Item F02 F2
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COUNTY of MONROE i Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein,District 5
The Florida Keys Mayor Pro Tern James K.Scholl,District 3
Craig Cates,District 1
Michelle Lincoln,District 2
' David Rice,District 4
Board of County Commissioners Meeting
November 19, 2024
Agenda Item Number: F2
2023-3174
BULK ITEM: Yes DEPARTMENT: Project Management
TIME APPROXIMATE: STAFF CONTACT: Cary Vick
N/A
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Approval of a resolution ratifying the execution of a preservation
covenant by the County Administrator for West Martello.
ITEM BACKGROUND:
Hurricane Irma did significant damage to West Martello. The County received a DHR Special
Category Grant for the repairs. Upon completion, the grant required that a covenant be filed on the
property. This item is to ratify the covenant executed by the Acting County Administrator and to record
it.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION:
10/19/22 -Approval of Amendment 5 to extend date to 2/28/23
6/15/22 -Approval of Amendment 4 to extend date to 10/31/22
2/16/22 -Approval of Amendment 3 to extend date to 6/30/22
9/15/21 -Approval of Amendment 2 to extend date to 9/15/21
5/19/21 -Approval of Amendment 1 to extend date to 10/31/21
4/15/20 -Approval of a Grant Agreement
5/22/19 -Approval of five (5) Resolutions providing support for the National
Park Service, Division of Historic Resources (DHR) for the submission of five (5) grant applications
INSURANCE REQUIRED:
No
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES:
N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval
DOCUMENTATION:
194
BOCC Resolution- Ratification of Execution Preservation Covenant for W Martello Citadel Legal.pdf
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
N/A
195
Document Prepared by:
Joseph X. DiNovo
Assistant Monroe County Attorney
P.O. Box 1026
Key West, Florida 33040-1026
RESOLUTION NO. -2024
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA,
RATIFYING THE EXECUTION OF A PRESERVATION
COVENANT BY THE ACTING COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR RELATIVE TO THE REPAIR AND
RECONSTRUCTION OF THE WEST MARTELLO
CITADEL THROUGH FUNDING PROVIDED BY THE
FEDERAL EMERGENCY SUPPLEMENTAL HISTORIC
PRESERVATION FUND,HURRICANES HARVEY,IRMA&
MARIA RECOVERY (ESHPF-HIM) AND AUTHORIZING
THE RECORDING OF THE PRESERVATION
COVENANT IN THE PROPERTY RECORDS OF THE
WEST MARTELLO HISTORIC SITE
WHEREAS,the United States Congress enacted the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018,Division
B, Subdivision 1 (Further Additional Supplemental Appropriations for Disaster Relief Requirements
Act, 2018), Title VII, Department of Interior, National Park Service, Historic Preservation Fund
(Public Law 115-123) on February 9,2018; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Public Law 115-123, Congress provided additional funding to the
Historic Preservation Fund,administered by the National Park Service,for necessary expenses related
to the consequences of Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Public Law 115-123, a total of$50,000,000 was made available in
the Historic Preservation Fund for award to individual states for historic preservation projects-
providing relief for damage sustained by historic properties in areas that have received a major disaster
declaration pursuant to the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act(42 USC
5121 et seq.) as a result of Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Grant No. P19AP00012, the National Park Service awarded the
State of Florida $4,959,699 to fund subgrants for recovery, repair, and disaster mitigation activities
directed at historic properties damaged during the Hurricane Irma incident period of September 4,
2017, to October 18, 2017; and
196
WHEREAS, on June 21, 2019, pursuant to Chapter 2019-115, Laws of Florida (Line 3174),
the Florida Legislature appropriated $4,959,699 to fund subgrants administered by the Florida
Department of State, Division of Historical Resources for recovery, repair, and disaster mitigation
activities directed at historic properties damaged during the Hurricane Irma incident period of
September 4,2017, to October 18,2017; and
WHEREAS, on April 15, 2020, the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
approved a grant agreement (Grant No. 20.h.fh.100.005) with the State of Florida, Department of
State, Division of Historical Resources in the amount of$500,000.00; and
WHEREAS, on April 20, 2020, pursuant to Grant No. 20.h.fh.100.005, the Florida
Department of State, Division of Historical Resources awarded Monroe County $500,000.00 for the
repair of the West Martello Citadel damaged in Hurricane Irma. In particular, Grant No.
20.h.fh.100.005 funded the repair/reconstruction of masonry walls of the tower,reconstruction of the
historic arch and the updating of the West Martello Historic Site National Register of Historic Places
listing; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Subsection 11(d) of Grant No. 20.h.fh.100.005 and the
requirements of Section 54 U.S.C. § 302902 of the National Historic Preservation Act, Monroe
County, as a subgrantee of funds awarded pursuant to Public Law 115-123, is required to execute a
Preservation Covenant wherein Monroe County agrees to assume,after the completion of the project,
the total cost of continued maintenance, repair and administration of the grant-assisted property in a
manner satisfactory to the Secretary of the Interior by registering it with the deed of the property; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Subsection 11(d) of Grant No. 20.h.fh.100.005,a photocopy of the
executed covenant/easement, stamped registered with the deed, must be submitted to the National
Park Service; and
WHEREAS, on March 5, 2024, the Preservation Covenant relative to the repair and
reconstruction of the West Martello Citadel was executed by the Acting County Administrator as the
Authorizing Official for Grantee pursuant to Resolution No. 267-2007 of the Monroe County Board
of County Commissioners; and
WHEREAS, said executed Preservation Covenant is attached to this Resolution as
Attachment A.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1: Recitals. The recitations set forth above are hereby incorporated by reference
herein.
Section 2: The Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County ("BOCC") hereby
ratifies the execution of the Preservation Covenant by the Acting County Administrator on March 5,
2024.
2
197
Section 3: The Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County ("BOCC") hereby
approves the recordation of the Preservation Covenant by registering it with the deed of the property
comprising the West Martello Citadel Historic Site; and
Section 4: The Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County authorizes the
Monroe County Office of Clerk and Comptroller to record the Preservation Covenant by registering
it with the deed of the property comprising the West Martello Citadel Historic Site; and
Section 5: The Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County authorizes County
personnel to effectuate the conveyance of a photocopy of the executed Preservation Covenant,
stamped registered with the deed, to the National Park Service.
Section 6: Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective upon adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County,
Florida at a regular meeting of said Board on the day of 12024.
Mayor Holly Merrill Raschein
Mayor Pro Tern James K. Scholl
Commissioner Craig Cates
Commissioner Michele Lincoln
Commissioner David Rice
(SEAL)
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Attest: KEVIN MADOK, Clerk OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By: By:
As Deputy Clerk Mayor
ATTORNEYS OFFICE
APPROVED AS TO FORM
0n±nbnm 4 2024
3
198
ATTACHMENT
A
199
PRESERVATION COVENANT AGREEMENT
For an Emergency Supplemental Historic Preservation Fund
Hurricanes Harvey,Irma,and Maria Recovery Subgrant
INTRODUCTION
This preservation covenant agreement is made the 1st day of_ March , 2024, between Monroe County
Board ,;County Commissioners[Subgrantee](hereafter referred to as the"Grantor")and the Florida Department of
State, Division of Historical Resources, as the State Historic Preservation Office (hereafter referred to as the
"Grantee").This preservation covenant agreement is entered for the purpose of preserving the West Martello Towers
[Name of Property],a building that is important culturally,historically,and architecturally.
1. The Subiect Property, This agreement creates a preservation covenant on real estate legally described in the
attached Exhibit "A,"which is the site of the West MartelloTowers [Name of Property], located at 1100 Atlantic
Blvd,Key West_FL 33040 Monroe C ountl, [Street Address,City,County,State,ZIP](hereafter referred to as the
"Subject Property").
2. Grant of Preservation Covenant.In consideration of the sum of$500 0 00.00 [Subgrant Amount] received in
grant-in-aid financial assistance from the Grantee pursuant to a subgrant funded by an Emergency Supplemental
Historic Preservation Fund, Hurricanes Harvey, Irma, and Maria Recovery ("ESHPF-HIM") grant awarded to the
Grantee by the National Park Service of the United States Department of the Interior("NPS"), the Grantor hereby
makes and declares this preservation covenant,which shall run with the title to the Subject Property for the purpose
of assuring preservation of the,West Martello Towers [Name of Property].
3. Covenant re uired for Federal sub grant. This preservation covenant is entered into as a condition of the
eligibility of the Grantor for the financial assistance from Grantee and the NPS appropriated from the Historic
Preservation Fund for the ESHPF-HIM Grant Program.
4. Conditions of Covenant:
a. Duration. This preservation covenant is granted for a period of 20 years[$50,001—100,000:fifteen(15)years;
or$100,001 and above: twenty(20)years], commencing on the date when it is filed with the Monroe Couniv
Clerk of_Court[Name of County Recorder's Office].
b. Documentation of condition of the Subject Property at time of grant of this covenant. In order to make more
certain the full extent of Grantor's obligations and the restrictions on the Subject Property, and in order to
document the nature and condition of the Subject Property, including significant interior elements in spatial
context,a list of character-defming materials,features and spaces is incorporated as Exhibit"B"at the end of this
agreement. The Grantor has provided to the Grantee architectural drawings of the floor plans. To complement
Exhibit`B,"Grantor personnel have compiled a photographic record, including photographer's affidavit,black
and white photographs and negatives,or electronic image files saved as high-resolution images,photograph logs,
and a keyed location map.The Grantor agrees that the nature and condition of the Subject Property on the date of
execution of this preservation covenant is accurately documented by the architectural drawings and photographic
record,which shall be maintained for the life of this covenant in the Grantee's file for the Subject Property.
c. Restrictions on activities that would affect historically significant components of the Subject Property. The
Grantor agrees that no construction, alteration, or remodeling or any other activity shall be undertaken or
permitted to be undertaken on the Subject Property which would affect historically significant interior spaces and
features identified in Exhibit"B,"exterior construction materials,architectural details,form,fenestration,height
of the Subject Property,or adversely affect its structural soundness without prior written permission of the Grantee
200
affirming that such reconstruction,repair,repainting,refinishing,rehabilitation,preservation,or restoration will
meet The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties(hereinafter referred to as
the"Standards").
d. Restrictions on activities that would affect archeological resources.The Grantor agrees that no ground disturbing
activity shall be undertaken or permitted to be undertaken on the Subject Property which would affect historically
significant archeological resources identified in Exhibit "B" without prior written permission of the Grantee
affirming that such work will meet The Secretary of the Interior's "Standards for Archeology and Historic
Preservation".
e. Maintenance of recovered materials. The Grantor agrees to ensure that any data and material recovered will be
placed in a repository that will care for the data in the manner prescribed in the Standards for Archeology and
Historic Preservation or will comply with the requirements of the Native American Graves Protection and
Repatriation Act,and with 36 CFR 79 and 43 CFR 10.
f Duty to maintain the Subject Property. The Grantor agrees at all times to maintain the Subject Property in a good
and sound state of repair and to maintain the Subject Property,including the items detailed in Exhibit B [Other
structures or features of the site], according to the Standards so as to prevent deterioration and preserve the
architectural and historical integrity of the Subject Property in ways that protect and enhance those qualities that
make the Subject Property eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places.
g. Public access. The Grantor agrees to provide public access to view the grant-assisted work or features no less
than 12 days a year on an equitably spaced basis.The dates and times when the Subject Property will be open to
the public must be annually published and provided to the Grantee. At the option of the Grantor, the relevant
portions of the Subject Property may also be open at other times by appointment,in addition to the scheduled 12
days a year.Nothing in this agreement will prohibit a reasonably nondiscriminatory admission fee, comparable
to fees charged at similar facilities in the area.
h. Right to inspect.The Grantor agrees that the Grantee,its employees,agents and designees shall have the right to
inspect the Subject Property at all reasonable times,with twenty-four hours written notice,in order to ascertain
whether the conditions of this preservation covenant agreement are being observed.
i. Anti-discrimination. The Grantor agrees to comply with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C.
2000d),the Americans with Disabilities Act(42 U.S.C. 12204),and with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act
of 1973 (29 U.S.C. 794). These laws prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, religion, national origin, or
disability.In implementing public access,reasonable accommodation to qualified disabled persons shall be made
in consultation with the Grantee.
j. Covenant shall run with the land;conditions on conveyance.This preservation covenant shall run with the land
and be binding on the Grantor,its successors,and assigns.The Grantor agrees to insert an appropriate reference
to this preservation covenant in any deed or other legal instrument by which it divests itself of either the fee simple
title or other lesser estate in the Subject Property or any part thereof.
k. Casualty Damage or Destruction. In the event that the Subject Property or any part of it shall be damaged or
destroyed by fire, flood, windstorm, earth movement, or other casualty,the Grantor shall notify the Grantee in
writing within 14 days of the damage or destruction, such notification including what,if any, emergency work
has already been completed.No repairs or reconstruction of any type,other than temporary emergency work to
prevent further damage to the Subject Property and to protect public safety, shall be undertaken by the Grantor
without the Grantee's prior written approval indicating that the proposed work will meet the Standards. The
Grantee shall give its written approval,if any,of any proposed work within 60 days of receiving the request from
the Grantor. If after reviewing the condition of the Subject Property, the Grantee determines that the features,
materials,appearance,workmanship,and environment which made the Subject Property eligible for listing in the
National Register of Historic Places has been lost or so damaged that its continued National Register listing is in
question, the Grantee will notify the Keeper of the National Register in writing of the loss. The Keeper of the
National Register will evaluate the findings and notify the Grantee in writing of any decision to remove the
Subject Property from the National Register.If the Subject Property is removed,the Grantee will then notify the
201
Grantor that the agreement is null and void. If the damage or destruction that warrants the Subject Property's
removal from the National Register is deliberately caused by the gross negligence of the Grantor or future owner,
then the Grantee will initiate requisite legal action to recover, at a minimum,the Federal grant funds applied to
the Subject Property which will then be returned to the U.S.Treasury.
1. Enforcement.The Grantee shall have the right to prevent and correct violations of the terms of this preservation
covenant. If the Grantee, upon inspection of the Subject Property, finds what appears to be a violation, it may
exercise its discretion to seek injunctive relief in a court having jurisdiction.Except when an ongoing or imminent
violation will irreversibly diminish or impair the cultural,historical and architectural importance of the Subject
Property,the Grantee shall give the Grantor written notice of the violation and allow thirty(30)days to correct
the violation before taking any formal action, including, but not limited to, legal action. If a court, having
jurisdiction,determines that a violation exists or has occurred,the Grantee may obtain an injunction to stop the
violation,temporarily or permanently. A court may also issue a mandatory injunction requiring the Grantor to
restore the Subject Property to a condition that would be consistent with preservation purposes of the subgrant
from Grantee of ESHPF-HIM funds from the National Park Service. In any case where a court finds that a
violation has occurred, the court may require the Grantor to reimburse the Grantee and the Florida Attorney
General for all the State's expenses incurred in stopping,preventing and correcting the violation, including but
not limited to reasonable attorney's fees. The failure of the Grantee to discover a violation or to take immediate
action to correct a violation shall not bar it from doing so at a later time.
m. Amendments. The parties may by mutual written agreement jointly amend this preservation covenant,provided
the amendment shall be consistent with the preservation purpose of this preservation covenant and shall not reduce
its term of duration.Any such amendment shall not be effective unless it is executed in the same manner as this
preservation covenant,refers expressly to this preservation covenant,and is filed with the Monroe County Clerk
of Court[Name of County Recorder's Office].
n. Effective date; severability. This preservation covenant shall become effective when filed by the Grantor in
Monroe Count,,Clerk o(Court [Name of County Recorder's Office],with a copy of the recorded instrument
„WWW1e�
provided to the Grantee for its preservation covenant file.If any part of this preservation covenant agreement is
held to be illegal by a court,the validity of the remaining parts shall not be affected,and the rights and obligations
of the parties shall be construed and enforced as if the preservation covenant agreement does not contain the
particular part held to be invalid.
[INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
202
NROE COUNTY A'F7OMNEYS OFFICE
GRANTOR: Monroe Comity Roardof CouptyC'.ommissioners APPROVED ASTOFORM
f � STANTCOUPiIYA ORNEY
11 BY: Kev G.Wilson a 3.1t
Acting County Administrator
STATE OF FLORIDA
personally p' its y, f �I �'''^� �� .._..w 20_ ,
before me the undersigned.a NotaryPub I (Name of
� � COUNTY, ss: On this � � day o " �`
g _ pea d _.. b ..___
soni, to me personally known, who
ated
[Title andOrganization],that no s al hastbe nth procured b is
o or'ation and that he foregoing Tit Public for said State, �rsonall rP u
( t_ g ' g instrument was
signed on behalf of said corporation by authority of its Board of Directors, and that as such officer, heshe
acknowledged that he she executed the foregoing instrument as his,her voluntary act and the voluntary act of the
c�rt'poration.
J ..:.
f
G
OTA�Y)IIBIJC �
203
GRANTEE: Florida Department of State,Division of Historical Resources
By: .... .. . ro .w
lissa Slade Lotane,
Director and State Historic Preservation Officer
STATE OF FLORIDA,LEON COUNTY,ss:On this ;,)PI, day of e _v� .......__...........1 20, before me the
undersigned,a Notary Public for said State,personally appeared Alissa Slade Lotane,who stated that she is the duly
appointed and actively serving Director, Florida Department of State, Division of Historical Resources, and State
Historic Preservation Officer, and that she executed the foregoing preservation covenant agreement as her voluntary
act and as the voluntary act of the Florida Department of State,Division of Historical Resources.
NOTARY PUBLIC
Fx}1rKt�Mroh31.1�?
204
EXHIBIT A
Legal description of the WestMartello Towers,[Name of Properly]
[Legal Description Attached]
205
r` rno cC3 you y
g vaa — rn y r oc of c
cc (D r
w 9:- c fp a ca C O
¢•' ,� a yam,,, f6 III y y y O w y >._•�0.
✓' Zoc ocnO °� myy` �' o2 ORcEZ5=
m o fO my
mm a ;° m o ID C' o
o m o .W o
C C d a) j y C C to O E o .. b y O
a N O O .L-, f6 y c y W 0 0 O N.. w O
.Q-d Y ' y r N O -y0 m y m''Cc)
�,,; o Oi O O Oi 0
yy aai a oar y y c Qo c co y y o �o ndFs
o cw —aU a�— o y c m o
y
c ' {{o � ydo � dx m �Ooa`0i3
y N y a 7 w On'0
�I � ru- (IS
ayi `� fU a ym ° am may
a N _ d LL y + .6 C y
N N O C
4d E y O j 0
Tod y �•myo y " 0) > ioaawyou
"w U '..aN H U... � N C a X
�_„_,� L O H O�HL at �t.,. f0 3 y� yQ.
}
w
n v Y
k,
fk
r�7 a 'N r
u
�^ u
� VW
4
ry
a"
"s
k
4
tL
.. w
206 F °,
i
m
Yellow
bubbled
text is
shown on
the
drawing
"higgs
beach park
ded history
in red
dashed
lines"
green
bubbled text
is shown on
drawing in
green dotted
lines. 21�7
r
III il� ��
o "�^
1�� � ��� �
,1 �� ��.
ti in ' /l�//r, iili, e �l� is ,/� i �1�,p "r, �'r ,��
, � ,4
��•�mr!/%��r'l,� FJ =„�ii� � �'^^ rem 1 !" �✓ , �
1, � ,�,���,/,r � ���� �,,,,�'�i„ .`„l� ���,o'� / ,��. � /��-/ «i�/ F,� � k„ , rid I
�.. _, � � �� ::Vv 1 "� � �
1 �.. ,. � � �., � � �
V %/%//,,�� � , / l� /% ,/„ 1/ �%l f f �� l//,% 1 l r� ; ,
� 1 /,/, /,� /�/� ///i� „ l� l� �/ ��
l � ///�,��,����/�//��l'i�/ ,r� �'��) � r
n , ,, �i„,/�„r//,���� �Ar r i ,�,�e � / I
/�, ..�, f��� ., a�;��� . �r �,
i � � t 1 ���
�� �, � � ////l % , �/ � � r
I' � , ,1/f � ,l� ��� � .��1 �, . 11 ,, �(
� l�� � ��i ''/, �/��lll,��,,,�����I;, l��
����11 ll�,�,r��� �__ . 1 r ,, �,,,. , ,; r �,,, .,
,, ,. �.�..r��i �, - % � .?r;��C �,.��i7?c,..� �O.or1 I,a �<j a 1/r ,� ,. f �1 ki'
�,, .� ,.�,,� �<�rr,�/ / ,i,��',��, fir,�� a �,,N, � �.
y�i i �,> i �� / ��, � � �/ r r j�,rl
/� % �/ /� � ��/i/� ! ail/� ,� l�%1� rp / �i 1�l
l i /%/l/a r , /� , / /il D ��
1 %//i��/�1/r/�ii,�/�,of / ��n � 1 /� �� � � � r 1 � ��
r 0 /�/���//��� f /r /�1��1� , ��� /
/ �� i// lG � ���� �/� l� l�� l �.. ��. ..�,_,
.�1�i�i��/�///,,,i ��/i���/�,��., � � ,�� � „�. , 1�� ,./,, � �,,, N � i
r�.�.v, �r. ,ri %tlm,r, �.ii��.o.1�����,,,� i.. ��„�..r.. ,i�� � ,; � f
o+,. ,. 7i,1 �,,. „., ✓.. „� /. ..i i� ��„.�. �� u. ,..
,,,, 1�... ... w.../... �, .�,..� �,,., a, i. t, ,.>.'
�) i ,.� r/, � ��/o, /� �,/.ii/ �� // %� 1
�� ��i r 9 ,� � // i%l�/, -.�' / / �
i ' � r � i ., �i// i/ /, � ✓ � �,
l/ /i, i� i / /, �/
io � // 1, % / � 0�
� / if i / f �
f /i� / „i i�/ i � i
,,/ / � � l
/ r,
� ��� �
// �
, � f
� /
/ � � � ��
� 1 / // � l
, / � � � l 1
i, , i �
� ii � ,/ � i� it
1 / i , , / f � /// �/� l
°� �I� / / i � � u
1 � / ,,,� �, � / , / f r/� i � � 1
i / � I�
, � , / r� � .
1 , , �� � / , ,, , , ,�
l � � �� //,i,_/� �f/,.r%��, � �/�fiT.� � ��� � r i,, ,,
�'� , � ��, , / _r� . , ��.��. m
�, , �� r . ,/ , s , , i� �, 1 � � �, , 1
.� / / ,� /.r, , ,., � l.,r� re
,� y i , � , , ,, � � i �
�� , / � � � �
r � � . , , , .
��. , i i
U ,, i � i,,
i � � i � �
�, �, �:v
i i i � / i
t� )'� i ii
i .. � i � � �
�� �,� ii
i, / /
o i,� ii i ii /a i /
� i -
v /� / � ,./i/..��,,.. ,/ i�/
� < / 1�� , I
� r //, i,/ / / i c � � � /
/„
1 1 i� l �/7 ��_� � � i
l r� � i / / ,� % 1
/ I i / / i � i r/ � ��
i , �
� �„ i , 1
i � /
o,/
/ / / i
i , i/ I
ii
i, / / / ,
� , , �� 1� /
i / ,, „i/ , / � � l r
r/ /, /ii � l� �, / � ���
�, � �,� / � // // �/� I
� / � ,i
,,,, /. �
� l /� i // �� � ,
l � � / / � J
i / / � , „�
/ i / , ,fir
,, 1 � , � �,� ,, i /
��,f/ �/��/,r/,/,/ �, / � /�� < � �/ � �'„�� , ,, ,
��t���l/i��i,�, r,.l� �� t,�,�, ,./� , / / � ,, �� � ,� �,, ��r�, v
.�� �- n��, r!,��,i� ., n ,, � �/
�� „� � �,� /, 1 � �1 1
i � iai�� / �//� ,�„ /, , i /�/� / i
y ifs, �i1,��,,,,i /,/ i ,,J / ,� i / %/ /
i �/ i„ . ,i � ,/ i / /// / � r
1 r /, ///i/< .. / � / � f � ,
i � �� � � � // 0 / i
// �/ /
I � ., � / �
i� � ,�� �
� / /, _ � ,
�i / � / � i
f�/ i � � / /
1 _,, � %`
� , .�,,/
� � / i
� � ,, ,� � �il �
� � , � � � �
i 1 G /� � �
�, / / , ,���., ,i ei /
„ , l� � i � ,� i,, /�/� ///,i// �� � � l
/l� / � ,, � / �� °�
„� �fi ,, �� / � , , � ;, ��,/,i ��
/, / v � �� 1 � ���
,, / i � /
/ l��/
_, � i ,
r i f,
i
/ � ,/ ,��i
i /,
,j. � , ,�
,� � i ,/ ,�
� 3 0
, � , � � �
��
�, � �
� ,, �
� , � i i i �
1 i /
� i / �, � /
// ,i � � /
11 / i i% � / � ,�
� � ��
1 i i�
i , , ,� /
� � ,
� - / , ,i � / 0/ f /i � ���
I l i / � ,� ,/ / � �r i /� � / I
l ��� , � � / �, i � �
/ � � � � / � /
% � �� i � � � /, �/ „l
/ �i /�,
/ / i / i
� � �, � � �
� � � �, ��
�� ,, , � �
�,
. , �.� � /
,, �, ,
�., � . � , � , � i
��i�,��,/�, ,,�/ , ii„ /,��i / � ��1
��, /� 1/ � � i /� �/ , i l r�
/ i ,,,/ � �/ // � , / � l
�i� , � l / ��� ,
����i / , �/i � �/„ � ,i/ //. ,� �, r
/ r/ i i i . � � , , �
�/�� l � ���. � /„ /,,,,�� %/. � / � �n, �/� ,/�, i., � ,
,���� /�� t, �/ „� i �>,,, , , � ��ir //, r.� ,,., �. , ��,rG.
,r i /,, ,, �,�� ,i, ,� � �, / ,�� �, ,, / .� , , ,
� r � � f,<. .,�ri/ � �, � � i r
�� a� � �„/ o .� _�n / l
�.... ,.. �.. �.... ,.�...... . . ,. ,. .� / ,..,,., ,... � r l
a. �. .� ,,, �..„ � iv � / i
i ,, � a
1 / ,... f, i / r i� /
I i i ,.. � i /ri
1// i
1 / � i /
��
r, / �� � � /
L / / /
/ ii l
o r � ,�
,, / � �
�� i , , , .
��i��� � / /, i � 1 ,
i/ i �, � f
�/, i t /
��, � � � � /// i / / l
i i �
i � / i
r l i � � /
/ ,, i /
/�/ � � /
i/ o i /
� l / / % / ,, �� / �
V l / _ � i � � r,/ �
/ i . / /
� � � i/
�, ii .
l i 1 i , /
,, � , �
� / i
i /
� / ,,
/ � ,t / � � �
� i ,,/, // � 1 ,
i � , � � � /
/�,/ �i , , � � 1 �
,i„ i ���, �� �� r
� � � �, //%� / � / i � / l
i /�r
_ / , r/ � i �/� f i � ��„
�, ,�� �
l �„ _ , ,, � � / i � �/ , �
1 / , i � i � � rli, f
� / � / ,/ �
/� � � ,. , �
� / � , � /,ir, , �
,� � , i , ,i, /i�/, i
/ i�/ /�/ �/, l
/ 1 ,,, �� </� � �i �/,� li i,
i r ,,., ,,�� ,� �� ,/�/ r���
l / � / � / �v /l , �/, / , � ,�,, /, / / i
�� � o � /��. /�/ � ' � ,/
r �
h' i
� l/ / � ®� 1
/, ,; � i
,,
i it r i � '�� / i ,i�i/, ,//,�/�i /i �/
� ,//r ,,, / / / i ,i � / // //
� I l � /, / //, �f, / � l
//� ,/� 1 /� � �/
/�, /� � �
�' l / i /,/i // �/ i
� / ii / ,
/�
,,, � ,/ 1,
i, �� //�
i /,�,/�„/ ,// ,/� / i � , / � 1
r �, i / , / � � � �� � a
l � ,i i � / /� /% �i �.,
�� / ,� � l �
i /,, , / �/
/,_,,,,,%/,,��i / � �, �� ,
l � � /� // � 1, /, � ,
r � �f J /� ,, �i, /, � � , ,�
/� ,�1 ,1 �/. f / , � � ,� r, /,, � , /� �„ ,,
I � � 11 � ,� ,, � �. � �� �s
e +fir i i/.,, , ,, � i� �, . � -i� ��� I� l
�� � �, �.�
r 1... ,�! �,,.
„ s. �� .,- � t i ,� � r
r �,r,
� ,��
/� ,r l �
i I� .. �
�� r
1
/, � i l
l i
i � '�
/� �i 1 i
. �
9 / i /i i
i �,,
i /
i 1 /
io / �
l � � i /
1 i
„ ,, � � / �
/ /
/, i l
i / � / /
l / /� /
i „ 1
r � C l
i /, / / ,//
,, , , �
�i i � �
/ / 1
/ � l
i, / i � �
i �/ �� /
l �
i ,, , / / �
i / � l
I �/ i � /
i � / 1
l ,� /
� i �
/ ,� i � i i ,
f�� i � ,,�/ / �
� � � / �� i
/ � , /
�/ i/ �'
r � � % � �
// '
f � O/ � � � �
l 1 �/� , � i� l � �
�� � � i
i%% � � /
,�, /, ,��/ � ,f� / �r
,,,.�, , , i / //% /� �i
1 � /� J �� � ���,,, /�/, �/.� / �, , � �, �
c. / � r,.�i „� ��i ,,,,� i , �,/ � � I
fi„///, ,�� i,�i. /, �, ;,/,�i/ ���/ �, r � � f� .
u ., � � �/�G i 6, i
�, l � � � /�, // , � 1 � � 1
�, � <, � � /,� r ,
r /�� �i / l
< t � i
� i
/ 1� iii�
i /
i � � � i
�i / �
� / i
I � i
f i i 1
/ i� /�
i � �
/� / / �
� � f
r, � i
r � i � i
/ � �
� � r
/ � / i
,/ / ,
/� i, l �
�, it � / r � /
✓ � � /
� ��
� ,_ �
,, /,
i � �/ ,�
� , � ,/ � 1
� , � � i 1
� /i� � i � �
� � i
/ r �
1 i i / � � i , � f / � 1,
� / / �/ �� / � , � �i
t , , �, , , �/ � ��i/ �/ � � � I,� , �,,/
0 � /� � i,,� , , f/�,�/ � ,,� / i � r ,, � � �, 1
�� l� � /, l ,� /� �, , , ,� , , /,//�,
1 l �� /, , � //� � , � ,„ ,,��/ � / � ��
� I � � � �,,,,, / / �, / � i , ✓�,✓, �/ �� � i
I J /i ���� �,,,.���� �/,,, 7/�/�,,, r� � � � r�,
Ir� r r�/ ,l /, , ,// � r..,l �� � �/
��� t �1 :, ,,�� � , , , � � �i � i,,i ,,,, � i ., ,, ,,, „ ,�
1, i. . i � �,� r i it 1 �
,. � � �, i rii, ,i � /� � ,/ r a ,�
k, � /,��, l,,%, ,r./ � / „� /�/ / ,/
1, r � f i , � A � l,i� r/
/ � lrr, / � h f l �
�' i �i 1
, �
� ,
�,
� ,
� ,
� „ �,,
� t i� /i � i � / %�, ,
� � iii / � � / � ,ii / / r �
/l 1, / � / ��� / � �i�
i / / �i / l
1 / /
i �/� � / �
�� ,/ // r �� / r
1 J � � /, / /
I 1 �//�/ i/ /� /l 1
/ r / i � , �
i � �/� / � ,
li / li
f � i i
� i
a � � / ,
/ , i
� � � / � i 1
,,,, ,ii,/ / ;/
�� 1 f /
� �/ / i ,,
/ / �
� / /
� 1
�� /��
�, � � , �
� � ,
i /�//, t
, , , ,��
� „
l r/ /�� / .
� ,/ �� ,,
, /, � �
i � � � / i /,
i
i � � i
f / �// /
1 � �,
� �
�/ , , , /
�� /,
i � � ,/ �„ //�� � f� // ,i
,, � / , , � �� � ��i
� � 1 , � ,
1 / � r
,r
� � i
,� /
i � ,�
� /
,, / /
� , , ,
� , ,
� „ , ,�„
, � , �
�, o
/i
�� �i��
� � � � i 1
/ �� , 1
I � ,/ � � / ����� i
,/
�% i/ /
�,� � � /
i ��
t � �
� i i �i
/,
r
� i ��
i / i
i, / � / ,
,lll � /, ,., � i
� /�r i��,, , �i � � �o ,
,/i / i � ,�
, i �
1 , � i /
D � 0� � �
/ � � � � i i
f � / l � � � n
� � � �� /
/, i �.
r � ,, � ��
i, � i i�r � / / � , ��� �
1 , / ��� , ,�/ � // � � r
// e/ �, � , , , i �� �
i , / . / �,, ��, f ,� , �
J � � / �r�� l /gel ro/„�,!/1 ��, ��i,��, l /�n � �, a �,�l-„ i
i,� � ;/i,,, � ,/iorl�i/ ��,, /���, ,� / �� /� �1, � � i
i � I �. � <,., ,� � ...,,. i ., ,: � � � / 1 � / ii � if
,,,i / �✓l / l i � r l i 1
,�
„ r� , / � /� / � 1 ,
i � 1, � � �/� f / / �
� „/i � i
i l
/ i� /r// I/ � i
.� i�i /�/ / � � /
I / � / � � �
i � 1 r / � i
� ,� / i
1 r i � ,�/� i /�
t � / i
r / � � � /
i � i/
� � , � � o
i, , , / f
,// � ,.
/ � i //
� , / / D
,, � � 1 �'
i � , , , / � / / i 1 �
i � � � � l
i �� � ��
/ i / I
1 � � r ���', , � l i/
I / ��1 �
�1
,, i , 1 i
� � i / , �
� � � / / lr�
,� / � �
/ ,/ � /�
f ,,� �i �,.l � �
f � �, / , �� / �� / �( �
/ /, , ,,1 , i / / I
i / / �
� � � �, �, //� � / i 1/.
/ � � /
� i, /,i , ,r �, / � �l
� � �„ �,
, , , , , , , ,�f , �� � � i
i „ , i
o � � 1 i/,
r � , /,,, i,�, ,, r � 1 , , ,
i � � �� � ,/ it
/ , _ l� r r, yc � i �� n /
��, � r
�' � »�/„
e 1�� i�,
1 J; � „1 � ,�;� �� / � l
�..., � � �
I /i / J
i,
i � I� / i � �
i / �
„� o / i / /
i � l
-i,/. i,. / /� / l
/ 1
i /, i l � i�, i� ���
i � /i �/
i i.�, ��/,. �, l �, � r � i
�, � �< /„ �/ i i , i � �, f/ i /
� ��� � / i
� �/ 1 ,
/r � � � � i
/ �
i i�
/ i, i� /
�� / �, �
/,,,.,, � �� / f, /
,, � i /� �
/ / i � � / �
//� /,, /
� i / , �
�� �, l � i r
� �
l i , , i / i � � � 1
�� / � � �
i / / / �, �
i i � �
/ � �, �
i � � /
/ , i i
l i � � i � ,, i /�
�/, i ,
,, , � �
/ i , � ,,
i
� � �
f � ,,,,/, , . i %�
i
r � / ,
,, �
� f � , � i
i i
�, , i �, i
� � � / � i
� � ,i � /
r , l r / / i i
�t, i� �, � , � �
ri , / i /
� , ,� /i / �� � � /
, .. � � /, �
� , � 1, i
� � � � , / � /
� � i / i / i
1 �
l ii��� , , / ii �
� , , 1 � � ,
� i i �
/ ✓ i
/ ,, i / i1 /
� � / � � �
�� / ,/ � �
� �/
i ��
/ �� � � �� /
i � o// � / /
/i i
� ., i � � �
� � ,
i / , � / r
�/ ,, /
i %� � , , , f / , /
� , �/, , ,
i, i � � i
� , ,„ / �
i � � , ,i�
�/
� ,/ �/
f , �
� i
/ i i � / 1,. i � /f/,
� ,/ i � 1
�r t � , /�� �'/ , � , t
/ i ,/ ,� �
/i
l � i , , � � i , � I
/' // � i ,/
i , , � i
i „/ � �,
�� / �, � /� � � �,, / 1
, , � ,�
y � / � ,i
ii i� �/ �/
i / / �/ � /
� / / �, l
� � // , , / �
i �
� I r i //
1, ,,, , /
� �� / „ , i � � � � � / f
1 . ,�, / , ��� �, ,�,
s , , ,/ ��
/, 1,i
� / � �
,, �
i / f� �
i I � � � i / i
i r � / / / � i � / / � � /
/� � �� / i
�� �i ,� i
i , � // �/
i
, r �
� ,�
�, �/ i /, �
� ,, , � /
�/ �
� i i � � �/ i
� � �� , i
� �� � i
i,� �i
/ �a � � � i i
�� � � /� � �
i // � / �i i / , �
1 / � ��
�� � is, , , /��
/ � �
, ,
,� � //
� , �
it� �
�� � � � r
�� �, l i / ,. F � l�
� ,i , 1 � /,.i r
r / � i
i i � �� F
,,, � / � t
�, ,
� � �
/�
i i �t� �
i � �
� / / �. � � /
/, � / � �. i
1 ��,r% � � �� ��/ �
r � � i t
�i �,, a
� %, is �.
,, i � / f i�
/ ,, / /
� a , � .
� ,� ,��,� � ( r
/i � � //
,,,,,i, �/ / r � �
i � �, / /
i/��
i, �, r.
/ � /
/ i � /
/ � 1
/ �
i �, � / i
r ,� , � �, � i ,�
i � � 1,
r � � �, ,,, / �i � ✓ i 1 � l r ,/lIr
r 1 �� , ,� � � i /////,/ / / // � � I J
�� / ,� �,
i�, � / � //i � /, ,. _, r
,�, / / r� /
�i.. � � ��., / i. ,.. .,... .�.P ..
/ o i..... � �, ..... � i,
� � l�
< / r. ,,
t, .�. / � �
� i � � 3 � .,
�, � � � � � 1,
/ � r / �, i
� i i
i i .�,�
/. / � �% � /
,� 1,/i � � � y ,� ,
�� , � !�
,, �/ i
i r i.. � � �
/ 1 � l i, ,�, i � � f � /
r � i, ;�� / i rr� � r//� /'//�i
l i, / �i � t .�,
i i �/ /,� i /_ F i ,
/ , � ,
�, � �/ r /
� �, � � I ti
i/ � � G �,
/ ,i i� i��� / / 1
/ i �
1 , / � � ,
i � � 1
,�
� i � i, � � f
�, //, �
� � , / � m
� � /�
� / � , / � � l ,1 „t 1,
ii / �� � ,,lrH r� �`, , ,
i. � i � � , � ,� i r , , /�.�r � ,
� � � �
� / /, �// t
� // / � � ���, ., 1
/ , � �
,i i , /�
r i 1 � � �
� � �
l � �, �� � o
I �ll� f ,� i,/ �, � i� �
i� /,� � � �. �, �
� � / /,
� � � �
�� � � �, �
a � � �
1
,�,, � ,
�/� , � ,
. �, � � r , ,
/ , � � ,,
,/ i
,'// �
i , � � it
� i � � � i
� � � �/ � i
,i � i
�,�� // � � I i�/ l
i �/i /� i
��� / �, � i �i ii 1
�f�f � i / /�� �l
�� �/ � / /�
1 � i
�� � , r �, G� i � 1 ,
1 i � � /
� 1 �, � r �
i� � ,r �
i � � ,,,
�/
i� /
, � /
� �l r ,/i i
,� / r
,, / i l i
s � li ���, till ,, � �
r i i�i � �i � /� �
b / �a�i i i, ri,. / � i f
�4 �i ,�iilir`r`'�i.T`'., b� � l i � � � / 1
1 16�'. ... ,. ��,,,.n��//l'l./. i � i �� � � � I ,
� ,
v
/ /, i �
,, ,, � /
� . ��
, , , �
� , „ , , ,,, / , i / 0 J
,,, ,, , , 1 i �%�
� �, � �, , i � � � i l
� J ��,
l 1
i
i� � � � i
� l � // i
1 i „ , �� �/
/ 1
j/ � ,f r
f 1 i �/ � � /
/i / ,/ i � /
/ ��
/ � i / i
i
i / �
/i � l
i i � / r'
� i1 l
1 � � � i i i /
� � � � � t .
l
� ,, , � /
,,,, � 1
, � � i ,
� �,i
� �
� ,i
i /
,, � � � � �
�/ � � i �,
l � 1 / i /
1 � , / �,
,i � �
� / � � � 1 1 �
/'�i / � � i i � i
�///,, � � � �, � �f�
1 ��j� , ,/, % / � , 1, ,� l ��
l� 1 , �, ,� �, ,, , , , � , �/ � � I � �
1 P 1 , ✓� � /,. ,,,., ,���, �� , �� ��� l , t
.J i it �>> i/,, � i / � �� �i� � � � �
��fl / ,, ,� ,, / c l// .� /�, �,/� �' � „ �
1 �i / „ �.,,/,/�f,,,,.a/ ���/��i , � / �,, ,/ �, , ,!
�, s/��/u, :. �n,nr . � � ,,_,�/,ir/�i /�/,/ .,,
�,/� .,.I/ �, � ,,, r.:, I 1
i �P' � ,/ //////�/ i /,�,i/, � � r �//,� //r, ., j% � / 1
/ i / i / , i / i � � i JJ � /�� i
/ l /�, i � �ll 1 i� i
/ � r�- ,
/ ,
1 l i, / l � i - � i� i Is
f � �, � i r,
i,, / 1
/- � / � � �� r,, � 1
f J i i l i //o�/..
/ r / i � /,�i. /„ �l
I / i ��:, i � � �� i, I � � 1
f /i � i /,� . ,�, �i
/ � i� i,,�/ � ��i //�/�/ // �i � J n
/ I ��//� // i ,
��� /� � � �/ � r,
l ��i
/ � �, ,,.
� � / � �
r %� � i
� 1 r � ,,
i,
1 � � ,�, �/ � / �� � � 1
i r � /,
i � ,, , , ,,
� I
i,
/ /�
� � ,�,.
,/ � �
i
�, /, � � �
�, /i
,, � � �,
/ii �f� � ��� ,n ,l�
f � /,, �! �,�� � t
, / � 1 ti
� , / / i
��
� i
�� r � // /. � / �i ��
/ , � /l ,,, � i � //�/, ,
i � �
r n�� 1
, �
� / i� � t
i, , ,�� � ii �, , , 1
�, �_ ��i �I, i
i
1 �� � � � ,/ ,� i ���
� � �� /,
/ �
1 9 ,j
/, r � 1 ��,
i /„ t /� � � � � � 1
i �, f .�
��
.Illy t � i
,� �.,
l � � i,� / � ,� � �
� �
/ �, i i �.
r ��
i � k r
i �� � ���
/ � � � �
� � �
� / � / � ,
r �,� ,, i
, f , ,
r / � �
� �� � � � � ,
� 1
i , �, �
� � � , � � , 1 ���
�, i, �1 ,�,, , ,,,, , ,� ��, .� ,�
t � i / � � r. . �i i,
/ <. � / � �i r i f, � � mi � m%/ � , l
�i � f i Ol
i � I
i, i, /� �� / i �i l ,, �
/ � , � /
� /. , � ��i r ,l% i,� / ,, . _ , i
� � i,,, �//� � � , . , . , � ,4 , ,
� � f i , ,�,� , , � .
� I 1
f � �. �.
i, i /� �
1 i ii
i / /
� � ,
/ ii /// . � l � / i/i„< {
a � �„�l F� ii �
i i
/ � ✓ i
� i �/ �
,� , l ,,
i � �
� �
� ,
� / i
�i , ,� � � �,i , �
�i i� �i �, ,, /a, /� i / i f � � ,
f ,i l �, : ,�, , , ��
/ �l/ i/ /,. /��� �,
r �� l � .�. � ,/
1 � � //// /i , l
i/ �/ i ,
� / / i
1 � �
� � �
,J r i
1 i � ,�
�i /, � r r 1,
,�///% � , � ��l
� � � , �
r � � � 1
��i//,��,/,/� � �
/ � , � � �11 � � �� �
i ��, / �
�, � �
� i � � �
s � a �
1 �
l �
/ , �
l / ,/.�
� f ,, , �
, � �
,� , �
l �� , , � ��
� �� � l
//i ,
l � � i
f ,��, /�/� , ��
,,, i , / � �
�� / �� i 1
l , , � � �f
� 1
i i /,,i i /,'/. 1 l � l
, �
� / � /
� f
i �/ /
o � , � �1 ,
/,. / , , ��
t � � i�
i r �/ii / �i � � , 1
1 ,� /
�� �
/ i � t 1f ,, � , i
��
,/� i � l �,
� l �/t,/ ,, , r �/ � � l l
� 1 /,�,/r �� 1 �, l /� r � �
�,� � l
Y r �
i ,, i /
r /
/i
l
� /, � f,
� � � �1
� ii
�`
,� � � � i � �
��� �� � �
� t , , � � � �
,,, ,. . � � �� � �, 1
, � , , � �
� 1 , � I
, . � �
i i �,�� �
1 i � � I �
/ , � i / � � ,
� �
� i
/, � t
/� 1
�i� ,� ,, � � � ,,
�, � � � �.
/,
/,r
/ %�
��
,/ �
�/ �/ 1 �� , 1 i �
f, ,, , i �,
�� i�� f//� 1 � l
i � / ��
/ � , � / �
/ � , i �
r � � � ,
f ,/ /
��� i ��
i � , � 1, 1 i / i
� ,� � � � � ,l � f
i l � , ,
1 �/�i/// l , G „� � � � � �
i � ���l �� �� r � / � �� l 1
,�, ,/ , �v „��, � 1
1 � � � //� %r � � �
i , � I l
1 ,li�// ,��� , � � l,1 ,�,1 l 111 1
� , �
a , i �
i � � � 1 ��
� �, 1 � / /1� �/, � lr G 1 1
lr � ,��//��/� � tl ! t i � r
r
r �ll���� � r � 1
f �,/�i;,/ ,,, �i � � � � /�� �
r 1 �i/,,�/��/��/ i,�, / �l � � �i � �l ,l �r
/,���%�/,/,� l ��� /1 /i 1 � l> >
r/ ,�� � ,���� l%01�� l 0 , �//�i��i/ �� . , � r
� � �/�, i �/,, � 1 �/,/ � l
r � �/�� /� / ,�� /f r /,,,
i ���i�, /, � „ / /1 � ���
//, f/i, �� l �i
� �� �/% lei, ,� � l , r � / // �����,�;:, � j
,�/ �, , ,/„ li � ,� ���i 1,
i //i /� �/�, / � l � r/� �� � l
�� � /
„/ I �
i ✓ //I�� o r%✓� ✓ �/lip; �i /1 �. �,�� / f
1 1,f � /l/////� �,���/�%� i✓/�,, /�1 1� � , , .
� // � � �/ a/ � /%i, ,,Ilia ✓
l
f ✓ iiii, , /, 1,
/ ✓ � �.�, � ���, �������✓ ���1�1�� ,/ ci.. �„�: ,.;Ell ,� ..
f � ��/ i ��„� it /���%�� ✓ �,
1
✓ r I
i i
� ✓ �, / � it � /
✓,�� � ��/, / l „� if i, �� , r i.
l �
i
✓ i/ � � „ /�// � lei //i �
i
� / � , � � , , ✓ ✓ 1 it
i
✓ � i /. �� , i/ � it
i
f
f�
/ r
i
i
I / l
f
f
i
1
i
i
l
r
1 ✓
1
MEMIN
i
i
, r,,;„ ! r ,;�` �,..� "t ,a�� ;,, lZ � ^e,,�'�„ ; ,, , ; c3, �-,r� �s,t- �,fi •,, ;� :� �•, ,.
�V f ��� (;Pl'rru lliia 1�0},yrr/llll(l((lril'�i�6Nllfl r„�%�JU, �il1f �1+�.��j✓ ll'1JY,",��hl� r,��A"Y///, �///�/f�l;)� �/(l� Yl�N 1,,.
�, � rry� t,i, �- T �'..•, 1°a �� �. a� ��„�'o� e�; .J �,,; , . v� Z
m / r �" r,, ,:K�,,,X• rt0� ,,,�.�.e�r✓'(! ,o:E; rty r .t�";G� "" io (., i"W. ;11 ,r�r» l Jlrlririiu�/��QAY rr��J�111111r,(;rfJ1J1//,, , .���If�lllilrfll�lllll�u � r,7rlrrl11r4/1alJ��iY,r��i V11D///aYl//JI!(�/�ll//l/,��., � I (o•; ��, �V,
" rr•� /Ir•nIP � i � e/ q r,'ojrri ��/,/�i r�Jiau��ru PI Av>it � '" yu
I) 1J11 ,� I4�,,�%�:,..✓�96'r/llllril."J"�"Ul/lH'll�pr/,�aJll%/�Jaii,�fi!.,11� 1 �y�Hyll4/ ,,,Adll.QJ. ,�11�J1�1�,7%�l�l% olrl/r���%//1//�;lJ ',.i�h�� Y�IiN�,1, �I�'
�.. • Jx �;,r n� r�,,r�„r� � ,/ ,p//,:.rr /�//6ii�%/���la,lrCll� �1� (/����/r�///'�ir�l//l/ ��wi�l/r"•''^�.r�L�1(1I �i.: di G
� rl,° IW. �14 i d lL1�Yl//I%�rr,r��/��i J�Ulfflr �✓rl��U��fNu�l.�� l�l%,,.%l%%rl��ll��111))� �,/y,�r�, J` �Y
No ,� ,. ..3 � o�r� Pir r M �%�%%rYr rr%//a/�m��/�%% %Irl,?� ✓/ llr -� r,..1 i�d-:.
1 !'p "9 I iui filly',�dll�lfl'111fI1tf111)/y/ �Y1N�����11111Yf(��/in��VJ�ll,�lll•(4f� p,t,.}}�Yi�JIIIV`.��allllli�l�/%111111//���},�/%//�/r!//�ll��/,��/l�i�`�l';�" •�9r Y`�'
� •;. 'q� m,-.,)", �..;,� ,, ,s �, ••, .�xi�' '�$ g�U {J`°1,�.. t:;��'.4Q 1L-s,'.(�� „�i, ".:, i `., ",Ih���� '�'.P� iY
i o�," r�, ,� � / rrr/ fir, „ro, flrl!/ mi,�//ar��� //i�i��� /•/�llfr!r, a it �ilQ
" ..;, ,,,' � �r p ?��.�4�.f,�r r •� g fig.. ) ea-� ,!G/'// -;.. l/iy/ r� ,91N�ll�/. � ,...� r
1 T,r'� p !11 �� nredY�f� ��f rl�1� ��flu r� rficr llf l�J ���.Y( � ,//,��, e a t"�Gl�o-✓�u" pa
� 1i � I1 ., ��� 1 ,/.�, l�1 1k�r � l / � � 1r����,•• �,,� �L�� �
r J, ,�, ,,e"'a.- ,, •���, c�. , •o l�,rth the c , e �na� n,;„"far d a
i , i r- , - o>r,.�ir•r,�rrirr �i�grnr� I ,i�Ja,Vui
r ,.. 1��, �,. /tar ,7.r,ii ,foil �",,poi/ r �a i L/q��,.�a/r f� pj1` f ,/�� /• /u //.. �" ,.:Nt.
� r,( � ,✓/,t I i�lriJ 9d1✓ Ir�r/d// L i q�,�/�ar i/o��l/ll/1/!�/rir���/rrl%�%r l ll rri�G l� 111////�%�//O/ii„�///%%%/////����/1��� �, 1 �
< / r /ini •�, % uo ta�r f / / / //, r� r � r � � ,llr�/ rr » r xil r r,/» / ✓/ r lJ /� / p,%////� �i llr/�� i,�lr� ,r I �� ;��>�
Jl t l r 1 �,I1K''I/�lf�lrlll/�/ n%/rrc/„r,�% llr'. (,�IJJJ/J//l////✓��////,fi//IIJI,f,Pl��%1//�//l/,ro7/��%/G//��.�%�i//r � � +, I
,,. 1 / � of c / u� ro r/ //�� �r�r /i�.%/,/ /�/%,� I l,l� ,• �,llr f1 !
l"� Ga m,� 1 u ✓ /, J , /�/% r "./l/J�iJ/„!�fi/, , /„N�IN1110!/%//..r.,.////1�r%/%/1/'/.�i/ l 1 lUl, IO u � r ,1�
! 1 f' ll.,...,ear.>����. �rr r /1/!/l// ��/✓dir//�i//,�/rr��i//�l %%�/%�//i'/��%l//l. _i��l��%. �i�// � r/ % / � ,, V
I " . , � ,� ,� ,, /AP%% •�I�:� ,,,,� %ti,e � s=�, ron/f ,u r��,. >Mft x, � ,;
r �/ //t/l///� J 9/✓i "Jler ( 1///l/�/ll,(Ir'01 /Jl�l (1f %IJ///l///%�/✓G%///////�////%/%�/// eUIIIJJII�r/i��ii,.l�al, '
/ r, 1/cr r r �, rr/ rrr �// / r✓ r d.l
r ,I � r rrr,/ �, � // // �i r !„•iJ ,,///%�/r/r�///�./%�1111r117�.,ll�l�l�ir I,, l� � 1
/ , / /� d Ifh%�% �1%Ifr�Ill//�////%�%/%/�%/.,�/l�1JllIIV�J/,/a�,.�/�,, i��////r.J,//�O�/r✓/l,,//�. % ,
a r,.. ,,. ,. / n•, <, ;,,, n�G,,e Cl�t�.� UC�"1 rr '7 t ,, J 1 �0 / L T.� Se E)
n H r, � ray � r our/ f✓/ /, r % r, r 1 /� � /r,/!1 /A llNcf�V111J,1(� �/ � ,f
�Hr �u f r�/ r c! / r r r f✓ / r/io,//�i/J�I�r.,, 1 '� �(1
�Iurolr,Ii V��u,( /// �IlrlYU��, l/%/ ///111/¢11JJ/l ✓'�6�'rr �/%////9//J�lk1y0(((�r�l�f ,///,(///rJ�IIJJ/J,r7Jl/Alllli/"/,.O11Nf ,/��llyN/. J/r JJ//,r, / rl/�/" � ,
,,,I � >1J 1 ;"y,���„�; �� •�>,��, f � / ,e, >�, /��. G•,»tecll � l�oze�..,a�r ,� rk„
., •. ,:�s �r� ✓ /t e , u",,,�,as�r,z�rc, ,,zo � l r�c / _,G . /;� ,,; / , ,i �, ,
(�, ,, r,f f�,, � ,,<ir'�i , ,�� r� ,ray.: ��%Ut?� •C N ? ��, �7 ttl/4�� �' Sr ri�.4��" , ^� ,",.,
:.c � ✓ r„ 7 r, r � r,rai ,/ rrir/o/Till � r J ,�
�II 1/, � y� �lY,✓/�iQ/!�,,,�,� ar��r,'�, �r� t/�� „,J r�� ,.. � .� � ,%J� r�u��i` ,t�,•i v;�7<Q"��� 1
: r,-„� . , ; .,•� %,,,r, % /, , �Ya /r,.,s� s 4'�arn n try.ti r/,� a jf�',
��/r,�r / ,,,/rr Jl, r ,/„ i /,��r,./orr, r /o /, oii� ✓ i�i�i�i�rr,��/�k, r�lll �i�d)fl. I
p .�, ��T ,l�r�%///c��korr/���,�.�/�ur �i/%/I,/ ll/�l ./ � � //; G.! .�En•lm ry,, ' p•fl� c�'a• •<� r
4, r c r, r r / / r / ✓ r/ /,/ / /
r-
1 /
nr .r .sir. / / � i�//✓/�////./l ,,,% l/// )L �/V !:�. iP x.,4n%•, ,f..., �o � �. ,, ,;r ..„, /... ,.� .,,, /� -,*�' ,.�,r��n�r. 1s r G. ?Il - J I
,rri of r�,r O/ ,7/ ✓ r,,,,.ri/, / ///�%/ 1. ,ir /l r.J/ �/✓ / r 1
l '�" J1i,�. /r rrr To ,c%i �/ll /// 1//i/ ,/ //%/�/<�1G/��/////„/�//,Jill�,✓/// / f
��, , ?t r rt�6 •e.,c;,'UeU�t ,/ �-r1/lv�'T l�t,i„2 � ZYTC''biZ' ric II•t 1//%� /,�
r
l / /
urr 1, rr,•, � �//r/ /i/ //ll////////;,o/�l/ % ,.ilia//�irr/ 111 /.//ll/O / rr////�//�L // / // ,� / � f
h 1'l�rr,IJJG!,�� r/Ili�////�, r�ii�oi frleii��, i� „ ;,, � �///� r%; ;o �%%/% > , <, , ,�� , , „� ,a��, • drl
rrp a� � ro J e7`o 1 r r f ,roo.,./ c "i r rir i � /ol/r,.%// -I/- r•,�V�d 1. r j f / / /////////////, _��r��///!`'��. ,✓ llr/ .. 1�..
e � /r„ (•,ity�/'�, Y ut •8.� T' Q l .k�T4�..T%t�?i ;",,, S'F
/ � �r !l� i%!/%�/l,/////If.0/r,ll1/l//✓%u,o/1,l ..//r,�, f//!l/.�",�l%/ /rrG�/ G/i/%r%ir � � �.� 1' r "
f r �4•l (a �rGlllll�j Illla��///1� ,//1//d ��///////; �/lr/r //, �1�� - �r, /�„ •�%�i,' %� ,�,,,,,,�„a/rt "Ue�G,�,n
�', . , �� /r •eb �au, =ze xz?�,v dua ,//i ,c„� ,� ,;1 J, ,�
�i , r ,,rf/lG�//��/,//.,ill/�//,f1�i%/rr%/r //11/%/lllr,1////(l%//%�o/�✓✓��%r .,/l//a�/,e.,//l�or///�i/////l,�l r<, rI �, l
1 � , ; d�/st� hr �,u�•,th�r,/ce /.i�' a ,a,/, i ,,,.�
i r,/ rill col / y Ills/ t,l//�„ nu ,rI/ i �ri/rrG i/ u/ i✓/,ri•11 l////////,�/ /,!/////%////r, �/%%////%O///////////l//,� r//r �11�' �N ��,
r r„r r ,r r �r /
/ I
1 /
/
r,
i r � r rr / / �✓,/� r r r /r..�/ // / �/> ////,. ell((/r///,%%/�✓/..ri �,,. ,/ /. // fl ��r " �,�..>�/
r � ,- r ,J r r ✓,r o �i/l�/ii%Gd�//r G✓i%/��,/ll, /%:,//�r ill//,,/ / // � r
<1 ;r;, �r r �„4 • •!�r�� / r��/l�I,�; ,�,, �,ll��-.,o .�,, ,! „llll!(r o( .� J
� r r u„��.rrr/f�f�i "irl � / r r l � ,. r 0 i.,(J :,,yi// l��/r%/�f,ri�i%i,//,,,r//✓�/ ,.��r/ ,,.�,� /�>r / �r �.,.% � � r,� ��l�I A ' I, >r/ i,��1py�IV' r �;,,�a��rllll�� �����:r� ��� I � •
EXHIBIT B
Baseline Documentation
West Martello Towers
To remain eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places, a property must be able to convey its
significance.The following character-defining materials,spaces,and features have been identified as those that help
convey the significance of the West Martello Towers [Name of Property].Photo documentation is attached.
Significant Interior Spaces and Features
• Interior brick-lined rooms,originally used for storehouses, barracks,kitchen and powder magazines.
• Gun ports through the brick walls with remnants of metal framing and doors for the gun ports.
• Stairwell for the citadel, the central command center for the Martello, providing both protection and an
elevated vantage point for observing ships approaching Key West.
• Remnants of a brick archway "tunnel"connecting the outer walls and bays with the citadel.Formerly used
as a protected entrance to the citadel.
• Ammo bunkers, three concrete, earth covered bunkers built as part of the construction of Battery Inman, a
pair of gun emplacements installed in the 1900s.
• Covered arcade or walkway around the northeast side of the outer walls, which connected interior rooms
and provided protection for soldiers defending the Martello.
Significant Exterior Spaces and Features
• Exterior brick walled casemates,facing the ocean, and backfilled with earth to protect the Martello from
naval bombardment.
• Battery Inman,a pair of concrete gun emplacements installed to support the use of the Martello during WWI
and WWII.
• The Gardens. Since 1955, the grounds and courtyard of the West Martello have been developed and
maintained by the Key West Garden Club. The gardens include a wide variety of native and exotic plants,
including orchids, a butterfly garden and several species of trees. The Garden Club supports an ongoing
horticultural program as well as other community-oriented programs and activities.
Note: Descriptions of the historical spaces and features is taken from the original documentation in the
National Register of Historic Places Master Site File on the West Martello Tower, dated March 1976. The
file was prepared by William N. Thurston, Chief Preservation Planner, Department of State, Tallahassee,
FL.
212
West Martello Tower Hurricane Re air
20. h .fh . 100.005
RZUL2024�
i
Y * ,
r I
IIe�
�F
r ,
r
u �m
V rid ✓
1100 Atlantic Blvd
Key West, FL 33040
213
Location
GULF OF MEXICO
FLEMING KEY J FI
DREDGERS
fir" +;-;.� +✓ tt KEY
r
Yl�^J
d a'
v STOCK ISLAND
ATLANTIC OCEAN
SIT0c,
VY d vM1ti;�`,� dY°
w F
t LOCATION M NOT TO SCALE,..
Map of Key West
��'��; s r ci r� �% i 11�U Y �✓i�f�11���� �/����S J ���J�%�� ���������� ��� .fr i i�rr ���"^ �I!J' '�
fJ' p �� b /� Ni ✓ �I' 'it �"�i � � � %� ""'�a�;o;�rv�'"
Aerial View
214
NNW
A€R_L A.I P.... 0 1....0
4,
fix
�,,, % //���� ��ylf'� / r 1,�� �✓/ i�, ft it
�YIA1 , ) j
ii
� lN. %'
7 �"
A D�
REPAIR �», URR1GA.NE DAMAGED
BRICK MA RY AT CITADL
n
rlrt�� ,rfi Not tg
Picture of Area of Work
215
Pre-Dams a Photos
✓1 l/I
f
u 101
U�r of%
,
�YJ w I
View of Strangler Fig tree, historic arch,and wall before Hurricane Irma
1
kun,=J1�;kr
a
iJYI a
i l
I
View of exterior of West Martello Fort before Hurricane Irma.The Strangler Fig tree which fell in the
hurricane can be seen here.
216
i
'r
l
p � I
sia � w
Nl�fNwr�� rauwrlr����Gw6ruf�w�u�iuG��WV�u���rrrrrr� "i�/�rr�, /l�l(!u'!✓(�'��i�(i��(�����I ���
Exterior before Hurricane Irma
fl n it
J
V
Courtyard Fountain
217
Post-Dams a Photos
6 I zz I I I
�YL�m,rn�r:Y eYY�rYY m�Yw aw.."""n,r.L. ♦ �"'��'�
NYy m¢sV��YLort— YINLTII{4WwIP{� � � y. .IY9YwLY�MtMt Y10tINA1�lf y'
Ar/aaaW�{141nYYmila Y'JnY IYD IIM N �y
�y IIIIt11'fNl�WRKp WI MIGAIL1111tYa IIlIn6 "�
'1�IF�LY LI rM=�xY�vYY111nY mwl�� i1K!
s i'�ws m°A�im1amwr-wv siYnoa�iYv�nrr{e{'{' wm�vanY w� -�ww{- — ___ � w iwrrmoio�Y•ne'Y unwn� • I, �:
wYM{Mltp lT,B�.,. ,..•�YAY A X{0.1t�LMr�wP 111X LWLya W�MM�
�ryL� MYIM ryYM I ll��i CYILYB�N�N�i .,`'��
Rlr Mt�=�TIYIMIMtNI•MM11f14�u�NY "^ / nllwv�fWil�aif�[
mnnc. o�aa.Yuw _Y .ri 1'"� ( rwmwrrw�rm{Y"��a nancinwLa �.�c,�nuY
l�J anw«,nLa;Y.s�o�r..wNYMY �
a i r� il, n.n .mr— wwiw �xau
ss��11vm� ��Y{py� h
MAY 1e1{L�Y ' �1/CY �' r11Y1L 11YYiYf n YMLL Ypia
f
�"''+y�'' MLYrik'IXA§"r � � pqr ���YSYtM I�a{V 1�YYIfnA�.nnY
II ! UUY�Y de W><JY yem' 111ff16 '• N1M
Ap
/� wow{ nNCY6w��wwY nm r ,
PW
rs \ YirinLmwn-rrYmo YOYnYn r ra
� '' wrw�iwwirmi�',�^ BrrY. � • � ;_°
min y 1', amY 'wma r f wnnrrnY � u
+k Yw .n:aiea:�i�iYniL.Y.�c..oN
HC)Vl,h ArZl. `. • a»rumenwpLw�syminuin��,f'" +r
lr L E 0 V}Y� ��� WYL{�am�a4 �NF
YYYy6
�H f�,�IE, I w
p9
i
i C+
it ._ .,,,,—.��—.Y.-__ ... :....-........,.,m.,....,, ... ... �. '
Lem
1p` /r` munsai
�S
�------= =--------------,tea-------------------------�
i
aw.mm �
1`
218
/i�(l�
rr
w l I r8,r 1
i J �/ �� ,,, 'r��iar�r� ✓ //�r'' � r 111
l,�rrrr f rr a lrr
' °�/�`� ��%� %/, � �,��' ` r/r%"y✓1r� rp�� y ��1 y `r„p'rl', �o
F/
I/ r
1.0 Damaged Historical Arch with Historical Citadel in the Background
a i a
q p
aro
r
Iry
r
� r
I
e
e �a,„� a��" W�'v��r,'� ,:.. ' ,�. ^� uv. � nr i/"�,�o'✓rr
1.1 Damage to Historical Arch Showing the Strangler Fig Tree Prior to Removal
219
M,
aiivr�irra
IIIr,
�
,
�Ufi rill 0, / �Na
/fl1/,//i%/ii r ✓tr/i G/r�t/i r -. �,V rr ��
� ��i/) / 11J, ✓ J�� � r��ll�/ I,���j
wU f✓o ,r, ..M !, r��, ,,nuu
2.0 Damage to Historical Arch, Right Side
r
i
2.1 Damage to Historical Arch, Left Side
220
iwi, /l/ri 4'r /0, ` /bV "/ r i r, , N Y r 7v „' I N1I r 11✓1/ r DYw rY;1;77�� �/ V�r//ri�F i2.
��,��f�(11J/G r�,f`6JN NI��r� r9A� r/ ,N�i ,,. ?;Wlf���e���/i "y �r✓!�r
/ %%Orr
OWN
+vm;➢Y/ r�// � //,/ F "'"� �1r v rJ)ilr�ii"U���A�i7l�
il0irm I I I
�I
3.0 Historic Cooking Hearth
I%1 °RNe N
/� ir,if 1 Gl ,` aurUG i'/// 'IUN(/1 ii lli; i r/rl'Ur/i
/U
/
(N
100 1,
9
lf� IMINI Pf � I �11�"NF fl'„
UI
7 1f' rar,�oYw I ,
..... ��;eu ,. vah��,n ,U,+ � n..6a ,,✓oc��ir,�,,,,, +„c >' �,. ,�, � ��� ,! ,� .r„vG�/," "lyO�Oh��,rlic, "
4.0 Citadel Stair Tower, NE and NW Sides
221
// S r Ufa
//r�lll fir �a�`' ✓ii Vr / �Yi/rf%r� /' ✓ �%�� /i�//// %///ro/I
oo
/irfi
/ �/�ii/old/%,,,
/ /,
/SDI ja
vri%p!P
5.0 Interior of Citadel Stairwell
'n'�Nf�(�9d���Y 1/( � i J�� � �✓ "'�i "gr ��l 4 r p�l r
%i/ �l Hy Nr Jr r � Ira l
r r� 1' r r �y 1�✓1 ��1p o
nu„ r yui ��1 /IYt✓/l 61�� ° � ( //%/ rrr t; � � ✓ ,./,( // (�' r/ /i ✓
a' � J,�, r er rh, �f � f� 1 �j%��/ ,1� / 11 �� flrh✓/1/
�1„g �� i )a` a I ��% yy� ���fiY Yi �l�-" H. ✓,�% ����� ��. I�� �1 9 " r � ode
z,
i
6.0 Citadel Stair Tower SE Elevation
222
r%�r/rJ�i/➢1// i o//,////�/// �(q%/q/y�/rr/ r rr�l%r /��� ��%I //,, "�Ifl�llf%m
If
// i//% lJ�l
ef
�N/i",
1a r /o/irr 'Ur/ %�/r✓/ ��o
i rw`r � ✓i a;� "�'l t� a„any � �� '�w rvyi „�„ a'�,✓ r
7.0 Citadel NW Exterior Wall
6 I��
y �
r o
forYK
��n y
2
8.0 Niche in Citadel NE Wall, Inner Side
223
10/0
A
/ J/0000// rr
�g muuolul sI �,#„ ��,;,- � ar%ri��riil rriri�rp9
I I
rr
nr-
9.0 Granite Lintel Over Wall Opening, NE Exterior Wall of Citadel
jor
/
firtyri
a� r
Alf
r
6
9�� �
10.0 Top of the NE Exterior Wall
224
/J
1gSJ��ll
OF
MIN 011
�i
pI
�
'
Y
f 'O N
f o
AAA",All
11.0 Citadel NE Exterior Wall
225
Photos of Completed Work
r
r
i I
J
1.0 Repaired Historical Arch
r
f L,
/i
2.0 Repaired to Historical Arch
226
N'.r/I �fr ri;�r6r h�rlr'���I ",.rli6� ""Ifrfr jr°iV J� �ri I rl I I IU71��;,' � �G�ny�kyr+' N✓_�III, '`�I r' (' l�r ��V�j"
�G � (/ �/a//, o "/rr/�I�� r /i .a r�� r// �yj� "rw ✓�+ ji/�� � r (�
r / l ✓r�
r r
Ilf Y '
r
� I r
ul � Nd rr a rd
��� ' UI� I ✓�u w1'' '» � D�If7 '�11ii fir A�GY
' I Fig,
l
a69 J(P Po� 111 I rir`
I l
1 I!
ulll�yi!/��1�YIY�JI��������f,;l�d���i��J���1' ���/✓�,,(L,� �,r ��/ � �/.�/r l iir�w�,�,,, ro
3.0 Historic Cooking Hearth
���I(rIf(fllfffl,,,II�IfIf f11111r1lrljjjjfff I/r� �� �/ � ii //diiiiii�/��f �J�� j ,,
ors'
r
r
to
d
a
7rpiyor
4.0 Citadel Stair Tower, NE and NW Sides
227
i
i
I
;1
�J
1 ;
i
I 1
f
1 1
5.0 Interior of Citadel Stairwell
v
„r
o y�
w
u�ii f i 411 i lu Y1. '0
a
,%f
6.0 Citadel Stair Tower SE Elevation
228
flu
Al
Ff i
I r, a r /n��Pli✓ ?r�il'I� � rr ld+l�/�1N1�� 0( m� /y/Ult� ^��`i.
�r ( l�l �. I y�. f :�If✓ �iY�(iRav�drmDi ��5�"�VYr,�Ks�, � 9� p
� I
7.0 Citadel NW Exterior Wall
fr '
r
r r�
r �
I � ' i
8.0 Niche in Citadel NE Wall, Inner Side
229
/(�y� / ✓' �l: % � ,.f' VVV
V
ojl II) dyer V�� �6V�rv�
1 r 2
r
b/r / / l✓ � r , �/ rfd� /�116r1 ��r�✓ Y
r�ff
I
Y
uuv u
/
r
9.0 Granite Lintel Over Wall Opening, NE Exterior Wall of Citadel
av w,. IJ�/�rdnh ti�'wi�"�7rt,J�w'y
/ IV ''i/r P ► .
10.0 Top of the NE Exterior Wall
230
1
t
uuuuu �„
i
7l - I V ur
leti �IIII uuu �� 1 P
r
11.0 Citadel NE Exterior Wall
231