Q1lllom. J~ft'y",J~g.l1rnfL Count~_.__ .._.___._._.._.___._....__._._.....__.g.1~,f.~.~.Q4:.564 Circuit Court 16 Judge: Garda Datl'! Filed: 11/24104 'l of2 certiorari PBtiliOI'lS cllaHel'lg't1U development approval of NorthBt8f project Growth MlIlnagement/Plarming RBS Current Status: Court dani.xl petltlon !2i'!.4!OS. N~x! Activity: None Mmdin(j <'lppeat Fees billed to date: $14,OJ9S0 Costs; $261A9 OSbOHl, Jeff II, Momoe County _~__<<<___< Third DCA Judg~s: TBA Certiomri 3;>p0<~1 of C/\ P (14.SB4 on Nortflst<Jf Pg.lject. Growth Manal!~mel'lt!Ptanlllnll 30{H:l..S~ Date filed: 1ft 1ft.l(> V 8. B h$1Kl!ing ReS Current Status: Brieiing Comptele. Next Activity: Awali n.iling of tho Court. Billing l't~Ct\lIVild to date: 50, billings 'fe,r CA P 04.564. Q!tQQm, Jeff v. Monroo County: ~__m.~A.!>~M.{:I65 Circuit Court 161~ Judge: Garcia Pat~ Flied: 11/24!()4 ;{. 012 '.:ertlr.lr,~r! petition~ cha%nging developm.m! (ippIWYl.~i ()f Nmtflstilf pr<:Jjtld. Growth l\IIanagt'lnentfPlanning RaS Current Statu$>: Oral <lrgwy,ent held ~2j16/05< Next Activity: }\Wilit deciSIon 01 (;0;;11. Foas bllled to {lt1te: $3.920t,O C';lstS: $~46.fn 2H Asslgnvd AS\listant COllnty AUOnlny PJM '" Pedro M<lifGado JDS '" J\'MY Sanders RBS m Bob ShiHin90r 29