Loading...
Resolution 090-1980 ( {\I ...J. '\, RESOLUTION 4fr_,90-1980 WHEREAS, the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS of MONROE County, Florida, has received an application from Dorothy and Roland Howell, proposing to: Protect shoreline of a lot located a junction of canal and Garden Cove waterway channel by placing boulder riprap at "algae line" (ML"J line) and back-filling with 133 cubic yards of material waterward of MHW line and 667 cubic yards of fill landward of MEW line. The proposed riprap is 220 feet in linear distance following the natural curve of the MLW line along Garden Cover, continuing around the corner a short distance along the canal bank. The applicant also proposes to construct an 86 linear foot concrete dock and bulkhead along canal bank adjacent to a proposed twelve foot wide boat ramp. The dock is proposed to be six feet wide and to be used to moor a private boat. Equipment and material will be brought to the site over owner's upland and existing roads. Riprap is to be placed manually with aid of backhoe to insure boulders are set landward of vegetation line to prevent dis- rupting marine ecosystem. This upland area, designated as Garden Cove, is immaiately adjacent to a body of water also designated as Garden Cove and is approximately 20% developed for residences. The remainder of the area is unoccupied. Vegetation is terrestrial pioneer and/or weed species on the undeveloped areas. Vegetation on homesites is ornamental; natural and/or trans- planted. Terrestrial vegetation on the upland adjacent mproject is grass, a palm and a few small buttonwoods. Applicant proposes to align riprap landward of "algae line", an area composed of small pieces of coral rock and devoid of plant growth. A similarly positioned riprap seawall presently exists (See foreground of Photo #2) to south of proposed project. The vegetation here is green, brown, and red algae, and more lush than on the area proposed to be filled adjacent to the Garden Cove channel. Although the canal bank is less effected by wave action, vegetation along this area is green and brown algae with a few Caulerpa sp plants. Two red mangrove propagules are growing in the area of proposed bulkhead and dock. As the "algae line" is the MLW line along the east side of pro ject, "impact of this project will be minimal as no established vegetation is to be covered, according to applicant." "As the existing canal wall is nearly vertical, the installation of the bulkhead will little alter the attitude of attachment sites. Cutting of the canal bank to install a boat ramp will have minimal effect." BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, by the Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, Florida, that said Board hereby given its approval for the constructiort of the above mentioned project. ?---cIu RESOLVED this day of April, 1980, at a Regularly scheduled Meeting. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MONROE COUNT , FLORIDA Z BY A~E~T _ /~~k C~ C airman '-I-,f'-rD PAGE_ c; R APPROVED m,t BOOK lA 19D ,~ MEMORANVUM 61LOm: John CaAbon, M.S., envbtonmen-tal b.<.olog.w.t .:: '}..{::i:-,::::'~)i;:~/)\' TO. . ...... . . . . KERMIT LEWIN VATE. . .. . . ~~ ~.:::A:::.A 3/21/80 SUBJECT. . . HOWELL - FILL BELOW M H W PAGE.. . . . . 1 of 1 (-t~ ~+ The applicant proposes the construction of a rip-rap seawall of about 225 feet in length, which would affront Garden Cove Bay (Atlantic), and about 85 feet of canal concrete bulkhead. This bulkhead/seawall would uacessitate the depositing of about 130 cubic yards of marl material ~aterward of the mean hign water line. The plans, as submitted, indicate that the rip-rap placement and back fill would not extend beyond or into the diversified benthic algae bay bottom community. The proper~y in question is residential, and is comprised of previously filled wetlands. Erosion has occurred along this altered shoreline, accelerated by wind and boat wave actions. Beyond the eroded fill portion, ~hich is void of any macro biota, there exists the algae Caulerpa sp., l~limeda sp., Acetabularia sp. and Batophora sp., as well as various Rhodophitic and Phaeeophytic types. The fish Lutianus sp. and La~odon sp. (snappers & pinfish) were noted off shore. The placement of this proposed rip-rap seawall, with necessary back fill. would result in the beneficial effects of stabilizing this shore line and preventing further erosion. Recommendation - approval DER & COE permits would be required; attached is a DER bio-survey. I ~ 1 j,,, .~~ PLANNING, BUILDING & ZONING DEPARTM MONROE PERMIT APPLICATION FOR EXCAVATION, THE COUNTY ~~. DEPOSIT OF FILL, OR STRUtTURAL~CTIVITIES IN THE l-IATERS OR \-IETLANDS OF i'10iIROE COUilTY I 1 ) Property owners name & mailing address 2) Da te . For Department Use Onlj1 - U. ~-f1) 4ryd/~~/AIYC/ /-IOL0<!-/ I 3tc;/YD D 'c 1 3) Phone number -p J~)2..4 L- C::' fV(:' fA} 5L.' t e., 2..2. /'::) - 1"3, .!J-.6-S /Y E, /,.r7~' Sf-t2e c+, ~. f\1 / I~ /rJ,. Hi.),2,'eJ A :53/ 3XJ 37/- !..::;,fo 4) Contractor or agent's name, mailing address & phone number ~ "J/ ,. v-c; 5) Legal description of property: AA-Rc/o ~/ I), SUbdivisionUe4,v/sL Cs,~.Je'S " Key, Section, / Lot, 3~ 81 ock, Y Township, or mile marker, /)/}'c/J;!tIS 7oHC) Street, road Range, (if acreage) 6) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction & amount of material, (in cubic yards), to be excavated or discharged. ;c - J.. f: "';= Rlf' .o{fl? Se4 W4)/ v0; h.. Flhcw + g" 0 '4J... 'Is . ~ () ... /IV e J-r ~ r ' . , I <i 10 /:) b"o..k _ i I / 0 - LN J,/ch ,4 bou f- I d 0 <t.u... ~ ~.. "'""'-' I / Io-c. _, III <t~ ... c~ ~-i W ho,", ~ ;;0 F f. 0 F c.~ t'V'R I S~.q. WA II.. J} (;) r" I' t-Yl / J 'e"'i- t(J.l'I/c/ l",vh A/917e.. bill f.::>om,..". filled/deposited dredqed/excavated volume of material: LJ c.y. 0 c.y. /30 C.y. 670c.y. waterward landward waterward landward of M. H .l~. of M.H.W. of M. H. v/. of M.H.W. 7) Name, address & ZiPCOd~ adjoining property owners whose property affronts water way. I CD ~+ .J3- t...S~<;;;.f~; &; 1..6+ , _ S 6 ..sf!) stc:l-,/ A~ N6/ cl ~. R ::/~,~KS. ; ~ e C/C.ce.J - ~u.s ~ ~ I 90S E. 'R"lIe~ ~ ve:....... OceAN I~j.~ i~~fAj.e6/ j /Y)p,Q.'jAf-e) F/oR./d~ ~3~L~ ~~~ j:>~/Vc.~ c;)~ t::.eoN f3Jvd.:; ~t!S ~t'i J GI?t., I c.'i J-I c ~ J r-. ~ ~ I ~ I- , This completed application form will be accompanied by the following, or it will NOT be processed. a) T\\) (2) sets of drawings, on 8~ X 11 paper, showing location, plot plan, top vie\\' and cross section of proposal, drawn to scale. b) App'ication processing fee as follows: $25.00 for dredge, fill, docks OR any structures affronting natural water bodies. .""'- $10.00 for vertical seawalls onman-made bodies of water: "'$25.00 for any combination of the obove acti vi t:.es per sHe. Application is hereby made for a permit to authc'rize the activities described herein. I cel'tify that I am familiar with the information contained in this application, and to the best of my knowledge & belief such information is true, complete & accurate. I further certify that I possess the authority to undertake the proposed activities. All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied with, whether specified herein or not. The granting of a permit does not presume to give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of ny county, state or fede~al law regulating construction or performance of constr this type aci ity. '1fl. ,X licant For Department Use Only Person accepting application Fee & receipt # Approved by Assistant Director Cost of permit Estimated cost of construction 192- I , I COffS: 77~- /5;;3 lx.:~: '1~/- ;l..n:wl.()- SE 1(' - ~ ~ r- . 14:-, : t"l"""" i f-1lM/J i I I--_J SEe ,7-,Y1t\/' /~) - ,~ I I , CR < LiP ./ JIP I IlL ~ ;\,\.Fr:f~~/Io;II'" <_ /,2.;;' /(> Fer ~[_;YIL"'/ ::10.0 -_------l VEk lIef!, ---_____ ':n I--!f': 1,~'1:IZ, \ 7- -- ~- '4J ~ /'::;0 ' C AIII/l{ L____ /4?n/;,<;F/j i OU-::K fllAt tI voce 110 ':"TI":LlcTw2(~ 70 .....J bf' k4(~/) rN Fit. i q) Ino ' - i..::-(c~),,/t-~ ~'J. ,~"t-',_" !-IY v '1 I, ,r;< \!.../' , i I t '( I I f' I ! :;1 L_,;r! If. "" I o ,I '<' C) ~(~ I ! _f ~\ 1 /-.Jxi..;i~'/[~ \J i' 1 }' " 1'- J ,':I) ".} t' i -' / X~ cu. Yf)S ,')J Flit VI<>tl/ M A/.W.L 11. :.; ;., ~ '" ..... C#, "" '), so -~ t )l/~Th./t-; I t,~ iAfJ ~II \J .- "'1 PURPr,SE /flf, 57f1t"'.-<: /1'- :s,4;i?CL /11/6' o DATUM McAAf :::,U!/ I~VC=L AOJArf~T PROPERTY O"~fR~ (11 LOT _'.3 U.J~.57 ~/tJc 4,,",</(':..(.) c. F.eEE.... 'K_':.> (il LOT I - ~,('1(JTt-1 ~//.K ; ',?E CI2~c-L - 7'i2,iS/(f:;- I /'Ion:: ""':";(frOGilAr~/I$ / .5(;.:2//r-)" ,.1!::.o,'l'7TA~//r:;'L'1. L "'~~t"._-- :"~, / ;: // /, '/ \\ /'; " /, ./ " j/ I / .,,, J" '/ (..--.:-1 ,----_______ -- .I." ,-'.,), , 'v~ ( . -;;::;~-r-] ,7 ~; ( . 1 ) ~,.,..u~l"~ kD,L.:..!.:.:....-""--;-J ....i" i- c: I iV/"-- ~ \' I 1 \ ..... I ,\ "" I , '::001 Tlol'l -' \ \'~ \; . ".J "---J ' I ~ I , ,IIY'" ~O(, ::ATC~Y' ,.y,.. q~-i fJfDI&_~~~f;' --, h/WL/ :.K~101 ,::/a,40/ C i(;;~ '/i~{'T -: '~t) '1.) < \ , /0,- / /Hf: "'~'~~'6-.-7 "\_' i:tt, " ''-.;~ / f lj>.'(!f/ y"" ("" r \J . f ',-t'-"' " _ ,v " O----'/e(',I/( ("I?r X - I rJ f I rR J\~') ; ~,,-:! ~..' ,,\' '\) ')/ \jf ,/ V ~f\i , ;- I,ll /8 M4.%. ('i . , (/ A4 ~" II" 'r L'(!T.__~'1_ 3~ '-1/ 1/ ': 9//' /YI/ltl.' ::")'cIt.~/!",,:-\ ~J ?-!' , 'P " . I - , I'" - " I \' \,J" , \...(.. V--' \ \"TI, ll, ,'llt .,tY>vc /I'f.I-I.d/1 ~I \.I I I X ~ :1' \ ~ ,';(it~~~~7J-'- :~,:,~ .' . , <!A,)t-(,(/A,I,'D ,-,c 11!-/(,,( ',i ,I 4f,,! I i.1 'i~~,;"", It~---- - j. - f :j.. ~,~t.:.~ ?/ .') <, (j \;) i~ U ''l' ' , j I I i , , ~~... " \' ,I ....... r\' I ~, ,/.. 'I AU,f5 - v. Clb 4<:,0" o ~ P': /1 N so ;;~ CT I ,Pk. () p-,</ ( /"4; /?f1 fJ /1 '.Ie /...;. u ," ... () ] " \ ..." i ~ I: '-, : i ..,. ~ " .J 0, , ,\ . A- ~. / ",/'L'- <1T" I""'" i IN 1]'1','..... L'l(.""- '-; 'I... - r ... ~1/" , '- f ..;" i:' E)/ /'1.~. c""..-, ()(? ,,~~/ I' I- ':' 7A "'1 CIJN TY 0, ,.1 II' './k(. C ^_____~~[i / Jf " n..[ .,pr.j i(A't ICH ~~''f ",(.....Ir.!ll,ty 1 ',J ~jI4...J( r AI rr /~1-:.(" 't <,1-" . L9-L ~ .. . \!...,f(\ : I , , I I ! I I ' , ( I "- I I ~---- I I -r' _ ^' I C : ~...)I r~1 Ii i _ f I :SEe ,-Y-I,~t\/ /)-A / I , (~ < J..-.:;'<" I I1P ;:/\ ' \~-'Y/I / . / - ~,~ 1(. ru r~Q[ ,"'1114' E/ ,~.~) f!A- TI</II. '~ ,r" t~f'T ~/(ll:ll, \, 1/11. ,'(' - !DIIL~,_ ~ ----, ~. I:{J -, I.!.;n ' r- C /Jr./4t. I - p,l?ok':..Fl) i :/U<K' ;!~~i "VClC '" h:?- :t"J....... ! ft"",~ , I 4f-' JI/{l ~TKVClvKf1.> 70 be k4(~O M.! FIt I. (ij i I t;.----.I i /no' i \ I 1 I . I ;/ I ) i I So ~-~JilI PL ,4 AI (Y/91"/<. t-;J~AP~: '"0,)1 - ,/nr, ." o PUflPr,<,[ -S71!1:X11',' S.h6kE.:.' lA/I: OA f,I"4 /,,1t-Ad :-~.oj /ryr:L . ~OJA(f~T PROPfRT" O~~fR\ ~ e,\ LOT .'.3 ,(('e-57 :5/!/'e : A{A/ev,t) E, r.,k;.Ef....";.:S fii L Of I - :- {"urt-/ ~ ILK :)oE Cfr::~L - T;J:JL)S l'U:- /Ion:: j.~4,~ C 61.1,4,iJlr's :/ ,5 { ,;( L/~' y I'./.so "P,:r;,ic// c () . .'it,r-- u CorfU" 71f(- /S"i} OCt(: ~'1-;l.}"l{7-.>E K~", /:"/~ JI' ,\:,~ 1/ / ~\ ,(/ I" \\ I~ ' 11/' ;; I ~ "i.>' ; 'IV,S") '''V:,'C If:.... I 'I '/ V l I I ---, / .' / ,'-::,. A-c' --'::~-r-~7 /..~. ({ "'~ r.v,L-:..:---- ,,.:, c; <'oC4Tlc,j \~'\ ; ~\~, '"-,,. ' ~ LC)CAI 'Olv' /0......." c) -'~Y"" ~:1ZlL-~,-.. 1.:...t4Vi/' ~€7(,~ . C f \:)5 (fiA.(!T ._:C'/r" L' 'Nt ~~~~~~ D/ \ \ (. I '''- "'- , ~ 'if Ij-f ,:/', ci,~' ':\ '-!': - ,v;,' '+r--'V~(../"I(' cINE ,'JvnC// "Vjf" '!~/,rjrl"'~ :./''-.'('1'lr v i k('..(A.Ic) :/1 ,.....-vc~'-,' ~~' ,,\ 'v. ... \ \~ f.t\V , ':II)' ,v / v ,\ f' / rj. 'I, ' ,0 M'lJ( /' '"I}' l' :' It> - I " .A - r,r '" J" '. ./ '\,..."'> , ... A,. -1' --~1 ~,J ,-.J,-f /.'(J T./~'1 ~4 I 1}.~7 J !:;J II ~ '>' <I ,/W/il/ 5!-(O,""f'/!""':\"'~ . ~~. (, i~ ',_ ' '1'/ ~ ~J~- / CL.~, tVj''':' \ (''':J v" r.'/( f,tjOI/C ,"I-f,H."!/1 ,~/ \),' I oJ: ~' ;' /;,' k'~ '11.( t-- t, .',3;3 eLl. 'r'f)0 ,~~ "." \ r,' - __,_____~.______ ,c1({!ylr'U/1,'-/W,L .f \1 ",~T~~:"':I<D j),N,:', '~. ,; II 'IL.'I <'Il~'i) ,-,~ H" /1', L t, ~ (.I,. .... '-' .J>. '), t=ICL::M lJ c c, . , , '. 'oJ "t} ~ \, \ " :\ " \D' , ' \'\~} '. '~' \t) " \ '< \ , , , i' , '. 'l ,,' , r, ~! ' l. , ""i I ,~' : ' It-' --tt. : .i .----,.--~/ f i [-'~'~~'~' " '- .. ' l ~ c) \,'0 I~ ~I "l: ' I ~- ~ .", ~ ... ,) ..l.---.., \~ , " ~.\ I ':). C,/ ,4 r "- ': .:- J.f'/.:" ",-'",'( .::) :.:0 Ltcl ==:J n ....: l?~O;;r.y! k';J["/IfJ 1)0..'[" "->U, :,,' HC:- I .... '" " 4 9", OJ ;f~ '~ \, "< '~ /~ I , "~ ," "J ., IN i'-;/,{'(),,^/ (_-.- i:f- - ,L}T/t1./rIC , AT i/t,Y' / /1.( Go,'.- Qcf .1N' ;-,(r (. !I~ , ",CONlY Cf ,,/J!"/kr>E ',fA" :[(-11.1." ',) i A-PI :r:A.:!CN OY L,'C-It.',.r:l,.,Yf,l:ty't.AJ:~' iJ~,,:-"',/i SH[( T -' or / (jA I /~..---:'~_i J ~4- ---.--------. l- :5 E C ;r- ,)011/ (L) - A / I ~ -_{"! <'_ .i.~' iP /' II P y..,,..? /IIL. '-~ ~,i) \ ,~y-'_(V;/I" . I 2:;, I" 'u r "'-i,~,l'!LUI ::;1 <'.0 --_----3 ,'E*Tf(/l{ ~ '.,~ ,r~r: /.~~:':IZ., \, I," ~ l.t~1l'Il=_. ~c ~. T-- & (;\. ' ~, I , I I I i I ! I ! I ~, i ' L I I -, r' \ ~ ," I C ....) i ~,~ I ::. I L\' I j l ___-In- _ ,'______'--: /0.: ,":IN"C .-!~~ .': c/(o:: /t, " .. vDC '-:_I-~-')t){O'(h-- .~.._-~~: ~~;-~ fI(J :TKi/Clv.i!f6 70 \\. ':...~: 3~ /t'l/(c.o rtV .FIt t. l.':'''''' f:: / , t. t ,L' ff /'/" /!! ,? t.. r"" 'tl ' -y" ,~ ,,1;'~--~/V0Ilr v, vI ' ~/ I/;~~~. ",\ 'v, ... \~ I ~ ,''( \J I 'v '<:11 I~ < ~ / /8 M4~ / ,)I .ti A - Ifh'v J\./ Ai ---1. -,. ,1 J'r '( t!,-'1T /iJI"! 34 I.' ,( {It ~J J ::~ .~. i:. />1;1/1/ _L>J:'Ict'/I',.> '"?J4" 'F. ' I' - \ . ,l ,'" \. '''I \\,:;~I ,,')j ~ ~ -, Ir-'.~ I _,I) ~ C /If'//J( ~~ . fJ..:' , lb.....;; I ~ C1J L,---..i I , , /oe - :;h,,'r T"Ir' ;/ 1;,j'C4.1() ." f/x,{JEL i ;I I l 1\ --v (.,' / C L)~ ';/)J (" ,L ~ v' ''J i x. / \~/ "'.~ T,~ i " ,.c;/<{) ':-''l 11r....({IA~.'() rtlt .~t'Oi/C ,4f.H,j(/1 '..j.,' /I'-,k'." 4,'..(' I ..1 ~) I -'.-.I .L~// 4..' cu. 1'1/0 .~I 13./ Ic>u/ M J./ uJ. L (l. t )l'/~Th.l(. (.iC /;:Ap ~;): ''J I " "1 ~ u, .~ -\.;. 50 0 ~~~~ P:'.A~ ::-;" ,c-::f:T __..J f - /(If, ~ I OA rll~ JY/~'A^I _~J 4 /ry,:L AOJArf~l pqOPfRTT O~~fRS l e}l Lor }3;. :,J.C:,~ :51t)c 4~"^lr.::tJ (]1 LOT I - ~/('lU n-/ ~ ILk' ; OC::- NoTE; /o-"Htr!C6~,4;:Ji/S i ,5,;.:;:' 1/<' Y' /'.l.-:;O PURP(J~E .<..7f1b(ll'- ~,t.j,k€'L/N<: o "r...':.."Ct"t.'Al.::'S ct)f:EL. T/2,5!f:f: .] TTr:c4C() . CorfU: 751 K- If!i" 3 De~: '1'1-).>ft>lf7-J-E ~, \\ \ / ;./ / /, J -'1 1 / // ,// I ' '/ // ,/,/ -. i ,~ f , / / I /1 . ~ r-~; r:=:==_~-:~ ~(.,,:,,, ,O(.J, I lie, '"'0''' I r I ......oJ \ .(^v.(,.,~ J.~IJ---~----../ _ 'L/lO: .L) -~ , I ~- 11\ \~" , t/ '!o c.-1 Tlot' / - \ \\~ \ , \\J~ '- "' t '~~,.j / / L' c.>(-,~ T i:_-\ ;\.-/ /O~I(") ("J .'.., -v- _",---~T rE~ 5tl'1rRL.-1.~~~,~L----, , -...; ;-'411// 5A'C7(" ;:,;,;',:v'1 G t 0S C/1"11,;7 i ,- '., "-.' '., " \'.1 ..... ~ <:/Nr ~~ '~\ \J .. " "" \.iJ . \\.) '-I ~' '.Il '< " I : I ~ v ,) :l \,,~ :~ I ,.... 'i ~-4--/ I.' !~-J1 ...... , ; --r-'--' . -----J "',' . ,/1 " I'. r-:-'",' ,i->,' ,\ i~"':~~ i I i ! ,I 1 :. ~ 4,q I ~,' (j ,\) -, I...... \} ~-ll ! ()~ t I; I . ',< -{ \... () ~ " ... 'I ~_.l._.... ',c. ,c- ~ { \~..1 ~\d :: 'I' J /. /-1 ,~. , .. l)., 'J ,1(;.,<_,; C~'t..l""t.. '.~-i...~(. H ,). /('.[ "~,Oi~""F' 1..'1 .(~..o /1V[ /:'U IN (--;'/,~.'(~:'."'/ '- ("[/c _..)r~I,.../r,c I ~-~~ '" r i. f_,;' ~ .~.( (~.[1 (l(" .I,"f/ /. j ~C ;"l)liNTY ,;i ,.l /,'1.\/_1,,:"/1 (- r 1. ~ ~ "':-~<"fA. -'i ,F':'>( : r,\" ~ (;~~ H't tlA '''1/(., irl./4....d ,ii.. ~,l~[[ .L..~_'O; / -!L.~~~~~.~~__.j ~.~._._._----------"---~ .. ,QS 3201 GOLF COURSE BOULEVARD PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950 /~;> /d~:'--~~~'" ~.$'L~~~~ /1 <-- --.-<y-"\ ~r--"? ,.,,~- 1 ~~~;I ~?~" Of n.;;!J BOB GRAHAM GOVERNOR JACOB D, V ARN SECRETARY STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION SOUTH FLORIDA BRANCH OFFICE February 15, 1980 Hr. and Mrs. Roland Howell Vi ZCiJya Towe rs, Apt~ flf--=-A 150 S.E. 25th Road Miami, Florida 33129 Dear Hr. & Mrs. Howel I: Re: Monroe County - File No. 44-25647-5E, RipraD, boat ramp, seawall and dock As we advised you on November 30, 1979 , your application is incomplete without local approval, pui~an~ to Section 253.124, Florida Statutes, for fillina waterward of the existing mG~n/ ordinary high water line. - Please submit the enclosed copy of our biological CO~~tcnts together with your pel~it application to the Board of County Commissioners/City Councilor their authorized perrnitting authority. Section 253.124, Florida Statutes, states that the county commission/city council ". . .shall have in hand the (biological) report and findings thereof." It further states, "The report shall be read into the record and duly considered at the same meeting at which the board of county commissioners or other authorized body takes final action on the application for permit." You will need to obtain a copy of the minutes of the meeting or an appropria'te indication of the local approval. This letter, resolution or copy of the minutes should be sent to this office. Your application will remain incomplete without valid local approval. If you have any questions concerning this procedure, please contact us. Sincerely, '.. ~ / I" '/ \ . . tI'i 'If . / I ,..;. ./,' "tit" j'/{{L(., t(L. '-;~ i'.r1 (/(: ,LJ \- Michael F. Nowicki Credge & Fill Supervisor '. MFN/ds cc: John Carbon Enclosure DER Form 17-1.122(50) I' ~ U1;;.!:'ARTHENT OF ENVIRONMErrT.~L REGUU..TION PE~~IT APPLICATION APPRAISAL '1 44-25647-SE F~ e No.: Coun ty : Honroe Da te: 2 / L~ /80 Applicant Name: Dorothy and Roland Howell Address: Vizcaya Tm"ers Apt. 14-A , 150 S.E. 25th Road, Miami, FL. 33129 Agent (if applicable) :_ r~A Address: Location of project: Sectionts) 6 Township 61 S Range 40 E Sect,ion (s) Tmmship .:bnge Loca.l Reference: Andros Ave., G3rden Cove, ICev Larr;o ~'later Body: Garden Cove Water Classification of Project Area: III Adjiicent Wat"~rs : III Aquatic Preserve: NA Outstanding Florida Waters: John Penne1:am'1 Coral Ree f Stdl:~e Park On site inspection by: Richard F. Dumas Date of Inspection: 1/31/80 Original Application: Yes~ No Revised Application: Yes No X Date: Date of 2nd Insp. Biological and ~ater Quality Assessment A. Description of proposed project and construction techniques. Quantify area of project which extends into waters of the state (including the submerged lands of those waters and the transi- tional zone of the submerged land) as defined in Section 17-4.02 and Section 17-4.28, Florida Administrative Code. B. Biophysical features of general area. Include comments concerning extent of development of adjoining properties as well as relevant historical facts about the area. C. Biophysical featur8s of specific project site and spoil site if applicable. Include identification of bottom types and any relevant historical facts abo~t the azea of the project. D. Potential impact of project on biological resources and water quali ty. .~ddress long-term impact as ~,.;ell as i:r.mediate impact for all aspects of the project. E. Suggestions, where appropriate, for modifications that may reduce or minimize the potential impact of project. PERM l6-10(Rev.6/79) _.....(1...__,1 197 Dorothy anci ~\.V....and Howell if44-25647-5E Monroe County - Key Lar.;o Page Two ~' 0 }~({\ ,,/YJ1, / 8' 07 A. Applicant proposes to protect shoreline of a lot located at junction of canal and Garden Cove watervmy channel by placing boulder ripran at "algae line"(HLH line) and back- filling with 133 cubic yards of material waterward of ~1mv line and 667 cubic yards of fill landtvard of HHH line. The proposed riprap is 220 feet in linear distance follow- ing the natm..al curve of the ?fLH line along Garden Cove, continuing around the corner a short distance along the canal bank\~ \ The applicnrit also proposes to construct an 86 linear foot concrete dock and bulkhead along canal bank adjacent to a proposed twelve foot wide b02t ramp. The dock is pro- posed to be six feet wide and to be used to moor a private boat. Equipoent and material will be brought to the site over mmer's upland and existing roads. Riprap is to be pla:ed manually with aid of backhoe to insure boulders are set landward of vegetation line to prevent disrupting marine ecosystem. B. This upland area, designated as Garden Cove, is in~ediately adjacent to a body of water also designated as Garden Cove and is approximately 20% developed for residences. The remainder of the area is dnoccupied. Vegetation is terres- trial pioneer and/or weed species on the undeveloped areas. Vegetation on homesites is ornamental; natural and/or trans- planted. Terrestrial vegetation on the upland adjacent to project is grass, a palm and a few small b~ttonwoods. C. Applicant proposes to align riprap landward of "algae lir,e", an area composed of small pieces of coral rock and devoid of plant growth. A similarly positioned riprap seawall presently exists (See foreground of Photo #2) to south of proposed project. The vegetation here is green, brown, and red algae, and more lush than on the area proposed to be filled adjacent to the Garden Cove channel. Although the canal bank is vegetation along this 3rea a few Caulerpa sp plants. are growing in tho area of less effected by wave accion, is green and brown algae with Tv;o red mangrove prop'lgules proposed bulkhead and dock. (~ As the "algae line" is the HLW line along the east side of project, I/!_rn~..':~ ()f this project Hill be ~~p.imal. as no established vegetation is to be covered, according to applicant./ ..~:"''"'''''~-" ..~... _....~,'"~~'.:,.,....,.-,.,.>.'....:.....;,,..:..,..~.~*...?-.:>O..Ft.,..~.__. ,. \ ~ 8 Dorothy and Roland Howell 1f44-25647-5E Monroe County - Key La=go Page Three As the existing canal wall is nearly vertical, the install- ation of the bulkhead will little ~lter the attitiude of attachment sites. Cutting of the canal bank t~ install a boat ramp will have minimal affect. I ~... ~, \~1 '. .;~'...' ~., .....:...,'" . '_....:..;,;.H'<.;.~,..,,;. .;., .,~. '"' .... .' i'..."";' : .,..;, , .i?;1 ';",5ECi7:1:;~.lj'\A~/:ic:r~,::". ."-'.~.'!:,i::~~'-. . t.~. '.'~~~.~" ~tJi C'.-'k7 ':' . . '--~'~"'~~=..~.:~;:.;.':eiPi!r;P, l ~~\': .' /f/ : : J?" , FilL ""-M';\J~';'-('" '\...// . /1' , . -. \'>;'. ~ -dll/JI. .~!_t.:Q . }./'/" . <f' I . .'"' . _ __ . 10 p~: ~ 1.1: ~11i.W if 0.0 ,(/ ,! ~ ---- --.:..._-:=::J ~ ;f("~ ~ i // / .'" j ",,' ,- {'.............~. J:..-::::'::::==:"--" (y)tJ/ftl-" 1'-) -~.,,,,,~7-~ ~) . ::-., Af"r .J.}fJ,(:IZ. i l~::' ';f.v.G>~ kJ),J .... "-=-=--./ .::c /~ 1 ...~~ v..___,.__---~ . ).- l 17~- . . 17.~ ; ~ '. .... ~ << / . P \~ i r ..~! (};;;~. .J ~ ......... <!ocATlO^!- \~! r - r-~""~~Foi d~~t: "~CK ~~~~"'~~~!:~ ~:<LOC~-" ~'-1 ''...~l . Itr1O. 0 . '!JIY: ~ ~rr I I NO ~rJf!vq/,l~~ 7(j' : ~\( "~' I 11&ilf.I::- --..,.;i\,,~t.J ~ ...J PE' /uab D^, Flit. . ~~';"".#/ ;-t'W$~-;'!.I~~r.; ''''.5'" c~ . <lJ . } '1/:';" . i1J ~ c.~ ~ 100 I _ . '$l/.'/jL.NGAI: CN~\ '.~ = ; ':j ~1 f:~ "~I r.. \ ~ ,. ~ y ~~ i I ~()TI'/Y v f ketll..;t) .../1. ;.,IwELL .., '/ .,~ ~ ~:;: -4 ' i -f ,,~I ..:- <':}:) 't I . ~> ~\~~~~~' ~/ ~ ~l':J i ! / '.. .\,/. ',,) ~i I'Lr !I ~ ~ ,~~/ 4,q JJ 'JJ-~dtt~ O~ ! 1'.:l,1 ~b,:_---i . ..t7::;,j ~ .. ! ..i ...._: I:~' '['. .' ,:.../., ';:' l~! r _... " ~ J~"4"""'.~ i ~ ~~ . '1'/ ~ ! ~ \.' 'rVl/ (" . I . ~ <~" ~ ,eLl .~ ,. ~ ~,,., :>. e:. "' , :r ,I:' 1. i t..\.., 1-'. :1. " >f' N I /1-:lc':~,4r-< :;.,c ,C., .,... i~J \ I).' ..----- ~' \1 U";-,/r::'?itJA!</) .l,c 1/.fii.(/, -- O.C'I ,4(.(:(;.':> '1-0 ~A'./I.)(<I..I?I) (""I'~ .#.;-/.'P.I. - :..J.06 ;<,[f'.. ~ "C. .~ .2. eo1 CD I I IR I I I 01 . . . ~ ~:I ~~ :~ -, - '"'' ,';, . ':'.~;,:y\",. .'-"j,t ,/'~";.>'; 1-:I- t..-,,.-~<J: ~ <. , i,.'...~,.~~~\!, ~{,:..tr:. . ~... . "',';;" .- " , J /8 '--(~~:~ '-, A4 L!oT Air? 34 I ;./ I 1 1'1i.tIJ 9M('t:LIN~ G:, I cu. Yc.~ t'~ rllt"'!3()~ /Jut. WI 1 ! 133 C!./. Yf;6 ,,;)1"- hte blow MH. uU ~: b'.iAiJ ~l' \j I f:~/~T".I(' so iIfi..... o ~1liI so He!;T .. ] ~ Pt!.AA/ l- ft16 ' PURP05E Sm&ll€ S~,o<<L IAle- 0- fUN ,+1EAA./ ~i4 /€l~€l AOJ~Cr"T ~RO~rRTV O_~(Ri C0 ~()r 33'U-'e~T S/tJe: AJ2A1c"'<!L) @ I.or / - ~,"'vrtl fJl<<: Jt'E Mt~: 11{C1To(t;,f~~lIs I ,5vl2v<!"" At.so If '7,;.fc Ill! () _ ;:>kofro~(, R,/J Rf1fJ /'1/\/0 1=;(.(. IN C;t4k:/)r;A/ C(>j/€" - ,4T{lIv'r/C AT KE'r' /.A~C.,o'O:::f"I/'" /5t["e~'!A I cou..n or /r1(o~Ro~ STAH F~",).q I AP/'UCi.fIC" e'l' .Dc.t'!lTNY'1'A'''.-(lIJJvv<t<al sI"t1l1 I 0' I o. rr JI. ll-7<j I c. ;:J?E Ek~/;(5 ~<<~L . 7X!"''$~c ,,;.~,~;tt0J~ , .. ~/':"',.~:":',' - 1 ,;. '----.~-_- ~.QS~;~;~:: ',::~::h,~~~~;~~1 i~.~}; ~i.~i~-;:>';:;~:;~D~~:3~;~~f~~~'~. -.. LoT L f.'I(" . ~~7 ' \:.. " ~ : ~I-) f <1 :' "('~ ';\IJ " !"'f;' iX' ~''r;~WGAc {,.-, (1<< VJ ," .~ ~l;\ .. [;bkClTI/1' V i ~4.>/O /.1. IJatcu. ~) 'f.' 'I. ~ '\tn''t' ('(\' V.~, ~~"~ ~~' ~LJ/,,' ~; fBi' "'~. '/. . "Iii/it \)),'1 A " I')'" '"2 ^ ~:'~ t:oTNb,34 . '" l' ' M "}i~ ) , 0 . ~,' R:\J~"I! j , !!_ ~( IC/ I"/~'(J 96~lhI.: _", v . 0;1 ,~ J j I \ ~. ! .', v, I I if' ,'N / f}1 ~/ /1(I<:OI".J.;~F Fit: "1 ~~ t~4ITO?{/I~ltO ..',c .1/.;I;'t' LA^,f)WII~O rF M,f/.W.t o ~' ::5;cC I"'-/ON' A-A --_..-- -"-----_.- (- ~~ RiP f.)f1fJ FIt!.. -,t...;~y~ MIl'" ~L]O 10 FE'''.z:,~ ;t1tw E/ 0.0 _.:..._::::1 j!~TI(4.: - ~ .~t F.e€'T ;"",<,/.. \-. /.~ ('J :~-, ... ~ ....s.w -- ,'1 ....-.-r..... I l- I ~ ~ . I C111114~ I!.;n ' r- , , - ,--: PRe;.n~1) i t)Vllt IIn,,' " f)()C~ - I , I /2' : j No ~rk.VCTi/,tf~ 70 8'>"~ ......... bt: h';(t.~ oJ FlU. fr,...,p ! ~ . ;., 1001 _. , I I o ... ~ JtI . 1113 cu. Ys,% ~~ (,b I cu. YI);.. (1;: 1'1t(';!;oV'!: /W.H.Ult ~ Flit b '''tV M.~ uu. I , ... I ,,'-,16;1';<; R,ft,hf' "^I' - , 'i ! ----J II) ~ (l . ~~ .", . ,,- _L l- IN> ' 50 JI....I:l!:b.. 3IMI PURPOSE, .571"''&/lt sh6~eL/A/e 0& ruM Mt-A4I ~64 /(flI~l AOJAcrNT ~"O"(lny O"N(RS (0 Lor 33 .U~.5! SIc/C; /lJ2NO~tJ e-. ,r:~ctf,k)I"5 @ Lor I - ::$."'vrH ~/<<: .....{,e- ckef. ~VS~f!" l:()~: I'r!orc$j!AJ'II5> ;' .s'~IA'Er' N.:$O A77Ac;/r;/). t-€~}(;,L~\ CorfJ" 7rk'- If5} J>e~: lI'f-).),"'-I7-.>c I - f ,/4 ~ Jl.// I ~ , ~,~~~ "~ .v;, .-:r-7; <J< _! il'Jt:\(.~ kD.~ II - .:L'l-'€ '~' '" I \ ~\ "i ~oc4Tlo4 - t\\ \: . .\) '-.I' I I t _~ ~XfJT/~.,tJ /()."O (') lOX' .~r ~~ . ..... __ ......1lI1. I ~ I-1I4'/v ~'f'~1r:"; rkM c, ~s cr;."f I (; c.~ ~ I \\, .... ... '-I~) ~1 ':'c .", ~ I' i(' ;,; .i \) : I "" ..... ,.z I ' ~:I ~ ~ ~ I: ;~'" I! II o~ ~J :i. l\J k\ ~ L' ':i.) '\ '}, "" i ' 'V~, ; - O.OJ AcRe.::, - a.Db Ik,RF-S J. ~..- so F€er -, PLAN Pko!b4;,€1' i}1l:>,t:nP /1-.10 f:jt.(. IN C;,4,k' O,-,v CL"t/~ - AT.: .4~/!7C &T KeY (.'IU:'C,.() -OC'€4t41 /:5Cr ~!lil COlJNTY or 1J1~"AlRr;f!" :;Tlln /7(14'/)/# APPl t C '" T' I ON II y i)l:b'1/' r ~ .IMIW& ,tJ-.welL . )(:.~-J"~;',~':.?,_i:-.,:_,; r]:~t'L~':,,~,:,> '. ,:q~ ,.h"~<:~~' -:..\~:,1'';~<'~~:~:':<;',..: )/:c' ;,.; CDrfJ' 71/(- If$") - '~:".:; >. . t;FI~~?Z!i~1}f\\~~~J~~~~J;t,..~... ,,"""'::::~::>~~;";;\'i;?;'~;~:'~,?' ',-i;' 'J' .,: ,,:;,,:~~~.;.~:}.::~~, h"~"L,jfc"../1'.'h",~,,,,,,".4~'~'< :~" ",-'" ,.~,,"'''';A.,.1>e~. '1l{-"r'(pl.(i-J"'c;.",> 'ffi!,~~:r~;~\":~::f>~1';':~~;~r-'id''''>~:~;'.':.';:v;.;:~;~;~,;.,;.,),,;.~;~j.I>,~,,;::~:.J" ..:7\~::':"<'..'..'_.' ..,....~' ;",.'t~Z.:f ' I 'c, , , . ,.,., . ,,,,,." .." 4~' , ,.,,,, , "" ,",,'''''' '" " ,."'~'~'~' ..', 1" 'JT € i ",~: ~~ .~-J ;'elrrr:4t ' , . I I; '. " . . .' ,; . ('~ c,---;-:;r':,-' GAniC"'" .~=-~~~M"''''Z, \: I?'~s."-,.~,~~:'x;-I r ".,.',. .!oc~""^'~~: ~..,.. . _.._ ,0_ _.. .. ~J . . L'tx.'AT,O..../ .'~ O. I.';~~ ,.~ H;e!T i '~~j , r#WlI'~Wl:; ~~ "c ;~.;> C:/'r',"-'T i I ~ . B I (' <..,~ ..... ~~. ...:.~, '" Pin . =!-l ' ... '. 10:." ~' :<; '-.1 '.1 ; f ;:1;:';..;, " :: .~ "':-' .. ,:,t.Q (,' ~",i:,)!;:2~ .5;',;;,,_,",\ :;"~:."4' i f,,;- : :.-. .,: ~ I./:~~J(~~~ - ffI~l~~ ..;;d'"f ":'; ~ . A J/- ',/;'j\L ~1~Jif" , '.- ,,,....-'.., '''''',' r. ," 1.1 tIt\ \ IR ,P i f 4 01' . 0 . ~<.) ~~ .:!- ," - (,f." CU. Y()!.. t1F FiI(.J4&~ ,Itt,~. tilt /33 ~(..I.'~ ~i . '1' ,c:ltf t>l1<<U ~~~;~.;~1./)iA t~~..'J(. K'" """- :"1 . 'i I f ~F ;'J: (',e r/[.' /11.11:1.1 .. M./~w,i. ~. \ . ..,~ \ ~ f:-t,{, '!;' ; , ,,\)1-, ,.~ " O.t}J ACJ2f~ - 0.06 IkJ:'~:. ~ so FeeT J .:;,.,..~. L- /(){; " ' PURP05E .s7118bl€ .shO.lt:/. t#(: 0" TUM McAttI ~(-A It;V~L AOJACrNT PROP(MTy ORHER$ CD Lor 33 .u;e:'r :,/()C; ,4KNO~() e. F~~t'"";:;''k'5 '@ Lo; I - ~",n-I ~/<<: JoE" Ck~l. 'T!2US1(!e "tjor€: lWcrr()tS*"f;1f!~ I svl2V€i' AI$() ,47'T/lCHetJ. @ "'i Pk.op,y{' k'f' R/lj) AN~ ,ciLL IN c;,,,,~(),,,w cc"J/e-IJT(A~/nc AT !:c'Y' .cA(!W.Oa:'1;v/,xct'!7'A1 COUNTrCr ,.1'1t>;jK(JC SUT(' ,c.(a.{vA ."?ll ''''-ION BY D/'JI2C71f Y flhcAMP Jk~ll, I OArE /1. L,' 7'/ J. ....~ ~ . .-.............. : ~':~_\:\ , ,:t':' ~':Jl:._:::':: -~.'.. '. ..Corts,. 7rA"- If5*) )!&.t!~~; . ''pet{ :ql{ - ;l>~ 1{7- /e ";~. , .. . .. .':' (,.:.'......:.:.....::............ ..'.........~~... .. ..... '...'...'.......3....J.;~.:...;....'~,; ..' ' 1;':,0:';,.5.)' ,,,,ic '.(...:1i.s.'.\o::~ .. ..:~,.,..,y<~i..:tq..;~',!.,,\~.'fi.....;;::,' > . . . ., ri,. . ...see /"/OAI,t9"A,.".t.~ ..' .:;:'>:'.'.....::................:.......... ...................................,.:.'..".."'.'..'.....t........'.......'.:.'.' t ~~.~~":'/.~~~_{"!_._,..~::.~..._~~~~.:_:~.~-;'.~::d:_'.~ ,', ,',' .', ',' ,",.' ,"'_,. . ":: . '.. '.' , " ,',,' nQ11i ...... '. .......... ~"' 'a.'l 14 ' . ',.~ I .,..k'.;~~fIU... ~. u, ' 1" h".,'. p.<' .' ..,' ,0" L_t!!?H'" . d":,',, ' 10 h,r L~I.V/ c:-! : 1 r:::_~"1l0" . . -..;....~. \ r L1 r ... I 'So' .J V coCAT",,/) \~10 i , : C/M/A~_ ; " \ _y , ~, ~ - r.:'C'7'CN"'~'" '- I 1" - ;---: /:","'o./'.o:xl) Ot/(K #':4t' '/:.0:::4::' ':~~,<,~...:," -7 -~1 II. I - " . '~, ';:4'53.f~ .!C.'CAT/(),\./, I. I --- J''''~' :'"'t:' fcY'" (J I':):' ",",";". Rrr ; ; '2 ' I' )/(J ~T~uqW,f~ 70' ...~,. ~~ I fiF-&'r,::::::1;ar:IM~_::J I l~'- . h ,'~. -_._-.~~ ~_. -." 1 :t3-J:r f ....... ~c j(4(~./) tI/II I'1t(, . ;.". ~ I)./WL) :'t'~l"-/''<~''. C i(,:. Cl'if(tT r"."; m ). ^ :,,, ;." , ~. ~'('..{ ~:' ~! I . . it (~, . - <.. '~l ll" '. O(J f . W F, y~~, \'. -, , 1'- I -: ,,~/'<-'..,J:..i'l~>..."".L~/vG,1r .(/,,1:\\ ~ '~ <21 " "I' 'I? ~ ~..~1' ,~< :l j (:b,€cTI/y v.t/ ;aVA1.J~ M. f/.atEI.!. ~~'1 '12' I::' (~ '$;'1 ~ .~ . I \~~;J fI;" \, / ~..;' ~,~ : o .. 18~~i\ ,,~'!I... .~: . ~~~; 'I:~ . 1! · A4~! . ," {if 1A ~,' ,. ~ ca:.i LC([" Ah. ~<! ' /,., '. ;l' &:/~'L~l~., ,~~;" ,.:- ~ n I JI ~11t(/S/iJIit:""'€. It!" &,/ :",:. .' '~I ~ ".)i.?"'~' "l II. I . ~"'" ~' . .. '.' v ; 1 ; ~ ,,, 0 (.(~ I ev. y/)~ (1/' ,;li, 1/) I"" \> ':Q "f W nl' ,'01&~ "".t!.I#{r I 1\<;>0:: . " ~ ~ I /33 <: v. 'f'/)$ .,,~ .~l( .: )\ ,r,.,/.t blfItL' /WH.liLU . . J~ !A4l1~~'/JII",O '''r /11.;;:<1/;' - a.()} A,/Id~~ \J , . I ' . ~AAI()({/"~/) (""I' M.fl.W.1. - 0..06 ..4ck."F$ 'f:']If~/";t; 6tJ.i'A;> ~ SO .....l '", . 0 ... '. ~ _,_ SO i~t!i v _ ~ - -==::=J . I J '-\ " I /(, -~' ~ liI!i'aa___ "'v1lJ11' () ~ J~ J ~I ' , . .......L. ;r ~"i \ '.0 'J ~~ 'I~ \ - PL AN -, . L. -1 @ PK.O;:"~f' j}"" t:f:I,a !!AI!) Hi..(. IN c;,,,1.t20r-"'! <..-C'L/r: - AT,A~/rtc ~T KEY .;.'1/-2,>0" 0<-:(-"4111 /.'5(C t'~J;I" COUIlTY Of MOA/KoE '>TATE ...4;","/).1/ \ API". I CAT IOtt ij'f ...')o.(a71IY; ,.a.t~~, ~~LL I SH~T I qF I OArE II-..! /-7(1 1 /fY6 I PUrif>OSE. ~7fl8Cllt :sh6<<L /tVC 0& ruM MOI4/ ~{'Il leveL AOJACf"T PP,CP[ATY Q~eRS (0 Lei 33 .t.~~r $;(}C: ..4/d'fott) e. ,t:"~C€;')k'5 o LoT / - 6t'i,lT;Y ~/<<: Jc€ Cki:l - mtJST~c lot 4 N~TE; ,o;JdTO~*A,lJfI$ ;' ..s(,}~'V€r' I'l"SO A7TAClIf!() ~ :;.. ';1 . ',.