Resolution 671A-1988
to<
Planning Director
RESOLUTION NO. 671A..1988
A RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE ADMINISTRATIVE
BOUNDARY INTERPRETATION OF THE PLANNING
DIRECTOR IN LAND USE DISTRICT MAP BOUNDARY
INTERPRETATION NUMBER 20. Mates Beach No.2. Lts 46 and 47
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
The administrative decision of the Planning Director in Land
Use District Map Boundary Interpretation Number
20
dated
November 28. 1988
attached and incorporated by reference, is
hereby acknowledged, found to be in conformance with the
standards set forth in Sec. 9.5-3 (m), Monroe County Code, and
approved.
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of
Monroe County, Florida, at a regular meeting of said Board held
on the
6
day of
DQ~'iillR1H;~r
, A.D., 1988.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By .#ff~#/~
Mayor/Cha~rman
(SEAL)
Attest:
3 II ..."
<<:) 0 ,.-
z: )> rr1
::II ;z \:::l
o(""")~.. ~
r'"
r'1 :x''''. ."
(""") r~ ,:::J
Or; - ::.0
c:: - "7' 'lO
z:;:() c> :;t:)
....; .'- -0 ..,.,
:-< (-:, , "'" I"")
~ . . 0
r - :::0
~'t"<;, "'" 0
~~~f,J)r.
,1ppnOVEfJ AS TO FOfi:t:,
"ND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY.
,o&~~~
Attorney' Office r--~
RW/jh
.'
M E M 0 RAN DUM
TO:
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
Donald L. Craig, AICP, Assoc. AlA Assistant County
Administrator for Growth Management Division
Department: Planning
by: Jeanne DuBois
SUBJECT: Boundary Determination for Mates Beach No.2, Lots
46 and 47
MEETING DATE: December 6, 1988
Previous Relevant Board Action: 8/27/87 ( ) Referral: Yes____No~
Commissioners District
Recommended Action:Move the ISjNA district boundary in order to in-
clude Lots 46 and 47 of Mates Beach No. 2 in the Improved Subdivision
(IS) land use district.
Summary of RequestjReport On August 27, 1987, the Board of County
Commissioners approved a map change in the first round of amendments for
Lot 48 of Mates Beach No.2, from NA to IS. Lots 46 and 47 are immedi-
ately adjacent to Lot 48 and of substantially the same character, being
upland, scarified lots in a Monroe County approved subdivision known as
Mates Beach No.2.
Action bY:___Ordinance x Resolution
Citizens Committee Statement
Yes___No x
Attached
Agreement/Contract - No.
Approved by County Attorney as to LegalitY___Yes___N.A.
Standard Form
Approved by Risk Management___Yes___Not Applicable
Approved by Office Fiscal Management
Funding Source
N/A
Current Year Cost
Annual Cost
Budgeted___Yes___No
Will Proposal Require Additional Personnel?
--1L-No
If Yes State Number
Permanent___ Temporary___ Other
Board Policy(ies) Applicable
Planning Commission Action Taken~Yes5/26/87Date____N.A.
Alternatives:Allow the lots to remain in the Native Area which is
inconsistent with the purpose of the NA district which is to protect
undisturbed, natural areas. These are disturbed, upland lots.
Attached Documentation x Yes No
1/
.,
1
,~,;._._,;,
.,/.,--;.,:\.;:;;:,~,.' ".' .'.
r~.i\ '....."'.... <; .
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
November 28, 1988
TO:
Monroe County Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
Donald Craig
RE:
Boundary Determination for Mates Beach No.2,
Lots 46 and 47
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Background:
Lots 46 and 47 of Mates Beach No. 2 are currently in a Native
Area (NA) land use district. The owners of lots 46 and 47 wish a
boundary determination so that a single family residence may be
developed on these two lots. The lot adjacent to the west, Lot
48, was changed from NA to IS in the first round of map
amendments.
Recommendation:
Move the IS/NA district boundary to include lots 46 and 47 in
the Improved Subdivision (IS) land use district.
Alternatives:
Allow lots 46 and 47 to remain in the NA district which would
require the property owners to purchase TDR's in order to develop
a single family home on these scarified upland lots, and would be
inconsistent with the purpose of the NA district which is to
protect undisturbed, natural areas.
Findings of Fact:
1. The designation of the above property as Improved Subdivision
(IS) rather than Native Area (NA) will be consistent with the
purpose of the Improved Subdi vi sion Di strict, Section 9.5-213,
and the uses allowed within that district, Section 9.5-242.
2. The determination was based on the following:
These two lots are at the end of a road, with canals on
the east and south. The lot immediately adjacent to
these lots, Lot 48, was changed from NA to I S in the
first round of map amendments.
On the zoning maps in effect before the land use plan,
Lots 46 and 47 are shown as RU-1.
,f
, . ,.,.~
..,-;;." ~- "f1(j'f :."
On the land use maps signed
effective September 15, 1986,
imprecisely drawn but appears
the NA land use district.
by Charles Pattison,
the NAilS boundary is
to include these lots in
Lots 46 and 47 are no different from Lot 48, being
upland, scarified lots in the same approved subdivision.
A biologist from the Environmental Resources Department
made a site visit on November 16, 1988, and concluded:
"These two lots can properly be changed environmentally
from NA to IS as they are upland disturbed lots."
3. Analysis of the
surrounding properties
characteristics support
above property as IS.
existing uses of the property and the
indicate that the essential neighborhood
the determination to redesignate the
Attachments:
1. Application (With Proof of Fee Payment)
2. Biologist's Approval
3. Current Land Use District Map
4. Approved Amendment #56
4. Aerial Photo
5. Pre-1986 Zoning Map
6. Land Use District Map effective Sept. 15, 1986 (Pattison)
7. Proposed boundary change
, ,,'~~ .-...J
APPLICATION FOR LAND USE DISTRICT MAP DETERMINATION
APPLICANT
Ronald L. Barton
PHONE #745-3223
ADDRESS
Rt 3, Box 316
Big Pine Key, FL
KEY
Little Torch Key
MM 29
OCEANSIDE OR BAYSIDE?
Bayside
SUBDIVISION Mates Beach No. 2
PLAT BOOK
3
PAGE
80
BLOCK
LOT(S) 46, 47
MISC. LOCATION INFORMATION (ATTACH EXTRA SHEET IF NECESSARY)
~t end of County Road
REQUEST CHANGE FROM
NA
TO
IS
REASON FOR REQUEST:
To build a single family home. Lot
48 changed to IS in first round of Map Amendments.
PRESENT LAND USE:
Vacant
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Monroe County, Florida Nf! 4 4 7 8 9 5
~::~~::: ~~~13tJc~::~=::~:==:~::=~~~~~::~:I=~}L.1_________n__ 19 ~
Fo::~-'4t-r~1Dr~~---e~0~[~f-:n----- $ -_______Jff(L:____=~ ·
~---------&--tfi(JI. 'I ';-r ~ $
.Q~ "21FI :115------ 7-;-~g-----------------l/6-~--- ---12--------------- ----------------------------------------
. -- ---~------ --~ ---- ---- -~-- - ---- -- ---- -------- -- --------- -- ---- --- ---- - -- - - .i__ ___ _. __ ________ __ __ $ ______ n_ __ __ __ ___ _______ ____ ___________
~A..---------..----------------.-.-- OFFICER {JD · - /11' ,
BJ~___________________________________.__________ TOTAL $ ::::::::l::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::..... .......... ..... ...~'..
.,.. ..">,,,-,"~
" \)
, f
~/(. ~- .....!..A-,) L--:1' '-" (
I,. ..... J .
I
L,::~- ,1 II '.,'
>~ ',vL, ~~
)- ~. .. ~
;
~ ~ (,
(7./.' ::-/?_ t::: '- ~/
c:- '\r'
T.'
'- i ~....~.-~ ,.J
. !.()
/-,) 1--' I '-(17i/-'t-:;,L 14LL/
, ',"-, ~< <.\ ~~
\ ~, "1 :-....... -., _ ~ ) \ /
L'!;L -1"'-/..1 /I (\ ,'V" /, U L;::,-)I)
\'
""BIOlOGIST RfCDMMBlOSz.ti~U~:';L* /(/6 ~
AS PER -Of CDUm .." t/'j;b~
- - r-
t - 1",' (~'-
}L-:/1-
I
~
I
----j
I
I
i
---1
I
-J~
Ji
~i
,-
----<-
~
I
I
~
I
~
~
---
ft
.
ft
.
.
at
.
'\
11 _\
.. ... ,1.711 \
. I...."
· .!:. ."" 7 I.. >. "'_
: :;: :~~III:: :~~~
· .!c · · .,..~ i. ..!I; \
· · U 4 ^ ~'" ~.' I rUM ... f~~ 11 ~ I I
· ~.. 8'~ '~~rUl.'=" I II 11 1- - 11 1
~~\1 0) .\J"I1. YU,-~, I' 1M LJUI!!
\W ,,- I -..II
,,, ...,
.
11
.
It
.
Ie
,
.
1
.
,...---------
N
f
I 1"-200' ~
'~
I~
"c,j
: ,: J · '\ IS""
· · ~ ! '\ " 1
M ~r ~ \ ~ '
~ ,
\' a , '" ~
YUC:;u, .. -r.JU'!.,.;;; , I
I I · · ~ I '. I 'J'
· \ J L
I :nTIN'T'Y or n.")
----- or- :l------~~-----__________~
..I u .. " .. ..~~ ,. J ~ ' \.. \~,~ - - - -- - - - - - -- :~
I \ :~ I ' \ ~ , . .. -: - - - - - - - - -- - - -I
\ .....- --~V. 1\ : ~
\ H \ ~,\.. \ .. \( , \\.. 1:-------------.
\ H \ \ of \ \ .. ~t~. \\\~r l -~, ~1ATES '
~. \ 11_ ....LY.. \ \ .. \"i . \ ,\" ~. BEACH
j ~ ..~\\ .. \\\ ': \ '. \\\" 0\ S ~ ~
\ \ H, '0 \ .. \ I . ~ Ii \ '? _ ~ ~ R
\ \ II \ \ II \. " cl \.S':1tJ 1 ~ \ to : MU n
· \ \ \ , '~Ii\ I~ " \~\. r "': g
~--; \: \0\ :. l~; :,u ~{: 1 . ~ 1 j,"l
~ \.. \ ~I II I: ~ II YiI .. ';. .\ , .
.1 .. 'fa M ~\, I
,,' \\ \ 11 1 ~ 14 ~ I~\ I
" '~\(C[\'\ N l \ . \\f ~
" - f H ~ ~'" t:o~ n n \ u \ \ _ \ '\.. I
i'. tl ., - 1 . >
:' .:r1"~~
;!. I"~' · U
-' cC _
i ~ · H If . _.;
H ~ , ~Jil ~6' f "; :!l
fOI ~ 1~~~l1.\'SU I I
,~~ I
I I U I
o \.' IS ' I
I
I
'tI ~
I
Pursuant to Ordinance 039-1987 and Rule 9J-15.006 F.AC.,
the Monroe County Land Use District Map is amended as of
June 27th,1988 and indicated above and briefly' described os:
Include lot 48 on County Rd. in IS designation.
Add East/West and North/South boundaries around lot~
~ 3 of/;r ,.... Beach. Keep previous designation of ~ C.
~~ 'C - (seA sheets 371, 371A)
'" ~.~ · -:/ I-\vJofft:-~/"8H
DireCTor, Growt~onagement 00 e
Sheet # 371 (B) Amendment # 56
t
I I
1.=200'
.,
N
1--100' j
Aerial Maps, Monroe County, Florida
Real Estate Data, Inc. 23RJ.l Edition, 198'
Pllne' 01 She.t# il7
App'lcant: P>ar--~IJ
Key: I--i tf-~, tvrch
I" ~ </(, f-l.J7
File # (!J4rr~ ~!,q{fJt1JP..{
MUe MIIrker: 2 f'
,. ., - - ~- - r- - - - - I ; , ! i 'i ~ ".
\ .NA \-- i - -. _OJ r-T (-', - c:- "
{",: r-, l,r- . r--"~ "t- -:-~,.J\ ~
\.1.\, ,: 1'~S" ,\
'\ \\ \ II i ~,. \ , '. \ _ ',__...
\~~ U"-~ --:--.y /"', '\ \ '8' t'''''-'''',
I \ / I \'. ,'- "', !
\ ',\ '\ \- I
/\, I ~, \ I.' .. i, 1., "'.
}'-- "\'~--=---~-4 .;' \'4~
~ . ,
i
.
\
\ \,
\
I
I
I
I
1 ( \
'--- \
: /~,~p
I /
I '
1 \ ~,I
l' j<' /J
1 I I
" !
I
;1 l
<:'
~ I
\
~
~
\ /
. ~
J ...?
','- ~
~
."
N
f 1":z 600' ~
(
I
'-;,-,\ .
''>0(' ;,
1 ..~, -r ~
I
I
.....1
, ,
I----,~ I
I
--'
/
/
, I
l._ /
,
NA
\
\
1- -,~-\
, !b...
! UfiM 1 _,.
{ --~ -\ \
'i,- ('~
I (--~~
,) ,'J-,.~O'-'#-; ~
. .~ ~ ;.....J -, ,
?51 Ulr-T~[
." ,..... r~, __'"/ '. \
..... \ ~ ' : -"'. ;
I V...I '''')\:'":;. - -
~'
i "' .
lti
\ \\
~
:-
~ \}It'''Irrrof'f
~,
~r
I
Land Use District Maps
Monroe County, Florida
Approved by B. O. C. C. ,
Panel or Sheet# -212.f2.l__.
Applicant: ~/1
Key: L~f{-/e1b~__
, ,
@
February 28,1986
~h ~ tt 2
File II 1M T~~; ?:,c --tfC' II/th' =2..
Mile Marker: 1---$
~ . ~,~ 1 L..J.AL 'J
\]: I -- I.., ~oJ"f' .:J~ ~ , _.. T'" ,.' ~' \. Jr'lT..,:J i.. I
-" ; ~ 'It I' !. , ~ ..,;\ ~ _ :.. ~ ,
I ~ ..Q' , ~.... ~' ' ~' I. . I~ '" f!.. :- ,l:> '":; i(,\ ~ '-7
' -.1l ,.. - .... . oJ I'.S) j I' ~~. I" ~ '. ~ I. _, \ ,.._ _ '_' _ ___,.
~ I ,- ,~~... -.. " :'" ,~- -:- I- _~',
j ~-..Lc1~~"'-. \'- ", - . \~ ~ >. i
~ - !I'l ~ 'I \ '''J.~"" ~ V-.:.. - \'- -';'""\ ~ \,~--" .l.' " ~, ~_~..
ta.CIot : - ~ . , ij n\' ~ \ 'Z ""~,\ ~ ~ \ _ l \. ','
L~' .-:1,;~ ~ \?-c!~ 'i \"v~~:\ ~-~- h ~.~"""I.. "-.L~l:.
~ ~ .., ~ III \' u.. I' . '.
~ r'J ~ ~ t& ;. \ f:"" ~\... ,a ~ 1 \ ~-.I vi I, ~ _ ~ 'rJ,
- fII U.llll' 0 \... \ t-""\ ... ~ _ _~ \ \.. I
":... "'_.l~~\' ~ ..... ~:\ ',;, \ \~':;~ . _~__ fj1..._~~. -~~:l.
...." ,. \ \. ~ Mtt: ,l"'"'" .. \ \ .,., · 'OJ" .., .~, - . i
,.,j~., ~~ ~~. ~-\"\Oil \~ \'6~\' ~ t i\~~-O~I
... y ... ~~~" ,. ~\ 1m \. ~ \ () \.Y!: l1<l' '; 1~ J"'\. ::'l
':;' i. ~~ \ \. ~ \!'II':.. ~\~\. ~ \,\{.;:::J L"~ \Y;;. \ ,', '1
.'.("- I 7Lil' _ ~~,., ').. ~ \Z,\~~,~. ':. ~ _ ~ _ r---il
· · ::.i\t;! 0,. ~1t\"Z~ r 't:. I \" ~ ~ \ ~ J
~ , =a .1 .~~ \ \0 \. CS j'~ ~_ ~~~
~ · l' \ - \ S \ \i.,:'\ ~. ~ \ \ \'-'. ~ i1
C) t. K. ~ \ \a ~ \,~... \ \s ~ 1 \~ ~ \ ~ ~
o a. ~ ~\ \. c; \ \ "'f ~ ~ · ~ \ ~'JJ. ~1 ~
~ .. i.~ ~\ ,~\ \\ J~. \- " \ ~J A ~ ~
r It- ';, J.J i {~-: \ \ """ ~~ ~ tl \. ~ ~ , .' J
~ \' j ~ N ""\, ~ e. ~I"
~ \\ l' . \ 'l& \ \l2.~. . ~ \ ~ \11
- .- ~\~ \-~\. ~y)!i
j
./
" It
.
N
f
Monroe County Zoning Maps
Pre-September 15,1986
@I........
"
'4 ~'
""
I
I
J
~ 1"-ZOO' ~
Panel or Sh..t# is')..,
Applicant: t3t:.'....I-frn
Key: ~ it+l,y n ryl,
1,(/11- 96.. 't;t
Flle# .41.4-,1"'-'$ 6',; AI,!;L
Mil. Marker: 'Z.t
.. ... I I 11
III I
.. ~. -El,7 I 11 ~
~ JI I a:
: ~ : : :, .:i
ell( .. ell(
. II () . _ ~\': ~.' f u;' ,
I ~n n t6\'~ ~~~Ult II I 11 1 11
I/' .\1"'1 r---' Y t .~ .. L AMI
.....n..\1 nIB I II I
~ \IV _
1 D ~.I LI. 1 I 1 I I . I' I 7 . .
. 111. . I \
~----------~~,------QW~-----~
~.. 1 ~ I ~~\ \\. "
N .. .. ., It II II 11 .J" .. .7 .. \t 1 ~
-'I~." ~_ \1
\~. - \' M
CANAL ---.. ---~, l\
~ ~ \ .. \ \.. \ H \ \.. \ .. \. \ . \\
n\ 1a7 \ .. \ \ .. \ .. \ \ .. \ I h
I ~ \ .. \~\ 17 \ \ . \ If \ \ .. \ \ . \ \\ .
~ I \ ~ \ ~\ \ 17' .. \ a \ 7 \ \~
;( : \ g. \ 1U ~\ .. , ., \ . \ \
· \~ \ 1M \ H \ .. \ \ H \ \ .. ~ . = \ '
I \''1 .. \ ,.\ III \ \ .. \\ .. j~ .",," ""'~ ~\
· \ ~ \ .. '~\h \.., '. n ,! ..~~~ ,1\.11;" -I I
" II
. .,
. ..
. . .
>
-
r - I
. 17 -
.
. .. I
.
. II
I 14
I II
1
D
-------.
1
11
II
11
11
.
. 11
7 11
I 17
I ,.
4 .
I M
.~
II~
Pw.utInt to Section 9.5-24(aH2Hh) of the Monroe County Code,
the boundarle. of the land U.e DI.trlct Map are Interpreted to be
located a. Indicated above and briefly de.crlbed aa: rvQue TC:/Nl'\
.
boundary as shown to include Lots 46 and 47 in IS land use
district. Lot 48 included in IS on Map Arrendrrent errata sheet.
II
11
11
.,
..
.,
11
.
.
.
7
I
.
Director, Growth Management
She.t # 171 Key Little 'Ibrch
Date
BOCC R..olutlon
"
\
~\
~ ~ \
!I i \
~ I I
"-
r
1
.
.
I
..J _
~
(
c
r
'"
11
.
N
1
I t
1"= 200'
. ", .....
';j"
~".'"
_.; ;L-", :.:. '~" . ',';:
... '..-:: ;~... '-."".",,"
"""''''-~4' ',.