Loading...
10/15/1987 Public Hearing Special KK 002 Public Hearing/Special Meeting Board of County Commissioners Thursday, October 15, 1987 Key Colony Beach A Special Meeting/Public Hearing of the Board of County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m. on the above date at the City Hall in Key Colony Beach. Present and answering to roll call were Commissioner William Freeman, Commissioner Michael Puto, Commissioner John Stormont, and Mayor Pro Tem Eugene Lytton. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk; Michael Halpern, Special Counsel; Donald Craig, Planning Director; Dorr Fox, Land Use Planning Coordinator; Paula "Jennie" Luxton, Planning Aide; George Garrett, Environmental Resources Coordinator; members of the Press and Radio; and the general public. Prior to the beginning of the meeting, Special Counsel Halpern discussed the purpose of the meeting and the criteria used for the requested Map Changes. Amendment # 91 Tropic South, Inc.; NA to MU; Part of Boot Key, Parcel Nos. 10538, 10530, 10535, 10537, 10534, 10536, S16, T66, R32, Marathon. Frank Greenman, attorney representing the applicant; Craig Germane, the owner; and Lynn Kephart, an environmental con- sultant, addressed the Board. Mayor Hernandez entered the meeting at 9:30 a.m. and assumed the Chair. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to designate the area ACCC with SS and that existing uses are to be considered conforming and with the approval of the interim regulations, Items A and B, pur- suant to Mr. Greenman's letter dated October 14, 1987 (See Attachment #1). Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment #155 Jules and Dorina Toupin; IS to SC; Part of Lot 2, Block 6, Stratton's Subdivision, Upper Matecumbe Key. Fred Tittle, attorney, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5, (b) 4 and 3. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion carried. Amendment .257 John Baiamonte; SR to MU; Part of Tract 1 of I Lot 4 of Model Land Company Plat, Sll, T6l, - R39, MM 103.9, Oceanside. John Baiamonte and Fred Castro addressed the Board. Nancy Rayburn, a neighbor, spoke in opposition. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seaonded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the request because the applicant failed to KK 003 satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13. Joe Clock discussed and opposed the requested change. Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment #160 Armer White Inc. and victor Posner; SR to SC; From dividing line between Sections 22 and 23, which also is the W line of Lot 1, according to the Plat of Government Lots 1, ~ ~ 2, 3 of S23, T63, R37, and further by metes and bounds, Windley Key. Nicholas Mulik, attorney representing the applicants, and Phil Green, architect, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Mayor Hernandez to approve the request to designate SC. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion carried. Amendment #161 Ronald Samter and Anna Chavoustie; SR to SC; Part of Governmetn Lot 3 and Bay Bottom in S23, T63, R37, Windley Key. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to approve the request to designate SC. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: -"""'- Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion carried. Amendment #162 Manreb, Inc. ; SR to SC; Part of Government Lot 3 in S23, T63, R37, Windley Key. Fred Tittle, attorney representing the applicant, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen~ dation of the Planning Commission to approve pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5, (b) 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion carried. - I Amendment #164 Frank Froehling; NA to SC; On the island I I known as Windley Key and more particularly described by metes and bounds. Jim Matson, attorney representing the applicant, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommen- dation of the Planning Commission to approve pursuant to KK 004 Section 13-101 (d)5, (b)3 and 4. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes - I Motion carried. I Amendment #167 James Flenner; IS to SC; Coral Shores Sub- division, a part of Tract A, Plantation Key. Jim Flenner addressed the Board. Karen Sunderland Stroebel spoke in opposition. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Lytton to deny the request because the applicant failed to satisfy the burden required by Section 13. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman No Commissioner Lytton No Commissioner Puto No Commissioner Stormont Yes Mayor Hernandez No Motion failed. Motion was then made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to approve the request to designate SC. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes - Commissioner Lytton No Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion failed for lack of a four-fifths vote. Amendment #168 Clayton and Joyce Whitehouse; SC to UC; Plantation Beach, Tract P, Plantation Key. Clayton and Joyce Whitehouse addressed the Board. Jeff Meyers, representing Arthur Burkhold, addressed the Board and opposed the request. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to deny because the applicant has failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13 of the Land Use Plan. Roll call vote was unani- mous. Amendment #169 Yogendra Patel; IS to SC; Lots 4, 5, 6, 7, Block 9, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. Yogendra Patel addressed the Board. Anna Jernigan, a neigh- bor, opposed the request. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of Staff to approve the request to designate - SC. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: \ Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner stormont No Mayor Hernandez Yes Motion carried. KK 005 Amendment #170 Robert Vaughn: SR to SC: Lot 16 and South half of Lot 15, Block 3, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. and Amendment #171 Robert Foley; SR to SC; Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 3, Plantation Beach Subdivision, Plantation Key. fII"'.' and Amendment #172 Diane Droney; SR to SC; Lots 15, 16, 17, 18, Block 2, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. and Amendment .173 Jean Anderson; SR to SC; Lots 19, 20, 21, Block 2, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. and Amendment #174 Monte Green; SR to SC; Lots 8-13, Block 2, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. and Amendment '175 Harry Palen; SR to SC; Lot 11, Block 3, Plantation Beach, Plantation Key. and Amendment #176 Robert Vaughn; SR to SC; Lots 8, 9, Block 3, Key Heights, Section 1, Plantation Key. and Amendment '177 Karl Beckmeyer/William Horton; SR to SC; ..,..,.-... NE'ly 300' of Lot 10, Block 3, Key Heights, Section 1, Plantation Key. and Amendment 1182 Fred Snowman; SR to SC; Beginning of Wily corner of Lot 14, Tropical Coral Reef Estates and further by metes and bounds, Plantation Key. and Amendment '183 Jay Hershoff; SR to SC; Lots 1-4, Block 2, Key Heights, Section 1, Lot 1, Tropical Reef Estates, Plantation Key. Fred Tittle and Karl Beckmeyer, attorneys representing the above applicants, addressed the Board. After discussion, the Board recessed momentarily so that the attorneys could consult with the Staff concerning the Staff's ACCC proposal. After a short recess, the Board reconvened and motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to adopt the Staff's proposed ACCC/SC designation for this area pursuant to their report dated October 9, 1987 (See Attachment #2). Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment #179 John and Carolyn Lozano; UR to SC; Parcel of - land being a portion of Lots 9 and 13 of I Randall Adams Subdivision, Plantation Key. Larry Erskine, attorney representing the applicants, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for approval to SC pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)4. Roll call vote was unanimous. " KK OO() ;~ Amendment 1180 Josephine Wood; IS to SR/SC; Lot 6, ~andall Adams Subdivision, Plantation Key. ~l ~ Fred Tittle, attorney representing the applicant, addtkssed the Board. Dennis Paquette, a neighbor, addressed the Board and opposed the request. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to approve SC 150 feet back from the highway and SR-L for the - rest pursuant to Section 13-101 (b)3 and 4. Roll call vote I was unanimous. \ Amendment 1181 Paul Geier; IS to SC; Lots 25, 26, Block 6, Indian Harbor, Plantation Key. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for approval of SC pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)3. Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment '186 Rolando and Maria Alfonso/Segundo and Alina Collada; IS-M to IS-D; Lot 9, Block 1, Indian Waterways, Plantation Key. Segundo Collada addressed the Board. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to approve the request to designate IS-D. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton No Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No Mayor Hernandez -- Yes Motion failed for lack of a four-fifths vote. Amendment #194 Robert A. wittey; IS to SC; E 100 feet of W 500 feet of a tract of land known as a portion of the Absolom Albury 11.90 AC lot, Plantation Key. Robert and Judy Wittey addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for approval to SC pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)3. Amendment #195 Mitchell Kulkulski; NA to SRi Part of Government Lot 1 of fractional S32, T62, R38. Sylvia Ann Godfrey addressed the Board and requested SR-L. Karl Beckmeyer, representing Tavernaero Airport Park, addressed the Board and opposed the request due to the glide path of the adjacent Tavernier Airport. John Ham, repre- senting Kahiki Harbor Property Owners Association, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Puto to designate SR-L. Roll call vote was unanimous. - Amendment #207 Florida Keys Marine Inc.; SC to SRi \ Beginning of NE corner of Tract AB" accord- ing to plat of Plantation Tropical Park and further described by metes and bounds, Plantation Key. Joe Roth addressed the Board concerning the request. Sara s-r~ , ~- \ KK 007 , t \ JohI~on opposed the request. Motion was made by - ...,_Comrtissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for approval to SR pursuant to Section 13-101 (d)5 (b)4. Roll call vote was taken with the following results: Commissioner Freeman Yes Commissioner Lytton Yes ,- Commissioner Puto Yes Commissioner Stormont No I Mayor Hernandez No Motion failed for lack of a four-fifths vote. Amendment #212 Nancy Eppes; SR to SC; NW-ly half of Lot 14 according to George McDonald Plat of Govern- ment Lot 2 and further described by metes and bounds all in S34 and 37, T62, R33, Key Largo. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the request because the appli- cant failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment #216 Valerio and Maria Equizabel; IS to IS-D; Lot 8, Block 9, Ocean Park Village. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the request because the appli- cant failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13. Motion carried unanimously. -- Amendment #219 Walter Harvey; IS to UR or IS-D; Lots 1-8 and 13-17, Square 8, Palma Sola Subdivision, Tavernier Bend Area. Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Puto to deny the request because the applicant failed to satisfy the burden required by Chapter 13. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment #224 James and Ida Welborn; IS to SC; Lots 7, 8, 9, Block 1, Seaside Subdivision, Key Largo. Motion was made by Mayor Hernandez and seconded by Commissioner Puto accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission for approval to SC pursuant to Section 13-101 (d) (b)1-6. Joe Hackney, owner of property in the area, questioned the Board's action. Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment #227 Robert Peterson; URM to UR; Plat of survey of Limegrove Estate property .53 acres of Bay Bottom and part of Tract 1, Key Largo. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by - Commissioner Lytton to designate SR-L. Joanna Waggle addressed the Board. Roll call vote was unanimous. Amendment 1230 Alan popp; URM to SRi Tract of land in a part of Government Lot 1, S13, T62S, R38E, Key Largo. Leonard Wolfe, attorney representing Alan Popp, addressed the Board and withdrew the application at the request of his client. KK 008 Amendment #233 Lenora Albury; URM to MU; Part of Lot 8, Island of Key Largo, S6, T62 R39. Motion was made by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the request because the appli- cant failed to satisfy the burden required by Section 13. Motion carried unanimously. The Board recessed. ~ * * * * * . The Board reconvened with Commissioners Freeman and Stormont and Mayor Pro Tem Lytton present. The Board discussed the proposal to correct six scrivener's errors submitted by Donald Craig, Director of Planning, as per memorandum to the Board dated October 9, 1987 (See Attachment 13). Concerning Item II, motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to indicate that the record should remain as it is since it reflects the' intent of the Board. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to approve Items #2 through #6. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment #6 Arthur and Betty Lujan; IS to SR, SR to SC; Parcel B, Part of Government Lot 2, Key Haven, Little Raccoon Key. The Staff addressed the Board and advised that they were in receipt of an amended survey that met the requirements stated by the Board at the previous meeting. Jack Phillips, -- Surveyor, addressed the Board concerning the survey. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to accept the revised survey and to ratify Parcel C as shown thereon as SC and Parcel B as SR, all according to that certain survey by Phillips & Trice Surveying, Inc. dated October 13, 1987, Project No. 10-87-577, Drawing No. L-285. Roll call vote was unanimous. Peter Bacle of the Key Haven Property Owners Association briefly addressed the Board. There being no further action, the meeting was adjourned. * * * * * -. l __ u..___ ..___~__~_ _n_ Arr IfICJlI1I ~ 1111 "'/ , Franklin D. Greenman Gulfside Village Shopping Center Attorney At Law 5800 Overseas Highway Suite 40 October 14, 1987 Marathon, Florida 33050 - (305) 743-2351 To the Board of County Commissioners Monroe County, Florida Re: Boot Key Application for ACC/MU . Attached is Tropic South, I nc . , presentation to the Board of County Commissioners outlining its request to designate Boot Key as an Area of Critical County Concern with a MIxed Use land use designation. This area is presently zoned Native Area. Tropic South has a long history of developmental plans for Boot Key that have been presented at County, State and local level going back to the 1950's. The present proposal incorporates the environmentally sensitive development, and meets the legitimate developmental expectations of the developer. The outline pre- sented he re in for Area of Critical County Concern attempts to limit the development under the ACC/MU designation to development appropriate for the area, and meet the environmental concerns to protect the island. Section 11-104 of the Monroe County Land Use Plan prevents any development under ACC designation beyond that of the land use district which it supersedes. Tropic South's proposal requires a finding by the Board of the ACC/MU designation and the elimination of the NA designation. The density allocation in the proposal is less than the MU designtion allows, ie. , no indutrial activity, and meets the environmental concerns of the area. It is our legal opinion that the County cannot give an area the ACC designation that would allow greater uses than the uses allowed under its original Land Use Designation, without granting it a Land Use change that incorporates the proposed uses. Our pro- posal requires that the NA designation be removed in order that development occur on the island. It is our request that the Board allow the following: 1 . Establish Boot Key as a Mixed Use A re a. 2. Accept the attached proposal as the criteria for development of Boot Key as an Area of Critical County Concern. We respectfully request your favorable eonsideration. /$/- /~Cfr. '7 Franklin D.Greenman . BOOT KEY AREA OF CRITICAL COUNTY CONCERN A. Boot Key Area of Critical County Concern is hereby established for that portion of Boot Key which is currently owned by Tropic-South, Inc., and comprises approximately 750 acres of Boot Key. (see attached map with area outlined in yellow). B. PURPOSE: The Boot Key Area of Critical' County Concern is established for the purpose of acknowledging Boot Key as having substantial capital improvement deficiencies, providing for Mixed Uses on the property but reduced densities than would otherwise be provided (by describing them in this section), providing significant redevelopment opportunities, and reconciling the reaso- nable investment backed development expectations of the landowner with the need of preserving the environment, adding to the quality of life and economic base in the middle keys, and relieving the County of on-going expen- ditures which primarily benefit the landowner. ~ C. REGULATIONS: The Boot Key Development plan shall be prepared in accordance with the following principles: l. THAT, 1,000 hotel rooms divided in several different locations within the development. 2. THAT, 500 marina boat slips will be developed on baybottom owned by the developer including all normal uses except dry boat storage and major repairs. 3. THAT, 190 "Affordable Multi-Family" units will be developed. 4. THAT, 90 "Affordable Single Family Attached" resi- dences will be developed. 5. THAT, 75 Single Family residences will be developed on 5 acre lots, in the mangroves, being connected to upland areas by a series of elevated woooden walkways which will provide plenty of air, light, sunlight, and all other normal local elements to the area. All resi- dential vertical construction will be elevated in the same manner in order to provide a successful living environment for both man and the natural habitat in which the new structures are imposed. 6. THAT, 200,000 square fee t of Commercial lease space will be developed along either side of the current road- ways (S-93l) on Boot Key. 7 . THAT, 300 Townhomes will be developed along either side of the roadways on Boot Key in conjunction with the Commercial Space as outlined above. The townhomes will interact with the commercial space and will be entered from the side facing opposite the road while the commer- cial establishments will be entered from the road side. 8. THAT, a cultural arts facility will be constructed for the use of both the performing and visual arts and for the benefit of the tourists and local residents. . 9. THAT, a marine study/exhibition facility will be constructed for the benefit of tourists and local residents. 10. THAT, a bird and animal study/exhibition facility will be constructed for the benefit of tourists and local residents. II. THAT, a parking garage will be constructed at the bridgehead where the County Dump existed in a size suf- ficient to handle the parking requirements of the deve- lopment except that the number of spaces required for boat slips shall be reduced to one per slip. 12. THAT, consideration will be given to placing the "MARC" facility on top of the parking garage. 13. THAT, the parking garage shall be built to act as a hurricane shelter in at least 50% of the space. 14. THAT, a Boot Key Harbor Association shall be deve- loped, in addition to is other duties, shall serve to provide security and p'olice protection in the Boot Key Harbor, assist the Monroe County Port Authority, dredge and clear the harbor on the south side of the channel, and shall be funded internally (not through tax dollars) by assessments on all of the property improvements placed on Boot Key as herein described. 15. THAT, the County of Monroe will abandon the bridge and roadways to the Boot Key Harbor Association, which will provide comparable access to all of its members, maintain the bridge an roadways up to normal County Standards, repair the bridge from its current condition up to County Standards, and provide access to all other non-members but property owners on Boot Key at their fair share cost. . 16. THAT, Tropic-South will work with the other land- owners on Boot Key to achieve a homogeneous development of the entire island. 17. THAT, a sewer treatment plant will be constructed to . .. ~'.-'''~.".-. .,.. ..". .-,.". . -','~'.."..--.,....,~. .... ,-..'.'~, .. handle all of the sewage of the development. 18. THAT, Lighthouses will be bu il t along the outer perimeter of the property to indicate channel boundaries along with containing restaurants, items 9 and 10 herein, plus, other small commercial activities. 19. THAT, No industrial usage what-so-ever, except those contained herein, or already ~xisting on Boot Key shall be permitted on the property. 20. THAT, the development may' be "'phased" and constructed over time on a basis which is economically sound for the developer. A development and construction sequence schedule will be a part of the final plan as proposed to and adopted by the County. D . APPLICABILITY: All development within the Boot Key Area of Critical County Concern shall comply with each and every provi- sion of these land development regulations. On or be fo re February 1 , 1988, a preliminary plan depicting all of the elements above shall be submitted to the County. If a plan is not submitted in that time, The County Planning Staff may submit a plan on behalf of the County and landowner for consideration and action by the County. \ " F1 tte-J .$8, EjlJ-;-~ ~ ~~~ . . . ---- ..-. -- , "' "~~ ~I .=.... ~ .... iF::!:';' C ...., .......~~..... ~ z j II 0 DJ 0 i'~ JI", .. iJ .,a. 11 "It =::J ~:s:. ... ~ ~ B . .' ;.' , -" '\ ; i]"- ~- .,- .. _......... n .. .. n ' \ n .. .. .. I '. J d \ i \ \' ,._n - .' ' ~ l!' ' ! ! \ i'. o III N · ; III' 1";1-; I ;.. ~ I!! I j ~ ~ I .t~.r~ ~f'"'"'1~..,.11 .. .. J III ~ I f'"'"'1L... un " i.~;; I I ~ .;1 · ~P2~' [) ~Hi H ,': I I". ..i,' " · t'_Oo II ~. . ! · I ~~ ~ '.. . I I i i~ ~ ... ;' ~ I. , I ,: 011 ~ - _II , I ;. J ~ jal:" t~:I Ui~ . II" '... .. -,~~.~"I . ...., $"~.''''.':''' ~! . 1.1 . ." ...... _.', ,.- . " ..- -" , .!: . . I ~ 'f ....... IWOI . 't ~' !' ~ _ ."".: !Il'o'Pr~==-. A3lI ~00lI :,,~3= -; ~J; l .,;1 1ll'. .,. . '!'IIII' ;' __.._". . .~:- . I . ..' 4.,.,. 41.W IY/~AJY .#' o? . Monroe County Department Staff Report Date: October 9, 1987 . Request: At the September 10, 1987 Board of County Commissioners meeting, the County Commission directed the Planning Department staff to develop interim regulations for a proposed Area of County Critical This Area of County Critical Concern would encompass the land between US Highway 1 and State Road 4-A on Plantation Key (see Figure 1) . Background: The site is currently designated suburban residential (SR) . The Area of Critical Concern designation was introduced by Commissioner John Stormont as an alternative to the requests for suburban commercial (SC) zoning by the applicants for Map Amendments 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 182 and 183. Primary concerns in this district are: - Access control to Highway U.S. 1 and Old State Road 4-A; - Preservation of existing community character; - Preservation of tropical hardwood hammock. The proposed interim regulations address these concerns through the establishment of special criteria for access, permitted uses and bufferyards. Interim Regulations: I. All existing uses and intensities legally established prior to the implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan are considered to be conforming. II. Land use category SC-1 is established with the following permitted uses: - Detached residential dwelling; - Low intensity commercial retail uses include all use which generate less than fifty automobile trips per 1000 gross square feet per day. - All uses permitted in the BU-1 zoning category of the zoning regulations in effect immediately prior to the implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. ~ . I I 1. Land use category SC-2 is established with the following permitted uses: - Detached residential dwellings; - Low and medium intensity commercial retail uses include all uses which generate less than 100 trips per 1000 gross square feet per day. All uses permitted in the BU-2 zoning category of the zoning regulations in effect immediately prior to the implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. IV. For the purposes of these interim regulations, land use district boundaries shall be those boundaries in existence prior to the effective date of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. Lots previously zoned BU-1 shall be designated SC-l. Lots previously zoned BU-2 shall be designated SC-2. V. In no event shall new curb cuts on U.s. Highway 1 be made more frequently than every two hundred (200) feet, including within two hundred (200) feet, of an existing curb cut. In no event shall new curb cuts on Old State Road 4-A be made more frequently than every one hundred (100) feet, including within every one hundred (100) feet of an existing curb cut. All development will be encouraged to utilize existing curb cuts where two or more adjoining properties can be adequately served. Any exception to this rule due to a physical hardship of the land or parcel with question shall be made in writing by the Director of the Planning Department. VI. For U.S. Highway 1 and Old State Road 4-A, bufferyards shall meet the SC district scenic corridor and major street buffer criteria; as determined in Section 9-1104 of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. VI!. Land use map amendments shall not be permitted in the Plantation Key Area of County Critical Concern while interim regulations are in effect. VIII. No structure within the Plantation Key Area of County . Critical Concern shall be permitted above 35 feet. IX. All signage shall conform to the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. X. Property owners within the Plantation Key ACCC shall be encouraged to participate in a Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) procedure to allow the Transfering of Commercial Development Rights and density (FAR allowance) for a Hardwood Hammock acreas to already developed and/or scarified sites within the Plantation Key ACCC. XI. All regulations of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan not in conflict with the above interim regulations shall apply in the Plantation Key Area of Critical Concern. XI I. During the time frame of the interim regulations, the County shall determine and improve any cross-access roads between Old State Road 4-A and U. S . Highway 1 to county standards. County standards, as applied, shall allow interior lot access to U.s. Highway 1 via such cross access roads. Cross access roads shall meet curb cut access standards for U.s. Highway 1 as stated above. 3: "1J ." 0 r- - Q Z ~ c: :a z :a 0 ; m m ~ -A .. c: 0 - ~ I 0 0 z . c: z ~ -4 m i eo( eo( i "1J ~ ~ r- :a ~ m Z ~ Z 0 "" - n Z - I N G') 0 . :a c: C I - N m -4 . "1J - . ~ 0 c: I ~ N ::D I -4 r- ." "" 3: 0 0 I N m 0 z Z -4 0 m ::D Z IE] :~/) - /, - -~ - \~ ~ I ... ..~ . CD ..... 1\, , \ 0 \ - \ ,.\ VI "1' VI - 0 \::::=,1 -I ... \ l \ 0 - y I - \ (/) - n n \ . .. \ . - 0 0 c ::::s - '< 0 0 ::::s n . ... ::::s 7 ,~ . . . APPENDIX . Plantation Key Area of County Critical Concern The plantation Key Area of County critical Concern is delineated as that area between U. s. #1 and Old State Road 4A, beginning at the Woods Avenue Extension and continuing south to the southern end of Block 4 of Plantation Beach subdivision. The area is characterized, on its northern end, by undeveloped hammock, with scattered single family residences in existence when Old State Road 4A was the main artery through the Keys. Prior zoning for that area was BU-1, or light business utilization. On the southern end, commercial development has taken place within the context of former BU-2 zoning (medium office/shop utilization), and is in the process of developing further. Properties on the other side of Old state Road 4A are estate residential in character (many of the estate owners own extended parcels across Old State Road 4A in the northern portion). Character across current U.S. #1 is mixed, with light business, residential and governmental in the northern part, with "mom and pop" motels, one condominium, residential subdivision and a few light businesses. Currently, the Florida Department of Transportation has let bids for the improvement of u.s. '1, along the total length of the plantation Area of County Critical Concern, which will widen traffic lanes as well as provide center turn lane provisions along the southern part of the area, which will fairly well dictate access to these properties by southbound traffic. The specific purposes of delineating and enacting the Plantation Key Area of County Critical Concern is to permit development under interim regulations, within the context of existing and previously permitted uses and intensities, while at the same time providing access control in conjunction with DOT design and construction plans. Secondarily, the area's being placed under Area of County Critical Concern provides mechanism for utilizing a blend of older land use regulations (specific levels of business zonings instead of intermixed permissions of use and intensities) with those newer performance standards embodied in the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. Thirdly, because of the northern area's character, preservation of scenic corridor buffering can be achieved, and preservation of property use characteristics on both sides of the Area throughout its length can be maintained. parcel ownership is characterized, on the northern end, by relatively large frontages' and depths averaging 120 feet. Further south, due to the subdivision context of the parcels, smaller frontages exist (from 50 to 100 feet), with approximately the same depth, between highways. However, ownership pattern is such that the vast majority of the parcels contain (under ownership) two (and upward) lots. (Attached) Ownership according to parcel ID number, lot number and owner are included in the proposal. prior zoning pattern, contrary to other Keys areas, is cohesive, with no intermixed character, in the prior BU-l, BU-2 and BU-3 categories, so that sharp delineations into new usage/intensity categories is relatively simple. (Attached) DOT improvements call for no center turn lane in the northern portion, primarily because of the curve configurations. This portion parallels the previously zoned BU-l area. Significant center-turn lanes will be created along what parallels the previous BU-2 zoned areas. (Attached) Existing uses are also depicted on attached documents, indicating ability of the area to handle additional units. At the minimum, the interim regulations listed below would permit utilization of properties under a mixture of "old" zoning philosophy, by creating specifically layered use in context of new' Comprehensive Land Use plan regulations; These regulations should be placed as the interim regulations, so that confirmation by the focal point planning process would lead to confirmation of them as the permanent regulations for the area. Due to the nature of the interim regulations, and the character of the area, little additional focal point planning would be required, prior to adoption of final land use map amendments. INTERIM REGULATIONS I. All existing uses and intensities lawful prior to the implementation of the.comprehensive Land Use Plan are considered not to be non-conforming. II. For the purposes of these interim regulations, land use category SCl shall be taken to mean low intensity commercial use at a minimum, and former BU-l intensity and use at a maximum, as modified by these regulations. For the purposes of these interim regulations, land use category SC-2 shall be taken to mean medium . intensity commercial use at a minimum and former BU-2 intensity and use at a maximum. . In SC-I and SC-2 areas, SR by-right and minor conditional permit shall continue as authorized, for residential uses only. III. For the purposes of these interim.regulations, district boundaries shall be those boundaries in existence prior to the effective date of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan, and in context of paragraph 2 of these regulations, with SC-l conforming to previous BU-l and SC-2 conforming to BU-2, except that such SC-l uses and intensities shall be also authorized in SC-2 districts. IV. Existing curb cuts are permitted to be utilized with the provision that access be provided from Old State Road 4A where no curb cut exists on US.l within 200 feet of the proposed use, in SC-l. Those areas overlayered as SC-2 shall be permitted existing curb cuts with the provision that undeveloped properties without existing curb cuts shall be required to utilize those existing curb cuts authorized, for adjoining properties, as common access. In no event shall new curb cuts be more frequently placed within the Area of County Critical Concern than within 200 feet of existing curb cuts. V. Bufferyards in SC-l and SC-2 shall be treated as SC bufferyards along major arterial highways on both sides of parcels fronting access roads. VI. No land use map amendments shall be permitted in the Plantation Key Area of County Critical Concern while interim regulations are in effect. VII. No structures within the Plantation Key Area of County Critical Concern shall be permitted above 35 feet, regardless of number of st9ries. VIII. All signage shall conform to the Comprehensive Land Use Plan. IX. All other regulations of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan not in conflict with the above interim regulations shall apply. X. During the time frame of the interim regulations, the County shall determine and improve any cross-access roads between Old State Road 4A and US#1 to county . standards so as to facilitate off-US#1 access to properties wit~in the ACCC. . . , \ ~ ,.~ ~-:> ~~ ..,. . . (;.'.~ I t::.. I ., 2~" 'u) ~ ~ " ~L .>, ' ~ () '" I .. .. . r ~ . \ . .. ..\ a.. 'So '. 1." " ,~ s.1t1:.- c.."..~ .. ......t..~ - J j rl , ei , . ;" r \ I I " -, \ "_....__ <\ :':~:';;:;""'-i --.- , i \ ...' ~~~, ~. ; , :t. 1",1..: f\. ~ . 1 i'l c, c,~~~~. )> .~r... ; ,.... ~,...,..., ":L ~ ,.'Y'- - ~ . . . .;~ . .' J: jd J.';;;-;" ~ . .' '\..'.t. . 11.1:-- ~~\ ~.. '-I'" ~ ~ ,""- .....-.-.i;i 1 . .. ~~i L .~ ''- . IJ I - ~~........ ...- J:. .'.. \.\. (-.._ t · '" ....~ -1.- . - -....., - -. ....c. ...."..,~:...:... ';..1 ,"~&II l1'" 0 . ,....~ ~,.. ~~:~ l'1 r ... 'r./'-".' ..' 0 .rn;-- ., .'V. :p.- I t 11:=r' " ~.... I! ,T .....01 r,...!d~ ;,' y-J:.. __.. _(''!l~'" .., I · tilM ( ~:.._- ;::.~ ~=.:---:..~:. -; ~,~;-;:; · 'J~ .. / . .'.-. .,-. // .. '1_';;' ...... ( .,'".t:"''''' , ""'. ~\; / // ., "..e!~ f \ : .' ~1, '. I'"' ""' !i I 0 C _ I 'Z ~ on ,. .. \:,nC>"o ,. ~ ( (:- r r .( " t . ) ~ c' l" ) "" ~ L/ " C', ,J: \ r I ~, . __ 1 .;>. .. ,. . r-~~; ~ I f ~ '" ' 1 I \ :n ,i i / ,;:.0:' - .' ~ . ,t. r - -- .. ,. . ! . , -I ' / .... ",j \ '-~'l -'~ ~u:;." . '---." ........A 0 " BlL JMCfIE / . '\ ~ __, ~.r: ((' \1; f~t~ ~rr-' · '1- - - i ~+ p \ -.:l ~. 1.' \. .:J . : F'UTUlIA , ~" ,,~ I .--r -- ~ . VAGI .,,~~ o~.. .., :c~~/ - ~~~ / ... "..... 1 ,. ..~' "2 --- -<' : // ~ t.-..! / .... , .' /....~ 6''''.~ . ;' .Y' /;,~.- /.. j I I ~,... _/ r .... -,- /' ,....-.., \ - , ',- 1 - .... . . .-- - -, " . ~" \~ '-'- ""I:': -- :- Iv \ L'" ' ~-~ ~ ',l.~ Ul ....- 0 7- - --{ J.J 0 ); ~::J . . ~ . . :) c q;_'4 1\J ,,~ '1; '..1.:1. I....... ,," 1- ^-- , ~ \'. (' ., , .~ .' \ i ~ , , 1 frl -(' :;~.,~ ~t.. Co tat. t. '-3( "t~ .. J "~.~ I ,,'TV'll ~ .~~. 'f.~'~', ~ , .", - ......., t. -.. -.,9<. ....',. .. '.~"". ~/ au...;..- V.'\, .'. ~_-=::- -.-~~;; ~.~~17:41. _. ..- '.,. ~--i::AH'W.. .,.... /. :. Y;; 'L....&I....._. eo ~ :.::, /....~_.;;;;I<...._.. ..('~ , l.-., .........~...., '6, - . _U'N4 ~ 't.-.. . ~! F.. M"'Ilc.u~ ~ t" ' ''''".."".... " · .~t J ~".~,.~... )> :. :....t -"'.. . )"..~. - J...~-~'n-P_ '. t h'l --...._--;<:- i 0' 'U:.-,c ~ t.!,... """'IU:-..Io' \:1'" .. .-' ':J)...... _:.: .."....It "1 0 !:.' i ~.J ...... . ..~~'r..... '-:J>" ' IJ ~ ------:::- '" .v. () cJI 1M~~tiL (-..-.. ., ~.'i,'r.!::' -'~.J:... -f .~.. ""i ";:.~'I :'!:;Iirni fl.;)]" ~ I t '.H;'. " "~." "'. .... .~. Sl.. . ,...e,. of !.'"::-- -- . 0 ...-..... r"'-' '" 1"4 T &&4, .....f.'H#I.~.C... ,< ---~ .,.... C 7 ! : """.2.M. t ""':'" -':...~-':': ::.'~-' - - -....r- ,Il. ~ I ~ i iJ( / ~ ,. . If / tEe. . ~: ~D . :~ fi . I )>_ . ~ I It r ,/ [- . / ') ;% ~. I "'" Q> -..,' / .,.~'S./-\ ("'\ ~ i .,,~ . Q, '. 1""\ ~ o~ 1 .. I 0 ,.,. ..~ '. , L l> < , a ;::;Jl.-rM:rE I.' I \' r'lr ~ r /~ - \' r" , 0 'ex ":t _ ,. f l'J ;. ;~- ~ '~+-- 7_-:.8 "" ~. f .: r t\' ;; (' . . . . . ; ~ (J) . -. .-.~.-...~---_..._._- - --_._--_. ..-- ..- - --.-...... -- . - ~ -- ---..--.----.-. ----- --.----- '--'- (J~~~ p- '- ,".._~~_~ .e,PL..~-.--q('~-~--~--____.___________ 3& ~o V' ~----- -~- . ._-.---,---- - -..-....:..-.----." .-------.---.., ----,--_.----- '113 ~ ~ - --~..- _._._~-_..... .-.------.- -----...__._._--~'----~------_.--_. ".- . --. -_._--~~__.~7_o.._ _____ __.~____.._______... ___ (,8 ~ ~ .-- ~ . .._. - "._. -.-..... -." - --,,- --- -----.-.- -_.~ ... - ,.-.------ . ----- 713 S7( 0 c...-- - -. - -. -. -'_._----~_._.._-- '--'-'-"'- ..--_.. ...-------..------.-- Y!J b"'O S cH,-=c.~ I C-b-.L -- .- . ...- _'n. ---._- "__n .------f-.~!-~--.. 98 ~lo - -_. -----_.-- ~-_. '.,. ._-.....- -------- ---._--- loe 6"2-0 t....-- .... . -_. ...__._..._--_._---_.__..~----------~_._._._-- -.. . ------- -_.---...-.- "-'-'-' ~- --- ---.. ----- (flEY2"7c- ~. s- 6~ 3~ 00925, OoooD 00 C'~-I()lWL .._~ "-'-'-------'-'.- .-.~.._._---- -_.~- ---~- t7~9Z3~ _~/~ _tb.(._~__.~. ._._~_~_ ._ /2E 7 Z 3? ~ 5~E; I'L. - . -. - t;- -lP~ ~ -- (lc--- ? 2- c.r)- co I 'c4i F c ~316~~(1 '" -. '- -4 _.. ~--c-.~. _.___ -- (2c-r2J.I2- .___lZjlv?::U- '__H'" ___..___ _.____ _.. /Jf IV 0 '7 . --._-- ..- - ....-----.--- --_.~--------------- .----- .-- 12; 92<;3 f3 c LL SLf __h' --. . - - --- .--...______h_.._ .----. _.__ (Z.~':rz.s7 jJEfWUJt;" t f\C~. J6{. ____.__~___..___ __......._.__________________________ . 4L!:1 ~c~ D iNltc . 4ttf/Ii- . . - -- "'. ---...--..------____________.____ __._ ______ 0.0(. C{1: c;1, -~ f\A. OOfJ _ _'__"___.. _ ____._ .... _________ ..___ F,4(f2.~S . - .-... ._- ._-- ---.-. .-.--.-------------- -----. cft,~~/ /H~ ~ .- ..- 0 --+ - - .,. -- . .-...-~--------.-. ____________.__..___ /Cfl4~ W~ -. ...-j.- ....-...---.--_.__h__. .H' .. I~ - .-.--..- -~...~-_. . -.' -.--.-_____F.._____._____ __.________ _.___ ___ (u~ ~. I ... _ ____..._...________.___ ____...._ _____... -. ( - ... . --. _.___________.__.4 ________ .___...._..__.__._ ___ 1) V ~~LL .. '.' .-- . -'t 40(-'=-~' ~:':':~r'~------~. r /L<.'F~ ~(.J ~ ~~ tt( .. /L/c.-o -~//JSrtL.. ..~__ ._ ~ I .3 I ?>~ Lt ( L~ 1)c,..;;r6 . -- . --'.' n ~ J -.-..~-....:-~.--...-----.. ____. $ -~ . --"-'. ------------- - ~---.__.- -.- I z.. - 00/"2. oc) Jd-..-, fjYc ..~..... ~ _n... _ ____ ~ - O(~( IY~Se7L., ~ - 0' ,"Ol.- ------""e/W~ ~~_ --. . .' ..- 00/1 ~o A4.J(2.,1."..... d-.'"t~_ Q z~ ' . f ~.~ '-) -c L,.' -( 10 I 00 i:j o L~ 0(2.. I (-(/Ill\- f.-; 7,' h,!(O J..(H2~' ;/oc! St\ ~ ~ '/ft"d- tt- cr 9().c (u l c.lttTL.~,k::; S I J~ ~ t'c-c S~ ( ~~ '6 7 7"" 5 ~ &. __iJ2, ~ a.J!l..... f..: ()~ r ') C;-OD r & d~ ~) u ~00 ~, ItC<A-~~ I ~ ~o-<' f2.<.~1 (~L-~ ./ '7 ?- c c tv.. ^ <- P f{ c.:-(l:> FV< I 8.--uA ~ / Lf ( 91-- ere; - 000 (0 C> L:'~Ul tv Sf LU'ft / l~ \l:4J.. ~ t-cT I 0'~-~L L1- I ~IC7~O 2 ~'iJ~~ (4~ ) ~ ) -, ~e:-c L 3 'f( ,,10 J "-& J c......~ 1(00 <-f <'lw ) g,o M-~~ J b Z'io ~'^-~, {~ '-7 Z", J S",7\ y~r "-' u ~-.,. ~ , '6 ~"O rl ~( 3 5.-1{ 1__ 070 'S~ ~ - 1..-' 1... I z-;;-o IC.~ rlA-So\1J !.JAc.../c- 2.---, g 70 5 ~-<..d:., 7-91'-'1^- 3 4l \ (i'L~ p~ ~ J <-f rID 5lltLocJ~ ~.~~ 5- ::: j ~t "LB., D~~ G '7 If 'fa SAe.:-.v pJI I ~- ?\D J ~ CL-t.,~<<", ltv-u..~ I 'l 9~() (..- . Q(:./' \-:' r- ei (0 q7cJ ~cL "---n -..F] -- ,- : :; i"2C ~ j"T Ldl (D { i)~fV'i'~jr-! t-: ~~--:r- (j) . . ,~. . ., I ;::, ,.. J ~ ~c. I "- ~ I ~ q,,: ~ () :'.. -L " ( ( 7 j{ CL Ib5<.'X.tA IES <-If LbrO o'COO 000 <- 3 '1j , l.f I L 7"0 - o~oooo j f\A ,J..u-J p~ G 'f1l..-7(c ) 7 Y \ 2. 7Z-O t' LfIL7?o ~ -p_~ tf 4- ( 2. 7'fo 10 4 I :,7>0 J fL-<-G.~J.~ 2b~ ~<&~~ 11 /2 L/ ( l 770 J<uf~ ~ ~ /111 If Z71't1l-(,--S~ I :, 4 ( 27 '" J /U...Q ~ ("C. (-{ c..f ( L 7'lJ I' '/'2.,0-0 J ~ I~ i7~ (6 4(1.-(/0 (j If{ 2-~ 2-0 I~ Y t t ~ 30 ""'-It 5 rc== l. ~f..,.JL.~ f~ t" ~ / 19 ~(tD'fO ;3 r~ I L/-- f z.. S -<;CJ Pc 7 t2. 'it J ...u..rl.L L 'f( ~)b~ J 5111--' o~ U:?) ~~ 3 qIL~7() '-f '-Hz ~'iD ~ ( ~ ~fo \ ;; Lt''j, ,J <::,'\...J~ G (.1~ 7 1(0 ) /: 'iLO '; cr~O ! - (.IL(C rh iL4.'1 \ Z. J!> tJ f2. tv (: -f1. ~ '- I J t lfc-b I i, 7(,0 I ~_ I I . '( 70 ) '_/ /' ',~ " ' c,. ,,-t ' ., /'-' <,' . , . (ji ---" . ~ ",-- u ( ~ cr? o. ? ELse ~/HJ I )1A.. .-::-fL ru:=- (\... 'f(~U()c\.5 (7 CIO J ,11 ' }) (L c }-' ~:.:y I 5'~ C{ I . ( Q 2.0 iT c.30 '2-<-~ /;' I ~ (~<f 0 ~.(~(..~c:... \r"'-<.~ Lv...:;! S~ ( 2-/ e 0) "" '----- ""_'~ r Y(~O~<Jj _/.I.- ~ l J (3J--v.--~ ~~ ... I'. / L '.L. ' / ~(~c)7D (j. Ci't;a cL <<-~I- loLl U (~ / \ OYC , ~ I(H) ftCL\...-1" ~ I ! -Z ~~ 110 1t.1 It TH 0~ G...~~ ~ j (t.-O ~OJ u"-_td,,~ o..cLr, '1 --, ~T) P L.L~~ (2.0 I" ~~J~'1~' D~ I \ / , 1~6 p~ I~ I . ) ~ ~ ,~c ~ H-01~ tt-t~~ 1\ I~-J / 'to '. Jfl ~(ba 1 t1tt f<..~ P~YL ~1z-1s-~ ( '5 1/)... /(- YI31JtJ JQOO~1., ~ ( (. 4 I )rzD ( ? fio ] tlYtv"04-..iJ:t.i/ ~~ I r ZC() / c. 2-1 i') t' rlttA )~ 2 4) ?,.. 1- <='j' Fz, (Ff I /{~;r 2. " "2- ~ .- J .2-'-10 ? S.'lit ( ~ u..:11){~'~ ((~ - (" )! ( if ,L 'L 2 2. \'C_ './ -; l..- z. - J .' ) ...,. J - - ._ ,.,. '- k < II, L c. ,<-<,-,-_ \ L~___ J ) Z ? c- I . C .~ ( . ( .~ iu .,-'.... ) L,-' -4.- L\._ f r-:- " .:.~c ') .; (' (5) L./ , I --' '1,,'<-0 I - \ ~ -,1 I J, r S \ l~-n.. (J (~ I . "I 0 _~ :( 3LO ')70 Lc !>WI-rt-) Oa~ (C I! .,'ic (L 3\1) .u. I G Lk:;:- i) 31......"'0 pL~ I (V,SI ) ,. ... I ' --J. · I ..\~ ~ .. ........-- 4' n~.\ I . /,~ ' - ,~~~ .~,,~ \~ ---\: ,~V^ j ~\~. · \ 't. I V>ln~ ~D.~t'1~'f. \.. -;m7'""lm _ · .1;" · - . " · '-- f t. 3,n..u T' -,-, · .~. \ ..., ,...,. , _, ,'F.~ · - I -I t~" -~-~ '.- ..-- J ~. ' ~ ~ ':I ~ · " Z'" . _I ; .0( '" - J\ " O! ~ j :r'3 ~ ra: \ ~ ' " ~ ~ u X .; ." ' t .. 00 ..z. '<U , . v c::" -- C'l '- I -- v v'. .... , ' . ~ . ~ / .'" -- _/ ~ "'J. .,." . · ~'...., ... fJl' . lNi.'....... .. I ' {; .. , . .~ AN'I_',.& o .J o ..' -~ ~ ~ t" .-- - ~ ~ ~ . . ~~t~~;~-' . ... --. -.,' "- . _ _~~. ,,;:1....~,.-.- - toO .~ . .. .....,., " ~t I _....{':~....i,;;.' ~:.. ~~ ____ ...w......)., c*. ~L~ . _ /. .~~~.!_...o: n''h . ..=-ro-i'-"" . .. , hl t. III llJ C'C ~ O.l..l.nH ...... -:-L.. ~ ~.. "'",,", .. <l. 'U C\I "~~ ~~~ . ......"" '1"'''.'1''0," L.L. ell ~ I.",... _ 0 n. IAl _.~~..... lot a: ....... ... ... -' , <( ~ .& n: ~ , I'. ~ \' - . I ,. ... . .. .. . -- .. . .. .. ,. ~.. , . @: .. . . ! - . - ... , , I / .....j . / I I I VIJnLn.:! 31 JJ f"U... 1f3 ~ .. ., ~ .. . . "'.. . . J I. :- ~ I ,~ ' , f .. Co ~ .. · r I · i /' .. ..... ..... I. .....4. ~o .,~ >>.~. .r, . . ~'''.'_J'~'~'t!..J ,. _0., ____ . __ 'i,.' . ':,....... ....;:'f;:,.~_ ., -----.! ~ :....:-.~...,.. .- : . -~ .~'.'.r I ~.....,...- ... ~~,. ..... ~... I H,,,_...,.c ,... 4' ~ .. . .... '"'.. f4~ '. · '" ... l, ............ !,;., .. '.. \'" '" ,,>>;:../.. ...~. . -~" . . ..,....l' ... - .. '- ........ ~ ",\'.,"'... k ., :::t-/" :: . .... . ,.~ ..... lf~ '- .:.'i- ~". "I. ~,... ~ .. .. . . "". ""..~. . .......... , ..",... '.:~~....... . 't. ~ ...... ,"*.... ,. ',f <t!..,....; f'~~~ ." '7/ .M..!.,; . .... -, ,,~- '-'- ,Y J ' ~ ... "".".1 ( , ...~ 1. .--.~.. : -;.-~ ~-. _l-~j . __ #_ ~.. ./1It . .:. ,. -1 . ' '" I" ~ ~.. L.fI'l ~ y~ ~ \0\ \)0- ~ \ol 1t. .J.... 1) ~O"'W /. I "-... ~-4 f 4. to, (:.' ~ vl.' t;..., -z. "5., .~ ~ ; . '" ,~ . . ~ = >. . , oJ ~ . . . ~ ....'It.. s.r.1:.. ~\.",,:, .f: ....~t.rl. j ~ :;-!ltJ ~ ,~ ,.~ C-~I., ~ ( >" ,~ ...... . (, ..,. . , . . ~ .~_ <\J\ ~.1 ..-t.ll\. . . . ,,,", '" ' , ' ....., , , I · ", _ . . ,j . , _. ,'. ;:'ll'. ' ., I , \ . . \ - . . ~ I " ... '.. () ';~ \ u. q,. \~\ \~~~ ,. \ ... ~ . . ' 'I.a. ,: l : "'- ) .:t:h Q ~ \ ~~::~.! ;" "-- ~ .. ..f" . "\ ..:..~ 0 ' .- '- ~ ~ ",/ ( f) III h ~ ~ ( .) III 1. III 1LJ ;:- ... -I ~~ ~"l "'CO ~) .\. U -I ~ ~ i).. .:.:'.... ..) .... '" r-:::. '. Z; ."., <2 · ::..::. ...."" ~>>V1t/ '>- lu 'V' ...... .- , Z. I -~:: 0 . I ....... - .3N/7 I "" t7Uw ~_~' '''11 '. . ..... ~... .., ...:.. :'" If) ~ , .................~ ~.. I ....~~. :c '. CJ ILl :r: >- lLl . .... ..~.; V' '- ...... .-~~ .,- .-- /~ / .- f ~ .~.. ~~~ ~~~ '\", \)~ (,0 ~ 0((' \ \) ~~ o~ ~o ~ \.- , ~--- ..::...- ..;.;.- J. ... .-,. . .. t. I~~; ". :',_.: , IJ ~ ,.....-.. i .:. .., Tn _ t ... : ~.:..:: ~ ..... : : ,-:. ; ~ ' .. ::::..:":~':: .....'.... .. . .-'- -' : L - 0).' . . Rf.J-I " ... . . t> . ~ ',~" . ii:t "10: ~ ....~ ~""'" ", J~_ . ............. ~/. .... '\. ~'\.. -, ", " . ...~~.; , ,.~,: , ... / , .a . -- ~ ~ ~ ::> 1 ... - & ~~ ~ ~All..J . ~ - Ii" " .. Ii.. I!. , II I I .. .: II · .- l Ill!!... !, II ! ! J;- I : ~ I I. .~! = I ! ~ !::; ~ i : I : I ~ it g ,:! e ~ J J - i: :: J !\ g I. @I,~ ''''I~ Al 'I I, ':a oJ 0 n" II, · Ii i"..t '/ I, ~ 0:' lit :-I i i": I IE I, II I I ... I!t ..- 'I II 00 · .. III I: ....: e ~ ~!I II en :' f i i~= .eJ II:!I~~ .. ~~ '-!I:I N II I 9E', I"~.E .. a::: II I' ,I I! tiu a ~~ i: ': ': ~~cc .~ I'" ~ ~ liE I: i: :'!~ ~ Hn I~IIIIII IIi . ....;;;l 0' I' ItlJ , I ~..l .. .. ... =:=: 1:::1.......... ~l!l !I ': ,0 I~ I !!jr II!I -Iii i ~I:::~ -....-................ ~ " I I, I~ lit: Ili If S -::a III ~ Q=~ -.._-- ~! ii :i ~l I~ ...". II! ..f!lMli '...~s~Sol~eiillu !, 'I J pi I~ j....c 12 ~ ~. ~~ji~ .. ! I : I ~: ': _, ..:I.........~ ,I II , I ~ .. ,I I' I 0 - II I' , . ; ' " I . I II I .' : I: I .' I Roo II . _,,/ . I ~/: .- )l1111'\3015.1i ;.... I '3A V sa004\ ~ lllWII301S .Ii )I~lOtS .Ii .-......,. ~: , . ('..... , I .Zzl I ... . I II \: :: I :1 II ;1 :: ~!: :: t' a::: II II I . II = ~ t I: " ~ RC1 · · '-.j':: I ~ ~ i 8 ii $ I II iii ! : 'f1 - II II 3 . II B G =~!: I, . ~ .. I, II r:~ ~ i ;1 II ~ I_ B ~ .; i~ Ii . fI! t' ,I ~ i ~I ... I. , !~!i ~ I i ,I- i I P ~ I ,.-1 ill [3 [3 il ~; ': 11- I ,I 01 I ...~_ . ,I II ltl , . !::: I7l , II~I" I GJ EJ !r II N I , :I Ir.rt II II , --'-1 ,i ---~ I. I ~ \ \ ~~~ , \ ~ Q.,G.:C4r . ~ ~ , , I , \ . .. ~~ \ : . ...,....,. , , +\ia--e,S-.1. 41 - , < c i c ;;. I : I 0 . N - ... :I CL iZ . j -J C ~ ~ ~ is . ii .. . ~ ~ ~ i:) ~ ~~ l . , ~\. ~c.- <.JJ OO+..Z .Y lS ]NI1 HJlV" , W.., ..,J) '~ "*'\ , '\ ~ 00 + 09Z 'ns 3NI1 H:UytIt j J ... ~ . . ~ i ~~~~ j -0! :]].,2NI!'!S..... ~' J t~ i~~ ,. '~I - 2 ~ _ I.. I b ~ ~ I,,~ i N I I~ I . I~~ j d~ B ~a: - ~ ~* . ", ;ffiL.. ~ A . It /..' ','@~ . I \~; . . 'v' I , .--, , . I , I <__ .n , . I/') , , N I I /r:-r. 1 ~!~!: I+~I;~; . -,. -- . ! I -Ul. ! I I ~~~ ! I' ~~~ . ~ H-' ! ,lr: i . . . I J I ...J I ! .... u r 0 o _ 'III ~ i~ Oll i~ ... \ ~ . '" N ~. I ' ~ :1-:-1: " I :'~";-L>< I,,!::. 0',,",,0 .w .. : ' . --.Jlkrgj~ ~./~;t . ~)( . ~ a~ . ':~. /jJ _.. e I ~ - . ~I _..~ 8. ~ ~~' :~~ '> ....Il ! .~: j - \ 00+0:. 'YU H:>J.\fW . - .\~ 0" ~~~ ...... . :5 H:>.L'f" ! .. I ... u W ~ ~ --~...., r1 I~I~~ ~~I+i ~I , . '~I I I . I l:I::: ~ I u "'~. '-___Jl::JLJ C '" III . ;:j I I . I . 0 ... .---------? I~ ~ ..;.... jl8 @ - . a hr..t ~ fT: ~c .1 ' ~.>C v oJ 0 ~.. i:l I ... I . I I "-- -- (-- , I I :rl.t ~ =1' ~~ . I . )( u 0"'8.. a:...", It) N N . , ~ . ^ e. J rr~: 1-7 I W ~ e 'I.. -9 H:lllfW E ,. . r~ 00 "'li~Z "US 3NI1 H:>llfW 1'1 ... I ~ I .: I !If ..... '"" , II ' ..... ~,' ~~ '1'\ .- ~I / . , I . i~l..t i 0 ... I .... u ... ~ I I I I ~ I~ . - - .!.ja c ... ,I .~ ~~ !; I I I I N ~,.. m;- ~ .-. .. ~I~+)C I ; rlj:~:lt I ";rt · 'Ii c ... ~ - )C &. .... !:.. ~)l; c_ ~~ C:l c!: u I~: O~ ~... Igj . . t ~ It W:1r , . ~~.. i I .. c t. I . . -. I . , I I , I I r s: t" ~ t ~S'" ~ 0>" 1If_ l::i""C t;i ~..J .. . E~Z.... ... C ... 0 . - ..J I a ~u ~:;;i5~...ox~~ !~ ~~~ ~ ~ I 5: ~...J:) ~8 2. I ~i. ~~~ ~" I- ..... ..~ ~""~W_-'~:; ~I~ Sil g~~ u 01 ~ ~ d ~ _ . z . '" . N H ::>1 \flI~ ~ L JI' E l II:~ - I~~ E II: 9: N en I ~ ., 0... III ~~ ....- III ~. ! - 00 g~ ~ ol~ =i ~ . ~ .... ~- - ~ I ~-':5 I ~:!& E ..Jll. i5~ ~ ~ ~ :. .... ~ 0 ii..: w II: 2i ~ :, - ~ i II Q R . . ~ <U . - . 0 0_0 eE.... . i II C - . ! -- - I I .O^,. I I I ~~ '. ~ 4' . II I ~ I I ,/ . . on . ~ ~ 00 + .81 '\fl.S I . ; IIrr A CH 1fI' AJ .,.. J1-a BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OK~V~~: ~R~~'~04~E MA YOR Jerry Hernandez, District 1 Mayor Pro tem Gene Lytton, District 2 Wm. Billy Freeman, District 3 (305) 294.4641 Mike Puto, District 4 John Stormont, District 5 M E M 0 RAN DUM ---------- To: Board of count~~ioners From: Donald Craig ~ Director of Plan . g' . RE: Text Amendments - scrivener's errors Date: October 9, 1987 Please find in the attached list of six scrivener's errors which should be corrected be~ore the proposed text amendments to the Florida Keys Comprehensive Plan and Land Development Regulations are transmitted to the Department of Community Affairs. The errors include omissions, mistakes in citations, and unclear intentions. Those omissions and mistaken citations are underlined or explained. It would be appropriate for the Board to indicate their intended meaning and so instruct staff to make the corrections before transmittal of these amendments. Minutes of July 23, 1987 1. Junendment #76; 9-307; Page 99 In all other amendments referring to off-shore islands or spoil islands the phrase "in Key West Channel" is omitted. Was it the intention of the Board of County Commissioners to include it in this amendment? Minutes of July 27, 1987 2 . Amendment #6; 3-101C-5; Page 11 Should read: . . . park, solid waste, library, public buildings and emergency servics, . . . 3. Amendment #148; 13-101D3a (i) ; Page 300 States section 5-501b be revised; should be section 5-105B. 4. Amendment #167 - reads ...may be issued permitted without... should read ...may be issued permits without . . . Minutes of July 30, 1987 5. Amendment #70; 9-305A; Page 157 Add cross-reference to Section 9-305; should be add cross- reference to Section 9-304. 6. Amendment #107; 9-1001; Page 219 Reads to upgrade landscaping standard for Sparsely Settled district from Class A to Class C.~Should it be ...upgrade landscaping standard f~sparSelY Settled district from Class C to Class A?~ I 4,~ --. ---....- ..~--------- - .-- -------- ------_.- -- .---- --.- \ "Notwithstanding the foregoing, the replacement \ within six months of removal of a mobile home or recreational vehicle lawfully existing on the effective date of the Plan shall only be I required to comply with the County's regulations in effect prior to the effective date of the I Plan. " Amendment 154: 9-112; Page 99 Modify purpose statement of Off-Shore Island District: "The purpose of this district is to establish areas that are not connected to u.s. 1 as protected areas, while permitting low intensity residential uses and campground spaces in upland areas that can be served by cisterns, generators and other self-contained facilities." Amendment 166: 9-302; Page 155 Amend open space ratio regarding Off Shore Island from .95 to .90 Amendment *76; 9-307: Page 161 Under category "off-shore island", add a sub-category "campgrounds on spoil island in Key West Channel" with an allocated density of 5.0 campground spaces per acre and a maximum net density of 25 campground spaces per acre. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment 159: 9-206B; Page 115 Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to accept the Planning Commission's recommendation that Institutional and Institutional Residential be added to 9-206C2 and to add a new minor con- ditional use to the SubUrban Residential District: I "5. Churches, provided that: i a. the parcel proposed for development I is separated from any established residential use by a Class C I bufferyard: and b. access to U.S. 1 is by way of: i. an existing curb cut; ii. a signalized intersection; or iii. a curb cut that is separated from any other curb cut on the same side of U.s. 1 by at least 400 feet." I Motion carried unanimously. I I Amendment '60; 9-208C2b: Page 120 Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to deny the proposed Amendment 460 per Staff recommendation. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment 174: 9-306: Page 160 Motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to add a new subsection D for employee I housing as follows: "D. Unless the provisions of Section 9-306 C above are elected, any hotel of more than 50 units shall provide one employee housing unit for each 20 hotel units or fraction thereof, for use of or rental to employees I i I i II -.. II 159 -.------- Public Hearing/Special Meeting . Board of County Commissioners Monday, July 27, 1987 Key Colony Beach A Public Hearing/Special Meeting of the Monroe County Board of County Commissioners convened at 9:00 a.m. on the above date in the Key Colony Beach City Hall. Present and answering to roll call were Commissioner William Freeman, Commissioner Michael Puto, Commissioner John Stormont, and Mayor Pro Tem Eugene Lytton. Absent from the meeting was Mayor Jerry Hernandez, Jr. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk, Rob Wolfe, Assistant County Attorney; Tom Brown, County Administrator, Charles Pattison and Planning Staff, members of the Press and Radio; and the general public. Motion was made by commdssioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to approve the following actions by unanimous consent: Amendment '6: 3-10lC-5f Page 11 Accept the recommendat on of the Planning Commission to amend the definition of capital improvement as follows: Capital Improvement means the planning of, engineering for, acquisition of land or equipment, and the construction of improvements including but not limited to road, park, solid waste, library, public and emergency services, and police ~. facilities, but does not include routine maintenance. Amendment '12: 3-101 M-l Deny proposed Amendment '12. Amendment '121B7 l2-l0l0(d)7 Page 273 Deny proposed Amendment '12lB. Amendment ,12lC7 l2-l0l0(d)7 Page 273 Accept th& recommendation of the Planning Commission and insert the following sentence in Section l2-101D(d) before .standard applicable practices.... Needed improvements shall be determined through the end of a twenty-year time horizon beginning with the year the project is .built out. or completed. Amendment '121D7 12-101Gl, Page 275 Deny proposed Amendment '1210. Amendment '121E, 12-101I(3}a, Page 277 Accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission to insert the following at the beginning of Section 12-10lI(3)a: .The funds collected by reason of the establishment of the Fair Share Transportation Fee shall be used solely for the purpose of acquisition, expansion and development of the major road network system determined to be needed to serve new develop- ment, including, but not limited to: --...- ." II 163 ~ .-. = -------~ .---- -= , ,\;1' "LT"O' #94; 9-514C, D,.E; Page 177 ,\ .... ".;coaunendation of planning commission to add "the - ,." ."cks Department or the County Engineer" and delete ::. .. :'t(.t;)[ of planning". ~m~n~80n~ 195; 9-517; Page 178 _' -~;~commendation of Planning commission to add: I ~.. .at locations determined by the I :' l:HJ.ning Commission or the Public Works _ I ~irector and/or County Engineer." I ":'I,--;_:~!~_l~~ 1147; 13-101CJ Page 307 .;: -'-'\-:~t. recommendation of planning commission to amend sec- ," ',0 read: Except as provided in this section, proposed ~mendments to these Land Development Kegulations shall be accepted for review and ?rocessing annually on the anniversary date of adoption. Amendments to these regulations ~o implement plans developed for any Areas of .: r i tical County concern may be considered at d.ny time designated by the Board of County i:.:ommissioners. ':-T:,'.',Qment 1148; 13-10 lD3a (i) J Page 300 ,;,,:~~1->pt recommendation of planning commission to amend the \ ;10 ': i.::e provision for amendments to these regulations as ::) ll:)ws: Notice of a proposed amendment to either the text of these regulations or the Land Use Map shall be provided by publication... -. The advertisements for amendments to the Land use Map shall be in the following form....The advertisement for an amendment to the text of these regulations shall state in a brief form the nature of the amendment to be considered at the public hearing. (ii) Notice by publication shall be provided, in the case of amendments to the Land Use District Map, at least thirty (30) days prior to any required i public hearing and in the case of amend- ments to the text of these regulations at least fifteen (15) days prior to any i required public hearing. I! ;' and also accept the recommendation that 5-501b be revised to be consistent with this change. ~endment 1150; 13-l01D3b; Page 300 Ueny proposed Amendment 1150. ~endment 1154. V.2 Pa_e 150. Evaluation And Rankin Of The Impact potentials And Impact Sensitivities Of Florida Keys Habitats Accept recommendation of planning Commission to change the I fifth sentence, ninth line, to read as follows: it within twelve months after the effective , date of the Administration Commission rule . which establishes portions of the Monroe I County comprehensive plan and Land Develop- ment Regulations, Monroe County shall - S4".;.:a..,~~.~" -- "_.. ~_._--------.--------,.."..,......,.. , ............01..___. -_........c___# .-----....., II 1 7 1 -_._--~- -- - .------.-.-..-- .-- --- ------- _. . Amendment. t129; new Chapter 16, Page 314 Motion was w3de by Co~ssioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner- Freeman to deny propoaed Amendment '129 and recommend that the fees be adopted by Ordinance. Motion carried unani~ously. Amendment tl?11 6-102C and 01 Page 77 Motion was ~4de by Commissioner Puto and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission and add to the Planning Director's authority to issue certificates of compliance at the end of the paragraph: The Director of Planning is authorized in the case of the Improved Subdivision Districtd to survey the subdivision, and upon the written recommendation of the Ccunty Biologist, determine whether development may proceed in the subdivision without :urther biological review. If the Director of Planning so determines, then he shall certify the subdivision to the Board of County Commissioners and upon approval of the Board, no certificate of compliance shall be required for that subdivision when an application for development approval is filed; provided, however, that this provision shall not be construed to permit development to proceed in a certified subdivision without a building permit or without compliance with the other provisions of these regulations. -. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment ~167. rovide a blanket certification for a ro riate 1m roved Subd vision (IS) districts to expedite perm t process1ng Motion was made by Commissioner Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to create a new Sec. 5-20l(D), under DEVELOPMENT AS OF RIGHT, Volume 3, as follows: D. Certified IS Districts. This section authorizes the Development Review Co- ordinator to submit for certification by the Board of County Commissioners certain IS areas herein defined which may be issued permitted without review by the Land Planning Division.' 1. At any regularly scheduled meeting of the Board of County Commissioners, certification may be given to those IS areas recommended for approval and listing by the Development Review Coordinator. 2. The Development Review Coordinator shall recommend from time to time to the Board of County Commissioners any IS area which meets the following: (. ) documentation that all utilities and roads are in place consistent with the definition of IS; - . . II 183 I achieved. . Amendment t70: 9-305A1 Page 157 Accept recommendation of Planning commdssion to add cross- reference to Section 9-305 after 9-302 and 9-303; and to add cross-reference to 9-307 to 9-30SA2. Amendment '88; 9-506Kl Page 173 Accept recommendation of Planning Commission to correct typographical error: wreservew should have been wreversew. Amendment tl08: 9-10061 Page 224 Accept recommendation of Planning Commission to correct cross-references to 9-1102, 1103, 1104. Amendment t1261 12-102P1 Page 284 Accept recommendation of Planning commission to change typographical error reference to wroadway improvementsW to wparkw. ... Motion carried unanimously. Amendment tl13, Amendment tl14, Amendment t129A Motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to consider these proposed Amendments at this time. Motion carried unanimously. Charles Papy, attorney representing Lake Advertising, addressed the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Stormont to continue consideration of these proposed Amendments to October 1st. Roll call vote was una- nimous. Betty Wilson of the Highway Beautification Committee made a presentation concerning signs. -~ Amendment t173 After Board discussion, motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Lytton and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to continue con- sideration to July 31st. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment tl03 Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to approve Staff recommendation but request Staff to come back to the Board with a clarification of the reference to DBH. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment '107, 9-1001, Page 219 Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to add Improved Subdivision District (Commercial) to the list of districts requiring landscaping for parking areas with a Class A landscape standard. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was then made by Commissioner Stormont and seconded by Commissioner Freeman to upgrade landscaping standard for Sparsely Settled district from Class A to Class C. Motion carried unanimously. Amendment '110, 9-1006, Page 224 Motion was made by Mayor Pro Tam Lytton and seconded by Commissioner preeman to add at the end of the paragraph regarding street treeSI ...provided that 1n no event will 1esa than one street tree be provided for every lot. Existing natural native vegetation takes priority and satisfies I I