08/28/1987 Public Hearing Special
JJ 078
Public Hearing/Special Meeting
Board of County Commissioners
Friday, August 28, 1987
Key Colony Beach
I
A Special Meeting/Public Hearing of the Board of
County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m. on the above date
at City Hall in Key Colony Beach. Present and answering to
roll call were Commissioner William Freeman, Commissioner
Eugene Lytton, Commissioner Michael Puto, Commissioner John
Stormont, and Mayor Jerry Hernandez, Jr. Also present were
Rosalie L. Connolly, Deputy Clerk; Michael Halpern, Special
Counsel; Dorr Fox, Land Use Planning Coordinator; Paula
"Jennie" Luxton, Planning Technican; George Garrett,
Environmental Resources Coordinator; Bill Hunt, County
Biologist; members of the Press and Radio; and the general
public.
Amendment 120
Brian and Wendy Sullivan; IS to SC; Lot 2,
Block 1, Cudjoe Gardens, Cudjoe Key.
Linda Pierce, biologist, and Wendy Sullivan appeared before
the Board. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez, Jr. and
seconded by Commissioner Puto to approve IS to SC pursuant
to Section 13-101 5 (b)2. Roll call vote was taken with the
following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment 121
Calusa Trucking Co.; IS to SC; Lot 3, Block
15, Cudjoe Gardens 4th Addition, Cudjoe Key.
Tony Paterniti addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to
approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)4. Roll call
vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment 190
Jo Ann Kesson (Rick Bertran); DR to IS-D;
Blocks 1 and 2 except Block 1, Lots 9 and
10, Block 2, Lot 8, Knights Key village,
Marathon.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
JJ 079
Amendment t9l
Tropic South, Inc.1 NA to MU; Part of Boot
Key, Parcel Nos. 10538, 10530, 10535,
10537, 10534, 10536, S16, T66, R32,
Marathon.
...-.
Frank Greenman and Lynn Kephart addressed the Board. After
discussion with Special Counsel, the applicant requested a
continuance. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto 'and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to continue Amendment t9l
to the September 17th meeting in Key Colony Beach. Motion
carried unanimously.
Amendment t92A Wilson Shaw1 IS to URM1 Lot 6, Block 2,
Sombrero No.1.
Rosalie Shaw and Barbara Cavanaugh addressed the Board.
Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept Staff recommendation to deny
because applicant has failed to satisfy the burden required
by Chapter 13. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment t92B Lee & Mary Weir, Clair Baughman1 IS to URM1
Lot 10, Block 1 and Bay Bottom South and
adjoining Lot 10, Block 1, Sombrero No.2.
F. C. and Verna Bean; IS to URM1 Tract is,
Sombrero No.2. Wilbur F. and Verna Gamble1
IS to URM; Sec. 9/16 N 66209-37 Key Vaca,
Bay Bottom South of and adjoining Lot 10,
Block 1, Sombrero No.2. Nathan and Annie
Styron; IS to URM1 9/16 66 32 N 66209-30
Key Vaca, Bay Bottom South of Lot 10,
Sombrero No.2. Wilson Shaw1 IS to URM;
Lot 7, Block 1, Sombrero No.2.
.....
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment t93
Charles and Maria Diaz, Byron and Sheila
Hopkins, Keith Hopkins, Harold and Karen
Linden, Ivan and Hazel McCray, Anthony
DePiero, Walter Curry Thompson, Philip and
Arloa BUSS1 SR to URM1 Tipton's Subdivision,
Key Vaca.
Philip Buss addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to
accept recommendation of Staff to approve. Motion carried
unanimously.
Amendment t93A Fred Caldwel11 URM to MU; Part of Govern-
ment Lot 2, S9, T66, R32, and a tract of
bay bottom at Marathon, Key Vaca.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)5. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment t93B Joseph DeConda1 IS to IS-D1 Lot 6, Block 1,
Mead Subdivision, Marathon.
Frank Greenman addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Puto that
Mead Subdivision be declared IS-D under Errors and
Omissions. Motion carried unanimously.
JJ 080
Amendment 194
Nelson Perez; IS to IS-D; Part of Parcel
5-G, Lot 26, Sombrero Properties.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment 195
Prentice Ray~ IS to IS-D; Lot 34, Sombrero
Anglers Club S, Boot Key.
Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)5. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman
to direct Staff to develop an amendment during the next pro-
cess for the areas being considered IS-D. Motion carried
unanimously.
Amendment #96
Richard Frye~ SR to UR~ Part of Government
Lot 4, S2, T66, R32, Key Vaca.
Mrs. Frye addressed the Board. Motion was made by Mayor
Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to accept the
recommendation of the Planning Commission to approve pur-
suant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)5. Motion carried unani-
mously.
Amendment '97
James Aultman; SR to IS; Lot 16 and South
30 feet of Lot 17, Buttonwood Acres.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)5. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment #98
Jacqueline Perrin~ IS to SC~ Lot A, B, C,
D, Amended Plat, Sadowski Subdivision,
Marathon.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont
and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to direct Staff to
review Buttonwood Acres for inclusion as an IS district.
Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment #99
Leonard and Katherine McCulliss; IS to SC;
Lot 31 and North half of Lot 30, Buttonwood
Acres.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
JJ 081
Amendment 1100 Peter Edwards; SR to DR; Part of Government
Lot 2, 56, T66, R33, Key Vaca.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d) 5 3. Motion carried unanimously.
-- Amendment 1101 Wallie Carbough; URM to MU; Part of Govern-
ment Lot 2, S6, T66, R32, Key Vaca.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment 1102 Prentice Ray; URM to MU or MU-M; Lot 3,
Block 2, Stirrup Key Bight.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by
Commissioner Puto to accept recommendation of Staff to
approve MU. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment 1103 Margaret Krebs; URM to MU; Northwesterly
50 feet of Government Lot 2, S6, T66, R33,
Key Vaca.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning
Commission to approve as MU pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Motion carried unanimously.
.....
Amendment 1104 Prentice Ray; URM to MU or MU-M; Part of
Government Lot 2, S6, T66, R33, Key Vaca.
Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Staff to approve MU. Motion carried unanimously.
Amendment 1105 George and Gay Neth; IS to UC; Lots 1 and 2,
Block 2, Casa Blanca Subdivision, Marathon.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto to
accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to
approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)5. Roll call
vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton No
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment 1106 James and Billie Carpenter; None to URM;
West half tract of Edmonds Acreage,
Marathon.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning
Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)3.
Motion carried unanimously.
JJ 082
Amendment #107 Shirley Black; IS to SC; Lots 1 and 2,
Block 2, 1st Addition to Seacrest Sub-
division, Key Vaca.
Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to approve Lot 1 only as SC. Roll call
vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment #108 Antonio Marucci; IS to IS-D; Lots 18, 19,
21, 22, Fields Subdivision, Key Vaca.
Larry Erskine, attorney representing Mr. Marucci, addressed
the Board. James Millis, John Sherk, Joanne Anderson and
Barbara Sherk spoke in opposition to proposed Amendment
#108. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded
by Commissioner Freeman to deny because applicant has failed
to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13. Roll call
vote was unanimous.
Amendment #109 Claude Haliova; IS to SC; Tract "A", paraiso
Estates Subdivision, Marathon.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning Staff
to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)3. Roll call
vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment #110 Joan Stites; IS to SC; Part of SE Quarter
of SW Quarter, Sl, T66, R32, Key Vaca.
Larry Erskine, attorney representing the applicant,
addressed the Board. James Hendrick, attorney representing
a group of objectors, addressed the Board. Mr. Erskine
requested that their application be modified to request SR.
After discussion by Special Counsel, the Chair ruled that
the Board must consider Amendment #110 as requesting SC.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept Staff recommendation to deny
because applicant has failed to satisfy the burden required
by Chapter 13 and to have designation remain as IS. Roll
call vote was unanimous.
Amendment #111 Leonard Kasperowicz; IS to SC: Sunny Isle
Subdivision Motel Site, Marathon.
Frank Greenman and victor Sanctis addressed the Board.
Edward Lisoski voiced opposition to proposed Amendment #111.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by
Commissioner Lytton to accept recommendation of Staff to
deny because applicant has failed to satisfy the burden
JJ 083
required by Chapter 13. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment 1112 Mary Fincke and Larry Kling~ IS to SC~
Parts of Government Lot 3 beginning at
concrete monument marking easterly line
of Thompson Enterprises, Inc., Crawl Keys.
~
Larry Erskine addressed the Board. Motion was made'by Mayor
Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto to accept the
recommendation of the Planning Commission to approve pur-
suant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was taken
with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton No
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion carried.
Amendment 1116 Daniel Michie~ SR to UR~ Part of Lot 11,
Block 9, Coco Plum Beach, Fat Deer Key.
Daniel Michie addressed the Board. Motion was made by Mayor
Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto to approve the
request for UR. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
Commissioner Freeman No
Commissioner Lytton No
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont No
Mayor Hernandez Yes
Motion failed.
Amendment 1114 Victor and Frankie Demaras~ SR to SC; Part
of Government Lot 3, SS, T66, R33, Crawl
Key No.1.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner
Puto to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission
to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)S (b)3. Motion
carried unanimously.
Amendment 1115 M. B. Group, Inc.; SR to SC~ Part of land
in northeasterly part of Government Lot 3,
S5, T66, R33, Crawl Key.
Larry Erskine, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner
Puto to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission
to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)S (b)3. Motion
carried unanimously.
~-
Amendment 1121 Grace Gregor/Key Associates; SR to UR; Lots
60, 61, Block 21, Coco Plum Beach.
Frank Greenman, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner
Freeman to accept the recommendation of Staff to deny
because applicant has failed to satisfy the burden required
by Chapter 13. Roll call vote was taken with the following
results:
JJ 084
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont Yes
Mayor Hernandez No
Motion carried.
Amendment 1117 Joseph B. French; SR to IS-M; Blocks 16,
17, 18, 19, Coco Plum Subdivision.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment tl18 David Saville: SR to IS-M; Lot 6, Block 16,
Coco Plum Beach.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment 1119 John McCadden: SR to IS-M: Lot 3, Block 17,
Coco Plum Beach.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment 1120 Robert and Sue Palguda: SR to IS-M; Lots 9
and 10, Block 17, Coco Plum Beach.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment #122 Robert Watterson: SR to IS-M; Lot 11,
Block 17, Coco Plum Beach.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment 1123 John Bishop; SR to IS-M; Lot 5, Block 18,
Coco Plum Beach.
Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by
Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the
Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101
(d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous.
Amendment 1113 Harry B. Tracy; IS to MU; Lots 11 and llA,
Block B, Hawaiian Village, Crawl Keys.
Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by
Commissioner Stormont to accept the recommendation of Staff
to deny because applicant has failed to satisfy the burden
required by Chapter 13. Motion carried unanimously.
JJ 085
Amendment 1124 Stanford Bardwel11 SR to DR; Lots 1-5,
Block 20, Coco Plum Beach.
Frank Greenman addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to
accept the recommendation of Staff to deny because applicant
has failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13.
Roll call vote was taken wi th the following results':
-
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont Yes
Mayor Hernandez No
Motion carried.
Amendment 1125 Gottfried Heller1 SR to DR; Lots 62, 63,
Block 21, Coco Plum Beach.
Frank Greenman addressed the Board. Motion was made by
Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to
accept the recommendation of Staff to deny because applicant
has failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13.
Roll call vote was taken with the following results:
Commissioner Freeman Yes
Commissioner Lytton Yes
Commissioner Puto Yes
Commissioner Stormont Yes
Mayor Hernandez No
Motion carried.
-
After discussion, motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and
seconded by Commissioner Lytton to instruct Staff and attor-
neys to proceed with public notice that the September 11th
meeting will be moved to September 17th.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned.
*
*
*
*
*
-