08/12/1988 Public Hearing
MM
n69
Public Hearing/Special Meeting
Board of County Commissioners
Friday, August l2, 1988
Key Colony Beach
A Special Meeting/Public Hearing of the Monroe
County Board of County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m.
on the above date at the Key Colony Beach City Hall in Key
Colony Beach. Present and answering to roll call were
Commissioner William Freeman, Commissioner Jerry Hernandez,
Jr., Commissioner Michael Puto, Commissioner John Stormont,
and Mayor Eugene Lytton. Also present were Danny L.
Kolhage, Clerk; Rob Wolfe, Assistant County Attorney; Donald
Craig, Assistant County Administrator - Growth Management
Division; members of the County Planning Staff; members of
the Press and Radio; and the general public.
Fred Tittle, attorney, briefly discussed Agenda
Item No. 97. There was no action taken.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
37
37-M-50
Robert Stephens
Change from SC/IS to SC
Lots 1, 2, 3 and part of 4, Block 2;
Lots 4, 5 and part of 6, Block 1,
Day's Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 50
County Map No. 234
Fred Tittle and David Day addressed the Board concerning the
requested change. Dr. Hager and Harold Deboy addressed the
Board in opposition to the requested change and presented
petitions objecting to the change. (These petitions were
not presented to the Clerk, but were given to the Planning
Staff.) After examination, Donald Craig, Assistant County
Administrator, advised that only two of the petitions con-
cerned affected property owners and that the 4/5 Rule did
not apply. Messrs. Craig and Tittle then discussed the
ownership of the property and indicated that the property
was now owned by Mr. Day and that Mr. Tittle was duly
authorized to represent Mr. Day in this proceeding. Motion
was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Hernandez to accept the recommendation of the Planning
Commission and approve designation of SC pursuant to
9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b ii, iv, v. Roll call vote was taken
with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
3
3-L-lO
palmhurst, Inc.
NA/SR to UR
Porpoise Point, Section 3
Key: Big Coppitt
Mile Marker: 10
County Map No. 547
MM
n70
Jim Mattson, attorney representing the applicant, addressed
the Board. Roger Lloyd, a resident in the area, opposed the
request. Mr. Craig advised the Board of his meeting with
the Navy concerning the AICUZ and their indication to him
that the property is on a list for acquisition by the Navy.
He modified the Staff report and recommended SR designation.
Mayor Lytton objected to any reference to the condition of
being placed on an acquisition list. After a brief con-
tinuation, Mr. Mattson indicated that the applicant was
willing to accept the SR designation as recommended by
Staff. Motion was made by Commissioner Hernandez and
seconded by Commissioner Puto to approve the Staff recommen-
dation and designate the entire property SR. Roll call vote
was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
18
l8-L-30
Big Pine United Methodist Church
SR to SC
Part of NE, 1/4 of NW, 1/4 of
26-66 S-29E
Key: Big Pine
Mile Marker: 30
County Map No. 343
John Evers, Vice President of the Trustees of the Big Pine
united Methodist Church, addressed the Board. Vern
Pokorski, President of the Big Pine Civic Association, and
Grace Mannillo of the Big Pine Civic Association and repre-
sentative of Joan Renyu, an adjacent property owner,
addressed the Board in opposition to the request. Motion
was made by Commissioner Hernandez and seconded by Mayor
Lytton to accept the Planning Commission's recommendation of
approval to SC pursuant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iv, v.
Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Motion failed for lack of a 4/5 vote. Reverend Smith
addressed the Board. Joan Renyu, adjacent property owner,
entered the meeting and advised the Board that she did
indeed oppose the request. Reverend Smith asked several
questions concerning his ability to proceed with the
construction of the Sunday School Addition.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
25
25-M-5l
James and patricia Aultman
Change from IS to SC
Part of Lot 1, Block 1,
Sea Crest Subdivision
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 51
County Map No. 234
Franklin Greenman, attorney for the applicants, addressed
the Board. Carl Causey, an adjacent property owner,
addressed the Board and opposed the request. Motion was
made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner
Stormont to accept the recommendation of the Planning
Department for denial. Roll call vote was taken with the
following results:
MM n 7 1
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
34PS
34PS-M-52
Leonard and Arlene Kasperowicz
Change from IS to SC
Sunny Isle Motel Site
Key: Marathon
Mile Marker: 51
County Map No. 231
Frank Greenman, representing the applicants, addressed the
Board. Edward Lisoski also addressed the Board concerning
this matter. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen-
dation of the Planning Department for denial. Roll call
vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
48
48-M-76
Sarah Davis
Change from SR to UR
Tract A, Amended and Extended,
Matecumbe Ocean Bay Subdivision,
Section 1
Key: Lower Matecumbe
Mile Marker: 76
County Map No. 186
Fred Tittle, attorney for the applicant, addressed the
Board. Lucy Ann Niebler, Millie McClenithan, and Michael
Bier of the Lower Matecumbe Key Association addressed the
Board and opposed the request. Mr. Tittle entered an objec-
tion for the record to the application of the 4/5 Rule in
accordance with the current Code. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for
denial. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
61
6l-U-82
Paul and Johanna Safer
Change from SR to UR
Part of Lot 12. Square 10,
Stratton's Subdivision
Key: Upper Matecumbe
Mile Marker: 82
County Map No. l77
MM
072
Mr. Craig represented Mr. Safer, who could not be present,
and requested a continuation of this item until the Text
Hearings. Motion was made by Mayor Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Stormont to continue this request to the Text
Hearings. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
73
73-U-89
Josephine Wood
Change from IS to SRL
Lot 6, Randall Adams Subdivision
Key: Plantation
Mile Marker: 88.8
County Map No. 162
Josephine Wood addressed the Board. Dennis Pawkett, Danny
Reich, and Mr. Dennisen of the Upper Keys Property OWners
Association opposed the request. Dagny Johnson of the Upper
Keys Citizens Association also opposed the request. Mr.
Craig advised that the Planning Department and DCA had
modified their recommendation and that SR would be accep-
table to both the County Staff and DCA. Motion was made by
Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Department for the
designation of SR. Roll call vote was taken with the
following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Motion failed for the lack of a 4/5 vote. Motion was made
by Commissioner Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to reconsider the Board's previous action. Roll
call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commissioner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Motion carried. Motion was then made by Commissioner
Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the
recommendation of the Planning Commission for the designa-
tion of SRL, puruant to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b ii, iv. Roll
call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman
Commisisoner Hernandez
Commissioner Puto
Commissioner Stormont
Mayor Lytton
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Motion carried.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
82
82-U-92
Florida Rock & Sand Co., Inc.
Change from SC to I
Lot 6 of Government Lot 1 and 2
Key: Largo
Mile Marker: 92.5 Oceanside
County Map No. 151
MM n 7 3
Fred Tittle, attorney for the applicants, and Steve Toreci
of Florida Rock & Sand Co., Inc. addressed the Board. The
following persons spoke in opposition: Fred T. Dick; Joe
Kimball read a letter from the Blue Waters Property Owners
Association opposing the request; Michael Carey; Robert
Siebeck; Wayne Becker; Liz Larsen; Bill Skulthorpe of the
Upper Keys Citizens Association; and Dagny Johnson. Mrs.
Johnson submitted several documents for the record. Messrs.
Tittle and Toreci then rebutted the statements of the oppo-
nents. Mr. Craig addressed the Board and recommended denial
of the requested change to I and that the Staff be directed
to clarify the light industrial use possible in SC, in par-
ticular the 2 acre maximum acreage requirement, buffering,
hours of operation, etc. Motion was made by Commissioner
Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the
request per Staff recommendation and directing Staff to pro-
cess a Text Amendment in the current Six Months' Review
which would delete Section 9.5-267 B8(A) relative to light
industrial use in Suburban Commercial areas. Roll call vote
was unanimous. Mr. Tittle proffered an objection for the
record concerning the assurance by the Planning Director to
the effect that he has the ultimate power to cause a Text
Change without reference to DCA. He further proffered an
objection based upon the fact that the Commission has left
the applicant in the position of being a non-conforming use
and without any opinion from the County Attorney as to
whether or not, if the batching plant was destroyed, it
could be rebuilt; and, further, that he nor his client could
rely upon the statement by the Planning Director indicating
that the problem would be solved by any proposed Text
Amendment.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
94
94-U-l04
Madelon Ravlin, J. E. Ravlin,
Roxanne Hart
Change from IS to SC
Lots 1-25, Block 7, Largo Sound
Village
Key: Largo
Mile Marker: 104
County Map No. III
Request:
Property Location:
Jim Hendrick, attorney representing the applicants,
addressed the Board and read a Resolution from the Largo
Sound Village Property OWners Association supporting the
request. Nancy Rahbine and Dagny Johnson opposed the
request. Mr. Hendrick rebutted the statements of the
speakers. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to approve the Planning
Department's recommendation for denial. Roll call vote was
unanimous.
Agenda Item
File No.
Applicant:
Request:
Property Location:
97
97-U-98
David Russell
Change from SR to SC
Part of Tract 1 and Tract lA,
Mandalay Subdivision
Key: Largo
Mile Marker: 97.4 Oceanside
County Map No. 139
Fred Tittle, attorney for the applicant, withddrew that part
of the application pertaining to Part of Tract 1. Myron
MM
n74
Berson addressed the Board and indicated no objection to the
request on the remaining parcel which is Tract lA. Motion
was made by Commissioner Hernandez and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission for approval of Tract lA to SC pursuant
to 9.5-5ll(d)(4) and (5)b iii, iv, v, vi. Roll call vote
was unanimous.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned.
*
*
*
*
*