Resolution 120-1980
RESOLUTION #
120-1980
WHEREAS, the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS of MONROE COUNTY,
Florida, has received an application from Sam Humes to:
Place boulder riprap from the adjacent seawall (to north) to the
eXistin~ southeast corner of his lot. Clean fill is proposed to be
placed ehind the riprap. Existing mangroves, at this corner, are to
be preserved. Width of this fill is to be approximately 15' wide,
adjacent to the seawall, and taper to the width of the boulders at the
southeast corner of lot. Length of the riprap is approximately 100'
along the west face of applicants lot. Total depth of fill is five
feet. Applicant~s agent calculates waterward fill to be 111 cubic
yards and upland fill to be 27 cubic yards.
Riprap and fill will be transported by truck to applicant's site over
existing roads and owner's upland. Riprap will be placed by clam
bucket. Fill will be spread and compacted by a bulldozer. Applicant
say turbidity curtains will be used.
Upland's vegetated with terrestrial weeds, except where adjacent land
owners appear to have mowed a strip of grass regularly. Neighbor to
northeast has a concrete seawall with davits, neighbor to southwest has
his left shoulder wild except for a 15' wide concrete boat slip.
The applicant's irregular shoreline is vegetated with buttonwood, black
mangroves, and Borrichia sp. and appears to be approximately 12' to 15'
landward of adjacent property owner's (to north) concrete seawall. The
bay bottom in area of proposed filling is nearly devoid of vegetation
except for scattered Batophora sp., Thalassia testudinum and brown
algae. Bottom material is firm sand-shell fragments and small stones
in this area of heavy boat traffic. A shallow navigation channel
exists waterward of proposed riprap seawall and fill. Juvenile
fishes, minnows, a Sargeant major, barracuda, and gastropods were in
this channel at time of inspection.
The impact of this project would be minimal as this area is of lower
productivity. The installation of a riprap seawall may, in fact,
reduce turbidity from wave-wash of boats using adjacent channel.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners
of Monroe County, Florida, that said Board hereby given its approval
for the construction of the above mentioned project.
RESOLVED this
20th
day of May, 1980, at a Regularly
scheduled meeting.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF MONROE CO TY, E RIDA
~
By
(Seal)
Attest:
/ /;:~ /~/ t..-/ ." c~>
// Clerk
--~~:".--'.-'~>fi~- .,.
-; -,,'
,/
/ ./
.._,.-7"
APPltO'ItD AS' TO 10RM
AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY.
n /4~~
2..Cj(7
:.
0' \~...,,,'l! ""V'-ri'~ ",
.. ~.
,I. - s
:;[ '.h
'';.'11, 'I '. ~
\v q/.1/.J, l,~.\:;':{..."
\/".{ '- "'L~_
..."1 · "'h"'-:~l
"If. :.\JJ;, ..,if/
JIll c-~ H(
BOfl GRAHAM
GOVERNOR
3201. GOLF COURSE BOULEVA
PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950
JACOB D. VARN
SECRETARY
ST A TE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
SOUTH FLORIDA BRANCH OFFICE
April 16, 1980
Sam Humes
c/o;,.pa1.}l C. Kenson
P.O. 92
Marathon, Florida 33050
Re: Monroe County,
File No. 44-25055-5E
Dear Mr. Humes:
As we advised you on November 6, 1979 , your application is
incomplete without local approval, pursua~t to Section 253.124,
Florida Statutes, for filling waterward or the existing mean/
ordinary high water line.
,
Please submi t the enclosed copy of our biological comrr.ents
together with your permit application to the Board of County
COwr;1issioners/City Councilor thei::- authorized pe~,itting
authority. Section 253.124, Florida Statutes, states that the
county commission/city council". .shall have in hand the
(biological) report and findings the::eof." It further states,
"The report shall be read into the record and duly considered
at the same meeting at which the board or county co~~issioners
or other authorized body takes =inal action on the application
for permit."
" ....---
You will need to obtain a ccpy af the ~inutes of the meetlng
or an appropria te indication of the local approval. ';'1is
letter, resolution or copy of the minutes shculd be se~t to
t~is office. Your application will remain incomplete without
vk1i~ lo~~~ approval. If yo~ have any.questions concerning
this orocedure, olease contact us.
~. .
S incer e10f !
PAB/wb
Enclosure
cc: John Carbon
~'
-';:" -, ..
/.~' .--,. /._./ ~/~;;:0'_:-';
//._/~ ~.;.~- ./.-~
'-'--..-/~ --...- .- -- / ~
Philip'A. Barbaccia,
Environmental specialist
.'
DER Fo~ 17-1.122(50)
. ,
"\
",
l.
'..,... ~.-
"".::' \,..~#~.... .. J'
-'~ - --
. .'
zg&
:.
.s AN Hill1E S
{J44-25055-5E
Monroe County - Lower Matecornbe
Page 2
A. Applicant proposes to place boulder riprap from the ad-
jacent seawall (to north) to the existing southeast corner
of his lot. Clean fill is proposed to be placed behind the
rlprap. Existing mangroves, at this corner, are to be pre-
served. Width of this fill is to be approximately IS'
wide, adjacent to the seawall, and taper to the width of
.. the- boulders at the southeast corner of lot. Length..of the
,. riprap is approximately 100' along the west face of appli-
cants lot. 'Total depth of fill is five feet. Applicant's
agent calculates waterNard fill to be III cubic yards and
upland fill to be 27 cubic yards.
Riprap and fill ,.,ill be transported by truck to applicant's
site over existing roads and owner's upland. Riprap will
be placed by clam bucket. Fill will be spread and compacted
by a bulldo~er. Applicant says turbidity curtains will be
.used.
B. Upland's vegetated with terrestrial weeds, except where
adjacent land owners appear to have mowed a strir> of
grass regularly. Neighbor ~o north ea~t has a concrete
seawall with davits, neighbor to south west has left his
shoulder wild except for a 15' wide concrete boat sliF.
C. The applicant's irregular shoreline is vegetated with
buttonwood, black mangroves, and Berrichia sp. and ap-
pears to be approximately 12' to 15' landward of adja~
cent property owner's (to north) concrete seawall. The
bay bottom in area of proposed filling is nearly devoid
of vegetation except for scattered Batophora sp., Thal-
assia testudinum and brc~n algae. Bottom material is
firm sand..=shell fragments and. sP.lall stones in this area
of heavy boat traffic. -A shallow navigation channel
exists watenvard of proposed riprap seawall and. fill.
Juvenile fishes, minnows, a Sargeant major, barracuda,
i an.9 ga~t.ropods were in this channel at time of inspec-
.. tion.
--
D. The impact. of this project T..vould be minimal as this
area is of ldwerproductivity. The install~tion of
a riprap seawall may, in fact, reduce turbidity from
'wave-wash of boats using adjacent channel.
. .
,
........
~ ~
~ .
........' ~..
... '.:,' ". \ . ~.. ... .J'"
--.....
,.
2-g;
:.
MEMORMmul,\
TO. . . . . . . .. KERMIT LEWI~
DATE. . .. . . MAY 6, 198 0
'? .: SUBJECT:...... HUMES - FILL BELOW M.r:
FROM. .. .. .. JOHN CARBO \ \I 1".
LEGAL.... TOLLGATE SHORES, BLOCK 5, LOT 7.
LOWER MATECUMBE
Appl~cat!on was made for the establishment of a bulkheadlin of rip-raILnature, about
140 'feet in length, and for about 250 cubic yards of necessary back-fill, which is
intended for placement below the mean high water line.
This RU-l property is situated On previously filled and dredged land. The shore,
which faces the bay, has eroded. probably facilitated by boat wave action. There
are some wetland vegetative species populating this shoreline which are of a secondary
nature.\The area immediately watenJard of the Hlfw line is relati'lely void of nacro-
biota, h~;ever, dense and diverse benthic communities of various indigenous types of
ma~ine biota are prevalent beyond,the areas of eroded fill.
.
Discrepencies submitted within th~ origicnal application have been modified and cor-
rec ted.
The construction and presence of this proposal would not adversely affect the
adjacent environs.
Recommendation - aoproval
--
Both COE and DER permit ting 'Mould be required; at tached is DER survey.
,
..
. .
...
-.......,
_.~tr......
"
~ .
..
/. .
.,....
_"'_'_~ '__.' ._._. -0'._.,-- _. _,_ _______...__...:._._,_.._...
,,"""'....."...u;.;:;" ..,=....~..~:. -:~~::::.: :...~~.~ ..--":;::..:~::":':7~:':~':"":'~~: ~-;"'~:
. .. ____~___. .,,_..___. ~. ..._-....._. ..... .._.. ... .~~1..":-'_ ,.~..:.;,~;.
: ;~:1~~;;:~~:,_.:;)~~~:..~t2;~f. .,
-....... -~. --"P~:-
'-e. .....,..-:c <..
,-:.. ':-;:;. - ~
-,-' .....,..
~- _.;r .,''..:' .sM.:
\ r""
~c;..w;:FC<l"~. ...
" 'I.~:-;~i~_'~.'~:'.
4
SAM HUMES
100 IRWIN PLACE
iAWRENCEVILLE, N~~ 08648
/. "
f . \
,i,1 !,/
Contractor or agent 's'-name, ma i 1 i ng
PAUL KENSON, JR & ASSOC., INC.
P.O.B. 92
MARATHON, FL. 33050
,.' -. Ii .-, ,-...--
PLr\:J:!I';~_ !,I"I,flIiIC,~ ZO~Jlr:G DEDf:RT~'1E:lT
P[t-~i'iIT',i'r!I'nIC;1 FOR neAI/AIIO" -
DEPOSIT OF ilLL. OR STRlTcTmf;;C-;;'JI,,<~IES ,.
I N THE ',J~ T EF~-S--()R ~'J ETLMi5S-OF~':1orlROE COU:lT'{
aJdn:>ss - -l;-Oa te For Depa rtment Use 6nT)1
JO/1/79
~4~
//t1 ". 't1
i '}7.,.n
. J,r.
~
1) Property O\'mers name & lIlalTi ng
MaNRaE~
.-
COUNTY
.1>i'SCI'Eru...C\-.!5 ;t--J c~\d.,~
J.~~~~'~'-"" 1"-1I-JAt.. kod.\F\C"'... \MS
d1A ~/'6/go. J1
3) Phone number
609-771-0879
address & phone number
743-3585
5) Legal description of property:
'.
Lot,
7
Subdivision, 1QLLGATE SHOF~:
Block, 5
J-
Key,
LO\"er t-jatecumbe
Secti on ,;.'
Township,
Street, road or mile marker,
Range,
( i faCreag e)
6) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction & amount of material, (in cubic
yards), to be excavated or discharged:
9
SEE DESCRIPTION ON DIAGRAM SHEET
dredqed/excavated
fill ed/deDos itpd
volume of material:
-- -7-) 'I:'a-.-r;',~
f ~ ,_. ,
. c.y. c.y.
waterward landward
of M.H.W. of M.H.~.
address & ZlP code of adjoining property owners
250 c.y. c.y. .. --
waterward landward
of M.H.W. of M.H.W.
\'Ihose property affronts 't/a ter vlay.
LOT 6 PHILIP BRYAN
3140 HALLANDALE BLVD.
HALLANDALE, FL. 33009
LOT 7 RICHARD RUGGLES, ET AU
11201 SHAKER BLVD.
CLEVELAND, OHIO 44104
This completed application form will 'be accolnpaniea by the follol-ling, or it vlill
NOT be processed.
, . .
a) Two (~) s~ts ot Cira\'iings. on. 812 X 11 p~lpeY. sho\.ing loc~ltion, plot pLlI1, top vic\\'
. and cross sectiQn of proposal, droMn to scale.
b) Application processing fee as follow:;
. $25.00 for dredae fill docks OR any structures affronting natural water bodies.
b " ~
$10.00 for vertical seawalls onman-made bodies of water.
$25.00 for any combin~tion of the above activities p~r site.
Application is hereby made for a permit to authorize the activities described herein.
I certify that I am familiar with the information conttlined in this application, and
to the best of my knowledge & belief such information is true, complete & accurate.
1 further certify that I possess the authority to undertake the proposed activities.
All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied
with, whether specified herein or not. The granting of a permit does not presume to
give authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any county, state or federal law
regulating constr:u~~ion or performance of construction of this type of faci] ity.'..
~~>cuJ '2k;~0Y--
of applican / aqent
Date
;.-IFor Department Use Onlyl
...
/
. ~).. -. '/'~' w..
Fee & receipt #
Person accepting application
Approved by Assistant Director
Estimated cost of construction
Cos t of permit
" .
~.
.. .
~ '::' '... ..
-........___.1 ~._
L-.1f
.~
~---_._----_.-
. . .
.IOLL (;;i6..TE..
. 'BLVO
\0
~
I ~
r iI CD
4~/ 1.1L~
4 II~~ ,.-- ~LOT 7
I~S ~\$~< ~ ~ .
lJ....J 1\ 19
if.. ;-' .\\,~ /
\) r \r' -'../
)..\~/ ~ ~
t3 -I )i~
G tl:r '
/ ~j;~\~
=P'Co t":. - I, 1 Ro P.
?~~:Lfl~~~;;?-A ~
~.~,k-~\~r 1I:1PRt.P ~..L,
L= -- - "c,", il-
L }.J.C~f~t""',,,,uFC.~iM" ' 5' T S
, SO" ~ LU&' I'
I 2.4- ~2'"~
&
LOT C7 BLt<. 5
.:-rOLL c; l,.l"t:: 5HO~~
...COCAIYO~
.5e"" '- 'C - I=" 6"'" ,-
,
25
J
.:)0-
-~
'IOD
r
-:=.:.:: . u _5 C. AL E: - -,.-p. <:;:: DS. - "
~I f. ..
:n ~Oo 10DO 10DO
,
FR.OM ~OAA. \\.. \\4-5\
P L_ 6.. \--l
~. ~ 50.
, I
~ t',
V ---.. ,
5 15\' hVG, 1 '
. - . j
f1 ... \\ _ c8.! ~l c...~:t.
-t~l ~ ~
3"1-.~...\L.O
'-'('1... "'
2.1,l. c .'1.
--
,:,)( \50 'i~
'2.." ::11I,~c.'(.
,) )'1 Ji:..
..:::R.Tl'" lZ: 1> r r
L
~ ___ gx.\~T
\;;;,'??t- Cl..-U,~ ~U . . .
., ""......./ .
,~~.~ _ Muw.fJ.O
'>"- J-:-'\~L-\ D.O.,
~~.Q-
. .I..:::C? \ C. A. L _ ~ \0:'.. C. T \0 ...:s
\"" \ O'
,- ~SG.'''''Jt.\.L ~ \: lLL
~~. t4,O!-'l':;;.L
.M':;;.\.,;
,/
/" I 1:
I OJ' .
.,' l, PURPOSE: St.abiliz'2 Shor~l;lne
J . Mean Sea Level
,I. .'. DHUM
, ;~:, A~JACENT PROPERTY OI'lNERS':
. /\....~%-,;>hi1 & Merle Bryan ~ 3140 Ha!U..a,ndale 1
,jr;:/} Ha,11andale, Florida 33009
~K ' Richard Ruggles, et ux, 1~201
u~......./ Cleveland, Ohio .44104
c:...:.._~-oci~"e ~T t-:==__:...c=:=I
o & Ie 1:5
~N~
..15 /J u: H.e~:!> L IN 6 ~ I '-'- COo 1-
..:: 'l 'tE ~ D I &:l \1> A:,.:) 't EoG' t.l1){ I<:-
<- b "'" W'> .:l C\:l \"t4
~
-9l1o /80
IN
Bay of Florida
LOw'er. Matecumbe
.. .~
pK
8~039
f\ w~L.. ~~yI,m ~
AT
COUNTY oFMonroe STAHFlorid
Shaker -131 vctPPL ICAl ION BY Sam -,Humes
SHEET !l or1 DATE 10~20::"7
REV-I - \\- \6-''1
rz ev. 2 I - :22.:50
M<-.DJ- 3 3 - ~~
& EEv - 4 <\. - 2 - 8C>
. _0 _. - --.--1"""'.....--.'.... .-. -,-----~.-.-
....-..- _.~~,._-...-_..--,..: .-'.
. __'.'<o'''_~__ -~.:-- __
..
.' .
\
. ,: <; ......,~ ,
. , \
. '.
,- 1'1 -
. '. -. .:.. :".
...
. '. ,
... .... . ~ .
,
-"'h,
, .~,/-
~
, .
2J~
.. ,'"
"..-:.:,~
,,' ~
~ :..r --: ~f
~-',.','
.:::;:~;..;j~!0~!~~~;
~,~j~?L~,:~.;?';:~:~ "'~/~:.r ..~~~ t'
.-......
.,T_ ~
-. -
-. .
~ .
....