Resolution 283-1986
Board of Appeals
RESOLUTION NO. 283-1986
RESOLUTION REVERSING THE DECISION OF THE
ZONING BOARD OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA AND
GRANTING THE REQUEST OF HAMLIN BEATTIE AND
JOE HUDSON OF BAY COLONY VILLAS TO REVERSE
THE DECISION OF THE ZONING BOARD OF MONROE
COUNTY, FLORIDA WHICH DENIED A FINDING OF
FACT APPROVAL TO HAMLIN BEATTIE AND JOE
HUDSON OF BAY COLONY VILLAS.
WHEREAS, on June 26, 1986, the Zoning Board of Monroe
County, Florida, denied a finding of fact approval to build
within the Shoreline Protection Zone on the property described in
Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made a part hereof.
WHEREAS, Hamlin Beattie and Joe Hudson of Bay Colony Villas
have duly appealed said decision to the Board of County Commis-
sioners of Monroe County, Florida, sitting as the Board of
Appeals and the Board having reviewed the transcript of the June
26, 1986, hearing, and having considered argument of all parties
wishing to speak on the matter, and all premises considered, now
therefore,
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA, sitting as the Board of Appeals, as
follows:
1. That the June 26, 1986, decision of the Zoning Board of
Monroe County, Florida, denying a finding of fact approval to
build within the Shoreline Protection Zone be, and the same is
hereby, reversed for lack of competent substantial evidence for
said denial by the Zoning Board, in that the Zoning Board failed
to consider the existence of a second navigable channel accessi-
ble to the applicants' property.
2. That Hamlin Beattie and Joe Hudson of Bay Colony Villas
be, and it is hereby, granted a reversal of the decision of the
Zoning Board of Monroe County, Florida, denying their request for
a finding of fact approval to build within the Shoreline Pro-
tection Zone on the above-described property.
3. That the Clerk is hereby directed to forward a certified
copy of this Resolution by certified mail, return receipt
requested, to the Field Representative of the Department of
Community Affairs, P.O. Box 990, Key West, Florida 33041.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of
Monroe County, Florida, sitting as the Board of Appeals, at a
regular meeting of said Board held on the 17th day of September,
A.D., 1986.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA,
AS THE BOARD OF APPEALS
By ~..."-~~,,.,-.:\\_~
Mayor a~rman
(SEAL)
A ttes t : DANNY L. KOLHAGE, Clerk
--I2L(Ef~C
APPROVED AS TO FORM
r'D. tAL SUFFICIENCY.
fJ)' _______ .~
. '----.."..", ~
..-rr;'
~ ' "
(
,.e
.(
'~:'''' ~~::s .~...' '..~
Jt-''''' ., .~~..- "t'~:'llo!.'''',.' ',.
'.'", l!,;.' "~11' '
"~ ..' " '.' '" 'l~ ",~
, . ..' '. t..1 .!',~ "
" ,
, ~
'Tf' ~A~_~t.inued
--
... ...-
.... ~.: '~'~")'\o\'" "1' '" ~ ~... ."" '., . · ~ J""
---
.,...., '- . ~. . ,-
~..,~.,..-.-,.-,--
. .--
R' E~' ~I' [i, ~~I r;;n iY', ,~
..~ . ~ 1 r.l . f.J . ~ !-,
. I ~.'.., irt. ~. ~ :~ !-oj ;'.~
...t 7;, t?) M~ r! ~1
, ~;':l :', ;j ;".1 ~l <j:f
~ all~, r.J :....oI:i ':-'1>
'. ,
~(fi.'
~~f 918 '^Cl2250
F,XHIBIT A
FEB J ~ 1986
MO".IF'(I~ r::)U,'.JTY
ZONH'H~ GOARD
The h,lIow~'1 d.."lbed porllon of iuct I ..cordlna ~Ypl" 01 '~b' c;Lv!
rl1v1.1on oll.ota 3 And 4 on Upper .....tecwnbp I<ey. Monroe t':'fJvnt,.
J"lorlda, at i'cco~ d~d In Pl.' 800" 1, .t P.'. S9. of th., PubUc Recol'4.
of Monrol'l CO\.1nty. Florida: ·
-,~ '
..
.
f'rom lh, Ir.Ltrudlon 01 the North......utuly rlght-or-way Un. of the
_ . ,On J. ! r a..,,):? .h,!" ~ Y -'~~~.!- ~oa~ _~~,'. ~.)'. and the divl dinl.l~n4 bdwl:eD
.. ... - .. - .. .
7,.c" , .nd 8 ac.,~orcllnl to the &loulald f,1at Hc=nraed In Plat Book 1.
ra(C ~9, rW\ SoulS 4.. 11' ~O" We.l .lon. ..Id NOlt)...utel'ly ,,'.ht-oI-
",..a)' line a dlllanee o' il" 53 fut to the rulnt :). ':.oee1nnl'n', of thh m.'..
And 1:.W\.:h dt.crlpLlon; thence cor,llnue South 44- 11' 30" Wed alO1'1
.aJd Nc.~lhwClLcrl)' 7llht-ot-~'ay Un. a dhlance of ~CJO feet to th.
~l"i(Hnl Un. brl","cen 7.r~ch I and 9 accordinl to .ald pbt: thenc(o
Nt,rlb 39.47' ,We-t -.10111 .~d cllvldlnallne to the .ho'"l of the Ba, ·
Ilvrlda; tbthc;e n:eWldcrlnl .~d .hordlne 01 the B..y or Florida A &
N(,.rll..ulrrly dlrccllon.. cU.tane. of 200"eet, more or I.... to a
rdnt or !nlerHc.t1on with a lIn. which be.r. North 39. 47' "e.t rram
VII' roint ot btJllnr,ll'l~: then,e South 39. 47' Ea.t alonl ...14 lift. to the
I'tllnt of br-,lnnlnf.' D~ln," tract of land 20(\ leet on Sta'e lto",No. I
1n hla.mc:,rada, J'lorlda. and ..pprodrnately "00 fut to Bay of Flol".&'
toCclhu w1\b all r lllulan diM" pertalnlna w.lo the .ame.
.,
I
~ ' ,; f:""
:;'r~~' ,
. '. ~
, .
.' " .~.
l --
J
1-'
I 'J
.'
,.
ALSO:
^ r'uc~\ of II.l\,n,t:Jaed land In FlorI". Bay In Section 3%. To-.,.2al,
iJ) Soutn, Ran,. J1 E..t, Upper Matecumbe K.y, MODl'o. c..ty,
Florid., more l'uUcularly ....CI',,~.. .. 'oU....
",'j
,"
'{J
'~
~'
,J
, ..~
'r.~'
:,t~
...
1#-';...
: ~~.' ."
< '
~ .
f'rom tbe Intc,'l,ctlon 01 the tllrictlnllln. betwe.n Tracu.... 9
&.Jld the Nor'hwe 'luly "J,M-of-wa, U". of Stat. I\oa. th. I, an
.. .hown em PlIt of Subdi"l';'on 0{ Lol. , and 4. of Plat ..-It 1,
Pal' 41, . aid 5'.Jb41vhlo ' Pbt "eln, recorded In Pt., ao.k a, at
Pal. ~q, Publlc Ihcor4. ,,( Me'''" County. Flo~h5a. ....... Nor&J.
39 dpar... Z)' ,'\')" w..t a\on, .a'. cUvldln, line. a dl.lanca of
o48!1 f.u l, more cr 1.... to U.. m.... Mila tld. line on the ,,,.,, ..
F I"rida Bay &nlj Ole point of bc.lnnlnl. of the pArcel "erebaan..~
de.crlb.d; lh~n':' Nortb 50 d..r....%l. 20" We.t, a dhtanc. of
2ll. ~ hel; theree Nortb 61 d.,u.. )1'10'1 Ea.t. . dllt.DCI of
1 U. 5 lut: thue. South :H de.r... 2" Ea.t. a dht~c. of 1".4
fcrt, more or 1ell, to u.. .ald mU~n hI.h tld. Une: thene.Sont".
w&l~ClI)' me an"'''' In. ..Id mean hll" Ud. Une. a dhtanc. of 100
h,t, more or '.... '0 tb. polnt of be.lnn,n..
Curlhlnina O. tn aer"'. more or 1.... and lylnl ancl belnlla u..
Cowlly of M oru 0', In ..ld Stat. of Flo,lda.
I
!
SAVING Alld E XCEPTlNCi THI:.REFRC1\.4 tbat pOl'tJon of.&14
.,.,l.:",,!,:rd ,..,,1, ',uth.for. Cl>nv.y..~yM. D. SIc!.l'luI, a
.1111'. man, ./.11 "an'or. to THE &TATE or FLORIDA. a.
f r ."h., by Qui' ClaLm nud ~.cord..4 In Offld.1 Itecol'. 411,
at ..A&CI 1t3 ."d '64, Morlro. County, Florida Public Racerd..
,....1 :iUDJ1:CT TO .11 'C'lc:rvlltlon. .. ct)nhlnc:d within Tru.te..'
Il'r~ Jrr""'''! III ()fflri..l J\r(orr111)~r:IKC: ".14. Munroe County.
..,,,' "l.' .,.-.._-:,"),._
':::,;':' .'>( , '~'~, . .: ',';':- ~- . ""~:" ::;'. .": )<
.J'
l'Lt,..' . "..~.'. . /:.. .
, .. .' .....
,I' . .
".. ....: ~ .'. -,!,," :
.. . . . I ~..... , t .