Resolution 122-1980
--...
RESOLUTION #
122-1980
WHEREAS, the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS of MONROE County,
Florida, has received an application from La Vonne Bouthilet to
construct:
60 l.f. of concrete block seawall about 15 ft. waterward of MHW
and backfill with about 60 c.y. of clean limerock fill. About ~
10 c.y, of riprap will be placed along the toe of the seawall. The
proposed wall will be placed about 10' landward of the edge of the
adjacent peripheral channel. Additionally, a wood deck measuring about
10' wide x 20' long will be constructed waterward of the seawall for
access to the channel. All equipment and materials can be trans-
ported to the site over existing uplands.
The project site is located on the open water, oceanside shoreline of
Summerland Key in a residential area created by fill from the excavation
of a perpheral channel and upland canal systems. Residential develop-
ment is about 30-40% of available upland area and commercial development
is located along U.S. 1, a short distance to the north, A deep
perpheral channel is located immediately waterward of the shoreline
and adjacent bay bottoms are shallow (-1 to -3' MLW) and are either
seagrass or hard bottom-algae-sponge communities, Adjacent shoreline
are artificial or altered,
The project site is the applicant's residence and the uplands are
old eroded fill with little or no vegetation. Shoreline and intertidal
vegetation is absent. The MHW shoreline has eroded back about 25' from
the channel edge due to its exposure to open-water and orientation to the
south. Wakes from passing boats probably also account for some erosion,
The intertidal zone is gently sloping rock rubble and is about 10'
wide. The subtidal zone from MHW to the channel edge is about 10-14'
wide, and vegetated by turtle grass(Thalassia testudinum) and shoal-
grass (Halodule wrightii) where adequate sediments exist and by the
algae Batophora, Penicillus as well as various red algae. Observed
within this zone were two species of attached rock anemones, juvenile
barracude (Sphyraena) and snapper (Lutlanus) and silversides(Atherinidae),
This vegetated subtidal area provides abitat and a food source to
nearshore organisms in addition to binding the sediments and filtering
upland run-off. The extent of existing vegetation is limited by
unstable conditions created by wavewash and erosion.
To the west of the site is a similar eroded shoreline with a dock from
the uplands, scattered riprap boulders at about MLW and a seawall
landward of MHW. To the east for 60' is an unaltered eroded shoreline
and then a concrete seawall located about 1 to 2' landward of the
channel edge, Several hundred feet to the west is a concrete seawall
at about MLW with established subtidal vegetation in front. Inspection of
3 existing boat basins in the general area and the same shoreline
revealed that all three function to some extent 'as debris traps
collecting floating organic material and have no established benthic
vegetation or apparent animal communities. Creation of these bottom
discontinuities has caused the establishment of sediments that instead
of being well sorted rock rubble are essentially soft, silty marl
sediemnts overlying rock rubble.
The placement of the concrete seawall as proposed about 10' landward
of the channel edge with riprap along the tow will allow the applicant
to recover a portion of the eroded uplands and as well protec the
most heavily vegetated protion of the subtidal zone. The placment
of riprap to a foot or so above MHW will serve to reflect and absorb
wave energies and will allow the continued existence of the vegetated
zone. Habitat will also be provided by the riprap.
3/0
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners
of MONROE County, Florida, that said Board hereby given its approval
for the construction of the above mentioned project.
RESOLVED this
/cH.... day of
May, 1980
, at a
Regularly scheduled Meeting.
Attest:
,I
/
./".;. .'''' ..,..../,,/ ./"" - /,,..":',.. .~.
./ ,,'u'.6 / t. . /.
^~. I. ~-" ...''- _' .. ,f /
../ ler
By
.;
.. ,
(Seal)
.. '"7
~--~
;/. ,-/" -".
// ,,-
MfAOVID AS TO 1fJIIII
n~
~ A
3ft
\ :.
TO. . . . . . . .
FROM. . . . . .
SUBJ......
LEGAL.... .
"
KERMIT LEIHN
JOHN CAR130~
,BOUTHILET -
SUH:1ERLAND,
~.JATER\.JARD FILL
SU'PfETlLAND KEY COVE,
BLOCK 4,
LOT 8
This RU-l property affronts Summerland Cove, and is
composed of nreviouslv filled land.
~. ,.'
c:j;._.__._...__,__~,... ..'. ",~,',,,"",~"'.,
Biota within the area intended for backfillin~ include:
Anthrozoa (anemone), Rhinocephalus, Acetabularia (algae)
and some Thalassia (turtle grass).
9
Adverse effects would be short term until biota re-
establishes itself; long term effects are beneficial
as the shoreline is established and further erosion
is abated.
Reco~mendation - approval
. --
Hold for DER bio-assessment.
0/<-
i
..
Ll.'1 d. ")
. .
[0
<:. :~
I ,;, _, ,{ )J!
j
,/ J~j .. ,-(
ii
I
,
.,.;.-
;'f.-v../ I
-,....-, -~.-" /''''\
I ./ ~ 7<(
J-L/\,
"~'I
/,A...,i'.-:j
{' \
il
tl
I
I (" C /, '7 ('.;'
) J /v'.-\"."-1
; / ~)~ '1
I '. .
L....'J t;.t'( t,' ..-: ~ \ /
l,: _~ 11
~'" .""
'.~._h.~.""':--'
"
"'l.
f.
~ \
e
h,
,
...
.\.
. .
,"'~;-~~,,~,.l:::."~.:::::~ _~=~~:'~-'-""~----- ._-- ~- -- -,_.- --".- _. _.'"~"'e_" ..~.
, \~ ;~::Yfi;.~:~
.... ~.. '\:,~:"~'''\s.'_.''~,~>Q-:.' .r;:'!>>""'~~"'.~~!:'~.:.:r,'.A~.',".'; '~~.' '.' ~.~t'';:';;:'.'~.''. .~~.'..".';:~""~~. iu.'~"".~.'~.--"":"-~:_"".:''''.:''''~iIi.'.,~''''''''' ".,'""~',,-'
" .~""'.' ':_" ...,_.":,_~.~,~..~:!,:.::.,.~:...:~"",, ',.~;,..l. f' ;'oj"' " n'. l-c'!:"':' '~.M" ~r' ;J..".:;.[..\,:>~'~~\,\~,,,,~,~.~.. ',;.' ::r,'~""( ':..~'t:9V~, )'to-I..- J .J~,~, A'~'-~"";:"""''.1.;..- "-", ."ry,~"-~~"" ~"""':', ;..'~' ;.,.- .. .~
_ __- _ ,,"~,,>"'~i;"'~,~~>'-i;-,'''>~':J.fi/~-:?-",;C;';':'''"<';::''~~-:'r.h~'.A:~l.:'j>.";~;"'~""~;;'~.:t."'# if',....;;;:.'~,;"r).""'f..~\,'......'.;,.. <~..: ".r"~' , . . .'
-:'..'j)...~t;';q.t.,..;;//';:.~'.'1. ~;"I'!'<"" ':",:.' ~'~~~'.':$..~J~"\".'{":_'~ .-:.x:.~/\~~~"'!~A~'!~~_,~~,~_,,~~ ~ .".~~.: ~:,--~~j~"_'r~'f~/~JV~)..~'~I,._, t,,;. ..:.~: .~~".' ..--.,',.r'
rr.c r,.'. ~ 0 =
.C=:iUN.V
:.
/;.r' . '-'::'\
t,'. .., " \
:,};? . ,'" 1\
, ." "('
1_/',,> ,1 '",
. '.' .It [J'[ r ~ , ,
~ . . ,1 ,:1 .1,_ j I' 1,1 -' I \.... , l_ '
/
:)~~r("I-; }\P~)!,~""/\l 0."'1 ::-CR. E>:CJ;'1/\TIC'j.\1~ T~-':
D~FO~,lT CF;~I:!~" Q~ )JRlJ:(f!J~{tiC-AtT ~S
Pl Tl!E WITEr.:S ':)~I, '::ETLI"\,;DS OF :~O::ROE COUNTY
addre-s's---T2TDafe------T~or uepa rtment
1.-::::' Uctober 79 i
\3) Pha~~o~~mber )1
I 745-1302
address & phone number
Use Onlyj
:) Property O\'mers name &. l11a i 1 i ng
~rs. LaVonne H. Bouthilet
Post Office Box 250
Summerland Key, FL 33042
'~) Contractor or agent's name, mailing
ECOLOGICAL TECHNOLOGIES
-J c/o Lynn H. Kephart
523 Elizabeth Street
Ke West FL 33040 305 294-8719
j legal description of property:
. Key,
Summerland
Subdivision,
Summer land
Key Cove
Section,
3.5-
Lot,
8
Block,
4
Township, 66
Street, road or mil e marker, Caribbean Drive
Range, 28
(if acreage)
S) Describe the proposed activity, methods of construction & amount of material, (in cubic
yards), to be excavated or discharged. Rip-rap seawall and boat slip. 54 and 13
cubic yards to be excavated waterward of Hm'7 and 54 cy to be placed behind
seawall. 10 cy of rip-rap will' be placed watenvard of NHW, Boat slip will
be dug by backhoe and rip-rap will be placed with cherry picker. Fill from
boat slip will be placed, as indicated on dra\ving, in spoil site behind
seawall. Spoil will be leveled with bulldozer.
9redaed/excavateQ
filled/deDos~
riprap
spoil c,y, 0 c,y,
waterward landward
of M.H,W, of M,H,W.
\"hose property affronts
....-
volume of material:
""", 10
6 7 0 '~ 5 4
c,y, c.y.
waterward landward
of M.H.W. of M.H.W,
code of adjoining property owners
7) Name, address & zip
water way.
Enid C, Officer
Post Office Box 216
Sumrnerland Key, FL 33042
Dwight Sumner
Post Office Box 27
Sun~erland Key, FL 33042
This completed application form '\,,rilT'beaccoi11panied by the following, or it will
~CT be proc2sse~.
i : '.
a) Two (2)4setr of drawings, on 8 X 10~ paper, showing location, plot plan, top view
and cross section.of proposal, drawn to scale.
b) Application processing fee as follows: .
$25.00 for dredge, fill or structures on, or affronting natural bodies of water,
$10,00 for seawalls on man-made bodies of water,
$25,00 for any combination of'cbov2 activities per site.
Application is hereby made for a permit to authorize the activities described herein,
= certify that I am familiar with the information contained in this application, and
~o ,the best of my knowledge & belief such information is true, complete & accurate.
: further certify that I possess the authority to u~dertake the proposed activities,
All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work will be complied
with, whether specified herein or not, The granting of a permit does not presume to
1ive authority to violate or cancel the provisions of any county, state or federal law
regulating construc~19n or performance of construction of this type of facility, \
or Department Use Only,
79
'..L~....... .
.... ~ I
~ ~;~ .
, .
Fee &. receipt #
Approved by Assistant Director
2rson accepting application
Cost of permit
Estimated cost of construction
~ .
(9 \ ~ J r" L.,l1/ \ ~ V t: R r~~~Lt LL),:tS l.~) ~s ~~ <-02.CJ
A\ ~(1' ~ L - 1-1 ~ r ~/iJl\
,_~ ~ L~o\ \~~ ~~ k~~~\ ~CQl~~'( ~:tvJ.gr
@-""t2- ~ 2D ^.- --'-(.'~-+'~)~+ 4p -, 313
. ..... "~. ~... ..
~
j
I
II' ,MAN 1"\ADt.
GUT"
.
..
. . (r~'~"" .' .J
'.."~ .\ ..,:1 ...\. ""1.-:." .,1rl
~ ..."aiI..~~' ;~...f.oj ~ <oft
.t."w""';."~l'
.;'~
P~T"
~'NE.
CRO~:)~ \:)~Ol="\ l i~
--.-. -
SCA.LI:'_: 1.":. 10 I
>..
~ ~~.:.
"'I' /~
::~
;e....c.c..E..cr~~
- \~ Gu.'{o~,
/..
II
" ~
~. . . ,.-"
";;
,(
">
,
-2.6
~
C. \-\ A. ~T
/
~::-C~~k ,'B 'O~A.N
"D~~.
N
., -------., "-.--.-, -. --.,',',...,-----.'.- --,----."1-----
. 0Q
----------
,r'
L
,g
""I
I
I
),1 P~PCbEcO ~LI<-WAL.L..
.....J/RIP-RA~
! .
--
~')POSEO I'~OA.T <":>I.I\"
. !1:;"x'2.0'X.-,\-'M,S,L.
ji - S4 ':'0.,/05,
, I , ,
. . _~C:E.S"''' t.a,..... \0 x;;I. "'''i!J,
:t>~..; / - \~ c:u,,/OS,
--~:~ =,{:"~--'--;(,,I 1'7 '--""^'\.H,v-.J '=1 ~:'C.A'-E
~;~> ry[/'," -iJ,./ . .j."=4o'
,:,,~- "v "J I --f.A
--'---... .''\, ',,1.-"''''-1, --_
::t: . ..,. E)( I"!.T HJ IJ" WALL
:2..' . ~~I' ....) ;r------ .
- ._LF~(lf~4~-jc;'''>- '---f. -. by plAT-;::r---- _ 25 t
-. ;1.5
M ;:,r1 . M P.;cE.. - CUT
, (
......
~ ~'fr
....
i'
---- ~
M.... . oN . -=-:.
"D~
-----
-2.5 I
~~PO~E.. ~ ?::.OAT O,~S\N',
RE-CL_AII"\ \::..RcOE..D LAN~) ~
~RO'n~(;.., +1<0",", +u-tvR.~ E:iW5\ot-1
IN
,~ \ L I'- ~~ T \ c..
OCE.t-\N
,b..D:y p..,<::. E. N. '\ 't:N-J. N E.. R. S ~
~, Enid C. Officer
':2.., Dwight Sumner
j "
~I-
I
!
.j
-~ .......----- ,.. .....--
'~i .0(,._ l .:. ~~:.l
. ..41 ...
SHl:.E.T
L or .L
'DA..TL: \Q -7-5 --:EL--,~~PLlc.~t{T;LaVonne Bouthilet
~SSL---
" ,; *J'" '. I
:hl,t,w,'i~~r, ",. "t"'" r,...
: ..'
,.:=
, . .
. -----~..~"'_.-__"'O"_~__=----.u...........;........;'...::h.:.~:~:.\
. .
. ....:,... .-~:,..:. .~~......_. ........, ._'_' 4. _, ...,.;.....~:,':...::::.:~.::-:.:,'~ ~-,":.
~.
. ".'-:;-.,..:,
.;:u~<D
'.:>^~;;;:;:C+~!'.~~i;,;~:~r~~:i}:l1i~..~trj~f~ ~~'~r:~.f".4~"~~1~~~~%~~,~?~YA"
"1.
w.....~.",.._
r
J i
/'.
. ,.
.,
""\
oi,
. -q..
- ~=--~-~---:-~:=.~=:'=.==.'7'-'~'-~-'----~~ ~~,~-_=~~---:-:-~..,._.~,- "-t:~ .
~~:;"l~~~f,2:~t:.: ~;;'~:;i;::~)7,~~'
',:~~S:f2;';~;~~:;~:';;'~i~~~~~~~~~~~~~
. '~?~4"~' , ~ .~~4~~~ "f~''7 '"''''~.r~ '~~,,:~"'("o""'f':--r~iI:...~;...,.~~, l
~~~~,..~~~f4,......,..r/~":~,.~'~~,..-..:t'~~~<<J...:::;.-~~,~~:~ .'......~.4 ~
. ,~~::.i;"~~-e....;..1 ...~....~.~,,~:_....,..:,.~~, S.,.. .','.'!\....,,.
".. ""~~~~'~''''f'' .'...":f.t"'t~~~~~.:~/~7.~~~.,"';.~'\.,~~':..> :,~"""" ......::',.:"':,.y':",.~. "-~",
1-i$f!~':..~..\,.'I'I'PlrJ'~l~.ft'-.>.. ',...l\"..h ?S',!,"..."" ,!.
V' , ::~,}~~":~,"''''~!~;''':~~'''''Z':~:j,'~:",,,,,'ri....'~;:i''...J~ ..~-' .""." v",;~
..~I .' -t",
PUBLIC NOTICE
SAJOD-RP-S
------
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
Jacksonville District, Corps of Engineers
p, 0, Box 4970
Jacksonville, Florida 32201
Telephone: 904-791-2211
OFe 0 7
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
South Florida Branch Office
3201 Golf Course Boulevard
Punta Gorda, Florida 33950
Telephone: 813-639-4967
Permit Application No,
.~. J-
79K-1519
Permit Application No, 44-25249-5E
.
Authority:
Section 10 Df the River
and Harbor Act of 1899
(33 U.S.C. 403) and
Section 404 of the Clean
Water Act of 1977
Authority: Chapter 253 and/or
403 of the Florida
Statutes
Comment Peri od Ends: JAN 07 1980
Project Manager: Jim Bajek
Comment Period Ends: JMJ (17 7980
DER Contact: Mike Nowicki
,
TO ~JHOM IT MAY CONCERN: An app1 icaticn for a Permit has been received by the
above agencies and is being processed jointly in accordance with the applicable
Federal and State regulations,
APPLICANT:
Mrs. Lavonne H. Bouthilet
P.O. Box 250
Sum~erland Key, Florida 33042
WATERHAY & LOCATION: Hawk Channel (Straits of Florida) along the south shore
of Surnrner1and Key, just south of Highl",ay U.S. 1, Section 35, Township 66 South,
Range 28 East, Monroe County, Florida
WORK & PURPOS~: To construct approximately 100 lineal feet of concrete
bulkhead, with return walls on both ends, below mean high water and backfill
with ap~roximately. 54 cubic yards of spail material that will be obtained by
l]1echanically (backhoe) excavating a 12 foot wide by 20 foot long by -4 feet
~ean sea level de~p boat slip with access channel in naYig~ble waters. Also,
to place approximately 10 cubic yajds of rock riorap along the waterward toe of
the bulkhead. Turbidity screens will be used during project work. The purpose
of the project is to reclaim and to protect the eroded shoreline and provide
boat dockage for a private residence.
SAJ fL 642
8 Feb 79
NOTE: Florida residents may contact this office for information
on a 24-hou~ basis by calling toll free, telephone #1-800-342-5950,
Comments or objections should be submitted in writing.
~r. ~ , .
: .'
\
,
". .
- ,,:;;rr:~-:- .-... - . . .
.~~'{:).~~~?:~~~.-:. ,- ...'.."e.-
.......'\1'", .. ,.' s..~";"''''~V' ',' _ .I- ,".... ...'
.:...... ... . .:........' ,:o.l.-.. . .~. _'_' ......:__;,__,,"r.. "
.:-!-.~- .~. ~ ~ ~-~~ -
~ -,.,. ~~..- ~
,.,~:.,..,.~~ ,':;':.,..w.. -,
37($
,---._. ".._..---~.....,..',._,-,-~. -- ...,..,
.j..
. .
;F
. . . .
~ t.
.
.
activity will not degrade the oua1ity of the contiguous or receiving
wnterbody. If the impact of the proposed ilct.ivity can be expected to
affpct the a'luatic or marine hinlo9ical resources to such an extent a<;
to be contrary t.o the pub1 ic int.erest, resul t in harmful shorl1 in~l or
erosion of adjacent property, result in harmful obstruction to, or algera-
tion of the natural flow below MH\oJ in navigabl e bodies of water, or
result in violations of State water quality standards in any waters of
the State, then a permit may not be ~ranted.
Corrrnents regarding the National Considerations should be submitted in
writing to the District Engineer, Corps of En~Jineers, and those concern-
ing State Considerations to the State of Florida, Department of Environ-
mental Regulation, on or before the date of the comment period to the
appropriate address as noted 'above,
- .. J-
You are requested to ~ommunicate the information contained in this
notice to any other parties whom you deem likely to have an interest
in this matter,
If you have any questions or desire additional infonnation concerning
this application, you may .call the Corps of Engineers' project manager
for this appl ication or the Florida Department of Environmental Regula-
tion contact at the above telephone pumbers,
REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING: If the proposed activity involves the
discharge of dredgec1 or filled rreterial, any rerson rrey request a
publ ic hearing, The request must be submitted in writing to the
District Engineer or to the State of Florida, Department of Environ-
mental Regulation within 30 days of the date of this notice and must
stat~ the specific reasons for requesting the public hearing. On
other projects, any request for a publ ic hearing will be evaluated
as to whether additional, publ ic input is required in order to make
a final decision,
--
FOR THE DISTRICT ENGINEER:
~~~e./d ~
G!\ IL G, GREN
Chief, Opel'ations Division
i
..
. ,
, .
A.
~
3
!
. ,
-
..
<
.1
..~, "'"~
1 ~
"~,,,.,..l
,':r"""'f
, ,
',>' 'X
. ~,
iI,.
~..~=-==.~:..::~-=-:-:---'..,~.~~;~~' ~
3/1.,
. . '.i~~,~: 7%1:;:>.~.2'~.'~':~:>~'=: '-:.'.~ ~Ii_'_~~~'~ ~'.: -'
. v.' . '.' 'if"';"~.;$""!-,_,""<.~"", '"",w'r. 0'-""
" ".~. ..... ,.,.;,.,.,,'~
.-~,\
1- ,- , :~;~S~r'Y~-',"~i:~;:~:)~;:",~~:~~~'~~~~~~t~~~\r=:tt~)~~.~~~~~~~~~.
.... ~"'.,O"',._ . ,',' , . ~...i,. ,"M. "ifis!.t-.,,,...,. '~~'f,:~ri..Ir.;~\...jf:r,..r,);&j:'",::',~ c-
. .'. -./r;;!;:,jIi~~;;:r1;.~~~~4"'~:;,',}.:~)~">.. "'~"-"'_....~~~~,~;~~~~14~':~,~,:~~-
:.
.... -: -........ - ~ -... ."
. , ~..' ',-.......