08/03/1988 Special
MM 042
~ ...
<:
\.
~
Public Hearing/Special Meeting
Board of County Commissioners
Wednesday, August 3, 1988
Key Colony Beach
A Special Meeting/Public Hearing of the Monroe
County Board of County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m.
on the above date at the Key Colony Beach City Hall in Key
Colony Beach. Present and answering to roll call were
Commissioner William Freeman, Commission Michael Puto (late
entrance), Commissioner John Stormont, and Mayor Eugene
Lytton. Absent from the meeting was Commissioner Jerry
Hernandez, Jr. Also present were Rosalie L. Connolly,
Deputy Clerk1 Rob Wolfe, Assistant County AttorneY1 Donald
Craig, Assistant County Administrator - Growth Management
Division1 members of the County Planning Staff1 members of
the Press and Radi01 and the general public.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Reques t :
Property Location:
24
24-M-52
Aultman Construction
Change from SR to IS
Lot 13 and 1/2 of Lot 14,
Buttonwood Acres
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 52
County Map No. 231
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen-
dation of the Planning Commission to approve the IS designa-
tion pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, iv, v and based
on having found valid criteria for the amendment and con-
sistency with the statutes. Roll call vote was unanimous
with Commissioner Puto not present.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Reques t :
Property Location:
25
25-M-5l
James and patricia Aultman
Change from IS to SC
Part of Lot 1, Block 1,
Sea Crest Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 51
County Map No. 234
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicants, addressed
the Board and requested a continuance because of the 4/5
Rule. Commissioner Puto entered the meeting and took his
seat. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Stormont to continue this item to Monday,
August 8th. Motion carried unanimously.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
26
26-M-49
Rudolph and Louis Blanchette
Change from IS to URM
South of Lot 10, Sombrero Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
1/
."
MM
043
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve URM designation pursuant to
9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b v. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
31
3l-M-49
Kenneth and Patricia Combs
Change from IS to URM
Parcel south of Sombrero Subdivision i2
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission and approve designation of URM pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b v. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
36
36-M-48
Wilfred Sherer
Change from IS to URM
Parcel South of Sombrero i2
Key: Vaca
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve the URM designation pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b v and based on having found valid
criteria for the amendment and consistency with the statutes.
Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
27
27-M-52
Edward and Nancy Boland
Change from IS to SC
Lots F, G, H, and 1/2 of E,
Sadowski Subdivision Amended
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 52
County Map No. 229
Nancy Boland addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for
denial according to planning consistency analysis and cri-
teria and with the understanding of Staff interpretation on
2500 per lot ability. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
28
28-M-52
William and Mary Cadiz
Change from IS to SC
Lot 1, Overseas Estates
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 52
County Map No. 229
Kay Finley, attorney for the applicants, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
MM
Q44
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission for approval as amended to SC, pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b ii, iv. Roll call vote was unani-
mous. Commissioner Stormont noted for the record that the
DRC does recommend boundary determination.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
29
29-M-50
James and Billie Carpenter
Change from None to SC
Part of Tract 2, Edmonds Acreage Tracts
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 51
County Map No. 232
Kay Finley, attorney for the applicants, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Department for the approval of the alternative of
SR on a consistency basis. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
30
30-M-48
James and Billie Carpenter
Change from MU/CFSD14 to MU
Parcels near MM48
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
Kay Finley, attorney for the applicants, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation
of the Planning Commission for designation of MU pursuant to
9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii based on having found valid cri-
teria for the amendment and consistency with the statutes
and also directing that Part 6, Page 4 be changed so that
"x" is moved to "applicable" column. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
32
32-M-48
Ronald and Marilyn Farmer
Change from DR to SC
Lots 1 and 2, Halls Subdivision and
adjoining portion of Old State Road 4A
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
Kay Finley, attorney for the applicants, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission for approval to SC, pursuant to
9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, v. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
33
33-M-55
First Federal Savings & Loan
Change from SR to UR
Lots 58 and 59, Block 21,
Coco Plum Beach
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 54
County Map No. 222
MM n 4 5
Marcy Tangi of First Federal Savings & Loan Association
addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto
and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to accept the recom-
mendation of the Planning Department for denial. Roll call
vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
34PS
34PS-M-52
Leonard and Arlene Kasperowicz
Change from IS to SC
Sunny Isle Motel Site
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 51
County Map No. 231
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicants, addressed
the Board and requested a continuance because of the 4/5
Rule. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to continue this item to Monday,
August 8th. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
15
l5-L-27
Richard Kerwick
Change from NA to SRL
Part of Government Lots 7 and 8
Key: Little Torch
Mile Marker: 27
County Map No. 372
Richard Kerwick addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to
approve the SRL designation pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and
(5)b ii, iv, v and direct Staff to re-define planning con-
sistency analysis and criteria sheets to conform therewith.
Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
17
l7-L-28
Paul Opland
Change from NA to SRL
Part of Government Lots 7 and 8
Key: Little Torch
Mile Marker: 28
County Map No. 372
Richard Kerwick addressed the Board on behalf of the appli-
cant. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve the SRL designation pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b ii,iv, v. Roll call vote was
taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
MM
046
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
35
35-M-50
Katzen Burchers Partnership
Change from SR to DR or SC
Parts of Government Lots 1 and 2,
Tipton's Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 50
County Map No. 238
Susan Vernon, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Dee Millis, representing residents of 47th Street,
spoke in opposition. After lengthy discussion, motion was
made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of Staff to approve SC
designation and also direct Staff to pursue boundary deter-
mination. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
36S
36S-M-48
Planning Department
(David Ethridge)
Change from IS/SC to MI
Part of Government Lot 2
(S-9, T-66S, R-32E)
Key: Vaca
Mile Marker: 48
County Map No. 243
Franklin Greenman, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion
was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning
Commission and approve designation of MI pursuant to
9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, iv. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
37
37-M-50
Robert Stephens
Change from SC/IS to SC
Lots 1, 2, 3 and part of 4, Block 21
Lots 4, 5 and part of 6, Block 11
Day's Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 50
County Map No. 234
Fred Tittle, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Dr. Hagar spoke in opposition. Bob Ridings also
objected. Mr. Tittle rebutted. After discussion, motion
was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to continue this item to Monday, August 8,
in order to allow time for investigation of additional
facts regarding easements, etc. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
38
38-M-56
Jack Hurt
Change from DR to MU
Tract A, Amended Plat, Valhalla Island
Key: Crawl
Mile Marker: 56
County Map No. 219
MM
047
Buck DeVane, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded
by Commissioner Puto to continue this item to August 8th
because of the 4/5 Rule. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
42
42-M-60
Margarita Mitchell
Change from NA/SC/SR to URM
Part of Government Lot 1 (19-65-34)
Key: Grassy
Mile Marker: 60
County Map No. 212
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Department for denial. Roll call vote was unani-
mous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
38
38 -M-56
Jack Hurt
Change from DR to MU
Tract A, Amended Plat, Valhalla Island
Key: Crawl
Mile Marker: 56
County Map No. 219
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to reconsider the Board's previous
action inasmuch as Staff advised of an error and informed
the Board that this item did not in fact fall under the 4/5
Rule. Roll call vote was unanimous. Buck DeVane, attorney
for the applicant, addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Puto to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for
designation of MU pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, v.
Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
43
43-M-59
Jose and Angelo Torres
Change from IS to CFA/CFD
Lots 12-14 and reserved area,
Dorsett Subdivision Amended
Key: Grassy
Mile Marker: 59
County Map No. 213
Franklin Greenman, attorney representing the Dorsett
Subdivision Property Owners and Margarita Mitchell, spoke in
opposition of this application. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for
denial. Roll call vote was unanimous.
MM
n48
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Reques t:
Property Location:
44
44-M-57
J. Vitolo Construction Company
Change from SS/SR to DR
Grassy Key Subdivision except
Lot 12, Block 8
Key: Grassy
Mile Marker: 57
County Map No. 216
Lynn Kephart addressed the Board on behalf of the applicant.
John Whalton and Brian Schmitt spoke in opposition. Lynn
Kephart rebutted. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont
and seconded by Commissioner Puto to accept the recommen-
dation of the Planning Department for denial based on statu-
tory and consistency requirements. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
45
45-M-57
J. Vitolo Construction Company
Change from SR to SC
Part of Government Lot 2
Key: Grassy
Mile Marker: 57
County Map No. 216
Lynn Kephart addressed the Board on behalf of the applicant.
John Whalton spoke in opposition. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for
denial based on statutory and consistency requirements.
Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
46
46-M-57
J. Vitolo Construction Company
Change from SS/SR to IS
Grassy Key Beach Subdivision,
except Lot 12, Block 8
Key: Grassy
Mile Marker: 57
County Map No. 216
Lynn Kephart withdrew this application.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
48
48-M-76
Sarah Davis
Change from SR to UR
Tract A, Amended and Extended,
Matecumbe Ocean Bay Subdivision,
Section 1
Key: Lower Matecumbe
Mile Marker: 76
County Map No. 186
Fred Tittle, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded
by Commissioner Puto to continue this item to August 8th
because of the 4/5 Rule. Roll call vote was unanimous.
MM
049
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
49
49-M-75
Seraphin Manfredonia
Change from SR to IS
Matecumbe Ocean Bay Subdivision,
Lots 11-13, Block 3
Key: Lower Ma tecumbe
Mile Marker: 75
County Map No. 187
-
The President of the Lower Matecumbe Key Property Owners
Association addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission and
approve designation of IS pursuant to 9.5-5llCd)C4) and
(5)b iii, iv, v. Roll call vote was unanimous. Donald
Craig, Assistant County Administrator, directed that the
record reflect that the applicant was not present and had
not asked for a continuance.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned.
*
*
*
*
*
,....-