Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Item P8
P8 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY of MONROE �� i Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein,District 5 The Florida Keys Mayor Pro Tern James K.Scholl,District 3 Craig Cates,District 1 Michelle Lincoln,District 2 ' David Rice,District 4 Board of County Commissioners Meeting December 13, 2023 Agenda Item Number: P8 2023-1864 BULK ITEM: No DEPARTMENT: Planning & Environmental Resources TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Emily Schemper AGENDA ITEM WORDING: A Public Hearing Concerning a Request for Administrative Relief Pursuant to LDC Section 138-27 Made By Harold & Sherry Fried On Property Described As Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo, Re # 00449340-000000. ITEM BACKGROUND: Harold and Sherry Fried, the Applicants, have submitted a request for Administrative Relief for Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates Key Largo; Parcel ID 00449340-000000. The applicant is specifically requesting relief in the form of issuance of a ROGO allocation award and building permit for the construction of a single family house on the subject property. Permit application 19300570 was submitted on April 09, 2019, and entered ROGO on July 9, 2019. The applicant is eligible for Administrative Relief, has complied with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system, has been considered in the first sixteen consecutive quarterly allocations and has not received an allocation award. Owner/Applicant: Harold Fried Land Use District: Improved Subdivision (IS) FLUM: Residential Medium(RM) Tier: 1 Total Assessed Value (2023): $93,652 Total Just (Market)Value (2022): $131,957 Purchased: January 30, 2019 3786 Purchase Price: $20,000 Deed Type: Warranty Deed In accordance with Section 138-27 and Policies 101.7.1, the preferred option for granting administrative relief to a Tier I property is award in the form of an offer to purchase the property at its fair market value. Further, per Policy 101.7.3, the County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for Tier I lands. The Monroe County Land Authority has confirmed that the subject property would be eligible for purchase. Please See Attached Staff Report for Full Details and Analysis. PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: N/A INSURANCE REQUIRED: No CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the Board of County Commissioners find that the applicant has met the criteria and qualifies for Administrative Relief. Further, consistent with Comprehensive Plan Policies 101.7.1 and 101.7.3 and LDC Section 138-27(d) and (g), staff recommends that relief be in the form of an offer by the Monroe County Land Authority to purchase the property. DOCUMENTATION: Fried 19300570 Staff Report.docx Exhibit 1 Fried 19300570 Admin Relief App.pdf Exhibit 2 Fried 19300570 ROGO App.PDF Exhibit 3 FL Forever Removal.pdf Exhibit 4 Approved Q4Y31 Upr.pdf Exhibit 5 LDC and CP.pdf Fried 19300570 Resolution Purchase.docx FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A 3787 AA °`�emu..• MEMORANDUM MONROE COUNTY PLANNING&ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES DEPARTMENT We strive to be caring,professional and fair To: Monroe County Board of County Commissioners From: Michael Roberts, CEP; PWS, Assistant Director/Environmental Resources Through: Emily Schemper, Sr. Director of Planning and Environmental Resources Date: November 27, 2023 Subject: Request for Administrative Relief for Fried Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo; Parcel ID No. 00449340- 000000 Meeting: December 13, 2023 1. BACKGROUND On 07/18/2023 the Applicant submitted an Administrative Relief Application for Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates Key Largo; Real Estate No. 00449340-000000 (Exhibit 1). The applicant is specifically requesting relief in the form of issuance of a ROGO allocation award and building permit for the construction of a single family house on the subject property. Permit application 19300570 was submitted on April 09,2019,and entered ROGO on July 9,2019. The applicant is eligible for Administrative Relief pursuant to Monroe County Land Development Code (LDC) Section 138-27(a) in the form of an offer by the Monroe County Land Authority to purchase the property., having complied with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system,being considered in the first sixteen consecutive quarterly allocations, having not received an allocation award. Date Entered ROGO: 07/09/2019 (Exhibit 2) Date Entered Administrative Relief: 7/18/2023 Total ROGO/Tier Score: 18 Tier Points 10 Bldg designed/certified Green Bldg Code 0 Wetlands Tier 3 adj to Tier 1 w>50 0 Permanent Concrete Cistern (1,000 gallons) 0 Wetlands Tier 3 adj to Tier 1 w<50 0 Gray water reuse 0 Aggregation Points 0 *Solar photovoltaic 3KW or equiv. 0 Land Dedication Points 0 *Ductless A/C or High efficiency chiller 0 Mkt EMP/AFH project 0 Perseverance Points 4 Flood Zone 0 BAT/AWT 4 Payment to Land Acquisition Fund 0 Page 1 of 11 Reviewed by 19300570 3788 This application was ranked#112 out of 122 applications in Quarter 4, Year 31 (Exhibit 4). II. CURRENT CONDITIONS Location: Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo; Real Estate No. 00449340.000000. r� d I w i ! r I r I t yf y y Owner/Applicant: Harold Fried Tier: I Land Use District: Improved Subdivision(IS) Total Assessed Value (2023): $93,652 FLUM: Residential Medium(RM) Total Just (Market) Value (2022): $131,957 Purchased: January 30, 2019 Deed Type: Warranty Deed Purchase Price: $20,000 Monroe County Property Appraiser Values Certified 2022 & Certified 2023 2023CertifiedValues 202.2,Certified VAaluies + Market lirnpranrerrierri $0 $c + Market W3c Value, $0 $0 "^ + Market Land iVA ue $131,957 $86,279 = Just Market Value $131,957 $86,279 = Total Assessed Val ua-e $9 „652 $85,7138 Harold Fried and Sherry Fried, his wife,puchased the property January 30, 2019 with a Warranty Deed. Additional Relevant Information: Page 2 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3789 The property is located in Tier I on Key Largo and consists primarily of Tropical Hardwood Hammock. It is mapped as hammock in the County's 2009 Habitat GIS layer. Although the parcel lies generally within the Florida Forever acquisition boundary, the property was removed from the Florida Forever project at the request of the property owner(Exhibit 3). The property is adjacent to state owned lands (see figure below: subject parcel is outlined in blue; state owned lands in green; County owned lands in yellow). III. LEGAL ELIGIBILITY AND OPTIONS Policy 101.7.1 of the Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan and LDC Section 138-27 (Exhibit 4)provide a mechanism whereby an applicant who has not received an allocation award in the ROGO system may apply to the Board of County Commissioners for Administrative Relief. Policy 101.7.1 Monroe County, the state, or other acquisition agency shall, upon a property owner's request, offer to purchase the property for fair market value or permit the minimum reasonable economic use of the property, if the property owner meets the following conditions: 1. they have been denied an allocation award for four successive years in the Residential (ROGO) or Nonresidential (NROGO) Permit Allocation System; 2. their proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county, state, and federal regulations; 3. their allocation application has not been withdrawn; 4. they have complied with all the requirements of the Residential or Nonresidential Permit Allocation System; and 5. they follow the procedures for administrative relief contained in the land development regulations. Page 3 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3790 As used in this Policy, "minimum reasonable economic use" shall mean, as applied to any residentially zoned parcel of record which was buildable immediately prior to the effective date of the Plan, no less than a single-family residence. A purchase offer is the preferred option for administrative relief, if the subject permit is for development located within: 1. a designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever (or its successor) targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined no county,state or federal agency or any private entity is willing to offer to purchase the parcel); 2. a designated Tier 11 or III-A (Special Protection Area); or, 3. a designated Tier III area on a non-waterfront lot for affordable housing. Refusal of the purchase offer by a property owner shall not be grounds for the granting of a ROGO or NROGO allocation award. An application for administrative relief may be denied based upon any one of the following findings by a special magistrate or the Board of County Commissioners: 1. The applicant previously filed an inverse condemnation or other private property rights claim or cause of action that gave rise to a final judgment or order of dismissal issued by a court of competent jurisdiction in Monroe County's favor, and said claim or cause of action involved the same property and issues of fact that underlie the application for administrative relief; 2. A court of competent jurisdiction likely would determine that the failure of the applicant to qualify for an allocation award has not caused a taking of the property (whether such liability, at the time of application under this policy, is likely to be established by a court of competent jurisdiction should be determined based on applicable statutory, regulatory, and case law at the time the application is considered under this policy); 3.The property retains a practicable economically beneficial use despite its failure to qualify for an allocation award; 4. The applicant previously received an offer from a local, state, or federal governmental agency to purchase the property at its fair market value that was rejected by the applicant; or 5. The failure of the applicant to qualify for an allocation award can be attributed to laws or regulations that are imposed or mandated by an agency of the federal government. Page 4 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3791 Policy 101.7.3 Monroe County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for lands within the Florida Forever targeted acquisition or Tier I lands areas unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes by any county, state or federal agency or any private entity. The County shall routinely notify Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief request at least six (6) months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. Eligibility for Administrative Relief: The applicant has met the Administrative Relief eligibility requirements of Policy 101.7.1 and Section 138-27(a), below, having complied with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system, and having been considered in at least the first sixteen consecutive quarterly allocation periods and not having received an allocation award. The application was timely submitted. The applicant is requesting administrative relief in the form of one (1) ROGO allocation award and the applicant has not expressed a desire to sell the property to the County. Sec. 138-27. -Administrative Relief. (a) Eligibility. An applicant for an allocation award is eligible for administrative relief if: (1) The application complies with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system; (2) The application has been denied an allocation award for four successive years (first 16 consecutive quarterly allocation periods) in the ROGO Permit Allocation System; (3) The proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county, state, and federal regulations; (4) The ROGO allocation application has not been withdrawn; (5) The applicant has complied with all the requirements of the ROGO Permit Allocation System; and (6) The applicant has followed the procedures for administrative relief; and (7) The applicant has not received an allocation award. Relief Options under Administrative Relief. Page 5 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3792 If the BOCC chooses to grant administrative relief to the applicant,per Comprehensive Plan Policy 101.7.1 and LDC Section 138-27(g)(1)b., the preferred action for the subject property (a Tier I designated parcel) is an offer to purchase the property at its fair market value. Policy 101.7.1 A purchase offer is the preferred option for administrative relief, if the subject permit is for development located within: 1. a designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever (or its successor) targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined no county,state orfederal agency or any private entity is willing to offer to purchase the parcel); 2. a designated Tier 11 or III-A (Special Protection Area); or, 3. a designated Tier III area on a non-waterfront lot for affordable housing. Refusal of the purchase offer by a property owner shall not be grounds for the granting of a ROGO or NROGO allocation award. LDC 138-27(g) Board of County Commissioners action. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the BOCC may take any or a combination of the following actions: (1) Offer to purchase the property at its fair market value as its preferred action if the property is located within: a. A designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever (or its successor)targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined no county, state or federal agency or any private entity is willing to offer to purchase the parcel); b. A designated Tier 11 area (Big Pine Key and No Name Key); c. A designated Tier 111-A area (special protection area); or d. A designated Tier III area on a nonwaterfront lot or parcel for affordable housing. (2) Grant the applicant an allocation award for all or a number of dwelling units requested in the next succeeding quarterly allocation period or extended pro rata over several succeeding quarterly allocation periods as the preferred action for buildable properties not meeting any of the criteria in subsection (g)(1) of this section. (3) Suggest or provide such other relief as may be necessary and appropriate. Page 6 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3793 In addition,per Comprehensive Plan Policy 101.7.3 and LDC Section 138-27(d): The County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for lands within the Florida Forevertargeted acquisition or Tier I lands areas unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes by any county, state or federal agency or any private entity. The County shall routinely notify Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief request at least six (6) months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. The subject property is designated Tier I. In accordance with Section 138-27 and Policies 101.7.1 and 101.7.3, staff recommends that administrative relief be awarded in the form of an offer to purchase the property at its fair market value. The Monroe County Land Authority has confirmed that the subject property would be eligible for purchase. In the event purchase is recommended and the owner refuses the purchase offer,the applicant may remain in the ROGO System and continue earning perseverance points according to Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan. The owner could also pursue a Beneficial Use Determination (BUD) pursuant to LDC Chapter 102, Article IV, Division 2, though that option would require the owner to establish that applicable Comprehensive Plan policies and LDC provisions has caused a taking of the property, which is a standard the Department does not think the owner could satisfy in the quasi-judicial process. Per Policy 101.7.1, refusal of the purchase offer by a property owner shall not be grounds for the granting of a ROGO or NROGO allocation award. If the BOCC were to instead choose to grant relief to the applicant through an allocation award for one dwelling unit on the subject property (138-27(g)(2)), the following would apply: Per Section 138-27(h), the number of allocations that may be awarded under administrative relief in any one quarter shall be no more than 50 percent of the total available market rate allocations available, excluding banked administrative relief allocations and those allocations received from Key West, in a quarter for that subarea. Any allocations, excluding banked administrative relief allocations and those allocations received from Key West, in excess of 50 percent shall be extended into the succeeding quarter or quarters until the number of such allocations is 50 percent or less of the total number of market rate allocations available to he awarded. As shown in the table below,the current number of banked administrative relief ROGO allocations for the Upper Keys subarea is forty-nine (49). Page 7 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3794 Table shows Total Market Rate Allocations Unused ROGO Years 19-31 available for Administrative Relief Total Unused Market Rate Sub-Area Yr 19 Yr 20 Yr 21 Yr 22 Yr 23 Yr 24 Yr 25 Yr 26 Yr 27 Yr 28 Yr 29-31 Allocations Lower Keys 11 44 14 20 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 95 Big Pine/No Name Key 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Upper Keys 0 0 0 15 15 2 0 0 2 15 0 49 Total Allocations 11 44 14 35 21 2 0 0 2 15 0 F 144 Note: This table does not include all expired market allocations and may be revised to included expired allocation awards If relief were granted by an allocation award, it would come in the next quarterly market rate allocation quarter for the Upper Keys subarea: Year 32,Quarter 2. Ordinance 006-2020, adopted by the BOCC on January 22, 2020, amended the ROGO allocation schedule beginning Year 29. There will be eight (8) market rate allocation available Quarter 2 for the Upper Keys subarea in Year 2. ROGO Year 32 Allocation by Quarter (July 13, 2023 —July 12, 2024) Annual Qtr 1 Qtr 2 Qtr 3 Qtr 4 Market Rate: Allocation Upper Keys 30(a) 81b> 81b> 7(b) 7(b) (a)Per CP Policy 101.6.2 and LDC Sec. 138-24(a): Tier 1 annual limit in the Upper Keys Subarea shall be no more than three. (b)Per LDC Sec. 138-27(h): Administrative relief awards shall be no more that 50% of quarterly allocation. For reference, in the last quarterly allocation period (Year 31, Quarter 4), eight market rate ROGO allocations were awarded in the Upper Keys subarea by the Planning Commission in August,2023. The subject property/application was ranked number 112 out of 122 applications. Of the 114 remaining applicants, 84 are Tier 111; 19 are Tier III-A; and 11 are Tier 1, including the subject property. Page 8 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3795 Rank Permit# Name Dale Time Key Subdivision Lot Block RE# Tier Des. MARKET RATE DWELLING UNITS 1 "@ 19300780 Theiss,Michael E. 25-May-23 1.05 PM Key Largo Bay Harbor Amd 25&26 3 00490060-000000; 3 2 22301639 Mats,Frank 9-Jun-23 12:30 PM Key Largo Port Largo 3rd Add 259 00453473-000200 3 3 22301638 Meta,Frank 9-Jun-23 12.38 PM Key Largo Port Largo 3rd Add 253 00453473-000100 3 Sruur•-znzz Lucas,Michael 22-Jun-23 02:30 FM Key Largo Wynken-Elynken&Nod Estates 68 00436700-000100 3 4 norm? 5 SFDUP-2023-0124 Ora,Jorge 10-Jul-23 12:29 PM Key Largo Pirates Cove 1st Add 14 19 00495730-000000 3 6 22300566 G&E 99 Properties LLC 12-Jul-23 2:49 PM Key Largo Stillwright Point No.1 16 00514490-000000 3 7 22301236 G&E 99 Properties LLC 12-Jul-23 2:58 PM Key Largo Pamela Villa 22 6 00464980-000000 3 8 22300567 Domm Investments LLC 12-Jul-23 3:06 PM Key Largo Stillwright Point No.1 15 00514400-000000 3 9 22300230 11335 Property LLC 5-Apr-23 10:55 AM Key Largo Key Largo Beach Add Pt Lt 11 13 00503420-000000 3 10 22300264 11395 Property LLC 5-Apr-23 10.56 AM Key Largo Key Largo Beach Add Pt Lt 11 13 00503420-000000 3 11 22300560 Grey Properties LLC 14-Jun-23 11:08 AM Key Largo Point Pleasant Amd 12 2 00496480-000000 3 12 SFDUP-2022-0031 JSMG Holdings LLC 12-Jul-23 10:50 AM Key Largo Key Largo Beach 18 3 00501890-000100 3 13 21300113 Yoel Investment Corp 12-Jul-23 1112 AM Key Largo Largo Gardens 17 14 00458240-000000 3 14 SFDUP-2022-0029 D Lory Casa LLC 12-Jul-23 11:29 AM Key Largo Baccaneer Point 3 5 00496131-012100 3 15 22300299 62 Bonefish LLC 19-May-22 1:51 PM Key Largo Largo Sound Park 31 2 00470710-000100 3 16 21301074 Karim-Uriza'Smith 14-Jul-22 2.18 PM Key Largo Winston Waterways Amd. 5 2 00546420-000000 3 17 22300946 Estrada,Jesus&Anailyn 2-Feb-23 0117 PM Key Largo Key Largo Trailer Village 1st Add 2 11 00460380-000100 3 18 21301459 Fried,Harold 27-Sep-21 10:45 AM Key Largo Ocean Park Village 8 4 00446180-000000 3 19 20302106 Key Largo Reef LLC 27-Sep-21 01:34 PM Key Largo Seaside Re-subd. 20 1 00491800-000000 3 20 21301434 Correa,Octavio 6-Oct-21 02:00 FM Key Largo Pamela Villa 9 1 004133700-000300 3 21 21300766 3L Garden Investment LLC 8-0ct-21 02:35 FM Key Largo Ocean Isle Estate 22 1 00538280-000000 3 22 21300921 FGR Orange LLC 12-Oct-21 02:12 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd. 12 20 00527680-000120 3 23 21300920 FGR Orange LLC 4-Nov-21 3.35 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 11 20 00527680-000110 3 24 21300919 FGR Orange LLC 9-Nov-21 2:47 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 10 20 00527680-000100 3 25 21301135 Alsine,Emmanuel 15-Nov-21 106 PM Key Largo Cross Key Waterways Est.Sec.3 4 4 00468473-005201 3 26 21300450 NVJ Multiservices Inc 17-Nov-21 12:47 PM Key Largo Ocean Isle Est. 15 3 00538760-000100 3 27 21301795 Rodriguez,Miriam 19-Nov-21 1.50 PM Key Largo Largo Sound Village 19 11 00476170-000100 3 23 21301173 True Investor LLC 15-Dec-21 2.50 PM Key Largo Stillwright Point No.1 19 00514520-000000 3 29 21301963 Keys Property Holdings LLC 5-Jan-22 12:53 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 12 15 00526680-000000 3 0 _21302069_ Kevs Property Holduaas LLC .5-Jan-22 12,50 PM Key Lai Key Laroo Park Amd _ _ 13 15 Q0526b,IJ 0Q00C10 3 31 19300509 Penny's Investment Corp. 3-Feb-22 02:35 AM Key Largo Twin Lakes 1 7 00548740-000000 3 32 21301433 Correa,Octavio 3-Feb-22 0110 PM Key Largo Pamela Villa 8 1 00463700-000200 3 33 19300508 Penny's Investment Corp. 3-Feb-22 02:24 PM Key Largo Twin Lakes 6 6 00540G90-000000 3 34 21301750 Art&Art Corp 10-Feb-22 10.43 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 8&42 Lt 9 10 00525500-000000 3 35 21301982 Pozo,Eduardo&Martha 14-Feb-22 03:45 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 8 13 00526060-000000 3 36 21301245 Haroun,Hany&Christine 28-Feb-22 12:39 PM Key Largo Buccaneer Point 12 1 00496131-001310 3 37 21301564 Keys Property Holdings LLC 28-Feb-22 0113 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 20 10 00525610-000200 3 38 21301660 Keys Property Holdings LLC 20-Fat:-22 0114 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 10 10 00525610-000100 3 39 21302068 Costa II Investments LLC 28-FeL-22 01.15 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 2 15 00526580-000000 3 40 21300827 Labrador,Armondo 3-Mar-22 12:43 PM Key Largo Fort Largo 3rd Add 272 00453473-001410 3 41 21302029 Moleiro's Corp 14-Mar-22 10:27 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 21 10 00525630-000000 3 42 21301604 Henry Quintana Amd&Restated Revocable Trust V 24-Mar-22 12:55 PM Key Largo Buccaneer Point 18 2 00496131-003800 3 43 21302489 Orate,Rene&Mabel 29-Mar-22 04.00 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 2 28 00529210-000100 3 44 22300236 Fried'Ginlauma 6-Apr-22 09:58 AM Key Largo Tavernier Bend 19 00487380-000000 3 45 20301599 Pennys Investment Corp 12-Apr-22 11.30 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Estates 2 2 00447160-000000 3 46 20301600 Pennys Investment Corp 12-Apr-22 1131 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Estates 3 2 00447170-000000 3 47 18302572 Speer,Richard&Suzanne 12-Apr-22 03.03 PM Key Largo Buccaneer Point 1 1 00496131-000100 3 48 22300431 Rodriguez,Miriam 26-May-22 10 16 AM Key Largo South Creek Village 17 4 00467240-000000 3 49 21302009 Island Investment Partners Inc 21-Jun-22 12 22 PM Key Largo Key Largo Beach 24 2 00501790-000000 3 50 21300635 Bernal,Cl arc&2ai da 7-Jul-22 2.02 PM Key Largo Key Largo Ocean Shores Add. 11 12 00500230-000000 3 51 22301040 Abit Holdings LLC 12-0ct-22 3:45 AM Key Largo Largo Sound Village 20 7 00475350-000000 3 52 22301043 Abit Investments LLC 13-0ct-22 1125 AM Key Largo Largo Sound Village 19 7 00475340-000000 3 53 22201067 Abit Investment LLC 13-Dec-22 11.50 PM Key Largo Largo Sound Village 21 7 00475360-000000 3 54 22301445 Garcia,Lazaro 6-Jan-23 1.10 AM Key Largo Sunset Waterways 12 3 00530080-000000 3 55 22300765 Mendoza,Ansel mo 5-Jul-23 2:45 PM Key Largo Largo Gardens 3 14 00458090-000100 3 56 22300664 Hernandez,Leonel&Catherine 29-Aug-22 1100 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Estates 43 2 00447570-000000 3 57 22300847 Lazcos,Public 30-Aug-22 3.35 AM Key Largo Lake Surprise Estates 17 6 00535250-000100 3 58 22300937 Tiedemann,Jocelyn&Brian 15-Sep-22 11:15 AM Key Largo Holiday Homesites 11 10 00531550-000100 3 59 22300857 Gomez,Jesus 12-0ct-22 2:45 PM Key Largo Famela Villa 14 2 00463940-000000 3 60 21301071 Correa,Francisco 4-Nov-22 1.25 PM Key Largo Largo Sound Village 1 9 00475650-000000 3 61 22300822 Hutson,Ralph&Kathy 5-Apr-23 08:55 AM Key Largo Bay Haven Sec 3 1 9 00517650-000000 3 62 SFDUP-2023-0013 Chong,Redly 11-Apr-23 02:35 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 14 10 00525550-000200 3 Page 9 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3796 63 SFDUP-2023-0023 Chong,Rogelio 12-Jun-23 110 FM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amid 15 10 00525550-000300 3 64 21302361 Sunrise Pointe LLC 28-Mar-22 0217 PM Key Largo Sunrise Point Add Amd 18 6 00403950-000000 3 65 22301009 Garcia,Rene 25-Jul-22 12:03 FM Key Largo Winston Park 17 3 00546000-000000 3 66 19302067 Baxter,Andrew&Lisa 5-Aug-22 1.00 PM Key Largo Famela Villa 5 19 00464670-000000 3 67 20301593 Nelchris Properties LLC 14-Sep-22 2.00 PM Key Largo Bay Harbor Amid 59 16, 00489360-000000 3 68 21301849 Bahama 167 Construction Corp 16-Sep-22 10:28 AM Key Largo Winston Waterways No.2 11 6 00546820-000000 3 69 22301065 Resendis,Eduardo 12-Oct-22 12:40 FM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Estates 42 2 00447560-000000 3 70 22300424 Casariecto Corporation 3-Nov-22 9:55 AM Key Largo Largo Sound Villa e 11&SW112 Lt 12 00476470-000000 3 71 22300749 Hardison,Cathy 11 8:40 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 4 2 00523580-000000 3 72 22301632 Keys Property Holdings LLC 14-Nov-22 1125 AM Key Largo Riviera Village Rev&Amid 38 3 00510900-000000 3 73 22301704 Keys Properly Holdings LLC 6-Dec-22 1.45 PM Key Largo South Creek Village 20 5 00467260-000100 3 74 22300913 Wadigi Twin Paradise LLC 11 2.50 PM Key Largo Key Largo Beach 4 7 00502510-000000 3 75 21302215 Barrios,Salvador 12-Jan-23 1145 AM Key Largo Largo Gardens 23 13 00458060-000000 3 76 22300987 Agelis,Marianthi 7-Mar-23 02:06 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 4 17 00527160-000100 3 77 22301092 PidrelAskowitz 8-Mar-23 12.05 PM Key Largo Key Largo Ocean Shores Add 8 14 00500740-000000 3 78 20300934 94411 Tavernier LLC 11 11.50 AM Key Largo Seaside 2 1 00491580-000000 3 79 22301466 Morales,Carlos 11 10:50 AM Key Largo Ocean Isle Estates 21 3 00538830-000000 3 80 20301299 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:00 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090820-000000 3 61 20301303 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:02 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090020-000000 3 82 20301301 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:05 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090020-000000 3 63 20301300 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:07 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090020-000000 3 64 20301295 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:10 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090020-000000 3 85 20301298 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:12 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090820-000000 3 86 20301293 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04:15 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090820-000000 3 87 20301297 PL Ocean Residences Holding LLC 12-Oct-21 04.20 PM Key Largo metes&bounds 00090820-000000 3 88 20301216 Michael Cabanas Land Venture Inc 14-Dec-20 09:55 AM Key Largo Lime Grove Estates Sec 1 W 2 is 4 00435510-000000 3 89 19302159 Art Code Corp 30-Jun-21 1100 AM Key Largo Pirates Cove 1st Add. 15 16 00495210-000000 3 90 20301202 Marante,Freddy 7-Feb-22 11'.00 AM Key Largo Cross Key Waterways Est 6 9 00468473-016800 3 91 21302427 2ambrana,Jose&Rebecca 13-May-22 11:30 AM Key Largo EluewaterTrailer Village Sec.4 43 3 00489136-014300 3 92 @ 21300100 Lago,Shirely&Luis 5-May-22 1'.09 PM Key Largo Anglers Park 3&4 8 00552370-000000 3-A 93 21302208 Lucas,Paul 28-Mar-23 09:32 AM Key Largo Buccaneer Point 47 3 00496131-009100 3 94 19300197 TDGroup Holdings 1 LLC 26-Feb-21 1115 AM Key Largo Seaside Add.1 Pt Lt 7 1 00492520-000000 3-A 95 10301516 Alvarez,Reinaldo 28-Apr-21 9:00 AM Key Largo Twin Lakes 1 19 U0550530-000000 3-A 96 20301937 Grey Properties LLC 9-Aug-21 12:30 PM Key Largo Rev.Amd.Plat of Riviera Village 13 3 00510660-000000 3-A 97 20301633 Grey Properties LLC 1-Sep-21 10.10 AM Key Largo Harbor Shores 1 1 00521530-000000 3-A 98 21301199 Keys Property Holdings LLC 17-Sep-21 10.15 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd. 25 14 U0526500-000000 3-A 99 21301201 Keys Property Holdings LLC 17-Sep-21 10.16 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd. 24 14 00526490-000000 3-A 100 21300562 Island Invesment Partners Inc. 5-Oct-21 09.30 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Estates 11 3 00447710-000000 3-A 101 21300976 Teach,Miles 19-Nov-21 10:25 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Est. 17 2 00447310-000000 3-A 102 21300847 Cotter,William 5-Jan-22 115 PM Key Largo Twin Lakes 7 19 00550590-000000 3-A 103 21302342 MesalPalma 22-Feb-22 09.00 AM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 26 14 00526510-000000 3-A 104 21302341 MesalPalma 6-May-22 1:20 PM Key Largo Key Largo Park Amd 6 14 00526310-000000 3-A 105 21300614 Mazzarella,Micheal J 1-Aug-22 11:10 AM Key Largo Bowens Add to Riviera Village 1 6 00511990-000000 3-A 106 21300236 Gas Tech Investment LLC 7-Sep-22 9.14 AM Key Largo Harry Harris Ocean Park Estate 131:A 20 8 00450070-000000 3-A 107 18302491 Atlantic Salmon LLC 7-Dec-22 2.15 PM Key Largo Riviera Village Rev&Amd 12 3 00510650-000000 3-A 108 SFDUP-2022-0013 Crawdaddy Inc 12-4pr-23 02:15 PM Key Largo Bahia Mar Estates 8 9 00544920-000000 3-A 109 SFDLIP-2022- Crawdaddy Inc 12-4pr-23 02:18 PM Key Largo Bahia Mar Estates 11 9 00544950-000000 3-A 110 SFDLIP-2022- Crawdaddy Inc 12-4pr-23 02:19 PM Key Largo Bahia Mar Estates 10 9 00544940-000000 3-A 111 SFDLIP-2022-0009 Crawdaddy Inc 20-Apr-23 11.20 AM Key Largo Bahia Mar Estates 9 9 00544930-000000 3-A 112 19300570 Fried,Harold 9-Jul-19 08.47 AM Key Largo Harris Ocean Park Est 36 6 00449340-000000 1 113 1830004 TDGroup Holdings I LLC 7-Aug-19 0:41 AM Key Largo Adobe Casa Court 1 A 00481230-000000 1 pr 114 18300094 TDGroup Holdings I LLC 7-Aug-19 0.42 AM Key Largo Adobe Casa Court 1 A 00481230-000000 1 pr 115 19300533 BCD of the Keys LLC 15-Od-19 03.20 PM Key Largo Anglers Park a 12&PI Lt n 3 00551410-000000 1 pr 116 19300540 BCD of the Keys LLC 15-Od-19 03.30 PM Key Largo Anglers Park Pt a 10&PI LL n 3 00551400-000000 1 117 10300323 Fabel Holdings LLC 6-May-21 9:20 AM Key Largo Largo City 10 3 00500990-000000 1 110 21301065 Stocky 16 Rainbow Drive LLC 4-Nov-21 11.00 AM Key Largo Knowles Colony 1st Add 15 2 00564650-000000 1 119 21300646 Soria,Ramon 16-Nov-21 1:03 PM Key Largo GulFstream Shores 22 6 00565850-000000 1 120 21301554 Martinez,Patrocinio 13-Jun-22 9:00 AM Key Largo GulFstream Shores 7 2 00565170-000000 1 121 SFDUP-2022-0069 Fabel Holdings LLC1Brodkin 2-Jun-23 130 PM Key Largo Largo City 21 4 00509300-000100 1 122 SFDUP-2022-0070 Fabel Holdings LLClBmdkin 30-Jun-23 125 PM Key Largo Largo City 23 4 005W300-000200 1 IV. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the Board of County Commissioners find that the applicant has met the criteria and qualifies for Administrative Relief. Further, consistent with Comprehensive Plan Policies 101.7.1 and 101.7.3 and LDC Section 138-27(d) and (g), staff recommends that relief be in the form of an offer by the Monroe County Land Authority to purchase the property. V. EXHIBITS 1. Administrative Relief Application Page 10 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3797 2. ROGO Application 3. FDEP Florida Forever Project Removal Notice 4. Approved Upper Keys Subarea Quarter 4, Year 31 PC 08.23.2023 Ranking 5. LDC Section 138-27 & Comp Plan Objective 101.7 Page 11 of 11 Reviewed by_ES_ 19300570 3798 a�a A,PIP lU A 4"ia,Cl'vi �'a,selar l OANR,OE d)IJM'V,FLORIDA �E "I, aMING aAN1:)ENV IRON NlENTAI,Ri,,so iRf:'1 S li;P:VR'G°laall N'r is r c r,e fiApplication fiat-Residential Administi-kittive Relief onme County Land Development Code Section 138-2 Appliolioat bees: $1,01().00 In 40ditio n lea Me enfxfriic°aatltaaa (are,lhe„ftediraaringfi?eew arttoa aqt 17}v l"aa;dvertisi`n r Cost $2'�45.C1(.f �El[�f011✓//AIIY,Nk11iU7,�N%/GUlIIOWUlVIIIIIII'7RIIIIXnIlY.d10lICtlGIIIIIpP71 AlUCX!/E�/17h19D11iAillr�'!l'11A�1°PYGIA,�/,4grfIAUAU0,lA1,IH1pll�l�l!1[fV,l/,IIIItY,�1lGCr1(IrIII1GYfP�i&l!G1011fff(fY.IfP111uuWIgN Xw IRIIIaFJA iOYIYIlaXN!➢NIJ��OfiIYfUllt�JlIBIYG�II�INGY/COk1711YIPIIP�lIIC1l�11ffImIUA1m1111iRNlllRt/lllIII71�ttlI,�dI,Y,'�WI1IJtit1i170!�A,'�'f"1k176ftltlnPfWf�a (I) if kiln appliwint for an allocation award: a. Whose application has been denied an allocation award 'rr four 4 suce^ss've ,,. i the I'crnait Allocation System, and fails to receive an allocation award,said applicant may,apply to [lie board for administrative relierparsuant to tile ternns and conditions slit fearth hurcin,and b. Wfiosc proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county„ state, kind federal regulations;and u, Whose allocation application has not bcun withdrawn;and d. Who has complied with till requirements oftlnc Permit Allocation Systc m;and c. Applicant follows procedures for nolministrativo relief contained in fie land development regukotiowr kind f. Applicant has net reeeivod,an allocation award. (2) An application for administrative relief shall be invade ors it forinn prescribed by the Director of Planning,.and array he Nyland with the l)ircetor of Planning ne,.carlier than the conclusion of tlnc fourth annual allottation Qr'od and no 'at I as ow l a dr—cd eight,t RM da s `al fific foul-Ill annual t cat'o ac°'cast. (3) Upon filing of an application for adiniristro ive ral,ief, the Director of Planning eK, Environmental ltcsourcc,s shall forward to the Board of County t:ommissionena (BOC'C"') all relevant files and reeords relating to the,subject applications, Failure to file an application shall constitute a waiver of tiny rights under this section to assert that the sulajaat properly has been taken by [lie county without payment ofjuqt compensation as a result of the dwelling aunt allocation sy.stern. (4) Upon receipt of an application for administrative relief, the: BOC;,".C° shaH notice resat hold a Public (rearing at which little the applicant will he given kiln opportunity to be heard. (5) The l$C;9CC,, may review the relevant applications and applicable evaluation ranking, taking tesfiniony from county staff and. others ki% may be necessary and hear testimony and review documentary evidence subanitted'by that:applicant, (6) At the conclusion of the public hearing, the BOC'�C:'may take any or ar combination of the following actions pursuant to Monroe County Code Section 139-27(g) and Monroe C..ounty t'oruprehensive Plan Policy i0l,73: a. Offer to purchase the property at tnir market valne as the Board of County Comm,iw,^aionQrs preferred action if the;property is loc;rtcd nvith:in: i., A designated Tier I area any within the Floridan Forever (or its successor) targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt or a coanplete application for administrative relief,it has been determined no county,state or federal regency or arty, private entity is willing,to)coffer to purchase the parcel); it. A designated"tier ll area(Big Pint;Key and No sesame Key); iii.. Aw designated Tier I ll-A area,(Special protection Area);or iv. A designated'licr III areal ern a.nonwaterfront lot or pkiroel for affordable housing. b. Grant the applicant in allocation award for all or a number of dwelling units requested in the neat succeeding quarterly allocation period or extended pro rala over wverarl succeeding quarterly allocation periods as the preferred action for buildable properties not meeting.any of the criteria Monroe County Code .Section 1,38-27(g) and Monroe C'ourrty Comprehensive planar Policy 101.7.1 e. Suggest such other relief as may be necessary and appropriate. (7) Monroe County Comprehensive flan]policy ltil.7,;3: Monroe County shrill preclude tine granting art administrative relief in the form of the issuance of as btaikiing permit for lands within thQ Florida Forever targeted acquisition or"Pier 1'.land areas unless,after fill strays from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief; it has, been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for coil servalion purposes by any county,state or federal agoncy or any private entity. (8) Limits on adminish-kah,allocations per quarter: "Ilie number of allocations that may be awarded under adrninistrarlive relief in carry one quarter shall be no more than 50 percent of tho total available market raato allocations available, excluding banked achninisirative rubes" allocations kind those allouafianns received front Key Wcst, in a quarter for that subarea.Any allocations,excluding banked administrative relief'allocations and those allocations received from key West, on excess of 50 percent shall be extended into the suwreeding quarter or quarters until the number of such a]locations is 50 percent or less of the total number of markctrale allocations availabla to lie awarded. (9) llefusal of the purchase offer by the property owner shall not lie grounds,for the granting of a lv'C)C.O allocation award. Page,,t.ol'2. .<taat ItuViel]tu^aa<Icanr¢B^,plal"'aais a3v IJ318201_ 3 Mtatalic:nutta tauti a➢kind(late �� .._. 3799 wA PI,ILI 'A,T 10,Ni � �mrm rro I ()NR4)I.COUNTY,FLORIDA j1 PIANNING ANI11iNVIRON1441W]'Al,R1':SOA RCTS DETAR.1 M[FtYr Application for Residential Administrative Relief Monroe County Land Devel+ puierat Code Section 138- 7 ApI)dietatiortice; $1„()I0°()C) h]acklition to Me rrlgVic,ation fees„the„fi)llorrirrg fiwv also erlrlray: Advertising Cosis:$245°(1Cl om�Uw�amruurc�uiruic�,rvr®mrmnaraaosrut�!rmm�rr�a�rm�,u�,ui�rvranzvrrmau�msr�nr�w��mu�arUasu�,rausu�nnru�aumr��rs,m�urarvimaua�,mun,�a�aa,�,iw�Mtrca�vaa,a,�sm�araaarr�rnrm�;r�a���rmrccuieua+a+�varsrrrrerevn�us raHrrrmuiirrnnv+urrvu�ieslam�mw„suaarr+ramrna�usurApaR�s A'I TA(HNIIi;TY°I S1 I)C'()I'Y C)F CI.JIZ]tEN'1'PR(-)I)1'.IZ'1 Y Rid C OIZI)C:AIZI)„Z)C'(:)I'Y C)I,'"I'III; WITHIN Sty MONTHS()I'AI)1, WIS"I`IZ.A'IIVI"?APPLICATION SU13MITTAI,. III Y0L)IJAV1:.', QUl'Sl'It)NS OR W1SIl'lO MA F,,AN,h,l1d1O12LI"Mf°",NT.I"0 MITIVER A'OUdZ APPLICATION PLEASIe C,AI.N., N Ill (:iIZ() 1II MANA(.it°,MEN l ()I l"I(I,,C,I,OSI-S 1 1'(.)YOUIZ pIZ.C),II,C,1, Prog)emy Ouner's Nanra: (Business/Corp Documents showing aa1"uw.N a¢afdunu lmd to s,lov i . Property Owner's complete mailing address:_ � a?� Phone: ( ork,)..Gat ... :,...,. .,:,. (home). . ..... '.�. N:°)rarai6 Address:_- ...cr Ty_ _ .. .g CEO .... r 1 .......... � ._Ci .. ._... Agent's (Requiml fpwa aagerft an,EWentl aammtroodua ftm rarrrhe Adnvrnaaarnavoe Reita°fAppitarnuhaan foram At tarrrm enywamuwaoem°,) Acnt's cc7mlalefe maa9in address:._ f Phone: (°Fork)-. y � /, (Ilonle) ._........< l 1',rnail Address: -_.....:'� c' ------------- .- _,_ ._..._ _..,,.... (Please attach as notarized statement authorizing representation ol`thls application by till property owners. The statement should read: "I,(owner's name)authorize(individual you are tauthorir5ng to represent you) to represent my property for this application for Administrative Relief", ry � 6C44"IJ b2.t)I' '1"It"d"Y I)I:iSCI2II'T[ON:I ot(s) ,,,.� 131ock Subdivision � � rA l e`>I : Key(isl aucl}: _ ..,_ _...........Sheet: ' r ....�w"m . 12d?:... G' , '' t' ",Ca b If rr,eaes rrrad lmun ts,armcli legal dexcr,taalvn on.eepar ale seem. (Nr r"ccal1P) I3uilchng I'errraitApplicaUorf ff: _I � f�si t I2O(i0 Appticatron ti:°c--tV ]date of)nost recent ROGO applicatiom � ...... 'What kind of adminiwtrsativc a�eGel;are you seeking? .._ r�(.� ?��..... '"'�" NOTARY- (D Namtlel ihaa'suagnt to C~<1v'raon, �:arnoit�(::"rarBc yiu^Piteae,l i3©inxl nfl'aninty t'e7rtvruwa,rarrea^s nutum is f+a ea17i*q-pura'rYawett 9C)Scn iarcrrxrYy fs<la.tii�,a,"itc,f p'icar r, 4peoe�l 1'sr,8a,:.hr.n a�-caiY;air iil rr,e wasrnroa�tcrGarrrt i+rf snnawutalt�fas tFtasaintic haru�un�, ✓ } C h Apptca .G. , tifurc H CL()lJN I"Y ol1..... Sworn to and subscribed k3Ooru mc,by means of �hysicad presence or k online notarization this day of ) � 20 h q N r„SAME OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT) AI'1 MENT) I or�atly l ?!]n to ra... p i�F?to r�a i.ra .n) .._-_... ..._ � ataxy p ELODY GAL.LO Iro r. )IZ rardfr�ceel as era taawn. f s tiers - �... . Commissnon 4 HH 2 ofFBarida C� 80366 (IA Il,r Ct1��ty"1N'a M r .y Priblic �.u.,. a ° My Comm,Expires fain 26,2026 � " G Bonded through National Notary Assn. Print,`I"ypes or :'tamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public fitly eonrnrission cxlydr°cs: 'i"O I l;C'()IvII'l:,ETT"D I3Y STAFF-I>A°IT: �° l2("p(:0 AI�II.,I�A"N"i()N i . . ... Pa t?ot'a Achn Refit Regi entian akrag,lac,Uc,n G7.r 2'n',.?CN'F."y App9ic amifs In bI 1.and rinue � r� � 3800 Iscialmer 9arQ r t ur4yPFo 'erty Appraiser's office maintains data on property within the County solely foir the purpose of f Ulf]Ikng its responsibi ity to secure a just valuation for ad valorem tax purposes of all property within the County.The Monroe County Property Appraiser's office cannot gguarantee Its accuracy for any other purpose.Likewise,data provided regarding one tax year may not be applicable in prior or subsequent years.By requestingg Such data,you hereby understand and agree that the data is intended for ad valorem tax purposes only and should not be relied on for any other purpose, y continuing into this site you assert that you have read and agree to the above statement, Summary Parcel ID 004-49340-0000 0 Account# 1,548987 Property 10 1548987 MillageGreup 500P Location 128 CARIBBEAN Avc,TAVERNIER Address Legal BK6LT35HARRISOCEANPKESTATESICEYLARCO0R447-134-1350R789-1'732OR1.t1U3-2476AFF0R1627-1.107/080R24e[8-1.522/32 Description 0R2448-1.524/250R294.7..04120R2962-100/1.0I(DEC/REST) tlat h(r:1, be u d o nu cy,011,ouui7i+Ewt;�a.( Neighborhood 1.673 Property VACANT RES(0000) Ctass Subdivision HARRIS OCEAN PARK ESTATES Sec/Tvrp/Rng 23/62/38 Affordable No Housing Owner I ltVlC�f;9t'tLtalll;;l'. �C�V(Gb i,V,�wf;j�CVr"v� PO Box 9357 PO Box 9357 Tavernier FL.33070 Tav nftr Ft.33070 Valuation 2022 Certified 2021 Certified 2020 Certified 2019 Certified Values Values Values Values + Mat,ket Improvement VaIue $0 $o $0 $0 * Market Misc Value, $0 $o $0 $0 * Market Lanni Vahte $86,279 $77,:398 $77„398 $48,994 = Just Markct Value $86,279 $77,398 $77,398 $48,994 = Total Assessed Value $85,138 $7'7,398 :$77,398 $11,926 School ExensptValue $0 $o $0 $q School Taxable Value $86„279 $77„398 $77,398 $48,994 Historical Assessments Year Land Value Suillding Value Yard Item Value Just(Market)Value Assessed Value.. Exempt Value Taxable.Value MaciInurn Portability 2021 $77,398 $3 $0 $77,398 $77,398 $0 $77,398 $0 2020 $77,398 $0 $C3 $77,398 $77,398 $0 $77,398 $0 2019 $48,994 $0 $0, $48,994 $11,926 $0 $48,994 $0 2018 $40,200 $E $3' $40,200 $10,842 $C $40,200 $0 tla�. IIasacVi��G+ccti°,7i{.iluilwlwP•,c�o�ali�ra<tic^ :,d�I;,aiicJ^,Vrr,c,gcJrxr,tla i�..lur::G'Inge,,�€rya,'BIx,,,,tti,aJBI,.vr0,�[�Itit°t ztr�+.4artiN:,C"{riol,rrl:E'aui�a.,lt�rR,�rriFf, Ba'u ,�.1.arxll:,.rtr�l.rifottr Le""�.irld Land Use Numberof Units UnitTyp�e Frontage Diepth RESIDENTIAL DRY UNPERMITTED(01DM) 5,025,00 Squ are Foot a 0 Hp1 :,.If /k,3(701 f�. 1 Sales Sale Date, SalePrice Instrument Instrument Number Deed Book Deed Page Sale Qualification Vacant or Improved Grantor Grantee 1/30/2019 $20,000 Warranty Deed 2204219 29'47 0412 37-Unqualified Vacant 11/9/2007 $12,100 Quit Claim Deed 2448 1522 J-Unqualified Vacant. 8/1.6/2007 $12,100 Qu it C1,,.6rn Deed 2448 1.524 J-UnqUZIlified Vacant 2/1/1970 $1,000 Conversion Code 447 134 Q-Qua lified Vacant V'iew Tax Info Mi"0 - r!D cr Map V. TRIIM Notice 2022 ',�WAor?s OfAy No data availablefor the following rnodules:Building5,Yard Items,Permits,Sketchvs(ckckto enlarge),Photos. schneider 5 PA A L, C; I I ,'jr r7 I r fK'MMO 7/2 1 1 3802 Docft 2204219 02/04/2019 9!:32AM Filed & Recorded in Official Records of MONROE COUNTY KEVIN RADOM TH'IS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY AND RETURN -rol. 02 ray 4/2eiq 9;32pM Virginia Pennell DEED DOC STAMP CL Brit $140 00 Sunshine Title of the Keys, Inc. 102900 Overseas Highway #6 Key Largo, Florida 33037 Doclil 2204219 Our File No.: 19,012165 Bk# 2947 P9# 412 Property Appraisers Parcel identification(Folio) Number" 1548987 Florida Docurnentary Stamps in the amount of$140.00 have been paid hereon, sparm ikbCV0 WS Une for Rrxormv OV0 WARRANTY DEED THIS WARRANTY DEED, made the 30th day of January, 2019 by Eileen Perez Del Cueto, a married woman whose post office address is 10834 SW 74 Street, Miami, FL 33173 herein called the Grantor, to Harold Fried and Sherry Fried, husband and wife whose post office address is P.O. Box 9357, Tavernier, FL 33070, hereinafter called the Grantees: (14ftrever used herein the forms "Grantor" and "Grantee' include all the parties to this instrument and the heirs, legal eepresentatives and assigns of individuals,and the successors and assigns ot corporations) W I T N E S S E T'H: That the Grantor, for and in consideraflon of the sum of TEN AND 00/100'S ($10.00) Dollars and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remi�ses, releases, conveys and confirms unto the Grantee all that certain land situate in MONROE County, State of Florida,viz.: Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park, Estates,, according to the rnap or plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 4, P,age(s)126,of the Public Records of Monroe County,Florida. Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and taxes for the year 2019 and thereafter. The property described herein is vacant land and does not constitute the homestead of the granter as she resides at 10834 SW 74 Street,Miami, Florida 33173, TOGETHER, with all the tenements, hereditament s and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining, TO HAVE AND TO HOLD,the same in fee simple forever. AND,the Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantees that the Grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful authodty to sell and convey said land, and hereby warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whornsoever„ and that said land is free of all encumbrances, except taxes accruing subseqUent to December 31,2018. File lslo�19012165 Or 3803 Docp 2204219 Bk# 2947 Pq# 413 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above wied= Selivered in the presence of: ,.Ju� C� WitZL� #1 Signature Eileen Perez Del ueto 0 r _ I- /V 42 S; Wit ss#1 Printed N ftfnes-s# gnature Virginia Pennell Witness#2 Printed Name STATE OF Flo i a COUNTY OF `:-� The foregoing instrument was acknowledged bef a this�3¢th day of January, 2019, by Eileen Perez Del Gueto who is personally known to me or has produced L l C.. as identification and l did E3 did not take an oath. SEAL �,M�U;�tllrrrurrr���� No ary4Pu Virginia Pennell �►•� �'• Printed Notary Name My commission exp ti NONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS File No:19012165 is http://or.monroe-clerk.com/L-andmackWeb/search/index?theme=.blue§ion=searchCriteriaName&quickSearchSelection=# 717123,3:2-3804 Page 2 inc.. 02 June 2023 hand delivery Mr. Hal l rigid Mr. Hal Fried P.O. Box 9357 Tavernier, FL 33070 RE: Existing Conditions Letter for. 128 Caribbean Avenue Monroe County Building Permit Number: 19300570 Harris Ocean Park:Est. RE: 00449340-000000 Oceanside, Harry Harris Park, MM 92.7 Rey Largo Key Dear Mr. Fried, As requested, this letter should be considered as an existing conditions statement for the above referenced property. On Friday, the 02 June 2023 a site visit was conducted to inspect. the parcel and compare the existing conditions on 02 June 2023 to the original date of the Existing Conditions Report completed on 11, 16, and 2011 of March 2019. A thorough inspection was done on the entire parcel. The parcel property boundary lines were found to be intact.and, were delineated with rebar and white& yellow contiguous nylon string. The limits of clearing area were also delineated. with rebar at the corners of each of the clearing lines. No vegetation was missing or removed on the 02 Tune 2023 as per the original Vegetation Site flan dated March 2019. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments regarding this letter or the field visit, Rgard , Susan V. Sprunt, PhD ;c7� 6h i`D A G~`IOa iN 1 U70 X l`4.�x. 3805 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF Governor Environmental Protection Jeanette Nufiez L,Covrernozr •'� ` Marjory Douglas Building ' ti AL'9s 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard PiaHamilton Secretary ry Tallahassee,FL 32399 February 13, 2023 Harold Fried Sherry Fried PO Box 9357 Tavernier, FL 33070 TEE: )lte guest for Removal from Further Consideration Parcel I.T . No. 00449340-000000,Monroe County Thank you for your letter requesting that the above listed property be removed fi°om the Florida. Keys Ecosystem Florida.Forever project. This letter confirms that your property has been removed from the project. If you have questions, please contact,Shauna Allen of my staff at 850.245.2713 or by email at shatina.r.allen@floridadep.gov. Sincerely, Deborah Burr Program Administrator Office of Environmental Services Division of State Lands dB/sa 3806 MONROE COUNTY, FL ITEM 1 OF 1 PERMIT RECEIPT OPERATOR: stankiet COPY # : 1 Sec:23 Twp:62 Rng:38 Saab: Blk: Lot: RE 00449340000000 DATE ISSUED. . . . . . . . ,d ! / 1 ;, !��,; RECEIPT . . . . . . . .,03000054453 REFERENCE ID # . . . : 19300570 NOTES . . . . . .. . . . . . . ROGO Application SITE ADDRESS . . . . . : 128 CARIBBEAN AVE SUBDIVISION . . . . . . ; CITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . : KEY LARGO _ ... IMPACT AREA . . . . . . OWNER FRIED HAROLD FRIED SHERRY ADDRESS . . . . . . . . . . PO BOX 93S7 CITY/STATE/ZIP . . . : TAVERNIER, FL 33070 RECEIVED FROM . . . . : HAL FRIED CONTRACTOR, . . . . . . . : LIC # *OWNER,* COMPANY . . . . . . . . . . : FRIED HAROLD FRIED SHERRY ADDRESS . . . : PO BOX 9357 CITY/STATE/ZIP . . . : TAVERNIER, FL 33070 TELEPHONE . . . . . . . . : FEE ID UNIT QUANTITY AMOUNT PD-TO-DT THIS REC NEW BAL ROGO FLAT RATE 1.00 850.00 0.00 850.00 0.00 TOTAL PERMIT : 850.00 0'.00 850.00 0.00 METHOD OF PAYMENT AMOUNT REFERENCE NUMBER ---- 850.00 2420 —___.._—__..___ --------- ---------------- TOTAL RECEIPT 850.00 3807 SHERRY & HAL FRIED P. 0. BOX 9357 TAVERNIER, FL 33070 (305)'852-d635 ILI " CONSULTING SYSTEMS inc. blOLOOLcal assesswewts.cowsultatwws.hab%tat awal�sls EXISTING CONDITIONS REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 118-2 MONROE COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE Legal Description of Parcel: Block Lot Subdivision Key(island) Plat BooklPage Re# ,,„ 16 36 Harris Ocean Park Est. Key Largo 00449340-000000 Location: 128 Caribbean Avenue- Harry Harris Park- Oceanside Monroe County Building Permit Application Number: NA Property Owner(Last Name,First Name): Address (Mailing address for Owner): Fried Harold P.O. Box 9357 Tavernier, FL. 33070 Report Date: Date(s) of site visit(s): 18-20 March 2019 11, 16, 20th of March 2019 Name of Biologist: 7 Affiliation: 305 gi tion: Phones ( ) 852-1920 Susan V. Sprunt S., Inc. E-mail: susan@susansprunt.com Signature: I, , hereby authorize Monroe County Planning &Enviro mental' (PROPERTY Y OWNER-PRINT] Resources Department staff to access the property identified above for purposes of verifyip,°g the, , " information contained in this Existing Conditions Report: l Pagel of 4 3808 SUMMARY This Existing Conditions Report represents a vacant parcel on Caribbean Avenue within theAklarryHarris Park area of Key Largo Key. The parcel consists of a closed canopy of tropical hardwood hammock. The predominant canopy trees are: Mahogany (Swietenia mahagoni), Willow Bustic (Sideroxylon salicifolium), and Jamaican Dogwood (Piscidia piscipula). In additions there were sparse gumbo limb (Bursera simaruba) and pigeon plum (Coccoloba diversifolia) trees throughout. The understory and ground cover were typical for habitat of this type. The location of the trees and/or features on the Vegetation Site Plan (see Sheet of) are estimations only, and exact locations should be verified in the field by a land surveyor. II. Plant Species Ust Size Number to Common Name Scientific Name Status Numbers°b,` dbh be removeddlf Blackbead Pithecellobium keyensis RI 3 MED 1 Blolly Guiapira discolor N Caper, Jamaica Quadrella jamaicensis RM 1 SM 1 Coffee, Wild Psychotria nervosa RM 5 MED 4 Crabwood Gymnanthes lucida RI 1 MED 1 Darling Plum Reynosia septentrionalis T 1 XL 1 Dogwood, Jamaican Piscidia piscipula N 12 XL 6 Gumbo Limbo Bursera simaruba N 8 XL 5 i Inkwood Exothea paniculate RI 1 LAR 1 Mahogany Swietenia mahagoni T 15 XL 6 Marlberry Ardisia escallonioides RM 10 LAR 9 , Pigeon Plum Coccoloba diversifolia N 10 XL 3 Poisonwood Metopium toxiferum N 3 XL 0 B Rhacoma Crosspetalum rhacoma T 1 LAR 1 Randia Randia aculeata RM 1 MED 1 Snowberry Chiococca alba RM 4 XL 4 Stopper, Spanish Eugeina foetida RM 13 XL 13 . . Stopper, White Eugenia axillaris RM 11 XL le Velvetseed, Everglades Guettarda elliptica N Willow bustic Sideroxylon salicifolium N 13 XL 7 Yellow root Morinda royoc N Page 2 of 4 3809 (NI. .<EY: RM=Reproductive Maturity (Section 18-2 (5), Monroe County LDR) N=Native plant T= Threatened, State of Florida RI=Regionally Important,Monroe County,Florida E=Endangered, State of Florida SM(small) MED (Medium) LG(Large)XL (Extra Large) Mitigation sizes for Sectionl 18-2(5). III. Animal S' gies List Suitable Habitat Species Potentiall Common Name Scientific Name Status Focus A +c s Foraging Roosting Nesting No animal species listed as endangered, threatened, or otherwise protected as per Section 118-2 (d).were observed during the site survey. " Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or require additional information. Reg s, x;�" Susan V. Sprunt a M A p, Page 3 of 4 3810 00 M FJO t a9vd If `paleool aie al,uegi ssol —�..-. �ClinnaAd W anlionpoadag.suald. wool 01 • snlels lalaads ylrm pals!!sluald. 9M :paleao[ase lale018 Jo,v sluald. , y :Xluo suolzeutgso suollaaol lueld. ,.6[�;F • { • :SUON ?� . 1$ aualUlu10;lalIE5UUlKxolrp[S .I.SS n—j luowggelu eivalaptiis:..MS aau lleuolaNal as slsou ag:yd21 alelneealpuuU :Vd slsuaal—!apaapa :p I l J aallaln lasr elpras!d .Lad ' N esoniau auoga sd :Nd JI. � asua tl—M-11aaa44id :.L'Jd N aaal curr,rgllxul uunldzto :.LAW Op aaal eponr I�g9ualltaa r .:1 17 � ('R anliia„r a7e@ r,lq � ' a��i ueilln eaun r ,;d' �f„y • halt arae0rml arum L J V , � '�' ccaro^rea�o wn�vl'rdssoJ"7 —) QL 15u a:iwgislanlp egoPONO5.141.) ecpuraio~ay.) VJ aa7 agnietuis v rasuet{;:l:sq .sa i o�pia uohllxsy, ;L,y <t ,isle .lauMp fuladoad I • l :aamog � .. • i4a I -Ada F Y 6IOZ gaaayg ✓ °� �� • 000000-017£617too 3laad vaa30 suaeg 6" 9 31a `9£to I ` �jd• �� Pau PIOd P[oMH'iTgI L :io3 :alaas jA ucld OPS l"'I Ma any }K7 " 1 • �• � • Al —04 • i 1wg8 .100 !vas 9m 0 0 a !. .1att pi 11 I 110"I MC1YlwiROE CCI'UNT`i' 4PLANNING AM)ENVIRONMENTAL REsouRcEs DEPARTMENT 1� ' MFrResidential Permit Allocation( Application Monroe County Lad Development Code Section 13 -t. 1 2030 Comprehensive Plan Objective 101.6 rrrr�wrrcwina��urnWwoma�ram�sr�muwm�rr�usnawiairmarr��m�ruwxrr��reunMiar�rr���e�A��wmw�arwr� vmmu�� u�um� � ua�raira+r, Ww�� ¢miu! �rirremw!uxr �,w�ramou�m�iwCw��iar�ri�rrrim�rrre�mawv Applicsltio>n Fee. $850.M [MCCsuctiurnr3a-24,ab)nonreranndainitfool (i'r?oAl'f'L'.PL:>tV"rON FEE F7312.:1Fr%C3ltf)i'q,BIX'Fdc?T.rRNO PRINT(S1t+GLF-SIDED)AND ATTACH A COPY OF THE E CURRENT RECORDED DEED AND A PROPERTY RECORD CARD(L>AUD WI HIN nut DAYS Or SUBMITTAL;).. IF YOU IIAVE QUESTIONS OR WISI1'1'0 MAKE AN APPOINTMENT TO DELIVER YOUR .API}LICATION PLEASE CALL THE OFFICE CLOSEST TO YOUR PROJECT. [Marathon:(305)289-2500 Ivey Largo:(305)453-88001 ONCE THIS APPLIC ATION IS ACC 1'�I''I L)AND fly 171 1:7I 11.11 COMPLETE,REVISI 1�dS MAY Tile Mfll�F PURSUANT TO LAND IIEVE OPMEN.f CODE SECTION 1M,25. 1VJ�i�Wt'Y�'Yd�V'RtlJ@Y�iG��P1,61X�8iilYln!nNG'NDtilhipll�L"'IIMaIpIXI!Yd1�W"SXW'�E6'�I�!YPY�'!1�16'U66dGnGi�pllNd1"kIiVM'@UYI�Il�.tltld�SJ�iIV!�fi�WYC,'�11�dM4nli!�d�!YikN�INI1G�flIf�Y�i�WY�IIpP�IV�I�Y'I�1Si�4"I�:VI'��IpI�NIBk�gI�W tlk 'd(;1ilY�ti�'i�Y�i�48x'I�!WINIwM1YrdW$NU,'��7�"VIYItlV`�'FCC"�1118Ni"'l�J,'C2N��dilvCkJ1pW11!I�P96'TIl�� Owner(s)Ntanle: a " ( Ph. (llusiintsi/C"orp/lentity Docannents shover ing who is authoria.ewi to sitar and documentation showing entity is current and aLlim) Mailing Address: PO 13 Ovmer(s)Ernail Address: , a ( '� �'-`� 140c> as C' 10 g rt s Name 0 x autir9orra4.atrirn ,.. Ph..(W).� � ✓`�t ( t Ut roc the ItCIGO Appikidion from all property ownen'ae. lrthe Agent is Busine:a:adC.orp,therm a ocannnentation s h�owing'who in autlauri'sed to sign And entity is current and active.,) Mailing Address: 51A City: state:�" A dip: �1 (If A Agent mailing aaldmss is the same as owner then onty cane ittdar will ix sent to the owner.) A t lrots(s)Ellanil Address; ,. Block Subdivision—z4 /� dot �� I'RC.?1'l ItTY 1)I;SCRIiI?TICJII:I;ctt d Key island 44 6 0 Street If'nretcs and Minds,of act legal de.scription an separate Sheet Unitp Type(.It-t t ar ocy): A) I_Affordable/Employu Housing Unit or IE" _Market Date Residential Unit:(wied a category): I Commercial Apartment: V Dwelling Unit: Mobile Home: others: i Check"lies or No. If yes,theta attach the requested documents: Yes ...,No II The project is conibining vacant legally platted lets or contiguous vacant parcels for aggregation for the voluntary reduction of density,fear the retirement of development rights[see MCC Section 138-28(4)and Policy 101.6.41. Please attach a copy of a proposed restrictive covenant, and unity of title,running in favor of and enforceable by the County. Include,if applicable,Affidavit of No Eticunr ar<ances,Joinder, and Entity Affidavit. For Aggregation points a lot/parcel must contain a nnininntun of2,000 square feet of uplands.Please note a cornervation e:asenaent may be required. If parctEs were previously aggregated tx-.cause of ROW criteria[see If,the property hALS an Policy 101.6.4 and Monroe County Code Section 138-28(aX4)],then a existing approved subsequent ROGO allocation application will receive the same recorded aggregation points 'l i y° s th�"Zpp'�l crty have a dues the property owner rtuaaalveyr of extra atutd;ot�a tr;a1l assigned. Igoe pivviously recorded aggregation res[iiction`l Yes_N wvunt the car.rrnnC)die rJ point values ANE Y3re if"yr s,attach copy of recorded docurnent(s). 1''trrswxant cy 1 1A.4 property owner proposes a and Monroe County Code Section 138-28(at 4). Please attach a copy .sir,c rssedin>e r"c atio n7 of proposed unity of title, running in favor of and enforceable by the Yes F Ito County. Please note a conservation easemeant nna be re aired. - y (lf"M1t(J,the rrgincal aggregation points will he t7.45"d P9'6t;1 Applicant to initial and date each pal; Application Number: ItOGO APPLIC:A.TIC11A�ORMVISE D 1tt.18',2t118 Page I of 4 3812 The proposal includes dedication of vacant land pursuant to MCC Section 138-28(5)and Policy 101.6.4. Yes., No 1 Required attachments with this application are: 1) letter front the Biologist stating the property is dedicaleable,2)proof of ownership, including a copy of current Monroe County Property Record Card and a copy of the recorded deed showing you as the property owner,3)complete copy of title insurance policy and current Opinion of Title,4)proposed WARRANTY DEED(S)(Quit Clahn Deeds will not be accepted), and 5)land dedications must be in the same ownership as the owner listed above unless the applicant has an approved land dedication certificate. List the RE'(s)of the land to be dedicated: The applicant(s) is/are: requesting market rate housing point-, pursuant to MCC Section 138-28(aX6), Yes F.No because the proposed unit is an integral pail of employee or affordable housing project. Tile applicant(s) is/arc submitting monetiny payment to the County's Land Acquisition Fund for the Yes 'No PLII-ChaSe of County of land for conservation and retirement of development rights. Maximum of two whole points inay be purchased. Each point is 530,218.Number points purchased mid to be paid oil date of this application subanittial/acceptance by the:Planning& Environmental Department with a Money Order or Cashiers Check, X The proposed unit(s)will be affordable housing.Requhvd, Please attach a copy of a current affordable NO Yes housing approval from the Planning Department. MCC Section 138-24(c) and 139-2(a)O(e), "No affordable housing, allocation shall be awarded to applicants located within a tier I designated'area, within a V-7onc on the countys flood insurance rating reap, tier 11 or within a tier 111-A (special protection area)if clearing is proposed for any portion of an upland native habitat" N og The submitted Building Permit Application and plans for the residential dwelling unit includes Energy Yes and Water Conservation Points in accordance with the 2030 Monroe County Comprehensive Plan Policy 101.6.4(10)to allocation applications on lands designated as Tier 111. I/We are requesting the following points specified: Points Requested n 3 point-,.- Pro"es as dwelling unit designed wcording to and certified to the standards of asaistainable building rating or national model green Yes J N( building code 1> 2 I point: Dwelling unit includes,installation of permanent ronQrctc cistern with a minimum capacity of 1,000 gallons. Yes No 0 2 points: Dwelling unit includes the installation of a gray watcrrcuse system,inecting the requirements;of tile Florida Building Codc. Yes 0 F1 I point: Dwelling unit includes installation of a solar photovoltaic collection system,a minimum of 3KW in size or(]to equivalent in other yes No ---renewable energy systems. Ll 0.5,points. Dwelling unit includes installation of one or both of the following tccllllologics;* &Ductless air conditioningsysten. b,High effien;ncy chillers If Points are applied the systeni(s)must be maintained for a niminturn of five years from the C.O.Unless replace with a s Istern that provides a functional equivalent or increased oneMy or water sayLln I/We understand if the property is not on lands designated as Tier III or the requeskd point(s)are not reflected oil the current Building Permit Application eligible to submit into POGO or are not in compliance with the Energy and Water Conservation Point criteria the point(s) requested will not be assigned to_this up phc,ation. Is them a ding code en 11)rceni en t proceeding in blvi ag all or a portion o f the parcel p roposed for development? �11 Yes No Code Case fit, Ft Describe the enforcement proceedings and if this application is being submitted to COITed the violation: I certify that 1)1 have read and examined this application including attachments and know same to be true and correct;2)All provisions of laws and ordinances govertring this type of work are complied with whether specified herein or not, including the provision of Local, State, or Federal requirements regulating construetion or the peribmiance of constrixtion; and 3)Tune periods for County action set forth hi Section 1,10-142 of the'County Code are hereby waived. Applicant to initial and date each pa Application Number: 5 ROGO APPLICATIO eF-iO)�RM IRE WISED 10.18.2018 Page 2 of 4 3813 A PP 1 CA'110t,J Additionally, I understand an application for administrative relief may be submitted to the Planning & Envirorn-tremal RIcsources DLI)artinent as prescribed by the Director of Planning-, however, an application for administrative relief may not be submitted before the conclusion of the sixteenth quarterly allocation period and no later than one hundred eighty days following die close of the sixteenth quarterly allocation period based on the current ROGO application. Furthermore, I acknowledge if the property is sold the eights to the ROGO Application and/or Administrative Relief Application will automatically transfer to the new property owner of record. The records for notification will only be updated after the new property owner(i)submits a copy of the recorded deed. Please note if the ROGO Application includes aggregation, land dedication, or affordable housing, documentation will need to be submitted by the new property owner(s) to show the basis of the scoring of the ROGO Application has not changed. Otherwise, if the basis of the ROGO Application scoring has changed then the ROGO Application will automatically be withdrawn once the Department is aware of the change. IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE NEW PROPERTY OWNER TO UPDATE ALL CONTACT INFORMATION. Note,after 3 unsuccessful attempts to notify the applicant of record on the ROGO Application via certified mail,any allocation award shall expire. APPL ICA NTS ON BIG PfNE'Key&NO NAME ICE Y ONLY: luiiderstanddicreisaiiiitigilionrequii-eiiieiitfoi - new residences, non-residential floor area and instittitional uses on Big Pine Key &No Name Key in order to ensure that development bears its fidrshare of the required mitigation under the Federal Incidental "fake Permit. Prior to the permit issuance all mitigation requirements shall be satisfied according to the UP for each H value impacted by the proposed development in accordance with the three to one H mitigation ratio in the Habitat Conservation Plan. Pursuant to Section 122-8 of the Land Development Code, development that OCCUT9 within areas designated as "Species Focus Areas(SFAs)-or"Species Buller Areas(SBAs)"within unincoiTioratLxl Monroe County will be reviewed pursuant to the"Pen nit Referral Process"to ensure compliance with the Federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) Note: Properties requiring FWS technical assistance who receive an allocation award pursuant to Monroe County will be issued an allocation pursuant to Monroe Comity Code Chapter 138. Some applicants may or may not obtain the required FWS technical assistance prior to the expiration of the allocation award and/or permit. If the allocation award/pLirnit expires the,property would be sula_ject to the process again, 1,the Applicant,certify that ani famill "with the information cqjiWm-4 in this application,and that to'the best ofinyk-nowl-dy s, hinfi nation as t fe con1p]-te and accurate. Signature of Applicant'..- Date: COU NTY 0 Sworn to and subsc ed before me this dajrz:�� i J-A-)�" br�Lt> who is IS mw known to me OR (PRINT NAMF OF PERSO,N N1AWNGS-rA-1EMFr'[() as identification. OF to PRODUCED) LAUREN MStateARPNEZ N uta ry Pu U c- of Flo r¢d a . ......... #GG 182082 nature of Notary Pi lie 'AyComni.Expirts Feb4,2022 Banded through Niltiorlal Notary Assn. 1244Dt; ', -e- Stamp CoAnissioned Name of Notary public My commission expires: EEH "l'O Y STAFF-DATE: TIME.- PERMU All ofthe following must be submitted in o r to 11�1 cutpoete application Submittal: rd '4R Applicant to initial and date each pa Application Nuin ber: g ROGO APPLICATIO;�� M EVISED 110.18.2018 Page 3 of 4 3814 "id"M K,'�,TION (Plew Z/hec 1 8111 you attach cach required item to the application)' "u'a", F o plete application(unaltered gaid unbound) Correct fee(check or money order to Monroe County 111anning&E'n0roninental Resouives) Correct fee Monroe County Property Record Card amid Proof of ownership(i.e.Warranty Deed), Irapplic e,tile following must be submitted in order to have,it complete application submittal Notarized Agent Authorization lifter(notc:gruthorization is needed from all owners)of flic subject property) ElBuIdness/CorplEntily Decundents showing who is authorized to sign sand documentation 4howing entity is current and active. Trust Ownership docinnentaticin showing who is authorized to sign. Parcels previously Aggregated: If parcels were previously aggregated because ofROC GO criteria,then ar subsequent ROGO aliccation split ication will receive tire same number of extr i points originally assigned. Recluiredattachments: 1) ('Opy(5fpreviou,.il.otAggrcgatioiiRestrictiveCoveiiiiii-,,ind 2) Proposed(.1nity,ofTittc-,and 3) Copy of current deed;and 4) If applicable include Affidavit of No Encumbrances,Joinder,and Entity Affidavit,of ecteria. Aggregation (combining vacant legally platted lots or contiguous vacial parcels for aggregation for tile voluntary reduction of density,forthe reliremeall,ofdvvelopmont rights). Requiredattachments: 1) Proposed Aggregation Restrictive Covenant or Super-ceding Aggregation Restrictive Covenant;and 2) proposed LTrgiiyof Title;and. 3) Copy of current deed-,and 4) 1 fapplicable include All idavit or No Encumbrances.Joinder,and Entity Affidavit,et ceteria. land Dedication. Required attachments- 1) Letter front the Biologist stating the pro1wrly is dedicatcable;and 2) Proof of ownership,including it Copy Of OUTIVIA MOVIVOC County Property Record Card and a copy of the recorded deed showing you as the property owner.and 3) Complete copy of title insurance policy and current Opinion of'ritle;and 4) Proposed WARRANTY IYET'D(S)(Quit Claun Deeds grill not he acceplee;and 5) Land dedications must lie in the,same ownership in;the owncr listed above unless the applicant has an approved land dedication certificate;and 6) 14'applicabic include Affidavit of No Eli GUMbraireqq,Joinder,and F`,ntity Affidavit,ct octcria ElMonetary Payment to[lie County's Land Acquisition Fund for a maximum of Point 2:Moncy Order or Cash iem Check Affordable,Ifold.ing/Eniployee Housing- 1) Attach copy ofeurrentallbrdable housint-approval; 2) Proposed Affordable Housing Restriction;and 3) Copy of Current deed,,and 4) 117applicable include Affidavit ofNo,Encumbrances,Joinder,and Entity Affidavit,el,eoteria lAtiergyaxid Water(,:oiisewwationlloints:: Available ifilroperty only located in Tier Ill. ne following requested point are on the submitted Building Permit Application Plans: The proposed dwelling unit is dosignod to and ecrtifiial to standards of sustainable building rating or national model green building code. Sustainable Builifing Rating or National Afo&I Green Building Code means a roUng.system esiablushed by the Unilred Stales Green Building Council(USGB(.,)Leadership in Eneigy and Environmenial Degign(LELD)rating -ilrstcrn,the I,rilernotional Green Construclion C'o&(IOCC), the Oreen Building Initiagire's Green Globes rating systegi, the Florida Green Building Coalition standards, or a nationally recognized, high-ped6rinance given buildipig rating systein as opprored by the depcjrtaient. The proposed dwelling unit includes installation of a permanent concrete cistern with it minimum capacity of 1,000 gallons. The proposed dwelling unit includes the installation of a gray water reuse system,meeting the requirements of the Florida Building Code. Crory water reuse mean reusing winitewater froul residertial,commercial and industrial bathroom sinks,bath tab shower drains,and clothes washing equipment drains for reuse onsite,typically for toilet flushing, OThc Proposed dwelling unit includes installation oaf solar photovoltaic collection system,a mininular of 3KW in sire or the equivalent in other renewable energy systems. ElThe proposed dwelling unit includes installation of one or both of the following techno logics:* a. Ductless air conditioning system. Ductless air conifitioning means a system used to cool a structure that does not require duct work and consists of two separate component,,:im,outdoor condenser,and gin indoor evaporator(does not includo a window air conditioner which is self-colitaincd,or one piece). ll. high efficiency chillet-3 If deerned necessary to comploe,a full revimi ol'i he application,tile Planning&Environmental Reaguros Department reseries the right In request ad diftional hilarniallon. Applicant to initial and date each pa Application Nandber: OD t ROGO APPLICATION 41F . I 1RUVISED 10.18.2018 Page 4 of 4 3815 (VqPu' b1"1c.net" Mon:roe County, FL Disclaimer The(Monroe County Property Appraiser's office maintains data on property within the County solely for the purpose of fLIIfalling its responsibiVity to secure a just valuation for ad valorem tax purposes of all property within the County.The Monroe County Property Appraiser's office cannot guarantee its accuracy for any other purpose.Likewise,data p�arovided regarding one tax year may not be applicable in prior or subsequent years. y requestin such data,you frereby understand and agree that the data is intended for ad valorem tax purposes only and should not be relied on for any other purpose. y continuing into,this site you assert that you have read and agree to the above statement. Summary Parcel.ID 00449340- 0000 Account# 1.548987 Property ID 1548987 millage Group 5001) Location 128 CAR]BB EAN Ave,TAVERN I ER Address Legal 8K 6 LT 36 HARRIS OCEAN PK ESTATES KEY LARGO OR447-134-135 OR789-1732 COR1003-2476AFF OaR1627-1107/08 OR2448-1522/32 OR2448- Description 1524/25OR2947-0412OR2962',-100f101(DEC/REST) �I4otc Not Pobe1,scdr.rualr.�q,,��Idc,,('-ut'a'ee^ixr.r Neighborhood 1673 Property VACANT'RES(0000) Class Subdivision HARRIS OCEAN'PAIRK ESTATES Sec/TWp/ ng 23/62/38 Affordable No Housing Owner PO 8ox'9357 PC Box 9357 Tavernier FL33070 Tavernier FL,33070 Valuation 2018 2017' 2016 2015 • Market Improvement Value $0 $0 $0 $0 + Market Misc Val'uc $0 $0 $0 $0 • Market Land Value $40,200 $43„969 $37,865 $21,651 Just Market Value $40,200 $43„969 $37,865 $21;651 Total Assessed Value $10,842 $9,857 $8,961 $8,147 School Exempt Value $0 $0 $0 $0 School Taxable Value $40,200 $43,969 $37,865 $21,,651 Land Land Use Number of Units UnitType Frontage Depth RESIDENTI'AL DRY UNPERMITTED(01DM) 5,025.00 Square Foot 0 0 Sales Sale Date Sale Price Instrument Instrument Number Deed Book Deed Page Sale Qualification Vacant or Improved 1/30/2019 $20MO Warranty Deed 2204219 2947 0412 37' Unqualified Vacant, 11/9/2007 $12,100 Quit Claim Deed 2448 1.522 )-Unqualified Vacant, 8/16/2007 $12,100 Quit Claim Deed 2448 1524 1-Unqualified° Vacant. 2/1/1970 $1„000 Conversion Code 447 134 Q-Qualified Vacant View Tax Info 3816 Map D r TRIM J @ M � 111 f _ 4 inyop.i,e ,pxs_r.��yH:rsreai,l� `��" �>u /�yf/✓ + �dM a i� "�' ��w✓w N�i i Uie� ,�r✓' r+ Notice 2101 II4eIIu e s,Car�k No data available for the following modules:Buildings,Commercial Buildings,Mobile Home Buildings,Yard Items,Exemptions,Permits,Sketches(click to enlarge),Photos, Schneider GE4',.97.PAP�as6 3817 Docn 2204219 02/04/2019 9:32AM Filed & Recorded in Official Records of MONROE COUNTY KEVIN MADOK THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: 02/04/2019 9:32AN Virginia Pennell DEED IOC STAMP CL: Brit $140.00 Sunshine Title of the Keys:, Inc. 102900 Overseas Highway #6 DocN 2204219 Key Largo, Florida 33037 Bku 2947 P9h 412 Our File No.: 19012165 Property Appraisers Parcel Identification (Folio) Number: 1548987 Florida Documentary Stamps in the amount of$140.00 have been paid hereon. Space above this Line for Recording Data WARRANTYDEED THIS WARRANTY DEED, made the 30th day of January, 2019 by Eileen Perez Del Cueto, a married woman whose post office address is 10834 SW 74 Street, Miami, FL 33173 herein called the Grantor, to Harold Fried and Sherry Fried, husband and wife whose post office address is P.O. Box 9357, Tavernier, FL 33070, hereinafter (Whet-ever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee" include all the patties to this instrument and the iaeirs, legal representatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns of corporations) W I T N E S S E T H: That the Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND 00/100'S ($10.00) Dollars and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, conveys and confirms unto the Grantee all that certain land situate in MONROE County, State of Florida, viz.: Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates, according to the map or plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page(s) 126, of the Public Records of Monroe County, Florida. Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and taxes for the year 2019, and thereafter. The property described herein is vacant land and does not constitute the homestead of the grantor as she resides at 10834 SW 74 Street, Miami, Florida 33173, TOGETHER, with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in fee simple forever. AND, the Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantees that the Grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good'right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land, and hereby warrants the title to said 'a n d 'a ',wi l'I'defend the"same 1 " against ffie lawful claims'6f afl'persons whomsoever; and that said land is free of all encumbrances, except taxes accruing subsequent to December 31, 2018. File No: 19012165, LTF 3818 DocU 224219 BkN 2947PgN 41 f / , IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Graktor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. S r#—lSig—nature l and.�ieliwered in the presence of: � itne Eileen Perez Del ueto, Wjtr) ss#1 Printed N w ,. i ne s# ig a'ture , " r inia lPennell 'tP+Jitness 2 Printed dame STATE OF Flo I 'a. COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged befog e th' 30th dray of January, 2019, by Eileen Perez Del ueto who is personally known to me or has produced -�" � �� as identification and ❑ did ❑ did not take an oath. SEAL �r1�p�YrlB��� Io � JIJi, t ' J No ary Puu '^G Virginia Fennell Printed Notary Larne my commission expttO; .' r� �j j I' c ° u. ONROE COUNTY OFFICIAL RECORDS 3819 Re No:19012165 �TF 'LJ ate) I hereby authorize — c f' /JAI & t be listed as authorized agent [Name of Agent(individual)] B for 14AL IS lv for the OGO application submittal for (Name of PropertyOwner(s)the pplicarnt(s) on project) Build in Permit Application # � - for property described as Lot: Block Subdivision: !e / : Ivey (island): ZA a and R", Estate number: �> 4/2./c? Q -- P00000 This authorization becomes effective on the date this affidavit is notarized and shall remain in effect until terminated by, the undersigned. This authorization acts is a durable power of attorney only for the purposes stated. The undersigned understands the liabilities involved in the granting of this agency and accepts full responsibility (thus holding Monroe County harmless) for any and all of the actions of the agent naunned, related to the acquisition of permits for the aforementioned applicant. Note: Authorization is needed from each owner of the subject peaty. Therefore, one or more authorization fauns must Inc submitted with the litior if there are It nix°lle owner nperty Owner(s) inatnure r ` � Printed Name of Owner(s) 1 TA Y STATE 0 COUNTY The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this1-3—day f20(9.is _ personally known-"„ prrudneed identification Type of Identification), did/did not take an math. Notary o �w� a�u�atra r��v3ulN�z Ngtary PubiWc-state of Florida :�&;fit (,n jrnmissian 9 GC 1 2PE� My Comm,Expires Fete 4,2022 � t t�u40�d through Natlrar�aB Notary Assn, t'ne1 ] a'r:�1 12/2.311 3820 MONROE COUNTY, FL ITEM 1 OF 1 PERMIT RECEIPT OPERATOR: stankiet COPY Sec:23 TWp:62 Rng:38 Sub: Blk: Lot: RE . . . . : 00449340000000 DATE ISSUED. . . . . . . . 07/09/201.9 RECEIPT #. . . . 03000054453 REFERENCE ID # 19300570 NOTES . . . . . . . . . . . . . ROGO Application SITE ADDRESS . . . . . : 128 CARIBBEAN AVE SUBDIVISION „ . „ . . „ .. CITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . KEY LARGO IMPACT AREA . . . . . . OWNER . . . . . . . . . . . . : FRIED HAROLD FRIED SHERRY ADDRESS . . . . . . . . . . ... PO BOX 9357 CITY/STATE/ZIP . .. . : TA'VERNIER„ FL 33070 RECEIVED FROM . . . . : HAL FRIED CONTRACTOR . . . , . . . . LIC # *OWNER* COMPANY . . . . . . . . . . : FRIED HAROLD FRIED SHERRY ADDRESS . . . . . . . . . . PO BOX 9357 CITY/STATE/ZIP . . . : TAVERNIER, FL 33070 TELEPHONE . . . . . . . . FEE ID UNIT QUANTITY AMOUNT PD-TO-DT THIS REC NEW BAIL ROGO FLAT RATE 1.00 850.00 0.00 850.00 0.00 TOTAL PERMIT : 850.00 0.00 850.00 0.00 METHOD OF PAYMENT AMOUNT REFERENCE NUMBER CHECK 850.00 2420 --------------- TOTAL RECEIPT 850.00 3821 9EwAerrFLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF on nds ° A Governor 0Environmental Protection Jeanette Nufiez Lt.Governor 0, � �w Marjory Stoneman Douglas Building Sham Hamilton frMr&L 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard Secretary Tallahassee,FL 32399 February 13, 2023 Darold Fried Sherry Fried PO Box 9357 Tavemier,FL 33070 RE: Request for Removal from Further Consideration Parcel I.D. No.. 00449340-000000,Monroe County Thank you for your letter requesting that the above listed property be removed from the Florida. Keys Ecosystem Florida Forever project. This letter confirms that your property has been removed from the project. If you have questions,please contact, Shauna.Allen of my staff at 850.245.2713 or by email at shatina.r.allen@floridadep.gov. Sincerely, Deborah Burr Program Administrator Office of Environmental Services Division of State Lands D13/sa 3822 o$ -o �= _____ _________ ___ _________________________________ $P - ����� ��� rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr zoz o � yv w ozo $6 _____ __ W �= o> oM - o W - d' w g M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M a aaa Naaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa `a a`aaa a ease a asaa a s p a aPa as a "a "sa ga�� � a as r eym s aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa2 2 2 g 2aa22222E Pi seam - 'a a_ - - && - - - - _B- os - A m&& A aaaaaaaaP° as a s a s s s s s s s s v a as ad a a a s a q.tax. g p p .a. .t qm^ Aga w vAxx _ � P P v � E E E E Eas v d �a a"aa `a a s ease a "a "a a "a a a aaa.a a o0 3823 ��������� rvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrv___________ o$ $P — ^ Y t 85 ti^ti ti 2 s v O 2 s o w r 86 0 0 - 2 n W Z Q F 2 U W 2 LL a ........ ............ r. .................. ........... F= O F ¢ J �O p O j O n _ O UIT � UI Q UI _ W d' g n n gn gn n gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn gn n g� g�g�g�g�g�g�g�g�g�g�g� g�g�^y^y^y g^y -_--_----_g--_-_-_-_-_- S��SS�SSSSSSSSSSSSSe�B`m 88888888888�88���8888��8����� .5 d d d d.brv4.brv4 S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S m 8 $ tt m s s s m o E E E E E E E E�u 1 m¢m m tt s s x x s s m x p m m m m x¢¢¢¢ s m m 8 8 z ¢z z z z z z z v ¢ a a s a s a¢ zd sd ¢a a E zQ E z z z M &o A8 "v' -------- Pv 88 a$Sv N8 i A YY maarvs aaaaaaaasasN�� ¢c^c^ss ass � ���� � mm�mms �A a rvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrv_ry __rvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrvrv_mmmm ______rvrvrvmm = �5 3824 Objective 101.7 Monroe County shall establish policies to provide for the purchase of land from property owners who have not been awarded building permit allocations in the Permit Allocation System. Policy 101.7.1 Monroe County, the state, or other acquisition agency shall, upon a property owner's request, offer to purchase the property for fair market value or permit the minimum reasonable economic use of the property, if the property owner meets the following conditions: 1. they have been denied an allocation award for four successive years in the Residential (ROGO)or Nonresidential (NROGO) Permit Allocation System; 2. their proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county, state, and federal regulations; 3. their allocation application has not been withdrawn; 4. they have complied with all the requirements of the Residential or Nonresidential Permit Allocation System; and 5. they follow the procedures for administrative relief contained in the land development regulations. As used in this Policy, "minimum reasonable economic use"shall mean, as applied to any residentially zoned parcel of record which was buildable immediately prior to the effective date of the Plan, no less than a single-family residence. A purchase offer is the preferred option for administrative relief, if the subject permit is for development located within: 1. a designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever (or its successor)targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined no county,state or federal agency or any private entity is willing to offer to purchase the parcel); 2. a designated Tier 11 or III-A(Special Protection Area); or, 3. a designated Tier III area on a non-waterfront lot for affordable housing. Refusal of the purchase offer by a property owner shall not be grounds for the granting of a ROGO or NROGO allocation award. An application for administrative relief may be denied based upon any one of the following findings by a special magistrate or the Board of County Commissioners: 1. The applicant previously filed an inverse condemnation or other private property rights claim or cause of action that gave rise to a final judgment or order of dismissal issued by a court of competent jurisdiction in Monroe County's favor, and said claim or cause of action involved the same property and issues of fact that underlie the application for administrative relief; 2. A court of competent jurisdiction likely would determine that the failure of the applicant to qualify for an allocation award has not caused a taking of the property(whether such liability, at the time of application under this policy, is likely to be established by a court of competent jurisdiction should be determined based on applicable statutory, regulatory, and case law at the time the application is considered under this policy); 3. The property retains a practicable economically beneficial use despite its failure to qualify for an allocation award; 3825 4. The applicant previously received an offer from a local, state, or federal governmental agency to purchase the property at its fair market value that was rejected by the applicant; or 5. The failure of the applicant to qualify for an allocation award can be attributed to laws or regulations that are imposed or mandated by an agency of the federal government. ( Ord. No. 013-2022 , § 2(Exh. 1), 8-17-2022) Policy 101.7.2 Monroe County recommends that the Monroe County Land Authority dedicate a minimum of 35 percent of its annual budget each year for the purpose of acquiring land from qualified property owners as defined by Policy 101.7.1. Funds accumulated from this source shall be reserved for the acquisition of land from qualified property owners, but may also be used to acquire other properties when deemed appropriate by the Land Authority. Policy 101.7.3 Monroe County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for lands within the Florida Forever targeted acquisition or Tier I lands areas unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes by any county, state or federal agency or any private entity. The County shall routinely notify Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief request at least six (6) months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. 3826 Sec. 138-27. Administrative Relief. (a) Eligibility.An applicant for an allocation award is eligible for administrative relief if: (1) The application complies with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system; (2) The application has been denied an allocation award for four successive years(first 16 consecutive quarterly allocation periods) in the ROGO Permit Allocation System; (3) The proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county, state,and federal regulations; (4) The ROGO allocation application has not been withdrawn; (5) The applicant has complied with all the requirements of the ROGO Permit Allocation System;and (6) The applicant has followed the procedures for administrative relief;and (7) The applicant has not received an allocation award. (b) Notification of eligibility.Within 30 days of the finalization of evaluation rankings by the Planning Commission,any applicant determined to be eligible for administrative relief pursuant to subsection (a) of this section shall be notified of the applicant's eligibility for administrative relief by certified mail, return receipt requested. (c) Application.An application for administrative relief shall be made on a form prescribed by the Planning Director and may be filed with the Planning and Environmental Resources Department no earlier than the conclusion of the 16th quarterly allocation period and no later than 180 days following the close of the 16th quarterly allocation period. (d) Exceptions. Monroe County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for lands within the Florida Forever targeted acquisition or Tier I land areas unless,after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes by any county,state or federal agency or any private entity. The county shall routinely notify the Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief requests at least six months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. (e) Forwarding application to board of county commissioners. Upon the filing of an application for administrative relief,the Planning Director shall forward to the BOCC all relevant files and records relating to the subject applications. Failure to file an application shall constitute a waiver of any rights under this section to assert that the subject property has been taken by the county without payment of just compensation as a result of the dwelling unit allocation system. (f) Public hearing. Upon receipt of an application for administrative relief,the BOCC shall notice and hold a public hearing at which the applicant will be given an opportunity to be heard.The BOCC may review the relevant applications and applicable evaluation ranking,taking testimony from county staff and others as may be necessary and hear testimony and review documentary evidence submitted by the applicant. (g) Board of county commissioners action.At the conclusion of the public hearing,the BOCC may take any or a combination of the following actions: (1) Offer to purchase the property at its fair market value as its preferred action if the property is located within: a. A designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever(or its successor)targeted acquisition areas (unless,after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief,it has been determined no county,state or federal agency or any private entity is willing to offer to purchase the parcel); Created: 2023-10-18 10:45:58 [EST] (Supp.No.11,Upd.1) Page 1 of 2 3827 b. A designated Tier II area (Big Pine Key and No Name Key); C. A designated Tier III-A area (special protection area);or d. A designated Tier III area on a nonwaterfront lot or parcel for affordable housing. (2) Grant the applicant an allocation award for all or a number of dwelling units requested in the next succeeding quarterly allocation period or extended pro rata over several succeeding quarterly allocation periods as the preferred action for buildable properties not meeting any of the criteria in subsection (g)(1)of this section. (3) Suggest or provide such other relief as may be necessary and appropriate. (h) Limits on administrative allocations per quarter.The number of allocations that may be awarded under administrative relief in any one quarter shall be no more than 50 percent of the total available market rate allocations available,excluding banked administrative relief allocations and those allocations received from Key West, in a quarter for that subarea.Any allocations,excluding banked administrative relief allocations and those allocations received from Key West, in excess of 50 percent shall be extended into the succeeding quarter or quarters until the number of such allocations is 50 percent or less of the total number of market rate allocations available to be awarded. (Ord. No.006-2016, § 1(Exh. 1),4-13-2016) Created: 2023-10-18 10:45:58 [EST] (Supp.No.11,Upd.1) Page 2 of 2 3828 I RESOLUTION NO. —2023 2 3 A RESOLUTION BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD 4 OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS APPROVING THE 5 REQUEST FOR ADMINISTRATIVE RELIEF MADE BY 6 HAROLD & SHERRY FRIED ON PROPERTY 7 DESCRIBED AS LOT 36, BLOCK 6, HARRIS OCEAN 8 PARK ESTATES,KEY LARGO,RE#00449340.000000 IN 9 THE FORM OF A PURCHASE OFFER FROM THE 10 MONROE COUNTY LAND AUTHORITY OR 11 REFERRAL TO THE STATE OF FLORIDA DIVISION 12 OF STATE LANDS FOR POTENTIAL PURCHASE 13 THROUGH THE FLORIDA FOREVER PROGRAM. 14 15 16 WHEREAS, Harold & Sherry Fried submitted an application for administrative 17 relief under Policy 101.7.1 of the Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan; and 18 19 WHEREAS, the Department of Planning and Environmental Resources provided 20 a staff report to the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners regarding the 21 application; and 22 23 WHEREAS, the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners makes the 24 following findings of fact and conclusions of law: 25 26 1. The application for administrative relief from 7/18/2023 is for Lot 36, Block 6, Harris 27 Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo in Monroe County, Florida having RE# 28 00449340.000000. 29 2. The date of the ROGO application is 07/09/2019. 30 3. The ROGO allocation application has been in the ROGO system for at least four (4) 31 consecutive years and qualifies for administrative relief under Policy 101.7.1 of the 32 Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan. 33 4. Monroe County Code (MCC) Section 138-27 provides a mechanism whereby an 34 applicant who has not received an allocation award in ROGO may apply to the Board 35 of County Commissioners for administrative relief 36 5. The Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) has the authority to grant 37 administrative relief under Policy 101.7.1 and may grant the applicant a building 38 allocation, offer to purchase the property at fair market value, or provide such other 39 relief as may be necessary and appropriate. 40 6. The applicant applied for administrative relief on 7/18/2023, under Section 138-27 of 41 the MCC and Policy 101.7.1 of the Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan. 42 7. Policy 101.7.1, Policy 101.7.3, and Policy 105.2.8 of the Monroe County Year 2030 43 Comprehensive Plan provides criteria to be used for determining lands that are ADMINISTRATIVE RELIEF RESOLUTION Page 1 of 3 RE# 00449340.000000 19300570 3829 I appropriate for acquisition and the criteria includes the environmental sensitivity of 2 the vegetative habitat on the lot and the applicable Tier designation. 3 8. Policy 101.7.3 and Land Development Code Section 138-27(d), the County shall 4 preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building 5 permit for lands within the Florida Forever targeted acquisition or Tier I lands areas 6 unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative 7 relief,it has been determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes 8 by any county, state or federal agency or any private entity. The County shall routinely 9 notify Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief 10 request at least six (6) months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. 11 9. The subject property has the land use district designation of Improved Subdivision 12 (IS) and is located in the Harris Ocean Park Estates Subdivision and is located in a 13 Tier I designated area. 14 10. Monroe County Year 2030 Comprehensive Plan Policy 101.7.1, Policy 101.7.3, and 15 Policy 105.2.8 states the Board may offer to purchase property as the preferred action 16 for property located within Tier I. 17 18 NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY 19 COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA: 20 21 Administrative relief is granted to Harold&Sherry Fried,for Lot 36,Block 6,Harris Ocean 22 Park Estates, Key Largo in the form of a purchase offer by the Monroe County Land 23 Authority. 24 25 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, 26 Florida at a regular meeting held on the 13th day of December, 2023. 27 28 Mayor 29 Mayor Pro Tem 30 Commissioner 31 Commissioner 32 Commissioner 33 34 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 35 OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA 36 37 38 By: 39 Mayor 40 41 (SEAL) 42 ATTEST: KEVIN MADOK, CLERK 43 By: 44 45 ADMINISTRATIVE RELIEF RESOLUTION Page 2 Of 3 RE# 00449340.000000 19300570 3830 1 DEPUTY CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE RELIEF RESOLUTION Page 3 Of 3 RE# 00449340.000000 19300570 3831 Administrative Relief Request Lot 36, Block 6, Harris Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo BOCC Public Hearing Item P. 8 December 13, 2023 Location: Lot 36.1, Block 6 Harris Ocean Park Estates, Key Largo; Real Estate No. 00449340.000000. Owner/Applicant: Harold Fried Tier: 1 Land Use District: linproved Subdivision (IS) Total Assessed Value (2023): $93,652 FLUM: Residential Medium (R-M) Total Just (Market) Value (20123): $131,957 Purchased: January 30, 2019 Deed Type: Warranty Deed Purchase Price: $20,000 i State owned lends: green County owned lands: yellow r r ai e .......... e„r p L L it 1 Last quarterly allocation period (Year 31, Quarter 4): PW I P w r,,, W'. WI, T 1::ay "W P116, FIF. 1'ur rI., C"I'll 16( ,'W I I P" I I III i FW.,,LM q"rl'M I"'l I "1 At 0OV"VNI XX "I 1 7,"'F"""'Ai�j EKV"I J." .2 Adi","d rt.4r41d)nnM O. A W T3 MR4 :4,Ua. �b.11 6 n M I Ci 009 &13 P"'% .15 AA L"', W I.'r.1 "I ")0'E --- — �A' SAW""W Q"'N'd'.&1 PW"4A" 5 #1 W100iiaM, 11.11 VA W�'F, CC,P. Z3 Q�,t�PM %'L= AdC mWZ L 1,,, ;CO P`4 W.F,.4 SSA 13 VMPM V.A.—pl�' ",'�dh� M WMWI 110001 1 I'd I Af� P. In,I P.,"wW 41.1 3 1'—14d'W A114 VAPM KwLfk, RAF— W 0040 W1400D 3 iO $ICV A'k N W IMAM WMJ 4FEARIMI"M4 0u,k,' VID AA E, 004WAO 00I ,,�,:23 V�M"4 14 rCCJ49W0(i 3 -3 MUM, G&E"PI—..LLC 41 R 4 KA�Lgw 9141100P�#W I A TIA i C'v�N"d WIXA iV Zzwow 011AU Mml I'Ii �Dfnll C.1-1 G U,C Q,Co M R4 M" P—I"A". 004W1110 roxKlj 3 UP" 21 1k W 1,11 1 MW L X, 1� I f�;4 AA�' �061`v 141UM"sw'�'gll Fl."W,I V, K�',f 'C%Plmv U, 1,K,i4 U I-,4,91�X' 3 (Ka"Y'01 ixam, AM_ V�" 4M,v dlY T%.' 11P1 I I,,1 6.0 ftm PMIA 11 1J 'ArIM4 I WNW j 74 MCCIC1.3 W. A UM10:154)NKOMO V OR.'m U ' ,1 l, I vdlA PAPv 1" 3 ' "' 3 oa6W UOIN 13 "A)M,1 1,Ll,. , � M ACM10 A, '�... TC`41. 1 I2'zPIA �L F � )CY527 K4 MM 'D t3 ��IMDIU U,� 13 R U AM il�1. .Gr& 11 (1 1 C>eMf, P� i 01,R L-M 4 $4 12 JJ I��AIA Il,,L r :I I M AWA A I W),'0'40 MVCC 10 "1 N'.1" LC 11 I$Ir" P: S.'d i"A C� ? DXV1OXwXG 3 MUNI,, I'll X1 jal'I I A 3 "1 U U 4? Z Im (XK1W:1 W100) ',' a n C 111I.Y.)WIT, R.Ck". Hddrg 1.LC 1". 04 CIO F' 0 TY)COW00,11 17 M1111 V""� C 1, 1111 P "I Z'1*1, V Md 11 IN"VIV, P'�.'d 11m'kf 7,w 21 1!0�All "�y (NP"Vf,"', R W 41,KhIAJ:IIMa 9, C",UIIO'� P"0, r......�' IA'C T'N'Z 0i N F"� ':1 MAIG K",Ir"o L 1-1, M61- 11", 1 MINXI WIN) "Cf)(f Xf, P�0� P. rM 1 (14 P1 K., I'm VAN1,00101m, 31 11 CIP cc PM i" P'�1',, 9 1 1 WXY, I I UW0 11,U., 0"?1 (A II,114 I,w,r owry Ynh IN,i wry"')WWWO 21 CA, X V,1 LLC A4W 11 C12 Y.,F14 K"1 0",10,Flurvn ?.11 1 CM iVta MiCin, P "A 20�0 ITT, R.CI F�. 14"Id"1.L.I.0 All YY0120 0000CU 7 L':' a a NCORIVIf FUND.:LL.C. 12 a—Z 1 11?Q KI I(,,I. P. v X F?l�P0]MUP 12 Fi" 0 TY,).:Irj 001DA '." I, F"I" n N, I�F1,1 P.1,1 11 n MU,7�(X'(XCII L, I P" T�I,",I C1rtgf 2, 11"06111)air," 'p I r, 1 J14 �11 11 mil,.p el-,1, 0""'6000,OPM I I,X�P 11�A d I, I a E"".'W TOW',: IWK111 r" C K"",10u P S"I )"W"74 ofi"INA j 61� �Cll I.,""'L.'d (B AM 5"1 1 JIMP)V.i 7 1�3 "M i -Y N 11)1'A" 1,1 V 411 V��' ��' rX.�I*r V, I, X01"'I,10,01 1, )DA, I I I 11104 1 F, 0 af.".V)N.110000 1 10'Z1 1)41 C41 Ii LUI Pt I,0"' 11 1INx,rnab 22 ff D,C L,,,,, 1f. „I.m,u6xaxe upr E 9 a P 0.Al Y 10A W,1j 2iP V1111I I t L V)w P 50 1211 F.a 1:11, k' I r wf".CNMMIM) �3 'KV, .7. : 111.11 1 'Cr 004 11.1NIA 1611 "1 51 r", , K,,J.:VI P A,� V '5 IMINNIP)COUIA, 3 '1 q �Uflu Up� �� " SI, I P, W i'MUNIAN P.-I.�,W MAIM 1XIM. 1 7"', � P-1 'C m'0'10 le"N". 11 '_i- 1� 11, X1 Y,0 C YR L-1 P40 "'W'IA 7-- _PZ————I_'re,—————————ZoIT 72716 1 Z"Z7 _1 7 71"WM_$N_QG0_) T I'm III, TOO,,wI Itrw,A.I ULE I U 115 04 1. 1 W1,L, 1 0049,1112.0 OOM 1 MIMI I I U 111" lkw VIP AP110jr, 39 "MrA FI-0 'Y"Cn v 1," 14"" 11 1, WAR�MICKM 3 - All "� 8. Aff"10 1 12 JI)PHA 11"A Q'� 14ro CI'_' J M Mid"10 & I i"C'2 r.j K,,I Z Z 1111 '�,L L:WP, '�M%2 IF—I dd,6M�10,� 14-1,b 22 Mt K, ,P�k—1 8 11", V.AAGG�m )7 "V A U G"'i LIZ ?I D%.I I'M 5Y I I WI-175 A,inwiflo ��A Mrr) 111'!1 1,1 1'.1p 1,�111'L)Ilyl 1,1.11 5 l,� �0 a MG 0 MWO, A 3, "L:g P�11 (,),1 3 X, A'I� 1,all ..I M1d. ��n,CC4 I WC10111 1,A 0'I.GC- I I ",I "M I I I, P,,1 1,r, 10")1 11V .1 1 1'k' W 0,01 1,11.1,r IU I CP�CCJI ji �,A I a 21ax", U 11 N V.'M J,C (I I r,I'm K "W,I-,Iw i".1 AIM DM`C w ACYXX VY i II,C C)" 11 V.)25 AM I, f'J'"I-arA L,1 7 2 XUA"kj UM) VIA '2 "1 1�11O "I _' I r,PH N �I_, "I" I'll 11 "I'll" W1 all"k I M, M41 WWI— I 7.1 G VAMC, MAM WN0 111161c $4 11,21 111. 1 L. ' n "," 11 0"'k., I P"P" I -I I OW W XMICY1 1,A M2 11- Qm u.11-1 1 11 "'- .'.:F' , n, I .-I— I "'m X",I I 01 R�'16 W,� 24 u, 2A MIM 10 AID W V15 '1 nor,W M'A"Mdh"4 j )I", JI V)A L, I-L.a. IN, kkl %a R I I, fm;a1v MOM) �A 14 NIKIM T 11 amp M XMCM % G.T,,,.I,r,IUJ 22 114"�1'4 L il.'Mt k"," EW 8 CKAT'AVO,,CODY 3 X11111 Mlei W WNA'�I L LF r.,'N ,�11'F", 11 A". R�'I ]1C1,1JVQ KADVI A nr 0 C)41 2 NA/W1 MOW bPt E.I.I I�'V�Cl"ft' 400Q Ck �'IIIAI K,L I I�U I q-11—lia"M I 2M.,MY 9 Q)5.'M",Cf I 1! WMIJ2 E"', V_'_ CkM111 I L EI P1 K9 V "I R'" ._,' .1114 111 ", �w Di.P 1' 02 V) 19 MIKIM al NA I."I K"U'9'Elh 14 rx"AIMIMIX, 'I F D�1120:12 DOG'D C:6.16,1 V ONOOOM 11 20 1,�r,I 1i.1C)AiI EW,,, A 91 C, 1. x s 1`111 0, Q MWIZI��UM I 4=11* Aw 1�10"J'1 1), 12 Ck, 1,0, t lil il 1 03 M1:111111 wxyxx I 1 61, "VIM No H-W 9 x'-" Q't 4 F 1. K.,,1,1,1, 11 1 *11 M10.11ax" I 'IC NPIT1% I 1 1.1.L, 09�I R, S, A M,ri , Y)4-Am 4, NX➢V D.0 NNW I U 22 MRl 1,L., L.ry,5,SVR I I I- " I,,.f.'�C WIX M.� 1, n CXAI�lw NAY.0 14 151 Karl 4 IT.)Gr C:i Hddrq,11. ri 1:j I V� Vi Ik. Lli r "I I.— 111 A!ll f, NX10", G, 0-INPH 11 1-"p u, IYFIIOI�WMW I Mm Z mk 2 45 K�VL G-1, 3 t4 0041 VXM) I N,I I I'�" 1�"'0',� MV9,P" :,A P" CS"C"'A I I II I %MMCG� X I 10 J.1. 11'U",11 Y aj AN Q, "'J"J I L I E 2 1 X)MIF,_1' W,,RbDU.C UWAV4 Y& F, 2 W"WAN)I "Q 'V" P L4. "".1 0— 01 QYZ"WWWO A, I"I ?W911 11�'01 11."L.a' 11 A 7MV't MIMI I Y, 2 1-00 1 Z 1" 2 1 1'0 1 M I 11"'11 ('Jjffs'51�0 WMA 'a M, MY U_' U0 11 Li It N UA0'W MODa".1 1 ab F1,M..,,,, I) ""IC)-1 11." "i I 2 101%'R 10 0110"10 1 J, I�P"I ',1 4 XX:aW,`AaI I 'I F1 L I V, H",u,"'A'C, �L,�� 1 MIN&'�V) W .""Ajl'N,2 kild"w kk LhWk' a IMAM J0010AT &K h, K,L.,., �,I j_,5, 1 1 H�PI, I�,,I"o� i�v" V 4UP)VMM CI-,,F V1 ki,'2'X "2 1,,,, F,,Ii bred 4 1, M rl/'W I NfUlf, ROGO Relief Criteria LDC Sec. 138-27. - Administrative Relief. (a) Eligibility. An applicant for an allocation award is eligible for administrative relief if: 1) The application complies with all requirements of the dwelling unit allocation system; 2) The application has been denied an allocation award for four successive years (first 16 consecutive quarterly allocation periods) in the ROGO Permit Allocation System; 3) The proposed development otherwise meets all applicable county, state, and federal regulations; 4) The ROGO allocation application has not been withdrawn; 5) The applicant has complied with all the requirements of the ROGO Permit Allocation System; 6) The applicant has followed the procedures for administrative relief; and 7) The applicant has not received an allocation award. ROGO Relief — Action by BOCC LDC Sec. 138-27. - Administrative Relief. (g) BOCC actions. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the BOCC maytake any or a combination of the following actions: (1) Offer to purchase the property at its fair market value as its preferred action if the property is located within: a. A designated Tier I area or within the Florida Forever (or its successor) targeted acquisition areas (unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has been determined no county, state or federal agency or any private entity is willing to purchase the parcel); b. A designated Tier II area (Big Pine Key or No Name Key); c. A designated Tier III-A area (special protection area); or d. A designated Tier III area on a non-waterfront lot or parcel for affordable housing. (2) Grant the applicant an allocation award for all or a number of dwelling units requested in the next succeeding quarterly allocation period or extended pro rata over several succeeding quarterly allocation periods as the preferred action for buildable properties not meeting any of the criteria in subsection (g)(1) of this section. (3) Suggest or provide such other relief as may be necessary and appropriate. ROGO Relief Limits LDC Sec. 138-27 (d) Exceptions. Monroe County shall preclude the granting of administrative relief in the form of the issuance of a building permit for lands within the Florida Forever targeted acquisition or Tier I land areas unless, after 60 days from the receipt of a complete application for administrative relief, it has determined the parcel cannot be purchased for conservation purposes by any county, state or federal agency or any private entity. The county shall routinely notify the Department of Environmental Protection of upcoming administrative relief requests at least six months prior to the deadline for administrative relief. Policy 101.7.1 Refusal of the purchase offer by a property owner shall not be grounds for the granting of a ROGO or NROGO allocation award. Staff Recommendation In accordance with Section 138-27 and Policies 101.7.1 and 101.7.3: Staff recommends that administrative relief be awarded in the form of an offer to purchase the property at its fair market value. The Monroe County Land Authority has confirmed that the subject property would be eligible for purchase.