Resolution 206-1983
RE$~CUt!~N N~. 206
-1983
IDHEREA$, ~he B~ARD ~F t~UNtg t~mm!$$!~NER$ ~F m~NR~E t~UNtg,
FC~R!DA, has receivea an applica~ion from
ann
RUBEN tANt!CC~
WREREA$, in compliance wi~h $~a~e $~a~u~e, i~ is necessarM as
par~ of ~he permi~~ing procenure ~o rean ~he following Biological
Assessmen~ in~o ~he Recorn as follows:
The applicant proposes to place 57 cubic yards of rip-rap boulders and
fill material along a residential shoreline. The purpose of this project
is to prevent further erosion of the shoreline.
The length of the shoreline proposed for rip-rap treatment is estimated to
be 74 feet. Of the total amount of rip-rap and fill proposed, all but 12
cubic yards would be deposited landward of the M.H.W. line.
The applicant proposes to leave a five foot wide strip of subtidal shoreline
shelf undisturbed (landward of and abutting on offshore peripheral channel).
The waterward limit of the proposed rip-rap would be at the approximate
M.L.W. line.
The applicant proposes to place the larger rip-rap boulders first, followed
by the placement of smaller rip-rap within the boulder openings. Backfill
would be placed last.
The project site is located on the southeast side of Cudjoe Bay. This is
a residential shoreline on the southermost tip of Cudjoe Key. This portion
of Cudjoe Key has been dredged and filled such that a network of canals
and channels border all of the subdivided lots. In the applicant's situation,
a deep, dead-end canal borders his lot to the south and a shallow peripheral
channel borders the lot to the west. The canal shoreline here has already
been bu1kheaded.
Further offshore (within Cudjoe Bay), water depths increase gradually
(Maximum depth of -4 foot MLW is encountered). The offshore bottom is
generally hard, supporting a variety of a1gaes, sponges and corals.
The lot adjacent to the applicant's (lot 10) is undeveloped. The shoreline
here displays secondary emergent vegetation including buttonwoods (Conocarpus
erecta), white mangroves (Laguncu1aris racemosa), black mangroves (Avicennia
germinans), and red mangroves (Rhizophora mangle).
The applicant's shoreline (lot 11) displays no significant emergent vegetation -
apparently as a result of cutting and clearing several white and red mangrove
seedlings were observed in the intertidal portion of the shoreline.
The width of the intertidal area along this shoreline amounts to about
10-15 feet. An additional five feet of subtidal shoreline shelf is en-
countered before depths drop into the narrow offshore peripheral channel.
Those species of biota observed within the intertidal portion of the applicant's
shoreline included gastropods, for the most part. The following species of
gastropods were identified: banded tulips (Fascio1aria hunteria), thin
shelled oysters (Isognomon sp.), mussels (Braciodontes sp.) and false ceriths
(Batillaria sp.). - -
Isopods were observed in the same area.
Over the waterward extent of the intertidal zone, green algae (Batophora sp.)
is fairly well established.
Resolution
Ruben Cantil10
Page Two
The subtidal portion of the shoreline shelf displays a productive and
diverse community. This shallow water area supports healthy patches of
turt1egrass (Tha1assia testudinum) and Cuban shoa1weed (Ha1odu1e wrightii),
along with scattered green a1gaes (Cladophora sp., Penicillus sp. and U1va sp.).
Red algae (Taurencia sp.), is also found here.-- -- ------
A variety of sponges (Porifera) were observed along with sea cucumbers
(Ho1othuroidea) within the subtidal portion of the shoreline. Numerous
ki11fish (Cyprinodon ~.) were observed in the general area.
Anticipated impacts are primarily short term in nature. Principal in this
regard is the elimination, in part of the intertidal biota through the
placement of rip-rap. This biota is largely represented by sissi1e and grazing
gastropods. It is anticipated that these species will recolonize the newly
created rip-rap surfaces in similar numbers as the present population.
Positive impacts are anticipated in the form of a more stable shoreline
substrate.
Under the provisions of Chapter 253 and 403 of the Florida Statutes and
Sections 17-3 and 17-4 of the Florida Administrative Code, permitting
approval is recommended.
As a condition to this approval, it is suggested that the applicant place
the riprap prior to the deposition of the backfill.
BE !~ RE~~C~ED BY ~UE B~ARD ~f C~UN~Y C~mm!~~!~NER~ ~f m~NR~E C~UN~Y,
fC~R!DA, ~ha~ ~he above Biological Assess~n~ has been rean in~o ~he
recorn ann ouly consineren pursuan~ ~o florina ~~a~u~e 253.124 by ~he
Boaro of Coun~y Commissioners of ffionroe Coun~y, florioa, ~his
22nd
nay of July
, 19 83
a~ a regularly schenulen ~e~ing.
B~ARD ~f C~UN~Y C~mm!~~!~NER~ ~f
m~NR~E C Y, fC~R!~ I'
><Y~/;t.
ayor
By
(~EAC )
Attest: RALP~ W. Vjilllf~ CLERK
1 "~lVIy ..MA.>. {) ~
cter
BOARD OF COUNTY COMI\.,,~~.~. .ERS .~
Wil~elmina Harvey, District 1
Curt Blair, District 2
Mayor Protem Jerry Hernandez, Jr., District 3
MAYOR George E. Dolezal, District 4
Ken Sorensen, District 5
OK~y~~i~"~~,~9E
1305) 2944641
Lucien C. Proby
Monroe County Attorney
310 Fleming Street
Key West, Florida 33040
OFFICE OF:
Director
Building, Planning an
Zoning
P.O. BOX Room 205 Wing
Public Service Bui1di
5825 Jr. College Rd.
Key West, Florida
33043-4399
I, the undersigned, do hereby attest that all date and
information is complete in the package of the applicant as follows:
Certificate of Complete Enclosures
1.
County Biologist Report
2.
Resolution (RUBEN CANTILLO)
3.
Permit
4.
Application for Permit (RIPRAP AND FILL)
5,
Site Plan
6.
Location Map
7,
DER Assessment
Date 6 c2. ()-?3
i
L.
J
JUN 23 1983
COUi~ TY hi fYo.
v
v
v
v
V"
~
v
t.--
By6 Gay-
TOPS' FORM 3397 LITHO
DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE
DATE March 3, 1983
SUBJECT
Riprap fill, Ruben Cantillo
To
William Russell, Actinq Director
DEP'T
Plannina, Buildinq & Zoninq
FROM
DEP'T
Planninq, Buildinq & Zoninq
LEGAL
TWNSP 66S, RGE 28E, SECT 33,
Cutthroat Harbour Estates, First
Addition, Block 11, Lot 11, Cudjoe
Key, Monroe County, Florida.
INTRODUCTION
This application is to be reviewed by the Board of County Commissioners
in accordance with Chapter 19-111(a) of the ~1onroe County Code.
DISCUSSION
The applicant proposes to place approximately 57 cubic yards of riprap
along his open water shoreline. Approximately 12 of those cubic yards
will be placed at or below the mean high water line and the remaining
fill will be landward. The purpose is to prevent further erosion of
the property.
EVALUATION
The shoreline presently exhibits erosion. The placement of this fill
would not create an adverse environmental impact and would aid in
shoreline stabilization.
RECOMMENDATION
Approval with the condition that turbidity curtains be properly
employed.
Note :..Department of Environmental Regulation and Army Corps of Engineers
permit are required.
AH:cm
PERMIT
MONROE
COUNTY
~
-
PLANNING, BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTMENT
PERMIT FOR EXCAVATION. THE DEPOSIT OF
FILL. OR STRUCTURAL ACTIVITIES IN THE
WATERS OR WETLANDS OF MONROE COUNTY
PERMIT
NO.
1) Property owners name & mailing address
Ruben Cantillo
800 Northwest 39th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33126
2) Date
Jna. 27, 1983
3) Phone number
FOR DEPARTMENT USE ONLY
Resolution No.
Date:
643-0760
4) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address & phone number
Same As Above
5) Legal description of property:
Section
33
Key
Cudioe
Subdivision Cuthroat Harbor Estates
Township 6 6 S
Lot
11
Block 11 - First Addition
Range
28E
Street, road or mile marker De Lussan Lane
Volume of ma terial:
dredged/excavated
filled/ deposi ted
c,y,
waterward
of M.H, W.
c,y,
landward
ofM.H,W.
12 c,y,
waterward
ofM.H.W.
45 c,y.
landward
ofM.H,W,
ZONING: RU-l
PURPOSE:
Cost of Permit
Estimated cost of Construction
Biologist Comments - Restrictions or Special Conditions if any:
APPROVAL: With the condition that turbidity curtains be properly employed.
NOTE: Department of Environmental' Regulation and Army Corps of
Engineers permit are required.
Jeffrey M. Doyle,Ph.D./Director
Planning, Building and Zoning
@
1) yropei' t .. owners llcUf1e 0
MONROE
COUNTY
or "''''1'' I 'r L ~..(~",:l\.',r, I1r."n,\pT''','',' r,'r.p',' fIT, \,PP. T I(~^.TIf'\'T r,~('r.
,:\.. ,j~ .,C;, P!T Lr~T \'. (', " /' \'
'ATIC":, TI-P::: flFPClSE rf q IL, rr ST'l'rTPr"d,\-~IrS I" 11 T
,r. ..' ''D,' 1\,
..;'\11_1
mail ing acklress
2) rate
~) Phone nt1Jf1.her
Mr. Ruben Canti110 Jan. 27, 1983 1-643-0760
800 Northwest 39th Avenue
Miami. Florida
~) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address, phone & certification nt~ber,
N. A.
5) legal description of property:
Section, 33
Township, 66 South
Range, 28 East
(if acreage)
Key,
Cud10e
lot,
11
Surdivision, Cutthroat Harbor Estat{
First Addition
Plock, 11
Street, road or mile marker,
De Lussan Lane
Zoning,
. ~U =..3;
6) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction & amount of material (in cunic yards),
to be excavated or discharged. Describe pur~ose & intended use of project.
Purpose and use are to prevent further erosion of shore line and to prevent any washing
if fill from lot into open water.
Project is to place a line of boulders pra11e1 to shore line and extending from north
side of lot down to existing wall on the canal. Boulders will be kept 5 ft; landward of edge of
channel. dredged/excavated filled deposited
volume of c.y. c.y. 12 c.y. 4t; c.y.
material waterward landward waterward landward
of ~~.p..w. of V.H.l'.!. of P.H.W. of H.H.W.
7) Name, address f.r zip cede of anj oining property owners whose property affronts water way.
lot 10 (on Cudjoe Bay)--Mrs. Karen R. Sims, 4337 Wooda1e Avenue, South
Minneapolis, MInnesota 55424
lot 12 (on canal)--Mr. Gordon Sharp, P. O. Box 719, Summerland Key, Florida 33042
-
8 a) list other pennits issued and/or applied for, inc]ude applicant's name, for tPis site:
,-, only one, already granted and completed, for sea wall along canal, no. 9638
b) If application has been submitted for this proj ect (or one similar) in tre past,
explain reason for new application and give applicant's name if different from current
applicant.
N. A.
9) list all Federal and State agencIes that have receIved applIcat1ms for tins pro] ect.
Joint application to D. E. R. & U. S. A. C. O. E. with filing to D. E. R. (Marathon, F1a).
This completed application fom will be accanpanied by the
following, or it 'llill r--!CT be processed.
a) Two (2) sets of drawings, on 8~ x 11 paper, showing location, plot plan, top view and
cross section of proposal, drawn to scale.
b) Ppplication processing fee as follows:
$75.00 for dredge, fill, decks C'P any structures affronting natural water bedies.
$3Q.00 for vertical seawalls onInan-made bodies of water.
$75.00 for any canbination of the above activities per site.
Ppplication is hereby made for a permit to autDorize the activities described herein. I
certify that I am familiar with the infomation contained in this application, and to the best
of my knowledge & belief such information is true, complete & accurate. I furtrer certify that
I possess the authority to undertake tre proposed activities. Pll provisions of laws and
ordinances governing this type of work will be canplied with wrether specified herein or not. Th,ej
granting of a permit does not presume to give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of
any county, state or federal law regulating construction or performance of construction of this
type of facility.
SPew
cJ-l-t3
(2~ i..:J~
SH!TIature of applicant/agent
IIXob 38'1171
Fee & receipt #
T"'n
27, n~~~
For Department Use Cnlyj
Approved by Pss't. Director
Person accepting application &
Date
Cost of pemit
Estimated cost of cOIlstruction
> .'-
, .
~{~1/ 8-S
S,'fQ Vl~l:+ :
S-~~<3h.. "" r;p rc<f I/j~ &J~.
N 0 fkPc~'1 /'>0
2( ]!6~
b\~r .)U~~ ~~v~"
~ ~~_~tl\;(\y\:~if R~ _~. ,
G [)t,QL 1 Ar:J:Jt pv~^^r~ ~ fy'-(4LW~
. ~ . (J
. ....
- Cl;J?"'vyr1/f/J~;;'~v ~1/'"t.~~'
,---. • (
DRAWING SHEET
il
— 5 c. 4 L-rO 5 S
_...
... ........ ; .2
_ .. .2.. fv1 i_ A/ 0 0
--- ---
___
_....
% CWItn\IE
4;',,,,..,
—__
__
Li, ,t if /
• !;• • f"-.S P46. /1 V II t w
v __
N-' ) dY\i'l V _
i
_
z o .
_ -r- io •
. m.•\-.
0
; 1
, '
,,,•?-,'-) I/ %-2 c „--, .....
I_ 0 T- i / L,%.
,,cilr,,,16,,),
1
,•; ,
I 0 -
(-J',S?;, / _ ,
i , - -- --
k
•
s., 10 ;
• ,/,, i cr-: ,A, 1.,,•.t c-
l'A_ Yli tri t 1 ! ii il t .1) it ; 1 . ( 1 , fl , kL.5-- •:=LT... I .) t
'---'----'- - ----1` --.-----' ` - ^----,- ' —.-- C —
6 N (9-I— ------ — - - -----
PURPOSE: ,— ,.
DATUM:
Adjacent Property Owners: IN Cudjoe Key
1. lot 10--Mrs. Karen R. Sims
AT De Lussan Lane & Cudjoe Bay
4337 Woodale Avenue, South
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55424
COUNT" OF Monroe STATE Fla.
2. lot 12--Mr. Gordon L. Sharp
P. 0. Box 719 APPLICATION BY:
• Ruben Cantillo • Jan.
Summerland Key, Florida 33042
SHEET 1 OF 1 DATE 1981
DER Form 17-1.203(1) Effective November 30 , 1982
•••• .
•
-•
•
•
, •.,IN •. '- .
. . .
• .
,.... .. :.•. . •• • : .
•
• . . •
. .
•
' ..•
• . • •
- •
•
--VICINITY MAP
• ' • ....,,. . . . ., . • . •
APPLICATION OF RUBEN CANTII,LO
•
......• • ,..,,,....
- . . •
. • •
• • - , . ,..„. ,.• . . • - .
. . ''' d .;.,.-.•?,,'..: . . •.- . . • '
For placement• ipf. rip rap P wall.
. -...0 ,..,..,,,„.....!..,,,...,-:.,,',-,
-,.Y..' ..,i'?"'...i::.':" ' .•
SOURCE: Ni O.,, . , .. •
....
''. iiART NUMBER 11455 •• •
•
. - ',. .. .... .,;••:A;•: . ... ,......
•
. •
Mercator 'ptiijdctioll •9:f..:''.'1/40,006 at' Latitude 240. 38'•
•,-. ...
. . • 65/°jot . .
•
. .
•
•
•. • . • .
• ...,.... „
. - fibpr7ci
- ' 1 n .
•
. • •
•
•
. ..,. ::,,.......'„,:•.',',1:',2',..t•I• 1".•••••.-...:•44.•';•;. i••'•• • •••••,;••.,...... .•••••-•'' ' • . ,
•
• ,.,•••i•',.',..,,.•.!•,,,•‘:•:•$.•',.',:';-',7•,..:?..••'•:."•••;.-2 .- ' ''''• '.•; -•-•*:': ..' ' .•
•
. ,
• ..
.) .
-.;'4.•",•;_!'.,'."?'W.....1',.,...4]:•..•;,1•4'.,'.(.!•i:••.;-:•,..i?..-*:',:! •.'..•:.'. ::' '•'.t';',;:,./.:.;:
f
c )
.•. ..,,• ..w p!if..,.:•,;;.':!:,-.--N. ...,....-..,-,.;.,,:,.:,.• ,,n-;,.!,..••• -'', • • •••• ••• - i ) • . .
• . . . .
• • \ • •.i. 'Jcet,..„1.„•,1,-;•,..1,..:•:.-..,!,,,,:„.7; •,...!;,,,,,t!-•i: ,`,,...,", ',..':.;".!:::;:*- ' :..e.,,.S 1 / • \ •
.„;•;,.-';...':i0.P.:1,-;.- ..'...:::::•:..:::‘,..0.-.,:,..';1,,.',V,'2: . ''.''.'' ."...;".•..,' •...(7. \-- . f'
.':;;•;.. :'. ' '... ' :-.;•'.„.: :,.`a.t'....',...,...,V".•,-;';:;:.`.:,:::: ,....;•,-•:".--- .' , .':'::„:.f•::-.!;',•.;.. . ..! .•. ,'
•
1 ' i';'•'‘i'''i''4'.""'?i,g;:.;'is.',"..'..ii'-' '.-;,i'''.:,:',:,.1','-''''.,..',"'" '';'''-...!.. ' -.-.'1 ,--/ L\ •
k • .;:: •.'.-•i'•:•.'.i,i.i.Alf,;.'.'5:,Q.::'...,g,*.'''.•:'-'1.,' i-,1 -.•:, ':1:. -;-...'....••,• .. ::
-',','•?"•-•'.:;T:,s;'...':,i foz-•••';•,•iiT;').:',•:•'-•:•••,••:,:;•"•,:!•••,:;•',:L : .-, • :-..1.:••••••••.1.: i: • '.•:- . ,,. • f.--.--
\ .• .
1\ • 1;:',--;:-... .,..,1.•1:4:,`f•;•;'::,::,:i::....?:•••• •••,:i. •'•":•'-': : '••:••••':..'•:•Y 4. .1'' ' . • ' ) ./ • .
•
• ' ? . ..••'?.. ...1...:,:4,1•,...:;;',..:!:i.,.......,;........,...,..•1.•.-:., ... - ... ,..,„,, . .
•
. J
. . . .,.. ,.;;...:,.,....,,.,,..,.......,.,::::.,,::,..,:i.,...,-,:A ..,,,..;...,..„ •. : .. .,, ..i., .,...
. . ..
.., .
. -.....-...••••.'',.7..1...'''.;,‘,.,S.• •'''.• '•••'',.:l'.'•••;.-;.. •'.•'•• .• .
.
• N/
•.. ri-s.*\-._.
•
•
• . '1,' 14....';': '.,•:...•.,•:,-',',. '.•••• ' 1- • " •••'..) -• • •• ^r..j.\-).• • • ---'. - --1.
*'••'..,....!..i.: ...i.„\-...i..6;...;,:,:,,..,::,.!..•::F,,,.i.,,,::,-.,..,..,1-:;...,:......,..• -1.:[...,,..,.:::::::,,,5:,,,,-..,... ,. ..,..,..., ,,:,...,..,:c r--- ..:..; . .-.• . .
•.
-1\
.',,,,-..';',...,••..;.....,-,,;',,,, .....'....•1.-.•:-.,.....1...:.:,.:„ !:.:•••.,•,•,.•• ,..,.-•• ••:. i
. .
• . :1../••••,,;.!"....,,,-.,.'...',.:-.. .,..,•:•... -• • • :, .,. -:, -:. --'.... .... . ',.- c ti,..4 ; --. • , .
. .
.• ..,,,„-„.......:,..,• ,)..- ,:,..... -.,i•!:: i• , • :: . •..,,,:. •;• -:•. ---.._______...-----....../. ,
.
. , .....„...,,,:,...,,p,,,f,...,.,..,;• ,,,-,,-;,„..,,,•,•; , -....„,.. :,.. „.„,..,. , , ,,.. 11,.,, 74....), .,„ 1
,,,• .
. . . :.,;:::::,'..-1.:.:,:',..t„-:•.••gs.,:.:,`.',,, ,..-N- :10.,';..,•..•:-;:T...-:.'il'"•:,;.',,:::.:',..,, --.. '-. :•• • ,v:5-v : , T/. (c\-
. .
.,,--.':,...:.,,,,,...,. .,, ••• ,-i-2,,,':',..•:'-',;tif 0 ii„,..,.1V.::,1,.:,•Y.r ..,..'\ •p-} (
. . . :• •.q.:,,...,•;;„i....,-.2. :::.:'..-2,-,,--::.• •.' t-' :*-' •.'":••'... ' .* * - .. - -2 • ' -'1) ' ....----\----. .--..
r.' C1 • .1 .
••
•
........."---
• . •.` J.
'•;.•:•-i.'4..t-''':•:7, z/ •, -.'.••.;•;.'C.'..'T:: ::s:..77:-7-77•;T-_.s.......,,........_...... ...._
/ - Y....)
•.;' • ::•'...t.F.;,•',.f. 7t - •••. l'''''.:'N f- • . ••• • •-• !;*•:' . . .. - • ...
)
•
.,..,. • -:, . ‘,.-::•!-:....-:77- . • .o. ,-,•••••,.-- . , ,•:!.....•i:A"..it - , •••.' ,_..,---"-----2,--, .., . (
.
- ---1
• --• ...•••,• ••.:•,,.,-..-_,..,-.• • ••. -,':.,-,•••'.• - - .•••:-,•-:•-..,..y... ,---
. .
' ,‘--'..:''''''''',=.•-.„,.. ,S
• , . -. ,•• ..-.,•,'•Yi •••!..L.i'.:•...,.1.h. i "... • .!'......,.... --.,.... . • •
. f ..
. . , . ,.•• .- ,.,. ..•....:::!-....,:••.-•:-•''..t- - ..,......,•; ',..;.,;,•,------,...-- • ,,-,,,,-
. . . • .-:.:,-,•:7„:•.f:.,.::...,....;.,:•:,.:T.:Q--;••,.,„.:•.;2,-..i.- .....,P:,..',''..',..i,•.-,- Ir.:. -.-" - "--"N;-ii,i'it . .V- ,..." ,2 3 ivi."-Pe,J
• . '.. ..i.•...-:.zt. .•': r.'-,'",',".••-•"‘-•'•-•::.,•,...',.,..1.,•;:.•,.,..:•• C r , • . , ri:z.... .--...._
__.
.,.
• . :,• -•;i'''''''',1".•.:•' ,....-...,..j.•,!•',,•ii::....,". -•..; •.;.: ,•:.....'‘',!,,, t.- , .
• • -• - 1q)ii GU Dyi- i-ro V° 1
II
'.' ••• :::::.:::::!..4:i,•••,,,..••,':"..hse.:.:.:L._-,-.1::.,•,,,, , :, ..... ..,•,..:;!•••::::.;:.:iy :. y, .
.•
• -----....,. (4,, kIa r
- N -r...' -L -- • '-'-'- -:1
' :..''':1';.. Fi.' . ... '''•'..:-....' - ' '• '.:•:,...:••;. ' ^ 1),
- Q
•
... : .. . • ,.,...• .,,...•:..,.! . • ,)
1) . ,
- '..:.,,-...,:,..!......,... :.. .• .:.,,.. . . --. :..,.1 0L
cu
,.... . .
,, 1 s e,. • •
., • •,, •., ..:•., • , •.• .. •
..,....;.,,, o ,,,...,,, ..,:• .) - •i , - • ...,•wi,--•. -.
0 1) 1 t
• • ,...-....:,;,;4•..,,5t-,,,,,•,..1 .....,,•••,,,•:.,•::. .-%- . -••••:,::-...-,,..,4.:-.„ ,..: •••. :-•
. . . • .i-.__."‘. .:-: '4:
• .,.-,....,,,,,,-,.. ..,,....,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..-1,- , .,) ,,,,,,,..,,,,c. • -• -..•
.ij_-5,1 •
.. .., ., •
•••• •-••:.,.....-;-,..,..:•,...,•.:-•.•-•i.:,.--,•,.-•,•.,,,-,.: r . ' • '.;.. •
•
. .
..•• , ,f....:',FL, .." '. ''' "•••••: ;, ,'• .'• •
. .
. ,..• :•,:-:.-...••:',I,;........:::. -'•••!•-• ::,:i•:-;'•;•••••":' ;••••.:, •••.:. :•:•.!:: - . - ., .
•
•
. • - • . •
. .- ..
. •
. •
•
- •',••,;•-• - •••;;,.': ''.:••••:". • '.
•
BOARD.OF COUNTY COMMIS --.�- OF:
Wilhelmina Harvey, District 1 �c
Robert Ed'Swift, District 2 Dennis ,
MAYOR Jerry Hernandez, District 3 ' {"'�` r' Environmental Biologi
Alison Fahrer, District 4 '�,, kdA
Mayor Pro tern Ken Sorensen, District 5 -""Ft:; P.o.Box Wing II
') ' `} �� 5825 Jr. College Rd.
_L� w� Key West, Fla. 33040
, 4 OUNTY 0 MONROE
4 KEY WEST, FLORIDA 33040 �•
(305) 294-4641 °"�
February 8 ; 1983
Department of Environmental Regulation
3201 Golf Course Boulevard
Punta Gorda, Fla.
Re: DER File No. Ruben Cantillo - Rip Rap Revetment - #440654135
•
Dear Gentlemen:
. In response to your recent letter regarding the subject application,
please note the following:
/X/ The decision of the Board of County Commissioners
is a taehed/required but this project has not yet
been :submitted for their review.
•
/_j We have notified the applicant that a County permit
will be required for this project (see attached) .
When the application is received, the project will
•
be reviewed by the Board of County Commissioners and
you will be notified of their decision.
/ / This application is part of a major development •
project that is still being reviewed by the County.
After we receive a County permit application for
this project, it will be reviewed by the Board of
County Commissioners and you will be notified of
their decision.
/ X/ We are requesting a copy of your biological and
hydrographic surveys for this project.
/ X/ Other - A copy of the DER/Army Corps application was
not received. ,
•
. Should you have any questions , you may write . or. call me the
. . letterhead address and , telephone number.
.
Sincerrely, .
• tlf...;:
. Environmental Biologist . -
•
cm
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• / .
P FtUIT APPLICATION APPRAISAL
File No. : 440654135 ki42.211\144�Vl.�l-03
DEA:
OOQ: County: Monroe Nat: 3-28-83 -
Applicant ldaoet: Ruben Cantillo
Address: 800 Northwest 39th Avenue, Miami, FL 33126 .,•
•
Agent (if applies! :) : N.A.
Address: • N.A. •
Ilfcat'ion of project : Section( s). 33 Tovnship 66S Rinse " 28E
Se: : ion( s) Township Range •
Instructions on hod to get to site: end of DeLussan Lane, Cudjoe Key
Wster Body: Cudjoe Bay
. Section: ( ) 10 ( )404
.
Dater Classification of Project Area: III ,
Adj&coot L3tero: . III
Gregory of peters of the U. S. ( I, II or III). .
•
Aqu.atIc Preserve: . — •
o
Outetaadioa Florida k'aters: National Key Deer Refuge
On Bite Inapection By: _John A. Meyer ( )00E ( x )DLEi'
Date of Insp:ction: • 4-6-83 Oritioal Application: yea x D.n
Revised Application: Yes ' No x Date: Date of 2nd Innp.
( ) Loeatinn Hap Attached ( ) Dimensions ( ) Upland/W'atland
( ) Identity Quad ?t p__ ( ) Estimated Trene[tion Lino
( ) North Arrow ( ) Measured ( ) I1iotoo Taken:
( ) TLoa b Date of Sketch ( ) KHvLJoHwL indicated ( ) Furnished
( ) Mailable
•
JAM/is
•
FILE NUMBER: 440654135
APPLICANT: Ruben Cantillo
A. The applicant proposes to place 57 cubic yards of rip-rap boulders
and fill material along a residential shoreline. The purpose of this
project is to prevent further erosion of the shoreline.
The length of the shoreline proposed for rip-rap treatment is estimated
to be 74 feet. Of the total amount of rip-rap and fill proposed, all
but 12 cubic yards would be deposited landward of the M.H.W. line.
The applicant proposes to leave a five foot wide strip of subtidal
shoreline shelf undisturbed (landward of and abutting an offshore
peripheral channel) . The waterward limit of the proposed rip-rap
would be at the approximate M.L.W. line.
The applicant proposes to place the larger rip-rap boulders first,
followed by the placement of smaller rip-rap within the boulder
openings. Backfill would be placed last.
•
B. The project site is located on the southeast side of Cudjoe Bay.
This is a residential shoreline on the southernmost tip of Cudjoe
Key. This portion of Cudjoe Key has been dredged and filled such
that a network of canals and channels border all of the subdivided
lots. In the applicant's situation, a deep, dead-end canal borders
his lot to the south and a shallow peripheral channel borders the .
lot to the west. The canal shoreline here has already been bulkheaded.
•
Further offshore (within Cudjoe Bay) , water depths increase gradually
(maximum depth of -4 foot MLW is encountered) . 'The offshore bottom
is generally hard, supporting a variety of algaes, sponges and corals.
The lot adjacent to the applicant's (lot 10) is undeveloped. The
shoreline here displays secondary emergent vegetation including
buttonwoods (Conocarpus erecta) , white mangroves (Laguncularia
racemosa) , black mangroves (Avicennia germinans) , and red mangroves
(Rhizophora mangle) .
C. The applicant's shoreline (lot 11) displays no significant emergent
vegetation - apparently as a result of cutting and clearing several
white and red mangrove seedlings were observed in the intertidal
portion of the shoreline.
The width of the intertidal area along this shoreline amounts to
about 10-15 feet. An additional five feet of subtidal shoreline
shelf is encountered before depths drop into the narrow offshore
peripheral channel.
•
FILE NUMBER: 440654135
APPLICANT: Ruben Cantillo
Those species of biota observed within the intertidal portion of the
applicant's shoreline included gastropods, for the most part. • The
following species of gastropods were identified: banded tulips
(Fasciolaria hunteria) , thin shelled oysters (Isognomon sn.) , mussels
(Braciodontes sp. ) and false ceriths (Batillaria sp.) .
Isopods were observed in the same area.
Over the waterward extent of the intertidal zone, green algae
(Batophorb. sp. ) is fairly well established.
The subtidal portion of the shoreline shelf displays a productive
and diverse community. This shallow water area supports healthy
patches of turtlegrass (Thalassia testudinum) and Cuban shoalweed
(Halodule wrightii) , along with scattered green algaes (Cladophora
sp , Penicillus sp. and Ulva sp.) . Red algae (Taurencia sp.) is
also found here.
•
A variety of sponges (Porifera) were observed along with sea cucumbers
(Holothuroidea) within the subtidal portion of the shoreline. Numerous
killifish (Cyprinodon sp. ) were observed in the general' area.
D. Anticipated impacts are primarily short term in nature. Principal
in this regard is the elimination, .in part of the intertidal biota
through the placement of rip-rap. This biota is largely represent-
ed by sissile and grazing gastropods. It is anticipated that these
species will recolonize the newly created rip-rap surfaces in similar
numbers as the present population.
Positive impacts are anticipated in the form of a more stable shoreline
substrate.
•
FILE NUMBER: 440654135
APPLICANT: Ruben Cantillo
E. Under the provisions of Chapters 253 and 403 of the Florida Statutes and
• Sections 17-3 and 17-4 of the Florida Administrative Code, permitting
approval is recommended.
•
As a condition to this approval, it is suggested that the applicant
place the rip-rap prior- to the deposition of the backfill.
•
c AC I L I'_Y :..- ::I• • ... - . . : • --
LOCATION :
SITI Si PL': SD . . _____ --- - - — - - - -
COUNTY ( ir O'iELit -i'HAN -.1 iL ,.;. ) : --
Z - - - -
FACILITY TYPE : : • STATUS : OF
CLASS : TVP -[ ' .._..._. LNT,'Pl'OCESS . -- - -- -
(cont. ) — -- ---- _ -- . .
DEP. OFF I CT: : _ ..DUN`:'Y . SI .. LA , ...0 - •
SECT/TO'9;I .N_^-.� GE . - - SECIIENT . QUAD. — — — - -- -_
• E. .
POP. SERVU : : .SIGN L: P. •. DRI:,_;IN(. CLL 0.`,. 5 - . :_
DISPOSAL :=THOD (S ) :
( ) ACC.SP ILL, Li A: C. ( i i:TOUNDIIENT ) SU Rif ACi l'.-I::.. ... __.•.::...
( ) i3URIAL ( INJECTION -.; VOL. R::7U,.:';-. - :.. " :. -
( DI?_\I:.. II:I�:) - 1 , LAND APPLICATION ' OTHER.
( ) ENCAPSULATION ( ) LANDSPR:ADING -- -
RESPONSIBLE AUTIIORI'_ . . .AY :OT 3E FLANK , LAT/LONG.' . ' ALSO .''•S' ""' '
''!INN:.:T•:-I or J' DISPCS Ai :-'.ET1I01 :U.',nUIRED •
G:•ISTI6 52 ..)I ..)RE DC;E AND' E'ILL, INI:0W•IATiON
P Raj F-.C:. :.. .:.E . lib t2_ anti/iv t ... .' Unr-TE _ - . .. . .
. 7,);:-.,T E:-... 7•::•i.... : u_ j°e. Bay - --- - .--
c.I'i'Y 37 i z, _. ._lMttiwli ply- 33(d_S:_ __•I ii\;• I .. _ .
•
: ::: : .ia . . .. .
FILE NUMBER: 440654135
APPLICANT: Ruben Cantillo
PHOTO ORIENTATION
Photo #1: North to south view of the applicant's shoreline
Photo #2: South to north view of the applicant's shoreline
Photo #3: Southwest corner of the applicant's shoreline
Photo #4: Subtidal portion of the applicant's shoreline shelf
t; •
-- ` „4"':r•,^i rr+ .�e+•r•.•si'tr•.+r1- .t r-4. Y"Pma-- ,,, - ---•- r •d-w,:rysz' ..
t i r ,144 .. ti0-,...Yl "by i i,Y e hr .35,''•fii•y.� r qr ,tea . '.
•
..1:.--ram` -••-.1q tey of 'ti+�ate, `..r''' �*....i , ' t � � ,
ti et. ,,,,,,---tStel -,,,, +..-. , ,z R k7-•� s •t� }3. ).T;• ...sit w -3 )'•,T�rt Yt(,"V-14A
a� y. ^Ss" c;4. a • • t d��'1 ,5 t Z t r fi'.
•�`,,w,'yr'. •.--� -•4 .31:r;"°•�t qud fi��•�.d...+5a.1; _v..v��fi;1 1,.,--••2 tFT't' •a.- . •er , ` 1Y •• . ..i. i` i,•33,3,• is,'y„`'' .
jr; •
n` ? ` sr '�„;4:20 + { ?' ,-. :.Lt w`. '" '��.a� y•aL .2,- ib:• •J� , r t i U rti' , 11�+.�f',s;. ,�1 '.1,.
t• ,.. C: :< n,.y,� •S>r�'4 - -,w'•—•':.• 1. -t ., {„ �451.a. .t , 1. t tt S�` >,' .V1 ,A,.
t.
"44 V44.r'r..r�r'a• 4';‘..
'•6%tt 'y _• .fwr�y ° DS.. %t , .f v Y Nyya 1 'd J"4•y, {s. 4 -
• t+ ,rfT~ `Fi. ' '.' :�?'; ••L �.� � ,-w+:A. .,i Y,.a_. t I ?•-si,, Y F�^ t.s� *, .y%4'K-'i. .. 'S :,S..22.--?mo t :t`'s:.«.✓ fn,t.T' -jrtiY y..!� y Y r �� Ii t,"; 1,1'w �e-'• .i,.. NQ; 1ufIle, 0. '1,,. H 1'�{ r.a-
, `.. t r•,•,µ.•tS' �. -: �•• ••••.+'f'. 4C,,-gii, t� - • �C4 •• ' t >' l _�{- , try
`.„ a".. vxi .... "`rL.. .'t,•y. �Y-¢�+ "r •" ,..pt.'°rr `� ..,,, ..4., � , au% _,,,.1. H fir. •A) 7,.t- (S 'mot/
'w - ;'Q�4i/.•,3' .-4.- -1...L ..h. ;•• S`T+. ,R J . _•• k f k §Y.2t_ r ig +'gK to ?
r.2' t i•� d, r } .,y'� :r • L :. :;Z! '•1�i 4c P �4fl S' ,4 A•SJ 4l ^!' 9!
.•F !S�y•,-- 7 '�'7� ���. '74.TM-, .s.•i oii ;' 4•0 ii . i :(i-° '' • f. 'S • G' > , f j .4". _ "-try'n if-�
44�_.�' r.. • 1. 'i'�j: s .4.•'�r.,. ''f'
"M •
�X: 1,� C°jYl -'% 'tt..'.'1:�.` l „ t'K' f .K-dV •F`t. Nye 11`1�.:'>i" ••4 •• '3 •, ''• i1.Xt '• r'L x t: .1 ' ,' d y.r ..
61 4c3"�yy a t ti. s
` . r. '+i�0p,id:'r Y, ..1 :i `j 4.,,.., •1 tr„f .dS a k p t`' 'z�S� lr,`"Y'� ,, « - '- -41,'''c .`� 0,: rE.
J' cr-'. {r,' r J'>_ +}•`•N� Y rt s 'v'k Milt:, - < , + t . rii 'fi 1 ' r
•
t,'F ro• =.� y � �.��`yS�'�' 4%:� 4� �t ' y # ¢� �4r' t a •- 'T � ^+ F'� R}y � .'
.�.w ; * f • dsIhl.!^ ' % `�� `r`,' . r��', !*rlyC� t ►3 t ,r 2%6001�,'' •� • 1ei �yZ
. •
�7 , r n�1,X.,.1_r�-,f,ee,v....'r!_ l S• ..7„. . r' f r _ - }�..k[t `p y'r j 1 '•4%6A • 3ui 4. �:
I• d t • 14t., ik'.V:• r-..•i. ,e •\ ov'`,,,+ Ystr .•,r ?,T•:..� >,.s,. 1 .....P4.31 ,�� °„.24,i .- F •-,,:, •'p 'rp, r -/.-4
• ,... • r .n }4? �iJ.J.... .-...': --,i'tit. Z. _ •. w� `. r .,,, `4 :'-�41''1 t d v>l!f, , p 3 J H 4 t9 c yf, v t Y"
i s «
1d`4 , .�; , �' ., (. r } 6 .'�/it',
,�N ^;,,,' fit e+�Mi , y 1•_. Fy .
.. .�+ •'laced(.+' ''''`.x'9F4,^`t,3 'J;G ri kilF� L' t •:, '� )`'� , !. L}- `•J-,v}�'},1` , �,.,
• • ...,..t.,.. .,..
4 S'S`f' ° 'p�tC ti rg,..,�'t J�l Imo'�'. .< "? ''i.. i'' .,i7 t it--.1q i2 -•, tt vv .
Ft.% .
--'r3.am �.. .�. 'iitett, 3 '1df;t'+c+ - a_ 44, •`y ,"e i ° 'ri�.4,:i.iS „0,, iy.,•- R: • `'.A tf} ¢ lrr -.
i 5: c(..44� dtC}' •i�r �t p I • .¢'8 , t"}^'..,= 3S t .�a• fI :'i'S . �� ix+; ! r
J r-lik: p•,t" VI,-,� :q ''{�4 I f y'i,efi r ...IC • • 7F' i` 4,.,ti AV.Yiai,l ..iii,:-j ,.
- v •+r •phi ^t 4ba i t,,, •t ..;y,/- •,i.,. 114 '"` �" ' . ;. ` '�-, i c
04.
•
•
Fv.r `t,j +L•• ..ter:17,r7+'c'''•-• _• q� ^E" ,SQ?}^rd `•s .•y. ` kr t,.�y00 I•.� s ' ' fk :1. -1__ f., Q
. t 1��.•�:t Z'•Y� ,X�7 � '}•' S<b.�,•4� t.>_ -. Y Y�
~.•,* S, - = °[a .," N'M „e 1f4N.fsS r j. •4_!a Wt.
?.' .'i • ,*.',•..
`I.A'g' N: ' v.% tt `:. • `, _1:-
4-.1,
.�- 3--- - _ -. t :• + ' q w' v r . ' -- F G k� t t S
S` •.K A4 y1 ",. ✓- 'A_.xt ='4 { ' 1J 3 -2�i ,d � . u;ks. Ar c u`'
• ='�yyi,`-' .,. itjF S?�a[W a ,,'��y" 1a •
':Mill'
.Y ip l yet , ; "r' 1 't '
ff• --i.....- :: - r.,s._.:.rt ... .r�� . r • - e h 4'
rt� •
Y r ' .j .5 & i�L-A44 � • -4 .. r 5k., ' -,.•" , .raw. .:.
t-q,:•ap .T- � ar,e ,L,prD ' F;; ''.yam 4t '' t, r'J, ,,,,1^ •• • . .
•
•
3i... i :4,; .. • t '',.. *ram ;b y ti`> a S.r r-
tip. ,' '�.:^. : . _ .` • x.. aS'_1
.
}Y 'F. r = '3•,..a 'S'r F " ! Z•
y,. ., i.tf. w .s 4 .. • • .
• e • A.
�zn :Yt• •.+. �`...�� . t-.p����� .t�1�v,u�J"��7��""�3 �sly�� 4.r,js, ...
Y. .`,.� .. �' \ . r`VC'r 'AN- .yam.,. ... ,.,
E x'...t•*7 ill t,,,ry , 3??V . 'CXI�4z Y, t .p `ie'°.c� -
J:P, sl (,�J � � of {�� d.1• y'r�• 1 y _ %
'`<t�+;,,s',,� t
, - vr3wddi"'.•• +r'" '# h6 } i C '� t �.,i r• •
•
ylYat}, l y�nCL?¢ to r +. s' :. ,• �a '�a.ryyI9,! 1f .
� v s x; r� r1r ,,tr t ,t-w' ,� {Ry;y.,,rf. :,i ,_!r•lt, Yt ; ! c } �' fir`•: .r, .{r,___ '
" �.p d,�, , { �>,'Yt,, �}Yt '+Pa• j ,.,.y�-tA�`4 , '• `y. `} t,'a�*-.,ram` .kL "'`. ; .. '' • _
Ti X' ��3�[E. > It N wiiF ' , ,
$.70t ^T .� K ,: c k iNSb1 . -'M.:•�l;•:... 6-g".;hi^i73� ,
. .
Qt . V _ U "JI.'b. F a „„.„ _ •.` . r :. y,;i„ ,.d. >
d
22..0:.134:?',...1,...4• . ',. , . if.717.'"..4;* .• ,..• ll,Z.)-''•'..". .• "*I', .•'.7„...rffc .
0
Vrr, ti.
i. ..),-/-0 111.--°411r41 ti9 71
•
DRAW I H G &L.. E 1 Cyp( {J/1 ap/OCa4Scri)
•._... .—.-_ --- ..-- •-• I
•
•
•
•i '
1 __
•
•
•
- •
.,. ,.---_- . ,� L.. ,,� 1
, J
•
` i% •
`,1 F 111 11
�i+ , I l/j' I
�
I ,
. '•f ,. k• + • . 1 ( a , :( /
f 1
f , . - 1 1
0\ i
I •`! • 1
L
.;. ; Sys, . - - - - - -=}
, L,
• 1
1
(1• ! . 'F
t;
i
. ..• •• ! I "I I I
I M •
•
I
All- `f• Dt.,:i'.o^I_y LI...:1 t: . .. . 1U (.,1,I 'i)C' I:01' I
- • 1.)I I,;--1.1r:-,. L.!rrt•, K . :
,
43 ,+ t; ,
• '.:: .'
I ,• .Yi.:EIUC, ::,,ut :, . AT 11e Lilssan 1.:nl' ` l.lt ' Inc. 1,,-3''
•
:t'•i)yr , ':r I!:)t:rn '.iIkII
[ . 1l':. 1..' i`t' . l; I
1
.11••_1 '•• ,• + t . 1..,, i-I., • ..',',. TI1[,t.'": '..:1 r1: . � lti Jan.
•
irazigramay-mtleitaammatuamar..wwsermAr----••,-•.',,,....4.10..-^mars,..vmf.r., ,,,,fmgymr,„,gragcsg
. . - . • gg g.. . . .., ,.. .
• •
. , .
. * - • . . '
.• ••••'** : * • :: •.Z :".•'-' .::* • :.•*.:: ..:.,-••••- .. • "..:..-:'•-•:•:-.*::.•;:;-...:*.-
.
* '-. •
. ,-- ._ • ::i ,.
•• ...,, .
.•
. ,
. .
, .
C f rot:Ida -
.,.• ,
- .
. ,
13.147.0zarmsam.cairameatimaikakairfabsearettiumuo.lobazacr.arz41-itersztugubm
•.
. ...-1'./ :0 ii''' ' ,Z;•eV-.-- , ''. '' ' : *:•••••••••• ':•*-- :- '''i - .••:.: •• 1....6:.,...i,'i:.:;:. -_--1-,i.'.iF.--,- ,....-.:Th-.,-.,:-. ...,i
• ; . .
:ii •;a::•:•
!:':i:i:1;'::1:;:.!:::.:.. ::.:: '*.::.:...:...Y. ... ;.:i'ii': ;:ie.i' .!..:::.:.:.:'..%;1?:•.7i..,:-.-iiIiii- Z... :.:
'. .,-. -.. . _. •-•
• ., .. .
... -. .7:. "'''..• - .•- r‘,.___PI Lcz-..... ...... . - .• . _.,:„..„„,v„,:1-4.riv,.„:31,:: :. .,,u,"2- ,•,,,,,,,i.7.—.4.4 .„...,.....,i
1
. •
. .
. .
. . • . . , .. , , , ‘
.. ._ . .
. .
- . .
• , .. . . . . . . . .
'AA • . . . ' .
. \ ,
. .
• - I
' .
• ' . .
' - - •• ' r;..:riTi:1 . , .. tk . • ' i itt-••:4 . . -).4 ; ,
...
. ,
• i .'•..--. 1.,`'
..../.
. ...'-. - (4f___•*4 -.6
--------1 l '-- - . . -• •
. .., - .
. . -,,,_ . • ,
• .
- II ..___ 4/ L._
E.....,•
- : - - - -• :i ' ' ---• ' • '‘• ,i r--N.
r': .,••:.,„..) •••,''''',._ .
. : '-•(..-&21,7)_:_taz4H 7:32---tni:,---'' ---/ , .,_/,_. •.e j . . , --
' .
...
- ''• 1..'---..: 7 s. , . F--:
k....
. t
(1;,. "/. -6 .. LC.,••-.- ,... .,
' .7•4 _ . ••
, . i •'''••••• /I'
d‘n . ‘, • 1:',..;
:;::: , • . I) L. I - •t.\. r;
1)4 0,4 ' /11 L.c .,? • pf,,,, .
. .
_ . • •
-.. .
, _ .._. .... ..,.. .. . • „ _ .. • ... , , .
. .
. . . ,. . .
, .,.
. . . ',.-,:i.-i::17".'‘,r•f F'ii-.33441-7.-4-7"-' 77
. .
, . .. .
. . .. .. . .. . .
1 .
• .
t- . ..• c f Eic.-•r: .,1 -' . • .. •
• • .
. . •
. ...._ -.. , _.
. .
- • -
. ' . .• ....) 7- .______ 1 ...ji. ._-
// _ . !bi.i,Ivr-'11c;::flvx•-"e '''t'4,4.,2Asizi,..00/4ar.g..1
' i•••• - .'":': ...:••1'''' ....': • ''.. :,'...i;Ei:: 7-1 1. . _j_ ../.:713J-441.--- i.: .,::-7 ., :' :. •.' •::-.. . :..• .".i.". •:_-:-i-.,.i5::z:•i:i.7i:i1' i: ? i,:li;:l::l:i„.i.ir i.t-i:-i.•41.:.i'..i,sir.._•, t1-.,:•1,::::!-••.•E-:i,:-7..1..-1.i,:.
2Fitlqii;,
' ! -.---':i• t11,.....gz7li / • I
7-4-1ji --4(. ) :- ••.,J .-... .:. .7,-::i.--.--.-..7i;lilii-•::.:-..--.: ::,_:_;:-.:-• •:.:,,.,
, -
. .
• .
. . . . ... .
.7\__ •
.
iiiillnat'11jirArkAire-46tatt....r.IP'Maral.4 . Ago' ----..mketac.,..1
•-;••.:-,:-...-!.• :,:•••:-:-• •• .1:••7.1-:.-.,.tf•-:-1111.rti:lf7r:.:-.'•,! : .-:`:•:::i :=7.---'
:: • '''Pho,-(1:) 4(.... ..s, , . . .... .
.. .
, . . , .::...:i: :-. . •
i,77..„,:i.iy.;::. .:. „.:::: : .:...i.!.::1._i.5.::.., „.:,..,....::„.:::..i.f,,..0,.., . ,.. ..f:;.i.:, ,•.--... .ii,;