Resolution 282-1982
RESOLUTION
282 -1982
WHEREAS, the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE COUNTY,
FLORIDA, has received an application from ROBERT WILL
and
WHEREAS, in compliance with State Statute, it is necessary
as part of the permitting procedure to read the following Biological
Assessment into the Record as follows:
The applicant proposes to construct a rock retainer wall along the
shoreline of a residential lot. Total length of the proposed wall
would be 160 feet, involving approximately 225 cubic yards of rock
and backfill.
Although the location of the retaining wall relative to the shore-
line is somewhat unclear, it would appear that the applicant is
proposing to fill slightly past the approximate MLW line. It is
estimated that approximately 175 cubic yards of rock and fill would
be placed below the approximate MHW line (with approximately 50 ~
cubic yards of fill placed above the approximate MHW line). The
applicant claims that 100 of the 225 cubic yards used will be rock.
The purpose of this project is to prevent further erosion of the
applicant's property.
The waterbody adjoining the applicant's shoreline was created from
low, mangrove-dominated wetlands in the late 1950's or early 60's.
The uplands in this area were created through dredge spoil deposi-
tion.
Most of the shoreline in this area that have been left undisturbed
since initial dredging and spoiling have been revegetated with red
mangroves (Rhizophora mangle). Those shoreline where mangroves
have not been allowed to come back, (where cutting of the fringe
has occurred), display erosion, due to the soft, fine-textured marl
sediments that comprise the existing upland shorelines.
Seagrasses are found in combination with algaes over the shallower
shoreline ledges of this canal/lagoon system. Macrophytic growth
is limited over the bottom of this system, due in great part to
the somewhat "milky" transparency of these waters, caused by the
marl sediments.
The property adjacent to the applicant's (to the west) has been
bulkheaded slightly above the approximate MLW line. The adjacent
property to the southeast is undeveloped, displaying a mangrove
fringe along its shoreline. This general area (Sombrero section of
Marathon) has been subject to accelerated housing construction in
recent years, with development estimated at !40 percent of available
lots.
The applicant's upland property drops sharply at the erosion
(escarpment) line, forming a shoreline which drops in a gradual
manner to offshore depths. Sea purslane (Sesuvium portulacastrum)
has become established at the erosion line, while one or two button-
woods (Conocarpus erecta) and white mangroves (Laguncularia racemosa)
are established above the approximate MHW line at the base of the
escarpment.
" Resoiution
Robert Will
Page Two
Further waterward, within the intertidal zone, a previously
existing red mangrove fringe has been cut, with only root nubs
remaining. The distance from the erosion line to the waterward
extend of the intertidal zone (extreme low water line) is
approximately 30 feet. Green algaes (Penicillus sp.) and turtle-
grass (Thallasia testudinum) are found at this point and continue
waterward over the shallow, shoreline ledge.
Within the intertidal area itself, green algae (Batophora sp.) and
horn shells (Batillaria sp.) were observed.
Stabilization of this shoreline should have positive affect on
water quality and, to a lesser extent, the biota in the immediate
area, due to the elimination of erosion and consequential turbidity
and sedimentation.
Any filling done waterward of the approximate MLW line will eliminate
established submergent benthic biota.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MONROE
COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the above Biological Assessment has been
read into the record and duly considered pursuant to Florida
Statute 253.124 by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe
County, Florida, this
1st
day of November
, 19 82
at a regularly scheduled meeting.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
MONR UNTY, FLORIDA
c: /1 /I.. 17
By ~~ c... e(..J ~.--.., 1,,/
~ '.~ I
Mayor
(Seal)
Attest: RALPH II.' 'l~r,~.~Tr ,,~~~Y
n VI \,j~ U~ i.!., t;~:L.'d\
~"'~ IY\P~,O.~.
Cs Clerk
~
BY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Wilhelmina Harvey, District 1
Curt Blair, District 2
Mayor Protem Jerry Hernandez, Jr., District 3
MA YOR George E. Dolezal, District 4
Ken Sorensen, District 5
Luci.en C. Proby
Monroe County Attorney
310 Fleming Street
Key West, Florida 33040
~z~ ?=;:;!.J'~:~~:~}l~~1
OK~y~r; ~R~~E~E
1305l 2944641
OFFICE Uf:
Director
Building, Planning and
Zoning
P.O. BOX Room 205 Wing I
Public Service Buildin'
5825 Jr. College Rd. W
Key West, Florida
33043-4399
I, the undersigned, do hereby attest that all date and
information is complete in the package of the applicant as follows:
Certificate of Complete Enclosures
1.
County Biologist Report
2.
Resolution (ROBERT WILL)
3.
Permit
4.
Application for Permit (Proposed Seawall)
5.
Site Plan
6.
Location Map
7.
DER Assessment
Date I~- jf!-g:J-
/Dl1E'~~!?\f\11?~
ilJ{JE.&i'"'' "~I '"' .,) 1
L!.w,'
OCT 18 1982 .'"
COUNTY {r"""
nl I Y.
~./
t/
r/
v
v
v
V
t/
By qnq-tJ
J
I
o E PAR T MEN -T A l
It ~l31{.y
COR RES P 0 N 0 ENe t
SUBJECT:
nATE: Sep~emb~ 14, 1982
Will, Rob~ G. and Alice M; P~opo~ed Seawall
TO: Alan Lu~l~, Vbr..ec~o~ DEPT~lU.i.d.i.ng, Plann).ng and ZOrUng
-
FROM:~~M~k L. Rob~on, Env~on. Biol'OEPTflanrUng and ZOrUng
LEGAL: Section 15, Tow~hip 66S, Range 32E, Boot Key
Walo~~ Subd.i.v~ion, Lo~ 15, Block G
ZOrUng: RU-l
INrROVUCTION:
T~ appuca.tion ~ ~o be ~eviewed by .the- Bo~d 06 Coun~y COIrmi..Mion~
puMuant ~o Sec.tion 19-117 (aj (5j, M d p~opo~u ~o depMd MU below
mean /Ugh wat~.
VISCUSSION:
The appuca~ p~opo~e :to co~.:tJtuc:t a 160 une~ 600:t (by 4 6eu /Ugh)
~p~ap ~eawall. 60~ ~he p~po~e 06 ~ho~eUne ~tabiUza.Uon. App~o>uma.:tely
175 cubic YMM 06 6ill will be placed below ~he p~uent MHW une, 06
w/Uch 100 + cub~c y~d6 will be ~p~ap bould~ (~he volume 06 6~
~peu6ied on :the Coun~y p~d appucation appeaM ~ be incoMectJ. The
~eawall and 6ill. w.<.Lt beabou:t 7S 6eet ~eaw~d 06 ~he pJtuent MHW line,
covvu.ng pMt 06 :the in.:te.ilidal and ~ubtidal ~hel6.
A ~de v~d ind.i.c.ated that ~he CUMen:t ~ho~eUne, compo~ed 06 Mne maJr1.
~ed.i.menU, ~ und~going ~o~ion. The wat~ hnmed.i.ately o66~ho~e WM
~~bid due :to :the WMhout 06 ~ho~eUne matvu.al. Th~e WM no ~ign).Mcan:t
mang~ove vegeta..t.<-on, evidence ind.i.cated ~hat ~ed mang~ovu have been
ele~ed along :the ~ho~eUne. I~ ~hould be no:ted :tha~ :th~e ~ no ~eco~d
:that a County Land Cle~big Pvun.U. WM ~~ued 60~ ~~ activdy, M ~equbr..ed
by Sec. 18-18(b). SpCVL6e patchu 06 algae and ~eag~M~U we~e 60und gnow-
ing about 6 6eet ~eaw~d 6~om :the p~uent MHW une.
The attached VepaJz.tment 06 Env~onmen:tal Regulation biological ~epo~
fuCUMU :t~ p~opo~al in g~ea:t~ deta.<.L
I
EVALUATION:
Stabilization oil ~he ~ho~eUne W{U ~mp~ove wat~ quality. The ~e 06 MU~
clo:th behind :the JUpMp would de~eMe ~he otdwMh 06 Mne mate~al, 6Mth~
impnov~ng wat~ quality.
The p~opo~ed co~.:tJtuction may allow a mone abundant maJz..,(ne b~o~a :to utabLLoh
on ~he ~-t.a.bilized ~ubo.:tJta.:te. Some tOM 06 maJl...,[ne pnoduc:uvdy will occU/1.
due ~o 6dU.ng oil ~he bay bollom. The ~emoval 06 mangiwvu wdholtt a COWLty
Land Cl~ng Pvz.m.i;t ~ no~, bl my op~n).on, 06 ~u6Mc~ent ~mpouance. to
j~ti6Y a coMt action. Replanting 06 mang~ovu along the p~opMed ~eawa1i.
w~ paAtia1i.y mU.i.gate :the nemoval 06 the u~abwhed .:tJteu.
Will, Robent F. and Alice M.; P~opo~ed Seawall
Page 2
RECOMMENVATION:
App~oval: mang~ove ~eedUng~ ~hould be planted along p~opo~ed ~eawall;
~ e 0 6 6~~ elo~ . ~ec.omme.nded.
~,:.~: rJ.~9 :~~T:-;::~~,~ G-~'c~'~~'~: ;~.~:
I:~~'_'_h.' - l'-~::;.::J . ',. -, . .!. lW', \. _ t. - I.. t-.
~-:J ' :, '':'' r,', !.:. ".... ~c ;~: ~'"
t: t.~ ..,~ '. _. '0_' \,..., . ....
.... ~____"1..101 l.. .... _. .__~ .....
-"""'''''''':::3
. ." '.L' .-".-
~w
~~
A~' "";'J~~' \', PL\~iaXG, BrILDI::G & Zm:nlG DEP:\RT~lENT
.~ 'r-. '~tls PEr2HT FOR EXCoVIAl."Im:, THE DEPOSIT OF
',{'-L1l'l ;:,
\.~ ~..}/ FILL, OR STRlCTURAL ACTIVITIES I:-i THE
- -:':, ~.JATERS OR UETLA.l'lDS OF :-lmmOE COUNTY
1) Property mmers nm:Je & mailing address 2) Date FOR DEPA~r.'!P:T uSE O;:1:.Y
MCJ:'J~OE
C:::JUl\.lTY
PER:HT
rm .
Robert & Alice Will
'33 Will Lane
Watchung, N.J. 07060
3-2-82
3) Phone nurr:ber
(201)
757-4621
Resolution No.
Date:
4) Contractor or agent's nane, mailing address & phone number
owner
5) Legal description of property:
Section
15
Key
Boot
Subdivision Waloriss
TO'lo.-nship
66S
Lot
15
Block
G
Range
32E
Street, road or; mile marker Calzada De Bougainville
~
drec2ed/excavaced
Volume of material:
filled/deposited
c.y.
watenoJard
o f ~L H. i.,r .
c.y.
land\.Jard
of H.H.H.
c.y.
wa tenoJard
of H. H . i" .
:t125 c.y.
land,.,ard
of N.H.H.
'.
ZONING: RU -1
PURPOSE:
Cost or Per::dt
Esti~ate~ COSt of Construction
Biologist Comments - Restrictions or Special Conditions if any:
Approval: mangrove seedlings should be planted along proposed seawalls;
use of filter cloth is recommended.
Alan Lessler, Director
Planning, Building and Zoning
Date
=OlJNTV
-..' ~:. :''"r''''''~'I ,.' "1'
. u""<j''Y, ~ ......\\.\1..,., , "r~~I.'\..~l ," . ~'. ...; '.~"{""':'.\~
\"'--:-;'L\J.," I-_'~~ .::....? ~_,~,~ ('r. ,.(..."'.......~___...\......'.. ___
, , '-~,...v' ......... ' - .
!)r()~('1.:-V c~\nC'r:.; ll..~'~'\ ~~ :~:111 if'': ::('\:rl'~~
~ ....')" - l -l'_'"
l ( ~\ .~" r ~:r- ...... /~ ,IIC-h- dJ
;=. ,; ,'(...'/.1- j, ~/,. ,v L
/ (A- r-<-)~ l..I AI ("- 'iIj J
" /- ,
,I("'''!'' "
.... ... 1
'q'}:
"" t.,,,
~"\ t\I'(,~l~'
:1l ~1~h('~
/~ ;,~ L
/..'AJ
/,
f ,_ ___
, " - I)' 7 - 4 l. ;J... J
'.!.t;.r"_ 793 -7<;;1.:
(',,' ~7 ::') ~" c~ .
~n:ractor or agent's name, mailln~ :L1c.~,rcss, phone ,I,
.) ,13- ,.r1r,.. .JIJ..; /J ~ ,.. ;' !; .
c":t i ;' i C;1 t i C71
n',Im i 'e r .
, regal de~cri~ticn ef ?roperty:
Section,
-:'Oh71Ship,
Pange,
/',,-
_~ (S-
'~;.1- F-
~~ ey ~ /~ .... ...-
~\ll'divi~ion, Ie". lCR-;.J5'
(if acreage)
-
(..
lot, /';)-
PJ c'ck, "(';"
Zoning, ii..u,
Street, rond or
r~~ i J c
1":U kcr . /.' J
. C..-A. f..- ~--z ft () /2_
,')" '7 '.
...',J~:_Jc;....t)M L/J,'
,) Descyibe the rroposed activity, methods of constrllC~; en (( ::unount of Tl1:lteri<ll (in cubic ynrcs)
t,o he excavDtc? or d:.s)c!~argcd. ~escril'e purpcse 8 i:1~ e];r'cd use of rroj ect.
)ul'''je, ,7J /)."/..)';,, A/r? ;.1",,}, )'''(,/~ ,~.rrA"; ~Iy", fr- r/'J I/l.',ck /'(....40 I,(.C,//oIV~
,'I y'" /.J.1"lr ~ n- I,f'- t' ~.0'''''>1-:- ,/-_/4- -//~~;l t,.t' IY t '.....;.. ^ ( ',;, v .~~ // ,,',4!, 7' y. /-'--'~, [,{; ,.. /-~'/ L
/..z;-- Yf!"! T~-t'..-,/1~'.Ij 7,. f>Tl:'" /r~/~ ;:;LJ...t-, A... >('J>
(~~ " .(.. p ~,,~ ~ ~ & nc; ,1 cr. 111 /I. 7A!.":1f t>"........ r...
drecl~ed/excavnt('d
-~
c.)'.
wCiterward
of ~f.P.N.
- ...~.....
c.\'.
l~m(l\"nrd .
~ /.19 t.;L 4l;if1 ,t./ 6-:IJ~ v c... S' ~ ox. I' kl'e.P- 't y
fi j 1 en / c1 ep os i .!. C'd
c.)'. '!;'/rf-S- c.y.'
~~(' l~1JK\\\lrcl
or ~f.I!.W. or ~l.lU'.'.
'olme of
lJ.terial
of ~'.H.y".
') Kame, address ~ zip cede of ~nj oinin.c: T'ropC'rty ('wTIcr:: \\"~0S(, prc-;'crty ~rrrcmts ,.mtcr ".;W.
rd- /~ />"14-'1'-1;;;',"-5 T..L S-r.........;1\.$" -I}7 <!"'/I/'P,4 I " '>""(;:'~/A.J'..I/LL,.."t /he,,,2<'E ~~.. ~?Oj"
'. . _ I ..J
r- #- 1(,. ..c:.~' C"' C;' c.J J2.L-' A/;/1.tV 31';;..; ,5'" .8., J /- '\ L)l~ 1/1, ,L,A.l:..JN/,/\j,~ T" A.J /l1 :(._ H 'I,rO z- f
-
a) list other pemits issued-andt'm' aprlicd fOL incJ~:(:c ~lrr'JiCl1nt 's n~JJ-ne, for tris site:
/J.,u..f!, ...,4/1.01: ,l~-pc~_r G'IL},'J..L
b) If application has been submitted fnr this rrojec~ (or Cl~e si'T'ilar) in tre past,
1 . fIt' ~. 1'..,+ , .;.(' l'.r..f-' .. f ..
exp am reaso;l or new npp ica Ion 211., glve ar~ leL... S n2:'11C_. ClL...erenl,. rom currenl,.
applicant. fi/~,e'r
,.
) list all reueral and State agencIes that have rCCE'l.\'CG <.:ppJ.:'..ca.1CflS ror trlS pro] ecL
h /l/ IL /I..:! /' E.
1,/ ~ .' .,.
'This completed application fem '..:i E i-,c acccr.lpcmied by t~e
following, or it will ~CT be prccessed~
) Two (2) sets of drawings, on 8!:! x 11 paper, sr.mdng }C'cJ~:ion, pJot plan, tcp view and
cross ~ectian of proposal, dra~n to sC31e.
) Ppplication processing fee as follows:
$75.00 for dredge, fill, decks ('p any structures nffrmting natural water bcdies.
$30.00 for vertical sea\-'alls onman-~ode bcrlics or. '.,'c'tcr.
$75.00 for any canbination of the above activities per site.
:-,~lication is herehy made for a permit to alltl'orize t::C' :lcth'.:.ties dcscrihed rercin. I
C'rti:y that I am familiar with the infon::otion COT't:,d;~,:,c .~;> <':!~:s 3prlication, ::md to the ~est
~ my knm.;lec!ge & belief such information is true, cc:nrL'-::'c ,S accurate. I furtrer certify that
;Jo~sess the authority to undertake tre proposed <Jct iv it: C5. -"13 provisions of laws ffi1n
rclirwl1.ces governi:1g tHs type of work will be cmr1icc '.{it:1 \\'f'ct}'cr specified l~crcin or not.
r:ll1ting o[ a pennit does not presume to give authority to vielat0 or cancel ne rr~i5ions o~
ill' county, state or fec1.eral law regulatin~ construct ie,I or f'crfonnance of constructlOll cf trls
.\';)e of f aci 1 i ty.
TP
); Department Use 011y/
,? a .
,~~ Ii:. , r: if .0;/0"
Sl~naturc of arrlic~~t7ngcnt
. ", / /
::, /p/y;:L
I' Patl:
=fF377
fee [, receIpt If
-L- 1/--
fJ1-/
&~'
f\~prC'Ved by fss It. !)irector
~rsn~ ~~C0~t;~~ a~plication F.
//
/ u"
, G.
.....
"-,
)" \
. ,':f
<<:"
....
I"~
tj
'':/$ 'rC:/i
,- - '-
. .... ~ : -.
". ",... "
__.-i
.-7
..
. ,J
/.,.-.-)
'/ .-/
~
. . .... . ..,..
.Gu.'....
.....
'. .
.....':'
. .., ....w.,~ ..:0........
. ~~......~ ...~. . ..........~ '.......
, ., I . "CO
r- ,: , ,
1~7'"
C:,
- ...
I
...... -1,'
....-
" ,
~
, ~...J...
."
.
,
(,
"
,
..
...
... J
; :"
'"... .
o
~ ~~.(...,~
oJ J" ~ ... .
~ ~:tOg~
u ... ""'".., 11 I
".~: ... ~J
tt ,,0 ~
" 0
.. .
~ IJ
'"
~ ~
.
;
t f :
~ l tl"
. 10
f. ~
. '.
.-t.-
ll)
W
~
ft
III
;:c
\.lJ
~
;-
d,
I
'" .
:r. :
"
.]) ..
<l:
w:
a: .
r .
..... .,."._..",..,,,,, ~
"'::.2-'~'~:",~"",,' .
, .. .....~: ;,J ........
t.:)'" II II..
t-...""'" '''''.___
'.,.,..p.b' Lo.( :..:" ~'"..__~...rJ_ ~_ _____
,
r
~---:;"'-;:Z;-:-Z:;'M , 2:,0 < 'n Co i! J 17 in e, ,&,,,,(.
I .<, ;: -,; .... J!~J .~-I --, - . -.-.-,--",. ./;, /i /. Y i
/~ - '~'~~;~-",..-.;..--" ~\ .;/.........-
I/~t:-<'~~-'p
l. "~V J--<
.' _ (~~~___ f}/l ~ uJ J
C; I-C::-'r I...,., \ \.:,........ 111 !... w ,
j7,,.-.:..J! r::i/..l. v \.j_______ ..
(Hit-eo FiL.L)
f!e tv &i:
WALt, (Alf [:,..P)
l,
/ ' I
f .
I
/-i/,
I ,.F
<;',--;,~L c-
/ ,f .
- '0
- J
.0 ~ 7r.
"")/n
, . ~ -~. ,.... "<,
>4, _
/':..
CJ.,
.. /; ~
C-;( i:> JfI',U,'" L,;"~ il c;::/c?-
..:::-- ~f7?..,).. Ii- /f e A- .P
\ ,,-"',
I~ ~__
~~~
<-'G:'J~~ ~'fi?(rrJ Gp J!';'4-'() !ityc?iJ (/2/f' RHt)
. <2= (-.. I~~~' e c (...4!. lf~ M//J E:/2.. tJ.....-'t-..,. /-L-
-:::i" I I ~
-:;:. I( :1
"':''i" / I t~ /)J.J>t. N 1fl'.tQJ;:'
1\ \c ffr- C c> 0 ~ __5"/!- i., ').?A PeL S~ L
'\. ~-. - .W i'+ rC:-R- - ~--!'l'
C~.,~~. .~\ r~~:l'>.E " Ck:(h,,'f~"1=, t~ i..
it. \ ~ />- '1'-
I ~-\Y7v:11'"
"<\ )c
i::..P\/":~1(\~\)'. ~
., p, \~.......
"1'1 -I
5; c /.:'j.c7_ /r-I f-- r _ \
J '" .:.:~
f t !?i-
e ;,:....':r~ ' (..'
I
Nc A..Tit
1
T~!,~/JJr..5
5 -;-;: ..'<:'7~ 5,J _
t It(.. z.,,~Pri ., I, i?'
')31 0". Ih,-_A/~.l"...'_V:"" ()..'t/../
("o,.T />!~'-Y 1'0 ...
,l'le Iv';:":'C ('i'i-' r\ 7 ~
."17c;--[ \lv~
,...
'-'oJ
......
I' -,
v/c.i,.v
-"
U/'(/4'-;:
/ I v / I.=-
U)r'":-f-.c- ;':'~/) _<:
~)- ~. /;
17/ v'
i
..... J
" ,
\.,
I
" I
,J
"~ I
~I
I
\
"-::J ", ~,/v' (C_
r-",'" \. 1(:.,
leA ':!:~1, f/,""" ""'
- ie""\ 'i:~.J
@ I
em )'/1 (?-o 'r i::-IL.] l~o,,") <; q
/1;,(., /-"'C- dl.Jf?.. ....^'~I/t-tJ 1
? /' :;:;- I'> <! /-1- '"' VI)' I,.",
f/);::IIIJ/'-"~- !;.,/l.... ;11/,;..#. qP"U .?-'if
IN
AT
CO\mTY OF ST "'TE
"'~IC"'TION BY I
S~~ET OF CATE
0.(tX-k.
,.... r" ) /'
\;.~
r-'';~.~~$E :
5 ':-' c--i-(',:.' /...../ L >
i~;.\.u /~' / _~/'-_ 'j? ~,(- 5'
l~ /11';,: L-:':- ~ L i7.
B c.,v T i!. ~-7
::::- I 7
~...r;..J~
I.CJAcrHT p~~?E~rY C~~CRS:
CD r: 5 rc .; c..: /V:!.J
(i) /-::-" /' r j /-oL- r (t. c ,;;-;.:5-- )
/, ".. ...\, "
\. ;'.Y /1-/ ! 1(' ~-:, (, t' '
d- !/_
.5~ // c-- e: 7- T ~-:- p7
C p 1_ ~ If r>.-6 I>c- !?t' ,.~ 1"./:.u_L~/. (.l::.J:: /L ..,
-/'}/) /-/.::.. . --;; /->) >"J~ /. '/,/'/ /C /.' /~I i-
/..;, (.' '-' ,,' T 6-. t-::"':- /.. 1--
, 'l ~'" ~ f i ,.::: ri' A. V ~ .. G'..)' Io..r
t..'\AH.t...l'H:;h,. ..,-,,:..,.:''':'' :'_~'J0
?~~!-.,c_: c): S~':-4"~Y. :~.~>~
..--. --;, --, ,"""
...\,...:.....1.:........... 'J.
.i l .- T
.~ .... ~-J
-, ,
,
~-
.-.._6.\ "
Uf"'ll(j", r". 50. lH.~'"'' '- 1. .
Lr,m.l.' 1~, ,-_",I,('II""'~'. 11:'"";." l.:? ~..,:,.'.~..~.~.'-.-."...,:-:.,' ......;,....:._-"J.~\r~-.c~~.-:~.\' , , ,. ,.rl ~ 15
v -J L... v.. ~ _ _ _ _ _ _-..' ~ - -.-~ - .;I.=-.~;~=:'~ :2]::::' =v~~ ,
'.:'m'JT'\S:-:I? :'S SO:";':':-: I ?:~_\G::: ~<2 ~/,,::.:' J G:\ ~V:"f-:' ;-:::::~y J ~,:C~HOE COUNTY,
I~I.JORID.'; .'..:; S:~C'..;:~ E."': ~-=-_..,-~\ ~. '~;L;', .'_-,-J' =~\ 1.1=~\~' ::C'J~~= J, PP.GE 11)
i'C'.-'
I "
I :,----
, I
!
i
l\ ...-,
).~
f..: 8; \ ;~ ': ~~
~ ~~.~:\(l'Y
-~..._--'\
.r,lL.i:o.:.....~v
.-.~:" v u.',....-'~ .
sc;~~ :
40'
"" 14 _
, -
....
=
. ,
...'" ....
.
.
.
.
.
'.
~ 3ENCH JV:/'\rtKI Spi:-:e '- r cJ)
::l set in tree 9.00 '._0' =
:3 fee t above me an so a fC=
f;j...... 1 1 r-J
r , eve . .r;; I
~~ h ~ ~
~ ~ .' - / ~7"'; 81 C.O GE',':,.lU R.M.H W Ul'\t
";./1'. ,p--::; NOB'lO.OOW IOl.0t;"REt.!5'-',
!? 5p '. / /./,~ ,-;,' Sr.J' .'- tH..DO'
@ ~~ '.. .~////'/' l;
~"'. ~~~. //.<~ /'
~: . '~;J2~-- /~ ~
~ ~ ". ,,~h'. /" <.. r;OR.T/H ~
~~~~:~/ "." rl':>'
, .rl ,"",. ',';;}
: c: ., /<-;C/ ,. /0:-"
~ ~ 1;/ ~~<..{",~ L UJT n s co
r ,{ " " ,.. ? C;;.... .....0, Cl
(;;:; ".v ~\.. ',....' t IJ1
..---- ,_' ~';'t>.-:';> 0
II.I{ y,'<-" "1
'I / ^-, ;1",,'
I I , -;1
l/ ;' ~
,~~ /-'
/ l/" J// ___ _ L~
;; ;;// !.a'!..~. . IS9G,Q .: ~ "--1 ',::. '" ; ,....
1/'07~.-,~- \.; [.:;"(~, uO'tl c."J,. Co::' I:.Le.. ~,,~ '. ........ .- .,: . "."': '.,'... ~.: ':.,
/1:-:.....:..... . lC:,li(-:,r:..TUIol'COGlU:lO:. :'.':' ,~, " n LeVER-"-.':"
, 'III'J. ...... S'W [C~,U:'E.7E. DOCK.. ~, .EL.M_L C"N" J .,
S. .....:'..[NlI\.Lj:;Chlt; IO.""T 0 ~;,' '. " .! /
;; ,'.-
NOTE: Elevations shown hereon are relative L._l
to mean sea level as established by U.~.C. c:~
& G. S\';rY'ey. .,.J
i
6'"1
r
to
"l"
.J
~
::,
,
~
3=
.J
"
:c
J
..-
L:i
"~
c=
2:
c=
CJ
...J
~
..... ,
Vi
Q
o
o
III
-:
.J
.J
'l
J
..
"7 lR.c, 0 LF..\O N
IE.':>T r.OLL
"
j
'". L- , ~"
oo;r-
=
I
-0- Indicates 3/4" steel
I .
-,- Indicat~s bolt i'''ol~nd
;, I
pipe fOllnd .or se t. r'""1
1=
[d
d
set
:en
pa\12r:-,cn t.
_.- Indicates 40d s~ikc set:
T K-:;:::<:~.i3Y C}:'~TIFY tr,at the c:""t2'-;~'.ed ?lat is
a. t:n~e an.:: C0]Tec",; ::'8p::.'c~:;(;ntat5 0.'1 of the
1 <,-_n.:s su:C\'.:..yeQ 'by r:le on .4.p1'1.1 J, 1979.
3eCtrirJgs 2.!'e relative to an 2:..ss'Ls,ed. I,.eri-
d j 2..T1 Ctnd i,;i ven for the purpose of de 1 ine2.-
ting ?n[!les o;.ly. Dis""aY1ces 2.re in feet
;:~nd cE::ci:c:al Darts thereof, all of which I
certify tob~ correct.
1'14
<=
1 :-:i:;:':-:;:; Y C <..; '1' I F Y t )-. Go t I f. "c.. \I e s <= t asp j J: e in
the tree located 37 feet East of the S.E.
~"'L""":;'''''' of' lot 15 -;:'iOC'r' ",.,,, C.~ .....,"l-r:r.S
L I.) J 'C _ .' , _~ _ .. U J ..l. I . .'~ _ () ....J ...
:)\.;'l'l:i\'~sic.n c:nd 6.50 fc:et Sou~Jh of t.)1(:
;;cJrthGrn l~nc of Calzaca De EouC:'iinvil1ea
~:;,S sho....n by Plat'recorded in P}at Book J,
?;:-~ti"e 11) of ;.:onroe County Public Records
a t an e lc:;v a ti on 9.00 IE: e t 2.DOVe ;;.e 2...."1 se a
level. - ~
,.......lvita,!-~tL()d;
.'<'~I/"':'~'_>':'~' ; ~ l: :.'1' '.:~.' ': : .... ~~ ~,_.:.: (1. '/.J<~.;:' ~. ...).
_. _ c, "'; ,': ~:>.: ~. ....:: ~: c' ::-- . .~ . --
I
I
i':':'~
q
,d
.;.
dJ
CJ
~
.:J
o
c
P
"1
0; . ,." .:.
. : : C? OJ
2 (7.5.00':1 6; ::'I':~/X"=
: 0:....
I 0 '... .
~: . J:' l. J'
I "3~ DO' .
@: f-C..o:.'IP hL::l"~'OuY\' .----
. . \" ..11" r 10 ~U_E
P .',: r..~.L
'v' ': !!; L~ n OtN
, ,W
. l;z
~l":~
I~ II IZ.
t~~/'it
, o..lrI
::! - I, \/' I".b
,/ /. ~l~ I :j.
_1 ~ il'iL.... .,/ <cd
. r\/ 1 (..:-:::1
l0':- I ~
.(.. l I .;;..-
<,.; ,,-=:>
'.
.J
....
r..t
C-~
;-"1-
r.::..:;:;I
~
--,
='"
Cd
r;(J
~I IdJ
CJ
-,.J- ~
w
..,
pi g;;;
b Q
a
c (;b
~,
j'J
w d
"=' 0:;:
0
Q bd
""
iii
%
Cl
Cl
w
w
c!
~I
::1 \1 :: ~ ~ t t"J 8.
'w -- ,-.-. - ..-
P:::-:\:~; CER.t A
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
PERMIT APPLICATION APPRAISAL
I ~--. .. ~-~, ...~- ~ .., ~~~ '~-.~7~K:~:~
JUl 20 t9B2 " "Ll
1161 $0. FlA. DlSlllICI'
JlIAHCtl 0ffla1
? ::..~ ~
--- '';''''.
" - ~ ~
--------- -q """"'"-..~
File No.: 440530625
County:
Monroe
Date: 6-28-82
Applicant Name:
Robert G. Will
Address: 33 Will Lane, Watchung, NJ 07060
Agent (if applicable): Mr. Bert Knizel
Address: 102 Calle Ensueno, Marathon, FL 33050
Locati?n of project:" Section (s)
Section{s)
15
Township 665
Range
32E
Township
Range
Local Reference: Sombrero Isles
Water Body: Man-made waterbody connected to Sister's Creek
Water Classification of Project Area:
III Adjacent Waters:
III
Aquatic Preserve:
Outstanding Florida Waters:
On site inspection by:
John A. Meyer
Date of Inspection:
7-2-82
Original Application: Yes~ No__
Date of 2nd Insp.
Revised Application: Yes No
Date:
Biological and Water Quality Assessment
A. Description of proposed project and construction techniques.
Quantify area of project which extends into waters of the state
(including the submerged lands of those waters and the transi-
tional zone of the submerged land) as defined in Section 17-4.02
and Section 17-4.28, Florida Administrative Code.
B. Biophysical features of general area. Include comments concerning
extent of development of adjoining properties as well as relevant
historical facts about the area.
C. Biophysical features of specific project site and spoil site if
applicable. Include identification of bottom types and any
relevant historical facts about the area of the project.
D. Potential impact of project on biological resources and water
quality. Address long-term imoact as well as immediate impact
for all aspects of the project.
E. Suggestions, where appropriate, for modifications that may reduce
or minimize the potential impact of project.
PEfu~ l6-10(Rev.6/79)
WILL, ROBERT G.
#440530625
Monroe County - Marathon
Page Two
A. The applicant proposes to construct a rock retainer wall along the
shoreline of a residential lot. Total length of the proposed wall
would be 160 feet, involving approximately 225 cubic yards of rock
and backfill.
Although the location of the retaining wall relative to the shoreline
'is somewhat unclear, it would appear that the applicant is proposing
to fill slightly past the approximate MLW line. lt is estimated
that approximately 175 cubic yards of rock and fill would be placed
below the approximate MHW line (with approximately 50 cubic yards
of fill placed above the approximate W1W line). The applicant
claims that 100 of the 225 cubic yards us?d will be rock.
The purpose of this project is to prevent further erosion nf the
applicant's property.
B. The waterbody adjoining the applicant's shoreline was created from
low, mangrove-dominated wetlands in the late 1950's or early 60's.
The uplands in this area were created through dredge spoil deposi-
tion.
Most of the shorelines in this area that have been left undisturbed
since initial dredging and spoiling have been revegetated with red
mangroves (Rhizophora mangle). Those shorelines where mangroves
have not been allowed to come back, (where cutting of the fringe
has occurred), display erosion, due to the soft, fine-textured marl
sedi~ents that comprise the existing upland shorelines.
Seagrasses are found in combination with algaes over the shallower
shoreline ledges of this canal/lagoon system. Macrophytic growth
is limited over the bottom of this system, due in great part to
the somewhat "milky" transparency of these waters, caused by the
marl sediments.
\
I
The property adjacent to the applicant'S (to the west) has been
bulkheaded slightly above the approximate MLW line. The adjacent
property to the southeast is undeveloped, displaying a mangrove
fringe along its shoreline. This general area (Sombrero section of
Marathon) has been subject to accelerated housing construction in
recent years, with development estImated at -40 percent of available
lots.
C. The applicant'S upland proRerty drops sharply at the erosion
(escarpment) line. forming a shoreline which drops in a gradual
manner to offshore depths. Sea p\lrslane (Sesuvium portulacastrum)
has become established at the erosion line, while one or t~O~utton-
woods (Conocarpus erecta) and white mangroves (Laguncul.ria racemos,)
WILL, ROBERT G.
#440530625
Monroe County - Marathon
Page Three
are established above the approximate MH~ line at the base of the
escarpment.
Further watcrward, within the intertidal zone, a previously
existing red mangrove fringe has been cut, with only root nubs
~emaining. The distance from the erosion line to the waterward
extent of the intertidal zone (extreme low water line) is
approximately 30 feet. Green algaes (Penicillus sp.) and turtle-
grass (Thallasia testudinum) are found at this point and continue
waterward over the shallow, shoreline ledge.
Within the intertidal area itself, green algae (Batophora sp.) and
horn shells (Batillaria sp.) were observed.
D. Stabilization of this shoreline should have a positive affect on
water quality and, to a lesser extent, the biota in the immediate
area, due to the elimination of erosion and consequential turbidity
and sedimentation.
Any filling done waterward of the approximate MLW line will eliminate
established submergent benthic biota.