Resolution 204-1989
RESOLUTION NO. 204-1989
Planning Department
A RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE ADMINISTRATIVE
BOUNDARY INTERPRETATION OF THE PLANNING
DIRECTOR INLAND USE DISTRICT MAP BOUNDARY
INTERPRETATION NUMBER 32 Mates Beach No 2,
Lot 2
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA THAT:
The administrative decision of the Planning Director in
Land Use District Map Boundary Interpretation Number 32
dated
March
9,
1989, attached and incorporated by reference,
is
hereby acknowledged, found to be in
conformance with the
standards set forth in Sec. 9.5-3(m),
Monroe County Code, and
approved.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of
Monroe County, Florida, at a regular meeting of said Board held
on the 4~day of April, A.D., 1989
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
//)/~4I/J
Mayor/Chairman
(SEAL)
AttestDANNY 1... KOLHAGE, Clerk
~;(ff-1,dl!
Cl k
HOW
L
87: t7 d II ;:JdIJ 68.
.'
~, ,
" ilj
M EMORAND U M
TO: File , Boundary Determination No. 32
FROM: Dianne Bair
DATE: March 22, 1989
SUBJECT: Board of County Commissioners Action
The Report submitted to the BOCC on March 21, 1989 was to include
lots 2 and 3. At the Hearing upon objection from the owner of
lot 3, the BOCC approved the boundary determination but excluded
lot 3.
M E M 0 RAN DUM
TO:
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
Donald L. Craig, AICP, Assoc. AlA, Assistant County
Administrator for Growth Management Division
Department: Planning
SUBJECT:B~ Determination for Mates Beach No.2, Lots 2
DATE:March 9, 1989
MEETING DATE:March 21, 1989
PLANNER:Ty Symroski
BIOLOGIST:Pat McNeese
Previous Relevant Board Action: I I ( ) Referral: Yes___No_
Commissioner's District:
Recommended Action:Move land use district boundaries to include lots 2
Jf in IS district.
Findings of Fact:
1. The designation of the above ;)roperty as Improved Subdi vi sion (I S)
rather than Suburban Commercial (SC) will be consistent wi th Section
9.5-213, Purpose of the Improved Subdivision District, and the uses
allowed within the district, Section 9.5-242.
2. The determination was made based on the following:
The zoning maps in existence before the land use plan show the
lots as RU-1.
The SCIIS boundary on th,~ maps signE:!d by Charles Pattison is
imprecise.
Lots 2 and II are the only lots designated SC in the area as a
result of a first round map amendment.
~ l' -
. --..,..-- ..~ --. - - -'
.
.
Il.
Lot 2 is a vacant, filled and disturbed upland area.
3. Analysis of the existing uses on the property and surrounding proper-
ties indicate that the essential neighborhood characteristics support
the determination to designate Lots 2 and II IS.
Action bY:___Ordinance ~_Resolution
Citizens Committee Statement:
Yes X No
Attached
Board Policy(ies) Applicable:
Planning Commission Action Taken:
Yes
Date__N.A.
Attached Documentation: X Yes No
1. Application
2. Staff Analysis
3. Current Land Use District Map
4. Aerial Photo
5. Zoning pre-1986
6. Land Use District Map effective Sept. 15, 1986 (Pattison)
7. Proposed boundary change
APPLICATION FOR LAND USE DISTRICT MAP DETERMINATION
APPLICANT
4// AI ~"f/,d~g
k
:fL~ ~ ~
~~ ~C?~ ,
~~E
~~ ~~~~
~3
PHONE # ?/c1'~f/t/'t:1
ADDRESS
KEY
?~~
MM c?? $
OCEANSIDE OR BAYS IDE?
PLAT BOOK
PAGE
~./ ;;P-..2
J?cJ
SUBDIVISION
LOT(S)
~~
BLOCK
MISC. LOCATION INFORMATION (ATTACH EXTRA SHEET IF NECESSARY)
~~~ ~~ .
REQUEST CHANGE FROM~4 ~LTO~~ ~~..o-~...!
REASON FOR REQUEST: ~ ~~ ~ ....5?'~e5 ~ ~/~
-----
~..s-/..i?~~c?~
PRESENT LAND USE: ~ A';;:::--
DESCRIPTION OF EVIDENCE SUPPORTING REQUEST:
~~ ~~ ?~/?~ ~""",""..v~
,/ . .
SIGNATURE ~ ~~~
Fee pald
DATE ~P/
/~;) j -fx; ):;,j/fn .
r Y~(Ltdi~(ZJLbtd ~. 'U~ bVliie/fWJoc~ . .
~~) ~~<9~UL--t p~) ~S2J;~
~ ,bLct&~tnd ) oJ~12h 0vYtd L(~~--4Jz"
~YYL{)l/VL~J{l) (!tL<s~~) CO~
3. C~f)uJ ~ JG~ ~w~rn. ~
4 JJjA
5 % . .
(f;,. c1ff~ - ~fvl~ ~ IS.
)J~: Lb~ '3 L~ sQ .' / / . J
I A I, j~ r-- ~ / ., - /~ J ;.YJ f LtLL112 t),--tHL~~ f
~w;rrDVj R) (j,..(}--vc.) !J - -) d - f
LX[-'\.1VLC).0(l.c~ . )
M E M 0 RAN DUM
Date: March 8, 1989
To George Garrett, Coordinator, Environmental Resources Dept.
From: Pat McNeese, Biologist, Env:~ronmental Resources Dept. "1JJ;f\ '\
1J ,j
Re Lot 2, Mates Beach No.2; Donnelly--application for bound-
ary determination
-----------------------------------------------------------------
INTRODUCTION
The applicant is requesting a boundary determination be made
concerning the referenced lot. The property is presently located
within the Suburban Commercial (SC) land use district as is the
adjacent lot to the south, Lot 3. The adjacent lot to the north,
Lot 1 is located within the Mixed Use (MU) land use district as a
result of a map amendment effective since June of 1988. Most of
Mates Beach No. 2 is included within the Improved Subdivision
(IS) land use district. The SCIIS boundary falls between Lots 3
and 4, Mates Beach No. .2. The applicant feels that his lot (Lot
2) should be located wi thin the IS district. If this were the
case, Lot 3 would also be included within the IS district.
SITE DESCRIPTION
Lot 2 is a vacant lot located within a filled and disturbed up-
land area dominated by buttonwood and Brazilian pepper trees.
The lot is located along a manmade canal. Lot 3 is also charac-
terized by filled upland and has an existing single family resi-
dence and dock.
EVALUATION
Both lots (2 and 3) appear to fit the purpose of the IS land use
district much more closely than that of the SC land use dis-
trict. They are located wi thin a platted sub(Uvision and are
filled disturbed properties. The applicant's stated intent for
the use of Lot 2 is a single family residence and there is an
existing single family residence on Lot 3. Moving this boundary
would have the effect of eliminating the SC zoning altogether
from the west side of Barry Avenue.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the IS boundary be moved from its present
location along the Lot 3/Lot 4 boundary to a new location along
the Lot 2/Lot 1 boundary where the new district boundary would
then become an IS/MU boundary.
cc: Jeanne DuBois
;,,':~~"";'"
, ..<~......~..:._.....,~~~,_._~...._" ,,' ..-.. ..'~. ',:-;r'-,~ '.~.<:::.._t,-i="""';:~~:l',\!,:,'1'It}::: "~.;~~.':l<-",
Ie
.. ~; I.>. "J"\ "
: : · I ! :: : a, ~ '\ I S '\
- ., ~~ 3 I ..!I ~ \ \
".' f \\ M ~ I 11 F I ,
I 11 1 11 1 \ ,
I I ~,
, I: ~ . . - "L;~ , . . (1 \
I \ I ,
IIIN'!' Y Rnl!. n ,,~ .
---- r- ""------~,..------_________,
II .. II ~ .. ~; or .. ~~ ,'. \ \ ... '\\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J
\ w...---~v'-~ 1\ :
\ .. \ '," \ .. , T. ,\. I r-u---------
\.. of \ \ II ~. \ \\ r - ~ MATES
\ ~$lY: \ \ :. \ \ .'. \~\ tI" ~\... sBEA~
.. \ \ H \ \ .. " ~A \\\ ~, ~
r" ',{ .. \.. -n" 10< ,~';1" i: ~ - ~1 MU
\.. ,... \~ l ..~~ i1.~\rCiift \!t ~II .
\ Ie \ II \~ .,~Ch c. \1' (,:.JI
-\- \ II \~ .. \~ Ie t~ 11 \A\ 7 - 1
· ~\~\ \ ... \~\ M ~ .. ,~ 14 ~\\~\\' /
'Ir',..', , -H<<',... .,
--(~ ~~N~~"n \ \ _ \ __ \\\.. I
:::
e
Q
~
~
-
~
~
to-
~
U
.,
.
.
.
.
~\\
- IU
~Q) .~~~--
I .
4
1
.
.
Pursuant to Ordinance 039-1987 and Rule 9J-15.006 F.A.C.,
the Monroe County land Use District Map is amended as of
June 27th,1988 and indicated above and briefly. described as:
Include lot 48 on County Rd, in IS designation.
Add East/West and North/South boundaries around lot~
/,...-e-, 3 o-Yir' . Beach. Keep previous designation of ~ C.
'- ~---(. \.. -7 (S~heets 3718~71A)
DirecTor, Growt~anagement ~
Sheet # 371 (B) Amendment # 56
N
1
I I
1-=200'
.
J .
N
A... Mlap., Monroe County, Florldll
Real Eetate Data, Inc. z.3U-> Ecltlon, 19
f 1...00' f
Pane. ., .....t# 47
AppIIe....: j)rJ ,-1/"; e-u- v
Key: ~/ Tl'Z-r-- 77J rc ff
~f Lr 3
File # PJ. -r~ JIf: LH ,# L
".e MIl,.,: 2-K
....1_.
H_ .
...:......-'......~-;'l __.=!
".\ ~
\ 'I
..-..----
~. -;-T~--- ---... T I
--'--."--'~-7, N~':"
';, "Tfj
l,.;
\ ---/
...~. ...
\ \..- ...
\ \-~7 -.--
\ ~ -::... ' .~
.. \. ..
..... : \ n'\ ,,'
-;;---. ~r-:- -..l- .. '. \}~
'" 11.----- - '- t'\ ~ ry--
., r) .. _
.- "'fIl'
,... CD
. .
~- --- ..A N}~i-
\ --=:+z.--
"'"
~ R' U { 2' 4..
.~ '~~ ~
. ~..
l,;-'J. ",' '," P f.,
'l \'~,
(
.... '
t;-;,
N
N
Monroe County Zoning Maps
Pre-September 15,1986
~ 1"=200' ~
Panel or SheetN IS":L
Applicant: p" L/,uez.c.y
Key: L/ 17Z..? 7I!i.~c#-
LQ/> 2.,,$
File" II1Af6t; t!>E/k h' /iiI? 7-
Mile Marker: '2 f
\ 1, 1".254 ~~
\
\ (L o(
\ \ ~---J
--,\
. \ \
\ \
I )
I '
I
I J
,
I (
I _ _ .....
I J' S
.'
( I'
I (
I \~1 J
I ,..J(
I
It l
~ \
.. I (
\
I "-
i
1-\-
~
j~
N
I 1"... 600' j
.c:: ,- '.-~'''w.,...,
Land Use District Maps
Monroe County, Florida
Approved by 8.0.C.C., February 28,19'86
Panel or Sheet# ~/i?fz./ Flle# .Ji.}d.l~Adl#.:l
Applicant: })oBAlezLY
Key: 1-/77Le; -77N..LII
I
+
\
L '/
-)
\~, ~,
\
~ r- .,..
1 J4\ '~
: ;:~ ~
I ..... :;.
1 ,
'/,
,
, /:
'.-;:J ~
I JR I
, t-)
- - ~ -, \
NA
t
I
~
Po,w I
I~
./
@
Mile Marker: 2?
~.~... _ .-__ ,,_nn ."._
· I ~'ll!!1 t r.! ': J t \....
t I. 1- ~ n
· \. t. I 1 I · 1'-1""'.' ., · · ~ t
~-----------~~------a~-------______
1~ 1_ ,,' 1 \. \-:.~\----------
. .. .. . . at . . ." \
ll~' · ~ , ,---------
l L1. b~. I
- .. II ........-4: I I :
~ .. II'" \ \ .. ,.' ~--: :: \\. I i - - - - - - - --
. \ . . \ . ~. \\\ _~'
. or \ .. or \ \: .', ~. ~\
p, · \ \\: \ \. \ .. \ . \\\ 11 f v.\
, . \ \ . \ \ . " . ,,\ ~- - ~
l- \. \ \ · \.. .U\.l~ t.rr.s, \'. \....:,
~.\ - \ · , · 1
~ )\ .., at Jl. ~"'~Je --~
[;? \ ~ \. \." ,,~ I. . --F ~
;-\ \~ \.. i .... II 1 ·
~-rL- \~: \:'~ : " :
~.- - 1 \ ~ , , ~1I. \
- - -. \.. - ~ ~~ --. . \ tr
\ '" \ \ I .. p~ . \ . \\ .
~-";'-1\ ;1 r \ l 1
\.. _ _ _1 L .~\ " \ , · \ \\. \.
\ \\] \ ..
\.\r-~-~ \-~.. \ ,~.,. · \ \ _ , _
...::... ~;) ~~
fit Yil' .. · "J~ l
.,
\\\
\~
\\\
\\\
\ \\
\1\
.
Pur..ft' t. leetlon '.1-24(.)(..". .f 'M .....,.. c...e, CoM,
tho lito.....".. of tho Land tlee Dlatrlct ..... .e Interpreted to be
located aa Indicated above and briefly de.crlbed _:
Delete IS/SC boundary between lots 3 and 4. Add ~J/TS
boundary between lots 1 ;md? (NO'T'F.. T.nh:::: 4h. 47. ;::mri
__ 48 added to IS previously.)
Direct.... Growth .an..ement
Sheet# 371 Key Little Torch
Date
BOCC R..otutlon
"..-.,.
s
.
-7
I
I
I
,
,
,
I
~
\
--i
I
I
,/ I
,~
-\
.
.
"::J
N
1
I I
lM.200'
-- --
J)annp JL. 1&olbage
'-
BRANCH OFFICE
3117 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY
. MARATHON. FLORIDA 33050
TEL. (305) 743.9036
CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT
MONROE COUNTY
500 WHITEHEAD STREET
KEY WEST. FLORIDA 33040
TEL. (305l 294.4641
April 13, 1989
BRANCH OFFICE
P.O. BOX 379
PLANTATION KEY. FLORIDA 33070
TEL. (305) 852.9253
.
ICERTIFIED MAIL
" RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Department of Community Affairs
Howard Building
2571 Executive Center Circle, East
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
po;1'7I?Jf-/'-.:J..
and
Department of Community Affairs
Post Office Box 990
Key West, Florida 33041
fo~1 -{ ~~ /?tJ
Gentlemen:
o
At a Regular Meeting in formal session on
April 4, 1989, the BoarB of County Commissioners of Monroe
county adopted Resolution No. 204-1989 confirming the
Administrative Boundary Interpretation of the Planning
Director in Land Use District Map Boundary Interpretation
Number 32, Mates Beach No.2, Lot 2, Little Torch Key.
Enclosed please find a certified copy of said
R~olution.
i
Very truly yours,
...
r
Danny L. Kblhage
Clerk of Circuit Court
and ex officio Clerk
Board of County Commissioners
i
"
cc: Mayor M. Puto
Commissioner E. Lytton
County Attorney R. Ludacer
County Administrator T. Brown
Asst. Co. Admin. D. Craig
File
.-~._-_.,.._- -..---.--- ..-
-.---'
.~;dN'p'ER,:.,C~mpl~te Items 1 and 2 when ad ,itlon81 sorv &sIred, and complete Items 3
Put your address In the "RETURN TO"Sp
card from being returned to you. The retu~~e r~e~~ ~vers1Uslde. ~allure to do this will prevent this
delivered to and the date of deliverv, For addlt . ~ _8 w... oravlda YOU the name of the oenon
po,tm.ster for f881 and check box (81) for addltl lon~1 f~~. tt)8 following 8ervlce. lire available. Con,ult
1. 0 Show to whom delivered date and 8ddre~'~:'!Is:rv ce I requested.
, t(Extra ChargeJt '- .-!dress. 2. 0 Restricted Delivery
3. Article Addressed to' t(Extnz charge)t
. 4. Article Number
.e,... PI.. . Q 1:)'2.
-..~ ......1.116.1.,.[\.
~ V _ \ ' Type of Service:
-;;a.c..'"'\\ ~V,...\~..- 't.a.....~..... 0 Registered
~ : ..~~ L l!.. _ _.l. 0 Certified
l::. ~ 0 Express Mail
\~~I"Q.t.: ~1,01
.
5. Signature
X
Addressee
6. Signature
X
PS Form 3811, Mar. 1987
1-....
* U.S.G.P.O. 1987-178-268
P 027 136 170
RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL
NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVIDED
NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAll
(See Reverse)
SpeCial Delivery Fee
Restricted Delivery Fee
'"
'"
0>
~
()
.
o
~
.,
c
o
'"
M
E
(;
..
<f)
0.
P 027 136 162
\Ie
RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL
NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVIDED
NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAil
D Insured
D COD
Always obtain signature of addressee
or agent and DATE DELIVERED.
8. Addressee's Address (ONL Y if
requested and fee paid)
Postage
Certified Fee
DOMESTIC RETURN RECEIPT
J
~
i!
o
l!l
E
(;
..
<f)
0.
Special Delivery Fee
Restricted Delivery Fee
.SENDER: Complete Item. 1 end 2 when eddltlon,1 ..,vle.. .r. d..lred. end campi_Item. 3
end 4. '
PUt your add,... In the "RETURN TO" ~ on th. rev... .Ide. F,lIure to dothl. will prevent thl.
c.rd from being returned to you. Th, rMU'g "'.Iraft.. WIlJoM VGU ~. na(I)8I of e. ~
dellv.red to and th. data of dallVrV, or td "fen. ...,w:o ...."..tvIMt-.... avillhIb" CONU t
postm..t.r for f... end check box ..) for addltlONI ..rvloet,) requ, . .
1. 0 Show to whom delJverftt, dete, end .ddr....... .ddr... 2. t:It,~_rlC1ed~~v...Y
t(Extrdcharge)t '_ t~.tNDIwI,...t
3. Article Addressed to: ~ Number
:peA (j ~/!J" I~O
c TYpe 01 Service:
~6'" (/I-t:-Ia :Eo;< 99 () DFf~ D In,ured
~Cortlfled DCOD
K~'f ttJt 6'r/ tt-. ~&:1'1 / E_Mail
IWIIY' oo"ln Ilgnature of ..-
egont and DATE OJ'qVEAED.
5. Signature - Addressee . Addr_', Addr... (.ONL Y It
X requmed .nd tee p, d)
6. Signature Agent L/II~
X~'(Y\.~
7. Date of ~verY _ ~
-IE,
PS Form 3811, Mar. 1987
* U.S.Q.P.O. 1817-178-211
DOMESTIC AETURIt RECEIPT