11/25/1985 SpecialEE 065
1
1
1
Special Meeting/Public Hearing
Board of County Commissioners
Monday, November 25, 1985,
J
Tavernier Elks Club
d
I�
A Special Meeting of the Board of County
Commissioners convened on 'the above date in Tavernier.'
Present and answering to roll call were Commissioner William
Freeman, Commissioner Johnlil
, Stormont, and Mayor Pro Tem!
Alison Fahrer. Also present were Danny L. Kolhage, Clerk;
Robert Wolf, Assistant County Attorney; Charles Siemon,
Planning Consultant; JerrylAnnas, Ty Symroski, and Andy
Hooten of the Planning Department; members of the Press and
Radio; and the general public. Absent from the meeting were
Commissioner Ed Swift and ;Mayor Wilhelmina Harvey.
The Board discuss 'Ied Map No. U-01, Stark Property,
Lower Matecumbe, East End,iBayside, MM 77.5. The Staff
recommended that this area; remain CFA and NA. Mr. Fred
Tittle, attorney representing Captain Buck Stark, addressed
the Board and requested that the area be redesignated .DR/RV
for the upland portion of ythe property and NA for the
mangrove. Mr. Robby Requert, current lessee of the pro-
perty, addressed the Board. This matter was postponed until
later in the day.
Mr. Fred Tittle asked that consideration of Map No.
U-06, Tropical Reef Resort, Windley Key, Oceanside, MM 85.2,
be postponed until the final Upper Keys hearing.
The Board considered Map No. U-02, Coral Cove,
Upper Matecumbe, All Lots 'Except Nos. 1, 2, 4, and 5,
Oceanside, MM 80.7. Motion was made by Commissioner. Freeman
and seconded by Mayor Pro jTem Fahrer to approve the Staff's
recommendation that Lot 3,' Lots 6 through 15, and Parcel ID
#9619 be designated IS. Motion carried unanimously. Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem 'Fahrer to designate Map No. U-03,
Stratton's Subdivision, -The Islander Resort, Islamorad!a,
Oceanside, MM 81.5, as DR.i Motion carried unanimously'.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and I
seconded by Commissioner Freeman directing the Staff to
review all previously designated DR's to formalize criteria
for the DR designation concerning minimum acreage and speci-
fic facilities required and to review those currently
designated to see that they meet.the criteria to fulfill
their function. Motion ca�ried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner F,'reeman to designate Lots 2 t,hrough
11 of Block 6 of Map No. U;-04, Stratton's Subdivision,.
Islamorada, Bayside, MM 81;.5, as IS. Motion carried unani-
mously.
Mr. Jim Hendrick,representing Bay Hammock Land
Corp., addressed the Board concerning the newly -approved
major development and recorded plat. Motion was made by
Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner Stormont
to postpone consideration of this item to the next
appropriate hearing with Staff recommendations. Motion
carried unanimously.
The Board then discussed "The Moorings" property of
EE 066
Islamorada. Mr. Mike Barr addressed the Board. Motion was
made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner
Stormont to approve Area No. 64 to SR. Motion carried una-
nimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to accept Staff recommen-
dations that Map No. U-05 Area, Holiday Isle Resort, Windley
Kye, West End, Oceanside, MM 84, be retained as SC. Motion
carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer to designate Map No. U-07,
Selby Property Adjacent To Plantation Lake Estates,
Plantation, Oceanside, MM 86.9, as follows: Parcel ID #9352
as NA and Parcel ID #9337 and #9342-012 (known as property
owned by the Ellises at the southeast corner of South Drive)
as SR. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to accept the recommen-
dation of the planners to designate Map No. U-08 Area,
Tavernier Harbor, Block 1, Lot 6, Tavernier, Bayside, MM 92,
as IS/DM. Motion carried unanimously. Mike Barr and Arlene
Reiser addressed the Board concerning this matter.
The Board entered into a discussion of Map No. U-09
Area. Mr. Oliver Brown, owner of Lot 16 in Seven Acres, and
Mr. Cornell, owner of the property,, requested that the SR
designation be retained. The Staff recommended that the
property retain the SR designation. Arlene Reiser addressed
the Board. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to change the designation
of Map No. U-09 Area, Property North of Seven Acres, 2 Acre
Strip, Tavernier, Bayside, MM 94.4, to SS. Motion carried
unanimously.
The Board briefly discussed the Sophie Felton pro-
perty and the matter was referred to Staff.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer to retain the SR designa-
tion for Map No. U-10 Area, Bay Haven, Block 8, Lots 11 and
12, Tavernier, Bayside, MM 94.8. The Board also discussed
the possible re -visiting of this area for NA designation.
Mr. Tittle addressed the Board concerning Map No.
U-01 Area, Stark Property, and requested the Board to hold
this item over until the Marathon map meetings. Motion was
made by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner
Stormont to postpone consideration of Map No. U-01 Area,
Stark Property, Lower Matecumbe, East End, Bayside, MM 77.5,
to the Marathon map meetings. Motion carried unanimously.
The Board entered into a discussion concerning
Planning Area 34. Mr. Michael Fagin, representing the pro-
perty owners of Tract A - Wynken, Blynken & Nod, addressed
the Board concerning their current designation of URM and
requested .that the property continue to be designated as
Commercial. Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to retain the URM designa-
tion for Planning Area 34. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer to direct the Planners to
re -visit the SR, UR and URM categories for the purpose of
providing for a minor conditional use for property which
1
1
1
EE OG7
1
I
fronts US 1 to be used for
there be no direct access
vided by a frontage road of
that buffering be required
any adjacent residential of
carried unanimously.
The Board recesses
The Board reconver
The Board discussi
agreed that all future Pub
a.m. and run through to 5:.
resume at 7:00 p.m., and t
further agreed that Maps fi
be considered on December
p.m.
commercial uses, providing that
o US 1 and that access be pro -
other alternative accesses, and
between the commercial use and
non-commercial use. Motion
for lunch at 12:00 Noon.
ied at 1:30 p.m.
!d.future Public Hearings and
is Hearings would begin at 9:00
10 p.m., would break for dinner,
!rminate at 11:00 p.m. It was
it the Middle and Lower Keys would
.lth and December 12th at 7:00
Motion was made b, Commissioner Stormont and ,
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to designate Map No. U-11
Area, American Outdoors, Mandalay, Key Largo, Bayside,-MM
97.5, as SS. Motion carried unanimously.
11
The Board then di
Harbor Yacht Haven, Tracts
MM 97.4. Motion was made
seconded by Commissioner S
Haven, Tracts 1 and la, be
through 15 and the four to
IS. Motion carried unanim
li
cussed Map No. U-12 Area, Rock
1 and la, Oceanside, Key Largo,
y Commissioner Freeman and
ormont that Rock Harbor Yacht
designated SR; and that Lots 1
s South of Lot 15 be designated
usly.
Motion was made b� Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to designate Map No. U-13,
Sunset Waterways, Key Largo, Bayside, MM 101, as IS per
Staff recommendation. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made b
Map No. U-14 Area for cons
on the SC category: Durin
withdrawn. Motion was the
and seconded by Commission
designation, per Staff rec
Area, South Creek Village,
Oceanside, MM 102.8. Moti
Commissioner Stormont to delay
deration of Staff recommendations
discussion, motion was
made by Commissioner Stormont
r Freeman to retain the IS
mmendation, for Map No. U-14
Block 9, Lots 11-13, Key Largo,
n carried unanimously.
Motion was made b�, Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to retain the SR designa-
tion for Map No. U-15 Area, Albury Property, Section 1,
T61S, R39E, Lots 15. and 161, MM 105.8, Key Largo. Motion
carried unanimously.
The Board then discussed Point Laura. Mr. Mike
Barr addressed the Board concerning Point Laura.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to designate DCA Area 59,
Map #14, as SR. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to designate DCA Area 63,
Map #14, as SR. Motion carried unanimously. Mr. Sullen
Stewart of DCA addressed the Board concerning this matter.
I-
EE 68
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to .designate DCA Area 65,
Map #14, as SR and that the SR would be modified to include
Institutional uses subject to specified performance stan-
dards. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer to designate DCA Area 66A5
Map #14, as NA. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to designate DCA Area 67,
Map #14, as NA. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to designate DCA Area 68,
Map #14, as SS. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont that DCA Area 69, Map #14,
remain SC, except for those areas which are inundated
periodically by tides which will be designated NA. Motion
carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Stormont and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman that DCA Area 71, Map #15,
be designated as SS. Motion carried unanimously.
Consideration of DCA Area 72, Map #15, was
deferred.
No action was taken on DCA Area 74, Map #15.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to designate DCA Area 75,
Map #15, as SR with additional criteria. Motion carried
unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to retain DCA Area 76, Map
#15, as SC. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer to designate DCA Area 77,
Map #15, as SR with additional criteria. Motion carried
unanimously.
Motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Fahrer and
seconded by Commissioner Freeman to retain DCA Area 78 of
Map #16 as UC/UR. Motion carried unanimously.
Motion was made by Commissioner Freeman and
seconded by Commissioner Stormont to retain DCA Area 79, Map
#16, as SR. Motion carried unanimously.
Consideration of DCA Area 80, Map #16, was tabled
pending additional work to be done on hammocks in the Upper
Keys.
The Board then discussed the IS designation in
Sunset Waterways, Map No. U-13. No action was taken.
DCA Area 81 of Map #17 was discussed. Mike Barr
addressed the Board concerning this item. Motion was made
by Commissioner Freeman and seconded by Commissioner
Stormont that DCA Area 81 of Map #17 be designated IS; DCA
Area 82 of Map #17 be designated SR; and DCA Area 83 of Map
1
1
1
EE 069
#17 be designated IS with buffers and access to US 1 cri-
teria, per Staff recommendations. Motion carried unani-
mously.
No action was taken on DCA Area 84 of Map #17.�
Pam Martin of O.F.'JF. addressed the Board concerning
DCA Area 85 of Map #17. Motion was made by Commissioner
Stormont and seconded by CoT missioner Freeman to designate
Lots 5 through 17 of Ocean Isle Estates fronting on Garden
Cove Drive as CFA. Motion carried unanimously.
There being no further business, the meeting was
adjourned. !
i
I
1