Loading...
Item D10 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY Meeting Date: June 21. 2006 Division: Florida Keys Marathon Airport Bulk Item: Yes ----K- No Department: Florida Keys Marathon Airport Staff Contact Person: 1. Reggie Paros . AGENDA n,'El\t1 WORDL"IG: Approval to negotiate with FedEx GlOund Package Systt:m, Inc. (F edEx) regarding a property lease at Florida Keys Marathon IT'~''\./r n:.ir'k"I~ll()F'\Jn. '!J,-p':f""tl" pprlPv Ip~"p<;l "n:J("p. Inr,:Jl'pn {)n lhp ('()mmprri::ll J'lnrnn!r~mn M lhp .............~'I'..... .-...--------- -...... "'-" .... ...-...-...........,J, -- ---...... ....--....-.., ....r--- ------- --- ..--- --......-------- -r- .....-- ---r -- ......-- ,,"'____ _.......L TT_________ ~_..:I'W':I__1___ ___...&._______ .LL~_ _~.L_ _~...J L__ _______L_...J ..l.:L_ _~__-L'_ _..J__~_~_...__......:__ _L___..... nLlPVll.. J.J.V\ln;;\lliJl, .l'IiJUl,jA UGO) VULOlV\lVU LU1~ ~UIiJ auu ua;) applva\JUIiJU LUIiJ (I.11PVIL ;) aUUlUU;)UaUVU aUVUL the possibility of relocating to another larger site on the airport; the existing site would then become available once again for use by commercial air carriers serving the airport. There is an undeveloped area approximately 240' X 120' on the eastern end of the airport between a detentionlretention pond and the Sheriff's Hangar which is available for possible lease to FedEx. A Fair Market Value Appraisal has been obtained for the site in preparation of this agenda item and is attached hereto. PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: BOCC granted approval of a Lease Agreement with FedEx Ground Package System, Inc. on March 19, 2003. CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: nla STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Approval to negotiate with FedEx for the above referenced piece of property based on the appraisal. TOTAL COST: nla BUDGETED: Yes No COST TO COUNTY: SOURCE OF FUNDS: REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes nla. No AMOUNTPERMONTH_ Year DIVISION DIRECTOR APPROVAL: OMBl1'urchasing -.nfL,_ Risk Management nla i >~! ~~:>,-/ / / l / /_'// C' ~~.,~ . '7 ,~;:- -)ames R '"Re~ic;~P::s o/~~ (J (." /' APPROVED BY: County Atty ~ DOCUMENTATION: Included X_ Not Required_ DISPOSITION: AGENDA ITEM # Revised 2/05 ~+- '-- .un ~._- : "'OIIOOld '.....lNnD::J 3DIONDV'i san ~ ..J - ,., -1- .Ll::!Odl:H'\I' NOH.L '\I'1::!'\I'1., SA3~ '\1'011::101.::1 '~m"__ 8 Ol": - o. I -. "'OIIOOi~3~5)~~?j~~g!lNO~ /" IT [1'\ l.I,1 , - ~. .oi. .- .n.. . ~ (e .133HS) .1 -- j! gr-....: ~:! 1-. --. -.. ~.. . 'll I __Yn I NV'd '13~" DNIC'lna ! .....lNnO:) dO QIO'lf08 ", t . " ! ! l.K.I ~ .....~ ~ ~ l.,.,..."u.lI - .< - " s..........:.. " lJ 0 ~ (I:;l!:fl;f ~:!l:.!:d: .~ i ~ ~ '- :~ '\ , I, ... -7 .I " , " , .._. ij r~\'~'~'o"1FL:<:.~.~,...,".:,f..~.-, :2f<...,f...~ ",. ~ y t~, ..,..__:....f'~:~..~,-:,',,'.;,.,'!-~,~ii ~ :,/ ~ ':~';;,""'- ,: .~ ' i:i ~::: ~'Ji,i -I ~p' '-''' '-'''' /t.,. ..... fii:,:: _ ,:::: - ~ ~t=%/:, --._- I -._.._ fl'::~ ~ :,1 :':/ :,?':: ,~ "-.--. "-. ::::~~:~~ .__.~.: j L' ,! .~ .._~~.<--.. j!~) ~'J..i~7 :::--."i ~ /0/ -___~-_--,I~) ,.~ i// I'I~I~~J-~~"""""""";/h'/ r:ll, ~ ,""", """ [~~'~A .'VA 1 iJ\',fc"i'A~<{&;;~~~ ~ ---'l"',..,-----'II ff:BL' J ---, I " , , / II~~ < L I' IIIfYj "'; , Ilf~ i' ", ~ .~ ~ri;i ili ;~YI r i em II !i~ ~~\ I~.~ ','\\: : ';'::; ,-;-1.\ I j: K;\':~I c, ~'~-~<,.Ifr:-.."..I.I,I:,I!II: "',I; i :_l_L: :i~ i l.'~~-~ r - 'n :.:"<. ~:~jf'\ O<SJ ~ (~,:\: jli~"~ r"~;' ~-T1:i:~{; .:,t~~::-~:',...,I,II Ii ~ ", 11:1 I ':' II )~, I' ,':~!i/:' ~=~t'~~I'I;I:I- Ir 'II'~ Il~Lllst,I;~q~liml,;':~,II' \1, ~ 1">1 ,~ ,.~, 'on 11 I" 'I ~q" 1\':\ ~ ';,II~'; f:! ":'{~~~i;:I{I'>~<':~'" ~i li.:.ll i~! --..>.:,."> 1:,;;:.:1 ~ Ilil i' I': ';'/'I! . \ f ,: I ". \ hi,01'1) ',I iW,Yt;' L [1-1 ,di;':!!::!!:] I'li~~ i !:!j, !! H,?" Ii, ::j'- t ' ("I' :",,"':1 1 ~ ) !:l~ II' il':'-'/~'" I 'I i<:, y' "~,,l ;:;-.:',;':(;:i ~ :, ~~ 'I II -!:"_:E::i', ", <~;:!i~' il;~ ):)-! I ' ii >, ',,~J-.~~!; _ ~I J .::, ..'s: ~ <:I I '~ :;Sj , :'8: UQL Ilfj':-' '!8';' H If :(~[} : ~i' , : ci 0 ~--.'~ , :J ~ :~ : ~-;:-J ! lill I' , ...:.i..::.. ? ~ ~ .",: :-', J ~ ~ ~ :: ..:.. ~ S :? :;: ;:, ~ "' '.. l......l.......__ ..., :Jj < L.i:: ~ iHH ~ ::Q ;:;. ~ I ..:. . .~-::!f) APPRAISAL / CERTIFIED / SERVICES IN~~':::~,g~ ,~ 'P' ..< "'" ,. ,. '~""-':'''-::'-'~::r:''.~'~'''''':"~~-''::-:I:':~~~-r~'JflT'''"-."';t....~_.., ALAN G. SCHMITT, AS A, GAA STATE CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAISER # RZ 0000933 ags@schmittappraisals.com www.schmittappraisals.com CERTIFIED APPRAISALS COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL, CONDOMINIUM & VAC fJI:~morada Key We"'- MR. JAMES R. P AROS (289-6002) MARATHON AIRPORT MANAGER 9400 OVERSEAS HWY. SUITE 200 MARATHON, FLA.33050 DEARMR. PAROS: IN COMPLIANCE WITH YOUR REQUEST I HAVE EXAMINED & VALUED THE PROPOSED "FUTURE CORPORATE HANGER" LAND LOCATED AT MARATHON AIRPORT AS INCLUDED IN MONROE COUNTY REAL ESTATE PARCEL #104500 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLA. TO DETERMINE FAIR MARKET VALUE OF THE LAND AND TO RECOMMEND A VALUE FOR A FAIR LEASE/RENTAL. BASED ON MY INSPECTION OF SUBJECT & INFORMATION PROVIDED BY YOU, MARVIN SCHINDLER, MONROE COUNTY, AIRPORT PERSONNEL & IN COMPLIANCE WITH USP AP GUIDELINES & FIRREA REQUIREMENTS DOCUMENTED HEREIN, I HAVE DETERMINED: VALUE OF VACANT LAND TO BE LEASED $ DEPRECIATED V ALUE OF BUILDING: $ TOTAL VALUE:------------------------------------- $ MONTHL Y LEASE/RENT:--------------------- $ 388,800. N/A. 388,800. 3,888. 24INC bY, // <--..- ~'" ~:~ ALAN G. SCHMITT, ASA GAA STATE/CERT/GEN RZ933 DATE SIGNED: 8 MAY 2006 RECEIVED MAY - 9 2006 BY: 11100 OVERSEAS HWV, SUITE 200, MARATHON, FLORIDA 33050.305 - 289-1221. FAX 305 - 289-7381 PURPOSE & USE OF APPRAISAL: TO ESTIMATE THE FAIR MARKET VALUE IN FEE SIMPLE INTEREST OF THE FOLLOWING DESCRIBED LAND, 8 MA Y 2006. SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING FACTS & ASSUMPTIONS: MONROE COUNTY IS OWNER OF LAND & CHAINLINK FENCE. COUNTY IS CONSIDERING LEASING A 120' X 240' PORTION OF LAND TITLED "FUTURE CORPORATE HANGER" TO A 2ND PARTY. TYPICALLY COUNTY LEASES STATE THAT IMPROVEMENTS MADE BY TENANT BECOME COUNTY PROPERTY UPON COMPLETION OF CONSTRUCTION. ADDRESS, LEGAL DESCRIPTION & COUNTY RECORD I.D.: FUTURE CORPORATE HANGER OVERSEAS HIGHWAY MARATHON, FLORIDA .33050. GENERAL DESCRIPTION: A FENCED, VACANT PARCEL OF LAND BEING 120' X 240' = 28,800 SIF. LOCATED BETWEEN SHERIFF'S HANGER & DETENTION/RETENSION POND AT THE SE CORNER OF MARATHON FLIGHTSTRIP IN REAL ESTATE PARCEL # 104500, ALT KEY # 1122114 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA. SUBJECT TO TYPICAL UTILITY EASEMENT, BY PRESCRIPTIVE USE, OR COUNTY/CITY REGULATION. TAX INFORMATION: MONROE COUNTY 2005 REAL ESTATE TAXES: EXEMPT. MONROE COUNTY ASSESSMENT2005:--------LAND $1,316,250.(45cents @ SIF) BLDGS $ 2,034,128.($53.03@SIF) MISC $ 291,114. 2005 TOTAL ASSESSED V ALUE--------------------------- $ 3,641,492. OWNER OF RECORD: MONROE COUNTY FLIGHTSTRIP 500 WHITEHEAD STREET KEY WEST, FLA. 33040 ZONING: MONROE COUNTY ZONED: AD. CITY OF MARATHON FUTURE LAND USE MAP, PANEL 2, ZONED: AIRPORT. MONROE COUNTY FIRST ADOPTED ZONING IN 1960. CURRENT COUNTY WIDE LAND USE PLAN WAS ADOPTED 9/86, UPDATED 7/92, WITH 2010 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ADOPTED 1/96. FIVE YEARS PRIOR TO INCORPORATION, (11/99), MARATHON WAS SUBJECT TO A COMMERCIAL BUILDING MORATORIUM. IN JUNE 2004 THE MORATORIUM WAS REPLACED BY A RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCE (COMMERCIAL ROGO) WHICH ALLOWS 239 SIP OF NEW COMMERCIAL SPACE PER EACH NEW RESIDENTIAL UNIT BUILT. THERE IS APPROX. 30,000 S/F OF COMMERCIAL SPACE TO BE ALLOCATED. THE MAXIMUM ALLOCATION PER YEAR TO ONE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY IS 6,000 S/F. SUBJECT IS OWNED BY MONROE COUNTY & CURRENTLY NOT OCCUPIED. THE HIGHEST & BEST USE OF SUBJECT IS AIRCRAFT RELATED. COMMERCIAL ROGO IS THE RESULT OF THE MONROE COUNTY LAND USE PLAN OF SEPT/86 AS AMENDED 7/92 & SUBSEQUENTLY, WHICH TIES NEW & REMODEL COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION PERMITS TO A RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCE, BASED ON THE CARRYING CAPACITY OF VARIOUS INFRASTRUCTURE, SUCH AS INGRESS/EGRESS ROAD CARRYING CAPACITY, HURRICANE EV ACUA TION TIME & UTILITY & SEWAGE AVAILABILITY, AMONG OTHER RESTRICTIONS. INSURANCE AND FEMA FLOOD HAZARD DATA: ALMOST ALL OF MONROE COUNTY IS LOCATED IN A FEMA SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA. MONROE COUNTY PARTICIPATES IN THE NATIONAL FLOOD INSURANCE PROGRAM AND IS COVERED BY A REGULAR, NOT EMERGENCY PROGRAM. SUBJECT WITHIN FLOOD ZONE: "AE",AS DESCRIBED ON FIRM MAP #12087C-1581K. CITY OF MARATHON COMMUNITY #120681, DATED 2/18/05. CENSUS TRACT: SUBJECT IS LOCATED IN 2000 U.S.CENSUS TRACT #9713, WITH NO MSA's. UTILITIES, SEWAGE, TRASH DISPOSAL: AVAILABLE IN BERM OF ROAD: ELECTRICITY: FLA. KEYS ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE. 220V. 3 PHASE WATER: FLA. KEYS AQUEDUCT AUTHORITY STATE OF FLA. CORP. SEWAGE: CITY SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT. TRASH DISPOSAL: BY A LOCAL FEE CONTRACTOR, FOR COMMERCIAL TRASH REMOVAL, WITH FEES BILLED MONTHLY. EASEMENTS AND ENCROACHMENTS: TYPICAL UTILITY EASEMENTS BY PRESCRIPTIVE RIGHT, NO DETRIMENT TO VALUE. NO ENCROACHMENTS VISIBLY APPARENT. SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHBOUND SIDE OF U.S. HIGHWAY NO. 1 AT MILE MARKER 52.5 WITHIN INCORPORATED CITY OF MARATHON FACING THE SOUTHBOUND LANE OF PAVED 4 LANE, DIVIDED U.S. HIGHWAY NO.1, ILLUMINATED BY QUARTZ STREET LIGHTS. ACCESS TO SUBJECT CURRENTLY VIA SERVICE ROAD TO PERIMETER CHAIN-LINK FENCE. SITE DESCRIPTION: SUBJECT CONSISTS OF ONE PARCEL OF U.S. HIGHWAY NO. 1 FRONTAGE, BEING 120' WIDE BACKING 240' TO MARATHON FLIGHT STRIP, CONTAINING 28,800 S/F OF LAND. ACCESS ROAD, NOT INCLUDED. PROPERTY IS LEVEL AND ABOVE GRADE OF THE DEDICATED U.S. HIGHWAY NO. 1. NEIGHBORHOOD DATA: SUBJECT IS LOCATED AT APPROX. 52.5 MILE MARKER, IN THE INCORPORATED CITY OF MARATHON, A CENTER OF COMMERCE. MARATHON'S COMMERCIAL CENTER IS A "LINEAR" CITY THAT STRETCHES FROM U.S. # 1 MILE MARKER 45 TO APPROXIMATE MILE MARKER 60. THIS AREA INCLUDES BANKS, HOSPITAL, DOCTORS OFFICES, RESTURANTS, SUPER MARKETS, LOCAL RETAILERS & MARATHON AIRPORT. THE ATLANTIC AND GULF WATERFRONTAGE IS IMPROVED WITH MOSTL Y SINGLE F AMIL Y HOMES, DUPLEXES, AND CONDOMINIUMS. THE AREA IS DEVOTED TO TOURISM, SPORT FISHING AND AN ACTIVE RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOUSED IN MOSTL Y WATERFRONT WINTER HOMES APPEALING TO FINANCIALLY ABOVE AVERAGE NORTHERN BUYERS. DESCRIPTION OF THE IMPROVEMENTS: SUBJECT PROPERTY IS CLEARED, CHAINLINK FENCED & LEVEL. DISCUSSION OF THE APPRAISAL PROBLEM: THE PURPOSE OF THIS APPRAISAL IS TO DETERMINE THE FAIR MARKET VALUE IN FEE SIMPLE INTEREST OF THE LAND & PROVIDE ESTIMATE OF MONTHL Y LEASE RENTAL. TO ESTIMATE FAIR MARKET VALUE, A DETERMINATION OF HIGHEST & BEST USE IS REQUIRED. HIGHEST & BEST USE: IN ORDER TO DETERMINE HIGHEST & BEST USE THE APPRAISER HAS CONSIDERED THOSE USES THAT ARE LEGALL Y PERMISSIBLE, PHYSICALL Y POSSIBLE, ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE & FINANCIALLY, MAXIMALLY PRODUCTIVE & IN ACCORDANCE WITH FAA RELATED USE. AS IF VACANT: THE PROPERTY IS CLEARED & LEVEL.THE LIMITED NUMBER OF AIRPORT SITES, COUPLED WITH CITY/COUNTY YEAR 2010 LAND USE PLAN, SITE IS VACANT & AVAILABLE, THEREFORE THE HIGHEST & BEST USE WOULD BE AIRPORT RELATED. THE PRINCIPAL PURPOSE OF THE AIRPORT LAND USE CATEGORY IS TO PROVIDE FOR PRIVATE, COMMERCIAL & GOVERNMENT USE TO ENHANCE THE ECONOMIC, HEALTH & WELFARE OF THE RESIDENT POPULATION & THE VISITORS TO THE FLORIDA KEYS. VARIOUS TYPES OF COMMERCIAL, RETAIL AND GOVERNMENT USES MAY BE PERMITTED AT INTENSITIES WHICH ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE COMMUNITY CHARACTER AND THE NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND TO COMPLY WITH FAA GUIDE LINES. HEAVY INDUSTRIAL AND SIMILARLY INCOMPATIBLE USES ARE PROHIBITED. THE 3 APPROACHES TO VALUE: IN EVALUATING COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES IT IS MANDATORY THAT THE 3 ACCEPTABLE APPROACHES TO VALUE BE EXAMINED, NAMELY: 1) THE COST APPROACH TO VALUE. 2) THE SALES COMPARABLE APPROACH. 3) THE INCOME APPROACH. FINDING VALUES FOR EACH OF THE ABOVE BASED ON CURRENT DATA, ALLOWS RECONCILIATION INTO A FINAL VALUE ESTIMATE. A BUYER WOULD PAY NO MORE FOR AN IMPROVED PROPERTY, THAN THE AMOUNT THAT HE WOULD EXPEND BY PURCHASING A SIMILAR LOCATION AND CONSTRUCTING A SIMILAR BUILDING. IF PERMITTED. COST APPROACH TO VALUE: THIS APPROACH TO VALUE IS BASED ON THEORY THAT BUILDING NEW WITH SIMILAR AMENITIES, AND THEN DEPRECIATING THESE NEW IMPROVEMENTS TO EQUATE WITH THE APPRAISAL SUBJECT, WILL YIELD A DISCERNIBLE VALUE. LIKEALL THEORIES THERE ARE FLAWS WITH THIS APPROACH, IN THAT NORMALLY THE TIME TO CONSTRUCT A NEW BUILDING VS: BEING ABLE TO IMMEDIATELY USE THE EXISTING BUILDING IS NOT NORMALLY ADDRESSED. THE PRIOR MORATORIUM ON ALL COMMERCIAL PERMITS, REDUCED NOW TO A RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCE IS CAUSING AN INCREASE IN VALUE OF EXISTING IMPROVED COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES. PART OF THE COST APPROACH IS DETERMINING A VALUE FOR A ~------~-----~~---~~--~----~----~--_. COMPARABLE PORTION OF LAND. THE ONLY METHOD TO ARRIVE AT A LAND VALUE COST IS TO ANALYZE THE MOST RECENT SALES OF VACANT LAND TO DETERMINE THEIR COMPARABILITY. THE FLORIDA KEYS REAL ESTATE MARKET HAS BEEN VERY ACTIVE, AFFECTED BY THE NATIONAL ECONOMY WITH INCREASING SALES AND SHORTER MARKETING TIME, P ARTL Y ATTRIBUTABLE TO LOW INTEREST RATES.. TODA Y'S NEW YORK PRIME IS 7.75%. ESTIMATED MARKETING TIME FOR SUBJECT IS CURRENTLY 6-12 MONTHS. IN ADDITION THE IMPACT OF THE SEPT/1986, AS AMENDED JUL Y/92 COUNTY LAND USE PLAN, MILITATING AGAINST BUILDING IN GENERAL; ESTABLISHING A RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCE FOR RESIDENTIAL,(ROGO); AND NOW SUCCEEDED BY CITY OF MARATHON COMPHREHENSIVE PLAN DATED 3/9/05, CURRENT RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCES, HAVE NEGATIVEL Y AFFECTED THE DESIRE OF AN ENTREPRENEUR TO BUY LAND AND BUILD FOR SPECULATION. FOR THESE REASONS THE SALES OF VACANT COMMERCIALLY ZONED LAND HAS SLOWED. SUBJECT'S ZONING OF "AD" IS LIMITED IN THE FLORIDA KEYS. DEVOTED PRIMARILY TO TOURISM AND BUILDING OF 2ND HOMES FOR POTENTIAL RETIREES, THE USE OF LAND FOR COMMERCIAL PURPOSES WAS VIEWED AS APPROPRIATE TO LARGE SHOPPING CENTERS, SUCH AS PUBLIX OR HOME DEPOT WHERE LARGER ACREAGE TRACTS COULD PROVIDE REQUIRED PARKING, GREEN SPACE, OPEN SPACE RATIOS, AND REQUIRED SETBACKS.THE CITY OF MARATHON IS CONSIDERING LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS PURSUANT TO ESTABLISHING TRANSFERABLE DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS. BECAUSE OF SLOW SALES THE LATEST COMPARABLE SALES MAY INCLUDE ZONINGS, DIFFERENT THAN SUBJECT'S & POSSIBLY OLDER SALES. LAND SALES: VACANT PROPERTY--NO SELLER FINANCING. SUBJECT APPROXIMATE MILE MARKER 52.5 MILE ---SALE------SIZE--- PRICE----- PER SIF -------ZONE MARK DATE SIF 53 8/2005 63,162 $1,150,000. $18.21 MU-COML 52 3/2005 41,220 $ 787,500. 19.10 COM 55 5/2005 72,310 $1,325,000. 18.32 RES SALES OF VACANT COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES IN THIS AREA ARE LIMITED. BECAUSE FOR 5 YEARS PRIOR TO CITY INCORPOATION, 11/99, MARATHON AREA WAS SUBJECT TO A COMMERCIAL BUILDING MORA TORIUM.THE MORATORIUM WAS LIFTED JUNE 2004 & REPLACED BY A RATE OF GROWTH ORDNANCE (COMMERCIAL ROGO) WHICH IS BASED ON ALLOWING 239 SIP OF NEW COMMERCIAL SPACE PER EACH NEW RESIDENTIAL UNIT BUILT. CURRENTLY THERE IS APPROXIMATELY 30,000 SIF OF SPACE AVAILABLE TO BE ALLOCATED. THE MAXIMUM ALLOCATION PER YEAR TO ONE COMMERCIAL PROPERTY IS 6,000S/F. FEW COMPARABLE SALES OF VACANT LAND IS REFLECTIVE OF THE EFFECT OF THE CONSTRUCTION MORATORIUM. A BUYER MUST EITHER PROVE CONCURRENCY IN A VESTED RIGHTS HEARING OR BE WILLING TO PURCHASE EXISTING SQUARE FOOTAGE AND BY GENTRIFICATION AVOID COMMERCIAL LIMITATION. ENTREPENUERS ARE RELUCTANT TO RISK TIME & MONEY ON AN UNCERTAIN PERMIT PROCESS DISCUSSION OF COMPARABLE FACTORS: PRIVATE SECTOR SALES HAVE VARIOUS ZONINGS AND ARE VACANT PARCELS & INDICATE A VALUE OF APPROX. $18@ SIP FOR PRIVATE SECTOR PROPERTIES. SUBJECT'S USE IS TYPICALLY LIMITED TO AVIATION RELATED PURPOSES BY FEDERAL FAA REGULATIONS, QUALIFYING AS A SPECIAL USE PROPERTY. IN THIS CASE PROPOSED USAGE IS LAND BASED, NOT AVIATION RELATED, CAUSING SUBJECT TO BE PARTIALLY CONSIDERED FOR PRIVATE SECTOR VALUATION. PRIVATE SECTOR VALUE OF UPLAND S/F OF 28,800 SIP @ $18.00--= $518,400. MONROE COUNTY HAS PROMULGATED LAND RENTAL RATES & CHARGES FOR YEAR 2006 AT MARATHON AIRPORT, NOTING THAT IMPROVEMENTS MADE BY TENANT REVERT TO COUNTY OWNERSHIP. MARATHON AIRPORT PROMULGATED RENTAL RATES: LAND ONLY. GENERAL A VIA TION------------- $ .35 @S/F @YEAR (GUIDE LINE) COUNTY LEASED PROPERTY--$1.08 @SIP@YEAR+REVERSION COUNTY ASSESSED VALUE $.45 @S/F 28,800 S/F X $.35 YIELDS: ---------$10,080.@ YR. 28,800 S/F X $1.08 YIELDS:--------$ 31,104.@ YR DIVIDED BY 12 = $ 2,592.@ MONTH +REVERSION COMP ARABLE SALES APPROACH TO VALUE. THE THEORY UNDERLYING THIS APPROACH TO VALUE IS THAT SIMILAR PROPERTIES WITH SIMILAR AMENITIES AND APPEAL HAVE BEEN PURCHASED BY INFORMED BUYERS WHO HAVE NEGOTIATED WITH INFORMED SELLERS, NEITHER UNDER DURESS AND THUS HAVE ESTABLISHED A DISCERNIBLE MARKET PRICE, THAT, WITH ADJUSTMENTS FOR DIFFERENCES BETWEEN SUBJECT AND COMP ARABLES, MAY YIELD A MARKET VALUE INDICATION OF SUBJECT. SUBJECT IS COUNTY OWNED AND LIMITED BY FEDERAL A VIA TION AUTHORITY, (F AA) REGULATIONS. FOR THIS REASON THE COMPARABLE SALES APPROACH WAS EXAMINED BUT NOT USED. COMP ARABLE SALES APPROACH TO V ALUE:-------------------NOT USED. THE INCOME APPROACH TO VALUE: THE THEORY BEHIND THE INCOME APPROACH TO VALUE IS: WHAT IS THE VALUE TO AN INVESTOR? THE AMOUNT PAID FOR A COMMERCIAL INCOME PROPERTY CAN BE MEASURED BYTHE AMOUNT OF GROSS INCOME A PROPERTY WILL PRODUCE, LESS THE EXPENSES; HOW SECURE THE INCOME STREAM WILL REMAIN OVER THE NEAR TERM; AND WHAT COMPETING INVESTMENTS ARE PRODUCING, IN PROVIDING THE INVESTOR WITH AS GUARANTEED A STEADY INCOME AS CAN BE PROVIDED BALANCED WITH THE DEGREE OF RISK. TODA Y 4 TO 5% IN PROTECTED SECURE ACCOUNTS CAN BE HAD AT BANKS, AND PROVIDE THE INVESTOR WITH INSTANT LIQUIDITY. NEW YORK PRIME IS 7.75%. MUTUAL FUNDS COMPETE FOR THE INVESTOR'S DOLLAR. COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE MUST PROVIDE A HIGHER RETURN BECAUSE OF A LACK OF GUARANTEES AND LACK OF LIQUIDITY. RECONCILIATION: VALUE: COST APPROACH LAND:SPECIAL USE--------$259,200. VALUE: COST APPROACH LAND:PRIV ATE SECTOR:$518,400. COMBINED VALUE :---------------------------------------------- $777.600. VAL UE AVERAGED :-----------------------------------------------$388,800. ANNUAL LEASE ON VALUE A VERAGED:-----------------$46,656.+REVERSION INDICATED MONTHLY LEASE:-------------------------------$ 3,888. +REVERSION VALUE: COMPARABLE SALES APPROACH:------NOT USED VALUE: INCOME APPROACH:--------------------------NOT USED BECAUSE OF THE SPECIAL USE OF SUBJECT & THE REVERSION OF ANY IMPROVEMENT'S VALUE TO THE LESSOR, THE MOST RELIABLE BASIS FOR AN ESTIMATE OF VALUE & ACCORDED MOST WEIGHT IN ARRIVING AT FINAL VALUE ESTIMATE IS THE RECONCILED APPROACH. IN MY OPINION THE FAIR MARKET VALUE OF THE DESCRIBED LAND GENERATING $46,656 ANNUALLY DIVIDED BY CAPITALIZATION RATE OF 12% YIELDS --------------------------------------------------------------------$388,800. IN AN ATTEMPT TO KEEP THE APPRAISAL FEE TO A REASONABLE MINIMUM, AND WITHOUT IMP AIRING THE INTEGRITY OF THIS APPRAISAL, AREA, NEIGHBORHOOD, FLORIDA KEYS & STATE OF FLORIDA DATA HAS EITHER PREVIOUSL Y BEEN SUBMITTED TO THIS CLIENT IN OTHER APPRAISALS, OR IS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST FROM OUR FILES. THIS APPRAISAL IS SUBJECT TO THE LIMITING CONDITIONS ATTACHED, AND TO FACTS THAT AN ACCURATE LOCATION, SETBACK AND ELEVATION SURVEY MIGHT DISCLOSE. smc~ ALAN G. SCHMITT, AS A, GAA SIGNED 3 MAY 2006 STATE CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAISER # RZ933. .-., :"-"..~~'-:~.0~!~k~ ;.~~::. , - ' -~~:.. .'t :.F.:~.-.T. :<.~.~~~.:~:.'i.?:::7"::"~':"::'::~~:-:'!:.>;:'-~.:.. ,~.. -, . .- ...,., ,. - ,.. ,.,.,.~ ..;'\~.y...<../"~~""'.~-~(~."'....::"'.~.. ,'~,:,,"~" .-. ,..).-,~,"!,,,,,.^,,,,,,,,,,,.~ . -. ,.' TOFA TSA --.. ., - - - ~ - ~ . - .. ,.. .. ~ - ..... ~. - :m '-'-U'), ~._:'-IIII""I. f.~ - -'-- '" ,. - --. .. - - . . - - .. ..- - . . ~ . - -. ~ ..~.. FUTURE CORPORATE ....~.. . .. TSA HANGAR TOrA RESEI FUTU STOR DETE! RlmS'.,-: &':':MANciAR. .::: . . r__ . -. - . ).::~:\ -: ,<:{ ~ :;;::. :.: -.: --:: - -. roO--J. ir ! I I . "'" ., + +- +- +- +- +.. :+- + .... + .... + + ~ + + ..... +-.... ~ .. +- + + +- + +- +- +1 ~ ... +- .. + + ... +- .. + +- + ... ~ I + .... +D+ + + .... +- Q .... + +- + +- .. .. .. T + ~.. ~ ". T +...... + +.... .... . +- ... + DW ... ... + +- + OW. ... .. .. ... + . +- .... +- .... .... + + +- .. .. .. .. .. .. + + + .. + .. .. l' ... . r ~., _ . .. . . , " - . - - -. . ~. --. -- -- ,--' ,,--' ,--..' ,--' ,---' ,..--..J I.- ,,--' r--' ,---' ,--J ,,---' ,---J l t I ..-DETEN1l0NjRETENTlON POND- ,-oJ ,,--' ,---' "...--' ,....--J .--' -.... ,.-' ~:o; ,...-J ,--' ,---' ,---J "......-' ,--' r--' ~ ,--- "....--' :o~--'--'~ ,--...' ,---J STORM INLET ~ ,-.-I ,.--- .--- ,-- ,--J ,-.J ,-.J ,....-' .---' ,--J ,....-J "....--' ,.-' r-' ,--' ~ .,--' ,--' ,--' ,--' r--' ~ ~ - - - --, 'J I -. ~; ~ ~, I ! I ~ ,:I~I , ., ',';::I I I II I I . ~ ilU I , " : ,: . ""'.t./"} -'--~'~----JU I~!!'::::I:-~>_.#...il:'/~~Ii'rl"-ft-r" I .'1' :\\/'111 II ". Ii ~ I ,/ ,,-, /1', I' J. , " Ii I' I .: ) /,,-,' ----- _/ ' .> 1 U ~ 'III ,~ . iltl":K-- H : 5 ,'fr -< I !llllll ............--~' ---- ~ ~'It J .II~ .111{i~!; : I ~~'llil': lit -'J '~r,::: ~ ~ >} V I ,"< 0: 'I .;;' ~i' ~ ii!!i~~~'~ rtwL' LL -Li;iJJ~! '11'i;1 ~ I ~_ _ -"~, ~J ,'J I' S ~ ,,--:-'!!' Ilrli:n~~~~ _ (~'III~~I !J:'~-- -~j,~ I\~ ),!III-I ~ . ~ ,~ ' ,_ ::-''o...~ -jll ~ 1".1 ~_m' .. "~.s-..--._ u'i :~: '--;. -.J I't" :' :'1::, :1: 'I ' , '11' "--., .,$: -- - . . -:- - '0:;;:::"''' I I'" ; '. -- :::: i:::' '" ", " I' ,- '\ -----... -- i!ll.1 ~~:-1> -" ': -I .""". I .: '.~ ' 'X' 11",'11 'i~~~ ~i - i "- ~ Jiii!il'![U I I ~ ;~I'i .', t "'il: ( - \. ~~~~ Iii; II 0 ~~i U~' i fH}rr~:;i!.'1 i ,. 'i; jll i ~ :;i!~ " II' ~-..'~~" ,'if,;, ' !~' 1'/...:, ~, I I ',/ ~~~~ i/iJp oG'-~'-: ~]I"I:I '1\ ~!~i,' L:..+', :di,'11 ~~~f, 1'lr'J:'~'?I- ~ t /,1! ~ ,: _ ,~'~/( I i, I "i,I' ,ii, ,ilL," _ I 0 ,,__~ "1'1'/ I I ' \.. I, , II I' ., ,;; 1.8 I, I (',~-I ....... ~' il I ~--:-' ~ I ~i~~::' ~ ~ \,'<'~-;~i~::-;'I: I "q ~!" l :'R;--- ~~(~'J~~~~c ! !\f:-'~'! r "-- . ~;",', --- ~~':". ; I;. i !~ ;l~ ;-~r !~~~ I' 1 ~ -\:'I! 11ilJII . IY~! ~;~' ,~~' (flf ) I II i; / il! ,; ~ '\:'] ~Il\ ill; ~::~:~)I~:l/J\j i I 'I! ir: ~,:', ~I"." i,' 1111111 ,~I 0 {I ", I, -:' ~ ,l.. -...', 'r I I' 'U it! I ,~~ , g 61 j1/if~;:~U~::,~$'jI;h~-~~ ~~I;;;,\EITtril ;~ - ,1/iff~.,,' !l i>l;~ll!! ,ii I ;Ii C '- ---1 Ii ;~~~ I r' . - ,fEB1i:';:':',; -II ~ ,- .-~-~~j '~-~---I '---';/>1!i ;IT.~:w!~~ll ;:1 Ii II_;J:_,-J_ =-=-U:;_i;gJ~ i 1-- -- -\ / ( ~'"' :; \! '~ "--"~..._____~, ~~ '~!:!..--::I I _____ ,I~ , II i' ?;~ - a~,;~ --; ~r~'~~ - -:~ i/'{~~~;:---] - -~~~:~~--':_'il I ')'-.. {l}'f''" <itI1lf /NJi.: ~ l!:"~,' ". I . ~ I / (~,.," - i"----- ---.,- --..______.... ~i; !I~ ,-- ~~i~J -";,:/;1" i ,,/ /~ L ~ ).;~ I ~~,-,:---1 -; i' ______________.-,:~ ; ~ -- ~'~/l,'- _J /' ~ r :;- .' ,I;~~ r ii' ~ '~~~:;)~');'0'-- __ ,iSi;i}.:/,.i/ - ~-;/ ili2w~: :, '. I ~~' ~;",. ~ I...J" 'qij' " !1iW "fJ ;--",-, ----. .! . --<J '" " ~-' ~ ,:,: iJ2 ;;,' :.'" '-'----.: ,/ JiJ 7; "" .P ':: : I ;' r,a :';i I' 00' i:' _ i - --;:;----...:-1 '----- G,' r !JjtP "\ I' ~ :' ur :';;;,' :~iJ' :~/. : - 0-_ ------_ JJf ~I ,I~..u: ~ I~. . _'. \1 ~~-..., .......... ~ I '-. ~ ::, "., .1ft{G '~; -'. . ''"'''_n_. ------.... c,/;:~ ' 'I I~i~' /!;}~ I!!!L c. if rigl~; J' I~_ \0 .--- .--- ------... 'If --, ~I F<[~rUEN:IAL :' .I \. J'1a I \J I ~D ( ~ " A ~ :: ~~ gDD"f/' ~ ~_ . __l;U A,~~; _ ~no~ ~ ?h, '''6 It 3- 7c?/~ I......"'ag.,= <;CJ' 7L~ '" ~ "\ ~v-v--v-~~ ~_--...-- _._ ,--- v'- G.- ~---------~F,I \. \~ 120.00r I '- '- - ------.---<---:::.= - L - - -- i -)- I , ~---<''- - -- -. -'-.." _. -~. - I, ' I" _ I / ,,---- -- ~- '- - __n_ _~ _' '~ " I , I '" ~~"' --'- ~ _ '{ I 23 ;r,~JI ER _ ---....._ ''-..-' '_ _ , 'I PARK"iG l , ? ~;; ~i 1- '-=-~"'-- . 3 J ! } i ; -I ~'~ Ty'-== =-= - r- -- ' I' ) ~- --.L J' - ~". ,;JJi ir- - -~i" "0"" '1 ; f I I -----~,~ I--~""'J ( _ _ __ __ __. ~~ -"--'.~'. _.J ( _ _ _. ' 1___- "" _, / , I ',: i--..--",- _.A.. /-" , ' i ~~: -'1 ",I 2 _ __ i-'_ I __ _ _, i,l (. -- - -!J ; ~.~ -v--.,/~-"" ",i ~.._'~ .1= =c=,-_: ~:g , ') I' ; (5, ______, ''f ~I ) u~~ ~r" -. ----::;-1 ('J~" Ii:; <! 1 .1: ~ :' - - - " I " :. 'I " .-\.....~-".... - -t-'~ :"i)J --<"\...-^<:-- - - , '--\-, I i. l-,j .~ 'I I r - --~t-- ! j I I foe -- ~-01 )~' I 1_' ~..~- --.. > I !) ~ I I'~~":""- / ~ :~;":":~~~J. /.""11\1. .1C :~ :~':,:,,;g I I I I >-7~. ~ j :::i:~ ~: 8""":; _I ~~ [" J \ "'- - 'i 1 ~ ~,,=--"--".. . , -. ~ -~......._~ ~6l~)' i ---. . '-~ ~~ ~'~~~( ,~:t~":~~~'~,,~r,~fif. -.....'.. __~L- -.:::-'::~~ -~. . V 'v" -..- '-- i HWY #1 1 f... '~., ";.~ ...""'=:' 12..0 Prepared for: Appraisal/Certified/Services, Inc, (305) 289-1221 e www.interfloocl.com · 1~800-252-6633 10701 Marathon. Fla_ 33050 - .'..'. I ~~~C~F~1~jm~:',': , .- "."'- ~ ~ ~. , . - . . , ~ ,--oJ _ : . .. & ~',. , , ~ .- "<....., '^<~IJ~'~".6~\:~~;:~::: ~~}~~'~.~~.>'>>t;L:~>:.>>: , ~ Y'~l' 'l.<;~~:'l~'y': ~ .~"~ \~~I~titv;>>>.~< .:..:. ~~ ~-<.:+ /'~~~,." ~\.'.: , " y ~ ,. ..' .',\ ~ ::.,: . \~~>:~:-'~:~~CI<';"~: ~,:.;:"",~., ~(~' ,'(; \'i::,~,'.\-';;, ?-'~"'''11 :.: ;./ '.', <->'/' ";':~"'::~:<:::':~:ji':': ,,' '("....~........,/ '.o.>oIIl. --..<<..~~~.---:.-...', _ L ~,.-l.j , ~~,~~~--~~~_.__~~~_ .:',.. :';_:'>\{ I FLQODSCAPE ,. ~)., ~ ",' Effective Date February 18. 2005 ,(j( mo". ;n f ormation about flood .O""e< lln<l flood il'>$\ll"aoo... C o"uct , POOIeI"ed by Flood SOOrcoll an,77fLODO 1l.1I..l,JW _11ood:!oorc~ .c-orn ~~~~--..........,......,.---~---"" ", "'. ~ :;'.J:~"?~:. (:':~... ~;::-'"':"~':'...)~.~~~t .:;~,.~:~,; @I1\lQIjJ.'100l:'J SO\ll'e@rronl ~r>dJar ,!llodS'><J~& C<:>rpal'3tiOfl$ JlII rights lu~",~d. P"""'nt:S" 6,631.325 and 6.678.61~ Other p3t~I"ll$ p&l1dil'lg. ,of (nfo: ;l\fo@!llC>odsoure..com (f;5\ RATES & CHARGES 2006 Commence '1/1/06 3.0% M~;:[tr~~Jyt~~(~j ({Jl.)_lb~ '] MARATHON AIRPORT TERMINAL PUBLICLY EXPOSED SPACE 28.79 ISO. FT./YEAR 797.63 IMONTH MINIMUM NON-PUBLIC SPACE 19.43 ISO. FT./YEAR COVERED AREAS & STORAGE 14.03 ISQ. FT./YEAR LANDING FEE .86/1000 LBS. GROSS LANDING WEIGHT - 10.83 MINIMUM FOR 12,500 LBS OR LESS LAND RENTAL RATES AIRLINE 0.46 ISO. FT./YEAR GENERAL AVIATION .35 ISO. FT./YEAR r/ aOiPi../",.,4: COUNTY LEASED PROPERTY (PER 1992 R&C .85) 1.08 /SQ. FT./YEAR FUEL FLOW FEE 0.04 IGALLON UTILITIES 335.06 PER MONTH FBO - ADDITIONAL PROPERTY Rent for unimproved property - 13 cents per sq. foot, per year. Lower rate is offset by fuel flow charge. CPI yearly Buildingslimprovements - tenant will pay County match, 5% - 50%. Upon completion all improvements become County property IBEV 12/1/05 Q iv U1 o lh lh !!;'" " " ""0 ;? - C -= Z OJ X 0 r m C () 0 (fj C -l ~ ~ () r o ~ ~ m ;0 () )> .. ~ )> ^ m -~ ~ Q I --l DDD o )> o ;0 z (j) '"'0 m 0 ;0 ;0 < -l ~ o z DDD :;0 :;0 :;0 m :;0 m m m (fj (fj (fj () 0 0 0 :::u m m m m z z z ~ -l -l -l )> )> ):> 0 r r r Z .. ~ ::r: Q m t:'\ ;u U~ ..- ^ m -< C --l --l r m " ~ 0' m III ;U ^ m -< (C) ~ J> ^ m -< "'n C ... C """ (1) I" CJ :J Q. C fit (1) IJ) ~~ -- ~/ -""'-...:.~ 'i) <:! .-0 ., c-h ,;.: ~ ;. ^ m -( :>J o n ^ -. (J) --l :;; ;u c:: "U ^ m -( tj ~ ~'\ = ~ ~'-C ~ i~ :' ---r') i~ ~~ ;~ = ~ ~~ Nt::;) e! " L~ III r ^ m -< Property Information for 1122114 MONROE COUNTY PROPERTY ApPRAISER Page 1 of 1 PROPERTY INFORMA nON FOR: Alternate Key: 1122114 RE Number: 00104500-000000 Property Details OWNER 9F RECORD MONROE COUNTY FLIGHT STRIP 500 WHITEHEAD STREET KEY WEST FL 33040 Business Name: ANIMAL SHELTER. PW & \-lAINT PIf YSICAL. LW:::.UIOt'; 10600 A Y IA TION BL V D \'IARA TI iON LEJ;AL DESCIllPTIO:,,/ 66633 N66306-3 I KEY V ACCAS PT LOT 2 ORI44-590-59 I SF:!"';TI(>~, TOWNSHIP, RA~GI:: 06 - 66 - 33 MU,JAGJ;:GRQIip 50CM :e...CCgpl2 86 - COUNTIES OTHER THA'\ (j'CiUST) Building Oetails P!W~ER,(Y_MA-f' N.!JMBER QF BUILDI:'oOGS 12 N_l}~Jl!:!;;R OE_CQMM~R(!ALIH;JLDI~GS 12 TQ-LAL LIvING AREA 38360 YEARnIH-iILI 19M Land Details LA!:'lJtUSE CODE 1000 - COMMERC]AL DRY Parcel Value History L,\NIlA..REA 67.5 AC BVlLDII'lG TAX_ROJ"!" YMR L\JJSO;LJ,_A,,'l'_!,:Q!-S Ll\'IPRQY~_M E~TS 29 Lll4 292.359 294.329 200S 2004 2003 i Parcel Sales History 2.034.128 2,061.791 2,061,791 L-\NP 1.3] 6.250 10,125,000 10.[25,000 EXEMPTIONSjNOIJr.!_<::LUPIr-tG T AXABI.E SENIOR~) --------- 3.64 1 ,492 n 12,479,150 0 12,4&],[20 0 ,l1}ST 3.64 1.491 [2,4'79. [50 I ::'.48 LI ::'0 Th~r<e ill"e no sn les for this pan;"i. Monroe County Tax Collector Page 10f2 ~~ . (t~~,-~i;~"'\. ~~,' ,>}::';1~ Monroe County Tax Collector Details Tax Record >> Print View Shopping Cart Searches Account # (AK) Owner Name Mailing Address Site Functions Welcome Tax Search Occupational Lie. Contact Us Terms/Legal/Privacy Home Site Provided by... governmax.com T1.14 Tax Record prliJt 1+ .. .. +f ,~C~0J:lt ~ CAr<) 1 0f : Last Update: 3/16/200612:48:05 PM EST Ad Valorem Taxes and Non-Ad Valorem Assessments The information contained herein does not constitute a title search and should not be relied on as such. Account # (AK) 1122114 Tax Type Real Estate Tax Year 2005 Maili.ng Address f;]{jrJROE C<),ff.;TY ?L ,:;fi'T .,,) (: I'lH I T;-:I--' EP..D S F~'r" ST~<: 5'2 '< ;';::= ~ ~ , '< ,r, "0 ~ _" ~ _ _ Fa lio N\l.,!ber Assessed Value $3,641,492 00 Exempt Amount $3,641,492 00 'Taxable Value $0 00 Exemption Detail uC: li:XEHPT i;.lN3 Legal Description Millage Rate ~J c:"< /; :} Tax Districts Detail .-- Code Descrip~ion Exemption Am'= AmOUrlt - --'~- - " ."") ,.- ~~ - ~ _"0. ,":HH (I ~ ~~: Ci 5C ,)(J ,.~ (".I i).1 F & l.Ji':~:l~:-1 I"." ,. \". _ '-....I.~ - ~, "." ...........:... "-' -~ " -- _\~ (;- ,d) "illi'; HE!-,I.'I'li CI...:~o:"T;: ~~ .~ .~.- -. ~ 'j',:" L H '"j.)h :;;.; tl "l'O ;.U ::.; I (J ,-' SI) 1)0 . [':.:'".:': li\.II~) ~~) SO J:'I ;~L~TE~, r.<,:'\~\J~~<~~,:/,~' i<:r. ~)=...: ~:"III(l ;_~ O;:t.,f..... Y;l(~2-~s", : ~~ :S.J n.:: '... <. (~n .:.: ~._.:\=-._. _ i<~..l','_ ,..:.j::::'~ ~.i ". ..~"..-',' ~ ! ~~: < I ~.~(;. .o..? lu"1l1B..\. !1..:;UYjIC: - ~-:;'~ l h.'\. "-\1(-: r~"". -- ;.' C ~) f'l $n i),'] - -- ~- 5 ~ I If Paid By Amount Due $0 00 Prior Y~ar Taxes: Due r.,IO DEL I N\.~CE~'.~T .~'. ..>~;.~s PJ"llltJ <<First < Previous Next> Last>> Legal Disclaimer / Privacy Statement Subject looking North Street View looking East