Loading...
Item P1 P1 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY of MONROE �� i Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein,District 5 The Florida Keys Mayor Pro Tern James K.Scholl,District 3 Craig Cates,District 1 Michelle Lincoln,District 2 ' David Rice,District 4 Board of County Commissioners Meeting February 21, 2024 Agenda Item Number: P1 2023-2082 BULK ITEM: No DEPARTMENT: Planning & Environmental Resources TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Michael Roberts AGENDA ITEM WORDING: A Public Hearing To Consider Approval of a Resolution Approving the Issuance of a Special Permit to Allow a Temporary Construction Staging Area at Property Located at 131 Dubonnet Road, Tavernier, Monroe County, Florida. ITEM BACKGROUND: The applicant has requested a special permit to utilize the subject property for a temporary construction staging area. The staging area would facilitate the Tavernier Breakwater project being carried out by Monroe County. Location: Key Largo (Tavernier), approximate mile marker 92 (Oceanside of US 1) Address: 131 Dubonnet Road, Tavernier Legal Description: Block 4 lot 13 Tavernier Ocean Shores Key Largo Plat Book 4 Page 112 having Real Estate (RE)Number 00483200-000000 Property Owner/Applicant: Ophelia & Jose Benito Sanchez Agent: Josh Ptomey, WSP, USA. Size of Site: 11,586 SF per Monroe County Property Appraiser Land Use District: Improved Subdivision(IS) Future Land Use Map (FLUM) Designation: Residential Medium (RM) Tier Designation: Tier III 2980 Flood Zone: VE-12; VE-13 Existing Use: Developed Land Existing Vegetation/Habitat: Scarified/Developed Community Character of Immediate Vicinity: Single family residential REVIEW OF APPLICATION: This project is part of the Water Quality Improvement Program being funded by Monroe County for Canal Restoration Demonstrations. The Scope of Work for the Tavernier Breakwater and Weed Barrier System Restoration is to repair the breakwater and add an air curtain and seaweed prevention system. During Hurricane Irma, the storm surge toppled the boulders over the breakwater, which prior to the storm was providing a significant level of resiliency and storm surge protection to the homes. With the breakwater structure now severely damaged, this low-lying subdivision is subject to frequent and persistent flooding due to storms, astronomical high tides, and sea level rise. The repair activities are to be completed to return the breakwater structure to its previous condition prior to Hurricane Irma. In addition, the breakwater provided a barrier to the heavy loading of floating seaweed coming in from the ocean during the extreme heat of the summer that now clogs the canals, causing severe water quality problems, respiratory and health issues and environmental disaster. Repairing the breakwater and adding the air curtain and seaweed prevention system will help maintain better water quality in the canal systems near the breakwater, helping residents avoid respiratory distress and other health problems. The subject application is to provide for a temporary construction staging area for equipment and materials. Type of Equipment and Materials to be stored in Staging Area is limited to: 1. Trucks, clean fill material, and excavators to repair the breakwater and install the air curtain and seaweed barrier. The BOCC has the authority to approve temporary construction staging areas in accordance with Monroe County Code (MCC) §6-3. A special permit may be granted by resolution of the BOCC to allow a property to be used as a construction staging area for an off-site project. The BOCC shall hold a public hearing on the request for a temporary construction staging area and shall issue a resolution granting, granting with conditions or denying the request. The resolution shall take effect on the date of enactment by the BOCC. Applicability.A temporary construction staging area for an off-site project is a permitted activity in any land use (zoning) district, provided it is approved by a special permit and meets the criteria set forth in 2981 MCC §6-3. This special permit shall approve the temporary construction staging area location and use and shall not override or substitute for any other provision of the Florida Building Code and Monroe County Code that require an additional type of building permit, certification or approval. Criteria. Approval of such a special permit shall be granted only if the following criteria are met: (1) The temporary construction staging area shall serve a project being carried out in the vicinity of the construction staging area:In compliance. The proposed staging area serves the Tavernier Breakwater restoration project. (2) The temporary construction staging area shall serve a project being carried out by a governmental agency: In compliance. The breakwater restoration project is being carried out by Monroe County, Florida. (3) The temporary construction staging area shall not be located in a tier I designated area: In compliance. The proposed staging area is located on a property that is in a Tier III designated area. (4) The property subject to the request shall be posted and surrounding property owners within 300 feet shall be notified in writing at least 15 days prior to the BOCC public hearing, with the notice located so it shall be easily visible from all public streets and public ways abutting the property: In compliance. Planning&Environmental Resources Department staff shall carry out the notification as required. (5) Prior to establishment of the temporary construction staging area, a special building permit approving any associated temporary structure shall be issued in accordance with MCC §6-112: In compliance. The proposed staging area will not have any structure requiring a building permit. 2982 (6) No clearing or filling shall occur to accommodate the temporary construction staging area: In Compliance. The proposed staging area will be located in an open area of a developed lot. No native vegetation is proposed for clearing/removal. (7) Other than fencing, no temporary structure associated with a temporary construction staging area shall be located in any required setback: In compliance. According to the plans submitted with the application, no structure or storage will be located in a required setback. (8) The temporary construction staging area shall be compatible with existing uses on surrounding properties, as determined by the BOCC. If necessary, prior to issuance of a special permit allowing the temporary construction staging area, the board may attach conditions to any special permit approval to 1. avoid substantial harm to public health or safety; 2. avoid substantial harm to, or impairment of the normal use of, a public place; and/or 3. avoid substantial harm to the environment. Depending on the nature and anticipated duration of the use, as a condition of approval to the special permit, the board reserves the right to: 1. Provide a deadline for termination of the construction staging area; 2. Limit the hours of operation; 3. Limit the type of equipment and materials on the site; 4. Require fencing, landscaping and/or other screening to limit potential visual and noise impacts of the use on adjacent property owners; and 5. Require surface water management improvements to the affected site: The BOCC reserves the right to attach such conditions to any special permit approval at the February 21, 2024 public hearing. (9) The property shall be restored to its prior condition: Compliance to be determined upon termination of the staging area. 2983 PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: N/A INSURANCE REQUIRED: No CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval. DOCUMENTATION: 2024-008 Staff Report 2024-008 COMBINED PLANS Rcvd 01.08.24 Resolution Approving Special Permit for Tavernier Break-water Canal Restoration Project.pdf FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A 2984 MEMORANDUM MONROE COUNTY PLANNING&ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES DEPARTMENT To: The Monroe County Board of County Commissioners Through: Emily Schemper, Senior Director of Planning & Environmental Resources From: Michael Roberts, Assistant Director/Environmental Resources Date: January 30, 2024 Subj ect: A Public Hearing to consider a resolution of the Monroe County Board Of County Commissioners approving a special permit allowing a temporary construction staging area at property located at 131 Dubonnet Road Key Largo (Real Estate 00483200-000000), related to the Tavernier Breakwater Restoration Project. Meeting: February 21, 2024 1 I REQUEST: 2 3 The applicant has requested a special permit to utilize the subject property for a temporary 4 construction staging area. The staging area would facilitate the Tavernier Brekawater project being carried out by Monroe County in Tavernier. t l� i A l i 1, I U on 11 Subject Property in Blue (Aerial dated 2023) Page 1 of 5 2985 1 II BACKGROUND INFORMATION: 2 3 Location: Key Largo (Tavernier), approximate mile marker 92(Oceanside of US 1) 4 Address: 131 Dubonnet Road, Tavernier 5 Legal Description: Block 4 lot 13 Tavernier Ocean Shores Key Largo Plat Book 4 Page 112 6 having Real Estate (RE)Number: 00483200-000000 7 Property Owner/Applicant: Ophelia& Jose Benito Sanchez 8 Agent: Josh Ptomey, WSP, USA. 9 Size of Site: 11,586 SF per Monroe County Property Appraiser 10 Land Use District: Improved Subdivision (IS) 11 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) Designation: Residential Medium (RM) 12 Tier Designation: Tier III 13 Flood Zone: VE-12; VE-13 14 Existing Use: Developed Land 15 Existing Vegetation/Habitat: Scarified/Developed 16 Community Character of Immediate Vicinity: Single family residential 17 18 IH REVIEW OF APPLICATION: 19 20 This project is part of the Water Quality Improvement Program being funded by Monroe 21 County for Canal Restoration Demonstrations. The Scope of Work for the Tavernier 22 Breakwater and Weed Barrier System Restoration is to repair the breakwater and add the air 23 curtain and seaweed prevention system. During Hurricane Irma, the storm surge toppled the 24 boulders over the breakwater, which prior to the storm was providing a significant level of 25 resiliency and storm surge protection to the homes. With the breakwater structure now 26 severely damaged,this low-lying subdivision is subject to frequent and persistent flooding due 27 to storms, astronomical high tides, and sea level rise. The repair activities are to be completed 28 to return the breakwater structure to its previous condition prior to Hurricane Irma. In addition, 29 the breakwater provided a barrier to the heavy loading of floating seaweed coming in from the 30 ocean during the extreme heat of the summer that now clogs the canals, causing severe water 31 quality problems, respiratory and health issues and environmental disaster. Repairing the 32 breakwater and adding the air curtain and seaweed prevention system will help maintain better 33 water quality in the canal systems near the breakwater, helping residents avoid respiratory 34 distress and other health problems. 35 36 The subject application is to provide for a temporary construction staging area for equipment 37 and materials. Types of Equipment and Materials to be stored in Staging Area is limited to: 38 39 1. Trucks, clean fill material, and excavators to repair the breakwater and install the air 40 curtain and seaweed barrier 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 2 of 5 (File 42024-008) 2986 wara %ir� i "✓ any djl /, I� Y r � � ,x _ rrA/- k r ✓o„ 3 Y ll r ti Y PjN w»w r r, um rrI� N Zoning (IS) FLUM (RM) f. T-2------- O-R-A-N-6--E-----BL--O--S-S-O-M- , - 7 1� Y oe 9 9 0 $ II 12 13 1Y 15 ✓N' h +A ' nn ezn C A N A .. .. _. 0 Tier Overlay (Tier 11) Block 4 lot 13 Tavernier Ocean Shores 1 2 The BOCC has the authority to approve temporary construction staging areas in accordance 3 with MCC §6-3. A special permit may be granted by resolution by the BOCC to allow a 4 property to be used as a construction staging area for an off-site project. The BOCC shall hold 5 a public hearing on the request for a temporary construction staging area and shall issue a 6 resolution granting, granting with conditions or denying the request. The resolution shall take 7 effect on the date of enactment by the BOCC. 8 9 Applicability. A temporary construction staging area for an off-site project is a permitted 10 activity in any land use (zoning) district,provided it is approved by a special permit and meets Page 3 of 5 (File 42024-008) 2987 I the criteria set forth in MCC §6-3. This special permit shall approve the temporary construction 2 staging area location and use and shall not override or substitute for any other provision of the 3 Florida Building Code and Monroe County Code that require an additional type of building 4 permit, certification or approval. 5 Criteria. Approval of such a special permit shall be granted only if the following criteria are 6 met: 7 8 (1) The temporary construction staging area shall serve a project being carried out in the 9 vicinity of the construction staging area: In compliance. 10 11 The proposed staging area is adjacent to canal 90 and serves the Tavernier Breakwater 12 restoration project. 13 14 (2) The temporary construction staging area shall serve a project being carried out by a 15 governmental agency: In compliance. 16 17 The breakwater restoration project is being carried out by Monroe County, Florida. 18 19 (3) The temporary construction staging area shall not be located in a tier I designated area: In 20 compliance. 21 22 The proposed staging area is located on a property that is in a Tier III designated area. 23 24 (4)The property subject to the request shall be posted and surrounding property owners within 25 300 feet shall be notified in writing at least 15 days prior to the BOCC public hearing,with 26 the notice located so it shall be easily visible from all public streets and public ways 27 abutting the property: Compliance to be determined prior to public hearing. 28 29 Planning & Environmental Resources Department staff shall carry out the notification as 30 required. 31 32 (5)Prior to establishment of the temporary construction staging area, a special building permit 33 approving any associated temporary structure shall be issued in accordance with MCC §6- 34 112: In compliance. 35 36 The proposed staging area will not have any structure requiring a building permit. 37 38 (6) No clearing or filling shall occur to accommodate the temporary construction staging area: 39 In Compliance. 40 41 The proposed staging area would be located in an open area of a developed lot. No native 42 vegetation is proposed for clearing (removal). 43 44 (7) Other than fencing, no temporary structure associated with a temporary construction 45 staging area shall be located in any required setback: In compliance. 46 Page 4 of 5 (File 42024-008) 2988 I According to the plans submitted with the application, no structure or storage will be 2 located in a required setback. 3 4 (8) The temporary construction staging area shall be compatible with existing uses on 5 surrounding properties, as determined by the BOCC. If necessary, prior to issuance of a 6 special permit allowing the temporary construction staging area, the board may attach 7 conditions to any special permit approval to 8 a) avoid substantial harm to public health or safety; 9 b) avoid substantial harm to, or impairment of the normal use of, a public place; and/or 10 c) avoid substantial harm to the environment. 11 12 Depending on the nature and anticipated duration of the use, as a condition of approval to 13 the special permit, the board reserves the right to: 14 a) Provide a deadline for termination of the construction staging area; 15 b) Limit the hours of operation; 16 c) Limit the type of equipment and materials on the site; 17 d) Require fencing, landscaping and/or other screening to limit potential visual and 18 noise impacts of the use on adjacent property owners; and 19 e) Require surface water management improvements to the affected site: 20 21 The BOCC reserves the right to attach such conditions to any special permit approval at 22 the February 21, 2024 public hearing. 23 24 (9) The property shall be restored to its prior condition: Compliance to be determined upon 25 termination of the staging area. 26 27 28 IV RECOMMENDATION: 29 30 The Planning & Environmental Resources Department recommends approval. 31 32 Attachments: 33 Design, Permitting & Construction Drawings Page 5 of 5 (File 42024-008) 2989 ...... -----— 0 cn cn "d oi�W3 oz W ZaJQ Lu . V a m d s w F W 1 zW`ffi 8 u� � Y � + a 0 W 1p 6�3 o� o.Q4 y �4 y W y� e V' JIB maw a U'� o a aZ " uj y.W ry, III m'"^y I III S q N II�O�ry �p,,�I y,� b,W III y��'* 1 y; ,«�,,�;V� 1tl7 ��"!W III�nII'rd'd��i���ll�l"'N»a.m'ytt��X W M��Ai�nW;;w9 JL�.�W��li' i���d'Wk III III flridO"'lil "III Wm Film��m ll..4+ �,i�'rcrv¢..�w'Mw'li� fd„I o Q. NE. of w U wME y UHzi,g LL I; „A F o o rc K3 a K .. 82 [if 'lot 2 2 z_ al ° gw Z o� Z z U gm - 0.-0 E � 141 I y W Z o w c? o w o s V 1 3f f7� zOLL LU o LL z 0 yn' H O m o // 0 T Y�I r N U. W / C� F m /ram m z Z o o �;; w Q = U) LL O eG U) z.z. z �y a o I� rc zo a4 ln�a'�z zizNm�� s 0 ,°gFF aagw z rn o W Z......... N.aaa Nvvl1rnr1�� zz�° 2 N0000.'00 W m a_ aUUU��4�3 h•�' E 19g Quo NIIFIYW'S3AItr�Ae NMYd�WNB✓II EZOZIBL1b:N3Vyy.O'Id—�319tlL3lALS10ld Wtl LY4t 620EI8 U6:03M5 IOtr�J:1fi0AY1��+em��e�wazay L'6BL00916L�Z NtlMEZOZIuaiemryeag+alwaneyNunaU ao+uoWl'89L008�GI51W31'OddFd VdWVy Ali3 t'Po[W9 Y39Wf1N 1�3fONd 2 rM 0 s�a'o E np MLu 0Qi2a U' WU oLL ,• .. M >d "� O ° a 9 w w s ° s s s v n rn ap .. m ' s o 0 r, ,A z;€ �< 4w > Z �r o� m Lu z N �:8 p h VW� Q o w o z �x ; o z z W w IL z 0 ILI r z LL LL Eff off= w �¢ - ;, �K o= LLw = goo gaom g wos4 cz ° mygma Woa mq how a LLZo gig a _ ozm� - wm ° y w zo Nz � z no o p�° quo j = aw �> i;~M,7 g oaw+ •i w I dW m wofdu" 0g8&0wa 8Ww W� w g�"woiozoe 1° O0o� oE wp�,a oz ��wW ow zo ,!9 w° oz o " gw E �q w wa w `-'gy agg o m8wmwo zo _ ,° � zo 6z dR - wyw°g2 a --pss ow$ >p a 8� 6§ E ? ow��� > o z�> ` G- fm o°<� a wo <R F"��< wo 2.a, o rc w� ova bo o �� °� o qo w �39 8 ozU Jz -zo ° op � �Nwoz- � o� � yohw ° �i �� eywo� z � z_ � wdw wmarori ��' a� W °LL°r r> z> ° w�4o w<a,�, z° ��zw� x �° K �a _° w d _ w _ � szzw�r zwnw o a yw��o-,w�oa oym c°w4owo§g wu,z�< o o _ wN SVa�Wz3° c5 awul o go`}' w> FzW&mo _ I.,. o zoNo z � w oW4zo - z a xx° zoo op.- � o o z < ova%, o wwxr w" -o� zNog 00 Sao z o�izo�z �o�W� s z Nw r 1,Y o o . am. _ o > � o o�Qo � z z r Sozz $ �. wz -r ��=zv w� z5mw a z w z c�GNZ.�� Fxza ox m s a& _` 'w wggmo> � ¢o=w g� a w >' a Ng� �LL oW ,_� <<� a woaw Nw ox M ow9 aWozm qwq z M a 0' i � `J"-'-' - q=N�o � o x oz o¢z m of zwo e o� ap ' E� ' z m p a zo op `z m�W<z _ z oa t o z2� ¢ o'ayBW �F000w zo z Z.w o a�� o a - �w-, H w x. o azw _°pox >� o zN �z "- u� _wi�o�viaJ �� ww N ow o�ww a wz�;>o�� �zo Q - g o $yw se _ oa3a R. °«� a o � w�Z: w ° W.� z zwwo!a > o� NI1NtlW'S3AN'AB NMWO WV 61Lt 6202101(6 v031L0'id Ell'J'N3lSNW-'INp'31Eb13MLSlOId Wd 41Z42ZOZ14tC 03AY5 ZW0 v1t10AYi 6rnp'sa4aN vaiuvanet t69'A.OU910EOt"IIVdtl1'CZGEYaeiVvwvnN'u9v®relwa+sl A1'uno;i wiuuW-469[OWbC}5103fOtld\f btlWbl J.11O t691A09 F138WfiN 103fOtld —.. -----------.__.._._____________________________N__ N uj 2 � W H?,U kk w s S v W o a m M W (�"_ W C.2 W 3 o s`aLLI r m a V 4 ,.nn� y D s x WW. � � W H I �"���'�Ih�,JD�IIdV��.W d INIIIOPS3a rn �III� III �III�W�� ,�Illu��"� � u u" �"�'� � II I %'0 uj � I a r I' r �u wt E zgi� rO "lid i LI +Iy� 'rra Yt9 l k 1 M((i Cyy ,�i XO FOr� It WW Z _ W W d N am W w to o a owa O P,-.R ow QG Q OF Owa//y �yMllll I�+, �u Y 1Y� iit if �M1h I� p�/ 'i�� Ili tt�) '�U o U o W� � Wz Y � � 4u Fes} M' Nfr A. W 4 ti 4 d W T W Z�.....o w N �O x4 r 1 Q Q W W z S W Z w w�( H �• S � Y J r M� N Yx-OKd F�_ N mp OIL W U o w�0 aowoow� �pO o<< N U) O =z CD w =z pqFmm >lowz 5,) az2 @ WV O Z�Q� 00 zp px>w ui >Y 29Otq �x -- �~ w0 ao ap aw <ZZ �rN .� `�� ✓ r � r o zg a <-5z Tug xKwO Fz q� y ZW Z-O 9 W W Q°� d< wwz Pa ' I �l/rd p0 0. wow° �W x ax OD zVAN -0 x w Op K�a3ouf mw w 0 - ww �U QO WOj I Qak-zo Tito u4 mmw.w 4FO K / 0 po m 2 O K �r Ill p n r._r r-a a i...i wJ NWIVW'MAA8NMbU0 WV6YblEZMW0--9y0'b315VW-1IAI-8Vy3'!AL3Md WVU:4t2206rtZIE0-tm-0:y110Atli 6mp'a{IS 6u!rsl*3+e!uieney\gg[Og9\EL0214tlp�EE02N�e�emyeaiB gaw+anel NunoO ewun\y{69[A0910ES5103fOtlfi! VdWV1 Alq l'gBGW9�b38WfiN1031'Obd ---------------------- z ce w W ix z �3 CL :YD g ed F w w 0 -z . u d:9 w 6 Z 0 W M uj ru pi . 0 n .:" 0 w cc 0 2 it (L 0 ca 0 tj b z 0 LL z I Lu cmoiaonuisiav:a uw ii.c�1111114)01114111 11111AH-ld 11141911PS90 R;06 d" uj U1 y a. < LU U) z O w 0 U) 111 T, x of in V z F� 00 r .0 w Q � 0 Z 0 A z Irz w m rj� Lh <w CL Z C) 0 (D z > m 0 C) !i t� z of 0 w mi W> 0 W�w ZK . IIdIi " !<- w m �- vy , z < qi ft� iz W 0 w <> mw 0 0 w w w L I �LD Z.< w 0 w U<, w 8 0 jz- ��: a)< C) ;z w x w - w z w 2 was o 0 z M08 0 z w m 06 0 0 ww < w I W xuw W w 0< !R ZMZW W W Z)w w 5. >s w W,w w aw tm 2 .Z, < Z� 0 w w C/) m 2-1 0 fa a w 0' W L) LU Z w >0 0, .0 Z� Z, 0 090 ry CL z OW < ��§ �-� 3:T � z w Z, �O '0<. Woo w 7EFF 0 U'nQ ffi 9'Z� z m 0 8u z 0 T w 0 > z <-m Zzntt J, :0, 0 z W-17-U) w w ffwoowo z wa� §-, W,io, W.-� 0�e a- w z < Z w< Or w w W C6 w cz o w < 68 zoo 0 C)2� w Z 0 w w w Ow 0 w> f u 'd 0�-C) awa� wo,:�;�w z W. ILI M U W W m z -z- w /)b w L Ej w 0 0 w�-z 0>11ri�luwz \OP6�tm W m ;�=>Zow :5waz:E,m a,0 D m w m mmo0m m z< L.L, 0, Cl 0< 0 w Q X Z Z W Or Tw 0 z 0 C, z 0 W. ou Z 0 0 MO OM ri II 4 TO bk ZI LJ LJ . ...................... - --- ------------ ............. ....... -0 t m z W 0 uj z 01 < 0 > F— w od CC F UJ z 0 0.z 0 z' 0 0 uj ED (1M0LLOfIHLSNO'0 HOA—LON)LNqLLJJWU3d-lqmsaa %ory YX CL xw 2 ui cc U)i GS 5 ail o0l 2 w> -Z =4 0 UJ ><L> ui IM LU 06 < ui 0- az cl C) ui U) 0 UJ w �- 0 C( Z- > Q ZE Z, z 0 0 zt 0 wx QO ".......... LJ .........1.. �,Jlj ..................................................................................... _... ........................... LO N fE �WK ' Ilr Z 0 p0 +I kB w�Qd2_ wU o� 'oem 3E a' — �z�Q K! ui 0 CL w .. �F,LL g o wean m maz - m w o � LL � gg 1 ui 1 E✓sir„ �' � �'� q � LU �r� � A,E� ° r "r rrarly f { I)� ✓ y�u � �w � 14ysn „ I r fS Ilr r� arWrxp r � o o S a � a r n � o o o r w y — N V I� O o o w w Iui � z � O OO � z s O q "f Q' C� YLf Q[➢F- d .J. �I m o Z W w p ry a cZ—'J O o z ; z u + � � > m > p o � i o g 9 0 ra I n 0 a w o l.r p • \�r y'i F o 2 O z w o o „ i y� I f�,.�4W0 w✓ < = a d m w u Z O a N K 0 '' �„ y u In✓Yl r 1,,, „,..-,« z h m a a 3 0 a n I rI o I I r r w NlttlbW'S3vW�A0 NMb00 Wbnptt 620ZBt)v03110'id B1W'tl31SVW'1N1�-310b13lAlS101d WV 9[6 CZOZIONa�03AVS YO-- 6mpa5dO0d is wanel t69L009tEZOZ lutlbtEZ0yleialex.Vea+B+a wanel Nunon ao+udW-t6B[0091OE'd S1�3hltld\3 vawvi ua t eseotls a3ewnN ln3rona -—------- -- ------------------........ ................................ ID P, 0. o Z Z UN z o j zz 0 c) z d w o I: ui z MM cc 4 j LLI (00 a! 0 0'. ru U) ;E LU F-0: LLI z 55 0 0 Co 0 0 Ir o z 3: z (NOLLDIIIII-USNOO HOA iON) 01114111.Li�lltiH3d-Ill^liMDMS30,1%06 2tea, Iz Lu Ul 1:5 cn U) 0 —j U) z 0 < w w It m U) U) U) 0 ry C) 0— -z z 2 Ro w - 05 � Zzo z C) 0 0 0 < C) Fl �z LJ ................m.......__ ---------------- .... N Z w,,. {h 4e� E W W rel"ggr„ a- 'w p U V V o wgg tnotl tc M3 m15Q s= o n W .�,.. Z o p z U m IL " V�N10 111::111 WJS111111 W 11 y:ll 114IIIJIJI.UiII `:f-tIilOfSaG ',al''1106 BB OAVN('U)NOI1VA313 88 OAVN('U)NOIIVA313 w p _ Q +Ym Z, ....�...._ Z O _O 14 V V'! .,�' F- i, N 9 a�" W 3' R W �t H '^ I I,w B U) \mow i a (•..'I 98 OAVN(U)NOIIVAA13 BB OAVN(-U)NOUVtl 13 II//// 99 OAVN(U)NO1VA313 88 OAVN('U)NOI-LVA313 d , n a n O C:) 4 O O i O O P wE + 3 p+ N ' CO tf) U) '- 0 0 m e §wf w x> = w E W U) w U) - U)R r___ e t O O o J Of w o C) B9 OAVN('4)N UVA313 98 OAVN(U)NOUVA313 QryQryjjjj//// w 99 0AVN(U)NOUVA313 98 OAVN('4)NOUVA313 99 OAVN('U)NOIIVA313 ..,_. Q LO i O O LOCO 9 yp FRS ------------ , + 98 OhtlN('U)NOI1tlA313 [/\ 99 OAVN(N)NOI1tlA313 89 OAVN('U)N0I1VA313 COO 990AVN(U)N011YA313 w99 OAVN('U)NOIIVA313 98 OAVN(U)NOIIVAR13CD Q & e > `p III g� o O y, n 1 + i P. C) R e t e 1„ � o � Y U) rw $o W o m e e a CO m cn V/ / V V' m O ' O - ---- O 2. w d 1 a 99 OAVN('U)NOIIVA313 89 OAVN l'U)NOIIVA919 99 OAVN('U)NOUVA313 co NMM'93AIA!A9 WV O WVtr4 9ZOZI9lk�03l101d E10'9319tlW-11A133'19tlJ3'IA..d NN 9EBEZ0216tb-03AH9 rOGO�If10AV1 We®'nwS dOlid+awanel t'O9[009\EZ02�udpOp,2p2{vatervryeag»luarel-iluno`,•a—auo/q-t'890009WE.'f 51�3('Otldl'i tldWtll:u10 l'63t009:939WfiN 1031'O9d __..w_. _... 00 zg ag dwK /a z �� ° _ z O � yew wf w u m�Nl. z `' - o r .' � O c -C ujLLyS' offig'O a x wFm og W o R 0uwXUQ mO , R< CC uj I z O U) p w z U. ee OAVN Pa)NouVn313 e9 anvN h))Nouvn313 (u�� 'LUMI w II "� 11 u u uNulI a LUHI M mN �N DIIIIS301'%146 �Nr O O O O C) 2 w a $ g 1 Q0 U � N U e e Z '. .. ....... —- Z —_ — O _. _ — _ — a O U "' � U U e w e <w e M e e ------w e x o e e _ U e U 88 OAVN(V)NOIIVA313 99 OAVN(V)NOUVA319 c 99 OAVN Ill)NOIIVA313 99 OAtlN(U)NOIIVA313 � � � � 0 ° w g CD + VM o f + r r a \ Lo U e R O $------ -- 0 LU e e W `I e w ------ __. U U------------ --- U OUU g Q r i o m 99 OAVN('x)NOUVA313 U e 98 OAVN('4)NOIIVA313 ^ U 99 OAVN(9)NOUVA313 Be OAVN(V)NOIIVA313 0 e Q y e m o a 0 n Q r.,, q a r _ _._......... U OE ..-------- O ed W --w\ W U r W U e U `m LL U y— Oe rr e cr- e 98 OAVN('N)NOIIVAB13 98 OAVN('4)NO1VA919 P 99 OAVN(8)NOUVA313 y 99 OAVN(4)NOI1VA313 99 OAVN('4)NOUVA313 e e ¢ O O O x � w O � CD + + + e � u en e<m « v U ^ U J Q z G W W o W o m VJ b V/ 1 Y 3;a e m m Ew 0 � n e U ("�v,i Cl) + U a r � O ,,,,�,o�----- _s w _ a r O � e Q u� a i w W a .....� .... of Ne e o w U e.............. 98 OAVN('U)N011YA313 990ntlN(13)NOIlVA313 99 OAVN(4)NOI1VA313 N—W—AMN—C M-11E202t61@:011 1d 910'9316YW'll.-19V13L1191011 WV 9E'B EzoziEtM�03AV6 Z060 NOAtli W.+P'eil6 dO9d aawaa�sl t6910o9162oE 19CyrE6py\saMamMaaiB relwsney-qumO aoauaW-1'69tC0910CJ'SL�3fO9d4d VdWYl�ALIO l'69t009�N39WNN 1�3fO9d _ ..... ________ __________________________ • z 'o -ID (n W ak dWs - M"h d`�yt `� $ zr w Q W'S V rrly 1M' =O ¢ u c J Q N ........s t,"d 1V sw� ow 17i zvy Jg f� i U oLL p o Q� .. " /°1► o'"g z� d W Y U 4 O W W o a W W Z $Q w °e " s x 3 0° " s (��. g M $ g'z c E-K=W Z o .. 'm cn a o, d Z O 3 m W Ci Ct W TFIJ H usi I.I.' (I40LL3(' f 'SN03 UOJ L )DIMI 10I..,IMOd~NE'NST i%0 r.MU yu,•,�^� .m i ,iC:;"Ilr 11 L k _j �d aglo- (j r u', O ui r e Kl m w to s W b z — W $ § ag w a � LL' U. a� q m a LL Q = MIN, e<la � �r �e S - �w ov r� -_ a ow s` § _ w.-....- Ail Is ;Kara a$ U W Z QrWW U W � mod o`n; Q W z° 15 W o z LL Z O f 4 h o Q a w} �T NILtl1M1N'S3A!A�A6 NMbb0 WY 9B�tl E2WBLM 03tLOld 810'b3LNWliA1031BVLl'V.1S101d Wtl BOB 260Z1>tE�03A45 4BS9�100Ab1 fimp'sl!ew01wryo0 uo!sw3+aiwanel 4'69t60B\fZOZ WdtlLL20tis+e\amyea+B+a!urenel-RW6o0 ao+uoyy-t'6B1A09\QE05103tt1tld\�3 tltlWV1 At10 t69ta99 tl39Wf1N l>73fOtld 0 0 0 M f.� myg��,"A ■y1.My7o- r_s��_4�>n9m�e�e n�s _os d ,6Wm Fe(y>Uv�'4 ° i o So m o �6 b Z Q J .. w wa rZQo 0 s 7 iJ W Q N m o xxw',. � 5t Cim 'nti, imoo Hod Vim)ON11il L.I.1wim.. iOI 3 111 1"'%'ea' '�'6 II J Z d 0 0 LLU Q z a w,. � y a .. _, m o W V W� Z �o ffim� wa ON to R 1 d � w m 0 Q a a F mo w < w Z - LO W° m CY 000 Wp Z w I=- �dW w m w J °o N i w 0 N w � ¢ � o sw ° J J w I W .....� m v=i u=i z �w I z°s Z T W xz ako w z o 0 4b �mwS _ ..., ....w� I °zw°oa t1J .... °z " °z U > o°Uo Na�wZ, J SG °o d o w z°> I 'S �o E� a \ oN em mow Z rya ° L. o�aw a W w Y Ym° s� o co rz 4 I ° � N a w 0 W �zw a= LL H5 �o UY KU' WUiF w 10 OR w S 'SU (� WWwp E. z� �g�y wzK ZU ^w� aELL d��W m a 0W. z w wx w Cn z x m W F LL wh i Q O z Z (a— Iz .� o U LL 4 I I Y �QXz� ,Nll LL g °Nw � 8oz Uh xa 3� mo ,uuevw s�n.ne wuvda wv so-.ttezozretro.aauma eyotlaisvw-iinm azevr3iusyoia wvitszzsz/szte�aanvs mso..tnoun aMnz-auwaa w�wsey tsseooe�ezoz wev�eaoz�s,a,emnse,e+a�s,�,sy-gs+wo ao,sow.o-e9eoeuaeosio3rotlavd Vdw4y'n110 t'6BlA09�tl3ewnN 1�3f0l1d ------- ------------------------- ------- ........ --------------- zd 4 z LLI LU RE! 31 1 3.s ui :1 Lu ul Ui z E 0 Iz 2 - .......... R LU oqoiuonuisi�io,)tjoi iLoiiq)oiqiiuiviraiad-�msm i vis .............. ui w z > z 1, U) �o z z H. ............. w 4,- U) S2 1 .1 z U) o U) ............. w W ry ----------- ---------- _ 0 cr 0 � z Z W H os xa 8u o �� �� . H � o Q¢ id wd 4 us ow m w f1 0 4 Z p c W � ma E3os w kfkll,"ll ...0ti)°gull"IL.IL. VIIMH N d0PR 3 ,f 5,0`r'6 "h N wu � o c'r M k E H G m W _ o Q II p W m m OT — o X W U) �- - CO W a 0 ry a W co o m a �w W_ U _4 — W � Z �¢ a W i m + I I w � ¢ a w 4Y 1 1 e Ntt0tlW'S3hiA:A8 NMb00 WYSv:It EZtlZl9N0:03JJAld 810'031SYW'INI0318tl13lALSlOId Wd 95322NJ9g4�03AYS 9DS'O�NOAYI d+m+F+'llul�ro0 wi++'sO Pse�y"lawenelt'G9ilVo9.4CYnZ 01ItlNCE02VstnYeN%eu+q+elwanel 10— puna�ewuaW-I'�L009}02�$y0tl d YdWYl�AtIO I'692009+tl38WfIN iO3('Otld k; � f 2 y27 P `°eg ro e ° MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA RESOLUTION NO. -2024 A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE ISSUANCE OF A SPECIAL PERMIT ALLOWING A TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION STAGING AREA FOR A CANAL RESTORATION/WATER QUALITY IMPROVEMENT PROJECT AT PROPERTY LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS LOT 13, BLOCK 4, TAVERNIER OCEAN SHORES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 4, PAGE 112, OFFICIAL RECORDS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, HAVING A CURRENT ADDRESS OF 131 DUBONNET ROAD, TAVERNIER, MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, AND CURRENTLY BEARING PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION NUMBER 00483200-000000. 1 WHEREAS, an application has been received seeking a special permit allowing a temporary 2 construction staging area at property located at 131 Dubonnet Road, Tavernier, approximately located 3 at mile marker 92 (ocean-side); and 4 5 WHEREAS, the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners ("Monroe County", 6 `Board", `BOCC", or the "County") desires to grant the special permit allowing a temporary 7 construction staging area; and 8 9 WHEREAS, the temporary construction staging area would facilitate a canal 10 restoration/water quality improvement project being carried out by Monroe County; and 11 12 WHEREAS, due notice has been carried out and a public hearing has been held in 13 accordance with Monroe County § 6-3; and 14 15 WHEREAS, at said public hearing, the Board considered the full record created before it; 16 and 17 18 WHEREAS, the Monroe County BOCC hereby makes the following findings of fact and 19 conclusions of law: 20 21 1. The temporary construction staging area is not inconsistent with any of the criterion 22 provided in Monroe County Code of Ordinances § 6 3; 23 1 of 3 3003 I NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY 2 COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA: 3 4 Section 1. Title, Recitals, Findings of Fact, and Conclusions of Law. The foregoing title, 5 recitals, findings of fact, and conclusions of law are true and correct, and are hereby 6 incorporated as if fully set forth herein. 7 8 Section 2. The foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law support the Monroe County 9 BOCC's decision to approve the instant request for issuance of this special permit, subject to 10 the following approval conditions: 11 12 1. The temporary construction staging area shall only be used in association with the 13 Tavernier breakwater restoration project in Tavernier, 14 2. The expected commencement date of the temporary construction staging area is no earlier 15 than April 1,2024. Construction will not extend beyond six(6)months and the termination 16 date of the temporary construction staging area shall be no later than April 30, 2025. 17 3. Other than fencing, no temporary structure associated with the temporary construction 18 staging area shall be located in any required setback. 19 4. Upon termination of the temporary construction staging area,the property shall be restored 20 to its prior condition. 21 22 Section 3. Construction and Interpretation. This Resolution and its interpretation shall be 23 liberally construed and enforced in favor of the Monroe County BOCC and such interpretation 24 shall be entitled to and granted great weight in adverse administrative proceedings, at trial, in 25 bankruptcy, and on appeal, and all provisions of the Monroe County Comprehensive Plan, 26 Monroe County Codes, Florida Statutes, floodplain management regulations, and Florida 27 Building Code whose interpretation arises out of,relates to, or is interpreted in connection with 28 this Resolution shall be liberally construed and enforced in favor of the Monroe County BOCC 29 and such interpretation shall be entitled to and granted great weight in adversarial 30 administrative proceedings, at trial, in bankruptcy, and on appeal. 31 32 Section 4. No Liability. Monroe County expressly reserves and in no way shall be deemed to 33 have waived, for itself or for its officer(s), employee(s), or agent(s), any sovereign, 34 governmental, and any other similar defense, immunity, exemption, or protection against any 35 suit, cause-of-action, demand, or liability. 36 37 Section 5. Severability. If any provision of this Resolution, or any part or portion thereof, is 38 held to be invalid or unenforceable by any administrative hearing officer or court of competent 39 jurisdiction,the invalidity or unenforceability of such provision, or any part or portion thereof, 40 shall neither limit nor impair the operation, enforceability, or validity of any other provision of 41 this Resolution, or any remaining part(s) or portion(s) thereof. All other provisions of this 42 Resolution, and remaining part(s) or portion(s)thereof, shall continue unimpaired in full force 43 and effect. 44 45 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, 46 Florida, at a regular meeting of the Board held on the 21" day of February, 2024. 2of3 3004 1 2 Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein, District 5 3 Mayor Pro Tem James K. Scholl, District 3 4 Commissioner Craig Cates, District 1 5 Commissioner Michelle Lincoln, District 2 6 Commissioner David Rice, District 4 7 8 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 9 OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA 10 11 12 MAYOR HOLLY MERRILL RASCHEIN 13 MONROE CQ ATTORNEY 14 (SEAL) C 15 .. . . 16 ATTEST: KEVIN MADOK, CLERK — — - .... PETER MORRIS 17 ASSISTANT COU NTY ATTORNEY 18 Date: 2/6/2024 19 AS DEPUTY CLERK 20 3of3 3005 Planning Environmental Resources Department We stave to be caring, professional and fair ,�, J��/ / ri,�/ ," :� ,.r //�-.� /.rfr ,,/i, „� r:�,1"?r..�,y VP✓r a ,. ,"> • , r �/,", //O/,;;,' � �h� ;N rr l �/;) �fin'/ Temporary Construction StagingTavernier Bwhal rat , J �r awa � 1 , r IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVVVVIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII@II@IIIIII1111111JJ�8ffhfIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIV/%////9%//////////,,,%%%/rill, ,%///%/////////%%/////%///%////IJ�'N'�R NIIM1111 tillll llllllllllllfllllllllllllllll I 11111N��' A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A RESOLUTION OF THE MONROE ,�y %� COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS APPROVING A SPECIAL PERMIT ALLOWING A TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION STAGING AREA AT I f 1% PROPERTY LOCATED AT 131 DUBONNET ROAD KEY LARGO REAL E 4 2� ESTATE s oo g3 00 000000), RELATED TO THE TAVERNIER BREAKWATER RESTORATION PROJECT , / r t / rrr / r / f r„ / / Planning Environmental Resources Department We stave to be caring, professional and fair ,�, J��/ / ri,�/ ,� :� ,.r //�-.� /.rfr ,r/i� „� r:�,1,?r..�,y VP✓r a ,. Temporary Construction Staging Tavernier Brat ✓ a / IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIV�II IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII@II@IIIVU111111JJ�8fffififllllllllllllllllllllllllllV%%////9%/////////G!!;;%%%/rill,' r= � ,, ,„'!;;�,; i '��/ r /�/ l/ %/" %'v ,,, "i'�f� b � .�bl,., .,�/ � r'... 1) "y✓T r, /�..i�l I'll�/Il��%"'1" Location: Key Largo (Tavernier), approximate mile marker 92 (Oceanside of US 1) Address: 131 Dubonnet Road, Tavernier J Property Owner/Applicant: : Ophelia & Jose Benito Sanchez Agent: Josh Ptomey, WSP, USA Size of Site: 11 ,586 SF per Monroe County Property Appraiser / Land Use District: Improved Subdivision (IS) 'Affil rill Planning Environmental Resources Department We stave to be caring, professional and fair ,�, J��/ / ri,�/ ,� -� ,.r //�-.� /.rfr ,r/i� „� r:�,1,?r..�,y VP✓r a ,. �., a .c✓*..;,...� ,, i,,,,, ,,,/ / ` O�/i � Ali/�J�r'I 1��/ ;.��"JJJ� riAri )�6��i�1ti`r•. //J .f On ,'> • i �, �;' �l G,�.;. ' �/ � fh�i ;N ri �//111,�/rrrk ,,%ri,� r �i' ���/ Temporary Construction Staging avernier Br( l / / r r rr b / 1 � r, / %rc IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVVVVIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII@II@IIIIII1111111JJ18ffhfIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIV/%////9%%///////G!;;O%%/vim,' Maio%%///D��/////%///%%%%////%//////%�/m�,Z'(i�lAI�N�Ililll ltillll IIIIIIIIIIII(II IIIIIIIIIIIIII I k / i t r: 1 / „ �d m , �,,""N �� � � ������� IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII�I�I�IIIIIIIIIIIIIII N d wi li / Planning Environmental Resources Department ,. We stave to be caring, professional and fair Temporaryp Construction Staging Tavernier Br(� at i/ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIV�II IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII@II@IIIVU111111JJ�8ffhflfllllllllllllllllllllllllllV/%////9%%////////,,,%%%/rill, <,,,,,.1/%/�//%/O,/////////,/%/%�DNJ1Jz !Nk i�I�A4S 111 IIIIIIIIIIIIVfIf IIIVVIIIIIIf v Criteria. Approval of such a special permit shall begranted only if the %r '/� following criteria are met: ; 1. The temporary construction staging area shall serve a project being carried out in the rl vicinity of the construction staging area 2. The temporary construction staging area shall serve ar project being carried out b a p rY g g p J g y governmental agency 3. The temporary construction staging area shall not be located in a tier I designated area 4. The property subject to the request shall be posted and surrounding property owners '/'' within 300 feet shall be notified in writing at least 15 days,prior to the BOCC public hearing I Al Planning Environmental Resources Department ,, ��i muo��..� c* ,�, J��/ / ri,�/ ,� -� ,.r //�-.� /.rfr ,�ri� „� �:�,1,?r..�,y VP✓r a ,. We stave to be caring, professional and fair �., a .c✓*..;,...� ,, i,,,,, ,,,/ / ` O�/i � Ali/�J�('I 1��/ ;.'��"JJJ� riAri �6��i�1ti µ //J /1% Temporary Construction Staging Tavernier B vat , r a / � r / J� k/ I N /b /✓ / a�.. 1, '� r, i r z 1// 1 uuuuuiu wu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuiuuiuuiuu»»»��rrrrt��i�iuuuuuuuuuuuuivaiii�iiiiiiic�%;iiii iM11111/iiaiaa��a���r�NNr���r u�iftis r»�i nnnn 5. Prior to establishment of the temporary construction staging area, a-special building permit approving an associated temporary structure shall issued in accordance with p pp g y P ry MCC §6-112 6. No clearing or filling shall occur to accommodate the temporary construction staging area 7. Other than fencing, no temporary structure associated'with a temporary constructions staging area shall be located in an required setback g g Y q 8. The temporary construction staging area shall be compatible with existing uses on surrounding properties, as determined by the BOCC. If necessary, prior to issuance of a special permit allowing the temporary construction staging area, the board may attach conditions to any special permit approval to: a. avoid substantial harm to public health or safety; b. avoid substantial harm to, or impairment of the normal use of, a public place; and/or c. avoid substantial harm to the environment. "/ Planning Environmental Resources Department � -� We strove to be caring, professional and fair ;,e��//.,oi r Temporary Construction Staging G a � / r J r r r a � uuuuuiuuuuu uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuiuuiuuiuu»»»rrrrtiiuuuuuuuuuuuuivaiiiiiiiiiiic%;iiiirr, ,.r ii/of/iiiaaiairNNa�N�ru�iftis�r»innnn � % Depending on the nature and anticipated duration of the use, as a condition of approval the special permit, the Board reserves the right to: a. Provide a deadline for termination of the construction staging area; b. Limit the hours of operation; c. Limit the type of equipment and materials on the site yp d. Require fencing, landscaping and/or other screening to limit potential visual and noise impacts of the use on adjacent property owners,:.:and p J P p Y f, e. Require surface water management improvements to the affected site 9. The property shall be restored to its prior condition: Compliance to be determined upon termination of the staging area. I