Item F1
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
Meeting Date: March 16,2005
Division:
Engineering
Bulk Item: Yes
No X
Department: Engineering
Staff Contact Person: David S. Koppel, PE
County Engineer
AGENDA ITEM WORDING: Approval to recommend to FDOT Alternative 1 for the Card Sound
Road/C905 Intersection.
ITEM BACKGROUND: Improvements to this intersection are needed to facilitate traffic movement
during emergency and normal traffic conditions. FDOT has proposed four alternatives. Alternate 1
(recommended by County Staff) creates a new T -intersection with a free flow condition along the new
curve. Alternative 2 (recommended by FDOT staff) maintains the existing intersection and adds a new
curve. FDOT is recommending this because of its lower cost and lesser environmental impact. County
staff is opposed to this alternative because it is confusing and potentially dangerous. Alternative 3 is
the same as Alternative 2 except that the new curve would be built on a structure. Alternative 4 is
virtually what we have today except for minor improvements. All alternatives, except for Alternative
4, will have a design speed of 30 mph.
PREVIOUS RELEVANT BOCC ACTION: The BOCC has urged FDOT to expedite
improvements to the intersection.
CONTRACT/AGREEMENT CHANGES: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Approval as stated above. Monroe County will advance the
money to FDOT to expedite the project and accept reimbursement from FDOT at a later time.
TOTAL COST:
BUDGETED: Yes
No
COST TO COUNTY:
SOURCE OF FUNDS:
REVENUE PRODUCING: Yes
No
AMOUNT PER MONTH_ Year
APPROVED BY: County Atty _ OMB/Purchasing
DIVISION DIRECTOR APPROVAL:
David S. Koppel, PE, County Engineer
DOCUMENTATION:
Included X
Not Required_
DISPOSITION:
AGENDA ITEM #
Revised 2/05
h
~g ~
to
~
~
~
III ~
0
ci
z II( ~
0
[i ~
:l W ~
~ Z III Z
Z -", :5 ( 0 0 ~
8 ~ ~ ci ~ ~
1- ~____
III
_ w '" 3
~~ - g ~ '"
h
~
'"
~ ~
!:: ~
~ ~
U~
~ ~ " oJ
~
i:1 i 2 15
;00: U
l;j ;:!
"'
~ g <:
~
" ~
~ '"
u
!
\I"l?-<
00
0:'0
P:::E-<
Uc;n
o~
z~
<0
---'i:l..
<z
~Q
O\c;n
'P:::
P:::~
8>
oz
<0
OU
P:::z
00
z-
oE-<
oU
c;n~
oP:::
P:::~
<E-<
u~
>-.
~g ~
'"
~
~
Cl ~
10 4 ~
_ w
~ 5 .. 0 z
0 0 ~
2
~
III ~
- 8 ~
~
J" "l
>-
~
? :t
~ ~
~ ~
H~
~ ~ " '"
~
i:: ~ 2 ~
:0: u
&i ;:;
0;
~
~ ~ '"
co g
~ e
~
lr);""
OCl
o:'~
~E-<
UVl
C1~
Zo(!
<C1
"'""~
<z
:39
O'IVl
'~
~~
S;>
C1Z
<:0
OU
~Z
C10
z-
;:JE-<
o&l
VlVl
C1~
~~
<E-<
u~
f.-
~g ~
V)
~
~
E..;;
~
~
~
~
~
'"
f.-
~
;;: :t
~ ~
~ ~
u~
~ ~ ~ oJ
~
~ ~ ~ ~
~ "' w :!!
~
~
~ . <:
~
~ ~
'"
u
!
l/');;'"
oCi
o:';:J
P::E-<
Uv.l
Ci~
~o(l
___Ci
<~
l/')Z
00
0\-
,v.l
~~
U~
'-';>
CiZ
<0
OU
~Z
CiO
Z-
;:JE-<
O~
v.lv.l
Ci~
~E-<
<Z
U_
f--
~g ~
'"
~
~
~
... N ~
0
ci ~
~
~
.. N ~
0
ci
'"
u
~
~ 0-
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~ ~
d
~ ~ C: ~
~
~ ~ 2 ~
:<: "
f;j :>:
f.;
~
~ . -<
>!
C> ~
il '"
u
!
\1"):>-
00
":'~
"'1-<
Uen
01J:.1
~~
",,0
<~
v;Z
00
01-
,en
"'"'
UIJ:.1
'--':>
OZ
<0
OU
"'Z
00
Z-
~1-<
O~
en en
0"'
",1J:.1
<1-<
U~
.....
Q
~
o
~
Q
Z
:;;;;
o
rJJ
Q
~
~
u
.~:l ~
i]~
~ ~:~
;:...Q
.- ~ u
b!jQU
Ul~
~ '~.g ~
~j~r
"" ov
E~k
g .~~~~
:E~S
o
o
o
~:
;;;;
u
~
r
o
Z
:s: ~.B
~1lS
(!)C;tCll
~ 8.':"g
(/)",,0;::1
ollVl~O
~~~~
'@ 5b~ ~ u
~g~5 ~
.~~~]~
'gg~2~
E$E.~~
.~~t~ @
'~.s~~'B
~~3]~
o
o
o
",'
o
"'.
~
~"
~:~
U
:;:;3':
=...
.3::
u~
[0'::
EN
.~.~
~;;
<+--< F-o
~B~
~~.[
~ .s
Vvo
Z;:.o [/J
Qj~'~.E
ffi~~.~
.B]~~
.~:r~]
E"Oq;:;.,5
e3~5
.Q~:.g
~~~~ ~
~BCii g 8
._-g g:@ Q
~g~1::-=
'';:::.001)800
~~~J3~
.E
I
o
o
o
0"
"
"
:Sf;
1l~
'"at;
5"';.:
r:i"Sl
~~
.
~.~]
.gE'~
;>,,8 2
~~:~
~i'J
'6..s.~,@
g,~'~~
~~~g
::::Iu.....e
O;:G:: p..,
(/)OOllo..
g]g~ ~
'ZOO ;::1-
~~]~ ~
~~~~
8a::; ~ ,"C
.g~]j g
~ ~~~~
,B.,CC\l.....11l
.5 ~~ ~~
~ ~~g~
;;;
'"
02
o
o
o
~
~
"
~
"'
"
c
';d-ci
=~
;'~
l.j
;.-..~
,"0
~g
~~
~\~
"'0
=
o
.~
0-
o
"0
g
=
'I
OD
~
66
uS
~~
~~
"'-
"=
:~.~
cu.
o
o
o
<h
'"
]
o
Z
=
.S:
-;;
..
<l>
Q.
o
""
=
"
'"
.t:
<l>
E
o
<l>
()
'"
o
U
=
~
"
=
,;
=
o
U
'"
~
'"'
"
Q.
~
:::
:x
u
'"
0-
.5
o
z
v
'"
0-
.5
o
;Z
'"
"-
.5
o
z
S'j
d~H
.~ gg ;.~
H~H
,,-,"0 tl ~ Q
~lJlf
~ci!~~ 11
:<B~Cl,5
8.~ ~ ~ ]
.s~ &~'O
"0 ~"O;::
.g.g @.~
:'~g'g
~:~ ~ ~
~:::~'~
:j-5 ~ EF
~."=~~~
..o=L~ E::-:::
01)..0 u.3 i3
:~~ ~g
.g ~] ~"@
=.5 8 ~::
~~~ g~
~I~J3~
v
g~.~
~ ;::'.0
20 ro
_'0/l,..C
~.s .5
H~
~=g
Hi
.~~.~
>, c..s d
~~'o.g
s.~~~
~ Q) ;... c:
u... 0 0
t-<A.uu
u
u
"
N
""
,,;
'"
"
"
oc'
:::,
Eli
r-- ~.!::
~6::; 5-
_oU-.....<r>Q,j
.~~~ ~-~
~~in
:a~~'Egp
g.2~5~
u ~.~ [;
.;~~~~
: ~ ~ 0 .~
2.:9 -g ~ ~
.5~ g.~<g
dl~
(;;i Q)~ g
~~~~
o ~ \0_1..)
~:E < ~
~HI
Bg~~
g.~.s 2
::::"0 Q) 0..
'~1a:::B
-g~~~
~~~~
u
u
~
N
""
,,;
'"
'"
'"
oc'
:::,
~~]
m-.....~g.
mfl
u ~.~ 8. ,3
Q,l2-5 0 ~
-5 Q)......~ g
o~ 0 :> 0.
~~ ~~.~
~;gg-g~
_~ O"ro 0
o
~
"d@
E..s~
1!1
~.g ~
,30~
-".=
8.~.s
E~<O
-C.
V u V
~ 13 E
cd:8
V
g
N
'"
"
o
'"
oC
:!:,
i
.5
o
z
w
V
'"
"-
.5
i
o
Z
u
"
~
- "'~
e':! I: ~
-== 0 t>l)
~ '.0 :;;
;:: " <l>
= b "'"
0":1"0
"'" ,~ =
.~ ;g.~
C 0-
~W~
'"
-
"
"
Q.
.5
""
=
~
<l>
:::
~
"
"
Q.
E
!j
:c
.:!
..
~,
>-<
~
Eo-<
<
~
z
o
..
Eo-<
<
;;:I
...:l
<
;>
f;i<
Eo-<
Z
f;i<
~
f;i<
;>
o
~
~
~
..
Z
f;i<O
...:l"
~f:
<'-'
Eo-<~
~
f;i<
Eo-<
!;
If)
o
0'\
~
U
Q
Z
<
Q
<
o
~
Q
Z
;;:I
o
rJ1
~
<
u
C Q
E ~'B
~..... C) otl
~ g~eQ~~
~ ~loo'E~~
.sg~ S-B ..
"H ~~]~ ~~
~ E'~ 5 ~~ g
"'04.:r- u QJ ou
a :s:&3~.9 ~~
.~~.g.9 ~;c
]~-5 ~ ~'Q'~
~e [8 ~!5.~
s-;:;Qi't;; QJg:2:
t.~ ~] ~~~
~~ ~~ ~~g
~
'D
00
"'
~
N
3
0.
>
Co.
;g
!~
::'2
g
0;
Zj
Q
j
~:l d
~ -1 ~c
z ~
E
"'
'"
;i; :
u
c
"
E
~I
~
.s
"cg
P...V'
E 0
~~
"2gp
::f ~2
5cCfl..;::
~.~~
6~.g
'"7f-;~
"
'B
~~
c t
~i::
~;
'"Egf
~~~
<n on"
~H
"
on
~
o
Z
.Q
..::::'2
o.m
E ti
~~
'E~
~&~
... on"
-.So
~g~
::;:r;~
"
t
o
Z
N
"
>
~
;;:
m
.
~
'"
u
gp
o
.@
~~
~~
'S ~
<So
""'::l
~~
~'e
'E~
UU
l~
;;.....: .
6513
:.a a:"S
'"O~>
~!;~
o
.~
.~
o '
Be
0'5
~2"
'~
e
N
"
>
")
;;:
N
"
>
.;:;
o
c
jj
;;:
"
"
"
;;
'"
N
"
>
~
o
c
jj
<:
~
u
o
;;
'"
N
"
~
g
;;:
C
0.
U
C
o
"
o
"
'"
.
u
Ji
"
gp
o
'(;3
.ti2
mO
.~ lfj
g.~
.~
g~
:g'~
00
.~~
tJ:
"'2i....; .
00-0
0""
~~~
-<~ c..
"5
>0
"0
Q'';::
0"
'';:: t
"0.
~o
~~
u~
.sn~
3.S
~~
0"
.~ ~
8.~ ~
o~o
v:=:'.o
S'c;:a
~~g
"'
0.
>
~
S
"
'"
be
o
'5
~
g
.~
'"
ii
o
z
""
~
~
~
...
i;;
I~.
a
c
E
Z
U
C
"
~I
c'
ue'
c
"!
"E
u
8.
"
~
c
.~
E
j~
03
~g-
~t~
"'-1;
Q
0:
~
~i
~I
~
~:
o
~
S
~I;
~
o
Z
~'I
~~
~~
N-
O'"'
"Ow
U ~
U 0
~ p.1-
&Vl.fl
.':tCQ
-.8u
::)E:E
\J::IQ)
,f-;~
-C~
~j
"E~
u 0
0..
~1Zl-B
LJ).t;f)il)
C\.S'U
~~~
.g
,..,::::g
g.~
0",
<nO
~~
'ESO
" 0
0..
~Uj-5
'<:t O!)Q
~.~]
U::la)
>-;<~~
u~~
~
&i
~
'8
-o~
~~
"5 e
~~
~~
80
"8
~.
.20
i::~
~e
-"-
gi,s
000
~~~
~-E;~
5
>0
00
.g'~
I:
.SC~
~,E
~~
00
.g E
E:i]
g.,s g
U C''';:::
l:S'@;P
~~5
~.u
"'
~
00
<n
C
-a.
>
""
~
~,
N
'"
i
~!
~j
~
~i
c
~
o
"E
u
8.
u
I
o
,::
"C
~
"'
u
o
2l
sl
~i
~
'"
~:
[
2!1
E:
(.1.1:
:;;
t-
'1_15
~
u
o
~
E
o
z
I
8
o
z
"
o
~'~
E"~
:::,5
c
'B
!i
-Coo
" ~
~&~
~.~~
?S.g
~~~
,2
..c'E
0."
S2
",0
N'-
,. "'
'Egp
aE
;f:iZl-fi
...... ~::.l
r:-,E""G
Bg:fi
'"7f-;~
I
~]
95
~~
-Coo
u ~
;,::-g.g
..."'-=
~g~
;:)EE
~~~
"'
0.
>
"'
0.
>
~
"
'E
..=::r.
p.ii}
E1:
0\ ';:
-0"8:.
o ~
;:? g"e
8VJ-:5
~,r~
:J ."'
~~~
~
~
-c'1
o.~
E ~
;?;,~
-g~
~~~
~,~~
dg~
'"7f-;~
;:;
C
5j
'~!
"'
8'
"
o
~
>
e
]"
o
Z
o
'~
8
o
z
o
'"
.~
ii
o
z
,~
",0
!,g
u
"
0.
.5
o
z
~
E)
Oi
Z
"B~
u 0
0..
~cr:..s
lfl el)c.l
:'~~
~~~
"
.~
:
"
"
>
'"
'"
'JJ:;
~
';;
'"
Q
E-
Z
."'"
;is
"'"
;;.
o
~
~
~
.....
N
~
....
:=
~
E-
Z~
0.....
.....~
E-E-
u-<
~~
~1J1
"",,,,,,
E-;;'
~E=
u
~"'"
c;;-,'"
~~
uO
AE-
Zu
-<;:;
AO
-<~
O~
~
A
Z
P
o
IJ1
~
-<
u
'),
'),
'),
YO
1: 0
15 ~~
>.1)~
-'5 5 ~
~.~ ::-
~gCIJ
1j~~
~ 1.) c:
~~]
,,'1:: s:-g
> j:j (.l) en
::oj'"d l-,< C
.b ~ 5'0
.~'B~~
E"'"..<::
..... r.n 0 u
~2:O~
~.S~,g
'),
'),
'),
'),
~ 0
oj~
~2..<::
9 a3.~
- > >.
..<::"",
ace
~ 0,-
.- '"
b.01d .S!
!:1;:;~
.~ ~'s
""d ;>.0;;:
,,~
" '"
0"0 "
.~ a-E ~
.... u:t'i:l 0
~5~'B
...c.,..... it}
E]~ ~
r~ 0 ~ ~
<'.U U 0._
'),
'),
'),
'81
]~
" "
.8 ~
[) 0
0.., "
~'E
" "
a 5
5b2=l
:<j U
8Cl)
:::E,~
>>"
0"0
5-0
on2
'".-
" "
Ecr
P-l2
'),
'),
;2
.s
~
5;
~
o
o
tC
<.;.....;
"
'"
~
2:-
',S
Q
"
>
o
a
.s
'),
'),
'i:'
:;-
.s
tJ
"
UJ
"
;J
"
"
"
~
2
';;
;::
~
'),
'),
,-. '"
~]
;:: E
c "
'''' "
8 ~
r/l5
"0 E
C'~
oj oj
C'j s
;b[j
g.s :n
~ E.~
.~ ~.~
cij]~'
~~u
:~ ~.~.
.S g~
2._ 0
"
~
"
"
:0
c
"
E
"
.:.
.J:;'
c
~
<.J
"
'0
...
llo..
<.J
.~
p'
:I::
"
"
is
'0
==
YO
"
e
;::l
'"
~
"
"
SE
'),