Loading...
Resolution 103-1989 Planning Department RESOLUTION NO. 103-1989 A RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE ADMINISTRATIVE BOUNDARY INTERPRETATION OF THE PLANNING DIRECTOR IN LAND USE DISTRICT MAP BOUNDARY INTERPRETATION NUMBER 28, RE#11083-005 BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT: The administrative decision of the Planning Director in Land Use District Map Boundary Interpretation Number 28 dated January 25, 1989, attached and incorporated by reference, is hereby acknowledged, found to be in conformance with the standards set forth in Sec. 9.5-3(m), Monroe County Code, and approved. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, at a regular meeting of said Board held on the 21 day of February, A.D., 1989 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA By '?//~/;P4- Mayor/Chairman (SEAL) Attest:DANNY L. KOLHAGE, ~ 4~ )f,/!... -1-'4/.,(' Clerk , ,. tlPP~OVEDM T.~ '{> lEGAL stJFFICII!IftlY. ~Jn(\A_/ H!~:~. ,LJ~NOW '" 'j': ., ~i 0 ~'I JUtJNOW ",,-""! l\~' c: BE: 17 d 17Z 83.:1 69. Z E: OL\f Z - MVW 58. - "'llj ',..::;' ,.~ ,.' c'" _' .. i' J .....,i.:.JUJ~.ii'~..l ...,1\..) __,I u..J U j U ..1-, ,,_' U .:..n 1.:1 M E M 0 RAN DUM TO: FROM: The Board of County Commissioners Donald L. Craig, AICP, Assoc. AlA, Assistant County Administrator for Growth Management Division Department: Planning SUBJECT: Proposed Animal Shelter Site on Big Pine (RE# 11083- 005) Boundary Determination DATE: January 25, 1989 MEETING DATE: February 21, 1989 PLANNER: Ruth Grover BIOLOGIST: Pat McNeese Previous Relevant Board Action: None Referral: Yes____No~ Commissioner's District: Gene Lytton Recommended Action: It is recommended that the IndustrialjNative Area line be redrawn to correspond with the east and south property lines of the referenced property only. The line can be further modified if need- ed when additional boundary determination requests are initiated for other properties. Summary of RequestjReport: BACKGROUND Monroe County proposes to build a combination animal shelter and office bui Iding on the referenced property on Big Pine Key. The property is located within two land use districts: Native Area (NA) and Industrial (I). Due to the conditions of the property, it has been determined that the proposed building should be allowed as a use as of right in the Industrial district. However, the building site is currently located within the NA district (see attached map). Therefore, this boundary determination request has been initiated on behalf of Monroe County in order to expedite issuance of a building permit. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the Industrial/Native Area line be redrawn to correspond with the east and south property lines of the referenced property only. The line can be further modified if needed when addition- al boundary determination requests are initiated for other properties. SITE DESCRIPTION The property is fenced and occupied on the north side by a City Electric diesel generator unit, which is located within the Industrial district. That area has been filled. The remainder of the property consists of disturbed wetlands over which fill material has been unevenly scattered and compacted resulting in irregular low spots with wetland vegetation. The vegetation consists mainly of sparse clumps of Batis, Salicornia sp., sea blite, and Distichlis. The only wetland area within the proper- ty which appears to be relatively undisturbed is the ten foot strip along the south property line. There is also debris and a travel trail- er stored on the site. Outside the property line to the south is undis- turbed salt marsh and buttonwood habitat. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The designation of the above-mentioned lot as I rather than NA would be consistent with Section 9.5-220, Purpose of the Industrial District, and uses within the district, Section 9.5-249. 2. The above determination was made based on the following: a. The zoning maps in use prior to the adoption of the Land Development regulations show the subject property as General Use (GU). b. The Land Use District maps, signed by Charles Pattison, and dated February 28, 1986, imnrecisely show the NAil boundary. c. The Land Use District Maps, signed by Donald Craig, and dated January 19, 1988, show the subject lots as NA. d. The habitat type for this property would be defined as disturbed with salt marsh and buttonwood for purposes of permitting. e. Disturbed areas such as these were not intended to fall within the Native Area district unless special circumstances warranted such designation. f. Partial filling of the north side of the property for the gener- ator unit resulted in further encreachment in the form of irreg- ular fill and debris over the rest of the property. g. The undisturbed wetlands start at the south property line (the habi tat line). h, The NAil district boundary line should follow the habitat line. i. The land use in the vicinity of the subject site is industrial and vacant land. j. The NA designation was assigned to the property in error. 4. Analysis of the subject property and surrounding properties indi- cates that the essential neighborhood characteristics suuport the determination that the land use district boundary be redrawn to follow the existing habitat line and include the subject property in the Industrial district. Action by:___Ordinance ~Resolution Citizens Committee Statement: Yes~No____ Attached Agreement/Contract: No. N. A. Approved by County Attorney as to Legality:___Yes~N.A. Standard Form Approved by Risk Management:___Yes~N.A. Approved by Office Fiscal Management:___Yes~N,A. Funding Source: N.A. Current Year Cost: N.A. Arumal Cost: N.A. Budgeted:___Yes___No~N,A. Will Proposal Require Additional Personnel? X No If Yes State Number____ Permanent___ Temporary___ Other Board Policy(ies) Applicable: None Planning Commission Action Taken: Yes Date X N.A. Alternatives: 1. Leave the district designated NA Attached Documentation: X Yes No 1. Current Land Use District Map (1"=200') 2. Current Land Use District Map (1"=400') 3. Aerial Photograph 4. Zoning pre-1986 5. Land Use District Map Effective September IS, 1986 (Pattison) 6. Existing Land Conditions Map 7. Proposed Boundary Change I to- . ~ -= i 8IG PINE I( I ,-- "'~ "", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ------ NA I I , I , . ft . . . . . . . . , . . . . . ~-' . M ....1 . .. .. . . ... .. ICNO..... A. Land Use District Maps Monroe County, Florida Ja....ary 19,1988 Panel or Sheel# 3!Jl.... Appllc ani: M 0141DF (,001'-\1"( Key:-EI~ ~I"'E ~ W N File # I 1-.200' i Mile Marker: ~ \ ...... - -~.-::,:,..,.. 7":~"=Io.",=="~_ , ~ NA ..-..--- ..---- ~ ".... .~~~ \0 \'\\ 8C \ \ \ \ , , \ \ \ .. , \. \ \ , >."\?' \ ", ,.... . . . . . . . . . . . .-- \ \ ,. I - ,.".. ,." --~------- ---- " " , " , " , " .' " , " " " ,.-'............ -I--.. -..... I --I " , . , I . . . . . . . , , . , , . , , , , , . . . . , . I , , , \ \ \ \ \ \ . \ \ \ . \ \ \ \ Ii II ,R " , .- " · · .. ./~: 1 · · · , · · . . . . . . . . . t -' .J'! .; . . E ... "-1.-.. v. T I ',J ...1........,.:.... .,.........1... I Jf · I ~ I -->-- - - ~1~1:1 .. .;. · tfl-.!"~.'.. · · · · !( ~.~-~-,-~ ~ '..w-.' II ........... :_~_...: K .... ~ _..6~ .............. ...., -- " ,,~ . . . . . . . . . .~. J,;ij. ...,...... '. . . .. . . . . . .1. -1/;" . . . . . .. . . _ . ~../ ( ..... · · . . . . . . . .IZ-::: ~1_' . t. , . . . . . t · r, I :-;-r .~......I~:~~~~......... ....~; I :y llV --...... ;...'--'-"-; ... ".If I --- I .. · · ./ ,)- j. . . . t i.. . . . , . . . . . t I c1;~I E 26 I~ ~5ia · .ro""l: ~. .,. · · · · · · · · .. · ., -- . , I . , . , , . , ' , '. " '."" , ~ , ,""^ ',' ........'- ------ /':~ .- ~)\ ~ ~ .3536 7_t ~ i -1\.J S 11 r;:} ~ .,--...-..----.....---- , , , , , , " , , , , " " , , " .I' t ~ \ , , , , , N Land Use District Maps Monroe County, Florida January 19,1988 Pane' or Sh.etll :3,3Z Applicant: M ON12oE (" -Dol'lT:'t Key: ~I~ r:pl~~ __________ ~,' W l FI'ell _________ t- 1"= 400 ~ Mile Marker: -!:>-l--- r,.y '4 4 +r Zf i 'II �•' 1, t, • 1 1! 1t '11 ►11! PttaVo', ._ `-4 i — _ 1 ,I 1fr/ i; `i l j .., # y �` r�l - 1 i A. 11,. t► . ' A' 11l1 I1 r R ! 3 i L . 4 r ' a 1 pi ;1` - r :.. ...... -N.I.•.: -L'.zr",a,• , -. . • • i 4 ,- ? .4- e- r 4.- '''',,N4t iiit -...••• •-• .-. . •-,,,'$•iii I. • '1"r•' SS�Z '- f f 1 'r f. ''fC'C t9- 5 N Aerial Maps, Monroe County, Florida Real Estate Data, Inc. _ < - _ Editlon,l9 _t Panel or Sh.et# co FI Ie# L.�-� Applicant: /" cDR-zoe £c Der( i=gpp• i Key: ►h PUN' Mile Marker: _______ - g ~ >> ~ ,'. r'; ~ ~: .. \t.. ~~"'-J , ... " c... -" I \.J (). . '> ''\.' .-... . ." ) -->.~ ' w Z ,I ~ _ 4) ('<I . . . ~ =< ),- (' J , ,., ........ ~u- 3X o ( , i.. .J -r ( '- ..,"."., GU > I ~ i- .J..j ~ L I. 60- I , ..4 ...... ....- J .!J.C;1' __ l ~ _,~- ,_ _____~ I~T:~->;b~;~I; 4 .'/" ~T~,~.l .1.'-V"~ \~ I_~I~:~~ ~,~~;': . ~:I. : ~~ '" ',-J,:-~~ I .", :-:~~_, K N l...E ~ / ,_ ,J. -- - -;-::.. - q:;'--~,~._ , 1 . ____ _ 2 It-, ,0' I ;c... . '. " I , . , "\ ' ,,- I if> ( ,/~ _ ' ~ 1 - .~--~(). itt~ . . . -t-'- I I ." ~ . :. ;Z\7'~ ;:.~l.~ n, ~ --' N Monroe County Zoning Maps Pre-September 15,1986 .....,..",.. I , , I 1-.200' I Pan.. or ....t# 176 Applicant: ~ <XXJNTY Key: BIG PINE Flle# ,.... Mark.r: 31 Land Use District Maps Monroe County, Florida Approved by B.O.C.C., February 28,1986 Panel or Sheet# 8 OF Z I File # Applicant: ~:F (".alJ"-\T'Y Key: ~/~ Mile Marker:-.3L-_ SR I I I - ~.Q_: ~B~ , , IS i ~------- -_ .L _ __ _ ......... - - -, I I 1 ~ sc " , r-----~ : I J I ,__ · .1 /--- 1 ! )/ I I "r---/KEY I , J':' I , I ,.../ /<; I " _ ", ! r / I -~...-- , .... -- \ .,...-"'" "" , '\ \ ~E ~ \ ~ \ r\ I 'I -.---'--."....----------. , <> Ii ,"- , ,)", I 10 .,. ~I '- L <: ". N t @ I 1".600' I ~ -...J ~~ sc j/ ~,-, " " \ , \Y:: ;7 Ell 44' vie- : , # , N iv Air," ' ' • - I .abbp 41: ..' t�,.r, is ;'' v ,_ t___,. -jtk.r4-\,‘../. ,...--*. A lb. 4.4*• _._..�. 411 .. (4 -', 2 4 b - r f y: >> 'k....' t I #,.'1,._,*): 4 ii Ili. , t • t414.5• f^.+ r4 •�.1" LLL s, 1 ` ♦ •I.'✓}1.'r,'.4*'�, • :.,, „ - ,.] --- ' 0 � 4•4• • 4,2,' -`fit --1 *1` ••• le 5.1-F _.----- 1 I ' 1 \''•- f-1 0'4,,4; -41.. - :IT ; • i_ `1 1 n A i � ` s ' y `11 ' `.. f2G ►ice 1_♦ , [Z. �/ �,a 3 ,.' • lie Pt ,Tr ) r ,- __,.. 'elk'P.I .4, 'i, Lib (,,t ;eif• \\k\ at t '- \ +• 740 •M1 i `^ btu \`!�� 3 , i \ t 1, i,t a 1 /-" 1 tP ''.*'. .'".' (1)-; \ '.N _„,,,,• lk J 4 , ! ate .__ . 44 . 3 5 , ..„f If 0 4 .9 101ir 7 4t,s �go h,____ N Existing Land Conditions Maps Monroe County , Florida July 2, 1985 Panel or Sheet# 2 OF 7 _ File#_ r Applicant: — 1 '=2000 Key: B/6 2oiE Mile Marker: __ j\ _ B J BIG PINE KEY ~ . ~ . B ........ ,.-' I ;; ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , , .' ~' , , NA , , , , ~ 'JC.~*~***~ ----- I I~ > r! "- -- -- - .1- - . - . . )"~:-~ I , . . t . . . . . , . . . . . ,,'" I I I ~ ~ "'I_~_~ , VI I 1/ . · - 1 .'.' -;;, - · · · I . . . . . . . . at . . I I I I _ _7.J-P I ___ .~. J~~ ~ ,~2- ~ r r I I I I I I I I I L I I I I .1 - .......... .. Seetl Oft ... - 2.C.)( I)" ef 'M ...... c...a, c... 11M M........ of tlM LaM u.. DI..,lct .... .. 1.._......... .. 1M 1 locat." .. IMtea'." above anet IIrlef.y .....IIM.. _: Extend I boundary to include subject property as shown. . I DI, eet., ..wt h ........"'.", De.. 1-.200' ....# ::n? KQ BiCjl Pinp aocc ........... B J BIG PINE KEY ... . ~ i ~~ -,' I " " ; ; ; ; ; , , , , ~, ,-' , , NA , , , , ; ,.------ -----... I ~ J rf " 4 , .T I tt kf::-~ t I ~ . . . . . . . . . . l' . . . . . '" ,," ~ 1 1 1 rv -r'-~-~ 1 1 1./ . " · 1 .'.'.:J'r- - - -I. · . . . . . . It . . 1 I I 1 ...1_...1_ · _J/ ~ - KIIO-.- .- _, . . 1 ~_.,~2-~ ., I I I __ I I I I I I 1 I 1 1 T T T - --.-.- ~-.., .. Section 1.1-14(.)("" ef tM ........ c...e, c... tIM "...,... of '1M L.nd u.. DI."'e' ..... .. I......,.,..... .. M N tocat... .. Indlcat.d .bo.. and ....Ief.y d.."'M~ _: 1 ~ ~ Dt, _I., ..wt h ............nt o.t. 1""200' .....,# K.v aocc .........,_ APPLICATION FOR LAND USE DISTRICT MAP DETERMINATION APPLICANT Monroe County PHONE #294-4641 ADDRESS 5825 Jr. College Road, Wing III Stock Island, FL 33040 KEY Big Pine Key MM 31 OCEANSIDE OR BAYS IDE? Oceanside SUBDIVISION North of Silas Knowles SD No. 1 PLAT BOOK PAGE BLOCK LOT(S) MISC. LOCATION INFORMATION (ATTACH EXTRA SHEET IF NECESSARY) RE # 11083-005 REQUEST CHANGE FROM REASON FOR REQUEST: NAil TO I Monroe County proposes to build a combination animal shelter and office building on the referenced property on Big Pine Ke~ PRESENT LAND USE: Fenced and occupied on north side by a City Electric diesel generator unit. Remainder of property consists of disturbed wetlands. DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE SUPPORTING REQUEST: SIGNATURE Fee paid DATE ~~ y M E M 0 RAN DUM Date: January 3, 1989 To George Garrett, Coordinator, Environmental Resources Dept. /J . I')l'\ Pat McNeese, Biologist, Environmental Resources Dept.f/4/ proposed animal shelter site on Big Pine (RE# 11083- 005)--boundary determination From: Re ----------------------------------------------------------------- INTRODUC'I'ION Monroe County proposes to build a combination animal shelter and office building on the referenced property on Big Pine Key. The property is located within two land use districts: Native Area (NA) and Industrial (I). Due to the conditions of the property, it has been determined that the proposed building should be al- lowed as a use as of right in the Industrial district. However, the building site is currently located wi thin the NA district (see attached map). Therefore, this boundary determination re- quest has been initiated on behalf of Monroe County in order to expedite issuance of a building permit. SITE DESCRIPTION The property is fenced and occupied on the north side by a City Electric diesel generator unit, which is located within the Indus- trial district. That area has been filled. The remainder of the property consists of disturbed wetlands over which fill material has been unevenly scattered and compacted resulting in irregular low spots with wetland vegetation. The vegetation consists main- ly of sparse clumps of Batis, Salicornia sp., sea blite, and Distichlis. The only wetland area wi thin the property which appears to be relatively undisturbed is the ten foot strip along the south property line. There is also debris and a travel trail- er stored on the site. Outside the property line to the south is undisturbed salt marsh and buttonwood habitat. EVALUATION The habitat type for this property would be defined as disturbed with salt marsh and buttonwood for purposes of permitting. It is felt that disturbed areas such as these were not intended to fall within the Native Area district unless special circumstances warranted such a designation. In this case, it appears that par- tial filling of the north side of the property for the generator uni t resulted in further encroachment in the form of irregular fill and debris over the rest of the property. The undisturbed wetlands start at the south property line and it is felt that the Garrett/McNeese January 3, 1989 Page Two Industrial/Native Area boundary line should correspond with the habitat line. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the Industrial/Native Area line be redrawn to correspond with the east and south property lines of the refer- enced property only. The line can be further modified if needed when additional boundary determination requests are inti tiated for other properties. cc: permit application file Donald Craig Robert Herman Howard Tupper Jeanne DuBois ~f) ~w~ k,$ ~5fll4~/~' 11div~ (f}V htb1na. I ~ fAFd'h [f;O!()9rS r r u4 A/xJ?;( Prtd jltbmif r [..Jj'sAJAJiuJ/ BoCL ~Vfl.{ ~ .. ',,,,.,>.""'. """""'."'.~'''''''~'''''-~'_''''I'" fO 344 \ , " "-, - - r- ... I ... ... i3 .. N .. --~--- ... I ... I ... ::: ~ ... ~ --~---~ ... I ... I ... 01 0 0 r ~- -;.n: . _l-___J . . 01 ~ ~ ~ .. @ ~ N N [F' N lftiil .. l'!Ji) N ... ~ I?> ~W1[g $ irlm [g[gir ... ... l'!Ji) .. N <=lI ... ::: :mJ ~ lftiil ... ... lftiil 01 0 <=lI ... ... . . . == . == . ... ... ... ... . . ... . ... . . . lit GI lit 01 0 0 N ~ N ~ ... ... N .. N .. N N N N N N .. .. N ... N ... ~ ~ " ..... CIHIAImIL[g$irOWl Sir "- \ I I I I I I I I I , " " " " " , " Z :t- " " " " " " " " , , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ , I , , , , I tIJ - G) 'lJ - ~ ~ r <'-~~ lPc.ou~r.. . ....... co ~~~.~.'!. ~~~.:.../~) "0 ........ t'" # COUM~"" .- '"- ..... j1faiiltp JL. 1&olbage BRANCH OFFICE 3117 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY MARATHON, FLORIDA 33050 TEL. (305) 743.9036 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT MONROE COUNTY 500 WHITEHEAD STREET KEY WEST, FLORIDA 33040 TEL. (3051 294-4641 BRANCH OFFICE P.O. BOX 379 PLANTATION KEY, FLORIDA 33070 TEL. (305) 852.9253 I I March 2, 1989 CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Department of Community Affairs Howard Building 2571 Executive Center Circle, East Tallahassee, Florida 32301 ~ D2i \ '3 (.::, \61 ...'., and Department of Community Affairs Post Office Box 990 Key West, Florida 33041 " 0 '2. .., \~{Q I~O Gentlemen: At a Regular Meeting in formal session on February 21, 1989, the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County adopted Resolution No. 103-1989 confirming the Administrative Boundary Interpretation of the Planning Director in Land Use District Map Boundary Interpretation Number 28, RE,11083-005, Proposed Animal Shelter Site on Big pine Key. Enclosed please find a certified copy of said Resolution. f { Very truly yours, Danny L. Kolhage Clerk of Circuit Court and ex officio Clerk Board of County Commissioners by: . Rosall.e L. C Deputy Clerk Enclosure .=JY' cc: Mayor M. Puto -R Commissioner E. Lyt~n County Attorney R. Ludacer County Administrator T. Brown Div. Dir. D. Craig Pile j. II . P 027 136 1.11 M . E . .~ . ~ . ii E 0 u " c . ..; ~ ." . " . .; J . . u " $ ~ .. c 0 . .. f' '0 " "' . '" c '" ~ . ~ ~ ~ c TOTAL Postage and Fees S 0 ~ N , " .; c 0 Postmark or Date . '" '" E . E ~ . .~ Ul . 0. ; ii E 0 u P 027 136 150 RtCEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL NO INSURANCE COVERAGEPROVIDEO NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAIL (See Reverse) '41 ~ c ~ , .; g Postmark or Date '" E (; u. Ul 0. ... 2: w u 0 . w . a: ~ . .0 "" Z ~ " ~w >. a: "0: 1: 50 ~w :2 :l ... . ...- wO -> w > Eu 0- 2.~ =- oJ a: .~ ..9 00 ~w wO !,! o. ;30 w,," ~ e. ... "0 ~\C' ~w :g~ '" ~~ w .o_ w": ..:" ::ii E 0 ." c .~ cO .w 0 0 ~ E-o:E "tU-o :il~ Z ~ c 0 il . .~ w ~ e~ c ,,~ ~ ~ "", a ..:~ ~ . <i' (; ro M .!! c.... . ~ , E ~ . .~ 1: CD g CD ~lIIu ~ ....t: iii a. 0......11 E = .!! ~ o ~ i ~ () .EII =+- "'C :s c f ~\I' :; 0111" ~ "'C.t::: i~ ... "O~ 0 .2 t)!"l Q) f ~;,~ E~~......a; = "j ... g: C;:;:J .2'0 ctI '0 ~ tII .a:;[.tl 2 r: ~ e "O~ f ~:OE$ ;:-~~J!~.!~ : ai~~;O EPb'~'E~ ~ ~ ~ gN <( 8. ~ ~ Jj ~ ~ :~tIl;:. ~D)G.D ~ :g ~ 'Eii ({ (; 00 iii III "U.'- C ~""':~:g ~ .s::. .....Gllll :c ~QI~~-: "0 0 oeal . . :eEll j c (JC'O~.. 1 ~~~:g:g ~ CI) ..IllCll : 0 L" ('II OGlU-OC "'C ....-c .':::'CIl+- Ii z I ... .4j a:'>x;~ . 4J .~ H:Hi fl';l ~ e CD ~ uGi~ (J'1 f .~~~~i+- ; 1- 0... alL Q) U ;:~"O..!s: ~m Ii: -5~ of .t; ~ ~ w -g :. ~ 'Ou.. , Q' EG)O <( .. z~gei5ti ""J'- wC>~.E :1iv J' 0.. '0 >+-0 't.. J\ .~:a!. P .. u ,,_: '" OJ S:iJ' --- ~1 t9"3 !~:f o ~ " . ~d: ::i -- (I " o 50 wO Eu - 00 p -::J ~ \i' ",:'- r "- ~ * '" '" ~ ~ . ~ ~ -5 c ~ " ~ .....". " ..: .11 I J .- " - e . 0 - ;3 ~'~. '0 III . 1L:' ~ E c a !i!f . (; en Ul 0 U. ori X .; X ...: ~ * ~ . .0 ~w "0: ~w -> 0- oJ ~w ;30 .w &... ';;;<( cO 5-0 .0 c o . ~ c 8, . I- A. iii u w a: z II: ;) ... W a: u >= r:l ~ o o "" >. :2 ~~ wO ~"" . . :g~ ..:" .... S *11 ~.-t ". ~~ o ~ " 18 ~ ~ ;;: cD ! 0 a: ~ :; . ~ .,.-- <- '" ~ "-' '" . ~ - -5 c ) ~ " 8, >- ..: ..: .~ " I I , " - e ,~> -'- a - ;3 it '0 III . c c :; E a a en en 0 S ori u. X .; X ,.; '"