08/01/1988 Special
MM n 1 7
Public Hearing/Special Meeting
Board of County Commissioners
Monda~ August 1, 1988
Key Colony Beach
A Special Meeting/Public Hearing of the Monroe
County Board of County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m.
on the above date at the Key Colony Beach City Hall in Key
Colony Beach. Present and answering to roll call were
Commissioner William Freeman, Commissioner Michael Puto,
Commissioner John Stormont, and Mayor Eugene Lytton. Absent
from the meeting was Commissioner Jerry Hernandez, Jr. Also
present were Rosalie L. Connolly, Deputy Clerk1 Randy
Ludacer, County AttorneY1 Rob Wolfe, Assistant County
Attorney 1 Donald Craig, Assistant County Administrator -
Growth Management Division1 members of the County Planning
Staff1 members of the Press and Radi01 and the general
public.
The Board entered into a general discussion
regarding the upcoming Land Use Plan Map Amendment Hearings.
Fred Tittle, attorney, addressed the Board
regarding use of tapes at possible appeals. After
discussion, Mayor Lytton stipulated that the electronic
recordings made by the Clerk of Monroe County are available
to anyone who wishes to acquire same at cost. Dagny Johnson
spoke before the Board.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
1
l-L-5
Riviera Enterprises, Inc. and Nancy R.
Gary, Trustee
Change from IS to UR
Lots 1-15, Block 2, Lincoln Manor
Key: Stock Island
Mile Marker: 5
County Map No. 581
Request:
Property Location:
Jim Hendrick, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen-
dation of the Planning Commission and approve designation of
UR pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b ii, iv, v. During
discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Stormont to
amend the motion to approve only if the lots are used for
affordable housing. Motion died for lack of a second. Roll
call vote on the original motion was unanimous.
~
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
3
3-L-lO
Palmhurst, Inc.
NA/SR to UR
Porpoise Point, Section 3
Key: Big Coppitt
Mile Marker: 10
County Map No. 547
Jim Mattson, attorney representing the applicant, appeared
before the Board. Inasmuch as this request falls under the
4/5 Rule, the Board directed Staff to reschedule this item
for a full Board.
MM
018
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
4
4-L-17
Sandra McKay
Change from NA to SRL
Part of Government Lot 1
Key: Saddlebunch
Mile Marker: 17
County Map No. 498
Jim Hendrick, attorney representing the applicant, addressed
the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen-
dation of the Planning Commission to grant approval of
designation of SRL pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and 5(b). Roll
call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
5
5-L-17
Charles Munder
Change from NA to SS
Lot 26 of Government Lot 1
Key: Lower Sugarloaf
Mile Marker: 17
County Map No. 472
Charles Munder addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Puto to
accept the Planning Commission's recommendation to approve
designation of SS pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii,
iv, v and adherence to statutes. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
6
6-L-17
Irving Blumenthal
Change from NA to IS
Lot 8, Resubdivision of Government Lot 1
Key: Sugarloaf
Mile Marker: 17
County Map No. 472
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept Planning Department's recom-
mendation for denial on the basis of inconsistency and lack
of finding by the Planning Commission of appropriate cri-
teria. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
7
7-L-20
McKay-Richards
Change from SR/NA to SC
Part of Lots 1 and 2
Key: Sugarloaf Key
Mile Marker: 20
County Map No. 468
Jim Hendrick, attorney for the applicants, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont to accept
MM 0 1 9
the recommendation of the Planning Department for denial on
the basis of inconsistency and lack of any affirmation.
Motion died for lack of a second. Motion was then made by
Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Puto to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for
approval of the SR portion to SC pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4)
and (5)b iii, iv, v. Roll call vote was taken with the
following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
9
9-L-23
John and Sandra Pearce
Change from NA/SC to IS
Lot 1, Block 3, Cutthroat Harbor Estates
Key: Cudjoe
Mile Marker: 23
County Map No. 439
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve the IS designation pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, iv based on having found
valid criteria for the amendment and consistency with the
statutes. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
10
10-L-24
Joseph and Laverne Fisher
Change from NA to SC
Lot 75, Hudgins Subdivision
Key: Sununerland
Mile Marker: 24
County Map No. 412
Joseph Fisher addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for
denial. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
-
11
ll-L-25
Frank Hample
SS/NA to IS
Lot 26, Niles Channel Subdivision
Key: Sununerland
Mile Marker: 10
County Map No. 411
Donald Craig, Assistant County Administrator, discussed cer-
tain problems with this situation and recommended deferral
of decision on this item. After discussion, motion was made
by Mayor Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
defer any action and keep alive the applicant's due process
rights. Roll call vote was unanimous.
MM
020
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
13
l3-L-25
Owens-Albury
Change from NA to IS
Lots 1 and 2, Block 2,
Summerland Estates Resub. 2
Key: Summerland
Mile Marker: 25
County Map No. 413
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the Planning Commission's recom-
mendation of approval to IS pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and
(5)b iii based on having found valid criteria for the amend-
ment and consistency with the statutes. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
24
24-M-52
Aultman Construcction
SR to IS
Lot 13 and 1/2 of Lot 14,
Buttonwood Acres
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 52
County Map No. 231
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to continue this item for hearing on
August 3rd along with Item 25. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
14
l4-L-25
Leda Grodsky
Change from OS to SS
Island at north end of Summerland Key
Key: Summerland Key
Mile Marker: 25
County Map No. 409
Donald Craig, Assistant County Administrator, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen-
dation of the Development Review Committee to change the
designation to NA because of altered conditions. Roll call
vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
and
15
l5-L-27
Richard Kerwick
NA to SRL
Part of Government Lots 7 and 8
Key: Little Torcch
Mile Marker: 27
County Map No. 372
MM 0 2 1
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
17
l7-L-28
Paul Opland
NA to SRL
Part of Government Lots 7 and 8
Key: Little Torch
Mile Marker: 28
County Map No. 372
Richard Kerwick addressed the Board. Donald Craig,
Assistant County Administrator, requested a deferral in
order to further investigate. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
continue these two items for first consideration on
Wednesday, August 3rd. Motion carried unanimously.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
16
l6-L-28
William Oblander
Change from IS to SC
Lots 29 and 30, Block 1,
Jolly Roger Estates
Key: Little Torch
Mile Marker: 28
County Map No. 372
Garland Smith, representative of Mr. and Mrs. Oblander,
addressed the Board. Carol Dobson, Vice President of the
Jolly Roger Estates Property OWners Association, and Walter
Benjamin spoke in opposition. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Puto to
deny based on the consistency analysis according to statute
and lack of criteria fulfillment. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
18
l8-L-30
Big Pine United Methodist Church
SR to SC
Part of NE, 1/4 of NW, 1/4 of
26 -66 S-29E
Key: Big Pine
Mile Marker: 30
County Map No. 343
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to continue this item to Monday,
August 8th, for first consideration on the Agenda. Roll
call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
3
3-L-lO
Palmhurst, Inc.
NA/SR to UR
Porpoise Point, Section 3
Key: Big Coppitt
Mile Marker: 10
County Map No. 547
The Board revisited this item. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
continue this item to Monday, August 8th. Roll call vote
was unanimous.
MM
022
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
11
ll-L-25
Frank Hample
SS/NA to IS
Lot 26, Niles Channel Subdivision
Key: Summerland
Mile Marker: 25
County Map No. 411
The Board revisited this item. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
continue this item to the beginning of the process of the
Text Amendments and Staff was directed to notify the appli-
cant that he would be considered in the appropriate Text
Amendment review process. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
20
20-L-30
Koppen-Watkins-Groo
Change from SR to SC or IS
Tract 26 and 24
Key: Big Pine
Mile Marker: 30
County Map No. 357
Fred Tittle, attorney representing the applicants, addressed
the Board. Vern Pokorski, President of Big pine Civic
Association, and Grace Mannillo, Zoning Chairman of the Big
Pine Civic Association, spoke in opposition. Donald Craig,
Assistant County Administrator, addressed the Board. Fred
Tittle spoke in rebuttal. Motion was then made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to deny based on the lack of criteria presented and non-
conformance with statutory requirements. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
21
2l-L-30
Andew and Eniko Kovats
Change from IS to SC
Lots 10 and 11, Block 9,
Cahill Pines & Palms
Key: Big Pine
Mile Marker: 30
County Map No. 344
Eric Knudson, resident of Cahill Pines & Palms, and repre-
senting fifty-seven property owners, spoke in opposition to
this application. Vern Pokorski and Grace Mannillo also
opposed this application. Motion was made by Commissioner
Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the
Planning Department's recommendation for denial. Roll call
vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
22
22-M-49
Mary Brush
SR to ISD
Lot 13, The Sombrero Properties
Key: Boot
Mile Marker: 49
County Map No. 239
David Manns, attorney representing the applicant, addressed
the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and
MM
023
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to direct Staff to prepare
a Text Amendment to be immediately advertised to allow
an attached duplex a minor conditional use in SR and to
include consideration of density change in 9-302 if
required. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
23
23-M-48
Tropic South, Inc.
NA to DR
Parcels 10530, 10534, 10535,
10536, 10537, 10538
Key: Boot
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 245
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to continue until the Planning
Commission has acted. Roll call vote was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned.
*
*
*
*
*
-