Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Item R09
R9 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY of MONROE �� i Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein,District 5 The Florida Keys Mayor Pro Tern James K.Scholl,District 3 Craig Cates,District 1 Michelle Lincoln,District 2 ' David Rice,District 4 Board of County Commissioners Meeting July 17, 2024 Agenda Item Number: R9 2023-2589 BULK ITEM: No DEPARTMENT: Sustainability TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Rhonda Haag 9:00 am AGENDA ITEM WORDING: SUSTAINABILITY: A public hearing of the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, to consider approval of a resolution relating to the canal restoration program; imposing annual maintenance assessments for properties located within the canal restoration municipal service benefit unit for canals 105, 82-83-84, and 266; approving the non-ad valorem assessment rolls;providing for collection of maintenance assessments for the 2025 tax year; and providing an effective date. ITEM BACKGROUND: In 2017, the Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) adopted Ordinance 021-2017, creating the Monroe County Canals Municipal Service Benefit Unit(MSBU) to finance the canal restoration program. Section 3.08 of the Ordinance provides that each year, the BOCC will adopt an annual rate resolution setting the canal assessment for the upcoming fiscal year. The attached resolution states the amount of the assessment for each canal and also lists the assessment rolls for the program. As required by the Ordinance, notice of the public hearing on the annual rate resolution has been published in a newspaper of general circulation within the County for at least 20 days prior to the public hearing. The rates for the MSBU for canals 82-83-84 and canal 105 are proposed to be temporarily reduced by 50% from the previous year (Year 1)because the projects have not yet been constructed. The rates are anticipated to be increased back to the current rate the following year, assuming the projects have been or are under construction. The MSBU for canal 266, which has been in existence for several years, remains unchanged. PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: 10/18/2017: BOCC approval of Ordinance 021-2017, establishing a Municipal Service Benefit Unit for collection of special non-ad valorem assessments for the canal restoration program. 5270 11/24/17: Approval to advertise a public hearing to consider approval of a resolution of Monroe County, Florida electing to use the uniform method of collecting non-ad valorem special assessments levied within the County toward the cost of providing Operations and Maintenance costs for canal restoration demonstration projects and/or for canal skimming services for any canals within unincorporated Monroe County (the Notice of Intent resolution will be heard at the December 13, 2017 public hearing in Key Largo). 11/20/18: Discussion and direction on the County's three air curtains installed on Big Pine Key as part of the County's demonstration projects that were destroyed by Hurricane Irma. [Commissioners directed staff to proceed with an air curtain replacement at canal 266 and to proceed with an MSBU to fund the operations and maintenance.] 04/17/19: BOCC approval of Initial Assessment Resolution (Res. No. 121-2019), imposing annual maintenance assessment for properties on Canal 266. 7/17/19: BOCC adopts revised Initial Assessment Resolution (Res. No. 200-2019) imposing annual maintenance assessments for properties on Canal 266. 8/21/19: BOCC adopts Final Assessment Resolution(Res. No. 229-2019), imposing maintenance assessments for properties on Canal 266. 08/18/21: A public hearing to consider approval of the annual rate resolution for Canal 266 on Big Pine Key as part of the canal restoration program, imposing an annual assessment for the cost of Canal 266 operations and maintenance for FY 2022. 08/17/22: A public hearing to consider approval of the annual rate resolution for Canal 266 on Big Pine Key as part of the canal restoration program, imposing an annual assessment for the cost of Canal 266 operations and maintenance for FY 2023. 04/19/23: A public hearing to consider adoption of an Initial Assessment Resolution for Monroe County, Florida to collect special assessments within the Monroe County Canals Municipal Services Benefit Unit(MSBU) to pay for ongoing operation and maintenance (O&M) costs for canal water quality restoration project for Canal 105 in Tavernier in Key Largo; stating a need for such levy; setting a public hearing for adoption of a Final Assessment Resolution(FAR);providing for mailed and published notice of the public hearing on the FAR; and providing for an effective date. 04/19/23: A public hearing to consider adoption of an Initial Assessment Resolution for Monroe County, Florida to collect special assessments within the Monroe County Canals Municipal Services Benefit Unit(MSBU) to pay for ongoing operation and maintenance (O&M) costs for canal water quality restoration projects on Canals 82, 83 and 84 in Rock Harbor in Key Largo; stating a need for such levy; setting a public hearing for adoption of a Final Assessment Resolution (FAR);providing for mailed and published notice of the public hearing on the FAR; and providing for an effective date. 06/21/2023: A public hearing to consider adoption of a Final Assessment Resolution for Monroe County, Florida, to collect special assessments within the Monroe County Canals Municipal Services Benefit Unit(MSBU) to pay for ongoing operation and maintenance (O&M) costs for an existing canal water quality restoration project(air curtain) on Canals 82, 83 and 84 in Rock Harbor on Key Largo; stating a need for such levy; and providing for an effective date. 06/21/23: A public hearing to consider adoption of a Final Assessment Resolution for Monroe County, 5271 Florida, to collect special assessments within the Monroe County Canals Municipal Services Benefit Unit(MSBU) to pay for ongoing operation and maintenance (O&M) costs for an existing canal water quality restoration project (air curtain) on Canal 105 in Tavernier; stating a need for such levy; and providing for an effective date. 07/19/23: A public hearing to consider approval of the annual rate resolution for Canal 266 on Big Pine Key as part of the canal restoration program, imposing an annual assessment for the cost of Canal 266 operations and maintenance for FY 2024. INSURANCE REQUIRED: No CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: Not applicable STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval DOCUMENTATION: Ordinance 0212017 creation MSBU canal restoration.pdf Annual Rate Resolution 3 Sets of Canal MSBU°s FY 25.pdf FINANCIAL IMPACT: Effective Date: Ongoing Expiration Date: N/A Total Dollar Value of Contract: N/A Total Cost to County: N/A Current Year Portion: $0 Budgeted: N/A Source of Funds: MSBU CPI: N/A Indirect Costs: N/A Estimated Ongoing Costs Not Included in above dollar amounts: Revenue Producing: Yes If yes, amount: As shown in resolution. Grant: N/A County Match: N/A Insurance Required: N/A Additional Details: 5272 ORDINANCE NO. 021 - 2017 AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE IMPOSITION OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS FOR A CANAL RESTORATION PROGRAM; CREATING AND ESTABLISHING A MONROE COUNTY CANALS MUNICIPAL SERVICE BENEFIT UNIT ("MSBU") TO FINANCE THE IMPROVEMENTS; AUTHORIZING THE IMPOSITION AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS AGAINST PROPERTY WITHIN THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF MONROE COUNTY; ESTABLISHING THE PROCEDURES FOR IMPOSING ASSESSMENTS; ESTABLISHING PROCEDURES FOR NOTICE AND ADOPTION OF ASSESSMENT ROLLS; PROVIDING THAT ASSESSMENTS CONSTITUTE A LIEN ON ASSESSED PROPERTY UPON ADOPTION OF THE ASSESSMENT ROLL; PROVIDING THAT THE LIEN FOR AN ASSESSMENT COLLECTED PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 197.3632 AND 197.3635, FLORIDA STATUTES, UPON PERFECTION, SHALL ATTACH TO THE PROPERTY ON THE PRIOR JANUARY 1, THE LIEN DATE FOR AD VALOREM TAXES; PROVIDING THAT A PERFECTED LIEN SHALL BE EQUAL IN RANK AND DIGNITY WITH THE LIENS OF ALL STATE, COUNTY, DISTRICT, OR MUNICIPAL TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS AND SUPERIOR IN DIGNITY TO ALL OTHER PRIOR LIENS, MORTGAGES, TITLES, AND CLAIMS; AUTHORIZING EXEMPTIONS AND HARDSHIP ASSISTANCE; PROVIDING PROCEDURES FOR COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS; AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF OBLIGATIONS SECURED BY ASSESSMENTS AND PROVIDING FOR THE TERMS THEREOF; PROVIDING THAT THE COUNTY'S TAXING POWER SHALL NOT BE PLEDGED; PROVIDING REMEDIES; DEEMING THAT PLEDGED REVENUES SHALL BE CONSIDERED TRUST FUNDS; PROVIDING FOR THE REFUNDING OF OBLIGATIONS; PROVIDING THAT THIS ORDINANCE IS AN ALTERNATIVE MEANS OF IMPLEMENTATION AND FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR THIS ORDINANCE TO BE LIBERALLY CONSTRUED; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS AND CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN THE MONROE COUNTY CODE; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA: 2 5273 ARTICLE I INTRODUCTION SECTION 1.01. DEFINITIONS. As used in this Ordinance, the following words and terms shall have the- following meanings, unless the context clearly otherwise requires: "Annual Rate Resolution" means the resolution described in Section 3.08 establishing the rate at which an annual canal assessment for a specific year shall be computed. The final assessment resolution shall constitute the annual rate resolution for the initial fiscal year in which an annual canal Assessment is imposed or reimposed. "Assessed Property" means all parcels of land included on the Assessment Roll that receive a special benefit from the delivery of the service, facility or program or provision of a Local Improvement identified in the Initial Assessment Resolution. "Assessment" means a special assessment imposed by the County pursuant to this Ordinance to fund the Capital Cost or Project Cost, if obligations are issued, of Local Improvements or the Service Cost of services, that provide a special benefit to property as a consequence of a logical relationship to the value, use, or characteristics of property identified in an Initial Assessment Resolution. The term "Assessment" shall include Capital Assessments and Service Assessments. "Assessment Area" means any of the areas created by resolution of the Board pursuant to Section 2.02 hereof, that specially benefit from a Local Improvement or service, facility, or program. "Assessment Roll" means the special assessment roll relating to an Assessment approved by a Final Assessment Resolution pursuant to Section 3.06 hereof or an Annual Rate Resolution pursuant to Section 3.08 hereof. 3 5274 "Assessment Unit" means the unit or criteria utilized to determine the Assessment for each parcel of property, as set forth in the Initial Assessment Resolution. "Assessment Units" may include, by way of example only and not limitation, one or a combination of the following: platted lots or parcels of record, vested lots, land area, improvement area, equivalent residential connections, equivalent residential units, permitted land use, trip generation rates, front footage, rights to future trip generation capacity under applicable concurrency management regulations, property value or any other physical characteristic or reasonably expected use of the property that has a logical relationship to the Local Improvement or service to be funded from proceeds of the Assessment. "Board" means the Board of County Commissioners of the County. "Capital Assessment" means a special assessment imposed by the County pursuant to this Ordinance to fund the Capital Cost or Project Cost, if obligations are issued, of Local Improvements that provide a special benefit to property as a consequence of a logical relationship to the value, use, or characteristics of property identified in an Initial Assessment Resolution. "Capital Cost" means all or any portion of the expenses that are properly attributable to the acquisition, design, construction, installation, reconstruction, renewal or replacement (including demolition, environmental mitigation and relocation) of Local Improvements and imposition of the related Assessments under generally accepted accounting principles, and including reimbursement to the County for any funds advanced for Capital Cost and interest on any interfund or intrafund loan for such purposes. "Clerk" shall mean the clerk of the circuit court for the county, ex-officio clerk of 4 5275 the board, or such other person as may be duly authorized to act on such person's behalf. "County" means Monroe County, Florida. "County Administrator" means the chief administrative officer of the County, or such person's designee. "Final Assessment Resolution" means the resolution described in Sections 3.06 hereof which shall confirm, modify, or repeal the Initial Assessment Resolution and which shall be the final proceeding for the initial imposition of an Assessment. "Fiscal Year" means that period commencing October 1st of each year and continuing through the next succeeding September 30th, or such other period as may be prescribed by law as the fiscal year for the County. "Government Property" means property owned by the United States of America or any agency thereof, the State of Florida or any agency thereof, a county, a special district or a municipal corporation. "Initial Assessment Resolution" means the resolution described in Sections 3.02 hereof which shall be the initial proceeding for the identification of the service, facility, program, or Local Improvement for which an Assessment is to be made and for the imposition of an Assessment. "Local Improvement" means a canal restoration improvement project that has been constructed or installed by the County for the special benefit of a neighborhood or other Assessment Area. "Maximum Assessment Rate" means the maximum rate of assessment established by the Final Assessment Resolution for the service, facility, program, or Local Improvement identified in the Initial Assessment Resolution. 5 5276 "Obligations" means bonds or other evidence of indebtedness including but not limited to, notes, commercial paper, capital leases, reimbursable advances by the County, or any other obligation issued or incurred to finance any portion of the Project Cost of Local Improvements and secured, in whole or in part, by proceeds of the Assessments. "Ordinance" means this Ordinance, as it may be amended from time-to-time. "Owner" shall mean the Person reflected as the owner of Assessed Property on the Tax Roll. "Person" means any individual, partnership, firm, organization, corporation, association, or any other legal entity, whether singular or plural, masculine or feminine, as the context may require. "Pledged Revenue" means, as to any series of Obligations, (A) the proceeds of such Obligations, including investment earnings, (B) proceeds of the Assessments pledged to secure the payment of such Obligations, and (C) any other legally available non-ad valorem revenue pledged, at the Board's sole option, to secure the payment of such Obligations, as specified by the ordinance or resolution authorizing such Obligations. "Preliminary Rate" means the rates published for adoption as described in Section 3.08 hereof initiating the annual process for updating the annual Assessment Roll and directing the reimposition of Assessments pursuant to an Annual Rate Resolution. "Project Cost" means (A) the Capital Cost of a Local Improvement, (B) the Transaction Cost associated with the Obligations which financed the Local Improvement, (C) interest accruing on such Obligations for such period of time as the 6 5277 Board deems appropriate, (D) the debt service reserve fund or account, if any, established for the Obligations which financed the Local Improvement, and (E) any other costs or expenses related thereto. "Property Appraiser" means the Property Appraiser of Monroe County. "Resolution of Intent" means the resolution expressing the Board's intent to collect assessments on the ad valorem tax bill required by the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. "Service Assessment" means a special assessment imposed by the County pursuant to this Ordinance to fund the Service Cost of services that provide a special benefit to property as a consequence of a logical relationship to the value, use, or characteristics of property identified in an Initial Assessment Resolution. "Service Cost" means all or any portion of the expenses that are properly attributable to operations and maintenance of a Local Improvement and imposition and collection of related Assessments under generally accepted accounting principles. "Tax Collector" means the Tax Collector of Monroe County. "Tax Roll" means the real property ad valorem tax assessment roll maintained by the Property Appraiser for the purpose of the levy and collection of ad valorem taxes. "Transaction Cost" means the costs, fees and expenses incurred by the County in connection with the issuance and sale of any series of Obligations, including but not limited to (A) rating agency and other financing fees; (B) the fees and disbursements of bond counsel; (C) the underwriters' discount; (D) the fees and disbursements of the County's financial advisor; (E) the costs of preparing and printing the Obligations, the preliminary official statement, the final official statement, and all other documentation supporting issuance of the Obligations; (F) the fees payable in respect of any municipal 7 5278 bond insurance policy; (G) administrative, development, credit review, and all other fees associated with any pooled commercial paper or similar interim financing program; and (H) any other costs of a similar nature incurred in connection with issuance of such Obligations. "Uniform Assessment Collection Act" means Sections 197.3632 and 197.3635, Florida Statutes, as amended from time-to-time, or any successor statutes authorizing the collection of non-ad valorem assessments on the same bill as ad valorem taxes, and any applicable regulations promulgated thereunder. SECTION 1.02. INTERPRETATION. Unless the context indicates otherwise, words importing the singular number include the plural number, and vice versa; the terms "hereof," "hereby," "herein," "hereto," "hereunder" and similar terms refer to this Ordinance; and the term "hereafter" means after, and the term "heretofore" means before the effective date of this Ordinance. Words of any gender include the correlative words of the other genders, unless the context indicates otherwise. SECTION 1.03. FINDINGS. It is hereby ascertained, determined, and declared that: (A) Pursuant to Article Vill, section 1, Florida Constitution, and sections 125.01 and 125.66, Florida Statutes, the County has all powers of local self-government to perform county functions and to render county and municipal services in a manner not inconsistent with law and such power may be exercised by the enactment of county ordinances, including but not limited to the power pursuant to Section 125.01, Florida Statutes, to establish municipal service benefit units to provide recreation, transportation and other essential facilities. (B) The Assessments to be imposed pursuant to this Ordinance shall constitute 8 5279 non-ad valorem assessments within the meaning and intent of the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. (C) The Assessments to be imposed pursuant to this Ordinance are imposed by the Board, not the Property Appraiser or Tax Collector. The duties of the Property Appraiser and Tax Collector under the Uniform Assessment Collection Act are ministerial. (D) The purposes of this Ordinance are to: (1) provide procedures and standards for the imposition of Assessments within the County by resolution under the general home rule powers of a county to impose special assessments; and (2) authorize a procedure for the funding of public services, facilities, programs, or Local Improvements providing special benefit to subsequently identified property within the County. ARTICLE II GENERAL PROVISIONS SECTION 2.01. CREATION OF MONROE COUNTY CANALS MUNICIPAL SERVICE BENEFIT UNIT. (A) Pursuant to F.S. 125(1)(q) and (r), the Monroe County Canals Municipal Service Benefit Unit (MSBU) is hereby created to accomplish the improvements contemplated herein. The boundaries of the MSBU shall consist of all of the unincorporated area within Monroe County. (B) Each municipality with the county may request to be included within the boundaries of the MSBU. A certified copy of the resolution adopted by the municipality requesting inclusion in the MSBU must be received by the county prior to June 1 and shall be effective beginning the next fiscal year. Upon being included, all provisions of 9 5280 this ordinance shall apply within the boundary of such municipality. SECTION 2.02. CREATION OF ASSESSMENT AREA. (A) The Board is hereby authorized to create Assessment Areas in accordance with the procedures set forth in Section3.02 and 3.06. The Assessments Areas shall contain property located within the County that is specially benefitted by the services, facilities, programs, or Local Improvements proposed for funding from the proceeds of Assessments to be imposed therein. (B) Either the Initial Assessment Resolution proposing each Assessment Area or the Final Assessment Resolution creating each Assessment Area shall include brief descriptions of the proposed services, facilities, programs, or Local Improvements, a description of the property to be included within the Assessment Area, and specific legislative findings that recognize the special benefit to be provided by each proposed service, facility, program, or Local Improvements to property within the Assessment Area. SECTION 2.02. REVISIONS TO ASSESSMENTS. If any Assessment made under the provisions of this Ordinance is either in whole or in part annulled, vacated, or set aside by the judgment of any court of competent jurisdiction, or if the Board is satisfied that any such Assessment is so irregular or defective that the same cannot be enforced or collected, or if the Board has omitted to include any property on the Assessment Roll which property should have been so included, the Board may take all necessary steps to impose a new Assessment against any property benefited by the Service Costs, Capital Costs or Project Costs, following as nearly as may be practicable, the provisions of this Ordinance, and in case such second Assessment is annulled, vacated, or set aside, the Board may obtain and impose other Assessments until a valid Assessment is 10 5281 imposed. SECTION 2.03. PROCEDURAL IRREGULARITIES. Any informality or irregularity in the proceedings in connection with the levy of any Assessment under the provisions of this Ordinance shall not affect the validity of the same after the approval thereof, and any Assessment, as finally approved, shall be competent and sufficient evidence that such Assessment was duly levied, that the Assessment was duly made and adopted, and that all other proceedings adequate to such Assessment were duly had, taken, and performed as required by this Ordinance; and no variance from the directions hereunder shall be held material unless it be clearly shown that the party objecting was materially injured thereby. Notwithstanding the provisions of this Section, any party objecting to an Assessment imposed pursuant to this Ordinance must file an objection with a court of competent jurisdiction within the time periods prescribed herein. SECTION 2.04. CORRECTION OF ERRORS AND OMISSIONS. (A) No act of error or omission on the part of the Property Appraiser, Tax Collector, County Administrator, their deputies, employees, or designees, shall operate to release or discharge any obligation for payment of an Assessment imposed by the Board under the provision of this Ordinance. (B) When it shall appear that any Assessment should have been imposed under this Ordinance against a lot or parcel of property specially benefited by the provision of a service, facility, program, or Local Improvement, but such property was omitted from the Assessment Roll, the Board may, upon provision of appropriate notice as set forth in this Article, impose the applicable Assessment. Such total Assessment shall become delinquent if not fully paid upon the expiration of 60 days from the date of the adoption of said resolution. The Assessment so imposed shall constitute a lien 11 5282 against such property equal in rank and dignity with the liens of all state, county, district, or municipal taxes and special assessments, and superior in rank and dignity to all other prior liens, mortgages, titles and claims in and to or against the real property involved and may be collected as provided in Article VI hereof. (C) The County Administrator shall have the authority at any time, upon his or her own initiative or in response to a timely filed petition from the Owner of any Assessed Property, to correct any error in applying the Assessment apportionment method to any particular property not otherwise requiring the provision of notice pursuant to the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. Any such correction that reduces an Assessment shall be considered valid ab initio and shall in no way affect the enforcement of the Assessment imposed under the provisions of this Ordinance. Any such correction which increases an Assessment or imposes an Assessment on omitted property shall first require notice to the affected owner in the manner described in Section 3.05 hereof, as applicable, providing the date, time and place that the Board will consider confirming the correction and offering the owner an opportunity to be heard. All requests from affected property owners for any such changes, modifications or corrections shall be referred to, and processed by, the County Administrator and not the Property Appraiser or Tax Collector. (D) After the Assessment Roll has been delivered to the Tax Collector in accordance with the Uniform Assessment Collection Act, any changes, modifications, or corrections thereto shall be made in accordance with the procedures applicable to correcting errors and insolvencies on the Tax Roll upon timely written request and direction of the County Administrator. SECTION 2.05. LIEN OF ASSESSMENTS. 12 5283 (A) Upon the adoption of the Assessment Roll, all Assessments shall constitute a lien against such property equal in rank and dignity with the liens of all state, county, district, or municipal taxes and special assessments. Except as otherwise provided by law, such lien shall be superior in dignity to all other prior liens, mortgages, titles, and claims, until paid. (B) The lien for an Assessment shall be deemed perfected upon adoption by the Board of the Final Assessment Resolution or the Annual Rate Resolution, whichever is applicable. The lien for an Assessment collected under the Uniform Assessment Collection Act shall attach to the property as provided by law. The lien for an Assessment collected under the alternative method of collection provided in Section 5.02 shall be deemed perfected upon adoption by the Board of the Final Assessment Resolution or the Annual Rate Resolution, whichever is applicable, and shall attach to the property on such date of adoption. ARTICLE III ASSESSMENTS SECTION 3.01. GENERAL AUTHORITY. (A) The Board is hereby authorized to impose an annual Assessment to fund all or any portion of the Capital Cost, Project Cost, or Service Cost on benefitted property at a rate of assessment based on the special benefit accruing to such property from the County's provision of the subsequently identified service, facility, or program. (B) The amount of the Assessment that is imposed each Fiscal Year against each parcel of Assessed Property shall be determined pursuant to an apportionment methodology based upon a classification of property designed to provide a fair and 13 5284 j r reasonable apportionment of the Capital Cost, Project Cost or Service Cost among properties on a basis reasonably related to the special benefit provided by the service, facility, or program funded with Assessment proceeds. (C) All Service Assessments shall be imposed in conformity with the procedures set forth in this Article 111. SECTION 3.02. INITIAL ASSESSMENT RESOLUTION. The first step for the initial imposition of a Service Assessment shall be the Board's adoption of an Initial Assessment Resolution (A) describing the property to be located within any proposed Assessment Area; (B) containing a brief and general description of the services, facilities, or programs to be provided; (C) determining the Capital Cost, Project Cost or Service Cost to be assessed; (D) describing the method of apportioning the Capital Cost, Project Cost or Service Cost and the computation of the Assessments for specific properties; (E) establishing an estimated assessment rate for the upcoming Fiscal Year; (F) establishing a Maximum Assessment Rate, if desired by the Board; (G) authorizing the date, time, and place of a public hearing to consider the adoption of the Final Assessment Resolution for the upcoming Fiscal Year; and (H) directing the County Administrator to (1) prepare the initial Assessment Roll, as required by Section 3.03 hereof, (2) publish the notice required by Section 3.04 hereof, and (3) mail the notice required by Section 3.05 hereof. SECTION 3.03. ASSESSMENT ROLL. (A) The County Administrator shall prepare, or direct the preparation of, the initial Assessment Roll for the Assessments, which shall contain the following: (1) A summary description of all Assessed Property conforming to the description contained on the Tax Roll; (2) The name of the Owner of the Assessed Property; 14 5285 S (3) The number of Assessment Units attributable to each parcel; (4) The estimated maximum annual assessment for each Assessment Unit; and (5) The amount of the Service Assessment to be imposed against each Assessed Property. (B) Copies of the Initial Assessment Resolution and the preliminary Assessment Roll shall be available in the office of the County Administrator and open to public inspection. The foregoing shall not be construed to require that the Assessment Roll be in printed form if the amount of the Service Assessment for each parcel of property can be determined by use of a computer terminal available to the public. SECTION 3.04. NOTICE BY PUBLICATION. Upon completion of the initial Assessment Roll, the County Administrator shall publish notice of a public hearing to adopt the Final Assessment Resolution and approve the aforementioned initial Assessment Roll. The published notice shall conform to the requirements set forth in the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. SECTION 3.05. NOTICE BY MAIL. (A) For the initial Fiscal Year in which an Assessment is imposed by the Board against Assessed Property pursuant to the Uniform Assessment Collection Act and in addition to the published notice required by Section 3.04, the County Administrator shall provide notice of the proposed Service Assessment by first class mail to the owner of each parcel of property subject to a Service Assessment. (B) The mailed notice shall conform to the requirements set forth in the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. (C) Notice shall be deemed mailed upon delivery thereof to the possession of 15 5286 the United States Postal Service. Failure of the Owner to receive such notice due to mistake or inadvertence, shall not affect the validity of the Assessment Roll nor release or discharge any obligation for payment of a Service Assessment imposed by the Board pursuant to this Ordinance. (D) Notice by mail for Fiscal Years after the initial Fiscal Year shall be controlled by Section 3.08(D) hereof. SECTION 3.06. FINAL ASSESSMENT RESOLUTION. (A) At a public hearing named in the notices required by Sections 3.04 and 3.05 or to such time as an adjournment or continuance may be taken by the Board, after receiving oral or written objections of interested persons, the Board may then, or at any subsequent meeting of the Board, adopt the Final Assessment Resolution, which shall (A) create any Assessment Area; (B) confirm, modify, or repeal the Initial Assessment Resolution with such amendments, if any, as may be deemed appropriate by the Board; (C) establish the Maximum Assessment Rate, if desired by the Board and set the rate of assessment to be imposed in the upcoming fiscal year; (D) approve the initial Assessment Roll, with such amendments as it deems just and right; and (E) determine the method of collection. (B) All parcels assessed shall derive a special benefit from the service, facility, or program to be provided or constructed and the Service Assessment shall be fairly and reasonably apportioned among the properties that receive the special benefit. (C) The initial assessment roll as approved by the Final Assessment Resolution shall be delivered to the Tax Collector as required by the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. (D) The Final Assessment Resolution shall constitute the Annual Rate 16 5287 t ` Resolution for the initial Fiscal Year in which Assessments are imposed or reimposed hereunder. SECTION 3.07. EFFECT OF FINAL ASSESSMENT RESOLUTION. Assessments for the initial Fiscal Year shall be established upon adoption of the Final Assessment Resolution. The adoption of the Final Assessment Resolution shall be the final adjudication of the issues presented (including, but not limited to, the method of apportionment and assessment, the Maximum Assessment Rate, the initial rate of assessment, the initial Assessment Roll, and the levy and lien of the Assessments), unless proper steps are initiated in a court of competent jurisdiction to secure relief within twenty (20) days from the date of Board action on the Final Assessment Resolution. The initial Assessment Roll, as approved by the Final Assessment Resolution, shall be delivered to the Tax Collector, or the Property Appraiser if so directed by the Tax Collector, or if an alternative method is used to collect the Service Assessments, such other official as the Board by resolution shall designate. SECTION 3.08. ADOPTION OF ANNUAL RATE RESOLUTION. (A) The board shall adopt an Annual Rate Resolution during its budget adoption process for each fiscal year following the initial fiscal year for which a service assessment is imposed hereunder. The Annual Rate Resolution shall approve the assessment roll for the upcoming fiscal year. The Assessment Roll shall be prepared in accordance with the method of apportionment set forth in the Initial Assessment Resolution together with modifications, if any, and as confirmed in the Final Assessment Resolution. (B) The Board shall hold a public hearing to adopt the Annual Rate Resolution and the annual assessment roll for the ensuing fiscal year. At the public hearing, the 17 5288 Board shall hear comments and objections from owners and other members of the public as to the Preliminary Rate and proposed assessments. The Board shall make such increase, decrease or revision to any proposed Assessment as it shall deem necessary or appropriate. In addition, the Board shall make such changes, modifications or additions as necessary to conform the preliminary annual assessment roll with the adopted rate resolution and this article. The Board may continue said public hearing to a date and time certain without the necessity of further public notice to allow prior to final adoption increases, decreases or revisions to the Preliminary Rate or for such other reason deemed necessary in the sole discretion of the board. Upon completion of such public hearing the Board may approve the Annual Rate Resolution. (C) Notice of the public hearing for the Annual Rate Resolution shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation within the county, at least twenty (20) days prior to the public hearing. The published notice shall contain at least the following information: the name of the local governing board; a geographic depiction of the property subject to the assessment; the proposed schedule of the assessment; the fact that the assessment will be collected by the tax collector; and a statement that all affected property owners have the right to appear at the public hearing and the right to file written objections within 20 days of the publication of the notice. (D) In the event that the uniform method of collection provided for in the Uniform Assessment Collection Act is used and: (1) The proposed service assessment for any fiscal year exceeds the maximum assessment rate included in notice previously provided to the owners of assessable property pursuant to sections 3.04 and 3.05 hereof, 18 5289 (2) The method of apportionment is changed or the purpose for which the assessment is imposed is substantially changed from that represented by the notice previously provided to the owners of assessable property pursuant to sections 3.04 and 3.05 hereof, (3) Assessable property is reclassified in a manner that results in an increased assessment beyond that represented by notice previously provided to the owners of assessable property pursuant to sections 3.04 and 3.05 hereof, or (4) an assessment roll contains assessable property that was not included on the assessment roll approved for the prior fiscal year, then notice shall be provided by first class mail to the owners of such assessable property. Such supplemental notice shall substantially conform with the notice requirements set forth in section 3.04 and 3.05 hereof and shall inform the property owner of the date and place for the adoption of the annual rate resolution. The failure of the owner to receive such supplemental notice due to mistake or inadvertence, shall not affect the validity of the assessment roll nor release or discharge any obligation for payment of a service assessment imposed by the board pursuant to this article. (E) As to any Assessed Property not included on an Assessment Roll approved by the adoption of the Final Assessment Resolution or a prior year's Annual Rate Resolution, the adoption of the succeeding Annual Rate Resolution shall be the final adjudication of the issues presented as to such Assessed Property (including, but not limited to, the determination of special benefit and fair apportionment to the Assessed Property, the method of apportionment and assessment, the rate of assessment, the establishment or increase of a Maximum Assessment Rate, the Assessment Roll, and 19 5290 the levy and lien of the Assessments), unless proper steps are initiated in a court of competent jurisdiction to secure relief within twenty (20) days from the date of the Board action on the Annual Rate Resolution. Nothing contained herein shall be construed or interpreted to affect the finality of any Assessment not challenged within the required 20-day period for those Assessments previously imposed against Assessed Property by the inclusion of the Assessed Property on an Assessment Roll approved in the Final Assessment Resolution or any subsequent Annual Rate Resolution. (F) The Assessment Roll, as approved by the Annual Rate Resolution, shall be delivered to the Tax Collector as required by the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. If the Assessment against any property shall be sustained, reduced, or abated by the court, an adjustment shall be made on the Assessment Roll. ARTICLE IV COLLECTION AND USE OF ASSESSMENTS SECTION 4.01. METHOD OF COLLECTION. (A) Unless otherwise directed by the Board, the Assessments shall be collected pursuant to the Uniform Assessment Collection Act, and the County shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. The Resolution of Intent required by the Uniform Assessment Collection Act may be adopted either prior to or following the Initial Assessment Resolution; provided however, that the Resolution of Intent must be adopted prior to January 1 (or March 1 with consent of the Property Appraiser and Tax Collector) of the year in which the Assessments are first collected on the ad valorem tax bill. Any hearing or notice required by this Ordinance may be combined with any other hearing or notice required by the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. 20 5291 (B) The amount of an Assessment to be collected using the Uniform Assessment Collection Act for any specific parcel of benefitted property may include an amount equivalent to the payment delinquency, delinquency fees and recording costs for prior years' assessment for a comparable service, facility, program, or Local Improvement provided, (1) the collection method used in connection with the prior year's assessment did not employ the use of the Uniform Assessment Collection Act, (2) notice is provided to the Owner, and (3) any lien on the affected parcel for the prior year's assessment is supplanted and transferred to such Assessment upon certification of a non-ad valorem roll to the Tax Collector by the County. SECTION 4.02. GOVERNMENT PROPERTY. In lieu of using the Uniform Assessment Collection Act to collect Assessments from Government Property, the County may elect to use any other method authorized by law or provided by this Section as follows: (A) The County shall provide Assessment bills by first class mail to the Owner of each affected parcel of Government Property. The bill or accompanying explanatory material shall include (1) a brief explanation of the Assessment, (2) a description of the unit of measurement used to determine the amount of the Assessment, (3) the number of units contained within the parcel, (4) the total amount of the parcel's Assessment for the appropriate period, (5) the location at which payment will be accepted, and (6) the date on which the Assessment is due. (B) Assessments imposed against Government Property shall be due on the same date as all other Assessments and, if applicable, shall be subject to the same discounts for early payment. (C) An Assessment shall become delinquent if it is not paid within 30 days from 21 5292 the date any installment is due. The County shall notify the Owner of any Government Property that is delinquent in payment of its Assessment within 60 days from the date such Assessment was due. Such notice shall state that the County will initiate a mandamus or other appropriate judicial action to compel payment. (D) All costs, fees and expenses, including reasonable attorney fees and title search expenses, related to any mandamus or other action as described herein shall be included in any judgment or decree rendered therein. All delinquent owners of Government Property against which a mandamus or other appropriate action is filed shall be liable for an apportioned amount of reasonable costs and expenses incurred by the County, including reasonable attorney fees, in collection of such delinquent Assessments and any other costs incurred by the County as a result of such delinquent Assessments and the same shall be collectible as a part of or in addition to, the costs of the action. (E) As an alternative to the foregoing, an Assessment imposed against Government Property may be collected on the bill for any utility service provided to such Government Property. The Board may contract for such billing services with any utility not owned by the County. ARTICLE V ISSUANCE OF OBLIGATIONS SECTION 5.01. GENERAL AUTHORITY. (A) Upon adoption of the Final Assessment Resolution imposing Capital Assessments to fund a Local Improvement or at any time thereafter, the Board shall have the power and is hereby authorized to provide by resolution, at one time or from time to time in series, for the issuance of Obligations to fund the Project Cost thereof. 22 5293 (B) If issued, the principal of and interest on each series of Obligations shall be payable from Pledged Revenue. At the option of the Board, the County may agree, by resolution, to budget and appropriate funds to make up any deficiency in the reserve account established for the Obligations or in the payment of the Obligations, from other non-ad valorem revenue sources. The Board may also provide, by resolution, for a pledge of or lien upon proceeds of such non-ad valorem revenue sources for the benefit of the holders of the Obligations. Any such resolution shall determine the nature and extent of any pledge of or lien upon proceeds of such non-ad valorem revenue sources. SECTION 5.02. TERMS OF THE OBLIGATIONS. If issued, the Obligations shall be dated, shall bear interest at such rate or rates, shall mature at such times as may be determined by resolution of the Board, and may be made redeemable before maturity, at the option of the County, at such price or prices and under such terms and conditions, all as may be fixed by the Board. Said Obligations shall mature not later than 40 years after their issuance. The Board shall determine by resolution the form of the Obligations, the manner of executing such Obligations, and shall fix the denominations of such Obligations, the place or places of payment of the principal and interest, which may be at any bank or trust company within or outside of the State of Florida, and such other terms and provisions of the Obligations as it deems appropriate. The Obligations may be sold at public or private sale for such price or prices as the Board shall determine by resolution. The Obligations may be delivered to any contractor to pay for construction of the Local Improvements or may be sold in such manner and for such price as the Board may determine by resolution to be for the best interests of the County. SECTION 5.03. VARIABLE RATE OBLIGATIONS. At the option of the Board, 23 5294 Obligations may bear interest at a variable rate. SECTION 5.04. TEMPORARY OBLIGATIONS. Prior to the preparation of definitive Obligations of any series, the Board may, under like restrictions, issue interim receipts, interim certificates, or temporary Obligations, exchangeable for definitive Obligations when such Obligations have been executed and are available for delivery. The Board may also provide for the replacement of any Obligations which shall become mutilated, destroyed or lost. Obligations may be issued without any other proceedings or the happening of any other conditions or things than those proceedings, conditions or things which are specifically required by this Ordinance. SECTION 5.05. ANTICIPATION NOTES. In anticipation of the sale of Obligations, the Board may, by resolution, issue notes and may renew the same from time to time. Such notes may be paid from the proceeds of the Obligations, the proceeds of the Capital Assessments, the proceeds of the notes and such other legally available money as the Board deems appropriate by resolution. Said notes shall mature within five years of their issuance and shall bear interest at a rate not exceeding the maximum rate provided by law. The Board may issue Obligations or renewal notes to repay the notes. The notes shall be issued in the same manner as the Obligations. SECTION 5.06. TAXING POWER NOT PLEDGED. Obligations issued under the provisions of this Ordinance shall not be deemed to constitute a general obligation or pledge of the full faith and credit of the County within the meaning of the Constitution of the State of Florida, but such Obligations shall be payable only from Pledged Revenue in the manner provided herein and by the resolution authorizing the Obligations. The issuance of Obligations under the provisions of this Ordinance shall not directly or indirectly obligate the County to levy or to pledge any form of ad valorem 24 5295 taxation whatever therefore. No holder of any such Obligations shall ever have the right to compel any exercise of the ad valorem taxing power on the part of the County to pay any such Obligations or the interest thereon or to enforce payment of such Obligations or the interest thereon against any property of the County, nor shall such Obligations constitute a charge, lien or encumbrance, legal or equitable, upon any property of the County, except the Pledged Revenue. SECTION 5.07. TRUST FUNDS. The Pledged Revenue received pursuant to the authority of this Ordinance shall be deemed to be trust funds, to be held and applied solely as provided in this Ordinance and in the resolution authorizing issuance of the Obligations. Such Pledged Revenue may be invested by the County, or its designee, in the manner provided by the resolution authorizing issuance of the Obligations. The F Pledged Revenue upon receipt thereof by the County shall be subject to the lien and pledge of the holders of any Obligations or any entity other than the County providing credit enhancement on the Obligations. SECTION 5.08. REMEDIES OF HOLDERS. Any holder of Obligations, except to the extent the rights herein given may be restricted by the resolution authorizing issuance of the Obligations, may, whether at law or in equity, by suit, action, mandamus or other proceedings, protect and enforce any and all rights under the laws of the State of Florida or granted hereunder or under such resolution, and may enforce and compel the performance of all duties required by this part, or by such resolution, to be performed by the County. SECTION 5.09. REFUNDING OBLIGATIONS. The County may, by resolution of the Board, issue Obligations to refund any Obligations issued pursuant to this Ordinance, or any other obligations of the County theretofore issued to finance the 25 5296 F Project Cost of a Local Improvement and provide for the rights of the holders hereof. Such refunding Obligations may be issued in an amount sufficient to provide for the payment of the principal of, redemption premium, if any, and interest on the outstanding Obligations to be refunded. If the issuance of such refunding Obligations results in an annual Assessment that exceeds the estimated maximum annual Capital Assessments set forth in the notice provided pursuant to Section 4.05 hereof, the Board shall provide notice to the affected property owners and conduct a public hearing in the manner required by Article IV of this Ordinance. ARTICLE VI MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS SECTION 6.01. APPLICABILITY. This Ordinance and the Board's authority to F impose assessments pursuant hereto shall be applicable throughout the County. SECTION 6.02. ALTERNATIVE METHOD. (A) This Ordinance shall be deemed to provide an additional and alternative method for the doing of the things authorized hereby and shall be regarded as supplemental and additional to powers conferred by other laws, and shall not be regarded as in derogation of any powers now existing or which may hereafter come into existence. This Ordinance, being necessary for the welfare of the inhabitants of the County, shall be liberally construed to effect the purposes hereof. (B) Nothing herein shall preclude the Board from directing and authorizing, by resolution, the combination with each other of (1) any supplemental or additional notice deemed proper, necessary, or convenient by the County, (2) any notice required by this Ordinance, or (3) any notice required by law, including the Uniform Assessment Collection Act. 26 5297 SECTION 6.03. LIBERALLY CONSTRUED. This Ordinance, being necessary for the welfare of the inhabitants of the County, particularly the owners of property located therein, shall be liberally construed to effect the purposes hereof. SECTION 6.04. SEVERABILITY. The provisions of this Ordinance are severable; and if any section, subsection, sentence, clause or provision is held invalid by any court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining provisions of this Ordinance shall not be affected thereby. SECTION 6.05. CONFLICTS. All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby repealed to the extent of such conflict. SECTION 6.06. CODIFICATION. It is the intention of the Board, and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Monroe County in a new Article VI within Chapter 26 ("Waterways"); that the sections of this Ordinance may be renumbered or relettered to accomplish such i intentions; and that the word "Ordinance" shall be changed to "Section" or "Article" or other appropriate word. SECTION 6.07. EFFECTIVE DATE. A certified copy of this Ordinance shall be filed with the Department of State of the State of Florida within 10 days of enactment and shall take effect upon filing with said department. 27 5298 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida at a regular meeting held on the 18th day of October, 2017. Mayor George Neugent Yes Mayor Pro Tern David Rice Yes Commissioner Danny Kolhage Yes Commissioner Heather Carruthers Yes Commissioner Sylvia Murphy No (SEAL ' BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Atteit: `KEVIN MADOK, CLERK OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA �' �• � BY: BY: Deputy Clerk Mayor George Neugent F i ROE CO NEY PP OV A vCf✓f� PEu 4 UNTY EY Dade ()ILL11 7 o -n i- c r- C-, cm o rn --i rn;t !V c, cn c ©c, rrj z _ � N O Q 28 5299 RESOLUTION NO. - 2024 A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE CANAL RESTORATION PROGRAM; IMPOSING ANNUAL MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENTS FOR PROPERTIES LOCATED WITHIN THE CANAL RESTORATION MUNICIPAL SERVICE BENEFIT UNIT FOR CANALS 105, 82-83-84, AND 266; APPROVING THE NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENT ROLL; PROVIDING FOR COLLECTION OF MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENTS; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, in 2017, the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners ("BOCC") adopted Ordinance No. 021-2017 ("Ordinance"), establishing the Monroe County Canals Municipal Services Benefit Unit("MSBU")to finance canal restoration work in certain canals; and WHEREAS, in 2019, through adoption of Resolution No. 229-2019 (the "Canal 266 Final Assessment Resolution"), the BOCC provided that the assessment would be collected from certain properties lining Canal 266 on Big Pine Key ("Canal 266 Assessment Area"), and provided that the annual amount of the assessment would be $1,247.95 per parcel; and WHEREAS, in 2023, through adoption of Resolution No. 226-2023 (the "Canal 105 Final Assessment Resolution"), the BOCC provided that the assessment would be collected from certain properties lining Canal 105 in Tavernier('Canal 105 Assessment Area"), and further provided that the maximum amount of the assessment would be $74.25 per lot per month, or $891.00 per lot per year; and WHEREAS, because the breakwater repairs have not yet been completed, the amount of the assessment for canal 105 is being temporarily reduced by 50%to $445.50; and WHEREAS, in 2023, through adoption of Resolution No. 227-2023 (the "Canals 82-83- 84 Final Assessment Resolution"), the BOCC provided that an assessment would be collected for certain properties lining Canals 82-83-84 in Key Largo ("Canals 82-83-84 Assessment Area"), and further provided that the maximum amount of the assessment would be $47.92 per lot per month, or $575.00 per lot per year; and WHEREAS, because the breakwater repairs and air curtain have not yet been completed, the amount of the assessment for canals 82-83-84 is being temporarily reduced by 50%to 287.50; and WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Ordinance, now codified at Section 26-168 of the Monroe County Code,provides that the Board of County Commissioners will adopt an annual rate resolution during its budget adoption process for each fiscal year following the initial fiscal year of a wastewater assessment; and Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 1 of 8 5300 WHEREAS, the annual assessment revenue is necessary to continue to pay for canal restoration costs; and WHEREAS, a public hearing was held to consider this annual rate resolution and the assessment roll shown on Exhibit A, as required by Ordinance No. 021-2017, at which time the Board heard comments from owners and other members of the public as to the Preliminary Rate and made such increases, decreases and revisions as deemed necessary and also made such changes to the assessment roll as deemed necessary. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MONROE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, FLORIDA,AS FOLLOWS: Section 1.0. The non-ad valorem annual assessments for the canal restoration program will be levied at the rates for each Assessment Area shown in Exhibit A to this Resolution. Section 2.0. The assessment roll for each above-referenced Assessment Area for the upcoming fiscal year as shown on Exhibit A is hereby approved. Section 3.0. The non-ad valorem annual assessments for the canal restoration program will continue to be collected using the Uniform Method as set forth in F.S. 197.3632 and as set forth in Monroe County Ordinance No. 021-2017. Section 4.0. The effective date of this Resolution is July 17, 2024. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, at a meeting of said Board held on the 171h day of July 2024. Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein Mayor Pro Tem James K. Scholl Commissioner Michelle Lincoln Commissioner Craig Cates Commissioner David Rice BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: Mayor (Seal) Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: ATTEST: Kevin Madok, Clerk Monroe County Attorney's Office 6-24-2024 By: As Deputy Clerk Cynthia L. Hall, Sr. Assistant County Attorney Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 2 of 8 5301 Exhibit A Monroe County Canal 105 Assessment Area Assessment Roll Akey PID OwnerNamel Lots Annual Assessment 1592480 00482870-000000 EDWARDS NICOLE S 2 $891.00 1592609 00482990-000000 SALGADO ALEXANDER MANUEL 1 $445.50 1592340 00482730-000000 MESA JORGE 1 $445.50 1592366 00482750-000000 GASKELL ROBERTJR 1 $445.50 1592374 00482760-000000 SUAREZ NESTOR L 1 $445.50 1592382 00482770-000000 RUDOLPH STEVEN 1 $445.50 1592391 00482780-000000 MULDERINK MICHAEL 1 $445.50 1592412 00482800-000000 HORNER JASON J 2 $891.00 1592421 00482810-000000 DANIELS DOUGLAS PAUL 1 $445.50 1592439 00482820-000000 FABELO DOMINGO 1 $445.50 FLORIDA KEYS VACATION RENTALS 1592447 00482830-000000 LLC 1 $445.50 1592455 00482840-000000 WEBB DONALD J 1 $445.50 1592463 00482850-000000 SANCHEZ CARLOS EDUARDO 1 $445.50 1592498 00482880-000000 MOLINARO JOSEPH 2 $891.00 1592510 00482900-000000 GARCIA ESTEBAN 1 $445.50 1592528 00482910-000000 THOROUGHSCAPE HOLDINGS LLC 1 $445.50 1592536 00482920-000000 HOGUET CHRISTOPHER J 1 $445.50 DAVIS PENNY LIVING TRUST 1592544 00482930-000000 10/7/2020 1 $445.50 1592552 00482940-000000 CUBEDDU ROSANA 1 $445.50 1592561 00482950-000000 172 ORANGE BLOSSOM LLC 1 $445.50 ORANGE BLOSSOM INVESTMENT 1592579 00482960-000000 GROUP CORP 1 $445.50 1592595 00482980-000000 BENNETT NICHOLAS C 1 $445.50 1592617 00483000-000000 LODUCA JAMES D 1 $445.50 1592633 00483020-000000 DALLAS DENISE E 1 $445.50 1592641 00483030-000000 SMOLKA JAMES R 1 $445.50 1592650 00483040-000000 208 ORANGE BLOSSOM LLC 1 $445.50 M & M HOLDINGS ORANGE 1592668 00483050-000000 BLOSSOM LLC 1 $445.50 1592676 00483060-000000 GIACIN LARRY 1 $445.50 DRASKA FAMILY LIMITED 1592684 00483070-000000 PARTNERSHIP 1 $445.50 1592692 00483080-000000 EGUIZABAL VALERIO 1 $445.50 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 3 of 8 5302 1592706 00483090-000000 BUIGUES ROBERTO A 1 $445.50 1592714 00483100-000000 RICE ROBERT J 1 $445.50 1592722 00483110-000000 DOMINGUEZ EDUARDO 1 $445.50 1592731 00483120-000000 TRUJILLO CARLOS 1 $445.50 1592749 00483130-000000 BARSH GREGORY S 1 $445.50 1592757 00483140-000000 EGUIZABAL VALERIO 1 $445.50 1592765 00483150-000000 KRAUT OLIVER J 1 $445.50 1592773 00483160-000000 SPEER RICHARD 1 $445.50 1592781 00483170-000000 ALMOST HEAVEN LLC 1 $445.50 1592790 00483180-000000 CARRENO ANTONIO 1 $445.50 1592803 00483190-000000 BETANCOURT ROBERT 1 $445.50 SANCHEZJOSE BENITO REVOCABLE 1592811 00483200-000000 LIVING TRUST 5/16/14 1 $445.50 1592820 00483210-000000 TIGERS UNLIMITED LLC 1 $445.50 1592838 00483220-000000 GARCIA MICHAEL EDWARD 1 $445.50 1592846 00483230-000000 AMADOR THOMAS D 1 $445.50 1592854 00483240-000000 BELL JAMES R 1 $445.50 1592862 00483240-000100 I AM GROVE LLC 1 $445.50 TOTAL 50 $22,275.00 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 4 of 8 5303 Monroe County Canals 82-83-84 Assessment Area Assessment Roll Canal Annual # Akey PID OwnerNamel Lots assessment 84 1593117 00483490-000000 VERDERENE V 1 $287.50 84 1593125 00483500-000000 HARROUFF WADE B 1 $287.50 SERPICO LESLIE H REVOCABLE 84 1593214 00483590-000000 TRUST 07/28/2022 1 $287.50 84 1593222 00483600-000000 RUBIO ORLANDO 1 $287.50 84 1593338 00483710-000000 GILBERT ABEL 1 $287.50 82 1593486 00483850-000000 M & E HOLDINGS LLC 1 $287.50 82 9103609 00483850-000100 K& K LENDING LLC 1 $287.50 82 1593508 00483870-000000 CASTILLO DINELIA 1 $287.50 83 1593834 00484200-000000 DIGIORE PHILIP 1 $287.50 82 Confidential Confidential CONFIDENTIAL 2 $575.00 84 1593087 00483470-000000 CASARETTO ALBERTO 2 $575.00 84 1593109 00483480-000000 CABRERAJUAN 1 $287.50 84 9104625 00483500-000100 JONES DAVID M 1 $287.50 VAN HEDEN FAMILY REVOCABLE 84 1593141 00483520-000000 TRUST 7/17/2014 1 $287.50 84 1593150 00483530-000000 LARGOLUX CORPORATION 1 $287.50 84 1593168 00483540-000000 LARGOLUX CORPORATION 1 $287.50 84 1593176 00483550-000000 KAKKO MATTI 1 $287.50 84 1593184 00483560-000000 MONTES DE OCA RAUL J 1 $287.50 84 1593192 00483570-000000 CARPENTER GARY S 1 $287.50 84 1593206 00483580-000000 ANCHETA MAIKEL 1 $287.50 84 1593231 00483610-000000 PEREZ NOEL RUIZ 1 $287.50 84 1593249 00483620-000000 HERNANDEZ STEVEN 1 $287.50 84 1593257 00483630-000000 633 CUDA LLC 1 $287.50 84 1593281 00483660-000000 BATISTA RAMON 3 $862.50 84 1593290 00483670-000000 DIMONE MICHAEL 1 $287.50 84 1593303 00483680-000000 SALAS DELSYS 1 $287.50 84 1593311 00483690-000000 CHAO VICTOR A 1 $287.50 84 1593320 00483700-000000 FLEMING WILLIAM F 1 $287.50 84 1593346 00483720-000000 PAWLIK JAMES L 2 $575.00 MERILLE JOSE AND LIZETT 84 1593362 00483740-000000 REVOCABLE TRUST 1 $287.50 84 1593371 00483750-000000 601 CUDA PROPERTIES LLC 1 $287.50 82 1593419 00483780-000100 SALTY DOG INVESTMENTS LLC 1 $287.50 82 1593435 00483800-000000 SANAL INVESTMENTS LLC 1 $287.50 82 1593443 00483810-000000 RIVAS ARGELIO A 1 $287.50 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals-July 2024 Page 5 of 8 5304 82 1593451 00483820-000000 JONES OWEN T 1 $287.50 82 1593460 00483830-000000 IZQUIERDO ARIEL 2 $575.00 82 1593516 00483880-000000 NAVARRO ARIEL RAMIREZ 1 $287.50 82 1593524 00483890-000000 FERRY ROBERT C 1 $287.50 82 1593532 00483900-000000 811 BONITO LANE LLC 1 $287.50 PACIOS RAMON J REVOCABLE 82 1593541 00483910-000000 TRUST 10/29/2020 1 $287.50 82 1593559 00483920-000000 SALVA CONCEPCION A 1 $287.50 82 1593583 00483950-000000 SUNRISE POINTE LLC 1 $287.50 UA-82 1593591 00483960-000000 NUNEZ ERICK 1 $287.50 83 1593613 00483980-000000 CALLAHAN MARY TAN NA 1 $287.50 83 1593621 00483990-000000 IGLESIAS MAYTE 1 $287.50 83 1593630 00484000-000000 PACHECO FREDESJR 1 $287.50 83 1593648 00484010-000000 LOPEZ CHRISTOPHER M 1 $287.50 83 1593656 00484020-000000 GINORIS JOSCELYNE 1 $287.50 83 1593664 00484030-000000 RODRIGUEZ IVETTE 1 $287.50 83 1593672 00484040-000000 CORDERO JOSE 1 $287.50 RAMSEY BRUCE M REV TR 83 1593681 00484050-000000 01/19/2005 1 $287.50 PIONEER INVESTMENT 83 1593699 00484060-000000 ENTERPRISES INC 1 $287.50 83 1593702 00484070-000000 VAZQUEZJESUSCHINEA 1 $287.50 83 1593711 00484080-000000 PERRY EDOUARD B A 1 $287.50 ADRIAN GEORGE REVOCABLE 83 1593737 00484100-000000 TRUST 2/17/2005 1 $287.50 83 1593745 00484110-000000 CHORON RONALD L 1 $287.50 83 1593753 00484120-000000 PTASHINKSIJOSEPH 1 $287.50 83 1593761 00484130-000000 BRAUN MICHAEL D 1 $287.50 SLAUGHTER MICHAEL B REV REAL 83 1593788 00484150-000000 ESTATE TRUST 10/12/2018 2 $575.00 83 1593796 00484160-000000 LESTINOJOHN ROBERTJR 1 $287.50 DOLPHIN MONTESSORI 83 1593818 00484180-000000 CHILDRENS HOUSE INC 1 $287.50 83 1593826 00484190-000000 ACOSTA ANTONIO 1 $287.50 83 1593842 00484210-000000 LLERENA AURELIO 1 $287.50 83 1593851 00484220-000000 FADIO GEORGE J 1 $287.50 83 1593869 00484230-000000 721 SERVICE LLC 1 $287.50 83 1593877 00484240-000000 HUTSON RALPH 1 $287.50 83 1593885 00484250-000000 MCCABE HARRY M 1 $287.50 83 1593893 00484270-000000 DIAZ PEDRO E 1 $287.50 83 1593915 00484290-000000 ALVAREZ JUAN CARLOS 2 $575.00 83 9071503 00484290-000100 MARTINEZERNESTO 1 $287.50 83 9071514 00484290-000200 ALVAREZJUAN CARLOS 1 $287.50 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals-July 2024 Page 6 of 8 5305 SCHWARTZ ALAN LIVING TRUST 83 9080271 00484290-000300 09/24/2019 1 $287.50 83 1593974 00484350-000000 703 GROUPER LANE LLC 1 $287.50 UA-83 1593982 00484360-000000 CALHOUN DENNIS L 1 $287.50 SALTZMAN PATRICIA REV LIV TR 82 1594440 00484830-000000 5/28/2008 2 $575.00 82 1594458 00484840-000000 REDRUELLO DANIEL A 1 $287.50 82 1594466 00484850-000000 BENITEZJESUS M 1 $287.50 JUBILEE FAMILYTRUST 82 1594474 00484860-000000 10/17/2018 1 $287.50 82 1594482 00484870-000000 VILLALOBOS MARITZABEL 1 $287.50 82 1594491 00484880-000000 KAUFMAN KEVIN A 1 $287.50 82 1594504 00484890-000000 KNAPP PAUL L 1 $287.50 82 1594512 00484900-000000 KRISON PROPERTIES LLC 1 $287.50 82 1594521 00484910-000000 WROBLESKI MARK 1 $287.50 82 1594539 00484920-000000 WROBLESKI MARK 1 $287.50 82 1594547 00484930-000000 SCHEMER WILLIAM B 1 $287.50 KELLEY JOHN PATRICK TRUST 82 1594580 00484970-000000 AGREEMENT 3/8/2019 1 $287.50 82 8595018 00484970-000100 HERRERA SERGIO 1 $287.50 82 8647565 00484970-000101 EMERSON TODD J 1 $287.50 82 8661207 00484970-000200 FORBES JAVIER TRUST 1 $287.50 TOTAL 98 $28,175.00 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 7 of 8 5306 Monroe County Canal 266 Assessment Area Assessment Roll AK RECHAR PC OWNER NAME Canal,, Unit AnnualAsrnt 1382396 00310280-000000 0000 KRAEMER JAMES 266 1 $1,247.95 1382400 00310290-000000 0100 LANG FAMILY TRUST 03/31/2010 266 1 $1,247.95 1382442 00310330-000000 0000 DONOHUE KEVIN T 266 1 $1,247.95 1382451 00310340-000000 0100 DONOHUE KEVIN T 266 1 $1,247.95 1382469 00310350-000000 0100 SCIABARASSI ALFRED 266 1 $1,247.95 1382485 00310370-000000 0100 STONE LIVING TRUST 1/7/1997 266 1 $1,247.95 1382507 00310390-000000 0100 KESSEL LINDA 266 1 $1,247.95 1382523 00310410-000000 0100 CLARK SHARON L 266 1 $1,247.95 1382540 00310430-000000 0100 WILSON MICHAEL G 266 1 $1,247.95 1382566 00310450-000000 0100 REISNER MICHAEL D 266 1 $1,247.95 ALESI DENISE M LIVING TRUST 1382591 00310480-000000 0100 6/28/2012 266 1 $1,247.95 1382604 00310490-000000 0100 SHEARIN JERRY N 266 1 $1,247.95 1382612 00310500-000000 0100 DAVEYJOHN 266 1 $1,247.95 1382647 00310540-000000 0802 GUARINI CAROLYN RITA 266 1 $1,247.95 WEINBERG LAWRENCE REV TR 1382698 00310590-000000 0100 4/6/1996 266 1 $1,247.95 1382710 00310610-000000 0100 BAILEY SHARON S 266 1 $1,247.95 1382736 00310630-000000 0100 SACKETT JOELLE 266 1 $1,247.95 1382761 00310660-000000 0100 REESE WILLIAM KENTON JR 266 1 $1,247.95 1382779 00310670-000000 0100 HAIRSTON GREGORY 266 1 $1,247.95 1382787 00310680-000000 0100 AUSTIN ASHLEY LAUREN 266 1 $1,247.95 1382795 00310690-000000 0100 CUTLER CHARLES ALMOND 266 1 $1,247.95 1382809 1 00310700-000000 0100 SEVOR JEFFREY J 266 1 $1,247.95 1382817 00310710-000000 0100 RUGGIANO GEORGE W 266 1 $1,247.95 1382833 00310730-000000 0100 AWIS BRIAN 266 1 $1,247.95 TOTAL 24 $29,950.80 Monroe County BOCC-Annual Rate Resolution Canals—July 2024 Page 8 of 8 5307